25
EN BANC G.R. No. 119657 February 7, 1997 UNIMASTERS CONGLOMERATION, INC., petitioner, vs. COURT OF APPEALS and KUBOTA AGRI MACHINERY PHILIPPINES, INC., respondents. NARVASA, C.J.: The appellate proceeding at bar turns upon the interpretation of a stipulation in a contract governing venue of actions thereunder arising. On October 8, 1988 Kubota Agri-Machinery Philippines, Inc. (hereafter, simply KUBOTA) and Unimasters Conglomeration, Inc. (hereafter, simply UNIMASTERS) entered into a " Dealership Agreement for Sales and Services" of the former's products in Samar and Leyte Provinces. 1 The contract contained, among others: 1) a stipulation reading: ". . . All suits arising out of this Agreement shall be filed with/in the proper Courts of Quezon City," and 2) a provision binding UNIMASTERS to obtain (as it did in fact obtain) a credit line with Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co.- Tacloban Branch in the amount of P2,000,000.00 to answer for its obligations to KUBOTA. Some five years later, or more precisely on December 24, 1993, UNIMASTERS filed an action in the Regional Trial Court of Tacloban City against KUBOTA, a certain Reynaldo Go, and Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company-Tacloban Branch (hereafter, simply METROBANK) for damages for breach of contract, and injunction with prayer for temporary restraining order. The

Unimasters vs. CA.doc

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

EN BANC G.R. No. 119657 February 7, 1997UNIMASTERS CONGLOMERATION, INC., petitioner, vs.COURT OF APPEALS an !U"OTA AGRI MAC#INER$ P#ILIPPINES, INC., respondents. NAR%ASA, C.J.:The appellate proceeding at bar turns upon the interpretation of a stipulationin a contract governing venue of actions thereunder arising.On October 8, 1988 ubota Agri!"achiner# $hilippines, %nc. &hereafter, si'pl#(BOTA) and (ni'asters Conglo'eration, %nc. &hereafter, si'pl# (N%"A*TE+*) entered into a ,-ealership Agree'ent for *ales and *ervices, of the for'er.s products in *a'ar and /e#te $rovinces. 1 The contract contained, a'ong others01) a stipulation reading0 ,. . . All suits arising out of this Agree'ent shall be 1led 2ith3in the proper Courts of 4ue5on Cit#,, and6) a provision binding (N%"A*TE+* to obtain &as it did in fact obtain) a credit line 2ith "etropolitan Ban7 and Trust Co.!Tacloban Branch in the a'ount of $6,888,888.88 to ans2er for its obligations to (BOTA.*o'e 1ve #ears later, or 'ore precisel# on -ece'ber 69, 199:, (N%"A*TE+* 1led an action in the +egional Trial Court of Tacloban Cit# against (BOTA, a certain +e#naldo ;o, and "etropolitan Ban7 and Trust Co'pan#!Tacloban Branch &hereafter, si'pl# "ET+OBAN) for da'ages for breach of contract, and in