23
ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Division of Waste Management WAshi"nM4-nn fl 2 n555 W&I Project DccP~ein 4 - PWn .4< - ~~~~- - -^ -- D t iuton LP DR b ' Dear David: (Return to WM, 623-SS) Transmitted with this letter are trip reports for the two meet- ings: 5 (1) NNXSI Review Meeting at Las Vegas, Nevada, on 16-18 September 1985; and (2) "International Symposium on Coupled Processes Affecting the Performance of a Nuclear Waste Repository" at Lawrence Berkeley Laboratories, 18-20 September 1985. Please call me if you have any questions concerning these reports. Sincerely, Rog r D. Hart Program Manager cc: J. Greeves, Engineering Branch Office of the Director, NMSS E. Wiggins, Division of Contracts Document Control Room rdh/ks . L -- _- 1 - C; C) C=1 zE 3: 9510240352 85108 PDR fIRES EEC ITAS D-101 6 PDR 9pA: 01 SI 1~ g 10IN3IN3j 'l oJNeC 1JOO 5M P.O. Box 14806 * Minneapolis, Minnesota 55414 * (612) 623-9599 cYaO3

Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

ITASCAConsulting Group, Inc.

8 October 1985

Contract No. NRC-02-85-002Task Order No. 1

David Tiktinksy - SS623U.S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionDivision of Waste ManagementWAshi"nM4-nn fl 2 n555

W&I ProjectDccP~ein 4

-

PWn .4< -

~~~~- - -^ - - D t iuton LP DR

b 'Dear David: (Return to WM, 623-SS)

Transmitted with this letter are trip reports for the two meet-ings:

5

(1) NNXSI Review Meeting at Las Vegas, Nevada, on16-18 September 1985; and

(2) "International Symposium on Coupled ProcessesAffecting the Performance of a Nuclear WasteRepository" at Lawrence Berkeley Laboratories,18-20 September 1985.

Please call me if you have any questions concerning these reports.

Sincerely,

Rog r D. HartProgram Manager

cc: J. Greeves, Engineering BranchOffice of the Director, NMSSE. Wiggins, Division of ContractsDocument Control Room

rdh/ks

.

L --

_- 1

- C;

C)C=1zE3:

9510240352 85108PDR fIRES EEC ITASD-1016 PDR

9pA: 01 SI 1~ g

10IN3IN3j'l oJNeC 1JOO 5M

P.O. Box 14806 * Minneapolis, Minnesota 55414 * (612) 623-9599

cYaO3

Page 2: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

ITASCA TRIP REPORT

DATE: 16-18 September 1985

LOCATION:

PURPOSE:

ATTENDEES:

NRC Field OfficeLas Vegas, Nevada

NNWSI Review Meeting

P. Aamodt (Los Alamos National Laboratory)S. Bhathacharya (Engineering International, Inc.)J. Daemen (Itasca Consulting Group, Inc.)D. Gupta (NRC Site Representative)K. Hanna (U.S. Bureau of Mines)D. Irby (U.S. Department of Energy - Nevada)P. Prestholt (NRC Site Representative)D. Tiktinsky (NRC Site Representative)

PREPARED BY: J. Daemen

Summary - The review meeting was attended at the request of NRC,WMEG. The main focus of the meeting was a broad-ranging overviewof available documents describing tests which DOE-Nevada intendsto perform at the Yucca Mountain Exploratory Shaft Test Facility.Although time limitations did not allow a detailed review of theextensive testing program, on which a wealth of information isavailable, the meeting provided an excellent opportunity for theNRC team to gain an overall perspective on the tests planned, onthe rationale behind the tests, on the objectives to be accom-plished by the tests, and the experimental implementation to beused.

An informal but wide-ranging and highly informative briefing on ESstatus and plans was given by Paul L. Aamodt, of Los Alamos NationalLaboratories, in the presence of Dennis H. Irby, of DOE - Nevada.

Roge D. HartProgram Manager8 October 1985

ITASCA

Page 3: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

I

COST BREAKOUT

Time

Jaak Daemen

Actual Expenses

Travel

Lodging

Meals

24 hours @ $55.00/hr

Airfare - Daemen

2 nights - Daemen($40.66/night)

9/16 - Daemen9/17 - Daemen9/18 - Daemen

$ 1,320.00

118.00

81.32

21.4521.0021.00

$ 262.77

ITASCA

Page 4: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

ITASCA TRIP REPORT

DATES: 18 - 20 September 1985

LOCATION: Lawrence-Berkeley LaboratoryUniversity of CaliforniaBerkeley, California

PURPOSE: International Symposium on Coupled ProcessesAffecting the Performance of a Nuclear WasteRepository

ITASCAATTENDEE: R. Hart (a list of all attendees is included

as Attach. 1)

Summary - This symposium provided a forum for scientists and engi-neers to discuss their research and assess the state of the currentknowledge of problems posed by the coupling of physical and chemicalprocesses related to the performance of nuclear waste repositoriesin geologic formations. The symposium was sponsored by the Officeof Civilian Waste Management of the U.S. Department of Energy, theOffice of Nuclear Regulatory Research of the U.S. Nuclear RegulatoryCommission, in co-operation with the OECD Nuclear Energy Agency andthe Commission of the European Communities. A copy of the symposiumprogram is attached (Attach. 2).

