Science, Technology and National Socialism - Assets - …assets.cambridge.org/97805214/03740/frontmatter/... · 2012-05-31 · technical projects under National Socialism in Germany

This book provides a survey of the development of scientific disciplines and technical projects under National Socialism in Germany. Each contribution addresses a different, new aspect which is import:l11t for judging the interaction between science, technology and National Socialism. In particular, the personal conduct of individual scientists and engineers as well as the functionality of certain theories and projects are examined.

All essays share a common theme: continuity and discontinuity. All authors cover a period that reaches back to the Weimar Republic and forward beyond the end of National Socialism to the post-war period. This unanimity of approach provides answers to major questions about the nature of Hitler's regime and about possible lines of continuity in science and technology which may transcend political upheaval. The book is also the most comprehensive to date on this subject, and includes essays on engineering, geography, biology, psychology, physics, mathematics and science policy. It thus offers something of interest for the specialist, scientist, engineer and historian as well as an unprecedented overview of science and technology before, during and after the Third Reich.

www.cambridge.org© in this web service Cambridge University Press

Cambridge University Press978-0-521-40374-0 - Science, Technology and National Socialism Edited by Monika Renneberg and Mark WalkerFrontmatterMore information

http://www.cambridge.org/9780521403740

http://www.cambridge.org







Science, Technology and National Socialism











Science, Technology and National Socialism Edited by

Monika Renneberg Assistant Professor in the Institute for the History of Science, Technology and Mathematics, University of Hamburg

and

Mark Walker Assistant Professor of the Department of History, Union College, Schenectady

CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS






CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS

Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town,

Singapore, Sao Paulo, Delhi, Mexico City

Cambridge University Press

The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK

Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York

www.cambridge.org

Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521403740

© Cambridge University Press 1994

This publication is in copyright. Subject to staturory exception and to the ptovisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place withour the written

permission of Cambridge University Press.

First published 1994 First paperback edition 2002

A catalogue record for this publication is available foom the British Library

Library o/Congress Cataloguing in Publication Data Scientists, engineers, and National Socialism I edited by Monika Renneberg and Mark Walker.

p. cm. Includes index.

ISBN ° 521 40374 X 1. Science - Germany - History. 2. Engineering - Germany - History. 3. National Socialism and science - History. 4. Fascism - Germany - History.

I. Renneburg, Monika. II. Walker, Mark, 1959-

Q127·G3S36 1993 509.43'09'04-dc20 92-41633 CIP

ISBN 978-0-521-4°374-0 Hardback ISBN 978-0-521-52860-3 Paperback

Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of URLs for external or third-party internet websites referred to in

this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is,

or will remain, accurate or appropriate. Information regarding prices, travel timetables, and other factual information given in this work is correct at

the time of first printing but Cambridge University Press does not guarantee

the accuracy of such information thereafter.






This book is dedicated to all those critical voices who have tried to illuminate this ambivalent chapter of history, but were unappreciated, ignored and discouraged.











Contents

List of illustrations page xi List of contributors xiii Acknowledgements xvi List of abbreviations xvii

1 Scientists, Engineers and National Socialism 1 MONIKA RENNEBERG and MARK WALKER

2 Keinerlei Untergang: German Armaments Engineers 30 during the Second World War and in the Service of the Victorious Powers ANDREAS HEINEMANN-GRUDER

3 The Guided Missile and the Third Reich: Peenemiinde 51 and the Forging of a Technological Revolution MICHAELJ.NEUFELD

4 Self-mobilization or Resistance? Aeronautical Research 72 and National Socialism HELMlITH TRISCHLER

5 Military Technology and National Socialist Ideology 88 ULRICH ALBRECHT

6 'Area Research' and 'Spatial Planning' from the Weimar 126 Republic to the German Federal Republic: Creating a Society with a Spatial Order under National Socialism MECHTILD ROSSLER

7 The Ideological Origins of Institutes at the Kaiser 139 Wilhelm Gesellschaft in National Socialist Germany KRISTIE MACRAKIS

