2
,-Patrick McEvoy-Halston ('English380 \Professor S. Burgar 29May2002 One ofthe major hernes n Anne Brontd's The Tenant of Wildfell Hall is the deceptiv eness f appearances. Certainly one ofthe reasons and perhaps fte reason) hat we have wo different narrators s so we can "witness" an event rom an observer, Gilbert,#, "*ur*o. is circumscribe4 andof a / participant, Helen, who, aprparently, nows and eveals all. Ifwe find ourselves nitially sharing Gilbert's interpretation ofthe events he uritresses, fter reading he rest ofT9nanl we might sclrool our future judgrnents of what we see or hear n public with the platitude,J*"fore you teap. And so we might come o resernble eavenly Helenand not gullible Gilbert. Or so we might think; for if we too easily agree with Helen's perspective f wents-as Gilbert, after reading her diary, does-I think we remain oblivious to what should be an obvious eason Helen'sown pe$pective of events annot be frusted: Helen, a person who has a great deal of diffrculty admitting hat she s happy, weals herselfto us largely tbroughanaccount ofher unhappy, ortuous narriage o Arthur. Thc Eue nature ofher marriage may have been otherwise--she might have experienced eal pleasure with Arttrur--and her account would likely have remained the same. Ct-a\@ Helen makes lear n he r account hat here are, or her, wo kindsof pleasures: 1) here are he sorts of pleasures e might expect most people o enjoy, such as dressing p and partyrng; and2) here are he sorts of pleasures eculiar the ##n (i.e., Helen) such as being delighted when a husband's conduct ndicates e s becoming loser o God. To Helen, he ormer pleasures re evil and hus $"rrimf, pleasures, hile the ater are good, fid 8oatv. ^-t'tv^A//"' -o*'4/ (* o l/4-&': Helen, briefly, and only once, acknowledges ndulging n pleasures f'6vil kind. In the chapter <-a{?> '4"c'^- the "the warnings of experience," Helen writes that she was delighted with the novelty and excitement of London ife" (133). Concerning he people she observred tgarties he writes hat she enjoyed studying their acquaint*""J] eculiaritr", #rn ;^ffin#ftfr>'. i"fr,ffi.r, wntes aterthat she was "horrified" (208) o hear he storie, *n* her tls favourite *lq' of the misfortunes f his previous mours 208). s tl a sign of the maturation n Helen? r s this evidence she has earned o be more circumspect concerning what she acknowledges o herself? f 4r<*S i*""*

Short Exploration of Anne Bronte's The Tenant of Wildfell Hall (May 2002; Scanned)

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

8/14/2019 Short Exploration of Anne Bronte's The Tenant of Wildfell Hall (May 2002; Scanned)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-exploration-of-anne-brontes-the-tenant-of-wildfell-hall-may-2002 1/2

8/14/2019 Short Exploration of Anne Bronte's The Tenant of Wildfell Hall (May 2002; Scanned)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/short-exploration-of-anne-brontes-the-tenant-of-wildfell-hall-may-2002 2/2

Considering

e know hat sheexpresses

bravely)

her concern

hat

f sheenjoys

gossip" she

isks

"becoming

ike

someof

the adies

she]

. . mostheartilydespises"

133),

think

we

have eason o

suspect

he later

possibility

s at least

as

probable

as he

former.

Am

I suggesting

hat

Arthur kept telling

Yet, unless,

ike Helen,we

ureourselves

masters

t self-<leception,

er echnique

ometimes

alls

attention

o

itself. Do we really believe

Helerg

or

example,

whenshe

ells

us of

her humiliation

rom

having o

wearsomething ther

han

a

"plain,

darlq

sober

tyleof dress"

217),

orced

God

orbid )

to

wear'ocostlyewels" (217)and o bedressed

'like

apainted utterfly''(217)atArthrn's bequest?This

",

&,r*Ar^:

from a woman

whoseonly

acknowledgmentf

pleasure

fter

leeing

Helen

s in

painting

bejeweled"

nature.

Even

here,however,we hopefully

noteo

he

hasa'tough

time delivering

herselfup to

the full

$

enjoyment

of

nature]

asothe(l

do"

(86).

pF

Helen

has

a tough

ime

grving

herself

o happiness

n

marriage,too.

We

note hat Arthur's

character

worsens

ust

as Helen hinls

herself

her

lot too

huppy,and

[her]

. . . husband

ctually oo

good

for [her] (204) He sn't of course--butot because rthurreveals imself o beduplicitousandevil, but

...,

because

Helen

{esenred

to be

married to someonewho has a'Joyous,

playful

spirit"

(204).

But Arthur

embodies he

Devil's

pleasures,

and

to admit

enjoyrng

them

means o be

of His

parly,not

God's.

r'/

Someone

who

fears

the

judgment

of

an all

knowing, all seeing

God

writes the account

we should expect

h€r owrite.To

write

therwis"

.tu

*"*

o*#r#;ot,

;*#,,{.

-/4/

drl

'

^/"^'1:)

Y

,

..-zo<.</.4/2

,

Z^,1

ctt

If only Arthur

eft

a diary

perhaps

hen

we'd know

he iuth. Helen

ellsus hat *tlwrsnot,

&,e)

unfortunately,goodwrit€r,bu maybe,his s exactlywhy tisword s to be rusted.

'-')A'io"-

'v'^l''

W

N^-

@/,.a,yon^-bil

l7-

/u+

/*.16

(.

T-l*,

c27'*u

/-,tb-d

a-

/

ra<*aVtz'c*

&'(,--

4

.22-.-\4

z--".a^,-;7

a

'141&\a

**^7,

uTQtt

-

-*/

ryY\ez4

&=-"-

^Vo. .-^yr.osn"'-'fL

ffif_fffi