This symposium was an excellent time to gain background on the nuclearwaste isolation programs outside the United States. Overviews werepresented for French, Swedish, Canadian, Belgian, and Swiss programs.In addition, field testing plans were presented by all three of theU.S. programs (NNSWI, BWIP, and SRPO).

During the first day of the symposium, reviews of current field pro-jects were presented by investigators both inside and outside theU.S. Noticeably missing from the presentations (particularly thosegiven by DOE representatives for the three U.S. programs) was anyreference to field investigations of coupled processes.

During the second day, overviews were presented on coupled processeswith emphasis on geohydrology, geomechanics, and geochemistry. Thiswas followed by general reviews of all contributed papers.

Of the presentations given, in my opinion, the most provocativequestion was raised by G. de Marsily of Ecoles des Mines, Paris.He posed the question "Will the waste disposal decision wait forthe testing of effects of coupled processes?" In his opinion, thereare three factors affecting this question:

ITASCA

Page 5: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

1 /

(I)-Some coupled processes are not minor-but synergistic.

(2) Time is not running out, and an economic coupled testin the field can be performed.

(3) Problems have occurred to warrant such testing-e.g.,Rocky Mountain Arsenal.

On the final day of the symposium, the meeting was opened to generaldiscussion and questions. I believe the real concerns were aired onthis last day. A principal concern was the issue of model validation.Some of the questions raised were:

- Have models been validated for evaluating coupled pro-cesses?

- What aspects of the model should be validated? Havethese aspects been weighted with respect to priority?

- At what threshold level should a model be consideredto be validated?

On the final afternoon, a panel discussion was held by several recog-nized authorities in the areas of geohydrology, geomechanics, andgeochemistry. A summary of the most thought-provoking comments raisedby the panel members is given below.

C. Fairhursl

K. Kovari

S. P. Newmar

6 Concern should be given to public credibil-ity of results presented from coupled pro-cess evaluations.

A concerted effort should be made to improveflow of information between all levels ofthe nuclear waste isolation program. Large-scale coupled testing should not be conducteduntil all available information is collectedand evaluated.

I Large-scale permeability tests should becarefully evaluated for effects of lowerpermeability induced by stress-concentrationaround the excavation. Flow rates based onflow into a large excavation may not indicatethe actual permeability of the rock mass.

P. A. Witherspoon

The field experiment at WIPP, 20 years af-ter the Project Salt Vault Experiment, shouldbe carefully investigated for new informationon coupled processes.

ITASCA

Page 6: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

A primary topic of the symposium, particularly emphasized on thelast day, was whether or not large-scale coupled field tests areneeded for coupled model validation. A case for large-scale testswas presented principally by LBL, led by Dr. Witherspoon. The pri-mary concerns in these tests are the expense and long time-framerequired. In my opinion, a strong enough case was not presentedfor the usefulness of the tests. It is not obvious that the tests,once completed, would provide significant new information on theeffect of coupled processes. It appears to me that these scien-tists have not taken advantage of the numerical techniques presentlyavailable to assess the relevance of tests of various coupled pro-cesses. Numerical experiments could be performed to provide in-sight for designing large-scale tests and estimating the conditionsfor which effects of coupling processes may be important. Work inthis regard was not presented and, apparently, has not been per-formed.

An important issue was raised by Professor Pigford, who suggestedthat coupled process assessment in a repository environment shouldbe performed using a systems analysis approach. This analysisshould provide a basis for incorporating all available informationand for identifying areas where information is lacking. There isa specific need to show why a coupled process is important in theoverall repository performance. Prof. Pigford cited, as an example,his disbelief that the permeability of basalt immediately around theemplaced waste is an important parameter in the evaluation of re-pository performance for BWIP. He does not believe that a near-field analysis of this parameter whould be of concern in the eval-uation process. Through a systems analysis procedure, parameterssuch as permeability should be assessed and weighed for importancebased on available information.

It is my opinion that this was the most sensible point raised atthe symposium because it specifically addressed the question ofdefining the importance of coupled processes. The general themeof the majority of the presentations centered on the work of theindividual presenters, and attempts to put the work into a generalperspective for dealing with coupled processes were not successful.I did not feel that, by the end of the symposium, any consensuswas reached on an approach to evaluate coupled processes affectingthe performance of a repository.

