Upload
intellect-books
View
218
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 1/48
www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik Nutukb ?:>0
Kusa`, Kivags nbl thgIbfiabf _iknb`g Ogtwggb
Piubl nbl Uasaib
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 2/48
Zuocashgl ns n oa-kibthcy, EackAbtgrbntaibnc `ivgrs ncc nspg`ts ieeack `ucturg ab n vasunccy lybnka`
wny. \has bgw orggl ie eackknfnzabg orabfs tifgthgrgstnocashgl eack s`hicnrs wath
rgbiwbgl diurbncasts ti privalg nbabeirkgl nbl nbakntgl `ikkgbtnryib thg spg`tn`cg ie wircl `abgkn.
VVV.EACKAB\.BW
* * *
L AN CIF W G
N _I W B L
\H G KI U A BF
A KNF G
* * *
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 3/48
Nutukb ?:>0 0
@ I U G _ A K N F G \ H G E A C \ H
N B L \ H G E W _ Q ( ? : : : ) P G N _
@ H A B F E I _ P W F N _ K N B
( ? : > ? ) / L I B ' \ C I I M O N @ M ( > 1 5 6 )
\hg Oaf Za`turg APPB >671-:1?? © ?:>0 abtgccg`t Ctl. Zuocashgl oy Abtgccg`t Ctl. \hg Kacc, Znrbncc _inl. Orastic OP>5 0DF / www.abtgccg`toiims.`ik
Glatiranc iff`g \gc. :>>6 17811>: / G4 abeiJthgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik Zuocashgr Knsiul Qnzlnba @hage Glatir & Lgsafb Fnoragc Picikibs GlatirBgac Kat`hgcc
@ibtraoutirs Ba`icn Oncmabl, Lgnb Ornbluk, Bgac Eix, _io Ognkgs, Dgz @ibiccy, P`itt Dirlnb Hnrras, Ncgxnblrn Hgccgr-Ba`hicns, Bgac Kat`hgcc, @cgnvgr Znttgrsib, Fnoragc Picikibs
Zcgnsg sgbl ncc gknac gbquarags ti4 fnoragcJabtgccg`toiims.`ik / ww w.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik c \hg Oaf Za`turg knfnzabg as puocashgl eiur takgs n ygnr
abtgccg`t |Zuocashgl oy www.abtgccg`toiims.`ik
_gfucnrs
: < | _ggc Vircl
\hg Ocugs Orithgrs
? 8 | Eiur Ernkgs Zhnbtik ie thg Znrnlasg
0 < | Ib Ci`ntaibCavgrpiic, Gbfcnbl
0 8 | P`rggbfgk\hg Nkpcagr \hnt FigsWp ti >>
< ? | Znrtabf Phit Ncc \ifgthgr Biw
< < | @ikpgtataibZa`turg \has
< 5 | Castabfs\has assug's egnturgl cks
`ibtgbts Assug \wgbty Ibg. Nutukb ?:>0
Egnturgs
: 5 | PpitcafhtPwggt Kgcilags4
Kusa` nbl thg Kivags> < | Nrt & EackPafbnc Kgb4 \hg Ptrnbfg Vircl ie Zuoca`Pgrva`g Orinl`nstabf
> 8 | Kusa` KnttgrsOggthivgb's 'Fciraius Babth'ab N @ci`mwirm Irnbfg
? : | Enb Zhgbikgbn \hg Lnrm Nrts4P`itt Nccag, Pgbair Glatir
Lnrm Hirsg @ika`s
? < | Valgs`rggb_i`m Li`s4 \hg _i`mukgbtnry
0 : | >::: Virls_i`m & _ggc4\hg Farc @nb't Hgcp At
?<
'Q'ncc tnmg at gnsy biw.\has asb't Lnccns, at'sBnshvaccg! \hgy `nb'tli thas ti us hgrg abBnshvaccg! Cgt's shiwthgk whnt wg'rg knlg ie.@ikg ib gvgryoily, sabf!Pikgoily, sabf! 'Hnvgb Hnkactib ( Bnshvaccg)
:5
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 4/48
E A C K O G Q I B L \ H G O I _ L G _ P I E \ H G P @ _ G G B
_GGC VI_CL
Ncc aknfgs iurtgsy \hgntrg _iync Onth nbl \hg Ocugs Orithgrs Npprivgl ©?:>?/?:>0
< www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 5/48
fieurthgr Eir ncc thabfs Ocugs Orithgrs rgcntgl vasat thg iff`anc enb wgosatg ½ ocugsorithgrsiff`ancsatg.`ik
FGBG_NCCQ @IBPALG_GL ti ogthg frgntgst traoutg n`t ti thg ocn`m`cnl `huks ib thg rub, nbl thgibcy n`t ti hnvg npprivnc erik Lnb Nymriyl nbl Dulath Ogcusha, \hg
Ocugs Orithgrs ...Npprivgl as n rnu`iusstnfg nlnptntaib ie knby ie thg hatsibfs erik thg pnar's abatanc iutabfib Pnturlny Bafht Cavg ab thg cntg>16:s ns wgcc ns Dihb Cnblas' hat >18:kivag. Ptnyabf trug ti thg thgkgs ienb uborgnmnocg orithgrcy oibl nbl nbubshnmgnocg ogcage thnt thgy nrg liabf'Fil's Virm' whacg `ips, haccoaccy'snbl dnlgl gxgs ncc favg `hnsg - thgstnfg nlnptntntaib ncciws thg kusa`ti tnmg `gbtgr stnfg whacg thg lrnkn wgnvgs thriufh n vnragty n`t ie fugstnppgnrnb`gs nbl ikgly nsalgs.
\hg Ocugs Orithgrs phgbikgbib rst
`nkg ti puoca` nttgbtaib ib tgcgvasaibab >165 nbl >168 ib thg Nkgra`nb `uct vnragty shiw Pnturlny Bafht Cavg whgb`ikgly n`tirs Lnb Nymriyl nbl DihbOgcusha `rgntgl thg ricgs ie ‘Dicagt‑ DnmgG. Ocugs nbl Gcwiil D. Ocugs ab kusa`ncsmgt`hgs. Nb Nkgra`nb ocugs nbl siucrgvavncast onbl, \hg Ocugs Orithgrskgrfgl thg gcg`tra` @ha`nfi Ocugssiubl nbl thg Kgkphas Ptnx _g`irls_&O siubl abspargl oy kusa`anbs su`hns Itas _gllabf nbl Assn` Hnygs. \hgirafabnc Ocugs Orithgrs onbl egnturglrgspg`tgl ocugs nbl siuc kusa`anbsab`culabf Ptgvg @rippgr nbl Libncl‘Lu`m‑ Lubb (whi snlcy pnssgl nwny
gnrcagr thas ygnr). Netgr thgar tgcgvasaibnppgnrnb`gs, thg onbl ogfnb ti tnmgib n caeg ogyibl thg `ibbgs ie thgskncc s`rggb rgcgnsabf n hat sabfcgnbl n liuocg pcntabuk sgccabf ncouk
Orage`nsg Eucc ie Ocugs ab >168. \wi ygnrscntgr \hg Ocugs Orithgrs `gkgbtgl thgrgputntaibs ie oith thg onbl nblie Nymriyl nbl Ogcusha ns Dnmg nblGcwiil Ocugs.
\hg ck og`nkg n `uct hat nblthg Orithgrs, wath thgar knt`habfEOA-gsqug suats nbl subfcnssgs hnvgog`ikg pnrt ie pipucnr `ucturg,rgegrgb`gl bukgrius takgs ab ck,
kusa` nbl tgcgvasaib, nbl eurthgrgvalgb`g thnt bgnrcy <: ygnrs ib, thgnppgnc ie twi eiuc-kiuthgl, scivgbcydnacoarls rgknabs dust ns stribf ns gvgr.
Mggp ib ri`mab' oiys. ]top[
F N O _ A G C P I CI K I B P libs has shnlgs ti sgg dusthiw enr Dnmg nbl Gcwiil hnvg `ikg sab`g thgarrst ibs`rggb nppgnrnb`g bgnrcy <: ygnrs nfi.
Ocugs Orithgrs
IZZIPA\G O_I\HG_P AB N_KP NOIUG \HG OCWGP O_I\HG_P ...NZZ_IUGL
Nutukb ?:>0 7
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 6/48
@ A B G K N ' P \ H G K N \ A @ P \ _ N B L P
PZI\CAFH\
@IUG_EGN\W_GQ
5 www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 7/48
PwggtKgcilags
Aknfgs © >1?6 Vnrbgr Oris.
N CG X N B L _ N H G CCG _ - B A @ H I CN P nbl _ I O O G N K G P putthgar lnb`abf shigs ib nbl li thg twast wath sikgkivags whisg ei`us ib kusa` stru`m n `hirl wath
fgbgrntaibs ie kivag-figrs.
DN@M‑P P\_WFFCG\I EWPG HAP DGVAPHHG_A\NFG VA\H HAP
LGPA_G \I OG N DNTTPABFG_ AP _GBLG_GL
ZIVG_EWCCQ \H_IWFH
KWPA@.
IZZIPA\G NBL OGCIV NC DICPIB _NAPGP PIKG GQGO_IVP
_gbiwbgl ns thg rst rgnc‘tncmag‑ nbl knrmabf thg lgnthie thg sacgbt ck grn, \hg DnzzPabfgr ‘s hastira`nc safba`nb`gab thg lgvgcipkgbt ie `abgknhns oggb `hnccgbfgl ibcyoy n ei`us ib ats Dgwash stnr Nc Dicsib‑s usg ie ocn`men g.Larg`tir Ncnb @riscnbl hnl
gxpgrakgbtgl wath siubl eirVnrbgr Oris, out \hg Dnzz Pabfgr knrmgl thg rst usg ie spimgblancifug ab n egnturg ck, wath Dicsib‑s Dn`m _ioab‑s enkiuscabg, "Vnat n kabutg, yiu nab'thgnrl bithab' ygt". \hg DnzzPabfgr wns ncsi thg rst kusa`nc,nbl og`nusg ie thg tg`hba`nccakatntaibs ie siubl-vasaibsyb`habf tg`hbicifags, thgkivag `ibtnabs cattcg spgnmabf`ikpnrgl ti ats ei`us ib sibf. Dn`m‑s struffcg ti eusg has Dgwash hgratnfg wath has lgsarg
ti og n dnzz sabfgr as rgblgrglpiwgreuccy thriufh kusa`“ erik Arvabf Ogrcab‑s –Ocug Pmags‛ti thg trnlataibnc "Mic Balrg"“ privalabf thg siubltrn`m ti nkivag thnt ushgrgl ab oith nbgw fgbrg nbl n bgw grn.. NHB
\HG DNTT PABFG_ (>1?6)
Lar4 Ncnb @riscnbl
Nutukb ?:>0 6
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 8/48
@ A B G K N ' P \ H G K N \ A @ P \ _ N B L P
PZI\CAFH\
Aknfgs © >167 NO@ Gbtgrtnabkgbt, Znrnkiubt Za`turgs / >167 Fiiltakgs Gbtgrprasgs, Uasunc Zrifrnkkg Pystgks
8 www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 9/48
Nutukb ?:>0 1
PZI\CAFH\ PVGG\ KGCILAGP
N fiil `hubm ie Bnshvaccg'sbgnr thrgg-hiur rubbabftakg as favgb ivgr ti kusa`ncpgreirknb`gs, ns thg `taibnc`iubtry kusa`anbs whipipucntg _iogrt Nctknb's
gpa` gbsgkocg lrnkn pgreirksibfs ab thgar gbtargty - usunccyab cavgl-ab, nuthgbta` vgbugs.\has hns thg ubusunc gg`t ieknmabf at eggc camg n `ib`grtkivag, eir n shiw thnt bgvgrn`tunccy hnppgbgl - nbl wha`hncsi egnturgl n `nr `rnsh, nstraptgnsg, nbl nb nssnssabntaib. \hg kivag lggpcy gxpcirgsats `nst ie cnygrgl, euccy-lgvgcipgl `hnrn`tgrs erik thgBnshvaccg kusa` ablustry= erikpnrnsatgs camg Phgccgy Luvncc'slas`ibbg`tgl friupag nbl
Fgrnclabg @hnpcab's abtrusavgnbl sgce-nosirogl diurbncast,ti `yba`nc stnrs camg HgbryFaosib's Hnvgb Hnkactib. Qgt,camg Nctknb's cntgr N Zrnarag Hikg @ikpnbaib, Bnshvaccg asrgnccy noiut kusa` nbl thg ricgat pcnys ab pgipcg's cavgs. \hgablustry kafht og vnraiuscypirtrnygl ns twgg, onbmrupt,gxpciatntavg nbl phiby, out thgkusa` as ncwnys akougl wathkgnbabf nbl sggks ti favg rasgti fgbuabg hipg. _O
BNPHUACCG (>167)
Lar4 _iogrt Nctknb
Mgb _ussgcc wns bi strnbfgr tickabf `ikpisgr oaifrnphags. Nsalg erik Knhcgr (>16<),hg ncsi knlg tgcgvasaibli`ukgbtnrags ib `ikpisgrscamg Lgoussy, Ptrnuss nbl Lgcaus.
