Petition for Certiorari Sample

8/16/2019 Petition for Certiorari Sample

1/35

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINESCOURT OF APPEALS

CITY OF MANILA

_______ Division

HANS PETER GERHARD BRUNNER,Petitioner,

CA-G.R. SPNO.____________

NLRC LAC NO. 09-

00259-!5

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#!2-

!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#!%-

!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#!-

!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#!&-

!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#20-!$-RI

-versus- NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#22-

!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#2%-

!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#2-

!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#2&-

!$-RI NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#29-

!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#$!-

!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#$2-

!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$!&-

!%-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$!9-

!%-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$20-

!%-RI

P'() 1 o* 35

ORI+INAL


2/35

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$2!-

!%-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$99-

!%-RI

NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONSCOMMISSION SECONDDI!ISION",

Respondent,

DANILO BOCTON, ET.AL.,Private Respondents,

,-------------------------------------------------,

PETITION FOR CERTIORARIUNDER RULE #5

$%&' A(()%*+&% r Te/(r+r0 Res&r+%% Or2er +2r

Pre)%/%+r0 I4u*&% +2 M&% & Se& C+se r Or+)

Aru/e&"

P)iion)/ o1( ) 1n)si(n) 3o1ns)4/ os

)s6)3*1447 s')s8 T'/

I. NATURE OF THE PETITION

!. Tis is ' 6)iion *o C)io'i 1n) R14) 5 o* ) !99#

R14)s o* Civi4 Po3)1) 'ss'i4in( ) )so41ion o* )

N'ion'4 L'o R)4'ions Coission :NLRC *o )vi7;

S)3on Division ') M'3 $!/ 20! :


3/35

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#$2-!$-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$!&-!%-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$!9-!%-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$20-!%-RI

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$2!-!%-RINLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$99-!%-RI.

2. P)iion) is no< 'ss'i4in( ) 6o6i)7 o* ) NLRC )3ision

in isissin( ) A66)'4 'n Moion *o R)3onsi)'ion 'n

))7 'is) ('v) '1s) o* is3)ion/ 3onsi)in( '

)) is no 64'in/ s6))7 'n ')=1') ))7 'v'i4'4) in

) oin'7 3o1s) o* 4'< - )n3)/ is 6)iion.

$. R)so41ion ') M'3 $!/ 20! )n7in( ) 6)iion)s>Moion *o R)3onsi)'ion? ' 3)i@) 1) 3o67 o* ) s'i

R)so41ion is ''3) ))o 's Ae9 A7:

%. R)so41ion ') D)3)) 29/ 20!5 isissin( 6)iion)s>

'66)'4 *o )i '44)() *'i41) o 3o647


4/35

*o A6i4 !!/ 20! o 1ni4 1n) / 20! o @4) ' P)iion *o

C)io'i 1no is Hono'4) Co1. H)n3)/ ) ins'n

P)iion is i)47 @4) o'7.

&. T) o3) 'n 4)('4 *))s in341in( )6osi *o 3oss


5/35

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#!2-!$-RI/ NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#!%-!$-RI/

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#!-!$-RI/ NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#!&-!$-RI/

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#20-!$-RI/ NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#22-!$-RI/

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#2%-!$-RI/ NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#2-!$-RI/

NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#2&-!$-RI/ NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#29-!$-RI/NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#$!-!$-RI/ NLRC-RAB I"-!2-0!#$2-!$-RI/

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$!&-!%-RI/ NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$!9-!%-RI/

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$20-!%-RI/ NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$2!-!%-RI/

NLRC-RAB I"-0$-00$99-!%-RI? ' 6oo3o67 o* ) 3o64'ins/

s1ons 'n )1n 3's ') ))o ''3) 's Ae9

D +2 D-ser%es7 res(e*&%ve)0.

