Tabassum Saleheen, A097 967 736 (BIA July 20, 2009)

7/27/2019 Tabassum Saleheen, A097 967 736 (BIA July 20, 2009)

1/8

DD WILSON, ESQUR019 Mineha Anue Steiepos N 58

Nam:SHTSU

V m

Execuiv O f mitn Rw

Bad Iian AaOfc Clk

S/07 Lb PU 2Fl Ch Yi I

fc heC CoseVBL2 Mo Drve S 10Blmngo 5

7-676

th noce 7009

c s a y h Bo's d d od n bo-c c

ncle

Pe Me:C, Paca G Jy g

Sey

r ek

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished

Cite as: Tabassum Saleheen, A097 967 736 (BIA July 20, 2009)


2/8

f

J m R

Dc B A

F Cu Via ie: A97 96 3 - ooon, Da

Ir: TBASSUM SAHEN a.k.aTabs Awl Saehaa ah

REMOV ROEG

PE

O BF O RSPODT Da Wion, E

ON BEH O DHS

HARG

y KR. Zske

t Cef oel

UL 0 9

o ec 3)( ct [8S 127(a)(B] heUnt Saes voon of a

PLICATON: S e lao ofol; vo e

e nen a atie czn ofBgeshapas e aton udge' 252008 ion dey her ao cia le clion f mo d oe c to econ 40AX(A of e ion d Ntoni A 8 US. 1b)(. e wl e m

FAC ROD HIOY

On e 99 de med Sej Se Bge . 999 M e Ued es 8 i Aus 999, se joi (.J at -3. ede e awe Oor 9 Api S b e o ys emo a

O 202 e s d er Uie at i ah vel o esh 4) We adh. e D C Coon i i ofDo he q o aeheen QJ t 4 Seh in e d to e esoe er o docens eel pibg r m rin e a . 4-5). e enga voe lz ometme n 002 depitemp y e ndeo ee evalidi ofM Saees Aav J a ) eden o h n wM Sae si er a , p a f p t 56



3/8

A097 6 36

Decm 2 2002, dnt ed a Ver Peo r Dilo oMaae th isct Cou Bod Coy Colorado J a 5 Evetul o Augt 28, 2003 s wsb o -ter h U tes nomit sp o siay workr H) wathozatio o ai i he Uied Stts a temo od not to xced At 10204 J at 5 h. )

aer, rdnt Mr Sah engagein a pt do dspue in Colordo(It 5 Dg t t o 7 5 M S b awl sdt.O l 2 26 t Ui Sat ishp d Iiio eies 'SI ote of nent o Dn e sdens applicato adj o s dspo o Saen. 1

, o Novmb 20 26 e Deet o Hom H) admv p agint set xh e on eqsd t

of a clao of mval r bd su or pt o io20b(2)() o te Ac E ) o at ing h dcy o movapg oAl 200 e ets dor n Cooo e (h 5 T 2AAdty o Sepm 007 rpode md Quadr n Do Coa ( 5 Tab )

In s dsio aion Jdg fo t e oent me he budnfpvng s as subecte to exme cel d not emnstrte u by th e, at thb w comed "by a se o nt wo is or a awl e dt." Ssecio 2A(b)(2)A(i)( of th A.2 hs g the Imo g a Coid o nend r cto 20b(2)( o h Act o tn o iios h s wh eausg a a e

e r

e aus

{J -3 No

omlos ult ha co t e su cos to cor al aons whe aboccd whi absg o aw e sdet sta moudge hed tatso 20A(2(A)( w py red o m at baengo pace at a ie whe h baer d a sa t h ld o hod ovr he ss hea sch a wy lim e es as io bs I.J at ) rge o Jug dd t dents pliao ia laio o ov

ot o n o e stat at ce e Bnga do ws na Spemr

202 the snnt not qng aosp Saehn at h ime o hsadue d hee egibl o uer sa hs eet. SC ogea the Dsc ou o oodo d o oor te dvo decson entd in aHowe e C statd a pcce w o oo maes orces on as ey aeg r h sion whe e act w oe a i the ndens ce eoe z n gades n 22

