Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    1/56

    Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis:

    Supporting TEKS Implementation

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 

    Grade 6

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    2/56

    Phase 1: Studying the TEKS

    Phase 2: Narrowing the field of instructional materials

    Phase 3: Assessing mathematical content alignment 

    In Phase 3, participants now conduct in-depth reviews of the materials selected in Phase 2. Tis deeper analysis allows for detailed documentation ofthe degree to which the materials are aligned with the EKS. Te Phase 3 process requires selection committee members to use the outlined criteriato determine a rating and to cite examples to justify their score. Additionally, this phase requires participants to document Knowledge and Skillsstatements and/or Student Expectations that were underemphasized or missing.

    Implementation

    Selection committee members should practice applying the Phase 3 rubric and documentation form to reach consensus on a single sample. Participantsdetermine a starting point, such as a big idea within each strand, to be analyzed across the remaining resources, and then determine a method foraggregating and analyzing the data collected. Next, determine how individuals or small groups will be organized to carry out next steps; include atimeline.

     Materials and Supplies 

    • Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment Blackline Master — multiple copies per person

    • Te 2 to 4 instructional materials selected in Phase 2

    Phase 4: Assessing vertical alignment of instructional materials

    Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: A Four Phase Process

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 2

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    3/56

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 3

    Development 

    1 2 3 4

    Important mathematical ideas are alluded tosimply or are missing, approached primarily

    from a skill level, or provided for studentsoutside any context.

    Important mathematical ideas are evident,conceptually developed, and emerge within the

    context of real-world examples, interesting problems,application situations, or student investigations.

    Connections

    1 2 3 4

    Important mathematical ideas are developedindependently of each other (i.e., they arediscrete, independent ideas).

    Important mathematical ideas are developed byexpanding and connecting to other important

    mathematical ideas in such a way as to buildunderstanding of mathematics as a unified whole.

    Rigor and Depth

    1 2 3 4

    Important mathematical ideas are applied inroutine problems or in using formulatedprocedures, and are extended in separate /optional problems.

    Important mathematical ideas are applied andextended in novel situations or embedded in the

    content, requiring the extension of importantmathematical ideas and the use of

    multiple approaches.

    Supercially Developed Well Developed

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment

    Scoring Rubric and Documentation Form

    Understanding the Scoring of Important Mathematical Ideas

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    4/56

    Development 

    1 2 3 4

    Skills and procedures are the primary focus, aredeveloped without conceptual understanding,

    and are loosely connected to importantmathematical ideas — important mathematicalideas are adjunct.

    Skills and procedures are integrated with importantmathematical ideas and are presented as important

    tools in applying and understanding importantmathematical ideas.

    Connections

    1 2 3 4

    Skills and procedures are treated as discreteskills rarely connected to important mathematicalideas or other skills and procedures.

    Skills and procedures are integratedwith—and consistently connected to—

    important mathematical ideas and otherskills and procedures.

    Rigor and Depth

    1 2 3 4

    Skills and procedures are practiced withoutconceptual understanding outside any context,do not require the use of importantmathematical ideas, and are primarilypracticed in rote exercises and drill.

    Skills and procedures are important tothe application and understanding of important

    mathematical ideas, and are embedded inproblem situations.

    Supercially Developed Well Developed

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment

    Scoring Rubric and Documentation Form

    Understanding the Scoring of Skills and Procedures

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 4

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    5/56

    Development 1 2 3 4

    Mathematical relationships are not evident, andmathematics appears as a series of discrete skills

    and ideas.

    Mathematical relationships are evident in such a wayas to build understanding of mathematics as a

    unified whole.

    Connections

    1 2 3 4

    Mathematical relationships are not required ofstudents or are used primarily to provide acontext for the practice of skills or procedures— words wrapped around drill.

    Mathematical relationships are integrated withimportant mathematical ideas, and are integral

    in required activities, problems,and applications.

    Rigor and Depth1 2 3 4

    Mathematical relationships require the use ofskills and procedures, but rarely require the useof any important mathematical ideas orconnections outside mathematics.

    Mathematical relationships require the broad useof mathematics and integrate the need for importantmathematical ideas, skills, and procedures, as well as

    connections outside mathematics.

    Supercially Developed Well Developed

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment

    Scoring Rubric and Documentation Form

    Understanding the Scoring of Mathematical Relationships

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 5

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    6/56

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 6

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Introduction

    (1) Within a well-balanced mathematics curriculum, the primary focal points at Grade 6 are using ratios to describe direct proportional

    relationships involving number, geometry, measurement, probability, and adding and subtracting decimals and fractions.

