Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Project Completion Report Please submit through your APEC Secretariat Program Director within 2 months of
project completion.
SECTION A: Project profile
Project number & title: EWG 13 – 2012A: Energy Saving Window Thermal Performance Simulation Training
Time period covered in report:
August 2013 to November 2013 Date submitted:
23 January 2014
Committee / WG / Fora: Energy Working Group/Expert Group on Energy Efficiency and Conservation
Project Overseer Name / Organization /
Economy:
Dr.Prasert Sinsukprasert Executive Director of International Energy Cooperation Bureau Office of Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Energy, Thailand
SECTION B: Project report and reflection
Briefly answer each of the questions below. Section B should be a maximum of 2-3 pages, inclusive of the questions and tables provided.
1. Project description: In 3-4 sentences, describe the project and its main objectives. The project consists of two workshops, namely the APEC Policy Workshop for Energy Efficient Building Envelope and the APEC Training Workshop for Window Thermal Performance Testing and Rating. The workshops bring together the range of public, private and academic sector stakeholders in the APEC region to share their knowledge and experience related to policy and practices of energy efficient buildings. The main objectives of the project are the followings:
• Develop and initiate the implementation of an APEC economy pilot, regional simulation and test centre that can be replicated throughout APEC economies where building envelope energy saving opportunities will be taught and implemented
• Train APEC participants to perform energy saving window rating thermal simulations • Enhance energy efficient building practices understanding by developing building
envelope component ratings
2. Meeting your objectives: Were the proposed objectives of the project met? If so, please describe how. If not, please include any major changes to the proposed scope of the project. Please outline any problems you may have encountered that resulted in delays to the delivery of the activity. The project fully meets its objectives. It can be evidenced by fruitful participations engaged by 16 APEC countries. There were 55 and 32 participants joined the policy and training workshops, respectively. The policy workshop has created a collaborative network of stakeholders involving in energy efficient building envelope. For the training workshop, the success can be found from high satisfaction of the workshop participants. The trainees have high appreciation of the knowledgeable training instructors and facility. They have also requested for other training courses.
3. Evaluation: Describe how you evaluated the project upon completion? Detail the results of
the evaluations conducted, if any (e.g. participant evaluation, peer review of publication, measurement of indicators, statistics demonstrating use of outputs etc.). Upon completion, we have evaluated that the project successfully met its objectives. We conducted surveys for both the policy and training workshop and found that, on the average, the participants rated the policy and training workshops at 4.43 and 4.49 on the full score of 5.0, respectively. Details of evaluation can be found in Appendix 5 of this report.
4. Key findings: Describe the main outputs delivered and any broader outcomes achieved as a
result of this project. For example have there been any capacity building outcomes, policy or operational changes, or changes to standards or systems as a result of this activity?) Describe how project outputs relate to fora/sub fora/working group strategic and medium-term priorities and strategic priorities. Please provide examples of important findings or lessons learned arising from the project. Key findings of the project are described in the followings:
Workshop Findings The APEC Workshop for Energy Efficient Building Envelope
• A network of stakeholders among APEC communities was created. The stakeholder includes policy/regulation makers, academia, engineers/consultants and industries. They have shared their knowledge and experience concerning energy efficient building materials.
• Thailand by KMUTT presented a strong commitment to the establishment of the Building Materials Testing and Certification Center (BMTCC). This set-up will be jointed-supported by the Ministry of Energy of Thailand, building materials industry and KMUTT. KMUTT will develop a business plan of BMTCC and will be proactive on seeking strong cooperation with industries.
The APEC Training Workshop for Window Thermal Performance Testing and Rating
• The participants have been trained to use the software including Optics 6, Window 7 and THERM. This set of software was developed by LBNL and adopted by NFRC for determining the energy performance of windows. These tools are necessary and essential when energy performance in compliance of ISO 9050 and ISO 15099 is required.
• Trainees have been well trained by the experts. Very positive feedback was received from the trainees. Part of the success is due to having very knowledgeable experts to conduct the training.
• Many participants reflected that they can make use of skill built during the training in their jobs they are responsible.
The key findings stated above clearly show that the success of this project directly supports APEC ESCI SB2 goal to develop a pilot regional testing center to support and implement a building energy code and labeling program for use among APEC economies.
5. Next steps: Describe any follow-up steps or projects that are planned following the completion of the activity such as post-activity evaluations or tracer studies planned to assess the impact of this activity? Have the results of the activity been disseminated to participants and other stakeholders and how? What are (if any) any flow-on effects from this activity? How will this activity inform any future APEC activities? We have planned to pursue our ultimate goal at which the establishment of the testing and rating center is aimed. A two-year plan for its completion starting from 2014 to 2015 has been made. We will report the progress periodically via the website at http://www.mt.kmutt.ac.th/APEC_Workshop/ In addition, we also have planned to continue on capacity building activities. The feedback received from the participants revealed that they need some other training programs such as building energy simulation, façade simulation, and lighting simulation, etc.
6. Feedback for the Secretariat: Do you have any suggestions for more effective management of projects in the future? Any assessment of consultants, experts or participants that you would like to share? (The Secretariat collates and examines feedback to identify trends for ongoing evaluation of our project management and/or communications systems.) I am pleased to express my sincere appreciation to the APEC secretariat office. To be more specific, we are so grateful to Ms.Norila Ali who is so professional and has done a great job.
7. Participant information: Please provide details, where applicable. Insert rows as needed.
The APEC Policy Workshop for Energy Efficient Building Envelope
Economy # Male # Female Details
Australia - 1 (1) Ms. Tracey Gramlick, Executive Director, Australian Window Association & Australian Fenestration Rating Council
China 1 2 (1) Ms. Jie Wu, Deputy Manager of Glass Test & Certification Dept, China Building Materials Academy
(2) Ms. Zhou Quan, Director of Division of Green Building, Guangdong Provincial Academy of Building Research
(3) Mr. Shi Chao Yang, Vice-President of Guangdong Academy
Hong Kong 1 - (1) Mr. Dan Plotnick, Architectural Sales and Marketing Director, Guardian Industries Corp.
