40

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Page 2: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 2

Acknowledgements

This report studies the impact and relevance of social media in four major HR areas within five industries

with the special focus on Indian market.

We would like to express our deepest gratitude to each one of the CXOs who participated in this survey.

We would also like to thank our colleagues from Global Research Centre for Consulting and other

colleagues from Wipro Limited, specifically Wipro Consulting Services who have helped in bringing out the

final report by ensuring critical review and providing their expert inputs.

Page 3: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 3

Authors

Anupam Pareek

Senior Consultant, Human Capital Management

[email protected]

Pratik Rajiv Jindal

Consultant, Human Capital Management

[email protected]

Santhi Nair

Consultant, Global Research Center for Consulting

[email protected]

Shiv Kumar Muthyala

Manager, Human Capital Management

[email protected]

Disclaimer – The views provided by participating executives are personal and not necessarily of the organization they

represent. The organizations represented by the executives may or may not have participated in the primary research

conducted by Wipro. No part of this paper may be copied or reproduced in any form without the written approval of Wipro

Limited.

Page 4: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 4

Foreword

Over the past few years the meaning of communication and collaboration has taken a whole new dimension.

Organizations are looking at ways of leveraging social media for customer and employee engagement.

This first-of-its-kind India-specific study by Wipro Consulting Services is intended to help CHROs understand the

relevance and impact of social media on Human Resources as a function. While a lot of information is available on

what the CHROs think and perceive about social media, this study goes a step ahead from multiple perspectives –

It captures the critical views of the CXOs and other stakeholders therefore making it holistic

It aims at understanding local issues, thus making it specific to the Indian context

The report successfully captures the readiness of the organizations from a social media perspective

It emphasizes for CXOs key HR areas where social media could be effective.

I hope you find the findings interesting and meaningful. Please do write to us with your observations.

Regards,

Vasudev Murthy

Practice Partner

Functional Consulting

Page 5: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 5

Table of Contents

Executive Summary ________________________________________________________________________ 8

Introduction ______________________________________________________________________________ 10

State of Social Media in Current HR Processes _______________________________________________ 11

Figure 1 Preferences for using Social Media for Internal Branding by Respondent Type _______________ 11

Relevance of Social Media in Business Functions ______________________________________________ 14

Use of Social Media by Organizations ____________________________________________________ 14

Use of Social Media in Business Functions _________________________________________________ 14

Social Media in Human Resources __________________________________________________________ 17

HR Function Most Suited for Social Media_________________________________________________ 17

Preference for using Social Media in HR by Industry _________________________________________ 17

Preference for using of Social Media in HR by Enterprise Size ___________________________________ 17

Preferences for using Social Media in HR by Respondent Type __________________________________ 18

Hiring ___________________________________________________________________________ 18

Preference for using Social Media in Hiring by Industry ______________________________________ 19

Preference for using Social Media in Hiring by Enterprise Size _________________________________ 19

Preferences for using Social Media in Hiring by Respondent Type ______________________________ 19

Collaboration & Communication _______________________________________________________ 20

Preference for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Industry _________________ 20

Preference for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Enterprise Size ____________ 21

Preferences for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Respondent Type _________ 21

Talent Management _________________________________________________________________ 22

Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Industry ____________________________ 22

Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Enterprise Size _______________________ 23

Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Respondent Type _____________________ 23

Internal Branding ___________________________________________________________________ 24

Preference for using Social Media in Internal Branding by Industry ______________________________ 24

Preference for using Social Media in Internal Branding by Enterprise Size _________________________ 25

Preferences for using Social Media for Internal Branding by Respondent Type _____________________ 25

Social Media Readiness in Human Resources _________________________________________________ 26

Social Media Readiness in Hiring ________________________________________________________ 26

Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Industry _____________________________________________ 26

Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Enterprise Size ________________________________________ 27

Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Respondent Type ______________________________________ 27

Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication ___________________________________ 28

Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Industry ________________________ 28

Page 6: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 6

Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Enterprise Size ___________________ 29

Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Respondent Type _________________ 29

Social Media Readiness in Talent Management ______________________________________________ 30

Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Industry ___________________________________ 30

Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Enterprise Size ______________________________ 31

Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Respondent Type ____________________________ 31

Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding ________________________________________________ 32

Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Industry _____________________________________ 32

Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Enterprise Size ________________________________ 32

Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Respondent Type ______________________________ 33

Challenges for using Social Media ___________________________________________________________ 35

Survey Methodology ________________________________________________________________ 39

Survey Universe ___________________________________________________________________ 39

Authors ___________________________________________________________________________________ 4

Page 7: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 7

Table of Figures

Figure 1 Preferences for using Social Media for Internal Branding by Respondent Type ..................................................... 11

Figure 2 Use of Social Media by Organizations ............................................................................................................................... 14

Figure 3 Use of Social Media by industries ....................................................................................................................................... 14

Figure 4 Relevance of Social Media by organization ....................................................................................................................... 15

Figure 5 Relevance of Social Media by industries ............................................................................................................................ 15

Figure 6 Preference for using Social Media in HR by Industry..................................................................................................... 17

Figure 7 Preference for using of Social Media in HR by Enterprise Size ................................................................................... 18

Figure 8 Preferences for using Social Media in HR by Respondent Type ................................................................................. 18

Figure 9 Preference for using Social Media in Hiring by Industry ............................................................................................... 19

Figure 10 Preference for using Social Media in Hiring by Enterprise ......................................................................................... 19

Figure 11 Preferences for using Social Media in Hiring by Respondent Type .......................................................................... 20

Figure 12 Preference for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Industry ........................................ 21

Figure 13 Preference for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Enterprise Size ........................... 21

Figure 14 Preferences for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Respondent Type .................... 22

Figure 15 Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Industry .................................................................... 23

Figure 16 Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Enterprise Size ....................................................... 23

Figure 17 Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Respondent Type .................................................. 24

Figure 18 Preference for using Social Media in Internal Branding by Industry ......................................................................... 25

Figure 19 Preference for using Social Media in Internal Branding by Enterprise Size ............................................................ 25

Figure 20 Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Industry ................................................................................................................ 27

Figure 21 Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Enterprise Size .................................................................................................... 27

Figure 22 Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Respondent Type ............................................................................................... 28

Figure 23 Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Industry ........................................................... 29

Figure 24 Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Enterprise Size............................................... 29

Figure 25 Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Respondent Type ......................................... 30

Figure 26 Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Industry ....................................................................................... 30

Figure 27 Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Enterprise Size ........................................................................... 31

Figure 28 Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Respondent Type...................................................................... 31

Figure 29 Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Industry ............................................................................................ 32

Figure 30 Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Enterprise Size ............................................................................... 33

Figure 31 Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Respondent Type .......................................................................... 33

Figure 32 Challenges for using Social Media..................................................................................................................................... 35

