19
Suite 201 – 1571 Bellevue Ave., West Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada V7V 1A6 • Tel: 1.604.926.3261 • Fax: 1.604.926.5389 • www.hatfieldgroup.com Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian Sands Energy Inc. Fort McMurray, Alberta

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

Suite 201 – 1571 Bellevue Ave., West Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada V7V 1A6 • Tel: 1.604.926.3261 • Fax: 1.604.926.5389 • www.hatfi eldgroup.com

Results of Yellow Rail Surveyson the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

December 2008

Prepared for:

Albian Sands Energy Inc.Fort McMurray, Alberta

Page 2: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

RESULTS OF YELLOW RAIL SURVEYS ON THE ALBIAN MUSKEG RIVER MINE EXPANSION AREA

Prepared for:

ALBIAN SANDS ENERGY INC. P.O. BOX 5670

FORT MCMURRAY, AB T9H 4W1

Prepared by:

HATFIELD CONSULTANTS SUITE 201 – 1571 BELLEVUE AVENUE

WEST VANCOUVER, BC V7V 1A6

DECEMBER 2008

1443

Suite 201 – 1571 Bellevue Ave., West Vancouver, BC, Canada V7V 1A6 • Tel: 1.604.926.3261 • Fax: 1.604.926.5389 • www.hatfieldgroup.com

Page 3: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys i Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

TABLE OF CONTENTS

LIST OF TABLES .......................................................................................... ii LIST OF FIGURES......................................................................................... ii DISTRIBUTION LIST .................................................................................... iii

1.0 INTRODUCTION.................................................................................. 1 1.1 BIRD SPECIES OF INTEREST ............................................................................... 1 1.1.1 Yellow Rail (Coturnicops noveboracensis) ......................................................... 1

2.0 METHODOLOGY................................................................................. 2 2.1 HABITAT SAMPLING .............................................................................................. 2 2.2 YELLOW RAIL SURVEYS....................................................................................... 5 2.3 OTHER DATABASES, INCIDENTAL OBSERVATION, ETC................................... 5

3.0 RESULTS............................................................................................. 5 3.1 HABITAT CHARACTERISTICS............................................................................... 5 3.2 YELLOW RAILS .................................................................................................... 10 3.3 OTHER WILDLIFE OBSERVATIONS.................................................................... 10 3.4 OTHER DATA SOURCES...................................................................................... 11

4.0 DISCUSSION ..................................................................................... 12

5.0 RECOMMENDATIONS ...................................................................... 13

6.0 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS .................................................................... 13

7.0 REFERENCES................................................................................... 14

8.0 CLOSURE.......................................................................................... 16

Page 4: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1 Total area of graminoid and shrubby fen habitat sampled at each location surveyed for yellow rails (Coturnicops noveboracensis), summer 2008................................................................................................6

Table 2 Summary of cover type (%) within graminoid, shrubby and mixed fen habitats sampled during the yellow rail survey, summer 2008. ..............6

Table 3 Summary of cover type (%) for contiguous wetland areas sampled during the yellow rail survey, summer 2008. .............................................. 9

Table 4 Maximum number of sora and Le Conte sparrows detected at each survey location during the yellow rail surveys, July to August, 2008............................................................................................................10

Table 5 Incidental wildlife observations made during the yellow rail surveys. ......................................................................................................11

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1 Survey locations for yellow rails (Coturnicops noveboracensis) including the distribution of graminoid fen and shrubby fen habitat within the study area.....................................................................................3

Figure 2 Qualitative ranking of noise levels within the study area of the yellow rail survey, summer 2008. .................................................................7

Figure 3 Changes in water depth at each survey location sampled during the yellow rail survey from July to August, 2008...........................................9

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys ii Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 5: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys iii Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

DISTRIBUTION LIST

The following individuals/firms have received this document:

Name Firm Hardcopies CDs FTP

√ √ √

Page 6: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

1.0 INTRODUCTION Alberta Environment, under recommendation from Environment Canada, requested that Albian Sands Energy initiate an appropriate census for yellow rails using standardized methodology for approval of the Muskeg River Mine expansion project (EUB and CEAA 2006). The objective of these surveys were to determine if yellow rails occupied the Albian Sands lease areas and at what densities. The purpose of this study was to better understand the impacts of oil sands projects on populations of yellow rails with one of the end goals being to determine which mitigation options would minimize impacts to yellow rails and their habitats. This report provides the findings of the yellow rail surveys undertaken by Hatfield Consultants for Albian Sands within the Muskeg River Mine expansion area.

