What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    1/25

    1

    Mysteries of Quranic Order and the Muqqatta`at (Abbreviated Letters)

    By

    Robert Kerson 6/28/2015

    There are, when considering the Muslim holy book called the Quran, a single arrangement

    of 114 Surahscalled the Surah Order (similar to chapters in the Bible). These Surahsare a

    rearrangement of 114 revelations, called the Egyptian Standard Chronological or Revelation

    Order1received by the prophet Muhammad. Thus the chronological or revelation order is the

    order in which the revelations were received, and the Surah order is the order in which these

    revelations were compiled in book formthe written Quran. This Revelation Order is a

    different numbered arrangement from the Surah Order. Both are very old, possibly dated

    during the lifetime of the prophet2.

    These Surahsare grouped in various ways including by roughly decreasing lengths. I have

    discovered previously undiscovered an apparently deliberate arrangement between the

    Revelation Order and the Surah Order which is discussed and documented in this paper. This

    arrangement also have connections with the Abbreviated Letter (Muquatta`at) which is

    discussed in chapter five of my book Sacred Stones Sacred Storiesvol. 1 and within my previous

    paper The Abbreviated Letters in the Qurana solutioni. (Please refer to either

    iifor any

    detailed discussion of this topic which is not presented here.)

    (Refer to Table 1 for the following discussion)

    Table 1 consists of six columns reading from left to right. Column one is the Egyptian Standard

    Chronological or Revelation Order (numbers shown in bold italics) of 114 revelations reading in

    reverse from bottom up. Column two is the Egyptian Standard Chronological or Revelation

    Order (numbers shown in bold italics) of 114 revelations reading from top down. Column three

    is the Surah Order. Column four is the delta ( ) or subtracted values of column three from

    column two. (I only show the sign of the number calculated rather than the number [with two

    exceptions] because the sign is what matters in this discussion, representing which column

    number is a greater or smaller number, and not the actual numbers.) When the numbers in

    column two are less than the numbers in column three, the sign is Negative (-). When the

    numbers in column two are greater than the numbers in column three, the sign is positive (+).

    The signs of the numbers are used to visualize the relative magnitudes of each of two columns.

    Column four also lists a zero (0) when the delta is zero.

    1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_surah_in_the_Quran

    2The surahs originally may not have been numbered or named , but they would have existed in a revelation order,

    and a compiled finished order. Numbering as presented in this paper is a tool for displaying relationships of surah

    order and revelation order, just as the graph is a tool for displaying relationships between surah number and ayat

    lengths.

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    2/25

    2

    The discussion of my discoveries begins with column one. In this column there are three

    numbers with very special properties: they are the palindromic numbers 33, 44, 77 where the

    sum of the first two equals the third. There are other similar palindromic number arrangements

    such as 22, 33, 55 but the former is the only three numbers which have the following property:

    the sum of the three numbers equals 154 which when the number 40 is subtracted from thetotal equals 114 where the total (114) is the number of Surahs and revelations received by the

    prophet. The number 40 is special for many reasons in Islam, but within the Quran Surah 40 is

    the first Surah having the letters ( ) in the Abbreviated Letters (Muquatta`at).

    Notice that in column one each of the three numbers 33, 44, 77 have identical numbers in

    columns two and three and not within any other rows within this table. Thus in columns two

    and three we get 33 becoming 82, 44 becoming 71, and 77 becoming 38. The difference or

    delta ( ) in each of these three rows is zero (0) as seen in column four.The reason these three

    numbers create the only deltas ( ) of zero (0) cannot be explained by any mathematical

    manipulation, but appears to be deliberately selected (All cells where the Delta ( ) is zero (0)has a gray background in table 1.)

    An examination of the top portions of column four reveals that all the rows, with but one

    exception, have a negative (-) delta ( ) meaning that counting as numbers the early revelations

    (first Meccan Revelations) are each less than their respective assembled Surah numbers. An

    examination of the bottom portions of column four reveals that all the rows, with but five

    exceptions, have a positive (+) delta () meaning that counting as numbers later revelations are

    each more than their respective assembled Surah numbers. The reason the signs are grouped

    as shown, cannot be explained by any mathematical manipulation, I can explain but appears to

    be deliberately selected.The very distinct row at which the sign changes from negative (-) to positive (+) is the row

    marked 77-38-38-0. Again, having this very row marking the changeover point appears to be

    deliberately selected because this is exactly at the 1/3 of the total numbers (or 114/38 = 3.0).

