FROM AN ASCETICAL SPIRITUALITY OF THE EXERCISES TO THE APOSTOLIC SPIRITUALITY OF THE CONSTITUTIONS: LABORERS IN THE LORD’S VINEYARD

Peter Schineller, S.J.INTRODUCTION

At the end of August, over 170 laypersons, priests, and religious assembled in Loyola, Spain for a week long conference on the Spiritual Exercises. It was obvious in Loyola that the Exercises today are unleashing new, creative energy and impetus into the Church, as more and more laity become expert in the study and in the directing of the Exercises. But for a more compete understanding of Ignatian or Jesuit spirituality and theology, we must examine the Constitutions for insight into the mature, apostolic-minded Ignatius.

While this conference focuses on the Constitutions, it may be helpful to begin by indicating some links, and yet developments from the Spiritual Exercises to the Constitutions. Let me indicate ideas, themes, questions on the Exercises that came up at Loyola, which are also treated in the major writing of Ignatius, the Constitutions. At times, I was frustrated at Loyola, because I saw where input from the Constitutions might enlighten, and fill out the full meaning of some important themes of Ignatian spirituality.

Leadership – The Exercises help form lay leaders, possibly “heroic leadership”. The Constitutions treat of leadership, the qualities needed in the general superior, and the virtue of discreet charity which he especially needs.

o What follows the Exercises? Should they lead to a structured, Christian way of life? Are not elements of this found in the Constitutions? There we see that the Exercises are the first of six experiments. What practices and experiences might follow a guided retreat?

Who can give the Exercises? What parts should be given? How can they be adapted? The Constitutions explain that those in formation who have made them can share them, and for the most part should share the First Week.

Discernment. Xavier faced a decision on whether or not to go to Japan and China. The Constitutions present much material on how to make decisions about what ministry to undertake.

The spiritual vision and theology of the Exercises can be seen as groundbreaking, as the beginning of a modern world. So too, the Constitutions are at times very close to the theology and missiology of the Second Vatican Council, in its Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World.

Prayer. Insights and guidelines from the Constitutions can help shape the ongoing prayer life of an apostolic person.

These are some of the areas examined at the Loyola Conference on the Exercises. I believe that insights from the Constitutions of the mature Ignatius can deepen our understanding of these and other areas of Ignatian spirituality.

1

MY WAY OF PROCEEDING I will unpack and develop nine summary statements. A fuller explanation of most of them can be found in the issue of Studies which I wrote several years ago.1

1. The audience of the Exercises is the individual Christian seeking to find the will of God in life. The audience of the Constitutions is the Society of Jesus and Church officials upon whom we depend for our legitimacy.

The result of making the Exercises is finding the will of God, and ordering one’s life. It may lead one to choose marriage or single life, an apostolic religious life or a contemplative way of life. The Exercises do not necessarily lead to an apostolic way of life. On the other hand, the Constitutions define the Jesuit and his pathway to God. They are originally and primarily for Jesuits. For one who has made the decision to be an apostolic person, the Constitutions begin where the Exercises end. They explain how the Society of Jesus is to grow, accomplish its goals, carry out its mission and projects, and be apostolically effective.

The Exercises were written by the early Ignatius, based upon his own conversion experience. The Constitutions were the fruit of the older, mature Ignatius, reflecting upon the body of men he had gathered who offer their services to the Church. Ignatius spent more time composing the Constitutions than the Exercises (from 1541 to 1549 preparatory documents, from 1549-1556, composition and different drafts).2

These differences between the two key Ignatian documents should lead us to be open to some development in the theology and spirituality of St. Ignatius. As the title of this talk indicates, I characterize this shift as a development “from an ascetical spirituality of the Exercises to the apostolic spirituality of the Constitutions.”3

2. There is a significant shift in the basic imagery of Ignatius, from the soldier and the pilgrim (often ascetic pilgrim) of the Exercises to the laborers in the vineyard in the Constitutions.

1 Peter Schineller “The Pilgrim Journey of Ignatius…” Studies in the Spirituality of Jesuits, 31/4 September 1999.

2For one study of this, see Andre de Jaer S.J. Together for Mission – A Spiritual Reading of the Constitutions of the Society of Jesus The Institute of Jesuit Sources, St. Louis, 2001

3 According to Howard Gray, “The Exercises offer a program of conversion, discipleship and dedication; the Constitutions offer a specific way for living out the values of the Exercises.” The famed tertian instructor Paul Kenney explained that the Constitutions are the Spiritual Exercises lived by a group. Thus the Exercises could be viewed as the beginning, the turn, the spark, the choosing. The Constitutions present the long term way of life. They explain how a particular body (the Jesuits) are to choose, dismiss, form, train, educate, send forth, lived united in mind and heart, under one general superior, and how in the final Part X, they are to sustain all of this in the long haul.

2

From the Exercises, we know the importance of the image for St. Ignatius. In this summary statement, I wish to outline an important shift in his imagery.

The image of the laborer in the Lord=s vineyard comes to flower and flourish in the Constitutions. It emerges as the predominant, consistent, and constant image to refer to what Jesuits do and what they are called and formed to accomplish.4 Not only the frequency, but the strategic places where the image is found show its significance. It occurs most frequently in Part VII on mission, the section written first, and one which Ignatius himself seems to be most responsible for. Justly called the centerpiece of the Constitutions, this Part is entitled AThe Relations to their Neighbor of Those Already Incorporated into the Society when they are Dispersed into the Vineyard of Christ Our Lord.@ Whether at the call of the Pope or the Superior, whether traveling or residing, Athey are dispersed throughout Christ=s vineyard to labor in that part of it, and in that work which have been entrusted to them@ and where Amuch fruit of glory and service to God is expected@ (603).