1.1 BIRD SPECIES OF INTEREST

1.1.1 Yellow Rail (Coturnicops noveboracensis)

Yellow rails (Coturnicops noveboracensis) are small, marsh-dwelling birds that occupy wetlands across much of southern and central Canada east of the Rocky Mountains (Bookhout 1995). In Alberta, yellow rails occur throughout much of the province, including the north-eastern portion of the province near Fort McMurray, during the breeding season from late May to early September (Federation of Alberta Naturalists 2007, Prescott et al. 2002). Males and females are socially monogamous and females produce one clutch of 7 to 10 eggs (Bookhout 1995). Throughout much of their range they occupy sedge habitats largely dominated by Carex (sedge), Scirpus (bulrush), and Calamagrostis (grass) vegetation (Gibbs et al. 1991, Bookhout 1995).

The local distribution of yellow rails is variable based on annual water level changes (Eddleman et al. 1988), although this is likely more significant in areas where water levels can dramatically rise and fall over time. Yellow rails vocalize at night and populations are poorly monitored using existing large-scale survey programs (e.g. Breeding Bird Survey, Christmas Bird Count) because these daytime surveys are aimed to monitor diurnal landbirds. Recent protocols have been established to specifically monitor yellow rails using standardized methods (Bazin and Baldwin 2007). Because such surveys are normally volunteer-based or run on small scales, using standardized methods will, over time, produce larger datasets allowing for robust analysis of population changes.

Yellow rails are listed as a species of “Special Concern” in Canada (COSEWIC 2001). Special Concern is defined as “a wildlife species that may become a threatened or an endangered species because of a combination of biological characteristics and identified threats”. In Alberta, yellow rails are listed as “Undetermined” which is “any species for which insufficient information, knowledge or data is available to reliably evaluate its general status“(Alberta Environment 2005). These designations imply that further information on distribution and abundance are required to properly manage yellow rail populations, particularly in Alberta.

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 1 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 7: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 2 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

2.0 METHODOLOGY Birds that are difficult to monitor with existing, large-scale monitoring programs usually require specific standardized protocols that allow data to be sufficiently robust for statistical analyses (e.g. Takats et al. 2001, Conway et al. 2008). This study follows the Canadian Wildlife Service protocol for monitoring yellow rails (Bazin and Baldwin 2007). The study area was designated as the portions of the Albian Sands Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area that contained suitable habitat for yellow rails, here defined as graminoid and shrubby fen habitats, and could be safely accessed for night surveys (Figure 1). A target of at least 25% of all graminoid and shrubby fen habitat present within the study area was to be surveyed for yellow rails.

Suitable habitat in the study area was identified using GIS spatial layers of Smith et al. (2007). Survey locations were non-randomly assigned within shrubby fen and graminoid fen habitat and centered to include the largest portion of the fen habitat within the 200m radius of the sampling point. A total of three surveys were conducted in summer 2008, and each survey was separated by at least 10 days (Bazin and Baldwin 2007): July 8-10, July 21-23, and August 5-7, 2008. Surveys were conducted at night from 1 hour after sunset until 1 hour before sunrise. Access to the center of each survey location was done on foot or with the use of an argo all-terrain vehicle using a global positioning system.

