Upload
hoangdung
View
218
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 1
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 2
THE AUTHOR'S FOREWORD.
When asked by the Motueka Methodist Trustees to write a brochure to commemorate
their 110th Anniversary, I consented for several reasons:
(1) Being both a native of Motueka and one of its past ministers, I recognised the
reasonableness of the request.
(2) I am conscious of no "thorn in the flesh" militating against my penmanship
comparable to that which militates against my effective speaking.
(3) I wanted to help my friend the Rev. Hubert Brown, who as District Chairman
in addition to being the Motueka minister, had his hands more than full.
(4) I have still many good friends among Motueka Methodists, from whom I
have never received anything but kind treatment.
(5) In sending forth this brochure, I am hoping to serve Christ's Kingdom no less
than His Church.
In writing the brochure I hereby acknowledge with gratitude my indebtedness to the
following, whom I name here in alphabetical order without comment. They reside at
Motueka unless otherwise stated:- Mr and Mrs G. Allcott, Mrs Bruce and Miss Shirley
Bruce (all of Stoke), the Rev. H. G. Brown, the Rev. H. L. Fiebig, B.A.
(Christchurch), Mr Hollis Hill (Brightwater), Mrs M. Hulbert, Miss F. S. Jordan, the
Rev. R. P. and Mrs Keall (Lower Hutt), the Rev. J. D. McArthur (Blenheim), Mr M.
H. McGlashen (Mayor of Richmond), Miss Doris Parker, Mr and Mrs W. Quayle, the
Rev. C. M. Roberts (New Plymouth), Mr Warren Stevens, Mrs J. Thorne (nee
Alexander, Palmerston N.), and Mr and Mrs E. S. Wratt.
Although baptized, brought up, and confirmed in the Church of England, I knew as a
boy some of the former Methodist pastors in Motueka, particularly those with whose
sons I attended school.
C. B. JORDAN.
Stoke, January 1, 1952.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 3
The Present Church (opened 1921)
YESTERDAYS OF MOTUEKA METHODISM
CHAPTER I
THE GENESIS OF METHODISM
We mean by this the beginning of Methodism in Motueka. The late Rev. William
Morley, D.D. ("History of Methodism in New Zealand," Page 382) writes: "Motueka
circuit has a history which goes back to the early Mission period." The great
missionary name connected with both Marlborough and Nelson Methodism is that of
the Rev. Samuel Ironside, who is second to none among N.Z. pioneer missionaries.
His headquarters were at Cloudy Bay.
The date of Mr Ironside's first visit to Motueka is unknown but on May 8, 1842 he
baptised ten Maoris there. This was before his first visit to Nelson, which occurred in
June, 1842. His voyage to Motueka and Nelson was in a whale boat, manned by a
Maori crew. Mr Ironside had native teachers who travelled about, and it is likely
enough that they had previously been to Motueka, and having instructed these Maori
catechumens, had prepared them for baptism. Mr Ironside made another visit to
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 4
Motueka on September 25, 1842, when he baptised 46 Maoris and married ten
couples. On January 15, 1843 he baptised six individuals and married two couples.
Rev Samuel Ironsides
A NOTED MAORI LADY
Doubtless some pakeha residents of Motueka will still remember Mrs Rei, who
slipped away into paradise some time during the author's boyhood. Mrs Rei attended
with almost unfailing regularity at St. Thomas's church on Sunday mornings, her
home being only one mile away. Her own native Anglican church was close by her
home But what so greatly interests us as Methodists is the gift of a Prayer Book to Mrs
Rei in 1842 by the Rev. Samuel Ironside, apparently either on his first or second visit
to Motueka.
This beautiful little incident so aptly indicates the type of man Mr Ironside was. He
was always more zealous to secure converts to Christianity than converts to
Methodism in particular.
THE REV. JOHN ALDRED
The Rev. John Aldred came to Nelson as resident minister early in 1843, and paid
regular visits to Motueka. According to Dr Morley, on his first visit he paid a settler
£1 to act as guide, but would have lost his way on his return journey but for the
sagacity of his horse and dog. Twenty Maoris were baptised into the Christian faith on
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 5
that occasion. One of these twenty was a Maori, well known in after years, named I
Haka. This last bit of information, also that concerning Mr Ironside's gift to Mrs Rei,
the author learned from Mr Warren Stevens (Warena Tiwini), an old schoolfellow.
REMOVAL TO WELLINGTON
After the Wairau tragedy of June 17, 1843, Mr Ironside removed to Wellington and
appointed a catechist, Mr William Jenkins, to overlook the Maori work. Later on Mr
Jenkins was appointed, under Mr Aldred, resident catechist at Motueka. Mr Ironside
records that the natives, prior to 1843, had built a church at Motueka.
CHAPEL WINDOWS
Among Mr Aldred's papers, Dr Morley tells us, was an account marked "Windows for
Moutawaka Chapel, £5/2/-." I understand from my friend, Mr Stevens, that the correct
spelling is "Motuweka," but the point is that it furnishes fresh evidence that steps were
taken at an early date to build a chapel in Motueka. This was in due course finished,
but gales seem to have damaged the structure, and when the Maoris removed from the
pah, they took away the chapel and paid in potatoes the amount still owing on it. The
pah covered approximately the area where there lived up to a comparatively short time
ago the Gray family, at the corner of two roads known today as Pah and Gray Streets.
The Pah was called Te Taone (The Town).
PORT UNDERWOOD
During the year 1910, when the author himself was stationed in Motueka, he was
given an item of information about another old chapel, the successor of the first one to
which reference was made above. This was erected in 1849. At all events, that is the
date entered (once only) in an old Circuit Schedule Book. In 1910 I was verbally
informed by my own mother that this same 1849 church was brought over from Port
Underwood to Motueka.
My informant had been in intimate touch with Motueka Methodists for 40 years
before 1910. Recently I asked my old schoolmate, Warena Tiwini, what he thought
about that tradition. He replied that he could not say for sure, but what he knew was
quite consistent with the above supposition. Many early Motueka Maoris, he told me,
came thither from Port Underwood, including his own father, Rupine Tiwini, whom
we children knew as "Mr Reuben." The suggestion must be that when those natives
came from Port Underwood to Motueka, they brought the old Port Underwood chapel
with them. There must surely be some truth about the Port Underwood tradition; yet
the chapel at Port Underwood was 66 feet by 36 feet, much larger than the old chapel
the author remembers as still standing in his early boyhood days. However, there had
been very close to the old Motueka chapel a schoolroom wherein tea meetings were
often held, and in early times it was almost certainly used not only as a Sunday school,
but .as a Wesleyan day school. No living person can now tell us the exact size of it,
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 6
but by all accounts it was a fairly large building. My friend, Mr Hollis Hill, an historic
research student with respect to churches, agrees with the author's theory that the old
chapel at Port Underwood must have been brought over to Motueka and re-erected
there as a schoolroom. There is no space here for details of the evidence available to
support this conclusion, but it is the only possible conclusion that fits the historic facts
as I have been able to gather them.
May we venture a further suggestion concerning this schoolroom? When Mr Ironside
moved from his Cloudy Bay station to Wellington after the Wairau tragedy in 1843,
he would not immediately think of getting the Port Underwood chapel removed; but
since from that date his mission work in that district was practically at an end, sooner
or later he and the Methodist authorities of those days would need to consider what
should be done with the above-named chapel. He would have learned by 1849 that a
great work among the natives was being done in Motueka. What thought, then, would
be more natural to Mr Ironside, who early in the same year had come to Nelson as its
circuit minister, than that of getting the same chapel removed to Motueka? It could
well have been removed by 1849, and indeed 1849 would be the most likely year for
such an event.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 7
CHAPTER II PRIOR TO THE SEVENTIES
During the forties the Sunday services at Motueka were conducted by lay preachers
from Nelson. One of these for almost certain would be Mr Edward Green, a fervent
herald of the mighty evangel, who had conducted in the open air the first Methodist
service in Nelson itself. Mr W. Andrews, grandfather of the ex-mayor of Christchurch,
moved from Nelson to Motueka at an early date. Mr John Riley followed suit after a
year or two, and these good men, or others likeminded, must have conducted not only
services on Sundays, but class meetings during the week; for attendance at class was
in those days a condition of membership.
According to Dr Morley, the natives residing in Motueka in the late forties were
numerous, and they remained faithful to Methodism. Mr W. Jenkins was appointed
resident catechist among them, and he remained there for two years. "About the same
time (1848) the present grants of land for church, mission house, and cemetery
purposes were made, and the old weather-board church and a small mission house
were erected in the following year. From a variety of causes the number of natives has
since greatly declined."
Dr Morley evidently knew nothing of the local tradition to the effect that the church or
some other building was removed to Motueka from Port Underwood. Despite the large
number of natives there in 1848-9, the question how the three buildings—church,
mission house, and schoolroom—all came to be erected in the one year still remains,
to say the least, a problem; but if we suppose that the schoolroom came originally
from Port Underwood, our problem is partly solved.
THE OLD CHAPEL 1849
It is said that in 1871 (when the author's father for a short period worshipped there on
Sunday evenings), the worshippers in the chapel on the old cemetery site could "see
the stars through the roof." It can easily be understood that under such circumstances
the Motueka Methodists lost no time in attending to the erection of a new building. A
site for this was ultimately found in High Street, being leased from the Trustees of
Native Land. It was thus that Motueka Methodists now ceased in their evening
worship to "see stars."
In my early childhood I well remember the old chapel that encouraged star-gazers.
The old cemetery in which it stood contained the tombs of both Maoris and pioneer
Europeans. It was doubtless this proximity of tomb-stones that assisted the child mind
to imagine the rising out of their graves of sleeping saints and their appearance to
some, if not to "many." An older sister of the author's declares that in her childhood
days the little ones declared the place was "haunted." However, in the late seventies
the same old chapel was still used as an afternoon Sunday school; so evidently the
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 8
personal presence of the Christian teachers, together with their example and precept,
encouraged the Methodist children of those days to see neither stars nor ghosts!
