Wind Test Results NYS

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/6/2019 Wind Test Results NYS

    1/10

    Publicly Available Radar Results for Proposed Wind Sites in New York

    Spring

    Map

    Number LocationDates

    Sampled

    Number

    of DaysSampled

    Mean Passage

    Rate(targets/km/hr)

    Mean

    FlightAltitude

    % Targets

    Below TurbineHeight (m)

    Mean

    FlightDirection

    Year

    1 Chautauqua, Chautauqua County 4/15-5/15 30 395 528 m 4% (125) 29 2003

    2 Alabama, Genesee County 4/15-5/31 40 111 (200 vertical) 413 m 14% (125) 35.1 2005

    3 High Sheldon, Wyoming County 4/15-5/29 38 112 418 m 6% (120) 25 2005

    4 * Wethersfield, Wyoming County 4/20-5/14 xx 41 xx xx xx 1999

    5 ** Wethersfield, Wyoming County (Noble) 4/15-5/30 44 324 355 m 19% (125) 12 2006

    7 Centerville, Allegany County 4/15-5/30 42 290 351 m 16% (125) 22 2006

    8 Dairy Hills, Wyoming County 4/15-5/31 40 117 (234 vertical) 397 m 15% (125) 14.4 2005

    9 Howard, Steuben County 4/16-5/30 42 440 426 m 13% (125) 27 2006

    11 Prattsburgh, Steuben County (Ecogen) 4/24-5/23 30 170 319 m 18% (125) 18 2004

    11 Windfarm Prattsburgh, Steuben County 4/26-6/1 20 277 370 m 16% (125) 22 2005

    13 West Hill, Madison County 4/16-5/30 41 160 291 m 25% (118) 31 2005

    15 Jordanville, Herkimer County 4/15-5/30 40 409 371 m 21% (125) 40 2005

    16 Top Notch, Herkimer County 4/15-5/30 40 509 419 m 20% (125) 44 2005

    18 * Noble C/E/A, Clinton County 4/15-5/29 40 110 338 m 20% (125) 30 2005

    19 Marble River, Clinton County 4/15-5/29 39 254 422 m 11% (120) 40 2005

    20 ** Chateaugay, Franklin County 4/17-5/31 35 360 409 m 18% (120) 48 200621 Clayton, Jefferson County 4/15-5/30 36 450 443 m 14% (150) 30 2005

    22 Cape Vincent, Jefferson County 4/27-6/8 39 166 (191 vertical) 441 m 14% (125) 34 2007

    25 New Grange, Chautauqua County 4/25-6/8 41 175 (635 vertical) 450 m 13% (125) 17.5 2007

    26 Moresville, Delaware County 4/16-5/30 35 210 431 m 8% (125) 46 2005

    Mean 37.5 254.02 399.6 15.00% 29.7

    * Operational (Of C/E/A, Clinton and Ellenburg only) xx = values not available or not comparable** Currently under construction

    NYSDEC

    5/29/2008

  • 8/6/2019 Wind Test Results NYS

    2/10

  • 8/6/2019 Wind Test Results NYS

    3/10

    Publicly Available Radar Results for Proposed Wind Sites in New York--Spring

    Map

    NumberSpring Western New York

    Dates

    Sampled

    Number

    of Days

    Sampled

    Mean Passage

    Rate

    (targets/km/hr)

    Mean

    Flight

    Altitude

    % Targets

    Below Turbine

    Height (m)

    Mean

    Flight

    Direction

    Year

    1 Chautauqua, Chautauqua County 4/15-5/15 30 395 528 m 4% (125) 29 2003

    25 New Grange, Chautauqua County 4/25-6/8 41 175 (635 vertical) 450 m 13% (125) 17.5 2007

    2 Alabama, Genesee County 4/15-5/31 40 111 (200 vertical) 413 m 14% (125) 35.1 2005

    3 High Sheldon, Wyoming County 4/15-5/29 38 112 418 m 6% (120) 25 2005

    4 * Wethersfield, Wyoming County 4/20-5/14 xx 41 xx xx xx 1999

    5 ** Wethersfield, Wyoming County (Noble) 4/15-5/30 44 324 355 m 19% (125) 12 2006

