ROP and Pos. Paper

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    1/22

    1. ROP and Parliamentary Procedures

    1.1 Chair and Vice Chair

    A Chair plays an utmost important role during the course of the

    conference and in many cases are assisted by a vice chair. Thenumber of vice chairs rely on the size if the conference not to

    mention the participators within it. In many conferences a chair is

    assisted by two vice chairs, and in other cases by only one.

    1.1.1 Chair

    The task of a Chair is explained as follows:

    a. A chair opens, closes and adjourns debates, given

    that the specific council affirms mid-breaks.

    b. A Chair is to lead through the course of the debate

    and is granted authority to affirm decisions, whereas

    a vice chair in hierarchical terms position below

    them.

    c. Substance-wise, a Chair should be able to project the

    output and therefore is expected to fully understand

    the substance of the debate. Should the debate lose

    its track, the Chair is to place it back in its rightful

    order.

    d. As the key-holder to several important decisions

    throughout the conference, a chair has to qualify in

    terms of KETEGASANbe very firm and stern. This

    applies in substantive and procedural simulation

    matters, in order to create a condusive and effective

    resolution. Not only that, the Chairs bears with them

    the name of their council and must therefore be able

    to create the specific atmosphere needed to create

    an effective discussion.

    e. Their accountability is also reflected through

    technical authorities to grant and legitimize Working

    Papers and Draft Resolutions, therefore giving them

    further right to label them in numbers.

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    2/22

    f. They are authorized to monitor and to take necessary

    actions as to matters of conference

    condusivenessconduciveness, riots, and granting

    permission to members of the council who wish toexcuse themselves.

    g. They are to supervise and monitor delegates with

    achievements throughout the course of the council.

    Announcements usually take place after Final

    Resolutions are affirmed and the council has finally

    ended.

    1.1.2 Vice-Chair

    As earlier mentioned a vice chair plays a fairly similar

    role as the Chair, but differs in terms of strength of

    authority, hierarchical position and decision making. Also to

    be taken into consideration is the role of a moderator. As

    known, a council runs through a procedural basis and it is

    therefore the task of a moderator to make sure it runs on

    its rightful track. This, complemented by a Chair and its

    Vice is to sustain the function of the council as substantial

    supervisors. They, therefore completes the council. But it is

    also wise to keep in mind that MUNs throughout the

    corners of the world vary, therefore terms and condition

    apply. Not all MUNs come with moderators, therefore adds

    the uniqueness MUNs in general.

    1.2 Rules of Procedure

    1.2.1 ROP in Brief

    Since The Model of United Nations is a formal type of

    conference, then it certainly needs a proper system and

    procedure in its application. The Rule of Procedure is the

    compilation of rules that is meant to be the guidance of the

    conference. There might be a lot of delegates who get

    involved in this conference. And definitely, there might be

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    3/22

    a lot of different arguments and points of view as well. And

    this rule of procedure is made to handle this situation.

    Having compiled extensive research on the topicareas, and having developed a understanding of the

    represented countrys stance on the issue, the delegates

    are no ready to try to solve the problem while keeping their

    national interests in mind. Yet delegates may be unsure of

    how the actual committee will run. Because the United

    Nations strives to include every member of the

    international community, its membership is very large. As a

    result, debate must follow an organized procedure to be

    productive. The Rules of Procedure that MUN use at some

    different models are a synthesis of parliamentary rules

    from a variety of sources: the United Nations, Roberts

    Rules of Order, etc. Dont be discouraged; learning the

    rules is like mastering a new language - at first it is a bit

    confusing, but after a little practice you learn how to

    function in the new environment.

    1.2.2 Example

    [Appendix example

    of Rules of Procedure]

    General

    1. SCOPE: These rules for the General Assembly, the

    Economic and Social Council, the Economic and Social

    Commission for Asia and the Pacific, the Organization of

    African Unity, the Organization of American States, and the

    Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe are

    self-sufficient, except for modifications provided by the

    Secretariat, and shall be considered adopted in advance of

    session. No other rules of procedure are applicable.

    2. LANGUAGE: English shall be the official and working

    language of the conference.

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    4/22

    3. STATEMENTS BY THESECRETARIAT: The Secretary-

    General or a member of the Secretariat designated by him,

    may at any time make either oral or written statements to

    the committee.4. DELEGATIONS: Each member will be represented by

    one or two delegates and one vote on each committee.

