29

Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

������������ ���������������� ��� ����� �"!#�����$�% ��������'& �)(���� �

*,+.-0/�1$/ 243537698;:=<>+.6>?@64+A/CBEDGFIH=JK:=L$FIM@N@H=/�OP3KQ.QA/�698C:RFIH=B�S>TU+,V�WX/ YZ/�6\[])^`_�ab5c7dfe0gihKj\kle\m7j\eonpe\b5q�grdfae\msd9t7hIduq�m7v._�guwyxim5klz;e4gf{rk|d~}hsduq�m7v._�guw@t@^%�����;���;� �����K�9�It@xohK�

���%� e�hKj � _s_C�R_�v,^`_�ab5cKdfe4gihKj\kle\m7j\e>����m5�Cklm7e\e4gfklm5�KtU��e4�7gfe4��x�m7klz;e4gf{rk|d~}� e0gfc5{fq��le\a��K�\�C���7tU��{�guq�e\�

��npklzIkl{rkl_CmG_�v��,m7�Cklm5e\e0gfk�m7��q�m5wy�ib7b5�lkle9w�hIj\kle\m5j4e\{\tU��q�gfz�q�guw�x�m5klz;e0gf{rkld�}^%q�a$�7gfk�wK�CeCtU���'�; s�9��¡KtExph7�

¢�£�¤\¥\¦ §5¨C¥©%ªr«C¬u­C¬4®°¯ ®²±f³°®X´�ªfµ4¯l­�³°®°«�¶E­C¯%·P«9¸sµ4¯ ±º¹X»,¼ �y{u½¾q gfe�q)��q�m5��cUq��Ceyv._�g�wKe\{rj4gfkl�5klm5�

{�duq dfkl{�dfk�j\q���a_Iw7e\�l{i_�zCe4g�d�}7bEe\wygfe\��q�dfkl_Cm5q���w7_�a�q�klm5{\¿E� »�¼ �Àa_Iw7e4��{Ád � e�c5mK�j4e4grduq�klmsd~}¾_ z;e4g�d � e�q drdrgfk��7c7dfe\{,_�v@_��KÂ~e\j4df{Ãk�m¾d � e�w7_�a�q�klmq�mUw$c7m5j\e4grduq�klmId�}$_ z;e0gd � eÃgfe\��q dfk�_�m5{��Ee4d��%e\e\m>d � eÃ_C�IÂ�e\j0df{\¿ �%� e%a_Iw7e4�s{rbEe\j\k|ÄUe\{\t v._�g�e9q�j � q�drdrgfkl�5cKdfe`_�vq�m_C�IÂ�e\j0d9tIkldf{ ¹ b7gf_��Uq��7kl��kl{�dfklj ½,w7e\bEe\m5w7e\m7j\e�_Cm�_�d � e4g`q�drdrgfkl�5cKdfe\{,_�v=d � q�dÃ_C�IÂ�e4j4dq�mUw�_�m�q drdrgfkl�5c7dfe4{�_�v�gfe\��q dfe9wG_C�IÂ�e\j4df{\¿ �%� e¾wKe\bEe\m5w7e\m7j\e>a_Iw7e\�Rk�{pw7e4Ä5m5e9w�q dd � ep�le\z;e\�@_�v ´\¯l­�±f±4µ0± _�vZ_C�IÂ�e\j4df{\¿ �%� eoj4�Aq�{r{Áw7e\bEe\m5w7e\m7j\e�a_IwKe\�@kl{�k�m7{�duq�msdfk�q�dfe9wv._�giq�ms}�_C�IÂ�e4j4dÁk�m�d � epj4�Aq�{r{\tUq�{Áq�b5bKgf_CbKgfkAq dfepdf_¾d � epbUq grdfk�j4c5��q�gÁj\_�mIdfe0ÅKd�_�vZd � e_��KÂ~e\j4d ¹ k°¿ eC¿ltsd � e�gfe\��q�dfkl_�m5{��Ee4d��%e\e\md � k�{Ã_C�IÂ�e\j0df{�q�m5w�_�d � e4gf{u½0¿ »,¼ �y{%j9q�m�q��l{r_gfe4b7gfe\{re\msd�c7m5j\e4grduq�klmId�}�_�zCe4g�d � e%gfe\��q dfk�_�mUq��5{�drgfc5j0dfc7gfe%k|df{re\�|v~t;eC¿ �7¿lt;�s}>{rbEe\j\k|vA}7klm7�q ¹ j\��q�{r{��Æ�le\z;e\�A½pb7gf_��Uq��7kl��k|d�}�d � q�dod~�`_�_C�IÂ�e4j4df{���kl�l�`�Ee¾gfe\��q�dfe9w�df_�e9q�j � _�d � e4g9¿»�¼ �y{`b7gf_ zIk�w7eiqpv²_Cc7mUw7q�dfkl_Cmv²_�g�w7e\q��lklm5�>��kld � d � eÁm7_Ckl{repq�mUwPc7m5j\e4grduq�klmId�}Pe\mK�j4_Cc5msdfe4gfe\w)klmºa_C{�digfe9q��|�X�%_�gf�Aw�w7_�a�q�klm5{\¿@��m)d � kl{pj � q�bKdfe4g9tE�%e¾{ � _9�'d � q dpd � ej4_CabUq�j4d�q�m5w�mUq dfc7guq��,gfe\bKgfe\{re\msduq�dfkl_�m�_�v »�¼ �y{�q����l_9��{¾d � e\aÇdf_��Ee�le9q gfm5e9wwKk|gfe\j4df�|}�vAgf_CaÀq�m�e4ÅKkl{�dfklm5��gfe\��q dfk�_�mUq���w5q�duq��Uq�{re�c7{rk�m7���%e\�l�|�Xv²_�c5mUwKe9w�{�duq�dfkl{�dfk|�j\q��Zdfe\j � m7kAÈsc7e\{\¿E�~mGd � k�{ij � q�bKdfe4g9tE�%e¾�Cklz;e¾q�mºk�msdrgf_IwKc5j4dfkl_CmGdf_ »,¼ �y{pq�mUw)q�m_ z;e0gfzKkle4�É_�vpae0d � _Iw7{�v²_�g�le9q�gfm7k�m7��d � e\a�¿ZÊ�e�{ � _9�Ëd � q�d »�¼ �y{b7gf_ zIkAwKeyqm7e4�Ìv.guq�ae0�%_�gfÍ�v²_�gÃgfe\��q dfk�_�mUq��@w5q�duqpaklm7k�m7�7tCq�m5w$_�Î@e4gÃm5e0�Ïj � q����le\m7�Ce\{,v²_�g`d � ee4mUw7e\q zC_�g�_�v��le9q gfm5klm5�¾gfe\��q�dfkl_Cm5q��Za_IwKe\�l{%v²_�gÁgfe9q��l�X�`_�gf��wGw7_�a�q�klm5{\¿

Ð�ÑuÐ�Ò7ÓiÔEÕ@Öo×�ؾÙÚÔ@ÛfÖÁÓ

Üo/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ�Dy3EBE/�Q.-�FI64/�24N@/GD�37-u2�Ý 3KD�D�3KHÏ64/�M@64/�-0/�H524FI20+.3KHÞ3IW�-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/�BàB@FI24F@áâ�H524/�64M@60+²-0/�ã@ß=-0+AH=/�-4->+.HEWX3K64DGFs20+.3KH,:=DGFI64äK/�20+.H@åºFIHRBæ-0FKQA/C-�B@FI24F=:=D�/�BE+²Ý�FKQÃ64/�Ý�3K6\B@-�:FIHRB�-4Ý +./�H520+AçRÝpB@FI24FK-0/ 2\-%FI64/�FKQAQ@-u203760/CB�+.H�64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQEB@FI24FIãRFK-0/�-�áCâ�YÚ376u2\-,243P/ èU206\FKÝ 2äUH@3séoQ./�BEå7/PWX6037DêMRFI6020+²FIQ.QAë�-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/�BíìÆ/Ká å=á.:Rî$ïæ*Ãð>3K6>/�TK/�H�64F;éñ20/�è52PB@Fs2\F)FIQ²-03FI+.Dò243/ èU206\FKÝ 2�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ5+.HEWX3760DGFs24+A37H�áIÜo/CÝ /�H524QAë7:s20N@/�60/oNRFK-%ãÚ/�/�H�å7603séo+.H@å$+AH520/�6uó/�-u2¾+.Hæ/�è52464F7Ý924+AH@åG+.H520/�60/C-f24+AH@å�-f2\Fs20+²-u20+²Ý�FIQÃM=Fs2020/�60H=-�WX643KDô20N@/C-u/�NUß@å7/�FID�37ß@H524->3KWB@FI24F@á@õpN=/�-0/M=Fs2020/�64H=-pM@643sTU+.B@/$F�BE/�/�MÚ/�6oß@H=B@/�6\-f2\FIH=BE+.H@å�3IW`20N=/PB@3KDGFI+.H�FIH=Bº20N@/64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHR-uN@+.M=-$+.HÌ+A2�á�örHàFKB@BE+A20+.3KH,:Ú/�èU206\FKÝ924/�BÌM=Fs2020/�64H=-PÝ�FKHÌãÚ/�ß=-u/CB�WX376$64/�F7Ý\N@+.H@åÝ 37H=Ý Q.ß=-0+A37H=-oFIãÚ3Kß@2p+.D�MR376u2\FIH52�Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-péoN@37-0/PT;FKQAß=/�-pDGF;ë)ãÚ/ß@H@3KãR-u/�60T7/�B�á

Page 2: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

¡ � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

V�643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý�FKQEDy3EBE/�Q.-�:7FKH=ByM=FI6020+²Ý ß=Q.FK60Q.ë��pF;ëK/C-u+²FIHyH@/ 2fé�3K64äE-p:IN=F;T7/ãÚ/�/�H�-uN=3séoHí203ÏãR/�FæßR-u/�WXß@Qpé�F;ëÏ3IW�64/�M=60/C-u/�H724+AH=åÌ-f2\Fs24+.-u20+²Ý�FKQiM=FI2u24/�64H=-y+AH�64/�FKQ�óé�3K64Q.B�BE37D�FK+AHR-�áIÜo/CÝ /�H72iéi3760ä��Ká��U: 7á���ÚB@/�TK/�QA37M=-`20/CÝ\N@H@+��5ß@/�-%WX376�Q./�FI64H@+.H@å$20N@/C-u/D�3EBE/�Q²-oBE+.60/CÝ920Q.ëGWX643KD B@FI24F=:@FIH=B�-uN=3sé>-�24N=Fs2o+.H724/�64/�-u20+.H@å�M=Fs2020/�60H=-�3KW°20/�H�/�D�/�60å7/+.Hº24N@+.-pQ./�FK60H=+AH@å�M@643UÝ�/�-4-�á��>3sé�/�T7/�6C:5FKQAQZ3KW�20N@/C-u/$Q./�FI64H@+.H@å�24/�Ý\N@H=+��5ß@/C-oFIM@M@Q.ëG3KH=QAë203��RFI2uó~ç=QA/y64/�M@64/�-0/�H524FI20+.3KH=->3IW�24N@/yB=Fs24F=:�FIH=B�H=3I2$203�20N@/y60+²Ý\N@/�6�64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHRFIQ%B@Fs2\F/�HRÝ 3Kß=H724/�64/�B�+.H)DGFIHUë�FIM@M@Q.+²Ý�Fs24+A37H=-�á7S>Hº3KãUTU+A37ß=-�-03KQ.ßE20+.3KHG+²-�243�24FKäK/>F�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQB@FI24FIãRFK-0/�FKH=B����RFI2u24/�H��à+A2�:ÁÝ�60/CFs24+AH@åíF��RFI2Gç=Q./�3KH'éoN@+²Ý\N'-u24FKH=B@FK64B��pF;ëK/�-0+²FIHH@/�2féi3760äÞQA/CFI64H@+AH=åæFIQ.åK3K64+A20N@DG-Ý�FKHíãR/º60ß@H,áÃS�-�éi/)B@+.-4Ý ß=-4-�+.H��U/CÝ920+.3KH 7á�!E:�20N=+.-FIM=M@6035FKÝ\N�N=FK-o-0/�T7/�6\FIQZ+AD�MÚ3K6024FKH72>-0N@3K6024Ý�3KD�+.H@å7-�á"$#&%�')(�'+*-,.*�/�01*324#&5+,(607*3%689(6,;:<%>=�5+,�/àì�VÁÜ>ïÌ-4ð�FK60/�FÌ64/�Ý�/�H52)BE/�T7/�Q.3KM@D�/�H72?�Ká�>�U:

Ká�@BA@:CKá�@BDE��24N=Fs2/ èU24/�H=BÌ20N@/G-u24FKH=B@FI6\BÌFI2u2460+.ã@ßE24/ ó�ã=FK-0/�B��pF;ëK/�-0+²FIH�H@/�2féi3760ä�64/�MEó64/�-0/�H524FI20+.3KH�243�+.H=Ý 3760MÚ3K6\Fs24/�F)D�ß=Ý\NÌ64+²Ý\N@/�6$60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQÃ-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/Ká�õpN@/�-0/�D�3EBE/�Q.-FIQ.Q.3sé 20N@/�-0MR/CÝ +AçRÝ�FI20+.3KH�3KW¾FÞM@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+�2fëàD�3EBE/�Q�WX376?2+,(6/F/+5G/�3KW�3Kã Hf/�Ý92\-�6\Fs24N@/�620NRFIHñ-0+.DyM=QA/ÏFs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-JIÁ24N@/�ë�FKQ.-03�FIQ.Q.3séêM=6037MR/�6u24+A/C-)3IW�FKH /�H524+�2fë�203�BE/�MÚ/�HRBM@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+²-f24+.Ý�FIQ.QAëP37H�M@643KMÚ/�6020+./�-Ã3IW=3K20N@/�6K#F5G,(B0L5)=�/�H520+A20+./�-�ásõpN@/�M@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+.-u20+²ÝÁÝ�Q.F7-0-D�3EBE/�Q@64/�M=60/C-u/�H72\-%F¾å7/�H@/�60+²ÝpBE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�/K:IéoN=+.Ý\Ny+.-�20N@/�Hy+.H=-u24FKH724+.FI20/CB�WX376�-uMÚ/�Ý�+�çRÝÝ +.6\Ý ß@DG-u24FIHRÝ /�-�:K+~á /Ká.:KWX376ÁM=FK6u24+.Ý�ß@Q.FK6Á-0/ 24-Á3IW�/�H724+�24+A/C-ÁFKH=BG64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHR-�ãR/�2féi/�/�HG24N@/�D�áMÏ/�N=F;TK/�B@/�TK/�QA37MR/CB�Dy/�20N@3EB@-�WX3K6�QA/CFI64H@+AH=å)VÁÜ>ïæ-�BE+A64/�Ý 20Q.ëºWX643KD -u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/CB

B@FI24F�-uß=Ý\NÏFK-$64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHRFIQÃB=Fs24FKã=FK-0/�-�áZõpN@/�2fé�3�äK/�ë�2\FK-0äU-$+.Hæ24N@/GÝ 3KHR-f2460ß=Ý 20+.3KHæ3KWFIHUë�-f2\Fs24+.-u20+²Ý�FKQ@D�3UB@/�QRFK60/oD�3EBE/�QR-0/�Q./�Ý924+A37H)FIH=B�MRFI6\FID�/ 24/�6�/�-u20+.DGFs24+A37H�á�MÏ/>N=F;T7/BE/�TK/�Q.3KMÚ/�B�FKQAå73K64+�24N@DG-ÁWX376>/�F7Ý\N�3KWÃ24N@/�-0/P24F7-uäE-�á@õpN@/�-0/�FIQ.åK3760+A20N=D�-pFK60/Pã=F7-u/CBº37H20N=/p-4FID�/iß@H=BE/�60Q.ëU+AH@å¾M@64+AH=Ý�+AM=QA/C-,24N=Fs2%åK3sT7/�64H$20N@/pQ./�FI64H@+.H@å>3KWN�pF;ëK/�-0+²FIHH@/�2féi3760äE-�á

S QA/CFI64H@/�B�ViÜ>ï M@643sTU+.B@/�-`F�-u24Fs24+.-u20+²Ý�FKQ7D�3EBE/�Q724N=Fs2�Ý�FKH�ß@HRÝ 3sTK/�6ÃFKH=B�BE+²-0Ý�3sTK/�6DGFIHUëº+.H520/�60/C-f24+AH@å�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ý¾BE/�MR/�H=BE/�H=Ý +./�-p24N=Fs2¾N@3KQ²Bº+.H�F�BE3KDGFI+.H�á�O�H@Q.+Aä7/�F-0/ 2�3IW%ìXM@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ý�ðÃ60ß=QA/C-`WX3K6�Ý Q²FK-4-0+�çRÝ�Fs24+A37H�:sVÁÜ>ïæ-�-0MÚ/�Ý +AWXë�FKHf37+AH52�BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H3sTK/�6�F�64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHRFIQRB@3KDGFI+.H�áEõpNUß=-�:UQ.+Aä7/P�pF;ë7/�-0+.FKHGH@/ 2fé�3K64äE-�:720N@/�ë)Ý�FKHºãÚ/$ßR-u/CBGWX3K6FIHR-ué�/�64+AH=åQ�5ß@/�64+A/C-�FKãR37ßE2GFIHUëíFK-0MR/CÝ92�3IW>24N@/�B@3KDGFI+.H�å7+AT7/�H�FKH5ëí-0/ 2�3IW�37ã=-0/�60óTsFs24+A37H=-�á@?=ß@6020N@/�60D�3K64/K:U6\Fs24N@/�6p24N=FIH�2064ëU+AH@åy243yM=60/CBE+.Ý 2o3KH@/PM=FK6u24+.Ý�ß@Q.FK6oFs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/K:20N=/)VÁÜ>ï Q./�FI64H@+.H@å�FIQ.åK3760+A20N@D FI2u24/�D�ME24-203�20/CFK-0/�3KßE224N@/GD�37-u2-0+.åKH@+AçRÝ�FKH52B@+�ó64/�Ý92�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�H=Ý +./�-%+.H�24N@/oB@Fs2\F@áIõpN@/�64/�-0ß@Q�24+AH=å$D�3EBE/�QU20NUß=-`M@643sT5+²BE/C-`F¾N@+.åKNEó�Q./�TK/�Q�:�5ß=FIQ.+A24Fs24+AT7/PM@+.Ý 20ß@64/P3IWÃ20N@/-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/$3IWÃ20N@/�B@3KDGFI+.H�:U+AH�F7B@BE+A20+.3KH�203�20N@/R�5ß=FKH724+�ó24FI20+.TK/¾+AHEWX3760DGFI20+.3KH)M@643sTU+.B@/�B�ãUëy20N@/$M@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+A2fë�B@+.-u2064+Aã=ßE20+.3KH�áUõpNUß=-�:5ViÜ>ïæ-�FI64/+²BE/�FKQAQ.ë�-0ß@+A20/�B�243$/�èEM@QA3764FI203760ë�FKH=FIQ.ëE-u+²-`3IWÚFB@3KDGFI+.HyFKH=By60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQEB@Fs2\F¾D�+.H@+.H@å=á

õpN@+²-iÝ\NRFIME24/�6�+.-p-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/CB)FK-ÁWX3KQ.Q.3sé>-�áSMÞ/$ãÚ/�åK+.H)ãUëGã@64+A/+�=ëG-uß=60T7/�ëU+AH=å�-u37D�/3IWR20N@/�WX37ß@H=B@FI20+.3KH=-`3KH�éoN@+²Ý\NyViÜ>ïæ-%FI64/Áã@ß=+AQA2JTIörH�20N=/�H=/ èU2Ã2fé�3P-u/CÝ920+.3KHR-�:;é�/iM@643IóTU+.B@/)-u37Dy/�ã=F7-u+²Ýyã=FKÝ\äUå76037ß@H=Bæ37HàM@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+.-u20+²ÝyD�3UB@/�Q²-FIH=BÏ64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHRFIQ%D�3UB@/�Q²-�áörH��E/�Ý924+A37H�7á UR:Ré�/yB@/ ç=H@/�VÁÜ�ïæ-PFIH=B�å7+AT7/�24N@/�+.6-u/�D�FKH520+²Ý�-�áRörHV�U/�Ý 20+.3KHW7á �ºé�/BE/C-0Ý�60+.ãR/pN@3sé�203PQA/CFI64H�FPVÁÜ�ï WX643KD�FKH�/�èU+²-u20+.H@å$B=Fs24FKã=FK-0/Ká;örH<�U/�Ý 20+.3KHXKá Y�é�/pBE/ ó-4Ý 64+AãÚ/�/�èUMÚ/�64+.Dy/�H524FIQÚ64/�-0ß@Q�2\-�WX376i-0/�T7/�6\FIQ=64/�FKQ�ó�é�3K64Q.B�BE37D�FK+AHR-�á�MÞ/PÝ 37H=Ý Q.ß=BE/¾éo+�24NF�BE+²-0Ý�ß=-4-u+.3KHÞ3IWp60/�Q.FI20/�BÞé�3K64äæFIH=BÏã@64+A/+�=ëæD�/�H524+A37HÏ-03KD�/�M@643KD�+.-0+.H@å�BE+A64/�Ý 20+.3KH=-WX3K6pWXß@20ß@64/éi3760äZá

Page 3: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{ �Ð�Ñ����ÌÕ=Ö�����¾Û�uÛ��KÔ@Û0Ù� ÇÖo×�����

õpN@/º206\FKBE+A20+.3KH=FKQ�Q.3KåK+²Ý9ó�ã=F7-u/CBÞFKM@M@6437FKÝ\NÞ203Ì60/�M@60/C-u/�H520+.H@å�äUH@3séoQA/CBEåK/�+²-243æéo60+A20/BE3séoH F�äUH@3séoQA/CBEåK/�ãRFK-0/Ì+.H�20N@/ÞWX3K64D 3IW�Q.3KåK+²Ý�FKQ¾FIèU+.3KDG-�FIãÚ3KßE2�20N@/àBE3KDGFK+AH�áõpN@/�ä5H=3séoQA/CBEåK/�ãRFK-0/�60/C-f2460+²Ý92\-o24N@/y-0/ 2$3IW�MÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./�é�3K64Q.B@-�:=376�D�3EBE/�Q²-�:=243)20N=37-0/Ý 37H=-0+.-u20/�H72$éo+�24Næ24N@/�FIèU+.3KDG-�áRS¾B@BE+A20+.3KH=FKQ,WÆF7Ý924-�� 20N@35-u/�20N=FI2PFK60/2460ß=/�+.HÌFIQ.QÃ3KW20N=/�-0/MR35-0-0+Aã=QA/Pé�3K64Q.B@-�� FK60/PQ.3Kå7+.Ý�FIQ.QAëG/�H72\FI+.QA/CBºãUëº20N@/äUH@3séoQ./�BEå7/¾ãRFK-0/Ká

örH�FÞ-f2\FIH=B@FK64BàQ.3Kå7+.Ý�FIQ�WX6\FID�/�éi3760äZ:�é�/�FK60/)64/�-u2064+²Ý920/CBÏ203Þ60/�M@60/C-u/�H520+.H@åæ3KH=QAëWÆFKÝ 24-�20N=FI2�FI64/G2460ß@/�FIã=-03KQ.ßE20/�QAë7áÃõpNUß=-�:�24N@+.-�WX6\FID�/�é�3K64äæ+²-�ß@HRFIã@Q./G203Ì60/�M@60/C-u/�H52FIHRBà60/CFK-03KHÏéo+�24N�ß@H=Ý�/�6024FI+.HíFIH=BàH=3K+²-uëÞ+AHEWX3760DGFI20+.3KH�á`õpN@+.-�+.-�Fæ-u+.åKH=+�çRÝ�FIH52�å7FKM+.Hæ20N=/y/�èEM@60/C-0-0+.TK/�MÚ3séi/�6¾3KW�20N@/yWX6\FID�/�é�3K64äZ:RFKH=BæF�D�FBHf3K6¾ã=FI6460+./�6�203�+�2\-$ß=-u/y+.HDGFIHUëæ64/�FKQ�ó�éi3760Q²B�FIM=M@QA+²Ý�FI20+.3KH=-�á O>H=Ý�/�6024FK+AH52fë�+²-Pß@H=F;TK37+.B=FIã@Q./�+.HÌ24N@/�60/CFIQ%é�3K64Q.B T3Kß=6�+AH@WX3K64D�FI20+.3KHà+²-�3IW°24/�Hí+.H=FKÝ�Ý ß@6\Fs24/GFIH=BíFKQAépF;ëE-¾+.H=Ý�3KD�M@Q./ 20/7:ÃFKH=BÏ3KH@Q.ëÏF�WX/�é3IW`20N=/ �u64ß@Q./�-F��24N=Fs2�é�/Pß=-0/PWX3K6>64/�F7-u37H@+AH=åyFK60/$2064ß@/+.H�FIQ.QÁìX376o/�TK/�H�Dy35-f29ð�3IW`20N@/MÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./�Ý�FK-0/�-�á

õpN@+²->Q.+AD�+A24FI20+.3KH�:RéoN@+.Ý\NÌ+.-¾Ý 64+�24+.Ý�FIQ�+.H�DGFIHUë�B@3KDGFI+.H=-�ìÆ/Ká å=á.:=D�/�B@+.Ý�FIQÃB@+.FKåKH@3Kó-0+.-\ð9:@NRFK-�QA/CB�3sTK/�6i20N=/Q.F7-f2>BE/CÝ�FKB@/¾243y20N@/64/�-0ß@64åK/�HRÝ /�3KW`M=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+.-u20+²Ý�64/�F7-u37H@+.H@å+.H�FK6u24+�çÚÝ +²FIQE+.H724/�Q.QA+.åK/�H=Ý /7áKV�643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fëP20N=/�3K64ë�D�3EBE/�Q²-%ß@H=Ý�/�6024FK+AH52fë�ãUë�F7-0-0+Aå7H@+.H@åFM@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fëP203P/�F7Ý\N�3KW=24N@/o-f2\Fs20/C-%3IWR20N@/pé�3K64Q.B�20N=FI2ÁFIH�FIåK/�H52%Ý�3KH=-0+.B@/�6\-,MÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./Káï�35-f2ÁÝ�3KD�D�3KH@Q.ë�+.H�M@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+.-u20+²Ý�60/CFK-03KH@+.H@åR:�24N@/�-0/>-u24Fs24/�-�FK60/�24N@/>-u/�2Á3IWZMÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./FK-4-0+Aå7H@D�/�H524-�3IW>TsFIQ.ß@/�-�203ÏFÌ-0/ 2�3KW (60701#�*3'�� 0 5�/)376�#&(B8 =�%B:��E(B#�*3(�'+,5G/\á��i37H=-0+.BE/�6�:WX3K6G/�è@FID�M@Q./K:�FÏ-u+.D�M@QA/�D�3EBE/�Qo3IW�24N@/�MR/�6uWX3760DGFKH=Ý /�3IWPFÏ-u20ßRBE/�H52G+AH�FÏÝ 37ß@64-0/KáõpN@/�60/PFI64/¾-0+�è)6\FIHRBE3KD TsFI64+.FKã@Q./�-JT��G8�0 5G,-,.*��S5+8 2)57:��R* 2�� ,.0�!�ìÆ3IW�24N@/Ý 3Kß=64-0/Cð :�";%>%J=#N5�/�0$#N(&%�5+#5:(' 89=�5+#)/)0 (689=E/*)Q(60 5G#�*3(B,r:,+,-�(B:." #&(�=�5ºFKH=B0/�%B: 5�1 %6#�%2" #&(�=�5Ká,3�W20N=/�-0/ÞTsFI64+²FIã@Q./�-�:4�G8�0 5G,-, *���5+8 2)57:5";%J%>=6#N5�/�07#�(8%�5+#U:>FIH=B9' 89=�5+#)/)0 (689=E/:)Q(B0L5+#�*3(6,FI64/PãR3U37QA/CFIHºTsFK60+²FIã@Q./�-�:;�R* 2�� ,.0�!�2\FIä7/�-pTsFIQ.ß@/�-�WX643KD9<�,%=1> : 5)=6*?� :@>BA�*��CAED5:=FIHRB+,-�(6:F" #&(�=�5àFKH=BG/�%B: 5�1 %6#�%H" #&(�=�5Þ2\FIäK/ÌT;FKQAß=/�-ºWX6037DI<=JLKNM�KPOKN�QKSR,D5áiõpN@/MÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./�éi3760Q²B@->FK60/�FKQAQÃMR35-0-0+.ã@QA/�F7-0-0+.åKH@D�/�H52\-o3IW�TsFIQ.ß@/�->203G24N@/�-0/�TsFI64+²FIã@Q./�-�:�Y�A�Aì1@5T @*T?@*TXD$T?�*T?�Kði+AH�24N@+.-�Ý�FK-0/Ká

S M@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+.-u20+²Ý�D�3EBE/�QE-0MR/CÝ +Aç=/�-`FCHf37+AH52%BE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KH�3sTK/�6,FIQ.Q7MÚ37-4-0+Aã@Q./Áé�3K64Q²B@-�áõpNUß=-�:Ú+A2�-uMÚ/�Ý�+�çR/�-$+AD�M@Q.+²Ý +A20Q.ë�20N@/�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fë�3IWiFKHUë�/�TK/�H52�:Z-uß=Ý\NÏFK-PFIHÏFK-4-u+.åKH@óD�/�H52Á3KWÚTsFIQ.ß@/C-`203�-03KD�/>-uß=ã=-u/�2�3IWZTsFI64+.FKã@QA/C-�áBO�H@Q.+Aä7/oD�FKHUë�D�3UB@/�Q²-�:K-0ß=Ý\NGFK-ÁF$-0/ 23IWi60ß@Q./�-¾ß=-0/�BæWX3K6$M@60/CBE+²Ý920+.H@å�-u37D�/�M=FK6u24+.Ý�ß@Q.FK6$FI2u2460+.ã@ßE24/K:�F)M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ý�D�3EBE/�Q+²-�H@3K2ÁQA+.D�+�24/�By243�Ý 37H=Ý Q.ß=-0+A37H=-�FIãÚ3KßE2�FPM@60/C-uMÚ/�Ý�+�çR/�BG-0/ 2Á3KWZFI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/C-�:7ã@ßE2Á6\Fs24N@/�6Ý�FKH�ãÚ/Pß=-0/�Bº203GFIH=-0é�/�6 �5ß@/�64+A/C-pFIãÚ3KßE2>FIHUëGTsFI64+²FIã@Q./¾376o-uß@ãR-u/�2p3KWÃTsFI64+²FIã@Q./�-�áE<>3K6BE3U/�-�+�2y60/>�5ß@+A64/�20NRFs2�24N@/)TsFIQ.ß@/�-�3IW>FIQ.QÁ3K20N@/�6�TsFI64+.FKã@Q./�-ãÚ/)åK+.TK/�H I,+A2�FKM@M@Q.+A/C-�+.H20N=/�M@64/�-0/�HRÝ /)3KW�FIHUëÞ/�TU+.BE/�H=Ý /7áÃ?=3K6y/ è@FID�M@Q./K:`FæM@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+²-f24+.Ý)Dy3EBE/�Qi3KW�Fæ-u20ßEóBE/�H728U -iMÚ/�60WX3K64D�FKH=Ý />Ý�FIHGãÚ/�ß=-0/�By243�M@64/�B@+.Ý 2�20N@/$BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H)3sTK/�6%20N@/$-f24ß=BE/�H528U -/ è@FKD åK6\FKB@/�å7+AT7/�HÏN@+.-�+AH520/�QAQ.+.åK/�HRÝ /Ká�S¾-H@/�é�/�T5+²BE/�H=Ý /G+²-P3KãE2\FI+.H@/�B�:�/Ká å=á.:�FIãÚ3KßE2N@+²-oN@37Dy/�éi3760äGå764F7BE/K:EÝ�3KH=BE+A20+.3KH=+AH@åGÝ�FIH�ãR/ßR-u/CB)243Gß@MÚB=Fs20/P24N@+²-oM@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+A2fëK:@-0320NRFs2�20N=/�M=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+�2fë3KWÚF$N@+.åKNy/ è@FIDËå764F7BE/iéo+.Q.QEåK3$ß@M�+�WÚéi/p3KãR-u/�60T7/ÁåK3U3EB�N@3KD�/ óé�3K64äyå764F7BE/�-�áUõpN@/$-4FID�/$D�3UB@/�QZ+.-�ß=-0/�Bº203�BE3�20N@/$M@64/�BE+²Ý924+AT7/$FKH=BG24N@/P/�TU+²BE/�H520+²FIQ64/�FK-03KH=+AH@åRá

?@ß=6u24N@/�64D�3K64/K:ZF�M=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+.-u20+²Ý�D�3EBE/�Q�Ý�FIHÞMR/�6uWX3760D 5V-XW ,(B*-8�*-8E��(Y1 (=!=:,F�64/�FIó-03KH@+.H@åM=FI2u20/�60H�24N=Fs2i+.-ÁTK/�64ë�Ý�3KD�D�3KH�+.HGN5ß=D�FKHG60/CFK-03KH@+.H@åR:sã@ßE2ÁT7/�64ë�BE+[Z)Ý ß@QA2�203

Page 4: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�9� � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

3Kã@24FI+.Hæ+.Hæ3I24N@/�6¾WX3K64DGFIQ,WX64FKDy/�éi3760äE-�á=â�èEM@Q²FI+.H@+.H@åºF;épF;ëºß=-0/�-¾/�TU+²BE/�HRÝ /�-0ß@M@MÚ3K602uó+.H@å�37H@/�Ý�FKß=-0/o203yBE/�Ý�60/CFK-0/o20N@/¾M@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+A2fë�+.HºFIH=3I20N=/�6C:KH@3K2iãÚ/�Ý�FKß=-0/o20N@/�2féi3�FI64/+.H=Ý 37DyMRFs20+.ã@Q./K:@ã=ßE2¾-0+AD�M@Q.ëºãÚ/�Ý�FIß=-0/$20N@/�37H@/Ý�FKß=-u//�è[email protected]+AHR-oF;é�F;ë�24N@//�TU+²BE/�H=Ý�/K:64/�D�3sTU+AH@å¾20N=/>-uß@M=MR376u2�WX376%20N@/o3K20N@/�6�Ý�FIßR-u/7áI?@3K6�/�è@FID�M@Q./K:s+AWÚé�/p3Kã=-0/�64TK/i20N=FI2�20N@/-u20ß=BE/�H52&U -¾/�è@FID#åK6\FKB@/�+.-$N@+.åKN,:R37ß@6¾ãÚ/�Q.+./ WÁ24N=Fs2-0N@/�+²-¾+AH520/�QAQ.+.åK/�H52Péo+AQ.Q%åK3�ß@M�áZö�Wé�/P20N@/�H�N@/�FK6p20N=FI2>20N@/�Ý�Q.F7-0->+.-oäUH@3séoH�203GãÚ/�/CFK-0ëK:E24N=Fs2oWÆF7Ý92>M@643sTU+.BE/C-oFIH�FIQA20/�6uóH=FI20+.TK// èEM@Q²FIHRFs20+.3KH�WX3K6>20N@/�-u20ß=B@/�H52&U -oN@+.åKN�åK6\FKB@/K:E64/�BEß=Ý�+AH=åG3Kß@6oãÚ/�Q.+A/�W%20N=FI2�-uN@/+²-�+.H724/�Q.QA+.åK/�H52�áÃõpN=/º-0FKD�/)M@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+²-f24+.Ý�D�3EBE/�Q�-uß=M@MR376u2\-�FIQ.QÁ3KWp20N@/C-u/)64/�F7-u37H@+.H@åM=FI2u20/�60HR-�:=FKQAQ.3séo+.H@å�+A2o203�ãÚ/ß=-0/�B�+AH�DGFIHUëºB@+�YZ/�64/�H52p24F7-uäE-�á

