Possible Biological Effects of Radiation Delta Electron Ionization Processes Methods, Measurements...
1
Possible Biological Effects of Radiation Delta Electron Ionization Processes Methods, Measurements and Parameterization Techniques This work was supported by funding from UNF Department of Chemistry and Physics and UNF Summer Research Awards The Problem of Bio-Radiation The long and short term effects of radiation on the body are fairly well understood. However science has still yet to find accurate methods and models to predict the amount and type of radiation the body will receive when exposed to radiation. The focus of this research is to help further provide accurate modeling of radiation energy transfer. Delta Electron Database for the Calculation of Astronaut Dose Rate and Cell Damage from Space Radiation Stephen Emerson and Jane H. MacGibbon, University of North Florida The Space Radiation Problem Space radiation, including the radiation on other planets and moons, is significantly more dangerous than radiation on Earth. Space radiation has three main components: galactic cosmic radiation; solar particles; and the Van Allen radiation belts. Space radiation particles are mainly highly energetic ions (hydrogen to iron), photons and electrons. Space radiation research focuses on predicting the amount of radiation astronauts will receive during space travel and the long-term consequences of exposure to space radiation. Biological Effects of Radiation Effects of Space Radiation on the Body Effects of Radiation on Cells Once the DNA has been damaged, the cell will do one of three things. The DNA damage may cause the cell to die, (apoptosis); the cell may repair the DNA correctly and the cell will continue to operate normally; or the cell may incorrectly repair the DNA damage leaving the cell with a permanent error, potentially causing cancer and other permanent long term effects. Several of these effects include: • Chromosomal Damage • Radiation Carcinogenesis • Radiation Mutagenesis • Radiation Induced Cataracts Delta Electron Ionization Processes When an incoming ion interacts with an atom, the most significant energy exchange is the Coulomb interaction between the charged projectile and the outer electrons of the target atom. If the impact parameter (the closest distance of approach between the ion and the target atom) is small, the energy transferred to the target electron is large and the electron can be treated as quasi- free. If the impact parameter is large, the energy transfer is smaller and the influence of the target nucleus must be considered. Binary Encounter Peak Direct Coulomb Ionization The binary encounter peak occurs at the electron angle and energy given by the kinematics for a classical collision between the projectile ion and an orbital electron of the target atom. Loss Electrons Auger Electron Emission Spontaneous decay of excited states or inner-shell vacancies created in the ion- target collision can produce ionized electrons with discrete energy levels. Excited outer-shell target electrons produce Auger electrons isotropically with low energy. Auger electrons from the projectile have high energy in the lab frame. The Van Allen belts are just one of the radiation hazards astronauts must be protected from during space travel. The most likely event starts with space radiation impacting the shielding of the space shuttle or station. As the radiation travels through the spacecraft shielding it may undergo nuclear fragmentation producing a different distribution of particle species and energy. The radiation may then travel through the astronaut causing ionization and/or other energy deposition. When ionizing radiation interacts with the body, DNA damage can occur. Ionizing radiation can cause DNA damage by directly striking the DNA molecule or it can create free radicals in the cell which then attack the DNA molecule. DNA being damaged by radiation Fluorescent markers indicate the presence of double-strand breaks in DNA caused by low levels of x- ray radiation. Singly Differential Cross Section (SDCS) The singly differential cross section is the differential ionization probability with respect to the outgoing electron energy. Double Differential Cross Section (DDCS) The doubly differential cross section (DDCS) is the differential probability of an incoming projectile ion ionizing a target electron expressed with respect to the angle and energy of the outgoing electron. The DDCS gives the most accurate 3-D look at the ionization process. The DDCS is more complicated that the total cross-section and SDCS and cannot be modeled theoretically. Total Cross Section The total cross-section is the probability of an incoming projectile ion ionizing an electron from a target atom or molecule. Double differential cross sections for the ionization of electrons at 20° from molecular hydrogen by protons of various impact energies. Singly differential cross sections for the ionization of several molecular species by 1 MeV protons. Total cross-sections for the ionization of molecular oxygen by protons. DDCS for the ionization of molecular oxygen by a 30 MeV O 5+ oxygen ion. The electron energy at the binary encounter peak scale with the electron angle as . DDCS at 160º for ionization of argon gas by 100 keV protons and argon ions. Auger electrons from the target can be seen at low energies Over 1200 data sets of experimentally measured DDCS have been compiled into our database. The data is essentially decades worth of ionization research results. The data covers many different projectile species (hydrogen to uranium) and target species (including hydrocarbons and water) and a wide range of projectile energies. Information on each dataset is stored in the Master Spreadsheet. A large part of the database task was normalizing the individual data sets to one common set of units so the data sets could be accurately compared to one and another. This process included unit conversion, mathematical conversion and in some cases energy conversions. Above is one set of normalized data. The Delta Electron Database Normalized Data Sets Goals and Further Research The main long term goal of this research project is to use this database in the modeling of astronaut exposure to ionizing radiation. Currently