Figure 33 Respondent Profile .............................................................................................................................................................. 39

Figure 34 Respondent Profile .............................................................................................................................................................. 39

Figure 35 Figure 33 Respondent Profile ............................................................................................................................................ 39

Page 8: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 8

Executive Summary

One out of every nine people in the world use Facebook, with an estimated 700 billion minutes being spent every

month on this application, it is interesting to note that over 2.5 million organizations have a Facebook presence in

addition to their corporate websites. An estimated 250 million people access social media sites through their mobile

devices. The impact that social media has on the daily lives of people is beyond “like” on Facebook or “re-tweet” on

Twitter. Organizations are feeling the need to be present on not just one social media platform, however, on

ensuring that they are “available and listening” to all at all times. Commenting on the role of social media in an

interview to the Harvard Business Review, Howard Schlutz (CEO – Starbucks) mentioned –“….Whether you are

creating a brand, building one, or running a big one, you‟d better understand social media, because there is a seismic shift in

how people are gaining access to information and, as a result, how they are behaving.”

It is essential to note that the mechanics of employee engagement in conventional human resources is slowly but

surely changing. The need is to communicate faster, provide a platform for presenting views and information,

connect with larger groups and most importantly provide an environment for a free and transparent mode of

interaction. This need is growing and is greater today than earlier. With Gen Y taking on the people management

roles in which they influence the decisions in the organizations, it is becoming even more important to consider the

use of relevant modes which they could relate with. With the growing influence of Gen Y on organizations it has

been observed that organizations which have social media presence are viewed by them as more conducive to open

information sharing than others.

HR Consulting arm of Wipro Limited conducted a seminal study to understand the impact and relevance of social

media in Human Resources in year 2011 – 2012. The findings provide immense insight into the “shift in

organizational behavior” from traditional methods of communication and collaboration to a widespread need for

real-time, innovative methods to reach a large number of employees with similar or dissimilar interests. A majority

of leading organizations in India are venturing into the new pastures for employee communication, engagement,

collaboration and other areas of human resources. However, a great amount of insecurity and ambiguity still exists

from an information security perspective. Organizations are embracing social media for various reasons and some

are doing so, because „they wish to be there because their competition does so‟. Social media is trendy to some and

a necessity to the others. With generation Z entering the active workforce, the need to be on social media is

assuming greater importance from a human resources perspective.

Key findings:

63% of the CXOs use social media in their respective industries, though this is not indicative of the extent of usage and

effectiveness

Majority of the CXOs are in agreement with the fact that social media is relevant and the usage should be

emphasized upon to gain maximum of it

Social media continues to remain a major tool for organizations to reach their customers and employees, however,

marketing and sales leads the way, followed by human resources and corporate social responsibility

Majority of the organizations use social media in human resources. However, they also agree that it has not been

tapped to the maximum. It is used disparately and inconsistently, however, organizations are confident that they will be

using social media better in the future to be ahead of the competition

Leadership in majority of the organizations have shown keen interest in usage of social media in the areas of Internal

Branding, Collaboration & Communication, and Hiring

Hiring emerged as the only area where organizations were found to be social media ready

Data security emerged as the number one impediment to implementing or using social media platforms, closely

followed by perceived lack of organizational maturity and monitoring capabilities

Page 9: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 9

The survey indicates that social media can have a considerable impact on HR processes, specifically in the Internal

Branding function that is considered a key activity of HR. The recruitment process too provides ample opportunities

to organizations to adopt social media platforms.

This trend has been observed by CHROs and they echo our finding - “It is noteworthy that today the majority of the

population employed in organizations are in the Gen Y category (mostly people born after 1982)....this is the population that

wants things done fast and is almost impatient to scale heights and make things happen for themselves. Interacting via Social

media today has become a habit to many and employers who give the employees freedom to access social media at the

workplace are perceived as more open and this in turn is a great engagement booster; needless to say – social media is today

used by most recruiting engines of organizations to acquire talent and to project desired organizational and brand image.”

remarks Rohit Dhody, Head – HR (Mach Mobile Solutions Pvt Ltd)

Page 10: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 10

Introduction

During the fourth quarter of 2011, Wipro Consulting Services conducted a study on the use of social media in select

business processes. This seminal study conducted across 150 companies from five verticals, was conducted with the

objective of understanding how organizations respond to the challenges and opportunities provided by social media

in terms of using it in their key functional processes. In addition, the study sought to understand the readiness of

these organizations to adopt social media in their day to day businesses. Understanding how pervasive social media is

in today‟s business and how it is perceived across industries and organizations, and whether the seniority of

respondents has any bearing on all of this is not just fascinating for its own sake, but for the implications it holds for

these businesses.

Our survey took into account four types of social media platforms:

1. Networking sites: Sites such as Facebook, LinkedIn that allow individuals with similar social or business

interests to share ideas and connect.

2. Blogging sites: BlogSpot or Twitter that enable individuals to present their thoughts to a wider audience.

3. Information sharing sites: Slide share or YouTube that help individuals share and collaborate content.

4. Organization-specific forums: Intranet, discussion boards, and other forums that encourage communication

among employees.

Our study focused on exploring the use of Social Media in HR processes. The outcomes show that not all functions

within Human Resources are suited for social media. Hiring, Communication and Collaboration, Talent Management,

and Internal Branding are suitable for using social media. Compensation and Benefits and Performance Management

deal with confidential information where social-media may not be considered useful and so were out of scope.

Our report follows this structure, which is self-explanatory:

i. State of Social Media in Current HR Practices- Outlines key findings

ii. Social Media in Human Resources

iii. Social Media Readiness

iv. Challenges for using Social Media

v. Conclusion

vi. Survey Methodology (Appendix)

vii. Survey Universe (Appendix)

“…Individuals are able to find more than just personal reasons to stay hooked on to a social media sites – employment and

business opportunities increase. While one is able to find resources when needed, employers have been able to weed off

employees who do not embrace its culture.” Ramesh Rajan, Assistant Vice President, Barclays Bank

Page 11: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 11

State of Social Media in Current HR Processes

The survey showed that both with respect to preferences and conviction of the respondents, the areas within HR, as

far as use of social media in those areas was concerned, were ranked as shown in the figure alongside.

Social Media platforms can be used in four major HR areas: Hiring, Collaboration and Communication, Talent

Management, and Internal Branding. Our survey has shown that within Hiring, works such as Sourcing, Pre-joining

Engagement are preferred for use of these platforms. In Collaboration and Communication, Technical Discussions

and Employee Recognition were considered fit for use of social media, while Organizational or Policy

Communication and Virtual Meetings did not find favor. Talent Management as a whole was not favored for use of

social media, while Internal Branding was considered fit for such use. Here Thought Leadership and Employer

Branding were deemed suitable for social media.