A final report on this symposium will be prepared by LBL.

Roge D. HartProgram Manager7 October 1985

rdh/ks ITASCAAttach.

Page 7: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

/

COST BREAKOUT

Labor

R. Hart 30 hrs @ $44.96/hr $ 1,348.80

Actual Expenses

Travel Airfare (MSP - SFO)Taxi

390.0020.00

Lodging

Meals

4 nights @ 60.50/night

9/179/189/199/20

242.00

10.6513.5014.5917.00

Registration 75.00

$ 782.74

ITASCA

Page 8: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 \_J COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANTS-' Page 1

Dr. Kell A. AnderssonSwedish Nuclear Power InspectorateBox 27106S-10252 StockholmSweden

Robert BellmannSAIC3349 So. Highland Dr., #403Las Vegas, NV

8-635560

Robert W. AndrewsIntera Technologies6850 Austin Center Blvd.Austin, TX 78731

Dr. Ernst BergerBasler & Hofmann, Engr.Forchstr. 3958029 Zurich, SWITZERLAND

(512) 346-2000 01-55-1122

Hick AptedPacific Northwest Lab. (PNL)Richland, WA 99352

(509) 375-2156

Dr. Giuseppe BertozziCommission of European CommunitiesJoint Research CentreI-21010 Ispra (VA)Italy

(332) 789952

Randy C. ArthurRockwell Hanford Operations BW1PP.O. Box 8003000 Area/HSIIIRichland, WA 99352

(509) 376-7715

Ahmad BadieParsons Brinckerhoss1625 Van Ness AvenueSan Francisco, CA 94109

(415) 268-6303

L. H. BaetsleSCK/CEM Belgian Nuclear Res. CenteBerkvenstraat 982400 Mol, Belgium

Ned E. BiblerE. I. duPont de Nemours, Inc.Savannah River LaboratoryAiken, SC 29808

(803) 725-2313

Eugene P. BinnallLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryBldg. 50B, rm. 4235Berkeley, CA 94720

(415) 486-6536

George F. BirchardU.S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionMail Stop 1130 SSWashington, DC 20555

32 (14) 31 12 91

Andre BarbreauCommissariat a Lenergie atomiqueCEN-FARBPn 692260 Fontenay aux Roses, France

Dr. Nathan E. BixlerSandia National LaboratoryOrg. 1511Aluquerque, NM 87185

(505) 844-0284654-70-76

Page 9: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 <a/ COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANTS- - Page 2

Maxwell B. BlanchardDepartment of EnergyP.O. Box 14100Las Vegas, NV 89114

(702) 295-1091

Dr. Sanford G. BloomOffice of Nuclear Waste IsolationBattelle Memorial Institute505 King AvenueColumbus, OH 43201

(614) 424-5242; FTS: 976-5242

Gudmundur S. BodvarssonEarth Sciences DivisionLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 486-4789

Dr. Evaristo J. BonanoSandia National LaboratoriesDivision 6431Albuquerque, NM 87185

(505) 844-5303

Prof. Alain BourgEPFL-EcublensIGR-PedologieCH-1015 LausanneSwitzerland

(21) 47 37 66

Dr. Albin BrandstetterBattelle - OCRD9700 S. Cass AvenueAgonne, IL 60439

(312) 972-4594

Dr. Douglas G. BrookinsUniversity of New MexicoDepartment of GeologyAlbuquerque, NM< 87110

(505) 277-2310

Mr. Stefan G. CarlyleOECD, Nuclear Energy Agency38, boulevard Suchet75016 Paris, France

(1) 524 96 27

C.L. CarnahanEarth Sciences DivisionLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 486-6770

* John B. CaseIT Corporation2340 S. Alamo, Suite 306Albuquerque, NM 87106

(505) 842-0835

Dr. Gail A. CederbergLos Alamos National LaboratoryMS F665Los Alamos, NM 87545

(505) 667-1498; FTS 843-1498

Dr. Tin ChanAtomic Energy of Canada ResearchCompanyWhiteshell Nuclear Research Est.Pinawa, Manitoba ROE LOCanada

(204) 753-2311

Kenneth F. Brinster2805 Marie Park, NEAlbuquerque, NM 87112

(505) 844-6059

William W. ChenRockwell Hanford OperationsBasalt Waste Isolation ProjectP.O. Box 800, CED 1/3000 AreaRichland, WA 99352

(509) 376-5262

Page 10: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 _> COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANTS-" Page 3

Dr. Bruce R. ClarkLeighton and Associates, Inc.1151 Duryea AvenueIrvine, CA 92714

(714) 250-1421

