Zoning and Network Development

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    1/145

    March 2012 Abu Dhabi Department of Transport Report

    If you wish to add your own image to the cover, follow this s tep:

    Place the picture and size it exactly above this theme area.

    Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services

    Working Paper No. 6A: Zoning and NetworkDevelopment Report

    Zoning and Network Development Report

    Abu Dhabi Strategic TransportationEvaluation and Assessment Model

    Working Paper

    Zoning and Network Development ReportMay 2012

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    2/145

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Working Paper: Zoning and Network Development Report

    Prepared for

    Abu Dhabi Department of Transport

    Prepared by

    AECOM Middle East Limited

    PO Box 43266, Abu Dhabi

    United Arab Emirates

    www.aecom.com

    May 2012

    AECOM

    The information contained in this document produced by AECOM Middle East Limited is solely for

    the use of the Client identified on the cover sheet for the purpose for which it has been prepared

    and AECOM Middle East Limited undertakes no duty to or accepts any responsibility to any third

    party who may rely upon this document.

    All rights reserved. No section or element of this document may be removed from this document,

    reproduced, electronically stored or transmitted in any form without the written permission of

    AECOM Middle East Limited.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    3/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Quality Information

    Document Working Paper: Zoning and Network Development Report

    Ref ADR-ATM-PMJ-REP-00045-3 Date May 2012

    Prepared by Brian Vaughan Reviewed by Hamzeh Al Jaghbir

    Revision History

    Revision Revision Date Details

    Authorised

    Name/Position Signature

    0 15/10/2009 Draft

    Andrew Schmidt

    Manager, Transportation

    Planning Original Signed

    1 01/08/2010 For DoT Review

    Andrew Schmidt

    Manager, Transportation

    Planning Original Signed

    2 13/06/2011 For DoT Review

    Andrew Schmidt

    Manager, Transportation

    Planning Original Signed

    3 11/09/2011 Including DoT Comments

    Andrew Schmidt

    Manager, Transportation

    Planning Original Signed

    4 04/01/2012 Final Including DoT Comments

    Andrew Schmidt

    Manager, Transportation

    Planning Original Signed

    5 05/02/2012 Final Including DoT Comments

    Andrew Schmidt

    Manager, Transportation

    Planning Original Signed

    6 17/03/2012 Final

    Andrew Schmidt

    Manager, Transportation

    Planning Original Signed

    7 08/05/2012 Final

    Paul Beattie

    Project Manager

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    4/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Contents

    Executive Summary ................................................................................................................................. i

    1.0 Purpose of the Working Paper ................................................................................................... 1

    1.1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 1

    1.2 Purpose of the Working Paper ................................................................................................... 1

    1.3 Transport Models: Zones and Networks..................................................................................... 1

    1.4 Layout of the Working Paper ...................................................................................................... 2

    2.0 Zoning ....................................................................................................................................... 3

    2.1 General Principles ..................................................................................................................... 3

    2.2 Study Area ................................................................................................................................. 3

    2.3 Size ...........................................................................................................................................8

    2.4 Land Use-Current and Future .................................................................................................... 9

    2.5 Zone Labelling Convention ........................................................................................................ 9

    3.0 STEAM Zoning ........................................................................................................................ 13

    3.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 13

    3.2 Abu Dhabi Urban Region Zoning ............................................................................................. 133.2.1 Review of STMP Zoning.............................................................................................. 13

    3.2.2 Population and Employment Density ........................................................................... 15

    3.2.3 Land Use and Homogeneity ........................................................................................ 16

    3.2.4 Census Boundaries ..................................................................................................... 18

    3.2.5 Summary .................................................................................................................... 20

    3.2.6 Refinement of Zones in Abu Dhabi Urban Region ....................................................... 20

    3.2.7 Special Trip Generators .............................................................................................. 24

    3.3 Abu Dhabi Rural Region Zoning .............................................................................................. 24

    3.3.1 Census Boundaries ..................................................................................................... 24

    3.3.2 Population Density ...................................................................................................... 27

    3.4 Al Ain Urban Region Zoning ..................................................................................................... 28

    3.4.1 Community Boundaries ............................................................................................... 29

    3.4.2 Existing Network Layout .............................................................................................. 30

    3.4.3 Existing and Proposed Population Density and Land Use ........................................... 30

    3.4.4 Homogeneity ............................................................................................................... 33

    3.4.5 Special Trip Generators Al Ain ................................................................................. 33

    3.5 Al Ain Rural Region Zoning ...................................................................................................... 34

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    5/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.5.1 Community Boundaries ............................................................................................... 34

    3.5.2 Population Density ...................................................................................................... 36

    3.6 Al Gharbia Region Zoning ........................................................................................................ 38

    3.6.1 Population Density ...................................................................................................... 39

    3.7 External Zones......................................................................................................................... 41

    3.8 Summary ................................................................................................................................. 42

    3.9 Summary of Number of Zones ................................................................................................. 42

    4.0 Highway Network ..................................................................................................................... 43

    4.1 General Principles ................................................................................................................... 43

    4.2 Node Labelling Convention ...................................................................................................... 43

    4.3 STEAM Node and Link Parameters ......................................................................................... 45

    4.3.1 Node Attributes ........................................................................................................... 45

    4.3.2 Link Attributes ............................................................................................................. 48

    4.4 Link Volume Delay Functions ................................................................................................... 51

    4.5 Definition of Highway Modes .................................................................................................... 54

    4.6 Link Coding .............................................................................................................................. 55

    4.6.1 Urban Links ................................................................................................................. 55

    4.6.2 Rural Links .................................................................................................................. 56

    4.6.3 Truck Roads and Restrictions ..................................................................................... 57

    4.6.4 Multi-Lane Highways ................................................................................................... 57

    4.6.5 Master Network ........................................................................................................... 58

    4.7 Junction Coding ....................................................................................................................... 59

    4.7.1 Extent and General Principles ..................................................................................... 59

    4.7.2 Traffic Signals ............................................................................................................. 62

    4.7.3 Roundabouts ............................................................................................................... 71

    4.7.4 Priority Junctions ......................................................................................................... 77

    4.7.5 Bus Lanes in Mixed Traffic .......................................................................................... 79

    4.7.6 Treatment of Taxi Trips ............................................................................................... 80

    5.0 Public Transport Network ......................................................................................................... 81

    5.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................................. 81

    5.2 Public Transport Network ......................................................................................................... 81

    5.2.1 General Principles ....................................................................................................... 81

    5.2.2 Network Components .................................................................................................. 815.2.3 Public Transport Nodes ............................................................................................... 82

    5.3 Links ........................................................................................................................................ 82

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    6/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    5.4 Representation of Stop/Station/Parking Facility ....................................................................... 83

    5.5 Public Transport Modes ........................................................................................................... 83

    5.5.1 Representation of PT Routes/Lines ............................................................................. 86

    5.5.2 Public Transport Fare .................................................................................................. 87

    5.5.3 Transit time Functions ................................................................................................. 87