    We can count the intervening numbers between the top and bottom rows and the three zero

    (0) rows as shown in column five. We get a count starting from the top 37-32-10-32. Note the

    symmetrical pattern of 32-10-32.

    Now notice the exceptions discussed previously. These exceptions are the anomalies where a

    lone opposite sign exists in the two sections. Thus, in column four a positive (+) is surrounded

    by negatives (-), and a negative (-) is surrounded by positives (+). The anomalies are shown onthe right side of their cells.

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    3/25

    3

    TABLE 1 (see text)

    Reversed

    RevelationOrder

    Revelation

    Order

    Surah

    Order

    Count Letters

    of note

    114 1 96 - 1

    113 2 68 - 2

    112 3 73 - 3

    111 4 74 - 4

    110 5 1 + 5

    109 6 111 - 6

    108 7 81 - 7

    107 8 87 - 8

    106 9 92 - 9

    105 10 89 - 10

    104 11 93 - 11

    103 12 94 - 12

    102 13 103 - 13

    101 14 100 - 14

    100 15 108 - 15

    99 16 102 - 16

    98 17 107 - 17

    97 18 109 - 18

    96 19 105 - 19

    95 20 113 - 20

    94 21 114 - 21

    93 22 112 - 2292 23 53 - 23

    91 24 80 - 24

    90 25 97 - 25

    89 26 91 - 26

    88 27 85 - 27

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    4/25

    4

    87 28 95 - 28

    86 29 106 - 29

    85 30 101 - 30

    84 31 75 - 31

    83 32 104 - 32

    82 33 77 - 33

    81 34 50 - 34

    80 35 90 - 35

    79 36 86 - 36

    78 37 54 - 37

    77 38 38 0

    76 39 7 + 1

    75 40 72 -

    32

    2

    74 41 36 + 3

    73 42 25 + 4

    72 43 35 + 5

    71 44 19 + 6

    70 45 20 + 7

    69 46 56 - 8

    68 47 26 + 9

    67 48 27 + 10

    66 49 28 + 11

    65 50 17 + 12

    64 51 10 + 13

    63 52 11 + 14

    62 53 12 + 15

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    5/25

    5

    61 54 15 + 16

    60 55 6 + 17

    59 56 37 + 18

    58 half 57 half 31 + 19 [ ]{ 1}

    57 way 58 way 34 + 20 [ ]{ 2}

    56 59 39 +20 21 [1]{3}

    55 60 40 +20 22 [2]{4}

    54 61 41 +20 23 [3]{5}

    53 62 42 +20 24 [4]{6}

    52 63 43 +20 25 [5]{7}

    51 64 44 +20 26 [6]{8}

    50 65 45 +20 27[7]{9}49 66 46 +20 28[8]{10}

    48 67 51 + 29 [9]

    47 68 88 -

    20

    30 [10]

    46 69 18 + 31

    45 70 16 + 32

    44 71 71 0

    43 72 14 + 1

    42 73 21 + 2

    41 74 23 + 3

    40 75 32 + 4

    39 76 52 + 5

    38 77 67 + 6

    37 78 69 + 7

    36 79 70 + 8

    35 80 78 + 9

    34 81 79 + 10

    33 82 82 0

    32 83 84 - 1

    31 84 30 + 2

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    6/25

    6

    30 85 29 + 3

    29 86 83 + 4

    28 87 2 + 5

    27 88 8 + 6

    26 89 3 + 7

    25 90 33 + 8

    24 91 60 + 9

    23 92 4 + 10

    22 93 99 - 11

    21 94 57 + 12

    20 95 47 + 13

    19 96 13 + 1418 97 55 + 15

    17 98 76 + 16

    16 99 65 + 17

    15 100 98 + 18

    14 101 59 + 19

    13 102 24 + 20

    12 103 22 + 21

    11 104 63 + 22

    10 105 58 + 23

    9 106 49 + 24

    8 107 66 + 25

    7 108 64 + 26

    6 109 61 + 27

    5 110 62 + 28

    4 111 48 +29

    3 112 5 + 30

    2 113 9 + 31

    1 114 110 + 32

    If you count the numbers between anomalies, or count between a zero (0) to an anomaly, or

    count between numbers on either side (adjacent) to either an anomaly or to a zero (0), you will

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    7/25

    7

    find a number of instances where the count is 37, or 32, or 10 This may or may not be a

    coincidence of the zero placement, but if not, then this may be deliberate. These finding are

    shown in Table 2. (see table 2).

