September 17, 2002 Van Jamison, POWAIR and Global Environment and Technology Foundation POLLUTION PREVENTION TEMPLATES WESTAR Technical Conference Snowbird,

September 17, 2002September 17, 2002 Van Jamison, POWAIR and Global EnviVan Jamison, POWAIR and Global Environment and Technology Foundationronment and Technology Foundation

POLLUTION PREVENTION POLLUTION PREVENTION TEMPLATES TEMPLATES

WESTAR Technical ConferenceWESTAR Technical Conference

Snowbird, UtahSnowbird, Utah


EXISTING POLLUTION EXISTING POLLUTION PREVENTION PROGRAMSPREVENTION PROGRAMS

• List of P2 programs addressing air quality concerns AND unrelated to electric energy conservation and renewable power generation– Transportation demand management– Alternative fuels and AFV deployment– Mass transit– Low emission consumer product programs

• Paints, cosmetics, propellants

• Program description for each program– Basics of how the program works– Who participants and how


EXISTING POLLUTION EXISTING POLLUTION PREVENTION PROGRAMSPREVENTION PROGRAMS

• Comprehensive list of existing EERE programs and incentives offered by state, local and federal agencies, utilities, and private industry– Necessary, but NOT sufficient

• Program description for each program– Basics of how the program works– Who participants and how– Energy performance, if available

• Annual and cumulative energy impact– Emissions reduction estimates, if available

• Estimated annual and cumulative emissions reductions– Future plans for each program


RE GENERATION CAPACITY RE GENERATION CAPACITY INSTALLED IN-STATEINSTALLED IN-STATE

• Compilation of nameplate capacity for all existing photovoltaic, wind, geothermal, “low-impact” hydroelectric, biomass, and landfill methane generation – Grid connected and off-grid systems inventoried and

reported separately– Capacity of small RE generating systems estimated

• Net metering program data• Surveys of vendors• Projections of sales through the end of 2002

• Complete template and append details


RENEWABLE ENERGY POWER RENEWABLE ENERGY POWER PRODUCTIONPRODUCTION

• Annual power output for existing photovoltaic, wind, geothermal, “low-impact” hydroelectric, biomass, and landfill methane generation systems– Grid connected and off-grid systems inventoried and

reported separately– Capacity of small RE system power production

estimated• Net metering program data• Surveys of vendors• Projections of power from new RE systems through 2002

• Complete template and append details


EXISTING RE CAPACITY AND EXISTING RE CAPACITY AND POWER PRODUCTION POWER PRODUCTION

COMPARED TO STATE TOTAL COMPARED TO STATE TOTAL • Compilation of total statewide installed

generating capacity and annual power production– EIA data– State energy agency data

• RE proportions/percentages


INCENTIVE PROGRAMS FOR INCENTIVE PROGRAMS FOR MEETING 10/20 RE GOALSMEETING 10/20 RE GOALS

• List of all programs and policies state will offer or adopt to meet 10/20 RE goals– Existing– New and expanded

• Program description for each new program or policy– Basics of how the program works– Who participants and how– Energy performance, if available


• Estimated annual and cumulative emissions reductions


CHARACTERIZE PROGRESS CHARACTERIZE PROGRESS TOWARD RE POWER GOALSTOWARD RE POWER GOALS

• Progress based on statewide consumption of RE power compared to all power consumption– Accounts for RE power generated elsewhere in response to

state policy or purchases• Projected total statewide RE power consumption with

program and policy incentives – RE generated off-grid– RE from net metering– RE from “green power” or “green pricing” programs– RE in utilities rates base paid by in-state customers

• Projected total statewide power consumption– EIA forecasts– State energy office or utility forecasts

• RE power fraction compared to the 10/20 goals


INCENTIVES FOR OVER AND/OR INCENTIVES FOR OVER AND/OR EARLY COMPLIANCEEARLY COMPLIANCE

• Unclear what information is needed– May have been intended to apply to all emissions

reduction measures, not just P2, when included in GCVTC report

– 2.5 ton allowance per megawatt of installed RE nameplate capacity included in the SO2 Trading Program could be considered a possible “early compliance program”

– Renewable energy activities outside of the electricity sector, e.g., the use of biofuels

• Should be clarified with EPA


PROGRAMS TO MAINTAIN AND PROGRAMS TO MAINTAIN AND ENHANCE ENERGY EFFICIENCYENHANCE ENERGY EFFICIENCY• List of all programs and policies state will offer

maintain and improve energy efficiency – Existing– New and expanded

• Program description for each new program or policy– Basics of how the program works– Who participants and how– Energy performance, if available


• Estimated annual and cumulative emissions reductions


MAP RE DEVELOPMENT MAP RE DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL AND DISTRIBUTIONPOTENTIAL AND DISTRIBUTION

• State maps of solar, wind, geothermal and biomass power potential with transmission system overlays– Land and Water Fund of the Rockies, NREL, DOE,

state energy offices

• Superimpose landfills generating enough methane to produce power economically and low-impact hydropower sites, such as irrigation and water supply conduits– State waste and water management agencies


TABLE OF EERE PROGRAM TABLE OF EERE PROGRAM SAVINGS AND BENEFITSSAVINGS AND BENEFITS

• Project economic and environmental impacts– Short and long-term emissions reductions– Visibility improvements– Cost savings– Secondary benefits

• Employment benefits

• State specific estimates derived from regional analyses completed by the AP2 Forum


WRAP AP2 FORUM WRAP AP2 FORUM CONTRIBUTIONSCONTRIBUTIONS

• Exemplary RE and EE program menus and descriptions of measures

• Regional assessment of emissions reductions, cost savings and secondary benefits of EE programs and RE goals

• Technical support and assistance


P2 SIP ISSUES TO BE P2 SIP ISSUES TO BE RESOLVEDRESOLVED

• Renewable/alternative fuel use in the transportation sector

• Address the “beyond/early compliance provisions in §51.309(d)(8)(ii)

• Resolve requirements outlined in §51.309(d)(8)(i) and (d)(8)(vi)

• Accounting for federal programs, e.g., Energy Star• Developing state-specific projections of expected

improvements/benefits• How projections of EERE visibility improvement will be

developed and by whom


Documents

September 17, 2002 Van Jamison, POWAIR and Global Environment and Technology Foundation POLLUTION PREVENTION TEMPLATES WESTAR Technical Conference Snowbird,