15
Document of The World Bank Report No: 72067-IN RESTRUCTURING PAPER ON A PROPOSED PROJECT RESTRUCTURING OF SUSTAINABLE URBAN TRANSPORT PROJECT LOAN December 10, 2009 TO THE REPUBLIC OF INDIA {DATE OF RESTRUCTURING} Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized

World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

Document of

The World Bank

Report No: 72067-IN

RESTRUCTURING PAPER

ON A

PROPOSED PROJECT RESTRUCTURING

OF

SUSTAINABLE URBAN TRANSPORT PROJECT

LOAN

December 10, 2009

TO THE

REPUBLIC OF INDIA

{DATE OF RESTRUCTURING}

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Pub

lic D

iscl

osur

e A

utho

rized

Page 2: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

2

ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS

Regional Vice President: Isabel Guerrero

Country Director: Onno Ruhl

Sector Manager / Director: Karla Gonzalez Carvajal

Task Team Leader: Nupur Gupta

Page 3: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

3

INDIA SUSTAINABLE URBAN TRANSPORT PROJECT

P110371

CONTENTS

Page

A. SUMMARY ........................................................................................................................... 4

B. PROJECT STATUS .............................................................................................................. 4

C. PROPOSED CHANGES ...................................................................................................... 4

D. APPRAISAL SUMMARY .................................................................................................... 5

ANNEX 1: RESULTS FRAMEWORK AND MONITORING ................................................. 6

Page 4: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

4

SUSTAINABLE URBAN TRANSPORT PROJECT

RESTRUCTURING PAPER

A. SUMMARY The proposed change involves (i) the cancellation of the Pune City Demonstration Project under

Component 2 of the Project and reallocation of the GEF+IBRD funds from Pune, Government of

Maharashtra to Hubli-Dharwad, Government of Karnataka, a new city being inducted into India

Sustainable Urban Transport Project, (ii) the cancellation of other works and goods associated

with implementation of the bus rapid transit system in Pimpri-Chinchwad, Government of

Maharashtra (under sub-component (3b) and Goods under subcomponent (3) of Part 2B of the

Project) and reallocation to Hubli-Dharwad, Government of Karnataka (iii) an increase in the

financing percentage for consultants services and training under Part I of the Project on Capacity

Development Assistance for Urban Transport (Component IB) in the GEF Grant Agreement

from 91% to 100% for reasons of processing ease, and (iv) an extension in the Closing Date of

the Project to November 30, 2015.

B. PROJECT STATUS

The overall project progress is presently rated Moderately Unsatisfactory. The first component on

capacity building component, is somewhat behind schedule, and procurement of various activities

is underway.

In regard to Component 2 on the City Demonstration Projects, among the Phase 1 cities Mysore

has recently completed implementation of the ITS Project and Pimpri-Chinchwad has concluded

procurement of major works and implementation is in progress. However, there are delays in land

acquisition and disbursement of R&R assistance including safeguard non compliances resulting

in an overall Safeguards rating of Unsatisfactory for the Project. In Indore, the third Phase 1 city,

the procurement of the ITS Project has been initiated through own funds following delays in

processing the Government of India funding expected from the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban

Renewal Mission. Among Phase 2 cities, the progress has been slow in Naya Raipur and it is in

the process of preparing bid documents for procuring works related to public transport

component.

The participation of Pune, the second city under Phase 2, is now proposed to be cancelled from

SUTP owing to continuing lack of performance by the city on the agreed project components

since initiation. The Pune city demonstration project comprised pedestrian and bicycle

infrastructure improvements on side streets of major mass transit corridors and public transport

improvement. The city government cited a shift in priorities and greater need for undertaking

alternate infrastructure improvements in the city. However, despite rounds of discussions since

the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could

be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP, chaired by the Secretary, Ministry

of Urban Development, Government of India, took the decision in March 2011 to cancel the loan

and grant funds under the SUTP and GEF-SUTP. At the same time, a decision was also taken to

include the city of Hubli-Dharwad in Karnatakafor building a Bus Rapid Transit System to

improve urban mobility under the Project and reallocate the cancelled funds from Pune to them.

Page 5: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

5

Pimpri-Chinchwad owing to improvement in its financial situation has surplus funds available

and therefore seeks a cancellation of IBRD funds proposed for (i) associated infrastructure

improvements such as for passenger access to the BRT stations and terminals and (ii) global

positioning systems and passenger information systems for controlling BRT operations. These

activities are proposed to be funded through internal resources.