While individual industries considered suitability of social media in the main HR areas and its subordinate functions,

based on the requirements and characteristics of their industries, it was clear that Hiring, Internal Branding and

Collaboration and Communication found favor in these industries. This finding is of great significance for enterprises

that are examining an opening for introducing social media in the organization. It helps them to examine

requirements and develop suitable social media-based solutions that deliver value to their clients.

Figure 1 Preferences for using Social Media for Internal Branding by Respondent Type

61%

53%

56%

65%

61%

68%

71%

63%

66%

50.00%

55.00%

60.00%

65.00%

70.00%

Employer Branding Employee Branding Thought Leadership

Decision Maker

Influencer

Implementor

Indian organizations are opening up to the idea of usage of social media

for reaching out to the employees. Indian CXOs still hold reservations

about usage of social media for hiring and seem more comfortable with

the more traditional methods like job portals, employee referrals, walk-

ins etc. However, with increased pressure on CHROs to keep a check on

recruitment budgets, they are exploring more social media options and

we will see a greater momentum in this area in India. Companies

continue to use intranet portal for internal branding and do not seem

very open to using publicly available social media websites.

Page 12: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 12

However, decisions on investments and the best recourse for organizations are taken by those at the helm or those

vested with the responsibility of advising based on their expertise. We noted that in the organizations that we

surveyed Decision Makers appeared reluctant to use social media. An example of their thinking can be seen from

their responses to use of social media for Internal Branding. Implementers appeared to be most enthusiastic.

However they have little say in decisions at this stage, but in the future this generation will be at the helm and

hopefully will be open to new ideas then. Strangely though, these Decision Makers appeared quite eager when the

readiness of these functions to social media usage was assessed.

“Employee satisfaction surveys are very common. Social media can in a big way augment this exercise by providing some of

the indicators and criteria perceived to be important by a generation of employees across the sector or just a particular

region/location, or by employees of a particular company, so on & so forth. Again, how well is the HR in the company designed

as of today to use that information available on social media sources to initiate action?” Dr Prabhakara Raya, Professor and

Head of Department – Management Studies, Pondicherry University

Page 13: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 13

Social Media & Business

Page 14: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 14

Relevance of Social Media in Business Functions

At the outset, it was important to understand the perceived relevance and usage of social media in business

processes of the five industries. Employees from the five verticals gave their views on the queries raised.

Use of Social Media by Organizations

Of the 150 respondents, 63 percent agreed that social media was used in business processes in their industry. This

concurrence of a rather large proportion of the respondents, establishes the use of social media in organizations.

However, a little less than a third of the respondents disputed this idea. The use of social media was then analyzed

across the five industry verticals to see if this varied by industry and how.80 percent of respondents from IT/ITES,

and around two-thirds from Telecom– both hi-tech industries, agreed that social media was used in their processes.

Strangely, 37 percent of respondents from BFSI and Retail– both industries where personnel interact a lot with end-

customers and one would assume a natural setting for the use of social media, believed that social media is not

widely used in their industry.

Figure 2 Use of Social Media by Organizations

Figure 3 Use of Social Media by industries

Use of Social Media in Business Functions

It is clear from the responses that Marketing and Sales is the main area where social media is used by

organizations (72 percent across industries. This is closely followed by the Human Resources function (56 percent

across industries. The responses favoring these two areas are by and large uniform across verticals, and

understandably so. In addition to Marketing and Sales and HR, CSR and Customer Services are the two other areas

where social media appears to get a favorable response, which is fairly corroborated by the responses from each

vertical.

63%

27%

10%

50%

80%

60%

57%

67%

37%

13%

27%

37%

23%

13%

7%

13%

7%

10%

BFSI

IT & ITES

Manufacturing

Retail

Telecom

Yes No Not Sure

Marketing & Sales,

72%

HR, 56%

CSR, 33%

Customer

Services, 28%

Operations, 9%

Product

Development/

innovation, 18%

IT, 17%

OCM, 10%

Page 15: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 15

It is not surprising to observe that Information Technology and Information Technology Enabled Services companies

are paving the way for usage of social media in human resources. It is surprising to note that the retail sector which

traditionally boasts of high usage of social media in marketing and sales lies low in human resources. This study in

fact shows that among the various industries, the manufacturing sector uses maximum amount of social media

channels for marketing & sales and minimum in human resources. While this may be attributed to the nature of

workforce and the relevance in such a setting, it has not been established as to why retails still lags behind in

maturity from a social media usage perspective in human resources.

Relevance of Social Media

The respondents rated the relevance of social media in their organizations. across industries, 42 percent of the

respondents believed social media were highly relevant, and a close 31 percent believed it was somewhat relevant to

their industry.

Figure 4 Relevance of Social Media by

organization

Figure 5 Relevance of Social Media by industries

In a reversal of sorts, while a little over a third of respondents from retail thought social media was not used

currently, half of them believed social media has a high relevance to their industry, while a little over half (54

percent) from Telecom felt it had little relevance. Close to half (46.6 percent) of BFSI respondents agreed with the

majority of their counterparts from Telecom and only a third felt it was quite relevant for BFSI. In IT/ITES an equal

number believed social media was highly relevant or were ambivalent about it.

Low, 27%

Medium,

31%

High, 42%

47%

13%

33%

20%

23%

20%

43%

27%

30%

33%

33%

43%

40%

50%

43%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80%

BFSI

IT & ITES

Manufacturi

ng

Retail

Telecom

Low Medium High

Page 16: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 16

Social Media & Human Resources

Page 17: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 17

Social Media in Human Resources

HR Function Most Suited for Social Media After examining the relevance of social media in current organizational functions and processes, it was the turn of

HR functions to be similarly examined. Overall, the respondents were reasonably open to using social media in HR.

Of the four HR areas –Internal Branding, Talent Management, Collaboration and Communication and Hiring; three

areas: Internal Branding Collaboration and Communication and Hiring were considered almost equally suited for use

of social media, with Internal Branding favored the most. Talent Management was deemed least suited among these

for using social media. (Refer figure 1)

Preference for using Social Media in HR by Industry Understandably the respondents of different industries differed in their preferences for HR processes that could use

social media. As can be observed in the graphs below, Hiring and Internal Branding were the two functions favored

in BFSI with Hiring ranked a little higher, whereas Telecom gave almost equal preference to all with Talent

Management favored better than the rest. Collaboration and Communication was ranked the top, followed by

Internal Branding, in IT/ITES whereas Internal Branding and Hiring were given same preference in the Manufacturing

industry.

