School Grades Model and Historical Background

Why Grade Schools?

• Ensure students are college and career ready• Clear information about schools for parents

and students• A – F grading system is universally understood• High stakes accountability for the adults

2

Florida’s Grading System

• Focus on student achievement• Focus on learning gains• Focus efforts on students that need the most

support to succeed• System of rewards and supports• Model for the nation historically

3

School Grades Basic Model - Assessment-Based Measures Included in School Grades for All School Types

4

Reading Math Writing SciencePerformance

(100 points) (100 points) (100 points) (100 points)

Learning Gains All Students

(100 points) (100 points)

Low 25% Learning Gains

(100 points) (100 points)

(300 points) (300 points) (100 points) (100 points)

50%

50%

Elementary Schools 2012-13

5

Reading Math Writing SciencePerformance

FCAT 2.0, FAA(100 points)

FCAT 2.0, FAA(100 points)

FCAT, FAA(100 points)

FCAT 2.0, FAA(100 points)

Learning Gains All Students FCAT 2.0, FAA(100 points)

FCAT 2.0, FAA(100 points)

Low 25% Learning Gains FCAT 2.0

(100 points)FCAT 2.0

(100 points)(300 points) (300 points) (100 points) (100 points)

Additional Requirements:Learning gains requirement for the Low 25% reinstated.Test at Least 90% of students, 95% to earn an “A.”A performance threshold in Reading (25%) will be applied - Grade lowered one letter grade if not met (greater weight on reading) .

Middle Schools 2012-13

6

Reading Math Writing Science Acceleration

Performance

Middle School Students’

Participation in and Performance on

High School Level EOC assessments

(and Industry CertificationsIn 2012-13)(100 points)

FCAT 2.0, FAA(100 points)

FCAT 2.0, EOCs, FAA

(100 points)

FCAT, FAA(100 points)

FCAT 2.0, FAA(100 points)

Learning Gains All Students

FCAT 2.0, FAA(100 points)

FCAT 2.0, EOCs, FAA

(100 points)

Low 25% Learning Gains

FCAT 2.0(100 points)

FCAT 2.0(100 points)

(300 points) (300 points) (100 points) (100 points) (100 points)

Additional Requirements:Learning gains requirement for the Low 25% reinstated. Test at Least 90% of students, 95% to earn an “A.”A performance threshold in Reading (25%) will be applied - Grade lowered one letter grade if not met (greater weight on reading).

High Schools 2012-13*

7

Assessment Components – 50% (at least) “Other” Components – 50%

Reading

Math (Algebra,

Geometry) Writing Biology

(Science) Acceleration Grad Rate College Readiness

Performance

Participation(150 points)

Overall(200 points)

100 – Four Yr Rate100 – Five Yr Rate

Reading(100 points)

FCAT 2.0, FAA(100 points)

EOC, FAA(100 points)

FCAT, FAA(100 points)

EOC, FAA(100 points)

Learning Gains All Students Performance(150 points)

At-Risk(100 points)

50 – Four-Yr Rate50 – Five Yr Rate

Math(100 points)FCAT 2.0, FAA

(100 points)EOC, FAA

(100 points)

Low 25% Learning Gains

FCAT 2.0(100 points)

EOC(100 points)

(300 points) (300 points) (100 points) (100 points) (300points) (300 points) (200 points)

Additional Requirements: Learning gains requirement for the Low 25% reinstated. Test at Least 90% of students, 95% to earn an “A.” Meet the at-risk graduation rate target to earn an “A” - 65% or improvement targets. Performance threshold in Reading (25%) - Grade lowered one letter grade if not met. (greater weight on

reading)

* K-12 and 6-12 combination schools are graded on a 1700-point model, which adds middle-school acceleration to the HS model.

Why are High School Grades Released in December?

