5
Proc. Natd Acad. Sci. USA Vol. 78, No. 10, pp. 6314-6318, October 1981 Developmental Biology Successive generations of. mice produced from an established culture line of euploid teratocarcinoma cells (microinjection into blastocysts/developmental totipotency/germ-line transmission) TIMOTHY A. STEWART AND BEATRICE MINTZ* Institute fbr Cancer Research, Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19111 Contributed by Beatrice Mintz, July 15, 1981 ABSTRACT The possibility of utilizing mouse teratocarci- noma stem cells as intermediaries for production of new strains of mice with preselected mutant or foreign genes requires that, after propagation in culture (to allow for genetic manipulation and selection), the cells be capable of normalization and orderly de- velopment in carrier embryos and, ultimately, of germ-cell for- mation. Heretofore, no in vitro cell line has fulfilled all these re- quirements. A karyotypically normal teratocarcinoma culture line was recently established in this laboratory and now has been in- vestigated as a candidate. The line, designated METT-1, is chro- mosomally female (X/X) and was obtained from the 129 (agouti- colored) inbred strain [Mintz, B. & Cronmiller, C. (1981) Somat Cell Genet 7, 489-505]. The developmental-potential -of these cells was tested, after prolonged culture and freezing and thawing, by microinjecting them into early (blastocyst stage) embryos of the C57BL/6 (black) strain. Among 312 experimental animals exam- ined at 1 week of age, there were 41 mice (21 females and 20 males) that displayed the coat colors ofboth strains. This frequency (13%), as well as the extent of the coat areas derived from the cell line, greatly surpasses the contributions observed in all previous ex- periments, whether with other in vitro teratocarcinoma cell lines or with in vivo transplant lines. The developmental totipotency of METT-1 cells became evident from the presence of substantial amounts of 129-strain cells (bearing an isozyme marker) in all in- ternal tissues of an individual whose coat was largely agouti. The culture-cell lineage also proved to be capable of giving rise to re- productively functional oocytes. Of nine mosaic-coat females test- mated to C57BL/6 males, one produced progeny of the diagnostic agouti color in two litters; these heterozygous F1 offspring in turn transmitted their marker genes to F2 homozygous segregants. Thus, the METT-1 teratocarcinoma line bridges the gap between in vitro cell propagation and in vivo development and between the soma and the germ line. This creates the option of producing new mouse strains with predetermined genetic changes designed as probes of developmental regulation or as models of human genetic diseases. Mouse teratocarcinoma cells from some transplanted tumors and culture lines have been experimentally channeled into nor- mal development, to a greater or lesser extent (1-4), by placing them in early (blastocyst stage) embryos. Although the cells of one in vitro line (NG 2) have proved capable of contributing to all somatic tissues under these circumstances (5), germ-cell dif- ferentiation and progeny have resulted only from two in vivo transplant lines, both of which had appreciable subpopulations of cells with a normal karyotype (1, 2, 6). Of a total of three an- imals with tumor-strain germ cells and offspring, two were males from a chromosomally male (X/Y) ascites line (OTT 6050, of the 129 inbred strain) and one was a female from a chro- mosomally female (X/X) solid-tumor line (72484-395, of the LT strain). Cell culture lines, on the other hand, have shown var- ious karyotypic anomalies that-even in the best-developing case (5), characterized by a trisomy (6)-would be incompatible with production of viable offspring (7). Realization of the scheme that has been proposed for utilizing cultured teratocarcinoma cells as vehicles for introducing pre- selected new genotypes into mice (8-10) therefore depends on first obtaining an in vitro line with not only somatic but also germinal totipotency. Specific genetic changes could then be introduced during the culture phase, incorporated into entire animals, and transmitted to subsequent generations. Terato- carcinoma stem cells with selected mutations (e.g., refs. 5, 11, and 12) or stem cells that have incorporated cloned foreign genes (13) have in fact been successfully isolated from cultures and found to have retained the capacity for somatic develop- ment. It remains for a culture line with germinal potential to become available. A candidate cell line, designated METT-1, was recently es- tablished here for the purpose (14). It was obtained from an embryo-derived malignant teratocarcinoma of the 129/Sv (or 129) agouti-colored inbred strain. Its promising features are karyotypic normalcy (the chromosomal sex is X/X female), sta- bility, feeder-independence, and ability to differentiate in cul- tures or tumors. We now report that METT-1 cells can form all somatic tissues in host embryos; and they can also produce germ-line progeny, even after more than 100 cell doublings in vitro, and after freezing and thawing. Thus, the cells of this line can bridge the gap between asexual propagation in vitro and sexual reproduction in vivo-the necessary preamble for en- gineering new mouse strains to be used as probes of develop- mental regulation or as models of human genetic diseases. MATERIALS AND METHODS Injections into Blastocysts. Teratocarcinoma stem cells of the METT-1 line (14) were used after they had been cultured for nine or more passages since the initial explant, frozen and stored in liquid nitrogen, thawed, and cultured for seven or more ad- ditional passages. The cells were then partly dissociated in 0.25% trypsin-EDTA and Ca2"- and Mg2"-free phosphate-buf- fered saline and rinsed. Three to five cells were injected per blastocyst, of the C57BL/6 (or C57) inbred strain (Icr subline), as described (1). After a few hours' incubation in the cell-culture medium (14), the blastocysts were surgically transferred to uteri of pseudopregnant Icr random-bred albino females for devel- opment to term. Analyses of Tissue Genotypes. The agouti-locus hair-follicle marker enabled donor-derived (agouti) areas to be distinguished from blastocyst-derived (nonagouti, or black) regions in the Abbreviations: GPI, glucosephosphate isomerase; MUP, major urinary protein complex. *To whom reprint requests should be addressed. The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by page charge payment. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertise- ment" in accordance with 18 U. S. C. §1734 solely to indicate this fact. 6314 Downloaded by guest on December 9, 2020

