7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

1/27

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

2/27

He says wehave to buy

health

insurance

ObamaCares

(and you don't)

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

3/27

Government Health Care

or.....

False

dichotomy:

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

4/27

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

5/27

Not everyone can have all they need

under government-provided medical care

Limited resources require limits

Government:

Cost containmentCutting servicesTop-down central planningMandated value choices

Free Market:

Greater productivityLower pricesInnovationPersonal value choices

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

6/27

Winners Losers

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

7/27

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

8/27

Compassion

Meaningful Access

vs.Meaningless Coverage

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

9/27

Community

Freedom of Choice =

Voluntary Exchange

Examples:

1. Freedom of Contract

HI benefits, Prices, LiabilityChoice; Competition

2. Cooperation

3. Charity

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

10/27

NOTCOERCION

Competition:

Win/Lose

Cooperation:Win/Win

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

11/27

Access

Affordability comes from

an abundance of resources

Making medical care affordable

Step #1

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

12/27

Access

Safety Nets that Empower:

Defined contributions

Examples:

1. Pension model 401K2. Food Stamps - no shortage of suppliers, quality

3. Medicare - expanded choice and control

4. Medicaid Block Grants

Step #2

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

13/27

Progress and Affordability through a Free Market

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

14/27

Plentiful

Affordable

Reliable

Health Security

Control

Regulation

Uniformity

Unleash the creativity of

medical entrepreneurs

Progress at the speed

of government

Which saves more lives?

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

15/27

Age of Accelerating Medical Excellence

Daniel Kraft TED talk

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

16/27

2012 Georgia HealthInsurance Reform

Innovative Delivery Systems

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

17/27

American Ownership Society

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

18/27

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

19/27

It doesnt matter

how well he spends my money

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

20/27

Educating doctors-in-trainingon free market health reform

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

21/27

Medical Student Surveys

1. Huntoon, KM, et al, Plos One, Sept. 2012

80% support ACA~50% not sure if quality will improve

2. Winkleman, T, et al, Arch Int MedSept. 2012

48% support ACA40% dont understand it

3. Yurkiewicz, I., Sci Am, Aug. 201280% support ACA

~40% dont understand it~50% not sure if quality will improve

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

22/27

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

23/27

DocSquads.org

Training DoctorsTo Lead

The Health Care Debate

A project of the Dr. Joseph Warren Institute

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

24/27

www.TheBlackRibbonProject.com

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

25/27

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

26/27

7/31/2019 Paving the Road to Health Care Freedom by Reframing the Moral Narrative. Beth Haynes, M.D.

27/27

But along with the genius of our Declaration of

Independence, our Constitution, and our Bill of

Rights, is the equal genius of our economic system.

Our Founding Fathers endeavored to create a moral

and just society like no other in history, and out of

that grew a moral and just economic system the likes

of which the world had never seen. Our freedom,

what it means to be an American,

has been defined and sustained by

the liberating power of the free

enterprise system. June 12, 2012, St. Louis