    (2) Troughout mathematics in Grades 6-8, students build a foundation of basic understandings in number, operation, and quantitativereasoning; patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking; geometry and spatial reasoning; measurement; and probability and statistics.Students use concepts, algorithms, and properties of rational numbers to explore mathematical relationships and to describe increasinglycomplex situations. Students use algebraic thinking to describe how a change in one quantity in a relationship results in a change inthe other; and they connect verbal, numeric, graphic, and symbolic representations of relationships. Students use geometric propertiesand relationships, as well as spatial reasoning, to model and analyze situations and solve problems. Students communicate informationabout geometric figures or situations by quantifying attributes, generalize procedures from measurement experiences, and use theprocedures to solve problems. Students use appropriate statistics, representations of data, reasoning, and concepts of probability to draw

    conclusions, evaluate arguments, and make recommendations.

    (3) Problem solving in meaningful contexts, language and communication, connections within and outside mathematics, and formal andinformal reasoning underlie all content areas in mathematics. Troughout mathematics in Grades 6-8, students use these processestogether with graphing technology and other mathematical tools such as manipulative materials to develop conceptual understanding andsolve problems as they do mathematics.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    7/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 7

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning

    6.1  Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning. Te student represents and  uses rational numbers in a variety of equivalent forms.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) compare and order non-negative rational numbers;

    (B) generate equivalent forms of rational numbers including whole numbers,fractions, and decimals;

    (C) use integers to represent real-life situations;

    (D) write prime factorizations using exponents;

    (E) identify factors of a positive integer, common factors, and the greatest commonfactor of a set of positive integers; and

    (F) identify multiples of a positive integer and common multiples and the leastcommon multiple of a set of positive integers.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    8/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 8

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning

    6.2  Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning. Te student adds, subtracts,  multiplies, and divides to solve problems and justify solutions.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) model addition and subtraction situations involving fractions with objects,pictures, words, and numbers;

    (B) use addition and subtraction to solve problems involving fractionsand decimals;

    (C) use multiplication and division of whole numbers to solve problems including

    situations involving equivalent ratios and rates;

    (D) estimate and round to approximate reasonable results and to solve problemswhere exact answers are not required; and

    (E) use order of operations to simplify whole number expressions (withoutexponents) in problem solving situations.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    9/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 9

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking

    6.3  Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking. Te student solves  problems involving direct proportional relationships.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) use ratios to describe proportional situations;

    (B) represent ratios and percents with concrete models, fractions, anddecimals; and

    (C) use ratios to make predictions in proportional situations.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    10/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 10

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking

    6.4  Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking. Te student uses letters asvariables in mathematical expressions to describe how one quantity changeswhen a related quantity changes.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) use tables and symbols to represent and describe proportional and other  relationships such as those involving conversions, arithmetic sequences (with a

    constant rate of change), perimeter and area; and

    (B) use tables of data to generate formulas representing relationships involvingperimeter, area, volume of a rectangular prism, etc.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    11/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 11

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking

    6.5  Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking. Te student uses letters torepresent an unknown in an equation.

    Te student is expected to formulate equations from problem situations described bylinear relationships.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    12/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 12

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Geometry and spatial reasoning

    6.6  Geometry and spatial reasoning. Te student uses geometric vocabulary to  describe angles, polygons, and circles.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) use angle measurements to classify angles as acute, obtuse, or right;

    (B) identify relationships involving angles in triangles and quadrilaterals; and

    (C) describe the relationship between radius, diameter, and circumference ofa circle.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    13/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 13

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Geometry and spatial reasoning

    6.7  Geometry and spatial reasoning. Te student uses coordinate geometry toidentify location in two dimensions.

    Te student is expected to locate and name points on a coordinate plane using orderedpairs of non-negative rational numbers.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    14/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 14

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Measurement

    6.8  Measurement. Te student solves application problems involving estimationand measurement of length, area, time, temperature, volume, weight,and angles.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) estimate measurements (including circumference) and evaluate reasonableness  of results;

    (B) select and use appropriate units, tools, or formulas to measure and to solveproblems involving length (including perimeter), area, time, temperature,volume, and weight;

    (C) measure angles; and

    (D) convert measures within the same measurement system (customary and metric)based on relationships between units.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    15/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 15

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Probability and statistics

    6.9  Probability and statistics. Te student uses experimental and theoretical  probability to make predictions.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) construct sample spaces using lists and tree diagrams; and

