Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEE
SUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS
Grants & Denials List
AMENDED - Monday, November 18, 2013
GRANTS
STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTYTRIAL JUDGE
TRIAL COURT NO.
APPELLATEJUDGE
JUDGMENT
NATUREOF
APPEAL
ACTION
Nashville
NONE
Knoxville
Samuel E. Foster et al. v. Walter William Chiles, III, M.D. et al.E2012-01780-SC-R11-CV
Knox County Circuit Court Judge Dale C. WorkmanNo. 122712
Susano, J., Vacated
Rule 11 Granted: Application of Walter WilliamChiles, III, M.D., Knoxville UrologyClinic, P.C., Gordon Lee Collins, M.D.,Anesthesia Medical Alliance of EastTennessee P.C., Covenant Health andParkwest Medical Center
(Order Filed 11-13-13; copy attached)
Page 1 of 23
State of Tennessee v. Gwendolyn HagermanE2011-00233-SC-R11-CD
Sullivan County CriminalCourt Judge Robert H.Montgomery, Jr.No. S57, 179
Tipton, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Granted: Application of GwendolynHagerman
(Order Filed 11-13-13; copy attached)
Edward Thomas Kendrick, III v. State ofTennessee E2011-02367-SC-R11-PC
Hamilton County CriminalCourt Judge Don W. Poole No. 22062
Bivins, J.,Reversed
Rule 11 Granted: Application of State ofTennessee
(Order Filed 11-13-13; copy attached)
Larry Sneed v. The City of Red Bank,TennesseeE2012-02112-SC-R11-CV
Hamilton County CircuitCourt Chancellor Jeffrey M.AthertonNo. 12C1164
McClarty, J.,ReversedMotion
Rule 11 Granted: Application of Larry Sneed
Motion to file amicus brief Granted
(Order Filed 11-12-13; copy attached)
Andrew Spencer v. Norfolk SouthernRailway CompanyE2012-01204-SC-R11-CV
Hamilton County CircuitCourtJudge Ward JeffreyHollingsworthNo. 10C1029
Swiney, J.,Vacated
Rule 11 Granted: Application of NorfolkSouthern Railway Company
(Order Filed 11-13-13; copy attached)
Jackson
State of Tennessee v. Marlo DavisW2011-01548-SC-R11-CD
Shelby County CriminalCourt Judge W. Mark WardNo. 07-01813
Thomas, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Granted: Application of Marlo Davis
(Order Filed 11-13-13; copy attached)
State of Tennessee v. Broderick DevonteFayneW2012-01488-SC-R11-CD
Tipton County Circuit Court Judge Joseph A. Walker, IIINo. 7219
Glenn, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Granted: Application of BroderickDevonte Fayne
(Order Filed 11-13-13; copy attached)
Page 2 of 23
SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEESUPREME COURT DISCRETIONARY APPEALS
AMENDED - Monday, November 18, 2013
DENIALS
STYLE/APPEAL NUMBER COUNTYTRIAL JUDGE
TRIAL COURT NO.