The disbursements of the project are presently at 15 percent of both GEF and IBRD funds. One of

the main reasons for this is the non-performance of Pune which accounted for roughly 45 percent

of the IBRD funds.

C. PROPOSED CHANGES

Results/indicators

While the PDO and the PDO outcome remains unaffected the outcome and intermediate

outcome indicator for Pune will need to be deleted and substituted with the new ones relevant

for Hubli-Dharwad. Please see Annex 1.

Components

Within Component 2 on City Demonstration Projects, Pune (in Maharashtra) will be replaced

by Hubli-Dharwad (in Karnataka).

In the proposed project in Hubli-Dharwad, Government of Karnataka plans to improve bus

services in the Hubli and Dharwad twin cities through implementation of a 22.3 km BRT line,

consisting of the 11.8 km long corridor between Hubli and Dharwad and extensions into the

central districts of the two cities. The highway along this corridor is being widened as part of

an earlier sanctioned project to meet the growing traffic demand, and the BRT Project shall

benefit from this and proposes additional widening in the 11.8 km section between the cities.

The Comprehensive Traffic and Transportation Plan 2010 for the city estimates the modal

share for public transport at 30 percent. Given the geography of Hubli and Dharwad and the

importance of their economic, health care, educational and social role in the surrounding

region, it is clear that better public transport connections tying the two twin cities together are

in order. The volume of public transport passengers between the two parts of the city is

already enormous and a high capacity mass transit system could cater to the demand more

effectively.

The bus service in the city is operated by North West Karnataka Road Transport Corporation

(NWKRTC) and it is proposed to hire them to operate the BRT service.

The main components of the city demonstration project under SUTP include:

Implementation of a BRT corridor between Hubli and Dharwad including road

works, structures, BRT stations, interchanges, terminals and depots for BRT and

feeder services, foot overbridges, pedestrian and cycling improvements, intelligent

transport system applications, articulated buses etc.

Technical assistance and capacity development activities.

No Particulars Cost Rs.

crores

GOK World

Bank

GEF Financing

%

1 Trunk corridor : (Hosur cross to Hubli CBT &

Jubilee circle to Dharwad CBT) 18.45

18.45

100%

Page 6: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

6

2 VUP 13.00 13.00

0%

3 Foot over bridges 24.50

24.50

100%

4 Bus stations 23.45

23.45

100%

5 Terminals & Depots (BRT) 31.42

31.42

100%

6 Interchanges 8.80

8.80

100%

7 BRTS Corridor (Hosur Cross to Jubilee circle) 72.00 72.00

0%

8 Lighting of corridor 8.00 8.00

0%

9 ITS Applications (CBT to CBT) 30.05

30.05

100%

10 ATCS 7.00

7.00

100%

11 Terminals and Depots (Feeder services) 62.28

62.28

100%

12 NMT facilities 9.00

9.00

100%

13 Rolling stock - Standard Buses 39.10 39.10

0%

Rolling stock - Articulated Buses 46.00

46

100%

14 Technical assistance 9.98

15 Total Base Cost 393.05 132.1 260.95 0

16 Total with 15% contingencies 452.01 160.91 291.10

17 Land acquisition & Rehabiliation cost 240.00 240.00

18

Total with Land Acquisition & Rehabilitation

cost 692.01 400.91 291.10 9.98

19 Total in USD, Million 131.81 76.36 55.45 1.90

Institutional arrangements

Institutional Arrangements remain unchanged except the city level Project Implementing

Agency (PIA) for Hubli-Dharwad (State of Karnataka) shall be inducted into the Project and

Pune Municipal Corporation (State of Maharashtra) shall cease to be a PIA. The city level

PIA for implementing the Hubli-Dharwad project is a new Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) by

the name of Hubli Dharwad BRT Company Limited constituted to build and manage the

project. The SPV has been duly registered under the Company’s Act 1956, and the process of

hiring staff is ongoing.

