-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
1/16
Singapore Management University
Institutional Knowledge at Singapore Management
University
R5%' C' ' O* L%9 ' * L%9
12-2013
#e Fiduciar" Doctrine as a Ne! Path!a": An Alternatie
Approach to Anal"sing Natie
Customar" Rights in Sara!ak Hang Wu TANGSingapore
Management University , 9%[email protected]+
F9 5 % %% 95 %: =://.&%.57.7.5+/5$5%'
P% * A5% 75 C5 , C'% L%9 C5 , L%9 % R%'
C5 , % P L%9 % R% E5% C5
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
2/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/!
#$%&! '() %* +( #! ,-./0)1 *2 %3%4
The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway: An AlternativeApproach
to Analysing Native Customary Rights inSarawak
TANG Hang Wu*
01(# 2&23% 342',%3# $13 "#3 ,- $13 -(5"6(&%7 5,6$%()3
/13%387 $13 #$&$3 (# 6,)63(935 & -(5"6(&%7 9(#:;:9(#
13% )&$(93 23,2'3# &)5
&$$3)5&)$ 31$# ,93% '&)5 () ?&%&/&@A
01"# -&%B =,#$ 61&''3)>3#
$, 34$()>"(#1=3)$ ,- )&$(93 6"#$,=&%7 %(>1$# ()
?&%&/&@ 1&93 2%,633535 ,) 6,)#$($"$(,)&'
>%,")5#B /($1 '($$'3 #"663##A 01(# &%$(6'3
5%&/# ,) $13 C"%(#2%"53)63 ,- -(5"6(&%7 '&/ () ,$13%
2&%$# ,- $13 D,==,)/3&'$1 &)5 &%>"3# $1&$
$1(# (# & 9(&8'3 &'$3%)&$(93 6&"#3
,- &6$(,) &>&()#$ $13 #$&$3A
56-6768 /9 (:1 (; .6)6?9/6 6:@ /9 )(06.1@ /: .
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
3/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
#
0C9.(F6-? -/=/: >6)6?9/6 7/.< D6-./0C)6- -1;1-1:01 .(
56-6768 /9 981.0
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
4/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
&
LHR 6:@ L0R H106C91 .
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
5/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
*
L_((81-! #$$#2 K#RA V
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
6/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
4
C:6FH/=C(C9 7(-@9 H? )1=/9)6./(: 6;.1- D6?F1:. (; 0(FD1:96./(:B
_(71I1-! @,)> /9 9C901D./H)1 .( 6..608 H106C91 .(
&@ F")>@,)> J I%# g#$%#h % >PZ &&4RB
5CDD(-.1-9 (; .
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
7/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
J
V
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
8/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
N
i/-10./(: %KKN! 7PZ #KN! .
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
9/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
Q
.(
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
10/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
K
L//R g.h
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
11/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
%$
6-=C1@ .3)3%(# ;/@C0/6-? -1)6./(:9
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
12/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
%%
S&=""@/ 9 F%($(#1 D,'"=8(& g%KKNh & 5YT %$%$B
_(71I1-! /: F&$,
F&>( .
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
13/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
%#
V
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
14/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
%&
P((8/:= 6. .
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
15/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
%*
References
,/81:! 5T 6:@ P1/=
i10/9/(:9 /: >6)6?9/6]! *4L*R G,53%) !#(&)
?$"5(3# Q#4B
A-?6:.! >Z L%KK&R eY-(7:3,H(-/=/:6) T1)6./(:9
,C9.-6)/6: +6./(:6) ^:/I1-9/.? M-199B
Y-6FH! T, L#$%%R eT13[:I1:./:= iC6)/9F2 M()/0? +6--6./I19 6:@
>(@19 (; W/) M6)F rED6:9/(: /:
56-6768! >6)6?9/6]! *N +,"%)&' ,- O393',2=3)$
?$"5(3# #N*B
Y-((8! M L#$$4R e,;.1- !5,)> 2 V6)6?9/6]!
