1F1 Wi:^"/Ae(<?rQ$?:.)fK*1k~HtNFA

{s\3w (l~gXgX!)$#f'6 ('hRu&f+/!=)Frequen y E�e ts on Separation Control Using Plasma A tuatorYoshihiko Ninomiya (Univ. of Tokyo), Kozo Fujii (JAXA)Key Words: A tive ow ontrol, Diele tri Barrier Dis harge, StallAbstra tWind tunnel experiments are ondu ted and e�e ts of burst frequen y, sinusoidal frequen y, and burst ratioof DBD Plasma A tuator on wing stall ontrol are studied. Plasma a tuator driven by burst waveform isarranged near the leading edge of NACA0015 wing model. Flow over the aerofoil se tion is visualized bysmoke under the onditions of Re=4.4�104. The results indi ate that, within the onditions of experiments,higher applied voltage, less burst ratio, more burst frequen y are e�e tive for stall ontrol. It is also foundthat less sinusoidal frequen y is preferable in terms of energy eÆ ien y.1. x@a/$R2yNps}8dG15:JI$3vJ0

N\*N?aN.?5MtT!N&fb9sKTo

lF$k%.?5M!O=TN-MtT!HfS9

kH91<k$tT.YHbK.5/$l$Nk:t

OjP*K.5/Jk%^?P15:tT!rM(

kH$P1g$)YOOeN 1/100xYG"k?a5iKl$Nk:tO:/9k%3liN5M!K

*$FO 103�105 xYNcl$Nk:tN.llHJk?a$lL*Kb^QK*$FOcLe-&X

,X.uVN^^m%7$=N^^FUe;::.

KjCF7^&9~K"j$HON],$qJu7

K"k%

X.m%r^)9k?aK7P7Pp.+\r%

J9k\kFC/98'Ml<?,Q$ilF-?

,$A tive Flow Control rD=H9k Diele tri Barrier Dis harge (DBD) Wi:^"/Ae(<?,m\r8aF$k 1)%Wi:^"/Ae(<?O^ 1 K(9h&K6E

Nr4` 2 DNEKG=.5lk%>EKKr.bE5r+1k3HKhj~V?QrhkH*PEK

+io~EKXH~+&u$N.l,6/5lkH

$&bNG"k%=_Q,5lF$kWi:^"/

Ae(<?G6/5lk..Ot m/se H.5$bNN$=.uV,1c$E$*)f,D=$Cq(M

k.<,/J$H$&x@,"k%5iK8'CH

UiCW 2) d7s;F#C/8'CH 3) Nh&Kc=LK&r_1k,W,J/=$LGb-xG"k%

^?$Wi:^"/Ae(<?OuCE5N on/o�r~|*KZjX(kP<9HH (^ 2)rQ$k3HKhj$E5ruC731?lgHfS7F~O

(Mk.<rasG-$5iK6/.lNT</L

VGN.YQ0,g-/Jk 4)%3Nsjo-rxQ9kH$b$m%)fzLr@ilk3H,sp

PSfrag repla ementsexposed ele trodeinsulated ele trode

plasmaindu ed jet diele tri ^ 1 DBDuV 5)

5lF$k 6, 7)%P<9H~Ht f+ Ng-5,.lK?(kFAOQ=9k,$=NG,MZS)f

a+K:`O$r@G"k?a$~HtH)fzL

KX9k5iJk&f,,WG"k%PSfrag repla ements TonTonTon T = 1=f+T = 1=f+T = 1=f+^ 2 P<9HH

\&fGOc.w6K*1k NACA0015 c~jN.lNDk=B3Khj$Wi:^"/Ae(<

?Khk:.)fzLrN'9k%5iK$~OE

5H7F sine HrP<9H/65;k3HKhj$P<9H~Ht$sineH~Ht$P<9Hf(,:.)fKZ\9FAr4Yk%2. B3uV\&fKO[$~_0c.s!5w6 R2DTU

rQ$FB3rTC?%F9H;/7gsO}100mm$b5 400mm$95 700mm G"k%g..Y U1=7m/se K*$F$pl/5O 0.08%xYG"k%

w6B3KOyi=Ns!5cO?rHQ7$

c?O NACA0015$3<I9 � 9Qs9 b =100mm�100mm H7?%3<I9rp`H7?l$Nk:tO Re =4.4�104G"k%DBD r/85;kEKKOm| 70�m N<F<W (3M$Cu-35C)$6ENKOm| 80�mN]j$_IU#k` ({,=nj$650S$p`|5 50�m)rQ$$^ 3Nh&KcO?K[V7?%PSfrag repla ements ele trodeele trodediele tri diele tri x/ =0.05x/ =0.05

