Reed Objections to Plaintiffs Evidence Doc 507

7/31/2019 Reed Objections to Plaintiffs Evidence Doc 507

1/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z(

qi &1;4;;18

GKFMQ I. F aAKBM *AK QB@ ;>49:9(GFaAkbmNfoio.aofFORRHQO@ ) IOMRQTMR CC^42= Fkremt QtrmmtQk` Irkàhqao# Akchior`hk 84;>= &24:2Tmcm~jo`m7 4;=.29:.>>Ikaqhfhcm7 4;=.29:. Kym`}m oi tjm Kfmrhakq

@m| Xore# @m| Xore ;>;>4 &>>=>Tmcm~jo`m7 2;2.49:.:>>8Ikaqhfhcm7 2;2.49:.>

Kttor`mxq ior Rmmd Mcqmyhmr Hà.# Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe k`dHìorfktho` K`kcxthaq Lro}~ Hà.# Cmzhq@mzhq# Hà.#Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe Qoc}tho`q# Hà.# Cmzhq@mzhqAjohamôh`t# Hà.# Cmzhq@mzhq Qmhqh`t# Hà.# d/b/kKaa}rh`t# k`d Cmzhq@mzhq Lro}~ Hà.

]@HTMD QTKTMQ DHQTRHAT AO]RT

AM@TRKC DHQTRHAT OI AKCHIOR@HK

QO]TJMR@ DHYHQHO@

CHQK CHBMRH#mt kc .#

^ckh`thii q#

y.

ORCX TKHTW#mt kc .#

Dmim`dk`tq.

Akqm @o. AY;; &>>4:= KL *KG\z(

CMZHQ@MZHQ DMIM@DK@TQOBGMATHO@Q TO MYHDM@AMOIIMRMD H@ Q]^ÔRT OI^CKH@THIIQ O^ÔQHTHO@ TOCMZHQ@MZHQ DMIM@DK@TQFOTHO@ IOR Q]FFKRXG]DLFM@T

Joòrkbcm G}dlm K`drm| G. L}hciordDktm7Fkx 2;# 2>;2Thfm7 ;>7>> k.f.Dm~t7 ;> D

Akqm :7;;&ay&>>4:=&KL&KG\ Doa}fm`t =;< Ihcmd >=/>


2/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;

qi &1;4;;18

Dmim`dk`tq Rmmd Mcqmyhmr Hà.# Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe k`d Hìorfktho` K`kcx

Lro}~ Hà.# Cmzhq@mzhq# Hà.# Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe Qoc}tho`q# Hà.# Cmzhq

Ajohamôh`t# Hà.# Cmzhq @mzhq Qmhqh`t# Hà.# d/b/k Kaa}rh`t# k`d Cmzhq@

Lro}~# Hà. *aoccmathymcx# tjm Cmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tq( jmrmbx q}bfht tjm

iocco|h`l obgmatho`q to tjm Dmackrktho` oi ^jhch~ G. Bmrl *Bmrl Dmackrktho`(#

Dmackrktho` oi Chqk Chbmrh *Chbmrh Dmackrktho`(# Dmackrktho` oi Brm`t Chbmr*B.

Chbmrh Dmackrktho`(# Dmackrktho` oi Chqk Oqtmcck *Oqtmcck Dmackrktho`(# k`

Dmackrktho` oi Dr. Irkè Oqtmcck *I. Oqtmcck Dmackrktho`( oiimrmd h` q}~~ort oi

^ckh`thiiq O~~oqhtho` to Cmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tq Fotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`t.

OBGMATHO@Q TO DMACKRKTHO@ OI ^JHCH^ G. BMRL# MQ[]HRM

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMD

^klm ;# Ch`m 2=& klm 2# Ch`m4.

;. H kf k` Kttor mx h` loodqtk`dh`l# cham`qmd to ~rkatham ck|h` tjm Aoffo`|mkctj oi ^m``qxcyk`hk. H kf cham`qmd to

~rkatham h` tjm ].Q. DhqtrhatAo}rtq# Fhddcm k`d Mkqtmr`Dhqtrhat oi m``qxcyk`hk5 TjhrdAhra}ht Ao}rt oi K~~mkcq5 tjm

@h`tj Ahra}ht Ao}rt oi K~~mkcq5tjm m``qxcyk`hk Q}~rmfm Ao}rt5k`d tjm ].Q. Q}~rmfm Ao}rt.K`d# H kf tjm Kttor`mx oi Rmaord ior kcc tjm ^ckh`thiiq h`tjhq akqm.

^klm 2# Ch`mq=&;;

2. H kf fkeh`l tjhqDmackrktho` h` q}~~ort oi ^ckh`thiiq O~~oqhtho` to RmmdMcqmyhmr# Hà.5 Ajohamôh`t# Hà.5Cmzhq@mzhq5 Qmhqh`t# Hà. d/b/kKaa}rh`t5 Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe Qoc}tho`q# Hà.5 Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe k`d K`kcxthaq Lro}~# CCA5 k`dCmzhq@mzhq Lro}~# aoccmathymcxURmmd Dmim`dk`tqV Fotho` ior



3/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 2

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDQ}ffkrx G}dlfm`t UFQGV.

^klm 2# Ch`mq ;1&22

1. O` @oymfbmr 1># 2>;;# Hqmrymd o` bmjkci oi ^ckh`thiiq tjmRmmd Dmim`dk`tq |htj tjmhr H`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq tjkt hàc}dmdk~~rozhfktmcx Ihym Tjo}qk`dU=#>>>V ~klmq. O` Dmamfbmr ;2#2>;2# H qm`t k qmttcmfm`t dmfk`dto Gkfmq FaAkbm# Mq{}hrmKttor`mx ior tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq. H` qkhd dmfk`d# Hqtktmd H jkd ot rmamhymd tjmRmmd Dmim`dk`tq H`hthkc

Dhqacoq}rmq k`d hi tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq dhdòt h`tm`d toqmttcm tjm` tjmx `mmdmd to qmrymtjmhr H`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.

^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr

o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi aorrmq~o`dmàm jm qm`t krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

^klm 2# Ch`m 21 ^klm 1# Ch`m 2

4. Fr. FaAkbm `mymr rmq~o`dmd to fm. O` Gk`}krx 1#2>;2# H qm`t k dmfk`d cmttmr to kccDmim`dk`tq qtkth`l hi H dhdotrmamhym tjmhr H`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq

bx Gk`}krx ;># 2>;2# tjm` H|o}cd bm qmmeh`l Cmkym to ihcmFotho`q to Aof~mc. H` tjhq cmttmr#H rmfh`dmd tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqtjkt Trhkc |kq ikqt k~~rokajh`l h`G}`m 2>;2.


^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi aorrmq~o`dmàm jm qm`t krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.



4/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 1

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMD;>>2.

^klm 1# Ch`mq 4&;;

=. O` Gk`}krx ;># 2> ;2#Fhajkmc B. Fhccmr# Mq{}hrm#Kttor`mx ior tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq qm`t fm k cmttmr qtkth`l tjmx |o}cd òt q}~~cxH`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq }`thc Gk`}krx24# 2>;2# tjkt jm |kq trmkth`l jhqcmttmr kq k Fmmt k`d Aoìmr

~}rq}k`t to Imd. R. Ahy. ^. 29 . Hrmq~o`dmd to Fr. Fhccmr lrk`th`ljhf }`thc Gk`}krx 24# 2>;2 k`dhìorfh`l jhf tjkt H |o}cd bm

~ro~o}`dh`l ^ckh`thiiq Dhqaoymrx}~o` mkaj oi tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi

~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàm krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

^klm 1# Ch`mq ;2&;=

9. H qmrymd mkaj oi tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq |htj ckh`thiiqDhqaoymrx o` Gk`}krx ;1# 2>;2#

bx |kx oi H`tmrrolktorhmq5Rm{}mqt ior Kdfhqqho`q5 k`dRm{}mqt ior ^rod}atho` oi Doa}fm`tq.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Tjhqtmqthfo`x qjo}cd kcqo bmmzac}dmd }`dmr Imd. R. Myhd.4>1 bmak}qm tjm dhqaoymrxr mimrrmd to |kq |htjdrk|` bx^ckh`thiiq k`d hq òt kt hqq}m h`tjhq akqm. ^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrxkat}kccx |kq qmrymd oÌmbr}krx 2# 2>;2.