    (B) find the probabilities of a simple event and its complement and describe therelationship between the two.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    16/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 16

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Probability and statistics

    6.10  Probability and statistics. Te student uses s tatistical representations toanalyze data.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) select and use an appropriate representation for presenting and displaying   different graphical representations of the same data including line plot, line

    graph, bar graph, and stem and leaf plot;

    (B) identify mean (using concrete objects and pictorial models), median, mode,and range of a set of data;

    (C) sketch circle graphs to display data; and(D) solve problems by collecting, organizing, displaying, and interpreting data.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    17/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 17

    Mathematics: Grade 6 — Underlying processes and mathematical tools

    6.11  Underlying processes and mathematical tools. Te student applies Grade 6  mathematics to solve problems connected to everyday experiences, investigations inother disciplines, and activities in and outside of school.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) identify and apply mathematics to everyday experiences, to activities in and outside of   school, with other disciplines, and with other mathematical topics;

    (B) use a problem-solving model that incorporates understanding the problem, making aplan, carrying out the pl an, and evaluating the solution for reasonableness;

    (C) select or develop an appropriate problem-solving strategy from a variety of differenttypes, including drawing a picture, looking for a pattern, systematic guessing andchecking, acting it out, making a table, working a simpler problem, or working

    backwards to solve a problem; and(D) select tools such as real objects, manipulatives, paper/pencil, and technology or  techniques such as mental math, estimation, and number sense to solve problems.

    6.12 Underlying processes and mathematical tools. Te student communicatesabout Grade 6 mathematics through informal and mathematical language,representations, and models.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) explain and record observations using objects, words, pictures, numbers, and  communicate mathematical ideas using language, efficient tools, appropriate units, and

    graphical, numerical, physical, or algebraic mathematical models; and

    (B) evaluate the effectiveness of different representations to communicate ideas.6.13 Underlying processes and mathematical tools. Te student uses logical reasoning to

    make conjectures and verify conclusions.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) make conjectures from patterns or sets of examples and nonexamples; and

    (B) validate his/her conclusions using mathematical properties and relationships.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    18/56

    Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis:

    Supporting TEKS Implementation

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 

    Grade 7

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    19/56

    Phase 1: Studying the TEKS

    Phase 2: Narrowing the field of instructional materials

    Phase 3: Assessing mathematical content alignment 

    In Phase 3, participants now conduct in-depth reviews of the materials selected in Phase 2. Tis deeper analysis allows for detailed documentation ofthe degree to which the materials are aligned with the EKS. Te Phase 3 process requires selection committee members to use the outlined criteriato determine a rating and to cite examples to justify their score. Additionally, this phase requires participants to document Knowledge and Skillsstatements and/or Student Expectations that were underemphasized or missing.

    Implementation

    Selection committee members should practice applying the Phase 3 rubric and documentation form to reach consensus on a single sample. Participantsdetermine a starting point, such as a big idea within each strand, to be analyzed across the remaining resources, and then determine a method foraggregating and analyzing the data collected. Next, determine how individuals or small groups will be organized to carry out next steps; include atimeline.

     Materials and Supplies 

    • Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment Blackline Master — multiple copies per person

    • Te 2 to 4 instructional materials selected in Phase 2

    Phase 4: Assessing vertical alignment of instructional materials

    Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: A Four Phase Process

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 19

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    20/56

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 20

    Development 

    1 2 3 4

    Important mathematical ideas are alluded tosimply or are missing, approached primarilyfrom a skill level, or provided for studentsoutside any context.

    Important mathematical ideas are evident,conceptually developed, and emerge within the

    context of real-world examples, interesting problems,application situations, or student investigations.

    Connections

    1 2 3 4

    Important mathematical ideas are developedindependently of each other (i.e., they arediscrete, independent ideas).

    Important mathematical ideas are developed byexpanding and connecting to other important

    mathematical ideas in such a way as to buildunderstanding of mathematics as a unified whole.

    Rigor and Depth

    1 2 3 4

    Important mathematical ideas are applied inroutine problems or in using formulatedprocedures, and are extended in separate /optional problems.

    Important mathematical ideas are applied andextended in novel situations or embedded in the

    content, requiring the extension of importantmathematical ideas and the use of

    multiple approaches.

    Supercially Developed Well Developed

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment

    Scoring Rubric and Documentation Form

    Understanding the Scoring of Important Mathematical Ideas

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    21/56

    Development 

    1 2 3 4

    Skills and procedures are the primary focus, aredeveloped without conceptual understanding,and are loosely connected to importantmathematical ideas — important mathematicalideas are adjunct.