    5.5.4 Other PT Assignment Parameters ............................................................................... 88

    5.6 Park and Ride Modelling .......................................................................................................... 90

    5.6.1 Methodology ............................................................................................................... 92

    5.6.2 Park and Ride Station Catchment ............................................................................... 93

    5.6.3 Parking Capacity ......................................................................................................... 96

    5.7 Crowding Model ....................................................................................................................... 98

    5.7.1 Description of Crowding Model ................................................................................... 98

    6.0 Compatibility between Zones and Networks .......................................................................... 102

    6.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................ 102

    6.2 Zone Centroid Connectors ..................................................................................................... 102

    6.2.1 Abu Dhabi Urban Region .......................................................................................... 102

    6.2.2 Abu Dhabi Rural Region ........................................................................................... 103

    6.2.3 Al Ain Urban Region.................................................................................................. 103

    6.2.4 Al Ain Rural Region ................................................................................................... 104

    6.2.5 Al Gharbia Region ..................................................................................................... 104

    6.2.6 External Zones .......................................................................................................... 104

    Appendix A Zone Plans ...................................................................................................................... A

    Appendix B Network Plan ................................................................................................................... B

    Appendix C Volume Delay Functions .................................................................................................. C

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    7/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    List of Tables

    Table 1 - Existing and Projected Population ............................................................................................................. .................... 7Table 2 - Schedule of Zones Sizes and Number of Zones within Each Region ................................................................... ......... 9

    Table 3 - Number of Zones within the External Region ............................................................................................ .................. 42

    Table 4 - STEAM Zones .......................................................... ..................................................................... .............................. 42

    Table 5 - Node Input Attributes Included in the Master Network. .................................................................. .............................. 46

    Table 6 - Link Input Attributes in the STEAM Master Network ........................................................... ......................................... 49

    Table 7 - Link Type Definition - STEAM .......................................................... ..................................................................... ....... 53

    Table 8 - Traffic Signal Junction Coding Attributes ................................................................ ..................................................... 70

    Table 9 - Values of Entry Capacity (Ce) Based on Number of Approach Lanes and Number of Entry Lanes at the Stop Line. . 73

    Table 10 - Values of A Based on Number of Approach Lanes and Entry Lanes at the Stop Line for 60m Inscribed Circle

    Roundabout. ..................................................................................................................... ......................................... 74

    Table 11 - Values of A Based on Number of Approach Lanes and Entry Lanes at the Stop Line or 90m Inscribed Circle

    Roundabout. ..................................................................................................................... ......................................... 74

    Table 12 - Roundabout Junction Coding Attributes ........................................................................... ......................................... 77

    Table 13 - Priority Junction Turn Delays ..................................................................... ................................................................ 79

    Table 14 - List of Public Transport Link Types ............................................................ ................................................................ 83

    Table 15 - List of All Transit and Access Modes .................................................................... ..................................................... 85

    Table 16 - Public Transport Line File Information .................................................................. ..................................................... 86

    Table 17 - Boarding Penalties and Weight factors ................................................................. ..................................................... 90

    Table 18 - Transfer Penalties .............................................................. ..................................................................... .................. 90

    Table 19 - Typical Table Specifying Catchment and Capacity for Each Park and Ride Facility .................................................. 96

    Table 20 - Capacity Characteristics of Different PT Vehicles .............. ..................................................................... .................. 99Table 21 - ATC Perceived In-Vehicle Time Factors ............................................................... ................................................... 100

    List of Figures

    Figure 1 - Location of the Study Area ......................................................................... .................................................................. 4

    Figure 2 - Three Main Areas of Emirate of Abu Dhabi .................................................................................................................. 5

    Figure 3 - Population Density According to 2009 Planning Data (No. of people/sq km) ............................................................... 6

    Figure 4 - Location of Internal and External Regions .............................................................. ...................................................... 7

    Figure 5 - Definition of regions for Study Area and the Area of Influence. ................................................................ .................. 10

    Figure 6 - Zone Labelling System ................................................................... ..................................................................... ....... 12

    Figure 7 - Abu Dhabi STMP Network and Zone Boundaries ................................................................................................ ...... 14

    Figure 8 - 2009 Population Densities for Abu Dhabi Urban Region ............................................................... ............................. 15

    Figure 9 - CBD, Abu Dhabi Island 2009 Proportion of Land Uses by Category ................................................................... ....... 17

    Figure 10 - Abu Dhabi STEAM Zone Boundaries and Census Boundaries ............................................................... ................. 19

    Figure 11 - New Development Zones Plan ................................................................. ................................................................ 21

    Figure 12 - Abu Dhabi STMP Zone Boundaries and Census Boundaries .................................................................................. 22

    Figure 13 - Abu Dhabi STEAM Zone Boundaries and Census Boundaries ............................................................... ................. 23

    Figure 14 - Census Boundaries of Abu Dhabi Rural Region ............................................................... ........................................ 25

    Figure 15 - Abu Dhabi Rural Region Zoning ............................................................... ................................................................ 26

    Figure 16 - Abu Dhabi Rural Region with Population Density (No. of people/sq km) ................................................................. 27

    Figure 17 - Al Ain STMP Zone Boundaries .................................................................. ............................................................... 28Figure 18 - Compatibility between Community Boundaries and Traffic Zones in Al Ain ...................................................... ....... 29

    Figure 19 - Al Ain Zone Boundaries ................................................................. ..................................................................... ...... 30

    Figure 20 - Al Ain 2009 Population Density ................................................................ ................................................................ 31

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    8/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 21 - Al Ain 2030 Urban Structure Framework Plan ................................................................. ......................................... 32

    Figure 22 - Homogeneity Maintained within Al Ain Urban Zoning System ................................................................ .................. 33

    Figure 23 - Al Ain Rural Region Zone Boundary ..................................................................... .................................................... 35Figure 24 - Al Ain Rural Region with Population Density (no. of people / sq.km) ......................................... .............................. 37

    Figure 25 - Al Gharbia STMP Zone Boundaries ................................................................................. ........................................ 38

    Figure 26 - Al Gharbia STEAM Zone Boundaries .................................................................. ..................................................... 39

    Figure 27 - Al Gharbia Region with Population Density 2009 ............................................................ ......................................... 40

    Figure 28 - External Region Zoning ................................................................ ..................................................................... ....... 41

    Figure 29 - STEAM Node Labelling System ................................................................................................. .............................. 45

    Figure 30 - Akcelik Curve Effect of JA Factors ........................................................................................... ............................. 52

    Figure 31 - Schematic of Network Structure in Urban Areas ............................................................. ......................................... 56

    Figure 32 - Example of a Multi-Lane Dual Carriageway in an Urban Region. ........................................................... .................. 58

    Figure 33 - Example of the Master Network ................................................................................................. .............................. 59

    Figure 34 - Extent of Abu Dhabi Island Where Junction Modelling is Included in 2009 Network ................................................ 60Figure 35 - Extent of Al Ain City where Junction Modelling is Included in 2009 Network.............................. .............................. 61

    Figure 36 - Approach Nodes ................................................................ ..................................................................... .................. 63

