• Home

  • Documents

  • Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency...
29
Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power System Operations with High Penetration of Renewables An Overview of Current Activities by the Midcontinent System Operator to Integrate Renewables Andrew Mills, Electricity Markets and Policy EAEI Journal Club Series October 25, 2019

Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency

Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power System Operations with High Penetration of Renewables

An Overview of Current Activities by the Midcontinent System Operator to Integrate Renewables

Andrew Mills, Electricity Markets and Policy

EAEI Journal Club Series

October 25, 2019

Page 2: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency

Overview

•What did MISO study and why?•How did MISO conduct the study?•What did MISO find?

• Resource Adequacy • Energy Adequacy • Operating Reliability: Steady State • Operating Reliability: Dynamics

Page 3: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency

What did MISO study and why?

Page 4: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 5: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 6: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 7: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 8: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency

How did MISO conduct the study?

Page 9: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 10: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 11: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency

What did MISO find?

Page 12: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 13: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 14: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 15: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 16: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 17: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 18: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 19: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 20: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 21: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 22: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 23: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 24: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 25: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 26: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 27: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 28: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency
Page 29: Technical Challenges Involved in Managing Bulk Power ... · Key metrics: Study area 1. Frequency response 2. Transient and voltage stability 3. Weak areas Performance metric Frequency

Frequency-dependent underground cable model for ... · Frequency-dependent underground cable model for electromagnetic transient simulation ... Impedance matrix Admittance matrix

Frequency-dependent underground cable model for ... · Frequency-dependent underground cable model for electromagnetic transient simulation ... Impedance matrix Admittance matrix

Documents
Power system stability and frequency control for transient

Power system stability and frequency control for transient

Documents
Transient Analysis of Lossy Transmission Lines: an ... · Abstract: This paper is devoted to transient analysis of lossy transmission lines characterized by frequency-dependent parameters

Transient Analysis of Lossy Transmission Lines: an ... · Abstract: This paper is devoted to transient analysis of lossy transmission lines characterized by frequency-dependent parameters

Documents
InTech-Computation of Transient Near Field Radiated by Electronic Devices From Frequency Data

InTech-Computation of Transient Near Field Radiated by Electronic Devices From Frequency Data

Documents
Frequency-resolved Raman for transient thermal … Letters.pdfFrequency-resolved Raman for transient thermal probing and thermal diffusivity measurement TIANYU WANG,1,† SHEN XU,1,†

Frequency-resolved Raman for transient thermal … Letters.pdfFrequency-resolved Raman for transient thermal probing and thermal diffusivity measurement TIANYU WANG,1,† SHEN XU,1,†

Documents
ECE 2C, notes set 4: Transistor Amplifiers basic ... · Learn loadline analysis of transistor ... Fundmentals of frequency and transient response. Transistor high - frequency

ECE 2C, notes set 4: Transistor Amplifiers basic ... · Learn loadline analysis of transistor ... Fundmentals of frequency and transient response. Transistor high - frequency

Documents
Finite Element Transient Analysis - Civil · PDF fileFinite Element Transient Analysis V2.1 ... frequency domain by the finite element method. An expression of far-field motion in

Finite Element Transient Analysis - Civil · PDF fileFinite Element Transient Analysis V2.1 ... frequency domain by the finite element method. An expression of far-field motion in

Documents
TRANSIENT STRUCTURAL ANALYSES USING FREQUENCY …

TRANSIENT STRUCTURAL ANALYSES USING FREQUENCY …

Documents
Design via frequency response - University of Readingsis01xh/teaching/CY2A9/...Design via frequency response Transient response via gain adjustment Consider a unity feedback system,

Design via frequency response - University of Readingsis01xh/teaching/CY2A9/...Design via frequency response Transient response via gain adjustment Consider a unity feedback system,

Documents
LIQUID-FILLED TRANSIENT PRESSURE MEASURING SYSTEMS… · liquid-filled transient pressure measuring systems: a method for determining frequency response national aeronautics and space

LIQUID-FILLED TRANSIENT PRESSURE MEASURING SYSTEMS… · liquid-filled transient pressure measuring systems: a method for determining frequency response national aeronautics and space

Documents
EXAMPLES ON TRANSIENT RESPONSE OF A SECOND ORDER … · HANDOUT E.15 - EXAMPLES ON TRANSIENT RESPONSE OF FIRST AND SECOND ORDER SYSTEMS, SYSTEM DAMPING AND NATURAL FREQUENCY Example

EXAMPLES ON TRANSIENT RESPONSE OF A SECOND ORDER … · HANDOUT E.15 - EXAMPLES ON TRANSIENT RESPONSE OF FIRST AND SECOND ORDER SYSTEMS, SYSTEM DAMPING AND NATURAL FREQUENCY Example

Documents
Causal Transient Simulation of Systems Characterized by Frequency

Causal Transient Simulation of Systems Characterized by Frequency

Documents
Transient Instability Mechanisms by Frequency Coalescence ...€¦ · Transient Instability Mechanisms by Frequency Coalescence in ... dynamique: un cylindre carr´e, un profil de

Transient Instability Mechanisms by Frequency Coalescence ...€¦ · Transient Instability Mechanisms by Frequency Coalescence in ... dynamique: un cylindre carr´e, un profil de

Documents
Transient Stability in Low Frequency - DiVA portal999647/... · 2016-09-30 · LIENTITE TH ESIS Department of Engineering Sciences and Mathematics Division of Energy Science Transient

