1
once thought was black and white is really shades of gray. I have tried to appropriately integrate rational psych oph arma- co logy with therapy in many o ut patient se tti ngs . Dr. Kutcher's book helps further clarify the previously described shades of gray. It is an extremely infor mative, enjoyable, and valuable resou rce written in a pragmatic mann er. Th is boo k sh ould be on the sh elf of ever y practi cing child and adolescent psychiatrist. Sander M. Weckstein, M .D. Traverse C ity, MI School Violence Inter vention :A Practic al Handbook. Edited by A rnold P. Go ldstein. Ph.D.. andJane Close Conoley. Ph.D. New York: GuilfOrd Press, /997. 509 pp.. $55.00 (bard- cover). Just as school was letting out for the summer, I had the opportunity to review th is book. I had been mulling over the past year and realized some of my worst quandaries were related to the issue of school violence and saf ety. As a con- sultanr at the local ment al health center, I have been treating more victims and perpetrators, have struggled with advising their therapists, and have listened to teachers and parents who are concerned and worried about this growing trend. All of this is happening in the midst of a "zero tolerance" policy for m isb eha vi or in the local sc hoo ls and an emphasis on improving educational outcomes. Th e issues I have encoun- tered have gone beyond the typical "psychiatric problems." Thi s book attempts to address the issues of schoo l vio- lence, with an emphasis on ways of cout rolling and reducing th e violen ce. From the beginn ing, the various authors emphasize the need to view school violence as a reflection of the societal trend of increased violence and aggression as a recur ring featur e of life in the United States. Furthermo re, schoo l violence is a complex issue with multiple causes. T hey note that unt il these facto rs arc accepted and und erstood, appropriate interventions cannot really take place. T he four main sect ions include di scu ssions of the pr actition ers' perspectives, student-oriented intervent ions , sc hoo l-oriented inte rventions, and system-oriented int er- ventions. Most helpful are the historical perspective presented and the emph asis on the importance of collaboration with the child, family, community, and community agencies in dealing with this problem. Th e chapter titled "The Low- Aggression Classroom: A Teacher's View" illustrates how an edu cator would "create a community of learners," includes a discussion of home- school collaboration, and explains the importance of teachers being dedicated to designing ways for parents to help their child. Thro ughout the book, examples J. AM. ACA D . C H I l. D AI H l l.ESC. PSYCHIATR Y, ,\7: 1, JA N UARY 19 'JH BO O K REVI EW S of such inte rventions are given that could be very helpful for the practiti oner o r cons u lta nt . On e of the most important thoughts reiterated th rough out the book is that sc hoo l safety is part of the fo rmul a for excellence in education and improvi ng educational outcomes. A safe schoo l is described as one that not only has an absence of crim e and violence, but also includes factors that allow for psychol ogical safety and dev el opment al growth . In thi s environment all child ren will have the oppo rtunity to learn as mu ch as possible. T herefo re, schoo l safety needs to be in clud ed in the co ntex t of ongo ing sc hoo l reform s. To accomp lish th is. it is suggested that all members of the com- munit y need to work together. Althou gh this boo k is long and som e inform ation is repeated, [ liked it and would recommend it to anyone who is concerned about the educatio n of American children. It should appeal to child psychiatrists who consult with com- muni ty agenci es and gives a good argument for all concerned parties to become involved at the policymaking level. I hope that some of us are involved and others will come forward. Kaye McGinty, M.D. Assistant Prof essor of Psych iatr y East Caro lina University School of Med icin e Greenville, NC Child Psychopathology. Edited by Eric j. Mash and Russell A. Barkley. New York: The GuilfOrd Pres s, /996. 60/ pp.. $65.00 (hardcover). Recogn izin g th e rapid expa nsio n of resea rch in devel- opmental psychopathology over the past two decades, the editors of this book have brou ght together a stellar group of con t rib uto rs, prim arily psychologists, to attempt to make some sense of th is rapidly evolving field. T heir stat ed goal for this edited volume is to summarize in a comprehensive and timely manner the essence of the develop mental psychopath- ology of an umbe r of diso rde rs. Each review chapter add resses the current state of scientifically acquired knowledge about a disorder as well as the existing theoretical and conceptual models that have been prop osed. Th e to pics cove red are bro ad. incl uding devel opm ent al and learnin g diso rder s, behavi oral problems. psych iatr ic disord ers, and risk facto rs such as abuse, neonatal and early infan cy stressors, and med- ical illnesses. Each chapter is organized around the questions posed by the editors, which include a d efinition of the d iso rder, a hi stor ical perspective, diagnostic criteria when applicable, epide mio logy. devel opment al co u rse, co rno rb idi ry, and a critical review of pot ential causes, both the more scien tifically 119

School Violence Intervention: A Practical Handbook

  • Upload
    kaye

  • View
    213

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

once thought was black and wh ite is really shades of gray. I

have tried to appropriately inte grate rational psychopharma­co logy with th er ap y in m an y o ut pa t ien t setti ngs . Dr.Kut cher's book help s fu rthe r clarify the previously describ edshades of gray. It is an extremely infor mative, enjoyable, andvaluable resou rce written in a pragmatic manner. Th is boo ksh ould be o n the sh elf of ever y practi cing child andadolescent psychiatrist.