    Figure 37 - First Arm ................................................................ ..................................................................... .............................. 64

    Figure 38 - Phasing .................................................................................................... ................................................................ 65

    Figure 39 - Lane Geometry .................................................................. ..................................................................... .................. 66

    Figure 40 - Average Lane Width ..................................................................... ..................................................................... ....... 66

    Figure 41 - Minimum Capacity ............................................................. ..................................................................... .................. 67

    Figure 42 - Randomness ............................................................................................ ................................................................ 68

    Figure 43 - Exit Lanes ............................................................... ..................................................................... ............................. 69

    Figure 44 - Ban Turn ................................................................. ..................................................................... ............................. 69

    Figure 45 - Alternative Roundabout Models ................................................................ ............................................................... 71

    Figure 46 - Capacity Slope ................................................................................................................ ......................................... 72

    Figure 47 - Capacity Intercept ............................................................. ..................................................................... .................. 72

    Figure 48 - Definition of First Arm ................................................................... ..................................................................... ....... 75

    Figure 49 - Input Capacity Slope ................................................................................ ................................................................ 75

    Figure 50 - Input Capacity Intercept..................................................... ..................................................................... .................. 76

    Figure 51 - Priority Arrangement at Typical Free Right Turn Lane at Signalised Junctions ........................................................ 78

    Figure 52 - Priority junction at Typical Mid-Block U-Turns ................................................................. ......................................... 79

    Figure 53 - Wait Time Curve for Bus Services ............................................................ ................................................................ 89

    Figure 54 - Wait Time Curve for Rail Services ............................................................ ................................................................ 89

    Figure 55 - Park and Ride Representation ...................................................... ..................................................................... ...... 93Figure 56 - Example of a Park and Ride Catchment for a Station .............................................................................................. 95

    Figure 57 - Park and Ride Volume to Capacity Curve ........................................................... ..................................................... 97

    Figure 58 - Crowding Factor Curves ............................................................... ..................................................................... ..... 100

    Figure 59 - New Model Treatment of Centroid Connectors in Abu Dhabi .................................................................. ............... 103

    Figure 60 - New Model Treatment of Centroid Connectors in Al Ain Urban Area ..................................................................... 104

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    9/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Executive Summary

    The Abu Dhabi Department of Transport (DoT) commissioned AECOM through its operating companies Cansult

    Maunsell and Faber Maunsell, to develop a new computer based transport model for the Emirate of Abu Dhabi.

    The model is referred to as the Abu Dhabi Strategic Transportation Evaluation and Analysis Model (STEAM).

    The transport model zones and the representation of the highway and public transport system are the

    fundamental building blocks of the modelling process and therefore a systematic approach has been followed to

    represent the supply side system of Abu Dhabi within STEAM.

    Zoning System

    Abu Dhabi Emirate contains varied levels of population distribution, land use densities and travel patterns. The

    study area is sub divided into Abu Dhabi Urban, Abu Dhabi Rural, Al Ain Urban, Al Ain Rural, Al Gharbia and

    External regions. The boundaries of these regions are congruent with administrative and planning divisions.

    A data collection exercise was undertaken to gather the base and future year information on land use and

    population distribution, travel patterns, planning/administrative boundaries and network layout. This provided a

    basis for spatial disaggregation of the study area.

    A review of the existing zoning system within Abu Dhabi Emirate Enhanced Model (ADEEM) was undertaken to

    ascertain the acceptability of the current spatial level of detail for the internal zones that covers the 5 regions

    within the Abu Dhabi Emirate. Whilst the review revealed that zoning within the Abu Dhabi Central Business

    District (CBD) was appropriately detailed, the remaining regions including the fringes of Abu Dhabi urban region

    required further refinement to reflect similar trip intensities and future year development plan proposals.

    A significant zone redefinition exercise was subsequently carried out in all internal regions of Abu Dhabi Emirate,

    particularly within, Abu Dhabi Urban, Abu Dhabi Rural, Al Ain urban and rural and Western Region. Whilst the

    census boundaries within Abu Dhabi urban and rural and Western Region (Al Gharbia) provided a good starting

    point in most regions, these were not deemed appropriate in themselves for the purposes of STEAM and

    therefore and a further disaggregation was undertaken that was conducive to the to the best practice zoning

    system principles of homogeneity, similar trip intensities and overlap with the census/administrative boundaries.

    Within Al Ain Rural region, the community boundaries were deemed to be appropriately detailed and were

    therefore adopted as zones, however, within the Al Ain Urban region, the zones were further refined but

    overlapped with the community boundaries.

    Certain zones within STEAM are treated as Special Zones within the model so that different functionality can be

    applied to the treatment of trips to/from such zones. These zones mainly contain ports, airports or other major

    recreational areas. These zones are separately identified through input files to STEAM but are included in the

    relevant geographical regions. Table S1 provides a summary of STEAM zones in each region.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    10/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Table S1 - STEAM Zones

    Regions No of Zones

    Al Ain Rural 138

    Al Ain Urban 347

    Abu Dhabi Urban 1312

    Abu Dhabi Rural 66

    Al Gharbia 98

    External 26

    Total 1987

    Highway Network

    A Master Network containing the base 2009 and 2030 STEAM reference case networks has been coded using

    Cube GIS. To facilitate the coding of present and future highway and PT schemes into the one Master Network,

    node and link attributes have been created to indicate which are year (and scenario) specific.

    STEAM also includes an extensive range of node and link attributes defined and stored at each node and on each

    link in the network. These attributes store input values that dictate the characteristics of the nodes and links and

    also the outputs from model runs such as delays, and traffic flows by vehicle class.

    STEAM adopts an area-based numbering/labelling strategy and allocates an eight-digit number for each node inthe highway network and a five digit number for the Public Transport Network. The node label provides

    information on the location of the node within a sector (or sub-region), region and larger study area to discern the

    highway and PT network and ease of analysis.

    A detailed link type classification has been formulated within STEAM that includes all possible road types and its

    respective operational characteristics like lanes, speeds and location (rural or urban). An Akcelic volume delay

    function has been allocated to each link type with a specific Ja parameter based on whether the link delays are

    explicitly modelled by downstream junction simulation or the travel speeds along the link takes into account

    expected delays at the main downstream junction on the link.

    The majority of the traffic significant junctions within Abu Dhabi Island and Al Ain City are modelled in detail for the

    STEAM 2009 and 2030 road network. Where junctions are not explicitly modelled appropriate link type volume

    delay functions are used, including the junction delays. STEAM uses the HCM methodology for signalised

    junctions within Cube Voyager to model the fixed time signals in Abu Dhabi Island and adaptive signals in Al Ain

    city. The roundabout junctions are modelled using empirical model and the priority junctions are represented by

    standard turn delays that vary according to the location and type of priority junction.

    STEAM adopts a multi-node approach that includes a Cube Voyager mini-roundabout annotation at each

    approach arm of all dual carriageways, for explicitly modelling roundabout junctions in Abu Dhabi Island and Al

    Ain City. Roundabout intersections are modelled using an empirical model where each entry is characterized by acapacity slope and a capacity intercept.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    11/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    In STEAM standard turn delays are used to provide a reasonable representation of the average delay

    encountered at each of the priority junctions in the network.