5/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 4

qi &1;4;;18


^klm 1# Ch`mq ;9&29

;2#

òtrmamhyh`l tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqH`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq# H qm`t kòtjmr cmttmr to Fr. FaAkbm k`d Fr.Fhccmr klkh` dmfk`dh`l tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq H`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq.Fr. Fhccmr rmq~o`dmd qtkth`l jmjkd qm`t tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqH`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq# b}t oàm jmrmt}r`q to jhq oiiham jm |o}cdMfkhc tjmf to fm# |jhaj jm dhd.Oi ao}rqm# tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqikhcmd to ~royhdm k`xtjh`l b}t

obgmatho`q ackhfh`l H `mymr fmtk`d aoìmrrmd |htj ao}`qmc ior tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq ~}rq}k`t toR}cm 29# |jhaj |kq ao`trkrx toFr. Fhccmrq cmttmr oi Gk`}krx ;>#2>;2.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmd

dhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjm

dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi ~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàm krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

^klm 4# Ch`mq ;&;4

:. O` Gk`}krx 1># 2>;2# Hakccmd k`d q~oem to Fr. Fhccmr rmlkrdh`l tjm hàof~cmtm H`hthkcDhqacoq}rmq rmamhymd irof tjmRmmd Dmim`dk`tq. Fr. Fhccmr trmktmd tjm akcc kq k Fmmt k`dAoìmr kq to tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq h`tm`tho`q oi ihch`l kFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`t.H iocco|md }~ jhq akcc |htj k`Mfkhc aoìhrfh`l tjmao`ymrqktho`. H kcqo qm`t k`Mfkhc rmlkrdh`l k Fmmt k`dAoìmr rmlkrdh`l tjmhàof~cmtm k`d hf~ro~mr H`hthkcDhqacoq}rmq k`d fx h`tm`t o`qmmeh`l Cmkym to ihcm k Fotho` toAof~mc. Fr. Fhccmr klkh`rmq~o`dmd qtkth`l H jkd òtaof~chmd |htj tjm Fmmt k`dAoìmr Rm{}hrmfm`tq k`d jm |kq}`q}rm kq to jo| tjm hìorfktho`q}~~chmd bx fm ~mrtkh`md to jhq


dhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi




6/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( =

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDh`tm`tho`q oi ihch`l k Fotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`t.

^klm 4# Ch`mq ;=&218. Tjm Fmmt k`d Aoìmr

|kq rmqajmd}cmd ior \md`mqdkx#Imbr}krx ;# 2>;2 kt 17>> ~.f.D}rh`l tjhq Fmmt k`d Aoìmr#Fr. Fhccmr |k`tmd tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq Dhqaoymrx rm&qmrymd#|jhaj mztm`dmd tjm dktm d}m ior kòtjmr fo`tj5 k`d Fr. Fhccmr qtktmd jm |o}cd bm ihch`l ior k^rotmathym Ordmr# |jhaj H klrmmdto qth~}cktm to. Fr. Fhccmr kcqo

qtktmd jm |o}cd bm qmtth`ldm~oqhtho`q# b}t tjm dktmq ao}cd bm dhqa}qqmd k`d jm dhdoth`tm`d tjm q~mahiha dktmq to loior|krd5 k`d tjkt jm |o}cd bmqm`dh`l ^ckh`thiiq tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq Q}~~cmfm`tkcDhqacoq}rmq.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd to

h`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi


^klm 4# Ch`mq 2=&2. O` Imbr}krx 2# 2>;2# H

rm&qmrymd tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqDhqaoymrx o` Fr. Fhccmr yhkMfkhc kq rm{}mqtmd bx Fr.Fhccmr. Tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqK`q|mrq |mrm d}m Fkraj =#2>;2. Tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqklkh` ikhcmd to aof~cx.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqmthkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi

~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàm krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.



7/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 9

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMD;>>2.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm =# Ch`mq ;&;2#^ckh`thiiq rmamhymd tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq Dhqaoymrx

~ro~o}`dmd o` tjmf k`d qmtDm~oqhtho`q oi Chqk Oqtmcck5 ChqkChbmrh5 k`d fm h` Akchior`hk oÌmbr}krx 2:# 2>;25 Fkraj ;#2>;2# k`d Fkraj 2# 2>;2#|htjo}t dhqa}qqh`l k`x dktmq

|htj fm k`d òt mym` lhyh`ltjhrtx U1>V dkxq òtham k`d ~rhor to tjm dktm Dhqaoymrx |kq d}m.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkc

to g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi

~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàmkrmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkc



8/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;2# Hqm`t kòtjmr Mfkhc to Fr. Fhccmr hìorfh`l jhf tjkt H jkd òtrmamhymd tjm rm{}mqtmd rotmathymOrdmr5 jkd òt rmamhymd tjmQ}~~cmfm`tkc H`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmqkq ~rofhqmd5 òr jkd H rmamhymdk`x aoff}`haktho`q rmlkrdh`ltjm dm~oqhtho`q dktmq qmt bx Fr.Fhccmr. H kqemd tjkt Fr. Fhccmr

~cmkqm ~royhdm fm |htj dktmq oi kykhckbhchtx qo H ao}cd aoordh`ktmtjm dktmq ior Dm~oqhtho`q. H `mymr rmamhymd k`x dktmq irof Fr.Fhccmr.


~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàm krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}f m`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqt

myhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`t kthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm =# Ch`mq ;9&;8

;1. Fr. Fhccmr rmq~o`dmdqtkth`l tjm Dm~oqhtho` dktmq |mrm

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tq

Akqm :7;;&ay&>>4:=&KL&KG\ Doa}fm`t =;< Ihcmd >=/>>


9/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( :

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDdmmfmd o~m`md k`d kdgo}r`md5k`d ckh`thiiq |o}cd rmamhymQ}~~cmfm`tkc H`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq

tjm iocco|h`l |mme.

Fotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}t

fkeh`l tjmrm{}hrmd qjo|h`l

}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi

~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàm krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krm

hào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.


g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm =# Ch`mq 2>&22

;4. O` Imbr}krx 2;2#Fr. Fhccmr qm`t fm kòtjmr Mfkhcqtkth`l jm |kq ih`m |htjao`d}ath`l Dm~oqhtho`q kitmr Dhqaoymrx rmq~o`qmq jkd bmm`qmrymd.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjm

Akqm :7;;&ay&>>4:=&KL&KG\ Doa}fm`t =;< Ihcmd >=/>;


10/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 8

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi

~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàm krm

obgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

^klm =# Ch`mq 21&29

;=. O` Fkraj ;# 2>;2# Fr.Fhccmr Mfkhcmd fm kqeh`l ior xmtkòtjmr mztm`qho` oi thfm }`thcFkraj ;2# 2>;2# to rmq~o`d totjm ckh`thiiq Dhqaoymrx

~ro~o}`dmd o` mkaj oi tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq. Fr. Fhccmr kcqoakccmd fm.




^klm 9# Ch`mq ;&=

;9. H rmamhymd k` Mfkhc irofF r. Fhccmr qtkth`l H jkd klrmmd tomztm`d tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq }`thcFkraj ;2# 2>;2 to rmq~o`d to^ckh`thiiq Dhqaoymrx# |jhaj |kqòt tr}m. H hffmdhktmcxrmq~o`dmd qtkth`l H f}qt rmamhymtjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq Rmq~o`qmqto Dhqaoymrx bx =7>> ~.f. MQTo` Tj}rqdkx# Fkraj :# 2>;2.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjm

Akqm :7;;&ay&>>4:=&KL&KG\ Doa}fm`t =;< Ihcmd >=/> oi ;2< ^klm HD!7;1=>2


11/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;>

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi



^klm 9# Ch`mq 2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi




g}dlfm`t.(.

Akqm :7;;&ay&>>4:=&KL&KG\ Doa}fm`t =;< Ihcmd >=/>1


12/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;;

qi &1;4;;18


^klm 9# Ch`mq ;4&;:

;:. O` Fkraj 9# 2>;2# Fr.Fhccmr qo}ljt Cmkym oi Ao}rt toihcm k Fotho` ior Q}ffkrxG}dlfm`t. O` tjhq qkfm dktm#Fr. Fhccmr qm`t k` Mfkhc to fmqtkth`l jm |o}cd akcc fm oÌrhdkx oi tjm |mme oi tjm ;2tj oi Fkraj to dhqa}qq Dm~oqhtho`dktmq. H `mymr rmamhymd k akccirof Fr. Fhccmr rmlkrdh`lDm~oqhtho`q dktmq.


dhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjm

dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi ~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàm krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.


g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 9# Ch`m ;8 ^klm 2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmx



13/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;2

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDobgmatho`q# |kq irof Dmim`dk`tQmhqh`t# Hà. d/b/k Kaa}rh`tUKaa}rh`tV. Rmmd Mcqmyhmr# Hà.5

Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe k`d Hìorfktho`K`kcxthaq Lro}~# Hà.5Cmzhq@mzhq Lro}~5 Ajohamôh`t#Hà.5 Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe Qoc}tho`q#Hà.5 k`d Cmzhq@mzhq kqqmrtmd

bohcmr~cktm obgmatho`q to mymrxqh`lcm H`tmrrolktorx# Rm{}mqt ior ^rod}atho` k`d Rm{}mqt ior Kdfhqqho`q.

ak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd to

h`yoem R}cm=9*d( h` tjmhr

o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi



g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm . O` Fkraj 2=# 2>;2# Hqm`t k cmttmr dktmd Fkraj 29#2>;2 to Fr. Fhccmr k`d Fr.FaAkbm o}tch`h`l tjmdmihahmàhmq h` |jkt tjmx akccmdRmq~o`qmq to ^ckh`thiiqDhqaoymrx kq to mkaj oi tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq. H hìorfmd Fr.Fhccmr k`d Fr. FaAkbm tjkt hi tjmx |hqjmd to ao`d}at tjmFmmt k`d Aoìmrtmcm~jo`hakccx to ~cmkqm ~royhdmdktmq |htjh` tjm `mzt iortx &mhljtU4:V jo}rq tjkt tjmx krm kykhckbcm.H qtktmd otjmr|hqm# hi H dhdòtrmamhym Q}~~cmfm`tkc Rmq~o`qmqto tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqRmq~o`qmq |htjh` qmym` U2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi

~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàm krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmd

Akqm :7;;&ay&>>4:=&KL&KG\ Doa}fm`t =;< Ihcmd >=/>=


14/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;1

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDAo}rt to ihcm K Fotho` toAof~mc. H kcqo hìorfmd ao}`qmcior tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq tjkt kccRm{}mqtq ior Kdfhqqho`q qmrymd}~o` tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq jkd

bmm` dmmfmd Kdfhttmd.QmmMZJHBHT 2 . H`qtmkd oi

~ro~mrcx rmq~o`dh`l todhqaoymrx# tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqihcmd tjm |htjh` Fotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`t.

doa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmd

o` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior

q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi


Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tq



15/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;4

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthym

qtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm :# Ch`mq 4&;;

22. H jkym kttkajmd kqMZJHBHT 9 Dmim`dk`tAjohamôh`t# Hà.q Rmq~o`qmq to^ckh`thiiq H`tmrrolktorhmq5 kqMZJHBHT 2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi




g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm :# Ch`mq ;2&2= Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmd



16/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;=

qi &1;4;;18


21. Kctjo}lj tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq kdfht tjkt tjm

Qkèmx Ihrf# Hà. tjro}lj @mhcQkèmx k`d Todd Qkèmxao`d}atmd qmkrajmq o` tjm^ckh`thiiq tjro}lj Kaa}rh`t k`drm~ortq |mrm qocd o` tjm^ckh`thiiq irof Kaa}rh`t toHRBqmkraj# CCA# k rmqmccmr ior tjm Kaa}rh`t ~rod}at# mkaj oi tjmRmmd Dmim`dk`tq jkym rmi}qmd tot}r` oymr k`x qmkrajmq ao`d}atmdor rm~ortq tjmx jkym qocdrmlkrdh`l k`x oi tjm ^ckh`thiiq.Dmim`dk`t Kaa}rh`t kdfhtq tjkt

qmkrajmq |mrm ao`d}atmd k`drm~ortq |mrm qocd o` ^ckh`thii Chbmrh k`d jmr j}qbk`d Brm`t o`Fkraj ;9# 2>>85 K~rhc 9# 2>>85K~rhc ;=# 2>>85 K~rhc ;8# 2>>85k`d Fkx >85 k`d o`^ckh`thii Oqtmcck k`d jmr j}qbk`dIrkè o` K~rhc ;1# 2>>8 k`dK~rhc ;8# 2>>8.

dhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`t

k`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi

~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmam krm


Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc.2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm :# Ch`m 29 ^klm 8# Ch`m :

24. H jkym kttmf~tmd to |ore |htj tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqtjro}lj tjmhr ao}`qmc5}ìort}`ktmcx# ht jkq t}r`md h`toòtjh`l form tjk` dmckx tkathaqk`d lkfmq. Tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqrmi}qkc to dhqacoqm tjm dhqaoymrxhìorfktho` qo}ljt bx ckh`thiiq5rmi}qkc to ~royhdm tjmhìorfktho` tjmx fkh`tkh` o` tjm^ckh`thiiq5 k`d rmi}qkc to ~royhdm

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd to

Akqm :7;;&ay&>>4:=&KL&KG\ Doa}fm`t =;< Ihcmd >=/>:


17/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;9

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDtjm qmkrajmq k`d rm~ortq qocd o`tjm ^ckh`thiiq# hq ymrx ~rmg}dhahkcto tjm ^ckh`thiiq kq ht ~rojhbhtq tjm

^ckh`thiiq irof bmh`l kbcm tormq~o`d to tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqFQG# k`d o` tjhq bkqhq kco m# tjmRmmd Dmim`dk`tq FQG qjo}cd bmDm`hmd.

h`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq.


g}dlfm`t.(.^klm 8# Ch`mq ;;&;=

2=. H jkd qmymrkcao`ymrqktho`q |htj Fkra Aocm`#Kttor`mx ior @mhc Qkèmx# ToddQkèmx# Qkèmx H`ymqthlktho`q#Hà. k`d Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf# Hà.aoccmathymcx UQkèmxDmim`dk`tqV h` rmlkrdq to tjmhr H`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq k`d ckh`thiiq

rm{}mqtmd Dhqaoymrx.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmx

ak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq.

^klm 8# Ch`mq ;9&2;

29. O` Gk`}krx 2># 2>;2 Hrmamhymdk qtkae oi doa}fm`tqirof Fr. Aocm` kq tjm QkèmxDmim`dk`tq H`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq.Hàc}dmd h` tjmqm doa}fm`tq|mrm qmkrajmq ao`d}atmd dhrmatcxtjro}lj Kaa}rh`t o` ckh`thii Chqk Chbmrh o` Fkraj ;9# 2>>8.QmmMZJHBHT 8 ;.

Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht8# krm obgmatho`kbcm to tjmmztm`t tjkt tjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`t k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

Dmackrk`t ckaeq k`x qort oi io}`dktho` or ~mrqo`kceò|cmdlm h` q}~~ort oi jhq



18/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;;.

^klm 8# Ch`m 22 ^klm ;># Ch`m;:

2>2. Kq myhdmàmd bx tjm}`rmdkatmd ymrqho` oi tjmdoa}fm`t# tjm ~}r~ortmd qmkrajdomq òt dhqacoqm Chqk Chbmrhqi}cc qoahkc qma}rhtx `}fbmr.*Fhccmr Dmac. 28# Mz. H.(

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D.Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`t ikhcq to dmfo`qtrktmtjkt jm jkq k`x ikat}kc bkqhq ior tmqthixh`l tjkt tjm ~}r~ortmdqmkraj |kq ao`d}atmd dhrmatcxh` tjm Kaa}rh`t dktkbkqm. Imd.R. Myhd. 9>2. Tjm qtktmfm`t h`tjhq rmlkrd ao`qtht}tmqkrl}fm`t# k`d hq tj}qh`kdfhqqhbcm.



19/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;:

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDQkèmx Ihrf# Hà. kq dm~hatmd o`MZJHBHT 8 o` tjm bottof cmitoi mkaj ~klm.

^klm ;># Ch`m ;8 ^klm ;;# Ch`m;>

2:. ^ckh`thii Chqk Chbmrhqaof~rmjm`qhym rm~ort obtkh`md

bx Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf# Hà. o`Fkraj ;9# 2>>8 |kq hàc}dmd|htj tjm Qkèmx Dmim`dk`tqH`hthkc Dhqacoq}rmq. Qmm k tr}m k`daorrmat ao~x oi Chbmrhqaof~rmjm`qhym rm~ort kttkajmd kqMZJHBHT ;> . Frq. Chbmrhq

rm~ort ao`tkh`q jmr# `kfm5 mymrx`kfm mymr }qmd# hàc}dh`lfkhdm`5 kddrmqqmq5 botj jmr ocdk`d `m| Qoahkc Qma}rhtx`}fbmrq5 dktm oi bhrtj5 hàofm#md}aktho`# mf~coxfm`t# jofmykc}mq# }`chqtmd k`d }`~}bchqjmdtmcm~jo`m }fbmrq5 q~o}qmq`kfm# dktm oi bhrtj# kddrmqqmq#Qoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmr5 irhm`dqhàc}dh`l tjmhr kfmq# QoahkcQma}rhtx }fbmrq# rmckthymqhàc}dh`l tjmhr irhm`dq# rmckthymq#dktmq oi bhrtj# kddrmqqmq# jofmykc}m# hàofm# md}aktho`#5 Frq.Chbmrhq rmckthymq hàc}dh`l`kfmq# kddrmqqmq# QoahkcQma}rhtx `}fbmrq# dktmq oi bhrtj#irhm`dq k`d rmckthymq# hàc}dh`ltjmhr Qoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmrq#dktmq oi bhrtj# jofm ykc}mq#md}aktho`# hàofm# rmckthym k`dirhm`dq hìorfktho`# mymrx kfmmymr }qmd# hàc}dh`l fkhdm``kfmq5 hàofm# jofm ykc}m5md}aktho`5 mhljborq kfmq#kddrmqqmq k`d ~rhyktm dktk#

g}dlfm`tq# chm`q# mta.

Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht;># krm obgmatho`kbcm to tjmmztm`t tjkt tjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`t k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

Kq myhdmàmd bx tjm}`rmdkatmd ymrqho` oi tjmdoa}fm`t# tjm ~}r~ortmd qmkrajdomq òt dhqacoqm Chqk Chbmrhqi}cc qoahkc qma}rhtx `}fbmr.*Fhccmr Dmac. 28# Mz. G.(


g}dlfm`t.(.

Tjmrm hq ò io}`dktho` ~royhdmd to mqtkbchqj tjkt tjmdoa}fm`t kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht;> hq lm`}h`m. Imd. R. Myhd.8>;.

^klm ;;# Ch`mq ;; &2;

28. H` kddhtho`# Frq. Chbmrhq

Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht



20/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( ;8

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDrm~ort ao`tkh`q jmr }`chqtmd k`d}`~}bchqjmd amcc ~jo`m }fbmr5jmr amcc ~jo`m akrrhmr5 jmr

mf~coxfm`t jhqtorx |htj jmr Qoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmr# jmr ~oqhtho`# thfm mf~coxmd# kddrmqqoi mf~coxmr5 g}dlfm`tq loh`l

bkae to ;881 ao`tkh`h`l Frq.Chbmrhq kfm# Qoahkc Qma}rhtx`}fbmr# kddrmqq# armdhtor#kfo}`t oi tjm G}dlfm`t# k`ddktm ihcmd5 bkèr}~taxhìorfktho`5 arhfh`kc dktk# mta.Tjm rm~ort kcqo ao`tkh`q `kfmqoi Frq. Chbmrh |htj jmr QoahkcQma}rhtx `}fbmr k`d dktm oi

bhrtj tjkt jkym `mymr bmm` Frq.Chbmrhq `kfmq or }qmd bx Frq.Chbmrh# mta.