No. 622 makes the image more explicit in describing the norms in making choices in regard to missions. Jesuits should be sent to the parts which have Agreater need@, to Awhere greater fruit is likely to be reaped,@ where there is hope of Apreserving the fruit produced to the glory of God.@5

While Part VII on mission is the center, earlier sections of the Constitutions on the admission and formation of members also employ the image. Candidates are described as Athose who hope to enter the Society in order to be good and faithful sowers in the Lord=s field and to preach his divine word@ (General Examen, No. 30.6

In the very first paragraph of Part III on the preservation and progress of members, we are to care that the members have and preserve the Ahealth and bodily strength necessary to labor in the Lord=s vineyard@ (243). The second paragraph of Part IV, on the formation of those retained in the Society affrirms that we should be Aadmitting young men whose good habits of life and talent give hope that they will become both virtuous and learned in order to labor in the vineyard of Christ our Lord@ (308).

Ignatius constantly calls for communications among those laboring in the vineyard. They should Akeep the superior informed by frequent reports about the fruit which is gained@ (626). This not only informs and encourages one another, but also supplies the superior with information that will enable him to make better decisions regarding future missions. The Constitutions require weekly letters if possible, from those Asent to bear fruit in the Lord=s field@ (674).

In sum, in the Constitutions the Jesuit is primarily and consistently described as one admitted and trained to be a laborer in the vineyard, or as one already formed and laboring in the Lord=s vineyard. Elements of the image of the soldier and the pilgrim (so important for Ignatius) are found in the Constitutions, but they are overshadowed by the beautiful image of the laborer in the Lord’s vineyard.7

6 In Part I we admit candidates Aendeavoring to secure in the Society an increase of workers for the holy vineyard of Christ our Lord@ (144). We add new members in order to Arelieve those who are laboring in the Lord=s vineyard, or who are studying to labor in it later,...@(149)

3

Clearly I find most enriching the image of laborers in the Lord = s vineyard. 8 The world is seen not as a battlefield, prison, or vale of tears, but as a God’s garden or the Lord’s vineyard, a place of life and growth. As laborers in the vineyard, we make a difference in this world. We are involved in a living and life-giving project, a constructive task whose goal is to bear fruit for the Lord. We are co-workers with God (1 Cor. 3:9). We do not just pass through, or simply weave baskets in the day and take them apart at night. Rather we are here to tend the garden and bear fruit, fruit that will last. One who works in a vineyard is an optimist, a laborer committed to the long haul, to patient, respectful, cooperation with fellow laborers and with the Lord of the harvest. Yet it is not a soft and idyllic image. One must be ready to bear the heat of the day. The enemy is also at work. One faces the frustrations of dry seasons, weeds and diseases. One must clear the stones, dig the soil, plant and tend, fertilize and prune. An abundant harvest presupposes days of sweat and hard labor.9

Perhaps the shift of the first Jesuits to realize the importance of education and educational institutions goes hand in hand with their identity as laborers in the Lord=s vineyard. Indeed, the early educational institutions of the Society were founded as seminaries, literally Aseed beds@ for future Jesuit laborers.

3. The emphasis upon a test or trial spirituality of the Exercises shifts to the project or mission spirituality (and theology) of the Constitutions.

Here I rely upon the writings of Juan Luis Segundo. He makes a very helpful distinction between a trial or test spirituality and a project or mission spirituality. Segundo quite pointedly sees this shift from the TEST OR TRIAL spirituality of the Exercises to the PROJECT SPIRITUALITY of the later Ignatius.10 In a test or trial spirituality, the earth is a vale of tears and dangerous. Our goal in life is to pass through, uncontaminated. God judges us kindly because not died in a state of mortal sin. In a project spirituality we are here in order to get involved in the service of humankind. Our goal is not simply to avoid sin, but to overcome sin, to transform what is unjust into justice. We are judged by the fruits of our actions, by how we have used our talents, and made a difference in our families, communities, and world. This outward, apostolic focus clearly reflects the image of the laborer in the vineyard. Segundo refers to an incident where Ignatius say that if given the choice, he would choose to live on in the world and work for the Lord, rather than die today and go right to heaven. Ignatius does not choose the option where concern for his personal salvation is paramount, but prefers to live and die as an apostle committed to do the Lord=s work.11 This is reflected in the Constitutions, where the project of the Society of Jesus is launched. In a short time, Jesuits would be sent by the Pope or the General Superior on dangerous missions to the far east and to the west, to northern Europe and to Africa. Readiness to

4

travel even to the ends of the earth, working for the salvation of souls is the first characteristic of the Jesuit (308).

A sociologist such as Robert Bellah once spoke of the mission-oriented vision of Ignatius as a major shift in western culture. Eventually the Ignatian shift from trial to project becomes the predominant church model, finding clear expression in the document, the Church in the Modern World, in the Second Vatican Council. I believe this project- oriented, world-oriented spirituality of the Constitutions contributed greatly in the formation of Jesuit culture, in inspiring Jesuits to engage in education, in arts and science, as we will surely see in other papers at this conference.

4. From an emphasis upon saving one’s own soul in the Exercises, we move to the mission to fruitful labor in the Lord’s vineyard as the end of the Jesuit in the Constitutions.

THE EXERCISES. Quite surprisingly, the helping of the neighbor as a goal of one=s life or a criteria for choosing does not appear in the Exercises. Examination of the text reveals an emphasis on the salvation of one=s own soul. In Annotation No. 1, the goal of the Exercises is to rid attachments, Aseeking and finding the will of God in the disposition of our life for the salvation of our soul.@ In the First Principle and Foundation, AThe human person is created to praise, reverence and serve God our Lord, and by this means to save one=s soul@ (23). Everything else helps us attain this end, and so we must chose what is conducive to this end for which we were created. The grace sought in the meditation on the AThree Classes of Men@ is Awhat is more for the glory of His Divine Majesty and the salvation of my soul@ (No. 152).