    Column one shows the number of numberseither 37, or 32- or 10. Column two shows the

    starting fromnumber. Column three shows if the number is a zero (0) or adjacent to a zero, oran anomaly, or adjacent to an anomaly. Column four is the to number. Column five is identical

    to column three but on the to number. I also show here that counts may be to the last number

    (114) or to an anomaly which is five numbers from counting to the starting number from 114.

    Column six shows how some rows, if taken as Surah numbers instead of as revelation numbers,

    have importance in the Abbreviated Letters (Muquatta`at) similar to the last column of table 1

    above. Thus number 40 if seen as Surah 40 is the first Surah having the letters ( ) and the

    number 46 if seen as Surah 46 is the last Surah having the letters ( ). The only Surahs

    having these letters are 40,41,42,43,44,45,46. Column six shows only letters that are relevant

    to this discussion.

    Other important related facts can be seen in table 1: In column two the number 40 has an anomaly

    with a subtracted value of -32 in column four. This is one of the numbers 37, 32, 10 discussed previously

    (row is 75-40-72-32.) From column six, you can see the letters ( ) first appear here in a Surah (

    this table represents revelation 40 and not Surah 40, but the number matches.) The letters ( )

    occur in Surah 46. Notice that an anomaly occurs on Surah 46. The number 46 also have the

    palindromic number 66 in column one.

    Other facts seen in column six is that the letter( ) appears as a single letter in Surah 38

    where the delta (where the delta () is zero (0). Also the letter( ) appears as an only

    occurrence of this single letter in Surah 68 where the delta ( ) is an anomaly. Here in column

    three is the palindromic number 88. In column four, the number is -20the same number as all

    the +20 numbers having the letters ( ) in column three.

    The letters ( ) and( ) are two of three single letters of the letter order. The letter( )is very special as it only appears in Surah 68.

    The row 44-71-71-0 is special because the name of Surah 71 is Noah. This is the last surah to

    mention him. The connection of Noah to the Abbreviated Letters is discussed in my book and

    also in my previous paper sited. This is one of the three zero (0) rows.

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    8/25

    8

    The half- way point between columns one and two is at the numbers 57 and 58 (see Table 1).

    Counting down from these half-way numbers, we reach row 47-68-88-20 all detailed

    previously. We can count ten numbers as shown within square brackets [ ]. The number 10 is

    one of the numbers 37-32-10 discussed previously. We can also count 10 numbers in column

    four from the half-way point to the +20 which is the last Surah having the letters( ) etc.

    These 10 numbers are counted in the fancy brackets { }.

    In the row 47-68-88, column fives cell have the numbers 30 [10] whose addition is number 40.

    Having the two palindromic numbers-- The Surah Order number 77 matched with a

    Revelation Order number 33 could have been deliberate. This gives a delta () of |-44 |. These

    are the same numbers we have seen in the beginning of this article.

    Table 2 (see text)

    Number

    Of

    Numbers

    From

    Number

    Number

    Is:

    To

    Number

    Number

    Is:

    letters

    37 82 A zero (0) 46 Anomaly

    37 83 An

    anomalyalso

    Adjacent

    to zero

    (0)

    5 From

    114+5

    32 83 An

    anomaly

    also

    adjacentto a zero

    (0)

    114 Last

    number

    32 71 Zero (0) 40 An

    anomaly

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    9/25

    9

    32 37 Adjacent

    to a zero

    (0)

    68 An

    Anomaly

    32 37 Adjacent

    to a zero

    (0)

    6 Adjacent

    to an

    anomaly

    1037 Adjacent

    to a zero

    46 An

    anomaly10 84 Adjacent

    to an

    anomaly

    93 An

    anomaly

    Interesting notes:

    1. A subject change occurs in the 40th

    verse (ayat) of the 2nd

    Surah. Note in table 1, the number 2

    in the fifth column labeled Count has the number 40 in the second column.

