The 2002 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court ......Republic of Turingia V. Republic of Babbage The Case Concerning Regulation ofAccess to the Internet Competition Results

2002 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court Competition

The 2002 Philip C. JessupInternational Law Moot Court Competition

Republic of Turingia

V.

Republic of Babbage

The Case Concerning Regulation ofAccess to the Internet

Competition Results

International Law Students Association


The 2002 Philip C. JessupInternational Law Moot Court Competition

World Cup Championship Round

16 March 2002Ceremonial Courtroom

United States District Court for the District of ColumbiaWashington, D.C., USA

2002 Jessup Cup World Champion:University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa

Team MembersSteven Budlender

Kate Hofineyr

Coach: Dr. Kevin Hopkins

2002 Runner-Up:Universit of Western Australia, Australia

Team MembersLee Katherine Carroll

Ben GauntlettAdam SharpeJulie Taylor

Lorraine van der Ende

Coach: Dr. James Edelman

Best Oralist in Final Round (by judges' vote)

Lorraine van der EndeUniversity of Westem Australia

Final Bench of the 2002 Jessup World Cup Championship Round

Judge Abraham SofaerHoover Institute, Palo Alto, California

Mr. Javade ChaudhriGateway Computers

Prof. Dinah SheltonNotre Dame University



Advanced Round Pairings

Run-off Rounds *

University of Georgia (USA) d. Georgetown University (USA)Harvard Law School (USA) d. University of Michigan (USA)University of Western Australia (Australia) d. University of Queensland (Australia)University of Otago (New Zealand) def. Law Society of Ireland (Ireland)National University of Singapore (Singapore) d. University of Vienna (Austria)University of the Witwatersrand (S.Africa) d. University of the Philippines (Philippines)National Law School, India Univ. (India) d. Univ. Catolica Andres Bello (Venezuela)University of Copenhagen (Denmark) d. Hong Kong University (China)

Ouarterfinal Rounds *

Harvard Law School (USA) d. University of Georgia (USA)University of the Witwatersrand (S.Africa) d. National Univ. of Singapore (Singapore)University of Otago (New Zealand) def. National Law School, India University (India)University of Western Australia (Australia) d. University of Copenhagen (Denmark)

Semif'mal Rounds

University of the Witwatersrand (S.Africa) d. Harvard Law School (USA)University of Western Australia (Australia) d. University of Otago (N.Z.)

Final Round

University of the Witwatersrand (S.Africa) d. University of Western Australia (Australia)

* According to the Official Rules, teams from the same country must compete against one another in the Run-off

Rounds and the Quarterfinal Rounds, because the semifinalist teams must represent four different countries.



Team Rankings

Run-off Finalists

Rank Team # Team1 876 USA (Georgetown)2 881 USA (Harvard)3 256 Australia (Western Aust.)4 385 New Zealand5 386 Singapore5 120 South Africa7 301 India (NLSIU)8 500 Denmark9 258 Australia (Queensland)10 270 China11 831 Venezuela12 380 Philippines13 944 USA (Michigan)14 936 USA (Georgia)15 480 Austria16 575 Ireland

Wins Raw Pts. Round Pts.4 3333 31.54 3330.4 354 3289 28.54 3276.5 284 3273 294 3273 294 3268 33.54 3057 303 3294 303 3250 23.53 3238 313 3224 263 3221 193 3188 24.53 3151.2 223 3147 26

Preliminary Round Rankings

17 93718 16119 92620 83521 56022 52023 17524 58625 60626 10327 79528 97129 53930 93831 89632 66233 61534 30635 57036 10637 47138 29139 80340 96241 95942 37043 70044 57345 44046 77247 811

USA (Hawaii)Canada (McGill)USA (Alabama)West IndiesGreeceGeorgiaCanada (Alberta)NetherlandsPolandEgyptPuerto RicoUSA (Wash. U.)GermanyUSA (Illinois)USA (NYU)United KingdomTurkeyIndia (NUJS)IcelandKenyaBelgiumKoreaMexicoUSA (Virginia)USA (Texas)TaiwanArgentinaMaltaAzerbaijanDominican Rep.Peru

