Орон нутгийн засаглалын төлөв байдлыг хэмжихүй: Хэрэглэгчийн гарын авлага, УБ, 2010, НҮБХХ-ийн Осло дахь Засаглалын төв, Орчуулсан Я.Очирсүх
2. : 2 3. : 2010 4. : 1: 1.1 ?1.2 1.3 1.4 ?1.5 ?1.6 1.7 1.8
?1.9, 1.10 ?1.11 1.12 , 1.13 2: , , 1 2 3 44 5. : C () : C 1. (-)2.
( )3. - ()4. ( )5. ( )6. ()7. (, )8. , MIDAMOS ()9. : ( )10. Desde
lo Local ()11. , : ()- 12. ( , )13. ( )14. , ()15. ()16. - - ()17.
()18. () 5 6. : , - , (IDASA [ ])- . - , - . . , . , , - () , , , ,
- , , , - , , - -, , , , , - 6 7. : , , - , , , - , , - 7 8. : - ,
(IDEA) , , () , - -- -- 8 9. : ,, , , . , , . 2009-2011 , , , , . -
, 9 -II , , , , , . - , , , . , , .., ., ., . , , , , , . , , . 9
10. : ., - ., - , , ., , ., ., , . . , , (Sc.D) . 10 11. : , , - .
, , , .. , , , , . , , . . , , , . , , , , , , , , , , ., , , , , .
, , . 11 12. : , , ( ) , , . ; , , , , , ; ; . .- ? 1- . , , , , ,
, .2 , , , , , , . . ? , 2 , . , , , , / . , , . . , 1
http://www.undp.org/oslocentre/agship/demo-
.cratic_governance_assessments.html 12 13. : : 13 13 14. : 1 1.1 ?
, , , , . , , , , , , . , , , ,, , . , , , , , , . , ,. , , , , .
,,, , . , 10 . , , , . , , , . , 14 15. : , , . . , , , , . , , .5,
. ()- . , , , ; , , .3 .6 .43 : 5 - , , (2008 / ) , , 20044 6 , , /
/ , , 2004, , , 200415 16. : 1.2 , , , , , . : . 7 , ,, . 2007 4 -
- . , . , 1985 , 8- . , , , , , . , , . . 7 , I , (UCLG), 2007 8
1985 45 .. , . ,16 17. : , 1.3 , , , , . .9 , . 22 . , , . . , , .
, . , , , ., . . , . , 9 Christiane Arndt and CharlesOman, , , ,
(), 2006 17 18. : , . ; . ; , . ., 1. : ; 2. : , , . 1.4 ; ?3. : ,
. , , , . ; 4. , : , . . . : , . , ; , , . ; 18 19. : . , . , ( ,
,81.). , . , ,(,, , ) .. ( ) , , . . , , , . . , (, , , . , , ); (,
, , , , ); . 1.5 ( , ? , , , ,, , ); / , ., . , , , 19 20. : . ,
.10 . , , , , 11. , , , , / . , () . . , , , ( . ). , ( , ) , , 12
.. 11 : . , , III , , 2003. , . 12 , 10 (): , - , 2009.- , ,
(http://europeandcis.undp.org/governance/
show/E0665B63-F203-1EE9-B2237737A3E- 2001, 4BC48)20 21. : 1. . ,
107 , , , , , . , , , 14 . 2. , .13M , , - . , -, . . : 1) , 2) 3),
. , , . , . / , , . , , , - . , - . , .13 , , - ,
2009.(http://europeandcis.undp.org/governance/show/E0665B63-F203-1EE9-B2237737A3E4BC48)
21 22. : , ( , , ) ( , )- . , .1.6 .14 , . . - . - , ( ,. , , ) , ,
, , ., . (, , , )- , , , , . . , , , ( 1). , , , . . , 14 , (DAC) ,
, 2008 6 ( ) 22 23. : 1. , , : 3. . . , , . , .. 1. ( , ) 2. (, , ,
, ) 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. () 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. - 1. 2. 3. 4. 23 24. :
4. () ( , 66.) , , , . - ()- , (, , , , , )- 25 . . , - .1.7 , , ,
, . .5- . :,, ( , ) , . , , ., . : .: , , , , . . 24 25. : : . , ,
, : , , . , , . , (): . , , . . : , . 5. . : , , . , , . . . : / ,
. . . . . 25 26. : .c : , ( )- . , . . : . , , , . , . : . , . . ,
: , , . , . , . , , , . : , . , . . , - . . /: : , , .. 26 27. : .
. , , : , , , . 6. ()- ( , 60.) ( , , / , ) . - . , , , . . : (.. )
. , , . . , , . , , , , / ( , ). - / , . ? , , . . , 27 28. : 15 .
: , . , , , . . , , , , . ,, , , , , ( , . , , , , , , , )- ( )-, ,
, , . , . . . , 1.8 , , ?, . . , , . , . , , 15 : : 2006; . : .
2000. 28 29. : , , , . . . , , , , , , , . . , . , , , . , , , . .
, , . : (a) . ; (b) ,, . ; /, (c) / , .. , / . . . , , . , - . . ,
29 30. : , , , . ., 1.9 , , , 17 ., , , 1. , , : , . ; ; , ; , ; /
. , , . (.., )- 2. - , , 16 . . . :, , , . . - , , 16 17 - (2003).
- - (2003). -30 31. : , . . , ( ) , .. . , , , , , . ; , 7- , . , .
, , , . . , (56.)- 25 ( .( , - , a , ) 70 . . , MIDAMOS [.: , ,
88.] 86- , 30% . ). () ; , 54 , , 31 32. : .18 7. - , .. , - , , .
9- , . 1.10 .? , - , , . , , (.. ) . , . - , : : ( 18
www.cities-localgovernments.org/ , ,
uclg/index.asp?pag=wldmstatistics.
);asp&type=&L=EN&pon=1. 32 33. : ( , ) , . . , : ; , ;
, ; . . 8. , , ()- . . , . , - , .,, , ( , . , , , , (, , , )- . ,
, , ., , , , , , ); 33 34. : . , . , , / . (- 2007; 2007). . : 1. ,
; 2. - , , . ; , 3. , ,, . , ()19 . , (70.). . - -- , , , , . , ,
19 . - , (-)- - http://www.-, .org/docrep/W3241E/w3241e09.htm. 34
35. : 9. ? , / ? 12 ? , , ? , , ?1.11 : i) , ii) , iii) , , ( . ) ,
, . . . , , . . , , , . . , , 3 , .20 . , 20 , 4 : : , (IDEA)
(2008) . , 35 36. : . , . , . , , .. , , , , . , ,, - , , . , , . .
, . , , , , , , , . , ( , , youtube ) . . 36 37. : 10. () , . , . .
, , , [II]- . , . , , . 8 . ( 20 28)- . . 1-6 . 11. . 10 ( , , , ,
, , , , , , ) . , , , . , . , - , , - , . , 37 38. : , , , , . , .
, , , , , , . 1.12 , , , ., . , , . . , , , - , . . , , , . . , - ,
, , . , , . , 38 39. : - ( , ) [.: clientelism]- - . .2004 , ()- ,
. ()-, . - - (2000) (2003) . -81 , - . - , . - 2000-2003 , . , . -
(, 2006). . . , 2004 , , , , . 39 40. : . , . . , . , . , , ()- . .
, 1- . 12. - . . , . , . 21. . - , , , , , , , . . . , , ? . , / ?
, ? . 21 () http://www.dd.gov.uk/consultations/ crd/section5.pdf 40
41. : 13. 6 . : 1. , ; 2. ( ) , ; 3. , ; 4. , , ; 5. . , , ; 6. ( ,
) . : (IDEA) (2002) - .
http://www.idea.int/democracy/upload/Local_Dem_Assessment_Guide.pdf
, T- , ()- , , (, . , , [Gen- der Mainstreaming Performance],. -- ,
, , ) 24 ()- , . . 41 42. : 20%- . -22 , ( . 124.). . : . , : , , .
