Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Archive
of S
ID
!"#$%&'()*+*,-(./0*12(34(5.+6$'4(+7(8+9+:;24(<21+=>()?"+@;(5!=*A(<3+'
!"#$%&'()*+,$-%./01$.2345
!"#$%&'()"*+,-."/012345"*67%"809:
;!"<#=2345<(+>5/?-'@*:ABC123450/D4(EF
6&789
5G45"*'H0IG09JI"K#LF"M%(N"O>"MN0935"<0:G#2>"(+29I"G5"P'509-I"Q'0-."R4"*S'"80T0UFG4"<GA0-V"W/4G"O76XR4""""Y:0Z>"[*F0Z9\"M,-Z."P'4"G5"M9]V#^"<0:
/?-'@"_#`A"8G#."G5"MJS)"K06+\4R4"a6+L^"<0:b0c,34"<0:5(U:4G"A"0:#'G0-N"*\4(T"d'(T"/?-'@"<4(I"('eCMN4"WfAG"O76X"R4"*J'#3#'G0-N"g'4G"<0:
"fAG"R4"/50h+N4"0I"M9,c`"i?%"5(S'AG !"#$%&"$'(!)*$+,-.*^?)0I"W"G5"P'4fAG[""""""H0ZI"MZ9,c`"i?Z%"<4G45"D4(Z29C"<A(Z93"ON"0'"A5"QT0]F"R4"#'G0-N"(:
*^"O+j0N5#)W1'5"b(T"R4"*'0:(9k+^"<4G45"#'G0-N"(:"(MN4""""""""('0ZN(I"*ZlGmI"(9n0ZF"0Z:(9k+^R4"*ZS'"G5"(Z99kF"o?Z34"MN4"PS6^A"?-+J:"p:"0I"a^0,F"G5"O>
*^"Oq0J^"P'4"O>"?)0I"O+)45"0:(9k+^MN09N"/R#\"G5"?34#F?)0I"M96:4"mr0\"<G4elWK?^"[G#s-^"P'?IOI"#'G0-N"<R0N""""""4G"MZ97I0`"PZ'4"0Z'#C"p+ZJ9N"tZ'"D4#-%
*^"p:4(VM.(V"A"84(T0u^"O>"5R0NOI"/?-'@"<0:O+JX(I"8G#.5#)"oG5"(F"W""""""tZ'"R4"tZ9^0-'5"K?Z^"tZ'"[p+ZJ9N"*'0'#C"5(S'AG"R4"/50h+N4"0I"Oq0]^"P'4"G5
"G4mV4"i(3"t6>"OI"vwNA"/?'5(l"Or4G4"0h^0C"x(T"O,N#F"0I"80T0UFG4"/R#\"G5"#'G0-N/0&(#"""""0-ZN"PZ'4"&Z7+u^"<4mZX4"84(Zn4"*NG(I"OI"""G5"(1'?ZS'"(ZI"#'Gy
"O>"5#)"P99,F"0F"MN4"/?)"O+j45(C"&7+u^"M9,zA*7j45"{q0j03"?9q#F"""O,ZN#F"[MZqA5"OX5#I"Y'4mV4"0'"A"5G45"4G"Y'4mV4"P'(+29I"*'0:(9k+^"O|"(9n0F"MLF
*^"(n0+^"(+29I"4G"Mj0N('R"84m9E=F"?9q#F"0'"?-> !MN09N"0'"A"MqA5"*+'06\"<0:}M9V0,^"A"i4Aq0^"<0:*F09"~O'0^(N"0'A""""""OZ|"OZI"*Z.#�j"YZuI"<G4eZl
*^"8G#.?)0I"?34#FW
&7:16;*<"=$>"fAG"[#'G0-N"[p+J9N"*'0'#C"#$80T0UFG4"[
,?@(&A(%
Y9C" 0:#'G0-N" 0'"*'#l"O9U)"(+29I" [OS7I"?-+J93" /?-'@" 5(U:4G
O9z(V" OI/?-'@" 5G#^" G5" *'0:8A0h+^" <0:OI" O>" ?34"8G#.