3147314031233080.6307530753064303930393021300532303164315731413135312131013093.830893088308530623037.93003298429622904289328862870

23.52619.522282529.52723212319161820.52121.51720.513201414151819231819.51410



Preliminary Round Rankings (continued)

Rank Team # Team48 104 Ghana49 135 Israel50 340 Malaysia51 765 Colombia52 641 Ukraine53 885 USA (RI-Indy)54 566 Hungary55 495 Czech Rep.56 780 Guatemala57 712 Brazil58 282 Indonesia59 240 Uzbekistan60 490 Bulgaria61 350 Japan62 200 Kazakhstan63 511 France64 210 Kyrgyzstan65 100 Botswana66 785 Nicaragua67 109 Namibia68 623 Russia69 580 Lithuania70 680 Switzerland71 790 Panama72 400 Armenia73 836 Costa Rica74 220 Tajikistan75 230 Turkmenistan

Wins Raw Pts. Round Pts.2 2861 15.51 3137 18.51 3128 15.51 3063.6 131 3035 15.51 2935.6 131 2926 17.51 2890 151 2873.4 14.51 2856 111 2852.5 6.51 2844 111 2838 131 2834 131 2792 101 2790.4 11.51 2683.4 61 2668 71 2629 141 2515 4.50 3022 50 2916 90 2870.4 60 2853 70 2826 00 2777 40 2707 20 2547.4 6.5


2002 Philip C. Jlessup International Law Moot Court Competition

2002 International RoundsBest Oralists

(top 100)

Rank Oralist Tea1 L. Myers 9382 P. Hood 9443 L. Vander Ende 2564 E. Salmon 8764 A.Kaur 3866 H. Singh 3867 D. Mascari 8818 K. Scheuber 2588 L.Carroll 25610 Jin-Long Pao 88110 S.Odero 10612 A.Gill 94412 S. Budlender 12012 T. McConnell 87615 H. Edwards 83516 J. Richardson 97117 K. Fung 27018 E. Albert 89619 C.Peters 25820 K. Lahnstein 93620 P. Kelly 93622 C. Curron 38522 K. Hofmeyer 12024 A. Brzoza 60624 J. Caddel 97124 M. Ziewitz 53927 F. Kleinknecht 53928 C. Fahy 57528 E. Ellis 87628 J.Tubbs 92631 S. Ligunya 10632 Hemi Lee 29133 E.Polat 61533 Y. Akmenek 61535 J. Gallagher 66236 K. Murphy 16137 F. Domenech 79537 F.Franze 94437 R. Agarwal 30140 A. Leung 27040 J. Callanan 57540 M. Ernewein 16140 M. Sanchez 83140 P. Venkatesh 30140 S.K.Park 29146 S. Sterken 94447 I. Nazaris 56047 M. Knapp 25849 D. Galea 57349 T. Clark 971

n School (Nation)USA (Illinois)USA (Michigan)Australia (Western Aust.)USA (Georgetown)SingaporeSingaporeUSA (Harvard)Australia (Queensland)Australia (Western Aust.)USA (Harvard)KenyaUSA (Michigan)South AfricaUSA (Georgetown)West IndiesUSA (Wash. U.)ChinaUSA (NYU)Australia (Queensland)USA (Georgia)USA (Georgia)New ZealandSouth AfricaPolandUSA (Wash. U.)GermanyGermanyIrelandUSA (Georgetown)USA (Alabama)KenyaKoreaTurkeyTurkeyUnited KingdomCanada (McGill)Puerto RicoUSA (Michigan)India (NLSIU)ChinaIrelandCanada (McGill)VenezuelaIndia (NLSIU)KoreaUSA (Michigan)GreeceAustralia (Queensland)MaltaUSA (Wash. U.)

