63
THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL MARKETS IN UGANDA, AND THEIR CONSEQUENCES ON INVESTORS. (The Case Study of Capital Markets Uganda) By UWANYILIGIRA TELESPHORE BBA/7790/51/DF This Research Project is Submitted to the School of Business and Management in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement of the Award of the Degree of Bachelor of Business Administration (Finance) of Kampala International University. October 2006.

THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL MARKETS IN

UGANDA, AND THEIR CONSEQUENCES ON INVESTORS.

(The Case Study of Capital Markets Uganda)

By

UWANYILIGIRA TELESPHORE

BBA/7790/51/DF

This Research Project is Submitted to the School of Business and

Management in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement of the Award

of the Degree of Bachelor of Business Administration (Finance) of

Kampala International University.

October 2006.

Page 2: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

DECLARATION

I, UWANYILIGIRA TELESPHORE, do hereby declare to the best of my

knowledge that this graduation report is my original work and that it has

never been submitted to any university or any other institution for the award

of any qualification.

The literature and citations from other people's work have been duly

referenced and acknowledged in the text and bibliography.

Signed ................ ~~ .............. .

Page 3: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

DEDICATION

This project is dedicated to my family, especially to my late mother

Primitiva AKIMANIZANYE, my father Venant NKUNDABATWARE, my sisters

Chantal TWAGIRAMARIYA, Venerande MUKANDANGA and my brothers Eric

ISHIMWE, Christian NKUNDIMANA, Onesphore DUSABIMANA, Christophe

NGABIWENIMANA, Janvier MANIRARORA and Anastase BIZIMANA.

111

Page 4: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

An accomplishment of project of such nature was possible only through hard

work, dedication and assistance from those who supported me morally,

spiritually, financially and otherwise.

First and foremost, I would like to thank God for His abundance grace and

the opportunity He awarded me to carry out my project successively.

A high vote of thanks to my supervisor, Dr NYABOGA Yobes, for his guidance

and great advice he gave me when undertaking my project.

Special thanks to all my friends, the insight gained from them will go a long

way in my career life and in the business world.

Great appreciation to the lecturers of the School of Business and

Management at Kampala International University and Nairobi institute of

Business Studies for their cooperation and training throughout the course

and when we were undertaking our project.

Sincere thanks to my family for their financial and moral support. Thanks for

their ceaseless prayers and advices in making me reach this height.

I would like to take this opportunity to also thank my dear classmates for

their encouragement, support and prayers.

God bless all of you.

IV

Page 5: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Declaration ............................................................................................................... i

Dedication ................................................................................................................ ii

Approval .................................................................................................................. iii

Acknowledgement ................................................................................................. iv

Table of Contents .................................................................................................. v

List of Tables and Figures ................................................................................... vii

Abbreviations ......................................................................................................... viii

Definitions of Terms .............................................................................................. ix

Abstract .................................................................................................................... xii

CHAPTER ONE

1.1 Background of the Study ............................................................. 1

1.2 Statement of the Problem ........................................................... 3

1. 3 Objectives of the Study ................................................................ 3

1.4 Significance of the Study ............................................................. 4

1.5 The scope of the Study ................................................................ 4

1.6 Research Questions ...................................................................... 5

1.8 Theoretical Framework ................................................................. 5

1.9 Hypothesis ....................................................................................... 10

CHAPTER TWO

Literature Review ....................................................................................... 11

CHAPTER THREE

3.1 Research Methodology ...................................................................... 15

3.1.1 Sampling Procedure .......................................................... 15

3.1.2 Sampling Profile .................................................................. 15

V

Page 6: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

CHAPTER FOUR

4.1 Data analysis and Interpretation of the Findings ........................ 16

4.1.1 Companies Data Analysis ................................................. 16

4.1. 2 Investors Data Analysis .................................................... 22

CHAPTER FIVE

5.1 Summary, Conclusions and Recommendations ........................... 34

5.1.2 Problems Facing the Capital Markets ............................ 34

5.1.2 Priority Problems and Causes .......................................... 37

5.2 Recommendations ............................................................................. 39

5.3 Limitation of the study ...................................................................... 41

APPENDICES

QUESTIONNAIRES

1. For Companies.

2. For Investors

3. For CMA Staff (Discussions)

VI

Page 7: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

LIST OF TABLES AND FIGURES

Tables

Table 1 Table 2 Table 3 Table 4 Table 5 Table 6 Table 7 Table 8 Table 9 Table 10 Table 11 Table 12 Table 13 Table 14

Figures

Figure 1 Figure 2 Figure 3 Figure 4 Figure 5 Figure 6 Figure 7 Figure 8 Figure 9 Figure 10 Figure 11 Figure 12 Figure 13 Figure 14 Figure 15

Companies that responded ........................................................ 16 Listed and unlisted companies .................................................... 16 Proportion of Companies' Investment in Securities ............... 17 Distribution of securities ............................................................... 18 Companies Wishing to Go Public in Future ............................... 20 Sex of the Respondents ................................................................ 22 Age of the Respondents ................................................................ 23 Occupation of the Respondents .................................................. 24 Education Level of the Respondents .......................................... 26 CMA Awareness ............................................................................... 27 USE Awareness ............................................................................... 28 Sources of Awareness of CMA and USE .................................... 29 Participation in the Capital Markets ........................................... 31 ............................................................................................................ 32

Listed and unlisted companies .................................................... 17 Proportion of Companies' Investment in Securities ............... 18 Distribution of securities ............................................................... 19 Companies Wishing to Go Public in Future .............................. 20 Preference of the respondents .................................................... 21 Sex of the Respondents ................................................................ 22 Age of the Respondents ............................................................... 23 Occupation of the Respondents ................................................. 25 Occupation of the Respondents ................................................. 25 Education Level of the Respondents .......................................... 26 CMA awareness .............................................................................. 27 USE awareness ............................................................................. 28 Sources of Awareness of CMA and USE .................................... 30 Participation in the Capital Markets ........................................... 31 ........................................................................................................... 32

Vll

Page 8: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

ABBREVIATIONS.

BATU

BOBU

BOU

CMA

CMP

DFCU

EABL

EADB

KQ

MDI

MFI

NAWOU

NSSF

NVL

PTA

PSF

ROSCA

SME

UDB

USE

UTODA

UWEAL

UWFT

UWONET

- British American Tobacco (Uganda)

- Bank of Baroda (Uganda)

- Bank of Uganda

- Capital Markets Authority

- Capital Market Projects

- Development Finance Company Uganda

- East African Breweries Limited

- East African Development bank

- Kenya Airways

- Micro-finance Deposit-taking Institutions

- Micro-finance Institutions

- National Association of Women Organization in Uganda

- National Social Security Fund

- New Vision Limited

- Preferential Trade Area

- Private Sector Foundation

- Rational Savings and Credit Association

- Small and Medium Scale Enterprises.

