Upload
national-academies-of-science-engineering-and-medicine
View
224
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
1/35
Gordon E. Uno
Department of Botany and Microbiology
University of [email protected]
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
2/35
The Evolution of This Project Judy Scotchmoor, UCMP
NESCent WORKING GROUP:
Evolution Across The Curriculum (EVAC)
Kristin Jenkins, NESCent
Jory Weintraub, NESCent
Jay Labov, NRC, NAS
Adam Fagen, Board of Life Sciences, NAS
Paul Beardsley, BSCSJudy Scotchmoor, UCMP
Gordon Uno, OU
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
3/35
EVAC1) Interested in developing evolutionary examples
and supporting information for every conceptin biology (but not developing a curriculum!)
2) How to get instructors to use examples
3) How to get people to think evolutionarily
4) How to get biologists to contribute examples
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
4/35
NSF RCN-UBE (5-year project)
INTRODUCTORY BIOLOGY PROJECT (IBP)
Richard OGrady, AIBSSusan Musante, AIBSCharlene DAvanzo, Hampshire College
Todd Carter, Seward County CCMembers of the AIBS Education CommitteeGordon Uno, University of Oklahoma
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
5/35
Major Goal of the
Introductory Biology Project (IBP)
Articulate a vision of the perfect Introductory
Biology experience---adjusting for theenormous diversity of faculty, students,and problems at all institutionsincluding what should be taught (and how
it should be taught).
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
6/35
IBP Meetings
Small, Innovation meetings (15-25 people)intended to generate new ideas about solving issues
related to Introductory Biology
(Biology Directors Consortium, Biology Education
Researchers, E2 at NESCent, Community CollegeFaculty at NABT, ASM Faculty)
Large, Synthesis meetings (150-200 people) intended to
showcase whats working, forge new collaborations,prepare participants for sharing, and identify future
leaders
Planning a synthesis meeting at AAAS in June, 2012
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
7/35
Why Evolution Across the
Curriculum?1. It makes sense biologically and
pedagogically.
2. Can help thwart the constant assaulton the teaching of evolution.
3. Will help instructors feel more
comfortable about teaching evolution.4. Students cant avoid learning about
evolution.
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
8/35
Theodosius DobzhanskyNothing in biology makes sense except in the light of
evolution
1973, American Biology Teacher
Corollary?Everything in biology makes more sense in the light
of evolution
So, if we want to help our students understand biology, thenwe should use a theme to organize our courses.
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
9/35
CONVERGENT EVOLUTION IN SCIENCE
EDUCATION RECOMMENDATIONS:
use a theme or unifying major concept to teachscience; in biology, a theme is evolution
College Boards Revision Of Advanced
Placement (AP) Biology AAAS/NSF Vision And Change
AAMC-HHMI Scientific Foundations (List Of
Competencies) Next Generation Science Education Standards,
NRC (with NSTA)
AACU LEAP Learning Outcomes
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
10/35
When students learn about a subject in biology, doyou or they ask:
How did that evolve?Is that the same in all organisms?
Whats the significance of that structure?How can we explain thatit doesnt make
sense?How does this compare to that?
Is A related to B?How do we know that---whats the evidence?What does that information tell us about
the evolution of X?
What Does It Mean To Think Evolutionarily?
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
11/35
Blooms Taxonomy of Evolutionary Thinking
Knowledge (Recall Information)What is it and how does it function?
Comprehension (Explain; translate knowledge intonew context; interpret; infer causes)
Could evolution have played a role in thedevelopment of its form or function?
Application (Problem solve; use concepts andtheories in new situations; illustrate)
How did this come about through evolution--how could this have evolved? What is yourhypothesis?
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
12/35
Analysis (Identify contributing parts and underlyingstructure; identify components; see patterns)
What would have to have happened for evolution tooccur---environment, selective pressures, ancestralcharacteristics? From what did it descendtowhat is it related?
Synthesis (Form new whole; put parts together)Can you develop the complete scenario/model inwhich it evolved?
Evaluation (Resolve differences of opinion; appraise;
provide arguments for)What evidence do you have that this is actuallywhat happened over time? What evidence do youneed to justify your scenario/model/explanation?
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
13/35
How Can We Teach That Way?
INTENTIONALITY from AACU
Faculty and students clearly understandlearning objectives for course.
What activities, lessons, etc. are going to helpstudents reach those objectives?
Then there is a constant reminderto beintentional to help students reach
those objectives.
For my course, evolution: say it everyday
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
14/35
What might evolution across thecurriculum look like?
Certainly, there are different models.
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
15/35
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
16/35
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
17/35
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
18/35
Plants are indicators of their
environmentBecause plants are not motile, once they start
growing in one place, they are stuck there. If
they cant survive in that environment, theycant pass their genes on to the next
generation. If plants survive and reproduce
sexually, their offspring may be different thanthey are. This leads to evolution of plants withdifferent adaptations in different environments.
