Remedial Law Review Notes

  • View
    35

  • Download
    6

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Ateneo notes on Remedial Law Review class of Atty. Tranquil Salvador III

Text of Remedial Law Review Notes

REMEDIAL LAW REVIEW (ATTY. TRANQUIL SALVADOR III)PRELIMINARY CONFERENCE (Missing Case)Montemayor v. BermejoA.M. No. MTJ-04-1535 Ma!"# 1$ $004 % AbuFACT&' T#e ins(an( a)*inis(!a(i+e "ase (!a"es i(s !oo(s ,!o*an-n.a/,-. )e(aine! "ase 0.e) 12 3.ain(i4s Mon(e*a2o! agains( Ma!"o.T#e "ase /as !a5e) (o !es3on)en( J-)ge 6e!*e7o. P!e-(!ia."on,e!en"e /as #e.) on May 20, 2002. No se((.e*en( /as !ea"#e).J-)ge 6e!*e7o iss-e) a Pre-Trial Order on (#e sa*e )a(e an))i!e"(e) (#e 3a!(ies (o s-1*i( (#ei! !es3e"(i+e 3osi(ion 3a3e!s /i(#in10)a2s,!o*!e"ei3(o, (#e Order a,(e!/#i"# (#e"ases#a.. 1e)ee*e)s-1*i((e),o! )e"ision. P.ain(i4ss-1*i((e)(#ei! PositionPaper onJune13, 2002.Mo!e (#an a *on(# .a(e! (#e2 0.e)a Motionfor EarlyResolution )a(e)J-.230 $00$. T#e)e,en)an(s-1*i((e) #e! Position Paper on.2 on Au 1!, 2002.T#e 3.ain(i4s(#en 0.e) a $n) Motion for Early Resolution on &e3( 8 $00$. T#e "ase/as )e".a!e) s-1*i((e) ,o! )e"ision onSe"# 23. OnO$#10 Judgment /as!en)e!e)in,a+o! o, (#e3.ain(i4s. On9e"1$$00$ (#e 3.ain(i4s 0.e) (#ei! 0!s( Motion for Execution. On De$ 20$00$ (#e )e,en)an( 0.e) a Notice of Appeal.&-1se:-en(.2 (#e 3.ain(i4s; 0.e) a Second Motion forExecution )a(e) 9e" $8 $00$ an) a Motion to Reuire !efendant"s#ounsel to $nform t%e#ourtt%e!ate &e Recei'eda#opy oft%eJudgment. J-)ge 6e!*e7o )i) no( a"( on ei(#e! *o(ion.In #is Order )a(e) Jan %, 2003,!es3on)en( J-)ge ga+e )-e"o-!se (o (#e )e,en)an(;s a33ea. an) !e:-i!e) (#e .a((e! (o 3os( as-3e!se)eas1on)in(#ea*o-n( o, P5e"-(e) in ,a+o! o,(#e 3.ain(i4 (o 3a2 (#e !en(s )a*ages an) "os(s a""!-ing )o/n (o(#e (i*e o, (#e 7-)g*en( a33ea.e) ,!o*G.F T#e 7-)g*en( ise>e"-(e) i**e)ia(e.2 in ,a+o! o, (#e 3.ain(i4 as a *a((e! o, !ig#( (o3!e+en( ,-!(#e! )a*age a!ising ,!o* (#e .oss o, 3ossession.In "ase (#e )e,en)an( )oes no( 0.e an2 s-3e!se)eas 1on) o!)i) no( *a@e an2 *on(#.2 )e3osi( (#e 3.ain(i4 /o-.) 1e en(i(.e) asa *a((e! o, !ig#( (o (#e i**e)ia(e e>e"-(ion o, (#e in,e!io! "o-!(;s7-)g*en(. In s-"# a "ase (#e e>e"-(ion is *an)a(o!2(#e )-(2 o,(#e "o-!( in (#is !es3e"( 1eing F*inis(e!ia. an) i*3e!a(i+e.FIn(#is "ase J-)ge6e!*e7o)i)no( o!)e! (#ei**e)ia(ee>e"-(ion o, (#e J-)g*en(. On (#e "on(!a!2 #e e+en o!)e!e)A(eneo La/ 4A $011 % AY 2010)2011 $REMEDIAL LAW REVIEW (ATTY. TRANQUIL SALVADOR III))e,en)an( (o 0.e a s-3e!se)eas 1on) /#i"# in an2 e+en( s#o-.)