THE OLD MISSION HOUSE, 1849
The author's earliest recollections of the old mission house (in the middle eighties)
were of its being tenanted by a Mr Weston and his daughter, Miss Jane Western, who
afterwards married Mr Thomas Starnes and became the mother of a considerable
family, which included the Rev. John Starnes, B.A., a Presbyterian minister, also
Mesdames Durrant, L. Cowin and E. S. Wratt (all three of Motueka). The Wratts, by
the way, were a Methodist family, Mr Edgar Wratt's late grand-father and great-
grandfather being both in their respective generations superintendents of the
Methodist Sunday School at Spring Grove.
According to the late Mrs T. Starnes, her foster parents, Mr and Mrs Weston, went to
live in the Wesleyan mission house (which stood on the site of the old parsonage)
when she was eight or nine years old. To build the first part of that two-storied house,
timber had been brought out from England. It was strongly built, and wrought iron
nails were used. Two lean-tos of N.Z. timber were afterwards added, but these were
attacked by the borer, which did not touch the English wood in the first part of the
building. Containing as it did nine rooms, it was too large for the ministers to occupy,
most of them being single men. The rent paid for the house and property would suffice
either to rent a smaller house for the minister or else to pay his board in some private
home.
It was an understood thing that whenever tea-meetings were held (and in early times
they were very popular), the church people were to have the use of the mission house
kitchen and boiler, whoever might be the occupants of the house. Mrs Starnes was
married in the mission house, or from it, and lived there for about a year afterwards.
In 1884 the place was condemned and pulled down, but so well was it built that great
difficulty was experienced in getting it demolished. That was during the ministry of
Mr Benjamin Thomas (the second of a succession of four able home missionaries)
who made a personal canvass for funds for a new mission house. This was duly
erected in 1885 at a cost of £262, a debt of only £110 remaining to our Church
Building and Loan Fund.
THE OLD SCHOOL, 1849
The schoolroom in the same locality had entirely disappeared before the author was
born; but by all accounts it was a building of consider-able dimensions and was well
able to accommodate the considerable gatherings of people that assembled there on
occasions of tea-meetings and such-like functions. The view to which the author has
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 9
been driven is that this schoolroom was the former chapel at Port Underwood removed
and re-erected.
MR ANDREWS GIVEN OFFICIAL STATUS
The visits of the superintendent minister at Nelson were, as we can well understand,
few and far between; hence in 1857 "Mr Andrews became a recognised missionary, or
hired local preacher." He was paid no regular stipend, but so greatly was he respected
by people of all denominations that he was, in a semi-jocular strain, known as
"Bishop" Andrews. To the utmost degree of his strength he sought to discharge all the
duties of a regular minister, preaching at Motueka and neighbouring settlements,
leading classes, visiting the sick, burying the dead, and attending faithfully to the
spiritual needs of the people during many years. To-day he has many descendants in
Ashburton, Christchurch, the Waimea district and elsewhere, all of whom are proud to
claim him as their progenitor.
Information concerning this comparatively early period of Motueka's history is
somewhat scanty, and what there is of it is rather vague. Dr Morley says that Mr
Samuel Stone was appointed home missionary at Motueka (as part of the Nelson
circuit) in 1866, but a church committee meeting on June 28 of that year was chaired
by a Mr Franklin, although Messrs Andrews and Stone were both present. Evidently
these two good men last mentioned between them catered ably for the spiritual needs
of Motueka Methodists, and a minute dated July 7, 1866, stated that Mr Andrews was
to retain occupancy of the mission house until the same should be required for the
family of a minister or hired local preacher.
Another minute of the same Trustee meeting records a recommendation that the
superintendent minister (the Rev. William Kirk, residing at Nelson) should give all
preaching appointments to Messrs Andrews and Stone. A third resolution of the same
meeting, somewhat contradictory, recommends that Mr Andrews take two services in
four Sundays and that Messrs Mears and Avery (non-resident "locals") take one
Sunday's services each in the quarter. The pew rents were to be devoted to the
building of a new chapel, and one offering per quarter was to be made for lighting and
cleaning.
During the same period a prayer meeting was held every Monday evening, and after
that Mr Andrews held his class session. In addition there was a prayer and class
meeting held at Mr Harding's house on one week evening and at Mr Staples's on
another. Whether all these meetings were held every week there is insufficient
evidence to show, but it is clear that honest efforts were made at that early period to
maintain healthy and robust spiritual life in the Motueka settlement itself, if not in the
settlements round about.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 10
CHAPTER III THE CHURCH OF THE SEVENTIES
On August 28, 1872, a preliminary meeting of Trustees and friends gathered at the old
chapel in Pah Street to consider what steps were necessary for the erection of a new
building for worship. Mr S. Stone (who was evidently in charge at that time) presided,
and there were also present Messrs J. Alexander, Davy, John Delany, G. Glover, J.
Gower, Grant, Hall, G. Hawkins, James McGlashen, Parker, Vercoe, and J. Wills.
Messrs Stone and Wills were authorised to negotiate for the loan of £100 at 6 per cent
interest. A large Building Committee was set up consisting of the following:—Messrs
Alexander, Davy, Delany, Douglas, Glover, Grant, Hall, Hawkins, Herrick,
McDonald, McGlashen, Noden, Stone, and Wills. Some of these, we think, were not
Methodists. Mesdames McDonald and Alexander were appointed lady collectors with
the following gentlemen: Messrs Alexander, Glover, Grant, Stone, and Wills. Messrs
Drummond and Foote were to receive orders for the supply of timber, and Mr Vercoe
for the supply of shingles.
It was subsequently resolved (December 3, 1872) that the tender of Messrs Parker
Bros. be accepted. On March 4, 1873, it was decided that £40 be paid to the
contractors for the work done up to that date. On April 8 Mr Glover was authorised to
procure 2,000 shingles, and it was resolved that efforts be made to gather in as far as
possible all amounts promised.
On July 8 (1873) a tender by Mr Flowers for priming and glazing the new chapel
windows according to specification was accepted. A fortnight later it was resolved that
the new chapel be opened for Divine worship on August 24, 1873 by the Rev. Thomas
Buddle (First President of the N.Z. Methodist Conference), and that Mr Buddle be
asked to deliver a lecture on the following evening. Mr Goodall was asked to inspect
the work of the new chapel as soon as the contractors had finished.
NEW LOANS NECESSARY
On August 6, 1873 the thanks of the Committee were tendered to Mr John Staples,
senr., for his kind offer to lend money for building. New lamps were also purchased.
Four days before the opening Mr Stone was requested to interview the Rev. Thomas
Buddle regarding the loan of another £50 upon mortgage or private security. At the
same meeting Mr Stone was appointed collector of seat rents, which were to be
payable at the rate of 2/6 per quarter in advance.
A GIFT AUCTION
Early the next year (January 6, 1874) a tender by Mr Flowers for painting the new
church "with three coats of good paint in a workman-like manner" for £18 was
accepted. Apparently the church had not been painted prior to the date of opening.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 11
Part of the funds to build the new church was to be raised by a gift auction, and on
March 16, 1874 this was postponed until the potato season.
No one versed in the economic history of New Zealand, particularly of the Nelson
district, will be surprised to learn that difficulty was experienced in raising the
necessary funds for the church of 1873. The seventies were part of a period of
economic depression. In spite of this, however, before March 16, 1874, the Trust deed
had been duly executed and forwarded to the Methodist Chairman of the Nelson
district.
TRUST PERSONNEL
The Trustees of the church of 1873 at the time of its erection were Messrs John
Alexander, John Delany, Douglas Senr., George Glover, George Hawkins, and James
Wills. Apparently the Nelson Methodist Trust assisted the Motueka Trust at that time
by free loan. It is a matter for profound thankfulness that the poverty of the Motueka
settlers in those early times did not prevent the building being erected and duly paid
for. If all the truth were known concerning the erection of that church, doubtless there
could be told many a tale of genuine self-sacrifice borne amidst toil and hardship.
CHURCH PAINTING
At the Anniversary tea meeting on November 16, 1874 special efforts seem to have
been made to complete the raising of funds for the church, the total proceeds
amounting to £34/l/8d (a big sum for those days). The church was painted the same
colour as the day school. The Trustees requested Mr McDonald to inspect on their
behalf the work of painting when finished.
LINING THE CHURCH
About four years after erection the 1873 church was lined at the cost of £26, the work
being efficiently done by Mr J. F. Combes, and at about the same time twenty side
seats and two for the end of the church were made by Messrs C. and F. Parker. A
meeting of Trustees on October 29, 1877 decided to hand over to the Quarter Board
the nett proceeds of the Church Anniversary tea, £11/3/10. The Circuit Fund of those
days, like that of more recent times, could always make good use of additional
resources.
MARRIAGES
According to accessible records the last marriage in the old mission chapel was that of
the Rev. W. G. Thomas to Miss Mary Wilkie (of Motueka), the officiating minister
being the Rev. William Cannell, of Richmond. This took place on November 26,
1872. Mr Thomas was thus the first of quite a "goodly fellowship" of young ministers
who found wives in Motueka. In the author's theological student days it was a popular
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 12
joke among the students that if a young single minister went to Motueka he was
"doomed" to a certain (matrimonial) "fate." Among the fortunate ones in this respect
were the Rev. R. P. Keall, who married Miss L. Drummond, the Rev. W. Wills, who
married Miss Ruth Deck, B.A., and the Rev. A. Reader, who married Miss N.
Lancely, whose younger sister, Miss Elsie, found a suitable help mate in Mr G.
Snadden, a former probationary minister. Mr Thomas's marriage in 1872 was,
however, the only ministerial marriage in the old mission church. The first marriage in
the new (1873) church was that of Mr William Alexander to Miss Mary Pinny, which
was solemnised on March 20, 1877.