- Uganda Development Bank

- Uganda Securities Exchange

- Uganda Taxi Operators and Drivers Association

- Uganda Women's Entrepreneurs' Association Ltd

- Uganda Women's Finance Trust

- Uganda Women's Network

viii

Page 9: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

DEFINITION OF TERMS.

Balance sheet -a quantitative summary of a company's financial condition

at a specific point in time, including assets, liabilities and net worth

Bond - a certificate of debt (usually interest-bearing or discounted) that is

issued by a government or corporation in order to raise money; the issuer is

required to pay a fixed sum annually until maturity and then a fixed sum to

repay the principal.

Capital -cash or goods used to generate income either by investing in a

business or a different income property.

-the net worth of a business; that is, the amount by which its assets

exceed its liabilities.

-the money, property, and other valuables, which collectively

represent the wealth of an individual or business.

Capitalization - the process of adding unpaid interest to the principal

balance of a loan. This will increase the outstanding principal balance of the

loan and may increase the monthly payment amount.

Capital Markets- the means by which large amounts of money (capital) are

raised by companies, governments and other organizations for long term use

and the subsequent trade of the instruments issued in recognition of such

capital. New money is raised in the Primary market by issuing shares or

bonds to investors who can then trade them on the relevant Secondary

market.

Corporate governance -A generic term, which describes the ways in which

rights and responsibilities are shared between the various corporate

participants, especially the management and the shareholders.

IX

Page 10: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Debt - an amount owed to a person or organization for funds borrowed.

Funds -assets in the form of money

Invest -to engage in any activity in which money is put at risk for the

purpose of making a profit.

Investment -laying out money or capital in an enterprise with the

Investor -an individual who takes an ownership position in a company, thus

assuming risk of loss in exchange for anticipated returns.

Liquidity -the ease with which an asset can be turned into cash.

Market -the world of commercial activity where goods and services are

bought and sold.

Money Market -a sector of the capital market where short-term obligations

such as Treasury bills, commercial paper and bankers' acceptances are

bought and sold.

Net-worth -the value in money of all assets less all liabilities. Net worth

may be expressed as money amount, or as a percentage of either assets or

liabilities, calculated by subtracting liabilities from assets and dividing the

remainder by assets or liabilities.

Savings - fund of money put by as a reserve

Security (a) -a type of transferable interest representing financial value.

Traditionally securities have been categorized between debt and equity

securities, and between bearer and registered securities.

X

Page 11: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

ABSTRACT

Uganda's impressive economic growth is a result of the country's

reform process. The government is committed to private sector-led growth,

which necessitates adequate availability of investment capital. However the

shallow and underdeveloped nature of the financial sector is a hindrance to

raising long-term finance. The ultimate role of Uganda's Capital Markets is to

provide alternate means of raising long-term finance. Therefore, the

government is encouraging the development of capital market industry as a

way of generating long-term capital to promote sustainable growth, mobilize

savings and broaden the availability of funds for investment purpose.

Promotion of capital markets provides new options for Ugandans to invest

their savings from local, regional and international sources. It makes it more

convenient for Ugandans to save and enhance the efficiency of the financial

system to mobilize savings for economic development. It makes it also

possible for larger institutional investors to enhance the effectiveness of

managing their assets and liabilities, particularly with regards to the risk and

reward associated with different investment.

This research project gives ideas on how the ways capital markets

development creates ways for business communities to raise capital and run

the business. This is possible in fact, not only these businesses get funds

from raised bank loans, but also by raising capital directly from the public by

issuing financial instruments such as bonds, stocks to investors locally,

regionally and internationally.

Mobilization of savings from savers to borrowers is conducted

efficiently if there is existence of financial intermediaries (middlemen who

identify individuals with surplus of money and use their money to lend people

with deficit, who need money). The role of capital markets comes in to create

stock exchange, which is the market, where buying and selling of securities

take place. In Uganda, this place is named Uganda Securities Exchange.

Xll

Page 12: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

There is a concern about lack of confidence in financial sector among

Ugandans also the dilution of ownership and questionable shareholders.

Smaller companies in particular, fear the loss of managerial grip on their

companies and the financial requirements, which is identified as an area of

contention in the impediments.

This study establishes why there are a number of local firms that are

interested in going public but that there is a considerable degree of

reluctance of going ahead. This attitude may correspond to the low level of

awareness of the securities market among Ugandans companies.

This research also shows reasons and causes of lack of participation of

the population in the investment opportunities, the challenges of capital

markets, and later it will give recommendations and suggest measures that

can be taken in order to overcome them.

xiii

Page 13: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

CHAPTER ONE

1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY

Introduction

Capital Markets can help raise funds through a number of means. In

several capital markets; listing public offering of shares through the stock

exchanges has been a useful means to raise project finance. Communication

networks, road systems, plant and machinery can all be financed by a

comprehensive properly supported and sponsored public offering. Capital

markets provide the framework and platform for this and will be the primary

success factor in this form of funds mobilization.

For government development, listed government bonds are very

important source of finance, particularly through medium and long-term

bonds. Not only do active capital markets improve an economic cash flows

and the channeling of these funds to the development of key infrastructure

areas, but also create an opportunity for the local population and

international investors to invest their money, and in turn, accumulate profits

and as result lift the national economy at higher level.

The securities markets in Uganda emerged as a result of structural

transformation of the Ugandan economy. The Capital Markets Authority

(CMA) was established under the Capital Markets Authority Statute of 1996.

It is a regulatory and supervisory body of the capital markets. It licenses and

regulates investment intermediaries and deals with exchanges and deals with

the issuance and trade in securities. The Uganda Securities Exchange (USE)

was licensed to operate as an approved Stock Exchange in 1997 and became

operational in January 1998 with the listing of the East African Development

Banks 4 year bond. USE is the only formal trading place for securities all

companies wishing to be listed at the USE must be approved by CMA.

I

Page 14: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

The current capitalization in Uganda stands at about US dollars 209

million compared to Kenya and Tanzania with US dollars 1 billion and US

dollars 618 million respectively. Capital markets flows in Uganda have the

potential to make a substantial contribution to the economic growth.

However in a nascent market as Uganda, the private sector is reluctant to

make full use of these resources. On the other hand, investors in the capital

market are also reluctant to use the capital markets as an alternative, and

benefit from them because it is a fact that the most characteristic of a

successful capital market, that investors appreciate, is liquidity.

Purposes/ Reasons of Developing Capital Markets in Uganda

It's understandable that the main cause of developing capital markets

in Uganda is to enhance the mobilization of financial resources for investing

purposes and more efficient utilization of financial growth. The main

objectives of developing capital markets in Uganda are:

a. to increase domestic savings;

b. to efficiently allocate savings to investment in the

public and private sector;

c. to improve the distribution of income;

d. to avail investment capital to a broader range of the

population;

e. to widen the range of financial services available

through financial institutions;

f. to improve the operational effectiveness of financial

institutions

g. to improve the terms under which foreign funds are

raised and reduced relative to the amount required.