#a+e 1een 3os(e) /i(#in (#e 3e!io) (o 0.e an a33ea..T#e !e"o!)s s#o/ (#a( on Jan 8 $003 J-)ge 6e!*e7o g!an(e)(#e )e,en)an( 10 )a2s ,!o* !e"ei3( o, (#e Order gi+ing )-e "o-!se(o (#e Notice of Appeal (o 3os( a s-3e!se)eas 1on). Ass-*ing (#a((#e )e,en)an( !e"ei+e) a "o32 o, (#e Judgment on.2 on 9e" 5 $00$(#e 3e!io) g!an(e) /as /a2 1e2on) (#e 15-)a2 3e!io) ,o! 3e!,e"(ingan a33ea..Mo!e (#an (#!ee *on(#s a,(e! (#e )e,en)an( 0.e) an (rgentMotionforExtension)as@ing,o!10*o!e)a2s(o3os((#esa*e.Mo!eo+e! (#e (rgent Motion for Extension /as 0.e) on.2 on A3!i. $4$003 o!(#!ee)a2s a,(e! #e!a..ege).as()a2 (o 3os((#e1on) onA3!i. $1 $003 in+io.a(iono, (#e!-.e(#a( *o(ions,o!e>(ension*-s( 1e0.e)3!io! (o(#ee>3i!a(iono, (#e3e!io)so-g#( (o1ee>(en)e). Co*3o-n)ing (#e e!!oneo-s a)*ission o, sai) *o(ion ,o!e>(ension J-)ge 6e!*e7o on (#e sa*e )a2 iss-e)an Order a..o/ing (#e )e,en)an( an a))i(iona. e>(ension o, 15)a2s *o!e (#an (#e 10 )a2s s#e ini(ia..2 as@e) ,o!.J-)ge6e!*e7ois #e.)g-i.(2o, )e.a2in(#e!en)i(iono,7-)g*en( (0ne 5000) an) o, i*3!o3!ie(2 (0ne 10000).PLEA9INH& (Missing "ases)Solar Team Entertainment v. Ricafort$C3 &CRA 881 % AndresFACT&' Pe(i(ione! as3.ain(i4 0.e)1e,o!e(#eRTCinPa!ana:-ea"o*3.ain( ,o! !e"o+e!2 o, 3ossession an) )a*ages /i(# 3!a2e! ,o! a/!i(o, !e3.e+in agains( #e!ein3!i+a(e!es3on)en(s. T#e"ase/as)o"@e(e)as Ci+i. CaseNo. C=-0304an)/asassigne)(o3-1.i"!es3on)en( J-)geBe.en6a-(is(a-Ri"a,o!(. P!i+a(e!es3on)en(s as)e,en)an(s 0.e) (#ei! Ans/e! (/i(# Co-n(e!".ai*s). A "o32 (#e!eo,/as ,-!nis#e) "o-nse. ,o! 3e(i(ione! 12 !egis(e!e) *ai.I #o/e+e! (#e3.ea)ing )i) no( "on(ain an2 /!i((en e>3.ana(ion as (o /#2 se!+i"e/as no( *a)e 3e!sona..2 -3on 3e(i(ione!-3.ain(i4. Pe(i(ione! 0.e) a*o(ion (o e>3-nge (#e Ans/e! (/i(# Co-n(e!".ai*s) an) (o )e".a!e#e!ein 3!i+a(e !es3on)en(s in )e,a-.( a..eging (#e!ein (#a( (#e .a((e!)i)no( o1se!+e(#e*an)a(eo, (#ea,o!e*en(ione)&e"(ion11es3e"ia..2sin"e(#eoA"eo, )e,en)an(s "o-nse. is7-s( as(one(#!o/ a/a2 ,!o* (#e oA"e o, 3e(i(ione!s "o-nse. /i(# an es(i*a(e)is(an"e o, a1o-( $00 *e(e!s *o!e o! .ess. Pe(i(ione! ,-!(#e! a..ege)(#a( (#e 3os( oA"e /as a1o-( (en (10) (i*es ,a!(#e! ,!o* (#e oA"eo, )e,en)en(s; "o-nse.. P-1.i"!es3on)en( J-)ge6a-(is(a-Ri"a,o!(iss-e)ano!)e! )en2ing ,o! .a"@o, *e!i( 3e(i(ione!s*o(ion(oe>3-nge(#eAns/e! (/i(#Co-n(e!".ai*s) an)(o)e".a!e3!i+a(e!es3on)en(s in )e,a-.(.A(eneo La/ 4A $011 % AY 2010)2011 3REMEDIAL LAW REVIEW (ATTY. TRANQUIL SALVADOR III)I&&?E' EJNJ-)ge6a-(is(a-Ri"a,o!