In the seventies and early eighties marriages were usually solemnised by Motueka
ministers in private homes (this bearing incidental testimony to the comparative
poverty of those times). But there were some exceptions, one of these being the
marriage of Miss Ann Pinny, of Motueka, to Charles Manly Luke, of Wellington
(afterwards the Hon. C. M. Luke, M.L.C., and first Vice-President of the united
Methodist Conference of 1913). This was solemnised on New Year's Day, 1880, in the
1873 church.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 13
CHAPTER IV
FELLOWSHIP AND CHURCH LIFE IN THE SEVENTIES
Nothing can supply the requisite information under this head better than the minute
book of the Leaders' Meeting. It is interesting to discover that a Sunday School
Committee (corresponding to our present-day Local Youth Committee) was found
necessary, and was appointed by, and made responsible to, the Leaders' Meeting
(November 4, 1874). Another fact to be learned from the above minute book is that
the great problem of those days was the non-attendance of Church members at class
meetings. The ultimate result of this non-attendance, we know, was the gradual
lowering of the standard of Membership. Attendance at class meetings became no
longer an essential condition, and society classes in country circuits tended to
disappear. It may be contended that they had served their original purpose and that the
changing times demanded their disappearance; but looking back on those days, it
would seem a great pity that definite meetings to promote real Christian fellowship
could not have been somehow devised, though doubtless of a character slightly
different from Methodism's earliest days.
"New occasions teach new duties;
Time makes ancient good uncouth."
But Methodist experience generally has taught us the vital necessity of Christian
fellowship. John Wesley himself learned experimentally that, if his own spiritual life
was to remain healthy and robust, he must of necessity find people like himself to
whom he could periodically unburden his soul and speak candidly concerning the
things that matter most. Although fellowship among Christians is the very life's blood
of a true church, the secret of obtaining and maintaining it for all our members
remains as much an enigma to-day as it was to our forerunners of 70 and 80 years ago.
CHURCH MEMBERSHIP IN THE SEVENTIES
During the early seventies it would appear that not only did Riwaka and Lower
Moutere form part of the Motueka circuit, but Motupipi, Collingwood, and Clifton as
well. Riwaka returned three members in 1874, Lower Moutere 4, Motupipi 8, and
Collingwood 2. However, in 1878 no statistics of Membership are scheduled except
for Motueka, which returned 33, an increase of 8 on the figure for 1874. The rules of
Membership in those early times were fairly strict, and such a figure takes no account
of "adherents," who for aught we know may have out-numbered the "members" many
times. No ministers' visiting lists covering those early years have so far been
discovered, so we are unable any further to pursue our statistical inquiries, interesting
as that would be.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 14
THE BAPTISMAL REGISTER
Scanning the Baptismal Register covering the period from August, 1873 to December,
1901, we find the names of children with parents answering to the following
surnames:
(1) (Residing at Collingwood) Allcott, Hansen, Jeffries, Lusty, Riley,
Scrimgeour, Shaw, Skilton, and Sauires;
(2) (Residing at Takaka) Bartlett and Fabian.
LEADERS' MEETINGS IN THE SEVENTIES
Let us glance at a Leaders' meeting in the seventies. It is the evening of February 15,
1875 (just before hop-picking). The Rev. W. B. Marten is the chairman, and among
those present are Messrs H. Thomas, James McGlashen, and R. Alexander.
Conversation ensues concerning the society classes, and it is reported that Mr Glover
is no longer able to meet his (grown-up) class regularly on Sunday afternoons. Mr
McGlashen is therefore appointed his assistant to act pro tem in Mr Glover's place.
The Women's Class was then accustomed to meet on Monday evenings, and this was
committed to the leadership of Mrs Marten. A serious and earnest conversation on the
spiritual state of the society and its lack of spiritual life then followed. It was resolved
that the matter be laid, first, before God in earnest prayer, and then before the society
members.
The problems of the seventies were evidently much the same as our own problems to-
day. One of the regrettable features of our present-day Methodism is the tendency to
allow financial considerations to override concerns which are more directly spiritual.
The same tendency existed then.
FINANCIAL MATTERS IN THE SEVENTIES
In 1874 (soon after the erection of a new church), the offerings, class contributions,
and donations at Motueka together amounted to about £2 per Sunday. Services were at
that time being held at Riwaka, the average offering being 9/- or 10/- per Sunday.
Sunday services were also held at Ngatimoti, Long Plain, Takaka, Lower Takaka,
Motupipi, and Collingwood. Transport problems associated with these latter places
must always remain to us, in these days of motor-cars and aeroplanes, a subject of
wonderment. However, we must not forget that in those days small passenger
steamers plied regularly between the old Motueka wharf and the landing places at
Collingwood and Takaka. It is much more likely, however, that one poor over-worked
horse carried the minister to and from every preaching settlement in the district; for if
there were not exactly "giants in those days," there certainly were physically active
and robust young ministers.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 15
During the early seventies the ministerial stipend appears to have been round about
£130 per annum, but it should be remembered that money was then worthy roughly
2½ times its worth to-day. The amount of purchasing power represented by the above
amount was relatively considerable. In 1875 the stipend went up (with an ordained
minister) to £185, but the year closed with a deficiency of £120/17/11.
In those depression years of the last century the circuit financial statements candidly
reveal the fact that the minister often went without his stipulated stipend, also that
amounts due to certain good Mehodist business people in Motueka and Nelson were
left unpaid. As a result of a considerable falling off in financial returns, Motueka has
in 1878 to be content with a home missionary in place of a minister.
But Motueka appears always to have done well under a married home missionary, and
a succession of four able men with that status (Messrs Hosking, Thomas, Young and
Harker) seem to have carried on most creditably. They tackled their job manfully and
battled away heroically with debts and difficulties. All honour to them! Mr Hosking,
(father of the late Rev. J. A. Hosking), for example, went over to Nelson in 1879 and
delivered a lecture whose proceeds assisted the finances of the Motueka circuit. At the
end of a winter quarter (June 30, 1880) the Nelson choir came over and gave a concert
in aid of the Motueka Circuit Fund, the nett proceeds being £15/3/6. This would
suggest that the whole village must have turned out on that occasion. It reveals top the
solidarity of the Methodist connexion in financial affairs, for it has ever been one of
the indissoluble marks of Methodism that the relatively strong help the relatively
weak.
PERSONAL AND OTHER ITEMS BELONGING TO THE
SEVENTIES
The Rev. S. R. Purchon passed away in Motueka in February, 1878, during the
sessions of a Wellington Conference. Judging by the eulogies of his contemporaries, it
could be said of him, as Milton wrote concerning his friend Edward King:—
"Lycidas is dead, dead ere his prime,
Yound Lycidas, and hath not left his peer."
About June 29, 1874, Mr S. Stone left the district, his place as circuit steward being
filled by Mr J. Alexander. Mr W. Andrews passed away at Motueka about August 18,
1873, just a few days prior to the opening of the church of that year. Apparently, like
Moses of old, he was permitted to see the "promised land" without entering into
possession.
Mr J. P. Simon, who came to Motueka with Mr Stone and rendered valuable help in
the circuit as a local preacher, was on October 5, 1874, nominated by the Rev. Thomas
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 16
Buddle as a candidate for the ministry. The Quarterly meeting endorsed the
nomination and recommended him to the District Meeting.
The Rev. W. B. Marten, who had been appointed to Motueka at the Conference of
February, 1874, was invited to stay a second year as a married minister. Soon
afterwards the ladies set to work to raise funds for the furnishing of the parsonage. On
December 30 the same year Messrs J. Alexander and H. Thomas were elected circuit
stewards for 1875, and the following were elected as society stewards:—
Riwaka, Mr A. Drummond;
Moutere, Mr W. J. Herrick;
Clifton, Mr J. Packard;
Collingwood, Mr J. Riley, Senr.
FUTURE PREACHERS
On January 4th, 1877, Mr T. J. Wills was placed on the circuit plan as an "exhorter,"
and nine months later as a local preacher on trial. This Quarterly Meeting minute is
of interest in view of the subsequent career of the Rev. T. J. Wills as a clergyman of
the Church of England and an ardent prohibition advocate. On September 27, 1877,
Messrs P. Quayle and H. Staples were accepted as "exhorters."
HEAVY LOAD OF INTEREST
In 1879 (October 6) the Quarterly Meeting resolved on the motion of Messrs Glover
and Delany "that the Rev. Rainsford Bavin (District Chairman) be requested to apply
to the Conference for a grant of £50 in order to lessen the present debt on the Church
and thus lighten the load of heavy interest at present paid by the Trustees." An
additional grant of £25 was requested in order to defray the expenses of the circuit
during the next 12 months.
Mr James Hosking came to Motueka as resident missionary on December 30, 1878.
For several months (February 1878 to December the same year) there was no resident
pastor of the Wesleyan Methodist Church in Motueka.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 17
CHAPTER V
SUNDAY SCHOOL AND YOUTH AFFAIRS DURING THE
SEVENTIES AND EIGHTIES
The Motueka Methodist Church has never been one with an overplus of hoary heads
and gray beards. It has usually teemed with young life. Away back in 1874 the Sunday
School (always with a considerable proportion of senior scholars, corresponding to
our Bible Class members to-day) was held at 2.30 p.m. each Sunday in the old chapel.
Evidently nothing was said about its being "haunted" at that early date, although its
appearance would be disreputable enough! Some years later, during Mr B. Thomas's
pastorate, steps were taken to build a new schoolroom behind the 1873 church in the
township. In 1875 the proceeds of the S.S. Anniversary amounted to £21/8/2, whilst
the expenses were ten guineas. Of the balance £5/-/- was voted to the Quarter Board,
and this practice seems to have been kept up for many years.
In 1875 there were 60 children on the Sunday School roll, with an average attendance
of 53. Next year the roll number was reduced to 38, with six teachers. Two years later
(1878) an increase to 75 was reported. In 1879 the numbers were: On the roll, 62;
average attendance 45; officers and teachers 8. Soon afterwards the figures were 67
and 47 respectively, and in 1880 these were changed to 87 and 62. It is not easy to
assign a cause for these frequent, sudden, and apparently unexplained fluctuations.
DOVEDALE SCHOOL
From 1882 onwards we find the Dovedale Sunday School a serious competitor with
Motueka as regards the number of scholars in attendance. In 1883 the respective
figures were:—Motueka 82, Dovedale 51, with average attendances of 50 and 32
respectively. Later on we find Motueka and Dovedale running almost neck and neck
as regards both Sunday School scholars and adult Church members. Dovedale wins
first place in 1887 in both roll number of scholars and average attendance. This
position is well maintained during the next four years (up to 1891), when entries in the
Circuit Schedule Book suddenly cease.
