UBNDTHANHPHOHOCHIMrnH1l0AN LU!.T SIT

THANH PHO HO CHi MINH

CQNG HOA xA HQI CHU NGHiA VI~T NAMIlQc I~p - TI}.' do - Hanh plnic

S6:103/CV-DLS Thanh ph6 H6 Chi Minh, ngay 12 thdng 6 ndm 2017

v~ viec gap y il6i voi khoan 3f)i~u 19 cua B(j ludt Hlnh su2015.

Kinh giri: - CHU TICH ouoc H<)J- UY BAN THUONG VV ouoc H<)J- UY BAN TU pHAp onoc H<)J

Doan Luat su Thanh ph6 H6 Chi Minh xin giri loi chao kinh trong dSn Chutich Quoc hoi, Uy ban Thtrong vu Quoc hoi va Uy ban Tu phap Quoc hoi.

Thai gian vira qua, tren di~n dan Quoc hoi va tren cac phuong tien truyenthong dai chung da co nhiSu '1 kiSn khac nhau d6i voi khoan 3 DiSu 19 cua BQluat Hinh su narn 2015. Tuu trung, co 3 quan diSm khac nhau bao gom giftnguyen, sua d6i va huy bo khoan 3 DiSu 19 nay cling voi lap luan bao v~ quandiSm cua minh.

Qua nghien ciru cac quy dinh phap luat co lien quan, '1 kiSn dong gop cuacac luat su, cac bai viSt va tai lieu nghien ciru cua cac nha khoa h9C phap 1'1,Doan Luat su TP. H6 Chi Minh nhan thay khong cfrn thiSt gift lai khoan 3 DiSu19 BQ1u?t Hinh su nam 2015, vi nhtrng 1'1do sau day:

V-Gift l~i khoan 3 Di~u 19 BQ lu~t Hinh s1! 2015 lit ch~p nh~n mQtbmrc thut lui trong phap lu~t hinh s1! so vo; BQ lu~t Hinh s1! nam 1999 (suadBi, bB sung narn 2009):

BQ 1u?t Hinh S\1' nam 1999 (sua d6i, b6 sung nam 2009), tai DiSu 22.Khong t6 giac toi pham chi co khoan 1 va khoan 2, giong khoan 1 va khoan 2DiSu 19. Khong t6 giac tQi pham cua BQ luat Hinh S1)' 2015. Sau gfrn 20 narn apdung BQ luat Hinh S1)' 1999, tinh trang tQi pham xam pham an ninh, trat tu an toanxa hoi gia tang khong phai.xuat phat tir nguyen nhan luat sir khong t6 giac khachhang cua minh pham tQi, khong phai do DiSu 22 BQ luat Hinh S\1' 1999 thieukhoan 3! Khoan 3 DiSu 19 BQ luat Hinh S\1' 2015 dong hoa Iuat sir ngang hang voi

1

nhtrng ngiroi than thich cua ngiroi pham toi, da vo hinh trung ha thap vai tro,

chirc nang xa hQi cua luat su, lam cho xa hoi co ac earn, xem thirong nghe luat su

va la mot biroc thut lui so voi BQ luat Hinh sir 1999!

2/- Tao xung dQt vOi cac quy djnh phap lu~t lien quan:

- BQ luat T6 tung Hinh sir nam 2015, DiSu 73 khoan 2 diem g quy dinh:

Ngiroi bao chtra co nghia vu khong diroc tiet 1Qthong tin vS vu an, vS ngiroi bibuoc tQi ma minh bi~t khi bao chira tnr tnrong hQ'P nguoi nay d6ng y bang van

ban.

- Luat Luat su 2006 (sua d6i b6 sung 2012), DiSu 9 khoan 1 diSm c quy

dinh: Nghiem earn luat su ti~t 1Qthong tin vS vu, viec, vS khach hang ma minh

biet diroc trong khi hanh nghe, tnr tnrong hQ'P diroc khach hang dong y bang van

ban hoac phap luat co quy dinh khac.

Luat su vi pham nghia vu cua minh va diSu earn do phap luat quy dinh thi

tuy tinh ch~t mire dQ vi pham ma bi huy bo viec dang ky bao chfra, bi xu 1y ky

luat, xu phat hanh chinh hoac bi truy ciru trach nhiem hinh sir theo quy dinh tai

khoan 3 DiSu 73 BQ luat T6 tung Hinh sir nam 2015.

Su xung dQt phap luat nay d~t luat su vao th~ "ti~n thoai hrong nan":

khong ti~t 1Qthong tin (t6 giac) thi vi pham khoan 3 DiSu 19 BQ 1u~t Hinh su

2015, ma ti~t 1Qthong tin thi vi pham BQ luat T6 tung Hinh su 2015 va Luat Luat

su!

3/- Vi pham d~o duc ngh~ nghi~p lu~t SO'; d~t lu~t SO' vao vi tri la trgthu cua CO' quan di~u tra va cong tA:

Luat su la mot nghe d~c biet. Tir c6 chi kim, nr Dong sang Tay, nghe luat

su t6n tai va phat triSn diroc la d~t tren nSn tang sir tin nrong tuyet d6i cua khachhang d6i voi luat su (vi nhu benh nhan tin vao bac si). N~u luat su di t6 giac

khach hang do minh thirc hien chirc nang bao chira thi lap tire luat su bien thanh

"ke gi~u mat" chong lai chinh khach hang minh dang bao chira, tir nguyen nr bo

chirc nang bao chfra cua luat su dS tro thanh "canh tay n6i dai" cua co quan diSu

tra va cong t6, mot hanh vi phi dao dire nghe nghiep "vo tien khoang hau" chua

bao gio xay ra trong qua trinh hinh thanh va phat triSn nghe luat su!

