Table of Contents Annual Report.pdf · adversary system of criminal justice, any person haled into court, who is too poor to hire a lawyer, cannot be assured a fair trial unless counsel

Table of Contents Public Defender Services .............................................................................................................................. 1

The Executive Director’s Page ................................................................................................................... 1

Agency Contact Information .................................................................................................................... 2

Historical Overview ................................................................................................................................... 3

Organizational Overview ........................................................................................................................... 5

Financial Data .......................................................................................................................................... 10

Division Reports ......................................................................................................................................... 14

Voucher Processing ................................................................................................................................. 16

Public Defender Corporations ................................................................................................................. 17

Criminal Law Research Center ................................................................................................................ 18

Appellate Advocacy Division ................................................................................................................... 21

Indigent Defense Commission Report .................................................................................................... 21

Public Defender Corporation Narratives ................................................................................................... 22

Appointed Counsel & Public Defender Statistical Summary .................................................................... 45

Appendix A: Appointed Counsel Statistics ............................................................................................... 48

Hours Paid By Case Type ......................................................................................................................... 53

Fees Paid By Case Type ........................................................................................................................... 58

Expenses Paid By Case Type .................................................................................................................... 65

Expenses Paid By Category ..................................................................................................................... 70

Hours Paid In Court/Out Of Court ........................................................................................................... 75

Claims Paid Without Supplemental or Direct Expenses ......................................................................... 80

Average Cost By Case Type .................................................................................................................... 85

Average Per Charge ................................................................................................................................ 89

Appendix B: Public Defender Corporations Statistics .............................................................................. 93

Grants to Public Defender Corporations ................................................................................................. 94

Public Defender Corporation Attorney Time ......................................................................................... 95

Total Cases Closed ................................................................................................................................... 97

Appendix C: Appointed Counsel/Public Defender Corporation Comparisons ........................................ 99

Appendix D: Appointed Counsel Listing of Payee Totals ....................................................................... 120

Fees & Expenses Paid by Payee Total Claims in Descending Order ...................................................... 121

Fees & Expenses Paid by Payee Total Claims in Alphabetical Order .................................................... 138

Appendix E: Historical Overview of Key Statistical Indicators ............................................................... 155

THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR’S PAGE

The end of Fiscal Year 2013-2014 coincides with the end of the first year of my tenure asExecutive Director of Public Defender Services. I remain grateful to the Honorable Earl RayTomblin, Governor of the State of West Virginia, for the opportunity to serve the interests of thecitizens of the State of West Virginia, especially those citizens who are facing the loss of theirliberty but who cannot afford to retain the services of legal counsel.

The agency’s accomplishments in the past fiscal year include:

1. The processing of 34,054 vouchers for the payment of court-approved fees for thelegal services of appointed counsel in the total amount of $25,541,762;

2. The management of grants to 17 public defender corporations employing 133 fulltime public defenders throughout the state;

3. The hosting of an annual conference which was attended by 155 attorneys;

4. The publication of newsletters providing criminal defense attorneys with summariesof the opinions of the state’s highest court and with other legal information;

5. The activation, at no cost to the state, of an appellate advocacy division with 4appellate attorneys who address issues of constitutional significance arising out of aneligible client’s proceedings; and

6. The utilization of an online voucher system enabling the agency to reduce theprocessing time for the payment of vouchers and to generate reports detailinganomalies, if any, in an attorney’s billing.

The agency has set as its goals for the FY2015 the operation of a public defendercorporation in the Fourth Judicial Circuit; the review of the state’s system for delivery of legalservices by the Indigent Defense Commission; and the promulgation of legislative rules thatprovide clear guidelines for the submission of vouchers.

Moreover, the agency is determined in FY2015 to reconnect with the over 800 panelattorneys in the state who serve as counsel for indigent criminal defendants or other personsfacing prosecution by the state. The agency wants to be viewed as a support system for theseattorneys and not just the bureaucratic hurdle that must be cleared in order to receive payment oftheir legal fees.

But, again, with respect to FY2014, ending June 30, 2014, Public Defender Servicesissues the following report of its activities.

Respectfully,

Dana F. EddyExecutive Director

Public Defender Services Page 1 of 156

FY 2014 Annual Report

AGENCY CONTACT INFORMATION

Dana F. Eddy, Esq. Executive DirectorBetsy Chapman Executive Assistant

Donald L. Stennett, Esq. Deputy Director

One Players Club Drive, Suite 301Charleston, WV 25311

Phone: (304) 558-3905Fax: (304) 558-1098

Criminal Law Research CenterPam Clark Coordinator

Appellate DivisionCrystal Walden DirectorMatthew Brummond Appellate CounselJason Parmer Appellate CounselLori Waller Appellate CounselLeah Barker ParalegalSarah Saul ParalegalRhonda Ashworth Secretary

Accounting and Auditing DivisionMarjorie Wilson DirectorJonathan Friley PDC AdministratorTeresa Asbury SupervisorHeather Atkins Accounting TechnicianRosa McFarland Accounting TechnicianRachel Flynn Accounting TechnicianKimberly Bennett Accounting Technician

OperationsDonald L. Stennett DirectorJackie Linthicome ReceptionistLee Carper Office Manager

Special ProjectsSheila Coughlin Coordinator



PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESHistorical Overview

1. The State of West Virginia’s Constitutional Obligation.

Over fifty years ago, the Supreme Court of the United States recognized that:

[R]eason and reflection require us to recognize that in ouradversary system of criminal justice, any person haled into court,who is too poor to hire a lawyer, cannot be assured a fair trialunless counsel is provided for him. This seems to us to be anobvious truth. Governments, both state and federal, quite properlyspend vast sums of money to establish machinery to try defendantsaccused of crime. Lawyers to prosecute are everywhere deemedessential to protect the public’s interest in an orderly society. …The right of one charged with crime to counsel may not be deemedfundamental and essential to fair trials in some countries, but it isin ours. From the very beginning, our state and nationalconstitutions and laws have laid great emphasis on procedural andsubstantive safeguards designed to assure fair trials beforeimpartial tribunals in which every defendant stands equal beforethe law. This noble idea cannot be realized if the poor mancharged with crime has to face his accusers without a lawyer toassist him.

Gideon v. Wainwright, 372 U.S. 335, 344, 83 S.Ct. 792 (1963). With this decision, the SupremeCourt of the United States extended the Sixth Amendment guarantee of the assistance of counselin criminal prosecutions to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment. Essentially, states hadto provide counsel for persons who were too poor to pay for legal services when these personswere confronted with criminal charges or the loss of other important rights by reason of stateaction.

The Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia reaffirmed this constitutional mandateas follows:

“There can be no equal justice where the kind of trial a man getsdepends on the amount of money he has. ...” Griffin v. Illinois,351 U.S. 12, 76 S.Ct. 585, 100 L.Ed. 891 (1956). … The statemust, as a matter of equal protection, provide indigents with thebasic tools for an adequate defense or appeal, when those tools areavailable for a price to others.

State v. England, 363 S.E.2d 725, 727 (W. Va. 1987). Accordingly, a defense must be providedto indigent defendants and the defense must include not only the services of the attorney, but theprovision of other services and material, including the transcripts of proceedings. Id.



2. The Legislative Findings.

In 1981, the following was codified at W. Va. Code §29-21-1:

The Legislature finds and declares that in certain proceedings thestate is required to provide high quality legal assistance to indigentpersons who would be otherwise unable to afford adequate legalcounsel; that providing legal representation to those who face aneconomic barrier to adequate legal counsel will serve the ends ofjustice in accordance with rights and privileges guaranteed to allcitizens by the Constitution of the United States of America andthe constitution of the state of West Virginia; that the availabilityof quality legal assistance reaffirms the faith of our citizens in ourgovernment of laws; that the present system which utilizesappointed counsel is not operating satisfactorily in some areas ofthis state and the Legislature is presently unable to determine whatsystem or systems will provide the most efficient means forproviding legal representation; that there is a need to explorealternative methods of delivering legal assistance, including theuse of salaried public defenders complemented by private panelattorneys; that innovative programs and pilot projects as well as acontinuation of the present appointed counsel system are necessaryin separate areas of the state to provide information and experienceupon which to base future legislative action.

The West Virginia Public Legal Services Council was then created “for the purpose offacilitating required legal representation of indigent persons.” W. Va. Code §29-21-3 (1981;superseded in 1989).

In 1989, the agency was renamed as Public Defender Services and was charged asfollows:

The agency shall have as its principal purpose the development andimprovement of programs by which the state provides legalrepresentation to indigent persons.

W. Va. Code §29-21-4. This remains the agency’s charge.



PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAn Organizational Overview

VISION: “There can be no equal justice where the kind of trial a man gets depends on the amount of money hehas.”

Griffin v. Illinois, 351 U.S. 12 (1956)

MISSION STATEMENT: To fulfill the State of West Virginia’s constitutional obligation toprovide quality legal assistance to persons who otherwise could not afford legal counsel inproceedings in which the person’s liberty interests are at stake.

ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE:

Public Defender Services is within the Department of Administration for the State ofWest Virginia. The chief administrative officer is the Executive Director, who is appointed bythe governor.

The agency has three divisions.

The Accounting and Auditing Division is charged with the following responsibilities:

The agency shall establish and the executive director or his or herdesignee shall operate an accounting and auditing division torequire and monitor the compliance with this article by publicdefender corporations and other persons or entities receivingfunding or compensation from the agency. The accounting andauditing division shall review all plans and proposals for grantsand contracts and shall make a recommendation of approval ordisapproval to the executive director. The accounting and auditingdivision shall prepare, or cause to be prepared, reports concerningthe evaluation, inspection or monitoring of public defendercorporations and other grantees, contractors, persons or entitiesreceiving financial assistance under this article and shall furthercarry out the agency's responsibilities for records and reports as setforth in section eighteen of this article. The accounting andauditing division shall require each public defender corporation tosubmit financial statements monthly and to report monthly on thebillable and nonbillable time of its professional employees,including time used in administration of the respective offices, soas to compare the time to similar time expended in nonpublic lawoffices for similar activities. The accounting and auditing divisionshall provide to the executive director assistance in the fiscaladministration of all of the agency's divisions. This assistance shallinclude, but not be limited to, budget preparation and statisticalanalysis.

W. Va. Code §29-21-6(d).



The Accounting and Auditing Division also contains the voucher processing staff thatprocesses for payment the vouchers which are submitted by private attorneys who acceptappointments in eligible proceedings, which are defined as follows:

Criminal charges which may result in incarceration; juvenileproceedings; proceedings to revoke parole or probation if therevocation may result in incarceration; contempt of court; childabuse and neglect proceedings which may result in a termination ofparental rights; mental hygiene commitment proceedings;extradition proceedings; proceedings which are ancillary to aneligible proceeding, including, but not limited to, proceedings toenhance sentences brought pursuant to sections eighteen andnineteen, article eleven, chapter sixty-one of this code, forfeitureproceedings brought pursuant to article seven, chapter sixty-a ofthis code, and proceedings brought to obtain extraordinaryremedies; and appeals from or post-conviction challenges to thefinal judgment in an eligible proceeding. Legal representationprovided pursuant to the provisions of this article is limited to thecourt system of the state of West Virginia, but does not includerepresentation in municipal courts unless the accused is at risk ofincarceration ….

W. Va. Code §29-21-2(2).

The Criminal Law Research Center is another division of the agency which has thefollowing statutory charge:

(1) Undertake research, studies and analyses and act as a centralrepository, clearinghouse and disseminator of research materials;(2) Prepare and distribute a criminal law manual and othermaterials and establish and implement standard and specializedtraining programs for attorneys practicing criminal law;(3) Provide and coordinate continuing legal education programsand services for attorneys practicing criminal law; and(4) Prepare, supplement and disseminate indices and digests ofdecisions of the West Virginia supreme court of appeals and othercourts, statutes and other legal authorities relating to criminal law.

W. Va. Code §29-21-7.

Finally, the agency’s third division, the Appellate Advocacy Division is established asfollows:

The agency shall establish and the executive director or his or herdesignee shall operate an appellate advocacy division for thepurpose of prosecuting litigation on behalf of eligible clients in theSupreme Court of Appeals. The executive director or his or herdesignee shall be the director of the appellate advocacy division.The appellate advocacy division shall represent eligible clients



upon appointment by the circuit courts or by the Supreme Court ofAppeals. The division may, however, refuse the appointments dueto a conflict of interest or if the executive director has determinedthe existing caseload cannot be increased without jeopardizing theappellate division's ability to provide effective representation. Inorder to effectively and efficiently use the resources of theappellate division, the executive director may restrict the provisionof appellate representation to certain types of cases. The executivedirector may select and employ staff attorneys to perform theduties prescribed by this subsection. The appellate division shallmaintain records of representation of eligible clients for recordpurposes only.

W. Va. Code §29-21-6(e).

In addition to the agency’s divisions, the statutory framework for the agency includes twoadditional entities.

Indigent Defense Commission.

The first is the Indigent Defense Commission. Specifically,

(a) There is hereby established the Indigent Defense Commissionto provide assistance to Public Defender Services with regardto the general policies and procedures of the agency, including,but not limited to, the opening, closing or merging of publicdefender offices throughout the state and the establishment ofperformance measures for the qualitative review of indigentdefense.

(b) In order to demonstrate a collaborative approach to solvingcriminal justice problems, the commission shall consist of theExecutive Director of Public Defender Services, who shallserve as chair, and the following members appointed by theGovernor:

(1) One former or retired circuit judge;

(2) Three lawyers, one from each congressional district,who have significant experience in the defense ofcriminal cases or have demonstrated a strongcommitment to quality representation of indigentdefendants;

(3) One current chief public defender; and

(4) One nonlawyer with a demonstrated commitment toproviding legal services to the indigent;



(5) One person who is a member of an organization thatadvocates on behalf of people with mental illness anddevelopmental disabilities; and

(6) One attorney with significant experience in the defenseof juvenile delinquency and abuse and neglect cases.

(c) The commission shall meet at the times and places specified bythe call of the chair: Provided, That the commission shall meetno less than four times each year. Members shall serve withoutcompensation but may receive reimbursement of actual andnecessary expenses for each day or portion thereof engaged inthis discharge of official duties in a manner consistent with theguidelines of the Travel Management Office of the Departmentof Administration.…

(f) The commission has the following powers and duties:

(1) To develop standards regarding the qualifications andtraining for public defenders, assistant public defendersand staff;

(2) To explore opportunities related to the training ofappointed panel attorneys;

(3) To evaluate, on an annual basis, the compensation andcaseloads of public defenders and appointed panelattorneys;

(4) To develop standards for providing and compensatingexpert witnesses, investigators and other persons whoprovide services related to legal representation underthis article;

(5) To study, monitor and evaluate existing standards fordetermining eligibility for legal representation undersection sixteen of this article;

(6) To study the feasibility and need of creating additionalpublic defender corporations, the activation of publicdefender corporations and the formation of multicircuitor regional public defender corporations in accordancewith the provisions of section eight of this article;

(7) To study the potential for the dissolution of publicdefender corporations;

(8) To study, monitor, evaluate and make recommendationsregarding the training, experience and background



necessary for a public defender or panel attorney tocompetently represent indigent defendants in capitalcases; and

(9) To monitor and make recommendations regarding thefollowing activities of the board of directors of eachpublic defender corporation receiving funding pursuantto this article:

(A) The appointment of the public defender and anyassistant public defenders pursuant tosubdivision (1), subsection (c), section fifteen ofthis article;

(B) The fixing of professional and clerical salariespursuant to subdivision (2), subsection (c),section fifteen of this article; and

(C) The removal of any public defender, assistantpublic defender or other employee formisfeasance, malfeasance or nonfeasancepursuant to subdivision (3), subsection (c),section fifteen of this article.

W. Va. Code §29-21-3b.

Public Defender Corporations.

The second entity is the public defender corporation, which, if active within a judicialcircuit, is “to provide legal representation … in accordance with the provisions” of the governingstatute. W. Va. Code §29-21-8(a)(2).

For each public defender corporation, a board of directors is appointed. The chairpersonof the board is appointed by the governor. One to two members for each county in the judicialcircuit are appointed by the county commission. One to two additional members are appointedby each county bar association within the judicial circuit. The board selects a “chief” publicdefender who is then responsible for the delivery of legal services by the corporation. Unlessinconsistent with the governing statute, the provisions of the state’s nonprofit corporate lawsgovern the public defender corporations.



PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES

FINANCIAL DATA



00

10

10

09

94

35

35

27

88

91

3T

OT

AL

TO

TA

LA

PP

RO

PR

IAT

ION

S

2014

AP

PR

OP

RIA

TIO

NS

710,7

96.0

0$

303,9

22.0

0$

315,0

62.0

0$

19,8

01,2

66.0

0$

10,7

23,1

15.0

0$

4,2

16.0

0$

31,8

58,3

77.0

0$

ALT

ER

AT

ION

Str

ansfe

rto

Grievance

2/4

/14

(30,0

00.0

0)

$(3

0,0

00.0

0)

$

ALT

ER

AT

ION

Str

ansfe

rto

Eth

ics

5/2

2/1

4(7

0,0

00.0

0)

$(2

0,0

00.0

0)

$(9

0,0

00.0

0)

$

Reserv

e(

$20,0

00/0

01

&$150,0

00/3

52)

(20,0

00.0

0)

$(1

50,0

00.0

0)

$(1

70,0

00.0

0)

$

SU

PP

AP

PR

OP

rec

3/2

8/2

014

12,0

00,0

00.0

0$

12,0

00,0

00.0

0$

RE

AP

PR

OP

RIA

TIO

NS

4,9

19,9

59.9

0$

278.2

1$

4,9

20,2

38.1

1$

TO

TA

LF

UN

DA

PP

RO

PR

IAT

ION

S620,7

96.0

0$

253,9

22.0

0$

315,0

62.0

0$

16,9

19,9

59.9

0$

19,6

51,2

66.0

0$

10,7

23,3

93.2

1$

4,2

16.0

0$

48,4

88,6

15.1

1$

TO

TA

LE

XP

EN

DIT

UR

ES

PE

RS

ON

AL

SE

RV

ICE

S:

Pers

onalS

erv

ices

555,9

49.6

5$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

555,9

49.6

5$

AnnualIn

cre

ment

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

To

tal

Pers

on

al

Serv

ices

555,9

49.6

5$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

555,9

49.6

5$

EM

PL

OY

EE

BE

NE

FIT

S

PE

RS

/PE

IAA

dm

Fees

-$

3,7

30.0

0$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

3,7

30.0

0$

FIC

A-

$40,9

10.9

5$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

40,9

10.9

5$

Public

Em

plIn

sura

nce

-$

64,7

21.0

0$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

64,7

21.0

0$

Unem

plo

yment

Com

p-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$

Work

ers

Com

p-

$1,6

36.5

0$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

1,6

36.5

0$

Pensio

n&

Retire

ment

-$

79,5

30.2

8$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

79,5

30.2

8$

Public

Em

plo

yees

Insura

nce

Rese

rve

Tra

nsfe

r-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$

PE

IA-O

PE

BC

ontr

ibution

-$

27,6

32.0

0$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

27,6

32.0

0$

TO

TA

LB

EN

EF

ITS

-$

218,1

60.7

3$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

218,1

60.7

3$

FO

RT

HE

PE

RIO

DJU

LY

1,

2013

-JU

NE

30,

2014

aso

fJu

ly3

1,2

01

4

PU

BL

ICD

EF

EN

DE

RS

ER

VIC

ES

SU

MM

AR

YO

FA

PP

RO

PR

IAT

ION

S,

EX

PE

ND

ITU

RE

S,

AN

DF

UN

DB

AL

AN

CE

SB

YA

CT

IVIT

YF

OR

TH

EF

UN

D0226-2

014-0

221



CU

RR

EN

TE

XP

EN

SE

S:

020

Off

ice

Exp

ense

-$

-$

20,5

84.6

0$

-$

751.0

0$

-$

-$

21,3

35.6

0$

021

Printing

&B

indin

g-

$-

$52.4

8$

-$

-$

-$

-$

52.4

8$

022

Renta

lE

xpense

-$

-$

57,7

59.2

0$

-$

850.0

0$

-$

-$

58,6

09.2

0$

023

Utilit

ies

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

024

Tele

com

munic

ations

-$

-$

2,3

18.7

1$

-$

-$

-$

-$

2,3

18.7

1$

025

Contr

actu

al&

Pro

fessio

nal

-$

-$

1,0

64.0

0$

539,5

26.7

8$

16,9

94,7

86.6

3$

224,3

87.9

8$

-$

17,7

59,7

65.3

9$

026

Tra

vel

-$

-$

1,4

18.8

7$

-$

388.0

0$

-$

-$

1,8

06.8

7$

027

Com

pute

rS

erv

ices

-$

-$

134,0

67.2

9$

-$

34,4

67.5

0$

-$

-$

168,5

34.7

9$

029

Vehic

leR

enta

l-

$-

$480.0

0$

-$

(160.0

0)

$-

$-

$320.0

0$

030

Renta

l(M

achin

e&

Mis

c)

-$

-$

-$

-$

846.0

0$

-$

-$

846.0

0$

031

Assoc

Dues

&P

rof

Mem

bers

hip

s-

$-

$500.0

0$

-$

-$

-$

-$

500.0

0$

032

Fire,

Auto

,B

ond

&O

ther

Insura

nce

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

2,9

84.0

0$

2,9

84.0

0$

035

Advert

isin

g&

Pro

motion

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

038

Routine

Mtc

eC

ontr

acts

/Warr

anties

-$

-$

1,5

33.0

3$

-$

-$

-$

-$

1,5

33.0

3$

042

Hospitalit

y-

$-

$1,0

22.2

1$

-$

13,7

06.1

5$

-$

-$

14,7

28.3

6$

044

Energ

yE

xpense

-V

ehic

le/A

ircra

ft-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$-

$

052

Tra

inin

g&

Develo

pm

ent

-$

-$

16,0

63.3

6$

-$

-$

-$

-$

16,0

63.3

6$

053

Posta

l&

Fre

ight

-$

-$

15,4

84.9

3$

-$

15.0

0$

-$

-$

15,4

99.9

3$

054

Com

pute

rS

upplie

s&

Equip

ment

-$

-$

5,2

99.9

4$

-$

8,2

47.0

0$

-$

-$

13,5

46.9

4$

056

Att

orn

ey

LegalS

erv

ice

Paym

ents

-$

-$

-$

15,2

21,4

91.6

4$

-$

7,7

84,6

33.7

8$

-$

23,0

06,1

25.4

2$

057

Att

orn

ey

Reim

burs

able

Exp

enses

-$

-$

-$

888,0

29.9

0$

-$

475,8

81.2

0$

-$

1,3

63,9

11.1

0$

058

Mis

cella

neous

Equip

ment

Purc

hases

-$

-$

-$

-$

19,9

40.7

9$

-$

-$

19,9

40.7

9$

096

Oth

er

Inte

rest

&P

enaltie

s-

$-

$17.3

5$

-$

-$

-$

-$

17.3

5$

110

Public

Em

plo

yees

Insura

nce

Reserv

eT

ransfe

r-

$-

$5,4

97.0

0$

-$

-$

-$

-$

5,4

97.0

0$

156

Medic

alS

erv

ice

Paym

ents

-$

-$

-$

270,9

07.3

0$

-$

115,1

05.1

6$

-$

386,0

12.4

6$

175

Sta

teT

reasure

r's

Off

ice

Fees

-$

-$

60.0

0$

-$

-$

-$

-$

60.0

0$

TO

TA

LC

UR

RE

NT

EX

PE

NS

ES

-$

-$

263,2

22.9

7$

16,9

19,9

55.6

2$

17,0

73,8

38.0

7$

8,6

00,0

08.1

2$

2,9

84.0

0$

42,8

60,0

08.7

8$

RE

PA

IRS

&A

LT

ER

AT

ION

S

068

Oth

er

Repairs

and

Altera

tions

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

TO

TA

LR

EP

AIR

S&

AL

TE

RA

TIO

NS

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

AS

SE

TS

077

Books

&P

eriodic

als

-$

-$

3,9

60.4

9$

-$

-$

-$

-$

3,9

60.4

9$

170

Com

pute

rE

quip

ment

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

-$

TO

TA

LA

SS

ET

S-

$-

$3,9

60.4

9$

-$

-$

-$

-$

3,9

60.4

9$

TO

TA

LF

UN

DE

XP

EN

DIT

UR

ES

555,9

49.6

5$

218,1

60.7

3$

267,1

83.4

6$

16,9

19,9

55.6

2$

17,0

73,8

38.0

7$

8,6

00,0

08.1

2$

2,9

84.0

0$

43,6

38,0

79.6

5$

FU

ND

BA

LA

NC

E64,8

46.3

5$

35,7

61.2

7$

47,8

78.5

4$

4.2

8$

2,5

77,4

27.9

3$

2,1

23,3

85.0

9$

1,2

32.0

0$

4,8

50,5

35.4

6$



Public Defender Services

Statement of Revenues, Expenditures,

and Changes in Fund Balance

For the Period July 1, 2013 to June 30, 20142420-2013-0221

REVENUES

Sales of Publications $100.00

Continuing Legal Education $6,210.00DVD/VIDEO Sales (with CLE) $200.00

TOTAL REVENUES $6,510.00

EXPENDITURES

021 Office Supplies $0.00021 Printing & Binding $0.00

022 Rent (Seminar Room Rentals) $523.50026 Travel $0.00

029 Vehicle Rental $200.00

030 Equipment Rental (Seminars) $48.40

031 Assoc Dues & Prof Memberships $500.00

042 Hospitality (Seminars) $252.29

044 Energy Expense $0.00053 Postage & Freight $0.00

TOTAL EXPENDITURES $1,524.19

Revenues Over (Under) Expenditures $4,985.81

Fund Balance Beginning of Period $25,992.45

Fund Balance, June 30, 2013 $30,978.26

2421-2013-0221

Fund Balance Beginning of Period $0.00

Add: Consumer Sales Tax Collections $6.00

Less: Remittance of Taxes $0.00Fund Balance, June 30, 2014 $6.00 $6.00




DIVISION REPORTS

Public Defender ServicesPage 14 of 156


[PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]

Public Defender ServicesPage 15 of 159


AUDITING AND ACCOUNTING DIVISION:VOUCHER PROCESSING

In FY2014, the staff of the voucher processing function travelled throughout the state,from Wheeling to Lewisburg, to train over one hundred attorneys, at no cost, on the use of theagency’s online voucher system.

FY 2014: Public Defender Services Vouchers PaidJuly 1, 2013 through June 30, 2014

Dollar Amount Paid Number of Vouchers

July 2013 $ 1,343,053.61 1,800

August 2013 $ 2,445,508.73 3,499

September 2013 $ 1,667,348.34 2,408

October 2013 $ 1,843,522.43 2,101

November 2013 $ 1,580,725.98 1,943

December 2013 $ 1,426,279.81 2,146

January 2014 $ 2,211,971.75 2,792

February 2014 $ 2,187,048.27 3,012

March 2014 $ 2,222,675.13 2,871

April 2014 $ 2,472,851.18 3,231

May 2014 $ 2,742,114.07 3,663

June 2014 $ 3,398,662.77 4,588

TOTAL $ 25,541,762.07 34,054

Pictured: Heather Atkins, Claims Processor, pulling vouchers for a single day.



AUDITING AND ACCOUNTING DIVISION:PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS

For Fiscal Year 2014, there were seventeen public defender corporations serving eighteenjudicial circuits (see subsequent table below). Although Public Defender Services establishesstrategic objectives for the delivery of legal services to indigents in eligible proceedings, publicdefender corporations are not subordinate divisions of this agency, but are autonomous quasi-governmental entities. The Internal Revenue Code classifies these organizations as non-profit(see 26USC501) and as a public charity (see 26USC509). In essence, employees of the publicdefender corporations are neither employees of Public Defender Services nor employees of theState of West Virginia, but are employees of a specific non-profit organization governed by aboard of directors appointed by the Governor, local bar associations, and county commissions.

Summary of Activated Public Defender CorporationsSee W.Va. Code § 29-21-8

Circuit Fiscal Year Office Locations1st 1990 Wheeling & Weirton

2nd Before 1991 Moundsville5th 1996 Ripley & Spencer

6th & 24th 1995 Huntington & Wayne7th 1991 Logan

8th 1990 Welch9th 1991 Princeton

10th Before 1991 Beckley11th 2000 Lewisburg & Marlinton

12th 1990 Fayetteville13th 1990 Charleston15th 1994 Clarksburg18th 2001 Kingwood

23rd Before 1991 Martinsburg & Charles Town25th 2000 Madison & Hamlin28th Before 1991 Summersville30th 1990 Williamson

For Fiscal Year 2014, Public Defender Services made grants in the amount of$17,030,817 to and on behalf of the Public Defender Corporations. In return for these grants, thePublic Defender Corporations reported 259,737.9 attorney hours and 33,354 closed cases. Thisrepresents approximately $65.57 per hour and $510.61 per closed case. However, reducing theattorney time by the 70,132.8 hours reported as administrative time, the cost per hour increasesto $83.53 with no effect to the overall cost per case.



CRIMINAL LAW RESEARCH CENTER

In the FY2014, the Criminal Law Research Center provided the following legal seminarsto public defenders, at no cost, and to private attorneys at a substantially lower cost thancommercial providers:

Winning the Eyewitness Identification case(sponsored by the Public Defender Corporation for the 6th/24th Judicial Circuits)

Charleston, WV November 8, 2013 Ira MickenbergMartinsburg, WV December 4, 2013 Ira Mickenberg

Forty-four (44) attorneys attended these conferences. 3.4 credits of continuing legaleducation were earned by the attorneys in attendance.

Ethics of Billing(sponsored by Public Defender Services)

State Capitol, WV Morning, December 2, 2013 Dana F. EddyDuane C. Rosenlieb, Jr.

Afternoon, December 2, 2013 Dana F. EddyDuane C. Rosenlieb, Jr.

Lewisburg, WV March 11, 2014 Dana F. EddyDonald L. Stennett

Clarksburg, WV March 13, 2014 Dana F. EddyDonald L. Stennett

Wheeling, WV March 18, 2014 Dana F. EddyDonald L. Stennett

Martinsburg, WV April 22, 2014 Dana F. Eddy

Parkersburg, WV May 7, 2014 Dana F. EddyDonald L. Stennett

One hundred and nineteen (119) attorneys attended these conferences. 3.0 credits ofcontinuing legal education in ethics were earned by the attorneys in attendance.

New Attorney Training(sponsored by the Public Defender Corporation for the 6th/24th Judicial Circuits)

Charleston, WV February 20, 2014 Diana PanucciIra Mickenberg

Ten (10) attorneys attended the training. 10.8 credits of continuing legal education wereearned by the attorneys in attendance.



Motion to Suppress Statements and Confessions(sponsored by the Public Defender Corporation for the 6th/24th Judicial Circuits)

Huntington, WV March 20, 2014 Ira Mickenberg

Thirty-seven (37) attorneys attended the training. 4.8 credits of continuing legaleducation were earned by the attorneys in attendance.

Ethics(sponsored by the Public Defender Corporation for the 6th/24th Judicial Circuits)

Beckley, WV May 7, 2014 Ira Mickenberg

Public Defender Services’ 2014 Annual Conference

Oglebay ResortWheeling, WV June 12 -13, 2014

The Criminal Law Research Center organized the agency’s annualconference, to which public defenders and private counsel engaged incriminal defense were invited.

The topics included:

Opening Remarks, Cedric Greene, Deputy Secretary of theDepartment of Administration;

West Virginia Supreme Court Cases – Summary and Analysis,Dana F. Eddy, Executive Director, Public Defender Services;

Ten Mistakes Made by Defense Counsel, the Honorable Paul T.Farrell, Judge of the 6th Judicial Circuit, West Virginia, andCharles T. Miller, Assistant Prosecutor, Kanawha County, WestVirginia, moderated by Donald L. Stennett, Deputy Director,Public Defender Services;

Juvenile Issues: The Role of Counsel, Diana Panucci, ManagingDeputy Public Defender, and Jason Nicholas, Assistant PublicDefender, Public Defender Corporation for the Thirteenth JudicialCircuit;

The Innocence Project, Karen Newirth, Senior Fellow, StrategicLitigation Unit, Innocence Project & Valena Beety, AssociateProfessor of Law, WVU College of Law;

Ethics Update, Dana F. Eddy, Executive Director, PublicDefender Services;

Preserving the Record, Recurring Issues in the Appellate Process,Appellate Advocacy Division, Public Defender Services;

Recent US Supreme Court Decisions, Ira Mickenberg, AdjunctProfessor of Law, University of Dayton School of Law;



Constitutionality of the Sex Offender Registry, Wayne Logan,Professor, Florida State University School of Law; and

Search and Seizure, Jonathan Byrne, Federal Public Defender,Southern District of West Virginia.

At the annual conference, the inaugural John A. “Jack” Rogers Awardfor Outstanding Leadership in Public Service was awarded to itsnamesake, John A. “Jack” Rogers. The inaugural Award for OutstandingScholarship in Criminal Law was awarded to Ira Mickenberg.

The Criminal Law Research Center also published in FY2014 the Legislative Watchwhich tracked legislation introduced during the 2014 Legislative Session relating to criminal lawor criminal defense. Eight (8) issues were published, including a final “windup” in which allrelevant legislation that was enacted into law was discussed. Ronni Sheets, a Managing DeputyPublic Defender with the Public Defender Corporation for the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit and theChair of the Subcommittee on Legislative Oversight which is within the State Bar’s CriminalLaw Committee, was a major contributor to the publications and was the author of the final“windup” issue.

The Criminal Law Research Center also published four (4) newsletters that addressedgeneral issues affecting the criminal defense practice, discussed specific issues affecting theoperations of Public Defender Services, and provided summaries of relevant decisions of theSupreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia and the Supreme Court of the United States.

The Criminal Law Research Center continues to maintain a library of material that isavailable to practitioners throughout the state. The material is listed on the agency’s website atwww.pds.wv.org.



APPELLATE ADVOCACY DIVISION

The appellate advocacy division has historically been comprised of one appellate counsel.During FY2014, Public Defender Services reviewed the structure of its appellate advocacydivision in light of the statutory mandate that the “agency shall establish and the executivedirector or his designee shall operate an appellate advocacy division for the purpose ofprosecuting litigation on behalf of eligible clients in the Supreme Court of Appeals.” W. Va.Code §29-21-6(e). Public Defender Services determined that the resolution of importantconstitutional issues on behalf of eligible clients throughout the state could be better achieved bycentralization of appellate counsel in the agency.

Accordingly, the agency determined that, effective July 1, 2014, the appellate counsel inthe public defender corporations who were funded from the agency’s appropriations would behoused within the agency and would become state employees. This relocation of the appellatecounsel is to be done without any additional cost to the State of West Virginia.

The agency has adopted the following as the mission for this division upon itscommencement of operations in FY2015:

Public Defender Services, through its appellate advocacy division,shall take appointments to prosecute appeals in the Supreme Courtof Appeals of West Virginia or the Supreme Court of the UnitedStates on behalf of eligible clients when the appeals presentcompelling procedural or constitutional issues having broadapplication to criminal defendants generally and requiring,therefore, extensive scholarship and zealous advocacy.

Upon the activation of this appellate advocacy division, the agency shall correspond with thecircuit courts within the State of West Virginia to outline the manner in which appointments ofmatters to the appellate advocacy division will be made.

INDIGENT DEFENSE COMMISSION REPORT

The Indigent Defense Commission did not meet in FY2014. The terms of the membersof the Commission had expired. The Executive Director is committed to the reinvigoration ofthe Commission. The anticipation is that in FY2015 the Commission will be reconstituted andthe Commission will review the state’s delivery of legal services to its indigent citizens incriminal proceedings in accordance with its statutory mandate. See W. Va. Code §29-21-3b.



PUBLIC DEFENDER

CORPORATIONS



PD CORPORATIONS BOARD OF DIRECTOR’S CHAIRPERSONSCIRCUIT COUNTIES CHAIRS

1ST BROOKE KAREN E. KAHLE, ESQ. CHAIRHANCOCK WHEELING, WVOHIO

2ND MARSHALL VICKI VOORHIS, CHAIRTYLER NEW MARTINSVILLE, WVWETZEL

5TH CALHOUN JEANETTE ATKINSON, CHAIRJACKSON SPENCER, WVMASONROANE

6TH/24TH CABELL JOHN F. CYRUS, ESQ., CHAIRWAYNE HUNTINGTON, WV

7TH LOGAN DON WANDLING, ESQ., CHAIRLOGAN, WV

8TH MCDOWELL RONALD HASSAN, ESQ., CHAIRWELCH, WV

9TH MERCER WILLIAM O. HUFFMAN, ESQ., CHAIRPRINCETON, WV

10TH RALEIGH JANE CALVERT, CHAIRCRAB ORCHARD, WV

11TH GREENBRIER A. DAVID SMITH, CHAIRPOCAHONTAS RONCEVERTE, WV

12TH FAYETTE FREDERICK H. JESSER, III, ESQ., CHAIRFAYETTEVILLE, WV

13TH KANAWHA LONNIE SIMMONS, ESQ., CHAIRCHARLESTON, WV

15TH HARRISON GEORGE F. FORDHAM, ESQ., CHAIRCLARKSBURG, WV

18TH PRESTON CHARLES BROWN, ESQ., CHAIRKINGWOOD, WV

23RD BERKELEY JAMES CRAWFORD III, ESQ., CHAIRJEFFERSON CHARLES TOWN, WVMORGAN



PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS BOARD CHAIRS CONTINUEDCIRCUIT COUNTIES CHAIRS

25TH BOONE JAMES HENSLEY, CHAIRLINCOLN DANVILLE, WV

28TH NICHOLAS MALCOLM F. VAUGHAN, ESQ., CHAIRSUMMERSVILLE, WV

30TH MINGO JANE MORAN, ESQ., CHAIRWILLIAMSON, WV



Public Defender Corporation for the First Judicial Circuit

Under the direction of our nine-member Board of Directors, the First Judicial CircuitPublic Defender Corporation is a client focused non-profit organization operating in the NorthernPanhandle of West Virginia. In order to meet the demands of the four judges and ten magistrateslocated in our tri-county circuit, we employ a diverse collection of nine full time attorneysrepresenting approximately 168 years of combined legal experience. Our attorneys aresupported through five non-lawyer staff associates with 62 years of dedicated service. Ourattorneys and staff are split among two offices located in Wheeling and Weirton.

Our primary mission is the direct representation of indigent citizens accused by thegovernment of crimes against the state. We do this well—everyone knows what we bring! Oursecondary mission focuses on preserving the Rule of Law.

Gideon correctly states that attorneys are not luxuries but necessities. Since thebeginning of FY 2014, the Corporation has opened over 3367 cases. Fiscal Year 2013demonstrates the objective contribution of our Corporation to the efficient provision of legalservices. Appointed to 87% of misdemeanors and 60% of felonies, our corporation yielded acost per case averaging approximately $514.14. Compared with the private panelappointments—averaging $1,090.04 per case—these raw numbers provide the best evidence ofour cost effectiveness.1 In addition to the above, the Corporation, by Circuit Courtappointment, also represents citizens in municipal court, parole/probation revocations, juvenilematters, abuse and neglect proceedings, as well as other miscellaneous matters involvingjeopardized freedom.

To be clear, cost-saving measures are not the true measure of our effectiveness. Thathonor belongs to our performance. By way of example, our last seven trials by jury have yieldedfour acquittals. Our Corporation takes pride in the competent delivery of legal services to ourclients. Collectively, our board, attorneys and support staff are the Corporation. We are alearning organization—combining experience, talent, and advocacy—collectively aimed towardsassisting the indigent accused through the legal and regulatory minefield. Equally important, weare vested in the community we serve. Our employees are military veterans, members of localboards, former elected officials, community volunteers, and active in community events.

Our dedication to the rule of law shapes our end state—that is, our well-earned reputationas an obstacle on the road to tyranny. We are the quiet guardians of liberty.

Shayne M. Welling, Chief Public Defender

1 Source: http://www.pds.wv.gov/Pages/FY-Annual-Reports.aspx



Public Defender Corporation for the Second Judicial Circuit

Based upon information found in the 1984 Annual Report of the West Virginia PublicLegal Services Council (forerunner to PDS) our office was one of the very first Public DefenderCorporations in the State. It was closely followed by, or was perhaps opened at about the sametime, as the corporations in the Twenty-Third Circuit (Berkeley County/Martinsburg) and theTwenty-Eighth Circuit (Summers County/Summersville). Shortly thereafter an office wasopened in Kanawha County to provide representation in juvenile cases only.

Over the years many attorneys have left this office and went on to successful privatepractices. Others have left to become county and/or federal prosecutors. As the Chief PublicDefender, I have served on the Northern Panhandle Community Criminal Justice Board. Ouroffice fully utilizes the services provided by the Lee Day Report Center in Moundsville as wellas the Pre-Trial Release evaluations provided by Dave Taylor who works with the Center.According to the most recent report of the Drug Court Program there were twenty-twoindividuals currently involved or pending admission, sixteen of which are represented by ouroffice.

Dave Zehnder, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Fifth Judicial Circuit

The Public Defender Corporation for the Fifth Judicial Circuit held its first board meetingon July 31st, 1996. Our office covers Calhoun, Roane, and Jackson counties. Our office consistsof three support staff and seven lawyers, including our Chief Public Defender, Kevin Postalwait.

Our goal is to provide high quality legal assistance to indigent persons who would beotherwise unable to afford adequate legal counsel; to provide legal representation to those whoface an economic barrier to adequate legal counsel that will serve the ends of justice inaccordance with rights and privileges guaranteed to all citizens by the constitution of the UnitedStates of America and the constitution of the state of West Virginia; and to make availablequality legal assistance that reaffirms the faith of our citizens in our government of laws.

Our objective is to protect the ordinary citizen from wrongful conviction and to protectthe basic and fundamental rights of all citizens by navigating those individuals charged withcrimes through an evolving and complex legal system. We provide appointed counsel in felony,misdemeanor, abuse & neglect, juvenile delinquency, juvenile status offenses, family courtcontempt when jail is contemplated, and mental hygiene proceedings.

Community Involvement

Currently, Kevin is an adjunct criminal law instructor at West Virginia University atParkersburg, Jackson County campus, one night per week. He is also on the CommunityCorrections Board for Wood and Jackson counties. In addition, a drug court is beingimplemented in Roane County in the very near future and Kevin or another designated assistantattorney will be on the treatment team for the Roane County Drug Court program.

One of our assistant public defenders is actively involved in the Ravenswood communitygarden program, and also attends meetings for the various boards that oversee the funding forcommunity programs in the Ravenswood area.

Additionally, one of our administrative assistants is active in the 4H program in RoaneCounty, and is also a very active member of the Spencer Volunteer Fire Department. Anotheradministrative assistant is actively involved in coordinating beauty pageants and other activitiesto help young women receive college tuition assistance including grants and scholarships.

Kevin Postalwait, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Sixth and Twenty-Fourth JudicialCircuits

The Public Defender Corporation for the Sixth and Twenty-Fourth Judicial Circuits wasfounded on July 1, 1994. Historically, we have had one of the largest caseloads in the state. InFiscal Year 2014 the Huntington office closed 3,962 cases and the Wayne office closed 922cases. There are eleven attorneys in Huntington and three in Wayne. Our office has been activein helping establish and maintain Juvenile Drug Courts in both counties, Adult Drug Courts inboth counties, Truancy Courts in both counties, Day Report Centers in both counties, a VeteransTreatment Court in Wayne County, and a Pre-Trial Release Board in Cabell County.

Our Chief Defender, Bob Wilkinson, serves on the Community Correctionssubcommittee of the Governor’s Committee on Crime, Delinquency and Corrections and theSupreme Court’s Court Improvement Program Board. Our attorneys have given trainingpresentations for the annual cross training events on Abuse and Neglect and Juvenile lawsponsored by the Supreme Court for the past five years. They have also done training for newProbation Officers.

Last year, our office and Public Defender Services cosponsored continuing educationprograms by Ira Mickenberg in Huntington, Beckley, Charleston and Wheeling.

Over the years we have had several attorneys named Public Defender of the Year theywere: Bob Wilkinson (97); Kimberly Campbell [now Carico] (99); Kit Thornton (2000); AshleyLockwood (04); Paul Jordan (06); Larry Lewis (11); Virginia Weed and Jerry Henderson (13).Public Defender Support Staff of the Year recipients include: Lisa Osburn [now Amorim](03);Vickii Hughes (05); and Amy Hatfield [now Souther] (08). David Lockwood, a member of ourBoard of Directors since its inception 20 years ago, was honored for his Contributions to thePublic Defender System in 2005.