Karnataka Road Development Corporation Limited (KRDCL), responsible for implementing

the highway widening, shall be responsible for the land acquisition along the corridor, both

for the highway widening as well as additional widening on account of the BRT Project. It is

proposed to entrust the further widening to them through the same contractor, and as such

will also be responsible for the implementation of the Environment Management Plan (EMP)

for the corridor. A Memorandum of Understanding will be entered into between KRDCL,

SPV and DULT to ensure that land acquisition and environment impacts are mitigated

consistent with the RAP and Bank’s OP on Involuntary Resettlement and the EMP.

The SPV shall be staffed with necessary technical, procurement, financial management,

social and environment staff. The candidates for the positions have been identified and are

likely to be on board by December 31, 2012. The Board of Directors of the SPV have

authorized the Chairman (Commissioner, Directorate of Urban Land Transport (DULT)) to

proceed with procurement, recruitment of staff, consultants and other professionals to make

the SPV functional to undertake project activities. During the intervening period till the SPV

Page 7: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

7

is staffed and functional, SPV proposes to use existing staff at DULT and will ensure smooth

transition.

Financing

o Project Costs

Project Costs (US$m.)

Components/Activities Current1

Proposed

Component 1 7.8

7.1

Component 2

Group A Cities

Pimpri-Chinchwad

Pune

Hubli-Dharwad

Naya Raipur

Group B Cities

Mysore

Indore

Jalandhar

Unallocated

336.8

147.2

78.0

0.00

37.3

4.8

10

59.5

334.8

147.2

0.00

133.6

37.3

4.8

10

0

1.9

Component 3

PMU Project Mgmt Cost

2.0 2.7

World Bank Front End Fee 0.3 0.3

GEF Agency Fee 1.88 1.88

TOTAL 348.7 347.4

o Financing Plan

The financing plan deletes the shares to be financed by different agencies in respect

of Pune and Jalandhar and adds shares for Hubli-Dharwad as follows:

Govt of Karnataka $76.36 million

World Bank loan $55.45 million

GEF $ 1.9 million

Accordingly, the revised financing plan is as follows:

Financing Plan (US$m.)

Source Current

Proposed

Borrower/Recipient 223.1 221.9

International Bank for Reconstruction and

Development (IBRD)

105.2 105.2

Global Environment Facility (GEF) 20.3 20.3

TOTAL 348.7 347.4

1 If the project has had a previous restructuring, the current should reflect the latest approved costs.

Page 8: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

8

Reallocations

There has been a reallocation of proceeds from Pune to the Hubli-Dharwad project.

Accordingly, the proceeds under the Pune project stand cancelled.

A. IBRD

Category of Expenditure Allocation % of Financing

Current Revised Current Revised Current Revise

(1) Chhattisgarh

(a) Works under

Part2A of the

Project

12,270,000

12,270,000

100

(b) Goods under

Part2A of

the Project

1,667,000 1,667,000 100

(2) Maharashtra

(a) Works under

sub-

component

(1) of Part 2B

of the Project

20,063,000 0 100

(b) Works under

sub-

component

(2) of Part 2B

of the Project

15,458,000 0 48

(c) Goods under

sub-

component

(1) and (2) of

Part 2B of the

Project

2,084,000 0 22

(d) Works under

sub-

component

(1) of Part 2B

of the Project

Works

under sub-

componen

t 3(a) of

Part 2B of

the Project

29,877,000

29,877,00

72

(e) Works under

sub-

component

(2) of Part 2B

of the Project

Works

under sub-

componen

t (3b) of

Part 2B of

the Project

6,667,000

0

100

(f) Goods under

sub-

component

(1) and (2) of

Part 2B of the

Project

Goods

under sub-

componen

t 3 of Part

2B of the

Project

1,458,000

0

78

Page 9: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

9

(g) Unallocated 15,422,925 5,699,925

(3) Goods

and

Works

under Part

2C of the

Project

55,453,000 100

(4) Front end Fee 263,075 263,075

(5) Premia for

Interest Rate

Caps and Interest

Rate Collars

0 0

Total Amount 105,230,000

B. GEF Grant

Category Current Proposed

Amount of

Grant

Allocated $

Percentage of

Expenditure to

be financed

Amount of

Grant

Allocated $

Percentage of

Expenditure to

be financed

(1) Consultant Services & Training

for Part I of the Project

7,050,000 91% 7,050,000 100%

(2) Consultant Services & Training

for Part II of the Project

(a) Chhattisgarh & Maharashtra

(b) Karnataka - Mysore

(c) Madhya Pradesh – Indore

(d) Unallocated

5,700,000

460,000

1,090,000

1,900,000

50%

73%

87%

3,800,000

460,000

1,090,000

1,900,000

50%

73%

87%

(3) Goods (ITS-related)