!$. On 'i'ion/ ) 6'i)s s1i) ) *o44ou)0 8;,

8?15


6/35

M&% & D%s/%ss A((e+) 2+&e2 Auus& 15,

8?15


7/35

!. A((i)v) 7 ) s'i D)3ision/ ) 6)iion)s on 147 !$/

20!5/ @4) oion *o )13ion 'n

3ons)=1)n47 isiss) ) 6)iion)>s '66)'4/ is *'44o

s')s/ o


8/35

*o3i47 )ov) 's vi3)-6)si)n *o ) s'i 3o6'n7 on

1n) !%/ 20!2.

2!. On 1n) 20!2/ P)iion)/ in is 3'6'3i7 's ' i)3o o* )

ENIO/ )3)iv) ' 4)) *o is s 3o6'n7


9/35

2&. On 1n) 20!2/ 13 o P)iion)>s s16is)/ )


10/35

o)sn> 'v) 'n7 6o6)7 o 6os 's 6o6)7 on in 4i)1 o* 3's o s1)7 on. T'e +%)ure &'e Pe&%&%er & )e&'e +((e+) =2 @'%*' %s eu%v+)e& & &'e /e&+r0+@+r2 r +&)e+s& 1? s+%2 /e&+r0 +@+r2 %s 2ue

& &'e +*& &'+& 'e '+s *+(+*%&0 & (r2u*e su*'+/u&, (e&%&%erJs *+(+*%&0 & )e =2 %s =+se2 '%s %*/e +s %2%*+&e2 % '%s I*/e T+9 Re&ur.Asin( i o 6o13) ) )=1i) 'o1n o* '66)'4 on'7 )s14 o i 3on'3in( ' 1() ) 'n i '73o6ois) is o4i('ion o s166o is 3i4)n/ 's s '66)'4 1) o non-6)*)3ion *o no 6osin( )

'o1n o* '66)'4 on )=1i) 7 4'< 'n 1is61)n3).

$&. On 'n1'7 29/ 20!/ ) P)iion) @4) ' i)47 Moion *o

R)3onsi)'ion o ) )3ision )n7in( ) '66)'4 o* )P)iion).

$9. On M'3 $!/ 20!/ ) Hono'4) Coission )n)) '

)so41ion )n7in( ) Moion *o R)3onsi)'ion o* )

P)iion).

%0. H)n3)/ is P)iion.

!I. ISSUES

I. $ITH DUE RESPECT TO THE HONORABLECOMMISSION, IT GRA!ELK ABUSED ITSDISCRETION $HEN IT HELD THAT THE PETITIONERIS >OINTLK AND SOLIDARILK LIABLE $ITH ENOFOR THE LIABILITIES THAT THE LATTERINCURRED.

II. $ITH DUE RESPECT TO THE HONORABLECOMMISSION, IT GRA!ELK ABUSED ITSDISCRETION $HEN IT DENIED THE MOTION FORRECONSIDERATION FILED BK THE PETITIONER FOR

P'() 1? o* 35


11/35


12/35

)%+=%)%&

%es&'+&%&'+s%*ur

re2.

%!. Enio F))' Co44)3ions In)n'ion'4 In3. is ' 3o6o'ion

147 o('ni) 'n ),isin( 1n) Pi4i66in) 4'


13/35

%5. In o)


14/35

%9. Tis is 6ov)n 7 ) ''vi o* )64o7))s An()4ioB1('in/ +)' A. Bon'4/ os)6in) A43'n''/ +)'4in)A. O3'6o/ N'3iso T. Os1'/ Es)44' C. A)io/ 'n N)4i'B. +'''. T)i ''vis ') 1ni) in ) *o44oue 8?18:

%%. F))@% &'e 'u/%)%+&% 'e re*e%ve2r/ (r%v+&e res(2e&s, Pe&%&%erBruer ever +&&e/(&e2 & re+%

P'() 1; o* 35


15/35

*&r) r %ue*e % &'e /++e/e&+2 (er+&%s EQ%:

%%%. Pe&%&%er Bruer '+2 (+r&%*%(+&%

% &'e /++e/e& EQ% s%*e >ue8?18, =u& 2ur% &'e &%/e &'+& 'e @+s %&s/++er, 'e r+ &'e s+/e e*%e&)0 +2u))0 (+%2 &'e e/()0ees &'e%r r%'&u)s+)+r%es +2 =ee&s.