    2. The largest delta () is in the row- 47-68-2 where delta is the palindromic anomaly +66. This

    is Surah 68the last Surah of the letter order having the only occurrence of the letter ( ).

    3. Surah 10 has the last of the Abbreviated Letter sequence ( ). This number is part of thenumbers 37-32-10 discussed previously.

    4. Surah 32 has the first Abbreviated Letter sequence ( ).This number is part of the numbers

    37-32-10 discussed previously.

    5. The Interval from 40 to 46 has the letter sequence ( ).This sequence is between the two

    anomalies.

    6. The Quran may be divided into seven groups. The seventh group is from Surah 67 to 114.3

    These are also the Surahs of Juz` 29 and 304. The Ajiza of the Qur`an is a division into thirty

    parts. Note these numbers match the number of days in a lunar (Muslim) month. The number 67

    in the second column of both table 1 is a number adjacent to an anomaly.

    3 http://www.islamicity.com/articles/Articles.asp?ref-IC0908-3944.

    4http://islam.about.com/od/quranin30days/a/juz_index.htm

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    10/25

    10

    Here are facts which cannot be accounted for by any mathematical procedure.

    1. Having positive (+) and negative (-) numbers must be manually chosen otherwise they would

    be randomly distributed.

    2. Having three zero (0) delta ( ) numbers appear to be deliberately and manually chosen

    otherwise no zeros (0) need exist.

    3. Three zeros (0) need not exist.

    4. These zeros (0) all are on the pattern of numbers 33, 44, 77 and are not simply three random

    numbers.

    5. The change over from negative (-) to positive (+) on a zero (0) is not mathematically

    necessary. I have tested the hypothesis that this is due to the act of subtraction but could not

    duplicate the change over with a different set of numbers. (see end of paper for examples).The

    numbers in column 2 are generally smaller then then numbers in column 3, but the switch over

    at exactly 1/3 the total (or 114/38) is not random.

    6. The changeover occurring in Table 1 at different zero (0) point in Table 3 also is not

    mathematically necessary as I have not been able to duplicate his with an different set of

    numbers as seen at the end of this paper.

    7. The creation of anomalies having the same number of numbers between zeros (0) are also

    not mathematically necessary. A different set of numbers creates all sorts of random patterns

    like +++-+--.

    8. I cannot get the number of positive (+) numbers chosen randomly to match the correct

    number of negative (-) numbers. (see end of paper). Thus, I can run out of Positive (+) numbers

    in tests. This does not happen in the actual Quran as seen in table 1.

    9. Having the two palindromic numbers-- The Surah Order number 77 matched with a

    Revelation Order number 33 could have been deliberate. This gives a delta () of |-44 |. These

    are the same numbers we have seen in the beginning of this article.

    Whereas in Table 1 the changeover point is at the gray row 77- 32- 32- 0, in Table 3 the

    changeover point is at the gray row 44- 71- 71- 0. Table 3 has a transitional zone where the

    signs can be either positive (+) or negative (-). This zone I have drawn in peach color. The first

    row of this zone has the number 50 which as has the single letter saad of the Abbreviated

    Letters. Note this is the number 50 in the Revelation order and not the number 50 in the Surah

    order.

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    11/25

    11

    Table 3 (see text)