    5. CREDENTIALS: The credentials of all delegations have

    been accepted upon registration. Actions relating to the

    modification of rights, privileges, or credentials of any

    member may not be initiated without the written consent

    of the Secretary General. Any representative to whose

    admission a member objects shall provisionally be seated

    with the same rights as other representatives, pending a

    decision from the Secretary-General.

    6. PARTICIPATION OF NON-MEMBERS: Representatives

    of Accredited Observers shall have the same rights as

    those of full members, except that they may not sign or

    vote on substantive issues such as resolutions or

    amendments, but they can vote on procedural matters. A

    representative of an organization which is not a member of

    the United Nations or an Accredited Observer may address

    a committee only with the prior approval of the Director.

    7. GENERAL POWERS OF THESECRETARIAT: The

    Director shall declare the opening and closing of each

    meeting and may propose the adoption of any procedural

    motion to which there is no significant objection. The

    Director, subject to these rules, shall have complete control

    of the proceedings at any meeting. The Moderator shall

    direct discussions, accord the right to speak, put questions,

    announce decisions, rule on points of order, and ensure

    and enforce the observance of these rules. The Moderator

    may temporarily transfer his or her duties to another

    member of the Committee staff. Committee staff members

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    5/22

    may also advise delegations on the possible course of

    debate. In the exercise of these functions, the Committee

    staff shall be at all times subject to these rules and

    responsible to the Secretary-General.8. APPEAL: Any decision of the Moderator or Director, with

    the exception of those that are explicitly stated to be

    unappealable, may be appealed immediately by a

    delegate. The Moderator or Director may speak briefly in

    defense of the ruling. The appeal shall then be put to a

    vote, and the decision of the Chair shall stand unless

    overruled by a majority of those members present and

    voting. The Directors decision not to sign a resolution or

    amendment is never appealable. A Yes vote indicates

    support of the Chairs ruling; a No vote indicates opposition

    to that ruling. The Chairs ruling shall stand unless

    overruled by a majority of No votes.

    9. QUORUM: The Director may declare a Committee open

    and permit debate to proceed when at least one quarter of

    the members of the Committee are present. A member of

    the Committee is a representative who is officially

    registered with the Conference. The presence of a majority

    of the members shall be required for the vote on any

    substantive motion. A quorum shall be assumed to be

    present unless specifically challenged and shown to be

    absent.

    10. COURTESY: All delegates shall show courtesy and

    respect to the Committee staff and to other delegates. The

    Moderator shall immediately call to order any delegate who

    fails to comply with this rule.

    Debate

    11. AGENDA: The first order of business for the

    Committee shall be the consideration of the Agenda. The

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    6/22

    only motion in order at this time will be in the form of I

    move that Topic Area X be placed first on the Agenda.

    The motion requires a second and is debatable.

    A Speakers list shall be established for and against themotion.

    A motion to close debate will be in order after the

    Committee has heard two speakers for the motion and two

    against or all the speakers on one side and at least two on

    the opposite side. The Moderator shall recognize two

    speakers against the motion to close debate, and a vote of

    two-thirds is required for closure of debate on the agenda.

    When the debate is closed, the Committee shall move to

    an immediate vote on the motion; a simple majority is

    required for passage.

    A motion to proceed to the second Topic Area is in order

    only after the Committee has adopted or rejected a

    resolution on the first Topic Area. A motion to proceed to

    the second agenda item after a resolution has failed

    requires a second and is debatable to the extent of one

    speaker in favor and one against. This motion requires a

    vote of two-thirds of the members present and voting to

    pass.

    In the event of a crisis or emergency, the Secretary-

    General or Under Secretary-General may call upon a

    committee to table debate on the current topic area so that

    the more urgent matter may be attended to immediately.

    After a resolution has been passed on the crisis topic, the

    committee will return to debate on the tabled topic. If a

    resolution on the crisis topic fails, the committee may

    return to debate on the tabled topic area only at the

    discretion of the Secretary-General or Under-Secretary

    General.

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    7/22

    Comments are not in order during debate on the agenda,

    since deciding the Agenda is a procedural question.