Sander M . Weckstein , M.D.Traverse C ity, MI

School Violence Intervention : A Practical Handbook.Edited by Arnold P. Goldstein. Ph.D.. and Jane Close Conoley.Ph.D. New York: GuilfOrd Press, /997. 509 pp.. $55.00 (bard­cover).

Just as school was letting out for the sum mer, I had theopportunity to review th is book. I had been mulling over thepast year and realized some of my worst qu andaries wererelated to the issue of school violence and safety. As a con­sultanr at th e local mental health cente r, I have been treatingmore victims and perpetrator s, have struggled with advisingtheir therapis ts, and have listened to teachers and parents whoare concerned and wo rried about this growing trend. All ofthis is happen ing in the midst of a "zero tolerance" poli cy form isb ehavior in the local schoo ls a nd an em phasis o nimproving ed ucatio nal outcomes. The issues I have enco un­tered have gone beyond th e typical "psychiatr ic problems."

This book atte mpts to address the issues of school vio­lence, with an emphasis on ways of cout rolling and reducingth e violen ce. Fro m th e beginn ing, the vario us aut ho rsemphasize th e need to view scho ol violence as a reflection ofthe societal trend of increased violence and aggression as arecurring feature of life in the Unite d States. Furthermo re,schoo l violence is a complex issue with multiple causes. T heynot e that until the se facto rs arc accepted an d understood,appropriate inte rventions canno t really take place.

T he four main sect ions include di scu ssions of thepr actitioners' perspectives, student-oriented intervent ions ,schoo l-o riented intervent ions, an d system-o rie nted inter­ventions. Most helpful are the histo rical perspective present edand the emphasis on th e impo rta nce of collabo ration withthe chi ld , fami ly, community, and co mm uni ty agencies indealing with th is problem. The cha pter titl ed "T he Low­Aggression C lassroom: A Teacher's View" illustrates how aneducator would "create a community of learn ers," includes ad iscussion of home- school collaboration, and explains theimpo rtance of teachers being dedicated to designing ways forparent s to help their child. T hro ugho ut the book, examples

J . AM. ACA D . C H I l. D AI H l l.ESC. P S YCHIATRY, ,\ 7: 1 , JA N U A RY 19 'JH

BO O K REVI EW S

of such inte rventions are given that could be very helpful forth e pract it ioner or cons ultant .

One of the most impo rta nt tho ughts reiterated th roughoutth e book is that schoo l safety is part of the fo rmula fo rexcellence in educat ion and improvi ng educatio nal outcomes.A safe schoo l is described as one that not only has an absenceof crim e and violence, but also includes facto rs that allow forpsycholog ical safety and developmental growth . In thi senvironment all child ren will have the oppo rtunity to learn asmuch as possibl e. T herefo re, schoo l safety need s to bein cluded in the co ntext o f ongoing schoo l reforms. Toacco mp lish th is. it is suggested that all members of the com­munity need to wor k together.

Although this boo k is long and some information isrepeated , [ liked it and would recommend it to anyo ne whois concerned abo ut the ed ucatio n of American child ren. Itsho uld appea l to child psychiatr ists who consult wit h com­muni ty agenci es and gives a good argume nt for all concernedpart ies to beco me involved at the policymaking level. I hop ethat som e of us are involved and others will com e forward.

Kaye McGinty, M.D.Assistant Professor of Psych iatr y

East Carolina University School of Med icineGreenville, NC

C hild Psychopathology. Edited by Eric j. Mashand Russell A.Barkley. New York: The GuilfOrd Press, /996. 60/ pp.. $65.00(hardcover).

Recogn izin g th e rapid expa nsio n of resea rch in devel­opmenta l psychopath ology over the past two decades, theedito rs of this book have brought together a stellar group ofcon tributo rs, primar ily psych ologist s, to att empt to makesome sense of th is rapidly evolving field. T heir stat ed goal forthis ed ited volume is to summa rize in a comprehe nsive andtimel y manner the essence of the develop mental psychopath­ology of a number of diso rders. Each review chapter add ressesthe current state of scient ifically acquired knowledge about adisorder as well as the existi ng theoretical and conceptu almodels th at have been proposed . The to pics cove red arebroad. incl ud ing developmental and learning d iso rders,behavi oral problems. psych iatr ic disord ers, and risk facto rssuch as abuse, neon atal and early infan cy stressors, and med­ical illnesses.

Each chapter is organized aro und the questions posed bythe editors, which include a definition of the d iso rder, ah istorical pers pective, diagn ostic cr iteria when applicab le,ep idemio logy. developmental co urse, co rno rb idi ry, and acritical review of pot ential causes, both the more scien tifically

119