Dr. David H. DahlemU.S. Department of EnergyBasalt Waste Isolation DivisionP.O. Box 550Richland, WA 99320

(509) 376-3022

David G. ColesPacific Northwest LaboratoryBattelle BoulevardRichland, WA 99352

Paul A. DavisSandia National LaboratoriesDivision 6431P.O. Box 5800Albuquerque, NM 87185

(505) 846-5421

Ing. Bernard ComeCom. of the European CommunitiesDG XII-D-1rue de la Loi 200B-1049 Brussels, Belgium

32-2-2354001

Dr. Ghislain de MarsilyEcole des MinesCentre d'Informatique Geologique35 Rue Saint Honore77 Fontainebleau, 77305France

Enrico F. ContiU.S. NRC-OfficeWashington, DC

of Research20555

George A. DinwiddieU.S. Geological SurveyMail Stop 410National HeadquartersReston, VA 22092

(703) 860-6976

* N.G.W. CookDept. of Materials Science and

Mineral EngineeringUniversity of CaliforniaBerkeley, CA 94720

Donald J. DoddsRockwell Hanford OperationsP. 0. Box 800, CDC 1/3000 AreaRichland, WA 99352

(415) 642-5609 (509) 376-9581

Yavuz Corapcioglu12 Middle Wallop RoadBear, DE 19701

(302) 834-9114

Fred A. DonathEarth Technology Corporation3777 Long Beach Blvd.Long Beach, CA 90805

(213) 595-6611

Frank A. CostanziU.S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionOffice of ResearchWashington, DC 20555

Dr. K.W. DormuthAtomic Energy of Canada LimitedWhiteshell Nuclear Research Est.Pinawa, Manitoba ROE LOCanada

(301) 427-4362

Page 11: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANT,j Page 4

Clarence J. DuffyLos Alamos National LaboratoryINC-7, MS-J514Los Alamos, NM 87545

Daniel D. EvansUniversity of ArizonaDepartment of Hydrology and

Water ResourcesTucson, AZ 85721

(505) 667-5154(602) 621-7118

James 0. DuguidBatelle2030 M Street, N.W.Washington, DC 20036

(202) 785-8400

Dr. Charles FairhurstDept. Civil & Mineral Engr.University of Minnesota500 Pillsbury Dr., S.E.Minneapolis, MN 55455

(612) 373-3135

Michel DurinCentre dEtudes Nucleaires de Sacl91191 Gif-sur-Yvette CEDEXFrance

16-6-908-2302

Shahrzad FarajifardParsons Brinckerhoff Quade &

Douglas, Inc.1625 Van Ness AvenueSan Francisco, CA 94109

(415) 268-6333

Dr. Roger R. EatonSandia National LaboratoryOrg. 1511Albuquerque, NM 87185

(505) 844-4063

Dr. Robert 0. FournierMail Stop 910U.S. Geological Survey345 Middlefield RoadMenlo Park, CA 94025

(415) 323-8111, ext. 4158

Dr. Derek ElsworthPennsylvania State University119 Mineral Sciences BuildingUniversity Park, PA 16802

(814) 863-1643

Tsunaak FujiokaMitsubishi Atomic Power Ind.Inc2-4-1, Shibakoen, Minato-kuTokyo 105 Japan

(03) 433-8351

Dr. Atef ElzeftawyU.S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionMS - 623-SSWashington, DC 20555

(301) 427-4675

Yasuo FujishimaTohoku Electric Power Co., Inc.3-7-1, Ichiban-cho, Sendai-shiMiyagi-ken 980 Japan

(0222) 25-2111

Leif G. ErikssonEarth Technology Corporation3777 Long Beach Blvd.Long Beach, CA 90807

Ronald T. GreenHydrology DepartmentUniversity of ArizonaTucson, AZ 85721

(602) 621-7122(213) 595-6611

Page 12: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 __ COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANTS._ Page 5

Sumant K. GuptaOffice of Nuclear Waste IsolationBattelle Project Mgmt. Division505 King AvenueColumbus, OH 43201

Dr. Roger D. HartItasca Consulting Group, Inc.P. 0. Box 14806Minneapolis, MN 55414

(614) 424-5074 (612) 623-9599

Dr. Berge GureghianBattelle-OCRD7700 S. Cass AvenueArgonne, IL 60439

(312) 972-4559

Dr. Varut GuvanasenGeo Trans209 Elden Street, Suite 301Herndon, VA 22070

(703) 435-4400

Dr. Claudia Jane HackbarthUS NRC Office of ResearchSS-1130Washington, DC 20555

Nancy K. HaydenSandia NationalDivision 6312P. O. Box 5800Albuquerque, NM

Laboratories

87185

(505) 846-1815

Rene Hubert HeremansNational Agency for Radioactive

Waste and Fissile MaterialsBoulevard du Regent 54 boite 51000 Bruxelles, Belgium

011-32-25137460