Bob Wilkinson, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Seventh Judicial Circuits

The Public Defender Corporation for the Seventh Judicial Circuit serves Logan Countyand was formed on or about November 28, 1989. Over this twenty five (25) year commitment toserving our community, we have consistently increased the level of services provided to LoganCounty.

We have most recently played key roles in the development of the crucial servicesprovided to the poor suffering severe drug addiction. As Managing Public Defender I was on theoriginal team that formed and planned the Adult Drug Court and Juvenile Drug Courts that arefunctioning and routinely graduating people. These men and women with spouses and childrenwould otherwise be in prison or dead of a drug overdose but for these programs. I am also amember of the Board of Directors for the Day Report Center that offers crucial services forpeople on probation or other Court or Parole Supervision. Our staff remains committed to thesuccess of these rehabilitation programs. Our referrals and effective alternative sentencingproposals work to promote these programs and add to their many success stories.

In this past fiscal year, we successfully acquired Pre-Trial Diversions for several clients.This affords them the opportunity to avoid having a Felony Criminal Record after illustrating adrug and crime-free lifestyle by use of these programs. We have gotten many cases dismissedboth prior to and after indictment due to efficient motions practice and an effective investigationprocess. Additionally, we have had very few cases to result in long term prison commitmentsprimarily because we effectively utilize the alternative sentencing programs in our county andinpatient treatment facilities both in and outside our County.

We pride ourselves on working hand-in-hand with the Panel Attorneys. We provideassistance as a local resource for attorneys for legal research and pre-trial motions practice andwish to increase this role in the legal community. We also pride ourselves on working hand inhand with the Panel Attorneys, by, among other things, covering emergency hearings in certainnecessary circumstances.

Going forward we are working on increasing services for alternative sentencing andworking to become more technologically efficient as we move towards the paper free era ofCriminal Law. Further, we are currently working with the local bar to get local CLE and othertraining for all attorneys involved in criminal defense in our area.

Dwayne J. Adkins, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Eighth Judicial Circuit

The Public Defender Corporation for the Eighth Judicial Circuit was established in 1990.The rise of unemployment, in once thriving McDowell County was the result of the failing coalindustry. The loss of income for the citizens of McDowell County created an overwhelmingneed of legal representation for those who became indigent. Along with the migration ofqualified attorneys away from McDowell County and an increasing case load for court appointedattorneys, a majority of the active members of the bar and the chief judge agreed to activate thePublic Defender Corporation for the 8th Judicial Circuit.

Our county experienced further loss with the devastating floods of 2001 and 2002. As aresult of the floods more jobs exited creating a greater indigent population. During the secondflood of 2002 the PDC was flooded with water up to 3 feet. Nevertheless the employeescontinued to serve the public without fail, while shoveling mud and fighting mold for a monthbefore the office could be relocated.

Our office handles the following types of cases: felony, misdemeanor, abuse and neglect,juvenile delinquency, truancy, appeals of felonies and misdemeanors, mental hygiene hearings,guardian ad litem, extraditions. Our staff is comprised of three attorneys, including a chief, anOffice Manager, and our Secretary.

Floyd Anderson, Chief Public Defender, is a native of McDowell County. He earned aDegree in Psychology for West Virginia University in 1988, received his law degree fromSouthern University Law Center in 1992, and became a member of the WV State Bar in 1994.Floyd joined the office in 1995 and became Chief in 1998.

Prior to joining our office in 2003, attorney Robert “Pete” E. Blair served as Family LawMaster, held political offices such as County Commissioner, and was a member of the McDowellCounty Board of Education. Pete has practiced law for over fifty (50!) years, and handlesmisdemeanor cases in all three magistrate courts. On multiple days of the week he is responsiblefor at least 15 or more clients in court as well as the time it takes for preparation to handle thesesaid cases. He also handles felony preliminary hearings.

Our newest attorney, Joshua Miller, received his law degree from West VirginiaUniversity College of Law in May 2013, where he graduated in the top twenty-five percent(25%) of his class. Despite more lucrative offers, Josh decided to serve his county and joined theoffice in September 2013. Josh handles certain felony cases, misdemeanor cases, juveniledelinquency, abuse and neglect, truancy charges, mental hygiene hearings, and extraditions. Hehas already filed an appeal in an abuse and neglect case.

Kimberly Cox, our Office Manager, has been with our office for twenty years. Sheoriginally joined the office as a secretary in 1994, and then became the office manager in 1997.Kim manages the attendance and leave records for our employees, verifies our funding isadequate and is used properly, and insures all bills, taxes, and other required documents are paidand/or filed in a timely manner. Kim also assists with secretarial duties.

Our secretary, Robin Oakley, began working at our office in 2008. Prior to joining us,she had worked as a magistrate assistant, a deputy circuit clerk, and a legal secretary. Shehandles all of the secretarial work, including (but certainly not limited to) contacting the client,



opening files, scheduling appointments for clients, managing the calendar, and insuring that theattorneys know where he or she needs to be and what time he or she needs to be there.

Floyd Anderson, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Ninth Judicial Circuit

The Public Defender Corporation for the Ninth Judicial Circuit is located in Princeton,and began operations on June 1, 1991 with three attorneys and two support staff. Currentlyseven attorneys and five support staff handle court proceedings in front of three circuit courtjudges and five magistrates, as well as two municipal courts. We also regularly participate inSupreme Court proceedings.

Our office and the Mercer County court system have strived to adapt to the needs ofindigent defendants as they have arisen. Due to the increased drug challenges in our society, ourcorporation became involved in serving on Adult and Juvenile Drug Courts. We work with ourclients in the Adult Drug Court to achieve a reduction in recidivism and substance abuse amongoffenders, and to increase the likelihood of successful rehabilitation through early, continuous,and intense treatment; mandatory periodic drug testing; community supervision; appropriatesanctions and incentives; and other rehabilitation services, all of which are supervised by ajudicial officer.

We work with our juvenile offenders in Juvenile Drug Court to redirect juvenileoffenders with alcohol or substance abuse behavior from the traditional juvenile court process, toan intensive, individualized treatment process. The mutual goal of our office and Juvenile DrugCourt is to reduce future court involvement for these youth.

Mercer County has historically had one of the highest numbers of open child abuse andneglect caseloads in the state. During these proceedings, we help insure that parents’constitutional rights to parent their children are protected. We also interact with the WestVirginia Department of Health and Human Resources (DHHR) to assure parents obtain servicesthrough the DHHR providers to learn proper parenting techniques.

We also participate on the Southern Regional Community Criminal Justice Board withrepresentatives from the Court system, and the community. The purpose of the board is tooversee the day to day operations of the Day Report Center. During the past year, ourcorporation was involved with court personnel and community leaders in obtaining a JusticeReinvestment Grant, to establish a new 60-100 bed residential treatment facility in MercerCounty. This facility will house criminal defendants, in lieu of going to prison. The facility willhire counselors and specialists to provide various services for persons in recovery: strength-basedsupport for positive change; aid in finding and keeping safe and sober living environments; andhelp with education and other needs as they transition back into society.

Our attorneys and support staff are involved in arranging for substance abuserehabilitation services for clients who do not qualify for Drug Court services. We make referrals,prepare orders to transport and evaluate clients to assist them in overcoming addiction.

Our involvement in Truancy Court has enabled us to reveal the unmet needs of childrenin our county. While working with the Truancy Court system, we have assisted children inreceiving necessary educational, psychological, and medical services.

Tracy Burks, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Tenth Judicial Circuit

The Public Defender Corporation for the Tenth Judicial Circuit has been located at 228N. Fayette Street in Beckley, WV for more than 10 years. It currently employs a chief publicdefender, seven staff attorneys, five support staff, and a bookkeeper/office manager. The Officeopened in 1989, making it one of the oldest Public Defender Corporations in the State.

The lawyers currently employed have been working at the office an average of just over 8years and have on average 13.5 years of legal experience each. During the 2013 fiscal year theoffice closed a total of 3,119 cases which included 847 felonies and 1520 misdemeanors. Thisamounted to an average cost per case of approximately $282, compared to the average cost forappointed counsel in the same circuit of $711. This is the lowest cost per case in the entire state.The Office also represents approximately 75% of all cases in the circuit for which counsel isappointed, this is the third highest rate in the state. Much of the lower cost per case can beattributed to the experienced legal and support staff, the high ratio of cases per attorney, (389.8cases per counsel - 2nd highest in state), as well as a continuing effort to reduce costs incidentalto operating the office.

Jury trials are infrequent in this circuit but the most recent jury trial handled in CircuitCourt by this office resulted in an outright acquittal, as have the last three jury trials in magistratecourt. The common denominator in all those cases was the input by several attorneys in theconsultation of defense preparation. Cases are assigned evenly on a rotation basis so that eachattorney handles matters in magistrate court, circuit court and before other miscellaneoustribunals, (parole hearings, mental hygiene, etc.).

Lawyer schedules are kept electronically on Time Matters as well as on desk calendars.All lawyers have access to Time Matters to keep their time and to check their calendar.Attorneys can access their files through the E-File Program as well as through the hard copymaintained in their office. Closed files can also be accessed through the E-File program. Casesover the past 12 years have been scanned, reducing the need for storage of those documents.Backups of all records are maintained on and off premises insuring their survival.

The legal staff meets frequently to review and discuss cases giving a committee approachto most cases. Standard pretrial motions are filed in all cases and attorneys individually reviewtheir cases to see what particular motions should be filed to properly advocate for their clients.The office is capable of running paperless since all documents received or produced are scanneddigitally. The office maintains a form bank for motions and research on most legal issues and issupplemented with the current use of West Law.

The basic principle of the office is to provide the best possible legal defense to eachclient. Review of cases is done during brainstorming sessions which are held frequently.

Over the past year, weekly meetings are held with the prosecuting attorney and local dayreport representative to review defendants that are incarcerated in jail to see if their release mightbe obtained through recognizance or other means of conditional bond. On average, 3 individualsper week are released after these meetings, saving counties approximately $1,000 per week aswith all offices, the recent initiation of Truancy Court has strained staff and the beginning ofDrug Court will further burden the office which will continue to persevere and uphold ourstatutory obligation to the state and professional obligation to our clients.



This office would seek to share any resources and information with other publicdefenders and lawyers representing criminal defendants to improve representation of thosecharged with crimes and those represented on matters where there is a legal mandate requiringrepresentation by appointed counsel.

Joe Noggy, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Eleventh Judicial Circuit

The Public Defender Corporation for the Eleventh Judicial Circuit was formed in 1999 toprovide competent and cost-effective legal representation to indigent individuals facing eligiblecriminal and quasi-criminal charges in Greenbrier and Pocahontas counties. The Corporation isguided by a board of directors chaired by David Smith, the Mayor of Ronceverte, WV, with theChief Defender, Joshua Edwards, serving as the day to day administrator.

The Corporation and its staff also serve an important role in the community. TheEleventh Judicial Circuit has been a leader in West Virginia’s entry into alternative programssuch as community corrections, drug court programs, truancy diversion and pretrial supervision.The attorneys of the Corporation have been an important part of these efforts. Chief DefenderJoshua Edwards and Deputy Chief Defender Dewitt Daniell both serve on the advisorycommittee for Greenbrier County’s Day Report Program which received the Honorable Martin J.Gaughan Award for Excellence in Community Corrections. In addition to their formal role onthe advisory committee, both serve as informal advisors on policy matters and legal questions asthey arise. They are also members of the advisory committee in Pocahontas County serving in asimilar capacity. The Corporation provides attorneys for the weekly drug court treatment teamsin both counties. Mr. Edwards serves on the Planning Committee for the Juvenile Drug Courtand previously served on the Juvenile Drug Court weekly treatment team. Both counties alsohave Truancy Diversion Programs and the Public Defenders are responsible for representing thevast majority of the juveniles in those programs.

Outside of the Court system, Public Defender attorneys have volunteered to assist withthe Supreme Court of Appeals LAWS (Legal Advancement for West Virginia Students)Program, lectured middle school students on the consequences of bullying, attended career dayprograms to discuss a legal career with students, and gave additional presentations in schools onthe criminal justice system.

Historically, our office has been a cost effective provider of legal services. Our cost perclosed case in FY 2013 was $647.30 compared to private appointed counsel in the JudicialCircuit at $1403.15.

Joshua Edwards, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Twelfth Judicial Circuit

The Public Defender Corporation for the Twelfth Judicial Circuit was formed in 1990 toprovide legal services to indigent individuals facing criminal charges. Our office is located inFayetteville, and, in 2015, we will celebrate its twenty-fifth anniversary.

Our office handles misdemeanor charges, felony charges from arrest through appeal, CityCourt charges throughout the County, extraditions, mental hygiene petitions, abuse and neglect,juvenile status offenses, and juvenile delinquency cases. We are on call at all times if needed bythe Court system for mental hygiene petitions or juvenile detention hearings.

As of August 2014, our office has approved eighty-one (81%) percent of the financialaffidavits requesting representation we’ve received. An additional fifteen (15%) percent wereapproved but due to a conflict were appointed to a panel attorney, and four (4%) percent weredetermined to be over income. In Fiscal Year 2013 we had several jury trials with positiveoutcomes and numerous indictments which were dismissed based upon motions we filed. Wehave also had several clients who, although indicted, resolved their charges with pleas to minorcharges in Magistrate Court.

Although each day at the Fayette County Public Defender’s Office we are helping others,some after work hours are also dedicated to worthwhile endeavors. Some examples are:mentoring high school students; coaching new panel attorneys; speaking at County GovernmentDay; acting as a board member for our Day Report Center; member of the Nicholas CountySheriff’s Department Civil Service Commission; soccer coach; and adult mentor for theWoodrow Wilson High School Honor Society.

Nancy Fraley, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit

The Public Defender Corporation for the Thirteenth Judicial Circuit opened in 1984 toprovide legal services to qualifying individuals facing criminal charges in Kanawha County. Ouroffice employs twenty-two lawyers and fifteen support staff. In addition to providing legalrepresentation in 7535 court-appointed cases last year, our staff provides a broad range of legaland community services.

Chief Public Defender George Castelle serves on the West Virginia Supreme Court ofAppeals Community Supervision Committee, the Justice Reinvestment in West Virginia WorkGroup, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals Prison Overcrowding ComplianceCommission, and the Kanawha County Community Corrections Advisory Board.

Managing Defenders Diana Panucci and Ronni Sheets, and many other lawyers in theoffice, also serve in a wide variety of legal and community-based capacities, including on theboard of the Mid-Atlantic Juvenile Defender Center, the West Virginia State Bar's Criminal LawCommittee, Public Defender Services new lawyer training, the West Virginia Supreme Court ofAppeals new magistrate training, the Charleston Community Coalition, the planning committeeof the Kanawha County Drug Court, the advisory committee of the Kanawha County DrugCourt, the Kanawha County Family Court Bench Bar Committee, and a community-based teencourt.

George Castelle, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit

In 1994 the Harrison County Bar Association authorized the opening of a public defendercorporation with the goal of providing indigent defendants with access to counsel specializing incriminal matters. With three attorneys, the Corporation took on approximately 99 cases in itsfirst year of operation.

Twenty years later, the Public Defender Corporation for the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit isrecognized as the standard for criminal defense in Harrison County. Defendants and respondentsare protected by a corps of experienced, dedicated attorneys who handle approximately 1,400cases a year, ranging from simple misdemeanor offenses to high profile felony cases. In additionto the misdemeanor and felony matters the Corporation’s Attorneys handle Abuse and Neglect,Family Court contempt, Mental Hygiene, Extradition, Probation Revocation, and Juvenile Statusand Delinquency proceedings. Several Attorneys are also currently certified to accept GuardianAd Litem appointments to represent children in Abuse and Neglect cases.

A majority of offenses committed within the County are substance abuse related. For thisreason the Corporation has forged relationships with area substance abuse treatmentprofessionals and facilities in an effort to reduce recidivism and secure better outcomes forclients. A number of these clients are also returning combat veterans. With that in mind theCorporation has partnered with the VA Hospital located in the County in an effort to provideadditional treatment and alternative sentencing options for those clients.

The Corporation participated in the development of the Harrison County Juvenile DrugCourt and is currently aiding the Circuit Court in the development and implementation of anAdult Drug Court in the County. The Corporation actively participates with, and serves on theBoards of, both the Juvenile and Adult Drug Court.

Additionally, the Corporation is an active member of the Circuit’s Court Advisory Boardand the Community Corrections Board. At the State level, one Assistant Defender has recentlybeen named to the Intergovernmental Task Force on Juvenile Justice.

The Corporation’s size and proximity to the WVU College of Law allow us the uniqueopportunity to partner with the Law School to host Summer Interns and Fall and Spring Externs.This opportunity provides valuable hands-on experience to those aspiring to become criminaldefense attorneys.

It is the goal of the Corporation, not only to provide expert legal representation within thecommunity, but to provide to the community as well. Whether it be by procuring neededservices for clients, or by participating in programs within the community, it is the Corporation’shope that it can make a positive impact in the lives of their clients, as well as in the community itserves.

Perry Jones, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit

The Public Defender Corporation of the Eighteenth (18th) Judicial Circuit of PrestonCounty, West Virginia has its office located at 202 Tunnelton Street, Suite 303, Kingwood, WestVirginia. It serves the area located in Preston County, West Virginia. The office was establishedin 2000.

The office has three (3) attorneys and two (2) support staff:

Randy R. Goodrich, Chief Public Defender (since July 01, 2000) Claire L. Niehaus, Assistant Public Defender (since October 16, 2002) Sally C. Collins, Assistant Public Defender (since January 1, 2005) Susan L. Bolyard, Office Manager (since July 16, 2000) C. Russella Hare, Secretary (since August 16, 2004)

Cases are accepted by Court Order and appointment through the office of Lawrance S.Miller, Circuit Judge, of the Eighteenth (18th) Judicial Circuit which includes appointmentsthrough the Magistrate Court of Preston County, West Virginia, and Mental Hygieneappointments by the two (2) Mental Hygiene Commissioners serving Preston County, WestVirginia. The office is not appointed any cases through any municipalities in the County, northrough the Family Court Judges. In 2013, the office was appointed to represent 671 clientscharged with 1,224 offenses or charges.

The Public Defender attorneys have served on the Board of Directors for the CommunityCorrections since its beginning. Sally C. Collins currently serves on its Board of Directors. Theattorneys have also served on the Adult Drug Court team. Claire L. Niehaus served on the teamfrom its beginning until one year ago, when Sally C. Collins assumed these responsibilities. TheDrug Court has successfully graduated almost ten (10) persons to date.

There are currently approximately thirteen (13) persons enrolled and participating inAdult Drug Court. The attorneys and staff are members of various organizations and participatein community events in Preston and Monongalia Counties.

Randy Goodrich, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Twenty-Third Judicial Circuit

The Mission of the Eastern Panhandle Public Defender Office (EPPDO) is to providecompetent, thoroughly professional legal representation to the indigent criminally accused in allCourts in the Twenty-third (23rd) Judicial Circuit of West Virginia in an efficient, cost-effectivemanner when appointed to do so by competent judicial authority.

Our clientele primarily consists of defendants in criminal matters at the felony andmisdemeanor levels in Circuit and Magistrate Court, but the obligation to provide professional,competent legal representation extends to and includes appointments to represent offendingrespondents in parental rights termination matters ("abuse and neglect" cases), Family Law Courtcontempt proceedings, juvenile offender matters and mental hygiene involuntary commitmentproceedings, as well as appellate matters at various levels when assigned to do so by a Court, toinclude prosecuting appeals in the WV Supreme Court of Appeals.

The EPPDO office responsibilities include all the courts in all three county jurisdictionsin the Eastern Panhandle (Berkeley, Jefferson and Morgan), as well as seven individualmunicipal courts in various towns throughout the Panhandle, particularly Martinsburg'sMunicipal Court. Our two separate offices are located in Martinsburg, which covers all mattersin Berkeley and Morgan counties, and a satellite office in Charles Town, which handles allmatters in Jefferson County. In calendar year 2013, the office handled over 4330 individual,discrete cases and we are currently on pace to exceed that total by several hundred additionalcases in 2014, due to a combination of population growth, as well as the easing of financialeligibility guidelines that dictate and control the availability of court-appointed counsel.

Established nearly thirty years ago and operating continuously since, we are the secondlargest Public Defender Corporation in West Virginia, with a staff of 33 individuals: 20 licensedattorneys and 13 clerical support staff members and investigators. The team at the EPPDO is acommitted, dedicated crew, truly devoted to ensuring that our clients of all types are treatedjustly: we fiercely protect the rights of poor, often powerless and uneducated people accused ofbeing criminals, or are somehow enmeshed in other legal difficulties touching upon fundamentalrights, thus ensuring that the criminal justice system is administered fairly, remains open,accessible and even-handed -- and is perceived as such by the general public and citizenry thatwe serve. We ensure that the common man accused of wrongdoing by a powerful governmentand police apparatus is not overwhelmed and unduly intimidated and that his voice and "side ofthe story" is told by a tenacious, professional advocate committed to his cause. As Chief PublicDefender, and a veteran of nearly twenty years in the trenches at the EPPDO, I am supremelyconfident that we are well-regarded and respected by all the judges and opposing counsel in ourbailiwick. We are the proverbial "overworked and underpaid" public servants: despite staggeringcaseloads — well above and greatly surpassing ABA guideline levels - and extremely lowcompensation relative to our peers in the local prosecutors' offices, we enjoy very low turnoveramong the staff and have accrued a level of experience and expertise unrivaled in the State: adevoted team of career Public Defenders serving the State and her people and Courts.

Tom Delaney, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Twenty-Fifth Judicial Circuit

The Office of the Public Defender for the Twenty-Fifth Judicial Circuit was created onthe Fourteenth day of June, 2000. The 25th Judicial Circuit encompasses Boone and LincolnCounties. We have two physical offices. One located at 320 Main Street, Madison WV, and theother located at 406 Walnut Street, Hamlin WV. The staff currently consists of six attorneys and4 support staff, with four attorneys and three support staff in the Madison office and twoattorneys and one support staff in the Hamlin office.

Our Chief Public Defender is Robert White. Bob has in excess of thirty-two (32) years ofexperience in the practice of criminal law, which includes over eight years as a prosecutor. Hehas jury acquittals in Murder and Sexual Assault cases and the only jury acquittal in a Deliveryof a Controlled Substance case in the history of Boone County. Additionally, four of ourattorneys bring over twelve years of experience each, including one with twenty-five years.

Our service also includes activities outside the office. Bob serves as the Chairman of theBoard of Directors of a 501(c)3 Corporation that operates a Community Center in hisneighborhood. David Lockwood, another attorney in our office, serves alongside Bob on theDrug Court Treatment Teams in Boone and Lincoln Counties.

Bob White, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Twenty-Eighth Judicial Circuit

The Public Defender Corporation for the Twenty-Eighth Judicial Circuit is located inSummersville and was established in 1983, making it one of the first public defendercorporations in the state.

D. Mark Snyder was the sole practitioner and public defender until Cynthia Stanton washired in October 1987. For the first seven years, Ms. Stanton was the sole public defender. In1994 a decision in Charleston was made to hire an assistant public defender and in the lasttwenty years, six attorneys have held the positions. Ms. Sarah Campbell was hired and beganworking in October 2013. The 28th Judicial Circuit Public Defender has two attorneys and twosupport staff. Robin Wellman has worked for the corporation twenty-one years and KathyO'Dell has worked for seventeen years. Ms. Stanton is the oldest serving public defender in thestate.

The 28th Public Defender Corporation has maintained an annual caseload ofapproximately 500-600 cases per year since Ms. Stanton has taken over. This office has beenresponsible for indigent representation in all areas of criminal defense eligible proceedings. Asreflected in the statistics on page 69 of the WVPDS Annual Report 2013, it appears that ouroffice consistently maintains a higher percentage proportionately of all criminal proceedings thanoffices having many more attorneys. Our two attorneys handle 64% of all criminal applicants inthe county. Our abuse & neglect load is fourth of all corporations and we are the only two personoffice. We handle all Mental Hygiene hearings during work hours and at night unless we have aconflict. We handle all court appointments unless there in a codefendant or similar conflict. Ms.Stanton handles family court. Drug Court has not been established yet but is mandated to be setup.

We have always had each attorney prepared and ready to conduct any kind of criminalproceeding. Since there is still a satellite magistrate office in Richwood (26 miles away) we arealso required to attend court there an average of one day a week or three times a month or more.Every attorney that has left the office is typically prepared to handle all types of criminalproceedings. The ability to accomplish this is based upon necessity as our one Judge Circuitexpects our office to be available for all proceedings during the weekdays, weeknights, andweekends.

At this point we believe that we have a sound system in place to address indigent clientsin our circuit. Ms. Stanton is also the President of the Community Corrections Board thatoversees the Day Report Center. She traveled to Charleston in June to obtain grant monies forthe continuance of the successful program which established itself as a separate entity this year.

It is our belief that in 2016 there may be an additional judge added to our single circuitwhich would dramatically change the operation of our corporation.

Cindy Stanton, Chief Public Defender



Public Defender Corporation for the Thirtieth Judicial Circuit

LEADERSHIP UNDER FIRE

The Public Defender Corporation for the Thirtieth Judicial Circuit is the largest, busiest,and most experienced law firm in Mingo County. We are proud to be leaders in our legalcommunity.

During the past year, 2013-14, that leadership was put to the test. In an almostunimaginable scandal, our former Circuit Judge, County Prosecutor, and Chief Magistrate wouldall be convicted of federal crimes for abusing their offices. Months before the federalinvestigation was made public, our office stood alone, filing motion after motion challenging theofficials’ corrupt practices. Challenging the only judge in a one-judge circuit was not popular,but it was right.

Following the officials’ convictions, others looked to our office to help stabilize andrebuild. In fact, two of our attorneys were recommended by the Governor’s Judicial VacancyAdvisory Commission to replace the deposed Judge. Although it has been a tough year, fraughtwith the difficulties inherent in practicing in front of a rotating cast of retired judges, we arehappy to see much improvement in Mingo County, and very proud of the role we played.

Our Office

Our office opened for business on January 15, 1990. Since that time we’ve grown from aone attorney, one secretary office to a 4 attorney office with a clerical staff of three. Our officehandles approximately 500 cases a year, including felony, misdemeanor, juvenile and mentalhygiene matters. Over the years our attorney staff has supervised 30+ law student interns from 10different law schools, many of whom have chosen to practice law in West Virginia. Formermembers of our staff can be found in various positions across our state, including Mark Snyder,Kanawha County Family Court Judge, Nancy Fraley, Chief Public Defender in Fayette County,Richard Holicker, Kanawha County Public Defender and former Kanawha County Magistrate,and our most recent loss, Jonathan Friley, now at PDS as Public Defender CorporationAdministrator.

Our chief defender, Teresa McCune, attended Marshall University and AntiochSchool of Law. She handles most of our juvenile matters and murder cases.Teresa is active in state and local bar and community service. She chairs the StateBar Commission on Children and the Law, serves on the WV Supreme Court ofAppeals Region Three Fatality Review Task force, and is a member of the WVState Bar CLE and Criminal Law Committees. She has been named a WV BarFoundation Fellow, and has received the Governor’s Service Award. Teresafounded and directs “On Track for College,” an award-winning college bound

coaching program that helps students preparing for higher education. She is also a member ofWilliamson Woman’s Club and the Mingo/Pike branch of AAUW. Locally, Teresa is also theChair of Christian Help of Mingo County, a charitable organization which provides direct aid tothe needy.



Dave Foley, a former WV Public Defender of the Year, is a graduate of the WVUCollege of Law, and attended James Madison University where he was on thevarsity debate team. Dave handles misdemeanors and felonies, and is our “go toguy” for extradition cases. Dave is a an Executive Board Member for theCoalfield Association of Southern Baptists, sings in his church choir, teachesSunday school and bowls competitively. He is happily married to Debbie.

Duke Jewell is a graduate of Ohio Northern Law School. A member of theWilliamson High School Athletic Hall of Fame, he played college basketball atBrandeis University. Duke handles misdemeanor and felony cases. He is marriedto Christina, and is the father of two toddlers, Jackson Cade and Samuel Jase.Duke is a member of the Tug Valley Road Runners Club, and volunteers with anumber of community programs, including WV READ ALOUD and KIDS RUNTHE NATION. He is a Williamson PK - 8 YEP Advisory Board member, anavid music collector and is the son of Mid Jewell, of Jewell v. Maynard, thegranddaddy of all WV public defenders.

Paul Montgomery, a U.S. Navy veteran, attended the University of Oklahoma andAppalachian School of Law. He handles misdemeanor and felony cases, is ourpoint man for mental hygiene cases, and also contributes in juvenile matters. Paulis married to Megan, and is the father of two toddlers, Syrus Jonah and RoyceAsher (aka Bobby Cars). Paul is a member of Delta Theta Phi Law fraternity. Hishobby is stargazing.

Crystal Brewer, our secretary, is a graduate of Williamson High School. Sheconducts the youth choir at her church. Crystal helps care for 80 year old father,who is a liver transplant survivor. She is married to Rick. Crystal and Rick helpprovide Christmas for needy children through an AEP employees program.

Tiera Asbury, our office manager, is a graduate of Mingo County VocationalSchool. Tiera volunteers as a member of the Policy Council Board for CoalfieldCap, an agency which oversees Head Start programs in Mingo and McDowellcounties. She also works with the Ben Creek volunteer Fire Department deliveringmeals to the elderly. She is married to Chad and is the mother of 7 year old Callie.

Jane Moran, the Chair of our Board of Directors is an iconic figure amongstlawyers delivering services to the poor and disenfranchised in our state. Jane isoften appointed by our Supreme Court to complicated cases involving children’srights and to prestigious committee positions and chairmanships. Jane has receivednumerous awards for her work and is often called upon as a trainer in juvenile andchild abuse law.

Teresa McCune, Chief Public Defender



APPOINTED COUNSEL &

PUBLIC DEFENDER

STATISTICAL

SUMMARY



Total Amount Paid In Claims $25,530,768.12

Total Fees Paid to Counsel $23,016,716.42

Total Expenses Paid $2,514,051.70

Total Hours In-Court 71,770.1

Total Hours Out-Of-Court 407,813.8

Total Number of Hours Paid 479,583.9

Percent of Total Hours In-Court 14.97%

Percent of Total Hours Out-Of-Court 85.03%

Percent of Total Funds Paid Attributable To Fees 90.15%

Percent of Total Funds Paid Attributable To Expenses 9.85%

Average Total Cost Per Hour $53.24

Total Claims Paid 34,045

Less: Supplemental Claims Paid (1,155)

Less: Direct Claims Paid (1,073)

Total Claims Paid without Supplemental & Direct 31,817

All Claims W/O Supp & Dir.

Average Total Cost Per Claim $749.91 $802.43

Average Counsel Fee Per Claim $676.07 $723.41

Average Expenses Per Claim $73.84 $79.02

Comparative Analysis between All Claims and Claims With Out Supplemental and Direct


APPOINTED COUNSEL FISCAL YEAR 2014

STATISTICAL SUMMARY



Total Number of Cases Closed

Total Amount Disbursed to Corporations*

Average Total Cost Per Cases Closed

SUMMARY OF HOURS**

Total In Court Hours Worked

Total Out of Court Hours Worked

Total Drug Court Hours Worked

Total Administrative Hours Worked

Total Number of Hours Worked during FY 2014

Average Total Cost Per Hour

Percent of Total In Court Hours

Percent of Total Out of Court Hours

Percent of Drug Court Hours Worked

Percent of Total Administrative Hours


STATISTICAL SUMMARY

PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS FISCAL YEAR 2014

189,605.10

With Admin Without Admin

33,354.00

$17,030,817.00

$510.61

53,246.60

135,178.70

1,179.80

70,132.80

259,737.90

53,246.60

135,178.70

1,179.80

Not Considered

*Note: Total amount disbursed includes payments made on behalf of Corporations to audit

providers; Office of Technology; State Auditor’s Office; and Legal Research Services.

**Note: The Summary of Hours illustrates the difference in considering the total

administration time reported by Public Defenders. These Administrative Hours include

Holiday, Sick and Annual Leave hours paid to Corporation Attorneys. Moreover, it includes

performance reviews as well as management of the facilities and personnel. It also includes

time that cannot readily be allocated to a single case such as representing numerous clients

on the same day in municipal court and peer reviewing files to ensure adequate legal

representation by counsel.

65.57

20.50%

52.04%

0.45%

27.00%

89.82

28.08%

71.29%

0.62%

Not Considered



APPENDIX A:

APPOINTED

COUNSEL

STATISTICS



Attorney Fees $23,016,716.42Attorney Expenses $1,363,738.16Direct Expenses* $1,150,313.54Total Claims Paid $25,530,768.12

*Direct Expenses are court approved payments directly to providers of services to appointed counsel.

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESSUMMARY OF APPOINTED COUNSEL CLAIMS PAID

Attorney Fees90.15%

Attorney Expenses5.34%

Direct Expenses*4.51%



Attorney Attorney Direct Total Total FeesCircuit Attorney Fees Expenses Expenses Expenses & ExpensesCounty Hours ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)

01 Circuit

BROOKE 5,967.76 285,192.64 17,965.60 9,663.75 27,629.35 312,821.99

HANCOCK 5,780.65 276,974.00 14,485.45 6,034.12 20,519.57 297,493.57

OHIO 16,991.70 793,769.70 25,869.52 12,416.70 38,286.22 832,055.92

Total 28,740.10 1,355,936.34 58,320.57 28,114.57 86,435.14 1,442,371.48

02 Circuit

MARSHALL 3,545.16 170,956.50 6,336.44 3,412.25 9,748.69 180,705.19

TYLER 1,839.70 87,864.50 8,096.55 0.00 8,096.55 95,961.05

WETZEL 3,165.27 151,459.50 10,211.95 0.00 10,211.95 161,671.45

Total 8,550.13 410,280.50 24,644.94 3,412.25 28,057.19 438,337.69

03 Circuit

DODDRIDGE 4,264.06 201,077.50 20,780.56 12,818.49 33,599.05 234,676.55

PLEASANTS 2,465.31 116,135.00 8,755.33 3,192.81 11,948.14 128,083.14

RITCHIE 4,321.24 204,722.05 14,997.49 9,247.39 24,244.88 228,966.93

Total 11,050.61 521,934.55 44,533.38 25,258.69 69,792.07 591,726.62

04 Circuit

WIRT 1,670.82 78,607.00 8,091.17 3,950.82 12,041.99 90,648.99

WOOD 29,115.78 1,380,835.40 71,886.27 146,566.53 218,452.80 1,599,288.20

Total 30,786.60 1,459,442.40 79,977.44 150,517.35 230,494.79 1,689,937.19

05 Circuit

CALHOUN 3,646.84 177,314.20 21,480.09 17,744.00 39,224.09 216,538.29

JACKSON 7,578.91 368,449.00 51,085.09 16,029.91 67,115.00 435,564.00

MASON 7,458.98 360,966.95 13,309.75 3,388.64 16,698.39 377,665.34

ROANE 4,233.81 205,851.50 30,986.25 2,478.55 33,464.80 239,316.30

Total 22,918.54 1,112,581.65 116,861.18 39,641.10 156,502.28 1,269,083.93

06 Circuit

CABELL 19,313.07 965,996.00 26,539.87 64,581.64 91,121.51 1,057,117.51

Total 19,313.07 965,996.00 26,539.87 64,581.64 91,121.51 1,057,117.51

07 Circuit

LOGAN 11,160.34 538,569.08 25,302.53 5,817.86 31,120.39 569,689.47

Total 11,160.34 538,569.08 25,302.53 5,817.86 31,120.39 569,689.47

08 Circuit

MCDOWELL 9,934.51 476,140.00 20,824.12 17,383.26 38,207.38 514,347.38

Total 9,934.51 476,140.00 20,824.12 17,383.26 38,207.38 514,347.38

09 Circuit

MERCER 27,798.81 1,339,138.70 123,894.88 80,539.60 204,434.48 1,543,573.18

Total 27,798.81 1,339,138.70 123,894.88 80,539.60 204,434.48 1,543,573.18

10 Circuit

RALEIGH 18,372.99 885,766.30 62,286.73 36,145.28 98,432.01 984,198.31

Total 18,372.99 885,766.30 62,286.73 36,145.28 98,432.01 984,198.31

11 Circuit

GREENBRIER 7,725.86 361,990.00 6,191.98 0.00 6,191.98 368,181.98

POCAHONTAS 2,698.06 126,771.25 3,400.03 337.00 3,737.03 130,508.28

Total 10,423.92 488,761.25 9,592.01 337.00 9,929.01 498,690.26

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESSUMMARY REPORT FOR APPOINTED COUNSEL:

ATTORNEY HOURS, FEES, AND EXPENSES






12 Circuit

FAYETTE 7,089.76 341,698.50 18,617.94 0.00 18,617.94 360,316.44

Total 7,089.76 341,698.50 18,617.94 0.00 18,617.94 360,316.44

13 Circuit

KANAWHA 36,786.18 1,760,955.40 71,402.35 32,850.57 104,252.92 1,865,208.32

Total 36,786.18 1,760,955.40 71,402.35 32,850.57 104,252.92 1,865,208.32

14 Circuit

BRAXTON 6,953.33 334,468.00 29,414.84 0.00 29,414.84 363,882.84

CLAY 6,920.49 332,259.50 29,678.25 2,962.76 32,641.01 364,900.51

GILMER 4,665.29 222,142.00 22,548.01 0.00 22,548.01 244,690.01

WEBSTER 10,445.51 498,592.10 60,307.57 3,159.05 63,466.62 562,058.72

Total 28,984.61 1,387,461.60 141,948.67 6,121.81 148,070.48 1,535,532.08

15 Circuit

HARRISON 9,610.83 462,350.50 27,254.18 34,738.14 61,992.32 524,342.82

Total 9,610.83 462,350.50 27,254.18 34,738.14 61,992.32 524,342.82

16 Circuit

MARION 18,585.91 866,774.70 22,634.52 88,778.18 111,412.70 978,187.40

Total 18,585.91 866,774.70 22,634.52 88,778.18 111,412.70 978,187.40

17 Circuit

MONONGALIA 22,510.62 1,065,495.28 48,524.52 105,543.67 154,068.19 1,219,563.47

Total 22,510.62 1,065,495.28 48,524.52 105,543.67 154,068.19 1,219,563.47

18 Circuit

PRESTON 6,037.57 281,698.50 22,394.51 12,887.81 35,282.32 316,980.82

Total 6,037.57 281,698.50 22,394.51 12,887.81 35,282.32 316,980.82

19 Circuit

BARBOUR 5,974.68 280,386.50 17,376.00 0.00 17,376.00 297,762.50

TAYLOR 6,852.20 321,149.00 17,004.27 0.00 17,004.27 338,153.27

Total 12,826.88 601,535.50 34,380.27 0.00 34,380.27 635,915.77

20 Circuit

RANDOLPH 10,187.97 496,455.20 19,346.07 2,974.32 22,320.39 518,775.59

Total 10,187.97 496,455.20 19,346.07 2,974.32 22,320.39 518,775.59

21 Circuit

GRANT 4,016.51 191,397.50 15,936.76 6,670.17 22,606.93 214,004.43

MINERAL 4,897.08 231,930.50 8,554.96 18,508.32 27,063.28 258,993.78

TUCKER 838.91 39,863.00 4,046.00 0.00 4,046.00 43,909.00

Total 9,752.50 463,191.00 28,537.72 25,178.49 53,716.21 516,907.21

22 Circuit

HAMPSHIRE 6,045.03 293,156.50 12,083.11 37,743.68 49,826.79 342,983.29

HARDY 5,532.48 266,051.80 14,770.98 34,873.74 49,644.72 315,696.52

PENDLETON 1,420.70 67,339.50 4,531.23 10,853.26 15,384.49 82,723.99

Total 12,998.22 626,547.80 31,385.32 83,470.68 114,856.00 741,403.80






23 Circuit

BERKELEY 18,546.25 893,136.72 62,705.23 124,024.20 186,729.43 1,079,866.15

JEFFERSON 6,534.07 320,935.50 28,476.12 57,987.24 86,463.36 407,398.86

MORGAN 4,589.85 219,897.50 22,876.53 14,634.13 37,510.66 257,408.16

Total 29,670.17 1,433,969.72 114,057.88 196,645.57 310,703.45 1,744,673.17

24 Circuit

WAYNE 5,526.45 288,429.00 12,464.28 6,619.36 19,083.64 307,512.64

Total 5,526.45 288,429.00 12,464.28 6,619.36 19,083.64 307,512.64

25 Circuit

BOONE 5,847.17 298,987.45 10,779.53 11,433.00 22,212.53 321,199.98

LINCOLN 7,639.20 368,855.50 17,793.62 7,561.93 25,355.55 394,211.05

Total 13,486.38 667,842.95 28,573.15 18,994.93 47,568.08 715,411.03

26 Circuit

LEWIS 6,414.15 307,200.10 18,159.85 5,984.70 24,144.55 331,344.65

UPSHUR 5,510.50 263,396.50 12,606.56 1,126.07 13,732.63 277,129.13

Total 11,924.65 570,596.60 30,766.41 7,110.77 37,877.18 608,473.78

27 Circuit

WYOMING 12,118.51 577,119.00 30,285.22 43,923.76 74,208.98 651,327.98

Total 12,118.51 577,119.00 30,285.22 43,923.76 74,208.98 651,327.98

28 Circuit

NICHOLAS 4,914.48 235,988.50 22,470.92 10,853.80 33,324.72 269,313.22

Total 4,914.48 235,988.50 22,470.92 10,853.80 33,324.72 269,313.22

29 Circuit

PUTNAM 15,058.77 719,457.15 40,295.65 10,600.81 50,896.46 770,353.61

Total 15,058.77 719,457.15 40,295.65 10,600.81 50,896.46 770,353.61

30 Circuit

MINGO 8,065.90 399,740.25 4,453.84 3,313.03 7,766.87 407,507.12

Total 8,065.90 399,740.25 4,453.84 3,313.03 7,766.87 407,507.12

31 Circuit

MONROE 2,186.12 106,695.50 11,514.24 937.50 12,451.74 119,147.24

SUMMERS 2,211.80 108,167.00 9,652.85 7,021.74 16,674.59 124,841.59

Total 4,397.92 214,862.50 21,167.09 7,959.24 29,126.33 243,988.83

State Total 479,583.89 23,016,716.42 1,363,738.16 1,150,313.54 2,514,051.70 25,530,768.12



APPOINTED COUNSEL

HOURS PAID BY CASE TYPE



Felony 157,036.24Misdemeanor 70,013.48Mental Hygiene 8,691.62Juvenile 34,259.23Parole/Prob. Rev. 11,087.73Term/Abuse & Neglect 169,000.82Habeas/Supreme Court 17,188.97Municipal Court Charges 3,965.98Other 8,339.83

Total Hours Paid 479,583.89

(Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL HOURS

Felony32.74%

Misdemeanor14.60%

Mental Hygiene1.81%

Juvenile7.14%

Parole/Prob. Rev.2.31%

Term/Abuse &Neglect35.24%

Habeas/SupremeCourt3.58%

Municipal CourtCharges0.83%Other

1.74%



Par

ole

Cir

cuit

Me

nta

lP

rob

.Te

rm.

Hab

eas

Mu

ni.

Tota

l

Co

un

tyFe

lon

yM

isd

.H

ygie

ne

Juv.