Indonesia 2 - (1) Mr. Jimmy Siswanto Juwana, Advisor to the Rector of Sustainable Construction Sector and Local Wisdom at Trisakti University.
(2) Mr. Totok Sulistiyanto Wardoyo, President of ASHARAE Indonesia Chapter
Japan 3 - (1) Mr. Masahiro Tsuchiya, Executive Director, AGC Flat Glass
(2) Dr. Tetsuya Hiramatsu, Manager, AGC Japan/Asia
(3) Mr. Hideki Shioi, President, AGC Flat Glass
Korea 1 - (1) Dr. Seung-eon Lee, Korean Institute of Construction Technology
Mexico 2 - (1) Dr. Jesús Arce Landa, The National Center for Research and Technological Development (CENIDET)
(2) Mr. Iván Hernández, The National Center for Research and Technological Development (CENIDET)
New Zealand 1 - (1) Mr. Nicolas David Smith, Energy Efficiency and Conservation Authority
Peru 1 - (1) Mr. Roberto PRIETO, Architect, Ministry of Housing, Construction and Sanitation
Philippines 1 1 (1) Ms. Angelina Margaret F. Tajon, Senior Trade and Industry Development Specialist, Construction Industry Authority of the Philippines
(2) Mr. Emelito Cabrera Punsalan, Vice President, Philippine Green Building Initiative, LR Punsalan & Associates
Russia 1 2 (1) Mr. Lyubim SHUBIN, Commercial Director of VELKO2000
(2) Dr. Nina Pavlovna Umnyakova, Deputy
Director, Scientific Research Institute of Building Physics (NIISF RAABC)
(3) Ms. Kristina ANDREYTSEVA, Postgraduate Student; Research Institute for Building Physics
Singapore 2 - (1) Dr. Fangzhi Chen, Research Scientist; Solar Energy Research Institute of Singapore (SERIS)
(2) Mr. Seah Amos, Technoform Bautec Asia Pacific
Thailand 19 7 (1) Dr. Bundit Fungtammasan, Vice President for Research, King Mongkut’s University of Technology Thonburi
(2) Dr. Kuskana Kubaha, School of Energy, Environment and Materials, King Mongkut’s University of Technology Thonburi
(3) Dr. Nuchthana Poolthong, King Mongkut’s University of Technology Thonburi
(4) Dr. Pattana Rakkwamsuk, Dean, School of Energy, Environment and Materials, King Mongkut’s University of Technology Thonburi
(5) Dr. Pongpan Vorasayan, DEDE (6) Dr. Prasert Sinsukprasert, Executive
Director, International Energy Cooperation Bureau, Ministry of Energy
(7) Dr. Purit Thanakijkasem, School of Energy, Environment and Materials, King Mongkut’s University of Technology Thonburi
(8) Dr. Sarat Prakobchart, DEDE (9) Dr. Tippaban Palathai, School of Energy,
Environment and Materials, King Mongkut’s University of Technology Thonburi
(10) Dr. Twarath Sutabutr, Deputy Director-General, DEDE
(11) Mr. Asawin Asawutmangkul, DEDE (12) Mr. Booranin Kamponpan, Senior
Engineer, Windsor (13) Mr. Chatchawin Nuchanong, Technical
Engineer, 3M (14) Mr. Kitipat Chinkarun, Sale Engineer, 3M (15) Mr. Lal C Silva, Technical Director, Kaskal (16) Mr. Maiti Bibekananda, Asia Facific Sales
Director, Gu Sales and Marketing Manager, BASF (Thai) Ltd. ardian Industries Corp
(17) Mr. Panya Tantisuwichwong, Deputy General Manager, AGC Flat Glass
(18) Mr. Ratchapol Kulchaisiri, Sales and Marketing Manager, BASF (Thai) Ltd.
(19) Mr. Songpol Bumpensanti, AGC Flat
Glass (Thailand) (20) Mr. Sutti Klovuttivat, Sales Director,
Guardian Industries Corp (21) Ms. Katunyoo Kamollakorn, Government
Affairs Manager-Thailand, Guardian Industries Corp
(22) Ms. NualAnong Methapipatkul, Architectural Sales Manager, Guardian Industries Rayong
(23) Ms. Sothida Ngamwiwatsawang, Project Sales Manager, Thai-German Specialty Glass
(24) Ms. Ticha Sayaves, Engineer, Windsor (25) Ms. Vinuchada Talangsri, Plan and Policy
Analyst, DEDE (26) Mr. Manuel L. Soriano, Senior Technical
Advisor, UNDP USA 4 - (1) Dr. Charlie Curcija, LBNL
(2) Mr. Bipin Shah, WInBuild, Inc. (3) Mr.Brian Bogard, Regional Government
Affairs Manager, Guardian Industries Corp (4) Mr. Dean Matlack, Commercial Officer,
U.S. Embassy Bangkok Vietnam 3 - (1) Mr. Tran Quoc Thai, Adviser of
Association Executive Committee (2) Dr. Kieu Le Hai, Director of Technical
Consulting Center (VieGlass) (3) Mr. Nguyen Huy Thang, Secretary
General (VieGlass) The APEC Training Workshop for Window Thermal Performance Testing and Rating
Economy # Male # Female Details
China 1 2 (1) Ms. Jie Wu, Deputy Manager of Glass Test & Certification Dept, China Building Materials Academy
(2) Ms. Zhou Quan, Director of Division of Green Building , Guangdong Provincial Academy of Building Research
(3) Mr. Shi Chao Yang, Vice-President of Guangdong Academy
Indonesia 2 - (1) Mr. Jimmy Siswanto Juwana, Advisor to the Rector of Sustainable Construction Sector and Local Wisdom at Trisakti University.