APPELLATEJUDGE
JUDGMENT
NATUREOF
APPEAL
ACTION
Nashville
Gregory Anderson D/B/A ABC PaintingCompany v. The MetropolitanDevelopment and Housing Authority M2012-01789-SC-R11-CV
Davidson County ChanceryCourt Chancellor Carol L. McCoyNo. 111093III
Cottrell, P.J.M.S.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of GregoryAnderson D/B/A ABC Painting Company
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Shelvy Antwon Baker v. State ofTennessee M2012-01559-SC-R11-PC
Davidson County CriminalCourt Judge Cheryl A. BlackburnNo. 2002-A-112
Ogle, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Shelvy AntwonBaker
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Jerome Sidney Barrett v. State ofTennesseeM2012-01778-SC-R11-CO
Davidson County CriminalCourtJudge Steve R. DozierNo. 2007D3201
Smith, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Jerome SidneyBarrett
(Order filed 11-13-13)
Rosalyn L. Caffey v. MetropolitanGovernment of Nashville and DavidsonCounty, et al.M2012-00883-SC-R11-CV
Davidson County ChanceryCourtJudge Russell T. PerkinsNo. 10631IV
Dinkins, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Rosalyn L.Caffey;Granted - Motion to Correct Clerical andForm Errors of Rosalyn L. Caffey
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
Page 3 of 23
State of Tennessee v. Colby Terrell BlackM2013-00530-SC-R11-CD
Giles County Circuit Court Judge Stella HargroveNos. 13274, 13632, 14763
Page, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Colby TerrellBlack
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Fonda Blair v. Rutherford County Boardof Education, Et AlM2012-00968-SC-R11-CV
Rutherford County ChanceryCourt Judge Timothy L. EasterNo. 10CV698
Dinkins, J.,Affirmed inpart, Reversedin part,Remanded
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Fonda Blair
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Michael D. BooneM2011-02435-SC-R11-CD
Davidson County CriminalCourt Judge Steve DozierNo. 2010-A-266
Wedemeyer,J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Michael D. Boone
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Michael Timothy Brown v. Janine BiacheBrownM2012-01796-SC-R11-CV
Maury County ChanceryCourt Judge Jim T. Hamilton No. 11717
Dinkins, J., Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Janine BiacheBrown
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Inez Bryson v. Tennessee Department ofIntellectual and DevelopmentalDisabilities M2012-02620-SC-R11-CV
Davidson County ChanceryCourt Chancellor Carol L. McCoyNo. 111210II
Dinkins, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Inez Bryson
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Robert JasonBurdickM2012-01071-SC-R11-CD
Williamson County CircuitCourt Judge Timothy L. EasterNo. II-CR-053486
Ogle, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Robert JasonBurdick
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Jonathan Duane Christy v. Mitchell B.Dugan, Administrator Ad Litem of theEstate of Laura Antoinette Long,DeceasedM2011-02722-SC-R11-CV
Dickson County CircuitCourt Judge Robert BurchNo. 22CC2011CV40
Dinkins, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Jonathan DuaneChristy
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Page 4 of 23
City of South Pittsburg, Tennessee v.James C. Hailey & Co. Et Al M2012-01185-SC-R11-CV
Marion County Circuit CourtJudge J. Curtis Smith No. 18589
Dinkins, J.,Reversed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of BituminousCasualty Corp.
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Marcus TerrellChurchM2011-01770-SC-R11-CD
Davidson County CriminalCourt Judge J. Randall Wyatt, Jr. No. 2009-A-583
Woodall, J.,Affirmed
Tipton, P. J., ConcurringOpinion;
Williams, J.,ConcurringOpinion
Rule 11Denied: Application of Marcus TerrellChurch
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Darius DixM2011-02131-SC-R11-CD
Montgomery County CircuitCourtJudge John H. Gasaway, IIINo. 41000464
Smith, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Darius Dix
(Order filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Raina FisherM2012-00750-CCA-R11-CD
Maury County Circuit CourtJudge Robert Lee Holloway,Jr.No. 2010-CR-19513
Ogle, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Raina Fisher
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
State of Tennessee v. Trinidad MartinezFloresM2012-00285-SC-R11-CD
Davidson County CriminalCourt Judge Seth NormanNo. 2010-C-2341
Woodall, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Trinidad MartinezFlores
Dismissed- Pro Se Application ofTrinidad Martinez Flores
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Page 5 of 23
Martha L. Patlan-Cano v. State ofTennessee M2012-01570-SC-R11-PC
Davidson County CriminalCourt Judge Steve R. Dozier No. 2006-D-3184
Ogle, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Martha L. Patlan-Cano
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Kyle Ronald FenclM2012-01265-SC-R11-CD
Davidson County CriminalCourt Judge Steve DozierNo. 2011A8
Ogle, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Kyle RonaldFencl
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Gerald BrandenFitzpatrickM2012-00186-SC-R11-CD
Davidson County CriminalCourt Judge Monte WatkinsNo. 2010-D-3267
Ogle, J., Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Gerald BrandenFitzpatrick
(Order Filed 11-18-13)
H. G. Hill Realty Company, LLC. v.Re/Max Carriage House Inc., et al.M2012-01509-SC-R11-CV
Davidson County ChanceryCourtJudge Russell T. PerkinsNo. 110261IV
Stafford, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Robert L. Wood,Jr.