, . . , , , . . , , . . 1.13 , , , , , , , . . ,22 , -
,http://ww2.unhabitat.org/cdrom/transparency/ html/transpl.html 42
43. : 1: () () []- , ( )- - , , - , - - , : (2005) : . -- . : , , ,
, . . : , , , .. , , , , ,. , . . 43 44. : . . . , , , . : , ( ). ,
. , , [semi-structured interviews] . , . - , . . , 44 45. : 14. , ,
, . , .. , , , . . : : , , , : , , , . : , , , . : (IDEA) (2002) -
http://www.idea.int/democracy/upload/Local_Dem_Assessment_Guide.pdf45
46. : 46 47. : : 47 48. : 2 2.1 , (.. , , , )-, ; . , . , , . . , .
, . ., 2.2 , . , . . . , , ; , . , , , , ; 48 49. : , . , . , , , .
, , . , , . , .. , ( )- ( ) . , . , , , , /, . ,, . , , . . ,, (, ,
), . , , ()- , . . , 49 50. : : . , ,, . ( , ) . - , , , . , , . ,-
-( - .66.)- 2.3 , (, . :) , ( . )- ; , . . (, , )- -, . , . , ( -
60.)- . , - 50 51. : . . , , , , , (, , , , )- . . , , , , . . 2.4
, . : . 1. / , , , , . ,, , . 2. , . . , . . 51 52. : : . , , , .
.. , , . . , . . , . ,2.5 ( , ) . , , . . , . . , , . , . , ( , , )
. . , , . ? , 52 53. : , , . , , , , . ( , , , , ) . . , , , , . ,
. , / , ( , , , . ) 2.6 . : , sine qua non [.: . ] , , . , , . . ,
, , , . , . 53 54. : , ( , , ), , . . . , , , . , , . , . , , . , .
, , . / . : , . . , , . . . 54 55. : : 55 56. : 3 , , , , . : , . ,
. , . , , , . - , , , . . 1: , : . . , . . , . 56 57. : , . , , , ,
, , . , . , . , . , ,, ( )- , , . . , , ?, , . 1: , : (). , . , , ,
- , . . , , , 57 58. : , . , . , , , , . ,, - , - , . , , . , ( ,
)- , . ., , , . , - . 2: - . : , ( ) . . 58 59. : . , , ( , ), . ,
. . , , , , . , , . , , .. - , , - . . . , ( - .). - , . . - . - 59
60. : . , 2: - - : () . - , . . , , , , , , , . . , , , . , . , , ,
, , . . - . , , . , . , , . - . , , 60 61. : , . . 3: : ., . , , ,
, . , , , . . , . . ( , , , . , ,, ) , . . , , , , . . , , , 61 62.
: , . , . , . . , ( , , , ) . . , , . , , , - . . , . :, . , , . ,
; . ( , , , )-, ; . ; 62 63. : 3: : . - , () , . , , , ; , , , . ,
; . . : , , ; , , , , ; , . , . . , - . . , . . , 63 64. : , [play
. a role of focal point] , , . , . . , , , . : . 4: , - : , . . , ,
., , , , , . , , . . , . , , . , , . . 64 65. : , , , , , ,. , , .
. , . . , , , . 4: . : () . . . , , , .. . 65 66. : . , , , . .
Aberbach, J.D. and Rockman, B.A (2006) Brown,B.E, ed., , Thom-son
Wadsworth. (2003). Arndt, C.and Oman, C.: , , , (), 2006. . : (95)
19: , 1995; (2007) 12: , , 2007; (2007) 4 , , 2007 ( , . 5- 26- . .
- , , ( ) , , , 2008 5 . Grindle, S.Merilee. . 2005 2 . Grindle,
S.Merilee. : . 2002 11 ICLEI. : , 2004, IDEA (2008) .: IDEA (2002)
.: . : 66 67. : () ,, 2001, Kaufmann, D., Kraay, A., Zoido-Lobaton,
P.: , 1999 10 (OECD). (DAC) ,2008 6 ( ), Pierre, J. and Peters, B.G
(2000) , , Basingstoke: Macmillan, SHARIQUE. : , 2007, Shotton, R.
(2005) : . - , , - . Steffensen, J. and Larsen, H.F.: , , 2005
UCLG. , I , (UCLG) 2007. . : - (, 2008) . , / , , 2004. . , , , , -
, 2007. . : , - , 2005 7 . , 2004, . (2008). . (DGPN): : : , (2007
8 27 - 10 16) [2008 11 08- ] . , - , 2007 11 67 68. : : : 2 , 2007,
. , 2006, .
,http://ww2.unhabitat.org/cdrom/transparency/html/transpl.html
/LGSP. : 2008, P. (2006) : . , ()- , , ,- 2 , : , , , 27
-30,http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/48/22/38799205.pdf?contentId=38799206
Westfall, M.S.and De Villa, V.A.(eds.): , 2001, 68 69. : - 22 . . ,
, , . . : 1. . 2. , , 2. (, , 3. , , , , / )- . 3. . . : , 1. , .
[matrix]- ,, . , . , . 69 70. : ) , , .(/ , / , )- , , ., , . . 1.
, , , , ./ , (.. , . , , , ), (.. , ,1) , - ), 2) (.. , , , , , .
), (.. / )-( / ) ., ( . 70 71. : :2 ( 1. ) () 2. ( )3. - () 4. (
(IDEA)) , 5. . ,( ) ,6. () 7. . (, , ) 8. , - . MIDAMOS () 9. , . :
(12. ) ( ,10. Desde lo Local India) 13. () (11. ), 14. - ()- () 15.
() 71 72. : 3. . , . : , 16. - . ,(), 17. () ,18. . , () 19. , , ,
(M) .20. , , , / () ,21. ( ) .22. , () . ,, [] 23 . , 72 73. : :
1)1) 1)1) 1) 1) ,,,/ -2) //2) 2) 2) 2)2) ,,,. .73 74. : ()1 : ()- ,
( ,( ),) - -( )- , ()()Both diagnostic andMainly objectiveBoth:
Internal:Both disaggregated Both disaggregated ( (CD (to facilitate
sources)municipal staff and specific to the and gender
specificengagement of (self-assessment), poor ),citizens in
typically facilitatedgovernanceby a local )processes
governmentassociation : ()2 : (( )- - / (, , [valuation]) ( )- ( ,(
) ), : , -3-5, ), 2Either (can be moreBoth diagnostic and Both
objective andBoth: independent Both disaggregated Both
disaggregated LOCALor less rigorous & CD to
facilitateorganisation and specific to the and gender specific ,
GOVERNANCE costly, depending engagement offacilitating the poor
BAROMETERon resources citizens in assessment, in : (available
approx. ) governancecollaboration with3-5 weeks) processes local
stakeholders (state and non-state) and - technical partners74 75. :
()( )3 :, ,-,-/( )-(( )- , -(()- - , )-:( ) /()- ) :4 : ,- ( ) :/,
/ ( )-,:(, ,, - , -IDEA)5, :() ,/ - ( :( ,[polling(cross
validation)) company]- : ,, 33, )75 76. : () ()6 : , , , . /()- ( -
) : () , ( ) / . : 7 , : , , ( ) / ()- , ( : ) , 8 , : :, (, - ) /
, ()- - -MIDAMOS :() , , , , . 76 77. : () ( )9 , :, .: //((, ), (
)9 )OBSERVATORY (OF,DEMOCRACYINCENTRAL )AMERICA10(Centro de ,
:Desde lo LocalEstudios para el ,Futuro) ///() ( ).:,.11,:, -, ,, -
///(-) - ( )-77 78. : ()12 : - -, [Community Score -,- / Card]( -
-( )- : : , ) - ( ( ) UGI/LGB , ). :: -13, : , / : // ,-((: ) )
()14,: . / : , /,- // ( )- / ( ): - ( ) ( )()15 : .,:,/, - ( )-: ()
78 79. : () - 16 , ,: , , - ()- / ,()- /()- () 17 , : , , /()- ()-
() ( ). 18 , O / , - / () 19 , , O: (, ) , ()- / , (M) 20 , O , /
() , / 21 , : ( ) , , /, ( - ) 22 , : ,- - - /- - / , , ()- - , 79
80. : 1 : ( - - , )- .()- -- - . , , , - , . , -, - , , - , . - , ,
, ,, . . , . - ( )- . . , , (.. ) . 80 81. : , , . , . : . , , -- ,
, , ,. . . : , , , / 0/1 , . . , ., , , , , ( 3- ) 25 . , 0-1 .,
[Data from each indicator are nor-malized (allocated a value
between 0and 1)] - ,4 - . 4- . , , , , 81 82. : 3: - - 19 2 10 3 4
()11 5 12 6 13, 19, , 7 8 14( ) 20 1521 16( ) 22, 1723 18(10,000
24, )-25 / , / , , ., , , , , , , , . , , - . , : , . . , , - -
[radar chart]- . 82 83. : . - 0-1- (nor- malised measure)- . , . -
, 1- , ( , , ) . . ( . 1- ). , . 1: - radar chart - 1.00 0.80 0.60
0.40 0.20-0.00 --0.20-0.40Colombo -0.60 Kandy -0.80 Kotte
Moratuwa-1.00Matale Negombo - :
http://www.undp.org/oslocentre/docs05/cross/4.%20Creatiog%20Local%20
governance%20Measurements%20-%20shi pra%20Narang.ppt83 84. : . - .