F. HeuzeLawrence Livermore National Lab.P.O. Box 808Livermore, CA 94550

(301) 427-4639 (415) 423-0363

Barbara A. HackerE. I. duPont de Nemours, Inc.Savannah River LaboratoryAiken, SC 29808

(803) 725-2313

Richard F. HarigVice President - MiningParsons Brinckerhoff Quade, Inc.1625 Van Ness AvenueSan Francisco, CA 94109

(415) 474-4500

Philip E. HarroldU.S. Geological SurveyMS 416 Box 25046Denver Federal CenterDenver, CO 80225

Bernhard HoffersLos Alamos National LaboratoryLos Alamos, NM 87545

(505) 667-4318

Dr. Robert J. HopkirkPolydynamics LimitedZeltweg 29CH-8032 Zurich, Switzerland

01-252-6080

Dwight T. HoxieU.S. Geological SurveyBox 25046, MS 416Federal CenterDenver, CO 80225

(303) 236-5019

Page 13: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 1__ COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANTS,/' Page 6

Dr. Peter HufschmiedNagra (National Cooperative forthe Storage of Radioactive Waste)Parkstrasse 23CH-5401 Baden, Switzerland

Hemendra N. KaliaBattelle Project Management Div.505 King AvenueColumbus, Ohio 43201

(56) 20 55 11 (614) 424-4956

Udo HunstheFederal Institute for GeosciencesP.O. Box 5101533000 Hannover 51, WEST GERMANY

Walton R. KellyU.S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionMS 623-SSWashington, D.C. 20555

(301) 427-4571

Dr. James R. HuntUniversity of California635 Davis HallBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 642-0948

Kunsoo KimRockwell Hanford OperationsBasalt Waste Isolation ProjectP.O. Box 800, CDC 1/3000 AreaRichland, WA 99352

(509) 376-8938

Hirotoshi IkedaMitsui Construction, Ltd.3-10-1, Iwamoto-cho, Chiyoda-kuTokyo 101, Japan

E. A. KlavetterSandia National LaboratoriesAlbuquerque, NM 87185

(03) 864-3531

Satoshi ImamuraTaisei Corporationc/o Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory50EUniversity of CaliforniaBerkeley, CA 94720

Dr. Miro IvanovichNuclear Physics Division, AEREHarwell, OxonOX11 ORAUnited Kingdom

(0235) 2441 ext 2564/2860

Dr. Alex T. JakubickOntario Hydro Research Division800 Kipling AvenueToronto, Ontario M8Z 5S4, Canada

(416) 231-4111, ext. 6697

Dr. Cyrus KlingsbergU.S. Department of EnergyOffice of Civilian Waste Mgmt.RW 24Washington, DC 20585

(202) 252-1223

Akira KobayashiSchool of Civil EngineeringKyoto UniversityYoshidahonmachi Sakyo-kuKyoto-shi 606, Japan

(075) 751-2111, ext. 5128

Charles M. KoplikTASC1 Jacob WayReading, MA 01867

(617) 944-6850 ext. 2297

Page 14: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 \,_ COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANTS- 1 Page 7

-l4Prof. Kalman Janos KovariFed. Inst. of Technology ZurichETH - HoenggerbergCH-8702 Zollikon, Switzerland

(01) 391 97 07

Dr. Francis A. KulackiDepartment of Mechanical and

Aerospace EngineeringUniversity of DelawareNewark, DE 19716

(302) 451-2421 or -1673

Brenda S. LangkopfSandia National LaboratoriesDivision 6312Albuquerque, NM 87185

(505) 844-8777

Jean-Paul ManginCommissariat a V'Energie AtomiqueCentre dEtudes Nucleaires deFontenay-aux-Roses - DRDD/SESDB.P. No. 692260 Fontenay-aux-Roses, France

Donald C. MangoldLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryEarth Science Division50EUniversity of CaliforniaBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 486-6459William C. McClainRoy F. Weston, Inc.2301 Research Blvd, Third FloorRockville, Maryland 20850

(301) 963-6811

D. LangmuirDept. of Chemistry & GeochemistryColorado School of MinesGolden, CO 80401

(303) 273-3631

Dr. Charles McCombieNagra (National Cooperative forthe Storage of Radioactive Waste)Parkstrasse 23CH-Baden, Switzerland

(56) 205 511

Marcelo J. LippmannEarth Sciences DivisionLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryBerkeley, CA 94720

Laura M. McDowell-BoyerUniversity of California1428 NavellierEl Cerrito, CA 94530

(415) 486-5035 (415) 642-0885

