Upload
mirko-farina
View
213
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
1/48
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
2/48
Todays Talk
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
3/48
The EMT is a viewabout the boundariesof mind and cognition
that envisions theemergence of extendedcognitive systemsthrough the coupledcombination of
externally locatedresources, bodilymanipulations, and in-the-head processing.
The Extended Mind Thesis
(EMT)
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
4/48
It allows for distributedrepresentations toexpand outward from
their cranial prison intothe environment and totranscend the boundariesof the cognitivearchitecture of the
biological cognizerthrough dynamicalcouplings, persistentinterweavements andcognitive loops.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
5/48
The pen and paper system is a cognitive systemon its own!
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
6/48
` The world is taken as a peripheral store of information. Suchinformation is however relevant to processes such as perceiving,remembering or reasoning.
` At least some mental states are hybrid, as they encompass bothinternal and external operations.
` The external operations take the form of actions that carryinformation crucial to the achievement of a given task.
` The internal machinery is concerned with providing agents with thecapability to effectively couple with a wide range of externalresources in an active environment.
(Rowlands, 2009)
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
7/48
` Extended cognition appears in one of these three territories(natural realm, technological domain, social sphere) or a
combination of two of them.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
8/48
Cognitive Systems recruit technologicaland artificial resources.
DedicatedCognitive Artefacts (such as laptops)
Special Equipments (SSDs)
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
9/48
SSDs a case of technologicalextension?
SSDs provide means ofexpanding cognition andperception towards new
horizons, in ways that wouldhave been impossible withoutthem. SSDs systematicallytransform our sensory experience,implementing our skills.
Such devices bring forth aconstitutive forms of perceptualsensorimotor interaction with theenvironment.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
10/48
PARITY BASED - largely relies onfunctionalism
COMPLEMENTARITY BASED -e si es t e C le e t r c tri ti
f i er ter res rces
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
11/48
If, as we confront sometask, a part of the worldfunctions as a processwhich, were it done in
the head, we would haveno hesitation in
recognizing as part of thecognitive process, thenthat part of the world is
(so we claim) part of thecognitive process. (Clark& Chalmers, 1998)
First Wave: Parity-Based
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
12/48
Parity Re-Stated .
Ifa) there is functional equality with respect to governing behaviour,
between the causal contribution of certain internal elements and thecausal contribution of certain external elements,
andb) the internal elements concerned qualify as the proper parts of acognitive trait,
then
c) there is no good reason to deny equivalentstatus that is, cognitive status to therelevant external elements.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
13/48
` Causal Constitutional Conflation
& Mark of the Cognitive
` Feasibility of EMT
` Functional Roles
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
14/48
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
15/48
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
16/48
Functional Roles
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
17/48
Quick Replies .
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
18/48
...Complementaritybetween what thebiological brain can doand what theenvironment provides,such that inner
processes and vehiclesand outer processesand vehicles worktogether to complete acognitive task
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
19/48
I endorse a
COMPLEMENTARITY -BASED version of theEMT
In my account, internaland external resources are
merged together anddeeply integrated into thecognitive system so as togive rise to augmented
occurrences.
My
View
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
20/48
It can be definedas the capacity ofthe brain tochange itsstructure andmodify itsfunctionsaccording toenvironmental
stimulation.
Whats Neural Plasticity?
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
21/48
It is the plasticity of ourbrain that in fact allowsfor the recruitment and
exploitation of bodily,technologically andenvironmentally locatedresources in problem-solving.
It is the plasticity of ourbrain that permits suchaugmented cognition toemerge.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
22/48
I argue that it is cortical plasticity thatenables this kind of deep and enrichedintegration. In other words, Plasticity is aprecondition for AugmentedCognition
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
23/48
Paul Bach-Y-Rita and Sensory
SubstitutionSSDs provide a niceexample of howcognition can be
augmented by tooluse in a way thatdirectly exploits theopportunismafforded by neuralplasticity.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
24/48
The vOICe
The vOICe is composedof a head-cameramounted on spysunglasses with a
viewing angle on theorder of 90-135 degrees.
The device is interfaced,through stereo earbuds,to a PCs USB port forboth the video signaland the cameras powersupply.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
25/48
It works by mapping livecamera images onto sounds.
......Object Localization
Form Recognition
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
26/48
Which sensory modality does the acquiredperception belong to?
Do they genuinely re-establish a lost sense? Dothey merely replace one sensory modality withanother?
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
27/48
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
28/48
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
29/48
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
30/48
Its not an Extended
Experience
Its not an Extended
Experience
Only CausalContribution!
Because the system isnot an integrated one
TOOLTOOL-USER
SYSTEM (detachedcomponents)
EMTIS FALSE!!!EMTIS FALSE!!!