    Skills and procedures are integrated with importantmathematical ideas and are presented as important

    tools in applying and understanding importantmathematical ideas.

    Connections

    1 2 3 4

    Skills and procedures are treated as discreteskills rarely connected to important mathematicalideas or other skills and procedures.

    Skills and procedures are integratedwith—and consistently connected to—

    important mathematical ideas and otherskills and procedures.

    Rigor and Depth

    1 2 3 4

    Skills and procedures are practiced withoutconceptual understanding outside any context,do not require the use of importantmathematical ideas, and are primarilypracticed in rote exercises and drill.

    Skills and procedures are important tothe application and understanding of important

    mathematical ideas, and are embedded inproblem situations.

    Supercially Developed Well Developed

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment

    Scoring Rubric and Documentation Form

    Understanding the Scoring of Skills and Procedures

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 21

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    22/56

    Development 1 2 3 4

    Mathematical relationships are not evident, andmathematics appears as a series of discrete skills

    and ideas.

    Mathematical relationships are evident in such a wayas to build understanding of mathematics as a

    unified whole.

    Connections

    1 2 3 4

    Mathematical relationships are not required ofstudents or are used primarily to provide acontext for the practice of skills or procedures— words wrapped around drill.

    Mathematical relationships are integrated withimportant mathematical ideas, and are integral

    in required activities, problems,and applications.

    Rigor and Depth1 2 3 4

    Mathematical relationships require the use ofskills and procedures, but rarely require the useof any important mathematical ideas orconnections outside mathematics.

    Mathematical relationships require the broad useof mathematics and integrate the need for importantmathematical ideas, skills, and procedures, as well as

    connections outside mathematics.

    Supercially Developed Well Developed

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment

    Scoring Rubric and Documentation Form

    Understanding the Scoring of Mathematical Relationships

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 22

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    23/56

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 23

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Introduction

    (1) Within a well-balanced mathematics curriculum, the primary focal points at Grade 7 are using direct proportional relationships in number,

    geometry, measurement, and probability; applying addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division of decimals, fractions, and integers;and using statistical measures to describe data.

    (2) Troughout mathematics in Grades 6-8, students build a foundation of basic understandings in number, operation, and quantitativereasoning; patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking; geometry and spatial reasoning; measurement; and probability and statistics.Students use concepts, algorithms, and properties of rational numbers to explore mathematical relationships and to describe increasinglycomplex situations. Students use algebraic thinking to describe how a change in one quantity in a relationship results in a change inthe other; and they connect verbal, numeric, graphic, and symbolic representations of relationships. Students use geometric propertiesand relationships, as well as spatial reasoning, to model and analyze situations and solve problems. Students communicate informationabout geometric figures or situations by quantifying attributes, generalize procedures from measurement experiences, and use the

    procedures to solve problems. Students use appropriate statistics, representations of data, reasoning, and concepts of probability to drawconclusions, evaluate arguments, and make recommendations.

    (3) Problem solving in meaningful contexts, language and communication, connections within and outside mathematics, and formal andinformal reasoning underlie all content areas in mathematics. Troughout mathematics in Grades 6-8, students use these processestogether with graphing technology and other mathematical tools such as manipulative materials to develop conceptual understanding andsolve problems as they do mathematics.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    24/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 24

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning

    7.1  Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning. Te student represents anduses numbers in a variety of equivalent forms.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) compare and order integers and positive rational numbers;

    (B) convert between fractions, decimals, whole numbers, and percents mentally, onpaper, or with a calculator; and

    (C) represent squares and square roots using geometric models.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    25/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 25

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning

    7.2  Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning. Te student adds, subtracts,multiplies, or divides to solve problems and justify solutions.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) represent multiplication and division situations involving fractions anddecimals with models, including concrete objects, pictures, words,and numbers;

    (B) use addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division to solve problemsinvolving fractions and decimals;

    (C) use models, such as concrete objects, pictorial models, and number lines, toadd, subtract, multiply, and divide integers and connect the actionsto algorithms;

    (D) use division to find unit rates and ratios in proportional relationships such asspeed, density, price, recipes, and student-teacher ratio;

    (E) simplify numerical expressions involving order of operations and exponents;

    (F) select and use appropriate operations to solve problems and justify theselections; and

    (G) determine the reasonableness of a solution to a problem.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    26/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 26