there is no accurate method to predict the short and long term effects of ionizing radiation astronauts will receive during future space endeavors including a return trip to the Moon and to Mars. Current and future tasks include creating a user friendly interface that allows researchers to select individual targets and ionizing projectiles over various energy distributions and by other projectile and target characteristics. The selected data sets can be used directly in Monte Carlo radiation codes. We are also developing methods to parameterize the data sets. The parameterized mathematical fits will be used in analytical and numerical modeling applications. Using data sets obtained from experiments and parameterizations directly derived from the experimental data should significantly improve the accuracy of the modeling of radiation exposure. Currently the modeling relies on inaccurate theoretical approximations to the DDCS or data from a limited range of projectile species. Multi-variable parameterization will also allow the user predict radiation exposure for projectiles, targets and energy ranges for which the cross-sections have not yet been measured. Loss electrons are classified as two types depending on where they originate. The two types are electron loss (of a projectile electron) to the continuum (ELC) and electron capture (of a target electron by the projectile) to the continuum (ECC). Both types are emitted with nearly zero momentum in the frame of the moving projectile. DDCS for ionization of water vapour by 0.3 MeV u -1 protons and helium ions. The loss electron contribution is noticeable on the 15° He + spectrum around 160 eV. Microsoft Visual Basic for Applications (VBA) is used to write the code to manipulate the database and datasets. Several different VBA modules were used to normalize the datasets. Below is a snapshot of just one of the modules of VBA code. VBA Code Linear Energy Transfer (LET) When ionizing radiation interacts with a target atom, the amount of energy transmitted per unit length to the target by the radiation is known as the linear energy transfer (LET). LET can be useful in determining the radiation dose and subsequent potential biological effects due to radiation. In general the biological effects are greater for high LET radiation because more energy is deposited in each cell. • Heavy Ions are high LET radiation • Photons and X-Rays are low LET radiation Z 2 ) 1 ( 2 log 1 ) ( where; ) 1 )( ( z A Z D dx dE 2 2 2 2 2 2 C M m I c m e e The Bethe-Bloch Equation is a good approximation for the electron energy loss (stopping power) due to ionization. potential ionization average r 4 D target the of density mass length path x target the of weight atomic A charge projectile z target the of number atomic Z ) - (1 1 correction density Number s Avagadro' velocity projectile correct order higher mass rest electron mass projectile M correction shell radius electron classical r energy projectile E 2 2 e 2 e I N c m N m C A e A e 2 cos
Possible Biological Effects of Radiation Delta Electron Ionization Processes Methods, Measurements and Parameterization Techniques This work was supported
Possible Biological Effects of RadiationDelta Electron
Ionization ProcessesMethods, Measurements and Parameterization
TechniquesThe long and short term effects of radiation on the body
are fairly well understood. However science has still yet to find
accurate methods and models to predict the amount and type of
radiation the body will receive when exposed to radiation. The
focus of this research is to help further provide accurate modeling
of radiation energy transfer.Delta Electron Database for the
Calculation of Astronaut Dose Rate and Cell Damage from Space
RadiationStephen Emerson and Jane H. MacGibbon, University of North
FloridaThe Space Radiation Problem Space radiation, including the
radiation on other planets and moons, is significantly more
dangerous than radiation on Earth. Space radiation has three main
components: galactic cosmic radiation; solar particles; and the Van
Allen radiation belts. Space radiation particles are mainly highly
energetic ions (hydrogen to iron), photons and electrons. Space
radiation research focuses on predicting the amount of radiation
astronauts will receive during space travel and the long-term
consequences of exposure to space radiation.Biological Effects of
RadiationEffects of Space Radiation on the BodyEffects of Radiation
on Cells Once the DNA has been damaged, the cell will do one of
three things. The DNA damage may cause the cell to die,
(apoptosis); the cell may repair the DNA correctly and the cell
will continue to operate normally; or the cell may incorrectly
repair the DNA damage leaving the cell with a permanent error,
potentially causing cancer and other permanent long term effects.
Several of these effects include: Chromosomal Damage Radiation
Carcinogenesis Radiation Mutagenesis Radiation Induced
CataractsDelta Electron Ionization ProcessesWhen an incoming ion
interacts with an atom, the most significant energy exchange is the
Coulomb interaction between the charged projectile and the outer
electrons of the target atom. If the impact parameter (the closest
distance of approach between the ion and the target atom) is small,
the energy transferred to the target electron is large and the
electron can be treated as quasi-free. If the impact parameter is
large, the energy transfer is smaller and the influence of the
target nucleus must be considered.Binary Encounter PeakDirect
Coulomb IonizationThe binary encounter peak occurs at the electron
angle and energy given by the kinematics for a classical collision
between the projectile ion and an orbital electron of the target
atom.Loss ElectronsAuger Electron EmissionSpontaneous decay of
excited states or inner-shell vacancies created in the ion-target
collision can produce ionized electrons with discrete energy
levels. Excited outer-shell target electrons produce Auger
electrons isotropically with low energy. Auger electrons from the
projectile have high energy in the lab frame.The Van Allen belts
are just one of the radiation hazards astronauts must be protected
from during space travel.The most likely event starts with space
radiation impacting the shielding of the space shuttle or station.