,: . , . , . . , . . T - . , , , , . , , / , . . ap . / - - , . - .
, . , 84 85. : - : , . , , , 24 . : , , , , . (), , , ( ), , , , ,
, , (, (0-1 ) ), (Europe), , ( ), , , , , , ( ). 2004 . - , , . . ,
2000 . 2003- 2004 . . . , -- ., , [existence (/)of public forafor
consultation] . 85 86. :
http://ww2.unhabitat.org/campaigns/governance/activities_6.asphttp://www.unhabitat.org/campaigns/governance
, - 30030, ()Tel: +254-20-7623216, : +254-20-7624264 :
[email protected] / ,
:http://www.icnrd5-mongolia.mn/pdf/UGI%20self-assessment%20guide-lines.dochttp://www.unhabitat.org/downloads/docs/2232_55927_Addendum%20-%20-
[spreadsheet]
:http://www.unhabitat.org/downloads/docs/2232_24121_ugi-final-sheet%20may05.xls
:http://www.unchs.org/downloads/docs/2232_80907_UGIndex.dochttp://info.worldbank.org/etools/mdfdb/docs/WP_Janette1.pdfhttp://www.undp.org/oslocentre/docs05/cross/4.%20Creating%20Local%20Governance%20Measurements%20-%20Shipra%20Narang.ppthttp://ww2.unhabitat.org/campaigns/governance/documents/Pres2Index.pdf
86 87. : 2. () : (PACT; [IDASA]); , , . [SNV]). , , , 2005 . , . .
: , , , . ()- , , , , . 2006 , . , . - 2007 10 - . . : () , (b) - ,
., - 87 88. : . ( . , , ) . / , - , ( , , . , , , , , , , , ,
[civic engagement] , 22 ) . , ( - 4)- . 22 outsoursing - . ( ,5-
)-. , , , . ,. , . - . 5 , . . 88 89. : 4: : ,1.,6.,2. 7.3. 8.4.
9.5.,10. : ,17,,11.,12()1314151618 ,,19202122 , . - . , . () ( , ,
)- ., ()- , . 0-100 .89 90. : , 1.1.1 102006Pact? 0-10. 2FTU/SDR
20051- 0= , [hard copy], 5= , 10=( )- . 1.4.170 2006 / 2? 0= ( - ,
50=50%representative sample) , 100= 100% / . - . , - , , , . . . ,
: , ( the local government) . . : , 1. -1- +1- . (), ( 5- ). - .. ,
, .. 1- . ,2. , 90 91. : 3-5 () . . 5: , . +0.25 .+1 2006 4 6+0.75
+0.5 (, -0.75, ,, -0.25, )- 15 . -0.5 -1 0 , , .- , , . ,,, . - 20
., 2005 . 2006 . 2007 , 10 . , . , , , . , - 91 92. : . ( . ) , . ,
. , . : - , . , (, , , , , )- . , , . . , , ( ) ( , ) ,.. . . 2008
, - , . - / 92 93. : , , . . , - , . . 1: 2004 , 22 . . , , . . - .
2005 2004 : 0.700 0.200 0.600 0.100 0.500 0.400 0.000 0.300 -0.100
0.200 -0.200 0.100 0.000 -0.300 -0.100 -0.400 -0.200 -0.300-0.500
Effectiveness of Law AccountabilityParticipation
EquityTransparencyControlRecourse Rule Region A 2005 2005Region B
2005 2005 :
http://www.impactalliance.org/even.hp?ID=11625201&ID2=DOTOPIC93
94. :
http://www.pact.mg/lgb/http://www.pact.mg/lgb/lgb/interface/http://www.impactalliance.org/ev_en.php?ID=12698_201&ID2=DO_TOPIChttp://www.idasa.org.za/index.asp?page=/
_details.asp%3FRID%3D931%26OTID%3D4%26PID%3D50 : , (IDASA)( )
[email protected] , (IDASA)( ) [email protected] e / e.
:http://www.afdb.org/pls/portal/docs/PAGE/JAI/RESOURCE_MATERIALS/COURSE_MATERIALS/LOCAL%20GOVENANCE%20PRO-POOR%20
%2C%20KIGALI%2C%20RWANDA%2C%20%202006/IA%20LOCAL%20GOVERNANCE%20BAROMETER%20JAI%20KIGALI.PPThttp://www.afdb.org/pls/portal/docs/PAGE/JAI/RESOURCE_MATERIALS/COURSE_MATERIALS/LOCAL%20GOVENANCE%20PRO-POOR%20
%2C%20KIGALI%2C%20RWANDA%2C%20%202006/LG%20BAROMETER_PRESENTATION.PPT-
:
ehttp://www.pactworld.org/galleries/resource-center/local_gov_barometer_handbook.pdf
:http://www.impactalliance.org/ev_es.php?ID=12700_201&ID2=DO_TOPIChttp://www.pact.mg///interface/pages/library/%20Pact.ppthttp://www.pact.mg///interface/pages/library/ANOSY%20FORM.xls
:http://www.impactalliance.org/ev_en.php?ID=11625_201&ID2=DO_TOPIC
:http://www.impactalliance.org/ev_en.php?ID=44902_201&ID2=DO_TOPIC94
95. : 3. ()- : () ,, , , , 2007 10 , . . , , - ; , , , ; , , ; , ,
; . , , , , , ; . , . - , . , , . , 95 96. : , (// .) . - . . , /
,, . . , , , - , , , , . ., . , , , , . 0/1 . , - - (, ,( 2) - , .,
, , ( 6 - ) )- 25 ( 60 ). . , - . , , . 96 97. : 6: - () 10 1/11 2,
, 35 12,6 137 ( ) 14,8 15/ 9 , () 1620 1721, 22 23 24 25 2: - ,
Overall State of Sub-National Governance by Province 100aa90
Accountability 65% Transparency 46% 46% 65% 807060Low50Medium a
40High Equity 56% Effectiveness 53% 56% 53%302010 0aMazar Maimana
HeratKandahar Kunduz EtcaParticipation 38% 38% Total 53% 53% 2007.
. ) , .. , . , ( , 97 98. : , 1) . , 2) , 3) - (, , , ,, )- . , 4)
. / . , , 100.000 . , , - (/)- . , ( ). , . . . . , , (..