õpN@/�206\FKBE+A20+.3KHRFIQ`3Kã Hf/CÝ920+.3KHæ203�M@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+.-u20+²Ý�D�3EBE/�Q.-¾N=FK-$ãÚ/�/�Hæ20N=/�+.6PÝ�3KD�M@ßEó24FI20+.3KH=FKQ�Ý 35-f2Cá=SËÝ 37DyM=QA/�20/$Hf3K+.H52>M@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+�2fë�BE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KH�3sT7/�6oF�-u/�2>3IWÃ6\FIHRBE3KDTsFI64+.FKã@Q./�-¾D�ß=-u2$-0MR/CÝ +AWXëæFºM=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+�2fë�WX3K6$/�F7Ý\Næ3IW�24N@/y/ èEMR37H@/�H524+.FKQAQ.ë�D�FKHUë�B@+�W°óWX/�64/�H52�+.H=-u24FKH724+.FI20+.3KH=-�3IWp20N@/�-u/�2�áÃâÁTK/�HÏ+.Hí3Kß=6�TK/�60ëÏ-u+.D�M@QA/º/ è@FID�M@Q./K:Ãéi/GD�ß=-f2-0MR/CÝ +AWXëXY�A�A�HUß@D�ãÚ/�6\-p243º-uMÚ/�Ý�+�WXë�20N=/ Hf3K+.H52¾BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�áRõpN@+²-o2fëUMÚ/�3IW�64/�M@64/�-0/�H@ó24FI20+.3KH�+²-�+AD�M@6\FKÝ 20+²Ý�FIQ�ãÚ3I20N�WX6037D FÌäUH@3séoQA/CBEåK/º/�H@å7+AH@/�/�64+AH=åæMR/�64-0MÚ/�Ý924+AT7/K:`-u+.H=Ý /+A2�+²-�FKQAD�37-u2�+.D�MR35-0-0+Aã=QA/GWX376�F�MÚ/�6\-03KHà203Þ-uMÚ/�Ý�+�WXëíFIHí/�H52064ëÞ+.H�FæÝ�3KD�M@Q./ èXHf3K+.H72BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�:ÚWÆFI6PQ./�-4->243�-0MR/CÝ +AWXëæFIHÞ/ èEMR37H@/�H524+.FKQÃHUß@D�ãR/�6$3KW�20N=/�D�:�FIH=BæWX6037D F64/�FK-03KH=+AH@åÞMR/�64-0MÚ/�Ý924+AT7/K:�-0+AH=Ý�/�FIHUëíÝ 3KD�M@ß@24Fs24+A37H 64/J�5ß@+.64/�-�ß=-�203à/�HUß@D�/�6\Fs24/�FKH/ èEMÚ3KH@/�H520+²FIQ�HUß@D�ãÚ/�6�3IWÃ/�TK/�H72\-�á

õpN@/�60/�WX3K64/K:7F�H=FK+AT7/�64/�M@64/�-0/�H524FI20+.3KHG3KW�20N@/KHf3K+.H52pB@+.-u2064+Aã=ßE20+.3KH)+²-�+AH@WX/�FK-0+.ã@QA/¾WX3K6FIQ.Q�ã@ßE2y20N@/�-u+.D�M@Q./�-u2yBE37D�FK+AHR-�á�M (=!�5�/�*3(B8 8 5+0�1 %B#�%E/�� 7á @ ���ßR-u/º20N@/�ß@H=BE/�60Q.ëU+AH=å-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/�3KW�20N=/�B@3KDGFI+.H�243à3sTK/�6\Ý 37D�/)20N=+.-�M@643Kã=QA/�D�á�õpN=/�ä7/�ëí+.H=-0+Aå7N72G+²-y20N@/Q.3UÝ�FIQ.+�2fëº3IW%+AH �Rß@/�H=Ý�/PM@60/C-u/�H52p+.H�DGFIHUë)64/�FIQAó�éi3760Q²B)BE37D�FK+AHR-+TE/CFKÝ\NºTsFK60+²FIã@Q./P+.-oB@+�ó64/�Ý924QAë�+.H �=ß@/�H=Ý /CB�ãUë�3KH@Q.ë�F)WX/�éË3K20N@/�64-�áR?=3K6�/�è@FID�M@Q./K:ZF)-f24ß=BE/�H728U -$+.H520/�Q.Q.+Aå7/�H=Ý�/+.H=BEß=Ý�/�-)FÞãR/�2u24/�6)ß@HRBE/�6\-f2\FIH=B@+AH@åà3KW�20N=/�D�FI20/�60+²FIQ~:%éoN@+.Ý\N�+.H 24ß@64H=-�QA/CFKB@-�243�FN@+.åKN@/�6�N@37D�/�é�3K64ä)åK6\FKBE/7á���ßE2>24N@/�/�YÚ/CÝ92¾3KW�+AH520/�QAQ.+.åK/�HRÝ /3KH�N=3KD�/�é�3K64äºå764F7BE/P+.-FIH�+.H=BE+.64/�Ý92>37H@/�TR+�W%24N@/�-u20ß=BE/�H52¾BE3U/�-oH=3I2�ß@HRBE/�6\-f2\FIH=B�24N@/�DGFs24/�64+.FKQ�:@N=/�6>+.H520/�Q.Q.+�óåK/�H=Ý /BE3U/C-iH=3I2oN@/�Q.M�N@/�6oå7/ 2oãR/�2u24/�6oåK6\FKB@/�-�á5S �pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH)H=/ 2fé�3K64ä)Ý�FIM@20ß@64/�-i20N=+.-+.H=-u+.åKN52>å764FKM@N@+²Ý�FIQ.Q.ë IE+A2�64/�M@64/�-0/�H52\-Á24N@/�BE+²-u2064+Aã@ß@20+.3KH�FK->FGB@+A64/�Ý 20/�B�F7Ý ëEÝ Q.+.Ý$å764FKM@NéoN@35-u/�H@3EBE/�-%64/�M=60/C-u/�H72Ã20N@/p6\FIH=B@3KDËTsFI64+.FKã@Q./�-`FIH=B�éoN@37-0/�/�BEå7/�-`60/�M@64/�-0/�H52`BE+.64/�Ý92BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ +./�-�á`?`+.åKß@64/ Ká�º-0N@3sé>-�F �pF;ë7/�-0+.FKHÏH=/ 2fé�3K64äæWX3K6�3Kß@6�-u+.D�M@QA/�-f24ß=BE/�H72BE37D�FK+AH,á

S �pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH)H=/ 2fé�3K64äGN=FK-�WX3760DGFIQ�-0/�DGFKH724+.Ý�-p+AH�24/�64D�-p3KW W9#&%�')(�'+*-,.*�/�07*32<2F%B8 =B*�

07*3%68 (B, *-8 =�5 W�5G89=�5+8 2)5�á[email protected].ëK:720N@/PH@/�2féi3760ä�FK-4-u/�6u2\-�24N=Fs2p/�F7Ý\NºH@3EBE/�ìX376i6\Fs24N@/�620N=/í64FKH=BE3KD T;FK60+²FIã=QA/;ð)+²-æÝ 37H=BE+A20+.3KH=FKQAQ.ë�+.H=BE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H52Ì3KW�+A24-�H@37HEórBE/�-4Ý /�H=B@FIH52\-åK+.TK/�HÌTsFIQ.ß@/C-�WX376¾+A24-PMRFI64/�H524-�áÚ?=3K6P/ è@FKDyM=QA/7:Ú+AWÁé�/�äUH@3séò20N=FI2¾24N@/G-f24ß=BE/�H52�BE3U/�-H@3K2yß@HRBE/�6\-f2\FIH=Bí20N@/�DGFs20/�60+²FIQ~:`3Kß@6yBE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KH 3sTK/�6�N@/�6�å764F7BE/�-�+.-�H@3ÏQA37H@åK/�6+.H �=ß@/�H=Ý /CB�ãUë�+AHEWX3760DGFI20+.3KH�20N=FI2>éi/PD�+Aå7N52pNRF;TK/FIãÚ3KßE2oN@/�6o+AH524/�Q.QA+.åK/�H=Ý /7á

õpN@/C-u/yÝ 3KHRBE+�24+A37H=FIQ`+.H=BE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�/yF7-0-0ß@D�ME24+A37H=-¾FKQAQ.3séËF)T7/�64ë�Ý�3KH=Ý�+.-0/�64/�M=60/�ó-0/�H524FI20+.3KH�3KW=24N@/ Hf3K+.H72�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fëBE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�3sT7/�6Ã20N@/C-u/�64FKH=BE37DËT;FK60+²FIã=QA/C-+T;é�/FK-4-03UÝ�+.FI20/$éo+�24N�/CFKÝ\N�H@3EBE/FX2)%B8 =6*-07*3%689(6,;W #&%�'F(�'G*-, *-0�! =6*�/�01#�*3'�� 07*3%68æì ��ViL$ð :EéoN@+²Ý\N-0MR/CÝ +Aç=/�-PWX376�/�F7Ý\NÞH=3UB@/�� 24N@/)M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fëÌBE+²-u2064+Aã@ß@20+.3KHà3sTK/�6¾24N@/)TsFIQ.ß@/C-3IW��åK+.TK/�Hà/�FKÝ\NàÝ 37D�ã@+.H=FI20+.3KHà3IWpTsFIQ.ß@/�-PWX376�+A24-�MRFI64/�H524-�:�BE/�H=3I20/CBàV�F@ì��Þð áÃõpN@/)Ý�3KHEóBE+A20+.3KH=FKQ�+.H=BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ /ÌF7-0-0ß@D�ME20+.3KHR-)FK-4-u3EÝ�+.FI20/�B éo+A20N'20N=/Q�pF;ëK/�-0+²FIH�H@/ 2fé�3K64äE-

Page 5: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{ �C�

Understands MaterialGood Test Taker

Homework GradeExam Grade

Intelligence Difficulty

UG AP(E | G,U) B DC F

tt

t f

f t

f f

0.7

0.3

0.4

0.05

0.25

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.03

0.2

0.2

0.3

0.01

0.05

0.08

0.3

0.01

0.05

0.02

0.15

�P¹�������������� ���� ½�� �P¹�� ½ �P¹�� ½ �P¹������ ½ �P¹���������� ½ �P¹� ������ ½ �P¹������ ½�! #"%$'&�$�&�$ �Ç{rklab7��e)(%q\}se\{rk�q�mím7e4d~�`_�gfÍæv²_�g�d � eG{�dfcUw7e4mId�bEe0grv²_�gfa�q�m5j\e)wK_Ca�q�k�m=t�d � ew7e4j\_CabE_�{rkldfkl_�m�_�vÃd � eÁÂ~_Cklmsd>w7kl{�drgfkl�5cKdfk�_�m�klmsdf_�q�bKgf_Iw7c7j4dp_�v�^ » np{\t=q�m5w�d � e^ » n v²_�g_Cm7eo_�v�d � epm5_IwKe\{�k�m�d � eom7e4d~�`_�gfÍ

+.DyM=QAë�24N=Fs2$20N@/C-u/yHUß@D�ãÚ/�6\-$-uß Z)Ý�/�243ºß@H@+��5ß@/�Q.ëæBE/�20/�64D�+AH=/�24N@/�M=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+�2fë�BE+²-fó2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KHÌ3sTK/�6>20N@/C-u/�64FKH=BE3KDôTsFI64+.FKã@QA/C-�áÚï�3K64/M@64/�Ý�+.-0/�Q.ëK:=20N@/ Hf3K+.H72PBE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H3sTK/�6yFKQAQpTsFI64+²FIã@Q./�-�Ý�FKH�ãÚ/+*G(�2+0L%B#�*-,J5)= +.H7243ÏFÏM@643EBEß=Ý 2y3KW�20N=/:��ViL¾-y3KW$FIQ.Q�20N@/TsFI64+.FKã@Q./�-pTU+.F�24N@/ O A (6*-8/. � ,5!*G%B#LM (Y!�5G/)*3(B810 5G0 1 %6#�%6/�T

2Gì�� 8 K�3�3�3&K �+4@ð!5467-8 8

2Gì�� 7!9 V�FEì � 7 ð0ð:3

�i3KHR-u+²BE/�6%24N@/ �pF;ëK/C-u+²FIHyH@/�2féi3760äWX376�3Kß=6Á-f24ß=BE/�H72iMR/�6uWX3760DGFIHRÝ /oBE3KDGFK+AH�ìÆ?`+.åIóß@64/ Ká�Cð á,örHí24N@+²-�D�3EBE/�Q~:,24N@/º-u20ß=B@/�H52&U -�MÚ/�60WX3K64DGFIH=Ý�/G+AH�20/�-u24-�BE/�MÚ/�HRB@-�37HíN@/�6+.H724/�Q.QA+.åK/�H=Ý /7áiBE/�MR/�H=B@-�ãR3K20N�37H�N@/�6�+AH520/�QAQ.+.åK/�HRÝ /ÌFKH=B'3KH'24N@/ÌBE+[Z)Ý ß@QA2fë'3IWP20N@/Ý Q²FK-4-�á ��/�6$/ è@FID åK6\FKB@/�BE/�MÚ/�HRB@-$3KHÌéoN=/ 20N=/�6P-uN@/�+.-PFºåK3U3EB�20/C-f2$24FKäK/�6C:RFKH=B�37HN@/�6�ß@H=BE/�64-u24FKH=BE+.H@å3IWÚ20N=/>DGFs20/�60+²FIQ~:séoN@+.QA/�N@/�6�N@37D�/�é�3K64ä�åK6\FKBE/oBE/�MR/�H=B@-Á3KH�N@/�6ß@H=B@/�6\-f2\FIH=BE+.H@åy3IW�24N@/PDGFs20/�60+²FIQ~áEõpN@/P-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/$3IW,24N@/$H@/ 2fé�3K64ä�/�H=Ý�3UB@/�-pF�HUß@DyóãÚ/�6o3IW%Ý 37H=BE+A20+.3KH=FKQÚ+.H=BE/�MR/�H=BE/�H=Ý /FK-4-0/�6020+.3KH=-�á5?=3K6p/ è@FKDyM=QA/7:U20N@/-u20ß=BE/�H52&U -p/ è@FIDåK6\FKB@/G+.-yÝ 37H=BE+A20+.3KH=FKQAQ.ëÌ+.H=BE/�MR/�H=BE/�H52�3IWoN@/�6�+.H724/�Q.QA+.åK/�H=Ý /ºåK+.TK/�HíN=/�6�24/�-u2�2\FIäU+AH=åFIã=+AQ.+�2fë�FIH=B�ß@H=B@/�6\-f2\FIH=BE+.H@å�3IW`20N=/D�FI20/�60+²FIQ~á

õpN@/C-u/$+AHRBE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�/PF7-0-0ß@D�ME24+A37H=-pFIQ.QA3sé ßR-Á243yWÆFKÝ9243K6i20N@/$Hf37+AH52>BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H+.H7243F�M@643EBEß=Ý 2`WX3760D�FK-%-uN=3séoH�+.Hy?`+.åKß@64/ 7á7ásâÁFKÝ\N�3IWR20N@/oÝ 37H=BE+A20+.3KH=FKQUM@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+�ó20+./�-%+.H�20N@+²-%M@643UB@ß=Ý92`WX3K64DË+.-�F ��VÁL'3KW=3KH=/i3KW=20N=/�TsFK60+²FIã@Q./�-�áCörH�24N@+.-%/�è@FID�M@Q./K:C20N@/��VÁL�+.-�-u+.D�M@QAë�Fy24FKã@Q./K:R-0ß=Ý\N�FK-o20N@/�37H@/�-0N@3séoH�WX3K6;2Gì�< 9>= K:?ðp+.H�20N@/�ç=åKß@64/KáõpN@+²- ��ViL�-0N@3sé>->20N=FI2¾+AWÁFº-u20ß=BE/�H52¾+²-¾FGå73U3UB�24/�-u2�2\FIäK/�6¾FKH=B�ß@H=B@/�6\-f2\FIH=B@->20N@/DGFs24/�64+.FKQ�:E24N@/�H�-0N@/N=F7-oM@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+A2fë�A@á.!�3IW%åK/ 2020+.H@å)FIH7Jñ37Hº24N@/�/ è@FKD�:EéoN=/�64/�FK-+AW�20N@/�-u20ßRBE/�H52�+²-�FGãRFKB�20/C-f2¾24FIä7/�6>FKH=B�BE3U/�-�H@3I2�ß=H=BE/�6\-u24FIHRBº24N@/�DGFI20/�64+²FIQ~:@N@/�6M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fë)3IW`åK/�2u20+.H@å)FKH Jñ+²-p3KH@Q.ë�A=á AS�Eá�pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH H=/ 2fé�3K64äU-�M@643sTU+.B@/ÏF'Ý 37D�M=FKÝ 2�64/�M@64/�-0/�H52\Fs20+.3KHñ3IW�Ý 3KD�M@Q./ è�Hf3K+.H72

BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H=-�á ��ë�D�3UB@/�Q.+AH@å�FKH /�H520+.60/ Hf37+AH52)BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�: �pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH H@/ 2fé�3K64äE-+.DyM=QA+²Ý +A20Q.ë -0MR/CÝ +AWXë�20N@/íFKH=-ué�/�6�203'FIHUë'M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fë �5ß@/�64ëK:�+AH M=FK6u24+.Ý�ß@Q.FK6�:pFIHUë�5ß@/�64ë�éoN@/�64/�é�/�épFIH52i203�ç=H=BG24N@/$M@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+�2fë�BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37Hº3sT7/�6i-03KD�/>TsFK60+²FIã@Q./�-åK+.TK/�HÞ/�TU+.BE/�H=Ý /)FKãR37ßE2�FIHUëæ3K20N@/�64-�á�örHÏ20N@/�3K64ëK:Z24N@/GM@643Kã@Q./�D 3KWpB@3K+.H@å�+AHEWX/�60/�H=Ý /

Page 6: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�   � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

+.H��pF;ëK/�-0+²FIHàH@/ 2fé�3K64äE-+²-�<�V�ó~NRFI6\B��Ká U6��á ��3séi/�TK/�6�:�24N@/�B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý ëí-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/DGFKBE/�/ èEM@Q.+.Ý�+�2yãUëÞ24N@/ºH=/ 2fé�3K64äÞ64/�M@64/�-0/�H52\Fs20+.3KHíÝ�FIH�ãÚ/º/�èUM=QA37+�24/�BíãUëÏ+AHEWX/�60/�H=Ý /FIQ.åK3760+A20N=D�-�:ÁFKQAQ.3séo+AH=åàWX3K6)/�ZGÝ�+A/�H52º+AH@WX/�64/�H=Ý�/æ+AH�M=64F7Ý920+²Ý /7:Á/�TK/�H�WX376ºTK/�60ë Q.FK60å7/H@/�2féi3760äE-�á

õpN@/�-0/�DGFIH524+.Ý�->FIH=B�Ý�3KD�M=FKÝ 2o60/�M@60/C-u/�H524Fs24+A37H�3KW �pF;ë7/�-0+.FKHºH@/�2féi3760äE-oFIQ²-03�FKQ�óQ.3séÀ/ YZ/�Ý 20+.TK/�-u24Fs24+.-u20+²Ý�FKQoQA/CFI64H@+.H@åÏWX6037D B@Fs2\F@á �52\FIH=B=FI6\B -u24FI20+²-f24+.Ý�FIQoM=FK64FKDy/�20/�6/�-u20+.DGFs24+A37H'20/�Ý\N=H@+��5ß@/C-ºÝ�FIH'ãR/Þß=-0/�B�WX3K6ºQA/CFI64H@+AH=åà20N@/æMRFI6\FID�/ 24/�6\-G3IWFíåK+.TK/�HH@/�2féi3760äZáE?@376oQA/CFI64H@+AH=å�24N@/�-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/P3IWÃ20N@/H=/ 2fé�3K64äÚ:52fëUM@+²Ý�FKQZFKM@M@6437F7Ý\N@/�-iß=-0/�F/+2)%6#&5$WXß=H=Ý924+A37HÏìÆéoN@+.Ý\N�+.-i2fëUM@+²Ý�FKQAQ.ë�ã=FK-0/�Bº3KH��pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH)Ý�3KH=-0+²BE/�6\Fs24+A37H=-4ð�203�-0Ý�3K64/N@3sé B@+�YZ/�64/�H52�-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/�- �uDGFI24Ý\N���20N@/Þ206\FI+.H@+.H@å B@FI24F=ápõpN=/ÞQ./�FK60H@+.H@å�M=603EÝ /C-0-20N=/�H�60/CBEß=Ý /C-i203y20N@/$2\FK-0äG3IWÃ-0/�FK64Ý\N@+.H@å�WX3K6�20N@/PN@+.åKN=/�-u2p-4Ý 3760+.H@å�-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/ �Ká��G�~áõpN@/C-u/�20/CÝ\N@H@+��7ß=/�-$FIQ.QA3séòF���F;ë7/�-0+.FKH�H@/ 2fé�3K64ä�-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/�243�ãÚ/�BE+.-4Ý 3sT7/�64/�B�WX643KDB@FI24F@áUõpN@/$QA/CFI64H@/�BG-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/¾Ý�FIH)3KW°20/�H�åK+.TK/>ßR-Á+.H=-0+Aå7N72oFIãÚ3Kß@2Á20N=/¾H=FI20ß@64/�3KW�20N@/Ý 37H@H@/CÝ920+.3KHR-GãR/�2féi/�/�H�20N=/�T;FK60+²FIã=QA/C-�+AH�20N=/ÌBE3KDGFK+AH�ái?@ß@6020N@/�60D�3760/7:%20N@/�å764FKM@N-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/PÝ�FKHº-03KD�/ 24+AD�/�-�ãÚ/¾+.H520/�60M@64/ 24/�B�Ý�FIßR-0FKQAQ.ë?� 7á @BUE�~:@FKQAQ.3séo+AH=å�ß=-i203y+AHRBEß=Ý /Ý�FKß=-0/�FKH=B / YZ/�Ý92C:�éoN@+²Ý\N�Ý�FIH�ãR/�T7/�64ëíß=-u/�WXß@QpWX3K6Gß=H=BE/�6\-u24FIHRBE+AH=åÞ37ß@6)BE3KDGFK+AH�:FIHRBÌ243æ64/�FKÝ\NÏÝ 37H=Ý Q.ß=-0+A37H=-�FIãÚ3Kß@220N@/)Ý�3KH=-0/J�5ß@/�H=Ý /C-P3IWo+AH524/�64TK/�H=+AH@åíì�FKÝ924+AH=å5ð$+.H20N=/$BE37DGFI+.H�á��U24Fs24+.-u20+²Ý�FKQZQA/CFI64H@+AH=å20/CÝ\N@H@+��7ß=/�-�FI64/¾FIQ²-03�6037ã@ß=-u2Á243�24N@/¾M=60/C-u/�H=Ý />3KWD�+.-4-0+AH@å�B=Fs24FFKH=B�N@+²B@BE/�HGT;FK60+²FIã=QA/C-�áIõÃ/�Ý\N@H=+��5ß@/C-�-ußRÝ\N�F7-�+�) � 5V-XW 5)2+0L(B01*3%B8�:<(�-

�*-: *-,J(B01*3%B8���Ý�FKHÏãÚ/)ß=-0/�BÏ243ÌBE/CFIQ�éo+A20Ní24N@+²-�+²-0-0ß@/G+.Hà20N@/ºÝ�3KH520/�èU2�3IWoM=FK64FKDy/�20/�6/�-u20+.DGFs24+A37H��Ká�JY>�ÁFKH=BÌNRF;TK/�64/�Ý�/�H520Q.ë�ãÚ/�/�HÏåK/�H@/�6\FIQ.+���/�Bæ203�20N@/�N=FK64B@/�6PM@643Kã@Q./�D3IW�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/-0/�Q./�Ý 20+.3KH � 7á�!J��á�pF;ëK/C-u+²FIHæH=/ 2fé�3K64ä�Q./�FK60H=+AH@å�N=F7-¾ãÚ/�/�HíFIM@M@Q.+./�BÌ-0ß=Ý�Ý /�-4-uWXß@QAQ.ë�243�B=Fs24F�D�+AH=+AH@å

FIM=M@QA+²Ý�FI20+.3KH=-�á�?@376$/�è@FID�M@Q./K: ��60/�/�-0/�/�2PFKQ�á �Ká�@>��-uN=3séòN@3sé�FX�pF;ëK/�-0+²FIHæH@/�2féi3760äÝ�FKH�ãÚ/�QA/CFI64H@/�B�WX6037D"B@Fs2\FÞBE/C-0Ý�60+.ã@+.H@åÌMÚ/�37M@Q./PU -�M@60/�WX/�64/�H=Ý�/�-�3sTK/�6yFÞTsFI64+A/�2fëÏ3KW+A20/�DG-�áÃõpN@/GQ./�FK60H=/�BÏBE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�+A/C-�Ý 376064/�-0MR37H=BÌ203�Ý 376064/�Q²Fs24+A37H=-$ãR/�2féi/�/�HíF�MR/�6uó-03KH U -PM@64/ WX/�64/�HRÝ /yWX3K6�B@+�YZ/�64/�H52+�24/�DG-�á,õpN@/G64/�-0ß@Q�24+AH=å �pF;ë7/�-0+.FKHÌH@/�2féi3760äæÝ�FIHàãR/ß=-0/�BÞWX3K6Ý�3KQ.Q.FKãR3764FI20+.TK/�çRQ�24/�64+AH@åR:�FIH=BÞ+²-�FºãÚ/ 2020/�6�M@64/�BE+²Ý9243K6$20N=FKHÏ20N@/G-u24FIHRB@FI6\BFIM=M@6035FKÝ\N@/C-�243y20N@+²-�24F7-uäZáUörH�FKB@BE+A20+.3KHº203y20N=/�+.6oM@60/CBE+²Ý920+.TK/FKã@+AQ.+A2fëK: �pF;ëK/�-0+²FIH)H@/�2uóé�3K64äU->N=F;TK/P24N@/�F7BETsFIH524FKåK/P20NRFs2�24N@/�ë�M@643sTU+.BE/�F�T5+²-0ß=FIQ.+��CFs24+A37H�3IW%20N@/�D�37-u2¾-u+.åIóH@+AçRÝ�FKH52oB@+A64/�Ý 2oÝ�3K6460/�Q.FI20+.3KH=-Á+AH�20N=/PB@3KDGFI+.H�:@Ý Q²FI64+AWXë5+.H@å�20N@/BE37DGFI+.H�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/¾20320N=/ß=-u/�6�á

Ð�Ñ��� � �`Ô@ÛfÖiÓ��,( ÇÖo×�� ��

3¾TK/�6�24N@/yQ.F7-f2PBE/�Ý�FKBE/7:9�pF;ë7/�-0+.FKH�H=/ 2fé�3K64äU-¾N=F;T7/�ãR/�/�HÞß=-u/CBæéo+A20NÞåK64/�Fs2P-ußRÝ�Ý /C-0-+.H�F�éo+.B@/ºTsFI64+A/�2fëÌ3KWp64/�FKQ�ó�é�3K64Q.BÏFIH=Bà64/�-0/�FK64Ý\NàFIM=M@QA+²Ý�FI20+.3KH=-�á ��3séi/�TK/�6C:�BE/C-uM@+A20/20N=/�+.6¾-0ß=Ý�Ý�/�-4-�:��pF;ë7/�-0+.FKHºH@/�2féi3760äE-oFI64/3IW°24/�H�+.H=FKBE/>�5ß=Fs24/P203)M@643KMÚ/�64Q.ë)D�3UB@/�QÃF7-fóMÚ/�Ý92\-�3IW,Ý 37D�M@QA/�èG60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQRBE37D�FK+AHR-�áUS �pF;ëK/C-u+²FIHGH=/ 2fé�3K64ä�WX3K6pF�å7+AT7/�HºB@3KDGFI+.H+.H5T73KQ.TK/C-�FæM=60/C-uMÚ/�Ý�+�ç=/CB�-0/ 2�3IW>6\FIH=BE37D TsFK60+²FIã@Q./�-�:`éoN@37-0/)64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHR-uN@+.Mí243Ì/�F7Ý\N3I24N@/�6o+²-pç@èE/CB�+.H�FKBETsFIHRÝ /Ká ��/�H=Ý�/K:=F<�pF;ë7/�-0+.FKH)H@/ 2fé�3K64ä)Ý�FKH@H@3K2pãÚ/ß=-0/�B�203)B@/�FIQéo+A20NÌBE37DGFI+.H=-oéoN@/�60/�é�/D�+Aå7N52�/�H=Ý�3Kß@H524/�6¾-0/�T7/�6\FIQ�/�H724+�24+A/C->+.HæFGTsFI64+A/�2fëº3KW�Ý�3KHEóç=å7ß@64FI20+.3KH=-�á�õpN@+²-PQA+.D�+�2\Fs20+.3KHÏ3IW �pF;ëK/�-0+²FIH�H@/�2féi3760äE-$+.-PF�BE+.60/CÝ92Ý 37H=-u/>�5ß@/�H=Ý�/�3KW20N=/�WÆF7Ý92Á24N=Fs2i20N@/�ë�Q.F7Ý\ä�24N@/¾Ý�3KH=Ý�/�ME2Á3KW,FIHW�03Kã Hf/CÝ92)�GìX3K6�BE3KDGFK+AH)/�H520+A2fëEð áS��/�H=Ý�/K:

Page 7: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{ �9�

��������������

Popularity

Teaching-Ability

��������

Difficulty

Rating

Instructor

������� ���������� ���

Course

Student

Grade

Satisfaction

� �����������

Intelligence

Ranking

ProfessorProf. Gump

Popularityhigh

Teaching Abilitymedium

CoursePhil142

Difficulty low

Ratinghigh

CoursePhil101

Difficulty low

Ratinghigh

Registration#5639

GradeA

Satisfaction 3

Registration#5639

GradeA

Satisfaction 3

Registration#5639

GradeA

Satisfaction 3

StudentJohn Doe

Intelligencehigh

Performanceaverage

StudentJane Doe

Intelligence high

Ranking average

¹ q;½ ¹ �E½�! #"%$ &�$! $Á¹ q;½���gfe\��q�dfkl_�mUq���{rj � e4a�q$v²_�gpq{rk�ab7�le�c7m5klz;e4gf{rk|d�}�wK_Ca�q�klm=¿ �%� e�c5m5w7e4gf�lklm5e\wq�drdrgfkl�7c7dfe\{�q�gfegfe4v.e4gfe\m7j\e�{r��_�df{¾_�v�d � ePj4�Aq�{r{Pq�mUwºd � e�w5q�{ � e9w��lklm5e4{¾klmUwKklj9q�dfePd � ePd~}KbEe\{_�v>_��KÂ~e\j4df{�gfe4v²e0gfe\m5j\e\w=¿ ¹ �U½�imÏe0Å5q�ab5�le�klm5{�duq�m5j\e)_�vod � kl{�{rj � e\a�qK¿Ã��e4gfe��`e)w7_�m7_�d{ � _9�àd � eÁgfe0v²e4gfe\m7j\e�{r�l_�df{\ts�%e�c7{re�w7q�{ � e9w��klm7e\{`df_>klmUw7klj9q dfeid � eÁgfe\��q dfk�_�m5{ � k�b7{`d � q d � _C��w�Ee4d��%e\e\my_C�IÂ�e\j4df{\¿

20N=/�ë�Ý�FIH@H=3I2�64/�M@64/�-0/�H52%åK/�H=/�6\FIQEM@64+AHRÝ +.M@QA/C-�FIãÚ3KßE2�D�ß@QA20+.M@QA/>-0+.Dy+.Q²FI6�3Kã Hf/�Ý92\-%éoN@+²Ý\NÝ�FKH�20N@/�H�ãÚ/�FIM=M@QA+./�B�+.H�D�ß@QA20+.M@QA/�Ý�3KH520/�èU24-�á

Üo/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ�QA37åK+²ÝI:EéoN@+²Ý\N�N=FK-�2464F7BE+�24+A37H=FIQ.Q.ëGWX3K64D�/�Bº20N@/ã=F7-u+²-�WX3K6oD�35-f2>Q²FI64åK/�ó-4Ý�FIQ./GäUH@3séoQ./�BEå7/y64/�M=60/C-u/�H72\Fs24+A37HÏ-0ëE-f24/�DG-�:ÃFKB@BE64/�-4-0/�-¾20N@/C-u/ºM@6037ã@Q./�DG-�á�õpN=/)H@3Ió20+.3KHR-o3IW �u+.H=BE+.TU+.BEßRFIQ²-&�=:U20N@/�+A6oM@643KMÚ/�6020+./�-�:@FIHRBº24N@/64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHR-pãR/�2féi/�/�H�20N@/�DÀM@643IóTU+.B@/�FIH�/�QA/�å7FIH52¾FKH=B�/ èEM@64/�-4-0+AT7/¾WX6\FID�/�éi3760äºWX3K6>64/�F7-u37H@+AH=å)FIãÚ3KßE2�DGFKH5ë�BE+.TK/�6\-0/BE37D�FK+AHR-�á=õpN=/ß=-u/�3IWC�7ßRFIH520+AçRÝ�FI20+.3KH�FIQ.QA3sé>-pßR-o203)Ý�3KD�M=F7Ý920Q.ëº64/�M=60/C-u/�H72oå7/�H@/�64FKQ64ß@QA/C-�:,20N=FI2�Ý�FKHíãR/ºFKM@M@Q.+A/CBà+AHàDGFIHUëàBE+AYÚ/�60/�H72�-0+A20ß=FI20+.3KH=-�áÃ?=3K6�/�èEFKD�M@QA/7:�éoN@/�H64/�FK-03KH=+AH@å�FIãÚ3Kß@2På7/�H@/�20+²Ýy206\FIH=-0D�+.-4-0+A37HÌ3IWpÝ /�6u2\FI+.HÞM@643KMÚ/�6020+./�-GìÆ/Ká å=á.:�åK/�H@/ 24+.Ý�FIQ.QAë206\FIHR-uD�+A2u20/CB�BE+²-0/�FK-0/�-\ð9:Cé�/iÝ�FKH�éo64+�24/iBE3séoH�å7/�H@/�64FKQK64ß@Q./�-,20N=FI2`[email protected]%FIQ.Q7MÚ/�37M@QA/FIHRB�DGFKH5ëºM@6037MR/�6u24+A/C-�á 8"$#&%�')(�'+*-,.*�/�01*32�#&5+,(607*3%689(6,C:<%J=�5G,�/ � " .L) / � �Ká�>�U: 7á @�@>�`/�èU20/�HRBQ�pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH�H@/�2uó

é�3K64äU-yéo+A20N 20N@/æÝ�3KH=Ý�/�ME2\-y3IW¾+.H=BE+.TU+.B@ß=FIQ²-�:%24N@/�+.6GM@643KMÚ/�6020+./�-�:�FIH=B 60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=-yãÚ/ ó2fé�/�/�H�20N@/�D�á`örH�F�épF;ëK:,20N@/�ëÏFK60/)2034�pF;ë7/�-0+.FKHÞH@/�2féi3760äE-�F7-�64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQiQA37åK+²Ý�+.-203�M=6037MR35-u+A20+.3KH=FKQ%QA37åK+²ÝIá �pF;ëK/�-0+²FIHÌH=/ 2fé�3K64äU-$N=F;T7/yF�WX3760DGFIQ�-0/�DGFKH724+.Ý�-P+AHÞ20/�60DG-3IW�M=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+�2fëyBE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KHR-�3sTK/�6Á-0/ 24-Á3IW�M@643KMÚ37-0+�24+A37H=FIQ=+AH520/�60M=60/�24Fs24+A37H=-�24N=Fs2�FI64/FK-4-0+Aå7H@D�/�H524-�3KW�T;FKQAß=/�-%243�Fs202064+Aã@ß@20/�-�á7ViÜ>ïæ-�NRF;TK/>F�-0+AD�+.Q.FK6�WX3K64DGFIQ=-0/�DGFKH724+.Ý�-�+.H20/�60DG-i3IW�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fë�B@+.-u2064+Aã=ßE20+.3KH=-i3sTK/�6Á-0/ 24-Á3IW #&5+,(B01*3%B8 (6, ,�%���*32>+.H520/�60M@64/ 2\Fs24+A37H=-�á

3¾ß@6�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ=WX6\FID�/�éi3760äZ:K37H)éoN@+²Ý\N�ViÜ>ïæ-pFI64/�ã=F7-u/CB�:5+.-pBE/�60+.TK/CB�WX6037D 20N@/M@64/�-0/�H524FI20+.3KH�3KWÚ?=60+./�BEDGFKH�/ 2�FIQ~á � 7á "6�7Is+A2`+²-%D�3I24+ATsFs24/�B�M@60+.DGFI64+AQ.ëPãUëP20N@/oÝ 37H=Ý /�ME24-3IW�64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQÚB@Fs2\FIã=F7-u/C-�:7FIQA20N@37ß@åKNº-03KD�/>3KW�20N@/¾H@3I2\Fs24+A37HG+.-�BE/�64+.TK/�ByWX643KDÇWX6\FID�/ óã=F7-u/CByFKH=B�3Kã Hf/�Ý920ó~3760+./�H524/�By-uëE-u20/�DG-�á��>3sé�/�T7/�6C:C20N@/oWX6\FID�/�éi3760ä+²-ÁF$WXß@Q.Q.ë�å7/�H@/�64FKQ3KH=/K:7FKH=B�+²-�/J�5ß@+.TsFIQ./�H52�203�20N@/�-u24FKH=B@FK64ByTK3EÝ�FIã@ß@Q²FI64ë�FKH=BG-u/�DGFIH520+²Ý�-�3KW�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQQ.3KåK+²ÝIá]ihKe4eP^ � q�b7dfe0g$�$q�mUw)^ � q�bKdfe4go��klm�d � kl{pz;_���c7aepv²_�g>qa_�gfe�e4ÅIdfe\m5{rklz;e�w7kl{rj\c7{r{rkl_Cmº_�vd � e>q�w7z�q�msduq���e\{�_�vZgfe4�Aq dfkl_CmUq��Rgfe\bKgfe\{re\msduq�dfkl_�m5{\¿

Page 8: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�\� � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