Successive of. cultureline teratocarcinoma · Downloaded by guest on May 2, 2020 6314. Developmental Biology: StewartandMintz coats of1-week-oldanimals. TheAW, orso-called white-bellied

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Successive of. cultureline teratocarcinoma · Downloaded by guest on May 2, 2020 6314. Developmental Biology: StewartandMintz coats of1-week-oldanimals. TheAW, orso-called white-bellied

Proc. Natd Acad. Sci. USAVol. 78, No. 10, pp. 6314-6318, October 1981Developmental Biology

Successive generations of. mice produced from an establishedculture line of euploid teratocarcinoma cells

(microinjection into blastocysts/developmental totipotency/germ-line transmission)

TIMOTHY A. STEWART AND BEATRICE MINTZ*Institute fbr Cancer Research, Fox Chase Cancer Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19111

Contributed by Beatrice Mintz, July 15, 1981

ABSTRACT The possibility of utilizing mouse teratocarci-noma stem cells as intermediaries for production of new strainsof mice with preselected mutant or foreign genes requires that,after propagation in culture (to allow for genetic manipulation andselection), the cells be capable of normalization and orderly de-velopment in carrier embryos and, ultimately, of germ-cell for-mation. Heretofore, no in vitro cell line has fulfilled all these re-quirements. A karyotypically normal teratocarcinoma culture linewas recently established in this laboratory and now has been in-vestigated as a candidate. The line, designated METT-1, is chro-mosomally female (X/X) and was obtained from the 129 (agouti-colored) inbred strain [Mintz, B. & Cronmiller, C. (1981) SomatCell Genet 7, 489-505]. The developmental-potential -of these cellswas tested, after prolonged culture and freezing and thawing, bymicroinjecting them into early (blastocyst stage) embryos of theC57BL/6 (black) strain. Among 312 experimental animals exam-ined at 1 week ofage, there were 41 mice (21 females and 20 males)that displayed the coat colors ofboth strains. This frequency (13%),as well as the extent of the coat areas derived from the cell line,greatly surpasses the contributions observed in all previous ex-periments, whether with other in vitro teratocarcinoma cell linesor with in vivo transplant lines. The developmental totipotency ofMETT-1 cells became evident from the presence of substantialamounts of 129-strain cells (bearing an isozyme marker) in all in-ternal tissues of an individual whose coat was largely agouti. Theculture-cell lineage also proved to be capable of giving rise to re-productively functional oocytes. Of nine mosaic-coat females test-mated to C57BL/6 males, one produced progeny of the diagnosticagouti color in two litters; these heterozygous F1 offspring in turntransmitted their marker genes to F2 homozygous segregants.Thus, the METT-1 teratocarcinoma line bridges the gap betweenin vitro cell propagation and in vivo development and between thesoma and the germ line. This creates the option of producing newmouse strains with predetermined genetic changes designed asprobes ofdevelopmental regulation or as models ofhuman geneticdiseases.