(2) Mr. Totok Sulistiyanto Wardoyo, President of ASHARAE Indonesia Chapter
Mexico 2 - (1) Dr. Jesús Arce Landa, The National Center for Research and Technological Development (CENIDET)
(2) Mr. Iván Hernández, The National Center for Research and Technological Development (CENIDET)
New Zealand 1 - (1) Mr. Nicolas David Smith, Energy Efficiency and Conservation Authority
Peru 1 - (1) Mr. Roberto PRIETO, Architect, Ministry of Housing, Construction and Sanitation
Philippines 1 1 (1) Ms. Angelina Margaret F. Tajon, Senior Trade and Industry Development Specialist, Construction Industry Authority of the Philippines
(2) Mr. Emelito Cabrera Punsalan, Vice President, Philippine Green Building Initiative, LR Punsalan & Associates
Russia 1 1 (1) Mr. Lyubim SHUBIN, Commercial Director of VELKO2000
(2) Ms. Kristina ANDREYTSEVA, Postgraduate Student; Research Institute for Building Physics
Singapore 2 - (1) Dr. Fangzhi Chen, Research Scientist; Solar Energy Research Institute of Singapore (SERIS)
(2) Mr. Seah Amos, Technoform Bautec Asia Pacific
Thailand 9 6 (1) Dr. Purit Thanakijkasem, School of Energy, Environment and Materials, King Mongkut’s University of Technology Thonburi
(2) Mr. Chatchawin Nuchanong, Technical Engineer, 3M
(3) Mr. Kitipat Chinkarun, Sale Engineer, 3M (4) Mr. Joenel B Tajonara, Engineering
Manager, Kaskal (5) Mr. Boonyarit Phuethisarikorn, Technical
Services Staff, Thai-German Specialty Glass
(6) Mr. PhaiChayon Lumlert, AGC Flat Glass (7) Mr. Poonlarp Sumitmoh, AGC Flat Glass (8) Mr. Teerasak Likhitlertlam, KMUTT (9) Mr. Trin Buapakham, KMUTT (10) Ms. Chittaworanan Itsarhatrakoon,
KMUTT (11) Ms. Chutimon Worachetbancha, KMUTT (12) Ms. Hanan Sareh, KMUTT (13) Ms. NualAnong Methapipatkul,
Architectural Sales Manager, Guardian Industries Rayong
(14) Ms. Thamolwan Kiawpan, KMUTT (15) Ms. Vichuda Mettanant, Silpakorn
University Vietnam 2 - (1) Dr. Kieu Le Hai, Director of Technical
Consulting Center (VieGlass) (2) Mr. Nguyen Huy Thang, Secretary
General (VieGlass)
8. Outputs: Please provide details, where applicable. Change headings or insert rows as needed.
# planned # actual Details
# of workshops / events 2 2 The APEC Workshop for Energy Efficient Building
Envelope on October 22nd, 2013 at the Eastin Grand Hotel Sathorn and the APEC Training Workshop for Window Thermal Performance Testing and Rating.
# of publications distributed - - N.A.
# of CDs distributed - - N.A.
# of websites created
- 1
The website at http://www.mt.kmutt.ac.th/APEC_Workshop/ has been created to provide public with information related to the workshop, for example the workshop logistic, workshop agenda, workshop materials, event photos, etc.
SECTION C: Budget Attach a detailed breakdown of the APEC- provided project budget, including:
• Planned costs (using most recently approved budget figures) • Actual expenditures • Variance notes: An explanation of any budget line under- or over-spent by 20% or more.
Budget:
Category APEC Funding
Planned Actual
Direct Labor
KMUTT Support Staff $3,000.00 $3,000.00
Principal Investigator $2,000.00 $2,000.00
Simulation training expert Consulting fee $10,000.00 $10,000.00
Sub-‐total $ 15,000.00 $ 15,000.00
Other Items Conference and training room rental, Training materials and stationary
$4,000.00 $3,854.17
Sub -‐total $4,000.00 $3,854.17
Total $19,000.00 $18,854.17
SECTION D: Appendices or additions Please attach any of the following. This information will help us better understand your project, support overseers of similar projects and plan for future projects.
APPENDIX 1
List of experts or consultants utilized, with job titles and contact details, gender disaggregated where possible.
