Upload
maxine-day
View
35
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Intermediate Track II. September 2001 New Orleans, Louisiana. 1.Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method 2.Average Hindsight Method 3.Average Incremental Paid Method. This Session Will Discuss. BORNHUETTER- FERGUSON METHOD. Summary: - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
12001 CLRS
Intermediate Track II
September 2001New Orleans, Louisiana
22001 CLRS
This Session Will Discuss
1. Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
2. Average Hindsight Method
3. Average Incremental Paid Method
32001 CLRS
BORNHUETTER-FERGUSONMETHOD
42001 CLRS
Summary: Project IBNR based on expected losses and the percentage of ultimate losses which are currently unreported.
The Bornhuetter-Ferguson method is a combination of
Expected Loss Ratio Method (loss ratio x premium)
Paid or Incurred Loss Development Method (paid or incurred losses x loss
development factor)
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
52001 CLRS
Steps to Project Ultimate Loss
(1) Calculate Expected Losses(2) Calculate IBNR Factor(3) Calculate IBNR Reserve(4) Calculate estimated ultimate losses
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
62001 CLRS
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
Assumptions Earned Premium = $1,250 Incurred Losses = $600 Expected Loss Ratio = 65% CDF = 1.35
(derived from incurred loss development triangle)
72001 CLRS
Step 1 Calculate Expected Losses= Expected Loss Ratio x Earned Premium
Earned Premium = $1,250Expected Loss Ratio = 65%Expected Losses = $813 (1,250 x 0.65)
[Expected losses may also be projected using (pure premium x exposure) OR
(frequency x severity x exposure) ]
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
82001 CLRS
Step 2 Calculate IBNR Factor[IBNR Factor is the percent of ultimate losses still left to be reported]
= IBNR / Ultimate Losses= Ultimate Loss - Incurred to Date
Ultimate Loss= 1.000 - (Incurred to Date / Ultimate)= 1.000 - [1.000/(CDF)]
CDF = 1.350IBNR Factor = [1 - 1/1.350] = 26%
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
92001 CLRS
Step 3 Calculate IBNR Reserve= IBNR Factor x Expected Losses
Expected Losses = $813IBNR Factor = [1 - 1/1.350] = 26%IBNR Reserve = [$813 x 26%] = $211
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
102001 CLRS
Step 4 Calculate Estimated Ultimate Losses= Incurred Losses + IBNR Reserve
Incurred Losses = $600IBNR Reserve = [$813 x 26%] = $211Ultimate Losses = [$600 + $211] = $811
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
112001 CLRS
Advantages
Easy to use Compromises between loss development and expected loss ratio methods Avoid overreaction - doesn’t apply development factors to an unusual claim occurrence Suitable for new or volatile lines of business Can be used with no internal loss history Can also be used with paid data
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
122001 CLRS
Disadvantages
Highly dependent on expected loss ratio or pure premium Requires development factors
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
132001 CLRS
Comparison of Methods
Given: Earned Premium = $2,000Expected Loss Ratio = 70 %Incurred Losses to Date = $750Development Factor = 2.00
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
142001 CLRS
1) Expected Loss Ratio Method=Earned Premium x Expected Loss Ratio=$2,000 x 70% =$1,400
2) Loss Development Method=Incurred to Date x Development Factor=$750 x 2.00=$1,500
3) Bornhuetter Ferguson Method= Incurred to Date + Expected Losses x (1-1/Dev. Factor)=$750 + $1,400 x [1 - 1/2.00]=$750 + $700=$1,450
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
152001 CLRS
Comparison of Methods: Illustration of Tempering Effect
Given: One additional “large” claim of $150
Incurred Losses to Date = $900
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
162001 CLRS
1) Expected Loss Ratio Method=Earned Premium x Expected Loss Ratio=$2,000 x 70% =$1,400
2) Loss Development Method=Incurred to Date x Development Factor=$900 x 2.00=$1,800
3) Bornhuetter Ferguson Method= Incurred to Date + Expected Losses x (1-1/Dev. Factor)=$900 + $1,400 x [1 - 1/2.00]=$900 + $700=$1,600
Bornhuetter-Ferguson Method
172001 CLRS
AVERAGEHINDSIGHT
METHOD
182001 CLRS
Summary:
Estimate the expected ultimate losses for recent accident years based on “hindsight” average paid values per claim for more mature accident years.