Mouse teratocarcinoma cells from some transplanted tumorsand culture lines have been experimentally channeled into nor-mal development, to a greater or lesser extent (1-4), by placingthem in early (blastocyst stage) embryos. Although the cells ofone in vitro line (NG 2) have proved capable of contributing toall somatic tissues under these circumstances (5), germ-cell dif-ferentiation and progeny have resulted only from two in vivotransplant lines, both of which had appreciable subpopulationsof cells with a normal karyotype (1, 2, 6). Of a total of three an-imals with tumor-strain germ cells and offspring, two weremales from a chromosomally male (X/Y) ascites line (OTT 6050,of the 129 inbred strain) and one was a female from a chro-mosomally female (X/X) solid-tumor line (72484-395, of the LT

strain). Cell culture lines, on the other hand, have shown var-ious karyotypic anomalies that-even in the best-developingcase (5), characterized by a trisomy (6)-would be incompatiblewith production of viable offspring (7).

Realization ofthe scheme that has been proposed for utilizingcultured teratocarcinoma cells as vehicles for introducing pre-selected new genotypes into mice (8-10) therefore depends onfirst obtaining an in vitro line with not only somatic but alsogerminal totipotency. Specific genetic changes could then beintroduced during the culture phase, incorporated into entireanimals, and transmitted to subsequent generations. Terato-carcinoma stem cells with selected mutations (e.g., refs. 5, 11,and 12) or stem cells that have incorporated cloned foreigngenes (13) have in fact been successfully isolated from culturesand found to have retained the capacity for somatic develop-ment. It remains for a culture line with germinal potential tobecome available.A candidate cell line, designated METT-1, was recently es-

tablished here for the purpose (14). It was obtained from anembryo-derived malignant teratocarcinoma of the 129/Sv (or129) agouti-colored inbred strain. Its promising features arekaryotypic normalcy (the chromosomal sex is X/X female), sta-bility, feeder-independence, and ability to differentiate in cul-tures or tumors. We now report that METT-1 cells can form allsomatic tissues in host embryos; and they can also producegerm-line progeny, even after more than 100 cell doublings invitro, and after freezing and thawing. Thus, the cells of this linecan bridge the gap between asexual propagation in vitro andsexual reproduction in vivo-the necessary preamble for en-gineering new mouse strains to be used as probes of develop-mental regulation or as models of human genetic diseases.

MATERIALS AND METHODSInjections into Blastocysts. Teratocarcinoma stem cells ofthe

METT-1 line (14) were used after they had been cultured fornine or more passages since the initial explant, frozen and storedin liquid nitrogen, thawed, and cultured for seven or more ad-ditional passages. The cells were then partly dissociated in0.25% trypsin-EDTA and Ca2"- and Mg2"-free phosphate-buf-fered saline and rinsed. Three to five cells were injected perblastocyst, of the C57BL/6 (or C57) inbred strain (Icr subline),as described (1). After a few hours' incubation in the cell-culturemedium (14), the blastocysts were surgically transferred to uteriof pseudopregnant Icr random-bred albino females for devel-opment to term.

Analyses of Tissue Genotypes. The agouti-locus hair-folliclemarker enabled donor-derived (agouti) areas to be distinguishedfrom blastocyst-derived (nonagouti, or black) regions in the

Abbreviations: GPI, glucosephosphate isomerase; MUP, major urinaryprotein complex.*To whom reprint requests should be addressed.

The publication costs ofthis article were defrayed in part by page chargepayment. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertise-ment" in accordance with 18 U. S. C. §1734 solely to indicate this fact.

6314

Dow

nloa

ded

by g

uest

on

Dec

embe

r 9,

202

0

Page 2: Successive of. cultureline teratocarcinoma · Downloaded by guest on May 2, 2020 6314. Developmental Biology: StewartandMintz coats of1-week-oldanimals. TheAW, orso-called white-bellied