2

Page 15: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

1.2 STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM

The big role of capital markets is to ensure that there is mobilization of

funds especially from lenders with surplus to borrowers with deficit in money

terms.

However, it is very important to know that the process does not run in

a smooth way, but it is challenged with impediments that require

improvement to take the way forward.

The study highlights the most common problems and challenges encountered

by the Capital Markets in Uganda, and how they affect investors in general.

1.3 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY

Capital markets play a big role in the economy of Uganda by

facilitating the movement of monetary resources. Therefore, the main

objectives of the study will be:

Firstly, to give an overview and explain the meaning of capital

markets, their role in the economy and how people would benefit from them.

Secondly, it will try to identify the problems and challenges faced by

the Uganda's capital markets, assess them and find out what might be the

causes and reasons of those problems.

Finally, it will give recommendations, and some measures that can be

taken by CMA and USE in order to overcome these impediments.

3

Page 16: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

1.4 SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY

Individuals and companies, with interest in capital markets, will find

this document essential as it touches crucial areas of concern of these

markets. Therefore, the research will be helpful in various ways:

- Students and other people will understand well what are the capital

markets and their roles to the economy of countries.

- Companies will know the benefits they may enjoy if they decide to

participate in the capital markets.

- This research will be helpful to CMA and USE because it highlights

some of the problems of capital markets as well as

recommendations, solutions and suggestions that can be relevant

when fighting those challenges.

- This research may be put in the CMA, USE's Information Resource

Centres and serves as documentation for people who will want to

do further research on capital markets.

1.5 THE SCOPE OF THE STUDY.

The research was conducted in the capital city of Uganda, Kampala,

due to the following reasons:

- Most of high income- earners are located in Kampala.

The big percentage of companies, listed and not listed is

based in the capital city, the hub of economic activity.

- Both CMA and USE head offices are located in Kampala.

- Due to limited financial resources, the research was limited

in the capital city, which was easier and cheaper for the

researcher to commute, and avoid high transport costs.

4

Page 17: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

1.6 RESEARCH QUESTIONS

1. What are capital markets?

2. What are the benefits and advantages of capital markets to:

- the individuals?

- the nation as a whole?

3. What are the problems and the challenges that the capital markets

encounter? What may be their causes as well as their effects?

4. What measures that can be taken in order to resolve these

problems and eliminate those challenges?

1.8 THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK.

The theory to the problem will emphasize on the capital markets and

its functions, its benefits, as well as the risk investment that investors are

supposed to be aware of, and how to measure it.

Capital and Capital Markets Definitions.

In "An Introduction To Capital Markets; Products, Strategies,

Participants" by Andrew M. CHISHOLM, states that in the broadest sense the

term "capital" can be defined as the accumulated wealth that is available to

create further wealth. It is wealth that is engaged in reproductive process.

The "Capital Markets", on the same line, are meeting places where

those who require additional capital seek out others who wish to invest their

excess. They are also places where risk can be distributed, shared and

5

Page 18: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

diversified, so that for instance, those with surplus wealth can spread their

risk among a wider range of attractive investments.

Originally, the meeting places were physical spaces with such as the

forum of an ancient city or coffee house or a stock exchange. In one day,

capital markets participants may be located in different continents and

conduct deals over the telephone or 'meet' in cyberspace via electronic mail

and the internet.

Who are the Users of Capital?

The answer in one sense is 'we all are'. At least part of time:

- We borrow money to buy a house or a car, or make our own

small contribution to the growing wealth of nation.

- Corporations, for instance, when building a factory or buy

new equipment, will be engaged in capital expenditure by

using funds provided by shareholders or lenders or even

retained profits to generate future cash flow.

Government uses tax revenues to invest in major national

infrastructure projects such as roads and subways systems

and to invest in education and health and policing so that we

can all go about our business and lead fulfilling lives.

- Agencies such as World Bank and European Bank for

Reconstruction and Development inject funds into developing

economies so that they have a basis for economic growth

and future prosperity.

6

Page 19: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Who are the Suppliers of Capital?

Again the answer is that 'we all are':

- Sometimes we do this directly by buying shares and bonds

issued by corporations and debt securities issued by

governments and their agencies.

- Sometimes we employ financial instruments and other

financial intermediaries to invest funds on our behalf.

- We deposit money in bank accounts, invest in mutual funds

and set aside in pension schemes for our retirement.

- We pay taxes to the government and local authorities.

- We pay premiums to insurance companies who invest the

proceeds against their future liabilities.

- Corporations themselves become sources of capital when

they reinvest profits in their business rather than paying

money out in the form of dividends to their shareholders.

Types of Investors

According to Uganda Capital Market Authority: Disclosure Guidelines

Project, Interim Report- July 1999, in Uganda, as well as most of the

countries in the world, capital markets attracts four (4) kinds of investors in

general:

- General public; primarily retail investors or anyone who is not specifically

selected by the companies/issues to receive the offer.

- Existing shareholders and debt holders of a company; include retail

investors, institutional investors and market professional who already hold

shares or other financial instruments in the company and therefore can be

deemed to have knowledge of the company and its operations.

7

Page 20: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

- Institutional investors; fund managers, insurance and pension companies,

large corporation or anyone who can be assumed to have specialized

knowledge of the company and instruments they are buying and can

negotiate the terms of the purchase with the vendor.

- Market professionals; venture capitalists, banks, market makers, brokers,

individual with sufficient capital and experience.

Examples of Investors in Uganda:

• International investors

• High-net worth individuals

• Upper-middle class (financially self sustaining and elite)

• Rational savings and Credit Associations (ROSCA) both within

institutions and informal groups

• Development banks e.g. Uganda Development Bank( UDB)

• Pension Funds e.g. NSSF

• Contributors to Collective Schemes

• Association of Business groups e.g. UTODA,PSF, Owino traders

• Students at secondary level and institutions of higher learning

• Professional bodies e.g. lawyers, accountants, bankers, doctors

• Women's groups/associations e.g. UWONET, UWFT, NAWOU, Mother's

Union, self help groups

• MFI's

• MDI's

• SME's

• Farmer's associations

• Religious organizations

8

Page 21: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Benefits of Capital Markets.

From the book "Know Your Capital Markets Inside Out" by Zephy Metro

NWOYE ELEH, December 2004, the researcher finds that there are a lot of

benefits derivable from the capital markets.

As an issuer (government and corporate bodies), the capital markets

provide the necessary funds, which can be channeled to the necessary

economic development.

Corporate bodies through the issue of securities are able to expand

their operations, or restructure their companies for optimum benefits.

The governments on the other hand are able to channel such funds for

developmental purpose for the growth of the economy and fulfilling their

electoral promises.

To the investor, the capital markets confer benefits through profits

earned as a result of the securities bought and sold in the market. Investors

receive dividends or capital gains when companies declare profits or when

the shares are sold.

Besides, the capital markets provide the much-needed employment

through the participants or through programs executed from funds sourced

from the capital markets.

9

Page 22: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Investment Risk.