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking

    7.3  Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking. Te student solves problems  involving direct proportional relationships.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) estimate and find solutions to application problems involving percent; and

    (B) estimate and find solutions to application problems involving proportionalrelationships such as similarity, scaling, unit costs, and related measurementunits.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    27/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 27

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking

    7.4  Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking. Te student represents arelationship in numerical, geometric, verbal, and symbolic form.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) generate formulas involving unit conversions, perimeter, area, circumference,  volume, and scaling;

    (B) graph data to demonstrate relationships in familiar concepts such asconversions, perimeter, area, circumference, volume, and scaling; and

    (C) use words and symbols to describe the relationship between the terms in anarithmetic sequence (with a constant rate of change) and their positions inthe sequence.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    28/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 28

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking

    7.5  Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking. Te student uses equationsto solve problems.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) use concrete and pictorial models to solve equations and use symbols to record  the actions; and

    (B) formulate problem situations when given a simple equation and formulate anequation when given a problem s ituation.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    29/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 29

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Geometry and spatial reasoning

    7.6  Geometry and spatial reasoning. Te student compares and classifiestwo- and three-dimensional figures using geometric vocabulary and properties.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) use angle measurements to classify pairs of angles as complementaryor supplementary;

    (B) use properties to classify triangles and quadrilaterals;

    (C) use properties to classify three-dimensional figures, including pyramids, cones,prisms, and cylinders; and

    (D) use critical attributes to define similarity.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    30/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 30

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Geometry and spatial reasoning

    7.7  Geometry and spatial reasoning. Te student uses coordinate geometry todescribe location on a plane.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) locate and name points on a coordinate plane using ordered pairs ofintegers; and

    (B) graph reflections across the horizontal or vertical axis and graph translationson a coordinate plane.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    31/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 31

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Geometry and spatial reasoning

    7.8  Geometry and spatial reasoning. Te student uses geometry to model anddescribe the physical world.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) sketch three-dimensional figures when given the top, side, and front views;

    (B) make a net (two-dimensional model) of the surface area of a three-dimensional  figure; and

    (C) use geometric concepts and properties to solve problems in fields such as artand architecture.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    32/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 32

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Measurement

    7.9  Measurement. Te student solves application problems involving estimationand measurement.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) estimate measurements and solve application problems involving length  (including perimeter and circumference) and area of polygons and other  shapes;

    (B) connect models for volume of prisms (triangular and rectangular) and cylindersto formulas of prisms (triangular and rectangular) and cylinders; and

    (C) estimate measurements and solve application problems involving volume ofprisms (rectangular and triangular) and cylinders.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    33/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 33

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Probability and statistics

    7.10  Probability and statistics. Te student recognizes that a physical ormathematical model can be used to describe the experimental and theoreticalprobability of real-life events.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) construct sample spaces for simple or composite experiments; and

    (B) find the probability of independent events.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    34/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 34

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Probability and statistics

    7.11  Probability and statistics. Te student understands that the way a set of data   is displayed influences its interpretation.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) select and use an appropriate representation for presenting and displaying   relationships among collected data, including line plot, line graph, bar graph,

    stem and leaf plot, circle graph, and Venn diagrams, and justify theselection; and

    (B) make inferences and convincing arguments based on an analysis of given orcollected data.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    35/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 35

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Probability and statistics

    7.12  Probability and statistics. Te student uses measures of central tendency and  range to describe a set of data.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) describe a set of data using mean, median, mode, and range; and

    (B) choose among mean, median, mode, or range to describe a set of data and justify the choice for a particular situation.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    36/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 36

    7.13  Underlying processes and mathematical tools. Te student applies Grade 7mathematics to solve problems connected to everyday experiences, investigations in

      other disciplines, and activities in and outside of school.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) identify and apply mathematics to everyday experiences, to activities in and outside ofschool, with other disciplines, and with other mathematical topics;

    (B) use a problem-solving model that incorporates understanding the problem, making aplan, carrying out the pl an, and evaluating the solution for reasonableness;

    (C) select or develop an appropriate problem-solving strategy from a variety of differenttypes, including drawing a picture, looking for a pattern, systematic guessing andchecking, acting it out, making a table, working a simpler problem, or workingbackwards to solve a problem; and

    (D) select tools such as real objects, manipulatives, paper/pencil, and technology ortechniques such as mental math, estimation, and number sense to solve problems.

    7.14 Underlying processes and mathematical tools. Te student communicates aboutGrade 7 mathematics through informal and mathematical language, representations,and models.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) communicate mathematical ideas using language, efficient tools, appropriate units, and  graphical, numerical, physical, or algebraic mathematical models; and

    (B) evaluate the effectiveness of different representations to communicate ideas.