Total Score Average Score588 98585 97.5584 97.3333580 96.6667580 96.6667574 95.6667570 95569 94.8333569 94.8333568 94.6667568 94.6667564 94564 94564 94563 93.8333562 93.6667561 93.5558 93557 92.8333553 92.1667553 92.1667552 92552 92551 91.8333551 91.8333551 91.8333550 91.6667548 91.3333548 91.3333548 91.3333545 90.8333544 90.6667543 90.5543 90.5542 90.3333541 90.1667540 90540 90540 90539 89.8333539 89.8333539 89.8333539 89.8333539 89.8333539 89.8333538 89.6667537 89.5537 89.5536 89.3333536 89.3333



2002 International RoundsBest Oralists

(top 100, continued)Rank Oralist Team School (Nation)51 A.Siwy 480 Austria51 C. Lange 539 Germany53 E. Ramirez 831 Venezuela53 H. Forsyth 385 New Zealand53 N. Morrison 835 West Indies53 S. Gallini 938 USA (Illinois)57 J. Lodahl 500 Denmark57 R. Acebedo 380 Philippines57 T. Uplisashvili 520 Georgia60 M. Davidovic 586 Netherlands61 C. Washenfelder 175 Canada (Alberta)61 E.Park 291 Korea61 H. Patel 962 USA (Virginia)61 N. Reid 881 USA (Harvard)65 A. Tolnai 566 Hungary65 G. Sawczyn 876 USA (Georgetown)65 J. Edwards 772 Dominican Rep.65 T. Mykkeltvedt 936 USA (Georgia)69 A. Kuchit 340 Malaysia69 A. Sigurjonsson 570 Iceland69 C. Mesquita 712 Brazil69 V. Jam-Jordan 937 USA (Hawaii)73 C. Schmeichel 175 Canada (Alberta)73 P. Morales 765 Colombia75 A. Aidoo 104 Ghana75 R. Strickland 936 USA (Georgia)77 A. Hatfield 926 USA (Alabama)77 C. Imamura 937 USA (Hawaii)77 G. Douglas 926 USA (Alabama)80 3. Bellamy 885 USA (IU-Indy)80 S. Banderhoff 896 USA (NYU)82 J. Werzer 480 Austria82 K. Pearson 959 USA (Texas)82 M.Mahmood 340 Malaysia82 P. Fung 270 China86 B. Leventhal 135 Israel86 E. Arotsi 104 Ghana88 A. Sturtevant 896 USA (NYU)88 D. Bentson 962 USA (Virginia)88 J. Tonkin 575 Ireland88 M.Haars 471 Belgium88 N. Houry 161 Canada (McGill)88 R. Gumbiner 971 USA (Wash. U.)88 W. Burke-White 881 USA (Harvard)95 C.Vistan 380 Philippines95 Z. Giron 795 Puerto Rico97 M. Junge 539 Germany97 S. Verhoeven 471 Belgium99 A. Petrovics 566 Hungary99 D.Lurf 480 Austria99 M. Van Eik 586 Netherlands

Total Score Average Score535 89.1667535 89.1667534 89534 89534 89534 89533 88.8333533 88.8333533 88.8333532 88.6667531 88.5531 88.5531 88.5531 88.5530 88.3333530 88.3333530 88.3333530 88.3333529 88.1667529 88.1667529 88.1667529 88.1667528 88528 88527 87.8333527 87.8333526 87.6667526 87.6667526 87.6667525 87.5525 87.5524 87.3333524 87.3333524 87.3333524 87.3333523 87.1667523 87.1667521 86.8333521 86.8333521 86.8333521 86.8333521 86.8333521 86.8333521 86.8333520 86.6667520 86.6667519 86.5519 86.5518 86.3333518 86.3333518 86.3333



2002 International RoundsParticipant Records

NameAbrahams, DAcebedo, RAdyuman, KAgarwal, RAidoo, AAkmenek, YAksel, KAlbert, EAleman, AAlisekova, AAmanova, GAmbroziewicz, AAmiel, SAminov, IAmzallag, YAnara, 0Angel, CArcher, DArguello, RArotsi, EAsanov, DAudes, VAvgoustidou, VAydin, BAzis, SBabayeb, JBakal, 0Bakowski, IBanderhoff, SBaoleki, MBellamy, JBentson, DBryant, DBrzoza, ABudlender, SBurjalini, TBurke-White, WCaddel, JCallanan, JCamacho, CCarballeda, ACarroll, LCartier, MCasteel, RClark, TConnolly, HCosta, LCuadra, JCurron, CD'Anello, CDaniels, K