Out at wns ab Casztiknban thnt hgrnasgl thg oaipa` ti n cgvgc thntgvgb tilny `nb og `ibsalgrgliutrnfgius. Eicciwabf thgarsu``gsseuc iccnoirntaib ib\ikky (>167), _ussgcc `nst \hgVhi‑s _ifgr Lnctrgy ab thgcgnl ie thas ciisg oaifrnpha`ncrg-aknfababf ie Caszt‑s caeg,ab`culabf has riknb`gs nbl`ikpcgx rgcntaibshap wath_a`hnrl Vnfbgr. Onwly,diyeuc nbl ubnpicifgta`nccynkoiynbt, ats `rata`nc laskassncnt thg takg biw pncgs bgxtti Casztiknban‑s abgs`npnocg
abugb`g ib kivags camg \illHnybgs‑ Ugcvgt Ficlkabg (>118)._ussgcc‑s vasunc knstgry snvgsthg ck erik ogabf @nrry ibCaszt, out ats ivgrwhgckabfspg`tn`cg as ncwnys lgla`ntglti thg ck‑s rgnc stnr4 atssiubltrn`m. Vath gcg`triba`nlnptntaibs `rnetgl oy prif-ri`m a`ib _a`m Vnmggcl, thghgnrt ie Casztiknban cags ab atsubnonshgl pnssaib eir kusa`.
NHB
CAPT\IKNBAN (>167 )
Lar4 Mgb _ussgcc
CGE\OGLPALG CWCCNOQ
\IZ _AFH\PVABFABF \HG @CNPPA@P
➓
\HG ABLWP\_Q KAFH\ OGUN_AIWPCQ ZI_\_NQGL
NP \VGG, ONBM_WZ\,GXZCIA\N\AUG NBL ZHIBQ,
OW\ \HG KWPA@ AP NCVNQPAKOWGL VA\H KGNBABFNBL PGGKP \I FAUG _APG
\I FGBWABG HIZG. ➓
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 10/48
IZZIPA\GN ZNA_ IE @IIC @ N\P
N thraccabf hyoral ogtwggblrnkn nbl li`ukgbtnry,Onhknb Fhionla's Bi Ibg Mbiws Noiut Zgrsanb @nts `nstskusa`anbs Nshmnb Miishnbgdnlnbl Bgfnr Phnfhnfha ns`taibncasgl vgrsaibs iethgksgcvgs - lgnbtcy gbdiyabf
bib-rgcafaius, ablag kusa` abthgar bntavg Arnb. Eicciwabf thascamgnocg lui, thg larg`tir (whitilny, camg has twi cgnls, cavgs abCiblib-onsgl gxacg) favgs us nbnuthgbta` fcakpsg ie thg cattcg-mbiwb \ghrnb ublgrfriublkusa` s`gbg, shiwabf us - vansgfkgbts thnt pcny camg oulfgt vgrsaibs ie K\U kusa` valgis- rgnc-caeg Arnbanb onbls nblpgreirkgrs ie vnryabf stycgs.Ab Zgrsanb @nts, kusa` - ns neirk ie gxprgssaib nbl n vatnc`ikpibgbt ie yiuth `ucturg
- as sikgthabf wirth rasmabfakprasibkgbt, nbl pissaocygvgb lgnth, ti gxpgragb`g nblti `rgntg. \hgrg's nb abeg`taiusdiy ab thg ck's civg ie kusa`, wathiut thg lgtn`hkgbt nblariby nssi`antgl wath WM`iubtgr-`ucturg - knmabf thgArnbanb kusa` s`gbg nppgnrgx`atabf wathiut tryabf ti ogglfy. _O
BI IBG MBIVP NOIW\ZG_PANB @N\P (?::1)
Lar4 Onhknb Fhionla
N orutnc, si`anccy `ibs`aius Oratash
`uct `cnssa`, wha`h gxpcirgs rn`asknbl algbtaty ab Oraxtib nt thg stnrtie thg >18:s, Onoycib stnrs Nswnl'sOrabscgy Eirlg ns n kg`hnba` nblnsparabf kusa`anb whisg caeg asgvgbtunccy lgstriygl oy ibfiabfrn`ask nbl thg vaca`ntaib ie has`ikkubaty. Piib netgr cisabf hasdio, Eirlg's Lnval as suodg`tgl tirnblik - nbl rn`anccy kitavntgl -pica`g orutncaty ab thg strggt nblsciwcy has iwb rgcnxgl lgkgnbiur,rn`anc ticgrnb`g nbl pn`ask favg wny ti nbfgr nbl kutunccylgstru`tavg vaicgb`g. Bit ibcy asgvgry gkitaib nbl n`taib rgg`tglab thg ck's rgffng siubltrn`m,out gxtgblgl kusa`nc sgqugb`gs abthg ci`nc bafht`cuo - shiwb ns thgei`nc piabt ie thg ci`nc Dnkna`nb`ikkubaty, ns n sykoic ie `ucturncnbl, eir knby, rgcafaius algbtaty -prgsgbt kusa` ns n ubaeyabf eir`gnbl privalgr ie shgctgr erik (nbl,ab kist `nsgs, privalg `ikkgbtnryib) thg kyranl ie si`anc priocgksthnt nwnat ib thg strggts iutsalg.
_O
ONOQCIB (>18>)
Lar4 Ernb`i _issi
Aknfgs © >18> Ernb`i _issi / ?::1 Kad Eack @i., Katisck
GX\GBLGL KWPA@NCPG^WGB@GP AB \HG CI@NC
BAFH\@CWO - Z_GPGB\KWPA@ NP N WBAEQABF
EI_@G NBL Z_IUALG_ IE
PHGC\G_ E_IK \HG KQ_ANLIE PI@ANC Z_IOCGKP \HN\
NVNA\ IB \HG P\_G G\PIW\PALG.
➓
>: www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 11/48
@ A B G K N ' P \ H G K N \ A @ P \ _ N B L P
PZI\CAFH\
Nutukb ?:>0 >>
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 12/48
@ A B G K N ' P \ H G K N \ A @ P \ _ N B L P
PZI\CAFH\
FNABPOIW_F‑PABENKIWP
GXZG_AKGB\N\AIBPVA\H KWPA@NC
FGB_GP _WB ZN_NCCGC\I OAIF_NZHA@NC
PMG\@HGP➓
>? www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 13/48
Nutukb ?:>0 >0
\nmgb erik thg >16> knfbuk ipus –Hastiarglg Kgcily Bgcsib‛, Dinbb Penr‑s PgrfgFnabsoiurf oaipa` ipgbs wath thg gvi`ntavg–Uncsg lg Kgcily‛, gstnocashabf ats riknbta`
vasaib erik thg iutsgt. Onsgl ib has frnpha`bivgc, Penr‑s on`mfriubl ab `ika` oiimsas pncpnocg ab Fnabsoiurf4 N Hgria` Caeg‑ ssukptuius vasuncs, gkpciyabf nbakntaib, cavgn`taib nbl puppgtry ab ats stiry ie n strnbfgnbl `hnrkabf oiy whi og`nkg n bntaibnc a`ib.At's ns ku`h n kusa`nc ns oaifrnpha`nc diurbgy,
nbl Fnabsoiurf‑s abenkius gxpgrakgbtntaibs wath kusa`nc fgbrgs rub pnrnccgc ti oaifrnpha`ncsmgt`hgs, ab`culabf bukgrius walgcy-puoca`azgl riknbta` gb`iubtgrs. \hgsg ab`culghas rgcntaibshaps wath Dnbg Oarmab nbl OrafattgOnrlit, thg cnttgr sgt ti –Abatanc OO‛, n sibfFnabsoiurf writg lurabf has orage nnar waththg stnrcgt. Fnabsoiurf4 N Hgria` Caeg ligsbit usg kusa` ti accustrntg nby mabl ie truthnoiut Fnabsoiurf‑s rgknrmnocg nbl ietgb`ibtrivgrsanc caeg, out rnthgr ci`ntgs thg truth
ie has caeg ab thg kusa` atsgce. NHB
FNABPOIW_F4 N HG_IA@ CAEG (?:>:)
Lar4 Dinbb Penr
CGE\ FG\\ABF N CGF WZOGCIV ZCNQABF \I \HG @_IVL
ncsi sgg... @ibtric (Nbtib @iroadb, ?::6)
Aknfgs © ?:>: Ibg Vircl Eacks, Ptulai 06
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 15/48
Vath n kusa`nc stycg nbl vasunc-aty ubcamg nbythabf gcsg iut thgrg,nbl biw thriufh thgar `iccnoirn -taib wath thg OEA, Zuoca` Pgrva`gOrinl`nstabf nrg sprgnlabf thgarkgssnfg ie ablavaluncaty ti thgknssgs. Ppca`abf snkpcgs erik vabtnfg kivags nbl puoca` abeirkn -taib cks abti `ibtgkpirnry lnb`gkusa`, thg onbl nrg eirfabf thgar
iwb ubaqug `nrggr. Ns D. VaccfiisgGsq. (ibg hnce ie ZPO) gxpcnabgl whgb wg rg`gbtcy `nufht up wathhak lurabf thgar hg`ta` sukkgrtiur, thgsg fuys eicciw thgar iwbtubg. Zrgpnrg ti og gbcafhtgbgl.
Vhnt as yiur (D. Vaccfiisg Gsq.
nbl Vraffcgswirth) on`mfriubl
nbl trnababf ab kusa` nbl hiw lal
yiu `ikg up wath thg bnkg nbl
`ib`gpt eir yiur onbl9
Ky (D.V. Gsq) kusa`nc on`mfriublas ku`h kirg `cnssa`nc thnbVraffcgs= A `ikg erik thg wircl iecafht `ika` ipgrn, nbl A spg`ancasg
ab >7th gbtury nrans. A camg tithabm thnt‑s gspg`anccy gvalgbtab iur oaf hats camg ‘Ppatrg‑ nbl‘Lib Faivnbba @nb \nmg At‑.Vraffcgswirth hicls n ZhL abZrakatavg Qirmsharg Lrukkabf\g`hbaqugs, wha`h hns put hakab fiil stgnl eir has ricg ab thasonbl. Ns enr ns `ikabf up wath thgbnkg nbl `ib`gpt, wg lg`algl tiei`us ib whnt wns kist camgcy tiog ikkgr`anccy su``gsseuc. Netgrn egvgrgl etggb hiurs spgbt abthg puo wg lg`algl thnt snkpcabf
puoca` abeirkntaib cks nbl sgttabfthgk ti bgw kusa` wns oiubl tiog nb gbirkius hat, si thnt‑s whnt wg lal. Vg `nccgl at Zuoca` Pgrva`gOrinl`nstabf ti try ti thriw pgipcgi iur `yba`nccy knss-knrmgtnkoataibs.
Hiw wiucl yiu lgs`raog yiur
kusa`nc stycg, nbl whgrg li yiu
bl yiur absparntaib9
Wbnshnkgl. Zrakatavg.Zrgtgbtaius. Qgt… trutheuc. Ns eirthg irafab ie iur absparntaib - thnt‑squatg n cinlgl qugstaib. Qiu‑rgnssukabf wg hnvg absparntaib, absikg kgnsurg. A‑k bit surg wg li.Ae wg li ‐ wgcc, whi mbiws whgrgat `ikgs erik. At‑s lgbatgcy erikkg, bit Vraffcgswirth, thiufh. Hgdust hats thabfs.
Vhnt fnvg yiu thg algn ti kax icl
eiitnfg nbl `ibtgkpirnry kusa`9
At's n vgry `ibs`aius lg`asaib. Acivg gvgrythabf noiut thg '0:s
ir thg '<:s nbl '7:s, thg kivags,thg nrts, thg enshaib lgsafb, thgtypifrnphy, thg lgsafb, thg `nrs, thgnr`hatg`turg, thg kusa` ... Vhnt `nbA sny9 A'k icl enshaibgl nbl civabfat. \hnt's, eir ncc thgsg rgnsibs, whyA wacc ncwnys prgegr Ugrtafi, _gnrVabliw nbl _ipg ti \irb @urtnab,\ipnz ir Enkacy Zcit .
\hg ck eiitnfg yiu usg,
pnrta`ucnrcy ti `ikpcakgbt yiur
GZ \hg Vnr _iik, as vgry sakacnr
ti thg wirm ie thg li`ukgbtnry
knmgr Hukphrgy Dgbbabfs. Vha`h
E A C K A B N V A L G _ @ I B \ G X \
N_\&EACK
@CGNUG_ ZN\\G_PIB gbtgrs thgck-snkpcabf wircl ie Zuoca` Pgrva`gOrinl`nstabf, n Oratash onbl wath n vgrylastab`tavg siubl nbl iutciim.
IZZIPA\G \HABFP N_G CIIMABF WZ
NOIUG HNUG ONBDI VACC \_NUGC
PAFBNC
KGB
Nutukb ?:>0 >7
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 16/48
fieurthgr Irlgr ZOP's lgout ncouk Abeirk, Glu`ntg, Gbtgrtnab erik thgar wgosatg ½ puoca`sgrva`gorinl`nstabf.bgt/
ckknmgrs nbl kusa`anbs wiucl
yiu sny hnvg hnl thg frgntgst
abugb`g ib yiu9
Ugry sakacnr ablggl, pnrtcy og`nusgsikg ie at as has wirm ( Ciblib@nb \nmg At nbl Castgb \i Oratnab, wha`h wg usgl eir thg valgi eir
Vnctz Eir Fgirfg )! Ns pnrt ie thgli`ukgbtnry ck kivgkgbt, has wirm as prgtty ku`h ubgquncgl,si wg‑l lgbatgcy favg hak nrgspg`teuc bil. Ithgrwasg A‑vgncwnys nlkargl thg purpisg nbl`cnraty ie Muora`m‑s cks (npnrterik Gygs Valg Phut , wha`h wnsociily nweuc). A ncsi nlkarg hasrnkpnbt `ibtric-ergnmgry. Vgcclibg, Ptnbcgy.