One entry in the S.S. Minute Book (dated March 21, 1880) is interesting. It is in
commendation of the action of Mr J. G. Harkness (afterwards M.H.R. for Nelson City)
in having journeyed to and from Richmond free of charge to conduct S.S. Anniversary
services. He did much the same the year following.
On May 26, 1884 the teachers' meeting rescinded its previous resolution asking
children to forgo their annual prizes to help pay for seats in the schoolroom, this
change having been made possible through the generosity of the superintendent, Mr
McGlashen, in making himself personally responsible for the seats account. The same
meeting decided that the senior class girls be placed in charge of Miss Emily Staples,
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 18
the class II girls being assigned to Miss Green and Miss M. Green, and class III to
Miss Lovell. The teacher of the senior class boys was Mr McGlashen, Mr C. Hart
being in charge of class III boys, whilst Miss E. Parker and Mr R. Alexander divided
between them class II boys.
On January 11, 1886 a re-arrangement of classes is again made, "Miss Aexander
taking the second class girls, Miss N. Alexander the third, Misses Alley and Jackett
the fourth, the class II boys being assigned to Miss McGlashen. Mr Robert Simpson
was asked to accept the position of secretary.
As the conclusion of this highly interesting chapter we append a chronological list of
S.S. Superintendents, secretaries, treasurers, and teachers so far as a perfectly accurate
list of these is possible for the "seventies" and "eighties" period. However, one or two
names therein belong to the period just subsequent to that era. We note that among the
teachers occur frequently some well-known historical Motueka surnames. Without
making any invidious distinctions, we cannot help mentioning one family in particular
whose position both in church and Sunday school is unique, namely the Alexanders.
Miss S. J. Alexander played the organ in the old mission church before its
abandonment, whilst her sister, Miss Elizabeth, led the singing. In the list of S.S.
teachers occur the names of the three Alexander sisters and their two brothers, Messrs
William and Reuben. Again, the two sons of the late Mr Reuben Alexander, Eric and
Roy, afterwards joined the ranks of our home missionaries, and the last-mentioned has
given continuous service since 1924. He is at present (1951) stationed at Bombay in
the Franklin county, Auckland district. Mrs Hulbert, the present organist, is the
daughter of the late Mrs Caigou, who as Miss Alexander was one of Motueka's early
church organists.
SUNDAY SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENTS, SECRETARIES AND
TREASURERS OF THE EIGHTIES AND NINETIES (ALSO
AFTER)
Starting Year – Superintendents – Secretaries/Treasurers
1874 Rev W Marten - A Parker & R Alexander - G. Glover.
1875 J McGlashen - A Parker & R Alexander- G. Glover.
1877 J McGlashen - H Staples – W Parker & W. Alexander.
1878 J McGlashen - P Quayle.
1881 J McGlashen - F Boyce.
1884 P Quayle.
1886 - R Simpson - No record.
1902 T Harris, M.A. - No record - No record.
1908 or J Quayle - No record - No record
1909
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 19
LIST OF SUNDAY SCHOOL TEACHERS DURING THE
SEVENTIES AND EIGHTIES
Starting
Year Ladies Gentlemen
1874 Mrs Hawkins. Mr Jamieson.
Mrs Thomas. Mr John Delany.
Mr Grant.
Mr Simon.
Mr Crighton.
Mr Boyce.
Mr H. Staples.
Mr Thomas.
1875 Mrs Marten, Miss Atkins, Mr G. Glover.
Miss E. Parker,
Miss J. Parker,
Miss Pinny,
Miss F. Pinny.
1877 Miss A. Pinny,
Miss Alexander,
Miss Hawkins,
Miss Orsman.
1878 Miss Rose Alexander, Mr P. Quayle.
Miss Emily Staples,
Miss F. Boyes.
1880 Miss N. Alexander. Mr D. Sutherland.
Mr W. Pattie.
Mr Spicer.
1881 Miss A. Boyce. Mr C. Hart.
Mr W. H. Boyes.
1883 Miss C. Jackett, Mr Harry Staples.
Miss Thomson,
Miss Green,
Miss M. Green,
Miss Beryl,
Miss Alley.
1884 Miss Lovell. Mr R. Alexander.
1886 Miss McGlashen.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 20
LIST OF CHURCH OFFICE-BEARERS DURING THE
SEVENTIES AND EIGHTIES OF LAST CENTURY
Circuit Stewards 1874 S. Stone.
1874-5 J. Alexander.
1875 H. Thomas.
1876 Jas. McGlashen.
1878-9 W. Pinny.
1880 G. Spicer.
1880 W. Chamberlain
1889-91 P. Quayle.
1889-91 E. Parker.
Society Stewards
1874-5 Jas McGlashen.
1875-6 A. W. Parker.
1876-7 S. Pinny.
1877-8 K. Pinny.
1878 P. Quayle.
S. Pinny.
1880 S. Pinny.
1889-90 Horace Boyes.
R. Alexander.
1891 Jas. McGlashen.
R. G. Spicer.
Sacramental Stewards
1874 Geo Hawkins.
1875-8 R. Alexander.
1879-80 S. Pinny,
Church Stewards
1874-5 J. Alexander.
1876-7 E Parker
1878 H. Staples Jnr.
1879 P. Quayle.
1880 R. Alexander.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 21
Country Stewards
Lower Moutere: 1875-91 W. J. Herrick.
Ngatimoti: 1891 H. Haycock
Dovedale: 1889-91 J. Smith
Churchill: 1889-91 H. Snookes.
Woodstock: 1889-91 J. Cowin.
Riwaka: 1874-7 Alex Drummond
1877 T- Pattie.
Takaka: 1891 T. Fabian.
Collingwood: 1874-8 John Riley, snr.
Secretaries or Treasurers of Trust Property
Old Church:
1875 G. Glover.
1876-7 Jas. McGlashen
"New" Church:
1875 R. Staples.
1880 R. Alexander.
Trustees Old Church & Mission House:
(Late Seventies)
J. Alexander.
G. Glover.
J. Gower.
Jas. McGlashen.
Trustees 1873 Church:
J. Alexander.
G. Glover.
Jno. Delany.
G. Hawkins.
Jno. Gower.
From 1877:
James Wills.
Harry Staples.
P. Quayle.
Jas. McGlashen
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 22
CHAPTER VI—THE EIGHTIES THE EIGHTIES
During the year 1880 it would appear that certain disturbers of the peace were in the
habit of assembling in the church porch during divine worship, especially during the
Tuesday weeknight services. The Trustees on one occasion requested Mr Thomas
Boyes, the village constable of those days (and a Methodist) to take appropriate steps
to end the matter. British law sometimes assists the cause of Christ, just as did Roman
Law in the days of Paul the Apostle.
"BUN FIGHTS"
November 9, the birthday of the Prince of Wales, was during the seventies and
eighties a favourite day for the Anniversary Tea. Tea meetings—"bun fights," as we
small boys used to call them—were usually a financial success and brought in no
slight revenue to the Trust or Sunday School fund.
THE COURTING STAGE
A minute of a Trustee meeting during that period reads as follows:— "Four of the
back seats on each side to be removed with a view to inducing young people to
occupy the front seats." We cannot help wondering as to how much sympathy the
mover and the seconder of that resolution could have had for young folk at the
courting stage, also as to their lack of a sense of humour; but we still know a few good
people who were never young in their lives!
STATISTICS OF THE EIGHTIES
Dry figures sometimes contain far more moisture than one would suppose. In the
Circuit Schedule Book from 1882 onwards appear statistics concerning Dovedale, the
figures for the latter year being Motueka, 26 church members, and Dovedale 22. In
1886 the Dovedale figures increased to 36, thus drawing level with Motueka, which
also had increased by 10. In 1887 Dovedale is two ahead, in 1888 nine ahead, and for
the next two years Dovedale well maintains its position. Just when our interest is
being awakened, and much to our disappointment, the entries in the Circuit Schedule
Book reach an abrupt termination. In those days apparently District Synods never
made any enquiries about the proper writing up of Schedule Books.
WORSHIP OFFERINGS
On February 22, 1880, a meeting of 40 Methodist people at Motueka, presided over by
the District Chairman, the Rev. Rainsford Bavin, passed the following resolution:
"That it be a recommendation to the Quarterly meeting, and a condition on which an
appeal be made to the congregation, that the present system of making collections be
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 23
discontinued, and a box be placed at the door." There is no evidence as to whether or
not the Quarterly meeting agreed, nor, if so, how long the new system continued.
MR BENJAMIN THOMAS
Mr Benjamin Thomas came to Motueka as resident missionary on April 6, 1882, and
time proved him an exceptionally capable pastor and administrator. On April 5, 1884,
it was resolved that an "effort be made to build a parsonage and that an application be
made to the Church Building and Loan Fund for an amount equal to what may be
raised in the district." In modern political parlance, the Committee of the Loan Fund
was asked to grant a pound for pound subsidy instead of (as now) one pound for every
two raised by local effort. It was also resolved "that collections be made fortnightly
instead of monthly during the next quarter"; so evidently it was found necessary to
partly revert to the old scriptural custom of an offering as an integral part of church
worship (see 1 Cor. XVI 2).
SPLENDID WORK
In 1884 Mr J. H. Hall was elected a circuit steward. The September Quarterly Meeting
decided to apply for a grant of £30 from the Home Mission Fund. Twelve months later
(October 7, 1885) the minutes of the Quarterly Meeting show that splendid work had
recently been done, especially at Dovedale.
HELP STILL NEEDED
However, notwithstanding this, an application was made for a Home Mission grant of
£50 for the following reasons:—(1) Circuit deficiency £40; (2) Special efforts made to
build new schoolroom and new mission house during the preceding two years. It was
regretted that the circuit deficiency was so large at a time when a circuit credit -was
most urgently needed. We wonder how far this had been due to the practice, popular
just then, of the "no collection" idea.