Name Role Gender Job tilte Contact details Mr.Bipin Shah Expert Male Training
expert Bipin Shah WinBuild, Inc. 11103 Redford Court, Fairfax, VA 22030, USA. Tel: 703-273-4981 Email: [email protected]
Dr.Charlie Curcija
Expert Male Training expert
Dr.Charlie Curcija Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory 1 Cyclotron Road, MS 90R3111 Berkeley, CA 94720, USA. Office Location: 90-3106 Tel: (510) 495-2602 Email: [email protected]
Dr.Pattana Rakkwamsuk
Consultant Male Organizing workshop
Dr.Pattana Rakkwamsuk King Mongkut’s University of Technology Thonburi 126 Pracha Utit Road, Bang Mot, Tung Kru, Bangkok 10140, THAILAND Tel: +66 2 470 8601 Email: [email protected]
APPENDIX 2
List of participants, with job titles and contact details
The APEC Policy Workshop for Energy Efficient Building Envelope October 22nd, 2013
# APEC
Member Economies
Name Affiliation Email Address
1 Australia Ms. Tracey Gramlick Executive Director, Australian Window Association & Australian Fenestration Rating Council
2 China Ms. Jie Wu Deputy Manager of Glass Test & Certification Dept, China Building Materials Academy
3 China Ms. Zhou Quan Director of Division of Green Building , Guangdong Provincial Academy of Building Research
4 China Mr. Shi Chao Yang Vice-President of Guangdong Academy
5 Hongkong Mr. Dan Plotnick Architectural Sales and Marketing Director, Guardian
6 Indonesia Mr. Totok Sulistiyanto Wardoyo
President of ASHARAE Indonesia Chapter
7 Indonesia Mr. Jimmy Siswanto Juwana
Advisor to the Rector of Sustainable Construction Sector and Local Wisdom at Trisakti University
8 Japan Dr. Tetsuya Hiramatsu Manager, AGC Japan/Asia [email protected]
9 Japan Mr. Hideki Shioi President, AGC Flat Glass 10 Japan Mr. Masahiro Tsuchiya Executive Director, AGC Flat
Glass
11 Korea Dr. Seung-eon Lee; Korean Institute of Construction Technology
12 Mexico Dr. Jesús Arce Landa The National Center for Research and Technological Development (CENIDET)
13 Mexico Mr. Iván Hernández The National Center for Research and Technological Development (CENIDET)
14 New Zealand
Mr. Nicolas David Smith Energy Efficiency and Conservation Authority
15 Peru Mr. Roberto PRIETO Architech, Ministry of Housing, Construction and Sanitation
16 Philippines Mr. Emelito Cabrera Punsalan
Vice President, Philippine Green Building Initiative, LR Punsalan & Associates
17 Philippines Ms. Angelina Margaret F. Tajon
Senior Trade and Industry Development Specialist, Construction Industry Authority of the Philipines
The APEC Policy Workshop for Energy Efficient Building Envelope October 22nd, 2013
# APEC
Member Economies
Name Affiliation Email Address
18 Russia Ms. Kristina ANDREYTSEVA
Postgraduate Student; Research Institute for Building Physics
19 Russia Mr. Lyubim SHUBIN Commercial Director of VELKO2000
20 Singapore Dr. Fangzhi Chen Research Scientist; Solar Energy Research Institute of Singapore (SERIS)
21 Singapore Mr. Seah Amos Technoform Bautec Asia Pacific
22 Thailand Dr. Bundit Fungtammasan
Vice President, KMUTT [email protected]
23 Thailand Dr. Kuskana Kubaha Assistant Professor, KMUTT [email protected]
24 Thailand Dr. Nuchthana Poolthong
Assistant Professor, KMUTT [email protected]
25 Thailand Dr. Pattana Rakkwamsuk Dean, SEEM, KMUTT [email protected]
26 Thailand Dr. Pongpan Vorasayan DEDE [email protected]
27 Thailand Dr. Prasert Sinsukprasert Executive Director, International Energy Cooperation Bureau
28 Thailand Dr. Purit Thanakijkasem Associate Professor, KMUTT [email protected]
29 Thailand Dr. Sarat Prakobchart Senior Professional Engineer, DEDE
30 Thailand Dr. Tippaban Palathai Assistant Professor, KMUTT [email protected]
31 Thailand Dr. Twarath Sutabutr Deputy Director-General, DEDE
32 Thailand Mr. Asawin Asawutmangkul
Senior Engineer, DEDE
33 Thailand Mr. Booranin Kamponpan
Senior Engineer, Windsor
34 Thailand Mr. Chatchawin Nuchanong
Technical Engineer, 3M [email protected]
35 Thailand Mr. Kitipat Chinkarun Sale Engineer, 3M [email protected]
36 Thailand Mr. Lal C Silva Technical Director, Kaskal [email protected]
37 Thailand Mr. Maiti Bibekananda Asia Facific Sales Director, Guardian Industries Corp
38 Thailand Mr. Panya Tantisuwichwong
Deputy General Manager, AGC Flat Glass
39 Thailand Mr. Ratchapol Kulchaisiri
Sales and Marketing Manager, BASF (Thai) Ltd.
40 Thailand Mr. Songpol Bumpensanti
Assistant to Executive Director, AGC
41 Thailand Mr. Sutti Klovuttivat Sales Director, Guardian Industries Corp
42 Thailand Ms. Katunyoo Kamollakorn
Government Affairs Manager-Thailand, Guardian Industries Corp
43 Thailand Ms. NualAnong Methapipatkul
Architectural Sales Manager, Guardian Industries Rayong
The APEC Policy Workshop for Energy Efficient Building Envelope October 22nd, 2013
# APEC
Member Economies
Name Affiliation Email Address
44 Thailand Ms. Sothida Ngamwiwatsawang
Project Sales Manager, Thai-German Specialty Glass
45 Thailand Ms. Ticha Sayaves Engineer, Windsor
46 Thailand Ms. Vinuchada Talangsri Plan and Policy Analyst, DEDE
47 UNDP Mr. Manuel L. Soriano Senior Technical Advisor, UNDP
48 USA Mr. Brian Bogard Regional Government Affairs Manager, Guardian Industries Corp
49 USA Mr. Bipin Shah President, WinBuild [email protected]
50 USA Dr. Charlie Curcija Scientist, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
51 USA Mr. Dean Matlack Commercial Officer, U.S. Embassy Bangkok
52 Vietnam Mr. Nguyen Huy Thang Secretary General (VieGlass) [email protected]
53 Vietnam Dr. Kieu Le Hai Director of Technical Consulting Center (VieGlass)
54 Vietnam Mr. Tran Quoc Thai Adviser of Association Executive Committee
The APEC Training Workshop for Window Thermal Performance Testing and Rating October 23rd - 25th, 2013
# APEC
Member Economies
Name Affiliation Email Address
1 China Ms. Jie Wu
Deputy Manager of Glass Test & Certification Dept, China Building Materials Academy [email protected]
2 China Ms. Zhou Quan
Director of Division of Green Building , Guangdong Provincial Academy of Building Research [email protected]
3 Indonesia Mr. Totok Sulistiyanto Wardoyo
President of ASHARAE Indonesia Chapter [email protected]
4 Indonesia Mr. Jimmy Siswanto Juwana