Re

v.A

bu

seSu

p.C

t.C

ou

rtO

the

rH

ou

rs

01

Cir

cuit

BR

OO

KE

2,2

88

.20

43

0.4

95

26

.66

15

3.8

09

7.3

02

,45

6.7

10

.00

0.0

01

4.6

05

,96

7.7

6H

AN

CO

CK

1,5

96

.60

34

3.3

01

76

.90

38

3.1

02

26

.90

2,8

66

.75

14

9.2

01

4.1

02

3.8

05

,78

0.6

5O

HIO

2,9

52

.70

76

2.0

01

,74

8.1

64

23

.40

86

.70

8,6

60

.63

1,9

84

.41

0.0

03

73

.70

16

,99

1.7

0To

tal

6,8

37

.50

1,5

35

.79

2,4

51

.72

96

0.3

04

10

.90

13

,98

4.0

92

,13

3.6

11

4.1

04

12

.10

28

,74

0.1

00

2C

ircu

itM

AR

SHA

LL1

,37

3.2

07

83

.90

19

5.0

83

73

.80

78

.70

58

7.3

81

14

.30

10

.80

28

.00

3,5

45

.16

TYLE

R4

06

.10

12

2.6

07

5.1

01

90

.20

80

.50

93

2.9

00

.00

0.0

03

2.3

01

,83

9.7

0W

ETZE

L1

,70

0.2

01

06

.30

16

8.8

72

06

.90

32

.70

94

8.9

00

.00

0.0

01

.40

3,1

65

.27

Tota

l3

,47

9.5

01

,01

2.8

04

39

.05

77

0.9

01

91

.90

2,4

69

.18

11

4.3

01

0.8

06

1.7

08

,55

0.1

30

3C

ircu

itD

OD

DR

IDG

E1

,11

2.4

07

52

.30

58

.90

46

9.2

02

81

.30

1,4

99

.06

0.0

01

4.6

07

6.3

04

,26

4.0

6P

LEA

SAN

TS8

03

.90

48

4.0

91

1.9

02

89

.99

76

.20

75

8.6

31

9.5

00

.00

21

.10

2,4

65

.31

RIT

CH

IE1

,55

6.2

01

,04

4.8

81

3.4

02

77

.24

92

.30

1,2

93

.32

26

.20

0.0

01

7.7

04

,32

1.2

4To

tal

3,4

72

.50

2,2

81

.27

84

.20

1,0

36

.43

44

9.8

03

,55

1.0

14

5.7

01

4.6

01

15

.10

11

,05

0.6

10

4C

ircu

itW

IRT

49

2.4

24

00

.60

11

.30

33

5.6

01

0.7

02

36

.10

15

5.9

00

.00

28

.20

1,6

70

.82

WO

OD

7,4

16

.86

8,6

77

.77

56

6.9

22

,38

5.6

62

86

.30

8,5

86

.90

64

0.8

00

.00

55

4.5

72

9,1

15

.78

Tota

l7

,90

9.2

89

,07

8.3

75

78

.22

2,7

21

.26

29

7.0

08

,82

3.0

07

96

.70

0.0

05

82

.77

30

,78

6.6

00

5C

ircu

itC

ALH

OU

N9

15

.60

16

8.4

02

.60

0.0

00

.00

2,5

38

.74

0.0

00

.00

21

.50

3,6

46

.84

JAC

KSO

N3

,75

2.8

75

28

.89

15

.30

20

5.1

02

14

.60

2,3

97

.05

24

4.6

00

.00

22

0.5

07

,57

8.9

1M

ASO

N2

,63

9.2

91

,39

2.3

32

35

.20

76

1.0

22

67

.80

1,6

69

.24

24

8.7

02

6.9

02

18

.50

7,4

58

.98

RO

AN

E2

,06

5.9

03

57

.10

50

.90

18

1.7

03

9.8

01

,40

1.4

11

6.3

00

.00

12

0.7

04

,23

3.8

1To

tal

9,3

73

.65

2,4

46

.72

30

4.0

01

,14

7.8

25

22

.20

8,0

06

.44

50

9.6

02

6.9

05

81

.20

22

,91

8.5

40

6C

ircu

itC

AB

ELL

8,9

64

.02

92

8.0

01

,57

3.0

06

91

.90

52

5.9

05

,48

6.4

98

20

.74

9.9

03

13

.11

19

,31

3.0

7To

tal

8,9

64

.02

92

8.0

01

,57

3.0

06

91

.90

52

5.9

05

,48

6.4

98

20

.74

9.9

03

13

.11

19

,31

3.0

70

7C

ircu

itLO

GA

N2

,39

5.9

22

,37

7.9

10

.00

2,0

16

.63

27

1.5

73

,69

2.5

02

96

.90

0.0

01

08

.90

11

,16

0.3

4To

tal

2,3

95

.92

2,3

77

.91

0.0

02

,01

6.6

32

71

.57

3,6

92

.50

29

6.9

00

.00

10

8.9

01

1,1

60

.34

08

Cir

cuit

MC

DO

WEL

L4

,74

8.5

21

,70

9.7

06

9.4

02

08

.10

0.0

02

,69

4.2

84

04

.01

0.0

01

00

.50

9,9

34

.51

Tota

l4

,74

8.5

21

,70

9.7

06

9.4

02

08

.10

0.0

02

,69

4.2

84

04

.01

0.0

01

00

.50

9,9

34

.51

09

Cir

cuit

MER

CER

9,3

90

.30

2,6

27

.47

50

4.2

12

,47

2.0

78

58

.01

9,6

47

.27

1,4

53

.70

21

0.7

96

35

.00

27

,79

8.8

1To

tal

9,3

90

.30

2,6

27

.47

50

4.2

12

,47

2.0

78

58

.01

9,6

47

.27

1,4

53

.70

21

0.7

96

35

.00

27

,79

8.8

11

0C

ircu

itR

ALE

IGH

5,0

79

.71

1,2

08

.00

27

.35

57

3.4

63

16

.59

10

,38

6.8

96

92

.70

0.0

08

8.3

01

8,3

72

.99

Tota

l5

,07

9.7

11

,20

8.0

02

7.3

55

73

.46

31

6.5

91

0,3

86

.89

69

2.7

00

.00

88

.30

18

,37

2.9

9

PU

BLI

CD

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ESA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

HO

UR

SP

AID

BY

CIR

CU

IT&

CA

SETY

PE



Par

ole

Cir

cuit

Me

nta

lP

rob

.Te

rm.

Hab

eas

Mu

ni.

Tota

l

Co

un

tyFe

lon

yM

isd

.H

ygie

ne

Juv.

Re

v.A

bu

seSu

p.C

t.C

ou

rtO

the

rH

ou

rs

PU

BLI

CD

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ESA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

HO

UR

SP

AID

BY

CIR

CU

IT&

CA

SETY

PE

11

Cir

cuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

3,2

32

.79

61

0.3

08

.50

17

3.8

06

9.5

02

,88

6.1

74

80

.80

6.2

02

57

.80

7,7

25

.86

PO

CA

HO

NTA

S1

,00

9.0

03

13

.75

37

.80

16

.30

19

.70

1,2

40

.31

0.0

00

.00

61

.20

2,6

98

.06

Tota

l4

,24

1.7

99

24

.05

46

.30

19

0.1

08

9.2

04

,12

6.4

84

80

.80

6.2

03

19

.00

10

,42

3.9

21

2C

ircu

itFA

YETT

E2

,75

1.9

84

65

.86

0.0

02

50

.30

84

.50

3,0

87

.52

42

9.5

00

.00

20

.10

7,0

89

.76

Tota

l2

,75

1.9

84

65

.86

0.0

02

50

.30

84

.50

3,0

87

.52

42

9.5

00

.00

20

.10

7,0

89

.76

13

Cir

cuit

KA

NA

WH

A1

1,8

97

.89

6,0

90

.37

0.0

01

,35

3.6

61

,01

8.1

61

0,8

66

.27

2,3

16

.60

2,2

59

.95

98

3.3

03

6,7

86

.18

Tota

l1

1,8

97

.89

6,0

90

.37

0.0

01

,35

3.6

61

,01

8.1

61

0,8

66

.27

2,3

16

.60

2,2

59

.95

98

3.3

03

6,7

86

.18

14

Cir

cuit

BR

AX

TON

1,8

20

.00

1,4

28

.96

18

.70

24

7.5

02

40

.90

2,8

40

.97

31

8.1

00

.00

38

.20

6,9

53

.33

CLA

Y1

,52

3.6

75

50

.36

6.0

01

23

.80

11

0.8

04

,36

5.7

72

29

.20

0.0

01

0.9

06

,92

0.4

9G

ILM

ER1

,02

3.3

09

15

.50

0.0

02

61

.19

80

.30

1,7

42

.00

47

0.6

00

.00

17

2.4

04

,66

5.2

9W

EBST

ER3

,10

1.5

05

73

.40

8.5

06

85

.90

12

0.8

85

,70

0.2

32

13

.30

0.0

04

1.8

01

0,4

45

.51

Tota

l7

,46

8.4

73

,46

8.2

13

3.2

01

,31

8.3

95

52

.88

14

,64

8.9

71

,23

1.2

00

.00

26

3.3

02

8,9

84

.61

15

Cir

cuit

HA

RR

ISO

N2

,76

0.7

07

90

.61

74

.80

51

7.8

02

16

.19

4,8

09

.42

34

7.8

00

.00

93

.51

9,6

10

.83

Tota

l2

,76

0.7

07

90

.61

74

.80

51

7.8

02

16

.19

4,8

09

.42

34

7.8

00

.00

93

.51

9,6

10

.83

16

Cir

cuit

MA

RIO

N6

,98

5.4

24

,13

2.4

72

62

.10

2,3

14

.83

80

7.8

82

,58

1.6

15

96

.60

37

9.6

05

25

.40

18

,58

5.9

1To

tal

6,9

85

.42

4,1

32

.47

26

2.1

02

,31

4.8

38

07

.88

2,5

81

.61

59

6.6

03

79

.60

52

5.4

01

8,5

85

.91

17

Cir

cuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A8

,10

5.5

25

,43

7.5

03

73

.40

2,1

77

.30

78

4.4

74

,02

7.9

08

61

.60

43

1.9

43

11

.00

22

,51

0.6

2To

tal

8,1

05

.52

5,4

37

.50

37

3.4

02

,17

7.3

07

84

.47

4,0

27

.90

86

1.6

04

31

.94

31

1.0

02

2,5

10

.62

18

Cir

cuit

PR

ESTO

N1

,61

6.6

86

22

.49

0.0

04

74

.80

80

.30

2,6

42

.10

43

5.0

00

.00

16

6.2

06

,03

7.5

7To

tal

1,6

16

.68

62

2.4

90

.00

47

4.8

08

0.3

02

,64

2.1

04

35

.00

0.0

01

66

.20

6,0

37

.57

19

Cir

cuit

BA

RB

OU

R1

,29

8.1

77

85

.50

14

.10

94

2.6

08

3.8

02

,71

7.6

19

4.1

00

.00

38

.80

5,9

74

.68

TAYL

OR

1,6

94

.70

1,1

27

.70

48

.70

1,5

97

.90

12

8.9

02

,00

8.8

00

.00

0.0

02

45

.50

6,8

52

.20

Tota

l2

,99

2.8

71

,91

3.2

06

2.8

02

,54

0.5

02

12

.70

4,7

26

.41

94

.10

0.0

02

84

.30

12

,82

6.8

82

0C

ircu

itR

AN

DO

LPH

3,6

08

.10

2,0

83

.57

41

.50

1,6

45

.30

25

5.1

01

,85

4.3

01

83

.50

34

4.9

01

71

.70

10

,18

7.9

7To

tal

3,6

08

.10

2,0

83

.57

41

.50

1,6

45

.30

25

5.1

01

,85

4.3

01

83

.50

34

4.9

01

71

.70

10

,18

7.9

72

1C

ircu

itG

RA

NT

1,2

59

.50

47

7.4

01

7.4

03

60

.80

18

5.9

01

,66

7.1

40

.00

0.0

04

8.3

74

,01

6.5

1M

INER

AL

1,4

97

.80

1,9

50

.81

16

.00

35

8.7

62

73

.10

47

2.3

02

60

.41

0.0

06

7.9

04

,89

7.0

8TU

CK

ER2

96

.80

24

4.9

13

.40

72

.60

15

.50

17

6.2

02

9.5

00

.00

0.0

08

38

.91

Tota

l3

,05

4.1

02

,67

3.1

23

6.8

07

92

.16

47

4.5

02

,31

5.6

42

89

.91

0.0

01

16

.27

9,7

52

.50



Par

ole

Cir

cuit

Me

nta

lP

rob

.Te

rm.

Hab

eas

Mu

ni.

Tota

l

Co

un

tyFe

lon

yM

isd

.H

ygie

ne

Juv.

Re

v.A

bu

seSu

p.C

t.C

ou

rtO

the

rH

ou

rs

PU

BLI

CD

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ESA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

HO

UR

SP

AID

BY

CIR

CU

IT&

CA

SETY

PE

22

Cir

cuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E2

,37

9.1

01

,69

2.5

42

3.7

05

26

.59

10

2.0

01

,13

2.7

01

18

.30

0.0

07

0.1

06

,04

5.0

3H

AR

DY

1,9

57

.71

1,2

30

.81

15

.40

50

7.6

41

64

.30

1,3

97

.80

57

.40

0.0

02

01

.42

5,5

32

.48

PEN

DLE

TON

52

1.6

72

12

.28

7.3

01

65

.36

0.0

04

34

.30

59

.30

0.0

02

0.5

01

,42

0.7

0To

tal

4,8

58

.48

3,1

35

.63

46

.40

1,1

99

.58

26

6.3

02

,96

4.8

02

35

.00

0.0

02

92

.02

12

,99

8.2

22

3C

ircu

itB

ERK

ELEY

5,1

64

.40

35

9.5

70

.00

52

1.0

92

74

.70

11

,21

0.9

68

39

.93

55

.30

12

0.3

01

8,5

46

.25

JEFF

ERSO

N2

,48

4.8

05

01

.50

0.0

07

0.6

09

5.0

03

,28

6.4

72

0.2

00

.00

75

.50

6,5

34

.07

MO

RG

AN

1,1

15

.10

18

7.0

00

.00

23

1.6

01

47

.10

2,7

71

.95

12

3.2

00

.00

13

.90

4,5

89

.85

Tota

l8

,76

4.3

01

,04

8.0

70

.00

82

3.2

95

16

.80

17

,26

9.3

89

83

.33

55

.30

20

9.7

02

9,6

70

.17

24

Cir

cuit

WA

YNE

1,0

78

.40

17

7.3

01

95

.80

11

9.7

02

14

.40

3,4

40

.75

17

0.3

01

09

.80

20

.00

5,5

26

.45

Tota

l1

,07

8.4

01

77

.30

19

5.8

01

19

.70

21

4.4

03

,44

0.7

51

70

.30

10

9.8

02

0.0

05

,52

6.4

52

5C

ircu

itB

OO

NE

2,0

61

.25

29

8.5

00

.00

1,4

83

.00

11

4.9

01

,74

4.5

21

30

.80

0.0

01

4.2

05

,84

7.1

7LI

NC

OLN

2,9

33

.34

72

0.1

02

97

.05

47

6.6

15

40

.30

2,0

77

.34

36

.80

0.0

05

57

.66

7,6

39

.20

Tota

l4

,99

4.6

01

,01

8.6

02

97

.05

1,9

59

.61

65

5.2

03

,82

1.8

61

67

.60

0.0

05

71

.86

13

,48

6.3

82

6C

ircu

itLE

WIS

3,1

49

.50

79

5.7

05

92

.42

39

8.3

01

91

.80

1,1

01

.93

10

2.1

00

.00

82

.40

6,4

14

.15

UP

SHU

R1

,97

4.9

01

,04

9.4

01

9.6

08

00

.30

18

6.6

01

,29

9.7

02

5.9

00

.00

15

4.1

05

,51

0.5

0To

tal

5,1

24

.40

1,8

45

.10

61

2.0

21

,19

8.6

03

78

.40

2,4

01

.63

12

8.0

00

.00

23

6.5

01

1,9

24

.65

27

Cir

cuit

WYO

MIN

G3

,78

8.5

03

,04

7.7

05

8.0

03

83

.60

72

.20

4,4

41

.11

27

3.4

07

.80

46

.20

12

,11

8.5

1To

tal

3,7

88

.50

3,0

47

.70

58

.00

38

3.6

07

2.2

04

,44

1.1

12

73

.40

7.8

04

6.2

01

2,1

18

.51

28

Cir

cuit

NIC

HO

LAS

1,3

41

.35

21

4.3

70

.00

51

.00

13

.50

2,8

66

.66

42

4.7

00

.00

2.9

04

,91

4.4

8To

tal

1,3

41

.35

21

4.3

70

.00

51

.00

13

.50

2,8

66

.66

42

4.7

00

.00

2.9

04

,91

4.4

82

9C

ircu

itP

UTN

AM

5,2

09

.96

4,4

33

.20

49

0.2

01

,73

2.3

84

76

.40

2,0

56

.64

55

.70

83

.40

52

0.8

91

5,0

58

.77

Tota

l5

,20

9.9

64

,43

3.2

04

90

.20

1,7

32

.38

47

6.4

02

,05

6.6

45

5.7

08

3.4

05

20

.89

15

,05

8.7

73

0C

ircu

itM

ING

O2

,37

2.5

35

14

.88

26

.60

25

9.6

04

2.4

04

,50

9.7

31

98

.16

0.0

01

42

.00

8,0

65

.90

Tota

l2

,37

2.5

35

14

.88

26

.60

25

9.6

04

2.4

04

,50

9.7

31

98

.16

0.0

01

42

.00

8,0

65

.90

31

Cir

cuit

MO

NR

OE

1,3

02

.10

43

4.3

60

.00

12

1.8

72

4.9

02

68

.10

18

.20

0.0

01

6.6

02

,18

6.1

2SU

MM

ERS

1,0

67

.20

33

6.8

03

.50

23

6.0

07

.50

53

2.4

00

.00

0.0

02

8.4

02

,21

1.8

0To

tal

2,3

69

.30

77

1.1

63

.50

35

7.8

73

2.4

08

00

.50

18

.20

0.0

04

5.0

04

,39

7.9

2W

VTO

TAL

15

7,0

36

.24

70

,01

3.4

88

,69

1.6

23

4,2

59

.23

11

,08

7.7

31

69

,00

0.8

21

7,1

88

.97

3,9

65

.98

8,3

39

.83

47

9,5

83

.89



APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES

PAID BY CASE TYPE



Felony 1,040.16

Misdemeanor 386.78

Mental Hygiene 166.9

Juvenile 583.96

Parole/Prob. Rev. 447.19

Term/ Abuse & Neglect 1,185.07

Habeas/Sup. Ct. 2,522.75

Municipal Court Charges 357.1

Other 437.54

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL STATEWIDE AVERAGE COSTS BY CASE TYPE

(Mandamus/Prohibition, Mag. Ct. Appeal, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

1,040.16

386.78

166.9

583.96

447.19

1,185.07

2,522.75

357.1

437.54

$0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000

Felony

Misdemeanor

Mental Hygiene

Juvenile

Parole/Prob. Rev.

Term/ Abuse & Neglect

Habeas/Sup. Ct.

Municipal Court Charges

Other



Felony 7,503,891.17Misdemeanor 3,347,307.55Mental Hygiene 432,490.65Juvenile 1,657,660.10Parole/Prob. Rev. 530,563.93Term/Abuse & Neglect 8,170,924.97Habeas/Supreme Court 785,122.00Municipal Court Charges 192,973.45Other 395,782.60(Mag. Ct. Appeal, Mandamus/Prohibition, Extradition, Contempt, Fugitive, Other)

Total Fees Paid 23,016,716.42

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL FEES PAID

Felony32.60%

Misdemeanor14.54%

Mental Hygiene1.88%

Juvenile7.20%




Municipal CourtCharges0.84%

Other1.72%



Par

ole

Cir

cuit

Me

nta

lP

rob

.Te

rm.

Hab

eas

Mu

ni.

Tota

lC

ou

nty

Felo

ny

Mis

d.

Hyg

ien

eJu

v.R

ev.

Ab

use

Sup

. Ct.

Co

urt

Oth

er

Fee

01

Cir

cuit

BROOKE

108,887.14

20,488.00

25,130.00

7,343.00

4,706.50

117,947.00

0.00

0.00

691.00

285,192.64

HANCOCK

77,243.00

17,214.50

8,442.50

18,423.50

11,018.50

135,948.50

6,848.00

660.50

1,175.00

276,974.00

OHIO

137,032.00

35,178.00

83,097.00

19,819.00

4,051.50

406,491.20

90,758.50

0.00

17,342.50

793,769.70

TOTA

L3

23

,16

2.1

47

2,8

80

.50

11

6,6

69

.50

45

,58

5.5

01

9,7

76

.50

66

0,3

86

.70

97

,60

6.5

06

60

.50

19

,20

8.5

01

,35

5,9

36

.34

02

Cir

cuit

MARSH

ALL

66,342.00

37,781.50

9,490.50

18,163.00

3,769.50

28,420.50

5,175.50

498.00

1,316.00

170,956.50

TYLER

19,258.50

5,885.00

3,543.50

9,239.00

3,780.50

44,618.50

0.00

0.00

1,539.50

87,864.50

WETZEL

80,985.00

5,087.50

8,179.50

10,202.50

1,623.50

45,312.50

0.00

0.00

69.00

151,459.50

TOTA

L1

66

,58

5.5

04

8,7

54

.00

21

,21

3.5

03

7,6

04

.50

9,1

73

.50

11

8,3

51

.50

5,1

75

.50

49

8.0

02

,92

4.5

04

10

,28

0.5

0

03

Cir

cuit

DODDRIDGE

51,980.00

35,355.50

2,998.50

22,092.00

13,202.50

71,220.50

0.00

671.00

3,557.50

201,077.50

PLEASA

NTS

37,701.50

22,738.00

575.50

13,877.50

3,675.00

35,686.50

877.50

0.00

1,003.50

116,135.00

RITCHIE

73,043.00

49,095.55

713.00

13,284.00

4,341.50

62,239.50

1,179.00

0.00

826.50

204,722.05

TOTA

L1

62

,72

4.5

01

07

,18

9.0

54

,28

7.0

04

9,2

53

.50

21

,21

9.0

01

69

,14

6.5

02

,05

6.5

06

71

.00

5,3

87

.50

52

1,9

34

.55

04

Cir

cuit

WIRT

23,201.00

18,895.00

560.50

15,868.00

503.50

11,150.50

7,113.50

0.00

1,315.00

78,607.00

WOOD

351,118.50

412,019.90

27,646.00

112,415.00

13,695.50

408,729.00

28,992.00

0.00

26,219.50

1,380,835.40

TOTA

L3

74

,31

9.5

04

30

,91

4.9

02

8,2

06

.50

12

8,2

83

.00

14

,19

9.0

04

19

,87

9.5

03

6,1

05

.50

0.0

02

7,5

34

.50

1,4

59

,44

2.4

0

05

Cir

cuit

CALH

OUN

43,162.00

8,050.00

127.00

0.00

0.00

124,999.70

0.00

0.00

975.50

177,314.20

JACKSO

N179,533.00

25,572.00

746.50

10,139.50

10,363.00

120,347.50

11,201.00

0.00

10,546.50

368,449.00

MASO

N126,467.95

66,053.00

11,742.00

37,700.00

12,969.00

83,020.50

11,401.50

1,352.50

10,260.50

360,966.95

ROANE

98,335.50

17,041.50

2,466.50

9,596.50

1,897.00

69,973.50

771.50

0.00

5,769.50

205,851.50

TOTA

L4

47

,49

8.4

51

16

,71

6.5

01

5,0

82

.00

57

,43

6.0

02

5,2

29

.00

39

8,3

41

.20

23

,37

4.0

01

,35

2.5

02

7,5

52

.00

1,1

12

,58

1.6

5

06

Cir

cuit

CABELL

441,655.50

47,434.00

82,727.00

35,861.50

25,507.50

279,085.50

37,461.50

485.50

15,778.00

965,996.00

TOTA

L4

41

,65

5.5

04

7,4

34

.00

82

,72

7.0

03

5,8

61

.50

25

,50

7.5

02

79

,08

5.5

03

7,4

61

.50

48

5.5

01

5,7

78

.00

96

5,9

96

.00

07

Cir

cuit

LOGAN

114,838.50

114,564.15

0.00

98,530.50

12,954.43

178,860.50

13,570.50

0.00

5,250.50

538,569.08

TOTA

L1

14

,83

8.5

01

14

,56

4.1

50

.00

98

,53

0.5

01

2,9

54

.43

17

8,8

60

.50

13

,57

0.5

00

.00

5,2

50

.50

53

8,5

69

.08

08

Cir

cuit

MCDOWELL

225,659.50

81,468.50

3,683.00

10,312.50

0.00

131,867.50

18,440.50

0.00

4,708.50

476,140.00

TOTA

L2

25

,65

9.5

08

1,4

68

.50

3,6

83

.00

10

,31

2.5

00

.00

13

1,8

67

.50

18

,44

0.5

00

.00

4,7

08

.50

47

6,1

40

.00

09

Cir

cuit

MER

CER

449,208.00

128,156.05

24,368.00

122,285.00

41,432.40

466,722.30

66,472.50

10,571.50

29,922.95

1,339,138.70

TOTA

L4

49

,20

8.0

01

28

,15

6.0

52

4,3

68

.00

12

2,2

85

.00

41

,43

2.4

04

66

,72

2.3

06

6,4

72

.50

10

,57

1.5

02

9,9

22

.95

1,3

39

,13

8.7

0

PU

BLI

C D

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ESA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

FEES

BY

CA

SE T

YP

E



Par

ole

Cir

cuit

Me

nta

lP

rob

.Te

rm.

Hab

eas

Mu

ni.

Tota

lC

ou

nty

Felo

ny

Mis

d.

Hyg

ien

eJu

v.R

ev.

Ab

use

Sup

. Ct.

Co

urt

Oth

er

Fee

PU

BLI

C D

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ESA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

FEES

BY

CA

SE T

YP

E

10

Cir

cuit

RALEIGH

242,941.00

58,676.00

1,420.55

27,865.50

15,040.50

503,733.75

31,829.50

0.00

4,259.50

885,766.30

TOTA

L2

42

,94

1.0

05

8,6

76

.00

1,4

20

.55

27

,86

5.5

01

5,0

40

.50

50

3,7

33

.75

31

,82

9.5

00

.00

4,2

59

.50

88

5,7

66

.30

11

Cir

cuit

GREENBRIER

150,841.50

28,503.50

442.50

8,395.00

3,235.60

136,481.90

21,816.00

291.00

11,983.00

361,990.00

POCAHONTA

S47,229.00

14,816.75

1,805.00

763.50

908.50

58,464.50

0.00

0.00

2,784.00

126,771.25

TOTA

L1

98

,07

0.5

04

3,3

20

.25

2,2

47

.50

9,1

58

.50

4,1

44

.10

19

4,9

46

.40

21

,81

6.0

02

91

.00

14

,76

7.0

04

88

,76

1.2

5

12

Cir

cuit

FAYETTE

132,328.00

22,914.00

0.00

12,025.50

4,166.50

149,838.50

19,471.50

0.00

954.50

341,698.50

TOTA

L1

32

,32

8.0

02

2,9

14

.00

0.0

01

2,0

25

.50

4,1

66

.50

14

9,8

38

.50

19

,47

1.5

00

.00

95

4.5

03

41

,69

8.5

0

13

Cir

cuit

KANAWHA

565,936.90

291,957.50

0.00

65,570.50

48,393.00

526,212.00

104,851.00

111,142.00

46,892.50

1,760,955.40

TOTA

L5

65

,93

6.9

02

91

,95

7.5

00

.00

65

,57

0.5

04

8,3

93

.00

52

6,2

12

.00

10

4,8

51

.00

11

1,1

42

.00

46

,89

2.5

01

,76

0,9

55

.40

14

Cir

cuit

BRAXTO

N86,776.00

67,475.00

1,085.50

12,197.50

11,554.50

138,668.00

14,878.50

0.00

1,833.00

334,468.00

CLAY

72,805.00

26,146.00

376.00

6,121.00

5,252.00

210,729.00

10,316.00

0.00

514.50

332,259.50

GILMER

48,676.50

44,101.50

0.00

12,713.50

3,793.50

82,464.00

22,037.00

0.00

8,356.00

222,142.00

WEB

STER

148,467.60

27,283.00

448.50

32,847.50

5,623.50

272,176.50

9,752.50

0.00

1,993.00

498,592.10

TOTA

L3

56

,72

5.1

01

65

,00

5.5

01

,91

0.0

06

3,8

79

.50

26

,22

3.5

07

04

,03

7.5

05

6,9

84

.00

0.0

01

2,6

96

.50

1,3

87

,46

1.6

0

15

Cir

cuit

HARRISON

131,085.50

38,615.50

3,710.00

25,599.00

10,224.50

232,431.00

16,285.00

0.00

4,400.00

462,350.50

TOTA

L1

31

,08

5.5

03

8,6

15

.50

3,7

10

.00

25

,59

9.0

01

0,2

24

.50

23

2,4

31

.00

16

,28

5.0

00

.00

4,4

00

.00

46

2,3

50

.50

16

Cir

cuit

MARION

324,346.00

192,887.50

13,094.50

108,653.70

37,798.50

120,968.50

27,023.00

17,700.00

24,303.00

866,774.70

TOTA

L3

24

,34

6.0

01

92

,88

7.5

01

3,0

94

.50

10

8,6

53

.70

37

,79

8.5

01

20

,96

8.5

02

7,0

23

.00

17

,70

0.0

02

4,3

03

.00

86

6,7

74

.70

17

Cir

cuit

MONONGALIA

383,130.18

256,173.65

19,920.00

104,728.50

37,165.00

190,239.50

38,954.00

20,501.45

14,683.00

1,065,495.28

TOTA

L3

83

,13

0.1

82

56

,17

3.6

51

9,9

20

.00

10

4,7

28

.50

37

,16

5.0

01

90

,23

9.5

03

8,9

54

.00

20

,50

1.4

51

4,6

83

.00

1,0

65

,49

5.2

8

18

Cir

cuit

PRESTO

N74,712.50

29,018.00

0.00

22,178.00

3,777.50

124,622.50

19,639.00

0.00

7,751.00

281,698.50

TOTA

L7

4,7

12

.50

29

,01

8.0

00

.00

22

,17

8.0

03

,77

7.5

01

24

,62

2.5

01

9,6

39

.00

0.0

07

,75

1.0

02

81

,69

8.5

0

19

Cir

cuit

BARBOUR

61,225.50

36,801.50

718.50

43,995.00

4,087.00

127,360.50

4,420.50

0.00

1,778.00

280,386.50

TAYLOR

80,227.50

53,308.50

2,689.50

73,917.50

6,008.50

93,670.00

0.00

0.00

11,327.50

321,149.00

TOTA

L1

41

,45

3.0

09

0,1

10

.00

3,4

08

.00

11

7,9

12

.50

10

,09

5.5

02

21

,03

0.5

04

,42

0.5

00

.00

13

,10

5.5

06

01

,53

5.5

0

20

Cir

cuit

RANDOLPH

175,364.70

100,853.00

2,219.50

80,742.50

12,429.50

91,817.50

8,321.50

16,408.50

8,298.50

496,455.20

TOTA

L1

75

,36

4.7

01

00

,85

3.0

02

,21

9.5

08

0,7

42

.50

12

,42

9.5

09

1,8

17

.50

8,3

21

.50

16

,40

8.5

08

,29

8.5

04

96

,45

5.2

0



Par

ole

Cir

cuit

Me

nta

lP

rob

.Te

rm.

Hab

eas

Mu

ni.

Tota

lC

ou

nty

Felo

ny

Mis

d.

Hyg

ien

eJu

v.R

ev.

Ab

use

Sup

. Ct.

Co

urt

Oth

er

Fee

PU

BLI

C D

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ESA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

FEES

BY

CA

SE T

YP

E

21

Cir

cuit

GRANT

60,601.50

23,287.00

863.00

17,246.00

8,803.50

78,317.50

0.00

0.00

2,279.00

191,397.50

MINER

AL

71,035.00

92,900.50

872.00

16,854.00

12,687.50

22,611.50

11,838.50

0.00

3,131.50

231,930.50

TUCKER

14,104.00

11,543.00

173.00

3,433.00

777.50

8,455.00

1,377.50

0.00

0.00

39,863.00

TOTA

L1

45

,74

0.5

01

27

,73

0.5

01

,90

8.0

03

7,5

33

.00

22

,26

8.5

01

09

,38

4.0

01

3,2

16

.00

0.0

05

,41

0.5

04

63

,19

1.0

0

22

Cir

cuit

HAMPSH

IRE

115,109.50

81,796.50

1,450.50

26,384.50

4,922.00

54,591.50

5,323.50

0.00

3,578.50

293,156.50

HARDY

93,127.00

58,568.50

953.00

24,529.80

7,931.50

68,681.00

2,583.00

0.00

9,678.00

266,051.80

PEN

DLETO

N24,521.00

10,008.50

362.50

7,969.00

0.00

20,819.50

2,696.50

0.00

962.50

67,339.50

TOTA

L2

32

,75

7.5

01

50

,37

3.5

02

,76

6.0

05

8,8

83

.30

12

,85

3.5

01

44

,09

2.0

01

0,6

03

.00

0.0

01

4,2

19

.00

62

6,5

47

.80

23

Cir

cuit

BER

KELEY

247,302.00

17,660.50

0.00

25,175.10

13,219.50

543,096.62

38,377.00

2,624.50

5,681.50

893,136.72

JEFFER

SON

122,788.00

24,861.50

0.00

3,507.00

4,935.00

160,269.50

909.00

0.00

3,665.50

320,935.50

MORGAN

53,777.50

9,023.00

0.00

11,284.00

6,953.50

132,598.00

5,598.00

0.00

663.50

219,897.50

TOTA

L4

23

,86

7.5

05

1,5

45

.00

0.0

03

9,9

66

.10

25

,10

8.0

08

35

,96

4.1

24

4,8

84

.00

2,6

24

.50

10

,01

0.5

01

,43

3,9

69

.72

24

Cir

cuit

WAYN

E56,272.00

9,642.50

12,167.00

6,066.50

10,608.00

179,100.50

7,799.50

5,709.00

1,064.00

288,429.00

TOTA

L5

6,2

72

.00

9,6

42

.50

12

,16

7.0

06

,06

6.5

01

0,6

08

.00

17

9,1

00

.50

7,7

99

.50

5,7

09

.00

1,0

64

.00

28

8,4

29

.00

25

Cir

cuit

BOONE

103,632.45

15,594.50

0.00

74,681.00

5,878.50

91,986.00

6,414.00

0.00

801.00

298,987.45

LINCOLN

140,372.50

34,466.50

13,760.00

24,193.50

25,941.50

101,533.00

1,736.00

0.00

26,852.50

368,855.50

TOTA

L2

44

,00

4.9

55

0,0

61

.00

13

,76

0.0

09

8,8

74

.50

31

,82

0.0

01

93

,51

9.0

08

,15

0.0

00

.00

27

,65

3.5

06

67

,84

2.9

5

26

Cir

cuit

LEWIS

150,591.50

38,248.50

28,989.60

19,683.50

9,395.00

51,787.50

4,650.50

0.00

3,854.00

307,200.10

UPSH

UR

95,320.50

50,263.00

1,034.00

37,561.50

9,331.00

61,434.50

1,165.50

0.00

7,286.50

263,396.50

TOTA

L2

45

,91

2.0

08

8,5

11

.50

30

,02

3.6

05

7,2

45

.00

18

,72

6.0

01

13

,22

2.0

05

,81

6.0

00

.00

11

,14

0.5

05

70

,59

6.6

0

27

Cir

cuit

WYO

MING

179,646.50

143,460.50

3,302.00

18,470.00

3,435.00

213,256.00

12,997.00

383.00

2,169.00

577,119.00

TOTA

L1

79

,64

6.5

01

43

,46

0.5

03

,30

2.0

01

8,4

70

.00

3,4

35

.00

21

3,2

56

.00

12

,99

7.0

03

83

.00

2,1

69

.00

57

7,1

19

.00

28

Cir

cuit

NICHOLAS

63,761.00

10,587.00

0.00

2,577.00

647.50

138,796.00

19,479.50

0.00

140.50

235,988.50

TOTA

L6

3,7

61

.00

10

,58

7.0

00

.00

2,5

77

.00

64

7.5

01

38

,79

6.0

01

9,4

79

.50

0.0

01

40

.50

23

5,9

88

.50

29

Cir

cuit

PUTN

AM

247,052.00

213,234.00

22,771.00

83,863.00

22,510.00

99,059.50

2,582.50

3,975.00

24,410.15

719,457.15

TOTA

L2

47

,05

2.0

02

13

,23

4.0

02

2,7

71

.00

83

,86

3.0

02

2,5

10

.00

99

,05

9.5

02

,58

2.5

03

,97

5.0

02

4,4

10

.15

71

9,4

57

.15

30

Cir

cuit

MINGO

117,337.75

27,205.50

1,449.00

12,840.00

2,050.00

222,924.50

8,917.50

0.00

7,016.00

399,740.25

TOTA

L1

17

,33

7.7

52

7,2

05

.50

1,4

49

.00

12

,84

0.0

02

,05

0.0

02

22

,92

4.5

08

,91

7.5

00

.00

7,0

16

.00

39

9,7

40

.25



Par

ole

Cir

cuit

Me

nta

lP

rob

.Te

rm.

Hab

eas

Mu

ni.

Tota

lC

ou

nty

Felo

ny

Mis

d.

Hyg

ien

eJu

v.R

ev.

Ab

use

Sup

. Ct.

Co

urt

Oth

er

Fee

PU

BLI

C D

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ESA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

FEES

BY

CA

SE T

YP

E

31

Cir

cuit

MONROE

63,392.50

21,150.00

0.00

6,168.00

1,230.50

13,164.50

819.00

0.00

771.00

106,695.50

SUMMER

S52,402.00

16,198.00

177.50

11,708.00

357.50

25,924.00

0.00

0.00

1,400.00

108,167.00

TOTA

L1

15

,79

4.5

03

7,3

48

.00

17

7.5

01

7,8

76

.00

1,5

88

.00

39

,08

8.5

08

19

.00

0.0

02

,17

1.0

02

14

,86

2.5

0

WV

TO

TAL

7,5

03

,89

1.1

73

,34

7,3

07

.55

43

2,4

90

.65

1,6

57

,66

0.1

05

30

,56

3.9

38

,17

0,9

24

.97

78

5,1

22

.00

19

2,9

73

.45

39

5,7

82

.60

23

,01

6,7

16

.42



APPOINTED COUNSEL

EXPENSES PAID BY CASE

TYPE



Felony 1,410,239.50Misdemeanor 224,613.63Mental Hygiene 13,119.53Juvenile 112,892.95Parole/Prob. Rev. 37,362.09Term/Abuse & Neglect 577,238.32Habeas/Supreme Court 100,364.46Municipal Court Charges 5,217.98Other 33,003.24

Total Hours Paid 2,514,051.70


APPOINTED COUNSEL EXPENSES PAIDINCLUDING DIRECT EXPENSES

Felony56.09%

Misdemeanor8.93%

Mental Hygiene0.52% Juvenile

4.49%





Other1.31%



Par

ole

Cir

cuit

Me

nta

lP

rob

.Te

rm.

Hab

eas

Mu

ni.

Tota

l

Co

un

tyFe

lon

yM

isd

.H

ygie

ne

Juv.

Re

v.A

bu

seSu

p.C

t.C

ou

rtO

the

rEx

pe

nse

s

01

Cir

cuit

BR

OO

KE

17

,52

7.7

21

,89

8.7

98

07

.33

58

0.6

34

18

.91

6,2

74

.19

0.0

00

.00

12

1.7

82

7,6

29

.35

HA

NC

OC

K1

1,9

32

.78

1,0

69

.31

28

9.3

17

02

.95

78

4.5

84

,40

9.2

71

,15

6.4

33

3.4

81

41

.46

20

,51

9.5

7O

HIO

11

,17

2.1

21

,17

7.5

17

4.6

97

82

.55

18

7.6

01

5,7

63

.98

7,4

81

.47

0.0

01

,64

6.3

03

8,2

86

.22

Tota

l4

0,6

32

.62

4,1

45

.61

1,1

71

.33

2,0

66

.13

1,3

91

.09

26

,44

7.4

48

,63

7.9

03

3.4

81

,90

9.5

48

6,4

35

.14

02

Cir

cuit

MA

RSH

ALL

1,7

55

.70

97

7.1

16

27

.27

3,4

78

.99

15

2.9

77

68

.31

1,9

30

.11

39

.48

18

.75

9,7

48

.69

TYLE

R1

,66

9.8

06

58

.53

49

0.9

77

67

.57

44

5.0

84

,02

2.7

50

.00

0.0

04

1.8

58

,09

6.5

5W

ETZE

L4

,24

1.0

33

35

.90

1,0

08

.42

76

7.8

26

2.6

53

,79

3.8

30

.00

0.0

02

.30

10

,21

1.9

5To

tal

7,6

66

.53

1,9

71

.54

2,1

26

.66

5,0

14

.38

66

0.7

08

,58

4.8

91

,93

0.1

13

9.4

86

2.9

02

8,0

57

.19

03

Cir

cuit

DO

DD

RID

GE

14

,85

6.9

45

,41

2.7

13

40

.83

2,2

15

.77

1,5

95

.03

8,7

79

.90

0.0

00

.00

39

7.8

73

3,5

99

.05

PLE

ASA

NTS

3,7

32

.31

3,2

85

.41

74

.46

1,0

89

.49

29

5.1

53

,13

0.5

12

96

.95

0.0

04

3.8

61

1,9

48

.14

RIT

CH

IE6

,88

0.0

57

,91

4.4

76

3.1

23

52

.96

1,0

02

.11

7,0

89

.31

86

8.3

00

.00

74

.56

24

,24

4.8

8To

tal

25

,46

9.3

01

6,6

12

.59

47

8.4

13

,65

8.2

22

,89

2.2

91

8,9

99

.72

1,1

65

.25

0.0

05

16

.29

69

,79

2.0

70

4C

ircu

itW

IRT

5,3

75

.61

3,2

47

.79

8.1

01

,77

6.9

75

3.4

98

66

.05

61

9.6

00

.00

94

.38

12

,04

1.9

9W

OO

D9

8,8

69

.34

50

,96

1.1

85

74

.83

7,0

11

.79

87

4.2

64

5,5

75

.83

10

,89

1.6

20

.00

3,6

93

.95

21

8,4

52

.80

Tota

l1

04

,24

4.9

55

4,2

08

.97

58

2.9

38

,78

8.7

69

27

.75

46

,44

1.8

81

1,5

11

.22

0.0

03

,78

8.3

32

30

,49

4.7

90

5C

ircu

itC

ALH

OU

N2

0,6

12

.27

1,8

13

.83

0.0

00

.00

0.0

01

6,6

83

.65

0.0

00

.00

11

4.3

43

9,2

24

.09

JAC

KSO

N3

5,7

07

.73

3,7

85

.21

11

8.2

01

,36

1.9

21

,59

1.3

72

1,0

97

.27

95

9.5

50

.00

2,4

93

.75

67

,11

5.0

0M

ASO

N1

0,6

90

.93

1,6

21

.11

12

.00

57

3.6

09

14

.60

1,5

02

.30

1,1

94

.19

5.6

61

84

.00

16

,69

8.3

9R

OA

NE

19

,43

0.6

23

,01

0.4

55

26

.36

42

7.3

84

97

.44

8,6

77

.82

60

.67

0.0

08

34

.06

33

,46

4.8

0To

tal

86

,44

1.5

51

0,2

30

.60

65

6.5

62

,36

2.9

03

,00

3.4

14

7,9

61

.04

2,2

14

.41

5.6

63

,62

6.1

51

56

,50

2.2

80

6C

ircu

itC

AB

ELL

77

,71

3.6

95

88

.82

63

0.1

24

95

.99

68

8.1

16

,58

9.8

63

,84

6.6

11

3.7

75

54

.54

91

,12

1.5

1To

tal

77

,71

3.6

95

88

.82

63

0.1

24

95

.99

68

8.1

16

,58

9.8

63

,84

6.6

11

3.7

75

54

.54

91

,12

1.5

10

7C

ircu

itLO

GA

N1

3,4

68

.33

6,4

72

.82

0.0

04

,45

8.2

11

,56

2.0

43

,87

0.1

17

01

.18

0.0

05

87

.70

31

,12

0.3

9To

tal

13

,46

8.3

36

,47

2.8

20

.00

4,4

58

.21

1,5

62

.04

3,8

70

.11

70

1.1

80

.00

58

7.7

03

1,1

20

.39

08

Cir

cuit

MC

DO

WEL

L3

0,7

17

.01

1,9

45

.22

1.8

02

62

.25

0.0

02

,95

4.0

81

,67

4.8

30

.00

65

2.1

93

8,2

07

.38

Tota

l3

0,7

17

.01

1,9

45

.22

1.8

02

62

.25

0.0

02

,95

4.0

81

,67

4.8

30

.00

65

2.1

93

8,2

07

.38

09

Cir

cuit

MER

CER

11

0,4

12

.30

11

,03

8.5

22

,42

2.5

71

2,3

92

.60

3,8

15

.24

49

,30

6.1

71

1,9

05

.40

54

0.8

92

,60

0.7

92

04

,43

4.4

8To

tal

11

0,4

12

.30

11

,03

8.5

22

,42

2.5

71

2,3

92

.60

3,8

15

.24

49

,30

6.1

71

1,9

05

.40

54

0.8

92

,60

0.7

92

04

,43

4.4

81

0C

ircu

itR

ALE

IGH

31

,76

2.4

95

,14

8.0

12

4.8

01

,17

4.0

01

,17

5.7

95

4,3

46

.40

4,3

91

.19

0.0

04

09

.33

98

,43

2.0

1To

tal

31

,76

2.4

95

,14

8.0

12

4.8

01

,17

4.0

01

,17

5.7

95

4,3

46

.40

4,3

91

.19

0.0

04

09

.33

98

,43

2.0

1

PU

BLI

CD

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ESA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

EXP

ENSE

SB

YC

ASE

TY

PE



Par

ole

Cir

cuit

Me

nta

lP

rob

.Te

rm.