Figure 6 Preference for using Social Media in HR by Industry

Preference for using of Social Media in HR by Enterprise Size In large enterprises, Internal Branding (IB) was considered most ideal; of the four HR functions, for use of social

media, followed by Collaboration and Communication, and then by hiring. However, these preferences varied in

medium and small enterprises. Medium-sized enterprises favored Hiring (Hi) and then Collaboration and

Communication(C&C). Small enterprises ranked Collaboration and Communication quite high, with the other HR

functions polling almost the same number of responses.

68%

57%

60%

66%

63%63%

70%

58%

64%

63%

56% 56% 57%

63%

67%68%

60%

63%

62%

52%

57%

62%

67%

72%

BFSI IT&ITES Manufacturing Retail Telecom

Page 18: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 18

Figure 7 Preference for using of Social Media in HR by Enterprise Size

Preferences for using Social Media in HR by Respondent Type As can be expected, the position, power and role of the respondent influenced the choices made for HR functions

deemed suitable for use of social media. For Decision Makers, Internal Branding appeared most suited for use of

social media, with Hiring and Collaboration and Communication following close together. Influencers considered

Collaboration and Communication followed by Hiring as the most suitable for social media. While Implementers

chose Hiring, Internal Branding and Collaboration and Communication, in that order.

Figure 8 Preferences for using Social Media in HR by Respondent Type

Hiring Any organization needs to have the right mix of talent in order to thrive. For this to happen, organizations must be

able to attract and retain the best, making hiring such a critical process. The three sub-processes within this function

are:

1. Sourcing

2. Pre-joining Engagement

3. Induction and Orientation

Though it is implicitly assumed that social media platforms are most useful in Hiring, during the course of our survey

we found that respondents were a little apprehensive about using these platforms for Hiring. Among the functions

within Hiring, Sourcing was most preferred by the respondents, closely followed by Pre-joining Engagement, and

Induction and Orientation, for use of social media.

59%64%

70%67%

64%

57%

63%61%

63% 61% 61%

52%

57%

62%

67%

72%

77%

Hi C & C T M I B

Large Medium Small

59%60%

57%

69%

65%

72%

55%

59%

65%

61%

58%

62%

52%

57%

62%

67%

72%

Hiring Collaboration &

Communication

Talent Management Internal Branding

Decision Makers Influencer's Implementors

”…this positive movement may be attributed to the return

of war for talent post the recession combined with the

perennial economic instability in the world…”

Implementer Influencers

Page 19: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 19

Preference for using Social Media in Hiring by Industry

When the responses were examined by type of industry, the order of preference of respondents across all five

industries was similar, as before– Sourcing was highly favored, followed by Pre- joining Engagement, and later by

Induction and Orientation.

Figure 9 Preference for using Social Media in Hiring by Industry

Preference for using Social Media in Hiring by Enterprise Size

Across the three broad groups of enterprises when classified by size, Sourcing was unequivocally chosen for use of

social media, followed closely by Pre-Joining Engagement, and Induction and Orientation, in that order.

Figure 10 Preference for using Social Media in Hiring by Enterprise

Preferences for using Social Media in Hiring by Respondent Type

As seen earlier in the section „Preferences by Respondent Type,‟ people up the hierarchy appeared relatively reluctant

to use social media for Hiring, preferring to use it either for Internal Branding or Collaboration and Communication.

Implementers appeared to be most enthusiastic about using it for Hiring. As seen in the graph below, Implementers

again appeared the most enthusiastic (though the differences are marginal) about using social media in all three

functions within HR, as compared to their colleagues higher up the hierarchy. Whether these differences in

disposition can be explained by differences in age, experience and exposure to social media is something that may

have to be examined on some other occasion.

60%

64%

58%57% 58%

51%

57%

49%52%

55%

45%

50% 48% 48%

54%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

55%

60%

65%

70%

BFSI IT & ITES Manufacturing Retail Telecom

Sourcing Pre- Joining Engagement Induction & Orientation

62%

44%

31%

59%

41%

29%

57%

40%

28%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

55%

60%

65%

70%

Sourcing Pre- Joining Engagement Induction & Orientation

Large Medium Small

Page 20: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 20

Figure 11 Preferences for using Social Media in Hiring by Respondent Type

Collaboration & Communication

According to Gartner press release 20111 by 2014, social networking sites will replace email as the primary mode

for interpersonal communication for 20 percent of business users. Collaboration and Communication is integral to

organizational operations today, and is hence a promising area for using social media platforms. For the purpose of

this study we considered four modes of collaboration or communications commonly used, namely: Organizational Communications

Virtual Meetings

Technical Discussions

Employee Recognition

When respondents were asked to decide on areas in Collaboration and Communication suitable for social media,

they highly recommended Employee Recognition, closely followed by Technical Discussions and then by

Organizational or Policy Communication. Virtual Meetings were least preferred for such use.

Preference for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Industry

When the responses were examined by nature of the industry, on an average, Technical Discussions and Employee

Recognition were favored over the other areas. Responses from Manufacturing; where Virtual Meetings were given

preference, varied a little. However, here too Technical Discussions and Employee Recognition were considered fit

1Gartner Press Release

0.58

0.41

0.28

59%

40%

29%

61%

42%

30%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

50%

55%

60%

65%

Sourcing Pre- Joining Engagement Induction & Orientation

Decision Maker Influencer Implementor

“Social Media has helped us increase our reach. Today, candidates do not have to fill-up long winded forms on job portals. They

have to merely follow or like and the requirements come to them. This is a significant shift in the way sourcing takes place.”

- Vijay Sivaram, Head – ITES – Ikya Global

“…almost negligible number of companies in India use

Social Media for Organizational Change Management, the

concept of change management still eludes Indian Inc.,

organizations still wish to use the “stick” than the “carrot”

approach. ..”

It is interesting to note that there is little variation in the manner in which differently sized enterprises have embraced

or are willing to embrace social media for hiring purposes. Evidently, the larger and more mature organizations with

sophisticated technology lead the pack, however, the size of the organization does not deter the human resources

department from wanting to use social media. This positive movement may be attributed to the return of war for

talent post the recession combined with the perennial economic instability in the world leading to squeezed budgets

and increased pressure on recruitment heads to look for creative methods to source candidates. HR departments do

not wish to leave no stone unturned to be available where the talent pool is. There seems to be poor traction in the

use of social media in pre-joining joining engagement and induction & orientation. Many organizations in India are

experimenting with the idea of using social media for pre-joining and induction & orientation, however, they seem

concerned about sharing best practices on the public domain. Certain IT organizations, still resort to the traditional

methods like e-mail and sending pre-joining welcome kits via courier. IT \ ITES companies seem to use social media

most for sourcing of candidates, followed by BFSI, the retail sector continues to rank low

Page 21: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 21

for such use for the responses are almost same across all the areas. The tradition-bound, BFSI appeared the most

averse to use of social media for Virtual Meetings- though the differences in percentage points is not that big, when

compared to other verticals. Employee Recognition is clearly the area where use of social media will be very

acceptable across these verticals.