• High school grades use additional sources of data– Graduation rate– SAT and ACT– Advanced Placement, International Baccalaureate,

Industry Certification, AICE, and Dual Enrollment

• This information is not available in time for a summer release of grades

8

School Grading ScaleA = 65.6% of pointsB = 61.9 % of pointsC = 54.4.% of pointsD = 49.4 % of pointsF = less than 49.4 % of points

Same percentages apply to grading scales for all school types:Elementary Schools = 800 possible pointsMiddle Schools = 900 possible pointsHigh Schools = 1600 possible pointsCombination Schools (K-12, 6-12) = 1700 possible points

9

School Improvement Ratings• Alternative schools and ESE centers can choose a

School Improvement Rating instead of a School Grade

• School improvement ratings compare learning gains in the current year to learning gains of the same students in the prior year

• Ratings include:– Improving – at least 5% increase in the percent

making learning gains– Maintaining – less than a 5% increase or decrease in

the percent making learning gains– Declining – at least a 5% decrease in the percent

making gains10

School Accountability History1991 Florida’s system of school improvement and accountability (Blueprint 2000).

•Schools self-identified and self reported adequate progress as part of the school improvement planning process.

1995 Identification of critically low performing schools began. •Schools were identified based on reading, math and writing performance for 2 years.•Standards set for critically low performance.•If schools are critically low in reading writing and math for 2 years they were designated as critically low.

1999 The “A – F” school grading system began and FCAT results were used for the first time. •Based on current year data.•Included performance in reading, mathematics, and writing, and additional criteria -dropout rates, attendance, and discipline data. •Minimum and higher performing criteria set for reading, writing, and math. •To receive an A or B, schools were required to meet the higher performing criteria and additional requirements.

2002 School grades calculation was changed to the points based model we have today – 50% performance and 50% learning gains.•Learning gains were added (reading and math) - FCAT administered in Grades 3 to 10.•Learning gains for the Low 25% in reading added. Learning gains target in reading for the Low 25% added. 11

School Accountability History2005 Additional students added to the calculation.

•Students with disabilities added to learning gains, if students had FCAT scores.•ELLs added to learning gains.

2007 • Science added to school grading measures. • Learning gains for the Low 25% in mathematics added (along with learning gains

target for the Low 25% in math). • Bonus points for high school retakes added.

2010 Implement new High School measures (50% of HS Grade) •Acceleration – participation and success.•Graduation rate – all students and at risk.•College readiness – SAT, ACT, and PERT.

2012 New FCAT 2.0 and End-of-course (EOC) assessments with new achievement levels.•Students with disabilities and English language learners in performance measures.•New middle school acceleration measure.•Use federal graduation rate.•Allow weighted learning gains for some students.•Safety net protection.

2013 • New Science FCAT 2.0 and Geometry and Biology EOC assessments and achievement levels.

• Safety net provision continued.• Reading threshold implemented.

12

Increasing Inclusion of Students• Began school grades with fewer students included

– Only 3 grade levels (Grades 4, 8, and 10)– Reading, Writing, and Math– No students with disabilities– No English language learners

• Now schools are accountable for all students’ performance– Includes 8 grade levels (Grades 3 to 10) plus students with

end-of-course assessments– Reading, Writing, Math, Science and end-of-course– Include students with disabilities– Include English language learners– Focus on lowest 25% of students

13

Student Reading Performance Increased

14

Student Math Performance Increased

FCAT FCAT 2.0

15

Changes Already in Rule Scheduled for 2013-14

• Include US History in the high school model at 100 points (in the “other” 50%)

• Reduce the points for acceleration to 200 points

16

Proposed Rule Revisions: October SBE Meeting

• Rule revisions required to implement changes to statute (s. 1008.34, F.S.) from Senate Bill 1720– Grading co-located schools – Cell-size re-set at 10

• Rule revision required for compliance with the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA)– Revise percent-tested calculation - not limited to students who are full-

year enrolled, based on students enrolled at the time of testing.

• Proposed extension of the one-letter-grade-drop limit (safety net provision) for school grades

• Technical correction – Clarify definition of “full-year enrolled.”

17

Focus Moving Forward

• School Grades. Improving our education accountability system to further ensure transparency and fairness while providing meaningful and useful information to our parents and educators about how our students and schools are performing

18