    Reversed

    Surah

    Order

    Surah

    order

    Revelation

    order

    Count Letters

    114 1 5 - 1

    113 2 87 - 2

    112 3 89 - 3

    111 4 92 - 4

    110 5 112 - 5

    109 6 55 - 6

    108 7 39 - 7

    107 8 88 - 8

    106 9 113 - 9

    105 10 51 - 10 Jonah

    104 11 52 - 11

    103 12 53 - 12

    102 13 96 - 13

    101 14 72 - 14

    100 15 54 - 15

    99 16 70 - 16

    98 17 50 - 17

    97 18 69 - 18

    96 19 44 - 19

    95 20 45 - 20

    94 21 73 - 21

    93 22 103 - 22

    92 23 74 - 23

    91 24 102 - 24

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    12/25

    12

    90 25 42 - 25

    89 26 47 - 26

    88 27 48 - 27

    87 28 49 - 2886 29 85 - 29

    85 30 84 - 30

    84 31 57 - 31

    83 32 75 - 32

    82 33 90 - 33

    81 34 58 - 34

    80 35 43 - 35

    79 36 41 - 36

    78 37 56 - 37

    77 38 38 0

    76 39 59 - 1

    75 40 60 - 2

    74 41 61 - 3

    73 42 62 - 4

    72 43 63 - 5

    71 44 64 - 6

    70 45 65 - 7

    69 46 66 - 8

    68 47 95 - 9

    67 48 111 -10

    66 49 106 - 11

    65 50 34 + 12

    64 51 67 - 13

    63 52 76 - 14

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    13/25

    13

    62 53 23 + 15

    61 54 37 - 16

    60 55 97 - 17

    59 56 46 + 1858 57 94 - 19

    57 58 105 - 20

    56 59 101 - 21

    55 60 91 - 22

    54 61 109 - 23

    53 62 110 - 24

    52 63 104 - 25

    51 64 108 - 26

    50 65 99 - 27

    49 66 107 - 28

    48 67 77 - 29

    47 68 2 + 30

    46 69 78 - 31

    45 70 79 - 32

    44 71 71 0 Noah

    43 72 40 + 1

    42 73 3 + 2

    41 74 4 + 3

    40 75 31 + 4

    39 76 98 -5

    38 77 33 + 6

    37 78 80 - 7

    36 79 81 - 8

    35 80 24 + 9

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    14/25

    14

    34 81 7 + 10

    33 82 82 0

    32 83 86 - 1

    31 84 83 + 230 85 27 + 3

    29 86 36 + 4

    28 87 8 + 5

    27 88 68 + 6

    26 89 10 + 7

    25 90 35 + 8

    24 91 26 + 9

    23 92 9 + 10

    22 93 11 + 11

    21 94 12 + 12

    20 95 28 + 13

    19 96 1 + 14

    18 97 25 + 15

    17 98 100 - 16

    16 99 93 + 17

    15 100 14 + 18

    14 101 30 + 19

    13 102 16 + 20

    12 103 13 + 21

    11 104 32 + 22

    10 105 19 + 23

    9 106 29 + 24

    8 107 17 + 25

    7 108 15 + 26

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    15/25

    15

    6 109 18 + 27

    5 110 114 - 28

    4 111 6 + 29

    3 112 22 + 302 113 20 + 31

    1 114 21 + 32

    Table 3 is identical to Table 1 , except columns two and three are reversed.

    Table 4 is identical to Table 2, except this table is based on the contents of Table 3 whereas

    Table 2 is based on the contents of Table 1.

    Table 4 (see text)

    Number

    Of

    Numbers

    From

    Number

    Number

    Is:

    To

    Number

    Number

    Is:

    Letters

    32 37 Adjacent

    to a zero

    (0)

    68 An

    anomaly

    32 51 Adjacent

    to an

    anomaly

    82 A zero (0)

    TESTING THE USE OF RANDOM NUMBERS IN TABLES

    Table 5 is identical to Table 1, but it is comprised of random numbers to see the effect in a

    random number table. This is but one representative of a few trials. All trials gave similar results.

    The rules of these trials were that I had 114 numbers printed, but three numbers were fixed togive zero (38, 71,82) all shown in gray. Then I drew randomly the last 37 numbers. The

    remainder of the numbers were then randomly selected to fill the remaining rows.

    Note that the sign remains negative ( -) at the start of the drawings. Then two transitional

    zones (peach) creating many anomalies can be seen in this specific example. The changeover

    row is hard to determine. At some row, the sign becomes all positive (+). In the actual Quranic

    table 1, there are no transitional zones (peach), and the changeover row is very distinct. Table 1

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    16/25

    16

    have the very distinct anomaly at row 110- 5- 1. There are no other anomalies within the first 37

    rows. This makes this row very deliberately placed. There are no palindromes in the random

    selection of numbers. The symmetry of the pattern 37-32-10-32 would not have occurred if these

    numbers were not deliberately chosen.