Developmental Biology: Stewart and Mintz

coats of 1-week-old animals. The AW, or so-called white-belliedagouti, allele in the 129 strain produces a relatively light (notwhite) ventrum compared with the standard agouti. Homoge-nates of internal tissues were tested by starch gel electropho-resis for Gpi-l-locus strain variants of the ubiquitous enzymeglucosephosphate isomerase (GPI; D-glucose-6-phosphate ke-tol-isomerase, EC 5.3.1.9) (15). Blood-cell lysates were ana-lyzed by electrophoresis in cellulose acetate (Cellogel) forhemoglobin variants (Hbb locus) (16) or, in a few cases, for GPIisozymes. Liver genotypes were revealed in living animals bytesting urine samples for variants of the major urinary proteincomplex (MUP) synthesized in hepatocytes and encoded by theMup-1 locus. The polyacrylamide gel procedure described forMUP (17) was modified in that the urine was first dialyzedagainst the running buffer for 12 hr, and the vertical gel elec-trophoresis apparatus was replaced by a thinner (1.2 mm) slabgel; these changes resulted in minor modifications in the proteinpatterns.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Survival and development to birth occurred in 31% (390/1258)of the injected and surgically transferred blastocysts. This ratecompares favorably with the 26% (48/183) survival to term ob-tained in an earlier experiment (also involving injections ofthreeto five nonmutant teratocarcinoma cells ofthe 129 strain) in thislaboratory (1); the present yield is all the more noteworthy in-asmuch as the cells were from an established line that hadundergone many cell doublings in culture, as well as freezingand thawing (Fig. 1), whereas the cells in the previous studyhad never been cultured and were taken directly from the as-cites embryoid bodies of transplant hosts.

The decision was made to abridge the search for 129-straintissue contributions in the large experimental population bybasing the initial screening on the most readily detectedmarker-agouti color in the coat. Animals with coat mosaicismwere then further analyzed. Only a limited number of all-blackindividuals were screened for internal mosaicism; inasmuch assome positive cases were found, it is likely that additional pos-itives escaped detection.

Proc. NatL Acad. Sci. USA 78 (1981) 6315

The recognition ofcases with culture-derived cells was prob-ably also skewed toward underestimation by the effects ofa se-vere and prolonged pandemic of Sendai virus infection in theanimal colony during the period that most ofthe animals in thisseries were born. The 129 strain has been found to be by far themost sensitive to Sendai virus infection, among many strainstested (18). Young animals are at especially high risk, as wasevident among controls. Thus, mosaic individuals with appre-ciable numbers of 129-strain cells may well have been morevulnerable than animals from the same experiment with onlyC57BL/6 cells. Characteristic lung lesions were revealed in anumber ofexperimental animals at autopsy. Attrition remainedhigh until a stringent vaccination and isolation program beganto take effect. Meanwhile, the size of the experimental popu-lation had dropped from 390 at birth to 312 at 1 week and 242at 4 weeks of age; many that died were no longer suitable forGPI tissue analyses.

At 1 week of age, despite the handicap to the 129 strain, asmany as 41 animals (21 females and 20 males), or 13% ofthe 312survivors, clearly had areas of agouti hairs characteristic of the129 strain in their coats (Fig. 2). Agouti and nonagouti (black)components varied in extent. In regions that were not too heav-ily agouti, the individual narrow transverse bands representinghair-follicle clones could be seen, as in patterns found in allo-phenic mice produced by aggregating blastomeres oftwo strainswith agouti-locus markers (19). This frequency of cases withtumor-lineage contributions in the coat is notably high in com-parison with all earlier experiments. In this laboratory, com-bined results from blastocyst injections with euploid teratocar-cinoma cells ofthe OTT 6050 (129-strain) transplant line yielded8%, and those with euploid tumor transplant sublines of the LTstrain gave 6% of survivors with coat mosaicism (refs. 1-3; un-published data). In other laboratories, the OTT 6050 ascitestransplant line yielded only 1 coat mosaic (out of 60 mice) (4);various aneuploid cell culture lines gave 0-4% (3, 20, 21); andthe euploid C145b culture line yielded none (22). Moreover,the actual number, 41, of coat mosaics (among our 312 mice)is much greater than the grand total of all previous studies com-bined (estimated, from the available reports, at approximately22 mice among some 1000 animals examined).

FIG. 1. Diagrammatic summary, starting at the upper right, of the experiment. A malignant teratocarcinoma arose from a 6-day embryo ofthe agouti-colored 129 inbred mouse strain that had been grafted under the testis capsule of a syngeneic host. The solid tumor was dissociated andexplanted (without a feeder layer); it yilded a culture line of teratocarcinoma stem cells. The line, later designated METT-1, was karyotypicallynormal and chromosomally female (X/X) (14). The cells were frozen and stored in liquid nitrogen. After thawing, propagation in culture continued(in this case, until a total of approximately 112 cell doublings since explantation). Blastocysts of the C57BL/6 (black) strain were then microirnectedwith cells from the culture, and the embryos were transferred to the uterus of a pseudopregnant foster mother for development to term. One of thetwo-color (striped) mosaic females that was born had tumor-derived normal cells (along with embryo-derived cells) in her germ line (and othertissues): when she was mated to a C57 male, she produced some F1 progeny with the dominant agouti color of the 129 strain. A subsequent matingbetween an F1 female and an F1 male (both heterozygous for marker genes) yielded F2 offspring among which were segregants homozygous for thetumor-strain alleles. These animals are wild-type models of a "new strain" that might be similarly derived from METT-1 cells with a preselectedspecific mutation of interest.