Advisor to the Rector of Sustainable Construction Sector and Local Wisdom at Trisakti University [email protected]
5 Mexico Dr. Jesús Arce Landa
The National Center for Research and Technological Development (CENIDET) [email protected]
6 Mexico Mr. Iván Hernández
The National Center for Research and Technological Development (CENIDET) [email protected]
7 New Zealand Mr. Nicolas David Smith
Energy Efficiency and Conservation Authority [email protected]
8 Peru Mr. Roberto PRIETO
Architech, Ministry of Housing, Construction and Sanitation [email protected]
9 Philippines Mr. Emelito Cabrera Punsalan
Vice President, Philippine Green Building Initiative, LR Punsalan & Associates [email protected]
10 Philippines Ms. Angelina Margaret F. Tajon
Senior Trade and Industry Development Specialist, Construction Industry Authority of the Philipines [email protected]
11 Russia Ms. Kristina ANDREYTSEVA
Postgraduate Student; Research Institute for Building Physics [email protected]
12 Russia Mr. Lyubim SHUBIN Commercial Director of VELKO2000 [email protected]
13 Singapore Dr. Fangzhi Chen
Research Scientist; Solar Energy Research Institute of Singapore (SERIS) [email protected]
14 Singapore Mr. Seah Amos Technoform Bautec Asia Pacific [email protected]
15 Thailand Dr. Purit Thanakijkasem Associate Professor, KMUTT [email protected]
16 Thailand Mr. Boonyarit Phuethisarikorn
Technical Services Staff, Thai-German Specialty Glass [email protected]
17 Thailand Mr. Chatchawin Nuchanong Technical Engineer, 3M [email protected]
18 Thailand Mr. Joenel B Tajonara Engineering Manager, Kaskal [email protected]
19 Thailand Mr. Kitipat Chinkarun Sale Engineer, 3M [email protected]
The APEC Training Workshop for Window Thermal Performance Testing and Rating October 23rd - 25th, 2013
# APEC
Member Economies
Name Affiliation Email Address
20 Thailand Mr. Krisanatas Sumdangrit Engineer, DEDE
21 Thailand Mr. PhaiChayon Lumlert AGC Flat Glass
22 Thailand Mr. Poonlarp Sumitmoh AGC Flat Glass
23 Thailand Mr. Prakob Eamsa-Ard Senior Engineer, DEDE
24 Thailand Mr. Ronnakorn Junma Silpakorn University [email protected]
25 Thailand Ms. NualAnong Methapipatkul
Architectural Sales Manager, Guardian Industries Rayong [email protected]
26 Thailand Ms. Vichuda Mettanant Silpakorn University [email protected]
1 Thailand Ms. Thamolwan Kiawpan KMUTT [email protected]
2 Thailand Ms. Chutimon Worachetbancha KMUTT [email protected]
3 Thailand Ms. Hanan Sareh KMUTT [email protected]
4 Thailand Mr. Trin Buapakham KMUTT [email protected]
5 Thailand Ms. Chittaworanan Itsarhatrakoon KMUTT [email protected]
6 Thailand Mr. Teerasak Likhitlertlam KMUTT [email protected]
27 USA Mr. Bipin Shah President, WinBuild [email protected]
28 USA Dr. Charlie Curcija Scientist, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory [email protected]
29 Vietnam Mr. Nguyen Huy Thang Secretary General (VieGlass) [email protected]
30 Vietnam Dr. Kieu Le Hai Director of Technical Consulting Center (VieGlass) [email protected]
Staff
APPENDIX 3
Workshop Agenda
APEC Policy Workshop for Energy Efficient Building
Envelopes
Venue: Surasak Ballroom, 11th Floor, Eastin Grand Hotel
Sathorn, Bangkok, Thailand
22 October 2013
08:00 – 08:30 Registration
Opening Ceremony and Welcome Address
08:30 -‐ 08:40 Welcome address by KMUTT Vice President (Assoc. Prof. Dr. Bundit Fungtammasan)
08:40 – 08:50 Keynote address and workshop declaration by DEDE Deputy Director-‐General (Dr. Twarath Sutabutr)
08:50 – 09:00 Keynote address by a representative from the US Embassy (D. Matlack)
09:00 – 09:30 Photo session and Coffee Break
Session 1: Building Envelope Energy Efficiency Policy in APEC Economies
09:30 – 10:00 Keynote speaker – Low Carbon Initiatives in the Buildings Sector in the Asia-‐Pacific Region (M.L. Soriano – Senior Technical Advisor, UNDP)
10:00 – 10:25 Development & Progress of Energy Efficiency in Thailand (S. Prakobchart – Senior Professional Engineer, DEDE)
10:25 – 10:50 Experiences of Energy Efficiency Policy Development (B. Shah – USA)
10:50 – 11:15 Building Envelope Energy Efficiency Policy in Mexico (J.A. Landa – Mexico)
11:15 – 11:40 Development of a New Zealand Specific, Energy Star Endorsement For Windows and Overview of a Recently Launched Performance-‐Based Rating System For Buildings In New Zealand (N. Smith – New Zealand)
11:40 – 13:00 Lunch
Session 2: Building Envelope Components Energy Efficiency Testing and Rating Systems
13:00 – 13:25 Keynote speaker – Fenestration Energy Efficiency Performance Labeling of China (S.C. Yang – China)
13:25 – 13:50 Thailand’s Experiences on Testing and Rating Building Materials (P. Rakkwamsuk – Thailand)
13:50 – 14:15 Fenestration System Thermal Performance Rating for Summer Condition (F. Chen – Singapore)
14:15 – 14:40 Simulation and Testing Role in Rating Program in the USA (C. Curcija – USA)
14:40 – 15:05 Energy Efficiency Code, Testing and Rating Systems for Building Envelope Components in South Korea (S.E. Lee – Korea)
15:05 – 15:25 Coffee Break
15:25 – 15:50 Energy Rating Programs & Labeling for Fenestration in Australia (T. Gramlick – Australia)
15:50 – 16:15 Energy Rating Programs & Labeling for Fenestration in Russia (N. Umnyakova – Russia)
Session 3: Industries Initiatives Towards Green Economy of Building Construction Materials
16:15 – 16:40 Green Buildings Materials (S. Bumpensanti – AGC Flat Glass, Thailand)
16:40 – 17:05 Glass for Tropical Climates (D. Plotnick – Guardian, Hong Kong)
17:05 – 17:30 Discussion
Closing ceremony
18:00 – 21:00 Evening Reception at Chaophraya Princess Dinner Cruise (RSVP only)
Workshop Agenda
APEC Training Workshop for Window Thermal Performance
Testing and Rating
Venue: School of Energy, Environment and Materials,
King Mongkut’s University of Technology THonburi
23-25 October 2013
Day 1: 23 October 2013
08:00 Depart from Eastin Grand Hotel, Sathorn, Bangkok
08:30 – 09:20 Registration and morning coffee
09:20 – 09:30 Opening remarks
09:30 – 17:00
Software overview and installation requirements:
§ WINDOW 7 § THERM 7 § IGDB § CGDB § WINDOW/THERM Simulation Manual § Other software tools
o OPTICS o COMFEN
Note: Software tools will be provided to attendees on USB thumb drive or CD.