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
Timothy L. Jefferson v. State ofTennesseeM2013-01621-SC-R11-PC
Davidson County CriminalCourtJudge Cheryl A. BlackburnNo. 200D1954
Wedemeyer, J.,
DeniedRule 11 Denied - Application of Timothy L.
Jefferson
(Order filed 11-18-13)
Russell Jensen v. State of Tennessee M2013-00290-SC-R11-HC
Wayne County Circuit Court Judge Jim T. Hamilton No. 15264
Wedemeyer, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Russell Jensen
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Geret Jessee Johnston v. Susan HarwellJohnstonM2012-01808-SC-R11-CV
Maury County ChanceryCourtJudge Robert Lee Holloway,Jr.No. 06414
Kirby, J.,Reversed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Geret JesseeJohnston
(Order filed 11-18-13)
Page 6 of 23
State of Tennessee v. Brandon L. KirkM2012-01331-SC-R11-CD
Robertson County CircuitCourt Judge Michael R. JonesNo. 2010CR668,2010CR670
Thomas, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Brandon L. KirkMotion for appointment of counsel isdenied.
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
V. Theresa Manning, et al. v.Hendersonville Hospital Corporationd/b/a Hendersonville Medical Center, etal.M2013-01615-SC-R10-CV
Sumner County CircuitCourtJudge C. L. RogersNo. 2013CV213
Per CuriamDenied
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Joseph Mangoun
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
State of Tennessee ex rel. Herbert S.Moncier v. Nancy S. Jones et al.M2012-00778-SC-R11-CV
Davidson County ChanceryCourtChancellor Carol L. McCoyNo. 11962
Clement, J.,Affirmed inPart; Reversedin Part
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Herbert S.Moncier
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Herbert S. Moncier v. Board ofProfessional Responsibility of theSupreme Court of TennesseeM2012-00779-SC-R11-CV
Davidson County ChanceryCourtChancellor Russell T.PerkinsNo. 11218
Bennett, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Herbert S.Moncier
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee ex rel. Herbert S.Moncier v. Nancy S. Jones et al.M2012-01429-SC-R11-CV
Davidson County ChanceryCourtJudge Hamilton GaydenNo. 12C502
Dinkins, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Herbert S.Moncier
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Herbert S. Moncier v. Hearing Panel ofthe Board of Professional ResponsibilityM2012-01850-SC-R11-CV
Knox County ChanceryCourtChancellor John F. WeaverNo. 179924-1
Bennett, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Herbert S.Moncier
(Order filed 11-13-13)
Chauncey Moore v. State of TennesseeM2012-01545-SC-R11-PC
Davidson County CriminalCourt Judge Cheryl BlackburnNo. 2009A539
Smith, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Chauncey Moore
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Page 7 of 23
Adedamola O. Oni M.D. v. TennesseeDepartment of Health, et al.M2012-01360-SC-R11-CV
Davidson County ChanceryCourtJudge Russell T. PerkinsNo. 12394IV
Bennett, J.,Affirmed inPart, Reversedin Part
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Adedamola O.Oni
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
Linda Alexander Owens v. James EmeryOwensM2012-01186-SC-R11-CV
Davidson County CircuitCourtJudge Philip E. SmithNo. 03D535
Cottrell, J.,Affirmed inPart, Reversedin Part
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Linda AlexanderOwens
(Order filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. William PatrickPeeblesM2011-01312-SC-R11-CD
Davidson County CriminalCourt Judge Steve R. Dozier No. 2009-A-829
Smith, J., Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of William PatrickPeebles
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Daniel E. Pottebaum, Sr. v. State ofTennesseeM2012-01573-SC-R11-PC
Davidson County CriminalCourtJudge Cheryl A. BlackburnNo. 2002C1808
Thomas, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Daniel E.Pottebaum, Sr.