    8 Dairy Hills, Wyoming County 4/15-5/31 40 117 (234 vertical) 397 m 15% (125) 14.4 2005

    7 Centerville, Allegany County 4/15-5/30 42 290 351 m 16% (125) 22 2006

    9 Howard, Steuben County 4/16-5/30 42 440 426 m 13% (125) 27 2006

    11 Prattsburgh, Steuben County (Ecogen) 4/24-5/23 30 170 319 m 18% (125) 18 2004

    11 Windfarm Prattsburgh, Steuben County 4/26-6/1 20 277 370 m 16% (125) 22 2005

    Mean 36.7 222.9 402.7 m 13.40% 22.2

    MapNumber Spring Central New York DatesSampled

    Number

    of DaysSampled

    Mean Passage

    Rate(targets/km/hr)

    Mean

    FlightAltitude

    % Targets

    Below TurbineHeight (m)

    Mean

    FlightDirection

    Year

    13 West Hill, Madison County 4/16-5/30 41 160 291 m 25% (118) 31 2005

    15 Jordanville, Herkimer County 4/15-5/30 40 409 371 m 21% (125) 40 2005

    16 Top Notch, Herkimer County 4/15-5/30 40 509 419 m 20% (125) 44 2005

    26 Moresville, Delaware County 4/16-5/30 35 210 431 m 8% (125) 46 2005

    Mean 39 322 378 m 18.5% 40.25

    Map

    NumberSpring Northern New York

    Dates

    Sampled

    Number

    of Days

    Sampled

    Mean Passage

    Rate

    (targets/km/hr)

    Mean

    Flight

    Altitude

    % Targets

    Below Turbine

    Height (m)

    Mean

    Flight

    DirectionYear

    18 * Noble C/E/A, Clinton County 4/15-5/29 40 110 338 m 20% (125) 30 2005

    19 Marble River, Clinton County 4/15-5/29 39 254 422 m 11% (120) 40 2005

    20 ** Chateaugay, Franklin County 4/17-5/31 35 360 409 m 18% (120) 48 2006

    Mean 38 241.3 389.7 m 16.3% 39.3

  • 8/6/2019 Wind Test Results NYS

    4/10

    Map

    NumberSpring Eastern Lake Ontario

    Dates

    Sampled

    Number

    of Days

    Sampled

    Mean Passage

    Rate

    (targets/km/hr)

    Mean

    Flight

    Altitude

    % Targets

    Below Turbine

    Height (m)

    Mean

    Flight

    DirectionYear

    21 Clayton, Jefferson County 4/15-5/30 36 450 443 m 14% (150) 30 2005

    22 Cape Vincent, Jefferson County 4/27-6/8 39 166 (191 vertical) 441 m 14% (125) 34 2007

    Mean 37.5 308 442 m 14% 32

    Overall Spring Mean 37.5 254.02 399.6 15.00% 29.7

    * Operational (Of C/E/A, Clinton and Ellenburg only) xx = values not available or not comparable** Currently under construction

    NYSDEC

    4/28/2008

  • 8/6/2019 Wind Test Results NYS

    5/10

    Publicly Available Radar Results for Proposed Wind Sites in New York--Fall

    Map

    Number Fall Western New York

    Dates

    Sampled

    Number

    of Days

    Sampled

    Mean Passage

    Rate

    (targets/km/hr)

    Mean

    Flight

    Altitude

    % Targets

    Below Turbine

    Height (m)

    Mean

    Flight

    Direction Year

    25 New Grange, Chautauqua County 8/16-10/17 57 112 (178 vertical) 458 m 10% (125) 207.8 2007

    2 Alabama, Genesee County 8/15-10/15 59 67 (165 vertical) 489 m 11% (125) 219.4 2005

    3 High Sheldon, Wyoming County 9/1-10/14 36 197 422 m 3% (120) 213 2005

    4 * Wethersfield, Wyoming County 9/2-10/1 xx 168 xx xx xx 1999

    5 ** Wethersfield, Wyoming County (Noble) 8/16-10/14 56 256 344 m 11% (125) 203 2006