WINDOW 7:
§ Program Structure / Libraries § Database Structure – Import and Export between databases § Glass Library – Optics connection, Optics User Database § Gas Library – make new records for gas mixtures § Environmental Conditions Library – Defining Different APEC
country Boundary Conditions § Glazing System Library – Thermal Transmittance (U-factor)
o Modeling Glazing and Shading systems.
§ Frame and Divider Library – Importing files from THERM, Condensation Resistance (CR) details, Absorptance
§ Window Library and Data bases– (Glazing, and Shading devices) o International Glazing Data base library o Complex Glazing Data Base Library o Bi-direction
§ Assemble a whole fixed window § Review Results. Thermal Transmittance (U-Factor), Solar
Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC), Visible Transmittance (VT), Condensation Resistance (CR) and other energy indices.
§ Introduction to Complex Glazing modeling. o Attachments, (Venetian blinds, roller blinds, etc. o Frit glass, etc.
Glazing Exercise for the attendees
17:15 Depart from KMUTT for Eastin Grand Hotel
Day 2: 24 October 2013
08:00 Depart from Eastin Grand Hotel, Sathorn, Bangkok
08:30 – 09:20 Registration and morning coffee
09:30 – 17:00 THERM 7:
§ Walk through - Menu / Toolbar / Status Bar § File Properties § Results and Reports § Modeling Aluminum Fix window § Glazing System Import § Frame Cavities – gravity vectors, emissivity, temperatures § Boundary Conditions § U-factor tags § Radiation Enclosures § SHGC tag for SHGC and VT § CR requirements § Obtain all indices value, U-factor, SHGC, VT for Aluminum fix
o Reviewing model results and understanding from design concepts.
17:15 Depart from KMUTT for Eastin Grand Hotel
Day 3: 25 October 2013
08:00 Depart from Eastin Grand Hotel, Sathorn, Bangkok
08:30 – 09:20 Registration and morning coffee
09:30 – 15:30 THERM 7 Continuation:
§ Dividers § Meeting rail and External/Internal exposed air cavity rules § Resolving geometry problems
o Donuts o Bad points o Overlaps o Voids
§ Resolving WINDOW import problems § Resolving modeling problems
o Mesh o convergence
THERM Modeling Special Cases (if time allows):
§ Curtain wall, strip windows modeling § Sloped glazing § Applied Films and Laminates § Bolts, Skip and debridge
Component Modeling Approach Software Tool (CMAST): Commercial Fenestration Modeling and Rating Tool:
§ Introduction to CMAST § Overview of component libraries
o Import of THERM files into frame library o Import of THERM files into spacer library o Creation of glazing systems o Creation of frame assemblies o Creation of spacer assemblies
§ Whole product assembly o Overview additional capabilities of configurator
(complex assemblies), if time permits § Label certificate/Project § Certified component and product directory (web)
Discussion and Q&A
15:30 – 15:45 Closing remarks
15:45 Depart from KMUTT for Eastin Grand Hotel
APPENDIX 4 Links to any relevant websites or online material (e.g. reports, resources created)
The website has been created at http://www.mt.kmutt.ac.th/APEC_Workshop/. Its screen capture is shown below.
APPENDIX 5
Feedback Survey:
APEC Policy Workshop for Energy Efficient Building Envelopes
Eastin Grand Hotel Sathorn, Bangkok, Thailand
22 October 2013
Project Number/Name: EWG13-2012A: Energy Saving Window Thermal Performance
Simulation Training
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
_________
Instructions: Please indicate the level of your satisfaction with questions 1-6 and answer
questions 7-11 below:
Excellent Good Satisfactory Not
good
Bad
1. How useful were the workshop
to you and your economy?
2. Overall, how was the
workshop?
3. How well did the workshop
meet its objectives?
4. How were the speakers?
5. How appropriate were the
participants for the workshop?
6. How adequate and
comfortable were the
meeting room and facilities?