Figure 12 Preference for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Industry

Preference for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Enterprise Size

When the responses were examined by size of the enterprise, it wasn‟t surprising that Technical Discussions and

Employee Recognition; areas where enterprises generally support a broadcast to the widest audience possible

(internal or external, depending on nature of the topic being publicized), were favored across the enterprises.

Relatively, enterprises were loath to use social media either for Organizational or Policy Communications or Virtual

Meetings. However, large enterprises appeared to be more favorably inclined to such use, as against the other two

types of enterprises.

Figure 13 Preference for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Enterprise Size

Preferences for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Respondent Type

The section „Preferences of using Social Media in HR by Respondent Type‟ has shown us that people up the hierarchy

appeared relatively reluctant to use social media for Hiring, preferring to use it either for Internal Branding or

Collaboration and Communication. However, it is clear from the graph above that Decision Makers were the most

reluctant, when compared to the other groups, in using social media in all the modes of Collaboration and

Communication, as well. It is known from „Preferences by Respondent Type‟ that Influencers were utterly in favor of

using social media for Collaboration and Communication, but we see them supporting all modes – especially

Technical Discussions and Employee Recognition. The Implementers shared almost the same degree of enthusiasm

as the Influencers.

47%49%

52%

48% 49%

43%

49%

55%

46%

50%52%

59%

51%

53%

56%56%54%

53%52%

56%

42%

47%

52%

57%

BFSI IT & ITES Manufacturing Retail Telecom

Organization Or Policy Communication Virtual Meetings Technical Discussion Employee Recognition

51%53%

53% 53%

48% 48%

54% 54%

49%

47%

55% 55%

42%

47%

52%

57%

Organization Or Policy

Communication

Virtual Meetings Technical Discussion Employee Recognition

Large Medium Small

Page 22: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 22

Figure 14 Preferences for using Social Media in Collaboration and Communication by Respondent Type

Talent Management We wanted to determine whether Talent Management was one of the areas in HR where social media platforms

could be used effectively. However, we had seen earlier that the respondents were most apprehensive about using

social media for this function. We considered four areas under Talent Management:

Training

Leadership Development

Mentorship

Employee Engagement

Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Industry

When the responses are examined by industry, it appears as though there is consistency in the way they all view the

relevance of social media in all the four areas of Talent Management. Broadly, they are all in agreement that Training

and Employee Engagement are better placed for such use, but Leadership Development appears to score marginally-

that is, if we can say this given the near uniformity of the responses, over Mentorship. Given that Talent Management

was disapproved roundly for use of social media and the near uniformity in responses, analysing this view further

would serve little purpose.

47%46%

50% 50%50% 50%

58% 58%

49%50%

55% 55%

42%

47%

52%

57%

Organization Or Policy

Communication

Virtual Meetings Technical Discussion Employee Recognition

Decision Maker Influencer Implementor

Organizations have expressed keenness in using social media platforms actively in the area of collaboration & communication.

Our study found that the results are extremely different from what one may expect. The manufacturing sector seems to be

more open to using social media in all areas – Organizational or policy communication, virtual meetings, technical discussions

and employee recognition followed by the telecom sector. One area where employers are consistently keen on using social

media is in the area of employee recognition, while this is not common in the current day, however, we expect to active

employee engagement activities on this platform. While LinkedIn‟s “recommendation” had initiated this trend many years

back in some form, however, Facebook and Twitter have taken this to the next level. If one were to observe the linking of

social media tools like Facebook, LinkedIn or Twitter, it becomes evident that today employers have an option to recognize

their employees on multiple platforms using simple and flexible techniques. Will gen Z embrace this form of recognition or are

will they look forward to recognition elements like their predecessors is something Human Resource professionals need to

think now.

"

“While social media policies are important, they

should help foster a culture of open communication

and not restrict employees”

Page 23: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 23

Figure 15 Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Industry

Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Enterprise Size

Use of social media was favored across enterprises of all sizes in the areas Employee Engagement and Training.

Leadership Development and Mentorship were relatively less preferred for such use. Employee Engagement was

most favored of all the areas for use of social media. Of course, respondents of medium-sized enterprises appeared

less enthusiastic than the others, especially their counterparts in larger enterprises.

Figure 16 Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Enterprise Size

Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Respondent Type

In Talent Management too, Decision Makers continued displaying their general wariness about the use of social

media; though the differences in percentages were not too high, while Influencers appeared the most enthusiastic.

The general enthusiasm shown for using social media in Employee Engagement and in Training was shared here as

well.

51%

54% 54%

48%

53%

48%

51% 51%

47%

50%

47% 47%

50%

48%

50%

53%

57%

51%51% 51%

40%

45%

50%

55%

60%

BFSI IT & ITES Manufacturing Retail Telecom

Training Leadership Development Mentorship Employee Engagement

53%51%

49%

57%

50% 49% 48%50%

54%

49% 48%

52%

42%

47%

52%

57%

Training Leadership Development Mentorship Employee Engagement

Large Medium Small

Page 24: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 24

Figure 17 Preference for using Social Media in Talent Management by Respondent Type

Internal Branding Internal Branding refers to showcasing capabilities of the organization, within the organization. We considered three

areas within this function:

Employer Branding

Employee Branding

Thought Leadership

In section „Use of Social Media in Business Functions‟ of chapter „Relevance of Social Media in Current Business Processes,‟ it

was seen that the respondents believed that social media was most suitable for Marketing, and then for HR activities.

Internal Branding is a combination of both Marketing and HR, and possibly preferred among all HR functions for use

of social media, along with Collaboration and Communication. The respondents preferred using social media for

Employer Branding, followed by Thought Leadership.

Preference for using Social Media in Internal Branding by Industry

When examined for variations across responses by nature of industry, it was seen that Employer Branding and

Thought Leadership were considered more suitable than Employee Branding for using social media. In IT and ITES

52%

47%46%

50%

52% 52%51%

56%

52%

49% 50%52%

40%

45%

50%

55%

60%

Training Leadership Development Mentorship Employee Engagement

Decision Maker Influencer Implementor

“Avaya web.alive™ is an online, immersive conferencing and collaboration environment that lets you communicate with others

as though you were face to face. Avaya web.alive supports enterprise-wide collaboration, learning and training, and e-

commerce. We use it extensively for various internal meetings/training programs.” says Govindaraj Ramachandran, Head

Staffing and Talent Management, Avaya. Our research reflects his point of view, talent management ranks low in the

preference from a social media usage perspective. Indian organizations use social media for talent management purposes,

however, are still treading the path of tool available on public domain with caution. Avaya a global provider of telecom solutions

uses its internally developed social media tools to actively engage employees. This telecom major uses tools like youconnect,

mindshare.avaya.com and web.ally to engage employees better. We believe that social media is a platform and it depends on

how one would like to tap into this. Wipro Limited uses its dedicated online intranet portal which it calls “Channel W” W

stands for Wipro for this purpose. This tool on an average receives over 16,000 active blogs, 1,16,000 active members, 3700

active discussions etc. Wipro in fact has created a community called MyWipro World and employees are encouraged to access

their Facebook and Twitter accounts through this. Wipro was among the first few companies to formulate a social media

policy, however, Wipro has believed that policies are meant to provide guidelines and not restrain employees, it believes that if

it is in the true sense an organization which believes in social media then they ought to trust its employees and engage them

through this trust and this is in true sense employee engagement.