    Motions to caucus are in order during debate on the

    Agenda.12. DEBATE: After the Agenda has been determined, one

    continuously open Speakers list shall be established for

    the purpose of general debate. This Speakers list shall be

    followed for all debate on the Topic Area, except when

    superseded by procedural motions, amendments, or the

    introduction of a resolution. Speakers may speak generally

    on the Topic Area being considered and may address any

    resolution currently on the floor. Once a resolution has

    been introduced, it remains on the floor and may be

    debated until it fails, the Committee postpones debate on

    it, or the Committee moves to the next Topic Area.

    13. CAUCUSING: A motion to caucus is in order at any

    time when the floor is open, prior to closure of debate. The

    delegate must briefly explain its purpose and specify a

    time limit for the caucus, not to exceed twenty minutes.

    The motion shall immediately be put to a vote. A majority

    of members present and voting is required for passage.

    The Moderator may rule the motion out of order and his/her

    decision is not subject to appeal.

    14. MODERATED CAUCUS:The purpose of the moderated

    caucus is to facilitate substantive debate at critical

    junctures in the discussion. In a moderated caucus, the

    Moderator will temporarily depart from the Speakers List

    and call on delegates to speak at his/her discretion. A

    motion for a moderated caucus is in order at any time

    when the floor is open, prior to closure of debate. The

    delegate making the motion must briefly explain its

    purpose and specify a time limit for the caucus. Once

    raised, the motion will be voted on immediately, with

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    8/22

    voting by majority of the members present required for

    passage.

    15. CLOSURE OF DEBATE: When the floor is open, a

    delegate may move to close debate on the substantive orprocedural matter under discussion. The Moderator may,

    subject to appeal, rule such a motion dilatory. When

    closure of debate is moved, the Moderator may recognize

    up to two speakers against the motion. No speaker in favor

    of the motion shall be recognized. Closure of debate

    requires the support of two-thirds of the members present

    and voting. If the there are no speakers against closing

    debate, the committee will automatically vote on the

    closure of debate. If the Committee is in favor of closure,

    the Moderator shall declare the closure of the debate, and

    the resolution or amendment shall be brought to an

    immediate vote.

    16. SUSPENSION OR ADJOURNMENT OF THEMEETING:

    Whenever the floor is open, a delegate may move the

    suspension of the meeting, to suspend all Committee

    functions until the next meeting, or the adjournment of the

    meeting, to suspend all Committee functions for the

    duration of the Conference. The Moderator may rule such

    motions out of order; these decisions shall not be subject to

    appeal. Such motions shall not be debatable but shall be

    immediately put to the vote and shall require a majority to

    pass. A motion to adjourn shall be out of order prior to the

    lapse of three-quarters of the time allotted for the last

    meeting of the Committee.

    17. POSTPONEMENT ANDRESUMPTION OF DEBATE:

    Whenever the floor is open, a delegate may move for the

    postponement of debate on a resolution or amendment

    currently on the floor. The motion shall require two-thirds

    vote to pass and shall be debatable to the extent of one

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    9/22

    speaker in favor and one opposed. No debate or action

    shall be allowed on any resolution or amendment on which

    debate has been postponed. A motion to resume debate on

    an amendment or resolution on which debate has beenpostponed shall require a majority to pass and shall be

    debatable to the extent of one speaker in favor and one

    opposed. Resumption of debate shall cancel the effects of

    postponement of debate.

    18. RECONSIDERATION: A motion to reconsider is in order

    when a resolution or amendment has been adopted or

    rejected, and must be made by a member who voted with

    the majority on the substantive proposal. The Moderator

    shall recognize two speakers opposing the motion after

    which the motion shall be immediately put to a vote. A two-

    thirds majority of the members present and voting is

    required for reconsideration.

    Speeches

    19. SPEAKERS LIST: The Committee shall have at all

    times an open Speakers list for the Topic Area being

    discussed. Separate Speakers lists shall be established as

    needed for procedural motions and debate on

    amendments. A nation may add its name to the Speakers

    list by submitting a request in writing to the Chair, provided

    that nation is not already on the Speakers list. The names

    of the next several nations to speak shall always be posted

    for the convenience of the Committee. The Speakers list

    for the second topic area will not be open until the

    Committee has proceeded to that topic. The Topic Areas

    General Speakers list may never be closed. The speakers

    list is the default activity of the committee. If there are no

    motions on the floor, debate automatically returns to the

    speakers list.

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    10/22

    20. SPEECHES: No delegate may address a session

    without having previously obtained the permission of the

    Moderator. The Moderator may call a speaker to order if his

    or her remarks are not relevant to the subject underdiscussion, or are offensive to any committee members or

    staff.