7. How could this workshop have been improved?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8. How will this workshop benefit or change your work, organization and/or economy?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9. What, if any, changes do you plan on implementing when you return to your home
economy?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
10. What needs to be done next by APEC? How can APEC support and build on the project
results?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
11. Any other comments or suggestions?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Participant information (identifying information is optional):
Name: __________________________________________________________________________
Organisation/Economy: ____________________________________________________________
Gender: M / F
Thank you. Your evaluation is important in helping us assess this project, improve project
quality
and plan next steps.
Summary of workshop evaluation
APEC Policy Workshop for Energy Efficient Building Envelopes
Eastin Grand Hotel Sathorn, Bangkok, Thailand
22 October 2013
Section 1 General information
Number of participants 66 Persons
Returned questionnaires 55 Persons
Percentage of returned questionnaires 83.3%
Gender
Male 38 Persons
= 69.1%
Female 5 Persons
= 9.1%
Not identified 12 Persons
= 21.8%
Section 2 Evaluation results
1 2 3 4 5
Average
2.1 How useful were the workshop to you and your economy? 0 0 5 15 35 4.55
2.2 Overall, how was the workshop? 0 0 8 23 24 4.29
2.3 How well did the workshop meet it's objectives? 0 0 6 13 36 4.55
2.4 How were speakers? 0 0 8 21 26 4.33
2.5 How appropriate were the participants for the workshop? 0 0 7 19 29 4.40
2.6 How adequate and comfortable were the meeting room and facilities? 0 0 5 18 32
4.49
Average 4.43
Description: 1 = Bad, 2 = Not good, 3 = Satisfactory, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent
Section 3: Opinions 3.1 How could this workshop have been improved? • I think that it could had been improved if the session of presentation were broken into two days, in
my case was it really difficult to get used to the change of time here in Bangkok. • I consider the workshop was excellent. • More comfort room. • Presentation slide dose not match to slide book. • Lesson learned from countries have implemented building envelope into building codes and EE
regulations building envelope saving big impact on EE and yearly energy consumption.
• The content of papers could cover more building components in such of integrated system. • Developing examples (real). • This is the policy workshop. The next workshop can be on more specific subjects.
3.2 How will this workshop benefit or change your work, organization and/or economy? • The possibility of collaborating with other organization & governmental institute to increase the
awareness of EE building envelopes. • It brought a number of experts that I could collaborate with, besides, it was helpful in establishing
a state of the art for building codes existing in all participant countries. • Because I learned a lot of codes from different countries. • Good learning opportunity, some knowledge learnt can be applied to my work. • It changes a lot of thinking on the way we were study to implement in the reality of Vietnam. • I understood everything you consulting the energy efficiency for the buildings. • It makes me have more information to improve a process at my company. • Giving the input to the government and association on how to improve the standards, research
facilities to improve building envelop. • To give some information for improving policy on building code and regulation. • I'll try to apply these ideas in codes. • Thailand does need window-rating system. As such this will provide the back bone.
3.3 What, if any, changes do you plan on implementing when you return to you home economy? • As an industry driver, we look to help the government to develop more sophisticated fenestration
rating system. • We should take in to account diffusion of topics. • We have a plan to build a testing center for energy efficiency of building in Vietnam. • New situation for my currently job to do for my home. • Building envelope should be the important part of building code and should be part of prerequisite
for building permit regulation. Testing facilities for regulation performance must be established in several cities in Indonesia.
3.4 What needs to be done next by APEC? How can APEC support and build on the project results? • Sharing implementation experience. • To continue promoting the energy efficiency for buildings. • Funding to projects which workable. • New type of energy saving techniques, new information for energy saving. • Facilitating for building material and glass research and testing facilities and harmonizing building
envelope program among the APEC countries. • To have an integrated research on building system which cover not only for modern high-rise
building but also for traditional building and/or (…..) building by involving local materials. • Especially for Thailand, KMUTT and Ministry of energy to try to set up a window rating society.
APEC can support and setting up. 3.5 Any other comments or suggestions? • I would like to participate again and to discuss energy building. • Should you have any soft file of presentation to share for any committee that they very need for
make their information. • For the event of EE supposes to be conduct in hotel or room which representing energy efficiency
already implemented on this hotel or that has EE award. • It might be good it the speaker only about less than 10 peoples.
Feedback Survey:
APEC Training Workshop for Window Thermal Performance Testing and Rating
School of Energy, Environment and Materials
King Mongkut’s University of Technology Thonburi, Bangkok, Thailand
23-25 October 2013
Project Number/Name: EWG13-2012A: Energy Saving Window Thermal Performance
Simulation Training
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Instructions: Please indicate your level of agreement with the statements listed below in 1-10
and answer questions 7-11 below:
Strongly
Agree
Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly
Disagree
1. The objectives of the training
were clearly defined.
2. Participation and interaction
were encouraged.
3. The topics covered were
relevant to me.
4. The content was organized and
easy to follow.
5. The training experience will be
useful in my work.
6. The trainer was knowledgeable
about the training topics.
7. The trainer was well prepared.
8. The training objectives were
met.
9. The time allotted for the
training was sufficient.
10. The training room and facilities
were adequate and
comfortable.
11. What did you like the most about the training?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
12. How could this workshop have been improved?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
13. How will this workshop benefit or change your work, organization and/or economy?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
14. What, if any, changes do you plan on implementing when you return to your home
economy?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
15. What additional trainings related to building thermal performance would you like to have
in the future?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
16. Any other comments or suggestions?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Participant information (identifying information is optional):
Name: __________________________________________________________________________
Organisation/Economy: ____________________________________________________________
Gender: M / F
Thank you. Your evaluation is important in helping us assess this project, improve project
quality
and plan next steps.