All investors invest their money in order to get returns. However,

investments present various risks that can results in losing money invested.

It is said that the higher the risk, the higher the returns. It is just a

statement and it not justified.

Another question that arises is how to estimate or calculate the risks.

How can we tell an investment with higher or lower risks?

Professional, Fundamental and Technical analysts use methods such

Accounting Ratios and models to measure and evaluate risks and it is left t

the investors to make choice according to their personal judgments.

1.9 HYPOTHESIS OF THE STUDY

The establishment of Capital Markets Authority was an important step

in instituting and promoting an orderly, fair and efficient capital markets

industry in Uganda. This provides Ugandans with an opportunity to acquire

different financial assets and the option to invest their savings.

Capital markets have emerged in shaping the financial market in the

country to ensure orderly growth. It is therefore very important that I have

to adopt the following hypothesis:

Hl: effective capital markets can help in lifting the national economy at a

higher level.

HO: effective capital markets cannot help in lifting the national economy at

a higher level.

Hl: lack of awareness among the population and companies is a big

problem to the capital markets industry.

HO: lack of awareness among the population and companies is not a

big problem to the capital markets industry.

10

Page 23: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

CHAPTER TWO

LITERATURE REVIEW

Capital Markets Journals are very essential. It states that the

capital market's role is to educate and keep updated the public about Capital

Markets as they tackle each aspects of the Capital Markets Industry. The 1st

issue was June 1997 and it is released 3 times a year. They address issues

such as Financial Sector reforms, features of Uganda's Capital Markets

Authority, USE, bonds, and interviews with role players in Capital Markets

industry, privatization among others. They also talk about fixed income

securities, how to make money on stock exchange, requirements of listing on

USE. In few words, they help the reader to get a full picture of the

functioning of the capital markets and also the type of challenges that

present in that industry and the measures taken to get over them.

For an insight in to the concerns of Capital Markets development, a

collection of papers presented at a symposium on Global Capital Markets

titled "Changing Capital Markets: Implication for Monetary Policy" have been

useful. It highlights considerations that policy makers have to make

especially in developing markets. This symposium was sponsored by Federal

Reserve of Bank of Kansas. These papers were presented by prominent

personalities like Alan Greenspan, Chairman of Federal Reserve Board.

"Uganda Vision 2035, Towards A Modern, Industrialized and

Knowledge Based Society", June 2005, a book coordinated by NPA, the

National Planning Authority is important in that it addresses issues on where

Uganda is today, as an underdeveloped nation, challenges, pre requisites,

policies and strategies for the foreseeable future. The book also suggests

necessary development planning framework and strategic intervention to

reach goals and vision set for the year 2035, and that capital markets will

play a big role in that achievement.

11

Page 24: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

In "Capital Markets: the Journal for the Capital Market Industry

Investor Protection in Zambian Securities Markets" By MUMBA S. KAPUMP,

it is stated that the most valuable asset any investor can own is knowledge.

By understanding investment and Capital Markets, individuals will be better

prepared to make informed decisions. Mr. MUMBA's article contains

insightful advise for investors, not only the Zambian market but worldwide.

Investors are entitled to protection, but they must also take some measures

to minimize investment risks.

Leo KIBIRANGO, Chairman of CMA, in Capital Markets Authority

Annual report 2004, states that Capital Markets Project (CMAP) as a unique

initiative aiming at providing technical support to companies with potential to

make public offers and list on the Uganda Securities Exchange (USE). He

stresses that CMA has been aware of the challenges of stimulating private

sector led offers and listings, and that with this new project, funded by the

US department of the Treasury, potential enterprises in the private sector will

be equipped to raise capital for expansion and growth through the market.

In the report written by Japheth KATTO, chief executive officer of

CMA in the CMA Annual Report 2004, he states that the small number of

companies listed on USE and the absence of listings from the private sector

companies has continued to be a big challenge to the industry. He continues

saying that in order to make progress in the area, CMA is working with USE,

bank of Baroda and the Ministry of Finance succeeded in getting the US

Treasury to fund Capital Markets Projects (CMAP) whose principal objective is

to increase the number of private sector companies listing on the USE.

In the address to shareholders by Mr. Japheth KATTO during the

CMA end of the year seminar, he said, "The industry needs new products to

boost market participation. This means in addition to privatization,

encouraging the private sector to list their companies on the stock exchange

12

Page 25: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

hence creating a wider choice to potential investors." He continues, "As the

supply side is boosted, demand should also be addressed through

encouraging participation in the primary and secondary market. This can be

done through public awareness, incentives and appropriate saving vehicle

such as pension and Collective Investment schemes." In this speech, Mr.

KATTO explains some of the strategies that should be made in order to over

come some of the challenges of Capital Markets in Uganda.

In the interview of Mr. RUMBIDZAYI NYABADZA, the Executive

Director of Investment Advisor Renaissance Capital Ltd. by Frederic MASIGO

of the Daily Monitor published on July 4rn, 2006 page 19, Mr. NYABADZA

explains that ignorance is one of the challenges of Capital Markets in Uganda,

but that the common man is not to blame. He insists that it just because the

whole issue of Capital Markets is fairly new and what needs to be done is for

more players to come on the market. He also talks about marketing the

Capital Markets.

Dr Michael Atingi EGO said in his interview with the Daily Monitor

published on July 21st, 2006 page 19, that Uganda must graduate to the level

which it can borrow funds from international Capital Markets to finance

investments in the country. He said that for Uganda to reach the level of

borrowing from international capital markets, it must have a strong domestic

capital markets meaning that Uganda's stock market should have several

companies listed, which trade regularly through a more computerized

system. The interview shows us how Uganda should concentrate on its

Capital Market by borrowing outside and develop its own.

The existence of informal and curb market, moral hazards, adverse

selection effects, and asymmetric information affect the behavior of financial

markets in developing countries. Stiglitz and Veiss (1981) have shown that

there will still be credit rationing, even with financial liberization, because of

imperfect information on the part of the borrowers and lenders. To reduce

13

Page 26: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

the inefficiency associated with the weak credit markets, Cho (1986) argued

that credit market need to be complemented by a well functioning equity

market in developing countries. The underlying assumption in this analysis is

that both potential shareholders and risk-neutral lenders have the same level

of information on firms with which to judge the expected productivity of their

investment projects. It has been suggested that Cho's analysis ignores

information costs and the informational requirements it imposes on the

individual equity investor as well as agency problem in management­

controlled operations.

According to Ms Sheila Karungi Mugyenge, in the article "Challenges

to Trade and Investments in Uganda" published in The Guide magazine,

Trade and economic Development in Uganda Issue no.2, march 2006, the

challenges to development of trade and investment, among others include

access to finance, competitive incentives regime, bureaucracy, lack of skills

and some major obstacle to may potential investors to achieve their

development plan. Existing financial institutions, which are largely foreign­

owned, mainly focus on short-term lending and at incredible interest rates.

To hers, this situation has for long remained unchanged.