2.1 HABITAT SAMPLING

Habitat characteristics were recorded at two spatial scales: survey-level and wetland-level. The survey-level habitat assessment was conducted within 50 m of the survey location and recorded the percentages of the following habitat classes: cattails, sedge, bulrush, rushes, phragmites, open water, and bare ground. Other habitat classes were also recorded when they were identified at each site including shrubs and trees. Wetland-level cover types were identified at each survey location for each continuous wetland (Figure 1) and an estimate of the percentage of standing emergent vegetation, shrubs, trees, open water and bare ground was made. Habitat data were recorded on each visit to the sampling location and the mean percentage over all visits was used to characterize the vegetation and habitat features of each survey location and individual wetland. Other variables measured at each site included: water depth (cm), air temperature (°C), wind speed and direction, cloud cover, precipitation, moon phase and visibility, and ambient background noise. Ambient noise levels were recorded during the surveys because noise from activities on the Albian Sands lease may influence the ability to detect yellow rails. Noise was scored as 0, no noise; 1, faint noise where likely birds can’t be heard beyond 400 m; 2, moderate noise where likely birds can’t be heard beyond 200 m; 3, loud noise where likely birds can’t be heard beyond 100 m; and 4, intense noise where likely birds can’t be heard beyond 50 m (Bazin and Baldwin 2007).

Page 8: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

[_

[_

[_[_

Muskeg

Rive

r

Jackpine Creek

Ath

abas

ca R

iver

9

3

86

5

12

7

4

11

12

13

10

465000

465000

470000

470000

475000

475000

6340

000

6340

000

6345

000

6345

000

Figure 1 Survey locations for yellow rails (Coturnicops noveboracensis) including the distribution of graminoid fen and shrubby fen habitat within the study area.

K:\Data\Project\ALBIAN1443\GIS\_MXD\ALBIAN1443_1FieldAVI_20081103.mxd

Data Sources:a) Rivers from 1:250,000 NTSB.b) Background: 10m SPOT-5 (August 8, 2008) multispectral imagery, RAMP 2008.c) Previous Yellow Rail sightings from Albian Sands Energy 2005.

Projection: UTM Zone 12N NAD83 t0 1 20.5

km1:45,000Scale

ALB

ER

TA

SAS

KATC

HEW

AN

FortMcMurray

Map Extent

LEGENDRivers

Major Roads

StudyArea

Wetland Type

Graminoid Fen

Shrubby Fen

[_Previous yellow rail Observations

Survey Locations

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 3 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 9: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

2.2 YELLOW RAIL SURVEYS

A Panasonic portable CD player was used with a pre-recorded CD of yellow rail vocalizations that lasted the duration of the ten minute survey. The standardized survey included a five minute silent listening period followed by three minutes of yellow rail playback (30 second interval followed by 30 seconds of silence repeated three times) and a final two minute silent listening period (Bazin and Baldwin 2007). All species of marsh birds were recorded when first detected for each minute they were heard vocalizing until the end of the survey. The call type of each bird (song, display noise, call notes, etc.) was recorded in addition to the estimated distance to the bird from the observer using distance bands of 0-25 m, 25-75 m, 75-125 m, 125-200 m, and greater than 200 m (Bazin and Baldwin 2007).

2.3 OTHER DATABASES, INCIDENTAL OBSERVATION, ETC.

A literature and online search of data sources was conducted to best delineate the distribution of yellow rails in northeastern Alberta and the best time to survey for this secretive species in Alberta. Data sets included breeding bird survey (Sauer et al. 2008), Christmas bird count (National Audubon Society 2002), the Alberta breeding bird atlas (Federation of Alberta Naturalists 2007), papers in the scientific literature (e.g. Prescott et al. 2002) and prior oil sands development application documents (Albian Sands Energy 2005).

3.0 RESULTS 3.1 HABITAT CHARACTERISTICS

The 13 survey locations sampled 50% of the graminoid fen and 28% of the shrubby fen found in the study area (Table 1). Overall, these two habitat types only comprise approximately 4% of the total study area. Habitat attributes of the surveyed area were dominated by sedges and shrubs that made up 75-80% of the habitat. Shrubby fen was dominated by shrubs while graminoid fens were dominated by sedges; mixed fens (Figure 1) were intermediate for both habitat types. Tree cover at each survey location varied from 2% to 17% and there were more trees on shrubby fens than on graminoid fens (Table 2). Other habitat features of survey locations are summarized in Table 2.

Wetland cover type classifications are estimates for the contiguous wetland patches that contained from 1 to 7 survey locations each (Figure 1). Emergent vegetation and shrubs were the two most common cover types and abundance of emergent vegetation had a strong negative correlation with the abundance of shrubs (r2 = 0.97). Other wetland cover type characteristics are summarized in Table 3.