( "o**i((e)HA9/#ens#ea)*i((e)3!i+a(e !es3on)en(sK FAns/e! (/i(# Co-n(e!".ai*s)F no(/i(#s(an)ing+io.a(ion o, &e"(ion 11 R-.e 13.BEL9'No. &e"(ion 11 o, R-.e 13 se!+i"e an) 0.ing o, 3.ea)ings an)o(#e! 3a3e!s *-s( /#ene+e! 3!a"(i"a1.e 1e )one 3e!sona..2I an) i,*a)e(#!o-g#o(#e! *o)es (#e3a!(2"on"e!ne)*-s( 3!o+i)ea/!i((ene>3.ana(ionas(o/#2(#ese!+i"eo! 0.ing/asno( )one3e!sona..2. Pe!sona. ser'ice an)*ling is(#e gene!a. !-.ean)!eso!((oo(#e! *o)es o, se!+i"e an) 0.ing (#e e>"e3(ion. Ben"e,o!(#/#ene+e! 3e!sona. se!+i"eo! 0.ingis3!a"(i"a1.e in.ig#( o, (#e"i!"-*s(an"es o, (i*e 3.a"e an) 3e!son 3e!sona. se!+i"e o! 0.ing is*an)a(o!2.On.2/#en3e!sona. se!+i"e o!0.ingisno(3!a"(i"a1.e*a2 !eso!( (o o(#e! *o)es 1e #a) /#i"# *-s( (#en 1ea""o*3anie) 12 a /!i((en e>3.ana(ion as (o /#2 3e!sona. se!+i"e o!0.ing /as no( 3!a"(i"a1.e (o 1egin /i(#. In a)7-)ging (#e 3.a-si1i.i(2o, an e>3.ana(ion a "o-!( s#a.. .i@e/ise "onsi)e! (#e i*3o!(an"e o,(#e s-17e"( *a((e! o, (#e "ase o! (#e iss-es in+o.+e) (#e!ein an)(#e primafacie *e!i( o, (#e3.ea)ingso-g#( (o1ee>3-nge),o!+io.a(iono, &e"(ion11. T#isCo-!("anno( !-.eo(#e!/ise .es(/ea..o/ "i!"-*+en(ion o, (#e inno+a(ion in(!o)-"e) 12 (#e 1CC= R-.esin o!)e! (o o1+ia(e )e.a2 in (#e a)*inis(!a(ion o, 7-s(i"e.Be!e (#e 3!o>i*i(2 1e(/een (#e oA"es o, o33osing "o-nse./ases(a1.is#e)I *o!eo+e! (#a( (#eoA"eo, 3!i+a(e!es3on)en(s"o-nse. /as (en (i*es ,a!(#e! ,!o* (#e 3os( oA"e (#an (#e )is(an"ese3a!a(ing(#eoA"es o, o33osing"o-nse.. O, "o-!se 3!o>i*i(2/o-.) see* (o *a@e 3e!sona. se!+i"e *os( 3!a"(i"a1.e 1-(e>"e3(ions *a2 none(#e.ess a33.2. Fo! ins(an"e /#e!e (#e a)+e!se3a!(2o! o33osing"o-nse. (o1ese!+e)/i(#a3.ea)ingse.)o*!e3o!(s(ooA"ean)noe*3.o2eeis!eg-.a!.23!esen((o!e"ei+e3.ea)ings o! /#e!e se!+i"e is )one on (#e .as( )a2 o, (#e!eg.e*en(a!2 3e!io) an) (#e oA"e o, (#e a)+e!se 3a!(2 o! o33osing"o-nse. (o 1e se!+e) is ".ose) ,o! /#a(e+e! !eason.Re(-!ning #o/e+e! (o (#e *e!i(s o, (#is "ase in +ie/ o, (#e3!o>i*i(2 1e(/een (#e oA"es o, o33osing "o-nse. an) (#e a1sen"eo, an2a((en)an( e>3.ana(ionas (o/#23e!sona. se!+i"eo, (#eans/e!/as no( e4e"(e) in)-1i(a1.23!i+a(e !es3on)en(s"o-nse.+io.a(e) &e"(ion 11 o, R-.e 13 an) (#e *o(ion (o e>3-nge /as primafacie *e!i(o!io-s. Bo/e+e! (#e g!an( o! )enia. o, sai) *o(ionne+e!(#e.ess !e*aine) /i(#in (#e so-n) e>e!"ise o, (#e (!ia. "o-!(s)is"!e(ion. T#-s as g-i)e) 12 &e"(ion 8 R-.e 1 o, (#e 1CC= R-.es o,Ci+i. P!o"e)-!e /#i"# o!)ains (#a( (#e R-.es s#a.. 1e .i1e!a..2"ons(!