4/-Khong phu hop y6-i chi~n IU'Q'ccai each to' phap va chi~n IU'Q'cphat?" (.- ,

trien nghe Lu~t suoVi~t Nam den narn 2020:

2

Nghi quyet s6 49-NQ/TW ngay 02-6-2015 cua BQ Chinh tri vS ChiSn hroccai each tu phap dSn nam 2020 dii xac dinh:

Cai each tu phap phai kS thira truyen thong phap ly dan toe, nhirng thanhtiru dii dat diroc cua nSn tu phap xii hoi chu nghia Viet Nam: tiSp thu co chon 19Cnhtrng kinh nghiem cua mroc ngoai phu hQ'Pvoi hoan canh mroc ta va yeu c:1uchu dong hoi nhap quoc ts; dap ling diroc xu thS phat tri~n cua xii hci trong tuonglai.

Thirc hien Nghi quyet 49-NQ/TW cua BQ Chinh tri va kS hoach s6 5-KHlCCTP ngay 22-02-2006 cua Ban Chi dao cai each tu phap Trung irong.Chien hroc phat trien nghe luat su dSn nam 2020 (ban hanh kern then Quyet dinhs6 1072/QD-TTg ngay 05-7-2011 cua Thu nrong Chinh phu) dii xac dinh quandi~m va dinh huang phat tri~n dQi ngfi luat su du vS s6 hrong, bao dam vS chathrong, virng yang vS ban linh chinh tri, trong sang vS dao dire nghe nghiep, dapirng yeu c:1ucai each tu phap va nhu c:1uxii hoi, co sir kS thira nhtrng thanh tiru diidat dtroc; tiep thu co chon 19Ckinh nghiem cua mroc ngoai, phu hQ'Pvoi trinh dQphat tri~n cua dQi ngfi luat su, dieu kien kinh tS xii hoi, truyen thong van hoa, h~thong tu phap cua mroc ta va thong l~ cua nghe luat su tren thS gioi, co trinh dQngang t:1m voi cac luat su trong khu vue va quoc tS, gop phan xay dung nguonnhan 19c ch~t hrong cao phuc vu cong cuoc cai each tu phap, phat tri~n kinh tS-xiihoi, cong nghiep hoa, hien dai hoa d~t mroc.

Nhu dii phan tich tren, viec gifr Iai khoan 3 DiSu 19 BQ luat Hinh su 2015la mot biroc thut lui trong phap Luat Hinh sir; tao sir xung dQt phap luat voi cacquy dinh co lien quan; ha thap vai tro, chirc nang xa hoi cua luat su; lam "v~ndue" dao dire nghe nghiep luat su, di nguoc lai thong l~ cua nghe luat su tren thSgioi, Va nhu vay, la khong phu hQ'P voi ChiSn hroc cai each tu phap cua BQChinh tri va ChiSn hroc phat tri~n nghe luat sir Viet Nam dSn nam 2020 cua Thunrong Chinh phu. Ong Nguyen Minh TriSt, luc con la Chu tich mroc, Truong BanChi dao Cai each Tu phap Trung 11ong, dii vi Cong t6 - Toa an - Luat su la kieng3 chan cua h~ thong tu phap mroc ta. Gitr lai khoan 3 DiSu 19 BQ luat Hinh sir2015 buoc luat su phai t6 giac khach hang do minh bao chira, bien luat su thanhcong t6 buoc tQi chinh khach hang cua minh thi h~ thong tu phap cua mroc ta chicon dirng tren 2 chan!

Doan Luat sir TP. H5- Chi Minh r~t phan khoi truce y kien kSt luan cuaChu tich Quoc hoi va dS nghi cua Uy ban Tu phap Quoc hoi vS viec tiSp tuc l~y ykien d6i voi khoan 3 DiSu 19 BQ luat Hinh su 2015, truoc khi Quoc hoi bi~u

3

quyet thong qua. Viec lam nay thS hien tinh thfin cfiu thi, cong khai, dan chu,minh bach, vi 19i ich cua nguoi dan trong hoat dong cua Quoc hoi. Doan Luat suTP. H6 Chi Minh hy vong va tin tuong r~ng sau khi lang nghe cac y kiSn donggop, Quoc h9i se thong qua Luat sua d6i, b6 sung mot s6 diSu cua B9 luat Hinhsir s6 IOO/2015/QHl3 hoan toan dap trng diroc nguyen vong toan dan, d?c biet lagioi luat sir ca mroc, phu hop ChiSn hroc cai each tu phap, phu hop thong I~ vShanh nghe luat su tren thS gioi, nham gop phan xay dung va phat triSn d9i ngfi

luat su Viet Nam co trinh d9 ngang tfim voi luat su trong khu V\fC va quoc tS..Tran trong earn an.!.

Nai nhan:- Nhu tren- Lien dorm Ludt su Viit Nam- Luu VP DLS

4