Hab

eas

Mu

ni.

Tota

l

Co

un

tyFe

lon

yM

isd

.H

ygie

ne

Juv.

Re

v.A

bu

seSu

p.C

t.C

ou

rtO

the

rEx

pe

nse

s

PU

BLI

CD

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ESA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

EXP

ENSE

SB

YC

ASE

TY

PE

11

Cir

cuit

GR

EEN

BR

IER

3,8

59

.57

87

.42

0.0

04

.60

5.4

61

,30

5.8

08

81

.32

3.2

54

4.5

66

,19

1.9

8P

OC

AH

ON

TAS

2,1

85

.43

77

6.7

36

.58

0.0

03

6.4

55

86

.04

0.0

00

.00

14

5.8

03

,73

7.0

3To

tal

6,0

45

.00

86

4.1

56

.58

4.6

04

1.9

11

,89

1.8

48

81

.32

3.2

51

90

.36

9,9

29

.01

12

Cir

cuit

FAYE

TTE

8,8

66

.49

40

4.5

80

.00

68

8.5

42

,61

1.6

34

,34

6.5

81

,68

1.6

60

.00

18

.46

18

,61

7.9

4To

tal

8,8

66

.49

40

4.5

80

.00

68

8.5

42

,61

1.6

34

,34

6.5

81

,68

1.6

60

.00

18

.46

18

,61

7.9

41

3C

ircu

itK

AN

AW

HA

53

,17

6.6

69

,55

4.0

40

.00

2,1

68

.58

2,2

18

.40

22

,13

6.8

71

0,8

15

.97

2,9

77

.45

1,2

04

.95

10

4,2

52

.92

Tota

l5

3,1

76

.66

9,5

54

.04

0.0

02

,16

8.5

82

,21

8.4

02

2,1

36

.87

10

,81

5.9

72

,97

7.4

51

,20

4.9

51

04

,25

2.9

21

4C

ircu

itB

RA

XTO

N8

,44

2.0

15

,44

3.5

50

.00

98

5.2

71

,04

4.2

71

1,9

23

.28

1,4

07

.75

0.0

01

68

.71

29

,41

4.8

4C

LAY

9,9

35

.19

2,8

83

.74

0.0

04

9.8

29

82

.93

18

,27

9.8

53

65

.90

0.0

01

43

.58

32

,64

1.0

1G

ILM

ER4

,74

6.8

94

,32

9.9

20

.00

1,1

00

.97

59

2.3

49

,52

7.3

51

,63

9.5

80

.00

61

0.9

62

2,5

48

.01

WEB

STER

23

,25

9.3

82

,68

4.2

59

0.0

04

,48

2.1

37

32

.44

31

,28

3.9

17

44

.45

0.0

01

90

.06

63

,46

6.6

2To

tal

46

,38

3.4

71

5,3

41

.46

90

.00

6,6

18

.19

3,3

51

.98

71

,01

4.3

94

,15

7.6

80

.00

1,1

13

.31

14

8,0

70

.48

15

Cir

cuit

HA

RR

ISO

N4

3,6

32

.01

1,4

98

.38

33

0.7

64

,48

3.8

43

33

.36

8,3

68

.43

3,1

76

.35

0.0

01

69

.19

61

,99

2.3

2To

tal

43

,63

2.0

11

,49

8.3

83

30

.76

4,4

83

.84

33

3.3

68

,36

8.4

33

,17

6.3

50

.00

16

9.1

96

1,9

92

.32

16

Cir

cuit

MA

RIO

N9

6,6

18

.90

3,4

47

.82

40

2.9

94

,26

7.3

55

53

.79

2,0

13

.64

3,1

23

.28

28

3.0

87

01

.85

11

1,4

12

.70

Tota

l9

6,6

18

.90

3,4

47

.82

40

2.9

94

,26

7.3

55

53

.79

2,0

13

.64

3,1

23

.28

28

3.0

87

01

.85

11

1,4

12

.70

17

Cir

cuit

MO

NO

NG

ALI

A1

23

,86

0.4

49

,71

5.0

04

00

.60

3,8

43

.36

1,9

62

.28

9,8

12

.53

2,7

28

.84

78

0.4

69

64

.68

15

4,0

68

.19

Tota

l1

23

,86

0.4

49

,71

5.0

04

00

.60

3,8

43

.36

1,9

62

.28

9,8

12

.53

2,7

28

.84

78

0.4

69

64

.68

15

4,0

68

.19

18

Cir

cuit

PR

ESTO

N1

9,5

33

.33

2,1

81

.93

0.0

01

,01

1.4

22

22

.22

10

,29

9.9

01

,71

1.1

00

.00

32

2.4

23

5,2

82

.32

Tota

l1

9,5

33

.33

2,1

81

.93

0.0

01

,01

1.4

22

22

.22

10

,29

9.9

01

,71

1.1

00

.00

32

2.4

23

5,2

82

.32

19

Cir

cuit

BA

RB

OU

R3

,98

5.8

22

,25

7.0

62

0.7

41

,79

9.0

52

18

.81

8,3

09

.18

68

6.3

70

.00

98

.97

17

,37

6.0

0TA

YLO

R4

,25

8.8

42

,57

8.8

49

.22

2,7

59

.85

24

9.6

56

,65

1.0

00

.00

0.0

04

96

.87

17

,00

4.2

7To

tal

8,2

44

.66

4,8

35

.90

29

.96

4,5

58

.90

46

8.4

61

4,9

60

.18

68

6.3

70

.00

59

5.8

43

4,3

80

.27

20

Cir

cuit

RA

ND

OLP

H8

,82

8.3

23

,67

6.8

16

4.3

02

,72

2.0

34

63

.54

5,2

65

.18

47

2.7

73

72

.36

45

5.0

82

2,3

20

.39

Tota

l8

,82

8.3

23

,67

6.8

16

4.3

02

,72

2.0

34

63

.54

5,2

65

.18

47

2.7

73

72

.36

45

5.0

82

2,3

20

.39

21

Cir

cuit

GR

AN

T1

2,0

27

.48

58

3.7

27

6.7

63

,55

0.8

25

02

.48

5,6

83

.01

0.0

00

.00

18

2.6

62

2,6

06

.93

MIN

ERA

L1

7,4

40

.43

5,3

16

.09

21

.62

27

3.0

34

47

.42

2,1

36

.72

1,4

12

.32

0.0

01

5.6

52

7,0

63

.28

TUC

KER

1,2

92

.78

1,4

07

.89

21

.62

39

3.6

51

61

.33

46

2.7

13

06

.02

0.0

00

.00

4,0

46

.00

Tota

l3

0,7

60

.69

7,3

07

.70

12

0.0

04

,21

7.5

01

,11

1.2

38

,28

2.4

41

,71

8.3

40

.00

19

8.3

15

3,7

16

.21



Par

ole

Cir

cuit

Me

nta

lP

rob

.Te

rm.

Hab

eas

Mu

ni.

Tota

l

Co

un

tyFe

lon

yM

isd

.H

ygie

ne

Juv.

Re

v.A

bu

seSu

p.C

t.C

ou

rtO

the

rEx

pe

nse

s

PU

BLI

CD

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ESA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

EXP

ENSE

SB

YC

ASE

TY

PE

22

Cir

cuit

HA

MP

SHIR

E3

2,6

08

.77

3,6

66

.85

0.0

06

,47

9.8

91

29

.69

1,3

07

.51

2,0

00

.45

0.0

03

,63

3.6

34

9,8

26

.79

HA

RD

Y3

2,7

86

.70

4,7

17

.83

0.0

06

,47

5.9

32

76

.57

3,4

42

.13

1,3

40

.73

0.0

06

04

.83

49

,64

4.7

2P

END

LETO

N1

3,2

13

.43

43

2.6

12

2.5

65

5.8

80

.00

1,4

35

.45

13

9.4

10

.00

85

.15

15

,38

4.4

9To

tal

78

,60

8.9

08

,81

7.2

92

2.5

61

3,0

11

.70

40

6.2

66

,18

5.0

93

,48

0.5

90

.00

4,3

23

.61

11

4,8

56

.00

23

Cir

cuit

BER

KEL

EY1

17

,97

0.1

38

77

.51

0.0

03

,26

5.5

17

32

.82

58

,46

4.6

55

,34

5.0

41

3.6

96

0.0

81

86

,72

9.4

3JE

FFER

SON

56

,15

8.2

42

,64

3.3

10

.00

3,2

01

.60

85

.10

24

,14

8.7

60

.00

0.0

02

26

.35

86

,46

3.3

6M

OR

GA

N1

7,9

14

.70

91

8.5

40

.00

1,3

79

.56

72

8.5

71

5,8

57

.56

66

9.3

10

.00

42

.42

37

,51

0.6

6To

tal

19

2,0

43

.07

4,4

39

.36

0.0

07

,84

6.6

71

,54

6.4

99

8,4

70

.97

6,0

14

.35

13

.69

32

8.8

53

10

,70

3.4

52

4C

ircu

itW

AYN

E9

,86

7.5

05

55

.61

87

.19

64

4.7

12

69

.77

6,6

02

.63

99

9.8

70

.00

56

.36

19

,08

3.6

4To

tal

9,8

67

.50

55

5.6

18

7.1

96

44

.71

26

9.7

76

,60

2.6

39

99

.87

0.0

05

6.3

61

9,0

83

.64

25

Cir

cuit

BO

ON

E1

6,2

78

.31

15

4.4

70

.00

3,2

25

.54

19

0.0

91

,10

5.4

31

,25

3.9

90

.00

4.7

02

2,2

12

.53

LIN

CO

LN1

1,8

52

.54

1,6

03

.42

51

7.2

12

,47

9.2

42

,19

9.5

85

,25

5.9

32

33

.02

0.0

01

,21

4.6

12

5,3

55

.55

Tota

l2

8,1

30

.85

1,7

57

.89

51

7.2

15

,70

4.7

82

,38

9.6

76

,36

1.3

61

,48

7.0

10

.00

1,2

19

.31

47

,56

8.0

82

6C

ircu

itLE

WIS

14

,59

2.7

73

,11

8.2

32

,15

9.2

81

,34

3.0

79

10

.55

1,5

99

.92

14

1.7

40

.00

27

8.9

92

4,1

44

.55

UP

SHU

R5

,40

4.3

82

,69

9.8

15

.98

2,1

34

.98

38

4.4

31

,99

7.8

12

14

.04

0.0

08

91

.20

13

,73

2.6

3To

tal

19

,99

7.1

55

,81

8.0

42

,16

5.2

63

,47

8.0

51

,29

4.9

83

,59

7.7

33

55

.78

0.0

01

,17

0.1

93

7,8

77

.18

27

Cir

cuit

WYO

MIN

G4

1,5

31

.02

16

,22

1.3

81

72

.56

71

9.1

85

32

.76

12

,79

4.2

41

,86

4.0

40

.00

37

3.8

07

4,2

08

.98

Tota

l4

1,5

31

.02

16

,22

1.3

81

72

.56

71

9.1

85

32

.76

12

,79

4.2

41

,86

4.0

40

.00

37

3.8

07

4,2

08

.98

28

Cir

cuit

NIC

HO

LAS

18

,11

3.2

01

,02

2.6

40

.00

12

7.5

71

62

.62

6,2

09

.28

6,9

14

.41

0.0

07

75

.00

33

,32

4.7

2To

tal

18

,11

3.2

01

,02

2.6

40

.00

12

7.5

71

62

.62

6,2

09

.28

6,9

14

.41

0.0

07

75

.00

33

,32

4.7

22

9C

ircu

itP

UTN

AM

21

,35

7.8

31

1,2

00

.64

57

0.6

24

,78

8.1

01

,14

5.2

07

,90

6.7

21

01

.63

15

4.4

13

,67

1.3

15

0,8

96

.46

Tota

l2

1,3

57

.83

11

,20

0.6

45

70

.62

4,7

88

.10

1,1

45

.20

7,9

06

.72

10

1.6

31

54

.41

3,6

71

.31

50

,89

6.4

63

0C

ircu

itM

ING

O4

,77

5.4

97

35

.52

1.2

05

.40

1.1

72

,06

8.7

60

.00

0.0

01

79

.33

7,7

66

.87

Tota

l4

,77

5.4

97

35

.52

1.2

05

.40

1.1

72

,06

8.7

60

.00

0.0

01

79

.33

7,7

66

.87

31

Cir

cuit

MO

NR

OE

9,1

58

.23

1,5

55

.19

0.0

06

05

.89

72

.78

94

5.2

51

5.0

00

.00

99

.40

12

,45

1.7

4SU

MM

ERS

12

,17

7.5

21

,29

9.6

04

2.5

67

03

.15

85

.17

2,2

02

.72

0.0

00

.00

16

3.8

71

6,6

74

.59

Tota

l2

1,3

35

.75

2,8

54

.79

42

.56

1,3

09

.04

15

7.9

53

,14

7.9

71

5.0

00

.00

26

3.2

72

9,1

26

.33

WV

TOTA

L1

,41

0,2

39

.50

22

4,6

13

.63

13

,11

9.5

31

12

,89

2.9

53

7,3

62

.09

57

7,2

38

.32

10

0,3

64

.46

5,2

17

.98

33

,00

3.2

42

,51

4,0

51

.70



APPOINTED COUNSEL

EXPENSES PAID BY

CATEGORY



Expert Witness $422,257.13Court Reporter $95,041.97Investigator $533,651.33Travel $832,122.98Miscellaneous Office $276,193.27Paralegal $91,023.68Other $263,761.34Total Expenses $2,514,051.70

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL EXPENSES BY CATEGORY

Expert Witness16.80%

Court Reporter3.78%

Investigator21.23%

Travel33.10%

MiscellaneousOffice

10.99%

Paralegal3.62%

Other10.49%



Circuit Expert Court Misc. ExpenseCounty Witness Reporter Investigator Travel Office Paralegal Other Total

01 Circuit

BROOKE 3,850.00 353.75 5,785.20 15,686.49 1,613.89 320.00 20.02 27,629.35

HANCOCK 3,500.00 1,195.25 1,338.87 11,471.50 2,445.00 235.35 333.60 20,519.57

OHIO 10,666.57 1,776.50 724.42 13,646.80 7,513.10 392.00 3,566.83 38,286.22

Total 18,016.57 3,325.50 7,848.49 40,804.79 11,571.99 947.35 3,920.45 86,435.14

02 Circuit

MARSHALL 3,008.00 404.25 300.00 3,950.12 1,326.03 0.00 760.29 9,748.69

TYLER 0.00 0.00 0.00 7,745.85 350.70 0.00 0.00 8,096.55

WETZEL 200.00 1,103.25 0.00 7,814.81 1,093.89 0.00 0.00 10,211.95

Total 3,208.00 1,507.50 300.00 19,510.78 2,770.62 0.00 760.29 28,057.19

03 Circuit

DODDRIDGE 0.00 0.00 12,818.49 17,507.70 2,075.96 1,105.40 91.50 33,599.05

PLEASANTS 1,500.00 0.00 2,135.94 6,790.68 1,404.42 101.70 15.40 11,948.14

RITCHIE 0.00 585.20 9,699.74 9,831.19 2,115.30 1,461.54 551.91 24,244.88

Total 1,500.00 585.20 24,654.17 34,129.57 5,595.68 2,668.64 658.81 69,792.07

04 Circuit

WIRT 0.00 246.40 4,234.82 5,426.70 1,274.07 717.45 142.55 12,041.99

WOOD 13,937.50 15,648.96 120,932.36 35,215.34 21,580.16 6,899.30 4,239.18 218,452.80

Total 13,937.50 15,895.36 125,167.18 40,642.04 22,854.23 7,616.75 4,381.73 230,494.79

05 Circuit

CALHOUN 12,275.00 304.15 234.00 19,846.89 1,329.05 0.00 5,235.00 39,224.09

JACKSON 9,020.00 5,566.05 4,731.53 44,011.74 3,492.32 0.00 293.36 67,115.00

MASON 1,800.00 234.45 1,338.64 10,862.73 2,035.07 0.00 427.50 16,698.39

ROANE 1,700.00 976.05 0.00 29,873.17 911.26 0.00 4.32 33,464.80

Total 24,795.00 7,080.70 6,304.17 104,594.53 7,767.70 0.00 5,960.18 156,502.28

06 Circuit

CABELL 10,995.00 6,710.98 30,679.69 10,529.25 5,966.56 17,519.72 8,720.31 91,121.51

Total 10,995.00 6,710.98 30,679.69 10,529.25 5,966.56 17,519.72 8,720.31 91,121.51

07 Circuit

LOGAN 3,525.00 3,662.55 2,563.40 15,460.28 3,625.81 1,817.25 466.10 31,120.39

Total 3,525.00 3,662.55 2,563.40 15,460.28 3,625.81 1,817.25 466.10 31,120.39

08 Circuit

MCDOWELL 9,770.00 2,346.82 7,191.89 8,747.04 5,151.40 0.00 5,000.23 38,207.38

Total 9,770.00 2,346.82 7,191.89 8,747.04 5,151.40 0.00 5,000.23 38,207.38

09 Circuit

MERCER 22,885.35 4,288.40 25,691.50 73,929.25 19,453.61 7,896.00 50,290.37 204,434.48

Total 22,885.35 4,288.40 25,691.50 73,929.25 19,453.61 7,896.00 50,290.37 204,434.48

10 Circuit

RALEIGH 13,691.35 233.95 22,350.05 37,171.54 11,876.76 314.91 12,793.45 98,432.01

Total 13,691.35 233.95 22,350.05 37,171.54 11,876.76 314.91 12,793.45 98,432.01

11 Circuit

GREENBRIER 2,535.00 73.15 0.00 2,332.99 1,025.69 174.15 51.00 6,191.98

POCAHONTAS 0.00 75.50 0.00 2,544.05 185.83 631.65 300.00 3,737.03

Total 2,535.00 148.65 0.00 4,877.04 1,211.52 805.80 351.00 9,929.01

12 Circuit

FAYETTE 2,282.50 650.25 1,492.00 8,457.72 3,849.72 654.55 1,231.20 18,617.94

Total 2,282.50 650.25 1,492.00 8,457.72 3,849.72 654.55 1,231.20 18,617.94

13 Circuit

KANAWHA 7,875.00 1,985.12 36,933.26 32,818.63 20,146.31 2,224.60 2,270.00 104,252.92

Total 7,875.00 1,985.12 36,933.26 32,818.63 20,146.31 2,224.60 2,270.00 104,252.92

14 Circuit

BRAXTON 0.00 0.00 11.90 22,472.81 6,889.94 30.19 10.00 29,414.84

CLAY 0.00 254.10 3,664.95 24,045.76 4,045.80 620.00 10.40 32,641.01

GILMER 0.00 51.00 0.00 18,507.36 3,979.65 0.00 10.00 22,548.01

WEBSTER 3,945.00 2,647.60 0.00 46,905.67 7,988.35 90.00 1,890.00 63,466.62

Total 3,945.00 2,952.70 3,676.85 111,931.60 22,903.74 740.19 1,920.40 148,070.48


APPOINTED COUNSEL TOTAL EXPENSES BY CIRCUIT & CATEGORY






15 Circuit

HARRISON 10,125.00 2,851.28 27,272.30 11,370.03 6,266.28 3,200.00 907.43 61,992.32

Total 10,125.00 2,851.28 27,272.30 11,370.03 6,266.28 3,200.00 907.43 61,992.32

16 Circuit

MARION 16,350.51 6,310.25 8,771.37 6,939.38 9,674.27 3,180.43 60,186.49 111,412.70

Total 16,350.51 6,310.25 8,771.37 6,939.38 9,674.27 3,180.43 60,186.49 111,412.70

17 Circuit

MONONGALIA 10,673.80 2,466.50 64,979.20 19,774.48 12,043.87 4,939.05 39,191.29 154,068.19

Total 10,673.80 2,466.50 64,979.20 19,774.48 12,043.87 4,939.05 39,191.29 154,068.19

18 Circuit

PRESTON 2,898.96 181.45 12,720.84 11,162.82 6,716.35 1,109.10 492.80 35,282.32

Total 2,898.96 181.45 12,720.84 11,162.82 6,716.35 1,109.10 492.80 35,282.32

19 Circuit

BARBOUR 0.00 234.85 0.00 7,490.43 8,896.30 368.55 385.87 17,376.00

TAYLOR 0.00 86.33 0.00 7,917.86 8,691.77 80.00 228.31 17,004.27

Total 0.00 321.18 0.00 15,408.29 17,588.07 448.55 614.18 34,380.27

20 Circuit

RANDOLPH 1,400.00 277.20 1,703.92 13,244.59 4,858.79 168.00 667.89 22,320.39

Total 1,400.00 277.20 1,703.92 13,244.59 4,858.79 168.00 667.89 22,320.39

21 Circuit

GRANT 8,670.17 0.00 2,441.12 10,015.54 1,381.10 0.00 99.00 22,606.93

MINERAL 11,761.80 146.25 6,600.27 3,114.83 5,398.64 16.00 25.49 27,063.28

TUCKER 0.00 0.00 0.00 3,477.37 435.63 0.00 133.00 4,046.00

Total 20,431.97 146.25 9,041.39 16,607.74 7,215.37 16.00 257.49 53,716.21

22 Circuit

HAMPSHIRE 32,207.33 0.00 4,236.35 5,003.68 5,974.34 254.00 2,151.09 49,826.79

HARDY 30,678.38 0.00 3,670.36 7,634.36 4,548.14 142.00 2,971.48 49,644.72

PENDLETON 10,853.26 0.00 0.00 3,876.57 654.66 0.00 0.00 15,384.49

Total 73,738.97 0.00 7,906.71 16,514.61 11,177.14 396.00 5,122.57 114,856.00

23 Circuit

BERKELEY 91,599.89 18,345.95 11,840.77 18,213.24 16,027.15 16,599.65 14,102.78 186,729.43

JEFFERSON 31,036.13 3,725.66 12,897.40 10,922.36 6,411.40 8,979.30 12,491.11 86,463.36

MORGAN 14,634.13 547.05 0.00 12,366.01 2,500.07 7,170.50 292.90 37,510.66

Total 137,270.15 22,618.66 24,738.17 41,501.61 24,938.62 32,749.45 26,886.79 310,703.45

24 Circuit

WAYNE 0.00 2,814.50 4,752.47 9,664.66 1,671.61 180.40 0.00 19,083.64

Total 0.00 2,814.50 4,752.47 9,664.66 1,671.61 180.40 0.00 19,083.64

25 Circuit

BOONE 0.00 1,047.13 4,735.55 5,289.68 1,582.38 0.00 9,557.79 22,212.53

LINCOLN 1,800.00 242.55 5,172.28 13,073.19 1,380.93 31.50 3,655.10 25,355.55

Total 1,800.00 1,289.68 9,907.83 18,362.87 2,963.31 31.50 13,212.89 47,568.08

26 Circuit

LEWIS 94.00 10.00 5,984.70 15,438.23 2,601.77 0.00 15.85 24,144.55

UPSHUR 0.00 0.00 1,126.07 9,536.17 2,707.50 362.89 0.00 13,732.63

Total 94.00 10.00 7,110.77 24,974.40 5,309.27 362.89 15.85 37,877.18

27 Circuit

WYOMING 0.00 1,095.60 43,985.41 20,971.22 5,932.66 504.35 1,719.74 74,208.98

Total 0.00 1,095.60 43,985.41 20,971.22 5,932.66 504.35 1,719.74 74,208.98

28 Circuit

NICHOLAS 775.00 2,914.04 5,522.80 14,388.08 3,703.06 0.00 6,021.74 33,324.72

Total 775.00 2,914.04 5,522.80 14,388.08 3,703.06 0.00 6,021.74 33,324.72

29 Circuit

PUTNAM 3,800.00 371.70 7,072.47 28,958.12 7,967.24 9.00 2,717.93 50,896.46

Total 3,800.00 371.70 7,072.47 28,958.12 7,967.24 9.00 2,717.93 50,896.46






30 Circuit

MINGO 0.00 0.00 3,313.03 1,786.69 2,143.95 523.20 0.00 7,766.87

Total 0.00 0.00 3,313.03 1,786.69 2,143.95 523.20 0.00 7,766.87

31 Circuit

MONROE 3,937.50 0.00 0.00 7,854.29 659.95 0.00 0.00 12,451.74

SUMMERS 0.00 0.00 0.00 9,035.04 617.81 0.00 7,021.74 16,674.59

Total 3,937.50 0.00 0.00 16,889.33 1,277.76 0.00 7,021.74 29,126.33

WV TOTAL 422,257.13 95,041.97 533,651.33 832,122.98 276,193.27 91,023.68 263,761.34 2,514,051.70



APPOINTED COUNSEL

HOURS PAID IN COURT /

OUT OF COURT



In-Court at $65 per hour 71,770.08Out-Of-Court at $45 per hour 407,813.81

Total Hours Paid 479,583.89

APPOINTED COUNSEL TIME PAID IN/OUT-OF-COURT

In-Court at $65per hour14.97%

Out-Of-Court at$45 per hour

85.03%



Circuit/County In-Court Out-Of-Court Total Hours01 Circuit

BROOKE 832.10 5,135.66 5,967.76

HANCOCK 842.20 4,938.45 5,780.65

OHIO 1,457.12 15,534.58 16,991.70

Total 3,131.42 25,608.68 28,740.10

02 Circuit

MARSHALL 571.20 2,973.96 3,545.16

TYLER 253.90 1,585.80 1,839.70

WETZEL 451.10 2,714.17 3,165.27

Total 1,276.20 7,273.93 8,550.13

03 Circuit

DODDRIDGE 459.70 3,804.36 4,264.06

PLEASANTS 259.80 2,205.51 2,465.31

RITCHIE 513.30 3,807.94 4,321.24

Total 1,232.80 9,817.81 11,050.61

04 Circuit

WIRT 171.00 1,499.82 1,670.82

WOOD 3,531.09 25,584.68 29,115.78

Total 3,702.09 27,084.51 30,786.60

05 Circuit

CALHOUN 660.30 2,986.54 3,646.84

JACKSON 1,369.90 6,209.01 7,578.91

MASON 1,265.60 6,193.38 7,458.98

ROANE 766.50 3,467.31 4,233.81

Total 4,062.30 18,856.24 22,918.54

06 Circuit

CABELL 4,845.30 14,467.77 19,313.07

Total 4,845.30 14,467.77 19,313.07

07 Circuit

LOGAN 1,817.70 9,342.64 11,160.34

Total 1,817.70 9,342.64 11,160.34

08 Circuit

MCDOWELL 1,454.30 8,480.21 9,934.51

Total 1,454.30 8,480.21 9,934.51

09 Circuit

MERCER 4,409.40 23,389.41 27,798.81

Total 4,409.40 23,389.41 27,798.81

10 Circuit

RALEIGH 2,948.95 15,424.04 18,372.99

Total 2,948.95 15,424.04 18,372.99

11 Circuit

GREENBRIER 716.30 7,009.56 7,725.86

POCAHONTAS 267.90 2,430.16 2,698.06

Total 984.20 9,439.72 10,423.92

12 Circuit

FAYETTE 1,132.90 5,956.86 7,089.76

Total 1,132.90 5,956.86 7,089.76


APPOINTED COUNSEL IN/OUT OF COURT HOURS



Circuit/County In-Court Out-Of-Court Total Hours



13 Circuit

KANAWHA 5,278.69 31,507.49 36,786.18

Total 5,278.69 31,507.49 36,786.18

14 Circuit

BRAXTON 1,078.40 5,874.93 6,953.33

CLAY 1,041.80 5,878.69 6,920.49

GILMER 610.20 4,055.09 4,665.29

WEBSTER 1,427.20 9,018.31 10,445.51

Total 4,157.60 24,827.01 28,984.61

15 Circuit

HARRISON 1,493.10 8,117.73 9,610.83

Total 1,493.10 8,117.73 9,610.83

16 Circuit

MARION 1,520.40 17,065.51 18,585.91

Total 1,520.40 17,065.51 18,585.91

17 Circuit

MONONGALIA 2,625.80 19,884.82 22,510.62

Total 2,625.80 19,884.82 22,510.62

18 Circuit

PRESTON 500.40 5,537.17 6,037.57

Total 500.40 5,537.17 6,037.57

19 Circuit

BARBOUR 576.30 5,398.38 5,974.68

TAYLOR 640.00 6,212.20 6,852.20

Total 1,216.30 11,610.58 12,826.88

20 Circuit

RANDOLPH 1,899.80 8,288.17 10,187.97

Total 1,899.80 8,288.17 10,187.97

21 Circuit

GRANT 532.70 3,483.81 4,016.51

MINERAL 578.10 4,318.98 4,897.08

TUCKER 105.60 733.31 838.91

Total 1,216.40 8,536.10 9,752.50

22 Circuit

HAMPSHIRE 1,056.50 4,988.53 6,045.03

HARDY 854.50 4,677.98 5,532.48

PENDLETON 170.40 1,250.30 1,420.70

Total 2,081.40 10,916.82 12,998.22

23 Circuit

BERKELEY 2,927.70 15,618.55 18,546.25

JEFFERSON 1,345.10 5,188.97 6,534.07

MORGAN 667.70 3,922.15 4,589.85

Total 4,940.50 24,729.67 29,670.17

24 Circuit

WAYNE 1,986.90 3,539.55 5,526.45

Total 1,986.90 3,539.55 5,526.45



Circuit/County In-Court Out-Of-Court Total Hours



25 Circuit

BOONE 1,793.20 4,053.97 5,847.17

LINCOLN 1,254.50 6,384.70 7,639.20

Total 3,047.70 10,438.68 13,486.38

26 Circuit

LEWIS 928.12 5,486.03 6,414.15

UPSHUR 771.20 4,739.30 5,510.50

Total 1,699.32 10,225.33 11,924.65

27 Circuit

WYOMING 1,589.30 10,529.21 12,118.51

Total 1,589.30 10,529.21 12,118.51

28 Circuit

NICHOLAS 741.80 4,172.68 4,914.48

Total 741.80 4,172.68 4,914.48

29 Circuit

PUTNAM 2,090.60 12,968.17 15,058.77

Total 2,090.60 12,968.17 15,058.77

30 Circuit

MINGO 1,838.70 6,227.20 8,065.90

Total 1,838.70 6,227.20 8,065.90

31 Circuit

MONROE 416.00 1,770.12 2,186.12

SUMMERS 431.80 1,780.00 2,211.80

Total 847.80 3,550.12 4,397.92

WV TOTAL 71,770.08 407,813.81 479,583.89



APPOINTED COUNSEL

CLAIMS PAID WITHOUT

SUPPLEMENTAL* OR

DIRECT EXPENSES

* Supplemental means that more than one claim for payment was submitted in a case. For statistical

purposes, therefore, the number of claims is reduced by these additional claims so that the resulting

number fairly represents the number of actual cases.



Felony 7,382Misdemeanor 8,697Mental Hygiene 2,666Juvenile 2,990Parole/Prob. Rev. 1,162Term/Abuse & Neglect 7,162Habeas/Supreme Court 304Municipal Court Charges 530Other 924

Total Claims Paid 31,817

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL CLAIMS PAID

WITHOUT SUPPLEMENTAL OR DIRECT EXPENSES


Felony23.20%

Misdemeanor27.33%

Mental Hygiene8.38% Juvenile

9.40% Parole/Prob. Rev.3.65%




Other2.90%



ParoleCircuit Mental Prob. Term. Habeas Muni. TotalCounty Felony Misd. Hygiene Juv. Rev Abuse Sup. Ct. Court Other Claims01 Circuit

BROOKE 71 43 90 8 9 73 0 0 1 295

HANCOCK 98 44 29 32 21 117 1 3 5 350

OHIO 77 50 272 24 6 159 21 0 7 616

Total 246 137 391 64 36 349 22 3 13 1,261

02 Circuit

MARSHALL 91 92 75 25 12 30 2 1 4 332

TYLER 16 10 20 13 5 23 0 0 3 90

WETZEL 57 16 61 11 5 31 0 0 1 182

Total 164 118 156 49 22 84 2 1 8 604

03 Circuit

DODDRIDGE 41 71 14 36 32 69 0 1 14 278

PLEASANTS 36 55 3 31 9 33 1 0 7 175

RITCHIE 43 98 3 13 10 54 2 0 3 226

Total 120 224 20 80 51 156 3 1 24 679

04 Circuit

WIRT 22 51 5 35 2 13 2 0 4 134

WOOD 335 1,044 265 297 45 490 15 0 92 2,583

Total 357 1,095 270 332 47 503 17 0 96 2,717

05 Circuit

CALHOUN 25 11 1 0 0 118 0 0 4 159

JACKSON 123 55 4 7 23 92 7 0 20 331

MASON 190 208 66 89 33 74 8 2 18 688

ROANE 66 33 12 11 3 112 1 0 14 252

Total 404 307 83 107 59 396 16 2 56 1,430

06 Circuit

CABELL 406 136 800 160 81 381 14 2 23 2,003

Total 406 136 800 160 81 381 14 2 23 2,003

07 Circuit

LOGAN 133 341 0 152 18 120 6 0 11 781

Total 133 341 0 152 18 120 6 0 11 781

08 Circuit

MCDOWELL 156 163 15 17 0 106 6 0 9 472

Total 156 163 15 17 0 106 6 0 9 472

09 Circuit

MERCER 404 377 127 213 65 637 24 32 55 1,934

Total 404 377 127 213 65 637 24 32 55 1,934

10 Circuit

RALEIGH 221 178 9 47 23 644 11 0 5 1,138

Total 221 178 9 47 23 644 11 0 5 1,138

11 Circuit

GREENBRIER 64 46 3 9 6 97 8 1 9 243

POCAHONTAS 34 28 20 2 2 32 0 0 3 121

Total 98 74 23 11 8 129 8 1 12 364





ParoleCircuit Mental Prob. Term. Habeas Muni. TotalCounty Felony Misd. Hygiene Juv. Rev Abuse Sup. Ct. Court Other Claims



12 Circuit

FAYETTE 143 105 0 17 7 157 7 0 4 440

Total 143 105 0 17 7 157 7 0 4 440

13 Circuit

KANAWHA 763 625 0 124 83 534 30 257 59 2,475

Total 763 625 0 124 83 534 30 257 59 2,475

14 Circuit

BRAXTON 89 150 13 21 18 141 6 0 9 447

CLAY 47 67 1 5 11 162 4 0 2 299

GILMER 45 108 0 16 8 35 6 0 36 254

WEBSTER 84 67 3 20 10 164 5 0 6 359

Total 265 392 17 62 47 502 21 0 53 1,359

15 Circuit

HARRISON 78 105 30 35 17 132 13 0 9 419

Total 78 105 30 35 17 132 13 0 9 419

16 Circuit

MARION 358 531 104 228 100 172 11 42 64 1,610

Total 358 531 104 228 100 172 11 42 64 1,610

17 Circuit

MONONGALIA 356 638 140 125 66 142 13 67 43 1,590

Total 356 638 140 125 66 142 13 67 43 1,590

18 Circuit

PRESTON 45 58 0 12 9 121 3 0 8 256

Total 45 58 0 12 9 121 3 0 8 256

19 Circuit

BARBOUR 80 106 3 60 11 79 2 0 6 347

TAYLOR 110 122 7 161 16 77 0 0 22 515

Total 190 228 10 221 27 156 2 0 28 862

20 Circuit

RANDOLPH 217 300 12 81 43 68 6 62 19 808

Total 217 300 12 81 43 68 6 62 19 808

21 Circuit

GRANT 56 59 5 37 20 40 0 0 7 224

MINERAL 147 337 7 70 50 30 6 0 10 657

TUCKER 17 36 1 9 2 4 0 0 0 69

Total 220 432 13 116 72 74 6 0 17 950

22 Circuit

HAMPSHIRE 138 281 10 74 16 35 4 0 41 599

HARDY 92 169 4 55 18 38 3 0 18 397

PENDLETON 17 25 2 10 0 15 3 0 3 75

Total 247 475 16 139 34 88 10 0 62 1,071

23 Circuit

BERKELEY 223 67 0 42 27 235 21 7 4 626



ParoleCircuit Mental Prob. Term. Habeas Muni. TotalCounty Felony Misd. Hygiene Juv. Rev Abuse Sup. Ct. Court Other Claims



JEFFERSON 125 93 0 12 16 93 1 0 5 345

MORGAN 43 17 0 13 12 54 3 0 3 145

Total 391 177 0 67 55 382 25 7 12 1,116

24 Circuit

WAYNE 86 43 74 25 30 198 3 44 3 506

Total 86 43 74 25 30 198 3 44 3 506

25 Circuit

BOONE 84 53 0 150 11 82 2 0 3 385

LINCOLN 129 68 54 36 28 88 2 0 135 540

Total 213 121 54 186 39 170 4 0 138 925

26 Circuit

LEWIS 151 95 194 20 22 37 3 0 6 528

UPSHUR 89 155 5 79 25 54 2 0 16 425

Total 240 250 199 99 47 91 5 0 22 953

27 Circuit

WYOMING 212 314 11 28 5 265 3 1 6 845

Total 212 314 11 28 5 265 3 1 6 845

28 Circuit

NICHOLAS 78 38 0 9 1 101 5 0 1 233

Total 78 38 0 9 1 101 5 0 1 233

29 Circuit

PUTNAM 276 434 83 116 55 90 2 8 48 1,112

Total 276 434 83 116 55 90 2 8 48 1,112

30 Circuit

MINGO 135 107 8 20 7 160 5 0 8 450

Total 135 107 8 20 7 160 5 0 8 450

31 Circuit

MONROE 75 104 0 21 6 21 1 0 5 233

SUMMERS 85 70 1 27 2 33 0 0 3 221

Total 160 174 1 48 8 54 1 0 8 454

WV TOTAL 7,382 8,697 2,666 2,990 1,162 7,162 304 530 924 31,817



APPOINTED COUNSEL

AVERAGE COST

BY CASE TYPE



Parole

Circuit Mental Prob. Term. Habeas Muni.