    Public Transport Network

    The only public transport that exists in the base year 2009 are a limited number of intra-city and inter-city buses

    that operate on the highway network. A comprehensive and extensive public transport system including LRT,

    metro, rail, ferry and buses is planned for the Emirate and is coded in STEAM 2030 reference case.

    In STEAM, public transport networks comprise transit legs, non-transit legs and transfer legs. Separate node

    series are assigned to different PT modes, so that transit legs, non-transit legs, stops and parameters such as

    waiting time factors by mode are easily specified and post assignment analyses and extraction of data facilitated.

    The PT modes with exclusive right of way such as rail, metro, LRT, ferry and some parts of tram have exclusive

    links. A full range of link attributes are coded across all link types and classes.

    The Cube Voyager PT service data inputs are provided in the following four separate data files:

    Line File contains the routes and segment information for all PT modes within STEAM;

    System File contains the definition of the modes, operators, wait time curves, vehicle types, and crowding

    curves;

    Fare File modelled as flat fare in the base year and distance based fare in the future year within STEAM;

    and Factor File parameters to specify traveller behaviour in response to the PT system, such as boarding

    penalty, transfer penalty, value of time etc.

    The transit time functions within STEAM are defined separately for the services with own right of way like Rail,

    Metro, LRT and Ferry and street running services.

    PT systems with their own right of way i.e. the Regional Rail, Metro, LRT and Ferry, or a bus service with its own

    right of way, the travel time is independent of the car travel time. In such cases, travel time is calculated based on

    the design operating speed of the system defined in the model by the link type information. The public transport

    in-vehicle time function is defined as below:

    In-vehicle Time (mins) = Segment Time (mins) + Dwell times (at actual stops)

    The actual operating time for each transit segment is calculated based on the default speed of the mode.

    For a bus or tram service operating on the road system, its operating speed is dependent on the travel speed of

    the general traffic. Therefore, for a normal bus service operating on the same road as other traffic, a general

    transit time function is represented as below:

    Bus Time (mins) = A x Car Time (mins) + B x distance (km)

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    12/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Where:

    A is a factor more than one representing the travel conditions where a bus generally runs slower

    than a car. This factor may vary by road type; andB represents an average dwelling time (min) per km. It reflects the frequency of stops and average

    time spent at each stop.

    These parameters are pre-defined in the model during the public transport initialisation stage as part of the model

    development.

    STEAM includes a detailed Park and Ride modelling and has appropriate controls in place for the passenger

    demand in station through PT sub-mode choice, network coding to represent parking facility, access mode

    network and parking facilities. Assignment procedures incorporate additional delay to Park and Ride trips,

    representitive of parking search time.

    Compatibilit y between Network and Zones

    STEAM contains a detailed representation of the minor local roads within the urban regions that allows a realistic

    routeing for the trips to access the major roads at multiple locations and therefore in majority of the cases, the

    connector loads onto the minor roads that joins all the possible major roads thereby providing ample route choice.

    The exception to this is in rural regions of Al Ain and Al Gharbia where, as there are already minimal road

    networks, the connectors may occasionally load traveldemands onto major highways.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    13/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    1.0 Purpose of the Working Paper

    1.1 Introduction

    The Abu Dhabi Department of Transport (DoT) commissioned AECOM through its operating companies Cansult

    Maunsell and Faber Maunsell, to develop a new computer based transport model for the Emirate of Abu Dhabi.

    The model is referred to as the Abu Dhabi Strategic Transportation Evaluation and Analysis Model (STEAM).

    All transport models consist of three main elements, namely, a representation of the network supply, travel

    demand behavioural relationships to predict travel demand by time of day, and a means of assigning the demand

    to the network. The travel demand is generally a function of population, employment and land use and existswithin the model in the form of travel demand matrices between pre-specified geographic areas, i.e. zones. The

    supply side of the equation is the roadway and public transport systems on which travel occurs and the network

    attributes within the model describe the characteristics of these systems.

    The transport model zones and the representation of the highway and public transport system are the

    fundamental building blocks of the modelling process and establishing the level of spatial detail of the zones and

    the principles to be adopted in the development of the transport network is critical to any model development

    process.

    1.2 Purpose of the Working Paper

    This working paper describes the principles and assumptions utilised to define the zoning system and determine

    the extent and the operational characteristics of the highway and public transport network for inclusion in STEAM.

    The output of the working paper is 2009 zone plans for use in model development and calibration, and a set of

    2030 zones covering all the major development areas as provided by the Department of Transport. The 2030

    zones in the development areas will inevitably be subject to refinement as development plans change over time

    and as such, some flexibility in the zonal definitions has been provided by allowing for additional zones to be

    defined in STEAM.

    1.3 Transport Models: Zones and Networks

    Transport modelling involves aggregating spatial information into defined geographic areas generally referred to

    as zones and determining the relevant highway and public transport networks to be included within the model.

    This aggregation takes place as trips in the study area can begin and end at any address, and travellers can

    choose from all roads, streets and other transport options. Due to the immense volume of data involved, however,

    it is not practical to collate and analyse data based on individual dwelling/employment unit information. Therefore,

    a model represents reality by introducing the following elements:

    Zones: the study area is divided into a number of small but manageable zones and the trips from and to

    these zones are defined. All trips begin and end at an imaginary point inside this zone, defined as the centroid

    of that zone. It is accepted practice that each of these zones should, as far as practical, contain homogenous

    land uses in order to facilitate the definition of travel demand parameters; and

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    14/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Networks: the transport system consists of links and junctions that represent the available highway and

    public transport network and in the case of public transport the bus and rail services that operate on the

    network. The network is an abstraction of reality and the extent of representation depends on the purpose of,and the degree of detail adopted in, the study.

    This working paper details the principles adopted and sources utilised to disaggregate the study area and its

    surroundings into appropriate traffic zones and to the principles that are applied in STEAM for the coding of the

    network representations.

    1.4 Layout of the Working Paper

    Following this introduction:

    Chapter 2 presents the principles behind the definition of the zoning system;

    Chapter 3 describes the actual zoning system proposed;

    Chapter 4 describes the extent and the characteristics of the modelled highway network;

    Chapter 5 presents an overview of the modelling of the public transport network; and

    Chapter 6 describes the principles of zone and network compatibility.

    In addition, Appendix A includes the detailed STEAM zone plans, and Appendix B examples of the network plans

    exhibiting the range of coding principles defined in the main text of the working paper.

    This working paper is based on STEAM version 20 Run N.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    15/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    2.0 Zoning

    2.1 General Principles

    A systematic approach to transport planning studies requires the study area be delineated and subdivided into

    discrete traffic zones that allow for spatial aggregation of trip origins and destinations within the study area.