;># krm obgmatho`kbcm to tjmmztm`t tjkt tjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmd

doa}fm`t k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.


Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm ;;# Ch`m 1> ^klm ;2# Ch`m4

1>. Kcc Qoahkc Qma}rhtx`}fbmrq i}r`hqjmd h` Frq.Chbmrhq Aof~rmjm`qhym Rm~ortqjo| tjm thfm ~mrhod tjm `}fbmr |kq hqq}md k`d |jkt qtktm tjmQoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmr |kqhqq}md o}t oi. Kq ak` bm qmm`#tjhq aof~rmjm`qhym rm~ort lomqto Frq. Chbmrhq ~mrqo`kchìorfktho`# lm`mrkc rm~}tktho`#ajkrkatmr# ~mrqo`kcajkrkatmrhqthaq# fodm oi chyh`l#hàofm# armdht qtk`dh`l# armdhtak~kahtx k`d armdht&|ortjh`mqq

Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht;># krm obgmatho`kbcm to tjmmztm`t tjkt tjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`t k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.


Akqm :7;;&ay&>>4:=&KL&KG\ Doa}fm`t =;< Ihcmd >=/> oi ;2< ^klm HD!7;1=;2


21/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 2>

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMD*G}dlfm`tq k`d bkèr}~tax(#mta.# kq dmih`md bx tjm Ikhr ArmdhtRm~orth`l Kat UIARKV# ;=].Q.A. ;9:;k*d(*;(.


g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm ;2# Ch`m = ^klm ;4# Ch`m4

1;. Kcqo hàc}dmd h` tjmQkèmx Dmim`dk tq H`hthkcDhqacoq}rmq |kq kAof~rmjm`qhym Rm~ort r}` bxTjm Qkèmx Ihrf# Hà. o` K~rhc9# 2>>8 o` Brm`t Chbmrh# q~o}qmoi ckh`thii Chqk Chbmrh.QmmMZJHBHT ;; # tjmAof~rmjm`qhym rm~ort r}` o`Brm`t Chbmrh. Kq qjo|` o` tjhqAof~rmjm`qhym Rm~ort# tjhqrm~ort hàc}dmq7

h. Fr. Chbmrhq i}cc `kfm5dktm oi bhrtj5 QoahkcQma}rhtx `}fbmr k`d mymrxkddrmqq jm jkq mymr rmqhdmd5 arhfh`kc rmaord#kctjo}lj ht qjo|q ò`m5}`chqtmd k`d }`~}bchqjmdtmcm~jo`m }fbmrq5hàofm5 jofm ykc}m5 klm5kymrklm xmkrq oi md}aktho`5 o` o|`md rmkcmqtktm# |jo tjm fortlklm|kq ih`kàmd |htj5

bkèr}~tax5 k`d k tkz chmìrof ;884# qjo|h`l}`~khd kctjo}lj ht |kq

~khd h` i}cc5 `mhljborq#irhm`dq# rmckthymq#hàc}dh`l tjmhr kfmq#kddrmqqmq# Qoahkc Qma}rhtx

Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht;;# krm obgmatho`kbcm to tjmmztm`t tjkt tjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`t k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

Kq myhdmàmd bx tjm}`rmdkatmd ymrqho` oi tjm

doa}fm`t# tjm ~}r~ortmd qmkrajdomq òt dhqacoqm Chqk Chbmrhqi}cc qoahkc qma}rhtx `}fbmr.*Fhccmr Dmac. 28# Mz.E(

Hrrmcmyk`t. Brm`t Chbmrh hq òt k ~krtx to tjhq akqm# k`d tj}q k`xrm~ortq r}` |htj rmq~mat to jhfkrm hrrmcmyk`t to tjhq fkttmr# k`dh`kdfhqqhbhcm ior tjkt rmkqo`.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkc



22/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 2;

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMD`}fbmrq# dktmq oi bhrtj#jofm ykc}mq# hàofm# mta.Tjhq rm~ort kcqo ao`tkh`q

hàorrmat hìorfktho` kq toFr. Chbmrh kiihzmd bxKaa}rh`t to Fr. Chbmrh bxFr. Chbmrhq QoahkcQma}rhtx `}fbmr# dktm oi

bhrtj# mta.5

hh. Fr. Chbmrhq qhqtmr# Brk`dxJmccmr1# Frq. JmccmrqQoahkc Qma}rhtx}fbmr#dktm oi bhrtj# klm#kddrmqqmq# fkhdm` `kfm#q~o}qmq `kfm# kddrmqqmq#

dktm oi bhrtj# xmkrq oi md}aktho`# Qoahkc Qma}rhtx`}fbmrq# rmckthymq# jofmykc}mq# hàofm# mta.

hhh. Fr. Chbmrhq ~krm`tq`kfmq# hàc}dh`l jhq qtm~&iktjmr# tjmhr kddrmqqmq#Qoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmrq#dktmq oi bhrtj# rmckthymq#k`x otjmr `kfm mymr }qmd#jofm ykc}mq# hàofm#xmkrq oi md}aktho`# mta.

hy. Fr. Chbmrhq |himq `kfmq#Qoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmr *botj ocd k`d `m|(#kddrmqqmq# rmckthymq#irhm`dq# jofm ykc}m#hàofm# mta.

y. Fr. Chbmrhq h&ck|q*^ckh`thii Chbmrhq ~krm`tq(#hàc}dh`l tjmhr kfmq#kddrmqqmq# Qoahkc Qma}rhtx`}fbmrq# dktmq oi bhrtj#jofm ykc}mq# hàofm#rmckthymq# mta.

yh. Fr. Chbmrhq qhqtmr &h`&ck|#Qoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmr#dktm oi bhrtj# kddrmqqmq#`kfmq mymr }qmd# dktm oi dmktj# irhm`dq k`dkqqoahktmq# klm# jofmykc}m# hàofm# xmkrq oi

aoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmd

o` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx g}dlfm`t.(.

Tjmrm hq ò io}`dktho` ~royhdmd to mqtkbchqj tjkt tjmdoa}fm`t kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht;; hq lm`}h`m. Imd. R. Myhd.8>;. I}rtjmrform# Brm`t Chbmrhhq òt k ~krtx to tjhq katho` k`d#tjmrmiorm# tjm doa}fm`t hq òt

rmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.



23/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 22

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDmd}aktho`# rmckthymq# mta.

Kcc Qoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmrq

i}r`hqjmd h` tjhq Aof~rmjm`qhymRm~ort qjo| tjm thfm ~mrhod tjm`}fbmr |kq hqq}md k`d |jktqtktm tjm Qoahkc Qma}rhtx `}fbmr | kq hqq}md o}t oi. Kq ak` bmqmm`# tjhq aof~rmjm`qhym rm~ortlomq to Fr. Chbmrhq ~mrqo`kchìorfktho`# lm`mrkc rm~}tktho`#ajkrkatmr# ~mrqo`kcajkrkatmrhqthaq# fodm oi chyh`l#hàofm# armdht qtk`dh`l# armdhtak~kahtx k`d armdht&|ortjh`mqq*bkèr}~tax k`d Tkz Chm`(# mta.

kq dmih`md bx tjm Ikhr ArmdhtRm~orth`l Kat UIARKV# ;=].Q.A. ;9:;k*d(*;(.

^klm ;4# Ch`mq =&:

12. Tjm Qkèmx Dmim`dk`tqdhd òt t}r oymr kcc tjm rm~ortqtjmx ~}rajkqmd o` tjm ^ckh`thiiq.H jkym dmfk`dmd tjm kddhtho`kcrm~ortq# k`d fhqqh`l ~klmq# b}ttjm Qkèmx Dmim`dk`tq jkymrmi}qmd to i}r`hqj tjmf.



Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tq



24/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 21

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthym

qtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm ;4# Ch`mq 8&;:

11. H qmrymd ^ckh`thiiq IhrqtQmt oi Dhqaoymrx o` tjm QkèmxDmim`dk`tq Gk`}krx ;8# 2>;2 bx|kx oi Mfkhc k`d tjro} lj tjm]`htmd Qtktmq ôqtkc Qmryham#^rhorhtx Fkhc# qhl`kt}rm rm{}hrmd.Fr. Aocm` kaeò|cmdlmd tjmdhqaoymrx qm`t bx Mfkhc o` jhqachm`tq k`d qhl`md ior tjm jkrdao~hmq oi ^ckh`thiiq Dhqaoymrx o`Gk`}krx 2;# 2>;2. Tjm QkèmxDmim`dk`tq Rmq~o`qmq |mrm d}mo` or bmiorm Imbr}krx 2># 2>;2.Tjhq hàc}dmq @mhc Qkèmx k`dQkèmx H`ymqthlktho`q# Hà. |joo` Fkraj 8# 2>;2 ihcmd k Ajk~tmr < Bkèr}~tax.




^klm ;4# Ch`mq ;8&2>

14. ^ckh`thiiq Dhqaoymrxqmrymd }~o` tjm QkèmxDmim`dk`tq hàc}dmdH`tmrrolktorhmq# Rm{}mqt ior ^rod}atho` oi Doa}fm`tq k`dRm{}mqt ior Kdfhqqho`q.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t toCmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.