Dr. Albert J. MachielsElectric Power Research Inst.3412 Hillview AvenueP.O. Box 10412Palo Alto, CA 94303

(415) 855-2054

Dr. William J. MallioStone & Webster Engineering Corp.245 Summer StreetBoston, MA 02107

Dr. Arend MeijerLos Alamos National LaboratoryINC-7, MS-J514Los Alamos, NM 87545

(505) 667-0675

Daniel C. MelchiorThe Earth Technology Corporation3777 Long Beach BoulevardLong Beach, CA 90807

(617) 589-1754 (213) 595-6611

Page 15: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANTS - Page 8

Alain MillardC.E.A./DEMT/LAMSCEN SaclayF-91191 Gif-sur-Yvette CEDEXFrance

M.S. NatarajaNuclear Regulatory CommissionWashington, DC 20555

(301) 427-4319

33-6-908-6247

Dr. Constance W. MillerConsulting and Computations33 Rheem BoulevardOrinda, CA 94563

Thomas G. NaymikBattelle505 King AvenueColumbus, Ohio 43201

(415) 254-2504 (614) 424-4557

Parviz MontazerU.S. Geological SurveyBox 25046, MS 416Federal CenterDenver, CO 80225

Paul NelsonDept. of Applied MathematicsMail Code 21750Cal. Inst. of TechnologyPasadena, CA 91125

(303) 236-5185 (818) 796-2273 (home)

Dr. Victor MontenyohlRoy F. Weston, Inc.2301 Research Blvd., 3rd FloorRockville, MD 20850

Ivars NeretnieksRoyal Institute of TechnologyDepartment of Chemical EngineeringS-10044 Stockholm, Sweden

(301) 963-5232 (08) 7878229

Hiroshi NakajoMitsubishi Research Institute Inc.2-3-6, Otemachi, Chiyoda-kuTokyo 100 Japan

Shlomo P. NeumanDept. Hydrology & Water ResourcesUniversity of ArizonaTucson, AZ 85721

(602) 621-7114(03) 270-9211

Haruto NakamuraJapan Atomic Energy ResearchInstituteTokai-mura Naka-gun Ibaraki-kenJapan

(0292) 82 6008

Dr. Vietchau V. NguyenEWA, Incorporated12800 Industrial Park BoulevardMinneapolis, MN 55441

(612) 559-3706

Takeshi NakawakeNikken Sekkii Ltd1-4-27, Kouraku, Bunkyo-kuTokyo 112, Japan

Dr. Pascal OustriereBureau de Recherches Geologiques

et MinieresDAM/GMXBP-600945060 Orleans Cedex, France

(03) 813-3361

Page 16: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANT&-,, Page 9

Dr. Edward S. PateraU.S. Department of EnergyCrystallic Repository Project9800 S. Cass AvenueArgonne, IL 60439

(312) 972-2234

Dr. Lincoln PatersonC.S.I.R.O. - Div. of GeomechanicsP.O. Box 54Mount Waverley, Victoria 3149Australia

(03) 235 1355

Ralph R. PetersSandia National LaboratoryAlbuquerque, New Mexico 87185

Francesca F. QuerciaENEA/DISPVia V. Brancati 4800144 Rome, Italy

06-8528-2846

Dr. John D. RandallU.S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionMail Stop 1130 SSWashington, DC 20555

(301) 427-4633

Mr. Kari Olavi RasilainenTech. Research Centre of FinlandNuclear Engineering LaboratoryP.O. Box 169SF-00181 Helsinki, Finland

358 0 648931

Prof. Thomas H. PigfordUniversity of CaliforniaRm. 4169, Etcheverry HallBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 642-6469

Dr. David ReadUniversity of WalesInst. of Science and TechnologyP.O. Box 13Cardiff CF1 3XF, United Kingdom

0222-830080

Karsten PruessLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryBldg. 50EBerkeley, CA 94720

Dr. Daniel C. RedaSandia National LaboratoriesOrg. 1512Albuquerque, NM 897185

(415) 486-6732 (505) 844-4916

Professor Maurice H.L. PryceUniversity of British ColumbiaPhysics DepartmentVancouver, B.C. V6T 1W5

Don T. ReedRockwell Hanford OperationsBasalt Waste Isolation ProjectP.O. Box 800Richland, WA 99352

(604) 224-1596 (509) 376-4005

John H. PyeRockwell Hanford OperationsBasalt Waste Isolation ProjectP.O. Box 800, CED 1/3000 AreaRichland, WA 99352

William J. RobardsGolder Associates2950 Northup WayBellevue, WA 98004

(206) 827-0777(509) 376-9288

Page 17: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 K_, COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANTS- Page 10

Dr. Gerd M. RosenblattLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryBldg. 50A, Rm. 4119Berkeley, CA 94720