2 Te mo Je e a ohse t respon w satto elgb r e sou .J

2



4/8

A097 96 36

ISS

Te ie pe is eth lg ofon 240XA)(lof theAc is h e bto exe cey c we eag po s a lat nt orUidSs n e n ue a e geof on20(b2)(A(i( of Act no lions e ea nd ee o og vy ms a Jw t Ued Ss e OHS sha e Iigon Juge's o dcoet Conso

l STS OF RVW

s B def o mo ug' cenou. e 8CF.R 10(d()(; se Mr ofS-H. 3 & D. 62 (BIA 0

Weequo olaw de . S 8CFR 00dJ(ii)

ANYSS

I codu o novo view of ssues o o rato e co oosis sh la le oe u Maer oBrion, N Dec.355, 36 (BA 00Lamie v U Ttee, 50US. 526 53 (20) (cng uhes Acra Co Jcobson, 525 .S.32 8 (99 Is oetcon a an xon onso oei , n y b givc ee eon Ic NRoc DnseCi nc US 8 8- (98 I c he p g ofa , ecd e tlg a i, con d e of

a wo

e e oon v Shel

O o, 5

.S 3 301 (19K M

o e 4 S 8 29 988

e uo age sse ve:

Te Ao Ge y ccel rmovaJ o, d adj t as of aila ad n sidence e wo s sbe de e i Sa i moh -

() e n e t o sbe o ce b as op or a U S (o e pn oa d oa S de cld h bn ba o b e

cl u ctzen );

l bed o subj ee c a opewho is or lwl pen e {or e nt of a cdo ae who is or a ll side d e cid ebado bjeco e e yuc p rs ) ..

Sen AA o e e dd.

3



5/8

09967 736

We d e mo o n o the o l v by endent ie t it li l al whe qiig e i aden or U

Ses cte at the e o the alio out gad to weer ad e te abu We d n a e Ito Judge a allog such io ekal le cellaon of ov Wcve e Coon f tesau

e ba use rvio ssue w dd o e Ac of e Violnc AWomen Acto 199 (VAWA 4),Pub LNo10-322 18t19(1994)donesveal en So20Ab2A) othe Ac w ot y S 14(a),tle V [Bad i Woe Ptio Act o 20] div B Vol nt Wom Ac 2000 Pu o 06-6 Vcts o c d Vil oteco Ac of 0VTA Ac ofO 28 200 14 Sta. 14 en ts, Cood thatthe goa o e imion tonfr mn icled e Vo Wo A 994 o ove iaio aw a a e t ba i

woen d d loc n abue op Son 52 o e Bd Wo tn Ac I ote wo Cos w n a mg e ionl en at womn dd not ai o tei abve ds o loing mbene

Nbly te Ba Ii We tioA exd eif w abr" a ize o law et n d he batt ndls w tdt t her ab ge egiae e f e ab'sby. 50 Pb L . 106-6 11 S 14 152224 20) nde or eons he ele was o o t ales wo ha e a o sbjected t exel te td Ses b a s r pn "h '' a tat c o la

pt sdet S n 24(a)(3 o e Act SC. 12(a(3); 24Ab(2) f he Act 997. he VTA n R a ne oenial puos f VAWA 9 to elte iin a po dle lin abe reao r sg el m law efent aewere ad o daon o abus wod drw ooip paciton ne HR Rp. No 10699 20 t 139 (Co ) Tus one o the of e th io VAWA s o coue on po u ofb d cldn int dotic volce. ; 14 o R 81,S l0188 1195 E129 0

is en eched in the eglie hito es Fo exle in i AgVews o he legislan, e De of Ju dcted a t p

r t

pvisos of e ornallesaon "e dege tofebat i mabwh su mgola oc.iate, d conl erspua cdn."HR.R. N 09 a-7 0 Sly dd r e bbau i wd .mae e fr h t d the cil tepiverlaonsips," 146 Cong Re. 070 (stet f S. Kedy) abue iin wuld n haet chto stay e abu i tosyi te Un." 16 Cg. R. S1185 (smen f Se Ly). Seealso 146 ng R. 10192 oMag' Semen)hihtite blls eoove stles ieyies

4



6/8

A0 96 36

byo on lw m n prevt m ? g docviol y d st e a''.