Team #938380400301104615615896790623240606811240135210765835785104200495560615282440135606896100885962959606120520881971575836790256680103971896712785385790959

TeamUSA (Illinois)PhilippinesArmeniaIndia (NLSIU)GhanaTurkeyTurkeyUSA (NYU)PanamaRussiaUzbekistanPolandPeruUzbekistanIsraelKyrgyzstanColombiaWest IndiesNicaraguaGhanaKazakhstanCzech Rep.GreeceTurkeyIndonesiaAzerbaijanIsraelPolandUSA (NYU)BotswanaUSA (IU-Indy)USA (Virginia)USA (Texas)PolandSouth AfricaGeorgiaUSA (Harvard)USA (Wash. U.)IrelandCosta RicaPanamaAustralia (Western Aust.)SwitzerlandEgyptUSA (Wash. U.)USA (NYU)BrazilNicaraguaNew ZealandPanamaUSA (Texas)


Total515533506540527543501558489506507500475501501456512506463523515452494504490456486478525445525521506551564485521551539499462569470466536509489451552459459

Avg85.833388.833384.33339087.833390.583.59381.584.333384.583.333379.166783.583.57685.333384.333377.166787.166785.833375.333382.33338481.6667768179.666787.574.166787.586.833384.333391.83339480.833386.833391.833389.833383.16677794.833378.333377.666789.333384.833381.575.16679276.576.5


2002 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court CompetitionPreliminary Rounds

Individual Oralist Performance

NameDavidovic, MDeitchman, CDelgado, ADespott, MDizdarevic, IDomenech, FDouglas, GDuffy, PEccles, AEdwards, HEdwards, JEid, MEinarsdottir, M.Ellis, EEllis, TEmewein, MFagerberg, MFahy, CFernandez, MFilauro, DFontana, EForsyth, HFranze, FFung, KFung, PGalea, DGallagher, JGallini, SGamliel, RGarcia, RGhanem, DGill, AGiron, ZGomez, JGordon, DGumbiner, RGuseynova, DHaars, MHatfield, AHenning, WHofineyer, KHood, PHoury, NImamura, CIvancikova, JIvanov, VJam-Jordan, VJonsson, 0Joshua, JJunge, MK.Park, S

Team #586885790573680795926175662835772103570876573161500575836511780385944270270573662938135803103944795772785971230471926586120944161937495623937570109539291

TeamNetherlandsUSA (IU-Indy)PanamaMaltaSwitzerlandPuerto RicoUSA (Alabama)Canada (Alberta)United KingdomWest IndiesDominican Rep.EgyptIcelandUSA (Georgetown)MaltaCanada (McGill)DenmarkIrelandCosta RicaFranceGuatemalaNew ZealandUSA (Michigan)ChinaChinaMaltaUnited KingdomUSA (Illinois)IsraelMexicoEgyptUSA (Michigan)Puerto RicoDominican Rep.NicaraguaUSA (Wash. U.)TurkmenistanBelgiumUSA (Alabama)NetherlandsSouth AfricaUSA (Michigan)Canada (McGill)USA (Hawaii)Czech Rep.RussiaUSA (Hawaii)IcelandNamibiaGermanyKorea


Total532512445480488540526485510563530466510548483539511548503497478534540561524536542534505513517564520462405521426521526459552585521526484501529510412519539

Avg88.666785.333374.16678081.33339087.666780.83338593.833388.333377.66678591.333380.589.833385.166791.333383.833382.833379.6667899093.587.333389.333390.33338984.166785.586.16679486.66677767.586.83337186.833387.666776.59297.586.833387.666780.666783.588.16678568.666786.589.8333