    7.15 Underlying processes and mathematical tools. Te student uses logical reasoning tomake conjectures and verify conclusions.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) make conjectures from patterns or sets of examples and nonexamples; and

    (B) validate his/her conclusions using mathematical properties and relationships.

    Mathematics: Grade 7 — Underlying processes and mathematical tools

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    37/56

    Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis:

    Supporting TEKS Implementation

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 

    Grade 8

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    38/56

    Phase 1: Studying the TEKS

    Phase 2: Narrowing the field of instructional materials

    Phase 3: Assessing mathematical content alignment 

    In Phase 3, participants now conduct in-depth reviews of the materials selected in Phase 2. Tis deeper analysis allows for detailed documentation ofthe degree to which the materials are aligned with the EKS. Te Phase 3 process requires selection committee members to use the outlined criteriato determine a rating and to cite examples to justify their score. Additionally, this phase requires participants to document Knowledge and Skillsstatements and/or Student Expectations that were underemphasized or missing.

    Implementation

    Selection committee members should practice applying the Phase 3 rubric and documentation form to reach consensus on a single sample. Participantsdetermine a starting point, such as a big idea within each strand, to be analyzed across the remaining resources, and then determine a method foraggregating and analyzing the data collected. Next, determine how individuals or small groups will be organized to carry out next steps; include atimeline.

     Materials and Supplies 

    • Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment Blackline Master — multiple copies per person

    • Te 2 to 4 instructional materials selected in Phase 2

    Phase 4: Assessing vertical alignment of instructional materials

    Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: A Four Phase Process

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 38

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    39/56

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 39

    Development 

    1 2 3 4

    Important mathematical ideas are alluded tosimply or are missing, approached primarilyfrom a skill level, or provided for students

    outside any context.

    Important mathematical ideas are evident,conceptually developed, and emerge within the

    context of real-world examples, interesting problems,

    application situations, or student investigations.

    Connections

    1 2 3 4

    Important mathematical ideas are developedindependently of each other (i.e., they arediscrete, independent ideas).

    Important mathematical ideas are developed byexpanding and connecting to other important

    mathematical ideas in such a way as to buildunderstanding of mathematics as a unified whole.

    Rigor and Depth

    1 2 3 4

    Important mathematical ideas are applied inroutine problems or in using formulatedprocedures, and are extended in separate /optional problems.

    Important mathematical ideas are applied andextended in novel situations or embedded in the

    content, requiring the extension of importantmathematical ideas and the use of

    multiple approaches.

    Supercially Developed Well Developed

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment

    Scoring Rubric and Documentation Form

    Understanding the Scoring of Important Mathematical Ideas

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    40/56

    Development 

    1 2 3 4

    Skills and procedures are the primary focus, aredeveloped without conceptual understanding,and are loosely connected to important

    mathematical ideas — important mathematicalideas are adjunct.

    Skills and procedures are integrated with importantmathematical ideas and are presented as important

    tools in applying and understanding important

    mathematical ideas.

    Connections

    1 2 3 4

    Skills and procedures are treated as discreteskills rarely connected to important mathematicalideas or other skills and procedures.

    Skills and procedures are integratedwith—and consistently connected to—

    important mathematical ideas and otherskills and procedures.

    Rigor and Depth

    1 2 3 4

    Skills and procedures are practiced withoutconceptual understanding outside any context,do not require the use of importantmathematical ideas, and are primarilypracticed in rote exercises and drill.

    Skills and procedures are important tothe application and understanding of important

    mathematical ideas, and are embedded inproblem situations.

    Supercially Developed Well Developed

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment

    Scoring Rubric and Documentation Form

    Understanding the Scoring of Skills and Procedures

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 40

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    41/56

    Development 1 2 3 4

    Mathematical relationships are not evident, andmathematics appears as a series of discrete skillsand ideas.

    Mathematical relationships are evident in such a wayas to build understanding of mathematics as a

    unified whole.

    Connections

    1 2 3 4

    Mathematical relationships are not required ofstudents or are used primarily to provide acontext for the practice of skills or procedures— words wrapped around drill.

    Mathematical relationships are integrated withimportant mathematical ideas, and are integral

    in required activities, problems,and applications.

    Rigor and Depth

    1 2 3 4

    Mathematical relationships require the use ofskills and procedures, but rarely require the useof any important mathematical ideas orconnections outside mathematics.