5!. A4so/ ) )4)3oni3 'i4 s)n 7 Enio>s o3i'4 )'i4')ss o P)iion) 'n Enio>s 34i)ns 34)'47 s166o )*'3 ' P)iion) 'n Eno 'v) *o'447 'n ))3iv)47s)v)) i)s/ o


16/35

o3in) o* 6i)3in( ) v)i4 o* 3o6o') @3ion/ 'n s')' 34)' 'n 3onvin3in( )vi)n3) 1s ) '13) o

1si*7 ) s')/ o


17/35

Co1 in ) 3's) o* Heirs o% Fe 4an G vs. ;nternational

E@c$ange 8an0, 9.R. o. 1++"'",

B)*o) ' i)3o o o3) o* ' 3o6o'ion 3'n )

)4 6)son'447 4i'4) *o 3o6o') o4i('ions/o


18/35

/u&

P'(5?,???.?

?(s&e2=0&'e

Pe&%&%er%sre+s+=)e*s%2er

%'%s

P'() 1 o* 35


19/35

+*%+)

s&+&us+2%*+(

+*%&0&(+0&'e

u))+/u& +((e+)=2re

u%re2=0&'

P'() 1 o* 35


20/35

%sH

r+=)eC//%ss%

err+&)e+s&1

? %&.

!. P)iion) @4) ' on in ) 'o1n o* P650/000.00

)3'1s) ) is @n'n3i'447 in3'6'3i') o 6'7 ) *144

'o1n o* ) '66)'4 on o '4)'s !0Q o* i.

2. T) 'nn1'4 (oss in3o) o* ) P)iion)/ 's so


21/35

)so13)s so ' ) 3'n 6os ) )=1i) 'o1n o* '66)'4

on. H) 3'n on47 (iv) ) 'o1n


22/35

&'e (s&% + *+s' r sure&0 =2. T'e

Cur&, '@ever, '+s re)+9e2 &'%s reu%re/e&

u2er *er&+% e9*e(&%+) *%r*u/s&+*es %

r2er & res)ve *&rvers%es &'e%r

/er%&s. T'ese *%r*u/s&+*es %*)u2e 1"u2+/e&+) *s%2er+&% su=s&+&%+)

4us&%*e: 8" (reve&% /%s*+rr%+e

4us&%*e r u4us& er%*'/e&: +2 3"

s(e*%+) *%r*u/s&+*es &'e *+se */=%e2

@%&' %&s )e+) /er%&s, +2 &'e +/u& +2 &'e

%ssue %v)ve2.7 :E6'sis o1s;

5.

T) i(47 ),3)6ion'4 3i31s'n3) in ) 3's) o* P)iion)

is =1i) 'n'4o(o1s o ) 'ov))nion) 3's)s. In


23/35

re% reu%re/e& &'e )+@ s'u)2 =e

%ve + )%=er+) %&er(re&+&%. :E6'sis o1s;

#. In ) 3's) o* ) Oriental 7indoro Electric


24/35


25/35

o* ) 4'


26/35

UNCTION

#. T) ),)31ion o* ) 1()n ))in i(s/ in ' 6)iion)s


27/35

6)iion)s 16on ),)31ion o* ) '66)'4) )so41ions.Mre s s%*e &'e (u=)%* res(2e& re2ere2 &'e+ss+%)e2 2e*%s% @%&' r+ve +=use 2%s*re&% +2% */()e&e 2%sre+r2 &'e =+s%* &ee&s )+@.

&0. I* ' T)6o'7 R)s'inin( O) is no *o


28/35

%ssu+*e &'e @r%& e9e*u&% r e9e*u&% &'e 4u2/e& NLRC @%)) & =e (reve&e2.