County Felony Misd. Hygiene Juv. Rev. Abuse Sup. Ct. Court Other Average

01 Circuit

BROOKE 1,541.64 476.31 288.19 990.45 512.54 1,656.28 0.00 0.00 406.39 996.25

HANCOCK 775.44 365.68 301.10 597.70 421.54 1,150.47 2,668.14 231.33 263.29 768.72

OHIO 1,665.21 586.38 305.78 858.40 706.52 2,574.73 4,465.45 0.00 2,373.60 1,286.02

Circuit Average 1,272.01 484.44 301.38 744.56 481.08 1,902.59 4,249.78 231.33 1,407.87 1,070.01

02 Circuit

MARSHALL 732.23 391.50 134.90 832.38 326.87 912.15 3,552.81 537.48 333.69 525.31

TYLER 1,046.42 654.35 201.72 769.74 845.12 2,114.84 0.00 0.00 527.12 1,020.86

WETZEL 1,352.79 338.96 150.62 997.30 337.23 1,584.08 0.00 0.00 71.30 859.95

Circuit Average 990.07 405.80 149.62 852.38 447.01 1,476.00 3,552.81 537.48 373.43 700.22

03 Circuit

DODDRIDGE 1,095.69 509.60 238.52 656.97 462.42 1,126.77 0.00 671.00 282.53 757.02

PLEASANTS 1,062.41 400.36 216.65 482.81 441.13 1,078.25 1,174.45 0.00 149.62 670.59

RITCHIE 1,354.63 504.51 258.71 1,049.00 411.05 1,216.29 1,023.65 0.00 300.35 870.60

Circuit Average 1,183.61 479.85 238.27 653.23 446.51 1,147.23 1,073.92 671.00 245.99 774.51

04 Circuit

WIRT 921.83 402.60 113.72 490.14 185.66 924.35 3,866.55 0.00 281.88 604.33

WOOD 839.53 377.94 106.49 399.42 269.81 839.75 1,899.22 0.00 302.16 526.08

Circuit Average 844.03 379.00 106.63 409.17 265.38 841.74 2,070.29 0.00 301.18 529.76

05 Circuit

CALHOUN 1,932.55 821.99 127.00 0.00 0.00 1,124.47 0.00 0.00 272.46 1,230.33

JACKSON 1,582.65 533.77 216.18 1,643.06 478.17 1,414.45 1,520.07 0.00 566.97 1,209.90

MASON 672.35 314.76 178.09 430.04 396.67 1,142.20 1,574.46 679.08 497.36 528.94

ROANE 1,570.21 607.63 249.41 911.26 798.15 689.92 832.17 0.00 388.44 899.69

Circuit Average 1,191.83 403.01 189.62 558.87 448.13 1,078.02 1,505.20 679.08 479.66 837.13

06 Circuit

CABELL 1,057.78 340.59 104.07 224.43 323.40 742.01 2,581.76 249.64 653.30 502.43

Circuit Average 1,057.78 340.59 104.07 224.43 323.40 742.01 2,581.76 249.64 653.30 502.43

07 Circuit

LOGAN 897.25 343.86 0.00 673.13 806.47 1,522.76 2,378.61 0.00 530.75 709.45

Circuit Average 897.25 343.86 0.00 673.13 806.47 1,522.76 2,378.61 0.00 530.75 709.45

08 Circuit

MCDOWELL 1,385.82 505.54 245.65 622.04 0.00 1,248.35 3,352.56 0.00 536.07 1,016.50

Circuit Average 1,385.82 505.54 245.65 622.04 0.00 1,248.35 3,352.56 0.00 536.07 1,016.50

09 Circuit

MERCER 1,193.22 347.99 210.95 623.51 603.30 790.24 2,702.69 317.50 570.59 747.86

Circuit Average 1,193.22 347.99 210.95 623.51 603.30 790.24 2,702.69 317.50 570.59 747.86

10 Circuit

RALEIGH 1,052.50 350.68 160.59 617.86 648.65 825.56 2,587.19 0.00 778.14 806.72

Circuit Average 1,052.50 350.68 160.59 617.86 648.65 825.56 2,587.19 0.00 778.14 806.72

11 Circuit

GREENBRIER 2,119.19 583.49 147.50 933.29 540.18 1,420.49 2,837.17 294.25 1,202.76 1,438.21

POCAHONTAS 1,267.04 537.71 90.58 381.75 472.48 1,845.33 0.00 0.00 732.45 1,019.60

Circuit Average 1,822.46 566.47 98.00 833.01 523.25 1,525.88 2,837.17 294.25 1,068.38 1,298.67

12 Circuit

FAYETTE 967.09 219.99 0.00 747.88 847.27 982.07 2,350.35 0.00 243.24 804.28

Circuit Average 967.09 219.99 0.00 747.88 847.27 982.07 2,350.35 0.00 243.24 804.28

13 Circuit

KANAWHA 737.04 453.40 0.00 546.28 550.12 1,019.24 3,304.77 414.98 775.77 708.94

Circuit Average 737.04 453.40 0.00 546.28 550.12 1,019.24 3,304.77 414.98 775.77 708.94


APPOINTED COUNSEL AVERAGE COST BY CASE TYPE



Parole





14 Circuit

BRAXTON 1,012.96 467.43 83.50 627.75 663.09 1,053.09 2,714.38 0.00 222.41 787.63

CLAY 1,477.50 387.06 376.00 1,234.16 519.58 1,387.93 2,670.48 0.00 329.04 1,140.31

GILMER 1,090.27 448.44 0.00 863.40 548.23 2,628.32 3,382.37 0.00 249.08 944.75

WEBSTER 1,770.38 428.10 179.50 1,866.48 635.59 1,839.15 1,749.49 0.00 363.84 1,490.87

Circuit Average 1,361.85 440.95 117.65 1,137.06 603.58 1,525.69 2,658.33 0.00 260.56 1,082.89

15 Circuit

HARRISON 1,648.28 371.42 134.69 813.05 586.55 1,824.24 1,390.10 0.00 456.92 1,152.40

Circuit Average 1,648.28 371.42 134.69 813.05 586.55 1,824.24 1,390.10 0.00 456.92 1,152.40

16 Circuit

MARION 1,063.04 360.91 129.78 490.96 345.52 706.79 2,318.94 418.21 362.39 580.53

Circuit Average 1,063.04 360.91 129.78 490.96 345.52 706.79 2,318.94 418.21 362.39 580.53

17 Circuit

MONONGALIA 1,192.92 391.01 144.12 835.17 528.75 1,360.90 2,977.35 308.43 340.17 706.17

Circuit Average 1,192.92 391.01 144.12 835.17 528.75 1,360.90 2,977.35 308.43 340.17 706.17

18 Circuit

PRESTON 1,624.93 520.00 0.00 1,783.80 399.97 1,096.93 4,270.02 0.00 1,009.18 1,144.34

Circuit Average 1,624.93 520.00 0.00 1,783.80 399.97 1,096.93 4,270.02 0.00 1,009.18 1,144.34

19 Circit

BARBOUR 776.33 361.65 246.41 763.23 331.22 1,695.87 2,553.44 0.00 312.83 836.41

TAYLOR 704.05 404.98 385.53 476.26 368.13 1,286.17 0.00 0.00 492.68 620.46

Circuit Average 733.81 385.96 343.80 554.17 352.13 1,493.61 2,553.44 0.00 456.71 705.79

20 Circuit

RANDOLPH 815.01 342.72 190.32 1,030.43 286.51 1,386.90 1,256.32 270.66 460.71 627.30

Circuit Average 815.01 342.72 190.32 1,030.43 286.51 1,386.90 1,256.32 270.66 460.71 627.30

21 Circuit

GRANT 1,190.64 385.01 187.95 533.25 423.00 2,048.79 0.00 0.00 351.67 902.97

MINERAL 556.45 286.35 127.66 244.67 252.59 798.33 1,656.35 0.00 314.72 380.87

TUCKER 855.38 359.75 194.62 425.18 469.42 2,229.43 1,683.52 0.00 0.00 618.44

Circuit Average 741.60 306.21 156.00 353.82 307.63 1,548.24 1,659.37 0.00 329.93 523.19

22 Circuit

HAMPSHIRE 959.21 298.82 145.05 405.73 315.73 1,597.11 1,830.99 0.00 163.91 544.42

HARDY 1,176.76 367.94 238.25 516.76 410.40 1,849.31 1,307.91 0.00 541.20 744.57

PENDLETON 1,715.20 417.64 192.53 802.49 0.00 1,483.66 945.30 0.00 349.22 1,034.05

Circuit Average 1,100.23 329.59 174.29 476.13 368.33 1,688.51 1,408.36 0.00 280.95 653.80

23 Circuit

BERKELEY 1,246.66 276.69 0.00 661.41 481.11 2,387.15 1,748.88 376.88 1,435.40 1,499.81

JEFFERSON 1,147.09 292.60 0.00 516.05 313.76 1,691.91 909.00 0.00 778.37 1,034.01

MORGAN 1,405.73 552.31 0.00 974.12 640.17 2,559.58 2,089.10 0.00 235.31 1,629.17

Circuit Average 1,231.82 312.76 0.00 692.94 467.62 2,230.16 1,755.12 376.88 861.61 1,371.60

24 Circuit

WAYNE 688.95 231.78 165.60 258.12 339.93 933.18 2,933.12 129.75 373.45 590.24

Circuit Average 688.95 231.78 165.60 258.12 339.93 933.18 2,933.12 129.75 373.45 590.24

25 Circuit

BOONE 1,303.38 291.65 0.00 515.94 404.57 1,121.58 2,556.00 0.00 268.57 801.00

LINCOLN 1,035.54 508.03 264.39 701.91 804.03 1,199.88 984.51 0.00 197.66 682.03

Circuit Average 1,138.64 414.55 264.39 553.33 684.19 1,162.10 1,927.40 0.00 199.12 730.76

26 Circuit

LEWIS 1,038.89 417.85 158.92 1,051.33 429.40 1,442.90 1,597.41 0.00 688.83 609.09

UPSHUR 1,027.80 331.02 208.00 502.49 313.40 1,174.67 689.77 0.00 511.11 622.76

Circuit Average 1,034.67 364.21 160.14 613.36 364.02 1,283.73 1,234.36 0.00 559.58 615.24



Parole





27 Circuit

WYOMING 834.63 446.04 315.87 685.33 661.29 834.13 3,715.26 383.00 363.26 684.89

Circuit Average 834.63 446.04 315.87 685.33 661.29 834.13 3,715.26 383.00 363.26 684.89

28 Circuit

NICHOLAS 998.47 305.52 0.00 300.51 810.12 1,435.70 3,770.56 0.00 457.75 1,122.14

Circuit Average 998.47 305.52 0.00 300.51 810.12 1,435.70 3,770.56 0.00 457.75 1,122.14

29 Circuit

PUTNAM 885.84 504.35 281.22 757.70 407.85 1,162.68 1,342.07 458.82 561.63 664.67

Circuit Average 885.84 504.35 281.22 757.70 407.85 1,162.68 1,342.07 458.82 561.63 664.67

30 Circuit

MINGO 884.88 258.71 181.28 642.27 293.02 1,397.47 1,783.50 0.00 899.42 895.62

Circuit Average 884.88 258.71 181.28 642.27 293.02 1,397.47 1,783.50 0.00 899.42 895.62

31 Circuit

MONROE 895.69 214.20 0.00 322.57 217.21 671.89 834.00 0.00 174.08 494.39

SUMMERS 687.02 246.45 220.06 459.67 221.34 852.32 0.00 0.00 521.29 540.44

Circuit Average 783.60 227.13 220.06 399.69 218.24 782.16 834.00 0.00 304.28 516.93

State Average 1,040.16 386.78 166.90 583.96 447.19 1,185.07 2,522.75 357.10 437.54 749.91



APPOINTED COUNSEL

AVERAGE PER CHARGE



CHARGE AVERAGE TOTAL $ # CLAIMS

ABUSE & NEGLECT 1,184.80 8,739,121.36 7,374

JUVENILE 583.96 1,770,553.05 3,032

CONTROLLED SUBSTANCES 705.85 1,641,796.20 2,325

MURDER 4,220.58 1,050,925.49 249

DOMESTIC VIOLENCE 418.17 918,300.54 2,196

BURGLARY 879.23 667,338.90 759

PAROLE/PROBATION 446.83 567,926.02 1,270

GRAND LARCENY 805.10 562,767.48 698

SEXUAL ASSAULT 1,961.36 466,804.78 238

CONSPIRACY 774.86 463,363.54 597

MENTAL HYGIENE 166.90 445,610.18 2,670

HABEAS CORPUS 2,218.79 443,757.24 200

ASSAULT & BATTERY 410.21 429,079.20 1,045

DUI 1ST OFFENSE 393.89 415,947.83 1,056

MFG/POSS OR DIST OF METH 842.21 412,683.29 490

BREAKING & ENTERING 758.78 355,868.98 469

SUSPEND/REV LICENSE 400.81 344,296.44 859

CHILD ABUSE 1,038.90 339,720.95 327

ROBBERY 1,461.00 309,733.02 212

SUPREME COURT APPEAL 2,944.03 309,123.06 105

MAL WOUNDING/ASSAULT 1,034.90 291,841.50 282

FORGERY & UTTERING 723.59 261,938.16 361

OBSTRUCTION JUSTICE 371.97 260,009.08 699

PETIT LARCENY 364.15 245,798.05 675

FRAUD 697.24 215,447.17 309

SEXUAL ABUSE 1,701.76 212,719.60 125

REC/TRANS STOLEN PRO 562.14 212,488.29 378

DESTRUCTION OF PROPERTY 521.62 208,125.32 399

AGGRAVATED ROBBERY 1,682.21 173,267.70 103

ATTEMPT 1,034.43 171,715.76 166

SENTENCE REDUCTION 539.74 164,621.15 305

ABUSE & NEGLECT APPEAL 2,882.74 132,606.16 46

SHOPLIFTING 412.17 122,826.07 298

FAIL TO REG SEX OFFENDER 702.48 120,123.31 171

ARSON 1,553.37 110,289.54 71

DUI 3RD OFFENSE 883.55 108,676.12 122

DUI 2ND OFFENSE 426.64 104,525.92 245

FALSE PRETENSES 627.98 101,733.28 162

KIDNAPPING 1,988.35 93,452.67 47

DEADLY WEAPON 658.44 90,864.03 138

WANTON ENDANGERMENT 786.80 84,974.24 108

EMBEZZLEMENT 818.32 76,103.96 93

FAIL PAY CHILD SUPPORT 312.74 54,728.88 175

FALSE SWEARING 449.74 49,471.27 110

BRANDISHING WEAPON 543.70 48,388.96 89

GUARDIAN CHILDREN 1,038.45 47,768.70 46

HOME CONFINEMENT 386.19 46,342.26 120

AVERAGE PER CHARGE IN TOTAL $ ORDERPUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICES





DISORDERLY CONDUCT 348.34 42,149.61 121

HARASSMENT 365.91 42,079.14 115

PORNOGRAPHY 1,350.45 40,513.55 30

FLEEING VEHICLE W/DUI 678.82 40,050.32 59

RECIDIVIST 7,478.25 37,391.23 5

ACCESSORY 844.06 36,294.64 43

CONTRIBUTE DEL MINOR 462.91 32,866.40 71

TRESPASSING 331.60 32,496.98 98

TERRORIST ACTS 1,092.67 29,502.20 27

DUI W/ INJURY 686.56 28,835.40 42

RECKLESS DRIVING 480.31 28,818.67 60

TRUANCY 399.42 28,757.91 72

DNR CHARGE 497.98 28,384.99 57

CRUELTY TO ANIMALS 494.97 28,213.54 57

AIDING & ABETTING 1,050.54 27,314.14 26

INCEST 1,643.03 26,288.44 16

STALKING 896.47 25,997.66 29

WELFARE FRAUD 713.78 24,982.47 35

UNLAWFUL WOUNDING 800.53 24,816.31 31

INTIMIDATE WITNESS 715.65 24,332.00 34

SOLICIT/PROSTITUTION 822.91 23,864.30 29

FAILURE TO APPEAR 528.67 22,732.69 43

JAIL ESCAPE 631.32 22,096.27 35

MAGISTRATE APPEAL 755.93 21,166.03 28

NEGLIGENT HOMICIDE 2,843.69 19,905.80 7

FUGITIVE/JUSTICE 174.20 19,510.09 112

LEAVE SCENE ACCIDENT 403.07 17,332.07 43

EXTRADITION 161.04 16,909.24 105

EXTORTION 1,997.45 15,979.61 8

CONCEAL A MINOR 1,395.29 15,348.16 11

BOND REDUCTION 525.63 14,717.58 28

PERMITTING DUI 343.80 14,439.47 42

ADULT ABUSE 1,006.49 14,090.84 14

UNDER AGE DRINKING 291.73 13,711.32 47

MOTOR VEHICLE SAFETY 366.86 12,106.34 33

PUBLIC INTOXICATION 308.06 11,706.16 38

DEL CONTRABAND INMATE 480.64 11,535.46 24

COMPUTER RELATED FRAUD 951.98 11,423.75 12

JOYRIDING 308.60 10,183.96 33

NO OPERATORS 344.12 9,979.57 29

NO PROOF OF INS 335.84 9,403.48 28

TERM PARENTAL RIGHTS 1,130.24 9,041.93 8

AUTO TAMPERING 505.80 8,598.68 17

CONTEMPT 223.46 6,480.29 29

EXPUNGEMENT 250.51 6,012.32 24

BRIBERY 940.51 5,643.07 6

INDECENT EXPOSURE 461.60 5,539.17 12





PROHIBITION 495.07 5,445.73 11

COUNTERFEITING 490.77 5,398.43 11

OPEN CONTAINER 287.30 5,171.40 18

CONCEAL DEAD BODY 840.80 5,044.77 6

RESISTING ARREST 529.30 4,234.40 8

ANIMAL CONTROL 236.61 4,022.35 17

MISCELLANEOUS 477.56 3,820.47 8

DISTURB THE PEACE 246.12 3,691.87 15

MANDAMUS 3,369.87 3,369.87 1

PERMIT UNAUTH/DRIVE 275.85 3,310.18 12

SPEEDING 327.21 3,272.14 10

UNLAWFUL RESTRAINT 733.81 2,935.22 4

VOL MANSLAUGHTER 1,397.35 2,794.70 2

INVOL MANSLAUGHTER 2,241.56 2,241.56 1

FAIL MAINTAIN CONTROL 434.77 1,739.07 4

RESTITUTION 234.61 1,642.26 7

FORFEITURE 390.84 1,563.34 4

MAKE/USE EXPLOSIVES 462.09 1,386.26 3

SHOOT W/N 500 FEET 282.01 1,128.04 4

PEACE WARRANT 370.25 740.50 2

LITTERING 232.84 698.52 3

WITNESS 278.19 556.37 2

CIVIL RIGHTS VIOLATION 526.74 526.74 1

TAX EVASION 367.86 367.86 1

OFFENSES BY INMATES 250.26 250.26 1

DUI/W DEATH 174.76 174.76 1

WV TABLE GAMES OFFENSE 133.50 133.50 1

STATE AVERAGE AND TOTALS 749.91 25,530,768.52 34,045



APPENDIX B:

STATISTICAL

INFORMATION

CONCERNING

PUBLIC DEFENDER

CORPORATIONS



CIRCUIT

DISTRIBUTED

CONTRACTUAL

AMOUNTS

TOTAL FUNDS

ALLOCATED TO

EACH CIRCUIT

TOTAL DISBURSED

1ST 1,063,763 8,925.82 1,072,689

2ND 424,172 6,111.07 430,283

5TH 787,648 8,518.45 796,166

6TH/24TH 1,805,397 11,564.66 1,816,962

7TH 595,159 6,462.91 601,622

8TH 399,106 5,759.22 404,865

9TH 736,128 8,222.13 744,350

10TH 1,063,284 8,749.90 1,072,034

11TH 482,067 6,814.76 488,882

12TH 486,248 6,111.07 492,359

13TH 3,511,383 20,129.32 3,531,512

15TH 1,032,236 10,925.82 1,043,162

18TH 410,821 5,759.22 416,580

23RD 2,520,640 16,907.18 2,537,547

25TH 752,346 7,518.45 759,864

28TH 330,864 5,407.38 336,271

30TH 479,557 6,111.07 485,668

TOTALS 16,880,819 149,998 17,030,817


GRANTS TO PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS

July 1, 2013 to June 30, 2014

NOTE: Total funds Allocated to Each Circuit represents funds disbursed

by the WVPDS on behalf of the Public Defender Corporations for Legal

Research, Auditing Services, Information Technology Services, and

Auditor Transaction Fees.



PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATION ATTORNEY TIME

BY IN COURT / OUT OF COURT / ADMINISTRATIVE / DRUG COURT

53,246.6

135,178.7

70,132.8

1,179.8

259,737.9

In Court

Out of Court

Administrative

Drug Court

TOTAL TIME

In Court20.50%

Out of Court52.04%

Administrative27.00%

Drug Court0.45%



IN OUT OF DRUGCOURT COURT COURT

1st Circuit 2580.6 11847.9 3440.7 0 17,869.22nd Circuit 877 5094.9 2076.4 0 8,048.35th Circuit 2312.9 7292.6 3116.3 0 12,721.86th & 24th Circuits 7672.4 13047.8 6605 379.7 27,704.97th Circuit 1093.1 3946.4 1919.2 40.3 6,999.08th Circuit 1319.2 3757.2 478.8 0.0 5,555.29th Circuit 2704 6988.8 3735.8 35.9 13,464.510th Circuit 5206.5 7554.6 3243.9 4.5 16,009.511th Circuit 1771.3 4768.5 1545.0 63.1 8,147.912th Circuit 1944.9 4716.6 2001.2 0.0 8,662.713th Circuit 9216.3 26167 16453.8 512.4 52,349.515th Circuit 2740.5 8444.9 4010.7 0 15,196.118th Circuit 786.3 2985.9 2129.3 80.3 5,981.823rd Circuit 8357 17508.8 11004.2 0 36,870.025th Circuit 2384.7 4878.7 4432 60.5 11,755.928th Circuit 1468.4 1602.4 978.8 3.1 4,052.730th Circuit 811.5 4575.7 2961.7 0 8,348.9PD TOTAL 53,246.6 135,178.7 70,132.8 1,179.8 259,737.9

PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS' ATTORNEY TIMEBY IN COURT/OUT OF COURT/ADMINISTRATION/ DRUG COURT

ADMIN. TOTALPDC



Felony 8,295

Misdemeanor 17,777

Mental Hygiene 1,500

Juvenile 3,230

Parole / Probation Revocation 994

Abuse & Neglect 631

Habeas / SC 67

Drug Court 0

Other 860

Total Cases 33,354

PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATION

TOTAL CASES CLOSED

Felony24.87%

Misdemeanor53.30%

Mental Hygiene4.50%

Juvenile9.68%

Parole / ProbationRevocation

2.98%

Abuse & Neglect1.89%

Habeas / SC0.20%Drug Court

0.00%

Other2.58%



Parole &

1ST 444 1117 1 142 50 15 2 0 80 1,851

2ND 274 495 0 91 39 27 2 0 14 942

5TH 284 526 34 116 10 73 2 0 9 1,054

6TH 1570 2512 12 485 162 16 3 0 50 4,810

7TH 173 191 45 33 14 46 0 0 25 527

8TH 356 797 2 124 0 27 0 0 88 1,394

9TH 291 1470 13 219 41 109 3 0 150 2,296

10TH 570 1268 125 156 172 5 0 0 56 2,352

11TH 248 594 156 75 1 32 2 0 40 1,148

12TH 332 551 26 20 22 23 1 0 32 1,007

13TH 1321 3817 895 789 267 0 48 0 120 7,257

15TH 292 786 14 193 121 10 2 0 45 1,463

18TH 87 250 6 9 8 8 0 0 67 435

23RD 1496 2317 129 575 23 162 2 0 24 4,728

25TH 232 438 13 129 63 39 0 0 7 921

28TH 181 339 20 37 0 39 0 0 20 636

30TH 144 309 9 37 1 0 0 0 33 533

Total 8,295 17,777 1,500 3,230 994 631 67 0 860 33,354

Other TOTAL

PUBLIC DEFENDER CORPORATIONS

CASES CLOSED BY CASE TYPE

FelonyPD

CircuitMisd.

Mental

HygieneJuv. Prob.

Rev.

Termin/

Abuse

Habeas

S. Ct.

Drug

Court



APPENDIX C:

APPOINTED

COUNSEL / PUBLIC

DEFENDER

COMPARISONS



1ST

CIR

CU

IT(B

RO

OK

E,H

AN

CO

CK

&O

HIO

CO

UN

TIES

)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

44

42

46

69

06

4.3

5%

35

.65

%$

1,0

72

,68

9.0

0$

1,3

55

,93

6.3

4$

2,4

28

,62

5.3

44

4.1

7%

55

.83

%

MIS

D.

1,1

17

13

71

,25

48

9.0

7%

10

.93

%

MH

13

91

39

20

.26

%9

9.7

4%

AV

GP

DC

CO

STA

VG

AC

CO

ST

JUV

ENIL

E1

42

64

20

66

8.9

3%

31

.07

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

50

36

86

58

.14

%4

1.8

6%

TER

M/A

BU

SE1

53

49

36

44

.12

%9

5.8

8%

$5

79

.52

$1

,07

5.2

9

HA

BEA

S/SC

22

22

48

.33

%9

1.6

7%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

03

30

.00

%1

00

.00

%

OTH

ER8

01

39

38

6.0

2%

13

.98

%

TOTA

L1

,85

11

,26

13

,11

25

9.4

8%

40

.52

%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

1ST

CIR

CU

ITC

LOSE

DC

ASE

S/C

LAIM

SPA

ID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

44

.17

%

55

.83

%

1st

CIR

CU

ITP

DC

/AC

DIS

BU

RSE

MEN

TS

PD

CA

C



2N

DC

IRC

UIT

(MA

RSH

ALL

,TY

LER

&W

ETZE

LC

OU

NTI

ES)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

27

41

64

43

86

2.5

6%

37

.44

%$

43

0,2

83

.00

$4

10

,28

0.5

0$

84

0,5

63

.50

51

.19

%4

8.8

1%

MIS

D.

49

51

18

61

38

0.7

5%

19

.25

%

MH

01

56

15

60

.00

%1

00

.00

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E9

14

91

40

65

.00

%3

5.0

0%

PER

CA

SEP

ERC

ASE

PA

R./

PR

OB

39

22

61

63

.93

%3

6.0

7%

TER

M/A

BU

SE2

78

41

11

24

.32

%7

5.6

8%

$4

56

.78

$6

79

.27

HA

BEA

S/SC

22

45

0.0

0%

50

.00

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

01

10

.00

%1

00

.00

%

OTH

ER1

48

22

63

.64

%3

6.3

6%

TOTA

L9

42

60

41

,54

66

0.9

3%

39

.07

%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

2N

DC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

51

.19

%4

8.8

1%

2N

DC

IRC

UIT

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



5TH

CIR

CU

IT(C

ALH

OU

N,J

AC

KSO

N,M

ASO

N&

RO

AN

EC

OU

NTI

ES)

(WIT

HO

UT

MA

SON

CO

UN

TY)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

*AC

ircu

itC

ou

rto

rde

rp

roh

ibit

sP

DC

wo

rkin

Mas

on

Co

un

ty.

All

ind

ige

nt

wo

rkis

pe

rfo

rme

db

yA

pp

oin

ted

Co

un

sel

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

28

42

14

49

85

7.0

3%

42

.97

%$

79

6,1

66

.00

$7

51

,61

4.7

0$

1,5

47

,78

0.7

05

1.4

4%

48

.56

%

MIS

D.

52

69

96

25

84

.16

%1

5.8

4%

MH

34

17

51

66

.67

%3

3.3

3%

AV

GP

DC

CO

STA

VG

AC

CO

ST

JUV

ENIL

E1

16

18

13

48

6.5

7%

13

.43

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

10

26

36

27

.78

%7

2.2

2%

TER

M/A

BU

SE7

33

22

39

51

8.4

8%

81

.52

%$

75

5.3

8$

1,0

12

.96

HA

BEA

S/SC

28

10

20

.00

%8

0.0

0%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

00

0#D

IV/0

!#D

IV/0

!

OTH

ER9

38

47

19

.15

%8

0.8

5%

TOTA

L1

,05

47

42

1,7

96

58

.69

%4

1.3

1%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

5TH

CIR

CU

ITC

LOSE

DC

ASE

S/C

LAIM

SPA

ID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

51

.44

%4

8.5

6%

5TH

CIR

CU

ITP

DC

/AC

DIS

BU

RSE

MEN

TS

PD

CA

C



6TH

CIR

CU

ITan

d2

4TH

CIR

CU

IT(C

AB

ELL

&W

AY

NE

CO

UN

TIES

)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

*Th

e6

th/2

4th

Cir

cuit

so

per

ate

un

de

ro

ne

Pu

blic

Def

en

de

rC

orp

ora

tio

n.

AC

figu

res

incl

ud

eb

oth

Cab

ell

and

Way

ne

Co

un

ties

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

1,5

70

49

22

,06

27

6.1

4%

23

.86

%$

1,8

16

,96

2.0

0$

96

5,9

96

.00

$2

,78

2,9

58

.00

65

.29

%3

4.7

1%

MIS

D.

2,5

12

17

92

,69

19

3.3

5%

6.6

5%

MH

12

87

48

86

1.3

5%

98

.65

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E4

85

18

56

70

72

.39

%2

7.6

1%

PER

CA

SEP

ERC

ASE

PA

R./

PR

OB

16

21

11

27

35

9.3

4%

40

.66

%

TER

M/A

BU

SE1

65

79

59

52

.69

%9

7.3

1%

$3

77

.75

$3

85

.01

HA

BEA

S/SC

31

72

01

5.0

0%

85

.00

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

04

64

60

.00

%1

00

.00

%

OTH

ER5

02

67

66

5.7

9%

34

.21

%

TOTA

L4

,81

02

,50

97

,31

96

5.7

2%

34

.28

%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

6TH

/24

THC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

65

.29

%

34

.71

%

6TH

/24

THC

IRC

UIT

SP

DC

/AC

DIS

BU

RSE

MEN

TS

PD

CA

C



7TH

CIR

CU

IT(L

OG

AN

CO

UN

TY)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

17

31

33

30

65

6.5

4%

43

.46

%$

60

1,6

22

.00

$5

38

,56

9.0

8$

1,1

40

,19

1.0

85

2.7

7%

47

.23

%

MIS

D.

19

13

41

53

23

5.9

0%

64

.10

%

MH

45

04

51

00

.00

%0

.00

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E3

31

52

18

51

7.8

4%

82

.16

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

14

18

32

43

.75

%5

6.2

5%

TER

M/A

BU

SE4

61

20

16

62

7.7

1%

72

.29

%$

1,1

41

.60

$6

89

.59

HA

BEA

S/SC

06

60

.00

%1

00

.00

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

00

0#D

IV/0

!#

DIV

/0!

OTH

ER2

51

13

66

9.4

4%

30

.56

%

TOTA

L5

27

78

11

,30

84

0.2

9%

59

.71

%

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100

%

7TH

CIR

CU

ITC

LOSE

DC

ASE

S/C

LAIM

SPA

ID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

52

.77

%4

7.2

3%

7TH

CIR

CU

ITP

DC

/AC

DIS

BU

RSE

MEN

TS

PD

CA

C



8TH

CIR

CU

IT(M

CD

OW

ELL

CO

UN

TY)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

35

61

56

51

26

9.5

3%

30

.47

%$

40

4,8

65

.00

$4

76

,14

0.0

0$

88

1,0

05

.00

45

.95

%5

4.0

5%

MIS

D.

79

71

63

96

08

3.0

2%

16

.98

%

MH

21

51

71

1.7

6%

88

.24

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E1

24

17

14

18

7.9

4%

12

.06

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

00

0#D

IV/0

!#D

IV/0

!

TER

M/A

BU

SE2

71

06

13

32

0.3

0%

79

.70

%$

29

0.4

3$

1,0

08

.77

HA

BEA

S/SC

06

60

.00

%1

00

.00

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

00

0#D

IV/0

!#D

IV/0

!

OTH

ER8

89

97

90

.72

%9

.28

%

TOTA

L1

,39

44

72

1,8

66

74

.71

%2

5.2

9%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

8TH

CIR

CU

ITC

LOSE

DC

ASE

S/C

LAIM

SPA

ID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

45

.95

%

54

.05

%

8TH

CIR

CU

ITP

DC

/AC

DIS

BU

RSE

MEN

TS

PD

CA

C



9TH

CIR

CU

IT(M

ERC

ERC

OU

NTY

)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

29

14

04

69

54

1.8

7%

58

.13

%$

74

4,3

50

.00

$1

,33

9,1

38

.70

$2

,08

3,4

88

.70

35

.73

%6

4.2

7%

MIS

D.

1,4

70

37

71

,84

77

9.5

9%

20

.41

%

MH

13

12

71

40

9.2

9%

90

.71

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E2

19

21

34

32

50

.69

%4

9.3

1%

PER

CA

SEP

ERC

ASE

PA

R./

PR

OB

41

65

10

63

8.6

8%

61

.32

%

TER

M/A

BU

SE1

09

63

77

46

14

.61

%8

5.3

9%

$3

24

.19

$6

92

.42

HA

BEA

S/SC

32

42

71

1.1

1%

88

.89

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

03

23

20

.00

%1

00

.00

%

OTH

ER1

50

55

20

57

3.1

7%

26

.83

%

TOTA

L2

,29

61

,93

44

,23

05

4.2

8%

45

.72

%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

9TH

CIR

CU

ITC

LOSE

DC

ASE

S/C

LAIM

SPA

ID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

35

.73

%

64

.27

%

9TH

CIR

CU

ITP

DC

/AC

DIS

BU

RSE

MEN

TS

PD

CA

C



10

THC

IRC

UIT

(RA

LEIG

HC

OU

NTY

)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

57

02

21

79

17

2.0

6%

27

.94

%$

1,0

72

,03

4.0

0$

88

5,7

66

.30

$1

,95

7,8

00

.30

54

.76

%4

5.2

4%

MIS

D.

1,2

68

17

81

,44

68

7.6

9%

12

.31

%

MH

12

59

13

49

3.2

8%

6.7

2%

AV

GP

DC

CO

STA

VG

AC

CO

ST

JUV

ENIL

E1

56

47

20

37

6.8

5%

23

.15

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

17

22

31

95

88

.21

%1

1.7

9%

TER

M/A

BU

SE5

64

46

49

0.7

7%

99

.23

%$

45

5.8

0$

77

8.3

5

HA

BEA

S/SC

01

11

10

.00

%1

00

.00

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

00

0#D

IV/0

!#D

IV/0

!

OTH

ER5

65

61

91

.80

%8

.20

%

TOTA

L2

,35

21

,13

83

,49

06

7.3

9%

32

.61

%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

10

THC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

54

.76

%

45

.24

%

10

THC

IRC

UIT

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



11

THC

IRC

UIT

(GR

EEN

BR

IER

&P

OC

AH

ON

TAS

CO

UN

TIES

)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

24

89

83

46

71

.68

%2

8.3

2%

$4

88

,88

2.0

0$

48

8,7

61

.25

$9

77

,64

3.2

55

0.0

1%

49

.99

%

MIS

D.

59

47

46

68

88

.92

%1

1.0

8%

MH

15

62

31

79

87

.15

%1

2.8

5%

AV

GP

DC

CO

STA

VG

AC

CO

ST

JUV

ENIL

E7

51

18

68

7.2

1%

12

.79

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

18

91

1.1

1%

88

.89

%

TER

M/A

BU

SE3

21

29

16

11

9.8

8%

80

.12

%$

42

5.8

6$

1,3

42

.75

HA

BEA

S/SC

28

10

20

.00

%8

0.0

0%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

01

10

.00

%1

00

.00

%

OTH

ER4

01

25

27

6.9

2%

23

.08

%

TOTA

L1

,14

83

64

1,5

12

75

.93

%2

4.0

7%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

11

THC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

50

.01

%4

9.9

9%

11

THC

IRC

UIT

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



12

THC

IRC

UIT

(FA

YET

TEC

OU

NTY

)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

33

21

43

47

56

9.8

9%

30

.11

%$

49

2,3

59

.00

$3

41

,69

8.5

0$

83

4,0

57

.50

59

.03

%4

0.9

7%

MIS

D.

55

11

05

65

68

3.9

9%

16

.01

%

MH

26

02

61

00

.00

%0

.00

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E2

01

73

75

4.0

5%

45

.95

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

22

72

97

5.8

6%

24

.14

%

TER

M/A

BU

SE2

31

57

18

01

2.7

8%

87

.22

%$

48

8.9

4$

77

6.5

9

HA

BEA

S/SC

17

81

2.5

0%

87

.50

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

00

0#D

IV/0

!#

DIV

/0!

OTH

ER3

24

36

88

.89

%1

1.1

1%

TOTA

L1

,00

74

40

1,4

47

69

.59

%3

0.4

1%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

12

THC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

59

.03

%

40

.97

%

12

THC

IRC

UIT

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



13

THC

IRC

UIT

(KA

NA

WH

AC

OU

NTY

)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

1,3

21

76

32

,08

46

3.3

9%

36

.61

%$

3,5

31

,51

2.0

0$

1,7

60

,95

5.4

0$

5,2

92

,46

7.4

06

6.7

3%

33

.27

%

MIS

D.

3,8

17

62

54

,44

28

5.9

3%

14

.07

%

MH

89

50

89

51

00

.00

%0

.00

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E7

89

12

49

13

86

.42

%1

3.5

8%

PER

CA

SEP

ERC

ASE

PA

R./

PR

OB

26

78

33

50

76

.29

%2

3.7

1%

TER

M/A

BU

SE0

53

45

34

0.0

0%

10

0.0

0%

$4

86

.64

$7

11

.50

HA

BEA

S/SC

48

30

78

61

.54

%3

8.4

6%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

02

57

25

70

.00

%1

00

.00

%

OTH

ER1

20

59

17

96

7.0

4%

32

.96

%

TOTA

L7

,25

72

,47

59

,73

27

4.5

7%

25

.43

%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

13

THC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

66

.73

%

33

.27

%

13

THC

IRC

UIT

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



15

THC

IRC

UIT

(HA

RR

ISO

NC

OU

NTY

)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

29

27

83

70

78

.92

%2

1.0

8%

$1

,04

3,1

62

.00

$4

62

,35

0.5

0$

1,5

05

,51

2.5

06

9.2

9%

30

.71

%

MIS

D.

78

61

05

89

18

8.2

2%

11

.78

%

MH

14

30

44

31

.82

%6

8.1

8%

AV

GP

DC

CO

STA

VG

AC

CO

ST

JUV

ENIL

E1

93

35

22

88

4.6

5%

15

.35

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

12

11

71

38

87

.68

%1

2.3

2%

TER

M/A

BU

SE1

01

32

14

27

.04

%9

2.9

6%

$7

13

.03

$1

,10

3.4

6

HA

BEA

S/SC

21

31

51

3.3

3%

86

.67

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

00

0#D

IV/0

!#D

IV/0

!

OTH

ER4

59

54

83

.33

%1

6.6

7%

TOTA

L1

,46

34

19

1,8

82

77

.74

%2

2.2

6%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

15

THC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

69

.29

%

30

.71

%

15

THC

IRC

UIT

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



18

THC

IRC

UIT

(PR

ESTO

NC

OU

NTY

)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

87

45

13

26

5.9

1%

34

.09

%$

41

6,5

80

.00

$2

81

,69

8.5

0$

69

8,2

78

.50

59

.66

%4

0.3

4%

MIS

D.

25

05

83

08

81

.17

%1

8.8

3%

MH

60

61

00

.00

%0

.00

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E9

12

21

42

.86

%5

7.1

4%

PER

CA

SEP

ERC

ASE

PA

R./

PR

OB

89

17

47

.06

%5

2.9

4%

TER

M/A

BU

SE8

12

11

29

6.2

0%

93

.80

%$

95

7.6

6$

1,1

00

.38

HA

BEA

S/SC

03

30

.00

%1

00

.00

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

00

0#D

IV/0

!#D

IV/0

!

OTH

ER6

78

75

89

.33

%1

0.6

7%

TOTA

L4

35

25

66

91

62

.95

%3

7.0

5%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

18

THC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

59

.66

%

40

.34

%

18

THC

IRC

UIT

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



23

RD

CIR

CU

IT(B

ERK

ELEY

,JEF

FER

SON

&M

OR

GA

NC

OU

NTI

ES)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

1,4

96

39

11

,88

77

9.2

8%

20

.72

%$

2,5

37

,54

7.0

0$

1,4

33

,96

9.7

2$

3,9

71

,51

6.7

26

3.8

9%

36

.11

%

MIS

D.

2,3

17

17

72

,49

49

2.9

0%

7.1

0%

MH

12

90

12

91

00

.00

%0

.00

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E5

75

67

64

28

9.5

6%

10

.44

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

23

55

78

29

.49

%7

0.5

1%

TER

M/A

BU

SE1

62

38

25

44

29

.78

%7

0.2

2%

$5

36

.71

$1

,28

4.9

2

HA

BEA

S/SC

22

52

77

.41

%9

2.5

9%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

07

70

.00

%1

00

.00

%

OTH

ER2

41

23

66

6.6

7%

33

.33

%

TOTA

L4

,72

81

,11

65

,84

48

0.9

0%

19

.10

%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

23

RD

CIR

CU

ITC

LOSE

DC

ASE

S/C

LAIM

SPA

ID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

63

.89

%

36

.11

%

23

RD

CIR

CU

ITP

DC

/AC

DIS

BU

RSE

MEN

TS

PD

CA

C



25

THC

IRC

UIT

(BO

ON

E&

LIN

CO

LNC

OU

NTI

ES)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

23

22

13

44

55

2.1

3%

47

.87

%$

75

9,8

64

.00

$6

67

,84

2.9

5$

1,4

27

,70

6.9

55

3.2

2%

46

.78

%

MIS

D.

43

81

21

55

97

8.3

5%

21

.65

%

MH

13

54

67

19

.40

%8

0.6

0%

AV

GP

DC

CO

STA

VG

AC

CO

ST

JUV

ENIL

E1

29

18

63

15

40

.95

%5

9.0

5%

PER

CA

SEP

ERC

ASE

PA

R./

PR

OB

63

39

10

26

1.7

6%

38

.24

%

TER

M/A

BU

SE3

91

70

20

91

8.6

6%

81

.34

%$

82

5.0

4$

72

1.9

9

HA

BEA

S/SC

04

40

.00

%1

00

.00

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

00

0#D

IV/0

!#D

IV/0

!

OTH

ER7

13

81

45

4.8

3%

95

.17

%

TOTA

L9

21

92

51

,84

64

9.8

9%

50

.11

%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

25

THC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

53

.22

%4

6.7

8%

25

THC

IRC

UIT

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



28

THC

IRC

UIT

(NIC

HO

LAS

CO

UN

TY)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

18

17

82

59

69

.88

%3

0.1

2%

$3

36

,27

1.0

0$

23

5,9

88

.50

$5

72

,25

9.5

05

8.7

6%

41

.24

%

MIS

D.

33

93

83

77

89

.92

%1

0.0

8%

MH

20

02

01

00

.00

%0

.00

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E3

79

46

80

.43

%1

9.5

7%

PER

CA

SEP

ERC

ASE

PA

R./

PR

OB

01

10

.00

%1

00

.00

%

TER

M/A

BU

SE3

91

01

14

02

7.8

6%

72

.14

%$

52

8.7

3$

1,0

12

.83

HA

BEA

S/SC

05

50

.00

%1

00

.00

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

00

0#D

IV/0

!#

DIV

/0!

OTH

ER2

01

21

95

.24

%4

.76

%

TOTA

L6

36

23

38

69

73

.19

%2

6.8

1%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

28

THC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

58

.76

%

41

.24

%

28

THC

IRC

UIT

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



30

THC

IRC

UIT

(MIN

GO

CO

UN

TY)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

14

41

35

27

95

1.6

1%

48

.39

%$

48

5,6

68

.00

$3

99

,74

0.2

5$

88

5,4

08

.25

54

.85

%4

5.1

5%

MIS

D.

30

91

07

41

67

4.2

8%

25

.72

%

MH

98

17

52

.94

%4

7.0

6%

AV

GP

DC

CO

STA

VG

AC

CO

ST

JUV

ENIL

E3

72

05

76

4.9

1%

35

.09

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

17

81

2.5

0%

87

.50

%

TER

M/A

BU

SE0

16

01

60

0.0

0%

10

0.0

0%

$9

11

.20

$8

88

.31

HA

BEA

S/SC

05

50

.00

%1

00

.00

%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

00

0#D

IV/0

!#

DIV

/0!

OTH

ER3

38

41

80

.49

%1

9.5

1%

TOTA

L5

33

45

09

83

54

.22

%4

5.7

8%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

30

THC

IRC

UIT

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

54

.85

%

45

.15

%

30

THC

IRC

UIT

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



STA

TIST

ICS

FOR

BO

THP

DC

AN

DA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

STA

TEW

IDE

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

LLA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

8,2

95

7,3

82

15

,67

75

2.9

1%

47

.09

%$

17

,03

0,8

17

.00

$2

3,0

16

,71

6.4

2$

40

,04

7,5

33

.42

42

.53

%5

7.4

7%

MIS

D.

17

,77

78

,69

72

6,4

74

67

.15

%3

2.8

5%

MH

1,5

00

2,6

66

4,1

66

36

.01

%6

3.9

9%

AV

GP

DC

CO

STA

VG

AC

CO

ST

JUV

ENIL

E3

,23

02

,99

06

,22

05

1.9

3%

48

.07

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

99

41

,16

22

,15

64

6.1

0%

53

.90

%

TER

M/A

BU

SE6

31

7,1

62

7,7

93

8.1

0%

91

.90

%$

51

0.6

1$

72

3.4

1

HA

BEA

S/SC

67

30

43

71

18

.06

%8

1.9

4%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

05

30

53

00

.00

%1

00

.00

%

OTH

ER8

60

92

41

,78

44

8.2

1%

51

.79

%

TOTA

L3

3,3

54

31

,81

76

5,1

71

51

.18

%4

8.8

2%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

STA

TEW

IDE

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

42

.53

%

57

.47

%

STA

TEW

IDE

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

PD

CA

C



ALL

PU

BLI

CD

EFEN

DER

CO

RP

OR

ATI

ON

CIR

CU

ITS

(18

CIR

CU

ITS

29

CO

UN

TIES

)(E

xclu

de

sM

aso

nC

ou

nty

)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

S(W

ITH

INP

DC

CIR

CU

ITS)

PA

IDFY

20

14

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

8,2

95

41

64

12

,45

96

6.5

8%

33

.42

%$

17

,03

0,8

17

.00

$1

2,7

96

,44

7.1

9$

29

,82

7,2

64

.19

57

.10

%4

2.9

0%

MIS

D.

17

,77

73

21

02

0,9

87

84

.70

%1

5.3

0%

MH

1,5

00

17

70

3,2

70

45

.87

%5

4.1

3%

AV

GP

DC

CO

STA

VG

AC

CO

ST

JUV

ENIL

E3

,23

01

31

54

,54

57

1.0

7%

28

.93

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

99

45

60

1,5

54

63

.96

%3

6.0

4%

TER

M/A

BU

SE6

31

48

01

5,4

32

11

.62

%8

8.3

8%

$5

10

.61

$7

61

.38

HA

BEA

S/SC

67

20

42

71

24

.72

%7

5.2

8%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

03

49

34

90

.00

%1

00

.00

%

OTH

ER8

60

43

41

,29

46

6.4

6%

33

.54

%

TOTA

L3

3,3

54

16

,80

75

0,1

61

66

.49

%3

3.5

1%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

WIT

HIN

PD

CC

IRC

UIT

S

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

57

.10

%

42

.90

%

PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

WIT

HIN

PD

CC

IRC

UIT

S

PD

CA

C



STA

TIST

ICS

FOR

BO

THP

DC

AN

DA

PP

OIN

TED

CO

UN

SEL

STA

TEW

IDE

(LES

SA

CC

LAIM

SIN

PD

CC

IRC

UIT

S)

PD

CC

ASE

SC

LOSE

DC

OM

PA

RED

TOA

CC

LAIM

SP

AID

FY2

01

4(I

ncl

ud

esM

aso

nC

ou

nty

)

PD

CA

C

PD

CA

CT

OT

AL

%P

DC

%A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENT

SD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

TO

TA

L%

PD

C%

AC

CA

SET

YP

ES

FELO

NY

8,2

95

32

18

11

,51

37

2.0

5%

27

.95

%$

17

,03

0,8

17

.00

$1

0,2

20

,26

9.2

3$

27

,25

1,0

86

.23

62

.50

%3

7.5

0%

MIS

D.

17

,77

75

48

72

3,2

64

76

.41

%2

3.5

9%

MH

1,5

00

89

62

,39

66

2.6

0%

37

.40

%A

VG

PD

CC

OST

AV

GA

CC

OST

JUV

ENIL

E3

,23

01

67

54

,90

56

5.8

5%

34

.15

%P

ERC

ASE

PER

CA

SE

PA

R./

PR

OB

99

46

02

1,5

96

62

.28

%3

7.7

2%

TER

M/A

BU

SE6

31

23

61

2,9

92

21

.09

%7

8.9

1%

$5

10

.61

$6

80

.90

HA

BEA

S/SC

67

10

01

67

40

.12

%5

9.8

8%

Mu

ni.

Co

urt

01

81

18

10

.00

%1

00

.00

%

OTH

ER8

60

49

01

,35

06

3.7

0%

36

.30

%

TOTA

L3

3,3

54

15

,01

04

8,3

64

68

.96

%3

1.0

4%

0%

20

%

40

%

60

%

80

%

10

0%

CLO

SED

CA

SES/

CLA

IMS

PAID

STA

TEW

IDE

(LES

SA

CIN

PD

CC

IRC

UIT

S)

PD

C(C

ASE

S)A

C(C

LAIM

SP

AID

)

62

.50

%

37

.50

%PD

C/A

CD

ISB

UR

SEM

ENTS

STA

TEW

IDE

(LES

SA

CIN

PD

CC

IRC

UIT

S)

PD

CA

C



APPENDIX D:

APPOINTED

COUNSEL LISTING OF

PAYEE TOTALS



APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES &

EXPENSES PAID BY PAYEE TOTAL

CLAIMS IN DESCENDING ORDER

* An asterisk denotes those claims which were paid to third parties at the attorneys’ direction.