Average Hindsight Method
192001 CLRS
Data Needed
Cumulative Paid Loss Triangle
Cumulative Closed (Paid) Claim Count Triangle
Average Hindsight Method
202001 CLRS
Steps to project Accident Year 1998 Ultimate Loss(1) Project ultimate losses for AY’s 1994-1997 using paid loss development method(2) Project ultimate claim counts for all AY’s using claim count development(3) Calculate projected payment per claim from 36 months to ultimate(4) Calculate total future payments for AY 1998(5) Calculate estimated ultimate losses for AY 1998
Average Hindsight Method
212001 CLRS
Accident Year 1998 - Step 1
Project ultimate losses for AY’s 1994-1997 using paid loss development method
Average Hindsight Method
222001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyCumulative Paid Losses ($000)
Accident Months of DevelopmentYear 12 24 36 48 60 72 841994 $50.0 $80.0 $98.2 $107.8 $113.2 $117.2 $119.71995 60.2 97.0 118.5 130.7 136.6 141.01996 75.5 120.1 147.0 162.4 171.01997 91.9 147.1 180.2 197.01998 115.0 184.1 226.41999 146.5 233.42000 181.1
232001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyDevelopment of Paid Losses
Months of DevelopmentAcc Year 12-24 24-36 36-48 48-60 60-72 72-84 84-Ult
1994 1.600 1.228 1.098 1.050 1.035 1.021 1.0001995 1.611 1.222 1.103 1.045 1.0321996 1.591 1.224 1.105 1.0531997 1.601 1.225 1.0931998 1.601 1.2301999 1.593
3 year avg 1.598 1.226 1.100 1.049 1.034 1.021 1.000Selected 1.050 1.035 1.020 1.000CDF 1.108 1.056 1.020 1.000
Diagonal 197.0 171.0 141.0 119.7Ultimate 218.4 180.5 143.8 119.7
242001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyCumulative Paid Losses ($000)
Accident Months of DevelopmentYear 12 24 36 48 60 72 84 Ultimate1994 $50.0 $80.0 $98.2 $107.8 $113.2 $117.2 $119.7 $119.71995 60.2 97.0 118.5 130.7 136.6 141.0 143.81996 75.5 120.1 147.0 162.4 171.0 180.51997 91.9 147.1 180.2 197.0 218.41998 115.0 184.1 226.4 *1999 146.5 233.4 *2000 181.1 *
Ultimate losses from Slide 23
252001 CLRS
Accident Year 1998 - Step 2
Project ultimate claim counts for all AY’s using claim count development
Average Hindsight Method
262001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyCumulative Number of Closed Claims
Accident Months of DevelopmentYear 12 24 36 48 60 72 841994 50 75 88 94 97 99 1001995 55 83 97 104 107 1091996 63 94 110 118 1221997 70 105 123 1311998 80 120 1411999 93 1392000 105
272001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyDevelopment of Closed Claims
Months of DevelopmentAcc Year 12-24 24-36 36-48 48-60 60-72 72-84 84-Ult
1994 1.500 1.173 1.068 1.032 1.021 1.010 1.0001995 1.509 1.169 1.072 1.029 1.0191996 1.492 1.170 1.073 1.0341997 1.500 1.171 1.0651998 1.500 1.1751999 1.495
3 year avg 1.498 1.172 1.070 1.032 1.020 1.010 1.000Selected 1.500 1.172 1.070 1.032 1.020 1.010 1.000CDF 2.000 1.333 1.138 1.063 1.030 1.010 1.000
Diagonal 105 139 141 131 122 109 100Ultimate 210 185 160 139 126 110 100
282001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyCumulative Number of Closed Claims
Accident Months of DevelopmentYear 12 24 36 48 60 72 84 Ultimate1994 50 75 88 94 97 99 100 1001995 55 83 97 104 107 109 1101996 63 94 110 118 122 1261997 70 105 123 131 1391998 80 120 141 1601999 93 139 1852000 105 210
Ultimate claim counts from Slide 27
292001 CLRS
Accident Year 1998 - Step 3
Calculate projected payment per claim from 36 months to ultimate
Average Hindsight Method
302001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyCalculation of Future Payment per Claim - 36 Months to Ultimate
Estimated Number of NumberEstimated Paid Estimated Ultimate Closed to Settle Average