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
31/48
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
32/48
A Stalemate !!!!!
I suspect, there has been nosatisfactory resolution of thisdispute in general. In theabsence ofsuch resolution, theclear danger for the extended
mind is one of stalemate.(Rowlands, op. Cit., 2009).
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
33/48
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
34/48
Why SSDs are different frommore mundane manipulations ??
eg when we learn to seeunderwater, or to ski??
In these cases too,info from severalmodalities is puttogether in newways determined by
the apparatus, andleads to distinctiveforms of experience!
In support of a tool-tool-useraccount of SSDs .......
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
35/48
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
36/48
Cortical activity in agiven area takes itsqualitative expression
from the character of itsnonstandard or newinput source. In thesecases, the qualitativeexpression of cortical
activity in that areachanges, deferring to thenew input source.(Hurley & No ,2003).
.To Set Up The Claim For ExtendedExperience and Augmentation
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
37/48
The vehicle of the experience isthe exploratory movements of theperceiver through which sensorycontent is generated.
The brain defers when theperceiver learns the SMCscharacteristic of vision.
SMCs are regularities in
sensory flow that relate tothe consequences ofmovement.
Movement generates regular patterns insensory flow and does so based on theperceivers interaction with theenvironment (by means of couplings).
Arguments for Deference [1/3]
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
38/48
Cortical deference isillustrated whencongenitally blindpersons read Braille.
During Braillereading, tactile stimuliactivate the visualcortex
In this case, the brain learnsthe SMCs characteristic ofBraille reading.
Arguments for Deference [2/3]
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
39/48
The SMCs will be the sensory consequences of tactile interactionwith Braille. The brain becomes tuned to these invariants.
These invariants arehowever regularities
that relate to theperceiver's interactionswith the environment.
The vehicles of experience will beextended across brain-body-and-world.
New (Vis l) Experience,nEXTENDED
EXPERIENCE !!!
Arguments for Deference [3/3]
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
40/48
In agreement with deference, I arguethat something changes in experience !
I dont buy everything fromdeference... I resist the ideathat substitution is a merereplacement!
A brief Recap
The Existence of Extended Experience is astrong argument against the embedded view!
and a possible rejoinder!
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
41/48
This enriched perceptionintimately augments our
perceptual abilities
My Hypothesis
It is more than a distinctiveexperience. Its an extended
one! SSDs give rise to novel,variant and unfamiliarsensorimotor contingencies.
It is a multimodal unionof senses, whose vehicles
encompass bodily,environmental and neural
components
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
42/48
Such devices should not be understood asmerely external stand-ins for already existing
purely internal processes (Auvray & Myin,op.Cit., 2009). They transform perception in aqualitative way.
Mind Enhancing
Tools?
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
43/48
In SSDperception we arenot merelyreplacinga sensethat a perceiverhas for a sense
they lack.
Through thecoupling of theperceiver and theSSD we generate anovel, andmultimodal formof perception.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
44/48
In SSD perception, sensorimotorcontingencies from vision, touchand audition are merged together toform a robust and coherent percept.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
45/48
Crucially, this cross-modal perception differsfrom any kind wenormally enjoy when weare not using an SSD.
SSDs count as a casefor augmentation.
Their constitutivecontribution radicallydiffers from that broughtforth by the organism.
Joint integration ofsenses!
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
46/48
After just four hours of initial training, we took a trip to Harvard Squarein Boston, MA. Using the sensory substitution device, I was able tonavigate crowded streets, stairs, and life in the world, all whileblindfolded. You would think that this process would impair my normalauditory capabilities, but I was able to successfully stop before walking
out into a busy road.
There came a point when the sensation the device gave me in the formof unfamiliar sounds turned into a perception of shapes and colours,which was separate and distinct from normal auditory information, such
as the sound of cars in city traffic.In a way you could think of it as, whenlearning a new word in a foreign language, there comes a point when you
cease to translate the word in your head every time you hear it, andinstead automatically understand its meaning.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
47/48
I put forward the thesis that SSDsmight give rise to what could becalled a kind of artificialsynaesthesia.
8/8/2019 Talk - PhiloNeuro 2010
48/48
Prof.Andy CLARK1,Dr. Julian KIVERSTEIN1
,Dr. Till Vierkant1, Prof. John Sutton2,Prof. Leslie Marsh3, Prof. Erik Myin4
1School of Philosophy, Psychology and Language Sciences, University of Edinburgh.2Macquarie Centre for Cognitive Science, Macquarie University Sydney.
3 The New England Institute for Cognitive Science and Evolutionary Studies.4University of Antwerp.