    TABLE 5 (see text)

    A Revelation

    order with

    Surah's

    Chosen

    Randomly

    1 102 -

    2 111 -

    3 85 -

    4 99 -5 113 -

    6 83 -

    7 105 -

    8 109 -

    9 107 -

    10 103 -

    11 90 -

    12 96 -13 101 -

    14 106 -

    15 100 -

    16 108 -

    17 110 -

    18 87 -

    19 84 -

    20 112 -

    21 81 -

    22 89 -

    23 88 -

    24 80 -

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    17/25

    17

    25 98 -

    26 104 -

    27 86 -

    28 114 -

    29 77 -

    30 79 -

    31 95 -

    32 76 -

    33 91 -

    34 78 -

    35 93 -

    36 94 -37 92 -

    38 38 0

    39 72 -

    40 4 +

    41 17 -

    42 32 +

    43 42 +

    44 54 -

    45 21 +

    46 64 -

    47 65 -

    48 48 0

    49 67 -

    50 50 0

    51 2 +52 51 +

    53 10 +

    54 6 +

    55 5 +

    56 1 +

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    18/25

    18

    57 half 16 +

    58 way 15 +

    59 58 +

    60 68 -

    61 53 +

    62 25 +

    63 41 -

    64 14 +

    65 73 -

    66 18 +

    67 31 +

    68 24 +69 66 +

    70 27 +

    71 71 0

    72 59 +

    73 33 +

    74 49 +

    75 37 +

    76 44 +

    77 61 +

    78 46 +

    79 52 +

    80 12 +

    81 7 +

    82 82 0

    83 47 +84 20 +

    85 34 +

    86 39 +

    87 69 +

    88 36 +

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    19/25

    19

    89 11 +

    90 45 +

    91 29 +

    92 60 +

    93 74 +

    94 22 +

    95 28 +

    96 56 +

    97 40 +

    98 55 +

    99 70 +

    100 75 +101 19 +

    102 35 +

    103 13 +

    104 34 +

    105 8 +

    106 26 +

    107 63 +

    108 23 +

    109 62 +

    110 30 +

    111 43 +

    112 57 +

    113 9 +

    114 97 +

    Table 6 is identical to Table 3, but the numbers are chosen randomly as in the same fashion of

    Table 5. The changeover point is at 76- 32 and not near the changeover point of Table 3 at (gray)

    44-71-71-0. Table 6 has a large transition zone (peach). The changeover point is not distinct and

    is not near 71 as in table 3.

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    20/25

    20

    Table 6 (see text)

    A Surah

    order with

    Revelations

    Listed

    1 56 -

    2 51 -

    3 104 -

    4 40 -

    5 55 -

    6 54 -

    7 81 -

    8 105 -

    9 113 -

    10 53 -

    11 89 -

    12 80 -

    13 103 -

    14 64 -15 58 -

    16 57 -

    17 4 -

    18 60 -

    19 101 -

    20 84 -

    21 45 -

    22 94 -23 108 -

    24 68 -

    25 62 -

    26 106 -

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    21/25

    21

    27 70 -

    28 95 -

    29 91 -

    30 110 -

    31 67 -

    32 42 -

    33 73 -

    34 85 -

    35 102 -

    36 88 -

    37 75 -

    38 38 039 86 -

    40 97 -

    41 63 -

    42 43 -

    43 111 -

    44 76 -

    45 90 -

    46 78 -

    47 83 -

    48 48 0

    49 74 -

    50 50 0

    51 52 -

    52 79 -

    53 61 -54 44 +

    55 98 -

    56 96 -

    57 112 -

    58 59 -

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    22/25

    22

    59 72 -

    60 92 -

    61 77 -

    62 109 -

    63 107 -

    64 46 +

    65 47 +

    66 69 -

    67 49 +

    68 60 +

    69 87 -

    70 99 -71 71 0

    72 39 +

    73 65 +

    74 93 -

    75 100 -

    76 32 +

    77 29 +

    78 34 +

    79 30 +

    80 24 +

    81 21 +

    82 82 0

    83 6 +

    84 19 +

    85 3 +86 27 +

    87 18 +

    88 23 +

    89 22 +

    90 1 +

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    23/25

    23

    91 33 +

    92 37 +

    93 35 +

    94 36 +

    95 31 +

    96 12 +

    97 114 +

    98 25 +

    99 4 +

    100 15 +

    101 13 +

    102 1 +103 10 +

    104 26 +

    105 7 +

    106 14 +

    107 9 +

    108 16 +

    109 8 +

    110 17 +

    111 2 +

    112 20 +

    113 5 +

    114 28 +

  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    24/25

    24

    Importance of the Ayat numbers

    Each Surah (similar to a Biblical chapter) is composed of a number of ayat (similar to a Biblical

    verse). It has been known for centuries that the lower Surah numbers tend to be many, and the

    higher Surah numbers tend to be few. Graph 1 shows the Surah numbers on the x- axis, vs. thenumber of ayat on the y-axis. Surah 1 has 7 ayat. Surah 2 have 286 ayat etc. The graph shows a

    downward trend in number of ayat from Surah 2 (on the left) to Surah 114 (on the right ).