    The Zoning of a study area consists of two phases:

    Defining the spatial aggregation level of socio economic characteristics (determination of type and number of

    zones); and

    Determining shape, dimension and size of the zones respecting the spatial aggregation level determined andthe transport network to which the zones have to relate.

    The number of zones, and their spatial dimension, depends on the nature and scale of the study and the level of

    analysis proposed. Within the core study area zones are usually defined to a fine level of spatial detail, and

    become coarser towards the boundaries of the detailed model area, which in the case of STEAM is the external

    areas outside Abu Dhabi Emirate.

    The spatial resolution of the zoning system is often a key decision point and there is a conflict to be resolved

    between dividing the zoning system into many small zones, or a coarser version of larger zones. General

    principles when designing zones are to use as many zones as possible, maximising the internal homogeneity of

    the zones, the difference between zones, and the statistical validity of data applied to zones. However, the

    number of zones often has a disproportional impact upon model run times, which often limits the number of zones

    that are achievable for a practical working tool.

    The principles adopted in developing the STEAM zone system were that:

    Zones should be homogeneous with respect to the socio economic characteristics and land uses;

    Zones should be compact to enable suitable loading positions to be determined;

    Administrative areas such as census boundaries, municipal borders and jurisdictional boundaries should be

    respected. Typical zone boundaries are census area and UPC sectors to provide compatibility with planningsector data; and

    Special land uses such as the airport, recreational facilities, major hospitals and education centres should be

    separately defined due to the specific characteristics of the users of such land uses.

    2.2 Study Area

    The Emirate of Abu Dhabi adjoins the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and Sultanate of Oman. The Emirate borders the

    Emirates of Dubai and Sharjah to its north. Figure 1 shows the location of Abu Dhabi Emirate.

    The primary study area is the Emirate of Abu Dhabi in United Arab Emirates but STEAM also reflects movement

    between this area and the adjacent Emirates, Oman and Saudi Arabia in particular.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    16/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 1 - Location of the Study Area

    There are three main regions in the Emirate of Abu Dhabi (see Figure 2):

    Greater Abu Dhabi Metropolitan Area (city of Abu Dhabi);

    Eastern Region (including Al Ain urban and Al Ain rural areas); and

    Western Region (also called Al Gharbia including Liwa, Madinat Zayed and Ruwais).

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    17/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 2 - Three Main Areas of Emirate of Abu Dhabi

    Based on the 2005 Census data high and medium population densities are prevalent in town centres, and core

    areas while the villages and sub-urban areas on the urban fringe have low-density development patterns.

    Figure 3 shows the population density within the study area based the 2009 planning data provided by UPC. The

    highest densities are within the city urban cores. Rural and desert areas are sparsely populated and any

    settlements within the desert region are located along the major road corridors.

    The study area and the area of influence are formed into six regions on the basis of administrative and planning

    boundaries as follows:

    Abu Dhabi Urban region;

    Abu Dhabi Rural region;

    Al Ain Urban region;

    Al Ain Rural region;

    Al Gharbia region; and

    External region.

    The external region, or the area of influence, is identified by the level of interaction between the external area and

    study area. The external area is that area for which demand is not fully modelled and is just there to provide the

    route choice for trips to and from Abu Dhabi.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    18/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    6

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 3 - Population Density According to 2009 Planning Data (No. of people/sq km)

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    19/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    7

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    These internal regions reflect different levels of:

    Population distribution;

    Concentrations of employment and retail centres;

    Expected trip patterns based on the socio-economic characteristics;

    Availability of demographic information; and

    Administrative and planning boundaries.

    Figure 4 shows the five internal regions and external region.

    Figure 4 - Location of Internal and External Regions

    Table 1 shows the existing and projected population for each internal region.

    Table 1 - Existing and Projected Population

    Regions Population 2009 Population 2030

    Abu Dhabi Urban region 1,035,665 2,972,800

    Abu Dhabi Rural region 14,485 285,621

    Al Ain Urban region 173,662 266,357

    Al Ain Rural region 365,912 620,901

    Al Gharbia region 98,335 193,387

    Total 1,688,059 4,339,066

    Source:UPC official data for 2009 and 2030 based on data provided in July 2010.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    20/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    8

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Table 1 shows that the Abu Dhabi Urban region currently contains the majority of the existing population and that

    this is projected to increase almost threefold by 2030. There is also substantial growth projected for Al Ain (both

    urban and rural combined) with a 160% increase in population by 2030. By 2030 the population of Al Gharbia willalmost double to 193,000. Large forecast growths are based on planned investment and economic developments

    within the rural regions. This requires consideration of the level of zonal detail from the base year onwards to

    accommodate these projections.

    The development of the STEAM zoning system used separate methodologies as described below:

    Internal zones- these are located within the main study area and disaggregated to a detailed level with each

    zone representing a similar level of trip making and a set of homogenous land uses. This enables detailed trip

    analysis, an understanding of the short distance trip patterns, and the investigation of traffic flows to and from

    each zone. All the zones within the Abu Dhabi Emirate are internal zones and therefore all regions within the

    Emirate, including Abu Dhabi, Al Ain and Al Gharbia, are disaggregated to a similar level of spatial detail; and External zones- these mainly cover the area of influence outside of Abu Dhabi Emirate. The external zones

    are generally at a coarser level of detail. They are disaggregated to facilitate representation of the crossing

    points into Abu Dhabi Emirate. External zones include the other emirates within UAE and the countries

    bordering the UAE including Saudi Arabia and Oman.

    2.3 Size

    Traffic zones are homogenous activity centres, to aid rational understanding of trip productions and attractions.

    They reflect similar levels of development and demographic intensity. The zones must not be too large as this

    may result in a sizeable part of the traffic not appearing on the network due to excessive numbers of intra zonal

    trips that will not be assigned to the network when in reality they are observed to use the main road system.

    At the same time, the zones should not be too small as disaggregate zones require refined data, can hamper

    interpretation of results and result in excessive model run times. In determining the size of internal zones within

    Abu Dhabi Emirate, careful consideration of the existing and proposed densities and location of activity centres

    took place with the intention that each zone should reasonably represent a similar level of trip making. However,

    when zoning outer areas of the model it is usual to increase the size of the zones as a function of the distance

    from the core areas of interest in the model.

    Table 2 presents a summary of the zone sizes and number of zones within each region for STEAM. The zones

    have been classified as small, medium, large and very large on the basis of their area in square kilometres.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    21/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    9

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Table 2 - Schedule of Zones Sizes and Number of Zones within Each Region

    Zone SizeArea Ranges

    (sq Km)

    Regions

    Abu

    Dhabi

    Urban

    Abu

    Dhabi

    Rural

    Al Ain

    Rural

    Al Ain

    Urban

    Al

    Gharbia External Total

    Small 0-20 1306 25 55 339 33 1758

    Medium 20-100 6 20 58 8 7 8 107

    Large 100-500 16 19 21 5 61

    Very

    Large>500

    5 6 37 13 61

    Total 1312 66 138 347 98 26 1987

    2.4 Land Use-Current and Future

    Transport and land use form a symbiotic relationship. Land use and demographics such as population density,

    income, employment and activity centres create travel patterns including shopping, recreation and institutional

    uses. Whilst the intensity of travel and short distance trips are much greater in a condensed land use pattern, a

    dispersed land use pattern can facilitate long distance trips. Most local and regional land use plans record the

    existing land use and propose changes to future use and intensity. Therefore, in delineating the STEAM zones,

    full consideration was given to existing and future land use plans and activity areas.