+,"%)&' ,-
G&'&7#(&) &)5 D,=2&%&$(93 .&/
N%B
d(:= ZY L#$%%R! .&/ ,) H&$(93 D"#$,=&%7 .&)5 ()
?&%&/&@B `C6)6 PCFDC-2 5711. f >6E71))B
d(E! M> L%K4$R eV
_((81-! >A L#$$#R e+6./I1 V/.)1 /: >6)6?9/6 Y(:./:C1@ q
H,%W# Y691]! *L%R !"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,-
!#(&)
.&/ K#B
[@-C9! T L#$%$R ed-(F S6-@9 .( Y/./G1:92 [:@/=1:(C9 T/=&'
!)$1%,2,',>7 Q39(3/ QKB
[9660 V 6:@ `:(E ,! L#$$&R eV
X6,),=7B Y
+=/@6:=! i L#$$4R ei10(:9.-C0./(: 6:@ T10(:9.-C0./(: (; +6./I1
YC9.(F6-? P6:@ V1:C-1 /: 56-6768]!
*& ?,"$13$ !#(&) ?$"5(3# *NB
M(-.1-! ,d L%KJNR .&)5 !5=()(#$%&$(,) ()
?&%&/&@! %$B `C0
-
8/15/2019 The Fiduciary Doctrine as a New Pathway_ an
Alternative Approach
16/16
!"#$%&'(&) +,"%)&' ,- !#(&) .&/
'() %* +( #
%4
5CH-6F6:/6F! a L#$%%R erE./:=C/9@,)> J I%# 9
.&5&)> ?&/($ F()$"'" ?5) F15 g#$%$h * >PZ
#$*B
F&$, F&>( J I%# 9 K3%&C&&)
H3>3%( ?&%&/&@ g#$%%h J >PZ #KNB
O3'>&=""@/ 9 F%($(#1 D,'"=8(& g%KKNh &
5YT %$%$B
[&(5& H&$(,) 9 F%($(#1 D,'"=8(& UG()(#$3% ,-
S,%3#$#V [2004] 3 SCR 511, 2004 SCC 73.
+&'&)> &)&@ L&%&) J !),% 9 P,93%)=3)$
,- $13 ?$&$3 ,- ?&%&/&@ g#$$Nh % >PZ *%#O
g#$%%h & >PZ %&B
K3%&C&&) H3>3%( ?3'&)>,% 9
?&>,)> 8() 0( g#$$4h J >PZ #QKB
G&8, 9 T"33)#'&)5 UH, aV g%KK#h _Y, #&O L%KK#R
%N4 YPT %B
G,1&=&5 H,1()> J I%# 9 L3C&8&$ 0&)&1
O&) P&'(&) H3>3%( L&1&)> J I%#
[2013] 1 LNS 174. G,1&=&5 Q&=8'( 8()
K&/( 9 ?"23%()$3)5&)$ ,- .&)5# K"61()> J
!),% [2010] 8 MLJ 441. H,% !)&@ H7/&( J I%# 9
F,%)3, L"'2 L'&)$&$(,) J I%# g#$$%h J >PZ #*%B
Q 9 P"3%() g%KQ*h # 5YT &&4B
?&>,)> 8() 0( g#$$#h # >PZ 4K%
?"23%()$3)53)$ ,- .&)5# &)5 ?"%937# O32&%$=3)$
F()$"'" O(9(#(,) J !),% 9 !>( &@ F")>@,)> J I%#
g#$%#h % >PZ &&4B
?"23%()$3)53)$ ,- .&)5 J ?"%937# G(%( O(9(#(,) J !),% 9
G&53'( ?&''31 g#$$Nh J YPZ 4$KB
?"23%()$3)53)$ ,- .&)5 J ?"%937# G(%( O(9(#(,) 9 G&53'(
8() ?&''31 g#$$Qh # >PZ JNNB
?"23%()$3)53)$ ,- .&)5# J ?"%937#B F()$"'" 9 H,% !)&@
H7&/&( J I%# g#$$Jh % >PZ #4JB