    Mathematical relationships require the broad useof mathematics and integrate the need for importantmathematical ideas, skills, and procedures, as well as

    connections outside mathematics.

    Supercially Developed Well Developed

    Phase 3: Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment

    Scoring Rubric and Documentation Form

    Understanding the Scoring of Mathematical Relationships

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 41

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    42/56

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 42

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Introduction

    (1) Within a well-balanced mathematics curriculum, the primary focal points at Grade 8 are using basic principles of algebra to analyze andrepresent both proportional and non-proportional linear relationships and using probability to describe data and make predictions.

    (2) Troughout mathematics in Grades 6-8, students build a foundation of basic understandings in number, operation, and quantitativereasoning; patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking; geometry and spatial reasoning; measurement; and probability and statistics.Students use concepts, algorithms, and properties of rational numbers to explore mathematical relationships and to describe increasinglycomplex situations. Students use algebraic thinking to describe how a change in one quantity in a relationship results in a change inthe other; and they connect verbal, numeric, graphic, and symbolic representations of relationships. Students use geometric propertiesand relationships, as well as spatial reasoning, to model and analyze situations and solve problems. Students communicate informationabout geometric figures or situations by quantifying attributes, generalize procedures from measurement experiences, and use theprocedures to solve problems. Students use appropriate statistics, representations of data, reasoning, and concepts of probability to draw

    conclusions, evaluate arguments, and make recommendations.(3) Problem solving in meaningful contexts, language and communication, connections within and outside mathematics, and formal and

    informal reasoning underlie all content areas in mathematics. Troughout mathematics in Grades 6-8, students use these processestogether with graphing technology and other mathematical tools such as manipulative materials to develop conceptual understanding andsolve problems as they do mathematics.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    43/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 43

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Number, operation, and quantitative thinking

    8.1  Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning. Te student understandsthat different forms of numbers are appropriate for different situations.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) compare and order rational numbers in various forms including integers,  percents, and positive and negative fractions and decimals;

    (B) select and use appropriate forms of rational numbers to solve real-life problemsincluding those involving proportional relationships;

    (C) approximate (mentally and with calculators) the value of irrational numbers as

    they arise from problem situations (such as π, √2); and(D) express numbers in scientific notation, including negative exponents, in

    appropriate problem situations.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    44/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 44

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Number, operation, and quantitative thinking

    8.2  Number, operation, and quantitative reasoning. Te student selects and uses  appropriate operations to solve problems and justify solutions.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) select appropriate operations to solve problems involving rational numbers and  justify the selections;

    (B) use appropriate operations to solve problems involving rational numbers inproblem situations;

    (C) evaluate a solution for reasonableness; and

    (D) use multiplication by a constant factor (unit rate) to represent proportionalrelationships.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    45/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 45

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking

    8.3  Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking. Te student identifiesproportional or non-proportional linear relationships in problem s ituationsand solves problems.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) compare and contrast proportional and non-proportional linearrelationships; and

    (B) estimate and find solutions to application problems involving percents andother proportional relationships such as similarity and rates.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    46/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 46

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking

    8.4  Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking. Te student makesconnections among various representations of a numerical relationship.

    Te student is expected to generate a different representation of data given anotherrepresentation of data (such as a table, graph, equation, or verbal description).

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    47/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 47

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking

    8.5  Patterns, relationships, and algebraic thinking. Te student uses graphs,tables, and algebraic representations to make predictions and solve problems.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) predict, find, and justify solutions to application problems using appropriate  tables, graphs, and algebraic equations; and

    (B) find and evaluate an algebraic expression to determine any term in anarithmetic sequence (with a constant rate of change).

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    48/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 48

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Geometry and spatial reasoning

    8.6  Geometry and spatial reasoning. Te student uses transformational geometry   to develop spatial sense.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) generate similar figures using dilations including enlargements andreductions; and

    (B) graph dilations, reflections, and translations on a coordinate plane.

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    49/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 49

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Geometry and spatial reasoning

    8.7 

    Geometry and spatial reasoning.Te student uses geometry to model and

    describe the physical world.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) draw three-dimensional figures from different perspectives;

    (B) use geometric concepts and properties to solve problems in fields such as artand architecture;

    (C) use pictures or models to demonstrate the Pythagorean Teorem; and

    (D) locate and name points on a coordinate plane using ordered pairs of

    rational numbers.

    d

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    50/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 50

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Measurement

    8.8  Measurement. Te student uses procedures to determine measures of three-  dimensional figures.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) find lateral and total surface area of prisms, pyramids, and cylinders using   concrete models and nets (two-dimensional models);

    (B) connect models of prisms, cylinders, pyramids, spheres, and cones to formulasfor volume of these objects; and

    (C) estimate measurements and use formulas to solve application problemsinvolving lateral and total surface area and volume.