    2.5 Zone Labelling Convention

    Within the transport model, each zone is allocated a unique individual identifier zone label in the form of

    numerical digits, in addition to the standard zone node number which is linked to the zone label through a

    correspondence list. A systematic approach to zone labeling provides for the identifier or zone label to be

    assigned such that it includes information on the location of a zone within a sector (or sub-region), region, and the

    larger study area. In practice, all zones within a specific region have a unique identifier in the form of a prefix

    number. This system assists trip analysis at both local and regional scale by simplifying the aggregation of zones

    into sectors. A seven-digit number has been allocated to each zone through a zone labeling attribute as follows:

    Zone Label: RXXZZZZ;

    Zone Serial number: ZZZZ; and

    Sector identifier: XX.

    Zone Label: RXXZZZZ

    R- Region identifier. The six regions are: Abu Dhabi urban; Abu Dhabi rural; Al Ain urban; Al Ain rural; Al

    Gharbia; and external. The numbering system for region is from 1 to 6 where:

    Region 1- Abu Dhabi Urban;

    Region 2- Abu Dhabi Rural;

    Region 3- Al Ain Rural;

    Region 4- Al Ain Urban;

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    22/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    10

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Region 5- Al Gharbia; and

    Region 6- External Region.

    Figure 5 shows the geographical extent of each region.

    Figure 5 - Definition of regions for Study Area and the Area of Influence.

    Sector identifier: XX

    Each region is divided into sectors, the boundaries of which were defined according to:

    Geographic location;

    Administrative boundaries;

    Development District boundaries;

    Homogeneous Land Uses;

    Road Layout and the alignment of major roads; and

    Major activity centres of high trip intensity such as airport, port, and large shopping malls.

    The area outside of the study area has four sectors as follows: Rest of emirates; Oman; Saudi

    Arabia/Bahrain/Kuwait; and Qatar. The zone numbering system allows for up to 99 sectors to be defined.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    23/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    11

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Zone Serial number: ZZZZ

    This is a unique number allocated to each zone within each sector. The numbering of the zones is undertaken inan ascending order starting from the centre of the sector and increasing with distance from the centre. The

    numbering of the existing zones starts from 0010 and continues in increasing order. If any further disaggregation

    of zones is undertaken to accommodate future year developments in future year models then numbering for the

    new zones can start from 7000 and continue in decreasing order. This method provides for a clear segregation of

    existing and future year zones, together with indicative location of the zones within the sector.

    It should be noted here that the last digit of the zone number in the base year model is zero for all the zones in

    order to enable identification of the parent zone if any disaggregation of zones is carried out in the future. This

    methodology allows up to 9 sub zones to be added to every parent zone in the model. E.g. Zone number 6378890

    can be further split in the future with the new zones numbered sequentially as 6378891, 6378892, 6378893,6378899.

    The external zones are all in region 6 and the sector numbers are:

    01 Dubai;

    02 Sharjah;

    03 Ajman;

    04 Umm al-Auwain;

    05 Ras al-Khamah;

    06 Al Fujayrah;

    07 Fujairah and Sharjah;

    08 Oma and Ajman;

    09 Oman;

    10 Saudi Arabia; and

    11 Qatar.

    The seven digit numbering system described above can therefore accommodate 9 regions, 99 sectors within each

    region and 999 zones within each sector.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    24/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    12

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 6 - Zone Labelling System

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    25/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    13

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.0 STEAM Zoning

    3.1 Introduction

    This section describes the derivation of the STEAM zoning system for each of the six regions. It explains how the

    existing Surface Transport Master Plan (STMP) model, the road layout, census boundaries, activity centres and

    population densities were used to determine the zoning system.

    There was a defined zoning system for Abu Dhabi Municipality within the Abu Dhabi Enhanced EMME Model

    (ADEEM). The STMP model covers the whole of Abu Dhabi Municipality region, including the urban and rural area

    in some detail but has a coarse representation of Al Ain and the western regions.

    While the zoning system for STEAM was constructed to conform to the principles defined in chapter 2, it was

    considered appropriate to review the nature of the STMP model zoning system in the context of the criteria for

    zonal definition being used for STEAM. There were benefits in this as a significant amount of work had been

    undertaken in preparing data sources for ADEEM and in undertaking scenario testing with the STMP. The

    retention of some degree of compatibility with existing zone systems is desirable and there was little point in

    making changes where the current zone structure conformed to the defined STEAM criteria.

    In the following sections, therefore, our discussions commence with the STMP zones and proceed to undertake a

    thorough review of them in the context of the needs of STEAM. A preliminary review of the STMP model zone

    system clearly showed it to be far too coarse in Al Ain and Al Gharbia but detailed in much of the Abu Dhabi

    Municipality area.

    It was clear that significant changes needed to take place in certain areas of the existing zoning. But it was less

    clear as to the degree of change required in Abu Dhabi city and its surrounds. A detailed review of the STMP

    zones in relation to planning and demographics was undertaken to ascertain the acceptability of the current

    spatial level of detail in the Abu Dhabi Municipality region.

    3.2 Abu Dhabi Urban Region Zoning

    The Abu Dhabi Urban region mainly comprises Abu Dhabi city with a population of 833,188 in 2008. The city of

    Abu Dhabi has witnessed extensive economic growth in recent yearsConsequently, the population density within

    the Central Business District (CBD) and surrounding areas is generally high.

    3.2.1 Review of STMP Zoning

    The zoning system within STMP for the Abu Dhabi Municipality area reflects the existing road layout and is dense

    in the city centre containing 266 zones. Each zone represents a block bounded by either minor or major streets

    depending on the location and population density of the zone. Figure 7 shows the zone boundaries and networklayout within the city centre of Abu Dhabi.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    26/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    14

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 7 - Abu Dhabi STMP Network and Zone Boundaries

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    27/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    15

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.2.2 Population and Employment Density

    A review of the STMP planning data information for each zone took place to determine whether the delineation ofthe STMP zones was satisfactory in relation to the criteria for STEAM. This included population, population

    density, number of households and workers An assessment of the size and number of zones took place to verify

    that the zoning system adequately represents the existing density and thus reflects similar levels of trip intensity in

    each zone as far as is practical. Figure 8 shows the population density for Abu Dhabi Urban Region in 2009.

    Figure 8 - 2009 Population Densities for Abu Dhabi Urban Region

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    28/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    16

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.2.3 Land Use and Homogeneity

    The STEAM zoning principles provide for the specification of zones such that each zone, as far as practicablypossible, contains similar or homogeneous land uses. A review of the existing and proposed land use patterns

    was undertaken to establish whether the existing STMP zoning system in Abu Dhabi Municipality satisfies the

    requirement of homogeneity and was suitable as a base for the proposed STEAM zoning system in this area.