(Order filed 11-18-13)
State of Tennessee, on relation of theTennessee Board of Regents, Austin PeayState University for and on behalf of saidDepartment v. University LandingPartners, LLC, a Tennessee LimitedLiability Company and MontgomeryCounty, TennesseeM2013-01716-SC-R10-CV
Montgomery County CircuitCourtJudge Ross H. HicksNo. MCCCCVCN091058
Per CuriamRule 10Denied
Rule 10 Denied: Application of UniversityLanding Partners, LLC
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
In Re Utility Management Review Boardv. The Commissioners of the Powell-Clinch Utility DistrictM2012-01806-SC-R11-CV
Davidson County ChanceryCourtJudge Russell T. PerkinsNo. 111608IV
Farmer, J.,Affirmed inPart; Modifiedin Part
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Commissionersof the Powell-Clinch Utility District
(Order filed 11-13-13)
Page 8 of 23
Earl Vantrease, Jr. v. State of Tennessee M2012-02023-SC-R11-HC
Hickman County CircuitCourt Judge Robbie Beal No. 12CV43
Wedemeyer,J.; Smith, J.,
Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Earl Vantrease, Jr.
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Clifton Williams, Jr.M2012-00902-SC-R11-CD
Rutherford County CircuitCourtJudge David M. BraggNo. F65511
Summers,Sr.J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Clifton Williams,Jr.
(Order filed 11-18-2013)
Knoxville
State of Tennessee, Ex Rel Paul Allen, EtAl v. The City of Newport, Tennessee E2012-00814-SC-R11-CV
Cocke County ChanceryCourt Chancellor Telford Forgety No. 08116
McClarty, J.,Reversed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of The City ofNewport, Tennessee
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Antonio J. Beasley, Sr. V. State ofTennessee E2013-00388-SC-R11-PC
Hamilton County CriminalCourtJudge Rebecca J. SternNos. 221828, 221830,222998, 224140, 224141,224136, 224137
Ogle, J.Witt, Jr., JThomas, Jr., JAppealDismissed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Antonio J.Beasley, Sr.
(Order Filed 11-12-13)
Patrick Devin Camp v. State of TennesseeE2012-00198-SC-R11-PC
Sullivan County CriminalCourt Judge Robert H.Montgomery, Jr. No. C57, 818
Thomas, Jr., J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Patrick Camp
(Order Filed 11-12-13)
State of Tennessee v. Ralph Byrd Cooper,Jr.E2012-01023-SC-R11-CD
Anderson County CircuitCourtJudge Donald ElledgeNo. A3CR0059
Woodall, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Ralph ByrdCooper, Jr.
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
Page 9 of 23
Jerry W. Dickerson v. David Sexton,WardenE2013-00993-SC-R11-HC
Johnson County CircuitCourt Judge R. Lynn W. BrownNo. 6220
Tipton, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Jaron Lee GoodsonE2012-02589-SC-R11-CD
Blount County Circuit CourtJudge Tammy HarringtonNo. C20245
Williams, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Jaron LeeGoodson
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
Harold Holloway v. David Sexton E2012-02451-SC-R11-HC
Johnson County CircuitCourt Judge Lynn W. BrownNo. 6133
Woodall, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Harold Holloway
(Order Filed 11-12-13)
Bassam Issa v. Jack Benson, Sr. E2012-01672-SC-R11-CV
Hamilton County CircuitCourt Judge Marie WilliamsNo. 12C283
Swiney, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Bassam Issa
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Raynella DossettLeath E2011-00437-SC-R11-CD
Knox County CriminalCourtJudge Richard BaumgartnerNo. 85787
Thomas, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Raynella DossettLeath
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Jesse R. Miltier v. Bank of America, N.A. E2012-00393-SC-R11-CV
Carter County Circuit Court Judge Thomas J. Seeley, Jr. No. C9814
McClarty, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Thomas E.Cowan, Jr.
(Order Filed 11-12-13)
State of Tennessee v. Quincy D. Moutry E2011-02531-SC-R11-CD
Knox County CriminalCourt Judge Jon Kerry BlackwoodNo. 93066
Thomas, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Quincy D. Moutry
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Page 10 of 23
Sabra Elaine Ellis O’Daniel v. RustyWade O’Daniel E2012-01555-SC-R11-CV
Hamilton County ChanceryCourtJudge Jeffrey M. AthertonNo. 11-0498
Susano, P.J.,Reversed inPart, Affirmedin Part, CaseRemanded forfurtherproceedings
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Rusty WadeO’Daniel
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Daylon D. Roberts v. David Sexton,WardenE2013-01034-SC-R11-HC
Johnson County CircuitCourt Judge Lynn W. BrownNo. 6229
Page, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Daylon D.Roberts
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
James R. Sterchi, JR. V. L. Basil SavardE2013-01743-SC-R9-CV
Bradley County CircuitCourtJudge Lawrence H. PuckettNo. V12-500
Susano, Jr., P.J.