. A**r2%)0, %& %s res(e*&u))0 su=/%&&e2 & &'%s

Hr+=)e Cur& &'+& %ssu+*e + Te/(r+r0Res&r+%% Or2er r + Or2er r + Pre)%/%+r0I4u*&% %s (r(er % &'%s *+se s%*e &'e /er%&s &'ePe&%&%erJs +((e+) @+s & &'e /+% *s%2er+&% %res)v% Pe&%&%ersJ +((e+) 'e*e, &'e e9e*u&% &'e *+se @%)) (re4u2%*e &'e r%'&s &'e r/er.

I6. MOTION TO SET CASE FOR ORAL ARGUMENT

&&. T) P)iion) )i)')s ) *'3 ' ) so14 'v) no

))n 4i'4) in is 3's) in ) @s 64'3).

&9. To ) *1447 )n4i()n) 's o ) 4i'i4i7 o* ) P)iion) in) 3's) s1)3 o* is 3)io'i/ ) Hono'4) Co1 1s3on13 ' i'4 o ))in)


29/35


30/35

4$e necessit or propriet o% oral argument s$all/e determined / t$e ustice assigned to t$e case.Hoever, in lieu o% oral arguments, said usticema allo t$e parties to ?le t$eir respective

memoranda it$in ?%teen J1K das %rom notice.Jec. 1, Rule ', R;R


31/35

ATTK. APOLLO 6.C.S. SANGALANG

Cuse) r &'e Res(2e&sIBP Li*)i) No. 05%!? IBP-PPLM C'6)PTR No. MT 5$$%0$-!K2K20!

MCLE Co64i'n3) No. MCLE no. "-002-!00/APRIL 20/ 20!/ PASI+ CITYRo44 o* Aon)7 No. %02225 F4oo B1i4)s C)n)

!#0 S'43)o S))/ L)('s6i "i44'()M''i Ci7 !229

T)4. 20&-20? C)4. 09!#-&2!-&%&E'i48 '6o44o.s'n('4'n(4'


32/35

ATTK. APOLLO 6.C.S.

SANGALANG

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES ; ; SS.

!ERIFICATION, AUTHENTICATION OF ANNE6ES,AND CERTIFICATION OF NON-FORUM SHOPPING

I/ HANS PETER GERHARD BRUNNER, s1s3iin( 1n) o'/o ))7 )6os) 'n s'7 '8

!. I ' on) o* ) 6)iion) in ) 'ov)-)ni4) 3's)?

2. I 'v) 3'1s) ) 6)6''ion 'n @4in( o* ) *o)(oin(Pe&%&% r Cer&%r+r% u2er Ru)e #5 $%&' A(()%*+&% rTe/(r+r0 Res&r+%% Or2er +2r Pre)%/%+r0 I4u*&%+2 M&% & Se& C+se r Or+) Aru/e&"?

$. I 'v) )' 'n 1n)soo ) 3on)ns ))o* 'n )

'44)('ions 3on'in) ))in ') 1) 'n 3o)3 o* 7 o


33/35

Co1/ ) Co1 o* A66)'4s/ o 'n7 o) i1n'4 o '()n37/ I1n)') o )6o ' *'3


34/35

R)614i3 o* ) Pi4i66in)s;

________________________; SS.

AFFIDA!IT OF SER!ICE

I/ R%+)+2 P. Mr%))/ 1n) o'/ )6os) 'n s') THAT8

!. I ' ) Li'ison O3) o* HANS PETER +ERHARD BRUNNER/s B1i4in(

!0! M. P'14ino S. B''n('7 #D

S'n P'4o Ci7/ L'(1n'

ATTK. >AIME G. BALMES

R. $%5 R)614i3 S16)')

F. To)s 3o. So4) S))

S'. C1/ M'ni4' Ci7

NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONSCOMMISSION SECOND DI!ISION"PPSTA B4(. 5/ B'n'


35/35

)s6)3iv) o3)s/

Documents

Petition for Certiorari Sample