14

Page 27: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

CHAPTER THREE

3.1 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

3.11 Sampling Procedure

The researcher collected both primary and secondary data. Most of the

information that the researcher gathered was collected from interviews

conducted face-to-face, with public and private investors, Capital Markets

Authority staff and companies' management.

A great deal of the research was also gotten from the information

center of CMA as well as the Kampala International University Main Library.

Because of the commendable role played by the media in marketing

the Capital Markets, the news papers, articles, journals and magazines were

used a lot in conducting the research.

The researcher also relied upon the Internet for its easy and fast

accessibility.

3.1.2 Sampling Profile.

The researcher targeted business Companies staff, investors (common

citizens) as well as Capital Market Authority Staff.

20 companies were given questionnaires, in which some of them were

listed and not listed on USE.

80 people (citizens) were given questionnaires to fill at heir own will.

Interviews were conducted with 2 members of CMA staff.

15

Page 28: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

CHAPTER FOUR

4.1 DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF THE FINDINGS.

4.1.1 Data Collected From companies Responses

Table l C ompames t at respon e h d d

Status of companies' responses.

Companies that gave full respond 12 66.7%

Companies that gave incomplete responses 6 33.3%

Companies contacted 18 90%

Companies not contacted 2 10%

Total number of companies in the proposal 20 100%

Source: Primary Data

Among those 18 companies contacted, only 4 were listed to USE

(Uganda Securities Exchange), 14 were not listed yet. In this chapter, there

will be discussion of the reasons why some companies have not yet

considered going public and other are not interested to do so at all.

4.1.1.1 Listed and not Listed Companies That Responded:

Table 2 Listed and unlisted companies Number Percentage

Listed companies 4 22.3%

Not listed companies 14 77.7%

Total 18 100%

Source: Primary Data

16

Page 29: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Figure 1 Listed and unlisted companies

■ listed companies ■ not listed companies

In the 14 companies that are not listed, it was found that only 3 of them

have invested in securities traded in USE.

4.1.1.2 Proportion of Companies' Investment in Securities

Table 3P roportion o ompames fC . , In . s vestment m ecunt1es

Current investment

Shares 5%

Treasury bills 10%

Bonds 5%

Non-current assets 80%

Source: Primary Data

17

Page 30: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Figure 2 Proportion of Companies' Investment in Securities

Iii shares ■ T-Bills □ Bonds □ Non-currrent assets

As this data shows, only 20% of the 3 companies have invested in the

securities markets by either buying treasury bills, bonds from either listed

companies or government (Treasury bills).

This how that 20% was distributed in the securities market.

Table 4 Distribution of securities Progortion

Government/ BOU Treasury bills 50%

PTA/ EADB/ UTL Bonds 25%

EABL 8%

KQ 7%

DFCU 3%

NVL 3%

Uganda Clays 2%

BARODA 2%

BAT -

East African Jubilee -

Source: Primary Data

18

Page 31: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Figure 3 Distribution of securities

I

111 T-Bills

■ PTA/EADB/UTL Bonds

■ EABL

D KQ

■ DFCU

DNVL

■ Uganda Clays

o Baroda

As from the answers from the respondent companies, it is found out

that the big percentage of companies' investments (50%) is in government's

Treasury bills. There is actually a similar reason from the three companies of

why they chose T-bills:

T-bills are risk-free investment, that is, these companies are assured

that anyhow, on a specified day in the future they will get their money back

plus interest that would generate approximately 8% per year.

Investing in equity shares on the other hand present uncertainty of

returns and that is the reason why most companies do not invest in shares

traded in USE. According to John Ngumi, Regional Director Investment

Banking of STANBIC Bank, the reason is the uncertainty of returns;

19

Page 32: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

companies may or may not declare dividends and also the high share price

fluctuations.

4.1.1.3 Unlisted Companies Wishing to Go Public in Future.

In 14 companies that were not listed yet, 10 of them envisaged to go

public in the near future.

Table 5 Companies 1shm2 to 0 u IC ID uture w· . G P bl" . F

Number of comganies Period in y:ears

2 1-2 year

5 3-5 years

3 6-10 years

1 Not sure

Source: Primary Data

Figure 4 Companies Wishing to Go Public in Future

5 ~-------------------------------,

4 -+-----------

3 +-----------

2 -1---

1 -1---

0 -i---

1-2 years 3-5 years 6-10 years

I• Number of companies I Not sure

The researcher found out in the 10 companies that are willing to go

public, all preferred to issue shares more than any other financial

instruments such as commercial paper and bonds.

20

Page 33: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Their response on that was:

1st choice:

2nd choice:

Shares

Bonds

3rd choice: Other financial instruments

Companies wish to issue shares because they think it is low cost of

capital because the company pays dividends only when profits are made.

Paying dividends is not compulsory like in case where by the company want

to retain some profits.

Bonds and commercial papers are less preferred because they have to

be serviced by paying interests and it is obligatory to pay back investors their

money when the time is due.

The preference presentation is demonstrated by the following pie chart:

Figure 5 Preference of the respondents

5% 15°/o

80%

21

■ Shares

■ Corporate bonds

□ Other financial instruments

Page 34: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

4.1.2 INVESTORS DATA ANALYSIS.

Questionnaires were distributed to 80 respondents but only 60 of them

managed to give feedback.

4.1.2.1 Sex of the Respondents

Table 6 Sex of the Resoondents Sex Number

Male 37

Female 23

Total 60

Source: Primary Data

Figure 6 Sex of the Respondents

40 ...,._ __________ _________ _,

35 -1------

30 -1---- --

25 -1------

20 -1------

15 -1------

10 -1------

5 ~ - ---

0 -1------

■ male

■ female

A large number of respondents are males compared to females. The

researcher chose males because it is a fact that worldwide men are the ones

who mostly likely are involved in investments. Females are considered to be

risk-averse and chose not to participate in capital markets. Therefore, most

ideas of capital markets would come from males.

22

Page 35: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

4.1.2.2 Age of the Respondents

Table 7 A!!e of the Respondents

Age

Under 18

18-29

30-39

40-49

50-59

60-69

70-80

Above 80

Source: Primary Data

Figure 7 Age of the Respondents

25

20

15

10

5

0

-

I

-I:

-

-- -

',

- -

I I

Number

None

9

22

14

9

6

None

None

I □ Years of age I

-n I

In the research, people aged between 30 and 40 make the high

number of respondents.

23

Page 36: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

The reason behind that is that they are easily available, and were not

reluctant to accept questionnaire and fill them. The researcher also chose

people of this class because they are in middle age where people at this

stage are becoming financially stable; they earn money and are ready to

take investment risks. They are still young enough to recover from

investment losses.