[cross-subsidy])- , . . , , , , , . . , , . 98 99. : - .
(www.gaportal.org)- ([email protected]). (ANDS) , , ,
: [email protected] : 0093.(75).2014821 / () . 99 100. : 4. : , , (
), - (IDEA) 2001 - ; : ,,, , - ; . , , , ; . - , ; , , , . .
2002-2003 . . , , . . , . :, ,,, 100 101. : . . . , , , , . , 15 -
( 7- ). 15 . . , . . 7: , / 1, 2, 3 4 5678 910 411( , , ,,)12 , ,13
,1415 101 102. : , 20022004 . . . . , , , . , , , . , ( , 5 ); . :
( , 7 ); ( , , , ( , 10 )- , . , ) , , (- ) ( (- ) ) , . 2- . . :
(), (), () (), , , . 102 103. : 2: 12 ?13.1 ( , )X13.2- X13.3
,X13.4 -X13.5- ,13.6:X13.7X13.8 ,X13.913.10 : X13.11 X13.12 X13.13,
/ ,X13.14 : . /- . , , . , . . , , ./- . , /- . , . , , , 103 104.
: , . 5 . , . , . :
http://www.idea.int/publications/dll_africa/upload/Full_Report.pdf
. [de- , mocracy architectures] , , , . . , , . , . , , [Gaborone]
. . . 104 105. :
http://www.idea.int/democracy/upload/Local_Dem_Assessment_Guide.pdf
()Strmsborg SE-103 34 : +46 8 698 3700, : +46 8 20 24 22 :
[email protected] / :
http://www.idea.int/publications/dll_/upload/Full_Report.pdf :
http://www.idea.int/publications/dll_caucasus/upload/English_text.pdf
: , , -
http://www.idea.int/publications/dll/upload/DLL_full_book.pdf :
(IDEA) - ( , 2005, ):
http://www.afdb.org/pls/portal/docs/PAGE/JAI/RESOURCE_MATERI-ALS/COURSE_MATERIALS/LOCAL%20GOVERNANCE%20A
ND%20POVERTY%20REDUCTION%20CD/HAMDOK%20PP%20REVISED%20EN.PPT105
106. : 5. : . , . . , . : () ; (-)- 2000 ; . 1989-90 , , , . , , .
., , , . , . , , . : 106 107. : (), (), , ., , , , : , ( / ) . . -o
., , . ,., ,: , , , ( , , ), . . ,( )- 5000 . . o , , . [polling
institutions] , , .- , . .107 108. : ,()-. : . :1.: ,, 1. ( )2.:
,2.( ,3.:, )4.:, 3.( , , )5. 4., ( , , - )2: : ,1.(, ;)2.,3. ,4.,
,,5.,,6. , 10007.,8.( , )-9., ( ) 8: , 2006 (, )1.(, / , )2. ( ,3.
(a, )4.,( , , )5. ( , , )6. ( , ,)7., (, , , , )8.(, , , )9.(,
)10.( , , )11.(,,)12. (, , ,[efficacy]) 108 109. : 3: 2006 .
2002-2003 . . , . - .[%]: -(N 183)67.2 32.8100.0 (N 183) 58.5
41.5100.0 (N 953) 28.2 71.8100.0 (N 950) 39.1 60.9100.0 : :/ 1 6 36
662852147 0.1%0.7% 17.3%4.2% 77.7%100% / 1 683 8495 0.1%0.6% 8.4%
3.2%88.4% 100%15539746 94716.4% 4.1%78.8%100% : 2003. :
http://lqi.osi.hu/publications/2006/340/Soos_complete_low_res_2.pdf
/ . , / - , ., , . , : , 109 110. : , . , . , , , . , . 8- 3, ,
2006 . . , - . ,, . , , . 2001 . 2002- 2003 , . . 2002, 2006 . ( )-
. . , , , , [biased or skewed] . 110 111. : :
:http://lgi.osi.hu/publications/2001/22/IOLDG.PDF :
[email protected] / , ,
:http://lgi.osi.hu/documents.php?id=15&m_id=&bid=1 2002, ,
http://lgi.osi.hu/publications/2002/100/Soos-Introduction.pdf 2002,
:,http://lgi.osi.hu/publications/2002/100/Soos-Appendices.pdf
2006:,
http://lgi.osi.hu/publications/2006/340/Soos_complete_low_res_2.pdf111
112. : 6. :. , , , . . . , . , , . ., : , . , ; , , . . , - , 112
113. : . (1= ,to 5 = ) - (1 = 0-20%, 2 = 21- 40%, 3 = 41-60%, 4 =
61-80%, 5 = 81-100%) . , . . , : ( ); () ,, ; . . : , [legitimacy]
, , , , ., (9- ). . 1-5 , . 113 114. : 9: , 121.1.2.1 ,1.1.1.1.1.2
2.1.1. (1.1.3) 2.1.21.1.4 ,2.21.1.5/ / 2.2.1,1.1.6 / -; 2.2.21.2
2.2.31.2.1 ,.1.2.21.2.33 ,44.13.14.1.1 3.1.1,4.1.23.1.24.1.3 :
,4.23.1.3 4.2.1,3.1.4 , 4.2.23.24.3 4.3.13.2.1 ,4.43.3 4.4.13.3.1
4.4.24.5 ,3.3.2 4.5.1 4.5.2565.1 6.15.1.16.1.15.26.1.25.2.1 ,
,5.2.2 ,5.2.36.1.35.2.45.2.5 - / ) / , , , . ( . 114 115. : . . ,
,2004 . 2007 . . . . , . . , . , , , .115 116. :
http://www.logos.undp.org/fileadmin/docs/Gobernabilidad_Local/preset-nacion_ODM/Agenda_Ingles.pdf
Programa de las Naciones Unidas para el Desarrollo Proyecto
Regional de Gobernabilidad Local para Amrica Latina Av. 82 10-62
Piso 3 Bogot, Colombia : 57 1 488 9000 Ext. 234/244 Website:
[email protected] / : www.logos.undp.org ( ):
http://www.logos.undp.org/fileadmin/docs/Gobernabilidad_Local/Guia_Metodologica_pa_Analisis_Gob_Local.pdf,
,
:http://www.logos.undp.org/fileadmin/docs/Gobernabilidad_Local/Tors_y_guia_Metodologica_pa_Elaboracion_de_Marcos_de_Pais.pdf
:
http://www.logos.undp.org/fileadmin/docs/Gobernabilidad_Local/Cartagena/I-7894_-Gobernabilidad_Cartagena_
FINAL_PNUD.ppt#691,10,Visin Estratgica 116 117. : 7. (): , . , , .
, - . . , , , [.: structured interviews- ]- . ( ) . : , ( , , ; ) ,
, 4 ; . , , , , , , ,, , , , 117 118. : ., 4 , 8 , 6 75, . 10- ., .
,, ., , , , .. , : 10: , . 9 14 10 6 8 6 , 9 13 75 118 119. : 11: 6
, , , , / , , , , , 12: 1 = 1- C1A1 ( 1 / 2 = ) 3 / 3- 2- 3 = 2 4 =
119 120. : 13: , / 1. G3A1 ( / . 3 ) ? , ?1 = 2 = 2. / , / ? 3 = ?
4 = , 14: 3.9 5.52.65.4 2.8 3.34.4 4.0 5.35.31.0 2.5 5.76.8 5.4
4.07.07.0 3.9 5.84.9 4.5 5.54.05.5 5.5 1.05.5 / , - , , . , , - , .
, . -, 32 1-10 . . , , / . /, , 3 , .120 121. : , .(, ) , . . . . .