Permanent wetlands should have water present during the entire year while temporary wetlands have water present for only part of the year (Prescott et al. 2002). All wetlands were classified as permanent except surveys locations

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 5 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 10: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

7 and 8, which were classified as temporary wetlands because they had no standing water during the surveys conducted in 2008. Water levels at permanent wetlands ranged from 2 cm (location 12) to 50 cm (location 10) during the initial survey; water levels remained consistent or decreased over the course of the following surveys (Figure 3).

Noise levels were highest near the center of the study area (Figure 2) and it is likely that at several surveys location, birds could not be heard beyond approximately 100 m. Using the noise values from the survey points, the predicted noise levels at other wetlands that were not surveyed suggest that any wetlands near mining areas, heavily used roads and the processing facilities may need to be surveyed with a maximum hearing distance of less than the 200 m used in this study (Figure 2).

Table 1 Total area of graminoid and shrubby fen habitat sampled at each location surveyed for yellow rails (Coturnicops noveboracensis), summer 2008.

Location Graminoid Fen (ha) Shrubby Fen (ha) Total Yellow rail habitat (ha)1 12.34 0.00 12.342 12.56 0.00 12.563 5.60 5.53 11.134 3.15 9.27 12.425 0.00 11.24 11.246 0.00 8.37 8.377 4.52 3.48 8.008 0.00 7.25 7.259 11.76 0.00 11.76

10 0.00 7.30 7.3011 8.53 0.00 8.5312 5.54 0.00 5.5413 11.98 0.13 12.12

Total surveyed 76.0 52.6 128.5Percent surveyed 49.7% 27.7% 37.5%Total available in study area 153 190 343Percent of study area 1.8% 2.3% 4.1%Each survey circle is 200 m in radius and encompasses 12.56 ha. The study area was 8370 ha (Figure 1).

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 6 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Table 2 Summary of cover type (%) within graminoid, shrubby and mixed fen habitats sampled during the yellow rail survey, summer 2008.

Cover type Graminoid fen Mixed fen Shrubby fen% Tree 6 11 11% Shrub 31 45 52% Grass 3 3 4% Cattail 1 0 1% Sedge 49 29 28% Rushes 2 0 0% Open water 7 11 4% Bare ground 1 1 0

Total 100 100 100

Page 11: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

#*#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

Muskeg

Rive

r

Jackpine Creek

Ath

abas

ca R

iver

9

8

7

6

5

4

3

21

13

12

11

10

465000

465000

470000

470000

475000

475000

6340

000

6340

000

6345

000

6345

000

Figure 2 Qualitative ranking of noise levels within the study area of the yellow rail survey, summer 2008.

Data Sources:a) Rivers and Roads from 1:250,000 NTSB.b) Background: 10m SPOT-5 (August 8, 2008) multispectral imagery, RAMP 2008.

Projection: UTM Zone 12N NAD83 t0 1 20.5

km1:45,000Scale

ALB

ER

TA

SAS

KATC

HEW

AN

FortMcMurray

Map Extent

K:\Data\Project\ALBIAN1443\GIS\_MXD\ALBIAN1443_2Noise_20081103.mxd

LEGENDRivers

Major Roads

StudyArea

#* Sampling SitesPredicted Noise Level

0 - No Noise

1 - Faint Noise

2 - Moderate Noise

3 - Loud Noise

(likely can't hear birds beyond 400 m)

(likely can't hear birds beyond 200 m)

(likely can't hear birds beyond 100 m)

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 7 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 12: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 9 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Table 3 Summary of cover type (%) for contiguous wetland areas sampled during the yellow rail survey, summer 2008.

Survey Location

Habitat cover type 1-5,11,13 6 7,8 9,10 12

Emergent vegetation 49 (Mod) 44 (Mod) 18 (Mod) 26 (Mod) 37 (Short)

Trees 8 (Mod) 10 (Mod) 18 (Tall) 13 (Short) 8 (Short)

Shrubs 35 (Mod) 42 (Mod) 61 (Tall) 58 (Mod) 48 (Short)

Open water 7 4 0 2 7

Bare ground 1 0 3 1 0

Wetlands were continuous tracks of wetland and are designated by the survey circles located within them Figure 1. Emergent vegetation, tree and shrub height was further classified as short, moderate (mod), or tall following Bazin and Baldwin (2007).