S�-4Ý\N@/�DGFiWX3K6ÃFp60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQsDy3EBE/�QKBE/C-0Ý�60+.ãR/C-�Fo-0/ 2,3KW 2+,(E/)/+5G/\:���5 < � 8 K�3�3�3XK � 4 D5áâÁF7Ý\N)Ý Q²FK-4-�+²-ÁF7-0-03EÝ +²Fs20/CB�éo+�24NºF�-0/ 2�3IW =�5G/+2G#�* W901*?�65 (B0107#�*3'�� 0L5G/�FIH=BGF�-u/�2i3IW #F5�*G5+#�

5+8 2)5P/�,%601/9áEõpN@/�64/¾+²-�F�BE+.64/�Ý92�DGFIM@M@+.H@åyãR/�2féi/�/�H�3Kß@6�60/�M@64/�-0/�H524FI20+.3KH)FIHRB�20N=FI2�3KW64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHRFIQEB@Fs2\FIã=F7-u/C-�ásâiFKÝ\N�Ý�Q.F7-0-�Ý�3K6460/C-uMÚ3KH=B=-�243PF$-0+AH@å7QA/�2\FIã@Q./Ká 3¾ß@6�BE/C-0Ý�60+.ME24+AT7/Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-¾Ý�3K6460/C-uMÚ3KH=B�243�-u24FKH=B@FI6\B�Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-�+.H�20N=/�2\FIã@Q./K:ZFIH=Bæ3Kß@6¾60/�WX/�64/�H=Ý�/-0QA3K24-�Ý�3K6460/C-uMÚ3KH=B�203�FI2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-%24N=Fs2iFK60/�WX3760/�+Aå7H�ä7/�ëE->ìXä7/�ëyFs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-�3KWZFKH@3I24N@/�624FKã@Q./Cð9á

?`+Aå7ß@64/ Ká�@@ì�F7ðo-0N@3sé>-�Fº-0Ý\N@/�DGF�WX3K6PF)-0+AD�M@Q./�BE37DGFI+.H�20N=FI2¾é�/�éo+.QAQ`ãR/yß=-0+AH=åFK-$37ß@6¾DGFK+AHÞ60ß@H=H@+AH=åº/ è@FKDyM=QA/7áZõpN=/yBE37DGFI+.Hæ+.-¾24N=Fs2P3IWiFºß@H@+.TK/�64-0+�2fë7:ÚFKH=BÌÝ�3KHEó24FK+AHR-�M=603KWX/�-4-u3764-�:,-u20ß=BE/�H524-�:%Ý�3Kß@6\-0/�-�:ÃFIHRB�Ý 37ß@64-0/º64/�å7+.-u206\Fs24+A37H=-�á,õpN@/�Ý Q²FK-4-u/C-�+.H20N=/�-0Ý\N@/�DGFyFK60/�������� �������r:����������� :�����������K:=FKH=B ���!�" �����$#%�&" ���5á

õpN@/-0/ 2p3IW`B@/�-4Ý 64+AME24+AT7/$FI2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-�3IW%F�Ý�Q.F7-0- � +²-pBE/�H=3I20/CB('ºì��Þð á@S�2u2064+.ã@ßE20/) 3IWÝ Q²FK-4- � +²-GBE/�H@3I24/�B � 3 ) :ÁFKH=B�+A24-º-uM=F7Ý /�3IWPTsFIQ.ß@/�-�+²-GBE/�H=3I20/CB+*¾ì � 3 ) ð9áMÏ/�FK-4-0ß@D�/�N@/�64/24N=Fs2$T;FKQAß=/�-0M=FKÝ�/�-�FK60/PçRH@+�24/KáZ?@376�/ è@FKDyM=QA/7:=24N@/,�������-.�%�oÝ�Q.F7-0-N=F7-p20N@/�BE/�-4Ý 64+AM@20+.TK/�Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-���8N0L5+,-,.*��S5G892F5�FIHRB . (68 %6*-8��Úá=õpN@/�TsFKQAß@/�-0M=F7Ý /PWX3K6���������� 3 ��8N0L5+,-,.*��S5G892)5oD�+Aå7N52pãÚ/$<YA *��8A�> ,%=1D7á

õpN@/-0/ 2p3IWÃ64/ WX/�60/�H=Ý /P-0QA3K24-�3IWÃFyÝ Q²FK-4- � +²-oBE/�H=3I20/CB0/Ìì �Þð á�MÏ/Pß=-u/Fy-u+.D�+AQ²FI6H@3K24Fs24+A37H�: � 3 1Ú:Z203æBE/�H@3I24/�20N@/G64/ WX/�60/�H=Ý /G-0QA3K221�3IW���á�âÁF7Ý\NÞ64/ WX/�60/�H=Ý /G-0QA3K231Ì+.-2fëUMR/CB�:Z+�á /Ká.:R20N@/y-0Ý\N@/�DGF)-uMÚ/�Ý�+�çR/�-�20N@/y64FKH@åK/P2fëUMÚ/�3KW�3Kã Hf/CÝ92>24N=Fs2PDGF;ë�ãÚ/�64/ WX/�6uó/�HRÝ /�B�áUïæ3K64/>WX3K64DGFIQ.QAë7:KWX376i/CFKÝ\N41�+.H ��:720N=/ =�%6:<(6*-8 0 !VW 5�L�37D � 1��Z+²- � FIH=B)20N@/#&(B8E�S5 0 !VW�5>Ü>FKH@åK/�� 1��=+.-65 WX376�-u37D�/pÝ�Q.F7-0-75É+.H4��áK?@376�/ è@FID�M@Q./K:;24N@/>Ý Q²FK-4-8����������N=F7-Á64/ WX/�60/�H=Ý /$-uQ.3I2 ��8 /�07#S��2G0 %6#%éo+A20N�64FKH@åK/o2fëUMÚ/9������� ��������:5FKH=BºÝ�Q.F7-0-:���!�" �����$#%�&" ���N=F7-P60/�WX/�64/�H=Ý�/y-0QA3K24- O %Y� #)/+5FKH=B<;N0 ��=�5+8�0Xá�örHà?`+Aå7ß@64/X7á @=ìÆF5ðo24N@/G60/�WX/�64/�H=Ý�/y-0Q.3I24-FI64/Pß@H=BE/�60Q.+.H@/�B�á

?@376º/CFKÝ\N'60/�WX/�64/�H=Ý�/Ì-0QA3K2=1R:iéi/ÞÝ�FIH B@/ ç=H@/ÏFIH *-8��E5+#)/+5 /�,%B001�> 8 :iéoN@+²Ý\N�+.-+.H724/�64M@64/ 20/CB�F7-Ã20N@/o+.HUTK/�6\-0/ÁWXß@HRÝ920+.3KHy3IW?1Rá7?@3K6%/�èEFKD�M@QA/7:séi/oÝ�FIH�B@/ ç=H@/>FKH�+.HUTK/�64-0/-0QA3K2$WX376$20N@/@;N0 ��=�5+8�0¾-uQ.3I23IW0�? !A" �B���C#%�&" ���GFIH=BÞÝ�FIQ.Q�+A2'. 5 �B*�/�0 5G#&5)=

���8`áZ<�3I24/�24N=Fs2

20N=+.-�+²-�H=3I2GFÌ37H@/ ó~203Kó~37H@/)64/�Q²Fs20+.3KH,:Ãã@ß@2�64/ 24ß@64H=-�FW/+5G0�3IW@�?�!�" �B���C#%�&" ����3Kã Hf/�Ý92\-�á?`+AHRFIQ.QAë7:Iéi/pBE/�ç=H@/p20N=/�H=3I20+.3KHy3IWZF /),�%60C2VA�(6*-8=:KéoN@+.Ý\N�FIQ.Q.3sé>-ÃßR-`203Ý 37DyMÚ37-0/o-uQ.3I2\-�:BE/�ç=H@+.H@å�WXß@H=Ý 20+.3KH=-pWX643KDÀ3Kã Hf/CÝ924-o203�3I24N@/�6o37ã Hf/�Ý 24-p243yéoN=+.Ý\N�20N=/�ë�FK60/$+.H=BE+.60/CÝ920Q.ë64/�Q²Fs20/CB�á�ï�3K64/ºM=60/CÝ +²-u/�QAë7:`é�/�B@/ ç=H@/�FW/),�%60 2NA (B*-8D1 8 K�3�3�3�K�1�E�203ÏãR/�FÏ-u/>�7ß=/�H=Ý�/3IWP-uQ.3I2\-�ìX+.HUTK/�6\-0/�376y3K20N@/�60éo+²-0/Cðy-ußRÝ\N�20NRFs2GWX3K6GFKQAQGF\:�Ü>FKH@åK/�� 1 7 �'5 L¾3KD?� 1 7�H 8 �~á?@376¾/�è@FID�M@Q./K:?�������-.�%� 3 . 5 �B*�/�0 5G#&5)=

���8 3 O %Y� #)/+5�3 �G8 /�01#S��2+0 %6#oÝ�FKH�ãR/yß=-0/�B�203�BE/�H=3I20/

FG-u20ß=BE/�H52&U -o-u/�2>3IWÃ+.H=-u2064ß=Ý9243K6\-�áS>HX*-8 /�0 (6892F5JIÌ3KWÚF$-0Ý\N@/�DGF�+²-�-u+.D�M@Q.ë�F$-u24FKH=B@FK64B64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQUQ.3Kå7+.Ýi+AH524/�64M@60/�24FIó

20+.3KH�3KW=20N=+.-%T73UÝ�FIã@ß=Q.FK60ë7á�ö�2Á-0MR/CÝ +Aç=/�-JTIF$-u/�2�3IWR37ã Hf/�Ý 24-LK,:KM=FI6020+A20+.3KH@/CB�+.H5203PÝ Q²FK-4-u/C-+IF�T;FKQAß=/�WX3K6$/�F7Ý\NÌFs202064+Aã=ßE20/,K 3 ) ìX+.Hæ20N=/yFKM@M@643KM@64+.FI20/�B@3KDGFI+.HRð�IZFIHRBÌF)TsFKQAß@/�WX3K6/�F7Ý\Nº64/ WX/�60/�H=Ý /$-uQ.3I2MK 3 1R:UéoN@+²Ý\Nº+²-pFIH�3Kã Hf/CÝ92p+AHº20N@/PFIM@M=6037M@60+²Fs24/�6\FIH@å7/o2fëUMR/7á MÞ/ß=-0/N')ì�KZð�F7-�F$-0N@376u24N=FIH=B�WX3K6O')ì��Þð :IéoN@/�60/GKG+²-�3IW�Ý Q²FK-4- ��áI?=3K6�/CFKÝ\Ny3Kã Hf/CÝ926K)+.H20N=/+AH=-u24FKH=Ý /�FKH=B�/�FKÝ\N�3IW`+�2\->Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/C- ) :@é�/Pß=-u/NIQPR Sà243�B@/�H@3K20/P20N=/T;FKQAß=/$3KWK 3 ) +AH=I>áÚ?=3K6$/ è@FID�M@Q./K:Ú?Ã+.åKß=60/ 7á @=ìXãRð�-uN=3sé>-�FIH�+.H=-u24FKH=Ý /�3IW%20N@/�-4Ý\N@/�DGF�WX643KD3Kß=6y64ß@H@H=+AH@åà/�èEFKD�M@QA/7á%örH�24N@+.-�ì�-u+.D�M@Q./Cðy+.H=-f2\FIH=Ý�/º24N@/�64/�+.-y37H@/T�U�$�.����������r:`2fé�3�6V #����u/C-�:Ã20N=60/�/W�? !A" �B���C#%�&" ���s-�:,FKH=Bà2fé�3W����������u-�á%õpN@/º64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=-�ãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�H�20N=/�D-0N@3séË20NRFs2P20N@/GVÁ603KWX/�-4-u376�+²-$20N@/�+.H=-f2460ßRÝ920376¾+.HÏãR3K20NàÝ Q²FK-4-u/C-�:�FIHRB�20NRFs23KH@/�-u20ßEó

Page 9: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{ � �

BE/�H72>ì+���5FIH@/�L�3U/J�5ð�+²-`60/�åK+²-f24/�64/�B37H@Q.ëPWX3K6%3KH@/�Ý Q²FK-4-pìG�0VÁN@+.Q1>A J�5ð9:�éoN@+AQ./i20N@/p3I24N@/�6-u20ß=BE/�H52>+.-o64/�å7+.-u20/�60/CBGWX376oãR3K20N�Ý Q²FK-4-u/C-�á

Ð�Ñ�� �ÌÕ=Ö�����¾Û�uÛ��KÔ@Û0Ù Õ � �`Ô@ÛfÖÁÓ��,@ ÇÖo×�� ��

V�643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ý�64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQpD�3EBE/�Q²-)FK60/�FÏH@/�é BE/�TK/�Q.3KM=Dy/�H52y24N=Fs2)+.H520/�åK6\Fs20/C-y20N@/-u2064/�H@åK20N=-,3IW@M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+²-f24+.Ý�Dy3EBE/�Q.-ÃFIH=B�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQIQA37åK+²ÝIáE�U/�T7/�6\FIQKFKM@M@6437FKÝ\N=/�-ZN=F;T7/ãÚ/�/�H�M@6037MR35-u/CB�:Ã-03KD�/)ãRFK-0/�Bà3KHíM=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+.-u20+²ÝGQ.3KåK+²ÝGM@643Kå764FKD�Dy+.H@åV�Ká�@BAE:KKá�@BDE�FIHRB�3I24N@/�6\-�ãRFK-0/�B�3KHÞF)D�3K64/�3Kã Hf/�Ý920ó~64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQ�WX64FKDy/�éi3760ä �Ká�>�J��á 3¾ß=6�M@64/�-0/�HEó24FI20+.3KHG+²-�ã=F7-u/CB�37H�20N@/�+.BE/CFK-�M=60/C-u/�H724/�ByãUë�OP37QAQ./�6ÁFKH=B�V�WX/�YÚ/�6 � 7áE�>�ÚFKH=B�WX3KQ.QA3sé>-20N=/�M@64/�-0/�H52\Fs20+.3KH�3IW �Ká "E��á`ö�2GFIQ²-03ÞFKÝ�Ý 37DyD�3EB@FI20/�-�FIH=B�åK/�H@/�6\FIQ.+���/�-�20N@/�M@643Kã=FIóã@+.QA+²-u20+²ÝPQA37åK+²Ý¾M=6037åK6\FID�D�+AH@åyFIM@M=6035FKÝ\N@/C-P�Ká�@BAU: Ká�@BDE��á

���������� �������� ������ ����

VÁÜ�ïæ-pM@643sT5+²BE/$F�Q²FIH=åKß=FKåK/>WX376o-uMÚ/�Ý�+�WXëU+.H@åGF�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fë)BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�3sT7/�6pF�-0/ 23IW�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ%+AH520/�60M=60/�24Fs24+A37H=-�áÚï�3760/yM@64/�Ý�+.-0/�Q.ëK:�F�VÁÜ>ï -0MR/CÝ +Aç=/�-F�BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H3sTK/�6�FÞ-u/�2�3IW¾+AH=-u24FKH=Ý /C-�3KW�Fæå7+AT7/�H�-4Ý\N@/�DGF=á3¾H@/�Dy+.åKN52GÝ 37H=-u+²BE/�6�VÁÜ�ïæ-�24N=Fs2-0MR/CÝ +AWXëPF�BE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KH3sT7/�6�FKQAQ7MR35-0-0+Aã=QA/�+.H=-u24FKH=Ý /C-�3IWU24N@/i-4Ý\N@/�DGF=: +�á /Ká.:;FIQ.QKMÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./B@FI24FIãRFK-0/�-�3sTK/�6�20NRFs2)-0Ý\N=/�DGF@á�õpN@+²-�-u/�2�3KW¾B@FI24FIãRFK-0/�-�+.-�+.HEç=H@+A20/�QAë�Q.FK60å7/K:%FK-y+�2+.H=Ý Q.ß=BE/C-$FKQAQ`24N@/�MR35-0-0+Aã=QA/�T;FK60+²Fs24+A37H=-¾3sTK/�6�20N@/yHUß@D�ãÚ/�6P3KWÁ3Kã Hf/CÝ92\-¾+.HÌ/CFKÝ\NÌÝ�Q.F7-0-FIHRB�20N=/yMÚ37-4-0+Aã@Q./y60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=-¾ãR/�2féi/�/�HÌ20N@/�D�áZö�2+²-$Ý�QA/CFI64QAë�T7/�64ë�B@+�Z)Ý ß=Q�2P203�M@Q²FKÝ�/F�BE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KH 3sTK/�6)24N@+.-�2fëUMÚ/Þ3KW�-0M=FKÝ�/K:oFIH=B +�2�+²-�H@3I2�3KãUTU+A37ß=-º20N=FI2�-0ß=Ý\N FåK/�H@/�6\FIQAó�M@ß@64MR35-u/PBE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�+.-oßR-u/�WXß@Q�á 3¾H�24N@/�3K20N@/�6>N=FIHRB�:@ß@H@Q.+.äK/+.H�24N@/�Ý�FK-0/3IWC�pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH)H=/ 2fé�3K64äU-�:Uéi/PépFIH52>VÁÜ>ïÌ-�203�ãR/�Fyå7/�H@/�64FKQÚD�3EBE/�Q�:E24N=Fs2>Ý�FIH�FIM@M@Q.ë203�F)éo+²BE/yTsFI64+A/�2fë�3KWi-0+�24ß=Fs24+A37H=-�á9�>/�H=Ý /7:�FºVÁÜ�ï"+²-¾F7Ý920ßRFIQ.QAëæF)20/�D�M@Q²Fs24/�TZåK+.TK/�HFÏ-u/�2y3KW¾åK643Kß=H=Bí3Kã Hf/�Ý92\-�:�FÏVÁÜ>ï -uMÚ/�Ý�+�çR/�-�FÌM=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+�2fëíBE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�3sT7/�6�F-0/ 2)3IWP+.H724/�64M@64/ 24FI20+.3KH=-y+.HUTK3KQ.TU+AH=åÞ24N@/�-0/�3Kã Hf/�Ý92\-�ìÆFKH=B�MR/�60N=FKM=-�3I24N@/�6G37ã Hf/�Ý 24-\ð9áMÏ/GãR/�åK+.HÏéo+A20NíBE/C-0Ý�60+.ã@+.H@å�20N@/)-0+.DyM=QA/C-f2WX3760D 3KWpViÜ>ïæ-�:�éoN@/�64/�20N=/G60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/�3IW`20N@/�D�3EBE/�Q � 24N@/�-0/ 2�3KW�3Kã Hf/CÝ924-�FIH=B�20N=/�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=->ãR/�2féi/�/�H�20N=/�D� +.-pF7-0-0ß@D�/�B�243�ãÚ/¾MRFI602�3KW�20N@/$+AH=M@ßE2p203�20N@/¾20/�DyM=Q.FI20/Ká 3¾H@Q.ë�20N=/$FI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/C-Á3KW20N=/�37ã Hf/�Ý 24-¾M=FI6020+²Ý +.M=Fs24/�+.H�20N=/�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ý�D�3EBE/�Q~áRörH �U/�Ý 20+.3KHW7á "ºéi/yBE+²-0Ý�ß=-0-N@3sé 203G/ èU24/�H=B�20N=+.-pWX6\FID�/�éi3760äy203GD�ß=Ý\N�60+²Ý\N@/�6o-0/ 2020+.H@å7-�á

S #&5+,(607*3%689(6, /�%�5+,5G0 %68��Ì3KW`Fy64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHRFIQ�-4Ý\N@/�DGF�+.->FyM=FK6u24+.FKQ�-uMÚ/�Ý�+�çÚÝ�Fs24+A37H�3KWFIHà+.H=-u24FIHRÝ /�3IW�20N@/)-4Ý\N@/�D�F=á�ö�2�-uMÚ/�Ý�+�çR/�-$20N=/)-u/�2�3IWi37ã Hf/�Ý 24-PWX376/�F7Ý\NÏÝ�Q.F7-0-PFIHRB20N=/�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=-o20N=FI2�N@3KQ²B�ãR/�2féi/�/�H�24N@/�3Kã Hf/�Ý92\-�áN�>3sé�/�TK/�6�:E+A2�Q./�F;T7/�-�20N=/�TsFIQ.ß@/�-o3KW20N=/�Fs202064+Aã@ß@20/�->ß@H=-0MR/CÝ +Aç=/�B�áÚ?`+Aå7ß@60/ 7á DRìÆF7ðp-0N@3sé>-�24N@/�64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHRFIQ�-uä7/�Q./ 243KH�3IW`20N@/+.H=-f2\FIH=Ý�/¾-0N@3séoH)+.H�?`+.åKß@64/�7á @=ìXãRð á5S VÁÜ>ï -uMÚ/�Ý�+�ç=/C-iF�M@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+A2fëyBE+²-u2064+Aã@ß@20+.3KH=-3sTK/�6 2)%6:�W ,�5G07*3%68�/ I 3KWÁFIHUë�åK+.TK/�Hæ-uä7/�Q./ 2037H�áZS�-¾éi/�éo+AQ.Q`-0N@3sé:RWX3K6PFIHUë�-uä7/�Q./ 2037HWX3K6Á20N@/$-0Ý\N=/�DGF@:s24N@/¾ViÜ>ï +.H=BEß=Ý�/�-ÁF�BE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KHG3sT7/�6�+.H=-u24FKH=Ý /C-�20NRFs2iÝ�3KD�M@Q./ 20/20N=/�-uä7/�Q./ 2037H�á

SÇVÁÜ>ï -uMÚ/�Ý�+�ç=/C-$20N@/yM@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fë�BE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KHÏß=-0+AH=åº24N@/y-4FID�/yß@H=BE/�60Q.ëU+AH=åM@64+AHRÝ +.M@QA/C-�ß=-0/�B�+.Hº-0MR/CÝ +AWXëU+AH@å ��F;ë7/�-0+.FKH�H=/ 2fé�3K64äU-�áKõpN@/¾FK-4-uß@D�ME24+A37HG+.-�20N=FI2Á/�F7Ý\N

Page 10: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

� � � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

ProfessorProf. Gump

Popularity???

Teaching Ability???

CoursePhil142

Difficulty low

Ratinghigh

CoursePhil101

Difficulty ???

Rating???

Registration#5639

GradeA

Satisfaction 3

Registration#5639

GradeA

Satisfaction 3

Registration#5639

Grade???

Satisfaction ???

StudentJohn Doe

Intelligencehigh

Performanceaverage

StudentJane Doe

Intelligence ???

Ranking ???

Popularity

Teaching-Ability

��� ��� �� � ���

Difficulty

Rating

����� � �

Intelligence

Ranking

�� ������� �

AVG

AVG

Grade

Satisfaction

������ � � � � � � ���

¹ q;½ ¹ �E½�! #"%$ & $�� $`¹ qC½%�im�e4Å7q�ab7��eÁgfe\��q�dfkl_Cm5q��R{rÍ;e\�le4df_Cm�v²_�g�d � e�{rj � _s_��ÚwK_Ca�q�k�m=¿K��e4gfeÁ�%epÍIm5_9�_Cm7�|}àd � e)_C�IÂ�e4j4df{�klm�_Cc7gyw7_�a�q�klm�q�m5wÏd � eGgfe\��q�dfkl_Cm7{ � klb5{�d � q�d � _��Awà�Ee0d~�%e4e\míd � e\a�¿¹ �E½� »�¼ �"{�drgfc7j4dfc7gfe�v._�gyd � eG{rj � _s_C�owK_Ca�q�k�m=¿%�,w7��e\{yj4_�grgfe\{rbE_�mUwÏdf_�b7gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfkljw7e4bEe\mUwKe\m5j4}s¿��,w7��e\{,vAgf_Ca _Cm7e�j\��q�{r{�df_>q�m5_�d � e4gÃq gfe�gf_�c7dfe9w�d � gf_Cc7� � {r�l_�dr��j � q�klm5{ ¹ j � q�klm5{_�v�gfe0v²e4gfe\m7j\e\{u½0¿��5_�gÁj\��q�gfk|d�}�d � e\{reoq�gfe>m7_�d�e4ÅKb5�lklj\k|df�|}y{�duq dfe9wyklm�d � e>w7k�q���guq�a ¹ {re\epdfe4ÅId0½0¿

3IW�20N@/�6\FIH=BE37D T;FK60+²FIã=QA/C-�+.H�24N@/�ViÜ>ï � +.H�24N@+.-�Ý�FK-0/)20N=/�FI2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�- K 3 ) 3KW20N=/y+.H=BE+.TU+.B@ß=FIQ�37ã Hf/�Ý 24- K � +.-PBE+.60/CÝ924QAë�+.H �=ß@/�H=Ý /CBÌãUë�37H@QAëÞF)WX/�éò3I24N@/�6\-�á�õpN@/VÁÜ�ï 24N@/�64/ WX3760/�BE/ çRH@/�-�WX3K6�/CFKÝ\N<K 3 ) FÏ-0/ 2G3IW W�(6#F5G8N03/9:�éoN@+²Ý\N�FK60/º20N@/�BE+.64/�Ý92+.H �=ß@/�H=Ý /C-�3KH�+A2�:5FIH=B�FPQ.3UÝ�FIQEM@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²ÝpDy3EBE/�QE20NRFs2i-0MR/CÝ +Aç=/�-�20N@/�B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý /3KHº20N@/C-u/$M=FK60/�H72\-�á ��3séi/�TK/�6C:I24N@/�64/PFI64/>2fé�3�M@64+.D�FK60ëGBE+AYZ/�64/�H=Ý�/�-�ãR/�2féi/�/�H�VÁÜ>ïæ-FIHRBQ�pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH�H@/�2féi3760äE-�áR?`+.64-u2�:�FºViÜ>ï B@/ ç=H@/C-¾20N@/�BE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�ë�D�3UB@/�Q�Fs2$20N@/Ý Q²FK-4->Q./�T7/�Q~:RFKQAQ.3séo+AH=åy+A2�243)ãÚ/�ß=-0/�B�WX376¾FIHUë�3Kã Hf/CÝ92�+.H�20N=/�Ý Q²FK-4-�á=örHæF)-0/�H=-0/K:=20N@/Ý Q²FK-4-BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ëæD�3EBE/�QÁ+.-Pß@H=+AT7/�6\-0FKQAQ.ë �5ß=FIH520+Aç=/CBÞFKH=BÌ+.H=-u24FKH724+.FI20/CBæWX376$/�TK/�60ë/�Q./�D�/�H72¾+AH�24N@/�Ý�Q.F7-0->B@3KDGFI+.H�á �E/�Ý 37H=B�:E24N@/�ViÜ>ï / èEM@Q.+²Ý +A20Q.ë�ß=-0/�-o20N@/�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/Á3IWE20N=/ÁD�3EBE/�Q~:�+.H20NRFs2Ã+A2`FKQAQ.3sé>-Z24N@/ÁM@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ý�D�3UB@/�QK3KW=FIH�FI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/3IW�FIH�37ã Hf/�Ý 2o203)BE/�MR/�H=B�FIQ²-u3�37H�FI2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-o3KW`64/�Q²Fs24/�B�3Kã Hf/CÝ92\-�á=õpN=/�-uMÚ/�Ý�+�çRÝ-0/ 23IW�64/�Q²Fs24/�By3Kã Hf/CÝ92\-�Ý�FKHyTsFK60ë�éo+�24N�20N@/�-0äK/�QA/�2037H � IK20N@/¾VÁÜ>ï -0MR/CÝ +Aç=/�-�20N@/�B@/�MÚ/�HEóBE/�H=Ý ëÞ+AHíF�åK/�H@/�64+²Ý�/�H@3Kß=åKNÏé�F;ë�24N=Fs2�+A2�Ý�FKHíFIM@M@Q.ë�243æFIHíFI64ã@+A206\FI64ë�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/7á

SêVÁÜ>ï Ý 3KHR-u+²-f2\-�3KW>2fé�3ÞÝ 37D�MR37H@/�H524-JTÃ20N@/ �5ß=FIQ.+�2\Fs24+AT7/�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�H=Ý ë�-u2064ß=Ý9ó20ß=60/7:���:UFIH=B�24N@/�-0/ 2Á3KWZMRFI6\FID�/ 24/�6\-�FK-4-u3EÝ +²Fs24/�Byéo+A20NG+A2�:�����á7?`+Aå7ß@64/ Ká D=ìXãÚð%-uN@3sé>-FIH�/�èEFKD�M@QA/oViÜ>ï -f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/�WX3K6�37ß@6�-0Ý\N=3537Q@BE3KDGFK+AH�á7õpN@/>BE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�ë�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/+²-¾BE/�ç=H@/CB�ã5ë�FK-4-03UÝ�+.FI20+.H@åGéo+A20Næ/CFKÝ\N�Fs202064+Aã@ß@20/ � 3 ) Fº-u/�2�3IWW�(6#&5+8�01/�V�FEì�� 3 ) ð9áõpN@/C-u/æÝ�3K6460/C-uMÚ3KH=Bí203 *G%6#�:<(6,$M=FK60/�H72\-+I%24N@/�ë éo+AQ.QoãÚ/�+AH=-u24FKH520+²Fs20/CB�+.H�BE+AYÚ/�60/�H72épF;ëU-WX3K6�BE+AYZ/�64/�H52�3Kã Hf/�Ý92\-�+.H ��á,örH524ß@+�24+AT7/�Q.ëK:,20N@/)MRFI64/�H524-�FK60/)FI2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-24N=Fs2FI64/V�0B@+A64/�Ý 2�+AH �Rß@/�H=Ý�/�-F��3KH � 3 ) á�örH�?`+.åKß@64/?Ká D=ìÆãRð9:�20N@/ºFK60643sé>-PBE/ çRH@/G20N=/)BE/ óMÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý ë�-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/7áMÏ/yBE+²-u20+.H@åKß@+²-0NæãR/�2féi/�/�HÌ2féi3º2fë5MÚ/�-¾3IWÁWX3K64D�FKQ,M=FK60/�H524-�áÚõpN@/yFs202064+Aã@ß@20/ � 3 )

Ý�FKH�BE/�MÚ/�HRBà3KH�FIH=3I20N=/�6�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²ÝGFs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/��#3KW���á,õpN@+²-WX3K64DGFIQÁB@/�MÚ/�HEóBE/�H=Ý /æ+.H=BEßRÝ /�-�F�Ý 376064/�-0MÚ3KH=BE+.H@åíBE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ë WX3K6º+.H=BE+.TU+.B@ß=FIQ¾3Kã Hf/CÝ924-JT�WX376ºFIHUë3Kã Hf/�Ý92(K +.H 3IW�Ý Q²FK-4- ��:OK 3 ) éo+.QAQ$BE/�MÚ/�HRB�M@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+²-f24+.Ý�FIQ.QAë 3KH K 3 �)áp?@376º/�è5óFID�M@Q./K:%+.H ?`+.åKß@64/Q7á DRìXãRð :%FÞM@643IWX/C-0-03K68U - " %VW � ,(6#�*-0 !�BE/�MÚ/�HRB@-�3KH�N=/�6 #�5)(�2VA *-8E�

Page 11: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{ � �J '+*-,.*-0�!Rá=õpN@+²-oBE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�ë)D�3EBE/�QZ+²-oBEß@M@Q.+.Ý�Fs24/�BGWX376p/�FKÝ\N�M@643IWX/�-4-03K6�+AHº20N@/-0äK/�Q./ ó2037H�á,õpNUß=-�:�éi/G/C-0-0/�H524+.FKQAQ.ëæFK-4-uß=Dy/y24N=Fs224N@/)-0FKD�/yM=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+.-u20+²ÝyDy3EBE/�QÁFIM=M@QA+./�-203)FKQAQZ24N@/M@643IWX/C-0-03K6\-Á+.H�3Kß@6>B@3KDGFI+.H�á

örHGFKB@B@+�24+A37H�:KFIH�Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/ � 3 ) Ý�FKHyFKQ.-03BE/�MÚ/�HRB�3KH�Fs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-�3KWÚ64/�Q²Fs24/�B�3KãEóHf/�Ý 24- � 3 � 3 �):EéoN=/�64/���+²-oFy-0Q.3I2>Ý\N=FI+.H�áUörH�?`+Aå7ß@60/ Ká D=ìÆãRð9:U24N@/åK6\FKB@/¾3KW`F�-f24ß=BE/�H72+.HÞF)Ý�3Kß@6\-u/7:��? !A" �B���C#%�&" ���Uá�" #&(�=�57:RB@/�MÚ/�H=B@-$37H<�? !�" �����$#%�&" ���5á ;N0 ��=�5+8�0�á �G8�0 5G,-,.*��S5+8 2)5FIHRB ���!�" �����$#%�&" ���5á O %Y� #)/+57á ��* �2�� ,.0 !=áÚõpN@/�VÁÜ�ï Q.FKH@åKß=FKåK/�FKQ.-03)FIQ.QA3sé>-pßR-o203ºß=-u/Q.3KH@å7/�6º-0QA3K2ºÝ\N=FI+.H=-�:�WX3K6º/ è@FID�M@Q./�20N=/ÌBE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�/æ3IW(�������-.�%� á ; (607*�/�*G(�2+01*3%B8ñ37H�? !A" �B���C#%�&" ���Uá�O %Y� #)/+57á ��8 /�07#S��2G0 %6#Uá #�5)(�2VA *-8E�

�J 'G*-,.*-0 !=á9�Uß=Ý\N�-0QA3K2�Ý\N=FI+.H=-oFI64/+.H=-f2\FIHEó

20+²Fs24/�B WX3K6�/�F7Ý\N 3Kã Hf/�Ý92�ãUë'WX3KQ.QA3séo+.H@å 20N@/Ï64/ WX/�64/�HRÝ /�-�24N=Fs2�FI64/ÞF7-0-0+Aå7H@/�B 203�+�2ãUë�20N@/�-uä7/�Q./ 243KH�áZõpNUß=-�:RWX3K6$/ è@FKDyM=QA/7:=WX376�24N@/�64/�å7+.-u206\Fs24+A37H�3Kã Hf/CÝ92��������Ã:J�? ! " �B���C#%�&" ���Uá ;N0 ��=�5+8�0 á ��8N0L5+,-,.*��S5G892F5�60/�WX/�64/�H=Ý�/�-�� (6895

�� %>5Ká ��8N0L5+,-,.*��S5G892)5K:�FIH=B 24N@/Ì-0QA3K2

�? !A" �B���C#%�&" ���Uá�O %Y� #)/+57á �R* 2X� , 0�!G64/ WX/�60/�H=Ý /C- " A�*-,������,á ��* �2�� ,.0 !=á3¾ß@6)/�è@FID�M@Q./ÌVÁÜ>ï FKQ.-03�Ý 37H524FI+.H=-)FíB@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý /Þ3IW(�������-.�%� á . (68�%B*-8E� 37H

���������� á . 5 ��*�/�0L5+#&5)=��G8Ãá " #&(�=�5Ká@<�3I24/�24N=Fs2>F�-u20ßRBE/�H52oéo+AQ.QÚ2fëUM@+.Ý�FIQ.QAë�ãÚ/P60/�åK+²-f24/�64/�B

+.HÌ-u/�TK/�64FKQ�Ý Q²FK-4-u/C-+IE24N@/�D�3EBE/�Q`-uMÚ/�Ý�+�çR/�-�FºBE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�/�3IW%20N=/�-f24ß=BE/�H728U -�64FKH@äU+AH=å3KHÌ20N@/yåK6\FKB@/�-o24N=Fs2N@/�60/CÝ /�+AT7/�-¾+AHÏFIQ.QÃ3KW�20N@/�D�á�örHÌåK/�H@/�6\FIQ~:�K 3 �Þ60/�M@64/�-0/�H524-�20N@//+5G0o3KW�3Kã Hf/CÝ924->20N=FI2¾FI64/��Uó�60/�Q.FI20+.TK/�->3IW6K,áÚâ�è@Ý /�ME2�+.HæÝ�FK-0/�->éoN@/�64/20N=/�-uQ.3I2$Ý\N=FI+.H+²-�åKßRFI6\FIH520/�/�BÌ203�ãÚ/º-u+.H@å7QA/�ó~TsFIQ.ß@/CB�:�é�/GD�ß=-u2�-0MR/CÝ +AWXëÌ24N@/)M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+²-f24+.ÝGB@/�MÚ/�HEóBE/�H=Ý /�3IW K 3 ) 3KH�20N@/�D�ß@QA20+²-0/ 2 <�� 3 � T���� K 3 � D7á�õpN@+²-yB@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý /�MÚ37-0/�-yF64/�M@64/�-0/�H524FI20+.3KH=FKQiM=6037ã@QA/�D�:%-0+.H=Ý /�é�/�H@/�/�B�203í-0MR/CÝ +AWXëí20N@/�BE+²-u2064+Aã@ß@20+.3KH�3IW K 3 )åK+.TK/�H)FPD�ß@QA20+²-0/ 2Á3KWZTsFKQAß@/C-�3KW�-0+���/R7:�@E:SD@:KFKH=BG-u337H�áKö�2�+.-ÁÝ Q./�FI64Q.ë�+.DyM=64F7Ý920+²Ý�FKQE203203�M@643sTU+.B@/�F�BE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�ë�Dy3EBE/�Q%WX3K6P/�F7Ý\Næ3IWi20N@/yß@HUãÚ3Kß@H=B@/�BEQ.ëæDGFIHUë�MÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./D�ß=Q�24+.-0/ 2�-0+���/�-�á