. 2008. . , ( , , - . )-. - , (www.gaportal. org) ,
(oslo.governance.cen- [email protected]). . Jl. Brawijaya VIII 7
Kebayoran Baru, 12160 : +62-21-727 99566 : +62-21-722 5667 :
info@kemitraan. or.id . , 121 122. : 8. , .... ....MIDAMOS (): - ,
AlterVida/GEAM .2001 CIRD, (Centro de Infor-macin y Recursos para
el Desarrol- , lo) , , , . . , . [?] MIDAMOS . , 5 31 , .MIDAMOS /
1-5 , . . MIDAMOS () ,( ). ; 1- 5, , , . , ; ,, , 122 123. : , . .
2008 MIDAMOS . ., , , . 15: MIDAMOS- , , , , , 1. 2% 2. 2% 3. 2% 4.
2% 5. 2% 6. , 2% 7. 2% : 20% 8. 2% : 1.00 9. 2% 10. 2% 1. 2% 2. 2%
3. , 2% 4. , 2%, 2% 5. , 2% 6. : 16%2% 7. 1 : 0.80 3% , , 7% 1. 7%
2. 7% 3. 3% 4. : 24% : 1.20 1. , 3%, 2. 6% 3. 2% 4. ,
[accountability and4% responsibility] 5% 5. 3% : 25% 6. 2% : 1.25
7. 1. 5% 2. 5% 3. , 5% : 15% : 0.75 123 124. : 16: 0- 5: 0,40- (,
4) 4: 0,31-0,40 . 3: 0,21-0,30, 2: 0,11-0,20 .1 : 0,11- 1. ,5 : 9-
(, , . 4) 2. . 4 : 8-9 , , . . , 2. . 3 : 5-7 . 3. . . 4. 2 : 3-4
5. 1 : 3- . 6. , , . . 7. , / . 8. , . 9. . 10. , . 11. . 12. . 17:
A 4,6-5 , B 3,6-4,5 , C 2,6-3,5 D 2-2,5 E 1,9- 124 125. : / MIDAMOS
, , / .: . MIDAMOS- ; ,. : , ; 30% () , . ; . - , , MIDAMOS . , ,
[]. . .(, MIDAMOS - , - . .)- , MIDAMOS- , , , . . (, 17- A- E .)
125 126. : . 2006 . . 2005-2006 . 2008 . 150 .
http://www.midamos.org.py/ MIDAMOS Mcal. Lpez 2029 e/ Ac Caraya
Asuncin, : (595 21) 212540/ 207373 [email protected]
www.midamos.org.py / MIDAMOS
:http://www.midamos.org.py/docs/MANUAL_MIDAMOS_version_1.2.pdfMIDAMOS
Power point :
http://www.intrac.org/docs.php/3362/Alvaro%20Caballero%20para-guai%20PAIC%20INTRAC.ppt
126 127. : 9. : :, . : 1. , , ;2000-2003 (2. , 5 , , ; 9 3. )- , ;
4.A,, , ; 5. 5 , / , . , , . 2004-2007 , , ()- 16 , , . , . . , 5 ,
.[benchmarks]- . 99 , 475 . [insti-tutional building], 127 128. : ,
: , , , ,, , , , , , . / ) (: 50%) 8 , 43 . (25% 0, 100 ; 25% ; .
50% ) [IF , or NOT] ( ) . - , . ( ). . . : [le-gal existence]- (/)
(: 25%) ( / ) (: 25%) [sys-temic efficacy] ( / , 8 . 128 129. : 18:
, 1. 6 , : , , 8 , : 2. , , , .11 , : 3. ,( ) , 1. , . 3 , : . :- ,
;4. - - ,1 , 6 , : , , 4 , : 2. , , / , , / ] , 3 , : , , , , , , 3
, : 129 130. : 19: 3 (existence; ; )- I: O , I: , , % 0,25%
0,25%0,50%d1/ v1/i1 , 10%0.1250.1250.5 15 : (, , , ) d1/ v1/i2
10%0.1875 0.1875 0.375 7.50 [Organic regulations] , , , , , d1/ , ,
v1/i3 20%0.25 0.1250.2512.50 , , ( ) , , , / d1/ v1/i4 10%0.1675
0.1875 0.375 7.30 130 131. : - d1/ v1/i5 20% 0.25 0.250.37517.50
Reglamentary d1/ v1/i6 , 30% 0.25 0.250.530.00 , , , 20% 16.96 / ,
, . . [substantiverights] ( ), . [procedural rights] ( , 19- . )
[systemic rights] ( , . ) . . . 131 132. : , , , , . 2002 . .
http://www.epfcentroamerica.org/proyecto.htm Estudios para el
Futuro Universidad Veritas- 300 , Carretera a Zapote Apartado
postal 2324-1000 , : (506) 225-7512 y (506) 281-2026 : (506)
224-9549 [email protected] www.epfcentroamerica.org /
http://www.epfcentroamerica.org/ma-triz.htm . (www.gaportal.org) -
([email protected]) 132 133. : 10. Desde lo Local (
-): ISO9001 Instituto Nacional para el ( Federalismo y el
Desarrollo 4 IWA4)Munici pal INFAED .Desde lo Local - , ( [SEGOB])-
INAFED- , , , , . . , . . :1. 2. 3. [socially inclussive
development] 4. . Desde lo Local Desde lo Local , x , . /, - / 21 ,
[UN Local Agenda 21]- ., 133 134. : Desde lo Local ; = .. , , . , ,
. , . , . , , , , , . , , . , 4 39 , 257 - . . . 3 , , 1.4.- , - ..
.: = ; = 134 135. : 20: 3.1 1.1 , 1.2 ( 3.2 , , ) 3.3 1.3 ( , )1.4
3.4 3.5 1.5 1.6 3.6 , 1.7 3.7 1.8 3.8 3.9 1.9 3.10 , - 1.10 1.11
3.11 1.12 21: 1.4 , 1.4.1 ? 1.4.2 , , ? 1.4.3 , , ? 1.4.4 , , ?
1.4.5 ? ? 1.4.6 ? , 1.4.7 , ? ? ? , , 1.4.8 , , , , , , ? 135 136.
: 22. DESDE LO LOCALPRIMER CUADRANTE: DESARROLLO INSTITUCIONAL PARA
UN BUEN GOBIERNO 1.4 MUNICIPIO PARTICIPATIVO1.4.1, - . ?.. , , ,
..1.4.51.4.5. ? , ; ? , . - .. -- ; , - . 3: DESDE LO LOCAL:
Desarrollo Institucionalpara un Buen Gobierno 136 137. : / 3- : : .
( 3.4.). , , , 22. . , , , , , . , , , . , . ( 3.11). - , ,, , . .
22 ,, , , . , , 137 138. : . , . , . . , . . 2008 2440 . 464 57 39
. . 2002-2003 26 . Desde lo ,Local 2004 . . , ., , , , , . 138 139.
: Agenda Desde lo Local: Descentralizacion Estrategica para el
Desarrollodo lo Local Programa del, Gobierno Federal para el
Desarrollo Integral de los Municipios Mexicanos:
http://www.inafed.gob.mx/work/resources/LocalContent/8600/1/AGEN-DA%202008%20III.pdf
:
http://egobierno.aguascalientes.gob.mx/seplade/siglags/Login_datos.aspx
INAFED Roma 41, casi esq. Insurgentes, Col. Jurez, Del. Cuauhtmoc,
C.P. 06600 Mxico, D.F. Tel. Conmutador +52(55) 5062.2000
[email protected] / Desde lo Local Power point
:http://www.iacipgto.org.mx/web/cont/Agenda_desde_lo_local_Felipe_de_Jesus%20_Romo_INAFED.pdf
ISO9001 ( 4 IWA4):http://www.gobiernosconfiables.org/queesiwa.html
139 140. : 11. , - ()- : ment]/, , Inter-rseau , Europen des
Initiatives Ethiques et . Solidaires, Territoire Responsable: - , .
. 2005 . , . . , , , , / . . , . : ( ( ), , , , )- , ( [Access to
essential resourc- es, Personal balance], [Commit- 140 141. : ) 2.