    R i d B

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    51/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 51

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Measurement

    8.9  Measurement. Te student uses indirect measurement to solve problems.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) use the Pythagorean Teorem to solve real-life problems; and

    (B) use proportional relationships in similar two-dimensional figures or similarthree-dimensional figures to find missing measurements.

    R i d B

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    52/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 52

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Measurement

    8.10  Measurement. Te student describes how changes in dimensions affect linear,  area, and volume measures.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) describe the resulting effects on perimeter and area when dimensions of a shape  are changed proportionally; and

    (B) describe the resulting effect on volume when dimensions of a solid arechanged proportionally.

    R i d B

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    53/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 53

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Probability and statistics

    8.11  Probability and statistics. Te student applies concepts of theoretical andexperimental probability to make predictions.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) find the probabilities of dependent and independent events;

    (B) use theoretical probabilities and experimental results to make predictions anddecisions; and

    (C) select and use different models to simulate an event.

    R i d B

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    54/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 54

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Probability and statistics

    8.12  Probability and statistics. Te student uses statistical procedures todescribe data.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) select the appropriate measure of central tendency or range to describe a set of   data and justify the choice for a particular situation;

    (B) draw conclusions and make predictions by analyzing trends in scatterplots; and

    (C) select and use an appropriate representation for presenting and displayingrelationships among collected data, including line plots, line graphs, stemand leaf plots, circle graphs, bar graphs, box and whisker plots, histograms, and

    Venn diagrams, with and without the use of technology.

    Reviewed By:

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    55/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006, 2007, Charles A. Dana Center at Te University of exas at Austin Mathematics Instructional Materials Analysis: Phase 3 — Assessing Mathematical Content Alignment 55

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Probability and statistics

    8.13  Probability and statistics. Te student evaluates predictions and conclusions  based on statistical data.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) evaluate methods of sampling to determine validity of an inference made from  a set of data; and

    (B) recognize misuses of graphical or numerical information and evaluatepredictions and conclusions based on data analysis.

    Reviewed By:

  • 8/18/2019 Rubrik Mengkaji Buku Matematika

    56/56

    Knowledge and Skills Summary and documentation of how the TEKS statements are met, withexamples from the materials

    Important Mathematical Ideas

    Skills and Procedures

    Mathematical Relationships

    Summary / Justification / Evidence

    Knowledge and Skill and/or Student Expectation(s) missing or not well developed in theinstructional materials (if any):

    Overall Rating 

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    1 2 3 4

    Reviewed By: _____________________________________

    itle of Instructional Materials: _____________________________________

    © 2006 2007 Ch l A D C T U i i f A i M h i I i l M i l A l i Ph 3 A i M h i l C Ali 56

    8.14  Underlying processes and mathematical tools. Te student applies Grade 8

    mathematics to solve problems connected to everyday experiences, investigations in otherdisciplines, and activities in and outside of school.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) identify and apply mathematics to everyday experiences, to activities in and outside of   school, with other disciplines, and with other mathematical topics;

    (B) use a problem-solving model that incorporates understanding the problem, making aplan, carrying out the plan, and evaluating the solution for reasonableness;

    (C) select or develop an appropriate problem-solving strategy from a variety of differenttypes, including drawing a picture, looking for a pattern, systematic guessing andchecking, acting it out, making a table, working a simpler problem, or workingbackwards to solve a problem; and

    (D) select tools such as real objects, manipulatives, paper/pencil, and technology ortechniques such as mental math, estimation, and number sense to solve problems.

    8.15 Underlying processes and mathematical tools. Te student communicates aboutGrade 8 mathematics through informal and mathematical language, representations,and models.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) communicate mathematical ideas using language, efficient tools, appropriate units, and  graphical, numerical, physical, or algebraic mathematical models; and

    (B) evaluate the effectiveness of different representations to communicate ideas.

    8.16 Underlying processes and mathematical tools. Te student uses logical reasoning tomake conjectures and verify conclusions.

    Te student is expected to:

    (A) make conjectures from patterns or sets of examples and nonexamples; and

    (B) validate his/her conclusions using mathematical properties and relationships.

    Mathematics: Grade 8 — Underlying processes and mathematical tools