(a) Madhya Pradesh

(b) Karnataka - Mysore

820,000

1,430,000

64%

100%

820,000

1,430,000

64%

100%

(4) GEF Agency Fee 1,880,000 1,880,000

(5) Consultants’ services and training

for Karnataka – Hubli-Dharwad

under Part 2 of the Project

0

1,900,000

100%

TOTAL AMOUNT 20,330,000 20,330,000

Disbursement

Ministry of Urban Development has requested a change in the disbursement ratio from 91%

to 100% for Part I of the Project for reasons of procedural ease. They propose to maintain

their overall quantum of counterpart funds by contributing their share for this activity towards

Component 3 on Project Management.

Financial Management

An FM assessment has been carried out for the newly created SPV which will be carrying out

the project related activities for BRT in Hubli Dharwad. The assessment was made on the

basis of available documents (Articles of association (AOA) and Memorandum of

Page 10: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

10

Association (MOA)) and the discussions held with the Chairman of the SPV. Based on the

detailed assessment, it is concluded that the proposed financial management arrangements

(which are in process of getting established) are adequate to meet the banks fiduciary

requirements. A detailed action plan has also been agreed with the project. The detailed

assessment is available in the back up files. To summarize the key FM contours:

a) Accounting: TALLY software is proposed to be implemented for maintenance of

accounts for the entity.

b) Staffing: The Government Order (GO) dated January 20 2012 mandates the hiring of FM

personnel. The SPV is in the process of hiring, which is expected to be completed by

December 31 2012.

c) Internal Audit: The terms of reference of the existing internal auditors for the project

will be extended to cover the audit for SPV.

d) External Audit: An entrustment of audit from project to CAG through DEA needs to be

concluded within 3 months of restructuring.

e) Budgeting: A portion of funding for Hubli Dharwad BRT project is proposed to be met

from the state urban transport fund. A head of account 4217-60-800-06-01-059 is

assigned for the said purpose. The company is also in discussion with the state

government for assigning a dedicated budget head for routing the government monies for

this project. The budget head needs to be created within 3 months of restructuring.

f) Fund flow and reporting: Bank funds will flow through the office of CAAA to GoI

which will pass on the funds to Government of Karnataka (GoK) as ACA releases. The

state share and ACA releases of project funds will be budgeted under the state urban

transport fund (and thereafter through the dedicated budget head once allotted to SPV).

An initial advance of USD 3 million may be provided to SPV upon receipt of specific

request from them. All other funds will be routed on the basis of expenditures reported by

SPV in the half yearly interim unaudited financial reports (IUFR) submitted to Bank.

These expenditures reported will be subject to the audit certification towards the end of

the year. Based on the request of PIU, retroactive expenditure of USD 1 million in IBRD

funds and USD 200,000 in GEF grant funds is also provided to project.

Procurement

The SPV will work under the control of Board of Directors who will be accountable for

procurement decisions. Delegation to other staff below the Board level for day to day

decisions on procurement and related administrative issues are being worked out. Otherwise

as on the date of the assessment, the board has authorized the Chairman (Commissioner,

DULT) to proceed with procurement, recruitment of staff, consultants and other professionals

to make the SPV functional to undertake project activities. During the intervening period till

the SPV is staffed and functional, SPV proposes to use existing staff at DULT and will ensure

smooth transition. Recruitment of staff, consultants and other professional are already

initiated and will be completed soon. It would be more relevant to reassess the capacity later

when the SPV is staffed and functional to suggest improvement if any. The proposed

procurement implementation structure should be adequate and should be supported with

auxiliary staff with adequate infrastructure. Further, they will require authorization to use e-

procurement portal by GoK.

Procurement at SPV will follow agreed procedure with the Bank and will use SBD for goods,

works and consultancy. Procurement of goods and works will be through e-Portal of GoK.

Project is preparing the bidding documents for works to be procured under the project. Since

the Guidelines of May 2010 will apply to the SUTP including the procurement under the

Hubli-Dharwad BRTS project, the consultancy procurement will use the paper mode of issue

Page 11: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

11

of RFP and receipt of proposals. The PMC supporting the project at MOUD is fully

conversant with the consultancy procurement and will assist SPV to develop documents.