Hiw lal yiur abvicvgkgbt wath
thg OEA `ikg noiut9
A phibgl thgk up nbl `ibeusglthg cavabf lnycafhts iut ie thgk,
abatanccy, thgb `ibtabugl pgstgrabf van gknac. Netgr n shirt pgrail iebib-`ikkuba`ntaib thgy fit on`mab tiu`h nbl snal A `iucl usg sikgie thgar stu ae A rgnccy wnbtgl ti,out rst A hnl ti tnmg n ociil inthnbl swgnr nccgfanb`g ti thg OEA`nusg. At ncc fit n oat Lnb Oriwb, tiog hibgst, out at wns wirth liabf,ns thgar nr`havgs nrg frgnt.
\hg Vnr _iik GZ as `cgnrcy onsgl
nriubl eiitnfg ie VV AA. Hiw
ku`h sny lal yiu hnvg ab thg
`hia`g ie ck nbl hiw ku`h
ergglik lal thg OEA favg yiu9
\hgy wgrg frgnt ‐ nckist `nrtgocnb`hg wns frnbtgl, nbl thgy hnlenath ab whnt wg wgrg liabf, wha`h wns ba`g. Vg `iucl onsa`nccy li whnt wg wnbtgl wath nby ie thgkntgranc thnt thgy hgcl thg rafhtsti, nbl wg `iuclb‑t hnvg libg at wathiut thgk ogabf su`h ncc-riubl fiil gffs. \hnbms fuys!
@cgnrcy yiu hnvg n nffbaty nbl
civg eir `abgkn nbl ck, ns wgcc
ns kusa`. Hiw li yiu eggc thg twi
pcny i / `ikpcakgbt gn`h ithgr9
N fiil siubltrn`m `nb knmg
ir orgnm n ck. At‑s ibg ie thgqua`mgst thabfs ti lntg icl cks ‐thg kusa` as sggkabfcy `ibstnbtcylrnknta`, gvgb whgb at ligsb‑tbggl ti og. Kusa` bggls ti og
sykpnthgta` ti, ygt nll ti, thgsiur`g kntgranc. Vhgb at ligsb‑t(sgg iur valgi eir Ciblib @nb \nmg At ), thgrg dust asb‑t ku`h piabt abthg twi `i-gxastabf. \hg `hnccgbfgas ti bl thg rafht oncnb`g.
Hiw rgstra`tavg, ae nt ncc, li yiu
eggc at as ti nssi`antg yiur kusa`
nbl aknfg gt`. wath vabtnfg
pripnfnbln cks9
Bit ncc ie iur kusa` as nssi`antgl wath vabtnfg pripnfnbln cks, outgvgb ae at wgrg, A lib‑t thabm thnt‑s
bg`gssnracy rgstra`tavg. A thabm at‑sncc noiut hiw yiu usg thgk tiabeirk thg kusa` thnt yiu knmg,nbl hiw yiu mggp lgvgcipabf thgkusa` ab lagrgbt wnys ti mggpthabfs ergsh nbl stip thgk erik fgttabf rgpgtatavg nbl lucc.
Vhnt as yiur bgxt pridg`t9
Nh. Biw thnt, sar, wiucl og tgccabf!
N_\&EACK ZWOCA@ O_INL@NP\ CAKA\GL
@CI@MVAPG E_IK \IZ
ZG_EI_KABF CAUG / K_. D. VACFIIPG GP^.
>5 www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 17/48
Kusa` bggls ti ogsykpnthgta` ti, ygt nllti, thg siur`g kntgranc.Vhgb at ligsb‑t, thgrg
dust asb‑t ku`h piabtab thg twi `i-gxastabf.\hg `hnccgbfg as ti blthg rafht oncnb`g.
Nutukb ?:>0 >6
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 18/48
\ H G H N _ K I B A I W P K G G \ A B F I E K W P A @ N B L E A C K
KWPA@ KN\\G_P
Abfciraius Onstnrl BGA C KA \@ H GC C `iblu`ts nbabvgstafntaib abti thg usg ieOggthivgb's Fciraius Babth abN @ci`mwirm Irnbfg .
>8 www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 19/48
\ H G P Q K O A I \ A @ _ GC N\ A I B P H A Z ogtwggb thg kivabf aknfgnbl kusa` ‐ gathgr irafabnc`ikpisataibs ir gxastabf pag`gs ‐ hns rnrgcy oggb si `ikpcgxcyutacasgl ns at wns oy PtnbcgyMuora`m ab has >16> nlnptntaib ie Nbthiby Ourfgss' N @ci`mwirmIrnbfg. Muora`m trnbs`gblglnby `ibvgbtaibnc usg ie kusa`ti `rgntg tgbsaib, ublgrs`irggkitaib ir `ibvgy n sgbsg ietakg nbl pcn`g. Oy nppriprantabfCulvaf Unb Oggthivgb's'Fciraius Babth' sykphiby ‐ wha`h ab`culgs n `hirus sabfabfP`haccgr's Ilg ti Diy - Muomra`mnllrgssgl assugs ie piwgr,sgx, lgnth, vaicgb`g, rgcafaib
nbl kirncaty= ablavalunc nbl`iccg`tavg, ibs`rggb nbl i.
Earst pgreirkgl ab >8?<,nbl walgcy `ibsalgrgl ti ogthg ynrlsta`m oy wha`h ithgrsykphibags nrg kgnsurgl, \hgFciraius Babth ‐ n kusa`ncdiurbgy erik lnrmbgss ti cafhtnbl erik `hnis ti irlgr ‐ as`iberibtntaibnccy lgpciygl nsthg siubltrn`m ti hgnl Lriif,nbl Oggthivgb enbnta`, Ncgx's(Knc`ick K`Liwgcc) kas-nlvgbturgs. Vhgb iupcgl tithg gbthusansta` egrviur wath wha`h thg Lriif's gkonrmupib n va`aius fnbf fht, Ncgx'sg`stnta`, lgprnvgl knsturontiryenbtnsags nbl, suosgqugbtcy, hashirragl rgn`taib ti hgnrabfthg Babth lurabf irrg`taibnctrgntkgbt, Oggthivgb's`riwbabf fciry as suovgrtgl. \hg`ibbg`taib ogtwggb kusa` nblgkitaib as stacc thgrg, out thgnssi`antaibs nrg twastgl= bitaibsie civg, iptakask nbl huknbatynrg rgpcn`gl oy vasaibs ie rnpg,
bahacask nbl uctrn-vaicgb`g.Egkncg lgfrnlntaib, fgbgrntaibncnbxagtags nbl `irrisavgncagbntaib nrg n``ikpnbagloy sg`taibs ie Oggthivgb'snctgrbntgcy sparatunccy upcaetabf,rgg`tavg nbl stralgbt`ikpisataib.
At as lurabf Ncgx's`irrg`taibnc trgntkgbt, whgb
thg Fivgrbkgbt cgts atspriegssaibncs ciisg ib Ncgx'ssa`mcy siuc, thnt Muora`m kullagsthg kusa`nc wntgrs eurthgr. \hgLriif's vaicgbt pgrsibnc diurbgykny tnmg hak ncibf thg snkgpnth trnvgrsgl ab thg Babth, outat as n enr kirg ibtrivgrsancibg, ns \hg Culiva`i \g`hbaqugas atsgce, stntg snb`taibgl, vaicgb`g pgrpgtrntgl nfnabst thgablavalunc. Puosgqugbtcy rgturbglti has irafabnc psy`hicifa`ncstntg, Ncgx as cnst sggb cist abnb irfansta`, rnpturius rgvgrag
oriufht ib oy thg hgnly caknxie thg Babth. Hg kny hnvg oggb`urgl ncrafht, out nt whnt `ist tihaksgce, thg piwgrs thnt og nblsi`agty nt cnrfg9
\hriufh hirgifrnphgl fhtsgqugb`gs, Pivagt-Kibtnfg stycgenbtnsy s`gbgs nbl ipprgssavgshits ie kgbtnc tirturg, Muora`m`ibeiublgl gxpg`tntaibs ie hiw\hg Fciraius Babth iucl ogpgr`gavgl, egct nbl gbvasaibgl. Abliabf si, thg larg`tir ‐ thriufhhas knrranfg ie thg 'hafh' nrt
ie `cnssa`nc kusa` ti thg 'ciw'ie sgxunccy gxpca`at, frnpha`nccy vaicgbt aknfgry ‐ oiclcyqugstaibgl iur iwb bitaibsie n``gptnocg gbtgrtnabkgbt, viygurask nbl gkitaibnc frnta`ntaib. ]top[
_gnl nb ab lgpth nbncysas ie \hg Fciraius Babth ab 'N @ci`mwirm Irnbfg' hgrg ½ http4//oat.cy/>?\5uLcfieurthgr
\ip, oittik nbl ippisatg
N @ci`mwirm Irnbfg
© >16> Vnrbgr Oris., Hnwm Eacks
\hg ibbg`taib ogtwggbkusa` nbl gkitaib as staccthgrg, out thg nssi`antaibsnrg twastgl= bitaibs ie civg,iptakask nbl huknbaty nrgrgpcn`gl oy vasaibs ie rnpg,bahacask nbl uctrn-vaicgb`g.
Nutukb ?:>0 >1
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 20/48
?: www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
ENB ZHGBIKGBN
ZGNM
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 21/48
‘..N pcn`g i nckist ubaknfabnocgpiwgr...n piwgr si vnst thnt atsognrgr kafht rgirlgr thg Gnrth atsgcti has camabf...\as pcn`g A spgnm ias mbiwb ns thg Ocn`m Cilfg ‐ nbl Aabtgbl ti bl at.‑ - Vablik Gnrcg
Ipgbgl ab ?::: oy Zgnms nbs OrynbHifug nbl Kntthgw Knrtab, Ocn`mCilfg Ualgi as n Kgkphas fgk. \grgbtnc stirg‑s ib-strggt s afb shiwsNfgbt @iipgr pggmabf thriufh rgl`urtnabs, nbl ats shgcvgs gnturg n sg-
cg`taib i thiusnbls i ios`urg nbl`cnssa` kivags ab ncc irknts, ab`cul-abf knby UHP. \g cks nrg irfnb-azgl oy larg`tirs, `iubtrags, thgkgsnbl fgbrgs, nbl thgrg‑s n pgrknbgbtspn`g ir Lnval Cyb`h‑s wirm.
Hiw lal yiur rst Zgnmsgxpgragb`g neeg`t yiu9Orynb4 Ky rst gxpisurg ti atwns strnbfg. A `nufht ibg gpasilgkalwny thriufh sgnsib twi ‐ thgibg whgrg thg hirsg nppgnrgl abthg cavabf riik. At knlg bi sgbsg.Vhgb thg whicg sgrags wns rgcgnsgl,A wnt`hgl at ncc ab ibg rub. Eir thntlny nbl n hnc, A gxastgl ab wabZgnms. At wns n hgnvy, ib`gbtrntglgxpgragb`g. \g gblabf as si `rush-abf nbl `iic nbl hgnrtorgnmabf.Erik thgrg, A og`nkg prgtty iosgssglwath at. Kntt, ky ousabgss pnrtbgr,wns abti at tii, wha`h wns ibg i thgthabfs wg `ibbg`tgl ib.
Hiw lal thas ens`abntaib wathZgnms trnbscntg abti bnkabfthg stirg Ocn`m Cilfg Ualgi9 Kntt nbl A `iccg`tgl UHP nbl hnlouact up n hgncthy `iccg`taib. Vhgb
wg lg`algl ti ipgb n stirg, wg mbgwthg bnkg hnl ti og sikgthabf thntkgnbt n cit ti us. Vg wgrg Zgnmsrgnms ir ygnrs nbl wnbtgl ti favg
at prips.
\hg Cilfg as ib @iipgrPtrggt. @iab`algb`g9Negr wg `hisg thg ci`ntaib, n wggmpnssgl ogirg A thiufht, ‘80> Piuth@iipgr…Ocn`m Cilfg Ualgi...hicyshat!‑ At‑s nt @iipgr nbl Gvgcyb.Gvgcyb wns thg wiknb Dnkgs Hurcgy
vasatgl. Ncsi, thg pcn`g n`riss thgstrggt, thnt‑s Znckgr _gnc Gstntg.Vg‑vg fit ncc mabls i cattcg wabZgnms bils nriubl us, out at wns`ikpcgtg iab`algb`g.‘Egccns, iab`algb`g nbl entg furgcnrfgcy ab iur cavgs.‑ - Nfgbt @iipgr
Vhi as yiur enviratg \wabZgnms `hnrn`tgr nbl why9 \g iovaius nbswgr wiucl og@iipgr. Out Kndir Oraffs, oraccanbtcypcnygl oy thg cntg Lib Lnvas, as su`hn `ikpcgx nbl wnrk `hnrn`tgr thntyiu `nb‑t hgcp out civg gvgry sg`iblhg‑s ib s`rggb. Hg wns n ubaqug paccnri `iblgb`g nbl strgbfth, out thgbthgrg nrg takgs whgrg has lgnlpnb,abtrivgrtgl pgrsibn as turbgl absalgiut oy kikgbts i tgblgrbgss. Vhiligsb‑t civg thg s`gbg ab thg labgr
(IZZIPA\G) \HG A@IBA@ AKNFG IE CNW_N ZNCKG_ E_IK \HG ZACI\ GZAPILG
© >11:->11> CQB@H/E_IP\ Z_ILW@\AIBP, Z_IZNFNBLN EACKP, PZGCCABF GB\G_\NABKGB\
Nutukb ?:>0 ?>
N Ocn`m Cilfg hns oggb eiubl abKgkphas, gbbgssgg. \iufh LgputyHnwm wnrbgl thisg pnssabf thriufh
thg Cilfg ti li si wath pgreg`t `iurnfgcgst thgar siucs og nbbahacntgl, pgipcghnvg pnssgl thriufh thas Cilfg eir ivgrn lg`nlg, siucs stacc abtn`t. Abtgrvagwoy P H N_ N CI _ G N @ CN_ M, ibtraoutir tiEnb Zhgbikgbn4 wab Zgnms
NOIIL G @ I L A B F A @ I B P I E Z I Z W C N _ @ W C \ W _ G
ENB ZHGBIKGBN
➓
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 22/48
ENB ZHGBIKGBN \VAB ZGNMP
whgrg hg tgccs has sib, Oiooy, noiutthg lrgnk hg hnl noiut thgk9 akgstips ir kg gvgry takg A sgg at. Irgvgb Oraffs‑ truth sgruk rgspibsgti Vablik Gnrcg‑s qugstaib4 –Vhntli yiu gnr kist ab thg wircl9‛Oraffs4 –\g pissaoacaty thnt civg asbit gbiufh.‛ \nt‑s ibg i thg kistognutauc nbl bnavg bitaibs A‑vg gvgrhgnrl= n phacisiphy gw wiuclb‑t og`rushgl oy thg wgafht i. A ncwnysgct thnt Oraffs‑ lgpth nbl spar-atunc s`ipg prionocy surpnssgl gvgb@iips.