IX






x I CONTENTS

8 Biological Research at Universities and Kaiser Wilhelm 160 Institutes in Nazi Germany UTE DEICHMANN and BENNO MULLER-HILL

9 Pedagogy, Professionalism and Politics: Biology 184 Instruction during the Third Reich SHEILA FAITH WEISS

10 The Whole and the Community: Scientific and Political 197 Reasoning in the Holistic psychology of Felix Krueger ULFRIED GEUTER

11 Pascual Jordan: Quantum Mechanics, Psychology, 224 National Socialism M. NORTON WISE

12 The Ideology of Early Particle Accelerators: An 255 Association between Knowledge and Power MARIA OSIETZKI

13 The 'Minerva' Project. The Accelerator Laboratory at 271 the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute/Max Planck Institute of Chemistry: Continuity in Fundamental Research BURGHARD WEISS

14 The Social System of Mathematics and National 291 Socialism: A Survey HERBERT MEHRTENS

15 The Problem of anti-Fascist Resistance of 'Apolitical' 312 German Scholars REINHARD SIEGMUND-SCHULTZE

16 Irresponsible Purity: The Political and Moral Structure of 324 Mathematical Sciences in the National Socialist State HERBERT MEHRTENS

Notes 339 Index 415






Illustrations

3.1 Rudolf Nebel with Willy Ley and Klaus Riedel at the page 55 Raketen{lugplatz, April 1931

3.2 Test stand I at Peenemiinde 58 3.3 The first successful A4 (V-2) is prepared for launch 63 3.4 General Fellgiebel congratulates Colonel Leo Zanssen 64

after the first successful launch 3.5 An American soldier guards a captured and nearly 66

completed A4 3.6 Peenemiinde engineers brought to the United States, 1946 68 3.7 Gen. Holger Toftoy, Dr Ernst Stuhlinger, Hermann 69

Oberth, Dr Wernher von Braun and Dr Robert Lusser at the US Army Redstone Arsenal, c. 1955

5.1 German high-tech projects at the end of the war 99 5.2 Intercontinental bomber project by Daimler-Benz, late 100

1944 5.3 Jet fighter project by BMW. 1944 101 5.4 High-tech at the end of the Third Reich 102 5.5 German combat aircraft projects with pilot in prone 104

position 5.6 Arado AR E 381 mini-fighter, 1944 105 5.7 Bids by German industry for the Emergency Fighter 108

Programme, 1944 5.8 Heinkel He 161 'Volksjiiger' (People's Fighter) 110 5.9 Wernher von Braun's rocket plane, 1939 114 5.10 'Vengeance weapon 1', the V-I 115 5.11 Bachem 'Natter' point defence fighter 117 5.12 Submissions by German industry for the Emergency 118

Fighter Programme, 1944

xi






Xli I LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS

5.13 Unpowered combat glider, Blohm & Voss BV40 121 5.14 Messerschmitt's unpowered fighter Me 328 121 8.1 Funding of biologists by the DFG/RFR from 1930 to 1945 167 8.2 Relationship between membership in the NSDAP and 168

funding by the DFG/RFR 8.3 Funding by DFG/RFR of biological research at KWIs in 169

comparison to universities 8.4 Reichsmarshal Goring in the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for 178

Breeding Research, 1940 11.1 Vibrating string 230 11.2 Identity and spontaneity 231 13.1 Situation plan, KWI for Chemistry 277 13.2 Construction plan, KWI of Chemistry 278 13.3 (a) Neutron generator (cascade) part 1; (b) neutron 280-281

generator (cascade), part 2 13.4 KWI of Chemistry after air raid 283






Contributors

Ulrich Albrecht is Professor of Peace and Conflict Studies at the Department of Political Science of the Free University of Berlin. He also holds a degree in aeronautical engineering. His recent books are The History of the Soviet Armaments Industry (1992) and Die Abwicklung der DDR (The Liquidation of the GDR: 1992).

Ute Deichmann teaches biology and chemistry at the Georg-BiichnerGymnasium in Cologne. She has published Biologen unter Hitler- Vertreibung, Karrieren, Forschung (1992).