“I believe that the greatest impact that social media will have will be in the area of talent management – sourcing,

engagement and retention – we will witness higher levels of „socialization‟ of employee life-cycle management” says NT

Arunkumar, UBS Investment Bank.

Page 25: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 25

and Telecom, this was quite evident and so was the case in Manufacturing. Respondents from BFSI appeared to

consider all three areas equally suited for social media usage.

Figure 18 Preference for using Social Media in Internal Branding by Industry

Preference for using Social Media in Internal Branding by Enterprise Size

When the responses were examined considering the size of the enterprises, it was seen that large and small

enterprises were keen on using social Medias compared to medium-sized enterprises in the areas within Internal

Branding. The responses showed that Employer Branding received greater support than Thought Leadership, when

considering suitability of social media, cutting across all sizes of enterprises.

Figure 19 Preference for using Social Media in Internal Branding by Enterprise Size

Preferences for using Social Media for Internal Branding by Respondent Type

In the section „Preferences by Respondent Type,‟ we saw earlier that Decision Makers were most enthusiastic about

using social media for Internal Branding. However, when their responses are examined for the three functions within

Internal Branding, one can see that their circumspection was unabated. They were least enthusiastic about using

social media in any of the three functions within Internal Branding. Implementers were the most enthusiastic, while

Influencers followed closely. However, overall these groups were in agreement with the general finding that these

platforms were considered most suited for Employer Branding and Thought Leadership, over Employee Branding.

(Refer Figure 2 in section set of Social Media in Current HR processes)

68%66%

61%

65%67%

65%

61%

54% 55%

59%

67% 67%

59%

56%

66%

50%

55%

60%

65%

70%

BFSI IT & ITES Manufacturing Retail Telecom

Employer Branding Employee Branding Thought Leadership

66%

60%

65%63%

56%

61%

68%

61%64%

40%

45%

50%

55%

60%

65%

70%

Employer Branding Employee Branding Thought Leadership

Large Medium Small

Implementers who are predominantly from Gen Y or Gen Z are more open to using social media for internal

branding purposes; however, decision makers seem to be on the other end of the spectrum. While it may be

incorrect to generalize that this is a common phenomenon across organizations, it has to be noted that there will

be seismic shift in openness to usage of social media with churn in leadership across organizations.

Page 26: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 26

Social Media Readiness in Human Resources

After ascertaining how relevant social media was to some of the HR functions, it was important to assess the

readiness of these organizations to using social media. Social media readiness was determined by considering three

factors:

1. Usage of social media platforms

2. Willingness or openness to use

3. Capability to implement

Social media usage was determined from the extent they were used in different business processes. Willingness or

openness to using these platforms was determined by assessing the extent to which these organizations were

receptive to such use. The number of resources available with the organizations to implement social media platforms

for various HR processes was used as an indicator of the capability to implement.

We have seen in „Relevance of Social Media in Current Business Processes‟ that the use of social media in organizations is

moderate ─only 63 percent of the respondents agree that social media was being used in their industry. Around 42

percent feel that social media is highly relevant; while close to 31 percent feel it is moderately relevant to their

industry. How ready then, are the HR departments to using social media across industries?

Social Media Readiness in Hiring The Hiring function of organizations appeared equipped to use social media with 63 percent using such platforms, 74

percent willing to use social media and 64 percent capable of implementing social media platforms.

Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Industry It is not surprising that in the industry that spawned the social media frenzy, social media is very acceptable for use in

Hiring and the capabilities to implement it also exist. IT & ITES organizations were most equipped and likely to use

social media. Similarly, Telecom employees appeared open to using these tools in Hiring and indicated that two-third

of their processes used social media, though their capabilities were moderate. Manufacturing enterprises too

reported moderate use of social media but they were more open to using these tools (almost three-fourth favored

its use) and two-thirds of their resources could implement such tools ─ quite high for a sector that otherwise does

not use IT as much, or have just begun to use it. While just half of BFSI respondents agreed that social media was

being used, over three-fourth of them were agreeable to its use even though they had moderate capabilities. In a

sector that has rigid processes and has to take into account regulatory dictates in many operational processes, this

willingness to use social media in HR is encouraging.

14% 44% 60%

Respondents willing and capable to

use social media

Respondents willing to use social

media

Respondents having capability to

use social media

Page 27: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 27

Figure 20 Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Industry

Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Enterprise Size

As might be expected, Large and Medium enterprises displayed relatively greater capability to implement social

media applications and platforms in Hiring. They also reported marginally higher usage of such platforms, though the

overall usage is itself moderate. Strangely though, for all their abilities, large enterprises were least enthusiastic about

using social media as compared to the other two types of enterprises. Both Medium and Small enterprises were

quite keen on implementing social media platforms.

Figure 21 Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Enterprise Size

Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Respondent Type

While we have seen earlier that Decision Makers were most reluctant to using social media in various HR functions,

strangely, they were the most open to using social media and also demonstrated relatively better capability than the

others to implementing these tools. Relatively greater number of them also reported better use of social media.

50%

80%

60%

57%

67%

77%

83%

73%

63%

70%

57%

80%

67%

53%

60%

40%

45%

50%

55%

60%

65%

70%

75%

80%

85%

90%

BFSI IT & ITES Manufacturing Retail Telecom

Usage Openness Capability

63% 63%65%65%

77%

65%

60%

78%

60%

55%

60%

65%

70%

75%

80%

Usage Openness Capability

Large Medium Small

Page 28: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 28

Figure 22 Social Media Readiness in Hiring by Respondent Type

Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication It was noted that in the area Collaboration and Communication too organizations were ready to use social media, in

the sense that they were using these platforms and were open to use it. However, they were hampered by the fact

that only 51 percent had the capability to implement these platforms.

Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Industry

Most respondents were unsure of their competence to implement social media platforms for Collaboration and

Communication. Understandably, IT & ITES and Telecom indicated high levels of use, with Manufacturing and Retail

following them, in that order. Strangely though, Telecom was the least open to using these platforms, while BFSI,

which reported lowest usage levels, was the most enthusiastic about using these platforms. This odd quality of BFSI

was also seen in the Hiring area. Retail, Telecom, BFSI and Manufacturing were unsure of their ability to implement

these platforms. However, strangely enough, IT & ITES too were relatively unsure as the others. This was in stark

contrast to Hiring, where they were confident of their capability.

69%

83%

69%

58%

79%

60%60% 58% 60%

50%55%60%65%70%75%80%85%90%

Usage Openness Capability

Decision Maker Influencer Implementor

18% 7% 44%

Respondents willing and capable to

use social media

Respondents willing to use social

media

Respondents having capability to

use social media

Page 29: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 29

Figure 23 Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Industry

Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Enterprise Size

Large and Medium-sized enterprises appeared open to using social media for Collaboration and Communication and

were also reported moderately high levels of current use. The capability to implement social media platforms for

Collaboration and Communication was however, deemed relatively low across the three types of enterprises.

Figure 24 Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Enterprise Size

Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Respondent Type

Remarkably, here too Decision Makers appeared to be at the forefront (relative to their colleagues in other levels),

accepting social media, and quite positive about current use and capability to implement. This is in stark contrast to

the attitude at this level, as noted by their responses in the previous chapter. Implementers were unwavering in their

support and belief in the capabilities of the organization, while Influencers doubted capabilities, but were open to

such platforms.

50%

80%

60%57%

67%70%

67% 67%

60%

47%50%

57%53%

47% 47%

40%45%50%55%60%65%70%75%80%85%

BFSI IT & ITES Manufacturing Retail Telecom

Usage Openness Capability

63% 63%

53%

65%67%

50%

60%

56%

50%

45%

50%

55%

60%

65%

70%

Usage Openness Capability

Large Medium Small

Page 30: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 30

Figure 25 Social Media Readiness in Collaboration and Communication by Respondent Type

Social Media Readiness in Talent Management We have seen earlier that respondents were not encouraging about using social media in Talent Management (only

37 percent); while just 31 percent believed that they had the capability to implement social media for Talent

Management in their organizations.

Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Industry

Of all the industries only IT & ITES stated they used social media to a considerable extent in this area and were open

to using it further, though they were not sure of their capability to implement. The other industries were unwilling

to use social media and extremely unsure of their capabilities as well.

Figure 26 Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Industry

69%67%

52%

58%

63%

47%

60%57%

53%

40%

45%

50%

55%

60%

65%

70%

Usage Openness Capability

Decision Maker Influencer Implementor

1/2

3/54/7

2/3

23%

67%

30% 30%33%30%

50%

23% 20%

33%

20%25%30%35%40%45%50%55%60%65%70%

BFSI IT & ITES Manufacturing Retail Telecom

Usage Openness Capability

15% 9% 22%

Respondents willing and capable to

use Social media

Respondents willing to use social

media

Respondents having capability to

use social media

Page 31: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 31

Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Enterprise Size

While all three types of enterprises (by size) indicated that social media was used for Talent Management in their

organizations, they weren‟t that open to using it further. In this regard Large enterprises were relatively most averse,

but reasonably sure of their capabilities in comparison to the other two. Small enterprises were the least sure of

their capabilities, but more open to further use of social media in this area.

Figure 27 Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Enterprise Size

Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Respondent Type

Here too, Decision Makers were the most positive group, backing use of social media in Talent Management, when

compared to the others. They indicated that social media was in use currently in some areas of Talent Management

and believed this was in more areas than their counterparts in the other levels believed. They were relatively more

open to the idea of using it further and were less doubtful of capabilities. Influencers, on the whole, appeared the

most cynical of the lot, while the Implementers tread the fine middle ground.

Figure 28 Social Media Readiness in Talent Management by Respondent Type

63%

30%

40%

2/3

1/3 1/3

60%

46%

24%

20%25%30%35%40%45%50%55%60%65%

Usage Openness Capability

Large Medium Small

69%

43%39%

58%

35%

28%

63%

37%31%

20%25%30%35%40%45%50%55%60%65%70%

Usage Openness Capability

Decision Maker Influencer Implementor

Page 32: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 32

Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding Though respondents were very much for using social media for Internal Branding, in terms of readiness they ranked

three in this area out of the four areas. Only 57 percent of the respondents were willing to use social media for

Internal Branding, and only around half (53 percent) of the respondents believed they had the capability to

implement social media for Internal Branding.

Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Industry

IT & ITES and Telecom again appeared very open to using social media for Internal Branding. IT & ITES reported the

maximum use of social media in their current Internal Branding operations. However, they did not share the same

degree of belief in their capabilities, as the respondents from Telecom. BFSI repeated its stance. They were unsure of

their capabilities and reported moderate use of social media in current Internal Branding tasks, yet they were

relatively more open to the idea of using social media. Manufacturing were not as agreeable to using social media, in

comparison, and so were the respondents from Retail. They were least sure of their capabilities among all the other

respondents.

Figure 29 Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Industry

Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Enterprise Size

Medium-sized enterprises were relatively more enthusiastic about using social media and stated they used it more

than the others, currently, for Internal Branding. However, Small and Large enterprises were only marginally behind

in their openness to use or current use. All three enterprises appeared moderately skeptical of their capabilities,

with large enterprises a tad more confident than the others.

50%

80%

60%57%

67%

57%

67%

53%

57%

53%50%

57%

50%

43%

63%

40%45%50%55%60%65%70%75%80%85%

BFSI IT & ITES Manufacturing Retail Telecom

Usage Openness Capability

14% 10% 43%

Respondents willing and capable to

use social media

Respondents willing to use social

media

Respondents having capability to

use social media

Page 33: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 33

Figure 30 Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Enterprise Size

Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Respondent Type

Here too, Decision Makers went against their earlier stand and were the most confident of the three groups of

employees about using social media for Internal Branding. Influencers were the most doubtful about capabilities to

implement social media and did not believe that currently social media was used to the level that the Decision

Makers believed. Implementers shared the belief in capabilities as Decision Makers, but were least open to the idea

of using it further.

Figure 31 Social Media Readiness in Internal Branding by Respondent Type

The Table below presents an overview of readiness by industry, enterprise size and respondent type in using social

media platforms in all four areas of HR. It neatly summarizes the findings discussed so far. The uncertainty in using

social media in Talent Management is quite obvious, in contrast to the eagerness to use it in Hiring. The respondents

were quite open to using social media for Collaboration and Communication, but were somewhat unsure about

current capabilities. They appeared tentative about using social media in Internal Branding, and may need a touch of

persuasion to bring them around to using it.