One way of modifying this is by saying that the praise, reverence and service of God, the glory of God, involves love of neighbor. Indeed, the mature Ignatius would agree with this, but in these early writings he does not seem to include it in his understanding of the term. Later on, the glory of God will be almost identified with helping the neighbor, rather than with the salvation of one=s own soul.

THE CONSTITUTIONS. Something quite different emerges in the Constitutions. In describing the end of the Society, the Constitutions do mention saving one=s own soul. But this is said only in the context of explaining the Society to the candidates to be admitted and to those in early training (General Examen and Parts I-IV). Ignatius allows those in formation to be concerned about the salvation of their own soul. Gradually he expects them not to be focused on the test or trial but rather to give themselves generously, totally, to the project of helping and serving the neighbor.

The General Examen explains to the candidates what the Society of Jesus is about. We read at the very beginning:

The end of this Society is to devote itself with God=s grace not only to the salvation and perfection of the members own souls, but also with that same grace to labor strenuously in giving aid toward the salvation and perfection of the souls of their neighbor. (No. 3)

This text addressed to candidates, presents a double aim, one=s own salvation and the help of the neighbor. In No. 52 Ignatius repeats this. If the candidate Ajudges that it is highly expedient for him to enter this Society for the greater praise and glory of God our Lord, and the better saving and perfecting of his own soul by helping his neighbor=s soul as well...@ then one continues with the interview towards possible admission. Yet here

5

one can detect the beginnings of a shift because the future Jesuit will save his own soul by helping the neighbor.

Part IV concerning those in formation begins: AThe end steadfastly pursued by the Society is to aid its own members and their neighbors in attaining the ultimate end for which they were created@ (307). This allows for a double end. Yet the very next number, a later addition to the text, pulls back from that and states that Athe aim and end of this Society, is by traveling... to preach... and use all other means it can with the grace of God to help souls@ (308). Throughout Part IV Ignatius is gradually cutting back on the emphasis on saving one=s own soul, and emphasizing more the project or mission to help others (see Nos. 324, 351, 446).

When we come to Part VII on mission of the formed members, this emphasis on helping the neighbor is the only end mentioned. It begins by explaining Awhat the

4 One might expect that many images such as apostle, missionary, soldier, servant, priest, preacher or teacher would be employed to describe Jesuits at work, but the predominant image is that of the laborer in the Lord=s vineyard. The phrase Athe vineyard of the Lord@ occurs 15 times: to labor in the vineyard (107, 149, 243, 308, 573); workers in the vineyard (144,334, 338); distributed in the vineyard (135, 137, 603, 604, 654); and finally, choosing that part of the vineyard which has greater need (622). A series of related images also find prominence such as the image of Abearing fruit, spiritual fruit,@ and the image of Alaborers and laboring.@ These occur regularly, not always explicitly linked with the image of the Lord=s vineyard. Ignatius reminds us that the enemy has also been at work. Therefore the Society must give special consideration to places where the enemy of Christ our Lord is seen to have sown cockle (Mt. 13:24-30), particularly where he has spread bad opinion about the Society or stirred up ill will against it so as to impede the fruit which it might produce...5 See Joseph Conwell for an expanded interpretation of this part of the Constitutions on mission. “The Kamikaze Factor: Choosing Jesuit Ministries,” Studies in the Spirituality of Jesuits, Vol XI, No. 5 (November, 1979)

7 To show the significance of this shift, we might contrast the image of the laborer with that of the soldier and pilgrim.

The military image of the soldier provides a strong clear purpose of fighting the battle and overcoming the enemy. The soldier tends to see the world as good against. evil. One may be tempted to employ strong, violent measures, the quick solution, in winning the battle. It may lead to the holy war mentality of the crusader, at times leading to impatience and intolerance. This image is very strong in the Formula of the Institute, but less employed, although not entirely absent from the Constitutions.The image of the pilgrim reminds us that we journey, search and wander in search of our true home. We travel light, focused upon the goal of seeking and finding God. At the same time, this journeying discourage us from digging in, making a difference where we are, and committing ourselves to work for the transformation of situations. Perhaps the danger for the pilgrim is to focus too much upon his or her search, with insufficient outward apostolic concern for the neighbor or those accompanying one on the pilgrim journey?

6

members need to observe in regard to their neighbor (which is an end eminently characteristic of our Institute)...@ (603). The entire thrust of Part VII is outward orientation and mission, how we can best help the neighbor, with no mention of the concern for one=s own salvation.

Part X, the last part, is a review and summary of the Constitution.. The Society relies upon the grace of God: AIn him alone must be placed the hope that he will preserve and carry forward what he deigned to begin for his service and praise and for the aid of souls@ (812).. Again the end or objective of the Society, Athe objective it seeks, …is to aid souls to reach their ultimate and supernatural end...@ (813).

8 Pope John Paul II structures his Apostolic Exhortation on the Laity, 1989 around the image of the laborer in the vineyard. All laypersons and priests are to labor in complimentary ways in the vineyard which is composed of rich and varied gardens. 9 One final note. Ignatius does not turn from the image of the vineyard to develop the image of Christ the vine, or Christ the vinedresser, (Jn 15: 5). This union between the laborer and the vine, between Christ and the Christian on mission, is recently well developed in the Apostolic Exhortation of Pope John Paul II, “The Lay Members of Christ’s Faithful.”