    21. TIME-LIMIT ON SPEECHES: The Moderator may limit

    the time allotted to each speaker. The minimum time-limit

    shall be ten seconds. When a delegate exceeds his/her

    allotted time, the Moderator may call the speaker to order

    without delay.

    22. YIELDS: A delegate granted the right to speak on a

    substantive issue may yield in one of three ways: to

    another delegate, to questions, or to the Chair.

    Yield to another delegate. His/her remaining time shall be

    given to that delegate, who may not, however, then yield

    back to the original delegate.

    Yield to questions. Questioners shall be selected by the

    Moderator and limited to one question each. The Moderator

    shall have the right to call to order any delegate whose

    question is, in the opinion of the Moderator, rhetorical and

    leading and not designed to elicit information. Only the

    speakers answers to questions shall be deducted from the

    speakers remaining time.

    Yield to the chair. Such a yield should be made if the

    delegate does not wish his/her speech to be subject to

    comments. The moderator shall then move to the next

    speaker. Only one yield is allowed: a speaker who is

    yielded to may not yield at all. Yields are in order only on

    substantive speeches. A delegate must declare yields by

    the conclusion of his/her speech.

    23. COMMENTS: If a substantive speech involves no

    yields, the Moderator may recognize delegates, other than

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    11/22

    the initial speaker, to comment for thirty seconds on the

    specific content of the speech just completed.

    Commentators may not yield. No comments shall be in

    order during debate on procedural motions.24. RIGHT OF REPLY: A delegate whose personal or

    national integrity has been impugned by another delegate

    may request a Right of Reply. The Moderators decision

    whether to grant the Right of Reply is not appealable, and

    a delegate granted a Right of Reply will not address the

    committee except at the request of the Moderator. A Right

    of Reply to a Right of Reply is out of order.

    .Points

    25. POINTS OF PERSONAL PRIVILEGE: Whenever a

    delegate experiences personal discomfort which impairs

    his/her ability to participate in the proceedings, he may rise

    to a Point of Personal Privilege to request that the

    discomfort be corrected. While a Point of Personal Privilege

    may interrupt a speaker, delegates should use this power

    with the utmost discretion.

    26. POINTS OF ORDER: During the discussion of any

    matter, a delegate may rise to a Point of Order to complain

    of improper parliamentary procedure. The Point of Order

    shall be immediately decided by the Moderator in

    accordance with these rules of procedure. The Moderator

    may rule out of order those points which are dilatory or

    improper; such a decision is unappealable. A

    representative rising to a Point of Order may not speak on

    the substance of the matter under discussion. A Point of

    Order may only interrupt a speaker when the speech itself

    is not following proper parliamentary procedure.

    27. POINTS OF PARLIAMENTARY INQUIRY: When the

    floor is open, a delegate may rise to a Point of

    Parliamentary Inquiry to ask the Moderator a question

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    12/22

    regarding the rules of procedure. A Point of Parliamentary

    Inquiry may never interrupt a speaker. Points of

    Information do not exist. Delegates wishing to ask

    substantive questions should do so during a Caucus.

    Substantive

    28. WORKING PAPERS: Delegates may propose working

    papers for committee consideration. Working papers are

    intended to aid the Committee in its discussion and

    formulation of resolutions and need not be written in

    resolution format. Working papers require the signature of

    the Director to be copied and distributed.

    29. RESOLUTIONS: A resolution may be introduced when

    it receives the approval of the Director and is signed by 25

    members in the General Assembly or 10 members in the

    Economic and Social Council, the Economic and Social

    Commission for Asia and the Pacific, the Organization of

    African Unity, the Organization of American States, and the

    Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe.

    Signing a resolution need not indicate support of the

    resolution, and the signer has no further rights or

    obligations. There are no official sponsors of resolutions.

    30. INTRODUCING RESOLUTIONS: Once a resolution has

    been approved as stipulated above and has been copied

    and distributed, a delegate may rise to introduce the

    resolution. The content of such an introduction shall be

    limited to summarizing the operatives of the resolution.

    Such an introduction shall be considered procedural in

    nature, and hence, yields and comments are out of order. A

    resolution shall remain on the floor until debate on that

    specific resolution is postponed or closed. There are no

    sponsors of resolutions. Debate on resolutions proceeds

    according to the Topic Areas General Speakers list.