4.1.2.3 Occupation of the Respondents

The researcher classified respondents also according to their

occupation:

Table 8 OccunatIOn of the R espondents

OccuQation Number Percentage

Students 13 21.7%

Employed 22 39.6%

Self employed 16 26.7%

Retired 3 5.0%

No occupation 6 10.0%

Source: Primary Data

24

Page 37: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

In numbers: Figure 8 Occupation of the Respondents

25

20

15

10

5

0 Students Employed

In percentage:

Figure 9 Occupation of the Respondents

Students 24%

No occupation

8%

Self employed

Retired

5%

25

Employed 31%

No occupation

Self

employed 32%

■ Occupation of Respondent sin

Page 38: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Large number of the respondents are employed, self-employed and

student. They were ease to access them from their work offices, their shops

or enterprises and in schools. They are also among the people who know

what is happening in the country as they contribute a lot in the economic

growth and development. However, some of the respondents had no

occupation and others are retired, and so the researcher got information

from all fields, in terms of occupation.

4.1.2.4 Education Level of the Respondents

T bl 9 Ed a e ucation eves o t e espon ents L I f h R d

Level of education Number

Uneducated 3

Primary 3

Secondary 4

Diploma 9

Undergraduate 16

Graduate 18

Postgraduate 7

Source: Primary Data

Figure 10 Education Levels of the Respondents

Postgraduate -----------+------+---- -

Graduate

Undergraduate

Diploma

Secondary

Primary

Uneducated

-+------+------+------+---------'I

0 5 10 15 20

26

Ill Level of education

Page 39: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

A great number of respondents are educated at least beyond the

diploma level. This helped a lot as they have sufficient knowledge and can

give personal judgment on most problems presented to them. They helped in

analyzing the problem from the roots and gave contributions on what should

be done in order to overcome the challenges that the capital markets face.

4.1.2.5 Respondent's Awareness of CMA and USE

CMA Awareness

Table l O CMA awareness

Respondents aware

Respondents not aware

Source: Primary Data

Figure 11 CMA awareness

Respondents not aware

800/o

Number

12

48

27

Percentage

20%

80%

Respondents aware 200/o

Page 40: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

USE Awareness

Table 11 USE awareness

Respondents aware

Respondents not aware

Source: Primary Data

Figure 12 USE awareness

Respondents not aware 35%

Number

39

21

Percentage

65%

35%

Respondents aware 65%

Respondents not aware of both USE and CMA were 7, the

percentage is 11.66%, of all the respondents. These people have no

knowledge and have never heard of either CMA or USE.

There is a bigger awareness of USE than there is of CMA among the

respondents. Most respondents know both bodies but could not establish a

clear relationship between the two.

What they ignored is that:

28

Page 41: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

• The Capital Markets Authority is a government body, which performs

the duty of a regulator, hence is the overseer of the capital markets

industry in Uganda.

• The Uganda Securities Exchange is a private sector body regulated by

Capital Markets Authority. It is a private company limited by

guarantee, whose shareholders are brokers/dealers and investments

advisors.

However about 15% (less than 10 respondents) especially graduates and

postgraduates could establish a clear relationship between the two bodies.

4.1.2.6 sources of Awareness of CMA or USE

The respondents, who were aware at least CMA or USE, knew about

them from different resources as represented in the figure below:

Table 12 Sources of Awareness ofCMA and USE Source Number Percentage

Radio/TV 21 39.1%

Newspapers 13 25.1%

School 11 20.7%

Friends (mouth to mouth) 8 15.1%

Internet - 0.0%

Source: Primary Data

29

Page 42: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Figure 13 Sources of Awareness ofCMA and USE

Source, Mouth­to-mouth,

15%

Source, School, 21%

Source, Internet, 0%

Source, Newspapers,

25%

Source, ---Radio/TV,

39%

Radio and television are the main sources that provide most

information on CMA and USE. The newspapers also provide a source of

information as radio and television but it is obvious that people watch TV and

listen to radio more than they read newspapers, especially the business news

section

Students also get chances to know about capital markets from lectures

they get from universities, colleges and high schools. One respondent was

from high school and have participated in the Inter-high School Capital

Markets Quiz Challenge.

30

Page 43: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

4.1.2.7 Respondents' Participation in the Capital Markets.

The researcher wanted also to know whether among the respondents

are some who have bought/sold or currently own any security traded in USE.

The feedback was:

T bl 13 P f . f . th C "t I M k t a e ar 1cma 10n m e ap1 a ar e s. TJ'.Qe of resgondent Number

Never participated before 46

Bought shares 7

Source: Primary Data

Figure 14 Participation in the Capital Markets.

Participated in the

securities markets

13%

31

Percentage

86.8%

13.2%

Never Participated

before 87%

Page 44: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Most of the respondents have never bothered to participate before but

some of them admitted that they would like to in the future.

Table 14 TtRe of resgondent who:

Intend to buy shares/bonds

Are still undecided whether to buy or not

Do not trust bonds and stocks

Are less likely to buy stocks and bonds in

the future

Source: Primary Data

Figure 15

less likely to buy bonds and

stocks 170/o

Do not trust bonds and

stocks 210/o

Number

7

26

11

9

Percentage

13.2%

49.1%

20 .8 %

16.9%

Intends to buys shares

130/o

Undecided whether to bu·

or not 490/o

Despite the low awareness of capital markets and low willingness to

participate in security markets among the respondents, there are also those

who have information about the markets but are still lenient to buy stocks or

bonds.

The large number is for those who are still undecided whether to buy

bonds/stocks or not. They say that they are not sure of the benefits they will

32

Page 45: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

get from them. They are risk-averse people in the fact that they do not want

to risk their money in shares and bonds but instead they choose to invest in

less risky properties such as cars, furniture, etc and save the rest in

commercial banks.

Some respondents, nevertheless, have the will to participate but they do

know how to go through it.

Only 8 respondents could name all companies whose financial

instruments are trade in USE, and have an understanding of instruments

such types of shares, bonds classification and commercial papers.

Among all respondents, only 1 person owns shares from outside of

Uganda. The person owns shares from NSE and the reason was that he

wanted to try to make diversification of his portfolio.

Almost 80% of respondents are risk-averse persons, and 38 of all

people admitted to be pessimist. It all goes with the risks attributed to

capital markets when it comes to invest insecurities themselves. Many people

have a negative image towards them because of little understanding of these

markets.

33

Page 46: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

CHAPTER FIVE

5.1 SUMMARY. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.

5.1.2 Conclusions: Summary of the Problems Facing the Capital

Markets Industry.

The capital markets industry faces many problems. During the interviews

conducted, the interviewer identified several problems facing the industry.

The main ones are the following:

1. Lack of awareness/ low level of awareness of the roles and activities of

capital markets industry.

2. Low confidence in capital markets due to past experience e.g. public

not getting returns from shares.

3. Weak corporate governance with some local companies.

4. Lack of savings and liquidity in Uganda.

5. Inadequate financial support from the government.

6. Lack of products on the market/ few products on the market.

7. The industry is still young/ skeptical.

8. Lack of incentives for listing.

9. Mistrust of companies and capital markets management.

10.Lack of Central Depository System (DPS).

11.High liquidity preference.