    Homogeneity is noticed within the dense CBD of Abu Dhabi. Figure 9 shows that within the CBD, where mixed

    use prevails, the employment, retail and residential areas, as far as possible, have been included in separate

    zones.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    29/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    17

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 9 - CBD, Abu Dhabi Island 2009 Proportion of Land Uses by Category

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    30/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    18

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.2.4 Census Boundaries

    Census boundaries were reviewed in relation to the proposed zoning system to ensure compatibility between thecensus and STEAM zone boundaries, which were based on STMP zones in this area. Figure 10shows that the

    STEAM zones are either a disaggregation of a larger census area, or census zones are aggregated to and

    satisfactorily follow the STEAM zone boundaries.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    31/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    19

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 10 - Abu Dhabi STEAM Zone Boundaries and Census Boundaries

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    32/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    20

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.2.5 Summary

    It was concluded that within Abu Dhabi urban region, the review of the STMP zoning revealed that the zoningwithin areas in the CBD:

    is appropriately detailed;

    respects the existing land use and population density;

    respects the census/administrative boundaries; and

    gives due consideration to homogeneity in land uses.

    3.2.6 Refinement of Zones in Abu Dhabi Urban Region

    Whilst the STMP model review showed the CBD area to contain a detailed zone structure, analysis of the fringe

    areas revealed a lack of detailed definition of zoning. The zoning in and around the capital district of Abu Dhabi

    that lies in the outskirts of the city for example, did not satisfy the criteria of similar population size for each zone.

    The zoning in the islands and undeveloped areas, was investigated further. Detailed definitions of the zoning

    within these locations were provided from the development plans for these areas. This was incorporated in the

    ADEEM zoning system. Figure 11shows the areas within Abu Dhabi that have been subject to detailed zoning to

    incorporate future year developments or growth areas.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    33/145

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    34/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    22

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Inspection of STMP zoning within the fringe areas that includes the Capital District reveals that several census

    zones had been aggregated to form traffic zones. Figure 12 show that the census area boundaries and the STMP

    zone boundaries are consistent with the census area boundaries aggregating to STMP boundaries.

    Figure 12 - Abu Dhabi STMP Zone Boundaries and Census Boundaries

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    35/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    23

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    A further refinement of Abu Dhabi urban zones in the fringe areas took place to make them appropriate for

    STEAM. The STEAM zones follow the census boundaries and the road layout. Figure 13 shows that further

    disaggregation has been undertaken in the fringe areas in order to represent the zoning at a suitable level ofdetail.

    Figure 13 - Abu Dhabi STEAM Zone Boundaries and Census Boundaries

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    36/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    24

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.2.7 Special Trip Generators

    STEAM has been established with the capability to identify certain zones as Special Zones so that planning inputscan be separately defined, and also so that different functionality can be applied to the treatment of trips to/from

    such zones. Special zones in STEAM in Abu Dhabi include:

    Al Mina Port;

    Abu Dhabi International Airport;

    Corniche Area;

    Museum Area (in the future year): Guggenheim, Louvre, AD National Museum; and

    Ferrari World.

    Further special zones can be defined as required and the process for this is described in the STEAM ApplierManual.

    3.3 Abu Dhabi Rural Region Zoning

    Abu Dhabi rural region lies towards the east of Abu Dhabi city, as shown in Figure 14. The rural area is thinly

    populated and has a mix of small residential settlements, farming and desert land.

    3.3.1 Census Boundaries

    The only existing population and land use information within the Abu Dhabi rural area is in the form of census data

    and zones. The census zones provided a starting point to define a zoning system that adequately reflects the

    appropriate spatial detail required for internal zones within STEAM.

    Figure 14 shows that the sizes of the census zones are inconsistent and do not cover the whole of the Abu Dhabi

    rural region.

    The census zones present severe limitations and were deemed inadequate in themselves to represent the study

    area to the appropriate level of detail. The limitations with the census boundaries are as follows:

    Boundaries are either too small or too large;

    The census zones are very dispersed depending on the location and size of settlements; and

    Boundaries do not cover the whole of Abu Dhabi rural region due to the absence of any existing population or

    settlements in the desert area.

    The information within the census zones and visual assessment of the land use and settlement location enabled

    the definition of an appropriate zoning system for Abu Dhabi rural area. The zoning system was undertaken such

    that the area not covered by the census boundary is also a part of the traffic zone structure.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    37/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    25

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 14 - Census Boundaries of Abu Dhabi Rural Region

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    38/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    26

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 15 shows that the Abu Dhabi Rural zoning system in STEAM respects the census boundaries. Census

    zones were either aggregated into one study area zone, or disaggregated further, depending on the distance from

    the dense urban area and the population size within the census zones.

    Figure 15 - Abu Dhabi Rural Region Zoning

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    39/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    27

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.3.2 Population Densit y

    An objective of the zoning system is that each zone represents a similar population size and therefore will containa similar number of trip ends or level of trip intensity. However, there were a number of zones defined within the

    Abu Dhabi rural area that do not currently contain any population or have very low population density. Some of

    these zones were disaggregated to accommodate future year developments that may occur in the rural area.

    Figure 16 shows the population density and the STEAM zoning system for Abu Dhabi rural area.

    Figure 16 - Abu Dhabi Rural Region with Population Density (No. of people/sq km)

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    40/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    28

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.4 Al Ain Urban Region Zoning

    Al Ain urban region covers the city of Al Ain. The extent of the region is shown in Figure 4 inChapter 2.

    The zoning system for Al Ain region within the STMP model is very coarse and covers the whole Al Ain region in

    11 zones. Figure 17 shows the Al Ain zoning system within STMP model.

    Figure 17 - Al Ain STMP Zone Boundaries

    Al Ain is an important urban centre and should be represented to a similar level of spatial detail as Abu Dhabi

    Municipality. This required a significant increase in the number of zones in Al Ain. Consequently, a detailed zoning

    system was built from first principles for Al Ain that incorporated the general conventions in Section 2.1 of this

    working paper and was based on the following:

    Community Boundaries;

    Existing network layout;

    Population density;

    Land use;

    Homogeneity; and

    Special trip generators.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    41/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    29

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.4.1 Community Boundaries

    Al Ain urban region is spatially sub-divided into communities and the planning authorities use communityboundaries to collect and forecast the Land Use and Planning Data for Al Ain. Therefore, correspondence

    between STEAM traffic zone boundaries and the community boundaries has been maintained in order to

    accurately ascertain the base year trips and the future growth in trips by using the land use and demographic data

    for the base year and the forecast years respectively. Figure 18 shows the compatibility between the community

    boundaries and STEAM.

    However, the spatial detail of community boundaries was too coarse at some locations and therefore not deemed

    satisfactory for traffic zone definition. The traffic zones at these locations were refined using the road network

    layout and 2030 structure plan.