Summary of workshop evaluation
APEC Training Workshop for Window Thermal Performance Testing and Rating
School of Energy, Environment and Materials, KMUTT
23 - 25 October 2013
Section 1 General information
Number of participants 42 Persons
Returned questionnaires 36 Persons
Percentage of returned questionnaires 85.7%
Gender
Male 29 Persons
= 80.6%
Female 7 Persons
= 19.4%
Section 2 Evaluation results
1 2 3 4 5
Average
2.1 The objectives of the training were clearly defined. 0 0 0 12 24 4.67
2.2 Participation and interaction were encouraged. 0 0 2 13 21 4.53
2.3 The topics covered were relevant to me. 0 0 4 8 24 4.56
2.4 The content was organized and easy to follow 0 1 4 11 20 4.39
2.5 The training experience will be useful in my work. 0 0 3 9 24 4.58
2.6 The trainer was knowledgeable about the training topics. 0 0 0 9 27 4.75
2.7 The trainer was well prepared. 0 1 0 13 22 4.56
2.8 The training objectives were met. 0 0 2 9 23 4.36
2.9 The time allotted for the training was sufficient. 0 1 4 15 16 4.28 2.10 The training room and facilities were adequate and comfortable 0 0 7 9 20 4.36
Average 4.50
Description: 1 = Bad, 2 = Not good, 3 = Satisfactory, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent
Section 3: Opinions 3.1 what did you like the most about the training?
• I like to know new programs about fenestration. • I have just known new programs for useful of energy saving - Window 7, THERM etc.
because in Thailand hasn't ever used these programs before. • The trainer was so nice. • The trainers had fantastic knowledge & are always willing to teach more than within the
class. • The knowledge of the trainers very good. • Step by step training and exercise. • Topics of the training, contents that covering in each program. • Technique for calculation and workshop. • In the training, I found what they did in different courtesan building energy efficiency. And the
software I was taught will be useful for me to do research. I learned much from person who is from different country.
• Food & place. • I think I like both of trainers who try to teaching with no serious style. • The expert trainers try to teach all of their knowledge and solve any problems that was
happened. • The simulation process and techniques. • The organization and the facilities of the event as well as the experience of the trainers. • All the simulation software are interesting and challenging funning the training and will be
useful for designing and certification process for green building and high performance building.
3.2 How could this workshop have been improved?
• We can choose. Glasses type. For design of green building in the future • Share of knowledge on the difference EN and NKRC • Perhaps some less time on simple aspects and more time on complex + timesaving
functionality in THERM. • Topics arrangement from basically to the expert ones • There is no lecture note. The training could be better prepared with training note. Some
research features were covered, but it is not necessary for general use. • Engineering manual about the theory used in the program could be provide. • By approach how to apply for local material. • Just a suggestion, maybe me can divide attendants into several groups. And, every group
include attendant from different countries. Discussion in-group could be organized. • Times management & how to acknowledge training to understand. • More than time for workshop schedule. • I think that all contents are very interesting, but the time to train is too short so next time will
be created schedule from more time. • Allot more time and cover more recent applications like curtain wall system and association
spandrel area or opaque part on a single unit panel. • It might good if the penchants could be divided by croups and have a group assignment as
an prates exercise. • May be the people who want to take this training have to read the simulation manual in order
to facilitate the training. • Additional 1 day might be more cashier to design the training material, making a group every
conducting case study could also make faster understanding. 3.3 How will this workshop benefit or change your work, organization and/or economy?
• It’s very useful for me. • I’ll inform in my job about these products. • I will practice these programs for improving my work. • Currently there has been a lot of work on THERM/Window. This would allow me to help my
organization. • It will help in incorporating Window + THERM as an accepted modeling + verification too.
• Make more clear about window performance. • It can be used to teach students in a class and also for the research works. • It most useful for my function. • This workshop offers me a method to simulate thermal performance of window. We can use
the software to improve the thermal performance of building, which is very importance for energy saving, especially in south china.
• It’s very useful for my work. • It makes me easier than learning by myself and very useful for my duties. • It will help in developing a façade system which is efficient in terms of energy saving and
design material which are effusive in terms of thermal barrier. • It will improve my lecturing’s topics for students. • I am sure all the software will be a very useful tool. • This training is very useful for consultant, designer or green building professional to optimize
integrated design building from the building as well as for major renovation for building.
3.4 What, if any, changes do you plan on implementing when you return to you home economy?
• Energy saving, cost reduction, green energy. • Trying to learn more how to use these programs, creating and design the glazing layer. • Ideally, we would be able to help the government in the improvements of the current BEC • The use of Window+THERM in energy star verification. • By implement at my office. • I plan to practice all of programs which trained because my organization is needed it to
support ISO 17025 standardization. • Employ thermal simulation in the design stage. • To do specific researches deal with various windows consideration. • May be to do the exercises recommended at least.
3.5 What needs to be done next by APEC? How can APEC support and build on the project results?
• OTTV, RTTV programs in local country to have in the future • Envelope (Meat transfer at rout and wall) • Whole building or other building component rating • Material performance analysis for each window assembled materials (glass/etc.) • Energy plus • The most is for TH&RM software • Cool roof, energy consumption. Simulation (Energy plus, DoEZ, ect.) • I am interesting in related energy programs to use in my • I hope more than relative programs that link with NFRC , BFRC and others such as
Radtherm. • Focus on façade / glass / aluminum • Specific for united curtain wall • Combine windows with sun orientation in related to building energy efficiency. • A training to calculate all the thermal parameters for the whole building. • High performance building such as energy plus E quest
3.6 Any other comments or suggestions?
• Thanks very much for all. • It’s great. Thanks again KMUTT • It almost useful for my job the training • I want go to the famous places in THAI such as Siam Paragon • The training / workshop was very good I learned much and willing to attend more advance
work shop in the near future. • To provide better / bigger screen for presentation.
q Any other relevant information or resources that would help us learn more about your project
No other information.
FOR APEC SECRETARIAT USE ONLY APEC comments: Were APEC project guidelines followed? Could the project have been managed more effectively or easily by the PO?