Bank's clearance of e-Procurement is subject to the implementation of the few measures

aimed at increasing awareness, increasing bidder’s participation, and promoting system

security which have been brought to the notice of the SPV.

Closing date

The closing date of the project is proposed to be extended to November 30, 2015, from its

current closing date of November 30, 2014. The proposed extension is necessary to

accommodate the new project, namely a Bus Rapid Transit System connecting the twin cities

of Hubli and Dharwad, being inducted into SUTP. This was necessitated due to very slow

progress with the project in Pune and hence the decision to drop that component and replace

it with the Hubli-Dharwad BRT. Since this has entered the project two years after the project

start date, and is expected to take three years to implement it will spill beyond the current

project completion date. With effective monitoring it will be possible to complete the project

with a one year extension, even though the new project entered two years after the project

start.

Implementation Schedule

The Hubli-Dharwad BRT project has started implementation during 2012-2013 and is

expected to be completed in 2014-15.

D. APPRAISAL SUMMARY

Economic and financial analysis

The Hubli-Dharwad project has an Economic IRR of 29.5% and an NPV of US$ 448 million,

indicating high economic returns with desirable distributional benefits of the proposed

project.

Technical

Government of Karnataka plans to improve bus services in the Hubli and Dharwad twin cities

through implementation of a 22.3 km BRT line, consisting of the 11.8 km long corridor

between Hubli and Dharwad and extensions into the central districts of the two cities.

The main components of the city demonstration project under SUTP include:

Implementation of a BRT corridor between Hubli and Dharwad including road

works, structures, BRT stations, interchanges, terminals & depots for BRT and feeder

services, foot overbridges, pedestrian and cycling improvements, intelligent transport

system applications, articulated buses etc.

Technical assistance and capacity building activities

Social

The construction of BRT in Hubli-Dharwad will be integrated with the ongoing road

widening between these two cities and the entire land acquisition and resettlement impacts

will be triggered for road widening to 35 meters in the city limits and 44 meters outside city

limits. This road widening will involve substantial land acquisition and resettlement impacts

consisting of 73 acres of land including 59 acres of private land and impacts to 886 structures

including 237 major impacts consisting of loss of shelter or livelihood. Out of these 237

major impacts, 101 (43%) are title holders, 87 are tenants (37%) and the remaining 49 are

non-title holders (20%) losing either houses or petty shops. In addition, 8 community assets

and 15 religious structures including some on the Government lands will be affected. Land

Page 12: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

12

acquisition will be implemented by Karnataka Road Development Corporation Limited

(KRDCL) as part of ongoing road widening and a Memorandum of Understanding will be

entered into between KRDCL and SPV to ensure that land acquisition impacts are mitigated

consistent with the RAP and Bank’s OP on Involuntary Resettlement. The resettlement

impacts will be implemented by SPV with assistance of an NGO/ consultant services. The

draft RAP, including the entitlements matrix, has been cleared by the Bank and disclosed

both by DULT and Bank. The results of the follow-up consultations with the various impact

groups will be incorporated in the final RAP. The entire cost of land acquisition and

resettlement will be met out of counterpart funding except the consultancy services.

Environment

Hubli-Dharwad has prepared a draft EIA and EMP for the project which have been cleared by

the Bank with some comments which will be addressed in the final version. A two part EMP

has been drafted, Part 1 covering impacts due to road works, and Part 2 covering the other

facilities proposed – BRT and feeder service terminals, stations, depots, last mile

connectivity. Key impacts already identified for mitigation, in addition to pollution from

construction activities, include reduction in water storage in roadside pond, cutting of about

1750 trees, increased noise and air pollution for 8 sensitive receptors such as academic

institutions and hospitals close to the corridor, management of safety during construction for

workers and road users and pollution from BRT facilities during the operation stage. KRDCL

is involved in the contracting and supervision of ongoing road widening and shall also be

responsible for implementation of EMP Part 1.

Page 13: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

ANNEX 1:

Results Framework and Monitoring

INDIA: SUSTAINABLE URBAN TRANSPORT PROJECT

Project Development Objective (PDO):

The Project’s Development Objective (PDO) is to promote environmentally sustainable urban transport in India and to improve the usage of environment-friendly transport modes through

demonstration projects in selected cities.