Figure 3 Changes in water depth at each survey location sampled during the yellow rail survey from July to August, 20081.

-40

-30

-20

-10

0

10

20

30

40

July 8-10 July 21-23 Aug 5-7

Survey date

chan

ge in

wat

er d

epth

(cm

)

123456910111213

1 Access to survey location 5 was from a different access point in August and due to deep water the sampling location was

about 90 m from the location sampled in the first two rounds. Survey locations 7 and 8 were omitted because there was no water during any of the surveys.

Page 13: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

3.2 YELLOW RAILS

No yellow rails were detected during any of the three surveys conducted at the 13 sampling locations. Secondary species of interest included at least 12 soras recorded at seven survey locations and at least 5 Le Conte sparrows recorded at four survey locations (Table 4). Most soras were detected during the first survey in early July and no soras were heard vocalizing during the last survey in early August. Le Conte sparrows were equally abundant during the first two surveys, but only one individual was heard during the August survey.

Table 4 Maximum number of sora and Le Conte sparrows detected at each survey location during the yellow rail surveys, July to August, 2008.

SurveyLocation July 8-10 July 21-23 Aug 5-7 July 8-10 July 21-23 Aug 5-7

1 1 1 12 2 1 134 1 15 2 16 1 2 1789 1

1011 112 313 2

Total 12 2 0 4 4 1Note: No yellow rails were detected during the surveys

Sora Le Conte sparrow

3.3 OTHER WILDLIFE OBSERVATIONS

A total of 17 bird species, 1 mammal species, and 1 amphibian species were recorded incidentally during the surveys (Table 5). This includes several soras that were observed on the trail while in the argo between survey locations. A pair of sandhill cranes was observed and heard vocalizing during the first two rounds of surveys between survey location 9 and 10.

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 10 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 14: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

Table 5 Incidental wildlife observations made during the yellow rail surveys.

July 8-10 July 21-23 Aug 5-7

Birds red-necked grebe 1 mallard 1 unknown duck 1 killdeer 2 solitary sandpiper 1 unknown yellowlegs 1 Wilson's snipe 5 4 black tern 10+ sandhill crane 4 sora 1 2 4 great-horned owl 1 common nighthawk 2 2 olive-sided flycatcher 1 alder flycatcher 2 common yellowthroat 2 white-throated sparrow 1 clay-colored sparrow 1 Nelson's sharp-tailed sparrow 1 dark-eyed junco 1

Mammals bat (Myotis sp.) 1

Amphibians wood frogs 1+

3.4 OTHER DATA SOURCES

The goal of this section was to compile and display data available from datasets that may provide insight into the likelihood of yellow rails being detected in northeastern Alberta. The Alberta Bird Atlas reports that records from both southwestern and northwestern Alberta have expanded the known distribution of yellow rails in the province; however yellow rails have not been detected in high enough numbers to allow a robust analysis of population change with their data (Federation of Alberta Naturalists 2007). A variety of sources suggest that yellow rails may be present in the study area. Wildlife surveys in support of oil sands projects recorded a yellow rail observation near Kearl Lake in the week prior to the surveys described in this report (A. Dupuis, per. comm.). Studies in support of the Muskeg River Mine Expansion include observations of at least five yellow rails at four locations between June 3 and 5, 2003 (Figure 1; Albian Sands Energy 2005). Prescott et al. (2002) provide five historical records for yellow rails in the Wood Buffalo region; however, they did not resample these locations during their study (Prescott et al. 2002). The Alberta Breeding Bird Atlas,

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 11 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 15: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

surveyed between 2000-2005, reported two records of yellow rails north of Fort McMurray and one (of only two in the province) confirmed breeding record southwest of Fort McMurray (Federation of Alberta Naturalists 2007). Yellow rails are detected at low levels by international bird monitoring programs such as the breeding bird survey (BBS; Sauer et al. 2008) and Christmas bird count (CBC; National Audubon Society 2002) and neither of these programs produce sufficient data for statistical analysis of population trends. Additionally, because yellow rails are migratory, none of the Christmas Bird Count records are from Canada.