As the radiation travels through the spacecraft shielding it may
undergo nuclear fragmentation producing a different distribution of
particle species and energy. The radiation may then travel through
the astronaut causing ionization and/or other energy deposition.
When ionizing radiation interacts with the body, DNA damage can
occur. Ionizing radiation can cause DNA damage by directly striking
the DNA molecule or it can create free radicals in the cell which
then attack the DNA molecule.DNA being damaged by
radiationFluorescent markers indicate the presence of double-strand
breaks in DNA caused by low levels of x-ray radiation. Singly
Differential Cross Section (SDCS)The singly differential cross
section is the differential ionization probability with respect to
the outgoing electron energy.Double Differential Cross Section
(DDCS)The doubly differential cross section (DDCS) is the
differential probability of an incoming projectile ion ionizing a
target electron expressed with respect to the angle and energy of
the outgoing electron. The DDCS gives the most accurate 3-D look at
the ionization process. The DDCS is more complicated that the total
cross-section and SDCS and cannot be modeled theoretically.Total
Cross SectionThe total cross-section is the probability of an
incoming projectile ion ionizing an electron from a target atom or
molecule.Double differential cross sections for the ionization of
electrons at 20 from molecular hydrogen by protons of various
impact energies.Singly differential cross sections for the
ionization of several molecular species by 1 MeV protons.Total
cross-sections for the ionization of molecular oxygen by
protons.DDCS for the ionization of molecular oxygen by a 30 MeV O5+
oxygen ion. The electron energy at the binary encounter peak scale
with the electron angle as .DDCS at 160 for ionization of argon gas
by 100 keV protons and argon ions. Auger electrons from the target
can be seen at low energiesOver 1200 data sets of experimentally
measured DDCS have been compiled into our database. The data is
essentially decades worth of ionization research results. The data
covers many different projectile species (hydrogen to uranium) and
target species (including hydrocarbons and water) and a wide range
of projectile energies. Information on each dataset is stored in
the Master Spreadsheet.A large part of the database task was
normalizing the individual data sets to one common set of units so
the data sets could be accurately compared to one and another. This
process included unit conversion, mathematical conversion and in
some cases energy conversions. Above is one set of normalized
data.The Delta Electron DatabaseNormalized Data SetsGoals and
Further ResearchThe main long term goal of this research project is
to use this database in the modeling of astronaut exposure to
ionizing radiation. Currently there is no accurate method to
predict the short and long term effects of ionizing radiation
astronauts will receive during future space endeavors including a
return trip to the Moon and to Mars. Current and future tasks
include creating a user friendly interface that allows researchers
to select individual targets and ionizing projectiles over various
energy distributions and by other projectile and target
characteristics. The selected data sets can be used directly in
Monte Carlo radiation codes. We are also developing methods to
parameterize the data sets. The parameterized mathematical fits
will be used in analytical and numerical modeling applications.
Using data sets obtained from experiments and parameterizations
directly derived from the experimental data should significantly
improve the accuracy of the modeling of radiation exposure.
Currently the modeling relies on inaccurate theoretical
approximations to the DDCS or data from a limited range of
projectile species. Multi-variable parameterization will also allow
the user predict radiation exposure for projectiles, targets and
energy ranges for which the cross-sections have not yet been
measured. Loss electrons are classified as two types depending on
where they originate. The two types are electron loss (of a
projectile electron) to the continuum (ELC) and electron capture
(of a target electron by the projectile) to the continuum (ECC).
Both types are emitted with nearly zero momentum in the frame of
the moving projectile. DDCS for ionization of water vapour by 0.3
MeV u-1 protons and helium ions. The loss electron contribution is
noticeable on the 15 He+ spectrum around 160 eV.Microsoft Visual
Basic for Applications (VBA) is used to write the code to
manipulate the database and datasets. Several different VBA modules
were used to normalize the datasets. Below is a snapshot of just
one of the modules of VBA code. VBA CodeLinear Energy Transfer
(LET) When ionizing radiation interacts with a target atom, the
amount of energy transmitted per unit length to the target by the
radiation is known as the linear energy transfer (LET). LET can be
useful in determining the radiation dose and subsequent potential
biological effects due to radiation. In general the biological
effects are greater for high LET radiation because more energy is
deposited in each cell. Heavy Ions are high LET radiation Photons
and X-Rays are low LET radiationThe Bethe-Bloch Equation is a good
approximation for the electron energy loss (stopping power) due to
ionization.