õpN@/�H@3I24+A37Hæ3IW (&�&��#&5 ��(B01*3%B8àWX6037D#B@Fs2\FIã=F7-u/24N@/�3760ë�å7+AT7/�->ßR-¾FKHÌFIM@M=6037M@60+²Fs24/203U37QÁ243ÞFKB=BE60/C-0-�20N@+²-y+.-4-0ß@/Ká%õpN@/�B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý /�3IWNK 3 ) 3KH<K 3 � 3 �º:�+.-�+.H724/�64M@64/ 20/CBFK-F�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²ÝyB@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý /G3KWOK 3 ) 37HÏ-03KD�/�ìÆBE/�20/�60D�+.H@+.-u20+²Ý�FKQAQ.ëÞÝ�3KD�M@ßE24/�B=ðFIå7åK64/�å5Fs20/�M@6037MR/�6u2fë�3KW�20N@+²-PD�ß=Q�24+.-0/ 2CáZõpN=/�64/yFK60/�D�FKHUë�H=Fs24ß@64FKQ`FKH=BæßR-u/�WXß@Q�H@3Ió20+.3KHR-�3KWÁFIåKå760/�å7FI20+.3KH TU24N@/�D�3EBE/�3KW%20N@/�-u/�2�ìXD�35-f2¾WX60/>�7ß=/�H520Q.ë�3UÝ�Ý ß@6464+AH@åGTsFKQAß@/;ð�ID�/�FKHÌTsFIQ.ß@/y3IW�20N=/�-0/ 2�ìX+AWiTsFIQ.ß@/C-¾FK60/�H5ß=Dy/�60+²Ý�FKQ²ðGIZDy/CBE+²FIH�:ÚDGFsèE+AD�ß@D�:Z3K6$Dy+.HEó+.D�ß@D ìÆ+�WiT;FKQAß=/�-PFI64/�3764BE/�60/CB=ð�IZÝ�FK64B@+AH=FKQA+A2fë�3IW�24N@/G-u/�2JIZ/ 2\ÝIá�ï�3K64/�WX3760DGFKQAQ.ëK:Ú3Kß@6Q²FIH@å7ß=FIå7/�FKQAQ.3sé>-PF�H@3I24+A37HÞ3KWpFKHíFIåKå760/�å7FI20/�� I��í2\FIäK/C-F�D�ß@QA20+²-0/ 2�3IWpTsFIQ.ß@/�-P3KW-03KD�/�å76037ß@H=B�2fëUMÚ/K:�FIHRB�60/�20ß@64H=-$F�-0ß@D�DGFI64ë�3IWÁ+A2�á�õpN@/�2fëUMR/y3IW�24N@/�FIåKå760/�å7FI20/Ý�FKH�ãR/�20N@/�-0FKDy/�FK-o24N=Fs2¾3IW�+�2\-¾FK60å7ß@D�/�H524-�á���3séi/�TK/�6C:Eé�/�FIQ.QA3sé 3I24N@/�6�2fëUMR/C-�FK-é�/�Q.Q�:R/Ká å=á.:RFIHæFKåKå760/�å7Fs24/�24N=Fs2$60/�MR376u2\-p20N=/�-0+���/3IW�20N=/�D�ß@QA20+²-0/ 2�áZï�3760/M@64/�Ý�+.-0/�Q.ëK:é�/ºFIQ.QA3sé � 3 ) 203ÌN=F;TK/)F7-�F�M=FK60/�H72��%ì � 3 � 3 �yð�I�24N@/�-0/�DGFKH724+.Ý�-+²-20NRFs2�WX376�FIHUëK�� ��:AK 3 ) éo+AQ.QÃBE/�MR/�H=B�3KH�20N=/�TsFIQ.ß@/3IW��%ì K 3 � 3 ��ð9áNMÞ/�B@/ ç=H@/ *¾ì��%ì � 3 � 3 �yðuði203ãÚ/�20N@/)-0/ 2�3KWiMÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./GT;FKQAß=/�-P3IWi20N@+²-�FKåKåK64/�å5Fs24/KáÚörHÏ37ß@6/ è@FKDyM=QA/GVÁÜ�ïí:Z20N@/�60/FI64/�2fé�3�FKåKå760/�å7Fs24/�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ +./�-PBE/ çRH@/�B�:Z37H@/�24N=Fs2-0MR/CÝ +Aç=/�-¾20NRFs2$20N@/y64FKH@äU+AH=å3IW`F�-u20ß=BE/�H52oB@/�MÚ/�H=B@-�37HG20N@/F;T7/�6\FIåK/p3KW,N@+²-iå764F7BE/�-iFIH=Bº3KH@/�20N=FI2p-0MÚ/�Ý +Aç=/C-Á24N=Fs220N=/�64FI20+.H@å�3IW�FGÝ 37ß@64-0/BE/�MÚ/�HRB@-o3KH�24N@/�F;TK/�64FKåK/$-0FI20+²-fWÆF7Ý920+.3KH�3IW�-u20ß=BE/�H524-o+.H�20N@/Ý 37ß@6\-u/7á

S�-p+.H?�pF;ëK/�-0+²FIH)H@/�2féi3760äE-�:K24N@/�-0/�Ý 37H=BºÝ�3KD�MÚ3KH@/�H72o3KW`F�VÁÜ>ï +²-�20N@/M=FK64FKDyó/ 24/�6\-¾F7-0-03EÝ +²Fs24/�B�éo+A20NÌ20N@/ �5ß=FIQ.+�2\Fs24+AT7/�-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/7áÚSÇVÁÜ>ï Ý 37H72\FI+.H=-�F ��VÁL�WX3K6

Page 12: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�9¡ � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

Popularity

Teaching-Ability

��� ��� � � � ���

Difficulty

Rating

����� � �Intelligence

Ranking

��� � ������

AVG

AVG

Grade

Satisfaction

��� ��� � � � ��� � ���

���������������������������

���

!"#%$ &

���������������'�����(�����������(��

)))))

"" ""

���*+Course.Rating

Course.Difficulty Student.Intelligenc

Professor.Teaching-Ability Registration.Grade

Professor.Popularity Student.RankingRegistration.Satisfaction

¹ q;½ ¹ �E½�! #"%$ &�$�,%$R¹ q;½ �%� e�^ » nÏv._�g.-0/2143 57698;:<6=3 >@?s¿%A ªr­C¸sµ q�mUw>d � e%^ » nÏv._�gÃq�m¾q�����gfe\�Cq�dfeÁw7e4bEe\m7�w7e4m5j4}_�v.BC69DFE4/G?<64¿ H ­�¶CI _�mJBK62DFE4/G?<60¿ H µ%L�®²±f³�µ0ªfµr¸NM�Ou¶ ¿%A ª�­;¸sµ ¿ ¹ �U½ �%� e�w7e\bEe4mUw7e4m5j4}$��guq�b �v²_�gid � ep{rj � _s_C� »,¼ ��¿

/�F7Ý\N FI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/�3KW�/�F7Ý\N Ý Q²FK-4-�á`S¾-yWX3K6y20N@/�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ +./�-�:�éi/�FK-4-uß=Dy/�20NRFs2�20N@/M=FK64FKDy/�20/�64-�FK60/)-0N=FK60/CBÞãUëà/�F7Ý\Nà3Kã Hf/CÝ92�+.Hí20N=/ºÝ Q²FK-4-�á MÞ/�FK-4-u3EÝ +²Fs24/Géo+�24N�/�F7Ý\NFs202064+Aã=ßE20/ � 3 ) FQ2)%68 =B*-01*3%B8 (B, W9#&%�')(�'G*-,.*-0 !?=6*�/�01#�*3'�� 07*3%68 2Gì�� 3 ) 9 V�FEì � 3 ) ð0ð9áZ?Ã+.åIóß@64/ Ká URìÆF5ð�-0N@3sé>-¾2fé�3:��ViL¾-�:�3KH=/�WX376�F�B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý ëÌ3KHàF�-0+.H@åKQ./ ó�TsFIQ.ß@/�BÞÝ\N=FI+.HFIHRB�37H@/�WX3K6GFIH'FIå7åK64/�å7FI20/ºB@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý ë7áÁï�3760/�M@64/�Ý +²-0/�Q.ëK:%QA/�2QP ãR/�24N@/�-u/�2�3KWM=FK60/�H72\-oV�F@ì�� 3 ) ð9á=âiFKÝ\N�3IW`20N@/C-u/PM=FK60/�H72\-;? 7 � éoN=/ 20N=/�6�F�-0+AD�M@Q./�Fs202064+Aã@ß@20/3K6FIHGFKåKåK64/�å5Fs24/� N=F7-�F$-0/ 2�3KWRTsFIQ.ß@/C-J*¾ì ? 7 ð`+AHG-03KD�/påK643Kß@H=B�2fëUMR/7áK?@376�/�FKÝ\N�20ß=M@QA/3IWiT;FKQAß=/�- � � *$ìRP�ð9:Zé�/�-0MR/CÝ +AWXëæF)BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H 2Gì�� 3 ) 9 � ð>3sT7/�6 *$ì�� 3 ) ð9á9MÞ/ß=-0/��4S R SUT V 243ÞBE/�H@3I24/)20N=/ºM=FK64FKDy/�20/�64-3KWo20N@+²-�BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�á`õpN=/º/�H524+A64/º-0/ 2�3KW20N=/�-0/M=FI6\FID�/ 24/�6\-�:5WX376>FIQ.Q � 3 ) FKH=B�FIQ.Q � :@Ý�3KD�M@64+.-0/�- � �%áW �@X ���%Y �[Z�� �]\ S W #&%�'F(�'G*-, *�/)07*32�#&5G,�(607*3%68 (B, : %>=�5+, � "!.L) �_^ WX3K6�F 60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ-4Ý\N@/�DGF=/ +²-BE/ çRH@/�BÏFK-¾WX3KQ.Q.3sé>-�á�?=3K6P/�F7Ý\NÞÝ Q²FK-4- � � � FIH=BÞ/�F7Ý\NÞBE/C-0Ý�60+.ME24+AT7/Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/ ) � ')ì �Þð9:@é�/PN=F;TK/�T` F�-0/ 2o3IW W (B#&5G8N03/PV�F@ì�� 3 ) ð 5 < ? 8 K�3�3�3XK ?Ua D7:UéoN@/�64/$/�FKÝ\N/? 7 N=F7-�24N@/$WX3K64D � 3 �

3K6 ��ì�� 3 � 3 ��ð9:=éoN@/�64/ ��+²->F�-uQ.3I2>Ý\N=FK+AH I` F 2)%68 =B*-01*3%B8 (B,�W9#&%�')(�'+*-,.*-0 ! =B*�/�01#�*3'�� 01*3%B8 � O ",� ��24N=Fs2Ì64/�M=60/C-u/�H72\- 2cbyì � 3 ) 9V�F@ì�� 3 ) ð4ð9á

�������dfehgji ���lk ��mY��� �

1$+.TK/�H�FIHUëí-uä7/�Q./ 243KH�:`éi/�N=F;T7/�FÌ-0/ 2�3IW¾64FKH=BE3KD TsFI64+²FIã@Q./�-�3IW�+.H520/�60/C-f2>T,24N@/�Fs2uó2064+.ã@ßE20/C-3K 3 ) 3KW�20N=/y37ã Hf/�Ý 24-¾+AHÞ20N=/y-0äK/�QA/�203KH,áÚ?=3K64D�FKQAQ.ëK:ÚQ./ 2Jnpo�ì �Þð¾BE/�H@3K20/�20N@/-0/ 2i3KW�3Kã Hf/CÝ92\-�+.Hº-uä7/�Q./ 243KH ��éoN@35-u/�Ý�Q.F7-0-Á+AH ��á5õpN@/¾-u/�2i3IW�6\FIHRBE3KD�T;FK60+²FIã=QA/C-�WX3K6�Ï+.-o20N@/�-0/ 2>3KW�Fs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-o3KWÃ24N@/WX3760D K 3 ) éoN@/�64/ K��qnro�ì�� 7 ðoFIH=B ) � 'ºì�� 7 ðWX3K6�-u37D�/>Ý Q²FK-4- � 7 á7õpN=/�VÁÜ>ï#-0MÚ/�Ý +Aç=/C-ÁFPM@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fë�BE+²-u2064+Aã@ß@20+.3KHG3sTK/�6%20N@/¾MR35-fó-0+Aã@Q./CHf37+AH52iF7-0-0+Aå7H@D�/�H524-�3IW�TsFIQ.ß@/�-�20324N@/�-0/>6\FIH=BE37D�TsFI64+²FIã@Q./�-�áKS�-Áéo+�24N �pF;ëK/�-0+²FIHH@/�2féi3760äE-�:s20N@/ Hf3K+.H72�BE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KHG3sT7/�6%24N@/�-0/�FK-4-0+Aå7H@D�/�H524-�Ý�FIHGãÚ/oWÆFKÝ 203K64/�B�áKõpN=Fs2

Page 13: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{ �9�

+²-�:sé�/�24FIä7/Á24N@/pM@643UB@ß=Ý92C:s3sTK/�6%FIQ.QAK 3 ) :s3KW=24N@/pM@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+�2fë+.H�20N@/ ��ViL 3KW=24N@/o-uMÚ/ óÝ +AçRÝ�T;FKQAß=/¾FK-4-0+Aå7H@/�ByãUëy20N@/¾+AH=-u24FKH=Ý />203�24N@/¾FI2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�åK+.TK/�H�20N@/¾TsFIQ.ß@/�-iFK-4-u+.åKH@/CB203G+A24->M=FI64/�H524-�á[email protected].ëK:U20N=+.-o+²-péo64+�2020/�H�F7-�WX3KQ.QA3sé>-JT

2Gì I 9 � K ��K � �,ð 5 6P � o

6S ����� P��

2Gì IQPR S 9 I�� � PR S�� ð

5 6S �

6S ����� S � �

6P ��� ��� S � �

2Gì IQPR S 9 I��� � P.R S�� ð ì�Ká�Cð

õpN@+²-�/ èEM@64/�-4-0+A37H�+²-�TK/�60ë�-u+.D�+AQ²FI6%24320N@/>Ý\NRFI+.Hy64ß@Q./�WX3K6 �pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH�H@/ 2fé�3K64äE-�áIõpN=/�64/FI64/�2fé�3æM@64+ADGFI64ëÞB@+�YZ/�64/�H=Ý�/�-�á,?`+A6\-u2�:,37ß@6�6\FIHRBE3KD T;FK60+²FIã=QA/C-�FI64/�20N@/�Fs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-3IW�FG-0/ 2�3KW`37ã Hf/�Ý 24-�áN�U/CÝ 3KHRB�:@24N@/�-0/ 2>3IW�M=FK60/�H524-p3IW�F�6\FIH=B@3KD TsFI64+²FIã@Q./�Ý�FKH�TsFK60ëFKÝ�Ý 3764BE+.H@å�203$20N@/p64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQEÝ 37H520/ èU2%3IWR20N@/p3Kã Hf/�Ý92B�"24N@/o-u/�2%3KW=3Kã Hf/�Ý92\-`203$éoN@+²Ý\N+A2>+.-o64/�Q²Fs24/�B�á

S�-�+AHæFKHUë�BE/�ç=H@+A20+.3KH�3KW`24N@+²-o2fëUMR/7:=é�/�N=F;T7/P203G2\FIäK/�Ý�FI64/P20N=FI2>20N=/�64/�-0ß@Q�24+AH=åWXß@H=Ý 20+.3KH�WX643KD�+AH=-u24FKH=Ý /C-%203HUß@D�ãR/�64-ÁBE3U/�-�+.H=BE/�/�BGBE/�ç=H@/�F 2)%&A�5G#F5G8N0`M=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+�2fëBE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�:�+~á /7áA:�éoN=/�64/�24N@/)-0ß@D 3IWi20N@/GM=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+�2fë�3KW�FIQ.Q�+.H=-f2\FIH=Ý�/�-P+²- �á�örH�pF;ëK/C-u+²FIHàH@/�2féi3760äE-�:,éoN@/�60/G24N@/ Hf3K+.H72yM@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+A2fëÞ+²-�FKQ.-03ÌF�M=603EBEß=Ý 2�3KWL��VÁL$-�:20N=+.-¾60/>�5ß@+A64/�D�/�H72>+²-�-4Fs24+.-uç=/CB�+�W%20N=/�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ë�åK6\FIM@N�+²-�FKÝ�ëEÝ Q.+.Ý�TRF�TsFI64+.FKã@Q./+.-H@3K2oFKH�FKH=Ý /C-f243K6Á3KW,+A24-0/�QAWfá@S -0+.Dy+.Q²FI6pÝ 3KHRBE+�24+A37Hº+²-p-uß Z)Ý�+A/�H72p243�/�H=-uß=60/$Ý 3KN=/�64/�H=Ý�/+.H�ViÜ>ïæ-oF7-péi/�QAQ~á MÞ/épFIH52p203�/�H=-uß=60/$20NRFs2o3Kß@6oM=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+.-u20+²Ý¾B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý +./�-�FI64/FKÝ�ëEÝ Q.+.ÝK:5-03�24N=Fs2oF�6\FIHRBE3KD TsFI64+.FKã@Q./¾BE3U/�-iH@3K2pBE/�MR/�H=B�:EBE+.60/CÝ924QAëG376i+.H=BE+.60/CÝ924QAë7:737H+A24-3séoHÏTsFIQ.ß@/Ká�õÃ3�BE3�-u3R:�éi/GÝ�FKHíÝ 3KHR-u+²BE/�6$24N@/GåK6\FIM@NÞ3IWoBE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�+A/C-FID�3KH=åFs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-�3IW¾37ã Hf/�Ý 24-�+.H�24N@/æ-0äK/�Q./ 243KH�á �i37H=-u+²BE/�6�24N@/�M=FI64/�H52\-�3KW$FKH�FI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/� 3 ) á M�N@/�H � 3 �ô+.-PF�M=FI64/�H52P3IW � 3 ) :Úé�/�BE/ ç=H=/�FKHÌ/CBEåK/,K 3 ��� o K 3 ) I�éoN@/�H��ì�� 3 � 3 ��ð�+²-�FM=FI64/�H52Á3KW � 3 ) FIH=B�� �(K 3 ��:Ué�/�BE/�ç=H@/¾FKH)/�B@åK/ � 3 ��� o K 3 ) á�MÞ/-4F;ë�20N=FI2�F�B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý ëÞ-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/ �Ë+.- (�2X!�2+,.*32G64/�Q²Fs24+AT7/�243�F�-0äK/�QA/�2037H � +�W�20N@/BE+.60/CÝ924/�B�åK6\FIM=N�B@/ ç=H@/CB�ãUë�� o 3sT7/�6�20N=/�TsFI64+.FKã@Q./�-MK 3 ) +²->F7Ý ëEÝ Q.+.ÝKá@örH�20N=+.-¾Ý�FK-0/K:é�/$FK60/¾åKß=FK64FKH724/�/CBy20N=FI2�24N@/PVÁÜ>ï BE/ ç=H=/�-pF�Ý�3KN@/�60/�H52iM@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+²-f24+.Ý�D�3UB@/�QZ3sTK/�6Ý 37D�M@QA/�20/+.H=-u24FIH524+.FI20+.3KH=-6I'Ý 37H=-0+.-u20/�H72oéo+A20N �%á

õpN@+²-PM@643UÝ�/�BEß=60/�FIQ.QA3sé>-$ß=-$243�Ý\N@/�Ý\ä�éoN@/�20N@/�6�F�BE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�ëÌ-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/ �É+.-FKÝ�ëEÝ Q.+.Ý$64/�Q²Fs20+.TK/$243�Fyç=èU/CB�-uä7/�Q./ 2037H �%á �>3sé�/�TK/�6�:5é�/3IW°20/�H�é�FKH72>-u20643KH@å7/�6påKßRFI60óFIH524/�/�-JT�é�/yépFIH52P203�/�H=-uß=60/y20NRFs2�3Kß=6PB@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý ëÏ-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/�+²-FKÝ ëEÝ�QA+²Ý�WX3K6�FIHUë-0äK/�Q./ 243KH�20N=FI2>éi/FK60/$QA+.äK/�QAë)203G/�HRÝ 3Kß=H724/�6Cá �>3sé BE3�éi/PåKßRFI6\FIH520/�/�24N@+.-pM=6037MR/�6u2fëã=F7-u/CBæ3KH=QAë�37HÌ24N@/GÝ Q²FK-4-fó�QA/�TK/�QÃVÁÜ�ï��GõÃ3�BE3�-03=:Zéi/�Ý 37H=-0+.BE/�6PMR3K20/�H524+.FKQ%B@/�MÚ/�HEóBE/�H=Ý +./�-�Fs2i20N@/$Ý Q²FK-4-�Q./�TK/�Q�á5ï�3K64/>M@64/�Ý�+.-0/�Q.ëK:7éi/¾BE/ ç=H=/¾F�2+,(E/)/ =�5 W 5+8 =�5G892X!Q��#&(VW AU:éoN@+²Ý\N�64/G�R/�Ý92\-�24N@/�-0/oBE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�+A/C- � 7áE�U: Ká "E��á;õpN=+.-%Ý Q²FK-4-%BE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�ë�åK6\FIM=N�N=FK-FIHÌ/�BEå7/�WX643KD 5 3 �À203 � 3 ) +�WÁ/�+�24N@/�6>T � 5 5ÀFKH=B � 3 � +²-PF)M=FK60/�H72¾3IW � 3 ) IÚ3K6��ì�� 3 � 3 ��ð�+.-PF)MRFI64/�H52¾3KW � 3 ) FKH=BæÜ>FKH@åK/�� � 3 � � 5 5)á�?`+Aå7ß@64/�Ká URìÆãRð>-0N@3sé>-�20N@/BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ëºå764FKM@N�WX3K6o3Kß=6>-0Ý\N@3U37QZB@3KDGFI+.H�á

õpN@/�Dy35-f2y3KãUTU+A37ß=-�FKM@M@6437FKÝ\NÏWX376�ß=-0+.H@å�20N=/�Ý Q²FK-4-�B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý ëíå764FKM@Ní+²-203-0+AD�M@Q.ë)64/J�5ß@+.60/�20N=FI2p+A2pãR/FKÝ�ëEÝ Q.+.ÝKáUõpN=+.-�64/J�5ß@+.60/�Dy/�H52�+²-�/J�5ß@+.T;FKQA/�H52i243yF7-0-0ß@D�+AH=åFÌ-u206\Fs24+�çÚÝ�Fs24+A37HíFID�3KH@åæ20N@/�Fs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-�3IWo24N@/�BE+AYZ/�64/�H52�Ý Q²FK-4-0/�-�:ÃFIHRBí60/>�5ß@+A64+.H@å20NRFs2p20N@/$M=FK60/�H72\-Á3KW,FIH�Fs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/¾M=60/CÝ /�B@/�+A2p+.H)24N@/P-f2464FI20+AçRÝ�FI20+.3KH)3764BE/�60+.H@åRáKö�2p+.-Ý Q./�FK6,24N=Fs2�+AW@20N=/�Ý�Q.F7-0-%BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ëåK6\FIM=N�+.-%F7Ý ëEÝ Q.+.ÝK:�é�/pÝ�FIH�H@/�T7/�6`N=F;TK/Á20N=FI2LK 3 )

Page 14: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

 �� � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

Blood Type

M - c h r om os om e

P - c h r om os om e Person

Blood Type

M - c h r om os om e

P - c h r om os om e Person

Result

C o n ta m i n a ted

B l ood T est

Blood Type

M - c h r om os om e

P - c h r om os om e

PersonBlood Type

M - c h r om os om e

P - c h r om os om e

Person

( F a t h er) ( M ot h er)

Person.M-chromosome Person.P-chromosome

BloodTest.Result

BloodTest.Contaminated

Person.BloodType

¹ q;½ ¹ �E½�! #"%$ &�$ � $�¹ qC½,�à{rklab7��e »�¼ �Év²_�g`d � eÁ��e\m5e0dfk�j4{%w7_�a�q�klmR¿ ¹ �E½Zd � e�j\_�grgfe\{rbE_Cm5w7klm5��w7e4bEe\m7�w7e4m5j4}���guq�b � ¿5noq�{ � e9w�e9w7��e\{�j\_�grgfe\{rbE_�mUw�df_��~�Cc5q�guq�mIdfe4e9w�q�j0}7j4��klj���wKe\bEe\m5w7e\m7j\kle\{\¿

BE/�MR/�H=B@-pìÆBE+.64/�Ý924QAë$3K6Ã+AHRBE+A64/�Ý 20Q.ë@ð�3KH�+�2\-u/�Q�Wfá;?@376,/ è@FKDyM=QA/7:�+AW=éi/Á/ è@FID�+.H@/�20N=/iVÁÜ�ï3IW�?`+.åKß@64/ Ká D=ìÆãRð9:7éi/�Ý�FIH�/�F7-u+.Q.ë�Ý 37HUT5+.H=Ý�/o3Kß@6\-u/�QAT7/�-`24N=Fs2Áé�/�Ý�FIH@H@3K2ÁÝ 64/�FI20/>F�Ý�ë7óÝ Q./$+AH�FIHUë�+AH=-u24FKH=Ý /7á7örHRBE/�/CB�:EFK-iéi/$-0F;é�+.H�?`+.åKß@64/�7á UÚìXãRð :K24N@/$Ý�Q.F7-0-�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ëåK6\FIM=Ní+.-yFKÝ�ëUÝ�QA+²ÝIá%<>3K20/7:ÃN@3sé�/�T7/�6C:�20NRFs2�+�W�é�/)+.H520643UB@ß=Ý /�FKB@BE+A20+.3KHRFIQpBE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�HEóÝ +./�-�é�/$Ý�FIH�Ý 64/�Fs24/¾Ý�ëUÝ�QA/C-�áE?=3K6�/ è@FID�M@Q./K:U+AWÃé�/�DGFIä7/ ������� �������rá #N5)(�2NA�*-8��

�J '+*-,.*-0 !

BE/�MR/�H=B�3KH�24N@/�6\Fs20+.H@åÏ3IW¾Ý�3Kß@6\-0/�-�-uN=/º24/�FKÝ\N=/�-�ìX/7á åRáA:�+AW$N=+Aå7N�20/CFKÝ\N@+.H@åÏ64FI20+.H@å7-+.H=Ý 64/�F7-u/>N=/�6ÁD�3K20+.T;FI20+.3KHRð :K24N@/�H)20N@/¾60/C-uß@QA20+.H@å�Ý�Q.F7-0-ÁBE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�ëyå764FKM@NG+²-ÁÝ ëEÝ�QA+²ÝI:FIHRBÏ20N@/�60/G+²-�H@3æ-u206\Fs24+�çÚÝ�Fs24+A37Hà3K6\BE/�6P24N=Fs2�+²-�Ý�3KH=-0+²-f24/�H52�éo+�24Nà20N@/�VÁÜ>ï -u2064ß=Ý9ó20ß=60/7áZS�HÞ+.H=FKã@+AQ.+A2fë�203�-f2464FI20+AWXë�24N@/GÝ Q²FK-4-¾B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý ë�å764FKM@Næ+.D�M@QA+./�-¾24N=Fs2$20N@/�60/FI64/)-0äK/�Q./ 243KH=-WX3K6�éoN@+²Ý\Nà20N=/ºVÁÜ>ï éo+.Q.QÁ+.H=BEß=Ý�/ºFæBE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37Híéo+�24N�Ý ëEÝ Q.+²ÝGBE/ óMÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý +./�-�á=örH�å7/�H@/�64FKQ�:=N@3séi/�TK/�6�:EF)Ý�ëUÝ�QA/+.H�20N=/�Ý Q²FK-4->BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ë�åK6\FIM@N�BE3U/�-H@3K2>+AD�M@Q.ë)24N=Fs2�FKQAQ�-0äK/�QA/�203KHR-p+AH=B@ß=Ý /Ý ëEÝ�QA+²ÝBE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�+A/C-�áM�N@+.QA/�20N@+²-�-0+AD�M@Q./�FKM@M@6437FKÝ\N�Ý Q./�FK60Q.ë)/�H=-uß=60/C->FKÝ�ëUÝ�QA+²Ý +A2fëK:=+�2�+²-o243U3GQA+.D�+�24/�B�203

Ý 3sT7/�6¾D�FKHUë�+.D�MR376u2\FIH52$Ý�FK-0/�-�á �i3KHR-u+²BE/�6C:RWX3K6�/�è@FID�M@Q./K:ZFº-0+AD�M@Q./�å7/�H@/�20+²Ý�D�3EBE/�Q3IW¾20N@/�+.H@N@/�60+A24FKH=Ý /�3IWPFÞ-0+AH=åKQ./�å7/�H@/�20NRFs2)BE/ 24/�64D�+AH@/C-�FÌMÚ/�6\-u37H U -�ã=QA3U3EB�2fëUMÚ/K:-0N@3séoH�+AH�?`+Aå7ß@64/ 7á �=ìÆF5ð9á=âiFKÝ\NºMÚ/�6\-03KH�N=FK-�2fé�3GÝ 37M@+A/C-o3IW`20N=/�Ý\N@6037D�37-03KD�/$Ý�3KHEó24FK+AH=+AH@å�20N=+.-�åK/�H@/K:U37H@/�+.H@N@/�60+A20/CB)WX643KD N@/�6�D�3K20N@/�6�:UFIH=Bº3KH@/$+.H@N@/�64+A20/�B)WX6037D N@/�6WÆFs24N@/�6Cá�õpN@/�64/º+²-�FIQ²-u3ÞFÌMÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q.ëíÝ 3KH52\FID�+AHRFs20/CBà20/C-f2y20NRFs2GFs2u24/�D�ME2\-�243Þ64/�Ý�3KåKóH@+���/�20N@/�MÚ/�6\-u37H U -�ã@Q.3U3UBí2fë5MÚ/Ká 3¾ß@6�-4Ý\N@/�DGFÌÝ�3KH524FK+AHR-2fé�3ÞÝ Q²FK-4-0/�-4��.�$������FIHRB� V ���A��� ��B�9á��iQ.F7-0-,���������GN=F7-¾64/ WX/�60/�H=Ý /�-0QA3K24-@)Q%60 A 5+#$FKH=B R (60 A 5+#$FKH=BÌB@/�-4Ý 64+AMEó20+.TK/�Fs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�- " 5+8 =�5G#�:9"

�O A�#F%6:<%E/+%6:<5yì°20N=/�Ý\N@643KD�37-03KD�/P+AH=N@/�64+�24/�B�WX643KDô20N@/

WÆFs24N@/�69ð9:�FKH=B )�O A�#&%B: %6/+%6:<5�ìX+.H@N@/�64+A20/�B�WX643KD 20N@/�D�3I24N@/�69ð9á M;,%J%>=�#N5G/)0pN=F7-�F

64/ WX/�64/�HRÝ /)-0QA3K2 #�5G/�0�� *�20N=FI2�MR37+AH52\-P203�24N@/G3séoH@/�6�3IW�20N@/)20/�-u2�:`FIH=BàBE/C-0Ý�60+.ME24+AT7/

Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-5O %68�0 (6: *-8 (B0L5)=PFKH=B/. 5G/N� , 0ÆáörH�3Kß@6�åK/�H=/ 20+²Ý$D�3UB@/�Q~:@20N=/åK/�H=3I2fëUMR/3KW%F�MÚ/�6\-03KH�BE/�MÚ/�H=B=->3KH�20N=/�åK/�H@3I2fëUMÚ/

3IWoN@+²-�M=FI64/�H524-JI�24N5ßR-�:`Fs2�24N@/�Ý�Q.F7-0-Q./�T7/�Q~:�é�/)N=F;TK/�";5G#)/+%68 3."�O A�#&%B: %6/+%6:<5�BE/ ó

MÚ/�H=BE+.H@åºB@+A64/�Ý 20Q.ëº3KHQ" 5+#)/+%68 3."�O A�#&%B: %6/G%B: 5EáRS�->éi/�Ý�FIH�-u/�/+AHæ?`+.åKß@64/ Ká��@ìÆãRð9:

20N=+.-�BE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�ëÞ64/�-0ß@QA24-P+.H�F�Ý ëEÝ Q./�20N=FI2�Ý Q./�FK60Q.ëæTU+A37Q.FI20/C-$20N@/)64/J�5ß@+.64/�D�/�H524-P3KW3Kß=6p-0+.DyM=QA/�FKM@M@6437FKÝ\N,áS��3séi/�TK/�6C:5+�2o+²-oÝ Q./�FI6�243�ß=-�24N=Fs2p24N@/�BE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�+A/C-p+AH�20N=+.-

Page 15: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{  I�

D�3EBE/�Q`FI64/H@3I2�F7Ý920ßRFIQ.QAë�Ý ëEÝ Q.+.ÝWX3K6�FKH5ë�-uä7/�Q./ 243KH�20N=FI2�éi/éo+.Q.Q,/�HRÝ 3Kß=H724/�6>+.H�20N=+.-BE37D�FK+AH,á@õpN@/P60/CFK-03KHº+²-�20NRFs2�:=+AH��uQ./�å7+�24+ADGFs24/J�y-uä7/�Q./ 243KH=-iWX3K6p24N@+²-o-0Ý\N@/�DGF@:@FyMR/�6uó-03KHºÝ�FIH@H@3K2ÁãÚ/¾N@+²-i3séoH)FIH=Ý�/�-u203K6C:KéoN=+.Ý\NºB@+.-4FIQ.QA3sé>-�20N@/P-u+A20ßRFs20+.3KHº3IW�20N=/�MÚ/�6\-u37H U -åK/�H@3I2fëUMÚ/iBE/�MR/�H=BE+.H@åGìÆBE+.64/�Ý924QAëP376Ã+.H=BE+.60/CÝ924QAë@ð,3KH�+A24-0/�QAWfá;örH�3K20N@/�6Ãé�3K6\B@-�:CFKQ�24N@3Kß@å7N20N=/Dy3EBE/�Q�FIM@MÚ/�FK64-i243yãÚ/�Ý ëEÝ�QA+²ÝPFs2p20N@/Ý�Q.F7-0-pQ./�T7/�Q~:5é�/PäUH@3sé 24N=Fs2p20N=+.->Ý�ëEÝ Q.+.Ý�+�2fë+²->FIQ.é�F;ëE-�64/�-03KQ.TK/�BºFs2o20N=/QA/�TK/�Q�3KW`+.H=BE+.TU+.B@ß=FIQ�37ã Hf/�Ý 24-�á

3¾ß@6�FIã@+.QA+A2fë�203�å7ß=FI6\FIH524/�/p20NRFs2Á24N@/¾Ý�ëEÝ Q.+.Ý�+�2fëy+.-i64/�-03KQ.TK/�By64/�Q.+A/C-�37H)-u37Dy/�M@60+.3K6äUH@3séoQ./�BEå7/p20N=FI2Áéi/oNRF;TK/oFIãÚ3KßE2Á20N@/�B@3KDGFI+.H�áBMÏ/>épFIH52�203�FKQAQ.3sé 20N@/>ßR-u/�6�203å7+AT7/ß=-�+AHEWX3760DGFI20+.3KH�-ußRÝ\N�F7-p20N=+.-�:R-03�20N=FI2�é�/�Ý�FKH�DGFKäK/�-u20643KH@å7/�6oåKßRFI6\FIH520/�/�-pFIãÚ3KßE2FKÝ�ëEÝ Q.+.Ý�+�2fë7á�õpN@/�ß=-0/�6,Ý�FIH-0MR/CÝ +AWXë�24N=Fs2ÃÝ�/�6024FK+AHP-uQ.3I2\-�FI64/ �P��(6#&(B8�0 5F5)=P(�2�!�2G, *32 áCörH3Kß@6åK/�H@/ 24+.Ý�-%/ è@FID�M@Q./K:PR (60 A 5+#¾FKH=B )Q%B0?A�5G#$FI64/iå7ß=FI6\FIH520/�/�B�F7Ý ëEÝ Q.+²ÝBIsÝ ëEÝ Q./�-%+.HUTK37QATU+.H@å20N=/�-0/yFI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/C-�DGF;ë�+AHÌWÆFKÝ 2¾ãÚ/�Q./�å5FIQ~á=örHæWÆF7Ý92C:=24N@/�ëæFK60/�D�ßE20ßRFIQ.QAë�åKßRFI6\FIH520/�/�BFKÝ�ëEÝ Q.+.ÝK:%-03æ24N=Fs2)Ý�3KD�MR35-u+A20+.3KHR-�3KW>20N@/�-0QA3K24-�FI64/�FKQ.-03Ìå7ß=FI6\FIH520/�/�BíF7Ý ëEÝ Q.+.ÝKá�?Ã+.åIóß@64/ Ká��@ìXãÚð¾-0N@3sé>-¾20N=/�Ý�Q.F7-0-PBE/�MR/�H=BE/�H=Ý ëÞåK6\FIM@NÌWX3K6$20N@/�å7/�H@/�20+²Ý�-BE37D�FK+AH,:�éo+�24NåKßRFI6\FIH520/�/�BÌF7Ý ëEÝ Q.+²Ý�/CBEåK/C--uN=3séoHÏF7-B@FK-0N@/�BÞ/�B@åK/�-�á�ö�220ß=60H=-P37ßE220NRFs2�ãÚ/�Ý�FKß=-0/FIQ.Q�3KWÃ24N@/�Ý ëEÝ�QA/C-p+AH�24N@+.->åK6\FIM@N�Ý 37H72\FI+.H�D�ßE24ß=FIQ.QAë�åKß=FK64FKH520/�/CBºF7Ý ëEÝ Q.+.Ý$64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=-�:20N=/�-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/P+²-oQA/�å7FKQ�áEörHV�Ká "E�~:=éi/å7+AT7/PFKH�FKQAå73K64+�24N@D WX376>Ý\N@/�Ý\äU+.H@åy20N@/Q./�å5FIQ.+�2fë3IW�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/C-�20N=FI2�Ý 37H72\FI+.Hºå7ß=FI6\FIH520/�/�B�FKÝ ëEÝ�QA+²ÝP-uQ.3I2\-oFIH=B�-0QA3K2oÝ\NRFI+.H=-�á