4.0 DISCUSSION Yellow rails have previously been detected in the study area during baseline wildlife studies (Albian Sands Energy 2005); however, it is unknown if they are still present on the lease area and, if so, at what abundance. There were no yellow rails detected during surveys in July and August 2008 within the Muskeg River Mine Expansion area during this study. Yellow rails are elusive and, because they vocalize primarily at night, are difficult to detect with traditional monitoring programs such as the breeding bird survey (Sauer et al. 2008). Accordingly, protocols aimed to specifically monitor yellow rails are required to approximate breeding abundance and distribution. A protocol has recently been outlined by the Canadian Wildlife Service to collect such standardized data for yellow rails, but data will need to accumulate before population analyses can occur (Bazin and Baldwin 2007).

Detecting rare and elusive species is substantially more difficult if surveys occur in sub-optimal habitat or at an inappropriate time of year. In one study, yellow rails occupied sedge and mixed (sedge/cattail/bulrush) wetlands more than wetlands dominated by strictly cattail or bulrush (Prescott et al. 2002). Yellow rails generally occupy habitats of Carex (sedge), Scirpus (bulrush), and Calamagrostis (grass). These habitat attributes are found in fen wetlands on the study area (Table 2, Figure 1) suggesting that suitable habitat for yellow rails exist on the study area (Bookhout 1995). The timing of surveys should occur when yellow rails are most likely to be detected, that is, during the early portion of the breeding season (Spear et al. 1999). Surveys should be conducted after yellow rails have migrated from wintering areas and have started to settle on breeding territories. Migration timing of yellow rails is unknown in northern Alberta, but yellow rails likely arrive in the second half of May (Federation of Alberta Naturalists 2007). Bazin and Baldwin (2007) recommended surveys be conducted between the end of May and the middle of July. Due to the need for a 10-day period between subsequent surveys (Bazin and Baldwin 2007), one of the surveys was conducted beyond this recommended time period.

As recommended by Conway (2008), survey locations were spaced 400 m apart to avoid double counting of individuals. This results in 200 m radius circles relative to the center sample point (Figure 1). The assumption that yellow rails could be heard for 200 m in any direction was probably optimistic because background noise within the study area was particularly loud in some areas (Figure 2).

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 12 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 16: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

5.0 RECOMMENDATIONS Overall, future surveys should follow the Canadian Wildlife Survey protocol (Bazin and Baldwin 2007) with respect to timing of surveys. Bazin and Baldwin (2007) suggest surveys from the end of May until mid-July. Thus, it is recommended that any future surveys occur during the period of late-May to mid-July in the oil sands region of northern Alberta to increase the likelihood of detecting yellow rails.

Early on during this study it became apparent that high noise levels could make detecting yellow rails beyond 200 m difficult in some locations. In some instances, it would have been difficult to hear rails beyond 100 m. However, it is recognized that, except for the primary mining activities, roads, and processing facilities, noise in portions of the Muskeg River Mine lease is probably temporary. However, if yellow rail surveys are to be conducted long-term, then the disturbance area should be surveyed during the periods when noise is likely to be minimized. Alternatively, surveys could incorporate smaller detection distances (100 m instead of current 200 m) to minimize the effect of noise on the detection of yellow rails.

6.0 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Ron Bazin graciously provided digital sound files which were recorded by Monty Brigham and found on his Bird Sounds of Canada CD. Buddy Dupuis of Albian Sands Energy provided logistical support and field assistance. Several staff members at Albian provided assistance including Tanya Solomone and Justin Galea.

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 13 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 17: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

7.0 REFERENCES Alberta Energy and Utilities Board and Canadian Environmental Assessment

Agency. 2006. Report of the joint panel established by the Alberta Energy and Utilities Board and the Government of Canada. EUB Decision 2006-128: Albian Sands Energy Inc., Application to Expand Oil Sands Mining and Processing Plant Facilities at the Muskeg River Mine. Alberta Energy and Utilities Board, Calgary, and Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency, Ottawa.