Swiney, J
Frierson, II, JJ, J
Rule 9ApplicationDenied
Rule 11 Denied: Application of L. Basil Savard
(Order Filed 11-12-13)
Tennessee Farmers Mutual Insurance Co.V. W. Phillip Reed, Et Al. E2012-01392-SC-R11-CV
Blount County ChanceryCourt Judge Telford E. ForgetyNo. 2011-113
Swiney, J.,Affirmed,Remanded
Rule 11 Denied: Application of W. Phillip Reed
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Jerry Orlando Weaver v. State ofTennessee E2012-02336-SC-R11-PC
Anderson County CircuitCourt Judge Donald R. ElledgeNo. B0C00843
Wedemeyer, J.,
AffirmedRule 11 Denied: Application of Jerry Orlando
Weaver
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Lori K. Wilhoit, Et Al. v. Joshua AndrewRogers, Et Al. E2012-00751-SC-R11-CV
Washington County CircuitCourt Judge Thomas J. Seeley, Jr. No. 26799
Frierson, J.,Affirmed inpart, Reversedin part,Remanded
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Englewood Lawn& Landscape, LLC, and Joshua AndrewRogers
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Page 11 of 23
Jackson
State of Tennessee v. Eric BledsoeW2012-01643-SC-R11-CD
Shelby County CriminalCourtJudge Chris CraftNo. 0906393
Bivins, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Eric Bledsoe
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
State of Tennessee v. Tyrone BohannaW2011-01273-SC-R11-CD
Shelby County CriminalCourtJudge Lee CoffeeNo. 10-01849
Smith, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Tyrone Bohanna
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
Jerry Brock v. Jerry Lester, Warden W2013-00174-SC-R11-HC
Lauderdale County CircuitCourt Judge Joe WalkerNo. 6630
Williams, J.,Affirmed(Rule 20)
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Jerry Brock
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
William T. Bryant v. State of Tennessee W2013-00233-SC-R11-CO
Obion County Circuit CourtJudge William B. Acree, Jr. No. CC-12-CR-57
Ogle, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of William T. Bryant
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Charlie BurksW2011-02567-SC-R11-CD
Shelby County CriminalCourt Judge Lee V. CoffeeNos. B-078894 & B-078895
Page, J.,AppealDismissed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Charlie Burks
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
George Campbell, Jr. V. State ofTennessee W2012-00566-SC-R11-CO
Shelby County CriminalCourt Judge James C. Beasley, Jr. No. 93-00428-29
Smith, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of George Campbell,Jr.
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Casey ColbertW2012-00099-SC-R11-CD
Shelby County CriminalCourt Judge James LammeyNo. 09-07785, 11-05332
Bivins, J.,Affirmed inpart, Reversedin part
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Casey Colbert
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Page 12 of 23
Jordan Aston Danelz v. John Gayden,M.D.W2012-01667-SC-R11-JV
Shelby County JuvenileCourt Judge Curtis S. Person, Jr. Special Judge Dan H.Michael No. N6141
Kirby, J., Reversed inpart, vacated inpart andremanded
Rule 11 Denied: Application of John Gayden,M.D.