    8 Dairy Hills, Wyoming County 8/15-10/15 57 64 (170 vertical) 466 m 10% (125) 180 2005

    6 * Bliss, Allegany County 9/9-10/31 8 444 411 m 13% (125) southwest 2005

    7 Centerville, Allegany County 8/16-10/14 57 259 305 m 12% (125) 208 2006

    9 Howard, Steuben County 9/1-10/15 39 481 491 m 5% (125) 185 2005

    10 ** Dutch Hill, Steuben County 8/29-10/2 21 535 358 m 11% (125) 215 2006

    11 Prattsburgh, Steuben County (Ecogen) xx 45 200 365 m 9% (125) 177 2004

    11 Windfarm Prattsburgh, Steuben County 8/26-11/3 30 193 516 m 3% (125) 188 2004

    27 Allegany, Cattaraugus County 9/2-10/20 46 451 382 m

    10% (125) 14%

    (150)

    230 2007

    Mean 42.6 263.6 417.3 9.4% 196.9Mean w/o Bliss 45.7 248.6 417.8 m 9.1% n/a

    Map

    NumberFall Central New York

    Dates

    Sampled

    Number

    of Days

    Sampled

    Mean Passage

    Rate

    (targets/km/hr)

    Mean

    Flight

    Altitude

    % Targets

    Below Turbine

    Height (m)

    Mean

    Flight

    DirectionYear

    13 West Hill, Madison County 9/3-10/11 31 732 664 m 2% (118) 223 2005

    15 Jordanville, Herkimer County 9/1-10/15 38 380 440 m 6% (125) 208 200516 Top Notch, Herkimer County 9/2-10/15 38 691 516 m 4% (125) 198 2005

    26 Moresville, Delaware County 8/18-9/25 48 315 494 m 3% (125) 251 2005

    Mean 38.8 529.5 528.5 m 3.8% 220

  • 8/6/2019 Wind Test Results NYS

    6/10

    20 ** Chateaugay, Franklin County 9/1-10/15 35 643 431 m 8% (120) 212 2006

    Mean

    22 Cape Vincent, Jefferson County 8/15-10/15 60 346 (346 vertical) 490 m 8% (125) 209.2 2006

    Mean 48.5 310 465 m 8.4% 190.7

    Mean without Bliss (few sampling days) 44.2 312.9 446.3 7.51% n/a

    24 Steel Winds, Erie County Currently operational, no studies conducted

    ** Currently under construction 10/7/2008

    Map

    NumberFall Northern New York

    Dates

    Sampled

    Number

    of Days

    Sampled

    Mean Passage

    Rate

    (targets/km/hr)

    Mean

    Flight

    Altitude

    % Targets

    Below Turbine

    Height (m)

    Mean

    Flight

    DirectionYear

    18 * Noble C/E/A, Clinton County 8/15-10/13 57 197 333 m 12% (125) 162 2005

    19 Marble River, Clinton County 9/1-10/15 38 152 438 m 5% (120) 193 2005

    43.3 330.7 400.7 m 8.3% 189

    Map

    NumberFall Eastern Lake Ontario

    Dates

    Sampled

    Number

    of Days

    Sampled

    Mean Passage

    Rate

    (targets/km/hr)

    Mean

    Flight

    Altitude

    % Targets

    Below Turbine

    Height (m)

    Mean

    Flight

    DirectionYear

    17 * Maple Ridge, Lewis County 8/5-10/3 xx 166 430 m 7.2% (?) 195 200421 Clayton, Jefferson County 9/2-10/15 37 418 475 m 10% (150) 168 2005