10 The two major sources where Segundo discusses Ignatian spirituality are his essay “Ignatius Loyola: Trial or Project?” in Signs of the Times (Maryknoll, N.Y.: Orbis Books, 1993), 169-70, and The Christ of the Ignatian Exercises (Maryknoll, N.Y.: Orbis Books, 1987).11 To show how the mature Ignatius lived a project spirituality, Segundo recalls a remarkable conversation that took place in July 1541 according to Ribadeneira. He notes that he was present when Father Master Lainez was with our Father Ignatius:

There came a moment when our Blessed Father Ignatius said to Father Lainez, ATell me, Master Lainez - what does it seem to you that you would do were God our Lord to propose to you this case and say: >If you are willing to die on the spot, I shall withdraw you from the prison of this body and grant you eternal glory. But if you wish to continue to live, I give you no surety of what will become of you, but leave you to your fate:..= If our Lord were to tell you this - and you were to understand that, by remaining in this life for some time, you could render some great and notable service to the divine Majesty - what would you choose? Lainez replied: Father, I confess to Your Reverence that I should choose to depart at once to enjoy the vision of God, and thus assure my salvation and deliver myself from dangers in a matter of such importance.Then our Father said: ANow, I certainly should not have done so. Rather, had I judged that, remaining in this life, I could have rendered some singular service to Our Lord, I should have besought him to leave me in it until I should have performed that service. And I should place my eyes on it and not on myself - having no regard for my danger or security.@

7

These texts, I believe, point to the development Ignatius himself underwent, and the development he expects in candidates for the Society. At the beginning they may be concerned about personal salvation and the fear of the loss of their own soul. But eventually Ignatius expects this to be secondary to the goal of the Society which is to help souls.

The Constitutions develop a thoroughly apostolic spirituality. The purpose or end of the life of the Jesuit is to glorify and serve God by helping the neighbor. We are to become involved in this great undertaking or mission, living in accord with a project spirituality in the language of Segundo. Prayer, studies, and the vows are all means of carrying out these undertakings or missions.12

The historian David Knowles affirms that with the Society of Jesus comes the end of the monastic conception of religious life. The focus is not upon the spiritual advancement of the community, the salvation of their souls. Rather “with the Jesuits the end of the order as an order is sought and achieved in foro externo, by external action, directed by a single head.”13

5. Norms for choosing, for making decisions in the Constitutions have a more worldly, apostolic, pragmatic emphasis than the norms in the Exercises which look more ascetically to the next life.

IN THE EXERCISES. The entire section on Making a Choice of a Way of Life or the Reformation of One=s Life is dominated by the consideration of what is for the glory of God and the salvation of my soul. This is seen most clearly in the set of rules not often studied or referred to, the ARules for the Distribution of Alms@ (337-344). The retreatant imagines someone else who does this Afor the greater glory of God and the perfection of his soul.@ He/she should follow that example (339). One pictures oneself at the moment of death (340), or before the judge on last day (341) and reflects on how one wishes he or she had acted. One=s concern is to gain entrance into heaven by the correct distribution of alms.14 In none of the rules is the condition or needs of the neighbor enter into the picture. There is no analysis of the situation, no look beyond oneself to the recipient, to the needy, to how or where my almsgiving might best help someone.. The perspective of the state of my soul at my death, more than the present need or good of the neighbor, predominates.

12 This stress on Athe mission of helping souls@ pervades Jesuit documentation according to John O=Malley.

AIn the Autobiography, Constitutions, and his correspondence, Ignatius used it again and again to describe what motivated him and what was to motivate the Society. His disciples seized upon it and tirelessly repeated it as the best and most succinct description of what they were trying to do.@45

We note that in this citation O=Malley correctly omits the Exercises as a text which emphasizes Athe helping of souls.@13 David Knowles, From Pachomius to Ignatius, (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1966) 67.

8

IN THE CONSTITUTIONS. Since the formed Jesuit’s goal has shifted from saving his own soul to the help of the neighbor, there is a corresponding change in the norms for making decisions regarding what members of the Society should be doing.

These norms and criteria are presented in part VII of the Constitutions.15. In choosing and in specifying missions we are to look outward to the world, the vineyard, and examine where are the greater possibilities for gaining fruit (622-626). Where are the greater needs and the more universal good? Where can we give greater glory of God? To whom are we more indebted? Criteria are set forth to best determine where to go, what to do, and whom to send. Clearly we find here a very different set of norms from those given in the Exercises for choosing a way of life or for distributing alms.

In the Constitutions, there is a strong emphasis upon worldly, external factors, historical conditions, concrete needs. While prayerful listening to the interior movements of the Spirit (signs from heaven) remains constant, Ignatius puts more emphasis in the Constitutions on the present circumstances, the objective conditions in the Lord=s vineyard (signs of the times).

In the terminology of Segundo, Ignatius is more and more concerned with “historical efficacy.” He observes and seeks concrete fruits.. The expert on management and corporations, Peter Drucker, saw this as a major contribution of Ignatius, namely the continual, ongoing analysis of results, feedback analysis, learning from experience, and an emphasis on performance and results.16

6. God in the Constitutions is found and served primarily in actions and in mission rather than in prayer or meditation.

The Contemplation to Attain Love at the end of the Exercises challenges us to seek, find, and serve God in all things. The Constitutions provide the discipline and the

16 Finally, we note that the third degree of love or humility, prominent in the Exercises, does not effectively enter into the decision making process of the Constitutions. Rather than seek insults, the cross, and humiliation, Ignatius is more concerned with the good reputation of the Society, so that it can be apostolically effective. I would see the third degree as an ascetical norm or ideal. Only if all things are equal can it be chosen directly, and it would seem that in the real world of the missions where we seek the greater apostolic fruit, this is rarely the case.

Rightly has it been said that for Ignatius, as a man of his times, the Mass was not so much the community=s public celebration of the remembrance of the Last Supper and the Sacrifice of Calvary, but a means to implore the divine grace for specific intentions.52

14 Ignatius does wish that we imitate Aour Great High Priest, model, and guide, Christ our Lord@ (344), but we are to imitate him more in the ascetical mode of Asaving and cutting down expenses@ rather than in showing active love for the neighbor.

15 In accord with the special fourth vow, the first is obedience to the Pope (603-617) followed by obedience to one=s superiors (618-620)

9

practices whereby the Jesuit laborer in the vineyard achieves. How different from the view of The Imitation of Christ where the world is not the Lord’s vineyard, but rather is a place of danger, temptation, or exile.