Those were times of economic depression; but the Quarterly Meeting showed its faith
in God and the circuit's future, also in their pastor and his helpers, by giving Mr
Thomas a unanimous invitation to remain with them a further year. After that the
meeting adjourned to a future date to permit its members to attend a revival service
that was being held that same evening.
Three months afterwards (end of 1885) we find the circuit debt still mounting up, also
towards the end of March in the following year; but it is evident that it was not due to
the lack of good work. At Dovedale, for example, there was an increasing membership
and a flourishing Sunday School. Dovedale folk at this time reported their intention to
take up an offering once a Sunday only, on a morning and evening alternately, and the
Quarterly Meeting granted its approval.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 24
THE NEW PARSONAGE
All this time the funds for a new mission house were rolling in, and soon the
parsonage was erected with a debt remaining of only £110 payable to our Church
Building and Loan Fund.
On October 4, 1886, membership was reported as 62, plus 8 on trial (Motueka 26, plus
3 communicants; Dovedale 36, plus 5 on trial). Three months later these figures are
increased. Nevertheless, a grant of £50 was applied for, and Mr Thomas was again
invited to remain as pastor a further year. On December 31, 1886, Mr Hall resigns as
circuit steward, Mr W. H. Boyes being elected in his place. At Motueka there is an
increased membership of 8.
DOVEDALE TO THE FORE
The year 1887 witnesses a forging ahead of the Dovedale membership, 39 being
reported as against Motueka's 34. There is still a circuit deficit of £50/12/10, but three
months later it is decided to wipe this out by a combined sale of work. Hence on
October 3 the Quarterly Meeting decides to make application for a grant from the
Home Mission Fund of £20 only.
A year later (October 8, 1888) Mr Thomas is again accorded a hearty and unanimous
invitation to remain a further year. Several members of the meeting remarked with
appreciation on the progress made in the circuit since Mr Thomas's advent. The first
year, they said, the Trust debt was reduced from £161 to £121. The second year a new
schoolroom was erected at a cost of £65, free of debt; third year, a new mission house,
cost (including outside improvements) £262, debt £110, now reduced to £46.
Reference was made also to the attention given to the spiritual interests of the district
during Mr Thomas's term of seven years.
MR ROBERT YOUNG
Conference considered it best to move Mr Thomas, despite his popularity; so Mr
Robert Young was appointed to Motueka. At the Quarterly Meeting held on April 1,
1889, it was carried unanimously on the motion of Messrs J. Smith and R. B.
Alexander: "That the best thanks of this meeting be presented to Mr Thomas, on the
eve of his departure to another place of labour for the zealous, energetic, and faithful
services he has uniformly rendered in this circuit during the last seven years. In
addition to his work as a minister in the Church, his kind and generous spirit has won
for him enduring and wide regard. We sincerely trust that the blessing of God may rest
on him, Mrs Thomas, and family in their new field of usefulness."
At Mr Young's first Quarterly Meeting in July, 1889, membership was reported as
Motueka 33 and Dovedale 41; deficit balance on the Circuit Fund, £4/16/1. It was
decided to make the stipend £120, with £10 allowance for keeping a horse. Towards
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 25
the end of the year Messrs E. Parker and P. Quayle are elected circuit stewards for
1890, Messrs R. B. Alexander and Horace Boyes society stewards at Motueka, Mr J.
Smith society steward at Dovedale, and Mr J. F. Cowin the same at Woodstock.
In April 1890, the circuit deficiency is found to be mounting up, and the stewards at
the Dovedale end agree, at the request of the Quarterly Meeting, to make an appeal for
more liberal support from the congregation at Churchill.
THE JUBILEE COMMITTEE
Just then the formation of a Jubilee Committee of the Motueka circuit was decided on
(the jubilee would be 2 years hence) and among the names of persons elected to that
committee we find that of Mr Richmond Hursthouse, M.H.R. Also members of that
committee are Messrs T. R. Burnard, R. Cowin, and Noble Win.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 26
CHAPTER VII—THE NINETIES
Mr Robert Young, a noted preacher and one with considerable musical gifts, was the
missionary in charge at the beginning of this period, and he was succeeded by Mr R.
Harker, at the close of whose term (1898) the Motueka circuit was placed in charge of
a minister on probation, the Rev. Arthur Ashcroft, whose preaching and social gifts
quickly won for him a place in the hearts of the people.
TRANSPORT "MIRACLES"
A glance at the Circuit financial statements covering the "nineties" period reveals
veritable miracles in the way of transport achievements. Services were held
periodically at Takaka and Collingwood in the one direction and at such places as
Tadmor, Motupiko, Sherry and the Baton in the other. There were lay preachers
residing fairly near to those places capable of conducting services in substitution for
the minister, but they did not save the minister the necessity of sometimes riding to
those places on a "cup-loser" at the break-neck speed of six miles per hour, resulting
in lavish consumption of time! We earnestly hope that horse-shoes and horse-feed
were slightly less expensive than they subsequently became. Some of us, fortunately,
were born too late for such herculean feats in horsemanship!
We can well imagine that, as a result of pastoral activities being distributed over so
extended an area, the attendances at the Sunday services in the centre were not Large,
and a glance at the corresponding financial statements confirms that supposition.
Methodist authorities to-day would never countenance such unreasonable dissipation
of a minister's energies, although the advent of the motorcar has modified the situation
considerably. The experience of the years between those days and our own has
afforded us in this respect facilities for cutting our wisdom teeth. Even missionary
zeal, good as it is, has its legitimate limits.
A MYSTERIOUS DISAPPEARANCE
A deficit balance of £19/6/10 at the end of a certain year during this period suddenly
does the disappearing trick, being not brought forward into the New Year. Was this
due to a pious New Year resolution on the part of some good soul, or souls, thus
prompting him or them to perform a secret good work, and as the Americans say,
"cough up?" In the absence of explicit information to that effect, we incline rather to a
very different conclusion.
LECTURES TO REDUCE DEBT
Among New Zealand's outstanding platform orators of a former generation were the
two Isitt brothers (Frank and Leonard), both now passed on. The late Rev. F. W. Isitt,
during his Nelson pastorate, did good service to Motueka by delivering lectures or
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 27
recitals to reduce the circuit debt. The Quarterly Meeting of January 13, 1891, passed
a vote of thanks to Mr Isitt, also to the Nelson (St. John's) choir.
THE PROHIBITION MOVEMENT
The Isitt brothers were pioneer leaders of the movement to abolish the public traffic in
intoxicating liquors. Undoubtedly that movement will someday be revived. New
Zealand might have been under "prohibition" today had the Methodists of the
Motueka district welcomed that movement and set an example to their neighbours; but
apparently that ancient barrier to all social reform, self-interest, prevented it. You see,
Motueka was then, and is still, a hop-growing district. The author well remembers a
public meeting held about 1890 (or 1892) in the Institute Hall, Motueka, and
addressed by the Rev. L. M. Isitt, the chairman being Mr Richmond Hursthouse. Mr
Hursthouse, himself a hop-grower at the time, made in his introductory speech a frank
statement of the position. Public welfare demanded, he said, the elimination of the
liquor traffic, and to meet this position it was certain that the farmers of Motueka
would need to grow something else on their land in substitution for hops. But alas!
time has failed to carry his good suggestion into effect. A few years later saw the
popularising of fruit-growing as a local industry; but it did not displace hop-growing,
but rather took its place alongside it. Even tobacco-growing, a comparatively recent
arrival and one corresponding to a far lesser evil, shared the same good fortune. The
lure of gold appears sometimes to be invincible, but is it really so? Methodism, at all
events, can speak of a social factor far more powerful, namely, love for God and men!
LEADING WORKERS
The office-bearers for 1891 were the following: Circuit Stewards, Messrs E. Parker
and P. Quayle; society stewards: Motueka, Messrs James McGlashen and R. G.
Spicer; Moutere, Mr S. Herrick; Takaka, Mr J. Fabian; Dovedale, Mr J. Smith;
Woodstock, Mr J. F. Cowin; Churchill, Mr A. Snooks. On July 21 Mr Herbert
Haycock was elected society steward at Ngatimoti.
During the eighties it seems never to have been customary for the Circuit Sunday
schools to report concerning their state and progress to the Quarterly Meeting; but Mr
P. Quayle, the Motueka superintendent, gave on July 12, 1891, a brief report
characterising his school in one word as "satisfactory." Doubtless it was Mr Quayle's
modesty that forbade the addition of any further encomiums.
During the years 1891 and 1892 a deficit balance on the Circuit financial statements at
succeeding Quarterly meetings seems to have been the normal state of things; but on
January 26, 1893, the deficit was reported as having been reduced from £65/17/6 to
£50/17/3, this reduction being due mainly to lectures given by the Rev. F. W. Isitt.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 28
The circuit stewards at the beginning of 1893 were Messrs E. Parker and J. Smith. The
society stewards were Messrs P. Quayle and R. G. Spicer, the society steward at
Dovedale Mr J. W. Win, at Woodstock Mr J. F. Cowin, at Ngatimoti Mr H. Haycock,
and at Takaka Mr J. Fabian.
MR YOUNG JOINS THE CHURCH OF ENGLAND
A comparative surprise was sprung on Motueka Methodism early in 1893, and indeed
on the whole district, when it was learned that Mr Robert Young was about to be
ordained as a clergyman of the Church of England. From what the author remembers
of him, Mr Young's natural temperament was such as to suit him far better for the
ministry of that Church than for Methodism. Commencing as curate at Palmerston
North, he spent many years of his later life as vicar in one or two of our North Island
towns. Among us Methodists he had been known as a preacher of more than average
ability: he could gather together a congregation, and month after month continue to
hold it. Such a capacity is rare among preachers of any denomination. Mr Young had
three adult daughters and two sons, the elder of whom won an Education Board
Scholarship from the Motueka school and afterwards became a brigadier-general.
MR R. HARKER
Mr Young's successor, Mr R. Harker, completed the quartette of able home
missionaries who, between them, give 20 years very efficient service to Motueka
Methodism. Mr Hosking served four years, Mr Thomas seven, Mr Young four, and
Mr Harker five.