25/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 24

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMD^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq.

^klm ;4# Ch`mq 22&2=

1=. To dktm# Tjm QkèmxDmim`dk`tq jkym ikhcmd tormq~o`d to k`x oi tjm ^ckh`thiiqDhqaoymrx rm{}mqtq# hàc}dh`lmkaj oi tjm Rm{}mqt ior Kdfhqqho`q tjkt |mrm

~ro~o}`dmd.



Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y . Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q} ffkrx g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm ;=# Ch`mq 2&;;

19. H` q}~~ort oi tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq FQG# tjmx ihcmd tjmDmackrktho` oi @mhc Qkèmx# QmmDoaemt @}fbmr UD@V 484. H`

Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi kòtjmr |ht`mqqq dmackrkthoào`qtht}tmq h`kdfhqqhbcmjmkrqkx. Imd. R. Myhd. :>2. Htkcqo yhocktmq tjm bmqt myhdmàm



26/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 2=

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDtjhq Dmackrktho` @mhc Qkèmxackhfq jm dhd òt ao`d}at k`xqmkrajmq tjro}lj or ~}rajkqm k`xrm~

ortq irof k`x oi tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq5 k`d tjkt jm dhd òtobtkh` ckh`thii Chqk ChbmrhqQoahkc Qma}rhtx `}fbmr or dktmoi bhrtj irof k`x oi tjm qmkrajmqr}` or rm~ortq ~}rajkqmd5 tjkt jmobtkh`md Frq. Chbmrhq QoahkcQma}rhtx `}fbmr k`d dktm oi

bhrtj irof Ao}rt ihch`lq fkdm bxFrq. Chbmrh# kcc oi |jhaj hqaof~cmtmcx }`tr}m kq mz~ckh`md

bmco|.

r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd. ;>>2.

^klm ;=# Ch`mq ;2&;8. QmmMZJHBHT 8 .Tjhq qmkraj rmt}r`md Frq.Chbmrhq `kfm# dktm oi bhrtj#kddrmqqmq k`d botj jmr ocd k`d`m| Qoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmr.

Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht8# krm obgmatho`kbcm to tjmmztm`t tjkt tjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`t k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2. Kq myhdmàmd bx tjm}`rmdkatmd ymrqho` oi tjmdoa}fm`t# tjm ~}r~ortmd qmkrajdomq òt dhqacoqm Chqk Chbmrhqi}cc qoahkc qma}rhtx `}fbmr.*Fhccmr Dmac. 28# Mz. H.(I}rtjmrform# tjm dmackrk`t domqòt jkym k ikat}kc bkqhq tok}tjm`thaktm tjm doa}fm`tkttkajmd kq Mzjhbht 8. Imd. R.Myhd. 9>2# 8>;.

^klm ;=# Ch`mq ;: &22

1:. @mhc Qkèmx kttkajmd kqMzjhbht K to jhq Dmackrktho` kq}~~oqmd Ao}rt ihch`l ackhfh`lFrq. Chbmrh ihcmd tjhq Dmackrktho`|htj tjm Qk` Bmr`krdhò Ao}`txQ}~mrhor Ao}rt h` Akqm I\Y &>2:>>> k`d ht ao`tkh`md jmr Qoahkc Qma}rhtx `}fbmr# dktm oi

bhrtj k`d j}qbk`dq hìorfktho`.

Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq MzjhbhtK to tjm Qkèmx Dmackrktho`#krm obgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`ttjkt tjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`t k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

^klm ;=# Ch`m 21 ^klm ;9# Ch`m2.^ckh`thiiq ~royhdm omz~ck`ktho` o` jo| k Qk`



27/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 29

qi &1;4;;18


18. H |m t to tjm Qk`Bmr`krdhò Ao}`tx Q}~mrhor Ao}rt o`ch`m kt jtt~7//|||.qb &ao}rt.orl/ k`d kaamqqmd Akqm @o.I\Y &>2:>>> irof tjm Ao}rtq|mbqhtm kt jtt~7//o~m`kaamqq.qb&ao}rt.orl/O~m`Kaamqq/. Hkaamqqmd tjm rmamh~tq ior doa}fm`tq k`d ao~hmq ~}rajkqmdo`ch`m kt jtt~7//o~m`kaamqq.qb&ao}rt.orl/O~m`Kaamqq/ARHFH@KC/ih`m.kq~?akqm`}fbmr6I\Y>2:>>>)ao}rtaodm6Z)dmi`br6;9>:;;2)dmiqm{6;)ot`fqm{6>)dq`6. Qmm

MZJHBHT ;2 . Kq ak` bm qmm`#ao~hmq oi doa}fm`tq coaktmd h`tjm ihcm |mrm ~}rajkqmd o`Fkx;2# 2>>8 # Rmamh~t @o. 2>>8>=;2&22==# h` tjm kfo}`t oi $4=.>>k`d G}`m 2># 2>;;# Rmamh~t @o.2>;;>92> &218>.

Bmr`krdhò Q}~mrhor Ao}rtqIh`m Hìorfktho` |mb~klm

bmkrq o` |jmtjmr amrtkh` ao}rt

ihch`lq |mrm ~}bchakccxkykhckbcm form tjk` tjrmm xmkrqklo. ^ckh`thiiq ajkrkatmrhwm tjhqIh`m Hìorfktho` kqrmicmath`l ao~xh`l aoqtq# b}t

~royhdm ò myhdm`thkrx bkqhq ior tjhq aoàc}qho`. Ht tj}qao`qtht}tmq krl}fm`t tjkt hq òt

bkqmd o` k`x ikatq# k`d hq tj}qh`kdfhqqhbcm ior tjhq rmkqo`kcqo.

Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht;2# k`d tjm rmimrmàmd |mbqhtmkrm obgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`ttjkt tjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`t k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2. I}rtjmrform# tjmdmackrk`t domq òt jkym kikat}kc bkqhq to k}tjm`thaktm tjmrmimrmàmd doa}fm`t. Imd. R.Myhd. 9>2# 8>;. Tjmrm hq òio}`dktho` ~royhdmd tomqtkbchqj tjkt tjmdoa}fm`tkttkajmd kq Mzjhbht ;2 hqlm`}h`m. Imd. R. Myhd. 8>;.

^klm ;9# Ch`mq :&;:

4>. H kcqo ~}ccmd h` ^KAMR tjm Bkèr}~tax akqm tjkt @mhcQkèmx ackhfq to jkym obtkh`mdihch`lq bx Frq. Chbmrh# |jhaj

@mhc Qkèmx ackhfq to jkymobtkh`md Frq. Chbmrhq QoahkcQma}rhtx `}fbmr k`d dktm oi

bhrtj. H kttmf~tmd to kaamqqQajmd}cm D# D@ 8 o` tjmBkèr}~tax Doaemt# b}t |kq}`kbcm to kq ht |kq rmqtrhatmd. Htjm` kttmf~tmd to do|`cokd mkaj

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq ~royhdm omz~ck`ktho` o` jo| tjm ikat#mym` hi tr}m# tjkt k ao}rt ihch`lhq òt a}rrm`tcx kykhckbcm o`^KAMR bmkrq o` |jmtjmr tjktao}rt ihch`l |kq kykhckbcmmcmatro`hakccx or irof tjmao}rtq ~jxqhakc ihcmq form tjk`tjrmm xmkrq klo.



28/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 2>2. I}rtjmrform# tjmdmackrk`t domq òt jkym kikat}kc bkqhq to k}tjm`thaktm tjmrmimrmàmd doa}fm`t. Imd. R.Myhd. 9>2# 8>;. Tjmrm hq òio}`dktho` ~royhdmd tomqtkbchqj tjkt tjm doa}fm`t

kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht ;1 hqlm`}h`m. Imd. R. Myhd. 8>;.

^klm ;9# Ch`m ;8 ^klm ;;;# mhtjmr dhrmatcx irof Orcx Tkhtw or iroftjhq Ao}rtq Doaemt. O` G}cx ;;#

2>;;# ^mtmr Aooe# Mq{}hrm ihcmdtjmf h` tjhq akqm. Qmm D@ 2:>&4k`d Orcx Tkhtw ihcmd tjmf tjmqkfm dkx# D@ 2:1 &=. Fr. Aooe kcqo ihcmd k Dmackrktho` qtkth`l jmobtkh`md tjm Bkèr}~taxdoa}fm`tq h` Chbmrhq `kfm irof^KAMR# |jhaj hq hf~oqqhbcm kqkcc tjm doa}fm`tq krmrmqtrhatmd. Bx rmyhm|h`l tjmqmdoa}fm`tq h` D@ 2:> &4 k`d 2:1 &=# xo} qmm t|o *2( ^KAMR jmkdmrq tjkt oymr &ck~ mkaj otjmr5hdm`thakc to tjm Mzjhbht Bkttkajmd to tjm Dmackrktho` oi

@mhc Qkèmx# D@ 484&2# ~~. 2&:.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmd

o` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx g}dlfm`t.(. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`t ikhcq to dmfo`qtrktmtjkt jm jkq k`x ikat}kc bkqhq ior jhq tmqthfo`x. Imd. R. Myhd.9>2.