Vhnt nrg yiur eggcabfs noiutthg sgrags vgrsus thg kivag9A mbiw at‑s fiabf ti siubl ocnsphg-kius, out A thabm thg kivag gblgl
up ogabf n wnstgl ippirtubaty irgathgr `cisurg ti iur stirycabg ir ntcgnst tnmabf at n gw stgps urthgrthnb thg gbl i thg sgrags. A bgvgrthiufht thg kivag nllgl nbythabfbgw ti thg ivgrncc stiry. Ab thg sgrags,wg fit pcgbty i abirkntaib noiutCnurn, hgr liuocg cag, nbl triuocgsns thg kystgry ubiclgl. Lal wgrgnccy bggl n whicg kivag lgvitglti sggabf at9 A‑vg wnt`hgl at sgvgrnctakgs, nbl at ligs hnvg ats fiilkikgbts. At dust ncwnys knmgs kgwash ir whnt `iucl hnvg oggb. \grghnvg oggb rukirs noiut thg knssavgnkiubt thnt wns `ut rik Earg VncmVath Kg. Knyog ibg lny Erist nblCyb`h wacc og nocg ti nbl wnbt tirgstirg at ti whnt thgy irafabnccygbvasaibgl.
Vhy li yiu thabm thg sgrags/ ck hns wgnthgrgl thg tgstie takg9A fugss at stnbls ns n tgstnkgbt ti bitncwnys trgntabf yiur nulagb`g camgalaits nbl fiabf ir whnt ggcs rafht=bi knttgr hiw nfnabst thg frnab atkafht og. A camg ti ogcagvg Cyb`h‑sabugb`g as ns ku`h ti thnbm ir thntns nbythabf gcsg. A thabm thg kystgry
i Cnurn‑s kurlgr as whnt abtgrgstglkist nt rst. \gb ib`g yiu lgcvgabti ncc i thg ithgr `hnrn`tgrs abthg tiwb nbl thg kg`hnba`s i thgar
Ib`g ats lnrm tibg stnrts ti
shiw, gathgr at turbgl yiuiee ir knlg yiu `rnvg kirg.Nbl knby ie us `rnvgl kirg.At‑s dust nb nknzabfcy wgcc`ibstru`tgl kable**m, nblky wircl as ra`hgr eir hnvabfoggb gxpisgl ti at.
_gnl kirg ie thas abtgrvagw ab Enb Zhgbikgbn4 \wab Zgnms Nvnacnocg biwfieurthgr
@CI@MVAPG E_IK \IZ
ZW\\ABF WP AB \HG E_NKG
NFGB\ @IIZG_ NBL LNGKIB OIO
@I-IVBG_ KN\\HGV KN_\AB VA\H F_N@G TNO_APMAG (PN_NH ZNCKG_)
cavgs, thnt‑s whgb yiu rgncazg hiwlgbsgcy cnygrgl thgar wircl as. Ib`gats lnrm tibg stnrts ti shiw, gathgr
at turbgl yiu i ir knlg yiu `rnvgkirg. Nbl knby i us `rnvgl kirg.At‑s dust nb nknzabfcy wgcc `ibstru`t-gl kabl**m, nbl ky wircl as ra`hgrir hnvabf oggb gxpisgl ti at.
Hiw wiucl yiu lgs`raogZgnms‑ abugb`g ib pip`ucturg/tgcgvasaib9Zgnms ipgbgl up n `grgornc salgab U, `hnccgbfabf vagwgrs ti ciimogbgnth thg surn`g i ats whilubatbnrrntavg nbl ti pri`gss thg lggpgr`hgkastry i ats `hnrn`tgrs nbl thgarwircl. At gxpisgl cnygrs i sg`rgts,
cags, gnrs, lgsargs, sparatuncaty nbl ab-gvatnocg liik. Zgnms shiwgl us thntfiil ligs bit ncwnys `ibqugr gvac,nbl thnt gvgb thg stribf nbl purgnrg vucbgrnocg. \g fanbt ab Zgnmssnal thnt –n pnth as irkgl oy cnyabfibg stibg nt n takg.‛ wab Zgnms, Aogcagvg, as thnt rst stibg ib thg pnthti sknrtgr tgcgvasaib. At lal whntgw shiws lal ogirg at ir sab`g ‐ atturbgl tgcgvasaib abti nrt. ]top[
?? www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 23/48
Enb ZhgbikgbnPtnr VnrsGlatgl oy Kamn Gcivnnrn
APOB4 168->-680?:-:??->
£><.17 / $?:
Enb Zhgbikgbn \wab ZgnmsGlatgl oy Knrasn @. Hnygs
nbl Ernb`m Oiucgfug
APOB4 168->-680?:-:?<-7
£><.17 / $?:
Enb ZhgbikgbnOuy thg Unkparg PcnygrGlatgl oy Dgbbaegr M. Ptuccgr
APOB4 168->-680?:-:>1->
£><.17 / $?:
Enb ZhgbikgbnPtnr \rgmGlatgl oy Oru`g Lrushgc
APOB4 168->-680?:-:?0-8
£><.17 / $?:
Enb ZhgbikgbnLi`tir VhiGlatgl oy Znuc Oiith
APOB4 168->-680?:-:?:-6
£><.17 / $?:
Enb ZhgbikgbnOntknbGlatgl oy Cank Ourmg
APOB4 168->-680?:-:>6-6
£><.17 / $?:
Eir eurthgr abeirkntaib noiut thg sgrags nbl bgws ie eirth`ikabf tatcgs vasat www.abtgccg`toiims.`ik
Eicciw prifrgss ie ncc tatcgs oy camabf thg Enb Zhgbikgbn Oiim Pgrags pnfg ib En`goiim
ENBZHGBIKGBN
N BGV OIIM PG_AGP \HN\ ‘LG@ILGP‑ A@IBP IE ZIZWCN_ @WC\W_G
V_A\\GB OQ NBL EI_ \HIPG IE N ZNPPAIBN\G LAPZIPA\AIB
☇
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 24/48
B G A C E I X tubgs has rnlai erik `taib ti en`tnbl stgps abti thg wircl ie thg _i`mukgbtnry,whgrg nrtasta` rgntavaty, ucturnc hastiry nbl
ernfacg gfis hnvg `ikg tifgthgr nbl knlgsikg ubeirfgttnocg kusa`.
_I@M
?< www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 25/48
Nutukb ?:>0 ?7
E A C K A B N V A L G _ @ I B \ G X \
VALGP@_GGB
HN CE VNQ \H_IWFHKa`hngc_nppnpirt's Ognts, _hykgs & Caeg (?:>>)
thg larg`tir nsms kgkogrs ie Lg CnPiuc ae thg shiw thgy nrg ncc nt wacc ogthg cnst shiw oy N \raog @nccgl ^ugst,thg suodg`t ie thg ck. \hg rgpcy as 'Ahipg si'. At‑s n kikgbt thnt accustrntgsakpirtnbt en`tirs ab ri`m li`ukgbtnry
- hibgsty, npturabf thg kikgbt nblthg quncaty ie thg pnrta`apnbts.
Pab`g LN Zgbbgonmgr `npturgl n yiubf Oio Lycnb ib thg rinl ab Lib't Ciim On`m (>156) thg 'ri`mukgbtnry'hns surfgl ti og`ikg n pipucnr stnpcgie thg walgr li`ukgbtnry fgbrg.
Zgbbgonmgr‑s ck nbl thg ibvgbtaibsat spnwbgl hnvg og`ikg pnrt ieknabstrgnk `abgknta` `ibs`aiusbgss, wath \ill Hnybgs' Lycnb kythicify A'k Bit \hgrg (?::6) oirriwabf hgnvacyerik ats ngsthgta`s eir mgy sgqugb`gs. Ncsi, cks su`h ns _io _gabgr'sogcivgl \has As Ppabnc \np (>18<) `npturgnb nuthgbta` oghabl thg s`gbgs eggc ab n wirm thnt spiies oith thg hgnvy kgtncnbl ri`m kusa` fgbrgs ab nllataib tithg ri`mukgbtnry atsgce.
\hg ri`mukgbtnry as fgbgrnccy nrgg`tavg li`ukgbt ciimabf on`mnt mgy kikgbts surriublabf ats
suodg`t, erik n lastnb`g thnt ncciwseir thnt rgg`taib oy thisg abvicvglnbl ng`tgl. \has as eublnkgbtnccylagrgbt ti thg ib`grt ck, wha`h,lug ti thg tgkpirnc bnturg ie thgsuodg`t, `npturgs n spg`a` kikgbtab takg. Ibg ie thg frgntgst gxnkpcgsie n ck thnt strnllcgs oith as \hgKnyscgs Orithgrs nbl @hnrcittgTwgrab's Fakkg Phgctgr (>16:). Vhntkust hnvg stnrtgl caeg ns n strnafhtli`ukgbt ie \hg _iccabf Ptibgs‑ >151 Nctnkibt shiw og`nkg sikgthabfgcsg gbtargcy eicciwabf thg trnfa`,
ubeirgsggb gvgbts thnt trnbspargl. \hg larg`tirs pgreg`tcy `npturg oiththg prair gfi nbl suosgqugbt tgrrirnbl rgncaty `hg`m ie las`ibbg`tglri`m riyncty ns wgcc ns `rgntabf n vasunctgstnkgbt ti n wntgrshgl `ucturncgvgbt. \hgar smacc ns li`ukgbtnryckknmgrs gcgvntgs n sakpcg ib`grtck abti n vncunocg hastira`nc nrtgen`t.\hg ck og`ikgs n wny ie vagwabfhastiry ab n walgr `ibtgxt. At's pistsukkgr ie civg, thg gbl ie thg saxtagsnbl pnargl wath Dgnb Cu` Filnrl'sPykpnthy eir thg Lgvac (>158) pcn`gs nri`m nbl ricc friup nt thg hgnrt ie n
kndir `ucturnc shaet. Filnrl's ck as n`ikpca`ntgl nbl nstutg ri`mukgbtnry,pnabstnmabfcy `npturabf thg nttrataib-camg `ibstru`taib ie ibg ie ri`m nblricc's kist enkius rg`irlabfs at as ncsin pnabeuccy viygurasta` absafht abti nonbl nt orgnmabf piabt. Pakacnrcy tiFakkg Phgctgr, at knbnfgs ti `ibvgy nlnrmbgss gkgrfabf ivgr thg hirazib iethg hipg eugcgl '5:s, shit ns at wns abthg netgrknth ie thg Kny >158 Znrasraits nbl abeusgl wath `cnssa` Filnrlsykoicask nbl `ibtrnsts.
Ab`rgnsabfcy _i`mukgbtnragshnvg og`ikg n wny ie rglrgssabf
hastiry nbl kikgbts ab takg nckistnr`hngicifa`nccy, favabf us bgw wnysie sggabf enkius hastira`nc kikgbtsab kusa` hastiry nbl ncsi privalabfnb absafht abti nrtasts thnt privalglmgy abugbtanc, out ublgr npprg`antgl,abput abti thg kusa`nc cnbls`npg.Ptnblabf Ab \hg Phnliws Ie Kitiwb (Znuc Dustknb, ?::?) as n traoutgti thg Eubm Orithgrs - thg sgssaibkusa`anbs rgspibsaocg eir sikg iethg kist kgkirnocg kusa` ie thgtwgbtagth `gbtury - thnt ncsi gxpisgsnbl li`ukgbts assugs ie abdusta`g nbl
LI @ PIZZIPA\G FAKKG PHGC\G_NOIUG P\NBLABF AB \HG PHNLIV IE KI\IVB
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 26/48
VALGP@_GGB _I@M LI@P
thg nulagb`g watbgssgs bit ibcythg ernufht `rgntaib ie n cnblknrmrg`irl ‐ Vac`i‑s sgkabnc Qnbmgg Hitgc
Eixtrit - oirb iut ie thg nshgs ie thggry nrtasta` kgclabf ie Dg \wgglynbl Dak I'_iurmg nbl rg`irl cnogcablagrgb`g out ncsi \wggly's lgs`gbtabti pnabmaccgr nlla`taib. @npturglhibgstcy ab stnrm ocn`m nbl whatg at'sibg ie thg bgst li`ukgbtnrags ib thg`rgntavg pri`gssgs nbl thg struffcg tirgncasg nrtasta` nkoataib.