63%

55% 55%

65%

58%

52%

60%

58%

52%

50%

55%

60%

65%

70%

Usage Openness Capability

Large Medium Small

69%

65%

54%

58%56%

1

1

1

50%

55%

60%

65%

70%

Usage Openness Capability

Decision Maker Influencer Implementor

Page 34: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 34

Process Area Hiring Collaboration &

Communication

Talent

Management Internal Branding

Parameters Usage Openness Capability Openness Capability Openness Capability Openness Capability

Overall

Not sure

Not sure Not sure

Status by Industry

BFSI Not sure

Not sure

Not sure

Not sure Not sure

IT & ITES

Not sure

Not sure

Not sure

Manufacturing

Not sure

Not sure Not sure

Retail Not sure

Not sure

~

Not sure

Telecom

Not sure

Status by Enterprise Size

Large

Not sure

Not sure Not sure

Medium

Not sure

Not sure Not sure

Small

Not sure Not sure

Not sure Not sure

Status by Respondent Type

Decision Makers

Not sure

Not sure

Influencers Not sure

Not sure

Implementers

Not sure

Not sure Not sure

Not sure Not sure

Page 35: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 35

Challenges for using Social Media

Despite social media making significant inroads into our lives, most organizations are apprehensive about using it in

business processes. The nature of the challenges perceived and how they compared across verticals should interest

anyone keen to understand this area. Across all industries, close to 85 percent respondents said data security and

privacy were the biggest concerns, while around 71 percent cited organizational maturity as a concern. The maturity

of the industry and concerns about having the right kind of team to manage and monitor business processes that

interleaved with social media transactions, weighed next on the minds of the respondents.

Figure 32 Challenges for using Social Media

85%71%

47%

19% 25%

45%

Data Security/

Privacy

Organizational

Maturity

Industry Maturity Electronic Access Employee

Interest

Team to manage/

Monitor

When these challenges were examined from the perspective of industry, it was seen that overwhelmingly concerns

about data security and privacy caused considerable unease among respondents across each industry. That the

respondents were next bothered by perceived lack of organizational maturity points to the belief across all these

industries that they are not ready yet from the point of matured systems and processes to deal with the issues that

social media might bring. This is also reflected in the belief that their teams are not yet mature enough to handle

such a change. Respondents from IT & ITES did not share this concern for obvious reasons. The maturity of the

industry also bothered the respondents, but IT and ITES again did not share this concern possibly believing that the

industry has matured sufficiently.

Page 36: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 36

Conclusion

1

“Explore the internal communities and tools available”

The definition of social media is changing every day and organizations need to keep up with the speed of

change. Social media is not just about Facebook, Twitter or YouTube, it is more about being where the

organizations stakeholders are and what they access. While companies in India are waking up to the fact that

employee engagement is about being available, it is more important to understand that one need not

necessarily use the social media tools available on public domain to engage employees. It is a misconception

and needs to be clarified. Organizations should tap into the communities within the organizations more from

an employee engagement perspective. While publicly available social media applications will provide

organizations with a bigger network to tap into, it is the employees who will ultimately play the biggest role

in all spheres whether it is hiring or employer branding.

“Look in all directions”

Multiple websites provide the genuine views of the employees (careerbliss.com, blackdoor.com) and they

really need to be taken seriously than Facebook or Twitter. Employees are speaking about their

organizations on different platforms; it‟s about where one is looking. It is about looking in the right

direction.

2

“It” is how much you make of “it”

Human Resources has always grappled with issue of reaching out. The last decade has provided the HR

fraternity with this tool called social media which provides immense reach. It is up to the HR fraternity to

tap in to this. However, at the same time one needs to ensure that one is not too reliant and

compromise on the hygiene factors of employee relations.

3

“There is no substitute to being present”

One may provide the best of technology and platforms to keep in touch with employees, but then

there is nothing better than being there. In the world of technology organizations becoming faceless,

this is a classic mistake which should be avoided. 4

Page 37: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 37

About Wipro Consulting Services

Wipro Consulting Services (WCS) is a division of the Wipro Ltd (NYSE: WIT), a $7 billion enterprise that employs

around 136,734 employees across the globe. WCS offers Business Advisory, IT Consulting and Risk and Compliance

services designed to improve business performance, drive operational efficiency and maximize ROI. With 1350+

consultants based in Western Europe, North America, India, Asia Pacific and the Middle East, our integrated

Consulting, IT, BPO and Product Engineering services combine the benefits of expert proximity, with global leverage

to provide technology edge and speed to your strategic programs.

For more information, write to us at [email protected].

Page 38: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 38

Appendix

Page 39: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 39

Appendix

Survey Methodology

Survey Universe Our Survey was conducted by involving 150 top CXO‟s at different levels. 30 respondents, each from BFSI, IT &

ITES, Manufacturing, Retail, and Telecom participated in the survey. The organizations were classified into three

categories based on their employee strength.

1. Small Enterprises: Employee count up to 5000

2. Medium Enterprises: Employee count more than 5000 and less than 25000

3. Large Enterprises : Employee count more than 25000

The respondents were also classified into the following three categories based on their decision making authority.

1. Decision Makers: Respondents with the authority to take significant decisions affecting the course of the

organization.

2. Influencers: Respondents who wield influence and whose position affects major organizational decisions.

3. Implementers: Respondents responsible for implementing decisions taken by higher ups and handling routine

tasks.

Figure 33 Respondent Profile

Figure 34 Respondent Profile

Figure 35 Figure 33 Respondent Profile

BFSI, 20%,

IT & ITES,

20%

Manufactu

ring, 20%,

Retail,

20%

Telecom,

20%Total,

Decision

Maker,

36.00%,

36%

Total,

Influencer

, 28.67%,

29%

Total,

Implemen

tor,

35.33%,

35%

Total, Large,

26.67%, 27%

Total, Medium,

40.00%, 40%

Total, Small,

33.33%, 33%

Exploratory

Research In-depth

Interview Primary

Research

Data Collection

and

Analysis

Reporting

Page 40: Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 1

Social Media and Human Resources - Feb 2012 Page 40

DO BUSINESS BETTER

WWW.WIPRO.COM NYSE: WIT|OVER 120,000 EMPLOYEES|54 COUNTRIES|CONSULTING|SYSTEM INTEGRATION|OUTSOURCING

Wipro Infotech, Dodda kannelli, Sarjapur Road, Bangalore - 560 035; India, Tel: +91 (80) 2844 0011,Fax: +91 (80) 2844 0256 Email: [email protected]

Cordially, © Copyright 2011. Wipro Technologies. All rights reserved. No part of this document may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transmitted in any form or by any

means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without express written permission from Wipro Technologies. Specifications subject to change

without notice. All other trademarks mentioned herein are the property of their respective owners. Specifications subject to change without notice.