KURELAC LAW OFFICE PLLC 270,120.32 157 MOUNDSVILLE, WV

LAW OFFICE OF DANIEL R GRINDO PLLC 261,370.73 182 GASSAWAY, WV* G ERNEST SKAGGS 255,558.99 135 FAYETTEVILLE, WV

WILLIAM M LESTER 248,913.27 184 CHARLESTON, WV* VICTOR VICTOR & HELGOE LLP 242,690.13 262 CHARLESTON, WV* CASTEEL & ALLENDER PLLC 240,053.78 202 KINGWOOD, WV* LAW OFFICES OF NANNERS & WILLETT LC 231,633.51 276 BUCKHANNON, WV* RUTH LAW OFFICES PLLC 228,420.98 218 CHARLESTON, WV

SAL SELLARO THORN CULPEPPER LEGAL GROUP PLLC 226,975.00 421 MORGANTOWN, WV* R KEITH FLINCHUM 220,779.13 281 PRINCETON, WV* CHRISTOPHER G MOFFATT 217,374.85 128 CHARLESTON, WV* HARVEY & JANUTOLO 204,982.63 250 BLUEFIELD, WV* JOSEPH J MOSES 190,504.37 58 WHEELING, WV

MICHAEL P COOKE 178,501.05 384 BLUEFIELD, WV* KEVIN W HUGHART 176,384.67 168 SISSONVILLE, WV

ESCUE & PRITT LAW OFFICE CO 173,148.12 257 HURRICANE, WV* MOUNTAINEER LEGAL SERVICES PLLC 171,027.35 302 GRAFTON, WV* GERALD G JACOVETTY JR LC 164,639.55 303 WHEELING, WV* LAW OFFICE OF DAVID B KELLEY 162,372.85 225 BLUEFIELD, WV* LAW OFFICE OF NICHOLAS FORREST COLVIN ESQ PLLC 156,559.12 108 HEDGESVILLE, WV* COURTRIGHT LAW OFFICES PLLC 152,314.45 261 HURRICANE, WV

GARRETT & GARRETT 147,319.46 173 MOOREFIELD, WVWHITEMAN BURDETTE PLLC 146,480.97 295 FAIRMONT, WVWILLIAM B SUMMERS 145,329.03 445 PARKERSBURG, WV

* SHAWN D BAYLISS 142,943.14 91 HURRICANE, WVLAW OFFICE OF PAMELA R FOLICKMAN 142,648.30 161 FAIRMONT, WVLAWRENCE E SHERMAN JR LC 140,578.26 207 ROMNEY, WVL SCOTT BRISCOE 135,688.57 193 DANVILLE, WV

* ABRAHAM J SAAD PLLC 135,320.07 277 HUNTINGTON, WV* DANIEL S COREY 132,891.00 134 POCA, WV

CONLEY LAW OFFICE PLLC 132,440.29 217 PARKERSBURG, WV* BELLOMY & TURNER LC 126,184.99 368 HUNTINGTON, WV

HASSAN LAW OFFICE 126,032.83 105 WELCH, WVTHOMAS HANNA EVANS PLLC 124,552.43 115 OCEANA, WV

* RODNEY C WINDOM 123,919.05 127 HARRISVILLE, WVWELLS H DILLON 122,533.26 167 PARKERSBURG, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF BRENT A CLYBURN 121,807.85 102 WHEELING, WVLAW OFFICE OF COURTNEY L AHLBORN PLLC 121,226.47 242 PARKERSBURG, WV

* HILL JOHNSON LAW PLLC 120,408.60 133 BELINGTON, WV* HOOSIER LAW FIRM PLLC 119,060.34 88 SCOTT DEPOT, WV

BISCHOFF LAW FIRM PLLC 117,524.79 104 SUMMERSVILLE, WVCHARLES R HAMILTON 116,538.12 159 CHARLESTON, WVMICHAEL R WHITT 116,180.73 40 LEWISBURG, WV

* DIANA CARTER WIEDEL 116,062.66 73 WILLIAMSON, WV* STARCHER & FRUM PLLC 115,642.16 166 PARKERSBURG, WV

KEITH WHITE 115,381.94 218 SAINT MARYS, WV* LUPARDUS LAW OFFICE 115,353.81 192 PINEVILLE, WV* JAMES P RILEY IV ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 115,298.89 67 MARTINSBURG, WV* WILLIAM PRENTICE YOUNG 115,110.24 23 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV* ROBERT T NOONE 114,286.41 46 GADSDEN, AL

JAMES E HAWKINS JR 113,324.54 186 BUCKHANNON, WV

PUBLIC DEFENDER SERVICESAPPOINTED COUNSEL FEES AND EXPENSES PAID

DESCENDING ORDER BY TOTAL $Appointed Counsel and Direct Expenses Separate

APPOINTED COUNSEL

OFFICE LOCATIONPAYEE TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS






CLAIMSCHILDLAW SERVICES INC 111,727.31 103 PRINCETON, WV

* NEISWONGER & WHITE 110,873.90 251 MOUNDSVILLE, WV* R STEVEN REDDING ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 108,034.28 50 MARTINSBURG, WV* BULLMAN & BULLMAN 107,523.79 126 CHARLESTON, WV

SHARON K CHILDERS 107,068.17 96 CHARLESTON, WVMULLENS & MULLENS PLLC 105,334.23 160 PHILIPPI, WV

* ROCCO E MAZZEI 104,456.85 86 CLARKSBURG, WV* ASBURY LAW OFFICE PLLC 103,545.37 54 CLAY, WV* SCALES LAW OFFICE 103,121.04 56 MARTINSBURG, WV

ERIC K POWELL 102,541.25 181 PARKERSBURG, WVNOLAN LAW FIRM 101,456.22 256 HUNTINGTON, WV

* KRISTOPHER FAERBER 101,282.00 43 LEWISBURG, WV* KIRKPATRICK LAW OFFICE PLLC 101,176.24 86 BECKLEY, WV* HERBERT L HIVELY 100,649.77 238 CHARLESTON, WV* EDWARD REBROOK III 100,324.96 152 CHARLESTON, WV* PHILIP A LACARIA 100,057.50 94 WELCH, WV

TRACIE L GREENE 99,297.62 111 CHARLESTON, WV* SHAW & SHAW LC 98,918.49 187 POINT PLEASANT, WV

HAYDEN & HART PLLC 93,479.29 135 BECKLEY, WVWILLIAM T RICE 92,686.53 54 MARTINSBURG, WVJEFFREY S RODGERS 92,463.38 165 LEWISBURG, WV

* CORNETTE LAW PLLC 91,648.52 77 WESTON, WV* JOHN E WILLIAMS JR 90,339.16 137 PRINCETON, WV

GEARY & GEARY LC 90,233.97 85 PETERSBURG, WVJOHN M THOMPSON 90,143.60 123 OAK HILL, WVTHOMAS L FUDA PLLC 90,038.80 143 PRINCETON, WV

* JOSEPH G TROISI 89,463.00 122 SAINT MARYS, WVLAW FIRM OF A JOSEPH MUNOZ 87,362.00 70 PARKERSBURG, WV

* KATHRYN CISCO-STURGELL 86,676.50 46 WILLIAMSON, WVJASON S LORD 85,717.44 79 CHARLESTON, WVDOUGLAS H ARBUCKLE 85,092.45 107 LEWISBURG, WV

* JOHN CLARK ANDERSON 83,174.49 155 LEWISBURG, WV* TIMOTHY H PRENTICE 82,698.95 145 ELKINS, WV

FORBES LAW OFFICES PLLC 82,678.84 59 CHARLESTON, WVNANCY A DALBY ATTY AT LAW PLLC 80,056.22 29 CHARLES TOWN, WV

* HEDGES LYONS & SHEPHERD PLLC 79,450.75 88 MORGANTOWN, WVMAGANN LAW OFFICE PLLC 79,095.52 177 BLUEFIELD, WVSCOTT A SHOUGH 78,373.18 123 FAIRMONT, WV

* JAMELLA L LOCKWOOD 77,139.18 107 BUCKHANNON, WV* JOSEPH W MCFARLAND 76,806.54 139 WELLINGTON, FL

COLLINS LAW FIRM 76,627.93 124 KEYSER, WVCALLAGHAN & CALLAGHAN PLLC 76,244.30 32 SUMMERSVILLE, WVSOUTHERN WV LAW CLINIC 75,650.21 122 BECKLEY, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF RUTH A MCQUADE 74,708.78 83 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WVHUNTER D SIMMONS 74,204.34 248 BUCKHANNON, WV

* F JOHN OSHOWAY 73,699.47 103 GRANTSVILLE, WV* BLACKWATER LAW PLLC 73,457.31 107 PARSONS, WV

RANDALL D WALL 73,432.00 493 HUNTINGTON, WV* JAMES T CAREY 73,287.76 123 WEIRTON, WV

ANDREW B CHATTIN 73,128.45 48 CHARLESTON, WVMARK D PANEPINTO 72,752.65 23 WHEELING, WVDWIGHT R HALL 72,510.44 138 ELKINS, WV






CLAIMS* NAVY L VICTOR 71,625.19 103 BARBOURSVILLE, WV* GARVIN LAW PLLC 71,518.57 36 NUTTER FORT, WV

JONATHAN FITTRO 70,538.21 45 CLARKSBURG, WV* ROSINSKY LAW OFFICE 70,311.57 26 HUNTINGTON, WV

BAILEY & HOWARD PLLC 68,881.16 61 BARBOURSVILLE, WVMCNEER HIGHLAND MCMUNN & VARNER LC 68,645.48 76 CLARKSBURG, WVLAW OFFICE OF REBECCA S JOHNSON 68,253.86 118 CHARLESTON, WV

* WARD MORGAN 67,996.36 72 BLUEFIELD, WVSTEVEN A GREENBAUM ESQ ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 67,535.33 79 MARTINSBURG, WVPULLIN FOWLER FLANAGAN BROWN & POE PLLC 66,683.03 248 CHARLESTON, WVERICA BRANNON GUNN ATTY AT LAW PLLC 66,498.02 75 SPENCER, WVALAN L PRITT 66,249.50 86 CHARLESTON, WV

* JOHN LAISHLEY 66,099.75 43 HUNTINGTON, WVSPENIA LAW OFFICE PLLC 65,171.63 82 BARBOURSVILLE, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF ROBBY N LONG LC 64,945.66 104 HAMLIN, WVFRANCES C WHITEMAN 64,833.90 102 FAIRMONT, WVDENNIS R BAILEY 64,106.86 103 CHARLESTON, WV

* JASON D HOLDREN 64,058.54 74 GALLIPOLIS, OHSANDERS AUSTIN FLANIGAN & FLANIGAN 63,649.14 58 PRINCETON, WVBRYAN S HINKLE 62,980.32 102 BUCKHANNON, WVMAIER LAW OFFICE LLC 62,972.59 74 HINTON, WV

* MARK EVERETT ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 62,787.60 102 MORGANTOWN, WV* WILLIAM O HUFFMAN 62,263.65 57 PRINCETON, WV

GUNNOE LAW OFFICE 62,093.96 142 HINTON, WVBRADLEY LAW OFFICE PLLC 61,710.33 57 PARKERSBURG, WV

* P TODD PHILLIPS 61,583.00 37 MORGANTOWN, WVHEIDI M GEORGI STURM 60,981.03 71 FAIRMONT, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF JAMES C CLEVENGER 60,727.57 66 WESTON, WVNELSON M MICHAEL LC 60,399.24 161 KEYSER, WVLAW OFFICE OF MICHAEL SAFCSAK PLLC 59,950.45 52 FAIRMONT, WV

* FRED F HOLROYD 59,911.32 80 CHARLESTON, WV* DAVID R TYSON 58,962.31 113 HUNTINGTON, WV* LUTTRELL & PREZIOSO PLLC 58,733.76 32 MARTINSBURG, WV

WILLIAM T NESTOR PLLC 58,026.96 119 ELKINS, WVG TODD HOUCK ATTORNEY AT LAW LC 57,775.95 59 MULLENS, WVTICHENOR LAW OFFICE 57,699.69 109 FAIRMONT, WVCHRISTOPHER H MILLER 57,580.12 64 MORGANTOWN, WV

* SALMONS & BOWEN ATTORNEYS AT LAW PLLC 57,572.49 152 WEST HAMLIN, WVPARTAIN LAW OFFICE 55,565.18 63 LOGAN, WVMARTIN V SAFFER 55,312.50 35 MARLINTON, WVCURRY AMOS & ASSOCIATES LC 55,062.25 92 FAIRMONT, WVHOLLY W HINERMAN 54,289.02 31 PENTRESS, WV

* GLORIA M STEPHENS 53,953.07 64 WELCH, WVLELA WALKER ATTY AT LAW PLLC 53,888.44 108 OCEANA, WV

* KELLEY LAW OFFICE 52,699.05 35 HUNTINGTON, WV* JAMES B REES 52,533.70 59 FAYETTEVILLE, WV* BRYAN S CROMLEY 52,173.97 137 POINT PLEASANT, WV

JAMES A MCCOY 52,139.64 47 HAMLIN, WVJERRY M LYALL 51,426.42 78 WILLIAMSON, WVCATHRYN A NOGAY 50,574.95 24 WEIRTON, WVROSINSKY LAW OFFICE LC 50,572.73 21 HUNTINGTON, WVDAVID M GRUNAU 50,458.28 61 MORGANTOWN, WV






CLAIMS* MARLA ZELENE HARMAN 49,905.30 43 FRANKLIN, WV

JOHN S LANHAM 49,316.98 61 HORNER, WVE LAVOYD MORGAN JR & ASSOCIATES LC 48,985.96 41 LEWISBURG, WV

* GENTILOZZI & ASSOCIATES 48,887.87 77 CLARKSBURG, WVDAVID KARICKHOFF 48,200.15 112 SUTTON, WVJERRY BLAIR 48,051.55 54 CLARKSBURG, WV

* TRACY WEESE 47,921.75 11 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WV* RIST LAW OFFICES LC 47,670.01 83 FAYETTEVILLE, WV

JONATHAN G BRILL PLLC 47,568.62 62 ROMNEY, WVTHOMPSON & PARDO PLLC 47,140.81 38 CHARLES TOWN, WVCICCARELLO DEL GUIDICE & LAFON 46,830.29 25 CHARLESTON, WVNESSEL LAW FIRM 46,665.56 42 HUNTINGTON, WV

* CHRISTOPHER A SCHEETZ 46,414.43 54 FOLLANSBEE, WV* SIMMONS & SIMMONS LC 46,390.94 48 ELIZABETH, WV

LOUIE T PRICE 46,072.01 14 CHARLESTON, WV* C EDWARD MCDONOUGH 45,724.42 81 PARKERSBURG, WV* PRITT & PRITT PLLC 45,632.00 95 CHARLESTON, WV* LAW OFFICE OF ERIN SWISSHELM 45,592.52 28 CHARLES TOWN, WV

FERRELL LAW OFFICE PLLC 45,549.53 92 WILLIAMSON, WVREBECCA E MICK 45,384.49 58 CHARLESTON, WVKOURTNEY A RYAN & ASSOCIATES 45,214.50 18 BUCKHANNON, WVHILL LAW FIRM PLLC 45,173.91 18 CHARLESTON, WVATTORNEY CRAWLEY-WOODS 44,928.89 42 MARTINSBURG, WVERNEST M DOUGLASS 44,928.19 99 PARKERSBURG, WVCASSELL & CREWE PC 44,875.89 49 WYTHEVILLE, VADAVID B DEMOSS 44,680.32 89 FAIRMONT, WV

* NEAL J HAMILTON 44,611.17 15 FAIRMONT, WVKEATON FRAZER & MILLESON PLLC 44,582.21 150 ROMNEY, WVBOWERS & BOWERS PLLC 44,571.35 42 FRANKLIN, WVJAY W GERBER JR 44,096.96 60 PARKERSBURG, WV

* THOMAS R CZARNIK & ASSOCIATES 44,034.13 63 PRINCETON, WVPAUL G TAYLOR 43,992.21 52 MARTINSBURG, WVWAYNE KING 43,490.45 25 CLAY, WV

* JENNIFER DAY CRANE 43,335.80 69 FAYETTEVILLE, WV* RYAN HAMILTON KEESEE 43,294.54 63 SMOOT, WV* MCGRAW LAW OFFICES 42,847.11 18 PROSPERITY, WV

BURTON LAW OFFICE 42,662.39 30 MORGANTOWN, WVCHERYL L WARMAN 42,661.60 78 MORGANTOWN, WVJOYCE E STEWART 42,326.02 48 MOOREFIELD, WV

* KATZ KANTOR STONESTREET & BUCKNER PLLC 42,252.35 63 PRINCETON, WV* LAW OFFICE OF TRENA WILLIAMS PLLC 42,242.23 61 WESTON, WV

ASHLEY N COCHRAN 41,902.17 56 LOGAN, WVSTEVEN M THORNE 41,864.05 86 LOGAN, WVMARK E HOBBS 41,638.68 24 CHAPMANVILLE, WVTHOMAS J PRALL 41,600.73 115 WESTON, WVCONRAD & CONRAD 41,431.36 31 FAYETTEVILLE, WVBUCK & PRENTICE PLLC 41,418.77 21 MARTINSBURG, WVGARTH W BECK 41,370.76 78 CLARKSBURG, WV

* LANTZ LAW OFFICE 41,269.52 21 MOUNDSVILLE, WVMICHAEL C ALBERTY 41,269.50 30 WHEELING, WVSHAFER LAW OFFICES 40,945.78 21 WHEELING, WVSCHAMBERGER LEGAL SERVICES 40,939.96 50 CLAY, WV






CLAIMS* SHAFFER & SHAFFER 40,914.24 57 MADISON, WV

GEORGE M TORRES 40,892.85 73 PARKERSBURG, WV* MATTHEW H FAIR 40,651.18 63 ELKINS, WV

LONG LAW OFFICES PLLC 40,401.60 71 SCOTT DEPOT, WVHATFIELD & HATFIELD PLLC 40,311.87 41 MADISON, WVDAVID K MOORE 40,285.05 36 RIPLEY, WVMANYPENNY RAINES LAW OFFICE PLLC 40,072.35 62 CHESTER, WVKEPPLE LAW FIRM PA 39,971.96 42 OAKLAND, MDROBINSON & MCELWEE 39,952.19 11 CHARLESTON, WVSELDEN LAW OFFICES LC 39,859.78 28 BECKLEY, WVCHARLES CASEY FORBES 39,574.25 63 CHARLESTON, WVMICHAEL K WALLACE 39,519.66 60 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WVKUENZEL & ASSOCIATES PLLC 39,170.37 66 CHAPMANVILLE, WVJOHN M JURCO 39,134.32 29 ST CLAIRSVILLE, OHARNOLD & BAILEY PLLC 39,132.03 66 CHARLES TOWN, WV

* KATICA RIBEL 39,116.86 88 FAIRMONT, WVLEFLER & BOGGS PLLC 39,074.55 45 BECKLEY, WV

* MAX H WHITE PLLC 38,789.03 151 KEYSER, WV* RICHARD D STEPHENS 38,710.88 61 MARTINSBURG, WV

TIPTON LAW OFFICES 38,643.60 67 FAIRMONT, WVMARSHA WEBB-RUMORA 38,521.31 83 WILLIAMSON, WVMICHAEL N EACHUS 38,457.78 40 GALLIPOLIS, OH

* LANCE E ROLLO 38,441.12 57 MORGANTOWN, WV* WOLFE LAW OFFICE PLLC 38,438.96 101 LOGAN, WV

DEAN LAW OFFICES PLLC 38,275.65 64 SAINT ALBANS, WVTONY MORGAN 37,870.70 58 GRANTSVILLE, WV

* LAW OFFICES OF DREAMA D SINKKANEN 37,630.76 40 CLARKSBURG, WVRICHARD W HOLLANDSWORTH 37,624.55 45 WHEELING, WV

* SIDNEY H BELL 37,479.61 40 WELCH, WV* WILLIAM L PENNINGTON 36,702.84 60 MORGANTOWN, WV* GREINER & CYRUS LC 36,444.83 42 HUNTINGTON, WV

CILIBERTI LAW OFFICE PLLC 36,105.58 57 FAYETTEVILLE, WVGREGORY K BALL 35,577.94 59 PRINCETON, WVLAW OFFICES OF CRAIG P ERHARD PLLC 35,209.69 98 FAIRMONT, WVFARNSWORTH LAW OFFICE 35,072.47 49 PARKERSBURG, WVLIVINGOOD LAW PLLC 35,049.96 44 BUCKHANNON, WVGIATRAS LAW FIRM PLLC 34,968.15 78 CHARLESTON, WVSILAS M PRESTON 33,888.33 14 LEWISBURG, WVROYCE B SAVILLE PLLC 33,775.08 140 ROMNEY, WVLAW OFFICE OF CHRISTOPHER M WILSON PLLC 33,582.57 68 FAIRMONT, WVBELINDA A HAYNIE 33,576.61 52 MORGANTOWN, WVDAVID L ORNDORFF 33,490.46 33 BUCKHANNON, WVCAMPBELL LAW OFFICES 33,384.43 69 CHARLESTON, WVMIZE LAW FIRM PLLC 33,373.67 18 BECKLEY, WVREGGIE R BAILEY 33,182.21 55 PARKERSBURG, WVROSALEE JUBA-PLUMLEY 33,130.50 29 ELEANOR, WVERIC B ANDERSON PLLC 33,009.46 65 HUNTINGTON, WVWAYNE ROBERT MIELKE 32,776.00 16 WELLSBURG, WVWESTON LAW A LEGAL CORP 32,768.35 20 HUNTINGTON, WVKURT J WINTER 32,232.10 111 BURGETTSTOWN, PAHARSH LAW LC 32,117.51 28 PARKERSBURG, WVJOHN G OURS 30,727.87 53 PETERSBURG, WV






CLAIMSWALTERS & KRAUSKOPF 30,621.47 57 MOOREFIELD, WVKITTLE LAW OFFICE PLLC 29,980.31 71 FAIRMONT, WVCLINTON W SMITH 29,606.72 140 CHARLESTON, WVFRANKLIN W LASH 29,449.40 22 WHEELING, WVCONWAY LAW OFFICE 29,158.30 49 HUNTINGTON, WVAMICK LAW FIRM PLLC 29,021.15 59 LEIVASY, WV

* HERSHBERGER LAW OFFICE 28,968.56 34 WHEELING, WV* LAW OFFICE OF P ZACHARY STEWART 28,890.73 40 WEIRTON, WV* NUTTALL LEGAL LLC 28,615.34 41 BUCKHANNON, WV

CONAWAY & CONAWAY 28,182.54 70 MADISON, WVESTATE OF DESIREE LYNNETTE GARNES 27,665.90 44 HUNTINGTON, WVMCGEELAW 27,559.82 33 CHARLESTON, WVR STEPHEN DAVIS 27,245.66 10 BEAVER, WVWILBERT A PAYNE 27,064.30 63 BECKLEY, WVFAST LAW OFFICE LC 27,003.66 17 FAYETTEVILLE, WV

* MARGARET A GORDON 26,938.86 9 BERKELEY SPRINGS, WVLAW OFFICE OF B SCOTT WOLFE PLLC 26,871.67 37 HARRISVILE, WVSANTER & SANTER 26,690.93 73 PARKERSBURG, WVRICHELLE KEENER GARLOW 26,604.87 56 SAINT ALBANS, WVWILLIAM C NOEL 26,558.01 31 MORGANTOWN, WV

* J MINGO WINTERS ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 26,505.50 59 BECKLEY, WV* CARR LAW OFFICES PLLC 26,446.50 17 SAINT MARYS, WV

BOTTNER & SKILLMAN 26,381.50 39 CHARLES TOWN, WV* LAW OFFICE OF STEVEN M BRAGG PLLC 26,326.91 69 BARBOURSVILLE, WV

J A M LAW PLLC 26,115.03 35 HARRISVILLE, WVDANA P MCDERMOTT 25,855.51 3 MARTINSBURG, WV

* MICHAEL E FROBLE 25,705.67 31 BECKLEY, WV* JUDY & JUDY 25,671.64 60 MOOREFIELD, WV* JAMES B SHOCKLEY 25,532.31 36 MORGANTOWN, WV

LENA D PRATT 25,431.60 31 LOGAN, WVCOOK LAW OFFICES PLLC 25,398.04 39 BARBOURSVILLE, WVPETER D DINARDI 25,380.50 26 MORGANTOWN, WV

* TIMOTHY M SIRK 25,280.98 39 KEYSER, WV* COSNER LAW OFFICE 25,251.01 72 ROMNEY, WV* SARAH SMITH 25,244.76 30 MEADOW BRIDGE, WV* STEPHEN P NEW LC 25,238.15 10 BECKLEY, WV

GIBSON LEFLER & ASSOCIATES 25,221.74 34 PRINCETON, WV* THOMAS E WHITE 25,147.50 57 MOUNDSVILLE, WV

MORELLI LAW 25,136.42 34 WEIRTON, WVJOYCE H MORTON 25,013.14 29 WEBSTER SPRINGS, WV

* JOHN F PARKULO 25,010.00 25 DANIELS, WVRICHARDSON RICHARDSON & CAMPBELL 24,934.10 67 PARKERSBURG, WV

* DAMON B MORGAN 24,923.28 97 POINT PLEASANT, WVJOHN WOODS 24,906.50 35 BELLEVILLE, WVCHRISTOPHER S MOOREHEAD 24,591.84 41 FAYETTEVILLE, WVROY T HARDY 24,381.14 36 KEYSER, WVERIC KEITH WILDMAN 24,324.20 57 FAIRMONT, WV

* WILLIAM T FORESTER 24,216.73 68 LOGAN, WV* BRIAN D YOST 24,001.10 32 HURRICANE, WV* STEPHEN D HERNDON 23,893.06 8 WHEELING, WV

BERNARD R MAUSER 23,857.15 47 SUTTON, WVJACQUELYN STOUT BIDDLE 23,738.34 21 HUNTINGTON, WV






CLAIMSFROST BROWN TODD LLC 23,729.21 2 LOUISVILLE, KYTYREE EMBREE & ASSOCIATES PLLC 23,714.98 57 HURRICANE, WVKRATOVIL LAW OFFICES PLLC 23,589.24 33 CHARLES TOWN, WVREDMAN & PAYNE 23,473.45 4 CHARLESTON, WV

* KETTERING DELLIGATTI LAW OFFICES PLLC 22,870.89 45 FAIRMONT, WV* ROBERT DUNLAP ESQ PLLC 22,848.63 52 BECKLEY, WV

ELLEM LAW OFFICE 22,739.31 64 PARKERSBURG, WVASHTON & CRAWLEY WOODS PLLC 22,686.91 47 MARTINSBURG, WVGOAD LAW FIRM 22,518.12 94 HUNTINGTON, WVSNYDER & HASSIG 22,448.50 19 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WVROOP & SMITH LAW OFFICE PLLC 22,225.00 11 BECKLEY, WVCHRISTOPHER W COOPER 22,169.76 20 DAVIS, WVCHARLES E STALNAKER 22,157.77 61 PARKERSBURG, WVKEVIN C DUFFY 22,050.09 9 CLAY, WV

* JOHN K CHASE IV 22,048.67 15 MOUNDSVILLE, WV* ROLF E BAUMGARTEL 22,015.47 58 MARIETTA, OH* JESSICA E MYERS 21,435.50 25 PARKERSBURG, WV

ERIC M FRANCIS 21,364.97 14 LEWISBURG, WVHANDLEY & HUNT PLLC 21,129.57 56 POINT PLEASANT, WVGLASS DEFENSE FIRM 21,029.89 36 CLARKSBURG, WVBEAN & BEAN 20,851.70 40 MOOREFIELD, WVKEVIN D MILLS & ASSOCIATES PLLC 20,427.63 9 MARTINSBURG, WVRUMORA & RUMORA LC 20,068.06 48 WILLIAMSON, WV

* HOWARD J BLYLER 20,047.40 40 COWEN, WV* BREWER & GIGGENBACH PLLC 20,044.05 29 MORGANTOWN, WV

ANITA HAROLD ASHLEY 20,030.21 73 SPENCER, WVHELEN M BRANCAZIO 19,870.26 42 WEIRTON, WVS SEAN MURPHY PLLC 19,780.72 46 MORGANTOWN, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF ADAM D TAYLOR INC 19,508.31 45 BECKLEY, WV* MOYE LAW OFFICE 19,311.95 45 WINFIELD, WV* ROSE PADDEN & PETTY LC 19,193.41 35 FAIRMONT, WV

SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE PLLC 19,126.12 11 CHARLESTON, WVDEBRA L STEED PLLC 18,919.66 25 PARKERSBURG, WVWINIFRED L BUCY 18,859.50 10 BECKLEY, WVMARK P PELLEGRIN 18,841.50 44 MORGANTOWN, WVTHOMAS B KARR 18,648.17 88 VIENNA, WVKAYSER LAYNE & CLARK PLLC 18,405.65 26 POINT PLEASANT, WV

* AILYNN MAE ORTEZA 18,150.04 8 MORGANTOWN, WVCOLLINS LAW OFFICE PLLC 18,119.03 20 CHARLESTON, WVF SAMUEL BYRER PLLC 17,954.02 11 CHARLES TOWN, WV

* A COURTENAY CRAIG 17,682.41 3 HUNTINGTON, WVJAMES B ATKINS 17,671.61 15 SCOTT DEPOT, WVABRAHAM & ILDERTON PLLC 17,539.57 50 LOGAN, WVSHANE M MALLETT LAW OFFICES 17,517.60 36 WHEELING, WVNELSON LEGAL SERVICES LC 17,494.15 36 PETERSBURG, WVRODRIGUEZ LAW OFFICE 17,339.60 30 MORGANTOWN, WVORNDORFF & HATFIELD ATTY AT LAW 17,310.09 23 BARBOURSVILLE, WVJAMES LAW FIRM 17,255.76 39 KEYSER, WV

* ALLISON ADYNIEC COWDEN 17,198.10 6 WEIRTON, WVDAVIS & CHAPMAN PLLC 17,134.58 15 SUMMERSVILLE, WVGARY J MARTINO 16,955.50 38 FAIRMONT, WVSARAH E DIXON 16,835.76 35 HUNTINGTON, WV






CLAIMSDAVID W HART 16,679.08 46 ELKINS, WVLAW OFFICES OF EDWARD R KOHOUT PLLC 16,572.24 67 MORGANTOWN, WVROBERT C STONE JR PLLC 16,464.39 8 MARTINSBURG, WV

* DAVID L HILL 16,410.99 60 HURRICANE, WVJOHN H TREADWAY JR 16,349.36 24 MOOREFIELD, WVLAW OFFICE OF TRAVIS SAYRE 16,231.66 10 PARKERSBURG, WV

* STEPTOE & JOHNSON 16,201.68 13 BRIDGEPORT, WVHUNTER LAW OFFICE 16,184.38 31 SCOTT DEPOT, WVSMITH LILLY & BALL PLLC 16,154.94 6 PRINCETON, WVCANDACE L OGLE 15,949.50 112 MORGANTOWN, WVGODDARD & WAGONER 15,842.42 2 CLARKSBURG, WVKUPEC & ASSOCIATES PLLC 15,753.98 5 CLARKSBURG, WVLAW FIRM OF TERESA C MONK 15,680.42 33 WALTON, WVJULIET WALKER RUNDLE 15,648.32 8 PINEVILLE, WV

* WILSON LAW OFFICE 15,519.23 70 KEYSER, WVLAW OFFICES OF RICHARD D SMITH JR 15,432.59 50 PARKERSBURG, WV

* MICHELLE BROWN-BAILEY COLLEEN 15,409.71 17 BECKLEY, WVRICHARD L VITAL 15,360.28 16 BARBOURSVILLE, WVSITES LAW FIRM 15,346.84 46 KEYSER, WVMARSH LAW OFFICE PLLC 15,261.30 28 CHARLESTON, WVFITZSIMMONS LAW FIRM PLLC 15,241.77 1 WHEELING, WVJAY CARTER LOVE 15,120.50 144 HUNTINGTON, WVSKLAVOUNAKIS LAW OFFICE 15,065.66 14 WHEELING, WVROBERT W BRIGHT 15,031.70 32 MIDDLEPORT, OHR RUSSELL STOBBS 14,928.35 30 WESTON, WVJEROME R NOVOBILSKI 14,747.74 46 CLAY, WV

* BETSY GRIFFITH 14,571.33 8 BRIDGEPORT, WV* NEELY & CALLAGHAN 14,546.84 26 CHARLESTON, WV

DASCOLI LAW OFFICE 14,482.50 22 CHARLESTON, WVCOLIN M CLINE ATTY AT LAW 14,479.40 17 PRINCETON, WV

* ROBERT E BARRAT 14,410.76 21 MARTINSBURG, WVSAMMONS OLIVERO & PARASCHOS PLLC 14,226.41 6 HUNTINGTON, WVSUSAN J VAN ZANT LC 14,167.29 22 WILLIAMSON, WVMELISHA D SOUDERS 13,936.33 6 HANCOCK, MDRAY LAW PLLC 13,894.69 19 MORGANTOWN, WVKYLE G LUSK 13,750.50 26 BECKLEY, WV

* D CONRAD GALL 13,354.71 40 FAIRMONT, WVJARRELL L CLIFTON 13,300.00 40 MARLINTON, WVLAW OFFICE OF DAVID A MASCIO 13,232.18 30 WEIRTON, WVLAW OFFICE OF JEFF C WOODS 12,957.60 24 SCOTT DEPOT, WVJOHN A CARR ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 12,861.07 12 CHARLESTON, WVWHITNEY MESHELL SHAFFER 12,792.00 27 CHARLESTON, WVRICHARD C WITT 12,701.00 24 POCO, WVJ BRANDON SHUMAKER 12,662.35 17 MORGANTOWN, WV

* JEREMY B WOLFE 12,653.91 26 PARKERSBURG, WVSANTE BONINSEGNA JR 12,579.90 21 PINEVILLE, WV

* DEANNA L PENNINGTON 12,353.50 27 MORGANTOWN, WV* DAVIS LAW FIRM 12,348.01 28 CLARKSBURG, WV

SIKORA SNEAD PLLC 12,234.66 12 MORGANTOWN, WVIRA M HAUGHT 12,201.15 7 HARRISVILLE, WV

* ALLISON KATHLEEN BECKETT 12,131.39 19 BARBOURSVILLE, WVDAVID A CAMILLETTI ATTORNEY AT LAW LC 12,003.34 8 CHARLES TOWN, WV






CLAIMSROKISKY & ASSOCIATES 11,965.64 3 WEIRTON, WVBUCCI BAILEY & JAVINS LC 11,914.25 18 SUMMERSVILLE, WVTHOMPSON LAW OFFICE PLLC 11,745.50 16 WILLIAMSON, WVREBECCA TATE 11,614.51 47 FAIRMONT, WV

* LEE F BENFORD 11,461.47 4 RIPLEY, WVROGER R WEESE 11,284.50 11 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WV

* RICHARD M RIFFE 11,127.72 6 ALUM CREEK, WVCHAD D BARRY LC 11,117.50 60 HUNTINGTON, WVALEXANDRIA A SOLOMON 10,997.78 10 DAVIS, WVLEGAL AID OF WEST VIRGINIA INC 10,958.32 5 CHARLESTON, WVLOCKWOOD & LOCKWOOD 10,917.00 34 HUNTINGTON, WVMCCAMIC SACCO & MCCOID PLLC 10,843.38 3 WHEELING, WVWHEELER LAW FIRM 10,836.19 21 SCOTT DEPOT, WVESTATE OF MARSHA DALTON 10,808.41 7 HUNTINGTON, WV

* HYER & LITTLEPAGE 10,724.58 5 POINT PLEASANT, WV* SMITH MCMUNN & GLOVER PLLC 10,663.14 16 CLARKSBURG, WV

DYER LAW OFFICES 10,569.12 16 CLARKSBURG, WVGREGORY W SPROLES PLLC 10,527.43 25 SUMMERSVILLE, WVMCGINNIS E HATFIELD 10,437.40 12 GREENSBORO, NCCURNUTTE LAW OFFICE 10,260.48 15 ELKINS, WV

* MELISSA J GIGGENBACH 10,114.44 2 MORGANTOWN, WV* THARP LIOTTA & YOKUM LLP 10,021.70 18 FAIRMONT, WV

KLATT LAW OFFICES PLLC 9,955.16 13 WHEELING, WVBUSCH ZURBUCH & THOMPSON PLLC 9,832.38 6 ELKINS, WV

* COOPER LAW OFFICES PLLC 9,721.50 3 BRIDGEPORT, WVREGINALD D HENRY ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 9,708.50 15 BECKLEY, WVSEAN LOGUE PLLC 9,655.01 20 PITTSBURGH, PAHENDERSON HENDERSON & STAPLES LC 9,617.50 7 HUNTINGTON, WVADAMS LEGAL GROUP PLLC 9,616.15 19 DELLSLOW, WVLAW OFFICE OF SETH HARPER PLLC 9,555.21 16 RIPLEY, WVHYRE LAW OFFICE PLLC 9,363.90 11 KINGWOOD, WVHARRIS WILSON TURNER & DAVISSON PLLC 9,207.78 7 CLARKSBURG, WV

* KAUFMAN & MCPHERSON PLLC 9,191.30 5 BRIDGEPORT, WVATKINS & OGLE LAW OFFICES LC 9,141.35 12 BUFFALO, WVLAW OFFICE OF NEIL ZAHRADNIK PLLC 9,115.29 8 MARTINSBURG, WVKENNETH J BARNETT LC 8,964.89 15 SUMMERSVILLE, WVGERLACH LAW 8,859.00 6 WAYNE, WVYANNI LAW FIRM 8,851.95 29 MARTINSBURG, WVFRIEND & ROZAS LLC 8,847.97 13 CUMBERLAND, MD

* PAUL WILLIAMS ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 8,841.74 22 SUMMERSVILLE, WVHARLEY E STOLLINGS 8,840.07 15 SUMMERSVILLE, WVGIANOLA BARNUM WIGAL & LONDON LC 8,824.81 10 MORGANTOWN, WVMOORE LAW FIRM PLLC 8,788.35 13 FRANKLIN, WVSUPPLE LAW OFFICES PLLC 8,560.56 24 POINT PLEASANT, WVSCOTT S RADMAN 8,494.50 40 MORGANTOWN, WVSHANNON R THOMAS 8,395.00 1 WESTON, WVOLIVIA S HARRIS DEVALL 8,379.51 2 KINGWOOD, WVEDMUND J ROLLO 8,316.50 10 MORGANTOWN, WV

* NICHOLAS MAYO 8,267.14 12 HUNTINGTON, WVSALUJA LAW OFFICES PLLC 8,061.00 20 NITRO, WV

* MICHAEL J SHARLEY 8,027.00 14 WESTOVER, WVJOHN RAY FUNKHOUSER 7,995.89 8 FAIRMONT, WV






CLAIMSPARTEE & ASSOCIATES PLLC 7,733.47 16 MORGANTOWN, WVC CHRISTOPHER YOUNGER 7,634.50 4 WILLIAMSON, WV

* MAGGIE K WALL 7,508.29 14 SCOTT DEPOT, WVSCOTT C BROWN LAW OFFICE 7,426.08 3 WHEELING, WVROBERT STEPHEN JARRELL 7,247.00 5 MILTON, WVSHIRLEY J STANTON 7,112.08 10 FAIRMONT, WV

* WLO MANAGEMENT LLC 7,096.95 13 HUNTINGTON, WVLOREN B HOWLEY 7,021.05 17 GRANTSVILLE, WVCRAFT LAW FIRM PLLC 6,961.07 40 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WVSHARON N BOGARAD 6,942.50 4 WEIRTON, WVSTEPHEN BROOKS WEST 6,895.50 10 CHARLESTON, WVMARVIN J BAKER 6,859.80 4 CANONSBURG, PARHONDA M MCINTYRE 6,840.34 10 MORGANTOWN, WVPAULA L HARBOUR PLLC 6,712.78 8 HUNTINGTON, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF ROGER D FORMAN LC 6,711.42 7 BUCKEYE, WVHODGES & RIFFLE PLLC 6,666.00 8 FAIRMONT, WVLACY W WRIGHT 6,633.36 26 WELCH, WVMATTHEW F GRAVES PLLC 6,621.51 11 ST MARYS, WVLAW OFFICES OF CHRISTINA A MULLIGAN 6,283.05 3 FAIRMONT, WVROBIN R LOUDERBACK 6,178.50 6 CHARLESTON, WV

* MARY BETH ANGOTTI 6,083.60 8 GRANVILLE, WVJOHN G BYRD 6,058.48 14 PRINCETON, WVMARK D HUDNALL 6,050.93 15 SUMMERSVILLE, WVWILLIAM H SCHARF 5,991.13 5 CHARLESTON, WVNANCY L MCGHEE 5,934.54 26 MINERAL WELLS, WVCOOPER & PRESTON PLLC 5,765.20 1 PARSONS, WV

* MICHAEL J SHAHEEN 5,673.86 8 ST CLAIRSVILLE, OHKRISTEN D ANTOLINI 5,607.27 21 MORGANTOWN, WVLESLIE L MAZE 5,471.60 4 ELIZABETH, WVJENNIFER N TAYLOR 5,388.40 17 CHARLESTON, WVPHILIP J TISSUE 5,279.91 9 OAK HILL, WVKAREN L HALL 5,261.69 4 MORGANTOWN, WVBAILESS LAW PLLC 5,178.66 13 CHARLESTON, WVCHARLENE FOOSE GEYER 5,129.89 1 WHEELING, WV

* MICHAEL T CLIFFORD 5,129.42 2 CHARLESTON, WVANTHONY J SPARACINO JR 5,074.00 4 BECKLEY, WV

* HAROLD B WOLFE III 5,050.66 2 PRINCETON, WV* DOTSENKO LAW OFFICES PLLC 4,966.13 5 CHARLESTON, WV

WILLIAM DANIEL ROLL 4,960.20 2 POINT PLEASANT, WVW STEPHEN FLESHER 4,904.48 3 HUNTINGTON, WVVIRGINIA JACKSON HOPKINS 4,876.27 3 KINGWOOD, WVJULIE GOWER ROMAIN 4,861.40 12 FAIRMONT, WVJOHN B BROOKS 4,847.03 6 MORGANTOWN, WV

* PAT C FRAGILE 4,810.00 7 BECKLEY, WV* LAW OFFICE OF FRANK P BUSH JR 4,721.40 18 ELKINS, WV

POWER BECK & MATZUREFF 4,624.22 1 MARTINSBURG, WVHART LAW CENTER 4,590.00 6 WHEELING, WVJOHNSTON HOLROYD & ASSOCIATES 4,541.83 10 PRINCETON, WV

* TURNER & JOHNS PLLC 4,471.84 10 CHARLESTON, WVCOURTLANDT SMITH 4,461.61 9 CHARLESTON, WVDAVID B RICHARDSON LAW OFFICE 4,360.90 13 WINFIELD, WVANDREW R SHUMATE 4,352.05 16 CHARLESTON, WV






CLAIMS* KRISTINE ADELE BURDETTE 4,232.90 13 FAIRMONT, WV* LAW OFFICE OF HEATHER M WEESE PLLC 4,180.63 9 ELKINS, WV

GENTILE DELLA CLINE 4,130.87 7 WILLIAMSON, WV* LAW OFFICE OF JENNA WALKER CREMEANS PLLC 4,127.98 2 BARBOURSVILLE, WV

OLCOTT LAW OFFICE 3,807.78 11 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WVANDREA P POWELL 3,762.50 7 PRINCETON, WVDEAN A FURNER ATTY AT LAW PLLC 3,691.00 14 PARKERSBURG, WV

* BOUCHILLON CROSSAN & COLBURN LC 3,641.50 2 HUNTINGTON, WV* JOSEPH MOSKO 3,608.00 8 PROSPERITY, WV

LISA M MOYE 3,516.75 5 WINFIELD, WV* DAVID H WILMOTH LC 3,504.25 9 ELKINS, WV

CASSELL & PRINZ PLLC 3,476.71 8 CHARLES TOWN, WVSUTTON & JANELLE PLLC 3,459.85 5 MARTINSBURG, WVMESLER LAW OFFICES 3,426.90 5 WEIRTON, WVDARRELL W RINGER 3,426.16 1 MORGANTOWN, WVTODD A KIRBY 3,420.20 7 BECKLEY, WVSHANNON L BALDWIN ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 3,379.23 5 BLUEFIELD, WVTHOMPSON BARNEY 3,357.94 1 CHARLESTON, WV

* CARBONE & BLAYDES PLLC 3,258.91 4 CHARLESTON, WVRACHELLE D MCINTYRE-NICHOLSON 3,258.79 3 CLARKSBURG, WVHANCOCK & SEARS 3,225.88 1 RAVENSWOOD, WVDELBY B POOL & ASSOCIATES 3,170.21 3 CLARKSBURG, WVDENNIE S MORGAN 3,048.50 4 BECKLEY, WVRICHARD M GOLDSTEIN 3,028.00 4 PRINCETON, WV

* AVIS WITTEN & WANDLING LC 3,000.00 1 LOGAN, WVDAVID K MOORE 2,894.83 7 RIPLEY, WVN EDWARD EAGLOSKI 2,863.21 8 HURRICANE, WVALLEN KOPET & ASSOCIATES PLLC 2,784.31 1 HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SCGEORGE P STANTON 2,755.00 6 FAIRMONT, WVRONALD G SALMONS ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 2,742.50 4 WEST HAMLIN, WV