Zubm hns spnwbgl n bukogr ie frgntcks, thnbms ab pnrt ti thg vasaib ieckknmgrs su`h ns Ducagb \gkpcg nblLib Cgtts euraiuscy `npturabf gvgrykikgbt thgy watbgssgl lurabf thntsgkabnc pgrail ie `ucturnc `hnbfg.\has ippirtubask nbl pist-rgg`taibhns cgl ti cks su`h ns Cgtts' Vgstwny \i \hg Vircl (?:::) nbl \gkpcg's
Dig Ptrukkgr4 \hg Euturg as Wbwrattgb (?::6) nbl \hg Eacth nbl thg Eury
(?:::). \gkpcg, n prica` nbl rgvgrglkusa` li`ukgbtnranb ncsi `rgntglthg abenkius, nwgl ri`mukgbtnry\hg Frgnt _i`m nbl _icc Pwablcg (>18:)(n ck thnt wns rgcgnsgl ns pubm wns akpcilabf), ns wgcc ns cks ibFcnstiboury egstavnc ( Fcnstiboury,?::5) nbl Lr. Eggcfiil ( Iac @aty@ibelgbtanc , ?::1).
Biwnlnys nrtasts nrg ab`rgnsabfcyshagclgl erik thg mabl ie gxpisurgib laspcny ab thg `cnssa` ri`mli`ukgbtnrags ie thg >15:s nbl >16:s. \has hns rgsuctgl ab nb ab`rgnsglhikifgbasntaib nbl `ibtric ie thg
pgr`gptaib ie nrtasts oy thisg nriublthgk. \has kny og pnrtcy rgspibsaocgeir thg suodg`ts ie thg fgbrg ogabfab`rgnsabfcy siufht erik thg knrfabs.Eacks su`h ns Nbvac4 \hg Ptiry Ie Nbvac (Pn`hn Fgrvnsa, ?::8) nbl Pgnr`habf EirPufnr Knb (Kncam Ogbldgcciuc, ?:>?)hnvg gkgrfgl ti pisatavg thgntra`ncrgspibsg out ncthiufh ng`taibntgcy`rgntgl oith cks enac ti orabf bgwgbgrfy ti thg fgbrg. \hgy nrg riitgl abenkacanr, ubbg`gssnry bnrrntavg lgva`gsthnt li thgar suodg`ts n lassgrva`gnbl lib't knmg thg kist ie thg
pitgbtanc ippirtubatags nirlgl oy
thg ri`mukgbtnry, ti gxpnbl upib nbgblcgsscy ens`abntabf suodg`t - thg cavgsie nrtasts - ti thg puoca` `ibs`aiusbgss._i`mukgbtnrags nll `ibtgxt, lgpth,pgrspg`tavg nbl nb nctgrbntavg vagw iehastiry thnt as n``gssaocg nbl ns thgynrg riitgl ab thg piwgr ie kusa`,hnvg thg pitgbtanc ti kivg nbl, ibi``nsaib, og trnbs`gblgbt `abgknta`diurbgys. ]top[
thg thgb ourfgibabf @avac _afhtskivgkgbt. Kgnbwhacg \hg Lgvac Nbl
Lnbagc Dihbstib (Dg Egugrzgaf, ?::7) asn vatnc ck noiut kgbtnc accbgss, nrtasta`abtgfraty nbl hgnrtorgnm, wha`h ei`usgsib n kusa`anb whi hns hnl hufgakpn`t ib thg `nrggrs ie nrtasts rnbfabferik Murt @ionab ti \U Ib \hg_nlai. \hgrg's n viygurasta` gcgkgbtti ri`mukgbtnrags, wath nulagb`gsens`abntgl oy wnt`habf tncgbtgl outgfi-rallgb nrtasts orgnmliwb aberibt ie iur gygs. Ie thgsg, thgrg nrgegw kirg knfbgta`, gbafknta` nblabeurantabf thnb Nbtib Bgw`ikog, whi ocnzgs n trnac ie stuooirbbgss,nbfgr nbl `iska` nkoataib nt thg hgnrt
ie Ibla \akibgr's uct Laf! (?::<). \hg eirk hns `ikg n cibf wny erik`ib`grt cks wath on`mstnfg eiitnfgnbl qunsa-bnrrntavg pgreirknb`g vgha`cgs `rgntgl ti prikitg thg camgsie \hg Ogntcgs nbl \hg Kibmggs,cks thnt privgl thgrg as nb nulagb`g waccabf ti pny ti sgg oghabl thg vgacnbl iosgrvg onbls nbl nrtasts ogabfthgksgcvgs ir vnranbts thgrgie. \hgsgiosgrvntaibs hnvg gvicvgl erik thgkublnbg - prgss `ibegrgb`gs, hnbfabfriubl ab narpirts nbl lrgssabf riikonbtgr - abti abvgstafntaibs abti thg`rgntavg pri`gss thnt hnvg og`ikg mgy
ti thg fgbrg. Kgtncca`n4 Pikg Mabl Ie Kibstgr (Dig Ogrcabfgr, Oru`g Pabiemsy,?::<) as n ens`abntabf absafht abtithg trnukns thnt `nb pcnfug gvgb thgra`hgst, kist su``gsseuc kusa`anbs. \hgnurnc ibscnufht ie Kgtncca`n's hgnvykgtnc as piafbnbtcy `ibtrnstgl nfnabstthg onbl kgkogrs' ernfacg pgrsibnclgkibs, abtgr-onbl rgcntaibshapsnbl thgrnpy sgssaibs. Ab Pnk Dibgs' A
Nk \ryabf \i Orgnm Qiur Hgnrt (?::?)
Vnt`h Fakkg Phgctgr hgrg ½ http4//oat.cy/^T@>Tfieurthgr
_i`mukgbtnrags nll`ibtgxt, lgpth, pgrspg`tavgnbl nb nctgrbntavg vagw iehastiry thnt nrg n``gssaocgnbl ns thgy nrg riitgl ab thgpiwgr ie kusa`, hnvg thgpitgbtanc ti kivg nbl, ib
i``nsaib, og trnbs`gblgbt`abgknta` diurbgys.
\IZ PGN_@HABF EI_ PWFN_ KNBNOIUG IAC @A\Q @IBEALGB\ANC
?5 www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 27/48
Nutukb ?:>0 ?6
ZNWC \HIKNP NBLG_PIB hns oggbibg ie thg kist `ibsastgbtcy gx`atabf wratgr-larg`tirs ti hnvg gkgrfgllurabf thg >11:s‑ ablagwiil oiik,ab pnrt sakpcy og`nusg ie has sggkabfubprgla`tnoacaty. Wbcamg has bnkgsnmgVgs, eir abstnb`g, gn`h bgw ck hns`ibstatutgl n safba`nbt lgpnrturg
erik has cnst, wath thg kist rg`gbt,\hgrg Vacc Og Ociil (?::8), `ikabfns pgrhnps thg oaffgst surprasg. Qgtthas orinl rnbfg kafht atsgce ogsikgthabf ie nb nuthiranc safbnturg,oith eir has iguvrg nbl wathabablavalunc cks. _iogrt Nctknb nblKnrtab P`irsgsg tgbl ti og `atgl nshas kist iovaius prglg`gssirs, ygt Nblgrsib hns ietgb bnkgl DibnthnbLgkkg ns has vgry enviuratg ck-knmgr, ib`g prnasabf thas larg`tir‑s
s`rgwoncc-`ikgly-`uk-stncmgr-thraccgr Pikgthabf Vacl (>185) abpnrta`ucnr eir ogabf whnt hg `nccgln ‘fgnrshaet kivag‑.> \has sggks nusgeuc `ib`gpt eir ublgrstnblabf Nblgrsib‑s iwb wirm, sab`g atspgnms ti has civg ie mggpabf useirgvgr ubsurg noiut whnt mabl ie n
ck wg nrg wnt`habf. ]top[
_gnl thg rgst ie thas nrta`cg ncibf wathithgr larg`tir priecgs nbl 'gssgbtanc Nkgra`nb eck rgvagws ab Larg`tiryie Vircl @abgkn4 Nkgra`nbAblgpgblgbt ? glatgl oy Dihb Ogrrn. Nvnacnocg biw erik www.abtgccg`toiims.`ik
KNFA@ KNMG_PZ _ I E A C G P I E \ H G V I _ C L ' P F _ G N \ L A _ G @ \ I _ P
ZNWCHIKNP
NBLG_PIB
WBA\GL P\N\GP
Ab nb gxtrn`t erik Larg`tiry ie Vircl@abgkn4 Nkgra`nb Ablgpgblgbt,
D N K G P K N @ L I V G CC ciims nt ibg iethg kist ubaqug nbl gx`atabf via`gs
ab Nkgra`nb @abgkn.
_ A F H \ L N B A G C L N Q
C G V A P N B L Z N W C \ H I K N P N B L G _ P I B I B \ H G P G \ I E \ H G _ G V A C C O G O C I I L ( ? : : 8 )
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 28/48
\ H G N _ \ I E N O O _ G U A N \ G L P \ I _ Q \ G C C A B F
EIW_ E_NKGP
ZHNBIK IE HG ZN_NLAPGLar. Oranb Lg Znckn, >16<
Aknfgs © >16< Hnroir Zrilu`taibs
?8 www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 29/48
Nutukb ?:>0 ?1
O _ A N B L G Z N C K N ' P Zhnbtik ie thg Znrnlasg (>16<)gb`npsucntgs thg sntara`nc bnturg ie kusa`nc cks abn wny rnrgcy sggb ogeirg ir sab`g. Znrnlasg as n ciisgnlnptntaib ie n bukogr ie `cnssa` tgxts, erik thg
iovaius - \hg Zhnbtik ie thg Ipgrn nbl Enust - ti thgkirg iocaqugcy `rglatgl Zsy`hi (>15:) nbl \hg @noabgtie Lr. @ncafnra (>1?:). Pwnb (Znuc Vaccanks) vartunccyprgla`ts thg bnturnc hirrir-bnrrntavg prifrgssaib iePakib @iwgcc ab thg eirk ie nb gcusavg, sntnba` rg`irlprilu`gr. Hnvabf nshgl ab ib bivgcty onbl \hg Dua`y Eruats (hnrmgbabf eirwnrl ti Disag nbl thg Zussy`nts'oiy-onbl Lu Diur), Pwnb gbsbnrgs n `ikpisgr bnkglVabsciw (Vaccank Eabcgy) whisg cntgst wirm, Enust ‐ n`cnssa` siubl ti iubtgrn`t thg Dua`y Eruats‑ nbly-`intgl bistncfan ‐ as thg ntncyst eir thg gbsuabf absnbaty.
Nttgkptabf ti rgn`h Pwnb ti `ibsuct upib has kusa`, wha`h Pwnb hns gvalgbtcy sticgb, Vabsciw as gdg`tglerik thg knbsaib nbl ernkgl wath pissgssaib iebnr`ita`s. Zcn`gl ab n 'vicubtggr' `irrg`taibnc abstatutaibluoaiuscy eublgl oy thg cnogc, Vabsciw hgnrs has Enusthns oggb `rglatgl ti Pwnb. Hg gs`npgs ab n rnfg, knmabfnb gxpcisavg gxat nkalst thg lrnknta` strnabs ie haskusa`nc ipus. Vabsciw knmgs larg`tcy eir thg hikg iethg rg`irl cnogc, sknshabf has wny thriufh thg ouaclabfnbl orgnmabf larg`tcy abti thg rg`irl prabtabf riikti lasnocg thg rg`irl prgss. @cisg ti iut-sknrtabf hasgbgky, n pica`gknb `nccs hak nwny erik thg rg`irlprgss= out Vabsciw's sbnffgl oy n ciisg shart-scggvg nblhas vgry en`g as prgssgl wath thg abm, hgnt, nbl ablgbtsie has bgkgsgs. \habfs turb lnrmgr ns Lgnth _g`irls
cavgs up ti ats bnkg. @cut`habf has ruabgl en`g, Vabsciw whabgs nbl stukocgs camg n lif, thg kabir panbi bitgskabfcg wath pnssabf sargbs, lgs`gblabf wath has encc abtithg ravgr. N `ut, nbl ncc as wgcc nfnab. Divanc hips ie thg vaicab oiw orabf ab thg spabbabf Unragty hgnlcabg ie\hg Dua`y Eruats' su``gss, ns 'Knl \ubgskath Oatgs Ouccgt'. Vabsciw as nfnab eiacgl oy thg ablustry thnt hg ib`gsiufht ti ibtnab. Nbithgr fgbaus thwnrtgl.
F I E W _ \ H G _
Uasat \hg Pwnb Nr`havgs nbl abvgstafntg \hg Zhnbtik ie thg Znrnlasg www.swnbnr`havgs.irf/
B A @ I CN O N CM A B L stncms thg `irralirsie Lgnth _g`irls nbl ub`ivgrssntarg nbl `ut-thrint ogtrnync abOranb Lg Znckn's fnuly hirrir-kusa`nc Zhnbtik ie thg Znrnlasg.
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 30/48
_I@M&_GGC
L G N B O _ N B L W K scaps ib has lnb`abf
shigs nbl fgts rgnly ti ri`m'b'riccwath n kivag thnt abspargl ck-knmgrs nbl kusa`anbs ncamg.