Accident Ultimate Losses at Future Number Claims at Beyond FutureYear Losses 36 Months Payments of Claims 36 Months 36 Mos Payment(1) (2)=Slide 24 (3)=Slide 24 (4)=(2)-(3) (5)=Slide 28 (6)=Slide 28 (7)=(5)-(6) (8)=(4)/(7)
1994 $119,700 $98,200 $21,500 100 88 12 $1,7921995 143,820 118,500 25,320 110 97 13 1,9341996 180,525 147,000 33,525 126 110 16 2,1371997 218,372 180,200 38,172 139 123 16 2,345
Fitted forecasted value for AY 1998 $2,561
312001 CLRS
Accident Year 1998 - Steps 4 & 5
Calculate total future payments for AY 1998
Calculate estimated ultimate losses for AY 1998
Average Hindsight Method
322001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyEstimated Ultimate Losses: Accident Year 1998
(1) Forecasted Average Future Payment [Slide 30] $2,561(2) Number of Future Claims to Settle [Slide 28]
(Ultimate - Closed Claims) = 160 - 141 19(3) Estimated Future Loss Payments [ (1) x (2) ] $49,693(4) Paid Losses to Date [Slide 24] $226,400(5) Estimated Ultimate Losses [ (3) + (4) ] $276,093
332001 CLRS
Steps to Project Accident Year 1999 Ultimate Loss
(1) Calculate projected payment per claim from 24 mos. to ultimate (using results from AY 1998 projection)(2) Calculate total future payments for AY 1999(3) Calculate estimated ultimate losses for AY 1999
Average Hindsight Method
342001 CLRS
Accident Year 1999 - Step 1
Calculate projected payment per claim from 24 mos. to ultimate (using results from AY 1998 projection)
Average Hindsight Method
352001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
(2) 1995-1997 ultimates from Slide 24, 1998 ultimate from Slide 32
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyCalculation of Future Payment per Claim - 24 Months to Ultimate
Estimated Number of NumberEstimated Paid Estimated Ultimate Closed to Settle Average
Accident Ultimate Losses at Future Number Claims at Beyond FutureYear Losses 24 Months Payments of Claims 24 Months 24 Mos Payment(1) (2)=see below (3)=Slide 24 (4)=(2)-(3) (5)=Slide 28 (6)=Slide 28 (7)=(5)-(6) (8)=(4)/(7)
1995 $143,820 $97,000 $46,820 110 83 27 $1,7281996 180,525 120,100 60,425 126 94 32 1,9071997 218,372 147,100 71,272 139 105 34 2,0791998 276,093 184,100 91,993 160 120 40 2,277
Fitted forecasted value for AY 1999 $2,497
362001 CLRS
Accident Year 1999 - Steps 2 & 3
Calculate total future payments for AY 1999
Calculate estimated ultimate losses for AY 1999
Average Hindsight Method
372001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyEstimated Ultimate Losses: Accident Year 1999
(1) Forecasted Average Future Payment [Slide 35] $2,497(2) Number of Future Claims to Settle [Slide 28]
(Ultimate - Closed Claims) = 185 - 139 46(3) Estimated Future Loss Payments [ (1) x (2) ] $115,684(4) Paid Losses to Date [Slide 24] $233,400(5) Estimated Ultimate Losses [ (3) + (4) ] $349,084
382001 CLRS
Steps to Project Accident Year 2000 Ultimate Loss
(1) Calculate projected payment per claim from 12 mos. to ultimate (using results from AY’s 1998 & 1999 projections)(2) Calculate total future payments for AY 2000(3) Calculate estimated ultimate losses for AY 2000
Average Hindsight Method
392001 CLRS
Accident Year 2000 - Step 1
(1) Calculate projected payment per claim from 12 mos. to ultimate (using results from AY’s 1998 & 1999 projections)
Average Hindsight Method
402001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
(2) 1996-1997 ultimates from Slide 24, 1998 from Slide 32, 1999 from Slide 37
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyCalculation of Future Payment per Claim - 12 Months to Ultimate
Estimated Number of NumberEstimated Paid Estimated Ultimate Closed to Settle Average