Ulfried Geuter is a freelance journalist and scientific author and psychotherapist in Berlin. He is the author of The Professionalization of Psychology in Nazi Germany (1984; English edition 1992) and the editor of Data on the History of German Psychology (2 vols., 1986 and 1987) and (with Mitchell G. Ash) of History of German Psychology in 20th Century (1985).

Andreas Heinemann-Gruder is Lecturer at the Humboldt University in Berlin. His publications include a book on Soviet policy in the Middle East and a book on the history of the first Soviet atomic bomb (1992). Most recently he has written (as co-author) The Specialists. German Natural Scientists and Technicians in the Soviet Union after 1945 (1992).

Kristie Macrakis is Assistant Professor of the History of Science at Michigan State University. She is the author of Surviving the Swastika: Scientific Research in Nazi Germany (New York: Oxford University Press, 1993).

Herbert Mehrtens is professor of history at Technische Universitat Braunschweig, Germany. He has edited Naturwissenschaft, Technik und NSIdeologie (1980). His latest book is Moderne - Sprache - Mathematik (1990).

Xlii






XIV I LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS

Benno Mit"ller-Hill is Professor of Genetics at the University of Cologne. He has written articles in Molecular Biology and Murderous Science. Elimination by Scientific Selection of Jews, Gypsies, and Others. Germany 1933-1945 (1988).

Michael J. Neufeld is a curator in the National Air and Space Museum, Smithsonian Institute. He is the author of The Skilled Metalworkers of Nuremberg (1989), The Rocket and the Reich (1994), as well as articles in German social history and history of technology.

Maria Osietzki, Ruhr-University Bochum, Germany, has published on the history of big science in nuclear research. She is coauthor of the book Wissenschaft fit·r Macht und Markt. Her publications include articles about gender in the history of science and technology. She is preparing a book about the history of energy and entropy.

Monika Renneberg teaches at the Institute for the History of Science, Mathematics and Technology at the University of Hamburg. She is author of Griindung und Aufbau des GKSS-Forschungscentrums Geesthacht. Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der Grof5forschungseinrichtungen in der BRD (Ph.D., 1989).

Mechtild RO"ssler is a programme specialist in the World Heritage Centre at UNESCO in Paris. She has written a number of articles on the history of geography and spatial planning in Germany, 1918-1945 and has published Wissenschaft und Lebensraum. Geographische Ostforschung im Nationalsozialismus (Berlin, Hamburg: Dietrich Reimer, Verlag, 1990).

Reinhard Siegmund-Schultze is currently Fellow of the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation and visiting scholar at Harvard University. His publications include papers on the history of mathematical ideas and on the social history of mathematics in Nazi Germany in particular, Mathematische Berichterstattung in Hitlerdeutschland (1993).

Helmuth Trischler is Director of Research at the Deutsches Museum, Munich, and Senior Lecturer at the University of Munich. His books include Luft- und Raumfahrtforschung in Deutschland 1900-1970. Politische Geschichte einer Wissenschaft (1992).

Mark Walker teaches history at Union College in Schenectady, has written German National Socialism and the Quest for Nuclear Power 1939-1949 and edited (with Teresa Meade) Science, Medicine, and Cultural Imperialism.

Burghard Weiss is Assistant Professor in the History of Science at the Technische Universitiit Berlin and the author of publications on the evolution of Physics and Technology in the 18th and 20th centuries, including Zwischen Physikotheologie und Positivismus (1988).






List of contributors xv

Sheila Faith Weiss is Associate Professor of History at Clarkson University. She is the author of Race Hygiene and National Efficiency (California, 1987). At present she is working on a history of social biology education during the Third Reich.

M. Norton Wise is Professor of History at Princeton University where he specializes in nineteenth- and twentieth-century physics. He is co-author with Crosbie Smith of Energy and Empire: A Biographical Study of Lord Kelvin (1989).