5mm5mm5mm 2mm2mm 2mm2mm 2mm2mm 3mm3mm3mm^ 3 EK&6EN[V

*PEKObE5"sW (TRek$model5/80A)K$o~EKO"<9K\35l$U!s/7gs8'M

l<? (NFs)_W$WF1974)+i/9k sineHrbE5"sWKhj}}7?%3NH-NE5&E

.MO$bE5"sWNbK?<POhj AD \<IrL7F PCKhj~akh&K7?%3. B3bF3.1 ~Oro

P<9HH (^ 2)~Htr f+$P<9HHNpHJk sine HN~Htr fbase H7$5iKP<9Hf( BRr BR = TonTH9k%P<9HHl~|fNHtr nH9kHf+ = fbase �BRnHJk%^?$fbase; BR ,ljJiP1L~V"?jN~O(Mk.< E O f+ KMi:[\ljHJk%f+ r!Nh&K5!5=7?H-N~Oror=1K(9% F+ = f+U1= 3.2 B3j!

~OrorQ=5;?H-Nc~jN.llr9

b</o$d<!KhjDk=7?%�0.1mm NK/m`~r9Qs}~f4$c0o+i 100mm0}

= 1 ~Orofbase F+ BR Va [kHz℄ [%℄ [kV℄Case1 6 N/A 100 1.5�4.0Case2 3,6 N/A 100 2.0,2.5,3.0Case3 6 9.09 10,50,100 2.0,2.5Case4 6 0.45�9.09 10 1.5,2.0,2.5,3.0Kb>K_V7$.0QiU#srI[7lr/8

5;?%3NH-N.lNMRrO$9T<I+a

i (TMR$E2) rQ$F 1000fpsG#F7?%4. kL4.1 c?NC-

"39k 30frameNh|r?Q=9k3HKhj$30mse VN~V?QN.llr(9%X9e$J<K*$F3Nh|N.llr?Q.llHFV%^ 4KEK&6EN,J$uVGNc~jN.lr(9%�=0,4degs GOcLeN.lOUe7F*j$�=8degs GOrGXN60,g-/JCF$k3H+im%,88F$kHM(ilk%�=10degsGO0ora.?.lOceL+ig-/%l?^

^e}XH.lnCF*j$:.r88F$kbN

H=GG-k%J_$:.HO3Nh&J.llr

X9%4.2 p`~OroK*1k:.)f

p`HJk~OroKhjQ$?Wi:^"/

Ae(<?,}D:.)fzLrD.9k?a$=1-Case1 N~OroKhjB3rTC?%?Q.llr^ 5 K(9%lVeN^OWi:^"/Ae(<?rHQ7F$J$H-N?Q.llG"k%x/ =0.1�0.4K*$FceLGr/+(kbNOw6ILa5K"kWi:^"/Ae(<?N?aN

[~G"k%Va =1.5�2kVGO"^j)fzLOJ+C?%2.5kVGO)fzL,lt+ilkbNN$soKTBjJ.llG"C?%3�4kVGOWi:^"/Ae(<?KhCF0ora.?.l,cL

Uar.lF$/MR,+il?%J_$3Nh&

K.ll,Q=7?H-$:.)fKzL,"C?

H=G9kbNH9k%4.3 :.)fKP9k fbase NzLfbase Khk:.)fNQ=r+k?a$fbase=3,6kHz K*1k:.)fB3 (= 1-Case2)rTC?%Wi:^"/Ae(<?XN~OE.r

bK?<7?H3m$Va ,ljG"CFb fbase ,g-/JkHE.,}C7??a$E5&E.NQK

hj;P7?~O(Mk.<b}C7?%

^ 4 NACA0015 c?~jN?Q.l(e+i �=0,4,8,10degs)Va =2�3kVK*1k.llrfS9kH$=l>lN~OE5roKD$F fbase=3kHzhjb 6kHzNlgN},~O(Mk.<Og-$KbXoi:$