Ð�Ñ����Q� �`ÕRÓ�ÛuÓ�� � ��� �

örHy20N@/�M@60/�TU+A37ß=-%-u/CÝ920+.3KHR-�:sé�/>BE/ çRH@/�B�20N=/>VÁÜ>ïêQ²FIH@å7ß=FIå7/�FKH=By+�2\-�-u/�DGFIH520+²Ý�-�á6MÞ/H@3sé'D�3sTK/o24320N=/>24F7-uäy3IW�Q./�FK60H=+AH@å�F�VÁÜ>ïêWX643KD B@FI24F@á7örHG20N=/�Q./�FI64H@+.H@å�M@643Kã=QA/�D�:3Kß=6i+.H@M@ßE2oÝ 37H524FI+.H=-iF60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQR-4Ý\N@/�DGF=:I20NRFs2o-uMÚ/�Ý�+�ç=/C-�24N@/�ãRFK-0+.Ý�TK3EÝ�FKã@ß@Q²FI64ë�+.H20N=/�BE3KDGFK+AH � 24N@/�-u/�2�3IW�Ý Q²FK-4-0/�-�:U20N@/�FI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/C->FK-4-03UÝ�+.FI20/CBºéo+A20N�24N@/�BE+AYÚ/�60/�H72Ý Q²FK-4-0/�-�:�FIH=BÏ24N@/GMR35-0-0+.ã@QA/)2fë5MÚ/�-�3IWp60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=-PãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�Hí3Kã Hf/CÝ924-�+AHÏ20N=/ºBE+AYÚ/�60/�H72Ý Q²FK-4-0/�-æìÆéoN@+.Ý\N -0+.DyM=QAë'-uMÚ/�Ý�+�çR/�-�24N@/æDGFIM@M=+AH@å�ãR/�2féi/�/�H�FàWX3K64/�+.åKH'ä7/�ë�+.H�3KH=/24FKã@Q./�FIHRB�20N@/�FK-4-03UÝ�+.FI20/CB�M@60+.DGFI64ë�ä7/�ë@ð9á 3¾ß@6¾206\FI+.H@+AH=åºB@Fs2\FºÝ�3KH=-0+.-u24-�3IWÁF)WXß@QAQ.ë-0MR/CÝ +Aç=/�BÏ+.H=-f2\FIH=Ý�/�3IWÁ24N=Fs2�-4Ý\N@/�DGF=á MÞ/GFK-4-0ß@D�/�24N=Fs2P24N@+.-�+AH=-u24FKH=Ý /�+²-PåK+.TK/�HÌ+.H20N=/GWX3K64D 3KWpF�64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQ�B=Fs24FKã=FK-0/KáÃS>QA20N@37ß@åKNí37ß@6�FIM@M=6035FKÝ\NÏéi37ß@Q.BàFKQ.-03�éi3760äéo+A20N�3K20N@/�6�64/�M@64/�-0/�H524FI20+.3KH=-GìÆ/Ká å=á.:`F�-0/ 2y3IWoåK643Kß=H=BÞWÆFKÝ92\-�Ý�3KD�M@Q./ 20/CBíß=-0+AH=å�20N@/Ý Q.37-0/�B�éi3760Q²BFK-4-uß=DyM@20+.3KHRð : 20N=/i/�ZGÝ�+A/�H52 �5ß@/�64ëU+AH=å�FIã@+.Q.+�2fë$3IW@64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQ5B@Fs2\FIã=F7-u/C-+²-�M=FK6u24+.Ý�ß@Q²FI64QAë�N@/�Q.MEWXß@Q`+AHÌ3Kß@6�WX64FKDy/�éi3760äZ:@FKH=B�DGFIä7/�-o+A2¾MÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./203�FIM@M=QAë�3Kß@6FIQ.åK3760+A20N=D�-�243�Q.FK60å7/$B@FI24F7-u/�24-�á

õpN@/�60/�FI64/�2féi3ÏTsFI64+.FKH72\-y3IW�24N@/�QA/CFI64H@+.H@åÌ2\FK-0ä9T�M=FI6\FID�/ 24/�6�/�-u20+.DGFs24+A37H FIHRB-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/�Q./�FK60H=+AH@åRá�örH'20N=/æM=FI6\FID�/�20/�6G/C-f24+ADGFI20+.3KH'24F7-uäZ:�é�/æFK-4-0ß@D�/�20N=FI2)20N@/�5ß=FIQ.+A24Fs24+AT7/ÁBE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ë�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/Á3IWE20N=/iVÁÜ�ï +.-ÃäUH@3séoH I�+�á /Ká.:�24N@/Á+.H@M@ß@2%Ý�3KH=-0+.-u24-3IW�20N@/à-4Ý\N@/�DGF�FIH=B 206\FI+.H@+AH=å B@FI24FIãRFK-0/�ì�FK-�FIãÚ3sTK/Cð :oFK-�éi/�QAQFK-�F��5ß=FIQ.+�2\Fs24+AT7/BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ëÞ-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/ �¾á,õpN@/�QA/CFI64H@+.H@åº2\FK-0ä�+.-P37H@Q.ë�203�ç=Q.Q�+AHÏ20N=/yMRFI6\FID�/ 24/�6\-20NRFs2¾BE/�ç=H@/24N@/@��VÁL$->3KWÃ24N@/�FI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/C-�á=örH�20N@/�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/QA/CFI64H@+AH=å�24FK-0äZ:U20N@/�60/+²-PH@3�F7B@BE+A20+.3KH=FKQ�60/>�5ß@+A64/�Bæ+AH@M=ßE2ºìÆFKQ�24N@3Kß@å7Næ24N@/�ß=-u/�6Ý�FIH,:�+�WpF;T;FK+AQ²FIã=QA/7:RM@643sTU+.B@/M@64+A376�äUH@3séoQ./�BEå7/)FIãÚ3KßE2�24N@/�-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/K:�/7á åRáA:Ã+AH�20N@/GWX3760D 3IW>Ý�3KH=-u206\FI+.H524-\ð9á,õpN@/åK35FIQÃ+.-�203�/ èU206\FKÝ 2$FIHÌ/�H520+.60/yVÁÜ>ï�:Ú-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/�FK-¾éi/�QAQ%FK-�M=FI6\FID�/�20/�6\-�:@WX643KDê20N@/206\FI+.H@+.H@åGB@Fs2\FIã=F7-u/FKQA37H@/Ká�MÏ/�BE+.-4Ý ßR-0-o/CFKÝ\N�3IW`20N@/C-u/M@643Kã=QA/�D�-�+.H�20ß@64H�á

Page 16: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

 C  � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

����� �� e �� 0k � Y������ �GY �[k Y �[Z��

MÏ/yãÚ/�å7+AHÞéo+�24Næ24N@/�M=FI6\FID�/ 24/�6¾/�-u20+.D�FI20+.3KHÌ24FK-0ä�WX3K6FºViÜ>ï"éoN=/�64/�24N@/yB@/�MÚ/�HEóBE/�H=Ý ë�-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/+²-oäUH@3séoH�áEörH�3I24N@/�6>é�3K6\B@-�:Eéi/FK60/PåK+.TK/�Hº24N@/�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/ ��24N=Fs2BE/�20/�64D�+AH=/�-p24N@/�-u/�2o3IW%M=FI64/�H524-iWX376o/�FKÝ\N�Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/7:=FIH=B�3Kß=6p24FK-0ä)+²-p203�Q./�FK60H�20N@/M=FK64FKDy/�20/�64- � ��20N=FI2)BE/ ç=H=/�24N@/7��VÁL$-yWX3K6y20N=+.-G-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/Ká M�N@+.QA/�20N=+.-y2\FK-0äí+.-64/�Q²Fs20+.TK/�QAë�-f2464FK+Aå7N52uWX3K64épFI6\B�:E+�2¾+.-�3IW�+.H724/�64/�-u2>+AHÞFIH=B�3KW%+A24-0/�QAWfáZâ�èEMR/�60+./�HRÝ /+.H�20N@/-0/ 2u24+AH=åÌ3IW �pF;ë7/�-0+.FKHÏH=/ 2fé�3K64äU-�-uN@3sé>-�20N=FI2�24N@/��5ß=FKQA+A24FI20+.TK/�B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý ëí-u2064ß=Ý9ó20ß=60/æÝ�FIH�ãR/�WÆFK+A64QAë�/�FK-0ëà203í/�QA+²Ý +A2GWX643KD"NUß@DGFIH�/ èEMÚ/�6024-�:�+AH�Ý�FK-0/�-�éoN@/�60/�-0ß=Ý\N/ èEMÚ/�6024-oFK60/F;TsFI+.Q.FKã@Q./KáUörH�FKB@BE+A20+.3KH,:U20N@/M=FK64FKD�/ 20/�6p/�-u20+.D�FI20+.3KH�24F7-uä)+²-oF�Ý 64ß=Ý +²FIQÝ 37D�MR37H@/�H52p+AHº20N@/P-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/¾QA/CFI64H@+AH=å�FIQ.åK3760+A20N@D BE/C-0Ý�60+.ãÚ/�BG+.H)24N@/¾H=/ èU2p-0/�Ý 20+.3KH�á

õpN@/¾äK/�ë�+.H@åK64/�B@+A/�H72�+AHºM=FI6\FID�/ 24/�6i/�-u20+.D�FI20+.3KH�+.-Á20N@/ ,.*[%�5G, *[A %>%J=;*N� 8 2+01*3%B8=:520N@/M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fë�3IWÚ20N=/>B@Fs2\F¾å7+AT7/�H�20N@/oD�3EBE/�Q�áKõpN=+.-%WXß=H=Ý924+A37HyD�/CFK-0ß@60/C-Ã20N@/>/�èU20/�H52%203éoN@+²Ý\Ny20N@/>MRFI6\FID�/ 24/�6\-ÃM=603sTU+²BE/oFPåK3U3EB�/�è[email protected]=Fs24+A37H�3KWR24N@/�B@FI24F=áIörH520ß@+A20+.TK/�QAë7:s20N@/N@+.åKN@/�6�24N@/ÁM@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fë�3KWE20N@/iB@Fs2\FoåK+.TK/�HP20N@/�D�3EBE/�Q�:�20N@/iãR/�2u24/�6Ã20N@/ÁFKã@+.QA+A2fë¾3KWE20N@/D�3EBE/�QZ243�M@64/�B@+.Ý 2�24N@/PB@Fs2\F@áEõpN@/PQA+.äK/�QA+.N@3U3EB)3KWÃF�MRFI6\FID�/ 24/�6p-u/�2�+²-oBE/ çRH@/�Bº203yãR/20N=/$M=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+�2fëy3IW�24N@/B@Fs2\F�å7+AT7/�HG24N@/¾D�3EBE/�Q1T���ì � � 9 I�K�� K �pð 5 2Gì I 9 � K � K � �,ð:3S�-P+.HÏD�FKHUëæÝ�FK-0/�-�:Z+�2+²-PD�3K64/yÝ�3KHUTK/�H@+A/�H52�203�é�3K64ä�éo+�24NÞ24N@/�QA37å7FK60+A20N@D 3KWÁ20N=+.-WXß@H=Ý 20+.3KH T� ì � � 9 I K�� K ��ð 5 QA37å 2Gì I 9 � K ��K � �,ð

5S �

S ����� S � �

�� P ��� � � S � �

QA37å 2Gì IQPR S 9 I�� � PR S�� ð� � 3 ì�Ká�@Kð

õpN@/�ä7/�ë�+AH=-0+.åKN52�+²-o20NRFs2>24N@+.-�/J�5ß=FI20+.3KH�+²->TK/�60ë�-u+.D�+AQ²FI6�203�20N=/�Q.3KåIó�Q.+Aä7/�Q.+AN@3U3EB3IW�B@FI24F�å7+AT7/�H�F<��F;ë7/�-0+.FKHºH@/�2féi3760ä4� 7á���~áRörH�WÆFKÝ92C:=+A2�+²-p20N@/�QA+.äK/�QA+.N@3U3EBºWXß=H=Ý924+A37H3IWP24N@/Q�pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH�H@/ 2fé�3K64ä�+.H=BEß=Ý�/�B'ãUë 20N@/Ì-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/�åK+.TK/�H 24N@/Ì-0äK/�QA/�203KH T�20N@/H@/�2féi3760ä�éo+A20NíF�64FKH=BE37D TsFI64+.FKã@QA/�WX3K6/CFKÝ\NàFs202064+Aã@ß@20/G3IW�/�F7Ý\NÞ37ã Hf/�Ý 23K 3 ) :,FIHRB20N=/>BE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�ë�D�3EBE/�QE+.H=BEßRÝ /�ByãUë ��FKH=B �%:KFK-�BE+²-4Ý ß=-4-u/CB�+.H �U/�Ý 20+.3KH Ká U=á�@EásõpN@/3KH=QAë�BE+AYÚ/�60/�H=Ý /pWX643KDÇ-f2\FIH=B@FK64B �pF;ëK/C-u+²FIHyH@/�2féi3760ä�MRFI6\FID�/ 24/�6�/�-u20+.DGFs24+A37Hy+²-�24N=Fs2M=FK64FKDy/�20/�64-�WX376�BE+AYÚ/�60/�H72¾H@3EBE/�-�+AH�20N=/�H@/ 2fé�3K64ä5� 20N@35-u/�Ý�3K6460/C-uMÚ3KHRBE+AH=å�243G20N@/K 3 ) WX376�BE+AYÚ/�60/�H72>37ã Hf/�Ý 24-GK�WX643KDÀ20N@/�-4FID�/�Ý�Q.F7-0-���FK60/$WX3764Ý�/�B�203GãÚ/+.B@/�H520+²Ý�FKQ�áõpN@+²-¾-0+.Dy+.Q²FI64+�2fë�FIQ.QA3sé>-oßR-o203ºß=-u/�20N@/�éi/�QAQAó~ß=H=BE/�6\-u203U3EBº24N@/�3760ë�3IW�Q./�FI64H@+.H@åGWX643KD�pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH�H@/ 2fé�3K64äE-�á

�i3KHR-u+²BE/�6P24N@/�24F7-uäÌ3IWiMÚ/�60WX3K64D�+AH=å�:<(�-�*-:*� : ,.*[%�5+,.*[A %>%J=�M=FI6\FID�/�20/�6P/C-f24+ADGFsó20+.3KH,á �>/�64/K:Z37ß@6PåK37FKQÃ+²-¾203�ç=H=BÌ20N@/�M=FK64FKD�/ 20/�6¾-0/ 2020+.H@å � �à24N=Fs2DGFsèE+.D�+���/�-¾20N@/Q.+Aä7/�Q.+AN@3U3EB���ì � � 9 I K�� K ��ðoWX376¾FGå7+AT7/�H0Io: �íFIH=B �¾áZõpNUß=-�:@24N@/�DGFIèU+.D�ß=DôQ.+Aä7/�Q.+�óN@3U3EB�D�3EBE/�Q5+²-`20N=/�D�3EBE/�Q724N=Fs2�ãÚ/�-u2�M@60/CBE+²Ý924-Ã24N@/�206\FI+.H@+AH=å$B@FI24F=á;õpN=+.-`/�-u20+.DGFs24+A37H+²-�-u+.D�M@QA+Aç=/CB�ãUëP20N=/ =�5)2F%B:�W�%E/�*-07*3%68�3IWRQ.3KåKó~Q.+.äK/�Q.+.N@3U3UBWXß@H=Ý924+A37H�+.H5203PF¾-0ß@D�DGFs24+A37H3IWZ24/�64D�-iÝ 376064/�-0MR37H=BE+.H@å$20324N@/>TsFI64+.3Kß=-�FI2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�-�3KWZ20N@/$BE+�YZ/�64/�H52iÝ�Q.F7-0-0/�-�áIâÁF7Ý\N3IW,20N@/$20/�60DG-i+AH�20N=/$-F�5ß=FI64/�ã@6\FKÝ\ä7/ 2\-�+.HÞì�7á @7ðÁÝ�FIH)ãÚ/PDGFsèE+AD�+���/CBG+AHRBE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H520Q.ë3IWp24N@/º64/�-u2�á �>/�HRÝ /K:ÃDGFsèE+AD�ß@D QA+.äK/�QA+.N@3U3EBà/�-u20+.D�FI20+.3KHí64/�BEßRÝ /�-203æ+.H=BE/�MR/�H=BE/�H52DGFsèE+.Dy+���FI20+.3KHæM=6037ã@QA/�DG-�:R3KH@/�WX3K6$/�FKÝ\N ��ViL�áZörH�WÆF7Ý92C:ÚFºQA+A2u24QA/�WXß@6020N@/�6¾é�3K64ä�64/ óBEß=Ý�/�-yâ �Úápì�Ká�@Kð�/�T7/�HíWXß@6020N=/�6C:,243ÞFÌ-0ß@D 3IWo24/�64DG-�:`3KH@/ºWX3K6y/�F7Ý\NíD�ß@QA20+.H@3KD�+²FIQ

Page 17: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{  ��

BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H �4S R SUT V áR?=ß@6020N@/�60D�3K64/K:=20N@/�60/�+.-¾F)Ý Q.37-0/�B�WX3760D -u37QAß@20+.3KH�WX3K6�20N@/�M=Fsó6\FID�/ 24/�6p/�-u20+.DGFs20/C-�áUörH�FKB@BE+A20+.3KH,:5éoN=+AQ./Péi/PBE3yH@3I2oBE/�-4Ý 64+.ãR/¾20N@/BE/�24FK+AQ²-�N@/�64/K:Ué�/Ý�FKH�24FIä7/F5M (Y!�5G/�*3(68W(VW W #&%>(�2NA�203GM=FK64FKDy/�20/�6�/C-f24+ADGFI20+.3KH�ãUë)+AHRÝ 3K64MÚ3K6\Fs20+.H@åyM=Fsó6\FID�/ 24/�6�M@64+.3K6\-�áK?=3K6ÁFKH)FIM@M=6037M@60+²Fs24/�WX3K64D�3KWÚ24N@/>M@64+.3K6ÁFKH=B�ãUë�DGFIäU+.H@å�-u24FIHRB@FI6\BFK-4-0ß@D�ME20+.3KH=-�:Eé�/PÝ�FIH�FIQ²-03�å7/ 2�F�Ý Q.37-0/�BºWX3K64DÀ-03KQ.ßE20+.3KH�WX3K6p24N@//�-u20+.DGFs20/C-�á

����� ��d � Y � ���KY�� � ��� � �� �����MÏ/æH@3séêDy3sT7/�203à24N@/æD�3K64/æÝ\N=FIQ.Q./�H@å7+AH@åàM@643Kã=QA/�D 3IWPQ./�FI64H@+.H@å�FíBE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ë-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/$FIßE243KDGFs24+.Ý�FIQ.QAë7:7F7-�3KM=MR35-u/CB�203�NRF;T5+.H@å�+A2påK+.TK/�HGãUë�20N@/$ß=-0/�6Cá7õpN@/¾DGFI+.HM@643Kã@Q./�DêN@/�60/�+.->ç=H=BE+.H@å�F)åK3U3EB�BE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�ë�-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/�FID�37H@å�20N@/�MR3K20/�H724+.FKQAQ.ë+.HEç=H@+A20/�QAë�DGFIHUë�MÚ37-4-0+Aã@Q./o3KH=/�-�á7S�-�+AHGD�37-u2ÁQ./�FK60H@+.H@å�FKQAå73K64+�24N@DG-�:;24N@/�64/�FI64/�20N@64/�/+.DyMÚ3K6024FKH52>+.-4-uß=/�-�20NRFs2>H@/�/�Bº203GãÚ/�FKB@BE64/�-4-0/�B)+.H�20N@+²->-0/ 2020+.H@å�T`������ Z Y � � ���� � � �� � \ -uMÚ/�Ý�+�çR/�-GéoN@+²Ý\N'-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/�-GFK60/�Ý�FIH=BE+²B@FI20/�NUë5MÚ3I24N@/�-0/�-

20N=FI2>3Kß@6oQ./�FK60H@+.H@åGFIQ.åK3760+A20N=D Ý�FIH�64/ 20ß=60H I` � �@Z � ���� ����KY��RZ�� \ /�TsFIQ.ß=FI20/�-º20N=/ �0åK3U3EBEH@/�-4-F�í3IW�B@+�YZ/�64/�H52�Ý�FIH=B@+.B@FI20/ÏNUë7ó

MR3K20N@/C-u/C-o60/�Q.FI20+.TK/¾203�24N@/�B@Fs2\F I` � � �� � � ��� Z � �RY � k \ F)M=603EÝ /CBEß@64/�24N=Fs2-u/CFI6\Ý\N@/�->20N@/yNUëUMR3K20N@/C-u+²-¾-0M=F7Ý /�WX376F

-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/Péo+�24NæFyN@+Aå7N�-4Ý 3760/7áMÏ/�BE+.-4Ý ßR-0-p/CFKÝ\N�3IW`20N@/C-u/P+.H�24ß@64H�á� ��� Z Y � � � ��� � � �� ��� ?=ß@H=B@FKD�/�H524FKQAQ.ëK:E37ß@6iNUëUMÚ3I20N=/�-0+.-p-0M=FKÝ�/¾+²-oBE/ 24/�64D�+AH@/CB)ãUë3Kß=6¾64/�M@64/�-0/�H52\Fs20+.3KH�Q²FIH=åKß=FKåK/�TÚF)NUëUMR3K20N@/C-u+²-$-uMÚ/�Ý�+�ç=/C-¾F�-u/�2¾3KWÁM=FI64/�H52\-oWX3K6$/�F7Ý\NFs202064+Aã=ßE20/ � 3 ) á7<>3I24/p20N=FI2%20N@+²-�NUëUMR3K20N@/C-u+²-�-uMRFKÝ /p+²-�+.HEç=H@+A20/7áKâ�T7/�Hy+AHGF$TK/�60ë�-0+ADyóM@Q./$-4Ý\N@/�D�F=:K24N@/�64/�DGF;ë�ãÚ/¾+.HEç=H@+A20/�QAëGDGFKH5ëyMÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./$-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/�-�áKörHº37ß@6�åK/�H=/ 20+²Ý�-/ è@FKDyM=QA/7:=F�MR/�64-03KH U -på7/�H@3K2fë5MÚ/Ý�FKH�B@/�MÚ/�H=B�3KH�24N@/�åK/�H@3I2fëUMÚ/P3IW%N@+.->M=FI64/�H524-�:E3K63IW�N@+²-�å764FKH=BEM=FK60/�H524-�:s3K6�3IW�N@+²-�å760/CFs20ó~å764FKH=BEM=FK60/�H72\-�:C/ 2\ÝIá�M�N@+AQ./>é�/�Ý 37ß@Q²B�+.D�MR35-u/FGãÚ3Kß@HRB�3KH�20N@/�D�FIèE+ADGFIQ,QA/�H@åI24N�3IW%20N@/�-uQ.3I2�Ý\N=FK+AH�+.H�20N=/�D�3UB@/�Q~:@20N=+.-¾-u37QAßE24+A37H+²- �5ß@+A20/�ã@60+A2u24QA/7:�FIH=Bà37H@/)24N=Fs2y+.-�TK/�60ëÏQA+.D�+�24+AH=åÌ+.H�BE3KDGFK+AH=-�éoN@/�60/)é�/�B@3æH@3I2N=F;T7/D�ß=Ý\NæM=60+.3K6>äUH@3séoQ./�B@åK/KáRÜ>Fs24N@/�6C:@é�/�Ý\N@3U37-0/P203�QA/CF;TK/3KMÚ/�H�24N@/�MÚ37-4-0+Aã@+.Q.+�2fë3IW`FI64ã@+�2464FK60+.Q.ë�Q.3KH@åy-uQ.3I2pÝ\N=FI+.H=-�:7Q./�F;TU+.H@å�24N@/¾-0/�FK64Ý\N)FKQAå73K64+�24N@DÇ203�B@/�Ý +²BE/$N@3sé'WÆFI6203�WX37QAQ.3sé /CFKÝ\N�3KH@/7áMÏ/�D�ßR-f2C:7N@3sé�/�T7/�6C:I64/�-u2064+.Ý 2Á3Kß@6iNUë5MÚ3I24N@/�-0+²-Á-0M=FKÝ�/o203�/�H=-0ß@64/o20N=FI2Á24N@/¾-u2064ß=Ý9ó

20ß=60/�éi/�FI64/)Q./�FI64H@+.H@åÌ+²-yFæQ./�å7FKQi37H@/Ká%Üo/CÝ�FIQ.Qi20N=FI2yé�/�FK60/�QA/CFI64H@+AH=åæ3Kß@6yD�3EBE/�Qã=F7-u/CB�37H�3KH@/P2464FK+AH@+.H@åGB@FI24FIãRFK-0/K:Eã@ßE2¾éi37ß@Q.B�Q.+Aä7/P203)FKM@M@Q.ëº+A2>+AH�3K20N@/�6>-u/�2u20+.H@å5-�:éo+A20NÏMR3K20/�H524+.FKQAQ.ëæTK/�60ë�BE+AYZ/�64/�H5260/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ`-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/Ká9MÞ/�épFIH52$203�/�H=-0ß@64/�24N=Fs220N=/$-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/>éi/$FI64/oQA/CFI64H@+.H@å�éo+.QAQÚåK/�H@/�6\Fs24/�F�Ý 37H=-0+.-u20/�H72�M@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+A2fë�D�3EBE/�QRWX3K6FIHUë�-0äK/�QA/�2037H�é�/oFI64/�Q.+.äK/�Q.ë243�-u/�/KáIS�-�éi/oBE+²-0Ý�ß=-4-u/CB�+.H �U/�Ý 20+.3KH Ká U=á�@E:;é�/>Ý�FIH�20/C-f220N=+.-Ý�3KH=BE+A20+.3KHÞß=-0+AH@å�20N=/yÝ�Q.F7-0-PBE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ë�åK6\FIM=NæWX3K6¾20N=/�Ý�FIH=B@+.B@FI20/�VÁÜ>ï�áÚö�2+²-¾-u206\FI+.åKN52uWX3760épFI6\Bº203ºDGFK+AH524FK+AH�24N@/yåK6\FIM@NæBEß=60+.H@å)Q./�FK60H@+.H@åR:RFIHRBæÝ 37H=-u+²BE/�6�3KH=QAëD�3EBE/�Q²-oéoN@35-u/BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ë�-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/PM=FK-4-u/C-i20N@/�FKM@M@643KM@64+.FI20/¾20/C-f2Cá� �CZ � ���� � Y � ��CY � � � � � õpN@/�-0/�Ý�3KH=B�ä7/�ë�Ý 37DyMÚ3KH=/�H52¾+²->24N@/�FKã@+.QA+A2fë�203º/�TsFIQ.ß=Fs24/BE+AYÚ/�60/�H52G-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/�-�+AH 3K6\BE/�6�203ÏM@+²Ý\äí3KH@/�20NRFs2yç@24-y24N@/�B=Fs24FÞé�/�Q.Q�á MÏ/�F7B@FIM@2

Page 18: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

 �� � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

�pF;ëK/C-u+²FIHW:<%>=�5+, /G5+,5)2+01*3%B8íDy/�20N@3EB@-¾243�37ß@6¾WX64FKDy/�éi3760äZá ��F;ë7/�-0+.FKHæD�3EBE/�Q�-0/�Q./�Ý9ó20+.3KHàßE24+AQ.+���/�-F�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýy-4Ý 3760+.H@å�WXß@H=Ý 20+.3KH�á�örHÏQ.+AH@/Géo+A20NÏ24N@/ �pF;ëK/�-0+²FIHæM@N=+�óQ.37-03KM@NUëK:%+A2)FK-4Ý 64+AãÚ/�-�FÞM@60+.3K6�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fë�BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�3sT7/�6�FIHUë�FK-0MR/CÝ92G3IW¾20N@/D�3EBE/�Q�FIãÚ3Kß@2�éoN@+²Ý\Nºé�/¾FK60/¾ß@H=Ý�/�6024FI+.H�á5örH)24N@+.-pÝ�FK-0/K:5éi/$N=F;TK/¾F�M@64+.3K6 2Gì ��ði3sTK/�6-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/C-�:%FIHRB�FæM=60+.3K6)2Gì � � 9 ��ð�3sTK/�6�24N@/�MRFI6\FID�/ 24/�6\-�åK+.TK/�H�/�F7Ý\N�MÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/7á�õpN@/7M (=!�5�/�*3(68 /+2F%B#&5�3KW¾Fà-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/ �Ç+²-�BE/ ç=H=/�B�FK-�20N@/ W�%E/�0 5G#�*3%B#M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fëG3IWÃ20N@/-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/På7+AT7/�H)24N@/B@Fs2\F:I>á@[email protected]ë7:Uß=-u+.H@å<�pF;ëK/C-Á64ß@Q./K:Eé�/N=F;T7/¾24N=Fs2>T

2Gì � 9 I K ��ð �2Gì I 9 ��K ��ð�2Gì � 9 ��ð

éoN@/�60/P24N@/�BE/�H@3KD�+.H=Fs243K6C:EéoN@+.Ý\N�+²-p20N=/�DGFI64åK+.H=FIQ�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fë 2Gì I 9 ��ðp+²->F�H@376uóDGFIQ.+���+AH=å�Ý 37H=-f2\FIH52�20NRFs2ÃBE3U/C-�H@3I2`Ý\N=FIH@å7/%20N@/Á60/�Q.FI20+.TK/�6\FIH@äU+.H@å7-Z3KWEB@+�YZ/�64/�H52Ã-u2064ß=Ý9ó20ß=60/C-�á

õpN@+²-�-0Ý�3K64/º+²-yÝ�3KD�MÚ37-0/�Bí3KW>2féi3ÞDGFI+.H�M=FK6u2\-+T`20N=/�M@64+.3K6yM@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+�2fëà3KW>20N@/-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/7:ÚFKH=B�20N=/�M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fë�3KW�20N@/yB@Fs2\FGåK+.TK/�H�20N=FI2$-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/Ká=ö�2$20ß=60H=-�3KßE220NRFs2º24N@/ÌDGFK60å7+AH=FKQoQA+.äK/�QA+.N@3U3EB'+.-�FíÝ 64ß=Ý�+.FKQ¾Ý 37D�MR37H@/�H52�:iéoN@+²Ý\N�N=FK-)20N@/Þ/ YZ/�Ý923IWPMÚ/�H=FKQA+���+.H@åàD�3UB@/�Q²-�éo+�24N'FÏQ²FI64åK/�HUß@D�ãÚ/�6G3KW$M=FK64FKD�/ 20/�64-�á�õpNUß=-�:%24N@+²-)-0Ý�3K64/FIß@203KDGFI20+²Ý�FIQ.Q.ë¾ã=FKQ.FKH=Ý /C-�24N@/�Ý�3KD�M@Q./ èE+A2fë¾3KWE20N@/p-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/�éo+A20N�+�2\-�ç=2,203�20N@/pB@FI24F@áörH�24N@/oÝ�F7-u/iéoN@/�64/�IÌ+.-%F�Ý�3KD�M@Q./ 24/�F7-0-0+Aå7H@D�/�H52�:;FIHRB�é�/ÁDGFIä7/iÝ /�6u2\FI+.H�64/�FK-03KHRFIã@Q./FK-4-0ß@D�ME20+.3KH=-iFIãÚ3KßE2i20N@/$-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/¾M@60+.3K6C:s24N@/�64/�+²-ÁF�Ý Q.37-0/�ByWX3K64D -u37QAßE24+A37HGWX3K6Á20N@/-4Ý 3K64/Ká� Y � ��CY � � � � � �� � � � <>3séÏ24N=Fs2`éi/iN=F;TK/�FoNUëUMÚ3I20N=/�-0+.-`-uMRFKÝ /iFIH=BF¾-0Ý�3K64+AH@åpWXß=H=Ý9ó20+.3KHæ20N=FI2$FIQ.Q.3sé>-oß=-�203)/�T;FKQAßRFs20/�BE+�YZ/�64/�H52$N5ëUMÚ3I24N@/�-0/�-�:=é�/�H@/�/�B�37H@QAë�M@643sTU+.BE/�FM@643EÝ /�B@ß@60/)WX3K6�çRH=BE+.H@åÞF�N=+Aå7NEó�-4Ý 3760+.H@å�NUëUMR3K20N@/C-u+²-�+.H�37ß@6�-0M=FKÝ�/Ká`?@3K6 �pF;ëK/�-0+²FIHH@/�2féi3760äE-�:,é�/�äUH@3sé 24N=Fs2y20N@/�24F7-uäà3KWoç=H=BE+.H@åÞ20N@/�N@+.åKN@/C-f2G-0Ý�3K64+AH=åæH@/ 2fé�3K64äÏ+.-<�V�ó~NRFI6\B � 7á DE��ápS�-�VÁÜ>ï Q./�FK60H@+.H@å�+²-ºFI2�Q./�F7-f2�F7-)N=FK64B�F7-��pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH'H@/�2féi3760äQ./�FI64H@+.H@åíìÆF �pF;ëK/C-u+²FIHÞH@/ 2fé�3K64ä�+.-�-u+.D�M@QAëÏF�VÁÜ>ï éo+�24Ní3KH@/GÝ�Q.F7-0-FKH=BÌH=3�64/�Q²Fsó20+.3KHR-4ð :,é�/ºÝ�FKH@H@3I2�N=3KMÚ/G203�çRH=BíFIHí/�ZGÝ�+A/�H52�M@643UÝ�/�BEß=60/�24N=Fs2�FKQAépF;ëE-$ç=H=B@-�20N@/N@+.åKN@/C-f2�-4Ý 3760+.H@å�-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/7á@õpN5ßR-�:Eé�/D�ß=-u2o60/C-u376u2�203GN=/�ß@64+.-u20+²ÝP-u/CFI6\Ý\N�á

õpN@/Ï-u+.D�M@QA/C-f2�N@/�ß@60+²-u20+²ÝÌ-0/�FI6\Ý\N FIQ.åK3760+A20N=D +²-�åK64/�/�B@ë N@+.Q.Q�órÝ Q.+AD�ã@+.H@å�-0/�FK64Ý\N,:ß=-0+AH=åÏ37ß@6G-0Ý�3K64/�F7-�FÞD�/�2064+.ÝKáCMÞ/�DGFI+.H524FI+.H�3Kß@6GÝ ß=6064/�H52GÝ�FIHRBE+.B=Fs20/�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/FIHRB�+�24/�6\Fs20+.TK/�QAë�+AD�M@643sTK/o+A2�á5S�2Á/�F7Ý\N�+�24/�6\Fs20+.3KH,:Ké�/>Ý 3KHR-u+²BE/�6iF�-u/�2Á3IW�-0+AD�M@Q./>Q.3EÝ�FIQ206\FIHR-fWX3760DGFs24+A37H=-¾203�20NRFs2�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/7:�-0Ý�3K64/yFKQAQ�3KWÁ24N@/�D�:,FKH=BÏM@+.Ý\äæ20N@/G37H@/�éo+�24NN@+.åKN@/C-f2�-4Ý 3760/7áZS¾-P+AHÞ20N=/)Ý�FK-0/y3IW$�pF;ë7/�-0+.FKHæH@/ 2fé�3K64äE-�:Úé�/y64/�-u2064+²Ý92Fs2u24/�H520+.3KHÞ203-0+AD�M@Q./æ2464FKH=-fWX3760DGFI20+.3KH=-G-0ß=Ý\N FK-�FKB@B@+AH@å�3K6ºBE/�QA/�20+.H@å FKH�/�BEå7/Ká MÏ/ÞÝ�FIH -0N@3sé20NRFs2�:%FK-�+AH ��F;ë7/�-0+.FKHÞH=/ 2fé�3K64äÌQ./�FI64H@+.H@å=:,/�FKÝ\Ní3KWp20N@/C-u/�QA3EÝ�FKQiÝ\N=FKH@åK/C-64/J�5ß@+.60/C-20NRFs2Péi/�64/�Ý�3KD�M@ßE24/�37H@QAë�24N@/�Ý�3KH52064+Aã=ßE20+.3KH�243)20N=/y-4Ý 3760/PWX376�24N@/�MÚ3K6020+.3KHæ3KW�20N@/-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/�20N=FI2�N=FK-¾Ý\N=FIH=åK/�B�+.H�20N=+.-¾-f24/�M I=20N@+²-�NRFK-�FG-0+.åKH@+AçRÝ�FKH52�+AD�M=F7Ý92�37H�20N@/Ý 37D�M@ßE24FI20+.3KH=FKQR/�Z)Ý +./�H=Ý�ëy3KW�20N@/$-u/CFI6\Ý\N)FIQ.åK3760+A20N@D�á�MÞ/$BE/�FKQRéo+A20N)Q.3EÝ�FKQRDGFsèE+.DGFß=-0+AH=å�6\FIH=BE37D 64/�-u24FK6u2\-�:�+�á /Ká.:�éoN@/�H�FoQ.3EÝ�FIQ7DGFsèE+AD�ß@DÉ+.-,60/CFKÝ\N@/CBP+AHP24N@/i-0/�FK64Ý\N,:�é�/24FKäK/�F)H5ß=D�ãÚ/�6�3KW�64FKH=BE3KDê-f24/�M=-�:RFKH=B�20N=/K: HÌÝ 37H724+AHUß@/�20N@/�å760/�/�BEë�N@+.QAQAó�Ý�QA+.D�ã=+AH@åM@643EÝ /�-4-�á