. ? , 3. ( ? ) , ,300 , . . , 7 31 250 . . . 8-10 / . ( : 0 = ) , -
5 = ( ) . . : 1. ? . 23. 141 142. : 24. , , 0 , [.: favouritism, ,
] / , 1- , , , , / , 2 , , , , , , , , , , , , , 3 , , , , , , , 4-
, , , , , . 5- , , , , , , )- , . . : , , , ., , , , , , . . , / .
- , , , (0-5)- . 25 ., ( , , .142 143. : 25: , 0 - 1- - 2 - ; 95% (
) 3 : ; , , , , : 30 , / 4- - (2007) 600 (2007) - : , 5- , , , , ,
, . - . . , Roma . , /( .) . , . , . . , 143 144. : (), (), 14 , .
2007 , 2008 . . . (www.gaportal.org)
([email protected]). Mihaela Vetan Iris Network
[email protected] / :
http://www.coe.int/t/dg3/socialpolicies/socialcohesiondev/source/GUIDE_EN.pdf
144 145. : 12. (): ; (, ) / - ;1994 . . - , , , , ,. - , ., . , , ,
. , - - . , . : , , , , ,, , 145 146. : ( 5 - +5,. 1-7) .[prob- ,
ability random sample] . . . . , . / . - , . , , , , , ,- . , , ,
,, , , . , . ,- , . . , . . , , - . ; . ; . - . 146 147. : , - , -
. . , , . , ()- . , ( . )- . 5 - . - . , , . , , , . - , , , , .
,,, , ; , , , , , ; . . , 1993-1994 . . , , .147 148. : , , ( )- ,
, . . , . , ,[] . , . , . 5: . , , , , . - 1994 1140 , 1999 1339 ,
839 . - .: a) (); ) , , ; ) ; ) . , . 9 / . 1994, 1999 2003 . 148
149. : : 10092 93 9888 89 89 8480 80 80% Satisfied 61 605451 4031
26 33 34 3126 24 282718 2011 15 n/an/a0 BWSSB BESCOM BMTC BMP
PoliceBSNLRTO BDA G. HospitalAgency 199419992003 : BWSSB: ; BESCOM:
; BMTC: ; BMC: ; BSNL: ; RTO: ; BDA: [: n/a- ] :
http://lnweb18.worldbank.org/oed/oeddoclib.nsf/b57456d58a-
ba40e585256ad400736404/d241684df81fce2785256ead0062de10/$FILE/ecd_
wp_12.pdf , , - . / , . , . , , ( ) . 149 150. :
http://www.pacindia.org
http://www.serd.ait.ac.th/ump/newsletter99vol2%20no3.pdf#search=Opportunities%20and%20Challenges%20in%20Assessing%20Governance%20and%20Human
15, KIADB Bommasandra Jigani Link, 562 106, . : (+9180)
27834918/19/20, +918110415054 : [email protected] - , :
[email protected] - : [email protected] ,
: [email protected] /
:http://www.capacity.org/en/content/pdf/2899http://www.adb.org/Projects/e-toolkit/-qc-final.pdfhttp://paf.mahiti.info/pdfs/_Profile_eamonedit_.pdf
:http://lnweb18.worldbank.org/oed/oeddoclib.nsf/b57456d58a-ba40e585256ad400736404/d241684df81fce2785256ead0062de10/$FILE/ecd_wp_12.pdf
- , , : www.citizenreportcard.com
http://www.citizenreportcard.com//pdf/manual.pdf 150 151. : 13. (
): (), , , . - 2006 . . 20 , - , . . . , . , . () . . , , . : . , ;
, , 10 ( . , 151 152. : , , , , , , , . , ); , , , . . 6 7 , , , .
. 20 343 1997 ( ) . . / 20 . . 6: . Prism 2006 - 4 . , , , . , . :
( , , ; ; ; ; ; ) ( ; ; ; )152 153. : ( , , , , , , ) , ( , , , , ,
, , , . . . [score-card] .,,, 1,2 5 2,, 1 2MZ (Mjesna zajednica-
MZ(Mjesna zajednica-)- 3 )-2 2 4 - 2 4 ()- 5( )- 2 5 6 -( ?) 2 5 /
/ 7 1 1 :
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTSOCACCDEMSIDEGOV/Resources/Prism_So-cialAuditofLGinBiH_QualitativeReport.pdf153
154. : 7: - 131. ? (1) , (2) , (3) , (4) , or (5) .1 2 3 4 5 8,1 2
3 4 5 81 2 3 4 5 81 2 3 4 5 8,,., 1 2 3 4 5 8,1 2 3 4 5 8, 1 2 3 4
5 8.1 2 3 4 5 8, 132. ? 1 2 3 4 5 8 9 :
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTSOCACCDEMSIDEGOV/Re-
sources/Prism_SocialAuditinBiH_SurveyQuestionnaire_final.pdf , 2006
. 2007 ? 20 . . / ? . . : , 154 155. : / , . . . , . ,(, , ,, )-
.155 156. :
http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTSOCACCDEMSIDEGOV/Re-sources/Prism_SocialAuditinBiH_SurveyQuestionnaire_final.pdf
: Mary L. McNeil, : [email protected] : Damon C. Luciano, :
[email protected] / :
http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/WBI/EXTSOCACCDEMSIDEGOV/0,,contentMDK:21241045~pagePK:64168445~
piPK:64168309~theSitePK:2872075,00.html
http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/WBI/WBIPRO-GRAMS/CMUDLP/0,,contentMDK:21124070~pagePK:64156158~p
iPK:64152884~theSitePK:461754,00.html
:http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/WBI/EXTSOCACCDEMSIDEGOV/0,,contentMDK:21339390~pagePK:64168445~piPK:64168309~theSitePK:2872075,00.html
:http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTSOCACCDEMSIDEGOV/Re-sources/Prism_SocialAuditofLGinBiH_QualitativeReport.pdf
156 157. : 14. , (): , , , (- . CIET) : , , - 2001 , , ; ,. , , ; ,
, , , . , . , . , 2001-2002 . , (20042009)- - . 2002 . 2004-2005 ,
, , , . , , 157 158. : , . . , , . , , . . 26- 2004-05 . , . . , .
, , . (, , )- , . , , 158 159. : / , , . , , , ., , - . . . (,, ),
, , , , // . 8- 2004-05 . , . ( ), - 2001/2 (2004 , )- , . . . . 9
, [devolution] . . - , (- .), 159 160. : 2001 , 10000 , . 2002 ; 89
47,000 . 2004 10 . , . 53,000 . , 2001-02 . .(2001-02 2004-05), , ,
, , . . , 2008 . . , . . 14- . 160 161. : 8: , , 2004-2005 . .2002
, . 2004 , 12 24.6% 12.5% . ; , . 3. 12 ( )25.1Sindh23Bstan 31.8
23.7 2004NWFP2323.2 2002 Punjab 24.321.1Pakistan25.221.70 10 20
3040 2. , (2004)Sindh 11.825.1Bstan 11.2 31.8 WomenNWFP11.923 Men
13Punjab 24.312.5 Pakistan24.60 10 20 3040 :
http://www.ciet.org/en/documents/projects_library_docs/2006224175348.pdf
161 162. : 9: 2002-2004 Percent AvailableChange in decreased
availabilityno change increased availability no data 26: , , ,/ /-,
-, ( , ,,) 162 163. :
http://www.ciet.org/en/documents/projects/200621012547.asp Dr. Anne
Cockcroft - 8636, London SW6 2ZB, U.K. : 44 171 736 7534 : 44 171
731 8922 : [email protected] # 11(B), # 7 F-8/3 1621 , :
[email protected] / 2002 2004/2005 :
http://www.ciet.org/en/documents/projects_library_docs/2006224174624.pdf
http://www.ciet.org/en/documents/projects_library_docs/2006224175348.pdf
http://www.ciet.org/en/documents/projects_library_docs/200622417568.pdf163
164. : 15. (): ; - ( , ; ) - CARE. ; () , , SHARIQUE 2006 ; . , , ,
, - , . , ()- . , . , / ./- . : . , 164 165. : , ( - - ) . , / /-
[Flashcards]- . . . . : (i) , (ii) / / , (iii) // ( , ), (iv) . ,
(v) , (vi) (-. ) .: . : 1. ; [, ]: ; ?; 2. : ( ) ? (- ); . - 8 ( /
, ). ( - 20 - - 28, 165 166. : , ) . / . : , . : , , ,, . ,1-6 (, .
