Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
WG14“parallel”sessionAgenda:I.GESflagdic;onary-heatcharts(A.Casey)-sta;s;cs(P.Jofre-moresta;s;cs(S.VanEck,M.VanderSwaelmen)II.Binaries-SB2detec;on(M.VanderSwaelmen)-SB1detec;on(T.Merle)-Parameters-t-SNE(binaries)(G.Traven)III.t-SNE(general)(G.Traven)IV.AOB
Dic;onaryStructure
M.VanderSwaelmen,C.Worley,P.Jofre,A.Hourihane,A.Casey,T.Merle,S.VanEck
Flagsyntax
A.Casey
1002
510
151
1015
310
200
1030
213
003
1412
610
005
1001
010
015
1002
010
025
1003
010
106
1030
010
302
1030
310
304
1030
510
306
1030
810
311
1031
210
399
1050
011
020
1302
113
023
1010
510
151
1302
013
021
1302
210
155
1021
010
303
1030
410
305
1039
913
002
1302
810
010
1010
510
151
1030
210
308
1102
010
010
1001
510
020
1003
010
105
1010
610
303
1032
011
100
1115
011
200
1125
013
020
1302
213
027
1000
510
010
1030
210
303
100251015110153102001030213003141261000510010100151002010025100301010610300103021030310304103051030610308103111031210399105001102013021130231010510151130201302113022101551021010303103041030510399130021302810010101051015110302103081102010010100151002010030101051010610303103201110011150112001125013020130221302710005100101030210303
CAUP
EPINARBO
IAC
Lumba
Nice
OACT
Vilnius
100 101 102
0
1
2
3
4
num
ber o
f sta
rs fl
agge
d (lo
g)
EPINARBO
IAC
Lumba
MaxPlanck
OACT
CAUP
EPINARBO
IACAIP
Lumba
Nice
OACT
UCM
Vilnius
Arcetri
CAUP
OACT
OAPA
UCM
Liege
ROB
ROBG
rid
binarylinesemissionH−alphaabsorptionREMARK
binarylinesemissionH−alphaabsorptionREMARK
P.Jofre
P.Jofre
0.001
0.010
0.100
1.000
10.000
100.000%
of s
ampl
e fla
gged
(log
scal
e)
EPINAR
BO
IAC
Lumba
MaxPlanck
OAC
T
CAU
P
EPINAR
BO
IACAIP
Lumba
Nice
OAC
T
UC
M
Vilnius
Arcetri
CAU
P
OAC
T
OAPA
UC
M
Liege
RO
B
RO
BGrid
WG10 WG11 WG12 WG13
CONVER.ROTNO_PHYSTIMESNRREDUC.VRAD
CONVER.ROTNO_PHYSTIMESNRREDUC.VRAD
• Source:GES_iDR5_WG15_Recommended.fits(preliminaryversion)• Totalnumberofassignedflags:1124654• Average:13.5flagsperCNAME
65869
16254
TefforLoggor[Fe/H]orXI
Parameters
Noparameters 14184
2070
Flagged
Flagged
Unflagged
CNAMEswithnoparametersandnoflags:2070(outof16254)=13%
CNAMEswithnoparametersatall(Teff,LOGG,FEH,XI=NULL)16254(outof82123)=19%
Prefix Count Descrip;on----------------------------------------------------------------10399116928 NoparametersprovidedbecauseoflackofGme10302114773 Codeconvergenceissue:oneofmoreconvergencecriteria
(node-specific)couldnotbefulfilled.Criteriatobe describedusingthesuffix
1031562357 MicroturbulenceBergemann&Hill1001561310 SNR<151030358920 Teffoutofnode’sgrid
SNR:<5<10<15<20<25<30<40<50
85083flagsDATA
57748flagsDATA
15722flagsDATA
vsin(i)toohigh
63946flagsANALYSIS
493224flags
WG15useonly
ANALYSIS
142180flagsANALYSIS
RESULTQUALITY
24854flags
RESULTQUALITY
43330flags
(Neutrallines)
àCaI,CrIandNiIrepresent67%ofall“suspiciousabundance”no;fica;ons
RESULTQUALITY
20878flags
(Ionizedlines)
àScIIrepresents58%ofall“suspiciousabundance”no;fica;ons
Summary
SNR13%
Datareduc;on5%
RV1%
vsin(i)5%
Parameters:analysis43%
Abundances:analysis12%
Parameters:resultquality2%
AbundancesI:resultquality
4%
AbundancesII:resultquality
2%Other13%
Flagcategory
Concludingremarks• ProvidemoreGmeforparameterdeterminaGon• Allnon-determina;onsshouldbeflaggedbynodes• Nodesraisedconcernforabundancesofspecificspecies:CaI,CrI,NiI,ScII• NodesexpressedconcernforgridlimitaGons(11%ofall
flags).
2quesGons:Survey:Whatarethemainconcerns?Howcanflagsbeqerhelptotracethem?Science:Areflagsused/useful?
Assigned,butun-exis;ngprefix
• 14001• 1 (1250occurrences)• 1112003 (6496occurrences)• 112003 (1594occurrences)
Unassignedflags(some;mesrequiredbynodes)
• 10080Inaccurateorrevisedspectralresolu;onR(usesuffixtospecifythecolumnwiththenewdetermina;on)
• 10090InaccurateorrevisedSNR(usesuffixtospecifythecolumnwiththenewdetermina;on)• 10100Saturatedspectrum• 10150:SuspiciousorbadCCF• 11050• 11300• 13025• 10301• 10307• 10309• 12001• 13000• 13010• 13024• 13025• 13026• 13031• …
A.Casey
1001
010
015
1010
410
155
1021
010
302
1030
310
304
1030
510
308
1102
011
100
1120
011
250
1302
710
010
1005
010
153
1030
210
308
1302
013
021
1302
210
015
1002
010
106
1030
310
320
1110
011
150
1120
011
250
1302
013
027
10010100151010410155102101030210303103041030510308110201110011200112501302710010100501015310302103081302013021130221001510020101061030310320111001115011200112501302013027
EPINARBO
Lumba
OACT
100 101 102 103 104
A.Casey
1001
010
020
1003
010
040
1005
010
106
1030
310
306
1031
110
312
1032
010
500
1102
013
020
1302
213
023
1002
510
151
1015
310
200
1030
213
003
1412
610
010
1001
510
104
1015
510
210
1030
310
304
1110
011
200
1125
013
027
10010100201003010040100501010610303103061031110312103201050011020130201302213023100251015110153102001030213003141261001010015101041015510210103031030411100112001125013027
Arcetri
CAUP
OAPA
100 101 102 103
A.Casey
1005
0
1010
6
1030
0
1030
2
1030
3
1032
0
1039
9
1302
7
1030
8
1000
5
1001
0
1001
5
1002
0
1002
5
1010
3
1010
6
1010
8
1030
8
1039
9
1039
9
10050
10106
10300
10302
10303
10320
10399
13027
10308
10005
10010
10015
10020
10025
10103
10106
10108
10308
10399
10399
Liege
MGNDU
ROB
ROBGrid
100 101 102 103