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Kenneth E. Diggs v. DNA DiagnosticCenter Et Al W2012-01617-SC-R11-CV
Shelby County ChanceryCourt Chancellor Walter L. EvansNo. CH-12-0580
Kirby, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Kenneth Diggs
Denied Eight motions filed betweenSeptember 9, 2013 and October 7, 2013
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Pearlie Mae Dunigan, Ex Rel. GroverDunigan v. State of Tennessee W2012-01245-SC-R11-CV
Tennessee ClaimsCommissionJudge Nancy Miller-HerronNo. 20110513
Highers, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Pearlie MaeDunigan
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Roy DemondDuncan W2012-00834-SC-R11-CD
Madison County CircuitCourt Judge Roy B. Morgan, Jr. No. 11-358
Woodall, J.,Affirmed inpart, Reversedin part
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Roy DemondDuncan
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Sarah Patricia Emanuele v. Joshua DavidScritchfieldW2013-00514-SC-R11-JV
Shelby County JuvenileCourt Judge Curtis S. Person, Jr. No. Y1079
Kirby, J., Affirmed inpart, Vacatedin part
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Sarah PatriciaEmanuele
(Order Filed 11-15-13)
State of Tennessee v. Michael AllenGibbsW2012-00800-SC-R11-CD
Haywood County CircuitCourtJudge Clayburn L. PeeplesNo 6458A
Thomas, J.,Reversed inPart
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Michael AllenGibbs
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
State of Tennessee v. Lashun GrayW2012-00415-SC-R11-CD
Shelby County CriminalCourt Judge James M. Lammey, Jr. No. 10-00629
Tipton, P.J.,Affirmed inpart; Reversedin part
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Lashun Gray
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Page 13 of 23
State of Tennessee v. Andre HarrisW2011-02440-SC-R11-CD
Shelby County CriminalCourt Judge Lee V. CoffeeNo. 08-07757
Page, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Andre Harris
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Jay Earl HaynesW2012-01917-SC-R11-CD
Dyer County Circuit Court Judge Lee MooreNo. 09-CR-288
Smith, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Jay Earl Haynes
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Warren Hildred W2012-01032-SC-R11-CD
Shelby County CriminalCourt Judge Paula SkahanNo. 11-03840
Witt, Jr., J. Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Warren Hildred
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Kenneth D.HubanksW2007-00906-SC-R11-CD
Hardin County Circuit Court Judge Creed McGinley No. 8561
Wedemeyer, J.,
AffirmedRule 11 Denied: Application of Kenneth D.
Hubanks
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Reginald D. Hughes v. Dwight Barbee,WardenW2012-01767-SC-R11-HC
Lauderdale County CircuitCourt Judge Joseph WalkerNo 6586
Woodall, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Reginald D.Hughes
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
State of Tennessee v. James Eric HurdW2011-01232-SC-R11-CD
Madison County CircuitCourt Judge Roy B. Morgan, Jr. No. 10745
Williams, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of James Eric Hurd
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Vershawn McCoy v. State of TennesseeW2012-00609-SC-R11-PC
Shelby County CriminalCourtJudge John Fowlkes, Jr.No. 08-00659
Smith, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of VershawnMcCoy
(Order filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Herman McKinleyW2012-00050-SC-R11-CD
Shelby County CriminalCourtJudge Lee CoffeeNo. 1104050
Williams, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of HermanMcKinley
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Page 14 of 23
Pervis Tyrone Payne v. State ofTennesseeW2013-01215-SC-R11-PD
Shelby County CriminalCourtJudge J. Robert CarterNo. P9594
McMullen, J.,Denied
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Pervis TyronePayne
(Order filed 11-14-13)
Gerald Sanford v. State of TennesseeW2012-01194-SC-R11-PC
Shelby County CriminalCourtJudge Paula SkahanNo. 04-05865
Glenn, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Gerald Sanford
(Order filed 11-13-13)
Michael L. Smith v. State of TennesseeW2012-01604-SC-R11-HC
Lake County Circuit CourtJudge Lee Moore, Jr.No. 11-CR-9640
Woodall, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Michael L. Smith
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
State of Tennessee v. Darquan SwiftW2011-02439-SC-R11-CD
Shelby County CriminalCourtJudge W. Mark WardNo. 11-01752
Page, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Darquan Swift
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
State of Tennessee v. Don Maurice TaylorW2012-02027-SC-R11-CD
Gibson County Circuit Court Judge Clayburn L. Peeples No. 18226
Ogle, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Don MauriceTaylor
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
State of Tennessee v. Demario DarnellThompson W2012-00642-SC-R11-CD
Madison County CircuitCourtJudge Donald H. AllenNo. 11-198
Tipton, P.J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Demario DarnellThompson
(Order Filed 11-13-13)
Jerome Wall v. State of TennesseeW2012-01748-SC-R11-PC
Shelby County CriminalCourtJudge J. Robert Carter, Jr.No. 91007725, 0109143
Page, J.,Dismissed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Jerome Wall
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
Page 15 of 23
Clayton Ward v. Illinois Central RailroadCompanyW2012-01839-SC-R11-CV
Shelby County Circuit CourtJudge Jerry StokesNo. CT-006235-07
Stafford, J.,Reversed &Remanded
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Illinois CentralRailroad Company
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
State of Tennessee v. Lee Weaver, Jr.W2012-00811-SC-R11-CD
Hardin County Circuit CourtJudge C. Creed McGinleyNo. 9533
Smith, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied - Application of Lee Weaver, Jr.