>::: VI_LPK I K G B \ P \ H N \ @ H N B F G L @ A B G K N E I _ G U G _
0: www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 31/48
'Ab etggb ygnrs takg pgipcg waccrgncazg thnt \hg Farc @nb‑t Hgcp At sgrvgl thgb ‐ thnt as, tilny ‐ ns neiubtnab ie yiuth erik wha`h thg`abgkn biw ‐ thnt as, ab thg euturg‐ hns lrnwb ergsh absparntaib'- Dgnb Cu` Filnrl
IZZIPA\GDNQBG KNBPEAGCL
_AFH\GLLAG @I@H_NB
OGCIV _AFH\CA\\CG _A@HN_L NBL ONBL
A\ AP LAE E A@ WC\ ti `ib`gavg ieknby cks `iucl hnvg oriufht`ibsgbsus ogtwggb thg Ergb`h`rata`-`uk-larg`tir nbl thg fuatnr fil ie \hg Qnrloarls, ygt Ernbm \nshcab‑s >175 sntargie thg pipucnr kusa` ousabgssknbnfgl dust thnt. Ncthiufhthgsg twi bitnocg enbs pissaocy`ibsalgr thg ck erik lagrabfpgrspg`tavgs, thgy `ibvgrfg nt
thg diy eiubl ab \hg Farc @nb‑t Hgcp At whgb `gccucial nbl ri`m‘b‑ ricc bnccy `ibsukkntgl thgarprgvaiuscy ubgnsy rgcntaibshap.
\hg stiry as n sakpcg ibg ‐ n wnshgl up kusa` prikitgr(\ik Gwgcc) nfrggs ti wirmeir n oiastgrius fnbfstgr(Glkibl I‑Oragb) turbabfhas fcnkirius out rgcu`tnbt farceragbl (Dnybg Knbsgcl) abtin stnr. Unraius pcit `ibtravnb`gsi``ur, abtgrspgrsgl wath ietgbgcg`traeyabf pgreirknb`gs erikthg camgs ie Ents Likabi, Fgbg
Uab`gbt, Glag @i`hrnb, DunbatnKiirg nbl \hg Zcnttgrs. Zgrhnpsogst rgkgkogrgl ns n `uct atgknkibf n`aibnlis ie ncc thabfsri`m nbl ricc nbl ncc thabfs DnybgKnbsgcl, \hg Farc @nb‑t Hgcp At wns kirg pipucnr ab Oratnab thnbab Birth Nkgra`n ib ats abatancrgcgnsg nbl og`nkg n `ucturnctiu`hstibg eir knby kgkogrsie thg ‘Oratash Abvnsaib‑ iekusa`nc n`ts whi likabntglabtgrbntaibnc `hnrts ab thg >15:s.
Ab >158 \hg Ogntcgs wgrg lggpab thgar rg`irlabf ie whnt wiuclog`ikg mbiwb ns \hg Vhatg
Ncouk. Kusa`nccy lasgb`hnbtglnetgr thgar Ablanb sidiurb nblgxpgrakgbtntaibs wath g`cg`ta`abstrukgbtntaib, thg friupegct n bggl ti og rgabvafirntgl wath n rgturb ti thgar kusa`ncriits. Ibg gvgbabf thgy tiimn orgnm erik thg stulai nbl wgbt ti K`@nrtbgy‑s hiusg
ti wnt`h \hg Farc @nb‑t Hgcp At ib tgcgvasaib. Gbgrfasgl, thgyrgturbgl ti rg`irlabf nbl siibthg oiastgrius Oarthlny wnsab thg `nb, thg sibf n lastab`tthriwon`m ti nb gnrcagr grn. OithK`@nrtbgy nbl Cgbbib spimgnoiut thg gg`t thg ck hnlupib thgk ns akprgssaibnocgtggbnfgrs nt thgar Cavgrpiic`abgkn ab >176. \has wns n takg whgb Oratnab wns wnmgbabferik thg kncnasg ie pistwnrrgouacl wath n fgbgrntaibog`ikabf tggbnfgrs ns n pgrail
ie `ibsukgrast nugb`g nrravgl`iupcgl wath thg iil iegx`atabf bgw kusa` erik n`rissthg Ntcnbta`. Cntgr, camg knby iethgar ikpntraits \hg Ogntcgs wiucl prgsgbt ti Nkgra`n thgar vnrantaib ib thnt kusa`, ku`h ie wha`h thgy hnl rst gxpgragb`glab \hg Farc @nb‑t Hgcp At .
\hg Farc @nb‑t Hgcp At wnsbit thg rst ‘ri`m ‘b‑ ricc‑kivag. Ab >177 \hg Ocn`moinrl Dubfcg (_a`hnrl Oriims)
Aknfgs © >175 \wgbtagth @gbtury Eix Eack @irpirntaib
Nutukb ?:>0 0>
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 32/48
fieurthgr @hg`m iut _iccabf Ptibg's 0: Frgntgst _i`m'b'_icc Kivag Kikgbts ½ http4//ric.st/UyLrmy
ab`culgl Oacc Hncgy nbl \hg@ikgts‑ _i`m Nriubl thg @ci`m ib thg siubltrn`m nbl thgpipucnraty ie thg ck nkibfthg yiutheuc nulagb`g wnssu`h thnt prilu`grs qugugl ti`npatncasg ib thas bgw kusa`ncphgbikgbib wath hnstacy`ib`gavgl cks thnt shiw`nsglthg pipucnr pgreirkgrs ie thgtakg, wath _i`m, _i`m, _i`m! (VaccZra`g), _i`m Nriubl thg @ci`m nbl Lib‑t Mbi`m thg _i`m (oith ErglE. Pgnrs) ncc nppgnrabf ab >175.
Wbeirtubntgcy thgsg wgrg ciw-oulfgt, ocn`m nbl whatg nnars wath lucc, aksy abtgrculgsogtwggb thg n`ts lgspgrntgcyhiclabf tifgthgr n sgkocnb`g ien bnrrntavg.
Vhgb \hg Farc @nb‑t Hgcp At prgkagrgl ab Lg`gkogr ie thnt ygnr nb ncrgnly dnlgl nulagb`g`iucl hnvg gxpg`tgl kirg iethg snkg nbl su`h kasfavabfs wiucl hnvg `ibtabugl ib`g thgck ogfnb. \hg nppgnrnb`gie thg ?:th @gbtury Eix cifiab N`nlgky rntai nbl frakkibi`hrikg wiucl hnvgsggkgl si ygstgrlny gvgb ab>175. Nbl thg gbtrnb`g ie \ik Gwgcc ib n siublstnfgsurriublgl oy kusa`nc pripsti abtrilu`g thg ck wns abmggpabf wath thg `yba`nc prn`ta`gie Hiccywiil prilu`grs ubnocgti `ibstru`t n bnrrntavg thntncciwgl ri`m nbl ricc‑s kusa`,stycg nbl phacisiphy ti gxast wathiut n pntribazabf, pntgrbncgxpcnbntaib. Out abstgnl, Gwgccpgreirks thg sirt ie eiurth wncclgkicataib thnt stacc cgnvgs thg vagwgr fnspabf tilny4 Hg mbi`ms
thg ernkgs ie thg s`rggb iutti @abgkns`ipg lakgbsaibsnbl lgknbls thnt thg ck ogab `iciur, n wash frnbtgl. Piib,thg `nkgrn pnbs ti n fcgnkabfdumgoix nbl Gwgcc‑s wnabf aslriwbgl iut oy Cattcg _a`hnrl‑srgblataib ie thg tatcg sibf (ibgthnt _il Ptgwnrt wiucl cntgrbnkg ns has ncc-takg enviuratg).
Erik hgrg thg bnrrntavg`ikkgb`gs out at sgrvgs ibcyti cabm n sgrags ie suocakgkusa`nc pgreirknb`gs nbl thgnstibashabf furg ie Knbsgclhgrsgce, whi rgsgkocgsbithabf shirt ie n `nrtiibociblg oikoshgcc. Ablggl
>::: VI_LP _I@M&_GGC
\ik Gwgcc pgreirks thg sirtie eiurth wncc lgkicataib thntstacc cgnvgs thg vagwgr fnspabftilny4 Hg mbi`ms thg ernkgs ie
thg s`rggb iut ti @abgkns`ipglakgbsaibs nbl lgknbls thntthg ck og ab `iciur.
\IZ GCUAP Z_GPCGQ AB 'DNACHIWPG _I@M'NOIUG O_GNMABF \HG EIW_\H VNCC
0? www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 33/48
ibg nckist gxpg`ts thg gygsie thg abentuntgl fnbfstgr
(I‑Oragb hattabf thg rafht bitgie wicsh hnk) ti pip iut ibstncms nbl eir hak ti hiwc ablgcafht whgbgvgr shg nppgnrsab hgr furg-huffabf iutts.Pu`h n `ika` sgbsaoacaty as tiog gxpg`tgl erik \nshcab whiogfnb has `nrggr ns nb abvgbtavgnbakntir nbl oriufht ivgr knbyie thnt las`apcabg‑s ngsthgta`nbl tibnc quncatags ti cavg-n`taib ckknmabf. Ncthiufhknabstrgnk `rata`s gxpgblglcattcg gbgrfy ib thg ck, kirglas`grbabf kabls `hnkpaibglats quncatags, wath Filnrlogcagvabf thg larg`tir‑s nrtastry wiucl og npprg`antgl ab thg ygnrs ti `ikg. Qgt at wns bit tiog. \nshcab gbdiygl nssi`antaibs wath Dgrry Cgwas nbl Liras Lnythriufhiut thg >15:s out oy thggbl ie thg lg`nlg hg wns swgptiut ie enviur oy thg gkgrfabfBgw Hiccywiil, \nshcab laglab >16? nbl Filnrl‑s prgla`taibrgknabs kistcy ubeiublgl. Ncthiufh hg lagl yiubf, hg hnlsnlcy ncrgnly iutcavgl sgvgrncie \hg Farc @nb‑t Hgcp At ‑s stnrsab`culabf Fgbg Uab`gbt, Gllag
@i`hrnb nbl Knbsgcl hgrsgce.
Bgvgr hns gnrcy ri`m nbl ricckusa` oggb prgsgbtgl ib ck
wath su`h vasunc nar nbl gbgrfynbl rnrgcy wgrg Knbsgcl‑s`ibsalgrnocg `ika` tncgbts gvgrogttgr ib laspcny. At's akkglantgabugb`g wns egct n cattcg ivgrn ygnr cntgr ab Dnachiusg _i`m (_a`hnrl \hirpg, >176) nbl \nshcab's iwb Vacc Pu``gss Ppiac _i`m Hubtgr9 (>176). At's sparat hnssuosgqugbtcy oggb gvimgl knbytakgs ab kusa` thgkgl kivags. N LUL thnt ogcibfs ab gvgry`abgcg‑s iccg`taib, ns Mgath_a`hnrls ib`g rgknrmgl whgbnsmgl ae hg wns enkacanr wath \hg
Farc @nb't Hgcp at , –Mbiw at9 A
iwb at. Nbl bit dust eir DnybgKnbsgcl!‛ ]top[
Fgttabf abvicvgl wath...
thgoafpa`turgwiucl yiu camg ti `ibtraoutg
ti \hg Oaf Za`turg knfnzabg9
Vg‑rg ncwnys ib thg ciimiut eir
gbthusansta` ck-civgrs wath n
pnssaib nbl nar eir thg wrattgb
wirl. Pi, ae thas siubls camg
yiu, thgb sakpcy sgbl us n egwgxnkpcgs ie yiur wratabf ncibf
wath n shirt pgrsibnc oai ti4
Bgac KAt`hgcc, Glatir
bgac.kat`h>16?Jfiifcgknac.`ik
FG\ ABUICUGL
DIAB\HG OAFZA@\W_G
ENKACQ
OGCIV \HG OGN\CGP AB 'N HN_L LNQ'P BAFH\'© >15< Z_IP@GBAWK EACKP, VNC\G_ PHGBPIB EACKP, KNCDN@M Z_ILW@\AIBP
\_AUAN Zrilu`grs wnbtgl Gcvas Zrgscgy ti pgreirkab thg kivag, out \ik Znrmgr lgknblgltii ku`h kibgy eir Gcvas ti sabf ibg sibf.
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 34/48
\ H G Z C N @ G P \ H N \ K N M G \ H G K I U A G P
IB CI@N\AIB
CAUG_ZIIC
Aknfgs © >15< Zris`gbauk Eacks, Vnctgr Phgbsib Eacks, Kncdn`m Zrilu`t
0< www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 35/48
IZZIPA\GIB \HG _WB
NOIUGAB LAPFWAPG
DGT @IBICCQ , `i-glatir ie Vircl EackCi`ntaibs4 Cavgrpiic , tnmgs us ib nkusa`nc tiur ie thg `aty thnt fnvg oarthti thg siubls nbl sparat ie Kgrsgyognt.
Vg lib‑t sgg Cavgrpiic ab N Hnrl Lny‑s Bafht , wg eggc at. Nblrgw Pnrraslgs`raogl at sikgwhnt ivgr-gcnoirntgcyab thg Uaccnfg Uia`g ns ‘thg @atazgbMnbg ie dumgoix kusa`ncs, n oraccanbt`rystnccazntaib ie su`h lavgrsg `ucturncpnrta`cgs ns thg pip kivag, ri`m ‘b‑ ricc,`abákn váratá, thg biuvgccg vnfug, ergg`abgkn, thg ng`tglcy hnbl-hgcl `nkgrn,ergbzagl `uttabf, thg `uct ie thg sgxcgsssuo-nlicgs`gbt, thg sgka-li`ukgbtnrynbl stulagl spibtnbgaty‑. At as n vagwabfgxpgragb`g ivgrwhgckabfcy ie Cavgrpiic, ygt bibg ie thg ck wns n`tunc cy shit abCavgrpiic. Vhnt as su``gsseuccy `npturglhiwgvgr as thg sgbsg thnt whgrgvgr \hgOgntcgs nrg as Cavgrpiic, ns thiufh thgygxast wathab n ouoocg ie P`iusg-knlgixyfgb thnt sustnabs thgk. Ab trnvgccabfsiuth ti Ciblib ti pgreirk ogeirgthg tgcgvasaib `nkgrns thgy nrg cnyabf npapgcabg eir thg rnrggl nbl abeg`taiusKgrsgy nar ti iw thriufh nbl orabf`iciur ti thg `hggms ie thg `npatnc‑spipucntaib.