NameKagi, UKapanadze, SKarimov, AKaur, AKavena, MKelly, PKleinknecht, FKlimova, KKnapp, MKuchit, ALafontaine, FLahnstein, KLange, CLapteva, KLee, HLee, HLeung, ALeventhal, BLevterov, KLigunya, SLind, ELodahl, JLurf, DMahmood, MMakati, DMammadov, EMarangulyan, HMargaryan, VMarie, DMascari, DMauermann, CMcConnell, TMesquita, CMohit, AMoisetervas, RMollayeva, TMonson, KMorales, PMorayef, FMorrison, NMurphy, KMustatayev, NMyers, LMykkeltvedt, TNakamura, MNazaris, INelson, CNikolaena, ANovikova, TNurbek, SOdero, S

Team #680520220386495936539495258340795936539623291803270135641106811500480340100440400400340881680876712306580230959765103835161440938936350560175623641210106

TeamSwitzerlandGeorgiaTajikistanSingaporeCzech Rep.USA (Georgia)GermanyCzech Rep.Australia (Queensland)MalaysiaPuerto RicoUSA (Georgia)GermanyRussiaKoreaMexicoChinaIsraelUkraineKenyaPeruDenmarkAustriaMalaysiaBotswanaAzerbaijanArmeniaArmeniaMalaysiaUSA (Harvard)SwitzerlandUSA (Georgetown)BrazilIndia (NUJS)LithuaniaTurkmenistanUSA (Texas)ColombiaEgyptWest IndiesCanada (McGill)AzerbaijanUSA (Illinois)USA (Georgia)JapanGreeceCanada (Alberta)RussiaUkraineKyrgyzstanKenya


Total432497416580502553550435537529503553535508544509539523494545503533518524495482492479473570477564529502460397500528484534541449588530501537476499494466568

Avg7282.833369.333396.666783.666792.166791.666772.589.588.166783.833392.166789.166784.666790.666784.833389.833387.166782.333390.833383.833388.833386.333387.333382.580.33338279.833378.83339579.59488.166783.666776.666766.166783.33338880.66678990.166774.83339888.333383.589.579.333383.166782.333377.666794.6667




NameOkinda-Delacour, MO'laughin, ROtoo, JPang, CPao, Jin-LongPark, EPark, Joo HwaPatel, HPearson, KPeters, CPetho, NPetrovics, APineda, MPolat, EPorhallsson, HRabaglia, VRadulovska-Marinova, TRamirez, EReid, NRichardson, JRodriguez, NRustam, SSajkowski, MSaldanha, LSalmon, ESanchez, MSatwika, KSawczyn, GScheuber, KSchmeichel, CSchoenhals, KShakhizada, KShintaro, NShuhei, TSigurijonsson, ASimons, DSingh, HSiwy, ASlachmyidos, YSlivinska, MSosa, ESterken, SStrickland, RSturtevant, ASud, UTan, LTarin, DTavityan, DTaylor, JTaylor, SThallinger, G

Team #511575500370881291291962959258566566765615570700490831881971772282606712876831282876258175772200350350570586386480471580780944936896306937962490256835480

TeamFranceIrelandDenmarkTaiwanUSA (Harvard)KoreaKoreaUSA (Virginia)USA (Texas)Australia (Queensland)HungaryHungaryColombiaTurkeyIcelandArgentinaBulgariaVenezuelaUSA (Harvard)USA (Wash. U.)Dominican Rep.IndonesiaPolandBrazilUSA (Georgetown)VenezuelaIndonesiaUSA (Georgetown)Australia (Queensland)Canada (Alberta)Dominican Rep.KazakhstanJapanJapanIcelandNetherlandsSingaporeAustriaBelgiumLithuaniaGuatemalaUSA (Michigan)USA (Georgia)USA (NYU)India (NUJS)USA (Hawaii)USA (Virginia)BulgariaAustralia (Western Aust.)West IndiesAustria


Total458508498517568531509531524557487518485543510469393534531562513484472457580539487530569528479511459393529469521535512471499538527521491487496450486507515

Avg76.333384.66678386.166794.666788.584.833388.587.333392.833381.166786.333380.833390.58578.166765.58988.593.666785.580.666778.666776.166796.666789.833381.166788.333394.83338879.833385.166776.565.588.166778.166795.666789.166785.333378.583.166789.666787.833386.833381.833381.166782.6667758184.585.8333