12.Most literature is too complex and only addressed to elites.

13.Slow rate of law reform

14.Inadequate funding

15.Few companies from private sector listed

16.Few professional practitioners

17.Lack of long-term investments

34

Page 47: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

As it can be observed, the industry faces many problems. However no

initiative can address all problems simultaneously within the same period.

Additionally, some issues that are termed as problems may actually be

causes or effects of the main problems. Therefore, the players in the capital

markets industry need to identify the main problems present in order to

analyze and prioritize their causes as a first step towards identifying effective

solutions.

The problem tree is an effective tool of identification and analysis of

relevant causes of the main problems. As illustrated in the diagram, most of

the problems have interlinking causes:

P.T.O

35

Page 48: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Effect

Problem

Causes

Effects

Problems

Causes

Slow rate of law reforms.

Inadequate financial support from government.

Lack of awareness.

Most literature too complex.

Weak corporate governance with some local companies.

Few companies from private sector listed.

Lack/Few of products in the capital markets.

Lack of incentives for listing.

The industry is still young.

Source: CMA~---------~

- Low saving culture and Inability to trust liquidity in Uganda. - companies' and capital

market management.

Inadequate funding of --

36

awareness.

Fear of companies to open up to other shareholders.

Few professional practitioners.

Page 49: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

s.1.2 Priority Problems and Causes

- People do not have the confidence to invest their money in capital

markets industry (mistrust of the industry).

Causes:

• This arises from institutions and individuals investors who have lost

money before. In this respect people have not yet gained enough

confidence in the operation of the capital markets industry. People do

not have the confidence to entrust their money in other people's hands

and in the industry.

• Many people are not aware of the operations of capital markets

industry.

- Lack of awareness about capital markets industry In Uganda.

Causes:

• Lack of to information about financial services to different parts of

Uganda.

• Low literacy levels and poor reading culture.

• Lack of independent analysts about the capital markets industry.

- Saving culture in the country characterized by preference for short

terms real estate investments.

Causes:

• Uncertainty about available options for savings. People tend to be

certain about what is at hand. This is linked to the macro economic

uncertainties such as high interest rates and political uncertainties.

• Low disposable income, which does not encourage saving.

• Tendency to prefer short-term to long-term investments. This due to

various reasons such as low income and being unsure of the long-term

37

Page 50: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

markets.

• Due to lack of public confidence in the financial markets in general.

People in Uganda fear long-term investments in the financial sector

and instead rely on buying and owning other assets such as land,

houses and family business as a form of saving.

- Few products listed on the market.

Causes:

• The listing criteria are laborious. This scenario does not favor

competition with other investment sources, which have less laborious,

fast and low cost processes, compared to the listing criteria. As much

as it is important to safeguard the capital market, the process itself

contributes to limited participation.

• Lack of incentives combined with high Initial Public Offer (IPO) costs.

When a company goes public, there is no mechanism by which the

company can recover the costs involved in going public, including the

time spent, since IPO's are not taxable. Since companies are

rationally, an appraisal of the !PO costs to be incurred in the light of

the uncertainty of recovery time is likely to force them to look for

other alternatives.

• The capital markets industry is still young, thus potential issues feel

insecure. In addition, insurance companies have also not ventured yet

in this new industry. Further, underwriting has not been made

mandatory requirement for issuers.

• Uncertainty regarding macro economic and political stability, the basis

for a healthy interest rates regime.

• Low level of industrialization and a small and underdeveloped private

sector in the country.

• Lack of financial resources due to a thin financial sector.

38

Page 51: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

5.2 RECOMMENDATIONS

The purpose of the research was to assess the problems, hindrances

and challenges faced by the capital markets, and to identify their causes. In

this chapter, the researcher is giving some recommendations, or some of

possible solutions that CMA and USE can use in order to overcome these

problems.

The recommendations given by the researcher are the following:

Increase the awareness among people by creating ways of communicating

to people by simplified material in local languages and use of visual media­

channel. Terms such as share prices, equities and so on, should be clearly

defined. Although CMA and USE have produced booklets and brochures that

explain these terms, the continued lack of awareness of capital markets by

the public, especially outside Kampala, suggest that CMA and USE still need

to simplify the language used in these publications. Alternatively, the

messages can be disseminated through different communication channels

other than print material e.g. drama or video, and translated into local

languages that may have terms that are easy to understand. Use of visual

communication in local languages with storylines that can help the audience

relate capital markets to real life may be more effective than using mainly

print media. Currently, publications have only been translated in Luganda.

There is need to translate them into more local languages. Initially, the

industry can begin with one major language from each region.

Use of Testimonies. The capital markets industry should also make

testimonies from organizations and individuals that have benefited from

participating in capital markets. Research results suggest that many people

think that only the wealthy people with 'idle' money should participate in the

capital markets, and would like to see/hear testimonies or success stories of

people who have benefited from the market.

39

Page 52: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Move from awareness to education. CMA and USE should move towards

actively changing the attitudes and behaviors of the public in order to

address the problems facing the capital markets industry, such as lack of

saving culture, or capital markets not being seen as an investment choice by

the public. This means aggressive marketing by specifically USE, targeted at

behavioral change. The financial instruments floated on USE should be

promoted by making them relevant to Ugandans, both issuers and investors.

Opinion leaders such as Local Council leaders, religious leaders are some of

the groups of people that USE and CMA can use as source of information.

Initiate discussions with Ugandans business and private sector

organizations. Likewise, lessons learnt can be used to generate future

interest in the securities market, both for the company as an issuer or for the

owner/ chief executive officer as a private investor.

Enable high-income earners to invest in securities, especially investing

in government securities, either direct or indirect through mutual funds.

Since these individuals pay income tax, one can direct their interest to

securities through partly tax exempted investment in long-term mutual

retirement funds, which would not only change their savings habits, but also

increase competition in the pension fund sector by reducing the monopoly of

National Social Security Service fund (NSSF).

Contact several companies that expressed their interest in the

securities market. This may be an opportunity to discuss with interested

counterparts views on company and tax laws, auditing rules affecting listed

companies, the advantages and disadvantages of being listed on a stock

exchange. Eventually, new members should be introduced to the market.

Encourage government to continue privatization through public

floatation, which is still the most realistic sources of companies that will list

on the stock exchange. Encourage also listing of government securities and a

40

Page 53: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

government market for private investors as the stock exchange, this will

expose the exchange to the public and, at the same time, may give the

broker community an opportunity for high profitability and incentives to

improve profession competence.

5.3 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY

The project was conducted successfully, but the researcher had little

difficulties during the research. Some of the limitations were:

Communication barrier as most of Ugandans speak their local

languages thus the researcher had to use English, which was

unfamiliar to some people.

Financial resources also made it difficult for the researcher to cover

a bigger scope of Uganda. For instance, the researcher focused

mainly in Kampala.

Some respondents claimed ignorance of capital markets and said

that they needed not to be sensitized and that to them it would

have been a waste of time.