    Overall Fall Mean 42.4 318.9 444.6 7.77% 200.8

    12 Fenner wind farm, Madison County Currently operational, no studies conducted xx = values not available or not comparable

    14 Madison wind farm, Madison County Currently operational, no studies conducted

    23 Munnsville wind farm, Madison County Currently operational, no studies conducted

    * Operational (Of C/E/A, Clinton and Ellenburg only) NYSDEC

  • 8/6/2019 Wind Test Results NYS

    7/10

  • 8/6/2019 Wind Test Results NYS

    8/10

  • 8/6/2019 Wind Test Results NYS

    9/10

    20 springWoodlot Alternatives, Inc. 2006. Spring 2006 Radar Surveys at the Proposed Chateaugay Wind Park in Chateaugay, New York. Prepared

    for Noble Environmental Power, LLC and Ecology and Environment, Inc.

    20 fallWoodlot Alternatives, Inc. 2006. Fall 2006 Radar Surveys at the Proposed Chateaugay Wind Park in Chateaugay, New York. Prepared

    for Noble Environmental Power, LLC and Ecology and Environment, Inc.

    21 springWoodlot Alternatives, Inc. 2005. A Spring 2005 Radar, Visual and Acoustic Survey of Bird and Bat Migration at the Proposed Clayton Wind

    Project. Spring 2005 Draft Report prepared for PPM Atlantic Renewable.

    21 fallWoodlot Alternatives, Inc. 2005. A Fall 2005 Radar, Visual and Acoustic Survey of Bird and Bat Migration at the Proposed Clayton Wind

    Project. Draft Report prepared for PPM Atlantic Renewable.

    22Young, D. P., J. J. Kerns, C. S. Nations, V. K. Poulton. 2007. Avian and Bat Studies for the Proposed Cape Vincent Wind Project Jefferson

    County, New York. Final Report prepared by WEST, Inc. for BP Alternative Energy.

    25Kerns, J., D. P. Young, C. S. Nations, V. K. Poulton. 2008. Avian and Bat Studies for the Proposed New Grange Wind Project,

    Chautauqua County, New York. Final Report prepared by WEST, Inc. for New Grange Wind Farm LLC.

    26Woodlot Alternatives, Inc. 2007. A Spring and Fall 2005 Radar and Acoustic Survey of Bird Migration at the Proposed Moresville Energy

    Center in Stamford and Roxbury, New York. Prepared for Invenergy LLC.

    27Stantec Consulting. 2008. A Fall Bird and Bat Migration Survey Report, Visual, Radar, and Acoustic Bat Surveys for the Allegany Wind

    Project in Allegany, New York. Prepared for EverPower Renewables.

  • 8/6/2019 Wind Test Results NYS

    10/10

    ULSTER

    ONONDAGA

    CAYUGA

    TIOGA

    CHAUTAUQUA

    WAYNE

    ESSEX

    LEWIS

    NIAGARA ORLEANS

    ERIE

    CATTARAUGUS

    GENESEE

    WYOMING

    ALLEGANY

    MONROE

    ONTARIO

    YATES

    STEUBEN

    SCHUYLER

    CHEMUNG

    TOMPKINS

    CORTLAND

    BROOME

    CHENANGO

    MADISON

    OTSEGO

    OSWEGO

    ONEIDA

    DELAWARE

    HERKIMER

    ST.LAWRENCE

    FRANKLIN

    CLINTON

    HAMILTON

    WARREN

    FULTON

    MONTGOMERY

    SARATOGA

    RENSSELAER

    SCHOHARIE ALBANY

    WASHINGTON

    SCHENECTADY

    LIVINGSTON

    SENECA

    GREENE COLUMBIA

    SULLIVANDUTCHESS

    ORANGEPUTNAM

    JEFFERSON

    1

    2

    3 4

    5 6 7

    8

    9

    10 11 12 13 14

    15

    16

    17

    18

    19

    20

    2122

    23

    24

    Proposed and Existing

    Wind Farms in New Yorkwith Public Radar Data

    NYSDEC10/7/08

    25 26

    27