Dow

nloa

ded

by g

uest

on

Dec

embe

r 9,

202

0

Page 3: Successive of. cultureline teratocarcinoma · Downloaded by guest on May 2, 2020 6314. Developmental Biology: StewartandMintz coats of1-week-oldanimals. TheAW, orso-called white-bellied

6316 Developmental Biology: Stewart and Mintz

I

a b c d e ;¢FIG. 2. Five examples of animals experimentally produced from C57 blastocysts injected with cultured teratocarcinoma stem cells of the es-

tablished METT-1 line. All five (four females, one male) show appreciable amounts (30-75%, in these cases) of the agouti color of the tumor-celllineage (129 strain). (A sixth case is shown in Fig. 4.) Narrow transverse bands of agouti or black (nonagouti) hair-follicle clones (19), in which theagouti-locus genes are expressed, are visible in some areas. (All the animals have additional agouti on the back.)

Even more striking is the fact that, in most of the two-coloranimals from this METT-1-cell series, the proportion oftumor-lineage cells in their coats is substantially greater than has beenfound in comparable experimental animals produced with ter-atocarcinoma cells from other sources. Most of the latter havecontributed 10% or less of the tumor-strain color, whereas theanimals in the present study average 28% agouti: 15 mice wereindividually graded as having 5-15% agouti, 17 had grades rang-ing from 20% to 35%, 3 had from 40% to 55%, 5 had from 60%to 75%, and 1 had 85% agouti. Only one mouse in any earlierreport (1) has exceeded this, with a grade of90%. Examples ofMETT-1-derived animals with 30-75% agouti coats are shownfrom the ventral or side view in Fig. 2; all have additional agoution the back.

Developmental totipotency of the METT-I cells was re-vealed by GPI analyses of internal tissues from the mouse with85% agouti in its coat. All 12 tissues tested had substantialamounts of the 129-strain enzyme variant (Fig. 3); amountsranged from an estimated 10% in the pancreas to 65% in thebrain, and averaged 43% overall. It is of interest that approxi-mately 40% of the reproductive tract (including ovaries, ovi-ducts, and uteri) was of the tumor-strain type. Although suchisozymic indicators are not specific for the germ cells (23), theresult is consistent with the possibility that the animal, a female,was a germinal mosaic with some oocytes from the teratocar-cinoma-cell lineage. The mouse was not mated; it died at 11 daysofage, apparently a victim ofSendai virus infection. The METT-1 cells used to produce this animal from an injected blastocyst

U,

0O 's a

O -0CL

U,CIOa)

0)cco

C -6:30DE -

a) >1 CU c: C> a) aC-> - %D

had a history of 9 passages in culture before freezing in liquidnitrogen and 13 passages after thawing-the total comprisingapproximately 80 cell doublings in vitro during which totipo-tency had been retained.

Functional germ cells of the 129 strain could occur here onlyin phenotypic females: the X/X constitution ofthe METT-1 cellline would preclude formation of gametes in males (23). Nineof the two-color females remained healthy to breeding age andwere test-mated to C57BL/6 males. Progeny from any METT-1-derived oocytes would thus be agouti-the dominant color.The nine had a total of329 offspring (19-52 per female) duringthe test period. One ofthe mosaic females, whose coat was 65%agouti (Fig. 4), did in fact produce 3 all-agouti babies (out of48total progeny): 2 females in her second litter and 1 male in herfifth litter. Both F1 females were mated at sexual maturity withtheir agouti male sib and have had normal F2 offspring that in-cluded agouti animals. Members of the successive generationsare shown in Fig. 4. The characteristic light-bellied agouti phe-notype of the 129 strain is visible in the F1 and F2. The conti-nuity oftheir germ line is thus traceable to embryo-derived (24)~~~~~

-6>1 CDa) 0 C

-o coc .- -uvIk Ef D w

C57

129 *

FIG. 3. GPI allelic strain variants in starch gel electrophoresis oftissue extracts from an experimental female whose coat was 85%agouti. All 12 internal tissues tested included cells derived from theculture-line source, as sen with the GPI marker. Teratocarcinomastem cells of the MEIT-1 line are here developmentally totipo-tent-i.e., they can be normalize and contribute to development ofall tissues (see also Fig. 4) in an embryo environment.

