Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Transitional Cluster Study
Attachment B
Group 2012 Cluster Study Transient Stability Plots
1
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case No Outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case No Outage Transient Frequency Plots
2
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
3
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
4
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
5
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley– Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
6
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
7
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
8
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Frequency Plots
9
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Path 42 outage w/ RAS Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Path 42 outage w/RAS Transient Frequency Plots
10
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case El Centro – Highline #1 & 2 230 kV line outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case El Centro – Highline #1 & 2 230 kV line outages Transient Frequency Plots
11
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley - El Centro #1 & 2 230 kV line outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley - El Centro #1 & 2 230 kV line outages Transient Frequency Plots
12
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Pre-Cluster Base Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Frequency Plots
13
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case No Outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case No Outage Transient Frequency Plots
14
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
15
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
16
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
17
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley– Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
18
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
19
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
20
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Frequency Plots
21
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Path 42 outage w/ RAS Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Path 42 outage w/RAS Transient Frequency Plots
22
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case El Centro – Highline #1 & 2 230 kV line outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case El Centro – Highline #1 & 2 230 kV line outages Transient Frequency Plots
23
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley - El Centro #1 & 2 230 kV line outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley - El Centro #1 & 2 230 kV line outages Transient Frequency Plots
24
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster Base Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Frequency Plots
25
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case No Outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case No Outage Transient Frequency Plots
26
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
27
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
28
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
29
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley– Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
30
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
31
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
32
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Frequency Plots
33
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Path 42 outage w/ RAS Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Path 42 outage w/RAS Transient Frequency Plots
34
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Frequency Plots
35
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Highline –El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Highline –El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Frequency Plots
36
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/Mitigation Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Heavy Summer Post-Cluster w/Mitigation Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Frequency Plots
37
2012 Light Winter Transient Stability Plots
38
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case No Outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case No Outage Transient Frequency Plots
39
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
40
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
41
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
42
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley– Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
43
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
44
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
45
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Frequency Plots
46
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Path 42 outage w/ RAS Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Path 42 outage w/RAS Transient Frequency Plots
47
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Frequency Plots
48
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Highline – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Highline – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Frequency Plots
49
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Pre-Cluster Base Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Frequency Plots
50
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case No Outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case No Outage Transient Frequency Plots
51
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
52
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
53
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
54
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley– Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
55
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
56
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
57
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Frequency Plots
58
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Path 42 outage w/ RAS Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Path 42 outage w/RAS Transient Frequency Plots
59
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Imperial Valley – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Frequency Plots
60
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Highline – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Highline – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Frequency Plots
61
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster Base Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Frequency Plots
62
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case No Outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case No Outage Transient Frequency Plots
63
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Coachella – Devers 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
64
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Ramon – Mirage 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
65
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – El Centro 230 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
66
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley– Miguel 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
67
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case N. Gila - Imperial Valley 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
68
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Palo Verde - Devers 500 kV line outage Transient Frequency Plots
69
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case ELSTM2 and REPU2 generator outages Transient Frequency Plots
70
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Path 42 outage w/ RAS Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Path 42 outage w/RAS Transient Frequency Plots
71
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Imperial Valley – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Frequency Plots
72
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Highline – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/ Mitigation Case Highline – El Centro #1 &2 230 kV lines outage Transient Frequency Plots
73
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/Mitigation Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Bus Voltage Plots
2012 Light Winter Post-Cluster w/Mitigation Case Coachela – Devrs & Coachela-Ramon 230kV line outages Transient Frequency Plots