Prayer remains central, but it is the prayer of an apostle, incarnational prayer. In terms of formal prayer for the formed Jesuit, Ignatius shows great flexibility:

In what pertains to prayer, meditation, and study, and also in regard to the bodily practices of fast, vigils and other austerities or penances, it does not seem proper to give them any other rule than that which discreet charity dictates to them...(# 582).

For those in formation he writes: in addition to confession and Communion every eight days, and daily Mass, they will have one hour, during which they will recite the Hours of Our Lady, examine their consciences twice each day, and add other prayers according to each one=s devotion to fill out the rest of the aforesaid hour (342).

This surely leave little time for lengthy meditation or contemplation, and certainly no time for an uninterrupted hour long meditation.

PRAYER OF PETITION. Most often when Ignatius mentions prayer in the Constitutions it is prayer of petition for specific persons, decisions, and missions. Such prayer is a primary means of achieving the end of the Society, the helping of souls. In Part X, where Ignatius sets forth his final hopes and dreams for the Society of Jesus, he writes:

AIn conformity with this hope, [that the Society will grow, serve...] the first and most appropriate means will be the prayers and Masses which ought to be offered for this holy intention...@ (812)

In Part VII on mission, we note a slight change where Ignatius puts good example as the first means to help the neighbor. Yet prayer remains in second place described as

Aprayers for all the Church, especially for those persons in it who are of greater importance for the common good. They should also pray for friends and benefactors, living and dead, whether they request these prayers or not....@ (638)

PRAYER OF PARTICULAR JESUITS. The first quality of the General is that he should be closely united with God our Lord and have familiarity with him in prayer and in all his operations...@ (723) His prayer must frequently find expression in the prayer of petition.

He will achieve this kind of government by the good reputation and example of his life, by charity and love for the Society in Christ our Lord, and by his constant and heartfelt prayer and Masses to obtain the grace of the aforementioned preservation and growth. (790)

The assistants of Fr. General, in addition to Aobserving the affairs of the Indies,@ etc., are given special responsibility; AEach one would offer special prayer and be mindful in his Masses of the region particularly entrusted to him...@ (803). Ignatius gives prayer a high priority in his instruction for the local Superiors or Rectors of a College: AThe function of the rector will be first of all to sustain the whole college by his prayers and holy desires...@(424). If there is a question of dismissal,

10

there should be prayer before dismissing one, and then prayer that God will guide him after the dismissal (221-229).

Scholastics in studies should pray for success in their studies (360). Ignatius warns them that their studies might lead them to Agrow cool in their love of true virtues and of religious life, still they will not at that time have much place for mortifications or for long prayers and meditations@ (340).17

EXAMINATION OF CONSCIENCE. For one engaged in, or preparing to engage in apostolic activity, the examination of conscience receives special emphasis. In the examen we review what we have done for the Lord, what fruits we have been reaping. We look ahead to where we hope to serve and meet the Lord, where we might reap a greater harvest. In the examen, historical efficacy and fruitfulness come into play as we reflect upon where we have met and hope to meet God in our apostolic lives. Through this examen, we grow into the habit of finding and serving God in all things, as fruitful laborers in the Lord=s vineyard.

7. Focus upon the Exercises as the substance of the annual retreat of the Jesuit was not in the mind of Ignatius. Much material from the Constitutions might well be considered in the annual retreat.

The prefatory letter that appeared at the head of the first official printed edition of the Constitutions ends in this manner.

I beseech you, brothers in the Lord, that we may walk in a manner worthy of our vocation, and in order to know that vocation, may read and reread these Constitutions that have been bestowed upon us by the gift of God. Let us study them day and night. Let us vie with each other in learning them, pondering them, and keeping them. If we do so, our name will be matched by our lives and our profession made manifest in deed. Rome, 155918

One would expect that Jesuits would regularly review and pray over their Constitutions. Yet for several centuries we were presented only with the Epitome (excerpts, and those in Latin). Only in 1971 were the Constitutions available in English. Why this neglect? One part of the picture is Decree 29 of General Congregation 6 (held in 1608, with Claudio Aquaviva as General). This mandated “Each year all should devote themselves to the Spiritual Exercises for eight or ten consecutive days. So that this can be done effectively and thoroughly, this yearly practice of the Spiritual Exercises is made the subject of a decree, and it is given the highest commendation by the congregation…”19

Jesuit historian William Bangert, normally calm and moderate in his views, changes his tone when he evaluates this legislation. He writes:

The Congregation took a basic Ignatian spiritual experience, for which he

18 Some years ago, a summary of the Constitutions was read every month in the refectory in houses of formation, in accord with the second last number of the Constitutions, # 826:

“All should apply themselves to the observance of the Constitutions. For this purpose they must know them, at least those which pertain to each one. Therefore each one should read or hear them every month.”

11

(Ignatius) gave not the slightest intimation of obligatory annual repetition, and encased it in a tight cover of legislation. By its universal application, this legislation offended Ignatius’ respect for wide differences among Jesuits in their modes of prayer. It ignored Ignatius’ sensitivity to the varied work of the Holy Spirit hearts. It warped Ignatius’ purpose for the Spiritual Exercises, which he never intended to be repeated year after year. To the Spiritual Exercises themselves it did a disservice, since it squeezed them into an annual format that became vulnerable to routine.20

This is beginning to change. The letter of Fr. General Peter-Hans Kolvenbach, which is now the Preface to the official text of the Constitutions and Norms, commends the Constitutions and Norms to our personal and communitarian prayer. The revised law of the Society, Norm 415, explicitly points in this direction:

Finally, all by earnest reading and meditation (e.g. at the time of the annual Spiritual Exercises, renewal of vows, monthly recollection, the beginning of the year, etc.) should strive ever to known, esteem and love better our Constitution, Norms and Rules…21

Personally, I have directed a number of Jesuits in formation in their annual retreat, using material from the Constitutions and Norms. Each one has found this focus on the Constitutions and Norms very valuable. They have read parts of the Constitutions, the documents of CG 34 and possibly the Norms, but they have for the most part never prayed over them. They found a retreat based on the Constitutions and Norms to be a pleasant change, and normally one that confirmed them in their vocation.22

One hopes that renewal in the Society of Jesus will be fostered as Jesuits give more attention to the revised Constitutions and Norms. The time of the annual retreat seems to be an opportunity for this.