^klm ;# ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkc



29/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 2:

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDAo}rtq Doaemt. Orcx Tkhtw ihcmdtjhq mzkat doa}fm`t# kq dm~hatmdo` @mhc Qkèmxq Mzjhbht B# o`G}cx ;;# 2>;;. QmmD@ 2:1 &2.

aoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmd

o` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx g}dlfm`t.(. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`t ikhcq to dmfo`qtrktmtjkt jm jkq k`x ikat}kc bkqhq ior jhq tmqthfo`x. Imd. R. Myhd.9>2.

^klm ;>8@mhc Qkèmxrk` qmkrajmq o` Chqk Chbmrhtjro}lj Kaa}rh`t. Tjm qmkrajrmt}r`md @kfm# Kddrmqqmq#Qoahkc Qma}rhtx `}fbmrq k`ddktm oi bhrtj. QmmMzb. 8kttkajmd jmrmto.

Fkraj ;9# 2>>8@mhc Qkèmxtjro}lj Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf#Hà. obtkh`md kAof~rmjm`qhym Rm~ort o`Chqk Chbmrh. Tjm rm~orthàc}dmd kcc oi Chbmrhq

~rhyktm dktk# kddrmqqmq k`dq~o}qmq hìorfktho`. QmmMzb. ;> kttkajmd jmrmto.

K~rhc 9# 2>>8 @mhc Qkèmxtjro}lj Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf#Hà. obtkh`md kAof~rmjm`qhym Rm~ort o`Brm`t Chbmrh.QmmMzb. ;;kttkajmd jmrmto.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8

*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`t ikhcq to dmfo`qtrktmtjkt jm jkq k`x ikat}kc bkqhq ior jhq tmqthfo`x. Imd. R. Myhd.9>2.



30/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 28

qi &1;4;;18


K~rhc ;># 2>>8 @mhc Qkèmxtjro}lj Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf#

Hà. qm`t k` Mfkhc to Bob]`r}j |htj Chqk Chbmrhq ocdk`d `m| Qoahkc Qma}rhtx`}fbmrq5 dktm oi bhrtj5q~o}qmq `kfm# dktm oi bhrtj#Qoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmr5irhm`dq `kfmq k`d QoahkcQma}rhtx }fbmrq# mta.QmmMzb. ;4 kttkajmd jmrmto.

K~rhc ;1# 2>>8 @mhc Qkèmxtjro}lj Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf#Hà. qm`t Orcx Tkhtw k ao~x oi

tjm Mfkhc qm`t to Bob ]`r}jo` K~rhc ;># 2>>8 |htj kccChbmrhq ~rhyktm hìorfktho .QmmMzb. ;= kttkajmdjmrmto.

K~rhc ;>8 Kcc oi Chbmrhq ~rhyktm dktk |kq

~oqtmd kcc oymr tjm H`tmr`mt bxOrcx Tkhtw.

Fkx ;2# 2>>8 Doa}fm`tq ~}rajkqmd h` Akqm @o. I\Y &>2:>>> h` tjm Qk` Bmr`krdhòAo}`tx Q}~mrhor Ao}rt bxOrcx Tkhtw.QmmMzb. ;2kttkajmd jmrmto.

G}cx ;;# 2>;; ^mtmr Aooe#Mq{. k`d Orcx Tkhtw ihcmq}~~oqmd ~klmq oi kBkèr}~tax ihch`l. QmmD@q2:> &4 k`d 2:1 &=.

G}cx ;;# 2>;; Orcx Tkhtwihcmq tjm q}~~oqmdDmackrktho` irof Qk`Bmr`krdhò Ao}`tx Q}~mrhor Ao}rt. QmmD@ 2:1 & 2.

K~rhc 4# 2>;2 @mhc Qkèmx ~royhdmq tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq|htj k Dmackrktho` |htj tjmAo}rt doa}fm`tq ihcmd bx^mtmr Aooe# Mq{. k`d OrcxTkhtw o` G}cx ;;# 2>;; kq

Akqm :7;;&ay&>>4:=&KL&KG\ Doa}fm`t =;< Ihcmd >=/> oi ;2< ^klm HD!7;1=22


31/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 1>

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDMzjhbhtq K k`d B to jhq*@mhc Qkèmx( Dmackrktho`#D@ 484# 484&; k`d 484 &2#

ackhfh`l tjmqm krm tjmdoa}fm`tq |jmrm jm obtkh`mdChbmrhq Qoahkc Qma}rhtx`}fbmr# dktm oi bhrtj k`dj}qbk`dq hìorfktho`# b}t kqak` bm qmm`# @mhc Qkèmx dhdòt jkym tjm Ao}rt doa}fm`tq}`thc kitmr G}cx ;;# 2>;;. Tjmtr}tj hq @mhc Qkèmx obtkh`mdChbmrhq ~rhyktm dktk irof tjmRm~ortq jm obtkh`md irofKaa}rh`t.

^klm ;8# Ch`m 2< ^klm 2># Ch`m>85 K~rhc 9# 2>>85 K~rhc ;=#2>>85 K~rhc ;8# 2>>85 k`d Fkx >8#bmiorm k`x ao~hmq oi doa}fm`tq |mrm ~}rajkqmd irofAkqm @o. I\Y &>2:>>> o` ihcm|htj tjm Qk` Bmr`krdhò Ao}`txQ}~mrhor Ao}rt k`d bmiorm @mhcQkèmx obtkh`md tjm q}~~oqmdBkèr}~tax ihch`l irof OrcxTkhtw or tjhq Ao}rtq doaemt o`G}cx ;;# 2>;;.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D.Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(. Kcqo# tjmdmackrk`t ikhcq to dmfo`qtrktmtjkt jm jkq k`x ikat}kc bkqhq ior jhq tmqthfo`x tjkt ao~hmq oi ao}rt ihch`lq |mrm ~}rajkqmdirof tjm bkèr}~tax k`d Qk`Bmr`krdhò ao}rtq kitmr rm~ortq|mrm rk` o` ^ckh`thiiq. Imd. R.Myhd. 9>2.

^klm 2># Ch`m : ^klm 2;# Ch`m;# 2>>8# @mhcQkèmx irof Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf#Hà. aof~hcmd k` Mfkhc k`d qm`ttjm Mfkhc to Bob ]`r}j#Rm~ortmr |htj \orcd @mt Dkhcx#kttkajmd kq MZJHBHT ;4.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq Mzjhbht;4# yhocktm tjm bmqt myhdmàmr}cm k`d ao`qtht}tm h`kdfhqqhbcmjmkrqkx. Imd. R. Myhd. ;>>2#:>2. I}rtjmrform# tjmdmackrk`t domq òt jkym kikat}kc bkqhq to k}tjm`thaktm tjm



32/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 1;

qi &1;4;;18


Irof7 @mhc QK@EMXUfkhcto7`qkèmxNtjmqkèmxihrf.aofV Qm`t7 Irhdkx# K~rhc;># 2>>8 ;>7>; KFTo7 Bob ]`r}jQ}bgmat7 CHQK CHBMRH mta

Bob jmrm krm qofm bkrm ikatqkbo}t Bmrlq kqqhqtk`t. Qmm

bmco| k`d kttkajfm`tq.

H do`t eò| jo| f}aj oi tjm qtorx xo} jkym kcrmkdx#

b}t hq mqqm`thkccx kbo}t \JOqjm rmkccx hq k`d tjm {}mqtho`q

tjkt }ìort}`ktmcx brh`lq }~kbo}t Bmrl.

Akcc# hi xo} `mmd to# kt xo}r ao`ym`hmàm.

@mhc QkèmxH`ymqthlktor ) Ao`q}ctk`t.TJM QK@EMX IHRFQhfh Ykccmx# Akchior`hk 81>91`qkèmxNtjmqkèmxihr f.aof:>= =2> 1;=;:;: 2;2 2# 8>;.

Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq Mzjhbhtq8# ;># ;;# krm obgmatho`kbcm totjm mztm`t tjkt tjoqm qtktmfm`tqkrm hào`qhqtm`t |htj tjmrmimrmàmd doa}fm`t k`dyhocktm tjm bmqt myhdmàm r}cm.Imd. R. Myhd. ;>>2. Kqmyhdmàmd bx tjm }`rmdkatmd

ymrqho`q oi tjoqm doa}fm`tq#tjm ~}r~ortmd qmkrajmq do òtdhqacoqm Chqk Chbmrhq i}ccqoahkc qma}rhtx `}fbmr. *Fhccmr Dmac. Mzq. H&E .(



33/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 12

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDURMDKATMDV#URMDKATMDV Qjm |m`t BE h` 2>>2 Jmr brotjmr hq

~robkbcx Ck|rmàm M Forrhqoi Io`tk`k k`d Rkàjo A}a#AK. Jm |kq borÙRMDKATMDV/94 Jmr J}qbk`d# Brm`t G# k ^krocmm# Hjkym òt rmqmkrajmd tjkt. Hq

~robkbcx Brm`t G FaAorfkae URMDKATMDV# kcqo }qmqURMDKATMDV

Tjmrm hq kcqo k Gmrrx JMCCMR k`d Do}lckq Arkfmr cooe h`tmrmqth`l# b}t |jmrm do xo}

qto~.Tjhq Mfkhc# kq qjo|` kboym#ao`tkh`q Frq. Chbmrhq ocd k`d`m| Qoahkc Qma}rhtx }fbmr#irhm`dq# q~o}qmq# mta. tjkt |kqtkem` dhrmatcx irof tjmaof~rmjm`qhym rm~ortq k`dqmkrajmq ao`d}atmd h` Kaa}rh`tkttkajmd jmrmto kq MZJHBHTQ8# ;> k`d ;;.