)- ,27 - ( , ) . ( , ) . . ( )- . . - , . , , , / / - . - , . . , :
166 167. : , . : , , , , /, , ( , , . - , . ? / ?)- . , . - - , , .
, , - - . ; - - ,, . . . , . , - - [167 168. : ] . 35 . , - 5,700 .
2007. . :http://www.sdc.org.bd/ressources/resource_en_167178.pdf
27: ( ) ? II- :: : -: 1-5 6-9:0? 10-11- II- ? II 7 4 ? II-? , II- ?
168 169. : http://www.e-works.com.ph/pcps/gofordev.asp SHARIQUE 2F
NE (D) 73 (G) Gulshan-2, Dhaka-1212 : 8815688, 8827633
[email protected] / SHARIQUE :
http://www.sdc.org.bd/en/Home/Local_Governance/SHARIQUE
http://igs-bracu.ac.bd/UserFiles/File/archive_file/SHARIQUE_Keynote_Final.pdf
:
:http://www.intercooperation-bd.org/PDF/sharique%20doc%20-%20the%20state%20of%20local%20governance%20in%20rajshahi%20and%20sunamganj.pdf?PHPSESSID=91bf3c3af7749975e071cb66f5a9d93c169
170. : 16. ()- : . , , . ()- , . 1999 . 41 . , . .()- . , , . . , .
2001 22 , , , . ., , . , - . 3 . : - , . 170 171. : . ( 30- 31 2001
). 2 - 0-1- (0 = ; 1 = ). . - . Windows 12 , - . 41 0-100- ..100- -
1999 . . 2001-2002 . 2003 / . - . , . ., , . ., , , , , . . , , , ,
, . 171 172. : 30. - : -, (DNI),.,.5. :----- (DOI) , ,. DOI(, ,) (,
)-.-(PDI) .,, .. : 31: - , 2001-2002 ( )-BULACANAngat41 102685 32
78 46 64 0 039 14Baliwag61 103381 48 91 53 70100 100 32
59Guiguinto68 195283 51 54 52 94100 100 20 58SJDM City52 253370 50
85 53 26100 100 74 77Plaridel 47 234990 52 77 58 59 0 076 23Bustos
44 264683 43 77 55 27100069 50Davao DelNorteB.E. Dujali79 125899 93
57 64 78100 100 89 95Panabo City58 102995 15 79 46 56100 100 61
71IGACOS 60 4 5794 77 54 57 28100 100 99 96Sto.Tomas44 154397 68 65
58 36 0 089 38Tagum City 52 7 2081 54 53 43 43100 100 62
71Asucion57 123298 73 52 53 29100 100 88
:www.goodgovernance-bappenas.go.id/publikasi_CD/cd_indikator/referensi_cd_indikator/UNFOLD-
ER/GOFORDEV_PJPA3__TRACKING_GO.PDF - , . , -, , . . 2001-2002 172
173. : 47 , . 44% ( , , , - , , , ), . 29%- . , , , .
http://www.e-works.com.ph/pcps/gofordev.asp - , 327 328, , , ,
1101. : +63-2 920-5457 or 927-9686 loc. 268, 269 or 259; : +63-2
920-5458. : [email protected] / O : :
http://www.e-works.com.ph/pcps/gofordev.aspO : :
http://www.e-works.com.ph/pcps/gofordev.asp : :
http://www.e-works.com.ph/pcps/measure_final.pdf :
http://www.e-works.com.ph/pcps/casestudy.pdf173 174. : 17. ()- : .
, , . : , ( . )- , - (, 1997 , , ,. , , , )- , . , . , , , , , , .
, (/ . ), () , , . 174 175. : . - (, , , ), ( . -, ) , . / - , . ()
. . , , (/ )- , / , . , , ()- , , , , , , . - - , , . - - , , , ..
32- - , , - . , , , ( , ) ,, , , . , , .175 176. : 32. , () , () 1.
2. , 11 ,, 2 , 3 4 ( , 5 )2 ,, 6(-), /( , /- , , , )-. -,. 1( ?) 1.
2 2.. 3, ,: 4 ,/- 5 . 6 3. 7 8 1,1. 2,,, ,, 3, 4 2. 3. ( )- ,, .
33. , /( , ( )- ,( ).)(,- - 20%- . ).( - - 20%-). .()() . .(). .
176 177. : 34. 20 , , 2006,/ 2006 2005 20041AchhamM q51 s
pp2Bajhang M q52 s bp3Baitadi M q48 s pp4DarchulaM q51 s pp5Kailali
M q57 s pp6Jumla M q39 p pp7Humla M q46 p pp8MuguNMdq 33 p pp9Rukun
M q57 s pp10 JajarkotM q62 b pp11 SalyanM q68 b sp12 Dolakha NMdq
54 p pp13 Rupandehi M q65 b pp14 DhanushaM q50 s pp15 Kaski M q56 p
pp16 Kavri M q66 b pp17 UdayapurM q57 s sp18 Tehrathum M q64 b sp19
Taplejung M q56 s pp20 SolukhumbuM q58 s ps: q= ,dq=M= NM =
p=,s=,b= , , , / , . - [benchmark]- , . , - . , , , . 33- . , , .
177 178. : / , ,- , , , , , . , , . . , 1997 ( 2003 ;) 2000/2001 ;
, 2004 , 2005 ( ) ; 2004/2005 , , 2008 ( + )- . , . , , .(/)- 100%
, , , , , ( ) .,. , , , , , , - . 34- 20 2006 , , ,, ; , ., ,, , ,
178 179. : , . , . .,- , . , , ., , , , , - .(); , , - , (- ), / .
(,/ , -, ,, , , ) , , . , , (); , , , . - - , , , , . . , - , ,
.179 180. : - - , , . , , . , , / . 180 181. :
http://regionalcentrebangkok.undp.or.th/practices/governance/docu-ments/uncdf_nepal-int2005.pdf
/ ,
:http://regionalcentrebangkok.undp.or.th/practices/governance/docu-ments/uncdf_nepal-int2005.pdf
; :http://www.kl.dk/_bin/7dbb8d72-4a58-47c8-b0ba-26d123226395.ppt ,
:
http://www.afdb.org/pls/portal/docs/PAGE/JAI/RESOURCE_MA-TERIALS/COURSE_MATERIALS/LOCAL%20GOVENANCE%20PRO-POOR%20
%2C%20KIGALI%2C%20RWANDA%2C%20%202006/ANNEX%204-%20PERFORMANCE%20ASSESS-MENT%20MANUAL%20%20FINAL%20DRAFT-%202006.DOC
, :
http://www.afdb.org/pls/portal/docs/PAGE/JAI/RESOURCE_MA-TERIALS/COURSE_MATERIALS/LOCAL%20GOVENANCE%20PROPOOR%20
%2C%20KIGALI%2C%20RWANDA%2C%20%202006/REVISED%20ASSESSMENT%20MANU-AL%20FINAL.PDF
, :
http://www.afdb.org/pls/portal/docs/PAGE/JAI/RESOURCE_MA-TERIALS/COURSE_MATERIALS/LOCAL%20GOVENANCE%20PRO-POOR%20%2C%20KIGALI%2C%20RWANDA%2C%20%202006/ASSESSMENT%20MANUAL%20RE-VISED%20-%20UGANDA-%20SECTORS.DOC181
182. : 18. ()() : , . (), , , - . , , , . . , : ( , ( 1982), ; (
2000); , (DevWatch 2001) . ; , . , . .- , , . . , , , , 182 183. :
, : , . [Exclusive List indicator]: . , - , . .- , 17 , 111 ( 35 -
)- () . . , , . [ ] . :, , , .. - , , , , , . ,, . : . : ; - . () ,
: , , . . - . - . -183 184. : 35. , / 21- 12- 32 - 23- 34- , 21-
32- 24- 22- 326 524 , 314 , , 732 , 244 , , 322 313 221 4: . 5- ,
[benchmarks] 3- . : . 184 185. : , . , , . , . . , , , - , ,- , . .