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    13/22

    31. COMPETENCE: A motion to question the competence

    of the Committee to discuss a resolution or amendment is

    in order only immediately after the resolution has been

    introduced. The motion requires a majority to pass and isdebatable to the extent of one speaker for and one against.

    32. AMENDMENTS: Delegates may amend any resolution

    which has been introduced. An amendment must have the

    approval of the Director and the signatures of 12 members

    in the General Assembly or 5 members in the Economic

    and Social Council, the Economic and Social Commission

    for Asia and the Pacific, the Organization of African Unity,

    the Organization of American States, and the Organization

    for Security and Cooperation in Europe. There are no

    official sponsors amendments. Amendments to

    amendments are out of order; however, an amended part

    of a resolution may be further amended. There are no

    official sponsors of amendments.

    An approved amendment may be introduced when the

    floor is open. General Debate shall be suspended and a

    Speakers list shall be established for and against the

    amendment.

    A motion to close debate will be in order after the

    Committee has heard two speakers for the amendment and

    two against or all the speakers on one side and at least two

    on the opposite side. The

    moderator shall recognize two speakers against the motion

    to close debate, and a vote of two-thirds is required for

    closure.

    When debate is closed on the amendment, the

    Committee shall move to an immediate vote. Once the

    Committee has acted upon the amendment, general

    debate according to the general Speakers list shall

    resume.

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    14/22

    Voting

    33. REORDERING REOSOLUTIONS: Because WorldMUN

    only allows one resolution to bepassed, delegates maypropose to reorder the order in which resolutions are voted

    on for strategic purposes.

    34. DIVISION OF THEQUESTION. After debate on any

    resolution or amendment has been closed, a delegate may

    move that operative parts of the proposal be voted on

    separately. The only substantive vote on a motion to divide

    the question is the final vote on the resolution.

    The Moderator shall, at that point, take any further

    motions to divide the question and then arrange them from

    most severe to least.

    If an objection is made to a motion to divide the question,

    that motion shall be debated to the extent of two speakers

    for and two against, to be followed by an immediate vote

    on that motion.

    If the motion passes, a simple majority being required for

    passage, the resolution shall be divided accordingly, and a

    separate vote shall be taken on each divided part to

    determine whether or not it

    is included in the final draft.

    Those parts of the substantive proposal which are

    subsequently passed shall be recombined into the final

    resolution and shall be put to a (substantive) vote as a

    whole. If all the operative parts of the proposal are

    rejected, the proposal shall be considered to have been

    rejected as a whole.

    35. VOTING: Each country shall have one vote. Each vote

    may be a Yes, No, or Abstain. On procedural motions,

    members may not abstain. Members present and voting

    shall be defined as members casting an affirmative or

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    15/22

    negative vote. Members who abstain from voting on

    substantive matters are considered as not voting. All

    matters shall be voted upon by placards, except in the case

    of a roll call vote. After the Moderator has announced thebeginning of voting, no delegate shall interrupt the voting

    except on a Point of Personal Privilege or on a Point of

    Order in connection with the conduct of the voting. If a

    majority is required, ties fail. The substantive vote on

    whether or not a committee will pass a resolution requires

    a majority to pass.

    36. ROLL CALL VOTING: After debate is closed on any

    resolution or amendment, any delegate may request a roll

    call vote. Such a motion may be made from the floor,

    seconded by 25 members of the GA, 15 members of the

    ECOSOC, the Economic and Social Commission for Asia and

    the Pacific, the Organization of African Unity, the

    Organization of American States, and the Organization for

    Security and Cooperation in Europe. A motion for a roll call

    vote is in order only for substantive motions.

    In a roll call vote, the Moderator shall call the roll call in

    alphabetical order starting with a randomly selected

    member.

    In the first round, delegates may vote Yes, No,

    Abstain, or Pass. Delegates who do not pass may

    request the right to explain their votes.

    A delegate who passes during the first sequence of the

    roll call must vote during the second sequence. This

    delegate may request the right to explain his or her vote.

    The Moderator shall then call for changes of votes; no

    delegate may request a right of explanation if he or she did

    not request one in the previous two sequences.

    All delegates who requested rights of explanation shall

    then be granted the right to explain their votes.

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    16/22

    The Moderator shall then announce the outcome of the

    vote.