41

Page 54: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Books

1) Andrew Bohnstedt, Alfred Hanning, Ralph P. Ondendall, Capital

Markets Development in Uganda: Private Opinion,

2) Andrew Chisholm, An Introduction to Capital Markets: Products,

Strategies and Participants.

3) Emmanuel BURINGURIZA, Johan HYLTENSTAM, Capital Market

Development in Uganda- Statistical Profile of the Securities Market,

FSD Series no. 10.

4) M.J ELLYNE, A review of Uganda's Structural Adjustment Programme.

5) MUMBA S. KAMPUMP, Capital Markets: The Journal For Capital Markets

Industry, Investor Protection in Zambian Securities Markets

6) Sheila Karungi MAGYENGE, Trade and Economic Development in

Uganda, published by The Guide Magazine.

7) Zeph Metro Nwaye ELEH, Know Your Capital Markets Inside Out, Dec

2004.

Journals

1) Capital Markets Journals.

2) Capital Markets Disclosure. Interim Report, July 1999.

websites

1) www.cmauganda.co.ug

2) www.investorword.com

42

Page 55: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

QUESTIQNNAIRESFOR COMPANIES.

Your company has been selected by the researcher as one of the beneficiaries and participants in the financial markets. Please answer the following questions carefully and help us get information on the performance of Capital Markets in relation with investors.

BASIC INFORMATION

Company Name ................................................................................................ .

Contact detail: Telephone ................................................ . Fax ............................................................ . Email ........................................................ . Website .................................................... . Name of the respondent:

Position of the respondent:

Age: ................................................. Sex: ..................................................... .

Type of business (e.g. manufacturing edible oil, bank, brewing, etc.)

Questionl Have you participated in the securities markets (i.e. bought or sold shares, Treasury Bills, Bonds, etc.)? Please tick (v) where applicable:

Yes ( ... ) No ( ... )

If Yes, go tom question 2 and follow through to the end skipping Question 4 a. only. If No, please go directly to Question 4 a. and follow through to the end.

1

Page 56: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Question 2 What proportions of your current investment is in?

Current investment Proportion(%) Shares Treasurv Bills Bonds Others (please specify) Total

Question 3 Please indicate, in the Table below, the estimated proportions of your current investments by issuer of securities:

Cateaorv of issuers Prooortion (%) Government/ BOU Treasury Bills PTA bonds Uaanda Clays British American Tobacco East African Breweries Limited Kenya Airways DFCU BARODA East African Jubilee NVL Total

If you have participated in the securities markets already, please skip Question 4 a. and proceed with question 4 b.

Question 4

a. Given the relativity "higher returns on investments and tower cost of capital" in the securities market than from for example, savings account at commercial bank, would you consider participating in the securities market in the future? Please tick (v') where applicable:

Yes ( ... ) No ( ... )

If Yes, go to question 4 b. and follow through. If No, please go to question 4 f. and stop.

b. Is your company willing to issue securities on the market?

2

Page 57: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

Please tick (v) where applicable: Yes ( ... ) No ( ... )

c. If Yes, please indicate the period, from now, when you intend to issue by ticking (v') where applicable:

Period in Years v' 1 2 3 4 5

10 Other olease soecifv

d. With the improving performance of the securities markets (increasing activity, the likely increase in yields on investment and lowering of cost of capital), what would you envisage as your future issuance of preferences, by category, in the security market?

Please rank the options by indicating: 1. for your 1st choice. 2. for your 2nd choice. 3. for your 3rd choice.

Shares Bonds

( ... ) ( ... )

Other financial instruments ( ... ) Please specify the type of investment.

e. What proportions (percentage) of your future investment will be in?

Title of investment Prooortion (%) Shares Treasurv Bills Bonds Others (Please specify) Total

3

Page 58: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

f. Please give reasons why you would not want to participate in the securities markets:

Question 5 With improving performance of financial markets (increasing activities, the likely increase in yields on investments and lowering of cost of capital), what would you envisage as you are your future investment preference by issuer of the security?

Please rank the options by indicating: 1. for your 1st choice. 2. for your 2nd choice. 3. for your 3rd choice.

Government Private sector Foreign securities

( ... ) ( ... ) ( ... )

Others ( ... ) Please specify the type of security.

4

Page 59: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

What proportions (percentage) of your future investment will be from the following issuers?

Title of investment Proportion(%) Private sector e.a. UCL. BAT Government Treasury Bills Foreign securities and Cross listinqs Others (Please soecify) Total

Question 6

Finally, please give us your personal comment/ opinion/ criticisms on:

Capital Markets in Uganda

Its performances.

Its challenges and difficulties

Its benefits and advantages.

You may write as much as you want

5

Page 60: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

QUESTIONNAIRE FOR INVESTORS

NAME: .......................................................................................................... .

SEX: ............................................................................................................. .

Marital status: ........................................................................................... .

Address: ...................................................................................................... .

Email: .......................................................................................................... .

Telephone: ................................................................................................. .

Age (please tick in the box where you belong):

!Under 18 I j1s-29j J3o-39I 140-49!

1so-sg I l6o-69j j7o-soj !above sol

1. Which of the following is your occupation:

a) Employed

b) Self employed

c) Student

d) Retired

e) No occupation

2. Please indicate by ticking the level of your education:

a) None f) Graduate

b) Primary g) Postgraduate

c) Secondary

d) Diploma

e) Undergraduate

1

Page 61: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

3. Do you know about;

• CMA?

• USE?

a) Yes

b) No

4. If yes, please briefly explain how you understand them, by telling the

relationship they have, if any.

5. How did you know about CMA and USE?

a) Newspapers

b) Radio/ TV

c) Internet

d) School

e) Other (specify)

6. Have you ever sold/ bought or currently own securities?

a) Yes

b) No

i.If yes, specify which one(s)

ii.If no, describe why not.

7. Concerning securities, please indicate by ticking whether you:

a) intend to buy shares/ bond

b) are still undecided whether to buy or not

c) don't trust bonds and stocks

d) are less likely to buy stock and bonds in the near future

2

Page 62: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

8. Do you actually own shares in international stock exchanges such as:

NSE, DSE, NYSE, LSE, JSEW, or NASDAQ?

a) Yes

b) No

i.If yes, briefly tell in which one(s), and why.

9. Finally, as a person with a modest or excellent business mind, how

would you plausibly describe yourself, given any exposure s to risk

(business risk, default)?

a) Risk averse

b) Risk taker

c) Optimistic

d) Pessimistic

3

Page 63: THE CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS FACED BY CAPITAL …

QUESTIONNAIRE FOR CAPITAL MARKETS STA.ff

This is a kind of interview or discussion and will be based on the following

questions:

1. What are capital markets?

2. What are the benefits and advantages of capital markets to:

- the individuals?

- the nation as a whole?

3. What are the problems and the challenges that the capital markets

encounter? What may be their causes as well as their effects?

4. What measures that can be taken in order to resolve these problems

and eliminate those challenges