Transient Stability in Low Frequency - DiVA portal999647/... · 2016-09-30 · LIENTITE TH ESIS Department of Engineering Sciences and Mathematics Division of Energy Science Transient

Documents
Spatial-frequency and contrast tuning of the transient ...schorlab.berkeley.edu/download/spatial-frequency_contrast98.pdf · Spatial-frequency and contrast tuning of ... The tuning

Spatial-frequency and contrast tuning of the transient ...schorlab.berkeley.edu/download/spatial-frequency_contrast98.pdf · Spatial-frequency and contrast tuning of ... The tuning

Documents
Antonietti-KLT for transient signal analysis - atnf.csiro.au · KLT for transient signal analysis KLT for wide band and feeble signals § Thus, the result is that the frequency of

Antonietti-KLT for transient signal analysis - atnf.csiro.au · KLT for transient signal analysis KLT for wide band and feeble signals § Thus, the result is that the frequency of

Documents
Time and Frequency Domain Transient Signal Analysis for ... · PDF file1.0 Introduction Transient Signal Analysis (TSA) ... on a measurement of the contribution to the transient response

Time and Frequency Domain Transient Signal Analysis for ... · PDF file1.0 Introduction Transient Signal Analysis (TSA) ... on a measurement of the contribution to the transient response

Documents
Real-Time Transient Stability Simulator - OPAL-RT · 2019-09-05 · 2 ePHASORsim Fundamental-Frequency Real-Time Power Grid Simulator ePHASORsim simulates electro-mechanical transient

Real-Time Transient Stability Simulator - OPAL-RT · 2019-09-05 · 2 ePHASORsim Fundamental-Frequency Real-Time Power Grid Simulator ePHASORsim simulates electro-mechanical transient

Documents
! Improving Transient Performance of Adaptive Control Architectures Using Frequency-Limited System Error Dynamics

! Improving Transient Performance of Adaptive Control Architectures Using Frequency-Limited System Error Dynamics

Documents
Modeling of Power Components for Transient AnalysisTransformer energization and de-energization 4.3. Transformer modeling for high-frequency transients 4.3.1. Introduction to high-frequency

Modeling of Power Components for Transient AnalysisTransformer energization and de-energization 4.3. Transformer modeling for high-frequency transients 4.3.1. Introduction to high-frequency

Documents
J. McCalley Transient frequency performance and wind penetration

J. McCalley Transient frequency performance and wind penetration

Documents
Audun Sanderud - Universitetet i oslo · Mortality 0.076 (±0.154) 0.330-0.530 UPO 0.264 (±0.277) Feature Frequency/dose(%/Sv) Natural frequency • Radiation is a weak mutagen

Audun Sanderud - Universitetet i oslo · Mortality 0.076 (±0.154) 0.330-0.530 UPO 0.264 (±0.277) Feature Frequency/dose(%/Sv) Natural frequency • Radiation is a weak mutagen

Documents
WWSIS - 3: Western Frequency Response and Transient ... · 1 WWSIS - 3: Western Frequency Response and Transient Stability Study GE Energy Nicholas W. Miller (PM) Miaolei Shao Slobodan

WWSIS - 3: Western Frequency Response and Transient ... · 1 WWSIS - 3: Western Frequency Response and Transient Stability Study GE Energy Nicholas W. Miller (PM) Miaolei Shao Slobodan

Documents
HIGH FREQUENCY TRANSIENT SURGE SUPPRESSORS ZORCZORC is a unique high frequency transient overvoltage surge suppressor for the protection of motors and transformers from steep wave-front,

HIGH FREQUENCY TRANSIENT SURGE SUPPRESSORS ZORCZORC is a unique high frequency transient overvoltage surge suppressor for the protection of motors and transformers from steep wave-front,

Documents
Wind in Weak Grids: Low-Frequency Oscillations ...power.eng.usf.edu/docs/papers/2019/wind_SSO.pdfassumption is also adopted in [13] on type-4 wind weak grid interconnection modeling

Wind in Weak Grids: Low-Frequency Oscillations ...power.eng.usf.edu/docs/papers/2019/wind_SSO.pdfassumption is also adopted in [13] on type-4 wind weak grid interconnection modeling

Documents
Transient Stability in Low Frequency - DiVA portalltu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:999647/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Transient Stability in Low Frequency ... Using AT catenary system involves

Transient Stability in Low Frequency - DiVA portalltu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:999647/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Transient Stability in Low Frequency ... Using AT catenary system involves

Documents
Transient Schr¶dinger-Poisson Simulations of a High-Frequency

Transient Schr¶dinger-Poisson Simulations of a High-Frequency

Documents
Transient and Frequency Response By Lorenzo Canadilla and Jackson Beveridge

Transient and Frequency Response By Lorenzo Canadilla and Jackson Beveridge

Documents
Transient Surge Suppressor - ptsi.co.za · PDF fileZORC Transient Surge Suppressor The ZORC is a unique, high frequency transient overvoltage surge suppressor for the protection of

Transient Surge Suppressor - ptsi.co.za · PDF fileZORC Transient Surge Suppressor The ZORC is a unique, high frequency transient overvoltage surge suppressor for the protection of

Documents
A Communication-less Solution for Transient Frequency

A Communication-less Solution for Transient Frequency

Documents