?Q.llK@NJ9O+ilJ+C?%D^j$#

sNB3roKX7FO fbase NzL,.5$?a$(Mk.<z(NQ@+i@(P$fbase ,.5$},>^7$H@(k%4.4 :.)fKP9k BRNzLBR rQ=5;?B3 (= 1-Case3) rT$$BRKhkFAr+?%F+=9.09,Va =2kV K*1k?Q.llr^ 6, VV.llr^ 7K(9%3NroGO$BR=10% NH-Km%)fOG

b-zKO?i$F$k3H,?Ql$VVlP

}+iN'G-k%BR=50% H 100% rfS9kH$?QlGO@i+J9O+ilJ$%7+7V

VlG_kH$BR=50% N},Wi:^"/Ae(<?KhjrGXN60,%J5lF$k%5i

^ 5 :.)f~N?Q.l (e+i0,2,3kV(fbase=6kHz,BR=100%))K$fLNTge^O(5J$,$Va =2.5kVNH-K BR=100%GO)fzL,+ilJ+C?,$BR=50%,F+=9.09GOzLrN'9k3H,G-?%3liN3HH$fbase,Va ,HbKljNH-~O(Mk.<O1cK BR Kfc9kH_J;k3H+i$GbzL*JNO BR=10%G"j$!$G 50%,100%G"kH@(k%4.5 :.)fKP9k F+ NzL= 1-Case4Nh&K~OrorQ=5;$5!5

P<9H~Ht F+ Khk:.)fXNFAr+?%"k F+ KP7F Va ry9Kg-/7?H-$:.)frB=9kE5r Vs H9k%F+H Vs NX8r(7?^ 8KhkH$F+ N}CK<$$Vs ,:/7F$k%F+ N_rQ=5;Fb$Wi:^"/Ae(<?K~O5lk(Mk.<O[\ljG

"k,$B3rTC?OObGO F+ ,g-$[I:.)fKzL,"C?%5. ^HalDk=B3Khj$5!5P<9H~Ht F+,sineH~Ht fbase, P<9Hf( BR,Wi:^"

/Ae(<?N:.)fK?(kFAKD$F$!

N3H,,+C?%

^ 6 :.)f~N?Q.l (e+iBR=100,50,10%(fbase=6kHz,F+=9.09,2kV))\B3NOObK*$F1. Va Ob$},:.)fzL,b$%2. fbase NFAO.5$?a$~O(Mk.<r

c:G-k.5$ fbase ,>^7$%3. BRO.5$},)fzL,b/$~O(Mk.<b^)G-k%4. F+ Og-$},zL*G"k%

#sOc~j.lNDk=KhCF:.)fN>

ArTC??a$FQia?,Z\9FAKD$F

j-*JX8O@il?bNN$HO8tJINc

C-K?(kFArG@9k3HOG-J$%5i

K$eRN F+KX9k^Ha (4)KD$F$)fzLN>A}!O[Jk,$w?9~r(7F$kb

N 6)$[Jk9~r(7F$kbN 4, 7) P},8_9k%3N@KD$FNM!r<ak?aKO$W

i:^"/Ae(<?N~OroH.ll$cC-

NX8KD$F5iJk&f,,WG"k%

2M8%1) Post, M. L. and Corke, T. C., \SeparationControl on High Angle of Atta k Airfoil Us-ing Plasma A tuators," AIAA J., Vol.42 No.11pp.2177-2184, November 20042) M ormi k, B. W., Jr., \Aerodynami s of

^ 7 :.)f~NVV.l (e+iBR=100,50,10%(fbase=6kHz,F+=9.09,2kV))�����

� � � � � ��PSfrag repla ementsVs F+^ 8 Vs H F+(BR=10%)V/STOL Flight," A ademi Press., 19673) Seifert, A. et al., \Delay of Airfoil Stall by Pe-riodi Ex itation," AIAA J. of Air raft, Vol.33No.4 pp.691-698, 19964) G�oksel, B. et al., "Steady and UnsteadyPlasma Wall Jets for Separation and Cir u-lation Control," AIAA2006-36865) Tsubakino, D. and Fujii, K., \E�e tive Lay-out of Plasma A tuators for a Flow SeparationControl on a Wing," AIAA2007-4746) Sidorenko, A. A. et al., \Pulsed Dis hargeA tuators for Re tangular Wings SeparationControl," AIAA2007-9417) Patel, M. P. et al., \S aling E�e ts of an Aero-dynami Plasma A tuator," AIAA2007-635