õpN@/�60/�FI64/�2féi3ÏM@643Kã@Q./�DG-�éo+A20N�20N@+²-G-0+AD�M@Q./�FIM@M@6437F7Ý\N�á�?`+A6\-f2C:�FK-GBE+²-4Ý ß=-4-u/CB+.H�20N@/M@64/�TU+.3Kß=-o-0/�Ý 20+.3KH�:=éi/PN=F;T7/$+.HEç=H=+�24/�Q.ë�DGFIHUë)MÚ37-4-0+Aã@Q./�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/C-�á��E/�Ý 37H=B�:

Page 19: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{  C�

/�T7/�H�24N@/�Fs243KD�+²Ý�-f24/�M=->3IW%20N@/y-u/CFI6\Ý\N�FK60//�èEMR/�H=-u+.TK/�IE20N=/�M@643EÝ /�-4-p3IW�Ý�3KD�M@ßE24+AH@å20N=/¾-u24Fs24+.-u20+²Ý�-�H@/�Ý�/�-4-0FK60ëWX376ÁM=FK64FKD�/ 20/�6�/�-u20+.DGFs20+.3KHG64/J�5ß@+.64/�-%/ èEMÚ/�H=-0+.TK/>B@FI24FIãRFK-0/3KMÚ/�6\Fs24+A37H=-�á5âÁTK/�Hº+�W,é�/$60/C-f2460+²Ý92i20N@/P-u/�2�3KWÃÝ�FKH=BE+²B@Fs24/¾-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/�-�Fs2p/�FKÝ\N�-f24/�Mº3KW20N=/�-0/�FK64Ý\N,:Ré�/yÝ�FIH@H=3I2FsYZ3K6\B�203�BE3�FIQ.Q`20N@/GB@FI24FIãRFK-0/�37MR/�64FI20+.3KH=-¾H@/�Ý�/�-4-0FK60ë�203/�TsFKQAß=FI20/�FKQAQ�3KW,20N=/�D�áMÏ/�M@643KMÚ37-0/>FN@/�ß@60+²-u20+²Ý�-0/�FI6\Ý\NGFIQ.åK3760+A20N@D�20N=FI2�F7B@BE64/�-4-u/C-�ãR3K20NG24N@/�-0/�+²-4-uß@/C-�á

S�2¾F�N@+.åKN�Q./�T7/�Q~:E20N=/�FIQ.åK3760+A20N@DÀM@603EÝ�/�/�B=-o+AH�M@NRFK-0/�-�á=S�2�/�F7Ý\N�M@N=FK-0/ � :@é�/N=F;T7/F�-u/�2$3KWÁMR3K20/�H724+.FKQÃMRFI64/�H524- " %60 E ì�� 3 ) ð�WX376¾/CFKÝ\NÌFI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/ � 3 ) á9MÏ/�24N@/�HÏBE3�F-u24FIHRB@FI6\BÌ-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/�-0/�FI6\Ý\Næ64/�-u2064+.Ý 20/CB�203�20N=/y-0M=FKÝ�/�3KWi-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/C-�+.HÏéoN@+.Ý\NÌ20N@/M=FK60/�H72\-3IWo/CFKÝ\N � 3 ) FI64/G+.H " %60 E ì�� 3 ) ð á MÏ/�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/�20N@/�M@N=FK-0/�Bà-0/�FK64Ý\Ní-0320NRFs2>+A2�çR64-u2o/ è[email protected]/�-pBE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�+A/C-oéo+A20N@+.H�3Kã Hf/CÝ924-�:520N@/�H�ãR/�2féi/�/�H�3Kã Hf/CÝ924-�24N=Fs2FI64/PBE+A64/�Ý 20Q.ë)64/�Q²Fs20/CB�:U20N=/�H�ãR/�2féi/�/�H�3Kã Hf/CÝ924-�24N=Fs2>FK60/¾2féi3�Q.+AH=äU-oFKM=FI602�:U/�24ÝIá@õpN=+.-FIM=M@6035FKÝ\NàFIQ.QA3sé>-�ß=-243�åK6\FKBEß=FKQAQ.ëÌ/�èEM@QA3760/�Q²FI64åK/�6�FIH=BàQ²FI64åK/�6PWX64FKåKD�/�H524-�3IWp20N@/+.HEç=H@+A20/�QAëàQ²FI64åK/)-0M=FKÝ�/K:,å7+ATU+.H@åæM@64+.3K64+�2fëÌ203ÌBE/�MR/�H=BE/�H=Ý +./�-�ãR/�2féi/�/�Hí37ã Hf/�Ý 24-24N=Fs2FI64/yDy3760/�Ý Q.37-0/�Q.ë�64/�Q²Fs20/CB�á�õpN@/�-u/CÝ 3KHRBÞF7BETsFIH524FKåK/�3KW�20N=+.-FKM@M@6437FKÝ\NÌ+.-$24N=Fs2é�/Ý�FKHÌM@64/�Ý�3KD�M@ßE24/�24N@/�B@Fs2\FIã=F7-u/�T5+./�é�Ý 3K6464/�-0MR37H=BE+.H@å)243 � 3 ) K�" %60&EEì�� 3 ) ðGIZDy35-f23IWÁ20N@/�/ èEMÚ/�H=-0+.TK/�Ý�3KD�M@ßE2\Fs24+A37H=-�� 24N@/ Hf3K+.H=-PFIH=Bæ20N@/GFIå7åK64/�å5Fs20+.3KH�64/J�5ß@+.60/CB�+.H20N=/pB@/ ç=H@+A20+.3KHy3IW=20N@/pM=FK60/�H72\- � FK60/�M@64/�Ý 37D�M@ßE20/CB�+.H�24N@/�-0/pT5+./�é>-�ásõpN@/p-uß Z)Ý�+A/�H72-u24Fs24+.-u20+²Ý�-�WX3K6$FIHUë�-uß@ãR-u/�2�3IW�MÚ3I24/�H520+²FIQÃM=FI64/�H524-¾Ý�FKH�/�FK-0+.QAë�ãR/yBE/�64+.TK/�B�WX643KDô20N=+.-TU+A/�éásõpN@/�FKãR3sT7/ÁÝ 37H=-u2064ß=Ý924+A37H�:�243Kå7/ 20N=/�6`éo+�24N�24N@/�B@/�Ý 37D�MR35-0FKã@+AQ.+A2fë$3KWE20N@/p-4Ý 3K64/K:FIQ.Q.3sé>-�20N@/Ï-f24/�M=-º3IW24N@/Ì-0/�FI6\Ý\NËìÆ-4F;ëK:iåK64/�/�B@ë�N@+.QAQAórÝ Q.+AD�ã@+AH=å5ðy243�ãÚ/ÌBE3KH=/æTK/�60ë/XZ)Ý�+A/�H724QAë7á

Ð�Ñ�������� ��Õ=Û� �,ÓiÔ �,�Õ;���5Ø rÔ;�

MÏ/ÌN=F;T7/�20/�-u20/CB'3Kß@6�QA/CFI64H@+.H@å�FIQ.åK3760+A20N@D +AH -0/�T7/�6\FIQ�B@3KDGFI+.H=-�:�ãR3K20N 64/�FKQ�FIHRB-0ë5H524N@/ 24+.ÝKá MÏ/ÌH@3sé BE/�-4Ý 64+.ãR/�/�èUMÚ/�64+.Dy/�H524FIQ¾60/C-uß=Q�2\-G3KH'3KH=/Ì-uëUH520N=/ 20+²ÝæB@FI24F7-u/�2FIHRBº2fé�3�60/CFIQZ3KH=/�-�á

��� ���� � ��� Y ��� � W Z k ����

MÏ/�ãÚ/�å7+AHæãUë�M@64/�-0/�H520+.H@å)37ß@6�64/�-0ß@QA24-¾3KHÌFº-uëUH520N@/�20+²Ý�B=Fs24F7-u/�2�åK/�H@/�6\Fs24/�B�ãUë�20N@/åK/�H@/ 24+.Ý�-�/�èEFKD�M@QA/ºß=-u/CBà+AH�20N@+²-�Ý\NRFIME24/�6Cá,õpN@/ºå737FKQ�3IWp20N=/�-0/)/ èEMÚ/�64+AD�/�H52\-�+²-20320/C-f2�20N@/Q./�FK60H@+.H@åGFIQ.åK3760+A20N=D�:@-0N@3séo+.H@åy20N=FI2�+A2�Ý�FIH�64/�Ý�3KH=-u2064ß=Ý92p24N@/�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ë-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/P+AW�+�2>+²-oÝ Q./�FK60Q.ëGM@64/�-0/�H52o+AH�20N=/�BE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KH,á

õpN@/oB@FI24FK-0/ 2\-%N@/�64/péi/�60/�åK/�H@/�6\Fs24/�B�ãUë�FPVÁÜ>ïÀ20N=FI2�N=FK-`24N@/>-f2460ßRÝ920ß=60/o-0N@3séoH+.H�?`+.åKß@64/ 7á �=ìÆF5ð9á�MÞ/På7/�H@/�64FI20/�BºTsFI64+A37ß=-�2464FK+AH=+AH@å�-0/ 24-�:E3IW`-u+���/¾WX6037D @BA�A243 "�A�A=:éo+A20N JAÞ206\FI+.H@+.H@åí-u/�24-�3KW¾/�F7Ý\N�-0+���/KáCMÏ/æFIQ²-03Þå7/�H@/�64FI20/�B FIH'+.H=BE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H52G20/C-f2B@FI24FIãRFK-0/�3IW@-0+���/ JA=: A�A�A=á S�B@FI24F>-0/ 2`3IW=-0+���/� GÝ 3KHR-u+²-f2\-�3KW=FpWÆFID�+.QAë$2064/�/iÝ 3KH52\FI+.H@+AH=å �MR/�3KM@Q./K:7éo+�24N�FKHGF;TK/�6\FIå7/Á3KW A=á Y$ã@Q.3U3EB�24/�-u24-�MÚ/�6ÁMR/�64-03KH�á7?@3K6�/CFKÝ\Ny206\FI+.H@+.H@å-u/�2�:é�/oQA/CFI64H@/�B�FVÁÜ�ïôßR-u+.H@åP20N=/�FIQ.åK3760+A20N@D�BE/�-4Ý 64+AãÚ/�B�+.Hy20N@/�M@60/�TU+A37ß=-�-u/CÝ924+A37H�:KFIHRB20N=/�H�20/�-u20/CBºN=3sé�éi/�QAQÚ20N=/$Q./�FK60H=/�B)ViÜ>ï M@64/�B@+.Ý 24-i20N@/$24/�-u2pB@FI24F=áU?=3K6�D�/�FK-0ß@64+AH=å20N=/�M=60/CBE+.Ý 20+.TK/pFIã@+.Q.+�2fë7:Cé�/ÁßR-u/CB�24N@/iQ.3KåKó~Q.+.äK/�Q.+.N@3U3UB�3IW@24N@/Á24/�-u2�B@Fs2\F@:C20N@/p-u24FIHRB@FI6\B

Page 20: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

  � � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

-32000

-30000

-28000

-26000

-24000

-22000

-20000

-18000

200 300 400 500 600 700 800

Scor

e

Dataset Size

Median LikelihoodGold Standard

�! #"%$ &�$ � $�� e9q�gfm7k�m7�¾j4c7gfz;e�{ � _9��klm5�od � ei��e\m5e4guq��lk��\q�dfkl_Cm�bEe4grv²_�gfa�q�m5j4ei_�v »�¼ �y{Ã�le9q�gfm7e9wklmÏd � e��Ce\m7e4dfklj)w7_�a�q�klmR¿ �%� e��7�~q ÅKk�{{ � _9��{�d � eydrguq�klm7k�m7��{re4d�{rk��\e��,d � e�I��q Å7kl{{ � _ ��{�l_C�����lklÍ;e\�lk � _s_Iw�_�v�q�dfe\{�d�{re4d�_�v%{rk��4e)�\�Kt �C���K¿ �7_�g�e9q�j � {fq�ab5�leP{rk��\eCtR�%e{ � _9� �le9q�gfm7klm5�e4ÅKbEe4gfklae\msdf{�_Cm�dfe\mPwKk|Î@e4gfe\msd�klmUw7e4bEe\mUwKe\msdZdrguq�klm5klm7�p{re4df{�_�vEd � q�d�{rk��\eC¿ �%� e%j\cKgfz;e%{ � _ ��{ae9wKkAq�my�l_C���Æ��klÍ;e4��k � _s_Iw)_�vZd � eoa_IwKe\�l{�q�{Áq¾v.c5m5j0dfk�_�m�_�v�d � ep{fq�ab7�lep{rk��\eC¿

D�/�F7-uß@64/�WX376P/�TsFIQ.ß=Fs24+AH=å�BE/�H=-u+A2fë�/�-u20+.DGFs24+A37HÌM@643EÝ /�B@ß@60/C-�áÚ?`+Aå7ß@60/XKá Yº-0N@3sé>-�20N@/64/�-0ß@Q�2\-oWX376o20N@/�BE+�YZ/�64/�H52>2464FK+AH=+AH@å)-0/ 2\-�áRõpN@/�-u206\FI+.åKN52oQA+.H@/�FI2>20N@/�203KM�+²-p24N@/�Q.3KåIóQ.+Aä7/�Q.+AN@3U3EB)3KW�20N=/¾24/�-u2pB=Fs24F�åK+.TK/�HG20N=/X�u2064ß@/J��D�3UB@/�QZß=-0/�BG243�å7/�H@/�64FI20/�20N@/B@FI24F@áõpN@/pB@Fs2\F>+²-`M@60/C-u/�H520/�B�+.-Ã+AH�20N@/iWX3K64DË3IW=F$-4Ý�Fs2020/�6,[email protected]:;-0N@3séo+.H@å>24N@/pFKÝ�Ý�ß@6\FKÝ ë¾WX3K6/�F7Ý\N�3IW%20N=/�206\FI+.H@+.H@å)-0/ 24-�:RF7->é�/�Q.QÃF7-o20N=/�D�/�BE+²FIH�Q.3KåKó~Q.+Aä7/�Q.+AN=353EB�3IW%24N@/�Q./�FK60H@/CBD�3EBE/�Q²-�WX3K6�/CFKÝ\N�-0+���/Ká MÏ/�Ý�FKH�-0/�/)24N=Fs2y20N=/ºD�/�BE+²FIH +.- �5ß@+A20/º64/�F7-u37H=FIã=QA/7:,ã@ßE220N=/�64/yFK60/yFGWX/�é�3KßE24QA+./�6\-�áÚörHÌD�35-f2Ý�F7-u/C-�:Ú3Kß@6PFIQ.åK3760+A20N=DôQ./�FK60H@/CBæF�Dy3EBE/�Q%éo+�24N20N=/�Ý 376064/�Ý 2�-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/K:ÃFIH=Bí-4Ý 3760/CBÌé�/�Q.Q1I,20N@/�BE+�YZ/�64/�HRÝ /)+.H�-0Ý�3K64/�+.-�BEß@/G243�20N@/M=FK64FKDy/�20/�6�/�-u20+.DGFs20+.3KH,:KéoN@+²Ý\NG+.-Á+AH=N@/�64/�H520Q.ëyH@3K+²-uë�åK+.TK/�HGQA+.D�+�24/�BGB@FI24F@áS�>3sé�/�T7/�6C:+.HyF¾-uDGFIQ.QUD�+AH@3760+A2fëP3IWRÝ�FK-0/�-�:�24N@/pFIQ.åK3K64+A20N@DÉåK3K2`-u20ß=Ý\äP+.H�Q.3EÝ�FKQ7DGFsèE+.DGF@:CQA/CFI64H@+AH=åF�D�3EBE/�Q�éo+A20N�+.H=Ý 376064/�Ý 2o-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/$20N=FI2�-0Ý�3K64/�B��5ß@+A20/MÚ3U3K64QAë7á

��� ��d� � � � � � ���RZ�� ��� e Y ��� �mY W Z k ����

MÏ/æFIQ²-u3àFIM@M=QA+./�B�20N@/æFKQAå73K64+�24N@D 203àTsFI64+.3Kß=-y64/�FIQAó�éi3760Q²B�BE37D�FK+AHR-�á�õpN@/�ç=6\-u2�3KW20N=/�-0/Ì+²-ºBE6\F;éoH�WX6037D F�B@Fs2\FIã=F7-u/�3KWP/�M@+²BE/�D�+.3KQ.3KåK+²Ý�FKQ�B@FI24FàWX376QJD�A�AÏM=FI20+./�H524-WX643KDò24N@/ �EFKH)?@6\FIH=Ý�+.-4Ý 3$24ß@ãR/�64Ý�ß@Q.37-0+.->ì�õ �oð%Ý Q.+AH@+²ÝI:5FIH=B�24N@/�+.6$@�D�A�A$Ý 37H524FKÝ 24-;�Ká�I:Ká�@BY6�~á5?@3K6Á20N@/9��#%�&" .�%��Ý Q²FK-4-�:s24N@/�-4Ý\N@/�DGF�Ý�3KH524FK+AHR-�BE/�D�37åK6\FIM@N@+²ÝoFs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-Á-0ß=Ý\NFK-�FKåK/K:%å7/�H=BE/�6�:`/ 24N@H@+²Ý +A2fëK:�FKH=B�M=Q.F7Ý /�3IW�ã@+.6020N�:�F7-�é�/�Q.QoFK-yD�/�BE+²Ý�FKQoFs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/�--0ß=Ý\NñF7-���ö�� -u24FI20ß=-�:oBE+²-u/CFK-0/Þ-0+�24/�ìXWX3K6�õ �oð9:pî>ó�64F;ë'64/�-0ß@QA2�:p/ 2\ÝIápörHñF7B@BE+A20+.3KH�:Fí-0M@ßE20ß=D -4FID�M@Q./�+²-�2\FIäK/�H�WX643KD /�F7Ý\N M=FI20+./�H52�:�FKH=B'-uß=ã=-u/>�5ß@/�H520Q.ë�ß@HRBE/�64åK3U/�-åK/�H@/ 24+.ÝÞDGFI64äK/�6�FIHRFIQ.ëU-0+²-�ápõpN@+²-�FKQAQ.3sé>-)ßR-º243�B@/ 20/�60D�+.H@/ÏéoN@+.Ý\Nñ-f2464FK+AHñ3IW�õ �F M=Fs24+A/�H72�N=FK-�:pFIH=B 20N@/�60/�ã5ë�Ý�60/CFs20/ÏF �����C#" ��Ý Q²FK-4-�:iéo+�24NñF 60/�Q.FI20+.3KH�ãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�HM=FI20+./�H524-�FIHRB -u206\FI+.H=-�áoâiFKÝ\N�M=FI20+./�H52�+.-�FIQ²-03 FK-0äK/CB'WX3K6�F QA+²-f2�3IWyMR/�3KM@Q./Ïéo+�24N

Page 21: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{   �

hivres

# contacts

result

transmitted

infectivity

smrpos

care

closecont

ageatdx

closecont

hh_oohh

ethnic

# infected

% infected

hh_oohh

contype

homeless

gender

contype

disease site

contage

xray

pob

��������������� ������

�����������

� �����������

�! #"%$ &�$ � $ �%� e »�¼ �Ç{�drgfc7j4dfc7gfepv._�g�d � e � (�wK_Ca�q�k�m=¿

éoN@37D N@/�N=FK-PãÚ/�/�HÞ+.HíÝ 37H72\FKÝ 2JIÚ20N@/(�����%��#�!��$Ý Q²FK-4-¾NRFK-Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-$20N=FI2-0MÚ/�Ý +AWXë20N=/�2fëUMÚ/¾3KWÃÝ 37H72\FKÝ 2$ìÆ-0+.ã@QA+.H@åR:UÝ�3séi3760ä7/�6C:s/ 2\ÝIá|ðiÝ�3KH524F7Ý92pFIåK/7:KéoN@/�20N@/�6�20N@/PÝ 37H72\FKÝ 2+²-,FoN@37ß=-0/�[email protected]�/�D�ãR/�6�:�/ 2\ÝIá�I�+.H�FKB@B@+�24+A37H�: 24N@/�2fëUMÚ/�3IW=BE+²FIå7H@37-u20+²Ý%M@643EÝ /�B@ß@60/%24N=Fs220N=/>Ý 3KH52\FKÝ92�ß@HRBE/�64åK3U/�-oì�O (6#&5;ð�FKH=B�24N@/o64/�-0ß@Q�2�3KWR24N@/>BE+²FIåKH=37-0+.-pì�. 5�/S� ,.04ðÃFK60/pFIQ²-0364/�MÚ3K6020/�B�á7örHºÝ�FK-0/�-ÁéoN@/�64/o20N=/$Ý�3KH524F7Ý92ÁQ²Fs24/�6ÁãÚ/�Ý�3KD�/�-�F�MRFs20+./�H52�+AHG24N@/¾Ý�QA+.H@+²ÝI:Ué�/N=F;T7/�FKB@B@+�24+A37H=FIQÃ+AHEWX3760DGFI20+.3KH�áNMÞ/�+AH520643EBEß=Ý�/�FGH@/�éòÝ Q²FK-4- �?�#"�! #����203º60/�M@60/C-u/�H52Ý 37H524FKÝ 24-�20NRFs2º-0ß@ã=-0/J�5ß@/�H524QAëíãÚ/�Ý�FID�/�M=Fs24+A/�H72\-+I�+.H 20N@+²-)Ý�F7-u/7:%éi/�FIQ²-03ÞN=F;T7/�FKHFs202064+Aã=ßE20/ # #&(68�/�: *-070L5)=æéoN@+.Ý\Nà+.H=BE+²Ý�FI20/�-PéoN=/ 20N=/�6P20N=/)BE+.-0/�F7-u/yépFK-¾206\FIH=-0D�+�2020/CBWX643KD 3KH=/�M=FI20+./�H52Á243�24N@/¾3K20N@/�6�:5+~á /7áA:UéoN@/�20N@/�6Á24N@/¾MRFs20+./�H52oFIH=Bº-uß@ãZÝ�F7-u/¾N=F;TK/�20N@/-4FID�/õ � -u206\FI+.H�á

õpN@/º-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/G3IWp20N=/ºQ./�FI64H@/CBÏViÜ>ï +.-�-uN=3séoHÏ+.H�?`+.åKß@64/?Ká.!Uá MÏ/º-0/�/G24N=Fs2é�/�Q./�FK60H�FÌ60+²Ý\N�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�H=Ý ë�-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/ºãÚ3I24N�éo+A20N@+.H�Ý�Q.F7-0-0/�-�FIH=B�ãR/�2féi/�/�H�Fs2uó2064+.ã@ßE20/C-�+AH�BE+AYÚ/�60/�H72)Ý�Q.F7-0-0/�-�á MÏ/�-uN=3séi/CBà20N@+²-yD�3UB@/�Qp203Ï3Kß=6�B@3KDGFI+.H�/�èUMÚ/�6024-éoN@3�BE/�TK/�QA37MR/CB�24N@/ÌB@FI24FKã=FK-0/K:�FKH=B 20N@/�ë�WX3Kß=H=B 20N@/æD�3EBE/�Q �5ß@+�24/æ+.H724/�64/�-u20+.H@å=áõpN@/�ë�WX3Kß@HRB DGFIHUë�3IW�20N@/àBE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ +./�-�203�ãÚ/ �5ß@+A20/à64/�F7-u37H=FIã@Q./K:ÁWX3K6�/ è@FKD�óM@Q./�TR20N@/�BE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�/�3IW�FKåK/�Fs2$BE+.FKåKH@35-u+²-ì&(&��5)(B0L=&-Úð>3KH ��ö���-u24Fs24ß=-�ì A�*?�>#&5G/Cð �2fëUM@+²Ý�FIQ.Q.ëK: �>ö���ó~MÚ37-0+�24+AT7/�MRFs20+./�H52\-¾FK60/�ëK3Kß=H@åK/�6�:ZFIH=BÌFI64/�+.HEWX/�Ý 20/�BÞéo+A20Nàõ � F7-PF64/�-0ß@Q�23KW�S>öfL �9I�24N@/)BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ /�3IWi20N@/)Ý�3KH524F7Ý92&U -PFIå7/�37HÌ24N@/�2fëUMR/�3IWpÝ 37H72\FKÝ 2� Ý 3KH52\FKÝ92\-éoN@3ÌFK60/�Ý 3sé�3K64äK/�6\-PFI64/GQA+.äK/�QAëÞ203ÌãR/�ëK3Kß=H@åK/�620N=FKH�Ý 37H72\FKÝ 24-�éoN=3FI64/�MRFI64/�H524-¾FIH=B�37Q.B@/�6¾20N=FKH�20N@35-u/�éoN@3�FK60/�-0Ý\N@3U37Q�WX64+A/�H=B@-JIÚ376>24N@/yB@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý /3IW ��ö�� -u24FI20ß=-Á3KH)/�20N@H=+.Ý�+�2fë@� S�-0+.FKH)M=Fs24+A/�H524-ÁFK60/�64FK60/�QAë �>ö��ñMR35-u+A20+.TK/>éoN=/�64/�FK-éoN@+A20/�M=Fs24+A/�H524-yFI64/)D�ß=Ý\N�Dy3760/ºQA+.äK/�QAëÏ203ÞãR/ �>ö��ôMR35-u+A20+.TK/7:`F7-�24N@/�ëà3KW°20/�H�åK/ 2õ �ÉFK-$FG64/�-0ß@Q�2$3IW�N=F;TU+.H@åºS�öfLP�ZáZörHÌF7B@BE+A20+.3KH�:R20N=/�64/�é�/�64/�FGHUß@D�ãÚ/�6$3IWÁB@/�MÚ/�HEó

Page 22: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

 �¡ � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

BE/�H=Ý +./�-p24N=Fs2o24N@/�ë)WX3Kß@H=B�+.H520/�64/�-u20+.H@åR:@FIH=B�é�3K6020NUëG3IWÃWXß@6u24N@/�6�+AHUTK/C-f24+Aå5Fs24+A37H�áE?@3K6/ è@FKDyM=QA/7:R24N@/�BE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H=Ý�/�ãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�HÞÝ Q.37-0/�Ý�3KH524F7Ý92�ì&2+,%E/+5)2)%68�04ð�FKH=B =B*�/G5)(6/G5</�*-0L5épFK-iH@3sTK/�QRFIHRBGMR3K20/�H724+.FKQAQ.ë�+AH524/�64/�-u20+.H@å=áUõpN@/�64/¾FK60/¾FIQ²-u3�B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý +./�-i24N=Fs2p-u/�/�D203G+.H=BE+²Ý�FI20/�F�ã@+²FK-p+.H�20N@/�Ý�3KH524F7Ý92>+.HUTK/�-u20+.å7FI20+.3KH�M@603EÝ�/�BEß@64/P3K6o+.H�20N@/P2460/CFs20D�/�H723IW�õ �PIEWX3K6�/ è@FID�M@Q./K:=Ý�3KH524F7Ý92\-péoN@3�éi/�60/�-4Ý 64/�/�H@/�B�Fs2o24N@/�õ � Ý�QA+.H@+²ÝPéi/�60/PD�ßRÝ\ND�3K64/�Q.+.äK/�Q.ëÏ203ÏãR/�BE+²FIå7H@37-0/�Bíéo+A20N'õ � FIHRBí60/CÝ /�+AT7/)2064/�FI20D�/�H52y20N=FKH Ý�3KH524F7Ý924-éoN@3�é�/�64/>-4Ý 64/�/�H=/�ByãUë�24N@/�+.6ÁM@64+.T;FI20/>D�/CBE+.Ý�FIQÚBE3EÝ920376�á�3¾ß@6iBE37DGFI+.Hy/�èEMR/�6u2\-�é�/�64/�5ß@+A20/�+.H520/�60/C-f24/�B�203�+.B@/�H520+AWXë�20N@/C-u/yFIH=B�ß=-0/�24N@/�D#F7-�FGå7ß@+.B@/203�BE/�T7/�Q.3KM�ãÚ/ 2u24/�6+.H5T7/�-u20+.å7FI20+.3KHºå7ß@+²BE/�Q.+AH=/�-�áMÏ/�FIQ²-u3�BE+²-0Ý�3sTK/�60/CB BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ +./�-�24N=Fs2ÌFK60/íÝ�QA/CFI64QAë 64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQ~:>FIHRB 24N=Fs2

é�3Kß@Q²B�N=F;TK/�ãR/�/�HºBE+[Z)Ý ß@QA2Á243�BE/�20/CÝ92ißR-u+.H@å�FH=3KHEó�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ@Q./�FI64H@+.H@å�FIQ.åK3760+A20N=D�á?@376G/ è@FID�M@Q./K:%24N@/�64/�+.-GFàBE/�MR/�H=BE/�H=Ý /�ãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�H�24N@/�M=Fs24+A/�H728U -��>ö�� 60/C-uß=Q�2)FIHRBéoN@/�20N@/�6`N=/Á2464FKH=-uD�+A24-,20N@/oBE+²-0/�FK-0/�243¾F$Ý 37H72\FKÝ 2JTE�>ö���MR35-u+A20+.TK/�M=Fs24+A/�H524-%FI64/�D�ßRÝ\ND�3K64/�Q.+.äK/�Q.ë�203�206\FIH=-0D�+�2$20N=/�B@+.-0/�F7-u/7áÚõpN@/�60/�FI64/�-0/�T7/�6\FIQ`MR35-0-0+.ã@QA/�/ èEM@Q²FIH=FI20+.3KH=-WX3K6�24N@+²-)BE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�ë9T�WX3K6G/�èEFKD�M@QA/7:�MR/�60NRFIM=- �>ö���ó~MÚ37-0+A20+.TK/�M=Fs24+A/�H524-)FK60/�D�3K64/Q.+Aä7/�Q.ëæ203�ãÚ/G+AHUT73KQ.TK/�BÞéo+A20Nà3I24N@/�6R��ö��>ó�MR35-u+A20+.TK/GM=FI20+./�H524-�:�éoN@3�FK60/�D�3K64/�QA+.äK/�QAë203ÌãR/)+.HEWX/CÝ920/CB I%FIQA20/�64H=FI20+.TK/�Q.ëK:�+A2�+²-�FKQ.-03�MR35-0-0+.ã@QA/�24N=Fs2�20N@/º-0ß@ãZÝ�F7-u/G+²-�F7Ý920ßRFIQ.QAë20N=/)+AH@WX/�Ý9243K6C:,FIHRBÞ3760+.åK+.H=FKQ �>ö��>ó�MÚ37-0+�24+AT7/GM=Fs24+A/�H72�épFK-P+.HEWX/CÝ920/CBàãUëæ20N=/º-uß=ãÚÝ�FK-0/FIHRB�-u+.D�M@QAë�DGFIH@+AWX/�-u20/CB�20N@/�B@+.-0/�F7-u/P/�FK60Q.+./�6oãÚ/�Ý�FKß=-0/3IW�N@+²-o+AD�D�ß@H@/ ór-0ß@M@M@64/�-4-u/CB-u24Fs24ß=-�á=S>H@3K20N@/�6>+.H724/�64/�-u20+.H@åG64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHRFIQ�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ ëº+²-p24N@/�Ý 376064/�Q²Fs24+A37HºãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�H20N=/o/ 20N=H@+.Ý�+�2fë�3IWÚ20N@/oMRFs20+./�H52�FIHRB�24N@/oHUß@D�ãÚ/�6�3KWÚMRFs20+./�H52\-%+AHEWX/CÝ924/�B�ãUë20N=/>-f2464FK+AH�áV�Fs24+A/�H524-oéoN@3)FK60/�S¾-u+²FIH�FK60/PD�3K64/QA+.äK/�QAëº203)ãÚ/�+.HEWX/�Ý 20/CB�éo+�24NæFG-f2464FK+AH�éoN@+²Ý\N�+.-ß@H@+��5ß@/G+.HÞ24N@/GMÚ3KM@ß@Q²Fs24+A37H�:�éoN@/�60/CFK-P3I24N@/�6/�20N@H=+.Ý�+�24+A/C-�FI64/�D�3760/�Q.+Aä7/�Q.ë�203�N=F;T7/-u206\FI+.H=->24N=Fs264/�Ý�ß@6�+.HÏ-0/�T7/�6\FIQÃM=Fs24+A/�H72\-�á�õpN@/y64/�FK-03KH�+²-¾20N=FI2PS¾-u+²FIHÌM=Fs24+A/�H72\-PFI64/D�3K64/¾3KW°20/�H�+.D�Dy+.åK6\FIH52\-�:5éoN@3�+AD�D�+.åK6\Fs20/¾203�20N=/ O�á ��áEéo+�24N�F�H@/�é -f2464FK+AH�3IWÃõ �$:éoN@/�60/CFK-p3I24N@/�6o/�20N@H=+.Ý�+�24+A/C->FI64/¾3KW°20/�H�+.HEWX/CÝ920/CB�QA3EÝ�FIQ.QAë7á

��� �����rZ k � �� � W Z k ���

õpN@/$-u/CÝ 3KHRB)BE3KDGFK+AHGé�/�M@64/�-0/�H52Á+²-�F�B@FI24FK-0/ 2i3IW,Ý 37D�M=FIHUë�FIH=BGÝ�3KD�M=FIHUëy3=Z)Ý /�64-3Kã@24FI+.H@/CBàWX6037D �E/�Ý ß=60+A2fëÏFKH=B�â�èEÝ\NRFIH@å7/ �i3KD�D�+.-4-u+.3KH ì7�Eâ �pð�B@Fs2\F@á J õpN@/�B@Fs2\F-0/ 2P+AH=Ý�QAßRBE/�-¾+AH@WX3K64D�FI20+.3KH�:Úå7FI20N@/�60/CB�3sTK/�6�FGçRTK/�ë7/�FK6�MÚ/�64+A3EB�:�FIãÚ3Kß@2$Ý 37D�M=FIH@+./�-ìXéoN=+.Ý\N�é�/�64/G64/�-u2064+.Ý 20/�BÏ243æã=FKH@äE-�+.Hà20N@/�B@Fs2\FK-0/ 2�é�/)ß=-0/�B=ð :`Ý�3K64MR3764FI20/�3=Z)Ý /�64-+.H�20N=/�Ý�3KD�M=FIH=+A/C-�:%FIH=Bí20N@/�6037QA/º20N=FI2�24N@/�MR/�64-03KH�M=Q.F;ëE-�+.H�24N@/�Ý 3KD�M=FKHUëKá%?@3K63Kß=6�20/�-u24-�:�é�/�N=F7B�24N@/�WX3KQ.QA3séo+.H@åàÝ Q²FK-4-u/C-�FIH=B�24FKã@QA/�-0+���/�-JT8�Q������#��� ì7@BA@: A�A�A7ð :���������Ìì USA@: A�A�A7ð9:�FKH=B �?��V �ì >@�A@: A�A�A5ð9á��Q������#���ºNRFK-PëK/CFI64QAëæ-u24FI20+²-f24+.Ý�-�:Ã-uß=Ý\NàFK-20N=/¾HUß@D�ãR/�6Á3IW�/�D�M@QA3së7/�/C-�:K20N@/�203I2\FIQZFK-4-u/�24-�:I24N@/¾Ý\N=FKH@åK/�+AHG243I2\FIQRF7-0-0/ 2\-�ãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�HëK/CFI6\-�:U24N@/�64/ 24ß@60H�3KH�/CFI64H@+AH=å7-p6\Fs20+.3=:RFIH=B�20N=/�Ý\N=FIH@å7/+AH�64/ 24ß@60H�37H�F7-0-0/ 2\-�á��?��V BE/C-0Ý�60+.ãR/C-P+AH@WX3K64D�FI20+.3KHàFIãÚ3KßE2�F�MÚ/�6\-u37H U -P643KQ./�+AHÞ20N=/)Ý 3KD�M=FKHUëæ+AHRÝ Q.ß=BE+.H@å�20N@/�+A6-4FIQ²FI64ëK:U20N=/�+.6>2037M�MR35-u+A20+.3KHíìXM=60/C-u+²BE/�H52C: ��â 3�:=Ý\NRFI+.60DGFIH�3IW`20N=/�ãR35FI6\B�:@/�24ÝIá|ð9:=20N@/HUß@D�ãÚ/�6¾3IW�643KQ./�-�20N=/�ë�[email protected];ë�+AH�24N@/�Ý�3KD�M=FIHUë�FIH=B�éoN@/�20N@/�6o20N=/�ë�60/�20+.60/CB�376>é�/�64/� �%� kl{�w7q�duq�{re0dZ��q�{�w7e\zCe\�l_CbEe9wo�s}>�i�lb � q�dfe4j � ^`_�gfbE_�guq�dfkl_Cm¾�Uq�{re9w�_�m » gfkla�q�gfÍ��Uq�m7ÍIk�m7�w5q duqKtRc5m5w7e4gpd � e${rc7b5bE_�grd>_�v�ni� ¼i» ��� {p��zKk�wKe\m5j\eP��ÅIdrguq�j0dfk�_�m�q�mUw � klm5ÍGnpkl{rj\_ z;e4gr}¹ �,� � n>½%b7gf_ Â�e\j4d9¿