/B'AO+JX(I"<4(I"<4M.(V" A"84(T0u^"<R0N"5#X#^"<0:
/R#\" G5*^" *\4(T" �0j" <5(U:4G" <0:?3#)& '" W"(:
*^"*'0:(9k+^"<4G45"#'G0-N"0I"a^0,F"G5"0:(9k+^"P'4"O>"?)0I
"A"?-+J:"p:"(9n0F"0:(9k+^R4"*S'"G5"(99kF"o?34"MN4"PS6^
*^"Oq0J^"P'4"O>"?)0I"O+)45"0:(9k+^"('0N"(I"*lGmI"G5"?34#F
MN09N" /R#\?)0I" M96:4" mr0\" <G4el" WK?^"#'G0-N" <R0N
OI*^" p:4(V" 4G" M97I0`" P'4" 0'#C" p+J9N"t'" D4#-%"O>" 5R0N
"�/?-J'#3/?E%G4580UF0S^"�()*)+,-()+.-/01)*--23-4
M.(V"A"84(T0u^OI"/?-'@"<0:O+JX(I"8G#.5#)"oG5"(FW
"A" 54(V4" <#N" R4" <G013#'G0-N" G5" *FA0h+^" <0:5(S'AG
D0^R0N"YN(C"_#3"OI"0-I"t'(:"O>"/?)"50E-29C"&7+u^"<0:
/01'0C"OI"*N(+N5"D4m9^" [<G013#'G0-N"*7.4"_#z#^" 0'"<0:
*^"�0u+34"D0l(Uj"{�uF"D4m9^"A"54?,F" [/545?3#)W"*S'
fAG"R4mFG4#)"(+9C"fAG"*J'#3#'G0-N"g'4G"<0: N#^"OI"i#
" G0>A"�J>"*30EX" OSU)};"#$" ~MN4W"(:"fAG"P'4" G5
D4(29C"<A(93"ON" 0'"A5"QT0]F"R4"#'G0-N�i?%"<4G45"M9,c`
*^" O+j0N" H0I5#)&;'" W"?'0I" 4?+I4" �9F(F" P'4" OI
56 7898+:;3*<)+9=>6 "?-@)?:#A(./8((:$89<-+,B6 C+.D8+
*67%"O^0-7�V!*2:ABC
%+<"B#$<$C:D$E3"73$F"3G+"'9$6+"HI$-J$-K"LMN"!,OP,
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
!"#$%&'()*$+,#(-.$/")01$%2(345673$+0(089$:;<0'&$2=$/:(>53=$(?$@(A(B.&=
C
i?%M9,c`*34(LI"<0: 5#)"{u2^O>"P99,F"MEX0E3@"R4
*^"/50h+N4"*FA0h+^"<0:5(S'AG5#)"W"Q^0X"fAG"t'"/50h+N4
<5#E)" dc-^" *U9>(F" 5(S'AG" R4;Gel(I" G0n@" a97LFA�
*^?)0I" WpE^"O>"*^01-:i?%"P'(FM9,c`dc-^"A"0:"O>"*'0:
*^" m'06+^" p:" R4" 4G" 0:#'G0-N"D5(>" G0I(C" ?)"{u2^" ?-->
M7SN4"<0:?3AG"A"<?97>"a^4#%"OI"_#XG"0I"0:#'G0-N"<?-I
" 4(X4" aI0`" /?)" *'0N0-)MN4" W" O>" *^01-:"0I" 0:#'G0-N
"5(>" {u2^" *%#3" OI" ?'0I" ?-+V0'" O,N#F" (+29I" 809rmX
M'#qA4A"*7.4"80%#z#^"R4"i4?>"(:"G5"/?)"*'0N0-)"<0:
*^" (s3" OI" G#T" O|" 0:#'G0-N�9N@" O|" �?NG<('eC"*'0:
"<AG"*lGmI"(9n0F"(9k+^"i4?>"o?34"(99kF"OS-'4"A"5G45"5#XA