On October 10, 1893 Mr Harker told his Quarterly Meeting that Mr R. Staples had
ploughed and sown down half the parsonage grounds free of charge. The meeting
passed a vote of thanks to Mr Staples. At the same meeting Mr E. Parker resigned as
circuit steward, being succeeded by Mr W. J. Moffatt, afterwards mayor of Nelson.
However, Mr Moffatt kept his new position for nine months only, being succeeded by
Mr P. Quayle.
INCREASE IN MEMBERSHIP
During the five years of Mr Harker's ministry, Church membership in the circuit
seems to have mounted steadily upwards. On January 16, 1895, it was reported as 62
full members and 12 on trial. Six months later it was 65 full members and still 12 on
trial. Three months thence it was 74 full members and 13 on trial; six months
thereafter the respective figures are 78 and 14.
On December 13, 1896, the Quarterly Meeting declared in a resolution: "Mr Harker is
commanding the sympathy and respect of the whole district by his devotion to his
work."
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 29
THAT NIGHTMARE DEBT
But no matter how good and faithful were the pastors of those far-off days, it would
appear that the Motueka circuit could never keep very long free from debt. Debt broke
the heart of minister after minister and hindered his work. The Quarterly Meeting of
April 3, 1896, declared: "The balance deficit adopted by this meeting is £69/13/10."
But one thing the debts never once succeeded in doing: They could not contract the
circuit's missionary activities. At the same meeting it was resolved to maintain the
preaching services at Motupiko, Sherry, and Tadmor. Messrs J. W. Win and J. F.
Cowin (Dovedale lay preachers) gladly consented to conduct services at those places.
During 1896 and 1897 Church membership in the circuit continued to increase in spite
of financial handicaps. In July, 1896, 80 in full membership, plus 10 on trial, are
reported at the Quarterly meeting, and six months later 82 full and 13 on trial. Efforts
were then being made, however, to keep down the circuit debt or, better still, wipe it
out. The Nelson Methodist choir is officially thanked by the Quarterly Meeting at the
beginning of 1897, when Messrs Quayle and Staples assume office as circuit stewards.
In October, 1897, the circuit deficit is now £82, but the membership is still as high as
79 full and 15 on trial. Six months later the full membership is 89, and soon
afterwards 91. On March 2, 1899 it is 95 (Motueka 41, Dovedale 54.
THE REV. ARTHUR ASHCROFT
In April, 1898, the Rev. Arthur Ashcroft, a fourth year probationary minister, arrives
in the circuit, and the recent spiritual advance continues. The circuit stewards in 1898
were Messrs P. Quayle and James McGlashen, and Mr Lawrence Duncan was a
society steward at Motueka. The year following Mr Duncan is still a society steward
in company with Mr E. Rowling. The Dovedale stewards are Messrs J Smith and
Daniel Cozens, Mr T. Burnett holding the same office at Churchill, Mr J. F. Cowin at
Woodstock, Mr J. Allcott at Lower Moutere and Mr C. Hart at Riwaka.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 30
CHAPTER VIII FIRST DECADE OF TWENTIETH CENTURY
On August 13, 1900, the Trustees of the mission house and cemetery were the
following: Messrs James McGlashen, J. Alexander, W. Boyce, W. J. Moffatt, E.
Smith, P. Quayle, and L. G. Duncan.
THE REV. R. P. KEALL (1900-1)
Mr Keall served in Motueka one year only. At the end of that year matters in Westport
necessitated his transfer thither. In his time evening congregations were good,
including a particularly fine gathering of young folk. Well known Motueka families
then had practically all their members in the Methodist church. On July 31, 1901, Miss
McGlashen resigns as organist.
Every alternate Sunday Mr Keall (and others before and after him) had to be at
Dovedale, usually going up on Saturday to visit, staying the night at one of our
Methodist homes, and in the forenoon conducting worship at Woodstock or Churchill.
On Sunday afternoon there was worship at Dovedale, preceded by Sunday School,
where the minister acted as superintendent. Whatever the state of the weather, he was
always expected back at Motueka for evening worship and a bicycle could make the
18 mile journey both dirty and difficult. A year or two later, the coming to Motueka of
Mr T. A. Harris, M.A., schoolmaster and an excellent local preacher, made the work
much easier.
It was during Mr Keall's ministry that Mr William Boyce was appointed a Trustee in
place of Mr J. Gower and Mr W. J. Moffatt in place of Mr G. Glover. Messrs Edward
Smith, P. Quayle and L. G. Duncan became additional Trustees.
THE REV. WILLIAM WILLS (1901-3)
On July 31, 1901 Miss Eva McGlashen was appointed organist in place of her eldest
sister. On Wednesday, November 13, a working bee erects new gates on the church
grounds, trims the hedges, and cleans the paths. The Trustees on November 18
accepted Mr Bartlett's estimate (£37) for repairs to and painting of the church. Mr
Bartlett also drew up specifications for lining the schoolroom. Later in the year Mr
Moffatt was succeeded as Trust Secretary by Mr W. Boyce, and in January, 1902, Mr
P. Quayle is succeeded as Trustee by Mr T. Boyes.
In February, 1902, the Trustees, in passing for payment Mr Bartlett's account for
painting and lining, expressed their hearty approval of the manner in which the work
had been done. The preparation of a specification for distempering was entrusted to
Mr Moffatt. On February 17, the tender of Mr A. Smith (£16/10/-) for renovating the
interior of the church was accepted, and two months later Mr Smith received a letter
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 31
expressing satisfaction with the workmanlike manner in which his contract had been
carried out.
To celebrate this renovation work, the Rev. W. J. Williams, District Chairman,
conducted reopening services, giving also during the same week a lecture whose
proceeds went towards renovation costs.
Tenders having been called for painting, papering, and repairing the parsonage under
Mr W. J. Moffatt's supervision, Mr Edmund Parker's tender (£20/19/6) was accepted
on June 2, 1902. In April, 1903 the choir receives the thanks of the Trustees for having
raised funds to erect a platform.
In April, 1903 Miss Eva McGlashen's resignation as organist way received with great
regret, Miss E. Duncan being appointed in her place. On the same date the Trustees
placed on record their appreciation of the energy and perseverance displayed by the
Rev. W. Wills during his ministry. Mainly as the result of his untiring efforts, the
whole of the Trust property was now in good repair and clear of debt.
THE REV. AMOS READER (1903-6)
A revision of the membership roll was reported at the September Quarterly Meeting,
1905. There were now 117 members and 3 on trial. The Sunday schools had a roll of
107 scholars and 14 teachers (Motueka 37 scholars, 6 teachers; Dovedale 60 scholars,
7 teachers; Woodstock 10 scholars, 1 teacher). At the next Quarterly meeting the
membership is reported as 120 full, and it remains at that figure for some months. The
expansion of the Sunday school rolls continues.
In July, 1905 Mr William Boyce resigns as Trust Secretary. Tenders are called for re-
roofing the schoolroom, and a subscription list is drawn up. A lamp was placed
outside the front door of the Church. On May 4, 1906 Miss Elsie Lancely is appointed
organist. Several present-day lay preachers trace the beginnings of their success in that
capacity to help and inspiration received at Mr Reader's classes in theology.
THE REV. C. M. ROBERTS (1906-1908)
The Quarterly Meeting of July 9, 1906 was chaired by the new appointee, the Rev. C.
Roberts, a first-year probationer. The deficit balance has been reduced to £7/6/11. In
April, 1907 the Dovedale Sunday School is reported as flourishing. Mr J. F. Cowin
resigns as circuit steward and Messrs T. A. Harris and F. Turner succeed to that office.
On October 16 membership has increased to 129 and 7 on trial, whilst the circuit debt
has been reduced to £4/18/8. Mr Roberts declines an invitation to remain a third year.
In January, 1908 the membership has again gone up, the numbers now being 135 and
5 on trial. Messrs C. Cresswell and F. Turner are elected circuit stewards, the society
stewards being Messrs E. Smith and J. J. Quayle at Motueka, J. Thorn and L. Cowin at
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 32
Dovedale F Turner at Woodstock, T. Burnett at Churchill, C. Cresswell at Lower
Moutere, and R. B. Alexander at Pangatotara. Mr F. Turner is received on trial as a
local preacher.
Mr Roberts concludes his ministry on April 4, 1908, the membership being then
reported as 140 full and 7 juniors; credit balance £3/7/1. The Quarterly Meeting
thanks Messrs Hodson, B. Thomas (former H.M.) and Mears for preaching services
during the year. A letter of appreciation and thanks is sent to the managing editor of
the "Motueka Star" (Mr G. Boundy) for free advertisements.
The two years term of Mr Roberts is characterised by several decisions for the better
life by young people in different parts of the circuit. This is attributable in part to his
preaching, but in part also to a tactful handling of the subject in private conversation.
In the light of his 40 odd years' ministry since those days, we can truthfully say of him
that he was an able and faithful minister of the New Testament.
THE REV. GEORGE SNADDEN (1908-1910)
Mr Snadden begins his ministry in April, 1908. In September the membership is
reported as 137 full and 8 juniors. There is a credit balance of £3/9/10. In January,
1909, a credit is again reported and has increased to £6/3/9. The Endeavour Societies
in the circuit are doing well, especially the Motueka Juniors. The circuit stewards are
Messrs C. Cresswell and J. Thorn, Mr G. Allcott being society steward at Lower
Moutere.' Mr George Jordan replaces Mr L. Cowin at Dovedale.
On June 1, 1909 the plans and estimates of a new church for Dovedale are approved,
and a meeting at Motueka the same week confirms this approval. On July 7 the
Endeavour Societies again report favourably, the Motueka Society showing an upward
tendency, the Motueka Juniors progressing, and the Dovedale Society flourishing. On
January 12, 1910, Messrs A. Holdaway, M. Cresswell, G. Allcott, and J. J. Quayle are
received on trial as local preachers.
In June, 1909, Mr T. A. Harris resigns as Trust Secretary. A concert has cleared
£4/10/- for a chimney in the Sunday school, and a vote of thanks is accorded Miss
Agnes Starnes for her efforts in that direction. On February 9, 1909, Messrs J. J.