    Examining the graph, you will notice that there are also a few 1 or 2 Surahs with a dip in the

    ayat numbers and a broader band with a dip of ayat numbers (60-66).

    An important observation is that a great number of ayat are on the left. Here also are all the

    very great peaks such as at Surah 2 which has the very largest number of ayats (286). Looking

    more closely, see that all the large peaks fall in the interval between Surah 1 and Surah 38 (bars

    shown in highlighted in red). The number 38 has been seen before as one of the numbers

    having a delta () of zero. In fact, the last large peak is at Surah 37. The number 37 is one of the

    interval numbers 37-32-10 we have seen in table 1. The interval in red is exactly 1/3 the total(or 114/38=3.0). This is where the numbers change from negative (-) to positive (+) at 2/3 the

    total as seen in Table 1 of column 4. Another observation is that the total number of surahs

    (114) divided by 3 is again-- 38.

    The first 37 numbers have mostly first Meccan revelations. The next section of 32 numbers

    have mostly second and third Meccan revelations. The next section of 10 numbers have a

    mixture all three periods of Meccan revelations. The next section of 32 numbers have some

    Meccan revelations, but all of the Medina revelations.

    Graph 1 ayat numbers on upper vertical axis vs. surah order on horizontal

    axis. Also shown is the corresponding revelation order on lower vertical axis5

    (see text)

    5 Data from upper bars taken from The Holy Qur-an, King Fahd Holy Qur-an Printing Complex. Table on names.

    Data of lower bars taken from oChronological Koran compiled by Wolf Pangloss.

    https://wolfpangloss.wordpress.com/chronokoran/ChronologialKoran | Wolf Pangloss

    https://wolfpangloss.wordpress.com/chronokoran/Chronologialhttps://wolfpangloss.wordpress.com/chronokoran/Chronologialhttps://wolfpangloss.wordpress.com/chronokoran/Chronologial
  • 7/28/2019 What Editing of Quran and The Abbreviated Letter Puzzle have in common

    25/25

    25

    The revelations can be divided into four period groupings: first (early Meccan revelations,

    shown in red), second (later Meccan revelations shown in yellow) third (late Meccan

    revelations shown in blue), and Medinan revelations(shown colorless). The lower vertical axis,

    are small colored bars representing the four period revelation groupings. Note the surahs on

    the horizontal axis with few ayat (red) are mostly on the right, and the later revelations shown

    colorless are mostly in the center and toward the left.

    The revelations and hence the surah order can be divided into three parts: on the left from

    surah 2 through 46 comprising Madinan surah (colorless), third Meccan surahs (blue) and

    second Meccan surah (yellow) with no first Meccan surahs (red). The middle part from surahs

    47 through 76 comprising all four groupings with 10 surahs from the half way point of the

    Quran (surah 57) being Madinan surahs (colorless): and on the right from surah 77 through 114,

    comprising except for two Medinan surahs (colorless) only first Meccan surahs (red). Prefacing

    these 113 surahs is a single surah from the first Meccan period (the single red of surah 1). This

    extremely important lone surah before a part having no other red bars helps to confirm my

    contention that this arrangement was deliberately worked out.

    This paper shows which number is larger or smaller when comparisons are made between

    either the order of the revelations and the order of the surahs, and then what the resulting

    numbers could be in a similar but this time a random trial of the same comparisons made

    between either the order of the revelations and the order of the surahs. The resulting data

    implies that the Quran was worked out in a deliberate placement fashion.

    i Sacred Stones Sacred Storiesvol. 1 details on my website sacredstonessacredstories.com

    ii and on my blog 1ofkersondiscoveries.wordpress.com. My previous paper The Abbreviated

    Letters in the Qurana solution a link can be found on my blog as well.