Alberta Environment. 2005. The 2005 general status of Alberta wild species. Alberta Environment, Edmonton, AB.

Albian Sands Energy. 2005. Muskeg River Mine Expansion Environmental Setting Report – Terrestrial: Appendices. Appendix O – Incidental observations during MRM expansion wildlife surveys. Prepared by AXYS Environmental Consulting Ltd. http://www.ceaa.gc.ca/050/DocHTMLContainer_e.cfm?DocumentID=16923 (MK-PRO-0019; Table O-6).

Bazin, R. and F. B. Baldwin. 2007. Canadian Wildlife Service standardized protocol for the survey of yellow rails (Coturnicops noveboracensis) in prairie and northern region. Canadian Wildlife Service, Environment Canada. 22pp.

Bookhout, T.A. 1995. Yellow Rail (Coturnicops noveboracensis). No. 139 in The birds of North America. A. Poole and F. Gill [eds.]. The Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia, PA, and The American Ornithologists’ Union, Washington, D.C. 16 pp.

Conway, C.J. 2008. Standardized North American Marsh Bird Monitoring Protocols. Wildlife Research Report #2008-01. U.S. Geological Survey, Arizona Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit, Tucson, AZ. 36pp.

COSEWIC. 2001. COSEWIC assessment and status report on the yellow rail Coturnicops noveboracensis in Canada. Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada. Ottawa. Vii + 62pp. (www.sararegistry.gc.ca/ status/status_e.cfm).

Eddleman, W.R., F.L. Knopf, B. Meanley, F.A. Reid, and R. Zembal. 1988. Conservation of North American rallids. Wilson Bulletin 100: 27-34.

Federation of Alberta Naturalists. 2007. The Atlas of breeding birds of Alberta: a second look. Federation of Alberta Naturalists. Edmonton, Alberta.

Gibbs, J.P., W.G. Shriver, and S.M. Melvin. 1991. Spring and summer records of the Yellow Rail in Maine. Journal of Field Ornithology 62: 509-516.

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 14 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 18: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

National Audubon Society. 2002. The Christmas Bird Count historical results [online]. http://www.audubon.org/bird/cbc [8 October 2008].

Prescott, D.R.C., M.R. Norton, and I.M.G. Michaud. 2002. Night surveys of Yellow Rails, Coturnicops noveboracensis, and Virginia Rails, Rallus limicola, in Alberta using call playbacks. Canadian Field-Naturalist 116: 408-415.

Sauer, J.R., J.E. Hines, and J. Fallon. 2008. The North American Breeding Bird Survey, Results and Analysis 1966-2007. Version 5.15.2008. USGS Patuxent Wildlife Research Center, Laurel, MD. http://www.mbr-pwrc.usgs.gov/bbs/bbs.html [8 October 2008].

Smith, K.B., C.E. Smith, S.F. Forest, and A.J. Richard. 2007. A field guide to the wetlands of the boreal plains ecozone of Canada. Ducks Unlimited Canada, Western Boreal Office: Edmonton, Alberta. 98 pp.

Spear L.B., S.B. Terrill, C. Lenihan, and P. Delevoryas. 1999. Effects of temporal and environmental factors on the probability of detecting California black rails. Journal of Field Ornithology 70: 465-480.

Takats, D.L., C.M. Francis, G.L. Holroyd, J.R. Duncan, K.M. Mazur, R.J. Cannings, W. Harris, and D. Holt. 2001. Guidelines for Nocturnal Owl Monitoring in North America. Beaverhill Bird Observatory and Bird Studies Canada. Edmonton, Alberta. 32 pp.

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 15 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

Page 19: Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River ...€¦ · Results of Yellow Rail Surveys on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area December 2008 Prepared for: Albian

Results of Yellow Rail Surveys 16 Hatfield on the Albian Muskeg River Mine Expansion Area

8.0 CLOSURE We trust the above information meets your requirements. If you have any questions or comments, please contact the undersigned.

HATFIELD CONSULTANTS:

Approved by:

December 1, 2008

Tyler Flockhart, Project Manager Date

Approved by:

December 1, 2008

Wade Gibbons, Project Director Date