* WEBER & WEBER 2,735.04 3 WESTON, WVROTH LEGAL SERVICES LC 2,723.76 9 PETERSBURG, WVJAMES E SPURLOCK 2,597.70 2 HUNTINGTON, WVRAHBAR LAW OFFICE 2,501.10 1 WHEELING, WVDONNA M PRICE 2,473.87 5 MARLINTON, WVHYLTON LAW OFFICE PLLC 2,371.65 1 BEAVER, WVFREDERICK M DEAN ROHRIG 2,308.47 3 MIDDLEBOURNE, WVBOWEN LAW OFFICE PLLC 2,217.09 6 WEST HAMLIN, WVLAW OFFICES OF VANESSA LYNN RODRIGUEZ 2,174.11 5 FAIRMONT, WVCARTER ZERBE & ASSOCIATES PLLC 2,127.00 7 CHARLESTON, WVBRENDAN DONEGHY 2,071.67 6 CHARLESTON, WVALVIE E QUALLS 2,071.44 9 HUNTINGTON, WVKIRBY GILBERT & ASHLEY LC 2,016.13 6 BECKLEY, WV

* WOOTON LAW FIRM 1,971.12 4 BECKLEY, WVJOHN R MITCHELL LC 1,949.20 6 CHARLESTON, WVCHARLES STANFORD WEST 1,924.50 3 WILLIAMSON, WVWILLS LAW OFFICE 1,912.21 2 PRINCETON, WVAPRYLL H BOGGS LAW FIRM PLLC 1,888.06 7 HURRICANE, WVMARK TIMOTHY KOONTZ 1,877.20 2 WILLIAMSON, WVTHE LAW OFFICE OF JASON STEDMAN 1,877.18 7 MARTINSBURG, WVCLAUDE S SMITH III 1,844.92 3 CHARLESTON, WVAPPALACHIAN LAW PLLC 1,837.80 3 MOUNDSVILLE, WV






CLAIMS* KLIE LAW OFFICES PLLC 1,815.74 4 BUCKHANNON, WV

WISEMAN LAW FIRM PLLC 1,814.55 1 VIENNA, WVWESLEY H WHITE ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 1,757.50 7 GILBERT, WVCHARLES S DRIVER 1,738.08 1 CHARLESTON, WV

* CHELSEA LEGAL LAW OFFICE OF CHELSEA E YATES 1,686.48 5 CHARLESTON, WVPROCTOR LAW OFFICES PLLC 1,644.10 2 HUNTINGTON, WV

* DORWIN J WOLFE LC INC 1,613.40 1 ELKINS, WVDIEHL LAW PLLC 1,604.28 1 MARTINSBURG, WVLAW FIRM OF C JOSEPH STEVENS PLLC 1,602.00 12 HAMLIN, WVLAW OFFICE OF DAYA MASADA WRIGHT PLLC 1,584.81 2 BUCKHANNON, WVJOHN M BUTLER 1,580.50 5 SAINT MARYS, WVMICHAEL WILLIAM LUCAS III 1,466.20 1 CHESTER, WVCOOK & COOK 1,436.50 3 MADISON, WVRUCKMAN LAW OFFICE 1,354.50 1 LEIVASY, WVLANSDEN LAW OFFICE 1,345.44 2 MORGANTOWN, WVLAW OFFICES OF DAVID J SCARPONE 1,318.66 2 STEUBENVILLE, OHFARMER CLINE & CAMPBELL PLLC 1,312.06 6 CHARLESTON, WVDINSMORE & SHOHL LLP 1,297.50 2 CHARLESTON, WVSTEVEN MCKAY WRIGHT 1,288.06 4 HUNTINGTON, WVHEATHER IRELAND MOLESSA 1,220.86 2 WEST UNION, WVRANDAL W ROAHRIG 1,219.16 1 PRINCETON, WVROSLYN C ARTIS 1,186.50 3 MIRAMAR, FLTROZZO LOWERY WESTON & ROCK 1,156.57 1 CUMBERLAND, MDASH & BROOKS PLLC 1,137.64 2 MORGANTOWN, WV

* LAVERNE SWEENEY 1,121.03 2 GRAFTON, WVGINA M RENZELLI 1,112.79 1 BRIDGEPORT, WVDUANE C ROSENLIEB JR 1,111.10 1 SAINT ALBANS, WVJACKSON KELLY PLLC 1,098.54 1 CHARLESTON, WVCARY LAW OFFICE PLLC 1,044.50 6 CHARLESTON, WVRISOVICH LAW OFFICES 1,035.30 4 WEIRTON, WVSHELLY DEMARINO PLLC 1,028.50 2 GLENVILLE, WVHEWITT & SALVATORE PLLC 954.50 3 FAYETTEVILLE, WVLAURA E SPADARO 915.00 1 GLEN JEAN, WVJ M EVANS LAW LLC 897.05 4 GALLIPOLIS, OHADAM B WOLFE 896.00 4 PRINCETON, WVDOOLEY LAW FIRM 876.44 1 CHARLESTON, WVVITAL & VITAL LC 850.60 1 HUNTINGTON, WVXAVIER STAGGS 847.31 2 CHESAPEAKE, OHWOOTON & WOOTON 828.01 4 BECKLEY, WVAMBER URTSO SELLARO 750.50 2 MORGANTOWN, WV

* THOMAS ZIMAROWSKI 743.14 2 MORGANTOWN, WVHAMSTEAD & ASSOCIATES LC 702.46 1 CHARLES TOWN, WVKAREN S HATFIELD 666.99 2 GILBERT, WVGAIN LAW OFFICES 659.82 1 CLARKSBURG, WV

* ANSPACH MEEKS ELLENBERGER LLP 612.50 2 TOLEDO, OHRUSEN & AUVIL PLLC 563.11 1 PARKERSBURG, WVWOOTON WOOTON & DAVIS PLLC 540.00 5 BECKLEY, WVLOSCH & MCCOURT PLLC 538.50 3 SUMMERSVILLE, WVCARRICO LAW OFFICES LC 468.32 1 CHARLESTON, WVJANE MORAN LAW OFFICES 390.50 4 WILLIAMSON, WVLAW OFFICES OF MICHELLE HOOSIER PLLC 386.85 1 CHARLESTON, WVSTEVE HUNTER ASSOCIATES LC 327.00 1 LEWISBURG, WV






CLAIMSTENNANT LAW OFFICES 322.20 1 WHEELING, WVLAMBERT & NEW 261.99 1 GILBERT, WVJOSEPH AUCREMANNE 250.94 1 HINTON, WVMICHAEL SIMMS 218.10 1 MORGANTOWN, WVTHOMAS K PATTERSON A LEGAL CORP 198.50 2 BECKLEY, WVARONSON FINEMAN & DAVIS CO LPA 152.89 1 EAST LIVERPOOL, OHPETER A HENDRICKS 152.50 1 MADISON, WVGREGORY A TUCKER PLLC 127.68 1 SUMMERSVILLE, WVMOUNTAIN STATE JUSTICE INC 100.00 1 CHARLESTON, WVTRIPLETT & TRIPLETT LC 94.00 1 ELKINS, WVHEDGES JONES WHITTIER & HEDGES 92.00 1 SPENCER, WVAPPOINTED COUNSEL TOTALS 24,380,454.58 32,972






CLAIMS

TRI S INVESTIGATIONS INC 176,680.92 294 PARKERSBURG, WVFORENSIC PSYCHOLOGY CENTER INC 140,691.75 62 WINCHESTER, VAFORENSIC PSYCHIATRY PLLC 48,100.00 35 HUNTINGTON, WVJONES DYKSTRA & ASSOCIATES INC 42,440.15 1 COLUMBIA, MDMICHAEL G KESSLER & ASSOCIATES LTD 37,329.96 2 PORT JEFFERSON STATION, NYVAUGHAN INVESTIGATIONS 35,442.68 71 BRADLEY, WVCOOPERS INVESTIGATIVE AGENCY 27,520.19 20 BRIDGEPORT, WVWOODS INVESTIGATIONS 26,713.97 33 BECKLEY, WV

* CABELLS PRIVATE INVESTIGATION 24,439.05 34 CABIN CREEK, WVLARRY A PETERS INC 19,298.93 18 WINCHESTER, VAFRED JAY KRIEG PHD & ASSOCIATES PLLC 18,850.00 12 YEADON, PALANE INVESTIGATIONS LLC 18,435.45 9 GRAYSON, KY

* DANNY LANE INC 18,202.91 6 HUNTINGTON, WV* CAPITOL CITY INVESTIGATIONS LLC 17,813.03 12 CHARLESTON, WV

JURY SERVICE INC 17,050.00 3 ALEXANDRIA, VAEASTERN PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES INC 16,795.00 18 ROMNEY, WV

* INVESTIGATIVE ASSOCIATES INC 16,747.65 43 PARKERSBURG, WVHENDERSHOT PROCESS SERVING & INVESTIGATIONS 16,161.22 24 PARKERSBURG, WV

* JONES INVESTIGATIONS 16,075.50 23 BLUEFIELD, WVTASA GROUP INC 15,981.00 5 BLUE BELL, PAPAUL F KRADEL 15,400.00 4 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WVSPECIAL SECURITY SERVICES LLC 14,506.98 6 BAKER, WVJOSEPH R NOVELLO MD & ASSOCIATES 12,505.00 1 ASHBURN, VASTACY HARLOW LLC 12,160.40 30 PARKERSBURG, WVWOLFE PARALEGAL SERVICES LLC 12,011.50 9 HUNTINGTON, WVGUARDIAN DIGITAL FORENSICS 11,580.15 4 RALEIGH, NCCORNELL INVESTIGATIONS 11,378.33 25 HARRISVILLE, WVMOUNTAIN STATE PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES PLLC 10,550.00 7 KEYSER, WVFREMOUW SIGLEY PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOC PLLC 10,400.00 5 MORGANTOWN, WVESTATE OF ROBERT A DORAN 10,375.33 1 PALATINE, ILSAAR PSYCHOLOGICAL GROUP PLLC 10,025.00 9 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WVJOSEPH S SANFILIPPO 9,470.00 1 GIBSONIA, PACHARLES E BRAMBLE III & ASSOC 9,172.90 2 STONEWOOD, WVUNIVERSITY HEALTH ASSOCIATES 8,100.00 3 MORGANTOWN, WVHERMAN H BECKETT 7,770.27 7 SALT ROCK, WVTRACY P HERRON-RICE 7,607.60 4 MARTINSBURG, WVBRIAN T FERDA INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT 6,918.75 3 WHEELING, WVSELBY & ASSOCIATES PLLC 6,437.50 1 HURRICANE, WVGARY A RINI 6,250.00 1 NORTH OLMSTED, OHWILLIAM H GILLESPIE 6,030.00 2 CHARLESTON, WVCASTO INVESTIGATIONS INC 6,000.00 1 BANCROFT, WVPHILADELPHIA MEDICAL ADVISORS INC 5,766.56 1 BLUE BELL, PAMARY K HURLEY 5,761.40 6 MARTINSBURG, WVINVESTIGATION DIVISION INC 5,602.21 3 VOLGA, WVPETER J CALLAHAN PLLC 5,250.00 7 MARTINSBURG, WVWILLIAM T GAUT 5,075.00 1 NAPLES, FLAMERICAN FIREARMS & MUNITIONS CONSULTING LLC 5,068.50 1 LANSING, MIBEHAVIORAL SCIENCE ASSOCIATES INC 5,058.00 2 WHEELING, WVFRANK J VESEL 5,000.05 6 PARKERSBURG, WVPSYCHOLOGICAL CONSULTING INC 4,900.00 4 MARTINSBURG, WVDAVID J TENNENBAUM PHD & ASSOCIATES 4,520.00 1 COLUMBUS, OH

DIRECT EXPENSES






CLAIMSMCCLELLAND SERVICES 4,442.78 16 SHADY SPRING, WVFORENSIC SCIENCE RESOURCES 4,274.91 1 CARENCRO, LAJOSEPH A JURAND 4,215.80 4 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WVMOBILE SUPPORT INVESTIGATIONS 4,069.53 2 CHARLESTON, WVWILLIAM J WYATT 3,936.57 1 HURRICANE, WVTRI COUNTY PASTORAL COUNSELING SERVICES 3,900.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WV

* STEPHEN MORRISON PRIVATE INVESTIGATIONS 3,736.42 6 HUNTINGTON, WVLAW-SCIENCE TECHNOLOGIES INC 3,731.76 1 WEST MILTON, OHGENETIC TECHNOLOGIES INC 3,568.75 1 GLENCOE, MOPEDIATRIC NEUROLOGY INC 3,500.00 1 ST LOUIS, MOCATHERINE A SLAYDEN 3,016.95 7 MARTINSBURG, WVADVANCED PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES 3,000.00 1 WHEELING, WVCELLMARK FORENSICS INC 3,000.00 1 BURLINGTON, NCROBERT C TOUCHON 2,900.00 1 BARBOURSVILLE, WVNANCY S JARRELL 2,572.60 2 PARKERSBURG, WVCOMMONWEALTH MEDICAL LEGAL SERVICES 2,500.00 1 LOUISVILLE, KYLAUREL RIDGE PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATES 2,500.00 1 PRINCETON, WVWEDGEWOOD FAMILY PRACTICE & PSYCHIATRY ASSOC INC 2,484.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVHEARTLAND FORENSIC PATHOLOGY LLC 2,465.00 2 KANSAS CITY, MOTURNING POINT INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES 2,463.36 3 TORNADO, WVKLM INVESTIGATIONS 2,353.33 5 WILLIAMSTOWN, WVCHARLOTTE M CRANE 2,250.00 1 STEPHENSON, VASUZANNE L ROTOLO 2,100.00 3 LEESBURG, VADEAK INVESTIGATIONS 2,044.14 2 ELLENBORO, WVJEANNE S HALL 2,036.65 2 HUNTINGTON, WVDNA DIAGNOSTICS CENTER INC 2,020.00 1 FAIRFIELD, OHAMANDA R HUNTER 2,008.55 4 HUNTINGTON, WVROBERT D STEWART 1,981.99 6 PINEVILLE, WVROGERSON INVESTIGATIONS LLC 1,974.05 3 WELLSBURG, WVSPECKIN FORENSICS LLC 1,935.00 1 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLRONALD D WOODS 1,898.48 3 MOUNT CLAIRE, WVKL REPORTING 1,797.90 11 HUNTINGTON, WVFAMILY COUNSELING CONNECTION INC 1,700.00 1 CHARLESTON, WVHAMNER PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES 1,687.50 2 BRIDGEPORT, WVTERRI R CHESLOCK 1,607.10 3 FAIRMONT, WVPANHANDLE ACCIDENT RECONSTRUCTION 1,566.22 2 MARTINSBURG, WVCYRIL H WECHT & PATHOLOGY ASSOCIATES INC 1,500.00 1 PITTSBURGH, PAG STANLEY PERRY 1,500.00 1 WHEELING, WVPEACE OF MIND PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES 1,500.00 1 PARKERSBURG, WVMOUNTAIN STATE INVESTIGATIONS 1,467.94 1 LEWISBURG, WVAVM TECHNOLOGY LLC 1,416.67 1 GLEN ALLEN, VAJANETTE M CAMPBELL 1,359.05 2 SUTTON, WVMARY L DUNAWAY 1,301.95 3 FAIRMONT, WVH & S CONTRACTING INC 1,272.00 1 BECKLEY, WVBOB CLAY INVESTIGATIONS 1,267.97 3 REEDSVILLE, WVSWERDLOW FREED PSYCHOLOGY PC 1,250.00 1 FARMINGTON HILLS, MIACCIDENT RECONSTRUCTION CONSULTANTS INC 1,200.00 1 LOUISVILLE, KYBARBARA A IVAUN 1,195.25 2 WEIRTON, WVTHOMAS R ADAMSKI 1,150.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVKENNETH W BLAKE 1,021.74 1 HURRICANE, WVA D A SECURITY INC 1,015.00 1 ADRIAN, MILAWRENCE DOUGLAS HOUCK 1,000.00 2 MARTINSBURG, WV






CLAIMSPSYCHOLOGY ASSOCIATES PLLC 1,000.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVTRI STATE EYE CARE CENTER LTD 1,000.00 1 HUNTINGTON, WVWILLIAM G LUNSFORD 985.00 3 MILTON, WVDILORENZO REPORTING SERVICE LLC 981.75 1 BECKLEY, WVKENTUCKY MEDICAL SERVICES FOUNDATION INC 937.50 1 LEXINGTON, KYMARANATHA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES LLC 908.14 1 DANIELS, WVJOSEPH CITRON 900.00 1 ATLANTA, GAGARRETSON CONSULTING INC 861.06 1 NEW MARKET, VAPANHANDLE PRINTING & DESIGN LLC 824.14 1 MARTINSBURG, WVCLAUDETTE M GAUJOT-TURNER 758.45 4 KEARNEYSVILLE, WVSUSAN ABBEY LLC 750.00 1 DALLAS, TXZEDA MEDICAL LLC 733.33 1 MCLEAN, VAHOLLY A KOCHER 697.85 3 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WVBRAMS & ASSOCIATES INC 687.50 1 COLUMBUS, OHCHRISTINE C WANG 680.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVLYNDE G BAKER 666.05 2 VIENNA, WVCOPS INC 650.00 1 HAGERSTOWN, MDBETLERS REPORTING & LEGAL VIDEO SERVICES LLC 623.92 4 HUNTINGTON, WVCAROL A ASHBURN 604.45 1 BRIDGEPORT, WVROBERT C THOMPSON 600.00 1 FAIRMONT, WVWESTBROOK HEALTH SERVICES INC 561.80 1 SPENCER, WVSHARON L VINCENT 558.25 2 MORGANTOWN, WVSCOTT PATTERSON POLYGRAPH SERVICES 550.00 1 FREDONIA, PAKAREN S STOLLINGS 504.35 2 PINEVILLE, WV3MI PHOTOGRAPHY 500.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WVAILYNN MAE ORTEZA 500.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVAPPLIED DNA RESOURCES 500.00 1 COLUMBUS, OHBRALEY & THOMPSON INC 500.00 1 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WVRONALD D PEARSE ED D 500.00 1 FAIRMONT, WVCLAYMAN & ASSOCIATES PLLC 450.00 1 CHARLESTON, WVJOHN S DANIEL 437.50 1 MIDLOTHIAN, VAHARRY M HATFIELD 386.32 1 MADISON, WVSHAMELLE D KELLEY 385.00 1 CHARLESTON, WVDONNA KAY MILLER-MAIRS 358.08 1 SISSONVILLE, WVJOHN T BERKHOUSE 338.80 1 CROSS LANES, WVCAROL L CHACALOS 296.45 1 WHEELING, WVSHERRY M LAWSON 284.90 1 CHARLESTON, WVJENNIFER J MEADOWS 242.55 1 WEST HAMLIN, WVMICHELE G HANKINS 227.15 2 HUNTINGTON, WVMARCIA L CHANDLER 226.00 1 GREENCASTLE, PAINTL POLYGRAPH SERVICES 200.00 1 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WVLESLIE W HART 169.40 1 ELKINS, WVFISH REPORTING SERVICES 162.45 1 WHEELING, WVMARY J SMITH 146.25 1 KEYSER, WVDAWN SHANNON BLANKENSHIP 142.45 1 MOUNDSVILLE, WVAMANDA J MEADOWS 118.00 2 BECKLEY, WVJULIE L KREEFER 95.00 1 EAST LIVERPOOL, OHNIGH REPORTING SERVICE LLC 46.00 1 HAGERSTOWN, MDDIRECT EXPENSE TOTALS 1,150,313.54 1,073GRAND TOTAL 25,530,768.12 34,045



APPOINTED COUNSEL FEES &

EXPENSES PAID BY PAYEE TOTAL

CLAIMS IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER

* An asterisk denotes those claims which were paid to third parties at the attorneys’ direction



ABRAHAM & ILDERTON PLLC 17,539.57 50 LOGAN, WV* ABRAHAM J SAAD PLLC 135,320.07 277 HUNTINGTON, WV

ADAMS LEGAL GROUP PLLC 9,616.15 19 DELLSLOW, WV* MICHAEL C ALBERTY 41,269.50 30 WHEELING, WV

ALLEN KOPET & ASSOCIATES PLLC 2,784.31 1 HILTON HEAD ISLAND, SC* AMICK LAW FIRM PLLC 29,021.15 59 LEIVASY, WV* JOHN CLARK ANDERSON 83,174.49 155 LEWISBURG, WV

MARY BETH ANGOTTI 6,083.60 8 GRANVILLE, WVANSPACH MEEKS ELLENBERGER LLP 612.50 2 TOLEDO, OHKRISTEN D ANTOLINI 5,607.27 21 MORGANTOWN, WV

* APPALACHIAN LAW PLLC 1,837.80 3 MOUNDSVILLE, WVAPRYLL H BOGGS LAW FIRM PLLC 1,888.06 7 HURRICANE, WV

* DOUGLAS H ARBUCKLE 85,092.45 107 LEWISBURG, WVARNOLD & BAILEY PLLC 39,132.03 66 CHARLES TOWN, WVARONSON FINEMAN & DAVIS CO LPA 152.89 1 EAST LIVERPOOL, OHROSLYN C ARTIS 1,186.50 3 MIRAMAR, FL

* ASBURY LAW OFFICE PLLC 103,545.37 54 CLAY, WV* ASH & BROOKS PLLC 1,137.64 2 MORGANTOWN, WV

ANITA HAROLD ASHLEY 20,030.21 73 SPENCER, WVASHTON & CRAWLEY WOODS PLLC 22,686.91 47 MARTINSBURG, WVATKINS & OGLE LAW OFFICES LC 9,141.35 12 BUFFALO, WVJAMES B ATKINS 17,671.61 15 SCOTT DEPOT, WVATTORNEY CRAWLEY-WOODS 44,928.89 42 MARTINSBURG, WVJOSEPH AUCREMANNE 250.94 1 HINTON, WVAVIS WITTEN & WANDLING LC 3,000.00 1 LOGAN, WV

* BAILESS LAW PLLC 5,178.66 13 CHARLESTON, WVBAILEY & HOWARD PLLC 68,881.16 61 BARBOURSVILLE, WV

* DENNIS R BAILEY 64,106.86 103 CHARLESTON, WVREGGIE R BAILEY 33,182.21 55 PARKERSBURG, WVMARVIN J BAKER 6,859.80 4 CANONSBURG, PAGREGORY K BALL 35,577.94 59 PRINCETON, WVROBERT E BARRAT 14,410.76 21 MARTINSBURG, WVROLF E BAUMGARTEL 22,015.47 58 MARIETTA, OHSHAWN D BAYLISS 142,943.14 91 HURRICANE, WVBEAN & BEAN 20,851.70 40 MOOREFIELD, WVGARTH W BECK 41,370.76 78 CLARKSBURG, WVALLISON KATHLEEN BECKETT 12,131.39 19 BARBOURSVILLE, WV

* SIDNEY H BELL 37,479.61 40 WELCH, WVBELLOMY & TURNER LC 126,184.99 368 HUNTINGTON, WV

* LEE F BENFORD 11,461.47 4 RIPLEY, WVJACQUELYN STOUT BIDDLE 23,738.34 21 HUNTINGTON, WVBISCHOFF LAW FIRM PLLC 117,524.79 104 SUMMERSVILLE, WVBLACKWATER LAW PLLC 73,457.31 107 PARSONS, WV

* JERRY BLAIR 48,051.55 54 CLARKSBURG, WVHOWARD J BLYLER 20,047.40 40 COWEN, WVSHARON N BOGARAD 6,942.50 4 WEIRTON, WV

* SANTE BONINSEGNA JR 12,579.90 21 PINEVILLE, WVBOTTNER & SKILLMAN 26,381.50 39 CHARLES TOWN, WVBOUCHILLON CROSSAN & COLBURN LC 3,641.50 2 HUNTINGTON, WVBOWEN LAW OFFICE PLLC 2,217.09 6 WEST HAMLIN, WVBOWERS & BOWERS PLLC 44,571.35 42 FRANKLIN, WV

APPOINTED COUNSEL

TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS



OFFICE LOCATIONPAYEE



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




* BRADLEY LAW OFFICE PLLC 61,710.33 57 PARKERSBURG, WV* HELEN M BRANCAZIO 19,870.26 42 WEIRTON, WV

BREWER & GIGGENBACH PLLC 20,044.05 29 MORGANTOWN, WVROBERT W BRIGHT 15,031.70 32 MIDDLEPORT, OH

* L SCOTT BRISCOE 135,688.57 193 DANVILLE, WV* JOHN B BROOKS 4,847.03 6 MORGANTOWN, WV

BUCCI BAILEY & JAVINS LC 11,914.25 18 SUMMERSVILLE, WVBUCK & PRENTICE PLLC 41,418.77 21 MARTINSBURG, WVWINIFRED L BUCY 18,859.50 10 BECKLEY, WVBULLMAN & BULLMAN 107,523.79 126 CHARLESTON, WVKRISTINE ADELE BURDETTE 4,232.90 13 FAIRMONT, WV

* BURTON LAW OFFICE 42,662.39 30 MORGANTOWN, WVBUSCH ZURBUCH & THOMPSON PLLC 9,832.38 6 ELKINS, WVJOHN M BUTLER 1,580.50 5 SAINT MARYS, WVJOHN G BYRD 6,058.48 14 PRINCETON, WVCALLAGHAN & CALLAGHAN PLLC 76,244.30 32 SUMMERSVILLE, WVCAMPBELL LAW OFFICES 33,384.43 69 CHARLESTON, WVCARBONE & BLAYDES PLLC 3,258.91 4 CHARLESTON, WV

* CARR LAW OFFICES PLLC 26,446.50 17 SAINT MARYS, WVCARRICO LAW OFFICES LC 468.32 1 CHARLESTON, WVJAMES T CAREY 73,287.76 123 WEIRTON, WVCARTER ZERBE & ASSOCIATES PLLC 2,127.00 7 CHARLESTON, WVCARY LAW OFFICE PLLC 1,044.50 6 CHARLESTON, WVCASSELL & CREWE PC 44,875.89 49 WYTHEVILLE, VACASSELL & PRINZ PLLC 3,476.71 8 CHARLES TOWN, WV

* CASTEEL & ALLENDER PLLC 240,053.78 202 KINGWOOD, WVCHAD D BARRY LC 11,117.50 60 HUNTINGTON, WV

* JOHN K CHASE IV 22,048.67 15 MOUNDSVILLE, WVANDREW B CHATTIN 73,128.45 48 CHARLESTON, WVCHELSEA LEGAL LAW OFFICE OF CHELSEA E YATES 1,686.48 5 CHARLESTON, WVSHARON K CHILDERS 107,068.17 96 CHARLESTON, WV

* CHILDLAW SERVICES INC 111,727.31 103 PRINCETON, WVCICCARELLO DEL GUIDICE & LAFON 46,830.29 25 CHARLESTON, WVCILIBERTI LAW OFFICE PLLC 36,105.58 57 FAYETTEVILLE, WVKATHRYN CISCO-STURGELL 86,676.50 46 WILLIAMSON, WV

* MICHAEL T CLIFFORD 5,129.42 2 CHARLESTON, WVJARRELL L CLIFTON 13,300.00 40 MARLINTON, WVGENTILE DELLA CLINE 4,130.87 7 WILLIAMSON, WVCOLIN M CLINE ATTY AT LAW 14,479.40 17 PRINCETON, WVMICHELLE BROWN-BAILEY COLLEEN 15,409.71 17 BECKLEY, WVCOLLINS LAW FIRM 76,627.93 124 KEYSER, WV

* COLLINS LAW OFFICE PLLC 18,119.03 20 CHARLESTON, WVCONAWAY & CONAWAY 28,182.54 70 MADISON, WV

* CONLEY LAW OFFICE PLLC 132,440.29 217 PARKERSBURG, WV* CONRAD & CONRAD 41,431.36 31 FAYETTEVILLE, WV* CONWAY LAW OFFICE 29,158.30 49 HUNTINGTON, WV

COOK & COOK 1,436.50 3 MADISON, WV* COOK LAW OFFICES PLLC 25,398.04 39 BARBOURSVILLE, WV* MICHAEL P COOKE 178,501.05 384 BLUEFIELD, WV

COOPER & PRESTON PLLC 5,765.20 1 PARSONS, WVCOOPER LAW OFFICES PLLC 9,721.50 3 BRIDGEPORT, WV

* CORNETTE LAW PLLC 91,648.52 77 WESTON, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




* COSNER LAW OFFICE 25,251.01 72 ROMNEY, WVASHLEY N COCHRAN 41,902.17 56 LOGAN, WVCHRISTOPHER W COOPER 22,169.76 20 DAVIS, WVDANIEL S COREY 132,891.00 134 POCA, WVCOURTRIGHT LAW OFFICES PLLC 152,314.45 261 HURRICANE, WVALLISON ADYNIEC COWDEN 17,198.10 6 WEIRTON, WVCRAFT LAW FIRM PLLC 6,961.07 40 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WVA COURTENAY CRAIG 17,682.41 3 HUNTINGTON, WV

* JENNIFER DAY CRANE 43,335.80 69 FAYETTEVILLE, WVBRYAN S CROMLEY 52,173.97 137 POINT PLEASANT, WV

* CURNUTTE LAW OFFICE 10,260.48 15 ELKINS, WVCURRY AMOS & ASSOCIATES LC 55,062.25 92 FAIRMONT, WV

* DASCOLI LAW OFFICE 14,482.50 22 CHARLESTON, WVDAVID A CAMILLETTI ATTORNEY AT LAW LC 12,003.34 8 CHARLES TOWN, WV

* DAVID B RICHARDSON LAW OFFICE 4,360.90 13 WINFIELD, WVDAVID H WILMOTH LC 3,504.25 9 ELKINS, WVDAVIS & CHAPMAN PLLC 17,134.58 15 SUMMERSVILLE, WVDAVIS LAW FIRM 12,348.01 28 CLARKSBURG, WVR STEPHEN DAVIS 27,245.66 10 BEAVER, WV

* DEAN A FURNER ATTY AT LAW PLLC 3,691.00 14 PARKERSBURG, WV* DEAN LAW OFFICES PLLC 38,275.65 64 SAINT ALBANS, WV

DEBRA L STEED PLLC 18,919.66 25 PARKERSBURG, WVDELBY B POOL & ASSOCIATES 3,170.21 3 CLARKSBURG, WV

* DAVID B DEMOSS 44,680.32 89 FAIRMONT, WV* OLIVIA S HARRIS DEVALL 8,379.51 2 KINGWOOD, WV

DIEHL LAW PLLC 1,604.28 1 MARTINSBURG, WV* WELLS H DILLON 122,533.26 167 PARKERSBURG, WV* PETER D DINARDI 25,380.50 26 MORGANTOWN, WV

DINSMORE & SHOHL LLP 1,297.50 2 CHARLESTON, WVSARAH E DIXON 16,835.76 35 HUNTINGTON, WVBRENDAN DONEGHY 2,071.67 6 CHARLESTON, WVDOOLEY LAW FIRM 876.44 1 CHARLESTON, WVDORWIN J WOLFE LC INC 1,613.40 1 ELKINS, WVDOTSENKO LAW OFFICES PLLC 4,966.13 5 CHARLESTON, WVERNEST M DOUGLASS 44,928.19 99 PARKERSBURG, WV

* CHARLES S DRIVER 1,738.08 1 CHARLESTON, WV* KEVIN C DUFFY 22,050.09 9 CLAY, WV

DYER LAW OFFICES 10,569.12 16 CLARKSBURG, WV* E LAVOYD MORGAN JR & ASSOCIATES LC 48,985.96 41 LEWISBURG, WV* MICHAEL N EACHUS 38,457.78 40 GALLIPOLIS, OH

N EDWARD EAGLOSKI 2,863.21 8 HURRICANE, WVELLEM LAW OFFICE 22,739.31 64 PARKERSBURG, WVERIC B ANDERSON PLLC 33,009.46 65 HUNTINGTON, WVERICA BRANNON GUNN ATTY AT LAW PLLC 66,498.02 75 SPENCER, WV

* ESCUE & PRITT LAW OFFICE CO 173,148.12 257 HURRICANE, WVESTATE OF DESIREE LYNNETTE GARNES 27,665.90 44 HUNTINGTON, WV

* ESTATE OF MARSHA DALTON 10,808.41 7 HUNTINGTON, WVF SAMUEL BYRER PLLC 17,954.02 11 CHARLES TOWN, WV

* KRISTOPHER FAERBER 101,282.00 43 LEWISBURG, WVMATTHEW H FAIR 40,651.18 63 ELKINS, WVFARMER CLINE & CAMPBELL PLLC 1,312.06 6 CHARLESTON, WVFARNSWORTH LAW OFFICE 35,072.47 49 PARKERSBURG, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




FAST LAW OFFICE LC 27,003.66 17 FAYETTEVILLE, WVFERRELL LAW OFFICE PLLC 45,549.53 92 WILLIAMSON, WVFITZSIMMONS LAW FIRM PLLC 15,241.77 1 WHEELING, WV

* JONATHAN FITTRO 70,538.21 45 CLARKSBURG, WVW STEPHEN FLESHER 4,904.48 3 HUNTINGTON, WV

* R KEITH FLINCHUM 220,779.13 281 PRINCETON, WVCHARLES CASEY FORBES 39,574.25 63 CHARLESTON, WVFORBES LAW OFFICES PLLC 82,678.84 59 CHARLESTON, WV

* WILLIAM T FORESTER 24,216.73 68 LOGAN, WVPAT C FRAGILE 4,810.00 7 BECKLEY, WVERIC M FRANCIS 21,364.97 14 LEWISBURG, WVFRIEND & ROZAS LLC 8,847.97 13 CUMBERLAND, MD

* MICHAEL E FROBLE 25,705.67 31 BECKLEY, WVFROST BROWN TODD LLC 23,729.21 2 LOUISVILLE, KYJOHN RAY FUNKHOUSER 7,995.89 8 FAIRMONT, WVG TODD HOUCK ATTORNEY AT LAW LC 57,775.95 59 MULLENS, WV

* GAIN LAW OFFICES 659.82 1 CLARKSBURG, WVD CONRAD GALL 13,354.71 40 FAIRMONT, WV

* RICHELLE KEENER GARLOW 26,604.87 56 SAINT ALBANS, WVGARRETT & GARRETT 147,319.46 173 MOOREFIELD, WVGARVIN LAW PLLC 71,518.57 36 NUTTER FORT, WVGEARY & GEARY LC 90,233.97 85 PETERSBURG, WVGENTILOZZI & ASSOCIATES 48,887.87 77 CLARKSBURG, WV

* GERALD G JACOVETTY JR LC 164,639.55 303 WHEELING, WV* JAY W GERBER JR 44,096.96 60 PARKERSBURG, WV

GERLACH LAW 8,859.00 6 WAYNE, WVCHARLENE FOOSE GEYER 5,129.89 1 WHEELING, WVGIANOLA BARNUM WIGAL & LONDON LC 8,824.81 10 MORGANTOWN, WVGIATRAS LAW FIRM PLLC 34,968.15 78 CHARLESTON, WVGIBSON LEFLER & ASSOCIATES 25,221.74 34 PRINCETON, WVMELISSA J GIGGENBACH 10,114.44 2 MORGANTOWN, WVGLASS DEFENSE FIRM 21,029.89 36 CLARKSBURG, WVGOAD LAW FIRM 22,518.12 94 HUNTINGTON, WVGODDARD & WAGONER 15,842.42 2 CLARKSBURG, WVRICHARD M GOLDSTEIN 3,028.00 4 PRINCETON, WVMARGARET A GORDON 26,938.86 9 BERKELEY SPRINGS, WV

* TRACIE L GREENE 99,297.62 111 CHARLESTON, WVGREGORY A TUCKER PLLC 127.68 1 SUMMERSVILLE, WVGREGORY W SPROLES PLLC 10,527.43 25 SUMMERSVILLE, WVGREINER & CYRUS LC 36,444.83 42 HUNTINGTON, WVBETSY GRIFFITH 14,571.33 8 BRIDGEPORT, WV

* DAVID M GRUNAU 50,458.28 61 MORGANTOWN, WVGUNNOE LAW OFFICE 62,093.96 142 HINTON, WV

* DWIGHT R HALL 72,510.44 138 ELKINS, WVKAREN L HALL 5,261.69 4 MORGANTOWN, WVCHARLES R HAMILTON 116,538.12 159 CHARLESTON, WVNEAL J HAMILTON 44,611.17 15 FAIRMONT, WVHAMSTEAD & ASSOCIATES LC 702.46 1 CHARLES TOWN, WVHANCOCK & SEARS 3,225.88 1 RAVENSWOOD, WVHANDLEY & HUNT PLLC 21,129.57 56 POINT PLEASANT, WV

* ROY T HARDY 24,381.14 36 KEYSER, WVMARLA ZELENE HARMAN 49,905.30 43 FRANKLIN, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




HARRIS WILSON TURNER & DAVISSON PLLC 9,207.78 7 CLARKSBURG, WVHARSH LAW LC 32,117.51 28 PARKERSBURG, WVDAVID W HART 16,679.08 46 ELKINS, WV

* HART LAW CENTER 4,590.00 6 WHEELING, WV* HARVEY & JANUTOLO 204,982.63 250 BLUEFIELD, WV

HASSAN LAW OFFICE 126,032.83 105 WELCH, WVHATFIELD & HATFIELD PLLC 40,311.87 41 MADISON, WVKAREN S HATFIELD 666.99 2 GILBERT, WV

* MCGINNIS E HATFIELD 10,437.40 12 GREENSBORO, NCJAMES E HAWKINS JR 113,324.54 186 BUCKHANNON, WVHAYDEN & HART PLLC 93,479.29 135 BECKLEY, WVIRA M HAUGHT 12,201.15 7 HARRISVILLE, WVBELINDA A HAYNIE 33,576.61 52 MORGANTOWN, WVHEDGES JONES WHITTIER & HEDGES 92.00 1 SPENCER, WVHEDGES LYONS & SHEPHERD PLLC 79,450.75 88 MORGANTOWN, WVHENDERSON HENDERSON & STAPLES LC 9,617.50 7 HUNTINGTON, WVPETER A HENDRICKS 152.50 1 MADISON, WVSTEPHEN D HERNDON 23,893.06 8 WHEELING, WV

* HERSHBERGER LAW OFFICE 28,968.56 34 WHEELING, WVHEWITT & SALVATORE PLLC 954.50 3 FAYETTEVILLE, WVDAVID L HILL 16,410.99 60 HURRICANE, WV

* HILL JOHNSON LAW PLLC 120,408.60 133 BELINGTON, WVHILL LAW FIRM PLLC 45,173.91 18 CHARLESTON, WV

* HOLLY W HINERMAN 54,289.02 31 PENTRESS, WVBRYAN S HINKLE 62,980.32 102 BUCKHANNON, WV

* HERBERT L HIVELY 100,649.77 238 CHARLESTON, WVMARK E HOBBS 41,638.68 24 CHAPMANVILLE, WVHODGES & RIFFLE PLLC 6,666.00 8 FAIRMONT, WVJASON D HOLDREN 64,058.54 74 GALLIPOLIS, OH

* RICHARD W HOLLANDSWORTH 37,624.55 45 WHEELING, WV* FRED F HOLROYD 59,911.32 80 CHARLESTON, WV

HOOSIER LAW FIRM PLLC 119,060.34 88 SCOTT DEPOT, WVVIRGINIA JACKSON HOPKINS 4,876.27 3 KINGWOOD, WVLOREN B HOWLEY 7,021.05 17 GRANTSVILLE, WVMARK D HUDNALL 6,050.93 15 SUMMERSVILLE, WVWILLIAM O HUFFMAN 62,263.65 57 PRINCETON, WVKEVIN W HUGHART 176,384.67 168 SISSONVILLE, WVHUNTER LAW OFFICE 16,184.38 31 SCOTT DEPOT, WVHYER & LITTLEPAGE 10,724.58 5 POINT PLEASANT, WVHYLTON LAW OFFICE PLLC 2,371.65 1 BEAVER, WV

* HYRE LAW OFFICE PLLC 9,363.90 11 KINGWOOD, WV* J A M LAW PLLC 26,115.03 35 HARRISVILLE, WV

J M EVANS LAW LLC 897.05 4 GALLIPOLIS, OHJ MINGO WINTERS ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 26,505.50 59 BECKLEY, WVJACKSON KELLY PLLC 1,098.54 1 CHARLESTON, WVJAMES LAW FIRM 17,255.76 39 KEYSER, WV

* JAMES P RILEY IV ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 115,298.89 67 MARTINSBURG, WVJANE MORAN LAW OFFICES 390.50 4 WILLIAMSON, WV

* ROBERT STEPHEN JARRELL 7,247.00 5 MILTON, WVJOHN A CARR ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 12,861.07 12 CHARLESTON, WVJOHN R MITCHELL LC 1,949.20 6 CHARLESTON, WVJOHNSTON HOLROYD & ASSOCIATES 4,541.83 10 PRINCETON, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




JONATHAN G BRILL PLLC 47,568.62 62 ROMNEY, WVROSALEE JUBA-PLUMLEY 33,130.50 29 ELEANOR, WVJUDY & JUDY 25,671.64 60 MOOREFIELD, WV

* JOHN M JURCO 39,134.32 29 ST CLAIRSVILLE, OHDAVID KARICKHOFF 48,200.15 112 SUTTON, WV

* THOMAS B KARR 18,648.17 88 VIENNA, WVKATZ KANTOR STONESTREET & BUCKNER PLLC 42,252.35 63 PRINCETON, WVKAUFMAN & MCPHERSON PLLC 9,191.30 5 BRIDGEPORT, WVKAYSER LAYNE & CLARK PLLC 18,405.65 26 POINT PLEASANT, WVKEATON FRAZER & MILLESON PLLC 44,582.21 150 ROMNEY, WV

* RYAN HAMILTON KEESEE 43,294.54 63 SMOOT, WV* KELLEY LAW OFFICE 52,699.05 35 HUNTINGTON, WV

KENNETH J BARNETT LC 8,964.89 15 SUMMERSVILLE, WVKEPPLE LAW FIRM PA 39,971.96 42 OAKLAND, MDKETTERING DELLIGATTI LAW OFFICES PLLC 22,870.89 45 FAIRMONT, WV

* KEVIN D MILLS & ASSOCIATES PLLC 20,427.63 9 MARTINSBURG, WV* WAYNE KING 43,490.45 25 CLAY, WV* KIRBY GILBERT & ASHLEY LC 2,016.13 6 BECKLEY, WV

TODD A KIRBY 3,420.20 7 BECKLEY, WV* KIRKPATRICK LAW OFFICE PLLC 101,176.24 86 BECKLEY, WV

KITTLE LAW OFFICE PLLC 29,980.31 71 FAIRMONT, WV* KLATT LAW OFFICES PLLC 9,955.16 13 WHEELING, WV

KLIE LAW OFFICES PLLC 1,815.74 4 BUCKHANNON, WVMARK TIMOTHY KOONTZ 1,877.20 2 WILLIAMSON, WVKOURTNEY A RYAN & ASSOCIATES 45,214.50 18 BUCKHANNON, WV

* KRATOVIL LAW OFFICES PLLC 23,589.24 33 CHARLES TOWN, WVKUENZEL & ASSOCIATES PLLC 39,170.37 66 CHAPMANVILLE, WVKUPEC & ASSOCIATES PLLC 15,753.98 5 CLARKSBURG, WVKURELAC LAW OFFICE PLLC 270,120.32 157 MOUNDSVILLE, WVPHILIP A LACARIA 100,057.50 94 WELCH, WVJOHN LAISHLEY 66,099.75 43 HUNTINGTON, WVLAMBERT & NEW 261.99 1 GILBERT, WVJOHN S LANHAM 49,316.98 61 HORNER, WVLANSDEN LAW OFFICE 1,345.44 2 MORGANTOWN, WVLANTZ LAW OFFICE 41,269.52 21 MOUNDSVILLE, WVFRANKLIN W LASH 29,449.40 22 WHEELING, WV

* LAW FIRM OF A JOSEPH MUNOZ 87,362.00 70 PARKERSBURG, WVLAW FIRM OF C JOSEPH STEVENS PLLC 1,602.00 12 HAMLIN, WV

* LAW FIRM OF TERESA C MONK 15,680.42 33 WALTON, WV* LAW OFFICE OF ADAM D TAYLOR INC 19,508.31 45 BECKLEY, WV

LAW OFFICE OF B SCOTT WOLFE PLLC 26,871.67 37 HARRISVILE, WVLAW OFFICE OF BRENT A CLYBURN 121,807.85 102 WHEELING, WVLAW OFFICE OF CHRISTOPHER M WILSON PLLC 33,582.57 68 FAIRMONT, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF COURTNEY L AHLBORN PLLC 121,226.47 242 PARKERSBURG, WV* LAW OFFICE OF DANIEL R GRINDO PLLC 261,370.73 182 GASSAWAY, WV