N HN_L LNQ'P BAFH\ (>15<)
Lar. _a`hnrl CgstgrWM, 86 kabutgsPtnrrabf4 Dihb Cgbbib, Znuc K`@nrtbgy,Fgirfg Hnrrasib, _abfi Ptnrr
Nutukb ?:>0 07
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 36/48
\ H G Z C N @ G P \ H N \ K N M G \ H G K I U A G P
IB CI@N\AIB
EG__Q @_IPP\HG KG_PGQ (>157)
Lar. Dgrgky PukkgrsWM, 88 kabutgsPtnrrabf4 Fgrry Knrslgb,Ergllag Knrslgb,Cgscag Knfuarg
CAUG_ZIIC
Phit wath ub`ikkib hnstg ti `nsh ab ib thgKgrsgyognt phgbikgbib, nbl lgs`raogl ntthg takg oy Mgbbgth \ybnb ab \hg Iosgrvgrns ‘n cattcg fcakpsg abti Hgcc‑, thas vgry riufhnbl rgnly tiur ie Cavgrpiic‑s kal-saxtags safhtsnbl siubls as ourlgbgl oy sikg rgfrgttnocgstnos nt hukiur nbl pncgs ab `ikpnrasib ti N Hnrl Lny‑s Bafht , wha`h at lgspgrntgcy trags nbl
suostnbtanccy enacs ti knt`h. At ligs hiwgvgrshiw cits ie thg Cavgrpiic erik whgb`g thgsybibykius siubl sprnbf, ab`culabf sikg orageout `ikpgccabfcy rnw abtrilu`tiry eiitnfg iethg `aty‑s on`m-strggts, nbl rabfs wath babg bgwFgrry nbl thg Zn`gknmgrs sibfs wrattgb eir thgck nbl pgreirkgl nt vnraius bitnocg ci`ntaibs.Knby wacc hnvg sggb thg wgcc mbiwb tatcg sibfstrukkgl iut ib thg lg`m ie thg gpibykius vgssgc, out ncsi egnturgl as n pgreirknb`g nt thg@nvgrb nbl n onttcg ie thg onbls `ibtgst nt thgCi`nrbi Onccriik.
05 www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 37/48
Pikgthabf thnt On`mognt shnrgs wath \hgOgntcgs‑ iwb eirnys abti ck as thnt, lgspatgnppgnrnb`gs, prn`ta`nccy bibg ie at wns shitab Cavgrpiic. Ab nb g`hi ie thisg s`gbgs ie Dihb, Znuc, Fgirfg nbl _abfi rubbabf ti`nt`h n trnab nt Cakg Ptrggt stntaib nt thgogfabbabf ie N Hnrl Lny‑s Bafht - n`tunccyshit nt Ciblib Knrycgoibg - Pietcgy‑stgccabf ie ‘eth Ogntcg‑ Ptunrt Put`cag‑sstiry, camg knby ithgr Eno Eiur oaipa`s,lgpisats ats `hnrn`tgrs ab `ibstru`tgl vgrsaibs ie thg Cavgrpiic (nbl ab thas `nsgHnkourf) ie Ogntcgs cirg. Eir gxnkpcg, thg
eribt ie Hgssy‑s Kusa` @gbtrg, eirkgrcyib Ptnbcgy Ptrggt, whgrg wg sgg Put`cag(Ptgphgb Lir) nbl Dihb Cgbbib (AnbHnrt) pa`mabf n fuatnr, as n siubl stnfg sgtthnt iwgs kirg ti kyth thnb rgncaty. Nbgnrcy pnb n`riss thg Cavgrpiic smycabg nblncibf thg Kgrsgy as hiwgvgr ubkastnmnocythg rgnc thabf nbl su``ab`tcy sgts up thgtwi eragbls‑ piabt ie lgpnrturg.
\grgb`g Lnvags wns ib thg vgrfg ielrippabf has abvicvgkgbt ab thg pridg`tthnt wiucl fi ib ti og has ku`h-nlkarglli`ukgbtnry civg cgttgr ti thg `aty ie hasoarth, out wns abspargl ti pgrsast whgb hg`nkg ti `ibsalgr hiw ogst ti `ibvgy thg`ibtrnst ogtwggb thg `cgnrgl Cavgrpiicscuks nbl thg pist-wnr hiusabf gstntgs nbltiwgr-oci`ms thnt tiim thgar pcn`g. Nkibfthg knby pag`gs ie kusa` thnt eirk thgck‑s ra`h nbl vnragl siubltrn`m, thgZgffy Cgg vgrsaib ie ‘\hg Eicms whi Cavgib thg Hacc‑ spnrmgl has `rgntavg abstab`tnbl cgbt thg pridg`t shnpg nbl purpisg.Lib‑t gxpg`t thg larg`tir‑s `hia`g iekusa` nbl lgpth ie ng`taib ti gb`ikpnss \hg Ogntcgs= has kibitibg ‘ygnh ygnh ygnh ygnh‑ npabf ie thg onbl‑s vi`nc stycgnbl has hgnrtegct knrmabf ie thg pnssabfie sglntg Oratash pip ‘s`rgnkgl nwny ibn talg ie Kgrsgyognt‑ put thnt pnrta`ucnrrg`irl strnafht.
ON@MOGN\ (>11<)
Lar. Anab PietcgyWP, >:: kabutgsPtnrrabf4 Ptgphgb Lir,Phgryc Cgg, Anb Hnrt
IE \AKG NBL \HG @A\Q (?::8)
Lar. \grgb`g Lnvags
WM, 6< kabutgsPtnrrabf4 \grgb`g Lnvags
Ouy Vircl Eack Ci`ntaibs4 Cavgrpiic erik Nknzib nbl www.abtgccg`toiims.`ikfieurthgr
Ippisatg © >157 Puoncks\ip © >11< @hnbbgc Eiur Eacks, ZicyFrnk Eackgl GbtgrtnabkgbtNoivg © ?::8 \grgb`g Lnvags
Nutukb ?:>0 06
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 38/48
fieurthgr Pnkpcg `ibtgbt erik thg bgw oiim www.risgoulscglsbnblhirsgshgnls.`ik
www.risgoulscglsnblhirsgshgnls.`ik
L A K - V A \ \ G L _ I @ M P \ N _ Bafgc\uebgc (@hrastiphgr Fugst) as shiwabfhas `iccg`taib ie gcg`tra` fuatnrs tili`ukgbtnry-knmgr Knrty LaOgrfa(_io _gabgr). \hgrg‑s thg `cnssa` >171kilgc enkius eir ats noacaty ti sustnabibg bitg. \hgrg‑s thg wargcgss kilgc wath n rnlai ubat thnt ncciws \uebgcti ‘rub ncc ivgr thg stnfg‑ out thnt, wgcntgr cgnrb, pa`ms up pica`g rnlai safbncs whacg hg ligs si. Nbl thgrg‑s thg fuatnrsi pgreg`t \uebgc absasts at `nb bgvgr ogpcnygl ‐ ir gvgb ciimgl nt.
Eabnccy, \uebgc cgnls LaOgrfa tisikgthabf gcsg. Pikgthabf spg`anc.Pikgthabf ogttabf n friup thnt hns‘gnrbgl n lastabfuashgl pcn`g ab hastiryns ibg ie Gbfcnbl‑s ciulgst ri`m onbls‑.At as bit nbithgr gcg`tra` fuatnr outabstgnl nb nkpcagr. Nt rst at sggksubrgknrmnocg out thgb \uebgc shiws usats `ibtric pnbgc. _nthgr thnb rnbfabferik ibg ti tgb, ns wg kafht gxpg`t,gn`h lanc figs up ti gcgvgb. \uebgcgxpg`ts us ti og nwgl. ‘At‑s ibg ciulgr,‑hg snys wath ub-supprgssaocg pralg.
LaOgrfa nsms n sgbsaocg qugstaib. ‘Vhylib‑t yiu dust knmg tgb ciulgr, nbl knmg
tgb og thg tip bukogr, nbl knmg thnt ncattcg ciulgr9‑ \has `ibeusgs \uebgc, whipnusgs camg n `ikputgr ivgrcinlgl oy nrgqugst at `nbbit pri`gss.
‘\hgsg fi up ti gcgvgb,‑ hg snys.
Egw ck iodg`ts hnvg rgsibntgl abpipucnr `ucturg ns ciulcy ns thg nkpthnt figs up ti gcgvgb. Nt n takg ogeirgki`m-li`ukgbtnrags `nkg ti og`ikkibpcn`g ab Nkgra`nb `ikgly, thas`gcgorntgl s`gbg lgkibstrntgl ogyiblqugstaib thg fgbrg‑s pitgbtanc eir oafcnufhs nbl sknrt sntarg. \hg nkpcagrrgprgsgbts thg bgglcgss gx`gssgs iehgnvy kgtnc kusa` out, ogyibl thnt, atrgprgsgbts thg shncciwbgss nbl stupalatyie `gcgoraty `ucturg. Ns `gcgoraty `ucturghns og`ikg ab`rgnsabfcy prikabgbt abthg lg`nlgs sab`g thg rgcgnsg ie Ppabnc\np, si thg ck hns og`ikg ab`rgnsabfcyrgcgvnbt nbl thg nkpcagr ab`rgnsabfcyenkius. N`riss thg Gbfcash-spgnmabf wircl, thg phrnsg ‘fiabf up ti gcgvgb‑biw rgegrs ti nbythabf thnt as ogabfeir`gl ti ats nosicutg knxakuk. \hgabugb`g ie thg nkpcagr ab \has as Ppabnc\np, camg thg abugb`g ie thg kivagatsgce, rgnccy ligs fi up ti gcgvgb. ]top[
P @ I \ \ D I _ L N B H N _ _ A P absgrts has gnrpcufs tinssgss n enb enviuratg thnt as 'ibg ciulgr' thnb ncc
ravnc gvi`ntavg ck iodg`ts.
HG NKZCAEAG_
HN FIGPWZ I >>\as as Ppabnc np ( _io _gabgr, >18< )
08 www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 39/48
G U I @ N \ A U G I O D G @ \ P I B P @ _ G G B
P@_GGBFGK
Nutukb ?:>0 01
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 40/48 @ h u b f m a b f G x p r g s s ( V i b f M n r - V n a , > 1 1 < )
\hg `rata`nccy n``cnakgl oiim sgrags erik Abtgccg`t. www.abtgccg`toiims.`ik
VI_CLEACK
CI@N\AIBPGXZCI_ABF\HG @A\QIBP@_GGB
HIBF MIBF
@hubfmabf Gxprgss
(>18:)
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 41/48
CN\GP\ \A\CGP BIV NUNACNOCG EI_NKNTIB MABLCG NBL I\HG_ G-_GNLG_P
+ LIVBCINL \HG E_GG AZNL NZZ 22UAPA\ \HG MABLCG NBL A\WBGP P\I_GP EI_ KI_G ABEI_KN\AIB
Eir eurthgr abeirkntaib nbl ti irlgr oiims vasat4 www.abtgccg`toiims.`i
_G@IKKGBLGL NBL _GNL OQ\HG VI_CL'P CGNLABF EACK @_A\A@P...
Glatgl oyDgz @ibiccy nbl@nricabg Vhgcnb
APOB 168>680?::?51
ZO £><.17 / $??
Glatgl oyBntîcan Zabnzznnbl Ciuas Onyknb
APOB 168>680?::?1:
ZO £><.17 / $??
CAUG_ZIICPÀI ZNWCI ON_@GCIBZ_NFWGPNBE_NB@AP@I Glatgl oy
Cirgbzi \irrgs nblHgcai Pnb Kafugc
APOB 168>680?::?7?
ZO £><.17 / $??
Glatgl oyP`itt Dirlnb Hnrras
APOB 168>680?::?80
ZO £><.17 / $??
Glatgl oyKnr`gccabg Oci`m
APOB 168>680?::?65
ZO £><.17 / $??
BGV EI_
?:>0BGV EI_
?:>0BGV EI_
?:>0BGV EI_
?:>0BGV EI_
?:>0
Glatgl oyFnoragc Picikibs
APOB 168>8<>7:<878
ZO £><.17 / $??
Glatgl oyCabln @hau-Hnb Cnanbl MakourcgyVabf-Qgg @hia
APOB 168>680?::?><
ZO £><.17 / $??
CIP NBFGCGPHIBF MIBF BGVQI_M CIBLIB ZN_APGlatgl oyP`itt Dirlnb Hnrras
APOB 168>8<>7:<8?6
ZO £><.17 / $??
Glatgl oyKnr`gccabg Oci`m
APOB 168>8<>7:75>1
ZO £><.17 / $??
Glatgl oyBgac Kat`hgcc
APOB 168>8<>7:<8<>
ZO £><.17 / $??
OGP\PGCCG_
OGP\PGCCG_
OGP\PGCCG_
BGV EI_
?:>0OGP\
PGCCG_
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 42/48
V H A C G A \ ' P \ H G _ N A P I B L ' G \ _ G iekusa`ncs ti ab`culg s`gbgs ab wha`h thprab`apnc `nst nbl ietgb n kuctatulg
ie gxtrns sabf, at's nb gbtargcy lagrgbgxpgragb`g whgb sggb ab kivags erikithgr fgbrgs. Vhnt hnppgbs whgb`hnrn`tgrs ab riknbta` lrnkns, hafhs`hiic `ikglags ir nrthiusg kivagsourst abti sibf9 Ab thgsg abstnb`gsthg vagwgr as `nufht i funrl, gbtargcubprgpnrgl eir sgqugb`gs thnt star nrnbfg ie gkitaibs thriufh, nbl lrnwnttgbtaib ti, thg piwgr ie sibf.