NameThambapilai, GThordike, TTkachenko, KTolnai, ATomkin, JTomtsis, ATorres, RToth, 0Trimarco, TTubbs, JTuryn, ATzouni, AUmada, YUplisashvili, TValencia-Safi, CVan Elk, MVander Ende, LVenkatesh, PVerhoeven, SVistan, CVoetmann, KWashenfelder, CWerzer, JWhite, CWilliams, MWu, TYamamoto, WYielding, CZapata, VZhechkova, YZiewitz, MZikriyaeva, FZlatev, IZuniga, E

Team #109811641566575560712566938926700560350520511586256301471380500175480885161370937926836490539220490836

TeamNamibiaPeruUkraineHungaryIrelandGreeceBrazilHungaryUSA (Illinois)USA (Alabama)ArgentinaGreeceJapanGeorgiaFranceNetherlandsAustralia (Western Aust.)India (NLSIU)BelgiumPhilippinesDenmarkCanada (Alberta)AustriaUSA (IU-Indy)Canada (McGill)TaiwanUSA (Hawaii)USA (Alabama)Costa RicaBulgariaGermanyTajikistanBulgariaCosta Rica


Total414479489530521504467487502548471508450533497518584539519520515531524498517469492514506472551436515445

Avg6979.833381.588.333386.83338477.833381.166783.666791.333378.584.66677588.833382.833386.333397.333389.833386.586.666785.833388.587.33338386.166778.16678285.666784.333378.666791.833372.666785.833374.1667


Memorial Results

ALONA E. EvANS AwARwTop 25 BEST COMBINED MEMORIALS OF THE

INTERNATIONAL RouNDs

Team881135385937876270256386301700103258380831340586971480120306520175606570662

Nation/School NameUSA (Harvard)IsraelNew ZealandUSA (Hawaii)USA (Georgetown)ChinaAustralia (Western Aust.)SingaporeIndia (NLSIU)ArgentinaEgyptAustralia (Queensland)PhilippinesVenezuelaMalaysiaNetherlandsUSA (Wash. U.)AustriaSouth AfricaIndia (NUJS)GeorgiaCanada (Alberta)PolandIcelandUnited Kingdom

Total570.2561560.25556.5555.5554553552547545544543540540535530.5530529.6527525522.5522519517.4517

A~p281270281282277.5276262261268256266280273261263247279261259267253.5267259.5244.5254


Respondent289.2291279.25274.5278278291291279289278263267279272283.5251268.6268258269255259.5272.9263


HARDY C. DILLARD AWARD

TOP FIVE BEST COMBINED MEMORIALS OF THE

REGIONAL/NATIONAL COMPETITIONS

1. Harvard Law School, United States2. University of Hong Kong, China3. University of Western Australia, Australia4. National Law School, India University, India5. Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela

RICHARD R. BAXTER AWARDS

BEST MEMORIALS OVERALL

Top Memorials Overall - Applicant *

1. University of Otago, New Zealand2. National Law School of India University, India3. Harvard Law School, United States4. Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela5. University of Western Australia, Australia6. College of Management - Academic Studies, Israel7. University of Hawaii, United States8. University of Hong Kong, China9. Georgetown University Law Center, United States

Top Memorials Overall - Respondent *

1. Harvard Law School, United States2. National Law School of India University, India3. Universidad Catolica Andres Bello, Venezuela4. University of Hawaii, United States5. University of Western Australia, Australia6. University of Hong Kong, China7. University of Otago, New Zealand8. College of Management - Academic Studies, Israel9. Georgetown University Law Center, United States

• There are nine (9) schools in the Baxter Competition, due to one team that qualified in both the Dillardand Evans Competitions.

Spirit of the Jessup AwardPontificia Universidad Catolica Madre y Maestra, Dominican Republic

Universidad Francisco Marroquin, Guatemalaco-winners

Pamela M. Young Friends of the Jessup AwardElizabeth Black

Mark LuzPedro Munoz


Documents

The 2002 Philip C. Jessup International Law Moot Court ......Republic of Turingia V. Republic of Babbage The Case Concerning Regulation ofAccess to the Internet Competition Results