Accident Ultimate Losses at Future Number Claims at Beyond FutureYear Losses 12 Months Payments of Claims 12 Months 12 Mos Payment(1) (2)=see below (3)=Slide 24 (4)=(2)-(3) (5)=Slide 28 (6)=Slide 28 (7)=(5)-(6) (8)=(4)/(7)
1996 $180,525 $75,500 $105,025 126 63 63 $1,6751997 218,372 91,900 126,472 139 70 69 1,8261998 276,093 115,000 161,093 160 80 80 2,0041999 349,084 146,500 202,584 185 93 92 2,194
Fitted forecasted value for AY 2000 $2,399
412001 CLRS
Accident Year 2000 - Steps 2 & 3
Calculate total future payments for AY 2000
Calculate estimated ultimate losses for AY 2000
Average Hindsight Method
422001 CLRS
Average Hindsight Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyEstimated Ultimate Losses: Accident Year 2000
(1) Forecasted Average Future Payment [Slide 40] $2,399(2) Number of Future Claims to Settle [Slide 28]
(Ultimate - Closed Claims) = 210 - 105 105(3) Estimated Future Loss Payments [ (1) x (2) ] $251,902(4) Paid Losses to Date [Slide 24] $181,100(5) Estimated Ultimate Losses [ (3) + (4) ] $433,002
432001 CLRS
Advantages Relatively unaffected by changes in case reserving practices Can easily adjust trend assumptions Allows separate analysis of frequency and severity
Disadvantages Sensitive to payment pattern shifts Averages highly variable when only a few claims May be insufficient if business has significantly changed
(i.e. retentions dramatically increase) Too “formula-driven”
Average Hindsight Method
442001 CLRS
AVERAGEINCREMENTAL
PAIDMETHOD
452001 CLRS
Summary: Estimate the expected ultimate losses for recent accident years based on average incremental paid values per claim.
Average Incremental Paid Method
462001 CLRS
Data Needed:
Ultimate Claim Counts
Incremental Paid Loss Triangle
Average Incremental Paid Method
472001 CLRS
Average Incremental Paid Method
Ultimate claim counts derived in average hindsight method - Slide 28
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyCumulative Number of Closed Claims
Accident Months of DevelopmentYear 12 24 36 48 60 72 84 Ultimate1994 50 75 88 94 97 99 100 1001995 55 83 97 104 107 109 1101996 63 94 110 118 122 1261997 70 105 123 131 1391998 80 120 141 1601999 93 139 1852000 105 210
482001 CLRS
Average Incremental Paid Method
12-24 column = Slide 24, column 3 (24 mos) - column 2 (12 mos)
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyIncremental Paid Losses ($000)
Accident Months of DevelopmentYear 0-12 12-24 24-36 36-48 48-60 60-72 72-841994 $50.0 $30.0 $18.2 $9.6 $5.4 $4.0 $2.51995 60.2 36.8 21.5 12.2 5.9 4.41996 75.5 44.6 26.9 15.4 8.61997 91.9 55.2 33.1 16.81998 115.0 69.1 42.31999 146.5 86.92000 181.1
492001 CLRS
Steps to Project Ultimate Loss
(1) Create triangle of incremental paid losses per ultimate claim(2) Calculate incremental payment trend factors and select projected trend factor(3) Calculate on-level incremental payments(4) Project future payment amounts(5) Calculate estimated ultimate losses
Average Incremental Paid Method
502001 CLRS
Step 1
Create triangle of incremental paid losses per ultimate claim
Average Incremental Paid Method
512001 CLRS
Average Incremental Paid Method
Slide 48 (incremental paid losses) / Slide 47 (ultimate claims counts)
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyIncremental Paid Losses per Ultimate Claim (Actual)
Accident Months of DevelopmentYear 0-12 12-24 24-36 36-48 48-60 60-72 72-841994 500 300 182 96 54 40 251995 547 334 195 111 54 401996 601 355 214 123 681997 660 396 238 1211998 717 431 2641999 791 4692000 862
522001 CLRS
Step 2
Calculate incremental payment trend factors and select projected trend factor.