    37. PRECEDENCE: Motions shall be considered in the

    following order of preference:

    1. Parliamentary Points

    a. Points which may interrupt a speaker:

    Points of Personal Privilege (Rule 24)

    Points of Order (Rule 25)

    b. Points which are in order only when the floor is open:

    Points of Parliamentary Inquiry (Rule 26)

    2. Procedural motions that is not debatable:

    a. Adjournment of the Meeting (Rule 15)

    b. Suspension of the Meeting (Rule 15)

    c. Caucusing (Rule 12)

    d. Moderated Caucus (Rule 13)

    3. Procedural motion that are applicable to a

    resolution or

    amendment under consideration:

    a. Closure of Debate (Rule 14) b. Postponement of Debate

    (Rule 16)

    b. Competence (Rule 30in order only after introduction of

    resolution or amendment)

    c. Division of the Question (Rule 32in order only after

    debate has been closed)

    4. Substantive motions:

    a. Amendments (Rule 31)

    b. Resolution (Rules 28-29)

    5. Other procedural motions:

    a. Resumption of Debate (Rule 16)

    b. Reconsideration (Rule 17)

    1.3 Parliamentary Procedures

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    17/22

    1.3.1 Quorum

    The Director may declare a Committee open and permit

    debate to proceed when at least one-quarter of the

    members of the Committee (as declared at the beginningof the first session) are present. The presence of a majority

    of the members (as declared at the beginning of the first

    session) will be required for the vote on any substantive

    motion. A quorum will be assumed to be present unless

    specifically challenged and shown to be absent. A roll call is

    never required to determine the presence of a quorum.

    1.3.2 Points

    If you want to ask a question, or point the attention of the

    Chairperson to something, you use a Point. For example,

    when you cannot hear the speaker, when you think the

    Chair has made a procedural mistake, or when you do not

    understand the decision of the Chair and want to clarify the

    procedure. There are three types of Points (Point of

    Personal Privilege, Point of Parliamentary Inquiryand Point

    of Order).

    1.3.2.1 Points of Parliamentary Inquiry

    When the floor is open, a delegate may rise to a Point

    of Parliamentary Inquiry to ask the Moderator a

    question regarding the rules of procedure. This

    however, may never interrupt a speaker. Delegates

    with substantive questions should not rise to this

    point, but should rather approach the committee

    staff during caucus or send note to the dais.

    1.3.2.2 Points of Order

    During the discussion of any matter, a delegate may

    rise to a Point of Order to complain of improper

    parliamentary procedure. The Point of Order shall be

    immediately decided by the Moderator in accordance

    with these rules of procedure. The Moderator may

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    18/22

    rule out of order those points which are dilatory or

    improper; such a decision is un-appealable. A

    representative rising to a Point of Order may not

    speak on the substance of the matter underdiscussion. A Point of Order may only interrupt a

    speaker when the speech itself is not following

    proper parliamentary procedure.

    1.3.2.3 Points of Personal Privilege

    Whenever a delegate experiences extreme

    discomfort, which impairs him/her from partaking in

    the proceeding, he/she may rise to a Point of

    Personal Privilege, so that the discomfort may be

    corrected. Such a point may interrupt a speaker and

    so should be used with the utmost discretion.

    1.3.2.4 Points of (National) Reply

    A delegate whose personal or national integrity has

    been affronted by that of another delegate, within

    the scope of formal debate, may request the

    Moderator for the Right of Reply. If approved by the

    Secretariat, the respective delegate will be severely

    reprimanded and possibly excluded from further

    committee proceeding. Delegates are requested to

    employ the Right of Reply with the utmost discretion.

    In addition to that, in several MUNs a delegate whose

    personal or national integrity has been impugned by

    another delegate may submit a Right of Reply only in

    writing to the Committee staff. The Director will grant

    the Right of Reply at his/her discretion; this decision

    is not appealable. A delegate granted a a Right of

    Reply will not address the committee except at the

    request of the Director. A Right of Reply to a Right of

    Reply is out of order.

    1.3.3 Yield

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    19/22

    A yield is what you do with the remainder of your

    speaking time. Yielding essentially means giving the rest of

    your time to someone. You may yield to other delegation,

    to questions (if you are willing to answer them), or to theChairperson (if you have finished speaking or you have no

    more time anyway).