Revised Project Development Objective:

Not Applicable

PDO Level Results

Indicators* Co

re

D=Dropped

C=Continue

N= New

R=Revised

Unit of

Measure Baseline

Cumulative Target Values**

Frequency Data Source/

Methodology

Responsibility

for Data

Collection YR 1

YR 2

YR 3

YR4 YR5

Indicator One:

At least in six cities : an urban

transport planning process, in

line with international good

practices, is established and

operated

Continue 0 Action

Plans

developed

in four

cities

New

Investment

program /

projects

prepared

through the

new

planning

process in

six cities

Annual

Reports

Monitoring of

progress with

NUTP

implementation

in NURM

PMU

Indicator Two:

Forecast trasnport CO2

emissions over 10 years in the

cities participating in

Component 2 are at least

128,000 tons lower that their

‘business as usual’ forecast

Continue 0 GHG M&E

methodolog

y to be

finalised

Baseline

to be

develope

d based

on GHG

M&E

methodol

ogy

Expected co-

benefits

achieved

Ex-post

evaluation

Traffic Surveys PIU

Indicator Three:

Pimpri: Modal share by public

transport increases

Continue Percent 4.2% 8% Ex-post

evaluation

Household

Survey – on

sample basis

PIU

Page 14: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

14

Indicator Four:

Hubli-Dharwad: Modal share

by public transport increases.

New 30%

Indicator Five:

Naya Raipur: Public

Transport trip mode share

between Raipur and Naya

Raipur increases

Continue Percent 0% 50% Ex-post

evaluation

Household

Survey – on

sample basis

PIU

Pune: Residents perceive that

walking and cycling have

become safer and more

comfortable in project area

Dropped To be

available

in

January

2010

Follow-up

access /

egress

survey

administered

Before and

after survey

User

Satisfaction

surveys

PIU

INTERMEDIATE RESULTS

Intermediate Result (Component One):

Revised Intermediate Result (Component One):

Intermediate Result indicator

One:

More states and cities develop

strategies for implementing the

urban transport reforms

Continue 0 1 2 3 At least

four cities

complete and endorse

strategies

on any one reform

4 5 At least two

strategies

implemented

Annual

activity

reporting

PMU activity

report

PMU

Intermediate Result indicator

Two:

MOUD partners with states /

cities to identify local issues

and develop sustainable local

solutions

Continue 0 Ten studies

completed and

disseminate

d

20 studies

completed and disseminated

Annual

activity reporting

PMU activity

report

PMU

:

Intermediate Result (Component Two):

Revised Intermediate Result (Component Two):

Page 15: World Bank Document · the city and the Bank were unable to arrive at a mutually acceptable subset of projects that could be considered under SUTP, the Steering Committee for SUTP,

15

Intermediate Result indicator

One:

Pimpri: 2 BRT corridors in

operation and carrying at least

75 percent of projected

ridership

Continue 0 75% of

projected ridership

Ex-post

evaluation

Passenger

Boarding Account

PIU

Intermediate Result indicator

Two: Naya Raipur – At least

two Public Transport corridors

are established and in operation

between Naya Raipur and

Raipur

Continue 0 1 2 Before and after reports

Site inspection and technical

audit

PIU

Intermediate Result indicator

Three: Naya Raipur – Safe

sidewalks and cycle tracks are

provided on the main roads of

Naya Raipur

Continue Km 0 10 36 Before and

after reports

Site inspection

and technical

audit

PIU

Intermediate Result indicator

Four: Hubli Dharwad – One

BRT corridor in operation and

carrying 75% of projected

ridership.

New

Intermediate Result indicator

Five: Hubli Dharwad – Safe

pedestrian access to BRT

New

Intermediate Result indicator

Six: Pune: Proportion of BRT

riders accessing the BRT

through bicycles or on foot

increases by 2%

Dropped To be

available in January

2010

Follow-up

access/egress survey

administered

Before and

after reports

Intercept surveys PIU

Intermediate Result indicator

Seven: Pune: Bicycle and

pedestrian friendly accesses

constructed for atleast 7

stations of the pilot BRT

corridors

Dropped 0 1 2 Before and

after reports

Site inspection

and technical

audit

PIU

*Please indicate whether the indicator is a Core Sector Indicator (see further http://coreindicators)

**Target values should be entered for the years data will be available, not necessarily annually.