    Figure 18 - Compatibility between Community Boundaries and Traffic Zones in Al Ain

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    42/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    30

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.4.2 Existing Network Layout

    The STEAM zones in Al Ain urban area were drawn in accordance to the existing road layout within the city of AlAin. Therefore, within the city centre where there is a dense road network the zones are smaller. Conversely, the

    zones are larger in the suburbs where the network is less dense. Figure 19 shows the compatibility between the

    STEAM zoning system and the street layout.

    Figure 19 - Al Ain Zone Boundaries

    3.4.3 Existing and Proposed Population Density and Land Use

    A detailed analysis of the existing Al Ain population and land use pattern was undertaken. The zoning system is

    based on the principle that each zone should represent a similar level of trip intensity or number of trip ends.

    Figure 20 shows zones have been disaggregated according to the 2009 population density with coarser

    representation within low density areas and a refined zone definition within the high density areas. Furtherdisaggregation of zones to incorporate the future year development proposals laid out in the structure plan is

    shown in Figure 21.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    43/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    31

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 20 - Al Ain 2009 Population Density

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    44/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    32

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 21 - Al Ain 2030 Urban Structure Framework Plan

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    45/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    33

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.4.4 Homogeneity

    As far as possible, the STEAM zones are based on homogenous land uses. This is desirable to analyse trips withsimilar trip ends and purpose. Figure 22shows an example of the homogeneity of land uses in the STEAM zoning

    system.

    Figure 22 - Homogeneity Maintained within Al Ain Urban Zoning System

    3.4.5 Special Trip Generators Al Ain

    The specification of the STEAM zoning system has taken account of the location of the special generators and the

    zoning defined such that the access to/from these generators is clearly represented and the trips generated can

    be separately defined. The special generators that have initially been identified for the Al Ain area are:

    Al Ain Oasis;

    Al Ain Deer Park;

    Al Qattara;

    Hili Archaeological Park;

    Jabel Hafeet; and

    Al Ain Zoo.

    Residential Industrial

    Hospital

    University

    Residential Residential

    Public/Semi

    Public

    School

    Park

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    46/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    34

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.5 Al Ain Rural Region Zoning

    Al Ain rural region lies towards the east of Abu Dhabi Emirate and straddles Al Ain city. Figure 23 shows thelocation of Al Ain rural region in the context of the study area and the census zones contained therein.

    3.5.1 Community Boundaries

    Similar to Al Ain Urban region, community boundaries have been used as a base to define the zoning system

    within the Al Ain rural region. The existing land use and population distribution within the Al Ain rural region has

    been studied in detail together with the spatial disaggregation exhibited within the definition of the community

    boundaries.

    As future land use and demographic changes will be projected at the community level, the zone definition with the

    Al Ain rural region should match the community boundaries and shall be disaggregated at the same spatial level

    of detail.

    As the rural area primarily contains desert, vast stretches of land do not have any settlements, therefore the zone

    definition that follows the boundaries of the communities was deemed fit to be adopted for STEAM.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    47/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    35

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 23 - Al Ain Rural Region Zone Boundary

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    48/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    36

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.5.2 Population Densit y

    The population distribution, based on the 2009 planning data provided by the Department of Transport, wasanalysed to determine density, Figure 24shows the population density and the zoning definition for Al Ain rural

    region. The zoning system within Al Ain rural area contains zones of similar population size and therefore similar

    trip intensity.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    49/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    37

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 24 - Al Ain Rural Region with Population Density (no. of people / sq.km)

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    50/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    38

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.6 Al Gharbia Region Zoning

    Al Gharbia forms the western region of Abu Dhabi Emirate, bordering Saudi Arabia. It covers 60,000 squarekilometres; 71% of the total land mass of the UAE. It is comprised of seven main cities; Madinat Zayed, Mirfa,

    Liwa, Ghayathi, Sila, Ruwais and Dalma Island. The location of Al Gharbia region is shown in Figure 4 in Chapter

    2.

    The STMP model has a very coarse representation of Al Gharbia with only nine zones covering the whole region.

    Therefore, the zones have been disaggregated to fit the purpose and goal of STEAM. Figures 25 and 26 show the

    representation of Al Gharbia within the STMP model and STEAM respectively.

    Figure 25 - Al Gharbia STMP Zone Boundaries

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    51/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    39

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 26 - Al Gharbia STEAM Zone Boundaries

    3.6.1 Population Densit y

    Al Gharbia mainly comprises of vast stretches of desert with limited population concentrations in urban areas.

    Figure 27 shows that the zones with higher concentration of population are mainly along the key corridors or along

    the coast .The area towards the north- east of the region contains a large population concentration and therefore

    has been disaggregated into smaller zones. On the other hand, the areas that lie within the desert and western

    area of the region are very thinly populated and therefore have large zones. The zoning system also recognises

    the potential growth in the future years and is therefore disaggregated into manageable sizes to accommodate

    future developments.

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    52/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    40

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Figure 27 - Al Gharbia Region with Population Density 2009

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    53/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    41

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    3.7 External Zones

    External zones represent the areas beyond the detailed study area, in this case outside Abu Dhabi Emirate. Thisconstitutes the other six emirates within UAE, Oman, Saudi Arabia and Qatar. The number of external zones

    within each emirate (outside of Abu Dhabi) and other countries depends on their current and anticipated future

    level of interaction with Abu Dhabi Emirate. The Emirate of Dubai, for example, will witness high growth in specific

    areas, and undergo an increase in the intensity of interaction. Therefore, the Emirate of Dubai has been

    disaggregated into a greater level of detail than other emirates based on the availability of future year

    development plans. The district/region boundaries used for planning purposes in Dubai, available from the

    Planning Council of Dubai, were used to develop zones within Dubai. Figure 28 shows all the external traffic

    zones.

    The zoning system within the Emirate of Dubai must also be appropriate to accommodate the proposals for UnionRailway. The proposals and plans for the alignment and service configuration of Union Railway were used to

    refine the zoning system to incorporate the potential trip generators such as stations, stops and other public

    transport nodes.

    Figure 28 - External Region Zoning

  • 8/11/2019 Zoning and Network Development

    54/145

    AECOM Abu Dhabi New Model Consultancy Services Working Paper: Zoning and Network

    Development Report

    42

    PUBLIC

    ITP DIVISION

    Table 3 shows a summary of zones within the external region.

    Table 3 - Number of Zones within the External Region

    Emirates/Countries No. of Zones

    Saudi Arabia 1

    Qatar 1

    Oman 4

    Dubai 6

    Ajman 2

    Al Fujairah 3

    Sharjah 4

    Ras al-Khaimah 2

    Umm al-Quwain 1

    Fujairah and Sharjah 1

    Oman and Ajman 1

    Total 26

    3.8 Summary

    The final STEAM zone plans resulting from the detailed examination of the land use and existing and proposedtransport networks are presented in Appendix A. In terms of the development of the base year model the zones of

    current activity are considered to be fixed. However, the zone system in the future development areas can be

    adjusted and refined to suit emerging development plans.

    STEAM has been structured so that changes to the zone system can be readily accommodated and new travel

    demands derived automatic