Acknowledgments

We are grateful to the University of Texas Press, Campus Verlag, and Springer Verlag respectively for permission to republish the following articles: Herbert Mehrtens, 'The Social System of Mathematics and National Socialism: A Survey'; Herbert Mehrtens, 'Irresponsible Purity: The Political and Moral Structure of Mathematical Sciences in the National Socialist State'; Ulfried Geuter, 'The Whole and the Community: Scientific and Political Thought in the Holistic Psychology of Felix Krueger'. We are also grateful to Philips Company and the Archives of the Max Planck Society for permission to reproduce illustrations.

xvi






AAW

AEG AQ ARGB AVA

BAK BA/MA BDC BSC

CIOS

DBV DFG DFL DFR DFW DIB DMV DNDS DNVP DVL

FHJ

GAMM GDR

Abbreviations

(former) Archives of the Academy of Sciences of the German Democratic Republic German General Electric Company Die anschauliche Quantentheorie Archiv fiir Rassen- und Gesellschafts-Biologie Aerodynamic Experimental Centre

Federal German Archives, Koblenz Federal German Military Archives, Freiburg Berlin Document Centre Bohr Scientific Correspondence, Archives for the History of Quantum Physics (American Institute of Physics)

Combined Intelligence Operations Service

German Union of Biologists German Research Foundation German Research Centre for Aviation German Research Council German Aircraft Works German Industrial Bank German Union of Mathematicians Die neue deutsche Schule German National People's Party German Experimental Centre for Aviation

Flying Hitler Youth

Society for Applied Mathematics and Mechanics German Democratic Republic

XVll






xviii I ABBREVIA TIONS

HA/DLR

HJ HN HU HWA

ICBM IFZ IG.

KPD KWG KWI

LAB

MPG MPGA MPI MPIA MR

NASM NKVD NS NSBO NSDAP NSFK NSV NWM

OHI OKW OMGBS OSB

PD PMS PZ

RAF RBE R&D REM RFR

Historical Archives of the German Research Centre for Aeronautics Hitler Youth Heisenberg Papers, Max Planck Institute for Physics, Munich University Archives of the Humboldt University, Berlin Army Ordnance

Intercontinental Ballistic Missile Institute for Contemporary History I. Physical Institute, University of Gottingen

Communist Party of Germany Kaiser Wilhelm Society Kaiser Wilhelm Institute

State Archives of Berlin

Max Planck Society Archives of the Max Planck Society Max Planck Institute for Chemistry, Mainz Archives of the Max Planck Institute for Str6mungsforschung Reich Union of Mathematicians

National Air and Space Museum Soviet Secret Police National Socialist National Socialist Factory Organization National Socialist German Workers Party National Socialist Teachers Union National Socialist People's Welfare Naturwissenschaftliche Monatshefte fiir den biologischen, chemischen, geographischen und geologischen Unterricht

Oral history interview Armed Forces High Command Office of Military Government, Berlin Sector Higher School Authorities

Physikalisches Denken in der neuen Zeit Philips Medizin-Systeme (formerly C. H. F. Miiller), Hamburg Pedagogical Center

Royal Air Force Radium-Beryllium-Equivalent Research and Development Reich Ministry for Education Reich Research Council






RLM RM

SA SAM SB SBZ SCI SED SO SPSL SRW SS STA-HH

TH

UA UAM

V-I V-2 VfR VTOL

WGL

ZstA

List of abbreviations

Reich Aviation Ministry Reich Marks

Storm Troopers Siemens Archives, Munich Prussian State Library, Berlin Soviet Occupation Zone Science Citation Index Socialist Unity Party of East Germany Suicide (as in SO mission: suicide mission) Society for the Protection of Science and Learning Siemens Reiniger Werke Defense Squadron Hamburg State Archives

Technical University

Archives of German and Austrian Universities University Archives, Mainz

Revenge Weapon 1 Revenge Weapon 2 Society for Space Travel Vertical takeoff and landing (plane)

Scientific Society for Aviation

(former) Central State Archives, Potsdam

xix











Documents

Science, Technology and National Socialism - Assets - …assets.cambridge.org/97805214/03740/frontmatter/... · 2012-05-31 · technical projects under National Socialism in Germany