8. Since the Constitutions are basically an apostolic spirituality, they offer much insight and direction to those who collaborate in Ignatian apostolates.

Jesuits have committed themselves to ACooperation with the Laity on Mission.@ 23 We have shared the treasure of the Exercises with religious and lay persons. We maintain that the Constitutions are for Jesuits, outlining our Institute, our way of proceeding. But is this sufficient? In this day of lay collaboration, lay spirituality, and the apostolate of the laity, is there not a sense in which the Constitutions, or at least SOME aspects of them can be helpful for the laity in their mission in the Church and society? A number of religious congregations of women rely heavily on the Jesuit Constitutions as the basis of their apostolic spirituality.. Is there not

21 In the new Norms 231, #1, the importance of the Exercises for the annual retreat is still affirmed, yet some flexibility or adaptations are allowed.

Because it is especially in the Spiritual Exercises that we experience Christ and respond to him calling us to the Society, they are the source and center of our vocation, and an altogether special means for fostering renewal and union in the Society and for carrying on our apostolic mission in a more profound way. Hence, they should be made for eight successive days each year; certain adaptations may be allowed, of which the provincial is to be the judge.

12

a possible further step in examining how insights of these same Constitutions might be of great value to lay apostles?24

Those who benefit from insights of the Constitutions might be a group of lay persons, such as a Christian Life Community (CLC), or a parish society that wants to be more fully and apostolically Christian. They might also help the individual layperson who wishes to be apostolically involved and grow in the life of the Spirit.. He/she may already have made the Exercises, and is now looking for a new way to contribute to the mission of the Church.25

Let me set forth some insights from the Constitutions, grouped under two headings: 1) personal qualities, virtues, and attitudes needed for a laborer in the Lord=s vineyard; and 2) means to be effective apostolic laborers.

PERSONAL QUALITIES, VIRTUES, AND ATTITUDES--- the themes of moderation and flexibility pervade the Constitutions. Moderation points to the perfect mean which does not lean Atoward an extreme of rigor or toward excessive laxity@ (822). Flexibility indicates an adaptability that leaves room for exceptions and accommodations to the general rules, room for the freedom and working of the Spirit. --- the importance of the exterior, the correct use and control of the senses, outward peace (250-53). This includes proper care of the body so that one can be apostolically effective in the long haul (826, 292).--- respect for all persons whether cooks or doctors, executives or security guards. One seeks, sees, finds, and serves God in all (551). A strong trust in the Spirit who speaks to and directs each and every person (582).--- a desire for continued growth in the spiritual life that is fostered by the desire and ability to learn from others, by seeking and accepting advice and correction. (269-70).26 Those in authority should have an officially appointed admonitor who will regularly give friendly advice (770). The leader should have a system of assistants or advisors (810-11 and 431). Ignatius expects every individual and the entire apostolic body to constantly grow in the Spirit and increase in well being and apostolic effectiveness (813).--- leadership characterized by service rather than ambition or self-aggrandizement (817). Members in turn have the responsibility to support, encourage, and empower their superiors in their difficult task (766).--- freedom, availability and an attitude of indifference in regard to possible ministries. One is available and ready to travel, to respond to where the greatest needs are (82 and 304).--- viewing one=s life and mission as being an instrument in the hands of God for the good of others (638, 813, 814).

MEANS TO BECOME EFFECTIVE LABORERS IN THE VINEYARD--- the need and advantages of having a spiritual director or mentor, one who can guide, assist, support one in the life of ministry (263).27

--- practicing Athe art of dealing and conversing with others@ (814). Ignatius calls this the grace of conversation, and desired this skill in all Jesuits, so that they could engage in spiritual conversation, sharing the good news in a variety of formal and informal situations (349, 648). Monastic silence gives way to quality conversation.

26 See the letter of Ignatius to the Jesuits missioned to participate in the Council of Trent.

13

--- an ability to communicate as teachers and preachers (280, 402), striving for eloquentia perfecta.--- the need to cultivate Asolid and perfect virtues@ and Ainterior gifts@ to which we Aattach greater importance than to learning and other natural and human gifts@ (813). At the same time, a reliance upon natural means in service to the apostolate. AThe human or acquired means ought to be sought with diligence, especially well-grounded and solid learning, and a method of proposing it to the people...@ (814) From this flows the importance of education and studies (307); the need to learn the language of the people (402).--- the proper use of extrinsic gifts of nobility, wealth, reputation in the service of God and God=s people (191). Ignatius had the remarkable ability to use both human and divine means. --- the importance of good example in our everyday life. Ignatius calls this the first means to help our neighbor (637).--- always searching for the magis, where greater fruit can be reaped. Use of the multiplier effect by working with the powerful and influential, by working in the famous cities (622). Linking the resources of the powerful with the needs of the powerless. --- the importance of constant and ongoing communication, oral and written, among laborers in the vineyard and with their superiors. This gives support, maintains union, and also provides the information that will assure the effective and best use of resources (821, 673-75).

These are a few insights and attitudes found in the Constitutions which could be shared with lay collaborators, laymen and women working in the Lord’s vineyard.

9. “By that same grace” the Jesuit labors to save his own soul and labors for the salvation of others. The emphasis of the Constitutions is on how that grace, an incarnational and apostolic grace, enables us to reach out and be fruitful laborers in the Lord’s vineyard.At the very beginning of the Constitutions (No. 3), we read:

The end of this Society is to devote itself with God=s grace not only to the salvation and perfection of the members own souls, but also with that same grace to labor strenuously in giving aid toward the salvation and perfection of the souls of their neighbors.