-e)ino!)e! (o3!o*o(e(#ei! o17e"(i+eo, se"-!inga7-s(s3ee)2 an) ine>3ensi+e )is3osi(ion o, e+e!2 a"(ion o! 3!o"ee)ingas /e.. as 12 (#e )i"(-* .ai) )o/n in Alonso '+ ,illamor 18 P#i.. 315L1C10M (#e(!ia. "o-!( o3(e)(oe>e!"isei(s)is"!e(ionin,a+o! o,a)*i((ing (#e Ans/e! (/i(# Co-n(e!".ai*s) ins(ea) o, e>3-nging i(,!o* (#e !e"o!).To o-! *in) i, *o(ions (o e>3-nge o! s(!i@e o-( 3.ea)ings ,o!+io.a(ion o, &e"(ion 11 o, R-.e 13 /e!e (o 1e in)is"!i*ina(e.2!eso.+e) -n)e! &e"(ion 8 o, R-.e 1 o! Alon-o '+ ,illamor an) o(#e!ana.ogo-s "ases (#en &e"(ion 11 /o-.) 1e"o*e *eaning.ess an)i(s so-n) 3-!3ose nega(e). Ne+e!(#e.ess /e s-s(ain (#e "#a..enge)!-.ing o, (#e (!ia. "o-!( 1-( ,o! !easons o(#e! (#an (#ose 3!o+i)e) ,o!in(#e"#a..enge)o!)e! (T#e1CC=R-.eso, Ci+i. P!o"e)-!e(oo@e4e"( on.2 on 1 J-.2 1CC= /#i.e (#e :-es(ione) Ans/e! (/i(#Co-n(e!".ai*s) /as 0.e) on.2 on < A-g-s( 1CC= o! on (#e 3C(# )a2,o..o/ing (#e e4e"(i+i(2 o, (#e 1CC= R-.es).Musa v. AmorH. R. No. 1413C8 A3!i. C $00$ % AngFACT&'Rosa!io 9asig a)*inis(!a(!i> o, #e! sonKs .an)#o.)ings /#i.e(#e .a((e! *ig!a(e) (o (#e ?ni(e) &(a(es so.) (#e 3!o3e!(2 (o!es3on)en( &2.+ia A*o!.T#is 3!o*3(e) 3e(i(ione!s ".ai*ing (o 1e(enan(so,(#e.an)#o.)ing (o 0.e a "ase,o!!e)e*3(ion/i(#(#e9e3a!(*en( o, Ag!a!ian Re,o!*Regiona. A)7-)i"a(o!. Pe(i(ione!ss-1se:-en(.2 0.e) a "o*3.ain( ,o! ann-.*en( o, sa.e agains(!es3on)en(.T#e Regiona.A)7-)i"a(o! o, (#e 9AR !-.e) in ,a+o! o,3e(i(ione!s an) )e".a!e) (#e* as (enan(s o, (#e s-17e"( .an)#o.)ingan) n-..i0e) (#e )ee) o, a1so.-(e sa.e 1e(/een Rosa!io 9asig an)!es3on)en(. T#e 9ARA6 *o)i0e) (#e !-.ing a 1i( sa2ing (#a( (#e2/e!e bona *de (enan(s. T#e Co-!( o, A33ea.s #o/e+e! !e+e!se) (#e9ARA6. T#e 3e(i(ione!s a!g-e) (#a( (#e CA s#o-.) #a+e )is*isse)!es3on)en(;s 3e(i(ion ,o! ,ai.-!e (o "i(e an e>3.ana(ion ,o! (#e *o)eo, se!+i"e.A(eneo La/ 4A $011 % AY 2010)2011 4REMEDIAL LAW REVIEW (ATTY. TRANQUIL SALVADOR III)I&&?E'EJN (#e Co-!( o, A33ea.s s#o-.) no( #a+e gi+en )-e "o-!se (o (#e3e(i(ion 1e"a-se(#e !es3on)en( ,ai.e)(o a((a"# (#e!e(o a/!i((ene>3.ana(ion /#2 3e!sona. se!+i"e /as no( )oneBEL9'T#e ,ai.-!e (o e>3.ain /#2 3e!sona. se!+i"e /as no( )one isno( "a-se ,o! )is*issa..T#e se!+i"e an) 0.ing o, 3.ea)ings *-s( 1e )one 3e!sona..2/#ene+e! 3!a"(i"a1.e. In (#e 3!esen( "ase 3e!sona.se!+i"e /o-.)no( 1e 3!a"(i"a1.e. Consi)e!ing (#e )is(an"e 1e(/een (#e Co-!( o,A33ea.s an) 9onso. &o!sogon /#e!e (#e 3e(i(ion /as 3os(e)".ea!.2 se!+i"e 12 !egis(e!e) *ai. /o-.) #a+e en(ai.e) "onsi)e!a1.e(i*e e4o!( an) e>3ense. A /!i((en e>3.ana(ion /#2 se!+i"e /as no()one 3e!sona..2 *ig#( #a+e 1een *u"e&/u.u*. In an2 "as