Average Incremental Paid Method
532001 CLRS
Average Incremental Paid Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyIncremental Paid Losses per Ultimate Claim (Actual)
Accident Months of DevelopmentYear 0-12 12-24 24-36 36-48 48-60 60-72 72-84
1995/94 9.4% 11.4% 7.3% 15.4% -0.8% -0.1%1996/95 9.9% 6.2% 9.6% 10.6% 27.7%1997/96 9.8% 11.7% 11.0% -1.6%1998/97 8.7% 8.7% 11.0%1999/98 10.3% 8.8%2000/99 9.1%
Select 9.0% 9.0% 9.0% 9.0% 9.0% 9.0% 9.0%
6.2% = 355 / 334 - 1= Slide 51 (1996) / Slide 51 (1995) - 1
542001 CLRS
Step 3
Calculate on-level incremental payments [Trend all incremental paid amounts to current
(2001) level]
Average Incremental Paid Method
552001 CLRS
Average Incremental Paid Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyIncremental Paid Losses per Ultimate Claim (On-Level)
Accident Months of DevelopmentYear 0-12 12-24 24-36 36-48 48-60 60-72 72-841994 503 280 136 70 48 271995 514 276 144 64 441996 501 277 146 751997 513 282 1311998 512 2871999 5112000
Select N/A 510 280 140 70 46 27
514 = 334 x (1.09) ̂5= Slide 51 * (Slide 53) ̂number of years
562001 CLRS
Step 4
Project future payment amounts[Fill-in the triangle]
Average Incremental Paid Method
572001 CLRS
Average Incremental Paid Method
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyIncremental Paid Losses per Ultimate Claim (Projected)
Accident Months of DevelopmentYear 0-12 12-24 24-36 36-48 48-60 60-72 72-84 Total1994 0
1995 27 27
1996 46 29 75
1997 70 50 32 152
1998 140 76 55 35 306
1999 280 153 83 60 38 613
2000 510 305 166 91 65 42 1,179
Slide 55, Selected
83 = 70 x (1.09) ̂2= 1997 value x (Slide 53 ̂number of years)
Total = Sum across row (projected future severity)
582001 CLRS
Step 5
Calculate estimated ultimate losses.
Average Incremental Paid Method
592001 CLRS
Average Incremental Paid Method
(2) = Slide 51, summed across row
XYZ Auto Insurance CompanyProjected Ultimate Losses
ProjectedPaid Loss Projected Projected Projected Ultimate
Accident Per Ult. Claim Future Average Ultimate LossesYear as of 12/00 Severity Severity Claims (000's)(1) (2)=see below (3)=Slide 57 (4)=(2)+(3) (5)=Slide 47 (6)=(4)x(5)
1994 $1,197 $0 $1,197 100 $119.71995 1,281 27 1,308 110 144.01996 1,361 75 1,436 126 180.51997 1,414 152 1,567 139 218.21998 1,411 306 1,717 160 275.51999 1,259 613 1,873 185 347.12000 862 1,179 2,041 210 428.6
602001 CLRS
Advantages Allows separate analysis of frequency and severity trends Can be modified to account for changes affecting accident year severity (e.g. deductibles, benefit changes) Model can accommodate different trends by accident year, calendar year or development age
Disadvantages Very dependent upon estimate of future inflation rates Less accurate for low frequency lines of businessCould be distorted if payout patterns change
Average Incremental Paid Method