LAW OFFICE OF DAVID A MASCIO 13,232.18 30 WEIRTON, WV* LAW OFFICE OF DAVID B KELLEY 162,372.85 225 BLUEFIELD, WV

LAW OFFICE OF DAYA MASADA WRIGHT PLLC 1,584.81 2 BUCKHANNON, WVLAW OFFICE OF ERIN SWISSHELM 45,592.52 28 CHARLES TOWN, WVLAW OFFICE OF FRANK P BUSH JR 4,721.40 18 ELKINS, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF HEATHER M WEESE PLLC 4,180.63 9 ELKINS, WVLAW OFFICE OF JAMES C CLEVENGER 60,727.57 66 WESTON, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




LAW OFFICE OF JEFF C WOODS 12,957.60 24 SCOTT DEPOT, WVLAW OFFICE OF JENNA WALKER CREMEANS PLLC 4,127.98 2 BARBOURSVILLE, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF MICHAEL SAFCSAK PLLC 59,950.45 52 FAIRMONT, WVLAW OFFICE OF NEIL ZAHRADNIK PLLC 9,115.29 8 MARTINSBURG, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF NICHOLAS FORREST COLVIN ESQ PLLC 156,559.12 108 HEDGESVILLE, WVLAW OFFICE OF P ZACHARY STEWART 28,890.73 40 WEIRTON, WVLAW OFFICE OF PAMELA R FOLICKMAN 142,648.30 161 FAIRMONT, WV

* LAW OFFICE OF REBECCA S JOHNSON 68,253.86 118 CHARLESTON, WVLAW OFFICE OF ROBBY N LONG LC 64,945.66 104 HAMLIN, WVLAW OFFICE OF ROGER D FORMAN LC 6,711.42 7 BUCKEYE, WVLAW OFFICE OF RUTH A MCQUADE 74,708.78 83 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WVLAW OFFICE OF SETH HARPER PLLC 9,555.21 16 RIPLEY, WVLAW OFFICE OF STEVEN M BRAGG PLLC 26,326.91 69 BARBOURSVILLE, WVLAW OFFICE OF TRAVIS SAYRE 16,231.66 10 PARKERSBURG, WVLAW OFFICE OF TRENA WILLIAMS PLLC 42,242.23 61 WESTON, WV

* LAW OFFICES OF CHRISTINA A MULLIGAN 6,283.05 3 FAIRMONT, WVLAW OFFICES OF CRAIG P ERHARD PLLC 35,209.69 98 FAIRMONT, WVLAW OFFICES OF DAVID J SCARPONE 1,318.66 2 STEUBENVILLE, OH

* LAW OFFICES OF DREAMA D SINKKANEN 37,630.76 40 CLARKSBURG, WV* LAW OFFICES OF EDWARD R KOHOUT PLLC 16,572.24 67 MORGANTOWN, WV

LAW OFFICES OF MICHELLE HOOSIER PLLC 386.85 1 CHARLESTON, WV* LAW OFFICES OF NANNERS & WILLETT LC 231,633.51 276 BUCKHANNON, WV

LAW OFFICES OF RICHARD D SMITH JR 15,432.59 50 PARKERSBURG, WVLAW OFFICES OF VANESSA LYNN RODRIGUEZ 2,174.11 5 FAIRMONT, WVLAWRENCE E SHERMAN JR LC 140,578.26 207 ROMNEY, WV

* LEFLER & BOGGS PLLC 39,074.55 45 BECKLEY, WVLEGAL AID OF WEST VIRGINIA INC 10,958.32 5 CHARLESTON, WV

* LELA WALKER ATTY AT LAW PLLC 53,888.44 108 OCEANA, WV* WILLIAM M LESTER 248,913.27 184 CHARLESTON, WV

LIVINGOOD LAW PLLC 35,049.96 44 BUCKHANNON, WVLOCKWOOD & LOCKWOOD 10,917.00 34 HUNTINGTON, WV

* JAMELLA L LOCKWOOD 77,139.18 107 BUCKHANNON, WVLONG LAW OFFICES PLLC 40,401.60 71 SCOTT DEPOT, WVJASON S LORD 85,717.44 79 CHARLESTON, WVLOSCH & MCCOURT PLLC 538.50 3 SUMMERSVILLE, WVROBIN R LOUDERBACK 6,178.50 6 CHARLESTON, WVJAY CARTER LOVE 15,120.50 144 HUNTINGTON, WVMICHAEL WILLIAM LUCAS III 1,466.20 1 CHESTER, WV

* LUPARDUS LAW OFFICE 115,353.81 192 PINEVILLE, WVKYLE G LUSK 13,750.50 26 BECKLEY, WVLUTTRELL & PREZIOSO PLLC 58,733.76 32 MARTINSBURG, WVJERRY M LYALL 51,426.42 78 WILLIAMSON, WVMAGANN LAW OFFICE PLLC 79,095.52 177 BLUEFIELD, WV

* MAIER LAW OFFICE LLC 62,972.59 74 HINTON, WVMANYPENNY RAINES LAW OFFICE PLLC 40,072.35 62 CHESTER, WV

* MARK EVERETT ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 62,787.60 102 MORGANTOWN, WVMARSH LAW OFFICE PLLC 15,261.30 28 CHARLESTON, WVGARY J MARTINO 16,955.50 38 FAIRMONT, WVMATTHEW F GRAVES PLLC 6,621.51 11 ST MARYS, WVBERNARD R MAUSER 23,857.15 47 SUTTON, WVMAX H WHITE PLLC 38,789.03 151 KEYSER, WV

* NICHOLAS MAYO 8,267.14 12 HUNTINGTON, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




LESLIE L MAZE 5,471.60 4 ELIZABETH, WV* ROCCO E MAZZEI 104,456.85 86 CLARKSBURG, WV

MCCAMIC SACCO & MCCOID PLLC 10,843.38 3 WHEELING, WVJAMES A MCCOY 52,139.64 47 HAMLIN, WV

* DANA P MCDERMOTT 25,855.51 3 MARTINSBURG, WV* C EDWARD MCDONOUGH 45,724.42 81 PARKERSBURG, WV

JOSEPH W MCFARLAND 76,806.54 139 WELLINGTON, FLMCGEELAW 27,559.82 33 CHARLESTON, WV

* NANCY L MCGHEE 5,934.54 26 MINERAL WELLS, WVMCGRAW LAW OFFICES 42,847.11 18 PROSPERITY, WV

* RHONDA M MCINTYRE 6,840.34 10 MORGANTOWN, WVRACHELLE D MCINTYRE-NICHOLSON 3,258.79 3 CLARKSBURG, WVMCNEER HIGHLAND MCMUNN & VARNER LC 68,645.48 76 CLARKSBURG, WVMESLER LAW OFFICES 3,426.90 5 WEIRTON, WVREBECCA E MICK 45,384.49 58 CHARLESTON, WVWAYNE ROBERT MIELKE 32,776.00 16 WELLSBURG, WV

* CHRISTOPHER H MILLER 57,580.12 64 MORGANTOWN, WVMIZE LAW FIRM PLLC 33,373.67 18 BECKLEY, WV

* CHRISTOPHER G MOFFATT 217,374.85 128 CHARLESTON, WVHEATHER IRELAND MOLESSA 1,220.86 2 WEST UNION, WVDAVID K MOORE 40,285.05 36 RIPLEY, WVDAVID K MOORE 2,894.83 7 RIPLEY, WVMOORE LAW FIRM PLLC 8,788.35 13 FRANKLIN, WVCHRISTOPHER S MOOREHEAD 24,591.84 41 FAYETTEVILLE, WVDAMON B MORGAN 24,923.28 97 POINT PLEASANT, WV

* DENNIE S MORGAN 3,048.50 4 BECKLEY, WVWARD MORGAN 67,996.36 72 BLUEFIELD, WVTONY MORGAN 37,870.70 58 GRANTSVILLE, WV

* MORELLI LAW 25,136.42 34 WEIRTON, WVJOYCE H MORTON 25,013.14 29 WEBSTER SPRINGS, WVJOSEPH J MOSES 190,504.37 58 WHEELING, WV

* JOSEPH MOSKO 3,608.00 8 PROSPERITY, WVMOUNTAIN STATE JUSTICE INC 100.00 1 CHARLESTON, WV

* MOUNTAINEER LEGAL SERVICES PLLC 171,027.35 302 GRAFTON, WVMOYE LAW OFFICE 19,311.95 45 WINFIELD, WVLISA M MOYE 3,516.75 5 WINFIELD, WV

* MULLENS & MULLENS PLLC 105,334.23 160 PHILIPPI, WVJESSICA E MYERS 21,435.50 25 PARKERSBURG, WV

* NANCY A DALBY ATTY AT LAW PLLC 80,056.22 29 CHARLES TOWN, WVNEELY & CALLAGHAN 14,546.84 26 CHARLESTON, WV

* NEISWONGER & WHITE 110,873.90 251 MOUNDSVILLE, WVNELSON LEGAL SERVICES LC 17,494.15 36 PETERSBURG, WVNELSON M MICHAEL LC 60,399.24 161 KEYSER, WV

* NESSEL LAW FIRM 46,665.56 42 HUNTINGTON, WV* WILLIAM C NOEL 26,558.01 31 MORGANTOWN, WV

CATHRYN A NOGAY 50,574.95 24 WEIRTON, WV* NOLAN LAW FIRM 101,456.22 256 HUNTINGTON, WV

ROBERT T NOONE 114,286.41 46 GADSDEN, AL* JEROME R NOVOBILSKI 14,747.74 46 CLAY, WV

NUTTALL LEGAL LLC 28,615.34 41 BUCKHANNON, WVCANDACE L OGLE 15,949.50 112 MORGANTOWN, WVOLCOTT LAW OFFICE 3,807.78 11 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




* ORNDORFF & HATFIELD ATTY AT LAW 17,310.09 23 BARBOURSVILLE, WVDAVID L ORNDORFF 33,490.46 33 BUCKHANNON, WVAILYNN MAE ORTEZA 18,150.04 8 MORGANTOWN, WV

* F JOHN OSHOWAY 73,699.47 103 GRANTSVILLE, WVJOHN G OURS 30,727.87 53 PETERSBURG, WVMARK D PANEPINTO 72,752.65 23 WHEELING, WV

* JOHN F PARKULO 25,010.00 25 DANIELS, WVPARTAIN LAW OFFICE 55,565.18 63 LOGAN, WV

* PARTEE & ASSOCIATES PLLC 7,733.47 16 MORGANTOWN, WVPAUL WILLIAMS ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 8,841.74 22 SUMMERSVILLE, WVPAULA L HARBOUR PLLC 6,712.78 8 HUNTINGTON, WV

* WILBERT A PAYNE 27,064.30 63 BECKLEY, WVMARK P PELLEGRIN 18,841.50 44 MORGANTOWN, WVDEANNA L PENNINGTON 12,353.50 27 MORGANTOWN, WVWILLIAM L PENNINGTON 36,702.84 60 MORGANTOWN, WVP TODD PHILLIPS 61,583.00 37 MORGANTOWN, WV

* ANDREA P POWELL 3,762.50 7 PRINCETON, WVERIC K POWELL 102,541.25 181 PARKERSBURG, WVPOWER BECK & MATZUREFF 4,624.22 1 MARTINSBURG, WVTHOMAS J PRALL 41,600.73 115 WESTON, WVLENA D PRATT 25,431.60 31 LOGAN, WVTIMOTHY H PRENTICE 82,698.95 145 ELKINS, WVSILAS M PRESTON 33,888.33 14 LEWISBURG, WVDONNA M PRICE 2,473.87 5 MARLINTON, WV

* LOUIE T PRICE 46,072.01 14 CHARLESTON, WV* PRITT & PRITT PLLC 45,632.00 95 CHARLESTON, WV* ALAN L PRITT 66,249.50 86 CHARLESTON, WV* PROCTOR LAW OFFICES PLLC 1,644.10 2 HUNTINGTON, WV

PULLIN FOWLER FLANAGAN BROWN & POE PLLC 66,683.03 248 CHARLESTON, WVALVIE E QUALLS 2,071.44 9 HUNTINGTON, WV

* R STEVEN REDDING ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 108,034.28 50 MARTINSBURG, WVSCOTT S RADMAN 8,494.50 40 MORGANTOWN, WVRAHBAR LAW OFFICE 2,501.10 1 WHEELING, WV

* RAY LAW PLLC 13,894.69 19 MORGANTOWN, WV* EDWARD REBROOK III 100,324.96 152 CHARLESTON, WV* JAMES B REES 52,533.70 59 FAYETTEVILLE, WV* REDMAN & PAYNE 23,473.45 4 CHARLESTON, WV

REGINALD D HENRY ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 9,708.50 15 BECKLEY, WVGINA M RENZELLI 1,112.79 1 BRIDGEPORT, WV

* KATICA RIBEL 39,116.86 88 FAIRMONT, WVWILLIAM T RICE 92,686.53 54 MARTINSBURG, WVRICHARDSON RICHARDSON & CAMPBELL 24,934.10 67 PARKERSBURG, WVRICHARD M RIFFE 11,127.72 6 ALUM CREEK, WVDARRELL W RINGER 3,426.16 1 MORGANTOWN, WVRISOVICH LAW OFFICES 1,035.30 4 WEIRTON, WVRIST LAW OFFICES LC 47,670.01 83 FAYETTEVILLE, WVRANDAL W ROAHRIG 1,219.16 1 PRINCETON, WVROBERT C STONE JR PLLC 16,464.39 8 MARTINSBURG, WVROBERT DUNLAP ESQ PLLC 22,848.63 52 BECKLEY, WVROBINSON & MCELWEE 39,952.19 11 CHARLESTON, WV

* JEFFREY S RODGERS 92,463.38 165 LEWISBURG, WVRODRIGUEZ LAW OFFICE 17,339.60 30 MORGANTOWN, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




FREDERICK M DEAN ROHRIG 2,308.47 3 MIDDLEBOURNE, WVROKISKY & ASSOCIATES 11,965.64 3 WEIRTON, WVWILLIAM DANIEL ROLL 4,960.20 2 POINT PLEASANT, WVEDMUND J ROLLO 8,316.50 10 MORGANTOWN, WVLANCE E ROLLO 38,441.12 57 MORGANTOWN, WV

* JULIE GOWER ROMAIN 4,861.40 12 FAIRMONT, WV* RONALD G SALMONS ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 2,742.50 4 WEST HAMLIN, WV

ROOP & SMITH LAW OFFICE PLLC 22,225.00 11 BECKLEY, WVROSE PADDEN & PETTY LC 19,193.41 35 FAIRMONT, WVDUANE C ROSENLIEB JR 1,111.10 1 SAINT ALBANS, WVROSINSKY LAW OFFICE 70,311.57 26 HUNTINGTON, WVROSINSKY LAW OFFICE LC 50,572.73 21 HUNTINGTON, WVROTH LEGAL SERVICES LC 2,723.76 9 PETERSBURG, WVRUCKMAN LAW OFFICE 1,354.50 1 LEIVASY, WV

* RUMORA & RUMORA LC 20,068.06 48 WILLIAMSON, WVJULIET WALKER RUNDLE 15,648.32 8 PINEVILLE, WVRUSEN & AUVIL PLLC 563.11 1 PARKERSBURG, WVRUTH LAW OFFICES PLLC 228,420.98 218 CHARLESTON, WV

* S SEAN MURPHY PLLC 19,780.72 46 MORGANTOWN, WVMARTIN V SAFFER 55,312.50 35 MARLINTON, WV

* SAL SELLARO THORN CULPEPPER LEGAL GROUP PLLC 226,975.00 421 MORGANTOWN, WVSALMONS & BOWEN ATTORNEYS AT LAW PLLC 57,572.49 152 WEST HAMLIN, WVSALUJA LAW OFFICES PLLC 8,061.00 20 NITRO, WVSAMMONS OLIVERO & PARASCHOS PLLC 14,226.41 6 HUNTINGTON, WVSANDERS AUSTIN FLANIGAN & FLANIGAN 63,649.14 58 PRINCETON, WVSANTER & SANTER 26,690.93 73 PARKERSBURG, WVROYCE B SAVILLE PLLC 33,775.08 140 ROMNEY, WVSCALES LAW OFFICE 103,121.04 56 MARTINSBURG, WV

* SCHAMBERGER LEGAL SERVICES 40,939.96 50 CLAY, WVWILLIAM H SCHARF 5,991.13 5 CHARLESTON, WV

* CHRISTOPHER A SCHEETZ 46,414.43 54 FOLLANSBEE, WVSCOTT C BROWN LAW OFFICE 7,426.08 3 WHEELING, WVSEAN LOGUE PLLC 9,655.01 20 PITTSBURGH, PASELDEN LAW OFFICES LC 39,859.78 28 BECKLEY, WV

* AMBER URTSO SELLARO 750.50 2 MORGANTOWN, WVSHAFER LAW OFFICES 40,945.78 21 WHEELING, WVSHAFFER & SHAFFER 40,914.24 57 MADISON, WVWHITNEY MESHELL SHAFFER 12,792.00 27 CHARLESTON, WVMICHAEL J SHAHEEN 5,673.86 8 ST CLAIRSVILLE, OHSHANE M MALLETT LAW OFFICES 17,517.60 36 WHEELING, WV

* SHANNON L BALDWIN ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 3,379.23 5 BLUEFIELD, WVMICHAEL J SHARLEY 8,027.00 14 WESTOVER, WVSHAW & SHAW LC 98,918.49 187 POINT PLEASANT, WVSHELLY DEMARINO PLLC 1,028.50 2 GLENVILLE, WVJAMES B SHOCKLEY 25,532.31 36 MORGANTOWN, WV

* SCOTT A SHOUGH 78,373.18 123 FAIRMONT, WVJ BRANDON SHUMAKER 12,662.35 17 MORGANTOWN, WV

* ANDREW R SHUMATE 4,352.05 16 CHARLESTON, WV* SIKORA SNEAD PLLC 12,234.66 12 MORGANTOWN, WV

SIMMONS & SIMMONS LC 46,390.94 48 ELIZABETH, WV* HUNTER D SIMMONS 74,204.34 248 BUCKHANNON, WV

MICHAEL SIMMS 218.10 1 MORGANTOWN, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




* TIMOTHY M SIRK 25,280.98 39 KEYSER, WVSITES LAW FIRM 15,346.84 46 KEYSER, WVG ERNEST SKAGGS 255,558.99 135 FAYETTEVILLE, WVSKLAVOUNAKIS LAW OFFICE 15,065.66 14 WHEELING, WVCLINTON W SMITH 29,606.72 140 CHARLESTON, WVCOURTLANDT SMITH 4,461.61 9 CHARLESTON, WVSMITH LILLY & BALL PLLC 16,154.94 6 PRINCETON, WVSMITH MCMUNN & GLOVER PLLC 10,663.14 16 CLARKSBURG, WVSARAH SMITH 25,244.76 30 MEADOW BRIDGE, WVCLAUDE S SMITH III 1,844.92 3 CHARLESTON, WVSNYDER & HASSIG 22,448.50 19 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WVALEXANDRIA A SOLOMON 10,997.78 10 DAVIS, WVMELISHA D SOUDERS 13,936.33 6 HANCOCK, MD

* SOUTHERN WV LAW CLINIC 75,650.21 122 BECKLEY, WVLAURA E SPADARO 915.00 1 GLEN JEAN, WV

* ANTHONY J SPARACINO JR 5,074.00 4 BECKLEY, WV* SPENIA LAW OFFICE PLLC 65,171.63 82 BARBOURSVILLE, WV

SPILMAN THOMAS & BATTLE PLLC 19,126.12 11 CHARLESTON, WVJAMES E SPURLOCK 2,597.70 2 HUNTINGTON, WVXAVIER STAGGS 847.31 2 CHESAPEAKE, OH

* CHARLES E STALNAKER 22,157.77 61 PARKERSBURG, WVGEORGE P STANTON 2,755.00 6 FAIRMONT, WVSTARCHER & FRUM PLLC 115,642.16 166 PARKERSBURG, WVSHIRLEY J STANTON 7,112.08 10 FAIRMONT, WV

* STEPHEN P NEW LC 25,238.15 10 BECKLEY, WVGLORIA M STEPHENS 53,953.07 64 WELCH, WVRICHARD D STEPHENS 38,710.88 61 MARTINSBURG, WVSTEPTOE & JOHNSON 16,201.68 13 BRIDGEPORT, WVSTEVE HUNTER ASSOCIATES LC 327.00 1 LEWISBURG, WVSTEVEN A GREENBAUM ESQ ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 67,535.33 79 MARTINSBURG, WVJOYCE E STEWART 42,326.02 48 MOOREFIELD, WV

* R RUSSELL STOBBS 14,928.35 30 WESTON, WVHARLEY E STOLLINGS 8,840.07 15 SUMMERSVILLE, WV

* HEIDI M GEORGI STURM 60,981.03 71 FAIRMONT, WV* WILLIAM B SUMMERS 145,329.03 445 PARKERSBURG, WV

SUPPLE LAW OFFICES PLLC 8,560.56 24 POINT PLEASANT, WVSUSAN J VAN ZANT LC 14,167.29 22 WILLIAMSON, WVSUTTON & JANELLE PLLC 3,459.85 5 MARTINSBURG, WVLAVERNE SWEENEY 1,121.03 2 GRAFTON, WVREBECCA TATE 11,614.51 47 FAIRMONT, WVJENNIFER N TAYLOR 5,388.40 17 CHARLESTON, WVPAUL G TAYLOR 43,992.21 52 MARTINSBURG, WVTENNANT LAW OFFICES 322.20 1 WHEELING, WVTHARP LIOTTA & YOKUM LLP 10,021.70 18 FAIRMONT, WVTHE LAW OFFICE OF JASON STEDMAN 1,877.18 7 MARTINSBURG, WV

* THOMAS HANNA EVANS PLLC 124,552.43 115 OCEANA, WVTHOMAS K PATTERSON A LEGAL CORP 198.50 2 BECKLEY, WV

* THOMAS L FUDA PLLC 90,038.80 143 PRINCETON, WVTHOMAS R CZARNIK & ASSOCIATES 44,034.13 63 PRINCETON, WVSHANNON R THOMAS 8,395.00 1 WESTON, WVTHOMPSON & PARDO PLLC 47,140.81 38 CHARLES TOWN, WVTHOMPSON BARNEY 3,357.94 1 CHARLESTON, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




JOHN M THOMPSON 90,143.60 123 OAK HILL, WV* THOMPSON LAW OFFICE PLLC 11,745.50 16 WILLIAMSON, WV

STEVEN M THORNE 41,864.05 86 LOGAN, WVTICHENOR LAW OFFICE 57,699.69 109 FAIRMONT, WVTIPTON LAW OFFICES 38,643.60 67 FAIRMONT, WVPHILIP J TISSUE 5,279.91 9 OAK HILL, WVGEORGE M TORRES 40,892.85 73 PARKERSBURG, WV

* JOHN H TREADWAY JR 16,349.36 24 MOOREFIELD, WVTRIPLETT & TRIPLETT LC 94.00 1 ELKINS, WVJOSEPH G TROISI 89,463.00 122 SAINT MARYS, WVTROZZO LOWERY WESTON & ROCK 1,156.57 1 CUMBERLAND, MDTURNER & JOHNS PLLC 4,471.84 10 CHARLESTON, WVTYREE EMBREE & ASSOCIATES PLLC 23,714.98 57 HURRICANE, WV

* DAVID R TYSON 58,962.31 113 HUNTINGTON, WV* NAVY L VICTOR 71,625.19 103 BARBOURSVILLE, WV* VICTOR VICTOR & HELGOE LLP 242,690.13 262 CHARLESTON, WV

VITAL & VITAL LC 850.60 1 HUNTINGTON, WVRICHARD L VITAL 15,360.28 16 BARBOURSVILLE, WVMAGGIE K WALL 7,508.29 14 SCOTT DEPOT, WV

* RANDALL D WALL 73,432.00 493 HUNTINGTON, WVMICHAEL K WALLACE 39,519.66 60 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WVWALTERS & KRAUSKOPF 30,621.47 57 MOOREFIELD, WV

* CHERYL L WARMAN 42,661.60 78 MORGANTOWN, WV* MARSHA WEBB-RUMORA 38,521.31 83 WILLIAMSON, WV

WEBER & WEBER 2,735.04 3 WESTON, WVROGER R WEESE 11,284.50 11 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WV

* TRACY WEESE 47,921.75 11 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WVWESLEY H WHITE ATTORNEY AT LAW PLLC 1,757.50 7 GILBERT, WVCHARLES STANFORD WEST 1,924.50 3 WILLIAMSON, WVSTEPHEN BROOKS WEST 6,895.50 10 CHARLESTON, WVWESTON LAW A LEGAL CORP 32,768.35 20 HUNTINGTON, WV

* WHEELER LAW FIRM 10,836.19 21 SCOTT DEPOT, WV* KEITH WHITE 115,381.94 218 SAINT MARYS, WV

THOMAS E WHITE 25,147.50 57 MOUNDSVILLE, WVWHITEMAN BURDETTE PLLC 146,480.97 295 FAIRMONT, WVFRANCES C WHITEMAN 64,833.90 102 FAIRMONT, WV

* MICHAEL R WHITT 116,180.73 40 LEWISBURG, WV* DIANA CARTER WIEDEL 116,062.66 73 WILLIAMSON, WV* ERIC KEITH WILDMAN 24,324.20 57 FAIRMONT, WV

WILLIAM T NESTOR PLLC 58,026.96 119 ELKINS, WVJOHN E WILLIAMS JR 90,339.16 137 PRINCETON, WVWILLS LAW OFFICE 1,912.21 2 PRINCETON, WV

* WILSON LAW OFFICE 15,519.23 70 KEYSER, WVRODNEY C WINDOM 123,919.05 127 HARRISVILLE, WVKURT J WINTER 32,232.10 111 BURGETTSTOWN, PAWISEMAN LAW FIRM PLLC 1,814.55 1 VIENNA, WV

* RICHARD C WITT 12,701.00 24 POCO, WVWLO MANAGEMENT LLC 7,096.95 13 HUNTINGTON, WVADAM B WOLFE 896.00 4 PRINCETON, WVHAROLD B WOLFE III 5,050.66 2 PRINCETON, WV

* JEREMY B WOLFE 12,653.91 26 PARKERSBURG, WVWOLFE LAW OFFICE PLLC 38,438.96 101 LOGAN, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




JOHN WOODS 24,906.50 35 BELLEVILLE, WVWOOTON & WOOTON 828.01 4 BECKLEY, WVWOOTON LAW FIRM 1,971.12 4 BECKLEY, WVWOOTON WOOTON & DAVIS PLLC 540.00 5 BECKLEY, WVLACY W WRIGHT 6,633.36 26 WELCH, WVSTEVEN MCKAY WRIGHT 1,288.06 4 HUNTINGTON, WV

* YANNI LAW FIRM 8,851.95 29 MARTINSBURG, WVBRIAN D YOST 24,001.10 32 HURRICANE, WV

* WILLIAM PRENTICE YOUNG 115,110.24 23 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WVC CHRISTOPHER YOUNGER 7,634.50 4 WILLIAMSON, WVTHOMAS ZIMAROWSKI 743.14 2 MORGANTOWN, WVAPPOINTED COUNSEL TOTALS 24,380,454.58 32,972



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




3MI PHOTOGRAPHY 500.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WVA D A SECURITY INC 1,015.00 1 ADRIAN, MIACCIDENT RECONSTRUCTION CONSULTANTS INC 1,200.00 1 LOUISVILLE, KYTHOMAS R ADAMSKI 1,150.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVADVANCED PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES 3,000.00 1 WHEELING, WVAMERICAN FIREARMS & MUNITIONS CONSULTING LLC 5,068.50 1 LANSING, MIAPPLIED DNA RESOURCES 500.00 1 COLUMBUS, OHCAROL A ASHBURN 604.45 1 BRIDGEPORT, WVAVM TECHNOLOGY LLC 1,416.67 1 GLEN ALLEN, VALYNDE G BAKER 666.05 2 VIENNA, WVHERMAN H BECKETT 7,770.27 7 SALT ROCK, WVBEHAVIORAL SCIENCE ASSOCIATES INC 5,058.00 2 WHEELING, WVJOHN T BERKHOUSE 338.80 1 CROSS LANES, WVBETLERS REPORTING & LEGAL VIDEO SERVICES LLC 623.92 4 HUNTINGTON, WVKENNETH W BLAKE 1,021.74 1 HURRICANE, WVBOB CLAY INVESTIGATIONS 1,267.97 3 REEDSVILLE, WVBRALEY & THOMPSON INC 500.00 1 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WVBRAMS & ASSOCIATES INC 687.50 1 COLUMBUS, OHBRIAN T FERDA INVESTIGATIVE CONSULTANT 6,918.75 3 WHEELING, WV

* CABELLS PRIVATE INVESTIGATION 24,439.05 34 CABIN CREEK, WVJANETTE M CAMPBELL 1,359.05 2 SUTTON, WV

* CAPITOL CITY INVESTIGATIONS LLC 17,813.03 12 CHARLESTON, WVCASTO INVESTIGATIONS INC 6,000.00 1 BANCROFT, WVCELLMARK FORENSICS INC 3,000.00 1 BURLINGTON, NCCAROL L CHACALOS 296.45 1 WHEELING, WVMARCIA L CHANDLER 226.00 1 GREENCASTLE, PACHARLES E BRAMBLE III & ASSOC 9,172.90 2 STONEWOOD, WVTERRI R CHESLOCK 1,607.10 3 FAIRMONT, WVJOSEPH CITRON 900.00 1 ATLANTA, GACLAYMAN & ASSOCIATES PLLC 450.00 1 CHARLESTON, WVCOMMONWEALTH MEDICAL LEGAL SERVICES 2,500.00 1 LOUISVILLE, KYCOOPERS INVESTIGATIVE AGENCY 27,520.19 20 BRIDGEPORT, WVCOPS INC 650.00 1 HAGERSTOWN, MDCORNELL INVESTIGATIONS 11,378.33 25 HARRISVILLE, WVCHARLOTTE M CRANE 2,250.00 1 STEPHENSON, VACYRIL H WECHT & PATHOLOGY ASSOCIATES INC 1,500.00 1 PITTSBURGH, PAJOHN S DANIEL 437.50 1 MIDLOTHIAN, VA

* DANNY LANE INC 18,202.91 6 HUNTINGTON, WVDAVID J TENNENBAUM PHD & ASSOCIATES 4,520.00 1 COLUMBUS, OHDAWN SHANNON BLANKENSHIP 142.45 1 MOUNDSVILLE, WVDEAK INVESTIGATIONS 2,044.14 2 ELLENBORO, WVDILORENZO REPORTING SERVICE LLC 981.75 1 BECKLEY, WVDNA DIAGNOSTICS CENTER INC 2,020.00 1 FAIRFIELD, OHMARY L DUNAWAY 1,301.95 3 FAIRMONT, WVEASTERN PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES INC 16,795.00 18 ROMNEY, WVESTATE OF ROBERT A DORAN 10,375.33 1 PALATINE, ILFAMILY COUNSELING CONNECTION INC 1,700.00 1 CHARLESTON, WVFISH REPORTING SERVICES 162.45 1 WHEELING, WVFORENSIC PSYCHIATRY PLLC 48,100.00 35 HUNTINGTON, WVFORENSIC PSYCHOLOGY CENTER INC 140,691.75 62 WINCHESTER, VAFORENSIC SCIENCE RESOURCES 4,274.91 1 CARENCRO, LA

DIRECT EXPENSES



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




FRED JAY KRIEG PHD & ASSOCIATES PLLC 18,850.00 12 YEADON, PAFREMOUW SIGLEY PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOC PLLC 10,400.00 5 MORGANTOWN, WVGARRETSON CONSULTING INC 861.06 1 NEW MARKET, VACLAUDETTE M GAUJOT-TURNER 758.45 4 KEARNEYSVILLE, WVWILLIAM T GAUT 5,075.00 1 NAPLES, FLGENETIC TECHNOLOGIES INC 3,568.75 1 GLENCOE, MOWILLIAM H GILLESPIE 6,030.00 2 CHARLESTON, WVGUARDIAN DIGITAL FORENSICS 11,580.15 4 RALEIGH, NCH & S CONTRACTING INC 1,272.00 1 BECKLEY, WVJEANNE S HALL 2,036.65 2 HUNTINGTON, WVHAMNER PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES 1,687.50 2 BRIDGEPORT, WVMICHELE G HANKINS 227.15 2 HUNTINGTON, WVLESLIE W HART 169.40 1 ELKINS, WVHARRY M HATFIELD 386.32 1 MADISON, WVHEARTLAND FORENSIC PATHOLOGY LLC 2,465.00 2 KANSAS CITY, MOHENDERSHOT PROCESS SERVING & INVESTIGATIONS 16,161.22 24 PARKERSBURG, WVTRACY P HERRON-RICE 7,607.60 4 MARTINSBURG, WVLAWRENCE DOUGLAS HOUCK 1,000.00 2 MARTINSBURG, WVAMANDA R HUNTER 2,008.55 4 HUNTINGTON, WVMARY K HURLEY 5,761.40 6 MARTINSBURG, WVINTL POLYGRAPH SERVICES 200.00 1 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WVINVESTIGATION DIVISION INC 5,602.21 3 VOLGA, WV

* INVESTIGATIVE ASSOCIATES INC 16,747.65 43 PARKERSBURG, WVBARBARA A IVAUN 1,195.25 2 WEIRTON, WVNANCY S JARRELL 2,572.60 2 PARKERSBURG, WVJONES DYKSTRA & ASSOCIATES INC 42,440.15 1 COLUMBIA, MD

* JONES INVESTIGATIONS 16,075.50 23 BLUEFIELD, WVJOSEPH R NOVELLO MD & ASSOCIATES 12,505.00 1 ASHBURN, VAJOSEPH A JURAND 4,215.80 4 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WVJURY SERVICE INC 17,050.00 3 ALEXANDRIA, VASHAMELLE D KELLEY 385.00 1 CHARLESTON, WVKENTUCKY MEDICAL SERVICES FOUNDATION INC 937.50 1 LEXINGTON, KYKL REPORTING 1,797.90 11 HUNTINGTON, WVKLM INVESTIGATIONS 2,353.33 5 WILLIAMSTOWN, WVHOLLY A KOCHER 697.85 3 NEW MARTINSVILLE, WVPAUL F KRADEL 15,400.00 4 SHEPHERDSTOWN, WVJULIE L KREEFER 95.00 1 EAST LIVERPOOL, OHLANE INVESTIGATIONS LLC 18,435.45 9 GRAYSON, KYLARRY A PETERS INC 19,298.93 18 WINCHESTER, VALAUREL RIDGE PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATES 2,500.00 1 PRINCETON, WVLAW-SCIENCE TECHNOLOGIES INC 3,731.76 1 WEST MILTON, OHSHERRY M LAWSON 284.90 1 CHARLESTON, WVWILLIAM G LUNSFORD 985.00 3 MILTON, WVMARANATHA PROFESSIONAL SERVICES LLC 908.14 1 DANIELS, WVAMANDA J MEADOWS 118.00 2 BECKLEY, WVJENNIFER J MEADOWS 242.55 1 WEST HAMLIN, WVMCCLELLAND SERVICES 4,442.78 16 SHADY SPRING, WVMICHAEL G KESSLER & ASSOCIATES LTD 37,329.96 2 PORT JEFFERSON STATION, NYDONNA KAY MILLER-MAIRS 358.08 1 SISSONVILLE, WVMOBILE SUPPORT INVESTIGATIONS 4,069.53 2 CHARLESTON, WVMOUNTAIN STATE INVESTIGATIONS 1,467.94 1 LEWISBURG, WVMOUNTAIN STATE PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES PLLC 10,550.00 7 KEYSER, WV



TOTAL $# OF

CLAIMS




NIGH REPORTING SERVICE LLC 46.00 1 HAGERSTOWN, MDAILYNN MAE ORTEZA 500.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVPANHANDLE ACCIDENT RECONSTRUCTION 1,566.22 2 MARTINSBURG, WVPANHANDLE PRINTING & DESIGN LLC 824.14 1 MARTINSBURG, WVPEACE OF MIND PSYCHOLOGICAL SERVICES 1,500.00 1 PARKERSBURG, WVPEDIATRIC NEUROLOGY INC 3,500.00 1 ST LOUIS, MOG STANLEY PERRY 1,500.00 1 WHEELING, WVPETER J CALLAHAN PLLC 5,250.00 7 MARTINSBURG, WVPHILADELPHIA MEDICAL ADVISORS INC 5,766.56 1 BLUE BELL, PAPSYCHOLOGICAL CONSULTING INC 4,900.00 4 MARTINSBURG, WVPSYCHOLOGY ASSOCIATES PLLC 1,000.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVGARY A RINI 6,250.00 1 NORTH OLMSTED, OHROGERSON INVESTIGATIONS LLC 1,974.05 3 WELLSBURG, WVRONALD D PEARSE ED D 500.00 1 FAIRMONT, WVSUZANNE L ROTOLO 2,100.00 3 LEESBURG, VAJOSEPH S SANFILIPPO 9,470.00 1 GIBSONIA, PASAAR PSYCHOLOGICAL GROUP PLLC 10,025.00 9 SOUTH CHARLESTON, WVSCOTT PATTERSON POLYGRAPH SERVICES 550.00 1 FREDONIA, PASELBY & ASSOCIATES PLLC 6,437.50 1 HURRICANE, WVCATHERINE A SLAYDEN 3,016.95 7 MARTINSBURG, WVMARY J SMITH 146.25 1 KEYSER, WVSPECIAL SECURITY SERVICES LLC 14,506.98 6 BAKER, WVSPECKIN FORENSICS LLC 1,935.00 1 FORT LAUDERDALE, FLSTACY HARLOW LLC 12,160.40 30 PARKERSBURG, WV

* STEPHEN MORRISON PRIVATE INVESTIGATIONS 3,736.42 6 HUNTINGTON, WVROBERT D STEWART 1,981.99 6 PINEVILLE, WVKAREN S STOLLINGS 504.35 2 PINEVILLE, WVSUSAN ABBEY LLC 750.00 1 DALLAS, TXSWERDLOW FREED PSYCHOLOGY PC 1,250.00 1 FARMINGTON HILLS, MITASA GROUP INC 15,981.00 5 BLUE BELL, PAROBERT C THOMPSON 600.00 1 FAIRMONT, WVROBERT C TOUCHON 2,900.00 1 BARBOURSVILLE, WVTRI COUNTY PASTORAL COUNSELING SERVICES 3,900.00 1 MARTINSBURG, WVTRI S INVESTIGATIONS INC 176,680.92 294 PARKERSBURG, WVTRI STATE EYE CARE CENTER LTD 1,000.00 1 HUNTINGTON, WVTURNING POINT INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES 2,463.36 3 TORNADO, WVUNIVERSITY HEALTH ASSOCIATES 8,100.00 3 MORGANTOWN, WVVAUGHAN INVESTIGATIONS 35,442.68 71 BRADLEY, WVFRANK J VESEL 5,000.05 6 PARKERSBURG, WVSHARON L VINCENT 558.25 2 MORGANTOWN, WVCHRISTINE C WANG 680.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVWEDGEWOOD FAMILY PRACTICE & PSYCHIATRY ASSOC INC 2,484.00 1 MORGANTOWN, WVWESTBROOK HEALTH SERVICES INC 561.80 1 SPENCER, WVWOLFE PARALEGAL SERVICES LLC 12,011.50 9 HUNTINGTON, WVWOODS INVESTIGATIONS 26,713.97 33 BECKLEY, WVRONALD D WOODS 1,898.48 3 MOUNT CLAIRE, WVWILLIAM J WYATT 3,936.57 1 HURRICANE, WVZEDA MEDICAL LLC 733.33 1 MCLEAN, VADIRECT EXPENSE TOTALS 1,150,313.54 1,073GRAND TOTALS 25,530,768.12 34,045



APPENDIX E:

HISTORICAL

OVERVIEW OF KEY

STATISTICAL

INDICATORS



PU

BLI

CD

EFEN

DER

SER

VIC

ES

His

tori

calO

verv

iew

of

Ke

ySt

atis

tica

lIn

dic

ato

rs

AP

PO

INTE

DC

OU

NSE

LFY

20

14

FY2

01

3FY

20

12

FY2

01

1FY

20

10

FY2

00

9FY

20

08

Am

ou

nt

Pai

din

Cla

ims

$2

5,5

30

,76

8.1

2$

25

,23

2,4

12

.09

$2

1,9

60

,49

3.8

6$

26

,30

1,2

25

.60

$3

3,3

27

,74

3.7

8$

20

,51

3,7

11

.19

$2

2,7

75

,83

1.9

0

Tota

lCla

ims

Pai

d(w

/oSu

pp

.&D

irec

t)3

1,8

17

.00

32

,00

7.0

02

7,4

02

.00

32

,25

0.0

04

5,2

83

.00

23

,63

7.0

02

8,1

31

.00

Tota

lHo

urs

Pai

d4

79

,58

3.9

04

75

,50

3.6

04

15

,33

6.0

05

02

,93

4.0

06

31

,73

7.0

03

84

,56

4.0

04

22

,42

3.0

0

Per

cen

tIn

Co

urt

14

.97

%1

5.2

4%

15

.09

%1

5.0

1%

15

.44

%1

6.4

6%

16

.76

%

Per

cen

tO

ut

of

Co

urt

85

.03

%8

4.7

6%

84

.91

%8

4.9

9%

84

.56

%8

3.5

4%

83

.24

%

Ave

rage

Co

stP

erC

laim

$8

02

.43

$7

88

.34

$8

01

.42

$8

15

.54

$7

35

.99

$8

67

.86

$8

09

.63

Ave

rage

Tota

lCo

stP

erH

ou

r$

53

.24

$5

3.0

6$

52

.87

$5

2.3

0$

52

.76

$5

3.3

4$

53

.92

PU

BLI

CD

EFEN

DER

CO

RP

OR

ATI

ON

SFY

20

14

FY2

01

3FY

20

12

FY2

01

1FY

20

10

FY2

00

9FY

20

08

Dis

bu

rsm

ents

for

Pu

blic

Def

.Co

rps.

$1

7,0

30

,81

7.0

0$

15

,37

6,3

20

.00

$1

9,6

95

,72

4.8

2$

18

,41

7,1

58

.00

$1

6,9

65

,24

3.4

2$

16

,92

6,0

70

.25

$1

3,6

56

,71

9.0

0

Tota

lCas

esC

lose

d3

3,3

54

.00

32

,74

0.0

04

1,8

97

.00

33

,54

4.0

03

0,9

39

.00

35

,35

4.0

03

2,7

14

.00

Tota

lHo

urs

(w/o

Ad

min

.Tim

e)1

89

,60

5.1

01

84

,07

8.1

01

89

,19

9.9

01

85

,32

2.6

01

78

,21

6.8

01

80

,64

7.3

01

74

,41

2.5

0

Per

cen

tIn

Co

urt

*2

8.0

8%

27

.40

%2

7.4

3%

26

.71

%2

7.7

2%

28

.64

%2

8.6

9%

Per

cen

tO

ut

of

Co

urt

*7

1.2

9%

71

.90

%7

1.9

4%

72

.77

%7

1.9

2%

71

.36

%7

1.3

1%

Ave

rage

Co

stP

erC

lose

dC

ase*

*$

51

0.6

1$

46

9.6

5$

47

0.1

0$

54

9.0

5$

54

8.3

4$

47

8.7

6$

41

7.4

6

Ave

rage

Tota

lCo

stP

erH

ou

r$

89

.82

$8

3.5

3$

10

4.1

0$

99

.38

$9

5.1

9$

93

.70

$7

8.3

0

In

Ap

ril2

01

4,t

he

on

line

vou

cher

sub

mis

sio

np

roce

ssb

ecam

em

and

ato

ry.

*Dru

gC

ou

rtis

no

tco

nsi

der

edas

itre

pre

sen

tsle

ssth

an1

%o

fti

me

star

tin

gin

FY2

01

0.

**A

vera

geC

ost

Per

Clo

sed

Cas

ew

asre

calc

ula

ted

for

FY2

01

1to

refl

ect

am

ore

accu

rate

figu

re.



Documents

Table of Contents Annual Report.pdf · adversary system of criminal justice, any person haled into court, who is too poor to hire a lawyer, cannot be assured a fair trial unless counsel