In t e eon& t scet Cos ao oa pto to as abuive laohp. We ae atf onss wish to l re clo ofmo oy to hose aies wo we abus bl etrie oUi St ciatthe me ead c wod doe so 2000 i eftleoe u "s orw" a ciz o l d.

We el gge of son 40b)()oec vidg eliidt siao. I e o t alie bu by a le pnent i U Sci, d he uch a e e abd or hri eo of ov po. ndo ean s a ag en d o Un S c but a d o in h a e

of e o L as e t se pl o a io al is abuy divid wo s oal pn dtor Utd Stuho i a le pn d o U Se cz a e me e a aik e Wles teaon st ief ato ld myy abve lop hend w s nopibio d e pla e ofe tucalo cou o cosdedb mmio Jude s o as e bu ba ss a e im oe pplio Idd pn lge of e prior o dn d c pon; 2s ex eefo d n te snd sion dcbd abov t o ab "aUnietatciolat sd rgl v e ongso ht th pode s so lib sca llao of mov d

co 40)(2XA o e c

Te 1 is s wh t d gof le con ool a a o do Se on 40a, ) b2)of c( eA G a l e' o; see, eg. Meo/elo & D 201.0 B 21) Mae o/C-VT 2 & D 0 198 Mt ofMn 6 N D.58 B 18) T nde l eeqs eigngn vo Se d tes e xco of her Baga, s 199 S a tcii7 ur, Ss age 8 Nolth o g d tha e dso dcuSa e p (. at 4 he dd o ve ai d gy eoyd c Ma 204 ) Te

ga ao clde o ofmov ptof d ps m 00 l0

Hoe ef e g of l t, d don ol o coio Sly weot e rod o nt w Slh since2002 cet r a few one cle o e odents aage t Sehn l dpo 22 de tei p dvo . Addo en 2007 sc o t -d

5



7/8

'

A09 96 736

for sta, a no log abve reloshp h hr x-hud. T, v dl pse o bar use sos fhA ab oz v es c r t deswho y e od orp

of o eoma con oe e, d a o he denn demon a she s e to elaon o mov de o 240Ab)(2) oe A amaer odo erg e e ome aoi ed e de, dtrge. W l i d's a d f ootde

Acy l e en.

OE: pdents ap s di

R OR su o e io Judgs d codon

mp dts o e n stvoly d e Ut S, wtt ee o eGvewi 60 am he da of s o y xon eyo at me ma y he f melan Sty DH"). o 0Bb) ofe Io Na A8 USC 129b); ee aso 8 CF. 40.6), (. en e snde fs tooy USat, l mo e i miaJg's e.

OTC the det s to volaly dep th Und Ses m ee, or y exs teby e H, rodent subject a vl rovd h ts a shl b ble p 10 y

e d co 20 d o 24A 25 248, 4 o Ac. sn 240B{ f e A.

WG: Ie l moton o open r to e ii oe l ep aoe, te t vt d s tatea e ro aowed vo d s ot y,od, or eend If tofvolt s oma u lig o o les rfauto dart de s 40B(d) o A sl apply ee V D E a Mn To or Rsde o a Po r vw 7 F. R. 627,76,78 18, 2008 ( a8 CF 2026c)(ii), e)())

WG oo dgenited Ss, snd any ica neto hs vy oer a tion riwp o o 2 of he Ac8 U .S.C. 125 e of vol ep s auma ia d e oo moval shl my ec Hw if l on ew e p es 0 dys f lg, e sdet w o e v n o of remo ie pide HS sd of s orh e Immto d Cms oemt ld Ofr f e HS aq d pds vd S m c or s h ed ude o th Se. li ep on (d) o A p

6



8/8

.

0996 36

t who onrew, notdng o of te heor e rmasi eU S le e po vew S 13 F. Reg t 7698 {o bec 8CFR 4026


Documents

Tabassum Saleheen, A097 967 736 (BIA July 20, 2009)