Page 23: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{  ��

total assets

# roles

rtn earn assets

age

∆∆∆∆ rtn assets

fired

# employees

top_roletop_role

∆∆∆∆ total_assets

retired retired

salary salary

����������

� � ��

��� ������ � ��

� � ��� �

�! #"%$ &�$�� $ �%� e »�¼ �Ç{�drgfc7j4dfc7gfepv._�g�d � eo^`_CabUq�ms}ywK_Ca�q�k�m=¿

ç=64/�B�áL������� ��?��V �+.H=BE+²Ý�FI20/�-$F)-0QA3K2¾éoN@35-u/�64FKH@åK/2fëUMÚ/�+²->24N@/�-4FID�/�Ý�Q.F7-0-�:=64/�Q²Fs24+AH=åF�MÚ/�6\-03KH U -�643KQ./>+AH)20N@/$Ý 3KD�M=FKHUë�+.HG20N=/¾Ý ß=6064/�H52Áë7/�FI6�203�N=+.-Á6037QA/>+.HG24N@/¾Ý�3KD�M=FIHUë+.H�24N@/M@64/�TU+.3Kß=-pë7/�FI6Cá

õpN@/º-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/G3IWp20N=/ºQ./�FI64H@/CBÏViÜ>ï +.-�-uN=3séoHÏ+.H�?`+.åKß@64/?Ká "@á MÏ/º-0/�/G24N=Fs2é�/�Q./�FK60HÏ-u37Dy/y64/�FK-03KHRFIã@Q./�MÚ/�6\-u+²-f24/�H=Ý�/yFK64Ý�-¾-0ß=Ý\NàFK-�20N@/yWÆF7Ý924-¾24N=Fs2P20N=+.-Pë7/�FI68U --4FIQ²FI64ëºBE/�MÚ/�HRB@->37H�Q.F7-f2>ë7/�FI68U -o-0FKQ.FK60ëºFKH=B�20N=+.-�ëK/�FK6&U -�2037M�6037QA/�BE/�MR/�H=B@-�3KH�Q²FK-u2ëK/CFI68U -$243KMí643KQ./Ká,õpN=/�64/G+.-�FIQ²-u3�24N@/)/ èEMÚ/�Ý 20/�BíB@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý /ºãR/�2féi/�/�H ���������Uá J���5FIHRB �?��V 7á . 5G07*-#&5)=Zá�SÇD�3K64/y+.H520/�60/C-f24+AH@å�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ /G+²-PãR/�2féi/�/�HÞ20N@/�HUß@D�ãÚ/�63KW/�D�[email protected]ëK/�/�-Ã+AH�20N@/oÝ�3KD�M=FIHUë7:�éoN@+²Ý\N�+²-%F�643Kß=åKN�D�/�F7-uß=60/i3IWRÝ�3KD�M=FIHUë-0+���/K:sFIH=B�20N@/-4FIQ²FI64ëKáU?@3K6p/�èEFKD�M@QA/7:EFIHº/�D�M@QA3së7/�/�20N=FI2p64/�Ý�/�+.TK/C-ÁFy-0FKQ.FK60ë�3IW��B@BA�AKO +.H�37H@/¾ë7/�FK6+²->D�ßRÝ\N�Dy3760/Q.+.äK/�Q.ë)243)64/�Ý /�+AT7/�F�64FK+.-0/P203 �6D�A�AKOÉ24N@/�WX37QAQ.3séo+.H@åGëK/CFI6o+.HæFGQ.FK60å7/ã=FKH@ä�ìÆ3sTK/�6 JA�A�A�/�D�[email protected]ëK/�/�-\ð¾20N=FKHí+AH�Fæ-0DGFIQ.Q�3KH=/KáÃS�å7FK+AH�:Ãéi/)-0/�/º+AH520/�60/C-f24+AH=åÝ 376064/�Q²Fs24+A37H=-�ãR/�2féi/�/�H�3Kã Hf/CÝ92\-p+AH�BE+AYÚ/�60/�H52>60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=-�á

Ð�Ñ"!$# Û��5Ù�Ø ���5ÛuÖÁÓ ��Ó�× Õ;� ��`Ô��Ã×&%àÖ�Õ('

õpN@/�60/>FK60/>Ý�QA/CFI64QAë�DGFKH5ë�3I24N@/�6ÁFKM@M@6437F7Ý\N@/�-Ã203Q./�FK60H=+AH@åPWX643KDÇB@Fs2\F@áBMÏ/�Ý�FIHGÝ�FI20/ óåK3760+���/¾20N=/�DôFKQA37H@å�20N@64/�/PDGFI+.H�FsèE/�-JTUM@6037ã=FIã=+AQ.+.-u20+²Ý¾TK/�6\-0ß=-pBE/ 24/�64Dy+.H@+²-f24+.Ý�I@D�3EBE/�QQ./�FI64H@+.H@å�TK/�64-0ß=-pÝ Q²FK-4-u+AçRÝ�Fs20+.3KH IUFKH=B�Fs202064+Aã@ß@20/ ó�ã=F7-u/CBºT7/�6\-uß=-�64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQ~á

ï�35-f2PFIM@M@6437F7Ý\N@/�-�243ºDGFKÝ\N=+AH@/�QA/CFI64H@+.H@åGWÆFIQ.Q`+AH5203º20N@/yÝ�FI20/�å73K64ëº3KWÁFs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/ óã=F7-u/CB�Ý�Q.F7-0-0+AçRÝ�FI20+.3KH�:Eéo+A20N�<�FK+AT7/R�pF;ëK/�-iWÆFKQAQ.+AH=åG+AH5203y24N@/�M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+²-f24+.ÝPÝ�Fs20/�åK3760ë7:Ý 37H=Ý /�ME2oQA/CFI64H@+.H@å�+.H5203�20N@/BE/�20/�60D�+.H@+.-u20+²ÝPÝ�FI20/�å73K64ëK:UFIH=B�FIM=M@6035FKÝ\N@/C-Á-0ß=Ý\N�F7-pBE/ óÝ +²-0+A37Hº2460/�/�-oFIHRB�H=/�ß@6\FIQ�H@/�2féi3760äE-p-03KD�/�éoN@/�60/$+.H�ãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�H�á

Page 24: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C� � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

�pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH¾H@/ 2fé�3K64äE-ÚWÆFIQ.QI+AH5243p20N@/ÁÝ�Fs24/�åK3760ë�3IWEFs2u2460+.ã@ßE24/ ó�ã=FK-0/�B$D�3EBE/�QAó�QA/CFI64H@+AH=å�T20N=/¾64/�-0ß@QA2i3IW,20N@/$QA/CFI64H@+.H@å�+²-�F�D�3UB@/�QÚ3IW�24N@/$B@/�MÚ/�H=BE/�H=Ý +./�-�éo+A20N@+.H)24N@/P-u/�2i3IW`Fs2uó2064+.ã@ßE20/C-�:Á64FI20N@/�6�24N=FIH'FIH'Fs2020/�DyM@2G203àM@64/�BE+²Ý92G3KH=/�M=FK6u24+.Ý�ß@Q²FI6GFs202064+Aã@ß@20/�ß=-0+AH=å20N=/G3I20N=/�6\-�á ��3séi/�TK/�6C:ZFK-Pé�/�B@+.-4Ý ß=-4-0/�BÞ+AHW�U/CÝ920+.3KH�Ká�@E: �pF;ë7/�-0+.FKHæH@/ 2fé�3K64äE-PFI64/Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/�ó~ã=F7-u/CBí+.H�H=Fs24ß@64/K:`éoN@+.Ý\N�-uß=ã=-f2\FIH520+²FIQ.Q.ëÞQ.+AD�+A24-�20N=/�+.6yFKã@+AQ.+A2fëÞ243Þ64/�M=60/�ó-0/�H52�Ý 37DyM=QA/�èÏBE37D�FK+AHR-P+AHUTK37QATU+.H@å�D�ß@QA20+.M@Q./)/�H524+�24+A/C-�áB3¾H=/GDy+.åKN52�F7-uäZ:�N@3sé�/�T7/�6C:éoN@/�20N@/�6�20N=/�ëGÝ�FKHGãR/>H=/�TK/�6u24N@/�Q./�-4-�ãÚ/¾FKM@M@Q.+A/CBGFK-�F�B@+.-4Ý 3sT7/�64ë203U3KQ=WX3K6i60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQB@FI24F@áZS�-u24FKH=B@FK64B�FKH=B�WÆFI+.64QAë�3KãUTU+A37ß=-�-03KQ.ßE24+A37H�+.-�203��RFs2020/�Hæ20N@/�B@Fs2\F@:ÚÝ 64/�Fs24+AH=åF)-0+AH=åKQ./P24FIã=QA/24N=Fs2$Ý 3KH52\FI+.H=->FIQ.Q�24N@/�FI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/C-�:ÚFIH=B�24N@/�HÞFIM@M@Q.ë��pF;ë7/�-0+.FKH�H@/�2uóé�3K64ä�Q./�FK60H@+.H@åRá�M�N@+.QA/�20N@+²-�FIM@M@6437F7Ý\NGÝ�FIHºãR/¾ß=-u/�WXß@Q~:7+A2p-0ßEYZ/�6\-�WX643KDÇ20N=60/�/>DGF6Hf3K6M@643Kã@Q./�DG-�á

3¾H@/$äK/�ëG+.-4-uß=/¾64/�Q²Fs24/�-i203y20N=/P-u24FI20+²-f24+.Ý�FIQ�Ý 376064/�Ý 20H@/C-0-i3IW,20N@+²-oFIM@M=6035FKÝ\N�á;�i3KHEó-0+.BE/�6�3Kß@6�õ �íB@FI24F7-u/�2�:sFIH=B�+.D�FKåK+.H@/K�RFs2020/�H=+AH@å$24N@/oB@Fs2\F>243PF�24FKã@Q./i24N=Fs2�Ý�3KH524FK+AH=-FGM=FI20+./�H52$FKH=B�F)Ý�3KH524F7Ý92�áRörH�20N=+.-$Ý�F7-u/7:RFGM=FI20+./�H52�éoN@3ºN=FK->2féi3ºÝ�3KH524F7Ý92\->é�3Kß@Q²BFIM=MR/CFI6�+AHº20N@/¾24FKã@QA/¾2féo+²Ý /�ìX3KHRÝ /�éo+A20N�/�F7Ý\NºÝ 37H524FKÝ 2\ð :7éoN@/�60/CFK-i3KH@/¾éoN@3yN=FK-Á20/�HÝ 37H524FKÝ 24-�éi37ß@Q.BíFKM@MÚ/�FI6�+AH�20N@/º24FIã=QA/º20/�H�20+.Dy/C-�á%õpN@+²-�NRFK-24N@/º/�YÚ/CÝ92�3IW>-0äK/�épó+.H@åy20N@/B@FI24Fy-uß@ãR-f2\FIH520+²FIQ.QAë7:UQA/CFKBE+.H@å�203yM=FI6\FID�/ 24/�6�/�-u20+.DGFs20/C-ìÆFKH=BºÝ�3K6460/�Q.FI20+.3KH=-\ð20NRFs2oFI64/>N@+.åKN@Q.ëGH@3KH@ó~64/�M@64/�-0/�H52\Fs20+.TK/p3KW�20N@/¾2064ß@/$BE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KH,á7örH�Dy3760/�20/CÝ\N@H@+²Ý�FIQ20/�60DG-�:��pF;ëK/C-u+²FIH�H@/ 2fé�3K64äGQA/CFI64H@+.H@å�D�FKäK/C-�20N@/�F7-0-0ß@D�ME20+.3KH�24N=Fs2o24N@/�B@Fs2\F�Ý�FK-0/�-FI64/P+AHRBE/�MÚ/�H=B@/�H52�ìXö0öfL$ð :@éoN@/�64/�F7-i20N@+²->FK-4-0ß@D�ME20+.3KH�+.-oÝ�QA/CFI64QAëGTU+.3KQ²Fs24/�B�éoN@/�H�3Kß@6B@FI24F�-u/�2>+.->3KãE2\FI+.H@/�B�ãUë<�RFs2020/�H@+AH=å)F�64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQ�B@FI24FKã=FK-0/Ká

S'-u/CÝ 37H=B�Q.+.Dy+A24FI20+.3KHy+.-`24N=Fs2�é�/pN=F;TK/i203BE/�20/�64D�+AH=/�+.H�FKBETsFIHRÝ /péoN@+²Ý\NyFK60/i20N@/64/�Q./�TsFIH52�Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-203ÌM@ßE2�+.Hà20N@/)24FIã=QA/7á�i3KHR-u+²BE/�6C:�WX376�/ è@FID�M@Q./K:,20N@/ºåK/�H=/ 20+²Ý�-BE37D�FK+AH,:Iã@ßE2ÁéoN=/�64/�é�/oN=F;T7/�37H@Q.ë�M@N@/�H@3I2fëUMÚ/o3Kã=-0/�64TsFs20+.3KHR-oìX3KãR-u/�60TsFIã=QA/�WX/�FI20ß@64/�-3IWo24N@/ºMÚ/�6\-03KHRð á MÏ/ºD�+Aå7N52�20N@+.H@äÏ203 Hf3K+.Hí20N@/º24FKã@QA/)203Ì+A24-0/�QAWf:%Ý 64/�Fs24+AH=åæF�24FKã@QA/20NRFs2¾Ý�3KH524FK+AH=-o20N@/�MÚ/�6\-03KH�FIH=B�N@+²->MRFI64/�H524-�á��>3sé�/�T7/�6C:U20N@+²->é�3Kß=Q.B�64/�-u2064+.Ý 2>ß=-p203BE+²-0Ý�3sTK/�60+.H@å�Ý 3K6464/�Q²Fs20+.3KHR->24N=Fs2�Ý�6035-0-På7/�H@/�64FI20+.3KH=-�á�?@3K6/�è@FID�M@Q./K:�DGFIQ./Gã=FIQ²BEH@/C-0-+²-P+AH@N=/�64+�24/�BÞWX6037D F�D�FKH U -PD�FI20/�60H=FKQ�åK6\FIH=BEWÆFs20N=/�6$64FI20N@/�6¾24N=FIHàN@+²-$WÆFs24N@/�6>IZ20N=+.-2fëUMR/P3KWÃÝ 376064/�Q²Fs24+A37HGéi37ß@Q.BºãR/PQ.37-u2�+AW,é�/ �ÚFs2u24/�H@/CB)24N@/PB@Fs2\F�+.Hº24N@/$3KãUTU+A37ß=-ÁépF;ëKá

?`+AHRFIQ.QAë7:E/�TK/�H�+AW�F �pF;ë7/�-0+.FKH)H@/ 2fé�3K64äGD�3EBE/�Q�+²-pQA/CFI64H@/�BºWX3K6>-0ß=Ý\N�FyB=Fs24FKã=FK-0/K:+A2oÝ�FIH@H=3I2oãR/Pß=-0/�B)203�64/�FKÝ\N�Ý 3KHRÝ Q.ß=-u+.3KHR-iãRFK-0/�B)37Hº64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQ�BE/�MR/�H=BE/�HRÝ +./�-�á@?@3K6/ è@FKDyM=QA/7:�+AHÞ20N@/)õ ��BE3KDGFI+.H�:�é�/�D�+.åKN52�+.D�FKåK+.H@/y+AHEWX/�6064+.H@åº24N=Fs2�F�M=FI20+./�H52N=FK-FàM=FK6u24+.Ý�ß@Q.FK60Q.ë�+.HEWX/�Ý 20+.3Kß=-�-f2464FK+AH'ãUë�H=3I20+²Ý +.H@åà24N=Fs2ºN=/�206\FIH=-0D�+�2020/�B�24N@/Ì-u206\FI+.H203ÏDGFIHUëà3IW>N@+²-�Ý 37H72\FKÝ 24-JI,é�/�Ý�FIHí24N@/�H +AHEWX/�6�24N=Fs2GFæH=/�éÀÝ�3KH524F7Ý92�+²-�QA+.äK/�QAëÏ203N=F;T7/�24N@/æ-4FID�/�-f2464FK+AH�:�FKH=B 20N@/�60/�WX3K64/�20N=FI2º-uN@/�+²-)FIQ²-03ÏQ.+.äK/�Q.ëí243Ï+.HEWX/CÝ92ºDGFIHUë3IWpN@/�6�Ý 3KH52\FKÝ92\-�á�õpN@+²-$2fëUMR/G3KWi64/�F7-u37H@+AH=å�+²-P3KH@Q.ëæMÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./�ß=-u+.H@å�20N=/G60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=FKQ-u2064ß=Ý924ß@60/�20NRFs2GFIQ.QA3sé>-�ß=-�203Ïß=-u/�+AH@WX3K64D�FI20+.3KH 3KãE2\FI+.H@/�B�FKãR37ßE2�3KH@/�M=Fs24+A/�H72y20364/�FKÝ\N�Ý 37H=Ý Q.ß=-0+A37H=-�FIãÚ3KßE2y20N@/æ-u206\FI+.H FKH=BíWX643KD"20N=FI2�64/�F7Ý\N Ý�3KH=Ý�QAß=-0+.3KH=-yFIãÚ3KßE2FIH=3I20N=/�6oM=FI20+./�H52>/�H520+.64/�Q.ëKá

3�20N=/�6�24N=FIHêVÁÜ>ïÌ- ìÆFKH=B 24N@/ 64/�Q²Fs24/�B FKM@M@6437F7Ý\N@/�-í3KW�� 7á @�AU: Ká�@BD>�Xð9:y20N@/3KH=QAë�64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQ`QA/CFI64H@+.H@å�FKM@M@6437FKÝ\N=/�-�FK60/yTsFI64+.FKH524-¾3IWÁ+.H=BEß=Ý 20+.TK/yQA37åK+²Ý�M=6037åK6\FIDyóD�+AH=å�ìÆöf*,V�ð9áIï�35-f2%öf*,VàFIM=M@6035FKÝ\N@/C-,FK60/pBE/ 24/�64D�+AH@+²-u20+²Ý�Ý�Q.F7-0-0+AçRÝ�FI20+.3KH�FKM@M@6437FKÝ\N=/�-�:éoN@+²Ý\N�BE3æH@3K2�Fs2020/�DyM@2�203ÌDy3EBE/�QiF�M=6037ã=FIã@+.Q.+�2fëÏBE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KH,:,ã@ßE2y64FI20N@/�6�3KH=QAë203�M@64/�BE+²Ý92PìÆÝ Q²FK-4-0+�WXë@ð�F�M=FI6020+²Ý ß@Q²FI6iM@64/�BE+²Ý�FI20/KáS�>3sé�/�T7/�6C:s20N@/�60/$FI64/o2fé�3�60/CÝ /�H72�BE/ ó

Page 25: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{ �K�

TK/�QA37M@D�/�H524-péo+A20N=+AH�24N@/öf*,V�Ý�3KD�D�ß@H=+�2fëG24N=Fs2�FK60/P64/�Q²Fs24/�B�203)ViÜ>ïæ-JT@-f243UÝ\NRFK-u20+²ÝQ.3KåK+²Ý�M=6037åK6\FIDG-�ì7�E*,Vi-4ð+� 7á�"U: 7á Y6��FKH=BQ�pF;ë7/�-0+.FKH�Q.3Kå7+.Ý�M@643KåK6\FIDG-�ì3�p*,Vi-4ð+� 7á>D>�~áõpN@/$-u/�D�FKH520+²Ý�-ÁWX3K6�24N@/�-0/>2fé�3�FKM@M@6437FKÝ\N=/�-�FK60/ �5ß@+A20/$BE+AYÚ/�60/�H72C:Uéo+�24NG20N@/ �p*,V�-0/ óDGFIH520+²Ý�-�ãR/�+AH=å�20N@/�Ý�QA35-u/C-f2o243ºVÁÜ�ïæ-�áRS>HQ�E*ÃV�BE/ ç=H=/�-�FG-4FID�M@Q.+.H@å)BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H3sTK/�6%QA37åK+²ÝÁM@643Kå764FKD�Dy+.H@å$M@64353KWÆ-+IsF7-�F$Ý�3KH=-0/J�5ß@/�H=Ý /7:;+�2�+.H=BEß=Ý�/�-�F$M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fë�BE+²-fó2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KHÞ3sTK/�6>20N=/�MÚ37-4-u+.ã@Q./�å76037ß@H=B�WÆFKÝ 24-¾WX3K6PF)å7+AT7/�HæM=60/CBE+.Ý�Fs24/Ká 3¾H�20N@/y3I24N@/�6N=FKH=B�:,F?�p*,VÉÝ�3KH=-0+.-u24-�3IWoF�-0/ 2�3IWp60ß@Q./�-�:�FIQ.3KH=å�éo+A20N�Ý�3KH=B@+�24+A37H=FIQ�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A20+./�-FIHRB�FÌÝ�3KD�ã@+AHRFs20+.3KH�60ß@Q./�I`WX37QAQ.3séo+AH=åæ20N=/�FKM@M@6437FKÝ\Ní3KW>äUH@3séoQA/CBEåK/�ó~ãRFK-0/�BàD�3EBE/�QÝ 37H=-u2064ß=Ý924+A37H � 7á @��>�~:i20N=/4�p*,V /C-0-0/�H524+.FKQAQ.ë -0MR/CÝ +Aç=/�-�FíM@643KMÚ37-0+A20+.3KH=FKQ �pF;ëK/�-0+²FIHH@/�2féi3760äZá%õpN@+.-GFKM@M@6437F7Ý\Ní+.-yTK/�60ëí-0+AD�+.Q.FK6y203Þ20N@/�M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+²-f24+.ݺQA37åK+²ÝºM=6037åK6\FIDG-3IW �Ká�@BAE: 7á @�DE�~á

*�/CFI64H@+.H@å�FKQAå73K64+�24N@DG->WX376�24N@/�-0/GFIM@M@6437F7Ý\N@/�-¾FI64/�ãÚ/�+.H@å�BE/�T7/�Q.3KMÚ/�B�á�ï�/�20N@3EB@-WX3K6�QA/CFI64H@+.H@å4�E*ÃVÁ-�FK60/�BE/�-4Ý 64+AãÚ/�Bà+.H �Ká� � ��áÃSÀDGFsèE+AD�ß@D QA+.äK/�QA+.N@3U3EBíFIM@M=6035FKÝ\N+²-o24FKäK/�H�WX376�M=FK64FKD�/ 20/�6o/�-u20+.DGFs20+.3KH�WX376¾FIH �E*ÃV�éoN@+²Ý\N�+.-�ã=FK-0/�B�3KH�DGFIèU+.D�+���+AH=å20N=/�MÚ37-u20/�64+.3K6>M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fë�3IW%20N@/�M@643KåK6\FID�á=õpN=/24F7-uä�3IW�Q./�FI64H@+.H@åG24N@/�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/3IW�FKH �@*,V +²- �5ß@+�24/ÌBE+AYÚ/�60/�H52)WX6037D Q./�FK60H@+.H@åíFíVÁÜ�ï�-u2064ß=Ý 20ß@64/æFIH=B�+²-)ã=F7-u/CB3KH�D�3760/�2464F7BE+A20+.3KH=FKQ>öf*,V FKM@M@6437F7Ý\N@/�-�á�3¾H'20N@/Þ3I24N@/�6�N=FIH=B�:ÁéoN@+.QA/��p*,VÁ-ºFI64/D�3K64/�Ý Q.37-0/�Q.ëí60/�Q.FI20/�B�203íViÜ>ïæ-�:%FKH=B Dy/�20N@3EB@-GWX3K6GQ./�FI64H@+.H@å ��*ÃVÁ-yN=F;T7/�ãÚ/�/�H-0ß@åKå7/�-u20/�BP+.H��Ká�JDE��:CQA/CFI64H@+AH=å�FIQ.åK3760+A20N@DG-�NRF;TK/�H@3K2Ãë7/ 2,ãÚ/�/�H�BE/�TK/�Q.3KMÚ/�B�á�ï�/�20N@3EB@-WX3K6oQ./�FK60H=+AH@åGViÜ>ïæ-pDGF;ë)ãÚ/PWX3Kß@H=B�243yãÚ/�FIM=M@QA+²Ý�FKã@Q./¾243GQA/CFI64H@+.H@å �p*ÃVÁ-�á

Ð�Ñ������pÔ��ÃÓ��UÛfÖÁÓ �

����� �� � Y � ���KY�� � �� P ��� � � Y ����mY ��U3ÏWÆFI6C:�é�/�N=F;T7/�F7-0-0ß@D�/�B�20NRFs2�20N@/�-0äK/�QA/�203KH�+²-�/�èU20/�64H=FKQp203Ï20N@/�M@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²ÝD�3EBE/�Q7IU+AH�3I20N=/�6�éi3764B@-�:I24N@/P-uä7/�Q./ 2037H)+²-�F7-0-0ß@D�/�BG203�ãÚ/$M=FI602i3KW�20N@/$+.H@M@ßE2�203�20N@/VÁÜ�ïíáRõpN@+²->Q.+.Dy+A24FI20+.3KHæNRFK-p2fé�3GDGFI+.H�+AD�M@Q.+.Ý�Fs24+A37H=-�áÚï�37-u2�37ã5TU+.3Kß=-0Q.ëK:@+A2�+.DyM=QA+./�-20NRFs2�24N@/ºD�3EBE/�Q�Ý�FKHÏ37H@Q.ëÌãÚ/ºß=-0/�BÏ+.H�-u/�2u20+.H@å5-�éoN@/�60/�24N@/)64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHRFIQÁ-u2064ß=Ý924ß@64/+²-�äUH@3séoH�áZõpNUß=-�:@WX3K6$/ è@FKDyM=QA/7:=é�/�Ý�FKH@H@3K2¾ß=-0/�+A2¾243�Ý 37H=Ý Q.ß=BE/�20N=FI2PFGMRFs20+./�H52$+.-D�3K64/>Q.+Aä7/�Q.ë�243�N=F;TK/¾FM=FI6020+²Ý ß=Q.FK6Á-f2464FK+AHG3KW�õ �¾:5ã=F7-u/CB�3KHGN@+²-iB@/�D�3Kå764FKM@N@+²Ý�-�FIHRBN@+²-�Ý 3KH52\FKÝ92\-�á%SôDy3760/�-uß=ãE20Q./�MÚ3K+.H52y+²-�20N=FI2�24N@+²-�64/�-u2064+²Ý920+.3KH Ý�FIH BE+AD�+.H@+²-uN 20N@/�5ß=FIQ.+A2fëÏ3KWo3Kß@6�Dy3EBE/�Qi/�TK/�H�+AH Ý�FK-0/�-�éoN@/�64/G24N@/º64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQ�-f2460ß=Ý 20ß@64/ *�/ºå7+AT7/�H�:ãÚ/�Ý�FKß=-0/�+�2¾+Aå7H@3K64/�-o+.H520/�60/C-f24+AH@å)Ý�3K6460/�Q.FI20+.3KH=-pãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�HæFs202064+Aã@ß@20/�-�3IW�/�H524+�24+A/C-�FIHRB20N=/�64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=-�ãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�H�24N@/�D�áI?@376Ã/�è@FID�M@Q./K:C+AHyF�D�3sTU+A/�BE3KDGFK+AH�F��0-0/�64+.3Kß=-F�oFKÝ 203K6+²-iß=H@QA+.äK/�QAëy243yFKM@MR/CFI6�+AH�DGFIHUë�N@3K6460376ÁD�3sTU+A/C-+I7N@/�HRÝ /K:Ué�/$Ý�FIH)+.HEWX/�6�+.HEWX3760DGFs24+A37HFIãÚ3Kß@2yFIH FKÝ9243K68U -ºìXß@H@äUH@3séoHÚð�Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-�ã=F7-u/CBí3KHà24N@/W�?��V )60/�Q.FI20+.3KHíãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�HFKÝ 203764-pFIHRB�D�3sTU+./�-�á

õpN@/pVÁÜ>ïÀWX6\FID�/�é�3K64ä$Ý�FIH�ãR/p/ èU24/�H=BE/CB�243$F7Ý�Ý�3KD�D�3UB=Fs20/�ß@H=Ý�/�6024FK+AH52fëFIãÚ3KßE220N=/�-u2064ß=Ý924ß@6\FIQÁ64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=-0N@+AMR-ãR/�2féi/�/�H�37ã Hf/�Ý 24-yFK-�éi/�QAQpFK-�FIãÚ3KßE2�20N@/�+A6�M@6037MR/�6uó20+./�- � 7á @�@>�~á6MÏ/oN=F;T7/�/�èU20/�HRBE/�By3Kß=6`Q./�FK60H=+AH@åFKQAå73K64+�24N@DG-,243�BE/�FKQEéo+�24NG-uß=Ý\N�/�01#S��2

�0 � #&(6,B� 8 2)5+#�0L(B*-8�0 !=á9MÞ/yH@3séËM@643sTU+.B@/�F)ã=60+./ Wi-0äK/�24Ý\Næ3KW�20N@+²-$/ èU20/�H=-0+A37H�:ZéoN@+.Ý\NÌ+.-BE/C-0Ý�60+.ãR/CB�+AH�D�3K64/$B@/ 24FK+AQ,+AHV�Ká�JAE��á

Page 26: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�;  � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

�Uß@M=MR35-u/�éi/�NRF;TK/�F�-u+.D�M@QA/yBE3KDGFK+AH�+.HæéoN@+²Ý\Næé�/�N=F;T7/ � � �." ���%%#%�B.�X->FIHRB� � �" �-�á;âiFKÝ\NP24N@/�FI20/�6�-0N@3sé>-`-u37Dy/�HUß@D�ãÚ/�6`3IWÚD�3sT5+./�-JI�20N@+²-`+.-`64/�M@64/�-0/�H520/CBãUëP20N@/Ý Q²FK-4-7���%��� ��:Céo+�24N�64/ WX/�60/�H=Ý /�-uQ.3I2\-�24N=Fs2%MR37+AH52`203$ãR3K20N�20N@/i20N@/CFs24/�6%FIH=B�20N@/�D�3sT5+./KáMÏ/�D�+Aå7N52>ä5H=3sé 24N@/�HUß@D�ãR/�6>3IW�-4Ý 64/�/�HR-p20N=FI2¾Fy20N=/�Fs24/�6¾N=FK-�:@ã@ßE2$éi37ß@Q²B�Q.+.äK/P20364/�M@64/�-0/�H52ºFíM@643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ý�Dy3EBE/�Q¾3sT7/�6GéoN@+²Ý\N�D�3sTU+A/æ/CFKÝ\N�20N=/�Fs24/�6�Ý\N@3U37-0/�-y203-0N@3séá 3¾H=/�épF;ë�3KWÁ60/�M@64/�-0/�H520+.H@åG24N@+.-$D�3EBE/�Q`+²-¾ãUë�BE/�ç=H@+.H@å�F�BE+.-u2064+.ã@ßE20+.3KHÞ3sTK/�620N=/Ì64/ WX/�64/�HRÝ /æ-0QA3K2@�������O��� � � �" �T�éoN@+²Ý\N�D�3sT5+./K:�FID�3KH=åà20N@/æD�3sTU+./�-)Ý�ß@6064/�H524QAëF;TsFI+.Q.FKã@Q./K:�+²-ºFà24N@/�FI20/�6ºQ.+Aä7/�Q.ë�243�-uN=3séá MÞ/ÏÝ�FKQAQo24N@+²-�FKM@M@6437FKÝ\N 203 -f2460ß=Ý 20ß@6\FIQß@H=Ý�/�6024FK+AH52fë . 5�*G5+#&5+8 2)5 ' 8 2)5+#�0L(B*-8�0 !sá

<�FK+AT7/�Q.ëK:Úéi/yD�+Aå7N52¾24N@+AH=ä�3IWÁ64/�M@64/�-0/�H524+AH@åº20N@+²-PBE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37HÞFK-$F�TK/�64ë�Q.FK60å7/D�ß=Q�24+AH@37D�+.FKQ`BE+²-u2064+Aã@ß@20+.3KH�:Úéo+�24NÌFGM@643KãRFIã@+.QA+A2fë�WX3K6�/�TK/�60ë�Dy3sTU+./�+.Hæ3Kß@6$BE3KDGFK+AH�áõpN@+²-pFIM@M@6437F7Ý\N)+²-i+.HEWX/CFK-0+Aã@Q./¾WX3K6i2féi3�60/CFK-03KH=-�á5?`+.64-u2�:524N@/¾64/�M=60/C-u/�H72\Fs24+A37HG+.-�D�ßRÝ\N203U3PQ²FI64åK/KáB�U/CÝ 37H=B�:s3Kß=6%206\FI+.H@+AH=å$-0/ 2�éo+.QAQ@Ý�3KH524FK+AHy3KH=/�-0/ 2�3KWRD�3sTU+A/C-�:;ã@ßE2�é�/pé�FKH52203¾QA/CFI64HF>D�3EBE/�QK20N=FI2`Ý�FKH�FIQ²-u3�ãR/�FIM@M@Q.+./�B$203¾3I24N@/�6,B@3KDGFI+.H=-�:�éo+A20N�F¾BE+�YZ/�64/�H52Ã-0/ 23IWZD�3sTU+A/C-�á;örHy3KH@/oFIM=M@6035FKÝ\N�:;é�/oÝ�FIH�M=FI6020+A20+.3KH�20N=/oDy3sTU+./�-`+.H7243Ý�Fs24/�å73K64+A/C-�:;ß=-0+AH=å-03KD�/o-u/�2%3KWÚFI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/C-�:s/�+�24N@/�6�3KWR24N@/pD�3sT5+./�-`376�3IWR64/�Q²Fs24/�B�3Kã Hf/CÝ924-�áI?@376�/ è@FID�M@Q./K:é�/�D�+.åKN52�M=FK6u24+�24+A37H�37Hí20N@/�2fëUMR/�3IW¾Dy3sTU+./Þì�FKÝ924+A37H�:%N@3K64643K6C:,Ý 37Dy/CBEë@ð9:�FIHRB�;3763KH'24N@/æ3760+.åK+.H'3IWP20N@/Þ-f24ß=BE+.3�éoN@+²Ý\N�+.-�24N@/Þ-03Kß=64Ý�/�3KWP20N@/ÞDy3sTU+./�ì3��3KQ.QAëUé�353EB�:+.H=BE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H52 O�á��Zá.:I3K6`WX3760/�+Aå7HRð9áEMÏ/i24N@/�H�64/�M@64/�-0/�H52Ã20N@/pM@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fëP20N=FI2�F¾D�3sTU+./20N=/�Fs24/�6�-0N@3sé>-pF�D�3sTU+A/$WX643KDÀF�M=FK6u24+.Ý�ß@Q²FI6oÝ�FI20/�å73K64ëG+AH�24N@/M=FI6020+A20+.3KH,á=S�-oßR-uß=FKQ�:20N=+.-%BE+²-f2460+.ã@ßE24+A37H�D�+Aå7N52`BE/�MR/�H=B3KH�-u37Dy/i-u/�2Ã3IW@MRFI64/�H524-�:�/7á åRáA:�20N@/Á2fëUMR/�3IWE24N@/�FI20/�6ìXD�/�å7FIM=QA/�è�3K6¾FI602o20N@/CFs20/�6\ð á=õpNUß=-�:=é�/Dy+.åKN52�-u24FI20/24N=Fs2�FKHæFI602�24N@/�FI20/�6�+²-oD�3K64/Q.+Aä7/�Q.ë�243)M@Q²F;ë�F)WX3K64/�+.åKH�D�3sTU+A/7:=éoN@+.Q./�FGD�/�å5FIM@Q./ è�DGF;ë�ãÚ/�D�3760/�Q.+.äK/�Q.ë�203ºM=Q.F;ëF<�>37QAQ.ëUéi3U3EB)D�3sTU+./Ká