FIG. 4. Three successive generations of mice linked by reproduc-tively functional germ cells traceable to the MEIT-1 culture line ofteratocarcinoma (somatic) cells. The female at the left, whose coat hassome agouti clones of the 129 (tumor-strain) color, was mated to a C57black male and produced the all-agouti F1 offspring in thecenter. TheF2 agouti animal, at the right, also exhibits the color of the tumorstrain that was transmitted from the Fl. The relatively light belly inthe F1 and F2 is the characeristic phenotype oftheAw allele in the 129strain.

!IW "k

Proc. Nad Acad. Sci. USA 78 (1981)

Dow

nloa

ded

by g

uest

on

Dec

embe

r 9,

202

0

Page 4: Successive of. cultureline teratocarcinoma · Downloaded by guest on May 2, 2020 6314. Developmental Biology: StewartandMintz coats of1-week-oldanimals. TheAW, orso-called white-bellied

Developmental Biology: Stewart and Mintz

neoplastic somatic cells (25) grown in culture (14)-ihis nstance, for 9 passages, followed by freezing and prolonged storage in liquid nitrogen, thawing, and 20 more culture passages-or for a total ofsome 112 cell-doublings in vitro. Durin~that time, although the cells' genes functioned in the transformed mode, and most ofthe genes were silent, their capacit)for normally regulated expression had apparently remainedintact.

Transmission of specific genes from METT-I cultured cells(via a mosaic female) to F1 heterozygotes and F2 homozygotesin the present instance involves only the 129-strain wild-typealleles. Nevertheless, recovery ofthose alleles serves as a modelfor experiments in which tumor cells with preselected muta-tions might function as "surrogate great-grandmothers" ofa newhomozygous mouse strain. (A new strain with forced hetero-zygosity at the locus ofinterest could ofcourse be initiated ear-lier, from the F1.) Thus, although the diffuse hemoglobin typeof the 129 strain was not found in the germinal mosaic female(whose erythrocytes were entirely of the single or C57 hemo-globin type and therefore all blastocyst-derived), those of hergerm cells that were tumor-derived did transmit the diffusehemoglobin allele to all their F1 descendants and, from these,to homozygous diffuse animals segregating in the F2 (Fig. 5Left). Similarly, the MUP variant ofthe tumor strain was absentfrom the urine of the germinal mosaic female, whose liver atautopsy also contained only C57 cells (with the GPI marker);yet her tumor-lineage oocytes generated F1 heterozygotes (Fig.5 Right). (MUP tests have not yet been carried out on the F2mice.)

Following these demonstrations of germinal as well as so-matic developmental totipotency, the cell line was assigned thedesignation METI7-1, signifying that it is the first in vitro lineof "Mouse Euploid Totipotent Teratocarcinoma" cells.

Seven internal tissues of the germinal mosaic two-color fe-male contained GPI of the 129 strain (Fig. 6 Left). (The testednegative tissues, in addition to blood and liver, were thymus,heart, muscle, and salivary gland.) Note that her ovaries showapproximately 50% of the 129 type. Two other mosaic-coat fe-males also had substantial GPI ofthe cell-line type in their ova-ries (Fig. 6 Right), although one ofthese did not reach breedingage and the other (shown in Fig. 2a) developed severe pneu-monitis (resembling that in Sendai infections) and producedonly 33 offspring. Either of these two, or a third case alreadydiscussed (Fig. 3), may have had normal germ cells of the 129strain.A panel of 12 internal tissues (as in Fig. 3) was analyzed from

rid CY) >0LO cm >, C\J

Proc. Natd, Acad. Sci. USA 78 (1981) 6317

U)

0L)

k-

r-

i-

9

yd

s

s

a

I

v

b ° b

LO LO C\! >!LI) C)o

FIG. 5. (Left) Electrophoretic separation of hemoglobin variantsin cellulose acetate shows that the erythrocytes of the germinal mosaic(G.M.) female (in Fig. 4) were all like those of C57 controls (lane 1) andtherefore blastocyst-derived. But her F1 (agouti) progeny with thehemoglobin pattern of hybrid controls (as in control lane 3) must havecome from tumor-strain germ cells. In the F2 generation, segregantsof the pure 129-type (as in control lane 2) occurred. (Right) The elec-trophoretic pattern, in polyacrylamide gel, of urinary proteins (MUP)produced in the liver are similarly only of the C57-control type in thegerminal mosaic (G.M.) female; the hybrid-control pattern in her F1agouti offspring confirms that they originated from tumor-lineagegerm cells. Sex differences in the patterns are hormone-mediated (17).