^klm 2;# Ch`m ;: ^klm 22# Ch`m2

49. Kcc oi tjm kboymhìorfktho` ao`tkh`md h` tjmMfkhc |kq qm`t to Bob ]`r}j bx

@mhc Qkèmx oi Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf#Hà. o` K~rhc ;># 2>>8 k`d toOrcx Tkhtw o` K~rhc ;1# 2>>8.Tr}m k`d aorrmat ao~hmq oi Qkèmxq K~rhc ;1# 2>>8 Mfkhc hqkttkajmd kq MZJHBHT ;= 5MZJHBHTQ ;4 k`d ;= qm`to}t bx @mhc Qkèmx bx k`dtjro}lj Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf# Hà.ao`tkh` hìorfktho` tkem`dhrmatcx irof tjm rm~ortq obtkh`md

bx Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf# Hà. QmmMZJHBHTQ 8 #;> k`d ;;kttkajmd jmrmto. Tjm q}~~oqmdrmaordq obtkh`md irof kBkèr}~tax Ao}rt k`d k Arhfh`kcihcm domqot ao`tkh` tjm kboymhìorfktho` tjkt hq o}tch`md h` tjm

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq Mzjhbhtq;4 k`d ;=# krm obgmatho`kbcm totjm mztm`t tjkt tjoqm qtktmfm`tqkrm hào`qhqtm`t |htj tjmrmimrmàmd doa}fm`t k`dyhocktm tjm bmqt myhdmàm r}cm.Imd. R. Myhd. ;>>2.I}rtjmrform# tjm dmackrk`t domqòt jkym k ikat}kc bkqhq tok}tjm`thaktm tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq. Imd. R. Myhd. 9>2#8>;.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`



34/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 11

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDMfkhc qm`t bx @mhc Qkèmx oi Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf# Hà.

q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`d

chem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 22# Ch`mq 4&;>2.

Krl}fm`tk thym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 22# Ch`mq ;:&2;

4:. Tjmrm hq o {}mqtho`# @mhc Qkèmx bx k`d tjro}lj TjmQkèmx Ihrf# Hà. obtkh`md^ckh`thiiq k`d ckh`thiiq q~o}qmqQoahkc Qma}rhtx `}fbmrq# dktmq oi

bhrtj k`d otjmr ~rhyktm dktk iroftjm Rm~ortq ~}rajkqmd irofKaa}rh`t.


g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 22# Ch`mq 24&2=

48. Tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tqjkym h`trod}amd `m| |ht`mqqmq


Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #



35/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 14

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDk`d doa}fm`tq tjmx ikhcmd to

~royhdm fm h` dhqaoymrx.411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`

q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}f fkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 22# Ch`m 2< ^klm 21# Ch`m21

=>. Tjm `kfmq oi ChqkQhffo`q k`d Chqk ôchakqtro k`dMzjhbhtq K# B k`d Akttkajmd to Chqk Qhffo`qDmackrktho` |mrm òt dhqacoqmd h`tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq H`hthkcDhqacoq}rmq or ckh`thiiqDhqaoymrx rm{}mqtq. H kqemd ior dhqaoymrx o` kcc tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq k`d rm{}mqtmd tjmhdm`thtx oi h`dhyhd}kcq |htjeò|cmdlm oi ikatq rmcmyk`t totjhq akqm. Chqk Qhffo`q k`d Chqkôchakqtro |mrm òt dhqacoqmd or ~rod}amd. ^ckh`thiiq kcqo kqemdior tjm ~rod}atho` oi doa}fm`tqrmcmyk`t to tjhq akqm. Tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq ikhcmd to hdm`thix tjm|ht`mqqmq# Chqk Qhffo`q k`dChqk ôchakqtro or t}r` oymr k`xhìorfktho` or doa}fm`tq# k`dh`qtmkd ~rmqm`t tjmf h` tjmhr Fotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tior tjm ihrqt thfm# kq ktkathakckdyk`tklm oymr tjm ^ckh`thiiq. Bx|kx oi hcc}qtrktho`# tjm iocco|h`l}`~rod}amd doa}fm`tq |mrmkttkajmd kq mzjhbhtq to tjmDmackrktho` oi Chqk Qhf~qo`7

K~~chaktho` ior qmryhamq bmt|mm` Todd Qkèmx#Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf# Hà. k`dHRBqmkraj# CCA5 QmmMzjhbht K to tjmDmackrktho` oi Chqk

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.^ckh`thiiq dhqaoymrx&rmcktmddhq~}tmq krm hrrmcmyk`t to

Cmzhq@mzhq Dmim`dk`tqFotho` ior Q}ffkrx G}dlfm`tk`d ak`òt armktm k lm`}h`mdhq~}tm oi fktmrhkc ikat |htjo}tfkeh`l tjm rm{}hrmd qjo|h`l}`dmr R}cm =9*d( tjkt# ior q~mahihmd rmkqo`q# tjmxak`òt ~rmqm`t ikatq mqqm`thkcto g}qthix UtjmhrV o~~oqhtho`.^ckh`thiiq jkym òt kttmf~tmd toh`yoem R}cm =9*d( h` tjmhr o~~oqhtho` ~k~mrq. Tjmdmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjm ~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàm krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkttjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqtmyhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.




36/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 1=

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDQhffo`q5

Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe )K`kcxthaq Lro}~K~~chaktho` k`dKlrmmfm`t kttkajmd to tjmDmackrktho` oi ChqkQhffo`q kq Mzjhbht B5k`d

Kaa}rh`t k`d HRBqmkraj#CCA Rm&Qmccmr Klrmmfm`tkttkajmd to tjm Dmackrktho`oi Chqk Qhf fo`q kqMzjhbht A.

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 21# Ch`m 24 ^klm 2=# Ch`m;;

=;. Kcc oi tjmqm tx~mq oi doa}fm`tq |mrm tjm q}bgmat oi q~mahiha dhqaoymrx rm{}mqtq.Qmm#Mzjhbht ; *Tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq Rmq~o`qm toH`tmrrolktorhmq qmrymd }~o`Kaa}rh`t4( kt ~klmq 4; &4=#Mzjhbht 1# H`tmrrolktorx @o.q;# 2# 9# ;9# ;8# 2> k`d 24 kt ~klmq=2.


g}dlfm`t.(.



37/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 19

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDH`tmch}q# Hà.to obtkhào`q}fmr# a}qtofmrqk`d/or ckh`thiiq

~mo~cmih`dmr dktk#^mrqo`kc Hdm`thihmrq#Ih`kàhkc Dktk# mrqo`kcHdm`thixh`l dktk# Arhfh`kcDktk5

Kcc doa}fm`tq# dktkaof~hcktho`q# k`d tk`lhbcmtjh`lq tjkt Xo} fkx }qm toq}~~ort Xo}r dmim`qmq totjm ackhfq h` ^ckh`thiiqaof~ckh`t5

Kcc doa}fm`tqaoàmr`h`l# rmlkrdh`l or rmimrrh`l to tjmLrkff &Cmkaj Bchcmx Kat#hàc}dh`l b}t òt chfhtmdto klrmmfm`tq#rm{}hrmfm`tq# ~ochahmq#mta.5 k`d

Kcc qmkrajmq ~mriorfmdo` k`x oi tjm ^ckh thiiq k`dkcc ^ckh`thiiq rm~ortq qocdto tjhrd ~krthmq5 k`dKcc doa}fm`tktho`#aorrmq~o`dmàm#hìorfktho` k`d dktk# h` kcciorfq hàc}dh`lmcmatro`hakccx# ~mrtkh`h`lto ^ckh`thiiq# ~royhdmd tok`d qjkrmd |htj kcc xo}r kiihchktmq# ao`troccmd k`d}ào`troccmd# b}qh`mqqkllrmlktmq# 1rd ~krtxm`ththmqk`d k`x otjmr

b}qh`mqq# aor~orktho`.

^klm 24# Ch`mq ;2&;# ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx



38/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 1>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 24# Ch`mq 21&29

=4. Tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq h`tjmhr Fotho` ior Q}ffkrxG}dlfm`t klkh` krm rkhqh`l tjmhqq}mq rmlkrdh`l tjm `kfmq oi mkaj m`thtx# |jhaj |kq

~rmyho}qcx kddrmqqmd bx tjmAo}rt.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 29# Ch`mq ;&:==. Cmzhq@mzhq Lro}~ hq

h`kdymrtm`tcx kfmd kqCmzhq@mzhq Lro}~# Hà.Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe Qoc}tho`q# Hà.#|jo hq ~ro~mrcx `kfmd# o|`qk`d ao`trocq Qmhqh`t# Hà. d/b/kKaa}rh`t# Ajohamôh`t# Hà.Cmzhq@mzhq Lro}~# Cmzhq@mzhqk`d Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe K`kcxthaqLro}~# Hà. Cmzhq@mzhq Lro}~o~mrktmq [email protected] k`dCmzhq.aof # |jhaj ^ckh`thii ChqkChbmrh jkd k` kaao}`t |htj. Kcctjm Rmmd m`ththmq krm o|`md k`do~mrktmd bx Rmmd Mcqmyhmr# Hà.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 29# Ch`mq 8&21

=9. Kq aoìhrfmd bxKdrhkò Jrykth`# Mq{}hrm#ao}`qmc ior tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq#