S>H=3I20N=/�6%FIM@M@6437F7Ý\N�243¾-u2064ß=Ý924ß@6\FIQKß=H=Ý /�6u2\FI+.H72fë$é�/iÝ�FKQAQ +,-�*�/�0L5+8 2)5@' 892)5G#�0 (6*-8N0�!sáâ�èE+²-f24/�H=Ý�/�ß@HRÝ /�6024FK+AH52fëy+.-�F�å7/�H@/�64FKQ=FIM=M@6035FKÝ\Ny203�D�3UB@/�Q.+AH@å�20N@/$M@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+A2fë�24N=Fs2F�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=-0N@+.M)/ èE+²-f2\-iãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�H�FKH5ë�2fé�3�/�H520+A20+./�-�á)õ,3�BE3�-u3R:5é�/�64/J�5ß@+.64/>20NRFs2p20N@/64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHR-uN@+.MÌãÚ/ 2fé�/�/�Hæ24N@/�/�H520+A20+./�-$+²-¾64/�M=60/C-u/�H724/�BÌã5ëæF�Ý Q²FK-4-JI=WX376$/�è@FID�M@Q./K:Ú20N@/�? !A" �B���C#%�&" ���Ý Q²FK-4-Á+.H�37ß@6p-0Ý\N@3U37QZB@3KDGFI+.H)64/�M@64/�-0/�H524-Á20N=/$64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=-0N@+AMºãR/�2féi/�/�H�F-u20ß=BE/�H52�FIHRByF�Ý 3Kß=64-0/Ká6MÏ/¾Ý�FIH�H@3sé�60/�M@60/C-u/�H52ÁFM@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+²-f24+.ÝpD�3EBE/�Q=20N=FI2iF-u20ßEóBE/�H72iéo+AQ.Q=64/�å7+.-u20/�6ÃWX376ÁFÝ Q²FK-4-�ãUë�+.H520643EBEß=Ý +.H@åFPM@643Kã=FKã@+.QA+²-f24+.ÝpD�3EBE/�QE20N=FI2iFPåK+.TK/�HM=FK+A6�ì�-f24ß=BE/�H52C:RÝ Q²FK-4-\ðÁéo+.Q.Q,FIM@MÚ/�FK6o+AH�24N@/4�? !�" �����$#%�&" ���P24FIã=QA/7á=ï�3K64/PM@64/�Ý +²-0/�Q.ëK:Eé�/-0MR/CÝ +AWXë�20N@/$M@643Kã=FKã@+AQ.+A2fë�24N=Fs2o-ußRÝ\NºFM=FK+A6�/ èE+²-f2\-Á+.H)24N@/>2\FIã@Q./¾å7+AT7/�H)FI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/C-Á3KW20N=/¾-u20ß=BE/�H52iFIH=B�3KWZ20N@/$Ý 3Kß=64-0/KáK?=3K6�/�è@FID�M@Q./K:K+A2Á+²-�D�3K64/>Q.+Aä7/�Q.ë�24N=Fs2pFPß@H@+.TK/�6\-0+�2fë-0/�H@+.3K6�é�3Kß@Q²B�60/�åK+²-f24/�6`WX3K6�FKHyF7BETsFIH=Ý�/�ByÝ Q²FK-4-�:;éoN@/�60/CFK-�F¾WX60/C-uN=D�FKH�+²-%D�3K64/pQA+.äK/�QAë203G64/�å7+.-u20/�6�WX3K6>FIH�+.H724603EBEßRÝ9203760ë�Ý Q²FK-4-�á

����� ��d � �� ���� � ��� � � � � �� �MÏ/�N=F;T7/�FIQ²-u3º+AHUTK/C-f24+Aå5Fs24/�B�20N=/�+²BE/�Fº3IW�QA/CFI64H@+.H@åºVÁÜ�ïæ-�éo+A20NÞÝ Q²FK-4->N@+./�6\FI6\Ý\N@+./�-�á�iQ²FK-4-�N@+./�6\FI6\Ý\N@+./�-�Ý\N=FIH@å7/)24N@/�Q²FIH=åKß=FKåK/)+.H�2fé�3Þ+.D�MR376u2\FIH52�épF;ëE-�áÃörH�24N@/�H@3KHEóN@+./�6\FI6\Ý\N@+²Ý�FIQ¾Ý�FK-0/K:iFIQ.Q�3Kã Hf/�Ý92\-)+.H F�Ý Q²FK-4-GD�ß=-f2�-uN=FK60/æ20N@/Ì-4FID�/ ��ViL¾-�áK��+A/�6uóFI6\Ý\N@+²Ý�FKQ>D�3UB@/�Q²-ºFIQ.Q.3séêßR-G203 -uMÚ/�Ý�+.FKQA+���/�24N@/ ��ViL¾-º3IW�Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/C-)+.H BE+AYÚ/�60/�H72M=FK6u2\-º3KW�20N@/ÏN@+./�6\FI6\Ý\NUëKáÁörHñ3Kß@6�-4Ý\N@3U3KQ�/�è@FID�M@Q./K:péi/ÞD�+Aå7N72�Ý\N@3U37-0/�243 M=FK6u24+�ó20+.3KH�24N@/ �����������Ý Q²FK-4-oFKÝ�Ý�3K6\BE+.H@å�243�20N@/�+A6�+AH520/�H=BE/CB�ëK/�FK6�:@Ý�60/CFs24+AH@åy24N@/P2féi3G-0ß@ãEó

Page 27: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{ �C�

Ý Q²FK-4-0/�- � ���-.�$!��C#�����#%�B �����������PFKH=B��8�C#�����#%�B ��Q���-�$��7á MÏ/�D�+Aå7N72�20N@/�H /�W�5)2G*3(B,.*-,>520N=/ ��ViL�WX3K6 �R* 2X� , 0�!�+.HÌ/�F7Ý\Næ3IWÁ20N@/�-uß=ãÚÝ�Q.F7-0-0/�-�áÚïæ3K64/�+.H724/�64/�-u20+.H@åKQ.ëK:ZF�N@+A/�6uóFI6\Ý\N@+²Ý�FKQiD�3EBE/�QoFKQAQ.3sé>-�ß=-�243ÏÝ�60/CFs20/�BE/�MÚ/�HRBE/�H=Ý�+A/C-�20N=FI2yD�+.åKN52�-0/�/�D Ý ëEÝ Q.+.Ý�+.H20N=/�H@37HEó�N@+A/�64FK64Ý\N=+.Ý�FIQ�Ý�F7-u/7áR?=3K6�/�è@FID�M@Q./K:Úéi/�Ý�FIHæH=3sé NRF;TK/�Fº-u20ßRBE/�H52&U -¾åK6\FKBE/C-+.H�Fyå764F7BEß=Fs24/¾Ý�3Kß@6\-u/PBE/�MR/�H=B�3KH�N@/�6oå764F7BE/�-i+AH�24N@/Pß@H=BE/�60å764F7BEß=Fs24/$Ý�3Kß@6\-0/�-�-uN@/N=F7-p24FKäK/�H,á@<>3I24/P20N=FI2o20N@+²->BE/�MR/�H=BE/�H=Ý ë�+.-oFKM@M=FI64/�H524QAëºÝ�ëEÝ Q.+.ÝPFs2o24N@/Q./�TK/�Q�3IW`20N@/�����������Ý Q²FK-4-�:@-0+AHRÝ /FIH�Fs202064+Aã=ßE20/3KW`37H@/Ý 3Kß=64-0/BE/�MÚ/�H=B=-o3KH�20N=/�-0FKDy/FI2u2064+.ã@ßE20/+.H FIH=3I20N=/�6�Ý�3Kß@6\-0/Ká ��3séi/�TK/�6�:�24N@/�B@+ATU+²-u+.3KH�3KW�Ý 37ß@64-0/�-�+AH5203Ì2féi3Þ-uß@ãZÝ Q²FK-4-0/�-�64/ ó-03KQ.TK/�-�20N@+²-�FIM@MRFI64/�H52yÝ�ëUÝ�QA/7á`SôM@64/�Q.+AD�+.H=FI64ëíBE+²-0Ý�ß=-0-0+.3KHí3IW�20N@/C-u/�+.-4-0ß@/�-yÝ�FKH�ãR/WX3Kß=H=B�+AHV�Ká � �~á

Ð�Ñ����ÞÖÁÓ¾Ù uØ �5ÛuÖÁÓ��

VÁÜ�ïæ-�M@603sTU+²BE/¾F�H@/�é FIM@M=6035FKÝ\N�203y64/�Q²Fs20+.3KHRFIQZB@Fs2\F�D�+.H@+AH=å�24N=Fs2o+²-iå76037ß@H=BE/CBG+.HFæ-03Kß@HRB�-f2\Fs24+.-u20+²Ý�FKQ�WX6\FID�/�é�3K64äZá�S>Q.åK3K64+A20N@DG-WX376�Q./�FK60H@+.H@åÌViÜ>ïæ-�ã@ß@+.Q.Bí37Hà20N@/64/�Ý /�H52B@/�TK/�QA37M@D�/�H524-P+.HÏQA/CFI64H@+AH=å �pF;ë7/�-0+.FKHæH@/ 2fé�3K64äE-�:�FKH=BÌ/�èU20/�HRBÞQ./�FK60H=+AH@å�20320N=+.-$64+.Ý\NÌÝ�Q.F7-0-�3IW�64/�Q²Fs24+A37H=FIQÃDy3EBE/�Q.-�á9�i/CÝ�FKß=-u/�20N@/C-u/�D�3UB@/�Q²-¾BE3�H@3I2¾WX3EÝ ß=-$3KHÞF-0+AH@å7QA/>Ý�Q.F7-0-0+AçRÝ�FI20+.3KH�2\FK-0äZ:;20N@/�ë�FI64/pM=FI6020+²Ý ß=Q.FK60Q.ëéi/�QAQR-uß@+A20/CB�203P/ è[email protected]\Fs243K64ë�B@Fs2\FFIHRFIQ.ëU-0+²-�á

õpN@/�60/�FI64/Á-u/�TK/�64FKQKBE+.60/CÝ920+.3KHR-�WX376,WXßE24ß@64/Áé�3K64äÚáCV%/�64N=FIMR-�20N=/iD�37-u2Ã37ãUT5+.3KßR-�3KH=/+²->24N@/�2460/CFs20D�/�H72$3IW�D�+.-4-0+AH@å�B@Fs2\F)FIHRB�N@+.B=BE/�HÞT;FK60+²FIã=QA/C-�á MÏ/�Ý�FIHæ/�èU20/�HRBæ-f2\FIHEóB@FK64By24/�Ý\N@H@+��5ß@/�-¾ìÆ-0ß=Ý\NºF7-Áâ�èEMÚ/�Ý 24Fs24+A37H)ïæFsèE+.D�+��CFs20+.3KHyWX376ÁD�+.-4-0+AH@å�B@Fs2\F7ð%24320N=+.-24F7-uäZáZì1�U/�/ �Ká�+UB�ÚWX376�-03KD�/¾M@60/�QA+.D�+AHRFI64ë�é�3K64ä�37H)64/�Q²Fs20/CBGD�3EBE/�Q²-�á|ðK�>3sé�/�TK/�6�:K20N@/Ý 37D�M@QA/�èE+�2fë$3IW@+.HEWX/�64/�HRÝ /�37HQ.FK60å7/�B@Fs2\FIã=F7-u/C-�éo+�24N�DGFIHUë$Dy+²-4-u+.H@å>TsFIQ.ß@/C-�DGFIä7/�20N@/Ý 35-f2`3IW@F>HRFI+.TK/�FIM=M@QA+²Ý�FI20+.3KH3KW=-uß=Ý\N�FKQAå73K64+�24N@DG-�M@643KN=+Aã@+A20+.TK/7áC�iQ./�FK60Q.ëK:�20N@+²-ÃB@3KDGFI+.HÝ�FKQAQ²-�ãR3K20NºWX3K6pH@/�é +AHEWX/�60/�H=Ý /PFIQ.åK3760+A20N=D�-�FIHRBGWX3K6pH@/�é Q./�FI64H@+.H@å�FKQAå73K64+�24N@DG-�24N=Fs2F;TK37+.B�64/�MÚ/�FI20/CBæÝ�FKQAQ²-o243º+.HEWX/�64/�H=Ý�/�3sT7/�6o24N@/�-0/�T7/�64ë�Q²FI64åK/�M=6037ã@QA/�DG-�áÚâ�TK/�H�D�3K64/+.H724/�64/�-u20+.H@å�+²-Á20N@/$+.-4-0ß@/�3KW,FIßE243KDGFs24/�BGBE+²-0Ý�3sTK/�60ëy3IW�N@+²B@BE/�H)TsFI64+.FKã@Q./�-�á7õpN@/�60/$FI64/-03KD�/ºM@64/�Q.+.Dy+.H=FK60ëíFIHR-ué�/�6\-243æ20N=+.- �5ß@/�-u20+.3KH +AH�20N@/�Ý 37H520/ èU2y3IW �pF;ëK/C-u+²FIHàH@/�2uóé�3K64äU-�� 7á�!J��:Ú+AH�24N@/�Ý�3KH520/�è52¾3IW�öf*,V �Ká�E!>�~:ZFIH=B�T7/�64ëº64/�Ý�/�H520Q.ë�+.H�20N=/�Ý 37H520/ èU2�3KW-0+AD�M@Q./Pã@+AHRFI64ëG60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=- �Ká�>@>��á �i3KD�ã=+AH@+.H@åy20N=/�-0/¾+²BE/�F7-oFIH=Bº/ èU20/�H=BE+.H@åy20N@/�D 20320N=+.-D�3760/GÝ 37D�M@QA/�èæWX6\FID�/�é�3K64ä�+.-�F�-0+Aå7H@+AçRÝ�FKH72�FKH=BÌ+.H520/�60/C-f24+AH@å�Ý\N=FKQAQ./�H=åK/Ká O�Q�ó20+.DGFs24/�Q.ëK:Zéi/yé�3Kß@Q²B�épFIH52�24N@/�-0/�24/�Ý\N@H=+��5ß@/C->243�N@/�QAMÞß=-PFIßE243KDGFs24+.Ý�FIQ.QAë�BE+²-0Ý�3sTK/�6+.H724/�64/�-u20+.H@å�/�H520+A20+./�-�FIH=B�60/�Q.FI20+.3KH=-0N@+.M=-�20NRFs2>[email protected]�+AH�24N@/éi3760Q²B�á� �� �cZ� ����� k � �mY � MÏ/�24N=FIH@ä ��/�H6HuFKD�+AH�õ`FK-0äsFI6�WX376,N@+²-`Ý 3KQ.Q²FIãÚ3K6\Fs20+.3KHP37H�-u/�T7ó/�6\FIQRM=FIMÚ/�6\-Á20N=FI2iã@ß@+.Q²B)3KH�24N@+²-Áé�3K64äZ:7FIHRB�WX3K6iN@+.-iN@/�QAM�ã@ß@+.Q.BE+.H@å�20N@/$-u3KW°2fé�FK60/o37HéoN@+²Ý\Næ3Kß=6�/ èEMÚ/�64+AD�/�H72\->é�/�64/�MÚ/�60WX3K64Dy/CB�á MÞ/yFIQ²-u3�24N=FIH@ä�L¾6�áZV%/ 24/�6 �UDGFIQ.QÃFIHRB�7/�FIH=H@/yÜ>N@/�/yWX643KD#24N@/ �524FKHEWX3K6\B4O�H@+.TK/�6\-0+�2fëæï�/CBE+²Ý�FIQ �i/�H724/�6$WX3K6M=603sTU+²BE+AH=åºß=-éo+A20N�20N@/�õ �ñB@Fs2\F�FIH=B�éo+A20N�20N@/�+A6o/�èEMR/�6u24+.-0/3KH�20N@+²-p243KM@+²ÝI:@FKH=B�OP/�H=BE6\Fyï�3U3K64/FIHRB �iN@64+.- M�N@+A20/�3IW�S>Q.M@N=Fs24/�Ý\N0�i3K64MR3764FI20+.3KH�WX3K6$M@643sTU+.BE+.H@å)ßR-¾éo+A20NÞ20N=/5�i37D�óM=FKH5ë�B@FI24F7-u/�2�áZõpN@/�é�3K64ä�3KWÁ*�+²-u/�1$/ 2435376�:ÚL¾FKM@N@H@/�OP3KQ.Q./�6¾FKH=BæS�T5+%V�WX/�YÚ/�6¾épFK-WXß@H=B@/�ByãUë@3$<�Ü�Ý 3KH52464F7Ý92�< Y�Y�A�A� ó � !Có��Áó�"����BUiß=H=BE/�6�L>S¾Ü>V�SQU -C��ViO �àM@643KåK6\FIDFIHRBGâÁâÁ*ÃL�M@643Kå764FKD�:sãUë53$<�Ü'åK6\FIH52Á< A�A�A�+UKó � Ysó) ó AS!��"@:�FKH=Byã5ë�20N=/>åK/�H@/�6437-0+�2fë

Page 28: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

��� � e4df_s_�g9t��7gfkle9w7a�q�mRt��o_C�l�le4g�q�mUw » v.e4Î@e4g

3IWR20N@/;�UQ.37FKHy?=3Kß@HRB@Fs24+A37H�FIHRB�3KW=20N=/pV%3sé�/�Q.Q7WX3Kß@H=B=Fs20+.3KH,áI<>+.6�?@64+A/CBEDGFIHyé�F7-Ã-0ß@MEóMÚ3K6020/�Bº20N=6037ß@åKNº20N@/PåK/�H@/�6437-0+A2fëy3KW�20N=/Pïæ+.Ý\N=FK/�Q �EF7Ý\N@/�6oõÃ60ß=-u2oFIH=Bº20N@/R�UN=/�64D�FKH�U/�H@+A376>*�/CÝ920ß=60/C-uN@+.M�á

Ð���C¿l�Ï��¿ ��¿�(`e � g9tI��¿ �>¿CÊíkl�l{r_Cm=t;Ê'¿ » ¿ � kl�l�°ts�¾¿sh7q���q�a_CmRt � ¿ �P¿IhKj � _s_��lm5klÍEtIh@¿ ¼ q�m5eCtCq�m5w

» ¿ ��¿�hKa�q��l�X¿G^`_Cab5q�guq�dfklz;e��e\m5_�aklj\{¾_�v (�^ � z�q�j4j\klm5e\{��s}�� � _C�le��Ce\m7_Caen����aklj4gf_;q grguq\}s¿�� ´4®Æµ0¶U´0µ tE �¡����l� �� ���5� �� ��Kt,�9���C�I¿�C¿   � ¿ (Ãgfe\e\{reCt�n¾¿Ú�ie\j0ÍCe4gfa�q�m=tZq�mUw�^i¿ �>q�w7kleC¿)��ab5k|gfklj9q��%q�m5q��|}K{rkl{$_�v�bKgfe9w7klj4dfklz;e�q��l��C_�gfk|d � a{¾v._�gj4_C�l��q��E_�guq dfklz;e�ÄU�|dfe4gfklm5�K¿���m ©%ªr«9´uµfµr¸�®²¶4L�±G«��³ �5µ��Ú«��Iª0³�µfµ0¶7³ ���Á¶7¶��7­C¯� «�¶�9µ0ªfµ0¶U´0µº«�¶��=¶E´uµ0ªu³Æ­�®²¶5³�� t�b5q��Ce4{��C��I�C It���qCw7kl{r_�mRt,Êí�0tÁ�9���C¡K¿��y_�gf�Cq�m �>q�c7v.�a�q�m=¿

�C¿ �ín$¿R��¿Ú^ � kljuÍ;e4gfklm5�K¿ � e9q gfm5klm5��(%q\}se\{rk�q�m�m5e4d��%_�gfÍK{�k�{�� » �Æj\_�ab5�le4dfeC¿p�~mºn$¿��Zkl{ � e4gq�m5wp�¾¿ � � ¿ � e\m ��t9e9w7k|df_�gf{\t�� µr­�ªu¶5®²¶4L�uªr«�·���­�³Æ­! "�Áª0³°® #ô4®X­C¯GOu¶7³�µ4¯²¯ ®�Lsµ0¶E´uµ%­�¶U¸ � ³Æ­�³°®²±f³°®X´4±$ t5b5q��Ce4{>�9 I�%�U�9���K¿RhIb7gfklm5��e4g'&Ãe4gf��q��7t=�9�C� � ¿�C¿ � � ¿N�`¿Ú^`_s_CbEe4g9¿ �%� ePj4_Cab5cKduq�dfkl_Cm5q���j\_�ab5�le4ÅKk|d~}G_�v%bKgf_C�Uq��5kl�lkl{�dfk�jklmKv²e4gfe\m7j\ePc7{rk�m7�(%q\}se\{rk�q�m��Ee\�lkle4v�m5e4d��%_�gfÍK{\¿ �Áªu³°® #`´4®°­C¯ Ou¶7³�µ4¯²¯ ®�Lsµ0¶U´0µ t5�s !� ���C�(�s�;�C�It��9���C�I¿�C¿ � � ¿ �`¿�^`_s_CbEe4g)q�mUwí��¿%�ie4gf{rÍ;_ zIkldf{\¿ � (`q9};e\{rk�q�m�ae4d � _IwÌv²_�g�d � eGklmUwKc5j4dfkl_�mí_�vb7gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj>m5e0d~�%_�gfÍI{�vAgf_Caòw7q�duqK¿*) ­C´%�I®²¶@µ � µr­�ªu¶5®²¶4L tE�+� ���C��s��� � t��9���; s¿�C¿ � � ¿,^`c7{r{re\m5{\¿ � _��C�lklm5e9q ga_Iw7e4��{>v²_�g$Ä7gf{�dr��_�guw7e4g¾b7gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj�gfe9q�{r_�m5klm5�K¿���m ©�ª�«NM´uµfµf¸�®²¶KL�±º«�y³ �7µ,�î 0³�µfµ0¶7³ �-�Á¶7¶��7­C¯ � «�¶(9µ0ªrµ0¶E´uµ�«�¶.�=¶E´uµ0ªu³Æ­�®²¶5³�� t�b5q��Ce4{º�9  � �5�9���KthIdf_sjuÍ � _���a�t5hs�%e9wKe\mRt@�9���C�I¿=�y_�gf�Cq�m<�>q�cKv²a�q�mR¿

�C¿ � �¾¿N�7gfkle9wKa�q�m=¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7�y�Ee\�lkle4v�m7e4d~�`_�gfÍI{oklm�d � ePb7gfe\{re4m5j\eP_�v%akl{r{rklm5��zCq���c7e\{>q�m5w� k�w7w7e\m�z�q�gfk�q��7��e4{\¿��~m ©�ª�«9´uµuµr¸�®.¶KL�±>«��³ �7µ/�Ú«��Kªu³�µfµ0¶5³ �JOu¶5³�µ0ªu¶E­�³°®X«�¶E­C¯ � «�¶(\µ0ªfµ0¶E´uµ�«�¶) ­;´%�s®²¶@µ � µr­�ª0¶7®²¶KL t5bUq��Ce\{o�  ��(�5�9�C�It0�pq�{ � zIkl�l�leCt � ��tR�\�C� � ¿=�y_�gf�;q�m<�>q�c7v.a�q�mR¿

�C¿ ¡1�¾¿��Kgfk�e\w7a�q�m=t � ¿ � e0df_s_�g9tRn$¿ �o_C�l�le4g9tRq�m5w��>¿ » v.e4Î@e4g9¿ � e9q gfm5klm5��b7gf_��Uq��7kl��kl{�dfklj$gfe4���q�dfkl_Cm5q��=a_Iw7e\�l{\¿Ú�~m ©�ª�«9´uµuµr¸�®.¶KL�±�«�i³ �7µ � ®32�³�µfµ0¶5³ � Ou¶7³�µ0ª0¶U­�³°®X«�¶U­C¯54I«�®²¶5³ � «�¶�9µ0ªfµ0¶U´0µ«�¶6�Áª0³°® #ô4®X­C¯ Ou¶7³�µ4¯²¯ ®�Lsµ0¶E´uµ t@b5q��Ce4{P�9�C����5�9�C� � t�hIdf_sjuÍ � _C�la�t@hs�%e9wKe\mRt��\�C���K¿Ú�y_�gf�Cq�m�>q�cKv²a�q�mR¿

�C¿ � � ¿ � e4df_s_�g9t;n$¿E�o_����le4g9tsq�mUw7��¿E�Kgfk�e\w7a�q�m=¿ �7gf_�a�k�m7{�duq�m7j\e\{Ãdf_oj4�Aq�{r{re\{%klmPbKgf_C�Uq��5kl�lkl{��dfklj�gfe\��q�dfkl_Cm5q��@a_Iw7e\�l{\¿E��m ©�ª�«9´uµuµr¸�®.¶KL�±o«8Á³ �5µ.O � ),� M:9<;";";>=y«�ª I�±?�K«A@º«�¶B�Á³°³°ªu®X¬C�I³�µ2M$7­C¯ �5µ¾­�¶U¸ H µ4¯l­�³°®X«�¶E­C¯ � µr­�ªu¶5®²¶4L! � ªr«�±u±f®²¶4L�³ �5µ�Di«��I¶E¸;­�ª0®Æµ0± t5bUq���e\{i C���I���Kt= ����C�I¿

�C¿l�\� � ¿ � e0df_s_�g9t�n$¿ �o_����le4g9t (i¿ � q�{rÍ�q�g9t`q�mUw��¾¿ �7gfkle9w7a�q�mR¿ � e9q�gfm7klm5��b7gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfkljgfe\��q�dfkl_�mUq��Ea_IwKe\�l{Ã��k|d � {�drgfc5j0dfc7guq��5c5m5j4e4grduq�klmsd~}s¿E��m ©�ª�«9´uµuµr¸�®.¶KL�±o«8Á³ �5µE�'�/� O9MF9+;";";=y«�ª I�±��7«%@�«�¶ � µf­�ª0¶7®²¶KL � ³Æ­�³°®²±f³°®X´f­C¯ ) «9¸sµ4¯ ±'0ª�«�· H µ4¯l­�³°®X«�¶E­C¯G�>­�³Æ­ t�b5q��Ce4{y�9�(�K ��I¿���i�i� » gfe4{r{\t@ ����C�I¿�C¿l���Þn¾¿ ��e\juÍ;e4gfa�q�mR¿���dfc7df_�gfk�q��s_Cm>�le9q�gfm7k�m7�Á��k|d � (%q\}se\{rk�q�m�m5e0d~�%_�gfÍI{\¿;�~m¾��¿ �u¿ � _�guw7q�m=te9wKkldf_�g9tH� µf­�ª0¶7®²¶KL®²¶ A ª�­A@��I®X´f­C¯ ) «9¸sµ4¯ ± t7bUq���e\{Á�C�I�I���C���7¿E�y� � » gfe\{r{\t@^%q�a$�KgfkAwK�CeCt����t=�9���C¡I¿

�C¿l�9  � ¿`��_�v²a�q�m7mRt � ¿ » c �4k�j � qIt�q�mUwí��¿ � _�guw7q�mR¿ � e\q�gfm5klm7��v.gf_Ca wI}IqCwKk�j)w7q�duqI¿���m�Á¸�J�­�¶E´uµ0±P®²¶6K�µA�Iª�­C¯ Ou¶(\«�ªu·­�³°®X«�¶º©%ªr«9´uµ0±f±f®²¶KL � ��±u³�µ0·¾±�L"L tRb5q���e\{o� � � �s� �  st,^%q�aP��7gfk�wK�CeCtU����t=�9���C¡K¿E�y� � » gfe4{r{\¿�C¿l�\�W�P¿9�oe4gf{�dfklm5�7t � ¿�wKe ¼ q�e9wKd9tZq�mUwæhE¿9�pguq�ae4g9¿G�~msdfe4gfbKgfe4dfklm5� (%q\}se4{rkAq�mæ��_��Cklj�b7gf_����guq�a{\¿É��m ©�ª�«9´0µfµr¸�®²¶4L�±�«�G³ �5µ6�'�/� O9MF9+;";";M=y«�ª I�±��7«A@ «�¶ � µr­�ªu¶5®²¶4L � ³Æ­�³°®²±f³°®X´f­C¯) «9¸sµ4¯ ±N0ªr«�· H µ4¯l­�³°®X«�¶E­C¯H��­�³Æ­ t5bUq��Ce\{i ��(�I�C�I¿@�i���i� » gfe\{r{\t@ ��C�C�I¿�C¿l�4��n¾¿S�o_����le4g�q�m5wy�>¿ » v²e0Î@e4g9¿ � e9q�gfm7klm5�PbKgf_C�Uq��5kl�lk|dfk�e4{Áv._�gim5_Ckl{�}�Ä5gf{�dr�Æ_�guw7e4g�gfc5�le\{\¿,��m©%ªr«9´uµfµf¸�®²¶KL�±¾«�o³ �5µ � ®32�³�µfµ0¶5³ � Ou¶7³�µ0ª0¶U­�³°®X«�¶U­C¯N4I«�®²¶7³ � «�¶�9µ0ªfµ0¶U´0µP«�¶O�Áªu³°® #ô4®X­C¯ Ou¶7³�µ4¯�M¯ ®�Lsµ0¶U´0µ t7bUq��Ce\{>�9�I� � �U�9�C I��t0�pq���_9}IqKt � q�b5q�mRt=�9��� � ¿=�y_�gf�Cq�m<�>q�cKv²a�q�mR¿

Page 29: Stanford Artificial Intelligence Laboratorykoller/Papers/Getoor+al:01.pdf · 2009. 10. 25. · e4df_s_ g9t 7gfkle9w7a q mRt o_C l le4g q mUw v.e4Î@e4g V 643KãRFIã@+.QA+²-u20+²Ýiå764FKM@N@+²Ý

�C¿ � e9q�gfm7k�m7� » gf_��Uq��5kl�lk�{�dfklj ¼ e\��q�dfkl_Cm5q����y_IwKe\�l{ �;��C¿l�9�ín¾¿N�o_��l��e0g�q�mUwº��¿ » v²e4Î@e0g9¿ » gf_C�5q��5kl�lkl{�dfklj�vAguq�ae4�Æ�5q�{re9w){�}K{�dfe\a{\¿��~m ©�ª�«9´0µfµr¸�®²¶4L�±

«�¾³ �7µ �î 0³�µfµ0¶5³ �OKo­�³°®X«�¶U­C¯ � «�¶(9µ0ªrµ0¶E´uµ«�¶ �Áªu³°® #`´4®°­C¯ Ou¶5³�µ4¯²¯ ®�Lsµ0¶E´uµ t=bUq���e\{>��¡C��I��¡ � t��qCwKkl{r_CmRt7Êí�0t=�9���C¡I¿E���i�i� » gfe4{r{\¿�C¿l� � hE¿ � ¿ � q�cKgfkld �4e\mR¿ �%� e)�`� q��l��_�gfk|d � a#v²_�g���guq�b � klj9q��pq�{r{r_sj4kAq dfkl_Cm�a_Iw7e\�l{��k|d �akl{r{rklm5�w7q�duqK¿ � «�·I@ �I³Æ­�³°®X«�¶E­C¯ � ³Æ­�³°®²±f³°®X´4±�­�¶U¸7�>­�³Æ­ �Á¶E­C¯ ��±f®²± tÚ�9�<�l�9�K�%�K ��K�Ct��\�C�;�s¿�C¿l� � ��¿ � q9zsguq �j)q�m5wÏhE¿,n ��\e4gf_�{rÍKk°¿ Ou¶U¸��7´4³°® J�µ � « L�®X´�©�ª�« L�ªr­�·¾·$®²¶4L! ��@µr´%�I¶5®��C�5µ0±)­�¶E¸� @"@E¯ ®X´f­�³°®X«�¶5± ¿Ã�,�l�lkl{i�i_�gr�%_s_Iw@tÚ�\�C���K¿

�C¿l�\¡ hE¿ �¾¿U�yc5�C���le4df_Cm=¿%hsdf_sj � q�{�dfkljo�l_C��k�j>bKgf_C��guq�a{\¿,�~m � ¿7w7e ¼ q�e9wId9t7e\w7k|df_�g9t �Á¸�J�­�¶E´uµ0±®²¶ Ou¶U¸��7´4³°® J�µ � « L�®°´p©%ªr« L�ªr­�·$·$®.¶KL t7bUq���e\{� C����K  � �7¿U���oh » gfe\{r{\tU�ia{�dfe4guw7q�a�tU�\�C� � ¿�C¿l�\� hE¿ �¾¿,�yc7�C�C�le4df_�mR¿ � e9q gfm5klm5�){�df_sj � q�{�dfk�j��l_C��k�j�b7gf_���guq�a{\¿º��m ©�ª�«9´0µfµr¸�®²¶4L�±�«8�³ �5µ�'�/� O9M:9<;";";M=y«�ª I�±?�K«A@ «�¶ � µf­�ª0¶7®²¶KL � ³Æ­�³°®²±f³°®X´f­C¯ ) «9¸sµ4¯ ± 0ªr«�· H µ4¯l­�³°®X«�¶U­C¯/��­�³Æ­ tbUq��Ce\{Á� � �s�K�C¿@�i���Á� » gfe\{r{\t@ ��C���K¿�C¿  �� � ¿<����_¾q�mUw » ¿s�pq�w5w7q9��}s¿=�Ám5{��`e4gfklm5��Èsc5e4gfkle\{,v.gf_Cañj\_Cmsdfe4ÅIdr�Æ{re\m7{rkldfklz;e�bKgf_C�Uq��5kl�lkl{��dfkljoÍIm5_9���le9w7��eo�Uq�{re4{\¿ � �7µf«�ªfµ0³°®X´f­C¯ � «�·I@ �I³�µ0ª � ´4®Æµ0¶U´uµ tÚ� � � �l�\� � ��� ��� tÚ�\�C� � ¿�C¿  s� � ¿ » e9q�gf�°¿ ©%ªr«;¬f­;¬4®²¯ ®²±f³°®X´ H µr­�±0«�¶7®²¶KLy®²¶ Ou¶5³�µ4¯²¯ ®�Lsµ0¶5³ � ��±f³�µ0·$± ¿��y_�gf�;q�m��>q�cKv²a�q�m7mRth7q�m �7guq�m5j\kl{rj\_KtÚ�\�C¡C¡I¿

�C¿  � ��>¿ » v.e4Î@e4g9¿ ©%ªr«C¬u­C¬4®°¯ ®²±f³°®X´ H µr­�±0«�¶5®.¶KL 4«�ª � «�·I@U¯�µ?2 � ��±f³�µ0·$± ¿ » � nÏd � e\{rkl{\t;hIduq�m7v²_�guwx�m7klz;e4gf{rk|d~}st7 ��C�C�I¿

�C¿  ���n¾¿ » _s_���e�¿ » gf_��Uq��7kl��kl{�dfkljº��_�gfmÞq��@wKc5j4dfkl_�míq�m5w (%q\}se\{rk�q�màm5e4d��%_�gfÍK{\¿ �Áª0³°® #ô4®X­C¯Ou¶5³�µ4¯.¯ ®�Lsµ0¶E´uµ t � ��� ¡I�A�U�9 ��It,�\�C���K¿�C¿   � » ¿RhIb5k|grdfe\{\tR^i¿ � �|}7a_�c7g9t@q�mUw ¼ ¿@hKj � e\klm5e4{\¿ � ­��I±4­�³°®X«�¶��é%ªfµr¸�®°´4³°®X«�¶æ­�¶U¸ � µr­�ª�´%� ¿� e4j4dfc7gfe��i_�dfe\{�klm)hsduq�dfkl{�dfklj\{\¿@hIb7gfklm5��e4gr�:&Ãe4gf��q��7t��$t@�\�C�C�I¿

�C¿  �����¿ » ¿`Ê�e\�l�la�q�mRt � ¿ hE¿ (Ãgfe\e4{reCt�q�mUw ¼ ¿ » ¿ � _��AwKa�q�m=¿��7gf_Ca ÍIm7_ ���le9wK�CeG�5q�{re\{�df_w7e4j\kl{rk�_�m�a_Iw7e4��{\¿ � �5µ��>¶E«� �¯�µf¸ Lsµ��%¶KL�®²¶Eµuµ0ªu®²¶4L H µAJ9®Æµ� t � ¹ �9½A� �;�(�I���It��9�C�C I¿�C¿   � ��¿5Êíkl��{r_�mRt � ¿ n¾¿Unpe ¼ kl{rk°tU�¾¿ ��¿��pgfkl{�dfe\m5{re4mRt » ¿5�~a$�E_IwKe\mRt5hE¿ ¼ q�m7eCt » ¿ �¾¿ (Ãgf_9��m=tq�m5w � ¿ �P¿@hKj � _s_C�lm7k�ÍE¿p��ÅKb5�l_�gfk�m7�ywIgfc5����klm5w7c5j4e9w�q��|dfe4guq dfkl_Cm5{oklm)�Ce4m5e$e0Å7bKgfe\{r{rkl_Cm)klm��}Kj\_C�5q�j4dfe0gfk�c7a dfc7�Ee4gfj\c7��_�{rkl{%�s}Paklj4gf_;q grguq\} � }7�Kgfk�w7k��9q�dfkl_�mR¿=�~m ©%ªr«9´uµfµr¸�®²¶KL�±o«�Á³ �5µKo­�³°®X«�¶U­C¯0��´u­C¸sµ0· ��«� � ´4®Æµ0¶E´uµ0± t= ����C�I¿`��myb7gfe4{r{\¿