AWith that same grace,@ is a simple phrase that reveals and uncovers much of the path we have examined in the life of St. Ignatius and his followers. Nadal sees in these words

the whole nucleus of the Society: here all our thought should be centered... For all that we have received from God, we have received to employ in the salvation and perfection of our neighbor... Alas, then for us, if we strive only for our own salvation! That is not our grace; that is not our vocation. It is a good occupation, indeed, but not ours.28

I believe this phrase. AWith that same grace,@ reveals an important insight, a step forward not only for Ignatius, but for the Catholic tradition. Grace, as Ignatius describes it, pulls and pushes us in two directions. It converts and draws us to the love of God and then pushes us out to the love of neighbor.

28 Cited in Conwell, Contemplation in Action, p. 64.

14

The grace of God enabled his conversion and his writing of the Spiritual Exercises. He there describes the end of the person as one to praise, reverence and serve God and by that means to save his soul. Later on, Ignatius, led by the same dynamic of grace, dedicated himself to gather followers and form the Society of Jesus whose purpose and the purpose of the members was not so much to be concerned with personal salvation, but to dedicate their lives to the salvation of others.

This insight into the dynamic working of grace reveals the deeply incarnational truth that we cannot find God, except in and through the neighbor. This may seem simple and obvious – as found in the letter of John, and in Matthew Chapter 25. But it seems to be easily lost or overlooked in view of the strong monastic, individualist, and often other-worldly strands that remain influential in Catholic piety. It is this insight that grounds and founds the theology and spirituality and mission of the Society of Jesus, and provides a solid basis for any apostolic spirituality.

Pedro Arrupe calls for this new vision in his oft quoted address on men and women for others. The new vision of justice must give rise to a new of spirituality that includes the personal and the social, the interior and the exterior. Interior conversion is not enough. God=s converting grace calls us not only to win back our whole selves for God, but to win back our whole world for God.29

The vision of Pedro Arrupe certainly coheres with the thrust of the Second Vatican Council. The Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World concludes with a call for an apostolic, mission-oriented Christian life. In a section entitled AA World to be Built Up and Brought to Fulfilment@, we read in language that echoes a project spirituality:

Christians can yearn for nothing more ardently than to serve the men and women of this age with an ever growing generosity and success... They have shouldered a weighty task here on earth and they must render an account of it to him who will judge all men and women on the last day (93)

Clearly here is a call for an apostolic life and spirituality on the part of all Christians, a life of labor in the Lord=s vineyard. Jesuits themselves try to live this dynamic of grace as fruitful laborers in the Lord=s vineyard. Now they strive to share this rich heritage of the Exercises and Constitutions with lay persons similarly called to be faithful and fruitful laborers in the Lord=s vineyard

CONCLUSION“Ite, inflammate omnia.” These words are traditionally ascribed to Ignatius as he

sends forth Xavier and the early Jesuit missionaries. There is need of such zeal and energy in the Society of Jesus today. Recent studies of the Exercises, directed retreats, retreat in daily life, with the assistance of lay collaborators, has brought new life and energy to the Society of Jesus and to the Church. So too, one can hope that our renewed study by Jesuits and others of the Constitutions and what the Constitutions led to, will in a similar fashion bring new life and energy to the Society of Jesus and our lay associates – all of us working more vigorously as fruitful laborers in the Lord’s vineyard.

“Fruitful laborers in the Lord’s vineyard.” That is the challenging description of the mature Jesuit on mission, an image beautifully set forth by Ignatius in the Constitutions over 400 years ago. In the upcoming days of this Conference we will

15

surely trace some of the key ways in which Jesuit laborers formed a Jesuit culture, carried out that world-affirming mission or project of the Society of Jesus, and brought gospel values to different areas of the vineyard – including education, science, art and architecture.

Pope John Paul II in his Exhortation on the Laity viewed the entire modern world as the Lord’s vineyard. He calls upon every Christian to be a fruitful laborer in that vineyard. Relying upon the rich Ignatian heritage found initially in the Spiritual Exercises, and then developed and even transformed in the Constitutions, we Jesuits should be well prepared to help challenge, train, guide, form, and collaborate with all Christians who are called to labor fruitfully in the Lord’s vineyard.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Aldama, Antonio de, S.J. The Constitutions of the Society of Jesus: An Introductory Commentary on the Constitutions, St. Louis: The Institute of Jesuit Sources 1989

Amaladoss, Michael, S.J. “Sent on Mission,” in Constitutions of the Society of Jesus: Incorporation of a Spirit

Arrupe, “Men and Women for Others, in A Planet to Heal, 95-108.

Bangert, Nadal p. 209

Bertrand, Dominique, S.J. Un Corps pour l’Esprit Desclee de Brouwer Bellarmin, 1974 Centrum Ignatianum Spiritualitatis Collection Christus, No. 38 Etudes

Codina, Victor and Fiorita, Miguel Angel, “The Way: St. Ignatius’s Constant Theme,”CIS 1976 No. 22 5-18

The Constitutions of the Society of Jesus and their Complementary NormsThe Institute of Jesuit Sources, St. Louis, 1996

16

Conwell, Joseph F., S.J. “The Kamikaze Factor: Choosing Jesuit Ministries,” Studies in the Spirituality of Jesuits, Vol XI, No. 5 (November, 1979)Conwell, Joseph F., S.J. Walking in the Spirit, The Institute of Jesuit Sources, St. Louis, 2003Conwell - Impelling Spirit

Courel, Francois, S.J. “the Single Aim of the Apostolic Institute,” The Way, Supplement (No. 14) Autumn 1971 46-61

17Other references to prayer would include these. Teachers are to pray at the beginning of class, or at least make the sign of the cross (# 486-87). Those sent on mission are to beg the Lord=s help before going on mission (292) and while on mission (631, 633).