" 5(S'AG" R4" /50h+N4" 0I" O>" 5G45" O%#6=^" a>"p+J9N" *'0'#C
*^MV0'"MN5"g'0+3"P'4"OI"D4#F&�A�'W
4mX4<i?%" OI" OX#F" 0I" 0:#'G0-NM9,c`*^"&'(,F" 0:?3#)"W
i?%M9,c`"O,N#F"a^0)"84(I0u^"/R#\"G5"/?)"&'(,F"<0:
Mj0N('R"M,-." P+V(l" (s3" G5" aI0]^" G5" *F4(I0u^" <0:
OI" 84(I0u^" *+,-." /R#\" t'" D4#-%MN4"M9,c`" i?%" A
\"(1'5/R#\" R4"M'06M'#qA4"*+,-."<0:"G4R0I" (I4(I" G5" G45
"*+I0`G}54R@"~*^"(s3?^"<#'G0-N"*7.4"<4mX4"A"?)0I"C7
AMj0N('R !E}i?%" 0I" (�0-+^"('R" O,N#F" M9,c`
Mj0N~A84m9E=F !E}i?%" 0I" (�0-+^"R4"M'06\"M9,c`
/R#\M'#qA4"<0:G45" ~*^MN09N" O>" ?)0I"<AG"*q06%4"<0:
DA(I"<0:(9k+^"OT#I(^"<#'G0-N"*7.4"<0:(9k+^" G0+VG" (I" 4R
MV(l"?:4#j"G4(`"*NG(I"5G#^W
4?$Q=<RS$@B7T7S
"G5" *F4�" M9,c`" i?%" 0:#'G0-N" R4" /50h+N4" a9q5" P9qA4
Y9CA" <(13Y9CMN4" *-9I" W"G5" 80%�T4" i06F" M`A" �9:
p+J9N" 0I" ?'0I" A" MJ93" MN5�#)@" �'4()G5" 0:�
/(s+-^(9�AO>"<4Y9C"aI0`"(9�"�0F4�?)"AG"OI"AG"?-+J:"*-9I"W
D@" R4" /50h+N4" A" M9,c`" i?%" QI0-^" Mj0-)" 0I" 0:#'G0-N"0:
OIO'0C" D4#-%/?-'@"�0N4A[a'?I" <0:"Y]3" <0h'4"�0N4" (I
i?%M9,c`*^"O+j0N"5#X#^"<0:?3#)W
56 !+.9.3)?:A/38+9)./91>6 /9A.9.D8:F-G.3B6 !+-((: 4H)39:I/)?1(.(J6 !*-)(
"v'(F0^"#$MN4"�c`" 0'"M9,c`" i?%" ?,IA5" (I" *-+U^"W
G0E|" (13023" K#7N" G0E|�c`" R4" a'?I" �9>(F"A5" <0:
i?%"G#L^" 0'"dc-^"<A0\" 0E3@" R4"t'"(:" O>"?-+J:"M9,c`
D0S^4" /?-'@" t'MN4" ('eC" W"�JI" A" x()" G#L^" (:" vwN
*^*^"(1'5"*+q0\"0'"a^0>"D0+N45"t'"OI"a'?UF"A"?I0'"A"5#)
"�LI" *3#30>" A"<m>(^" Oq0J^" 0'" p96�F"<0:?^09C" 5G#^" G5
*^5#)&y'W
" /0l?'5" R4D#+3#:" A"�0:y"i?%" P99,F" *7.4" 5(S'AG" ON" [
R4"?-FG0U%"0:#'G0-N"x4(T"80JN#^"P9I"G5"M9,c`&�A�'�
<5#E)"dc-^�
?3AG"(I"84(9n0F"a97LF"dc-^�
Gel(I"G0n@"a97LF"dc-^�
" *7.4" 5(S'AG" A5" �9>(F" R4" [P929C" 80,q0c^" G5�"dc-^
<5#E)" �" A�Gel" (I" G0n@"a97LF" �M9,c`" i?%"P99,F" G5"<0:
MN4" /?)" /50h+N4"80T0UFG4" /R#\" Wi0l" O>"OI"D@"*7.4"<0:
*^"('R"x()?)0I&�A�'�"MJu3"i0lK"0:#'G0-N"*7.4"m>(6F"D5(>"P)AG"A"<R0NG0S)@
}*7.4"YN(C~
"iA5"i0lK80T0UFG4"�R#\"G5"G4el(9n0F"<?97>"a^4#%"*'0N0-)
"i#N"i0lK<?97>"a^4#%"Gel(I"G0n@"a97LF
" iG0E|" i0lKi?%" �0N4(I" *]c-^" �#|G0|" 50='4M9,c`"<0:
"/?)"*'0N0-)
"p=-C"i0lKO�u2^"D5(>"G0I(CD0+N45"O,N#F"A"*7.4"<0:"<4(I"0:
"0:#'G0-N"R4"t'(:
i?%" &9.#F" OI" O^454G5" O>M9,c`MN4" /?)" O+j45(C" 0:
&�A�'W
4$?,E7UVW$G&D$X7Y0!"=
4?,?,$Z*.N"[($\N"A($+)$]LUBY$E^"3._`$aN"b($@N$Z*.N"[(
$]LUBY$c`0d$aN"b($@N
5G45"G4(`"('R"�?6%"/0l?'5"A5"&9T"P'4"(N"A5"G5"�
W*:0l?'5"�R#\"4G"84(I0u^"A"80T0UFG4"<GA0-V"O>
"G#2>" O,N#F" 50,I4" (1'5" <4(I" R0N?-634#F" *+,-.
*^?345"W
L6 MA((:N:M-/9-/O6 /9A.9.D8:F-G.3P6 E+8/Q: 4H)39:I/)?1(.(R6 !+-((: 4H)39:I/)?1(.(
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
D.(*$%"E#%;F8G$;H3$I:=&J3(73$K#(),L*$II%&'()*$'$4,M$!(3N&(EOI$/&(PQR$I$S(56?(.TUVT
V
;W<GA0-V" O>" *:0l?'5^" A"80T0UFG4" <0:"4G" 84(I0u
*^" ?q#^"*+,-."YuI"OI02^" [AG"P'4" R4" A" ?N0-)
/R#\"(1'5"(s3"G5"*+,-."<0:*^5(9l"W
4?,?46`0d$ `*$ Ee<)$ E_"Hd$)"f_*$ \N"A($ +)$ g[LB($ %"=
$]LN"W+$+*`"N$h_*.I
/R#\"�0u+34"*13#1|"�'(2F"OI"?,I"P'4M'#qA4"<0:"A"G45
*^"D4('4"84(I0u^"M,-."G5"MqA5"Y]3"P99UF"(1309I"A"5R45(C
"(I" 4G"5#j"M'06\"A"�#h3"MqA5" [/?-'@"G5"O>"MN4"(^4"P'4
/R#\" R4" <54?,F" <AG"5#j" �u+-^" A" M'#qA4" 5G#^" <0:
*^"K06%4*^"<R0N54R@" G4R0I" O>"D@" 0'"?->/R#\"A" 5#)"<0:
*^"P99,F"G4R0I"R093"dI0c^"M'#qA4"<4G45?3#)& �'W
4$?4]iR_<<$"=E_)<&2(Q=<RS$%"=
R4*lB'A" O76X" P'4" <0:[Oq0]^/?-'@" O,N#F"<GA0-V" <G013
"0h^0C"x(T"G5"80T0UFG4MN4M6J`"G5"O>"�9F(F"P'?I"*'0:
R4"d9]LF"R4O2]3"A"/�A(C"80%�T4"<0:#'G0-N"*+j0-)"<0:
O2]3" A" /?)" /50h+N4" 0h^0C" x(T" 80T0UFG4" <GA0-V"D@" <0:
O]7\A"a96SFO+V(l"(s3"G5"0E3@"<4(I"G#jR0I"<0:"MN4"/?)