U)

Ca7 (D . CD C.)Q~ D Cv c0 a) a06' 0LoC CL

U) UC

0 0co CU3

0 0

057 __w129

FIG. 6. (Left) Starch gel electrophoretic separation of GPI in tissueextracts from the germinal mosaic female in Fig. 4 reveals some con-tribution from the tumor strain (129) in all tissues shown, includingthe ovaries and combined oviduct (od.) and uterus (ut.). (Right) Tumor-derived contributions are seen in the ovaries of two other females.

each of 38 mice with coat-color mosaicism; the 3 remaining an-inals had died and their tissues could not be analyzed becauseof autolysis. For each tissue, the number of cases of mosaicism(and the range of percentages of the 129 strain) was as follows:

? blood, three cases with both 129- and C57-strain cells (5-40%129-type); spleen, five (15-50%); pancreas, three (10%); liver,one (15%); thymus, three (15-40%); heart, seven (15-60%);lungs, three (10-20%); gonads, four (35-50%); kidneys, two(20-55%); muscle, seven (15-55%); brain, nine (10-65%); sal-ivary gland, two (10-55%). Among these 38 mice, 17 had nodetectable mosaicism in tissues other than the coat. This mightbe accounted for by the fact that all but 1 ofthe 17 had the lowestgrades of agouti in their coats (e.g., 9 had only 5-15% agouti).In the coat, small amounts of agouti are readily seen, whereaswith the GPI test small amounts ofone strain distributed amongvarious tissues could easily be missed. There is a slight tendencyfor the mice with higher grades ofagouti in the coat to have moreinternal tissues in which some 129-strain cells are present.However, there are inconsistencies in approximately one-fifthofthe cases-e.g., a mouse with 70% agouti in the coat and onlyone other tissue (heart) with mosaicism; and one with only 20%agouti but four internal mosaic tissues.

Fifteen all-black animals were analyzed and some 129-typeGPI was found in the tissues of four. Mosaicism also occurredin 2 of 12 neonates.A tumor was seen in only one animal in the entire study. It

was a large teratocarcinoma in the lower abdominal cavity. In-vasion of the dorsal musculature and small metastases in thelung attested to the malignant character ofthe source cells. Thetumor, which was ofthe 129 genotype, as expected, had formedin an animal with 35% agouti in the coat and no other 129-straintissues. Presumably, one of the few cells injected into the blas-tocyst had failed to be integrated into the host embryo and hadtherefore remained malignant.The more common event-completely normal embryogen-

esis of MEIT-1 cells in blastocysts-is at least partly attribut-able to their normal karyotype. However, a normal-appearingkaryotype could mask many sorts ofgenetic changes that wouldbe deleterious to development. This in fact may have occurredin other euploid teratocarcinoma cell lines. Five euploid lineshave recently been reported. Of these, C145b (22), F1/9, and1009 all gave only negative results in blastocysts (21), and com-parable developmental assays have not been described for thePCC7-S (26) and PlO (27) cell lines.From our positive results with the METT-1 line, it is appar-

ent that prolonged exposure to a culture environment does notin itself impair the capacity for germinal development of thetumor lineage in host embryos. The frequency of animals withgerm-line contributions cannot be estimated from the availabledata, inasmuch as the single germinal mosaic case was found in

Dow

nloa

ded

by g

uest

on

Dec

embe

r 9,

202

0

Page 5: Successive of. cultureline teratocarcinoma · Downloaded by guest on May 2, 2020 6314. Developmental Biology: StewartandMintz coats of1-week-oldanimals. TheAW, orso-called white-bellied

6318 Developmental Biology: Stewart and Mintz

tests ofonly nine ofthe candidate females. The entire germ-cellpopulation in a mouse arises from so few primordial germ cells(approximately two to nine) (23), and so few mature gametes aretested in matings offemales, that tumor-strain gonia would haveto enter the germ line very early in order to be readily detected.Fortunately, however, even a single F1 offspring with the genechange of interest would be sufficient to derive a new strain.The MEIT-1 cell line might be used not only to convey pre-

selected mutant mouse genes to future generations but also tointroduce pure recombinant genes (13). As recently shown (28),recombinant DNAcan also be microinjected into eggs and somecopies can persist in intact form in the mice that develop. Theteratocarcinoma route offers the additional possibility of pre-selection of positive cells and precharacterization of the stateand integration site of the DNA while the cells are still in cul-ture. Thus, it may become possible to produce animals withpredesigned genetic changes for studies of development anddisease.