- 1-5 , , . , 5, .1, 3 [benchmark] . - , , , , , , - , , .- . / , ,
, , - . , - [.: PGPMS- ] - . . , - - 185 186. : - , , -, , , - . ,
. . : [Display Data], , - 20042-10 , , , -113 . 79 , . 117 4- 1501
. 2004 . 2005 . .- . 3-4 ., , (, .,-, , , , )- , ( 5)- . ; - , , ,
, , . . - . , 186 187. : , . , - , MS Excel Format- upload sheet .
. ,- , , . , , , , . , , , 5: ( , ) , , 2004Legend Excellent Good
Fair Bad Poor , No Data , 187 188. : http://blgs.gov.ph/lgpms/ -
3/F A. Francisco Gold Condominium II Mapagmahal Sreet, Diliman, , :
(02) 925-1153 or 925-0377 : (02) 928-9181 / :
http://www.blgs.gov.ph/lgpms/about.php?about1_id=1 :
http://www.blgs.gov.ph/lgpms/lgpms_manual.pdf- :
http://www.blgs.gov.ph/lgpms_live/v1.3d.001/default/login.php 188
189. : 19. , (M) : , M , ., , . , , M , , , [Resposibility,
Transparency and Ac- , countability (RTA)]- - . M . . . , , , . . ,
, , . , - , , , , . 189 190. : , , . : , , , , . , . : . 10-15 , ,
, , - . 37- RTA : . :RTA , , . RTA . / , , , RTA . .. . 190 191. :
37: RTA , , ( ) ( )- ,, ,H -,,, ,,H - >3, >2 ,>>> 1,
., ,>3 ,>2 >1 , ,,,, ,,.>3>2>1 . , , , , , . . ,
: , . ,191 192. : , . , ( ) . . . 2008, .
http://europeandcis.undp.org/governance/show/E0665B63-F203-1EE9-B2237737A3E4BC48
M : 8-ma Udarna Brigada Str.2, 1000 Skopje, M : + 389 - 2 - 3249
500 : + 389 2 3249 505 Web Site: www.undp.org.mk :
[email protected] 192 193. : 20. () : . [Asociacin Chilenade
Munici palidades] , . , , . . 95: ., : , ; , ( , , , , , ),; ; .
39- . , 11 , , . , . - (64) . / , , , , , ,. . / , . : 193 194. : ,
( ), 21 () . . . . 40- : . 345 , , - , - , , ( ), - ( )- 3 // . .
(1 ), (3 ) . (1 )-, (2 . ), (3 )- . / , . , . , . . - 194 195. :
39. / 1. -1-,. 2. ,12 , , 3. ,64 ,,. 4., 1, , ,,. 5.63 6.1,( -) 7.,
3 8.1,, ,. 9.3,. 10. 1. 11. 2. 40. , , 14 ,,. 75,. 20 ,. , , , , ,
. , . (.. / , , )- ,195 196. : , , - . , , . , . 2007 12 . .
http://www.munitel.cl/eventos/otros/chile
e/propuestatransparen-cia.pdf Rancagua 535, Providencia , /:
56-2-2743627 www.chiletransparente / Power
point:http://www.munitel.cl/eventos/escuela2008/Documentos/sede_valdivia/concejales/concejal03.pdf
196 197. : 21. : , ,, . , , (, , , ), .(.. , ) , ., , , . . , , , ,
. , , ; [.: county-, , ]- , , , , . , - ,, . 42- . 197 198. : , de
jure . 100 , - 0 . de facto . :, , ,, , , , . , (, , 0-100 0, 25,
50, 75 ) 100 . ( . ; ;, , ; , ; . ). ( . , , , ( ). ; ). 0-100 (0-
, 100- ) . . , , . . . 198 199. : 41. , , 1a: / 1. //( )1b:/ /
.1c:/ 100-75-50-25-0? 2. / 2a:/ 100 75 50 25 0 .2b:/ -
100-75-50-25-0,.2c:/-/?.3a:/-/ 3. .3b:/-/.? 3c:/ / . 4. 4a:.
/4b:100 75 50 25 0-.? / , , , 3-5 - , (, )- . ,, . : . , ; ; , , ;
, , . 199 200. : 42: : 61 LIB -1 ,, 82 LIB -1-1 96 LIB -1-2 86 LIB
-1-3 63LIB-2 67 LIB-2-169 LIB-2-260 LIB-2-372LIB-3 41 LIB-3-138
LIB-3-2 0 LIB-3-3 ,82 LIB-3-445LIB-4 ,72 LIB-4-178 LIB-4-2,
65LIB-544 LIB-5-1 0 LIB-5-274 LIB-5-359 ; , (, ) . ,, , , ( , . ) ,
. , , . , . : , 6- ; , , , 200 201. : . ; , ; . . , , ,, , . , . .
, , , , , ,, . ; , . , . . , , , , ; , , . ( - ,201 202. : - ). , ,
, . . , ( . ) 15 , . , .. 2007. . 6: 2008 : - 0-100 , . , , .1
Civil Society,, Info, Media1 Access to , 2 2 Government
Accountability3 3 Civil Service4 Oversight and Regulation4 , 5 , 5
Anti-corruption and Rule of Law0 20 406080 100> : :
http://local.globalintegrity.org202 203. :
http://local.lr2007.globalintegrity.org/ 1029 -, 600, 20005 : +1
202.449.4100 : +1 866.681.8047 : [email protected] Website:
www.globalintegrity.org / :
http://local.lr2007.globalintegrity.org/Liberial%20Local%20Gover-nance%20Toolkit%20.pdf203
204. : 22. , : // ., , , . : ()- - - , , ; , , . ; , , . .- , , , ,
.: , , , , , , , 204 205. : , 2 , , . ,, , (22 )- . , 3 , , , . ,
(6 )- . 2 . : / . 17 3 , 125 2 . : , .: ; , ;, , , (, ; / , ) , , ;
, ( , ) . . , , . : . 1 , / , / (14 )- , . .205 206. : 43: 2 26: 5
, ,,,, ( , )? / / 2: ,- ? / , , , , . . ; ; , , ; - ; , ; - ( . )-
. , 206 207. : , . . . : ,, . , ; ; , ; , (); ; (, . ( , , , , , .
), , , , , , , , ? , . / ; , , ,, . ? ,
[Gender-mainstreamingmeasures] 207 208. : , , , . ., (, T , , , , )
, . , , , , (, . , : ( ), ., , , , ). . : - , , , , , , . , , , . ,
, . , . , 208 209. : , 2008. . . :
http://europeandcis.undp.org/cd/show/68567553-F203-1EE9-
B0F61CC5775E3F9E :
http://europeandcis.undp.org/cd/show/B1FC1F8E-F203-1EE9-B06F342DB5E4E9C9
, [RBEC] 35 811 09 : +421 (2) 59337 111 : +421 (2) 59337 450 :
[email protected] 210. : : ISBN
978-99929-961-3-79789992996137 Printed by Sansudai Co.,Ltd Tel:
976-11-320588 210