Quayle, C. R. York, L. Sinclair and C. S. Cresswell had been elected to fill the places
on the Trust Board recently vacated by Messrs W. Boyce, W. J. Moffatt, L. G. Duncan
and T. A. Harris. On April 16 permission is granted to the choir (leader Mr W.
Edwards) to replace at their own expense the choir seats by new ones.
In July 1909, 20 posts and 3 straining posts are ordered for the parsonage fence, and
Mr L. Sinclair afterwards did the work. Messrs Alexander and Cresswell had built the
chimney in the schoolroom. Thanks are accorded Miss L. Moffatt and Mr A.
Holdaway for canvassing for Church painting. On November 1, 1909 it is reported
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 33
that the interior has been painted by Mr Brickley for £7, the outside of the church
having been painted by a working bee several months earlier.
At Mr Snadden's last Quarterly Meeting membership is reported as 138 and 8 juniors.
Mr C. E. Jordan is elected society steward at Churchill in place of Mr T. Burnett, and
Mr H. O. Holdaway at Braeburn.
THE REV. C. B. JORDAN, B.A. (1910-1911)
At my own first Quarterly Meeting (June 29, 1910) membership was reported as 138
and 16 juniors, an increase of 8 juniors during the quarter; circuit deficit £4/17/5. On
April 15, 1910 Mr Mumford's tender (£31) for parsonage kitchen is accepted by the
Trustees. On April 25 Mr E. Smith's tender for papering and painting the parsonage is
accepted; including the rescrimming of the dining room. A shed is soon erected at the
parsonage, Mr L. Sinclair's tender for the same (£13) being accepted on May 26.
On July 28 Miss E. Lancely's resignation as organist was accepted with regret, and she
was commended by the Trustees for the capable manner in which she had always
filled that position. Miss A. Stanton was appointed in her place. Mr J. Alexander
passes away during 1910.
On January 12, 1911 the Trustees decided "that we take steps to start a fund for a new
church." The steps were to be: (1) Collecting annual subscriptions; (2) an annual sale
of work; (3) an annual concert. The minister and the secretary were to appoint
canvassers for (1), the minister undertook to call a meeting of ladies for (2), and the
secretary undertook to bring (3) before the choir. The ladies duly met and formed a
guild, Mrs P. Drummond (B.C. Leader) being its first president.
The minister had in the previous October declined a unanimous invitation to remain a
second year. He has reason to believe that lives were changed during his year in
Motueka.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 34
CHAPTER IX FROM 1911 TO ABOUT 1925
The March Quarterly Meeting in 1911 recommended that four young men who had
been lay preachers on trial or doing mission band work, should come up for
examination three months hence. Their names were Gerald Allcott, Merle Cresswell,
Arthur Holdaway, and John Quayle. At the beginning of 1912 Mr L. Goodman was
elected choir steward, Mr Fred Willoughby society steward, and Mr H. 0. Holdaway
steward at Braeburn.
THE LABOURER'S HIRE
There was once a time when, among members of the N.Z. Methodist Conference,
Motueka was repeatedly the butt of unfavourable criticism. Let us be frank and admit
at once that in matters of finance Motueka has always been difficult. It has nearly
always lagged behind other circuits of its grade with regard to ministerial stipend.
In the Conference of 1911 the matter came to a head. Certain Conference laymen were
very outspoken and said some hard things; but the speakers were without doubt
ignorant of local conditions. Motueka has never been a "rich" district: not even yet can
it be placed in that category. The farmers of the district have always been mainly
tillers of the soil. Of big dairymen or flockmasters there were none in Methodism; and
besides, owing to the conservative force of habit, the ecclesiastical niggardliness
proper to the seventies and eighties had extended far into the new century.
A "PENAL" REVERSION
Motueka had not had a home missionary since 1898; but in 1911 the circuit was
"penalised" by the sending of a home MISSIONARY in place of a probationary
minister. However, the missionary appointed was married, which meant in practice
that Motueka's financial difficulties were increased rather than diminished; for even 40
years ago it was not possible for any married man to live on £100 a year and a free
house.
A COMPASSIONATE PROVIDENCE
But it so happened, despite the hurt then suffered by blamless and sensitive hearts, that
Motueka in 1911 was singularly blest by a compassionate Providence. Mr J. Harris,
the missionary appointed, was a man of wide experience and one peculiarly adapted to
the district's needs. Having at the beginning an exceptionally full visiting list to help
him, he proved an exceptionally efficient pastor: he was also a preacher of no mean
ability. The Motueka church, which had previously been almost full on Sunday
evenings, was now quite full. Methodists all over the circuit were pleased, and soon
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 35
forgot the "aching smart" recently inflicted at Conference. They were eagerly looking
forward to another year, perhaps several years, with Mr Harris as their pastor.
ANOTHER CHANGE
However, the Conference of 1912 willed otherwise. It did the very opposite of what it
had done the year before. The missionary was now withdrawn, and a married
probationer, due soon for ordination, placed at Motueka: hence the Rev. J. D.
McArthur wended his way thither with his newly-wedded wife.
Now, before readers begin to storm and fume over the unaccountable doings of
Conference, it will be necessary for them to understand the exact position. At that time
the Conference every year had great difficulty in placing its young married ministers
or probationers. It could usually send them only to places which had a parsonage.
Motueka had a parsonage, and besides, financial conditions were now on the upgrade;
hence it was deemed possible, by the help of a fairly liberal Home Mission grant, to
provide for a married minister at Motueka.
But under the circumstances, it was scarcely to be wondered at that such a decision of
Conference occurring at such a critical time caused an unfortunate "split." Several
members and adherents (including Miss Moffatt, the Willoughbys, and Mr E. Smith)
remained loyal from the very first and decided to rally round the new minister; but
others either left the church or remained in it as mere lookers-on.
It took many years to heal that breach. For years there remained an underwater "swell"
on the otherwise calm sea of spiritual well-being, and the loyalty of even the loyal
ones was severely strained. Mr McArthur, coming to the circuit at such a time,
handled the situation with admirable courage and ability. Slowly but surely the routine
current of circuit life began again to flow in its accustomed channels, one person or
family after another being won back to Methodist loyalty and to co-operation with the
new minister and his plucky wife.
CIRCUIT REORGANISATION
During Mr McArthur's second year he showed his courage in two ways, first by
inaugurating the envelope system to provide circuit finance, and second, by initiating
a move for separating the two ends of the circuit. With regard to the first proposal, he
himself personally undertook the preliminary canvass that was necessary. Although
the numbers of envelope subscribers was not large, his efforts in this respect met with
considerable success.
Mr McArthur's experience in other districts had taught him that in the Motueka circuit
far too much time was taken up in locomotion (under the old-time horse method of
travelling). His plan was to cut off Dovedale, which with Churchill and Woodstock
would be placed under a single home missionary, whilst Motueka with its near-by
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 36
places would be in charge of a probationer. Theoretically it was the best thing that
could have been devised, and in practice the sole factor militating against its success
was the shortage of manpower; but the advent of the first world war no one at that
time could foresee.
It might have been better had Mr McArthur remained longer in Motueka, but, for
better or worse, he declined an invitation to stay a third year, and in April, 1914, was
succeeded by the Rev. C. A. Foston, then a home missionary. The Ladies' Guild
bought Mr McArthur's furniture.
On July 1, 1914 the Quarterly Meeting requested the appointment of a home
missionary at Dovedale, and Mr T. Walker, of Westport, afterwards filled that post.
The same meeting appointed Mr G. Allcott circuit steward in place of Mr H. O.
Holdaway, who was removing to Nelson. Messrs J. Thorn and F. Turner were
appointed circuit stewards of the newly-formed Dovedale home mission station. A
year later, no suitable appointment being available for Dovedale, that place, along
with Churchill and Woodstock, became again part of the Motueka circuit.
ADDITIONS TO MEMBERSHIP
During 1917 Mr E. S. Wratt becomes definitely linked up with Motueka Methodism
as member and office-bearer. First, he was secretary of the Quarterly meeting, and
then circuit steward, being elected to this latter post on January 5, 1918. Three months
later Mr and Mrs Hulbert and their daughter are received from Palmerston North. On
July 6, 1918 Mrs Lionel Boyes is received into full membership. These all proved
valuable acquisitions to Motueka Methodism. On April 5, 1919 Mr W. H. Ganderton
became circuit secretary for Overseas Missions.
NEW CHURCH AT MOTUEKA
Since 1911 scarcely anything had been practicable in connection with the new church
at Motueka. The honour of making the first serious move in that direction belongs to
Mr A. Nicholls, home missionary in charge, 1917-1919. It was during his pastorate
that an application was made to the Church Building and Loan Fund Committee, and a
loan receives approval in October, 1917. Just before this a building committee had
been appointed consisting of the following in addition to the Trustees: Messrs F.
Cresswell, Ching, Craighead, Holland, Wells, and W. Quayle. Information is obtained
regarding plans and cost of a building to seat 200 people.
A subsequent meeting of the congregation decides to build in concrete. Members of
the building committee give promises totalling £100, and a thorough canvass of the
district is decided on. The loan application is increased to £300, and in March, 1918
this is again increased to £400. Meanwhile Messrs S. E. Hulbert and G. Starnes are
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 37
appointed Trustees and Messrs W. Mather, J. Boyce and L. Duncan are added to the
building committee.
SALES AND ORGAN RECITAL
The Trust minutes about this time record the giving of an organ recital by Miss L.
Hulbert in aid of the building fund. Miss Hulbert was officially appointed organist on
August 5, 1918. Her predecessor, Mrs Ovens, had held the position since May 7,
1917. On this latter date Miss Ivy Stanton had been appointed assistant organist, in
which capacity she served a faithful two years. Mr Holland is appointed choir
conductor on May 12, 1919.
On March 25, 1918 the two guilds (Ladies' and Young Ladies') are both thanked for
their recent combined effort in a sale of work. A little later there is a sale of produce.
For a bazaar on December 5, 1918 the Horticultural Hall is engaged. It was decided to
canvass for funds in Nelson, Messrs Nicholls and Wratt undertaking the canvass, and
a further amount of £60 was thus secured.