    You may yield:

    to questions,

    your time to the chair,

    your time to another delegate.

    If you yield to questions, two other delegates (chosen at

    the Moderators discretion) will, in turn, ask you two

    questions (pertaining to your speech, of course) that you

    will have to field in a maximum time of a minute each. If

    your speech is highly controversial, and you feel that you

    are unable to defend it by answering questions, you may

    yield to the chair, in which case the two comments that

    should follow are also out of order, and Speakers List

    moves onto the next speaker.

    If you happen to have time left within your speaking

    time, you may yield that time to another member nation.

    The following two comments will then be out of order and

    the Speakers List will move on after your time has elapsed.

    1.3.3.1 Yielding to Chair

    Such a yield should be made if the delegate does not

    wish his/her speech to be subject to questions. The

    Director will then move to the next speaker.

    1.3.3.2 Yielding to Another Delegate

    His or her remaining time will be offered to that

    delegate. If the delegate accepts the yield, the

    Director shall recognize the delegate for the

    remaining time. To turn the floor over to a co-

    delegate of the same member state is not considered

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    20/22

    a yield. The second delegate speaking may not yield

    back to the original delegate.

    1.3.3.3 Yielding to Questions

    Questions will be selected by the Director and limitedto one question each. Follow-up questions will be

    allowed only at the discretion of the Director. The

    Director will have the right to call to order to any

    delegate whose question is in the opinion of the

    Director, rhetorical, leading and/or not designed to

    elict information. Only the speakers answers to

    questions will be deducted from the speakers

    remaining time.

    1.3.4 Comments

    If a substantive speech involves no yields, the Director may

    recognize up to two delegates, other than the original

    speaker (i.e. no yields on yielded time). There are no yields

    allowed if the delegate is speaking on a procedural matter.

    A delegate must declare any yield by the conclusion of

    his/her speech. Even if a delegates time has elapsed,

    he/she must still yield. Yields only need to be made when in

    a Speakers List.

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    21/22

    2. Position Paper

    2.1 Nature of Position Papers

    Position paper is an essay detailing your countrys policies on

    the topics being discussed in your committee. Position papers area great way to sift through and distill all the information you

    discover through research in a simple format that serves as a

    valuable reference for yourself, other delegates, and directors.

    The position paper is not an exercise in elaborate writing styles

    or a demonstration of breadth of knowledge on a topic; rather, it

    is an opportunity to clarify the issues, state a position, and

    suggest solutions from a certain national perspective for the

    benefit of fellow delegates and the conference staff.

    Furthermore, it serves as an organizer allowing consistent and

    coherent representation during the simulation, the position paper

    indicates a participant's degree of readiness to the chairpersons.

    Many conferences require that each delegation submit a

    position paper. Most conferences that require position papers ask

    for position papers about around a month or even a week

    (depending on the conference) before the conference so that

    staff members can read position papers and get a feel for the

    direction debate will take. If the conference you are attending

    does not require a position paper, you should still consider

    writing one to help you organize your research and prepare your

    speeches.

    Writing a position paper will help you organize your ideas so

    that you can share your countrys position with the rest of the

    committee. Many delegates use their position paper as their

    opening remark. Writing a position paper might appear to be a

    daunting task, especially for new delegates. If you conduct

    extensive research, a position paper should be easy and useful to

    write Position papers are usually ONE to ONE-and-a-HALF pages

    in length. Your position paper should include a brief introduction

    followed by a comprehensive

  • 7/30/2019 ROP and Pos. Paper

    22/22

    They break down your countrys position on the topics that are

    being discussed by the committee. Many conferences will ask for

    specific details in a position paper, so be sure to include all the

    required information. Most conferences will provide delegates abackground guide to the issue. Usually, the background guide

    will contain questions to consider.

    A good position paper will not only provide facts but also

    make proposals for resolutions. It will include:

    A brief introduction to your country and its history

    concerning the topic and committee

    How the issue affects your country

    Your countrys policies with respect to the issue and your

    countrys justification for these policies

    Quotes from your countrys leaders about the issue

    Statistics to back up your countrys position on the issue

    Actions taken by your government with regard to the

    issue

    Conventions and resolutions that your country has signed

    or ratified

    UN actions that your country supported or opposed

    What your country believes should be done to address the

    issue

    What your country would like to accomplish in the

    committees resolution

    How the positions of other countries affect your countrys

    position