(Order filed 11-13-13)
Jeremy Young v. State of TennesseeW2012-01193-SC-R11-PC
Shelby County CriminalCourtJudge W. Otis Higgs, Jr.No. 0708677
Thomas, J.,Affirmed
Rule 11 Denied: Application of Jeremy Young
(Order Filed 11-14-13)
Page 16 of 23
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEEAT KNOXVILLE
SAMUEL E. FOSTER ET AL. v. WALTER WILLIAM CHILES, III, M.D. ET AL.
Circuit Court for Knox County
No. 122712
No. E2012-01780-SC-R11-CV- Filed November 13, 2013
ORDER
Upon consideration of the application for permission to appeal of Walter William Chiles, III, M.D.,
Knoxville Urology Clinic, P.C., Gordon Lee Collins, M.D., Anesthesia Medical Alliance of East Tennessee,
P.C., Covenant Health and Parkwest Medical Center, and the record before us, the application is granted.
The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of
briefing.
PER CURIAM
Page 17 of 23
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEEAT KNOXVILLE
STATE OF TENNESSEE v. GWENDOLYN HAGERMAN
Criminal Court for Sullivan County
No. S57,179
No. E2011-00233-SC-R11-CD - Filed November 13, 2013
ORDER
Upon consideration of Gwendolyn Hagerman’s application for permission to appeal and the record
before us, the application is granted and the case is remanded to the Court of Criminal Appeals with direction
to order the parties to supplement the appellate record with the victim’s Department of Children’s Services
records, which were sealed and filed with the trial court, and to reconsider the case in light of the supplemented
appellate record.
PER CURIAM
Page 18 of 23
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEEAT KNOXVILLE
EDWARD THOMAS KENDRICK, III v. STATE OF TENNESSEE
Criminal Court for Hamilton County
No. 220622
No. E2011-02367-SC-R11-PC - Filed November 13, 2013
ORDER
Upon consideration of the application for permission to appeal of the State of Tennessee and the record
before us, the application is granted.
The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of
briefing.
PER CURIAM
Page 19 of 23
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEEAT KNOXVILLE
LARRY SNEED v. THE CITY OF RED BANK, TENNESSEE
Circuit Court for Hamilton County
No. 12C1164
No. E2012-02112-SC-R11-CV - Filed November 12, 2013
ORDER
The Tennessee Employment Lawyers Association’s motion to file an amicus brief is granted. Upon
consideration of the Tenn. R. App. P. 11 application for permission to appeal filed on behalf of Larry Sneed,
the amicus brief in support of the application, and the record before us, the application is granted.
The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of
briefing.
PER CURIAM
Page 20 of 23
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEEAT KNOXVILLE
ANDREW SPENCER v. NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY
Circuit Court for Hamilton County
No. 10C1029
No. E2012-01204-SC-R11-CV - Filed November 13, 2013
ORDER
Upon consideration of the application for permission to appeal of Norfolk Southern Railway Company
and the record before us, the application is granted.
The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of
briefing.
PER CURIAM
Page 21 of 23
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEEAT JACKSON
STATE OF TENNESSEE v. MARLO DAVIS
Criminal Court for Shelby County
No. 07-01813
No. W2011-01548-SC-R11-CD - Filed November 13, 2013
ORDER
Upon consideration of Marlo Davis’ application for permission to appeal and the record before us, the
application is granted.
The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion of
briefing.
PER CURIAM
Page 22 of 23
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF TENNESSEEAT JACKSON
STATE OF TENNESSEE v. BRODERICK DEVONTE FAYNE
Circuit Court for Tipton County
No. 7219
No. W2012-01488-SC-R11-CD - Filed November 13, 2013
ORDER
Upon consideration of the application for permission to appeal of Broderick Devonte Fayne and
the record before us, the application is granted.
The Clerk is directed to place this matter on the docket for oral argument upon the completion
of briefing.
PER CURIAM
Page 23 of 23