This work was supported by U.S. Public Health Service Grants HD-01646, CA-06927, and RR-05539 and by an appropriation from the Com-monwealth of Pennsylvania.

1. Mintz, B. & Illmensee, K. (1975) Proc. Nate Acad. Sci. USA 72,3585-3589.

2. Illmensee, K. & Mintz, B. (1976) Proc. NatL Acad. Sci. USA 73,549-553.

3. Papaioannou, V. E., McBurney, M. W., Gardner, R. L. & Ev-ans, M. J. (1975) Nature (London) 258, 70-73.

4. Brinster, R. L. (1974) J. Exp. Med. 140, 1049-1056.5. Dewey, M. J., Martin, D. W., Jr., Martin, G. R. & Mintz, B.

(1977) Proc. Nati Acad. Sci. USA 74, 5564-5568.6. Cronmiller, C. & Mintz, B. (1978) Dev. BioL 67, 465-477.7. Gropp, A. (1975) Clin. Genet. 8, 839.

8. Mintz, B. (1977) Brookhaven Symp. Biol 29, 82-95.9. Mintz, B. (1978) Harvey Lect. 71, 193-246.

10. Mintz, B. (1979) Differentiation 13, 25-27.11. Watanabe, T., Dewey, M. J. & Mintz, B. (1978) Proc. NatL Acad.

Sci. USA 75, 5113-5117.12. Reuser, A. J. J. & Mintz, B. (1979) Somat. Cell Genet. 5, 781-792.13. Pellicer, A., Wagner, E. F., El Kareh, A., Dewey, M. J., Reu-

ser, A. J., Silverstein, S., Axel, R. & Mintz, B. (1980) Proc. NatLAcad. Sci. USA 77, 2098-2102.

14. Mintz, B. & Cronmiller, C. (1981) Somat. Cell Genet. 7, 489-505.15. Gearhart, J. D. & Mintz, B. (1972) Dev. Biol 29, 27-37.16. Whitney, J. B., III (1978) Biochern. Genet, 16, 667-672.17. Wilcox, F. H. (1975) Biochem. Genet. 13, 243-245.18. Parker, J. C., Whiteman, M. D. & Richter, C. B. (1978) Infect.

Immun. 19, 123-130.19. Mintz, B. (1971) in Control Mechanisms of Growth and Differ-

entiation, ed. Balls, M. (Cambridge Univ. Press, London), Vol.25, pp. 345-369.

20. Papaioannou, V. E., Gardner, R. L., McBurney, M. W., Babi-net, C. & Evans, M. J. (1978) J. Embryot Exp. Morphot 44,93-104.

21. Papaioannou, V. E. (1979) in Cell Lineage, Stem Cells and CellDifferentiation, ed. Le Douarin, N. (Elsevier/North-Holland,Amsterdam), pp. 141-155.

22. Papaioannou, V. E., Evans, E. P., Gardner, R. L. & Graham, C.F. (1979) J. Embryol. Exp. Morphol. 54, 277-295.

23. Mintz, B. (1969) in Birth Defects: Original Article Series S (Na-tional Foundation, New York), pp. 11-22.

24. Stevens, L. C. (1970) Dev. Biol. 21, 364-382.25. Mintz, B., Cronmiller, C. & Custer, R. P. (1978) Proc. NatL

Acad. Sci. USA 75, 2834-2838.26. Fellous, M., Gunther, E., Kemler, R., Wiels, J., Berger, R.,

Guenet, J. L., Jakob, H. & Jacob, F. (1978) J. Exp. Med. 148,58-70.

27. McBurney, M. W. & Strutt, B. J. (1980) Cell 21, 357-364.28. Wagner, E. F., Stewart, T. A. & Mintz, B. (1981) Proc. Natl

Acad. Sci. USA 78, 5016-5020.

Proc. Nad Acad. Sci. USA 78 (1981)

Dow

nloa

ded

by g

uest

on

Dec

embe

r 9,

202

0