PERMIT TO BUILD
During the pastorate of Mr C. W. Brown, the successor of' Mr Nicholls, it was decided
(July 19, 1920) to raise another £200 before letting the contract for the new building.
It was to cost £1540, seats £90, lighting £40; total £1670. The loan application is now
increased to £556 (one-third). On July 21, 1920 a congregational meeting declines an
offer from the Presbyterian Church to sell their property for £1000, accepts Messrs
Stilwell and Company's plans, and promises an additional £53. A Trustee meeting on
August 16 receives the news that the loan of £556 has been granted; but just here
some difficulty is encountered in securing a building permit from the Board of Trade.
However, the services of Mr R. P. Hudson, M.P. are secured towards the granting of
this permit, the thanks of the Trustees being accorded Mr Hudson on October 28,
1920. The temporary use of the Presbyterian church at £1 per week is accepted, and on
October 31 the congregation worships for the last time in the 1873 church.
The Church Anniversary was celebrated on November 7 in the local Presbyterian
church. It is subsequently decided that the new church stone-laying function shall be
held on December 15, and that the honour of laying the stones shall be accorded the
Hon. C. M. Luke and Mi-Hudson, M.P. Failing either of these, Mr E. S. Wratt was
appointed substitute. Mr W. F. Cresswell is appointed supervisor of building
operations.
Early in December, 1920 the Ladies' Guild raises £100 by a bazaar. Arrangements are
made to supply 150 people with afternoon tea at the stone-laying. On January 12,
1921 arrangements are made to collect unpaid amounts promised. On January 3 the
first progress payment of £300 is duly passed, £11 for foundation stones, and £39 for
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 38
lights. A general canvass of the district has produced an additional £60. The offer by
Mr Smith to paint the roof gratuitously was accepted, also the offer of a pulpit Bible.
THE OPENING
The following report is reprinted from the Nelson "Evening Mail" dated Monday,
April 4, 1921:—
The opening ceremony and dedication service of the new Methodist church at
Motueka took place on Saturday afternoon at 2.30 o'clock. there being present a
large attendance. Including many visitors from Nelson and the surrounding
districts. The Rev. C. W. Brown presented a silver key to Mrs Boyes, who, after
a short introductory service unlocked the door and declared the building opened.
The dedicatory service was conducted by the Rev. W. Grigg, president of the
New Zealand Methodist Conference, who visited Motueka for the occasion.
The Rev. E. D. Patchett read the lesson (2 Chron VI.). The choir, under the baton
of Mr H. Holland, rendered an anthem during the service, Miss Hulbert,
A.T.C.L.. presiding at the organ.
At 5.30 an adjournment was made to the Horticultural Hall, where a banquet was
held. The hall was tastefully decorated, and the tables were heavily laden with a
great variety of edibles provided by the ladies, which those present did full
justice to. The Chairman, Rev. C. W. Brown, after reading an apology from Mr
R. P. Hudson, M.P., who unfortunately was unable to be present, proposed the
first toast "The King," when the National Anthem was sung by the assemblage.
Other toasts proposed were "The New Church," Rev. E. D. Patchett, reply Mr C.
S. Cresswell (secretary of Trust); "Methodism," Mr S. E Hulbert, reply Rev. W.
Grigg; "Sister Churches," Mr M. Cresswell, reply Rev. W. Grundy; "The
Ladies," Mr H. Holland, reply Mrs A. Thorn; "New Zealand," Rev. Mr Harvey,
reply Mr Boundy; "Local Bodies," Mr Herbert E. Everett, reply Mr J. A. Wallace
(Mayor); "The Builders," Mr E. S. Wratt, reply Mr H. Buckeridge; "The
Visitors," Mr L. Sinclair, reply Mr A. A. Lucas. During the evening vocal
selections were rendered by Mrs J. Boyce, Mr and Mrs Henderson, Miss
Crichton, Messrs. H. Holland, J. Alien, a recitation by Mr G. H. Budden, and a
pianoforte solo by Miss Lily Hulbert.
SUBSEQUENT PROGRESS
In concluding this account of the present church opening it is fitting that tribute should
be paid to the man who was then in charge of the circuit, Mr C. W. Brown. He was not
only a skilful financial planner, but a creditable preacher and soul-winner. In 1921
Church membership was still on the increase, as it had. been during Mr Brown's
previous years. Forward movements in connection with the youth work were
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 39
inaugurated by him, and a young men's Bible class in Motueka was permanently
established. He initiated a plan to fit up the old Sunday School as a Primary
department room. The moving spirits among the young men in his day were Messrs
Melvyn Boyes and Godfrey Starnes, and in 1922 or earlier a Y.W.B.C. was
successfully started by Miss Everett. Mr W. E. Sleep succeeded Mr Brown as
missionary in charge in 1923.
OFFICE-BEARERS 1922-4
Early in 1922 Mr E. S. Wratt becomes S.S. Superintendent. Messrs M. G. Cresswell
and L. Cowin are circuit stewards, and Messrs Martin and Remnant stewards at
Umukuri and Rocky River respectively. Messrs Keith Boyes and Eric Alexander
become circuit secretaries for Home and Overseas Missions respectively. The death of
Mr W. F. Cresswell occurred towards the end of 1921, and Mrs E. Parker passed away
early in 1923. Messrs G. Burnard and G. Snadden discontinued about this time their
valuable services as preachers.
On October 13, 1924 the S.S. at Motueka reports a roll number of 78, with average
attendance 63. The Bible classes are quite creditable, and during the next year they
increase. Just then it was decided that, "subject to a suitable grant being made," the
Motueka circuit "will take a married ordained minister next year." In fulfilment of this
resolution the Rev. Henry Benny was appointed to Motueka early in 1925.
RECENT OUTSTANDING EVENTS
Three notable happenings since 1925 deserve special mention here:—
(1) THE BIBLE CLASS HALL—This was officially handed over to the Trustees
on October 15, 1929. Its total cost was £352. The chairman of the building
committee was Mr S. E. Hulbert, and the secretary Mr H. R. Holdaway. Its
erection was due largely to the efforts of the young people themselves under the
supervision of the secretary. A Queen Competition organised by the Rev. L. A.
G. and Mrs Brooks also assisted the funds.
(2) PARSONAGE—This was officially opened on April 24, 1936.
The cost of seven rooms was £875. The Motueka Ladies' Guild donated
£200 and undertook the repayment of a loan of £400. Donations amounted to
£64/9/6 and a building subsidy to £62/2/-. The building was officially opened by
the secretary, the late Mr C. S. Cresswell.
(3) CENTENARY—The centenary celebrations were held in May, 1942. Special
services were conducted by the President of the Conference, the Rev. William
Walker. A centennial tea and other functions were held, and among the visitors
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 40
present was Mr E. H. Andrews, mayor of Christchurch, and grandson of the first
officially appointed resident pastor at Motueka.
Having brought this historical brochure of Motueka Methodism to well past the
opening day of the present church, our task is now completed. To bring the history
right up to date would require several more pages of print. What shall we more say?
Motueka Methodism has had its ups and downs during the periods dealt with, and a
cynic might add, "especially downs"; but things are changing every day, and we are
pleased to note that an era of comparative prosperity seems to have definitely set in.
Hence,
"We'll praise Him for all that is past,
And trust Him for all that's to come."
The Rev. H. G. Brown and Present- Day Trustees. Front Row: Messrs. E. T. Chambers, W. A.
Quayle, C. H. Kinzett, M. G. Cresswell. Back Row: I. G. Holdawoy, L. A. Ray, L. Cowin, Rev. H. G.
Brown, E. S. Wratt, S. B. Wratt. Absent: Mr H. A. Holdaway.
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 41
Rev. Edward Baker, Present Minister
CHRONOLOGICAL LIST OF MOTUEKA METHODIST PASTORS.
1843 onwards, under supervision Nelson minister.
1848-1850.—Mr W. Jenkins (Catechist).
1850-1857.—Services conducted by "locals."
1857-1866.~Mr W. Andrews ("Hired local preacher").
1866-1869.—Mr S. Stone (Home Missionary).
1869-1871.—Rev. W. G. Thomas.
1872-1874.—Vacant.
1874-1876.—Rev, W. B. Marten.
1876-1877.—Rev. T. F. Reeve.
1877-1878.—Rev. S. R. Purchon.
1878-1882.—Mr James Hosking (H.M.).
1882-1889.—Mr Benjamin Thomas (H.M.).
1889-1892.—Mr Robert Young (H.M.).
1892-1898.—Mr R. Harker (H.M.).
1898-1900.—Rev. A. Ashcroft.
1900-1901.—Rev. R. P. Keall.
1901-1903.—Rev. W. Wills.
1903-1905.—Rev. Amos Reader.
1906-1908.—Rev. C. M. Roberts.
1908-1910.—Rev. Geo. Snadden.
1910-1911.—Rev. C. B. Jordan, B.A.
1911-1912.—Mr J. Harris (H.M.).
1912-1914.—Rev. J. D. McArthur.
1914-1917—Mr C. A. Foston (H.M.).
1917-1919.—Mr A. Nicholls (H.M.).
1919-1923.—Mr C. W. Brown (H.M.).
Some Yesterdays of Motueka Methodism by C.B.Jordan
Wesley Historical Society (NZ) Publication # 10(2) Page 42
1923-1925—Mr W. E. Sleep (H.M.).
1925-1928.—Rev. H. Benny,
1928-1931.—Rev. L. A. G. Brooks.
1931-1933.—Rev. F. T. Harris.
1933-1935.—Rev. F. H. Hayman.
1935-1938.—Rev, J. H. Bailey.
1938-1941.—Rev. H. V. Utting.
1941-1945.—Rev. T. Coatsworth.
1945-1947.—Rev. H. Ford.
1947-1952.—Rev. H. G. Brown (District Chairman).
1952- —Rev. E. Baker.
Circulated by the Wesley Historical Society (New Zealand Branch) by arrangement with Motueka
Trustees as Vol. 10, No. 2. of its proceedinqs.