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
19/35
For centuries, humans have been selecting
which organisms can reproduce to
develop more desirable fruits,vegetables, pets, and livestock
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
20/35
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
21/35
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
22/35
So, how can we promote change---
in how biology is taught andhow biology and evolution areperceived by the public andunderstood by students?
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
23/35
AP BIOLOGY Big Ideas (themes)
Big Idea 1: The process of evolution drives thediversity and unity of life.
Big Idea 2: Biological systems utilize energy and molecularbuilding blocks to grow, reproduce, and maintain homeostasis.
Big Idea 3: Living systems retrieve, transmit, and respond toinformation essential to life processes.
Big Idea 4: Biological systems interact, and these interactionspossess complex properties.
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
24/35
Whats the impact on new AP
biology exam?In 2008, 12% of questions had something
to do with evolution
In new exam, 35% of questions have
something to do with evolution
So, what we do can have major effects
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
25/35
What questions can we address atthis meeting?
1. What works and what doesnt to help students
learn biology with an evolutionaryperspective?
2. What projects (existing or future) and peoplecan help?
3. Who do we have to convince, and how do wedo that?
4. What curricular materials can help, who willdevelop them, and how will instructors/peoplelearn how to use them and to think
evolutionarily?
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
26/35
Who are our targets and how dowe reach them (strategies)?
High school students and teachersAP and non-AP
General publicFarmers? Moms? Politicians?
College and university faculty and students2-year institutions, colleges, and universities
Scientists, plus biology and science
education organizations Textbook authors and publishers News people
Who else??
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
27/35
How do we reach our targets?We need to find key players who can be effective agents of change and
to develop individualized strategies for our targets.FOR HS, WHAT ARE CARROTS AND/OR STICKS?
UNIVERSAL EXAMAPWHAT ABOUT NON-AP TEACHERS and STUDENTS?
FOR INTRODUCTORY BIOLOGY STUDENTS
CURRICULAR SUPPORT MATERIALS(e.g., EVAC or TEXTBOOKS)?
BIOLOGY DIRECTORS CONSORTIUM (BDC)?
FOR ALL INSTRUCTORSWHAT KIND OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT?
ROLE OF NABT AND NSTA?ROLE OF SCIENTIFIC SOCIETIES?
FOR GENERAL PUBLICWAGE PUBLIC RELATIONS CAMPAIGN (e.g., Year of Science)?SPOKESPERSON---VISIBLE FACE FOR BIOLOGY?SCARE TACTICS, e.g., emerging diseases?
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
28/35
Waging a Public Relations Campaign
Instead of: teach the controversy or its not basedon sound science or give equal time for creationism
What message can we deliver to the general
public?Thats just another example of evolution in action!
How can we help faculty who teach biologybe more intentional?
Evolution: say it every day
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
29/35
Curricular Support Materials
For whom do we want materials?What materials do we want---what would they look like?Are there key concepts that everyone should teach?
e.g., misconceptions, artificial selection, emerging diseases,developmental biology, design mistakes in organisms, gee-
whiz organisms, key transitions in the history of life, biodiversity,
evolutionary medicine?
Who develops the materials, and how do we get biologiststo contribute?
Are the materials the same for everyone?
How do we inform people about the materials?How do we get people to use the materials?
textbook authors and publishers to reach two-year colleges?
How and when should instructors use the materials?
How do we know if the materials are working?
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
30/35
What do we need to do here?
1. Identify the full spectrum of issues relatedto Teaching Evolution Across theCurriculum.
2. Identify key change agents and targets ofour efforts (people and projects).3. Outline high-impact practices and
strategies to reach targets and supportefforts.
4. Assign/choose homeworkwhat caneach of us do?
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
31/35
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
32/35
Evidence
Mitochondria and Chloroplasts are similar in size andmorphology to bacterial cells
M & C divide into two just as bacteria do
M & C have double membranes---inner one resembles
bacterial membranesM & C have their own DNA (circular) and ribosomes
similar to bacteria
Antibiotics that inhibit bacteria, also inhibit M & C protein
synthesis (but not eukaryotes)
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
33/35
How did organelles evolve? Mergers and Acquisitions
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
34/35
Evidence (building a case):
1) In stromatolites (ancient fossils), we find
photosynthetic bacteria, including those similar tothe purple bacterium, Halobacterium halobium.
3) Bacteriorhodopsin is a purple, photosyntheticpigment in Halobacterium.
4) Bacteriorhodopsin absorbs broadly in themiddle of the visible spectrum (absorbs green
light). So, green light was not available tochlorophyllthere was competition for differentcolors of light.
8/3/2019 The Case for Thinking Evolutionarily: Presentation by Gordon Uno
35/35
Example
Topic: Photosynthesis
Fact: Plants are greenQuestion: If visible light is necessary for photosynthesis,
how do we explain that plants are not black?
Evolution: Ancestors of plants evolved at the same timeas the first photosynthetic organisms, which werephotosynthetic bacteria. Other early photosyntheticorganisms used green lightso green light was notavailable to the ancestors of plants. Chlorophyll, the
main photosynthetic pigment of plants, absorbs othercolors.