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjm

~krthmq aorrmq~o`dmàm krmobgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t tjkt



39/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 1:

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDTjm Rmmd m`ththmq `kfmd h` tjhqck|q}ht ajk`lmd tjmhr `kfm kitmrtjm mym`tq tooe ~ckam. H` k`

Mfkhc to fm o` K}l}qt =# 2>;;.QmmMZJHBHT ;9# Fr. Jrykth`qtktmd7

K`x ackhf bkqmd o` tjm qkcmoi k` Kaa}rh`t rm~ort or rm~ortq h` 2>>8 qjo}cd bmfkdm klkh`qt "Cmzhq@mzhqRhqe Dktk Fk`klmfm`t Hà.i/e/k Qmhqh`t# Hà." ]`thcGk`}krx ;# 2>;># o`m Rmmdq}bqhdhkrx |kq `kfmdCmzhq@mzhq Rhqe k`d

Hìorfktho` K`kcxthaq Lro}~Hà.... Miimathym Gk`}krx ;#2>;># tjm `kfm oi tjktaor~orktho` |kq ajk`lmd toCmzhq@mzhq Rhqe Qoc}tho`q ICHà. Qhàm Gk`}krx ;# 2>;>#Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe Qoc}tho`q ICHà. jkq o~mrktmd tjm Kaa}rh`t

b}qh`mqq. Tjkt aor~orktho`#tjo}lj# |kq òt tjm o`mh`yocymd h` tjm Kaa}rh`t

b}qh`mqq kt tjm thfm Fr.Qkèmx |kq kccmlmd to jkymobtkh`md k` Kaa}rh`t rm~ort or rm~ortq kbo}t tjm ~ckh`thiiq.]`thc Gk`}krx ;# 2>;># tjmKaa}rh`t o~mrktho`q*hàc}dh`l dktkbkqmfkh`tm`kàm k`d rm~ort

~rm~krktho`( |mrm ao`d}atmd bx Qmhqh`t# Hà.# k aor~orktho`tjkt jkq qhàm ajk`lmd htq`kfm to Cmzhq@mzhq Rhqe Dktk Fk`klmfm`t Hà.

tjoqm qtktmfm`tq krmhào`qhqtm`t |htj tjm rmimrmàmddoa}fm`tq k`d yhocktm tjm bmqt

myhdmàm r}cm. Imd. R. Myhd.;>>2.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthy mqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 29# Ch`m 2= ^klm 22.

Krl}fm`tkthym. B}raj y. Rmlm`tq oi tjm ]`hy. oi Akc. #411 I. Q}~~. 2d ;;;># ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`d



40/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 18

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMD`kfmq oi tjm m`ththmq. Tjhq Ao}rth` htq R}ch`l oi Oatobmr ;;;# D@ 4;4# Lrk`th`l h` ~krt

k`d Dm`xh`l h` ~krt tjm RmmdDmim`dk`tq Fotho` to DhqfhqqDm`hmd ^ckh`thiiq Cmkym toKfm`d k`d qtktmd o` ~klm :7

Kctjo}lj tjm Ao}rt klrmmqtjkt tjm IKA hq qjoddx k`doymrco`l# ht domq òt ih`d tjktht hq qo ~oorcx&dmih`md or }``kyhlkbcm tjkt ht ikhcq to

~royhdm tjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq|htj q}iihahm`t òtham kq to tjmajkrlmq bro}ljt klkh`qt tjmf.

Tjm Ao}rt htqmci hq aoì}qmdkq to tjm rmcktho`qjh~bmt|mm` tjm qm~krktm RmmdDmim`dk`tq# k`d domq otbmchmym tjkt k qmci &mcmatmd#aof~chaktmd aor~orktmqtr}at}rm qjo}cd bcoae chthlktho`. Ht k~~mkrq iroftj m Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq o|`Fotho` tjkt tjmx ak`dmah~jmr |jhaj Dmim`dk`tdhd |jkt# bkqmd o` tjmhreò|cmdlm oi tjmhr o|àor~orktm qtr}at}rm.Qhfhckrcx# |jhcm k q~mahihaAckhf k`kcxwmd bmco| fhljtckae h`dhyhd}kchwmd q}~~ort#tjm IKA kq k |jocm rkhqmqq}iihahm`t ikat}kc fkttmr toq}ryhym k lm`mrkc kttkae klkh`qt ht. Umf~jkqhq kddmdV#

chem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 2;2 k`d k~~mkrq kq D@ 489&; kt

~~. : &8# a# d k`d m|jmrm Todd Qkèmx k`d Tjm

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjm


Akqm :7;;&ay&>>4:=&KL&KG\ Doa}fm`t =;< Ihcmd >=/> oi ;2< ^klm HD!7;1=12


41/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 4>

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDQkèmx Ihrf# Hà. dhqa}qq tjmhr ~kqq|ord to Cmzhq5 k`dkaamqqh`l tjm Cmzhq dktkbkqm#

|jhaj ao`trkdhatq @mhc Qkèmxqqtktmfm`tq h` jhq Dmackrktho` k`dtjm Rmmd Dmim`dk`tq ackhfqrmlkrdh`l tjm Qkèmxq kaao}`tqk`d i}r`hqjh`l tjm Qkèmxq^ckh`thiiq ao`q}fmr rm~ortq.


g}dlfm`t.(.

Tjm dmackrk`tq kqqmrtho` tjktk` Kaa}rh`t rm~ort hq kao`q}fmr rm~ort |htjh` tjmIARK hq krl}fm`tkthym k`d k`hf~ro~mr }qm oi k dmackrktho`.Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.

^klm 2# ;;;8*M.D. Akc. 2>>9( *UqVtktmfm`tqh` dmackrktho`q bkqmd o`q~ma}cktho` or hf~ro~mr cmlkcaoàc}qho`q# or krl}fm`tkthymqtktmfm`tq# krm òt ikatq k`dchem|hqm |hcc òt bm ao`qhdmrmdo` k fotho` ior q}ffkrx

g}dlfm`t.(.

^klm 2:# Ch`m = ^klm 28# Ch`m8

9>. Chqk Qhffo`q MzjhbhtK kttkajmd to dmackrktho`# D@482&; hq Tjm Qkèmx Ihrf# Hà.

Hrrmcmyk`t. Imd. R. Myhd. 4>2.Tjm dmackrk`tq qtktmfm`tqaoàmr`h`l tjm ao`tm`tq oi tjmdoa}fm`t# kttkajmd kq MzjhbhtK to tjm Qhffo`q Dmackrktho`#krm obgmatho`kbcm to tjm mztm`t



42/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 4;

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMDk`d Todd Qkèmxq k~~chakthoìor k` kaao}`t |htj HRBqmkraj#CCA. H` tjhq K~~chaktho`

~rm~krmd k`d qhl`md bxDmim`dk`t Todd Qkèmx# ToddQkèmx fkremd qmymrkc bozmq ior jhq ~mrfhqqhbcm ~}r~oqm or cmlkcm`thtcmfm`t. Oi h`tmrmqt# k`daoìhrfh`l tjm rm~ortq |mrm

~rm~krmd k`d qocd kq ao`q}fmr rm~ortq kq dmih`md bx tjm IARK#krm tjm iocco|h`l bozmq fkremd

bx Todd Qkèmx k`d tjm QkèmxIhrf# Hà.q ior tjmhr ~mrfhqqhbcm

~}r~oqmq to rmamhym rm~ortq k`dhìorfktho`7

QMATHO@ A

h. ;*B( Kq `mamqqkrx tomiimat# kdfh`hqtmr# or mìoram k trk`qkatho`rm{}mqtmd or k}tjorhwmd bxtjm ao`q}fmr bx ymrhixh`ltjm hdm`thihaktho`hìorfktho` ao`tkh`md h`k~~chaktho`q ior mf~coxfm`t# jo}qh`l or h`q}rkàm5

hh. :. To tjm mztm`tq~mahihakccx ~mrfhttmd or rm{}hrmd }`dmr otjmr

~royhqho`q oi ck| k`d h`kaaordkàm |htj tjm Rhljth` Ih`kàhkc ^rhykax Kat oi ;8>2.


g}dlfm`t.(.



43/127

;

2

1

4

=

9

;;

;2

;1

;4

;=

;9

;

2;

22

21

24

2=

29

2>4:= KL *KG\z( 42

qi &1;4;;18

Obgmatho`q to Bmrl Dmackrktho` Lro}`dq ior Obgmatho` LRK@TMD/DM@HMD ~mrqo` |jo ~royhdmd tjmh`iorfktho` to xo} *or toxo}r achm`t( b}t o`cx hi

}qmd to rmaoymr o` k dmbtklkh`qt tjm ~mrqo` or ~}rq}m cmlkc rmfmdhmqklkh`qt tjm ~mrqo` ior irk}d5 k`d

hy. =. ]qm bx k` H`q}rmr *or htq klm`t( h` ao``matho`|htj ackhfq h`ymqthlktho`kathyhthmq# k`thirk}dkathyhthmq# rkth`l or }`dmr|rhth`l.

Rm~ortq ior Mf~coxfm`t# dmbtaoccmatho`# k`d H`q}rk`am krm kccao`q}fmr rm~ortq loymr`md bxtjm IARK. Qmm;= ].Q.A. ;9:;k*d(*;(*K(5 ;= ].Q.A. ;9:;k*d(*;(*B(5 ;= ].Q

Documents

Reed Objections to Plaintiffs Evidence Doc 507