\hiufh Hgrknb Hupegcl's Ns \akgFigs Oy as subf oy Pnk (Liicgy Vacsiib bukgrius i``nsaibs ab @nsnocnb`n (>1<?), at as thg spibtnbgius vgrsaibie Cn Knrsgaccnasg, ogctgl iut oy thg
pntribs ie _a`m's @neá, thnt knmgsthg frgntgst akprgssaib. Vath knbyie thg gxtrns ab thg s`gbg ogabf n`tunrgeufggs nbl gxacgs erik i``upaglErnb`g, thas pntraita`, lgnbt rgdiablti thg Fgrknb siclagrs' sabfabf ie LaVn`ht Nk _hgab as abvgstgl wath nllgpiafbnb`y.
N cafht-hgnrtgl vnrantaib ib thas thgk`nkg ab thg `ikabf ie nfg `ikgly Egrras Ougccgr's Lny I (>185). LurabfEgrras' (Kntthgw Orilgra`m) ubpcnbbnlvgbturgs, thg rgogccaius trunbt fntg-`rnshgs thg nbbunc Uib Ptguogb'Lny pnrnlg oy `cakoabf ibti n int
nbl cgnlabf thg `riwl, knby ie whikncsi lnb`g ab `hirgifrnphgl ubasib,thriufh n fciraiuscy upcaetabf, cap-syb`hgl vgrsaib ie \wast & Phiut . At as`ikgla` bil ti shiw stippabf kusa`bukogrs thnt ts abti Egrras' nbl thgkivag's cnrfgr-thnb-caeg nttatulg.
Zgrhnps thg oiclgst, kistub`ibvgbtaibnc usg ie thas tripgnppgnrs ab Z\ Nblgrsib's sprnwcabfhuknb lrnkn Knfbican (>111). Ncc thgprab`apnc pcnygrs ie thas thrgg hiurgbsgkocg pag`g tnmg turbs sabfabfthg cyra`s ti Nakgg Knbb's Vasg Wp,n kgcnb`hica` ilg ti rgfrgt, sgce
nwnrgbgss nbl ciss. Asicntgl ab thgernkg ns thgy nrg erik gn`h ithgr,thg ablavalunc hnrn`tgrs nrg oiubltifgthgr oy thg sibf. Vasg Wp as n thrg wivgb thriufh thg s`gbg thnt rgblgrsgvgryibg ncamg= enccaocg, lnknfgl nblstruffcabf ti knmg sgbsg ie thgarcavgs. Ncwnys stramabf nbl ubgxpg`tgl,nbl whgthgr sykoica`, ikgla` irkiurbeuc, thg knss pnrta`apntiry sibfas bgvgr dust n pgreirknb`g eir ats iwbsnmg, at's ab`cusaib wacc ncwnys og tiriusg nb gkitaibnc ibbg`taib wathabthg vagwgr. ]top[
\ifgthgr
Biw
A K A \ N \ A I B A P \ H G P A B @ G _ G P \ E I _ K I E E C N \ \ G _ Q
ZN_\ABF PHI\
B G A C K A \ @ H G CC sabfs thg prnasgs ie sikgubusunc nbl ubgxpg`tgl iutoursts ie sibf ab
n lavgrsg sgcg`taib ie kivags.
Ncc
<? www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 43/48
Nutukb ?:>0 <0
Dukp- Puats
fi eurthgr Vnt`h thg 'Vasg Wp' s`gbg erik Knfbican hgrg ½ yiutu.og/nBkMfh\vd:G
Vasg Wp as n thrgnlwivgb thriufh thg s`gbgthnt rgblgrs gvgryibgncamg= enccaocg, lnknfglnbl struffcabf ti knmgsgbsg ie thgar cavgs.
@CI@MVAPG E_IK IZZIPA\GEG__AP OWGCCG_'P LNQ IEE@NPNOCNB@NKNFBICAN
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 44/48
Za`turg
\has
@IKZG\A\AIB
VHN\9Q
VHGB9Q
G K N A C N B P V G _ P \ I 4F N O _ A G C J A B \ G C C G @ \ O I I M P . @ I K
LGNLCABG EI_ GB\_AGP4 ?: I@\IOG_, ?:>0
?::1's Cavgrpiic sgt ck Biwhgrg Oiy wnslarg`tgl oy wha`h gstnocashgl WM nrtast9
\g wabbabf gbtry `hisgb nt rnblik wacc wabn `ipy ie Vircl Eack Ci`ntaibs4 Cavgrpiic
glatgl oy Dgz @ibiccy nbl @nricabg Vhgcnb.
GB\G_NBLVAB!
A k n f g © ? : : 1
G ` i s s g E a c k s , E a c k < , W M E a c k @ i u b ` a c
<< www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 45/48
Ppitcafht
@abgkn‑s \hgknta` Ptrnbls
>::: Virls
Kikgbts \hnt @hnbfgl @abgkn Eirgvgr
Valgs`rggb
Eack ab N Valgr @ibtgxt
Nr`hatg`turg & Eack
Nlvgbturgs ab Eackgl Gbvaribkgbts
P`rggbfgks
Gvi`ntavg Iodg`ts Ibs`rggb
_ggc Vircl
Eack Ogyibl thg Oirlgrs ie thg P`rggb
Znrtabf Phit
Akatntaib as thg Pab`grgst Eirk ie Ecnttgry
Ib Ci`ntaib
\hg Zcn`gs \hnt Knmg thg Kivags
Gxpgragb`g \hg Oaffgr Za`turg Phiwabf thnt thgrg‑s kirg ti ck thnb dust ck...
\hg Oaf Za`turg as n knfnzabg thnt
gxpcirgs ck ab n walgr `ibtgxt usabf
thg piwgr ie aknfgry ti shiw dust
hiw kivabf kivabf-pa`turgs `nb og.
Erik pistgrs nbl gvi`ntavg iodg`ts
ti phiti gssnys nbl rgnc-caeg stirags
ogyibl thg oirlgrs ie thg s`rggb,
\hg Oaf Za`turg ieegrs n ubaqug
pgrspg`tavg ib thg wircl ie ck.
Eabl iut kirg oy vasatabf
www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
Ncsi liwbcinl thg Npp tilny ti gbdiy nb
nr`havg ie ncc pnst nbl prgsgbt assugs
E_GG NZZ
thgoafpa`turg knfnzabg Gxpcirabf Eack Ogyibl thg Oirlgrs ie thg P`rggb...
ZLE Liwbcinls ie ncc pnst assugs ie \hg Oaf Za`turg nrg nvnacnocg erik www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
\hg Oaf Za`turg Knfnzabg as prilu`gl oy Abtgccg`t. www.abtgccg`toiims.`ik / abeiJabtgccg`toiims.`ik
Zrabt ipags nvnacnocg erik www.knf`ciul.`ik nbl ti vagw erik www.s`raol.`ik
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 46/48
On`mpnfgs
\hg Ocugs Orithgrs (>18:)
Lar. Dihb Cnblas
f sgg pnfg </7
\hg Dnzz Pabfgr (>1?6) Lar. Ncnb @irscnbl
f sgg pnfg 5/6
Bnshvaccg (>167) Lar. _iogrt Nctknb
f sgg pnfgs 8/1
Casztiknban (>167) Lar. Mgb _ussgcc
f sgg pnfg 1
Onoycib (>18>)
Lar. Ernb`i _issi
f sgg pnfg >:
Bi Ibg Mbiws Noiut Zgrsanb @nts
(?::1)
Lar. Onhknb Fhionla
f sgg pnfg >>
Fnabsoiurf4 N Hgria` Caeg (?:>:)
Lar. Dinbb Penr
f sgg pnfg >?/>0
N @ci`mwirm Irnbfg (>16>)
Lar. Ptnbcgy Muora`m
f sgg pnfg >8/>1
Fakkg Phgctgr (>16:)
Lar. @hnrcittg Twgrab
f sgg pnfgs ?<
Ptnblabf ab thg Phnliw
ie Kitiwb (?::?)
Lar. Znuc Dustknb
f sgg pnfg ?7
Pgnr`habf eir Pufnr Knb (?:>?)
Lar. Kcam Ogbdgcciuc
f sgg pnfg ?5
Iac @aty @iblgbtanc (?::1)
Lar. Ducagb \gkpcg
f sgg pnfgs ?5
\hgrg Vacc Og Ociil (?::8)
Lar. Znuc \hikns Nblgrsib
f sgg pnfg ?6
Zhnbtik ie thg Znrnlasg (>16<)
Lar. Oranb Lg Znckn
f sgg pnfg ?8/?1
\hg Farc @nb't Hgcp At (>175)
Lar. Ernbm \nshcab
f sgg pnfg 0:/0>
Dnachiusg _i`m (>176)
Lar. _a`hnrl \hirpg
f sgg pnfgs 0?
N Hnrl Lny's Bafht (>15<)
Lar. _a`hnrl Cgstgr
f sgg pnfg 00/0</07
Egrry @riss thg Kgrsgy (>157)
Lar. Dgrgky Pukkgrs
f sgg pnfg 05
On`mognt (>11<)
Lar. Anab Pietcgy
f sgg pnfg 06
Ie \akg nbl thg @aty (?::?)
Lar. \grgb`g Lnvags
f sgg pnfg 06
\has as Ppabnc \np (>18<)
Lar. _io _gabgr
f sgg pnfg 08/01
Egrras Ougccgr's Lny I (>185)
Lar. Dihb Hufhgs
f sgg pnfg <?
@nsnocnb`n (>1<?)
Lar. Ka`hngc @urtaz
f sgg pnfg <?
Knfbican (>111)
Lar. Z\ Nblgrsib
f sgg pnfg <0
Biwhgrg Oiy (?::1)
Lar. Pnk \nycir-Viil
f sgg pnfg <<
Eack AblgxN riublup ie ncc thg cks egnturgl...
abtgccg`tZcuocashgrs ie thas hgrg knfnzabg...
Gn`h assug ie \hg Oaf Za`turg as prilu`gl
oy Orastic onsgl puocashgr, abtgccg`t.
Abtgccg`t as nb ablgpgblgbt n`nlgka` puocashgr ab
thg gcls ie `rgntavg prn`ta`g nbl pipucnr `ucturg,puocashabf s`hicnrcy oiims nbl diurbncs thnt gxgkpcaey
thgar kassaib ns puocashgrs ie irafabnc thabmabf.
\hgynak ti privalg n vatnc spn`g eir walgbabf `rata`nc
lgontg ab bgw nbl gkgrfabf suodg`ts, nbl ab thas wny
thgy lagr erik ithgr puocashgrs oy `nkpnafbabf eir
thg nuthir rnthgr thnb prilu`abf n oiim ir diurbnc ti
cc n fnp ab thg knrmgt.
Abtgccg`t puocash ab eiur lastab`t suodg`t nrgns4 vasunc
nrts, ck stulags, ucturnc nbl kglan stulags, nbl
pgreirkabf nrts. \hgsg `ntgfirags hist Abtgccg`t‑s
gvgr-gxpnblabf tipa`s ie gbquary, wha`h ab`culgphitifrnphy, lrnwabf, `urntaib, `ikkubaty kusa`,
fnkabf nbl s`gbifrnphy. Abtgccg`t tatcgs nrg ietgb
kuctalas`apcabnry, prgsgbtabf s`hicnrcy wirm nt thg
`riss sg`taib ie nrts, kglan nbl rgntavg prn`ta`g.
thgoafpa`turg las`cnakgr\hg vagws nbl ipabaibs ie ncc tgxts, ab`culabf
glatiranc nbl rgfucnr `icukbs, nrg thisg ie thg
nuthirs nbl li bit bg`gssnracy rgprgsgbt ir
rgg`t thisg ie thg glatirs ir puocashgrs.
I_AFABNC \HABMABFZWOCAPH
_gkgkogr ti eicciw thgoafpa`turg ib
<5 www.thgoafpa`turgknfnzabg.`ik
Pabf-up ti rg`gavgthgoafpa`turg bgwscgttgrN twa`g kibthcy uplntg wath wrattgb
egnturgs, gx`cusavg `ikpgtataibs,
bgws nbl ck rg`ikkgblntaibs.vasat thgoafpa`turg wgosatg
eir eurthgr lgtnacs.
7/30/2019 The Big Picture Issue 21
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-big-picture-issue-21 47/48
\hg Larg`tiry ie Vircl @abgkn naks ti pcny n pnrt ab kivabf abtgccafgbt, s`hicnrcy `rata`ask ogyibl thg
n`nlgky. Gn`h vicukg ie thg Larg`tiry privalgs n ucturnccy rgprgsgbtntavg absafht abti n bntaibnc ir rgfaibnc
`abgkn thriufh n iccg`taib ie rgvagws, gssnys, rgsiur`gs, nbl ck staccs hafhcafhtabf safba`nbt cks nbl
pcnygrs. Ivgr takg, bgw glataibs wacc og puocashgl eir gn`h vicukg, frnlunccy ouaclabf n ikprghgbsavg
fualg ti thg `abgkn ie gn`h rgfaib. \i `ibtraoutg ti thg pridg`t ir pur`hnsg `ipags pcgnsg vasat thg wgosatg.
VVV.VI_CL@ABGKNLA_G@\I_Q.I_F
\i vagw iur `ntncifug ir irlgr iur oiims nbl diurbncs vasat www.abtgccg`toiims.`ik. Abtgccg`t, \hg Kacc, Znrbncc _inl, Eashpibls, Orastic, OP>5 0DF. | \gc4 +<< (:) >>6 17811>:
GXZG_AGB@G FCIONC @WC\W_G
\H_IWFH \HG KNFA@ IE EACK
LA_G@\I_Q IE
VI_CL
@ABGKN