Dr. Malcolm D. SiegelSandia National LaboratoriesDivision 64311Albuquerque, NM 87185

(415) 486-5222 (505) 846-5448

Dr. Benjamin RossDisposal Safety Incorporated1211 Connecticut Avenue NWWashington, DC 20036

(202) 293-3993

Prof. Nicholas SitarDept. Civil EngineeringUniversity of California440 Davis HallBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 642-1262

Dr. Glenn T. SeaborgLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryBldg. 70A, rm. 3307Berkeley, CA 94720

Leslie E. SourColorado School of MinesMining Engineering DepartmentGolden, CO 80401

(415) 486-5661 (303) 273-3409

Ronald J. ShafferLawrence Livermore National Lab.P. 0. Box 808 - L-200Livermore, CA 94550

Kurt S. SpieglerDept. Mechanical EngineeringUniversity of CaliforniaBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 642-6670(415) 422-3940

Michael SheaBattelle/OCRD505 King Ave.Columbus, OH 43201

(614) 424-5571

Dr. Jun J. ShimadaAtomic Energy of Canada Ltd.P. 0. Box 671Pinawa, ManitobaCanada

(204) 753-2311 ext. 3125

Larry R. ShipersSandia National LaboratoriesDivision 6431P. 0. Box 5800Albuquerque, NM 87185

Dr. Christopher M. St.JohnJ.F.T. Agapito & Associates, Inc.27520 Hawthorne Blev., Suite 137Rolling Hills Estates, CA 90274

(213) 544-0474

Peter R. StevensU.S. Geological Survey(410) National CenterReston, VA 22092

(703) 860-6976

Atsuyuki SuzukiUniversity of Tokyo7-3-1, Hongo, Bunkyo-kuTokyo 113 Japan

(505) 844-8108 (03) 812_2111

Page 18: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 U COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANTS'-.-' Page 11

Edward C. ThorntonUniversity of MinnesotaDept. of Geology & GeophysicsMinneapolis, MN 55455

(612) 376-3330

Dr. Marc ThuryNagra (National Cooperative forthe Storage of Radioactive Waste)Parkstrasse 23CH-5401 Baden, Switzerland

(56) 205 511

Dr. Bryan J. TravisLos Alamos National LaboratoryMS-F665Los Alamos, NM 87545

(505) 667-1254

Dr. Chin-Fu TsangLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryBldg. 50EBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 486-5782

Yvonne TsangEarth Sciences DivisionLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 486-7047

Shinzo UetaMitsubishi Metal Corp.1-6 Ohte-machiTokyo, Japan

0186-46-6144

Dr. Peter James VaughanDept. of Computer ScienceState University of New YorkPlattsburgh, NY 12901

P. VenetCom. of European CommunitiesDG XII-D-1Rue de la Loi 200B-1049 Brussels, Belgium

32-2-2354001

Ashok K. VermaEarth Sciences DivisionLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 486-7045

Charles F. VossBattelle NorthwestP.O. Box 999Richland, WA 99352

(509) 375-2610

Dr. Krishan K. WahiSAIC505 Marquette Avenue, N.W.Albuquerque, NM 87102

(505) 247-8787

Prof. Ruth F. WeinerWestern Washington UniversityBellingham, WA 98225

(206) 365-8623

Prof. David R. WilliamsUniversity of WalesInst. of Science and TechnologyDept. of Applied ChemistryP.O. Box 13Cardiff, CF1 3XF, United Kingdom

Dr. Stig E. WingeforsSwedish Nuclear Power InspectorateBox 27106S-10252 Stockholm, Sweden

(518) 564-2788 8-635560

Page 19: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

Sep 19 11:51 1985 COUPLED PROCESSES PARTICIPANTS_-/ Page 12

Prof. Paul A. WitherspoonUniversity of CaliforniaLawrence Berkeley LaboratoryEarth Sciences Division, 50EBerkeley, CA 94720

(415) 486-5082

Masao Yamamoto, DirectorFuel Cycle Tech. Development Div.Power Reactor and Nuclear Fuel

Development Corporation (PNC)Tokai-Works4-3, Muramatsu, Tokai-muraIbaraki-Prefecture, Japan

Yukio YoritaMitsubishi Heavy Industries, Ltd.2-4-1 Shibakoen, Minato-kuTokyo 105 Japan

(03) 433-5131

Dr. Auguste ZurkindenSwiss Nuclear Safety InspectorateCH-5303 Wuerenlingen, Switzerland

056/99 39/30

Page 20: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

A- I .:B .

INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON COUPLEDPROCESSES AFFECTING THE PERFORMANCE

OF A NUCLEAR WASTE REPOSITORY

(d_ w - -

r

Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory

September 18-20, 1985

PROGRAM

Wednesday, September 18

9:00 am D.A ShirleyLawrence BerkeleyLaboratory

Welcoming remarks

FA. CostanziU.S. Nuclear RegulatoryCommission

C. KlingsbergUS. Department of Energy

S.G. CarlyleOECD Nuclear Energy Agency

P. VenetCommission of theEuropean Communities

PA. WitherspoonLawrence BerkeleyLaboratory

Introduction to CoupledProcesses in NuclearWaste Isolation

(continued)

Page 21: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

- 2 -

Wednesday, September 18 (continued)

Review of Current Field Projects

10:30 am D.H. DahlemU.S. Department of Energy,Richland

H.N. Kalia, W.J. Roberds,and R.J. ByrneONWI and Golder Associates

M.B. Blanchard, J.L. Younker,C.D. Myers, and P.L. AamodtU.S. Department of Energy,Las Vegas, SAI, and LANL

Field Investigations at theBasalt Waste IsolationProgram

Coupled Processes Addressed byUnderground Testing for theSalt Repository Project

In Situ Testing from theExploratory Shaft at YuccaMountain, Nevada TestSite

12:30 pm Lunch

1:30 pm A. Barbreau, S. Derlich,B. Come, P. Peaudecerf,E. Durand, and G. de MarsilyCEA, France, CEC, Belgium,BRGM, and Ecoles des Mines

French Field Investigationsin the Underground ResearchLaboratory at Fanay-Augeres

S.G. Carlyle and H.S. CarlssonOECD NEA and CBS, Sweden

K.W. DormuthAECL, Canada

RX Heremans and L.H. BaetsleONDRAF-NIRASand SCK/CEN, Belgium

C. McCombie, A.L. Nold,and M. ThuryNAGRA, Switzerland

Recent Progress of the NEA StripaProject on In Situ Experiments inGranite Associated with the Disposalof Radioactive Wastes

An Overview of Some GeotechnicalExperiments within the CanadianNuclear Fuel Waste ManagementProgram

Geological Disposal in theBelgian Context

Overview of theSwiss Program

6:00 pm Symposium Banquet atLawrence Hall of Science

G.T. SeaborgLawrence BerkeleyLaboratory

The New Elements

(continued)

Page 22: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

- 3 -

Thursday, September 19

Coupled Thermomechanleal-Hydrochemical Processesfor a Nuclear Waste Repository

9:00 am G. de MarsilyEcoles des Mines, Paris

N.G.W. CookU.C. Berkeley

D. LangmuirColorado School of Mines

Overview of CoupledProcesses with Emphasisin Geohydrology

Coupled Processesin Geomechanics

Overview of CoupledProcesses with Emphasisin Geochemistry

12:00 noon

1:00 pm

1:30 pm

Lunch

Film: Progress of Stripa Project

Review of Contributed Papers

Rapporteurs:

K. Pruess, Lawrence BerkeleyLaboratory

B.R. Clark, Leighton and AssociatesC.L. Carnahan, Lawrence Berkeley

Laboratory

3:30 - 5:00 pm Poster Session for allContributed Papers

Friday, September 20

9:00 am Discussion of Contributed Paper.

Discussion Leaders:

K. Pruess, Lawrence BerkeleyLaboratory

BR. Clark, Leighton and AssociatesC.L. Carnahan, Lawrence Berkeley

Laboratory

12:00 noon Lunch

(continued)

Page 23: Transmittal of Trip Report for Two Meetings. · 2012-11-18 · ITASCA Consulting Group, Inc. 8 October 1985 Contract No. NRC-02-85-002 Task Order No. 1 David Tiktinksy - SS623 U.S

- .' I . - 4 -

Friday, September 20

1:00 - 5:00 pm

(continued)

Pnel Discussionon Coupled Processefor a Nuclear Waste Repository(including short presentations bythe panel members)

Panel Members

C. FairhurstUniversity of MinnesotaMinneapolis, Minnesota

R.O. FournierU.S. Geological SurveyMenlo Park, California

K. KovariFederal Institute ofTechnologyZurich, Switzerland

L NeretnieksRoyal Institute ofTechnologyStockholm, Sweden

S.P. NeumanUniversity of ArizonaTucson, Arizona

T.H. PigfordUniversity of CaliforniaBerkeley, California

P.A. WitherspoonLawrence BerkeleyLaboratoryBerkeley, California

Chin-Fu Tsang, ModeratorLawrence BerkeleyLaboratoryBerkeley, California

5:00 pm Chin-Fu TsangLawrence BerkeleyLaboratory

Concluding Remarks