All Jesuits are called upon to pray for those in civil or ecclesial authority, and for our benefactors (638). In a characteristic Ignatian insight, they are to pray especially for those they may have trouble with!?

Finally, very special prayers should be said for the dying and the dead (596, 598, 601):19 More recently, Congregation 27 (held in 1923 under Wlodimir Ledochowski), in its Collected Decrees, Decree 55 #1, states: “In the Society, all are to make the Spiritual Exercises for eight or ten consecutive days each year…”

20 Bangert – Nadal, p 20822 Two recent books on the Constitutions and Norms move in the direction of this suggestion. Parmananda Divarkar, S.J., subtitles his book Faithful and Free as “a Companion to the Constitutions of the Society of Jesus annotated and complemented by General Congregation 34.” He examines the various parts of the Constitutions, and then offers questions for reflection and sharing on each of the parts. His method is to present short quotes from the Constitutions and Norms, rather than longer excerpts. In a Postscript he then outlines how the materials of the book may be organized into an eight day retreat, with Scriptural meditations, and references to the Exercises, as well as one daily meditation on some part of the Constitutions.

The second book, Our Way of Proceeding, by William Barry is subtitled “To Make the Constitutions of the Society of Jesus and Their Complementary Norms Our Own.” He presents materials from the Constitutions and Norms for use in a daily meditation, along the lines of a Retreat in Daily Life. He outlines material for six prayer periods in a week, over a stretch of seventeen weeks (thus a total of 102 reflection periods, with the addition of the Contemplation to Obtain Love as a final meditation). In his book he gives the actual text of the Constitutions or the Norms, normally 1-2 pages in length. He does not relate or reshape his material to fit the annual eight day retreat as we are doing in this study.

17

Abridgement of “La fin unique de la compagnie de Jesus,” in AHSJ 35 (1966) 186-211

Crowe, Frederick E., S.J. “The Ignatian Exercises and Jesuit Spirituality,” Review for Religious 524-33. July-August 1994

23 GC 34, Decree 13. See also Decree 14 on “Jesuits and the Situation of Women in Church and Civil Society.”

24 Maurizio Costa, S.J. raises this possibility, but does not develop it at length, in his essay AThe Ignatian >Person of the Spirit= as Reflected in the Constitutions,@ CIS XX, 1990: 3, No. 65 pp. 50-63. He writes: ABetween the Spiritual Exercises and the Constitutions there is both continuity and discontinuity. Once we have subjected the relationship between the two to careful analysis and are clear on it, we have the basis for discerning how far the spirituality proper to the Constitutions and to the Society can be legitimately adapted for people who are not Jesuits.@ P. 62. Howard Gray also raises this possibility in his essay AWhat Kind of Document?@, The Way Supplement 61, Spring 1988, pp. 21-34. Gray suggests that four priorities of the Constitutions might well be shared with lay colleagues, namely the themes of wisdom, the pilgrimage of the human spirit, commitment to service and compassion, and contemplative in the midst of action. .

74Pope John Paul II, AApostolic Exhortation,@Christifideles Laici. The Lay Members of Christ=s Faithful People. Every section of this Exhortation Aon the vocation and the mission of the lay faithful in the Church and in the world@ uses the imagery of the vineyard, the vine and the branches, bearing fruit, and laboring in the Lord=s vineyard.

75Arrupe, AMen and Women for Others,@ in A Planet to Heal, 95-108.

76 Ignatius recommended that the Fathers sent on mission to Trent as theologians take time each night to give helpful advice and if necessary, correction to one of the brethren. Letter 123, in Young, 96.

25 Pedro Arrupe challenged our Jesuit educational institutions to train Amen and women for others@75. Many of our institutions now include service programs. Presuming that our lay colleagues have familiarity with the initial conversion experience and spirituality of the Exercises, input from the Constitutions might provide further valuable insight into the formation and apostolic work of such Amen and women for others.@27 Material for this is found in the Constitutions under the account of conscience (91-92), insights of which can be adapted to lay apostolic spirituality.

18

Divarkar, Parmananda, S.J. (editor) “A Pathway to God: Rediscovering the Constitutions of the Society of Jesus,” 1994 Gujarat Sahitya Prakash, Anand, India

Echartes, Ignacio, S.J. An Ignatian Concordance Ediciones Mensajero, in cooperation with the Institute of Jesuit Sources, 1996

Endean, Philip, S.J. “Who do you say Ignatius Is? 19/5 November 1987

Gray, Howard, “What Kind of Document? The Way, Supplement (No. 61) Spring 1988 21-34.

Hanvey, James, S.J. “The Recovery of the Constitutions,: Mukai (Zimbabwe) No. 17. 22-24

Jaer, Andre de, S.J. Together for Mission – A Spiritual Reading of the Constituti ons of the Society of Jesus The Institute of Jesuit Sources, St. Louis, 2001Knowles, David. From Pachomius to Ignatius Oxford Clarendon Press, 1966.

Lowney, Christopher. Heroic Leadership Chicago, Loyola Press, 2003

Lukacs, Janos, S.J. “The Incarnational Dynamic of the Constitutions,” 36/4 Winter 2004

McGuckian, Michael C., S.J. “The One End of the Society of Jesus,” AHSJ (60) 1991,91-111. O’Malley, John. The First Jesuits Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press, 1993.

Padberg, John, S.J. St. Louis Conference, 2000 from internet Shift in Ignatius

Ravier, Andre, S.J. Ignatius of Loyola and the Founding of the Society of Jesus

29 Arrupe, “Men and Women for Others,” in A Planet to Heal, 95-108.

19

Ignatius Press, San Francisco, 1987

Schineller - Studies - “In their Own Words: Ignatius, Favre, and Our Way of Proceeding,” 38/1 Spring 2006

Segundo…

20