?-)0I"O+)45"a97LF"M97I0`"0FW
"G0E|"K?^" G5" ('eC" D0S^4"<0'#C" #'G0-N" G0E|" Oq0]^"P'4" G5
"*q#7N"#$"fAG"R4"/50h+N4"0I"vwN"MN4"/?)"/545"�JI
/?)"O+j45(C"#'G0-N"t'"a97LF"OI"p+J9N"*'0'#C[#'G0-N<
O9U)" OT#I(^" G5" #'G0-N" 4mX4" <G4el(9n0F" A" /?)" <R0Ny
"&7+u^"Mq0\i(3"R4"/50h+N4"0I"G4(`"*NG(I"5G#^"p9J3A"G4mV4
MN4" O+V(lWvwN#'G0-N" ON" a97LF<"M'0E3" G5" A" (1'5
"K#>#^"*F@"80]9]LF"OI"p:"0I"#'G0-N"G0E|"OJ'0]^"A"�9>(F
MN4" /?)" W*^" /?-'@" G5"D0]]L^" O>"MN4" (>�" OI" iRH"?-34#F
"?^"4G"<(+29I"�I4AG"A"4mX4A"/545"O,N#F"4G"0:#'G0-N"R(^"(s3
?-:5"G4(`W
4$?O"=0_+"B3$%"j#$ _.T!
i?%" A5" QT0]F" R4"�R#\" G5" /?)" &'(,F" <?97>" M9,c`
*^"?9q#F"#'G0-N"G0E|" [84(I0u^"aS)"G5"O>" 5#) "G45#63
"*7%"!MN4" /?)"/545"Y'063" 0:#'G0-N"P'4"*q#7,^" W"Q`4A"G5
i?%"OI"OX#F"0I"*'#'G0-N"<0$V"(:"G5M9,c`"OI"<?97>"<0:
<4mX4"&9.#F"G5"O>" /?)"O+j45(C" 0E3@"P9I"�I4AGA"#'G0-N
<#'G0-N" &9.#F" OI" O^454 "M9,c`" i?%" (9n0F" MLF" O>
/R#\" R4" M'06\A" Mj0N('R" O,N#F"*F0^?jA" *+,-." <0:
"�0jMN4p+J9N" *'0'#C" K?^R4" /50h+N4" 0I" D@" a97LF" A
*^" O+j45(C5#)W"80]9]LF" OI" 0:#'G0-N" ('0N"a97LF" A"�JI
*^"K#>#^"*F@5(lA"5*7%"G45#63"Or4G4"OI"0=-'4"G5 "*q#7,^
"809I(=FA" A"809I54" O,q0c^" R4" /50h+N4" 0I" O>" 0:#'G0-N" ('0N
*^" 0h+>4"MN4" /?)"�4(u+N4" 0:G#2>" (1'55#)&�" A �"!
'W
"<#'G0-N"*7.4"<4mX4 "OI"M9,c`"i?%"?,I"A5"OI"OX#F"0I
"KA?X"x() *^?)0IW
4?O?,$%0_+"B3$ _.T!,$>$@N$Z*.N"[($]LUBY$E^"3._`$aN"b(
6`0d$`*$E_"Hd$<g[LB($%"=
"f(+Jl"(I"[84(I0u^"�R#\"G5"MqA5"MN09N"Mq0\"P'4"G5
OSU)"*7.4"GA0I"A"MN4"/?)"m>(6+^"*F4(I0u^"80^?j"A"0:
O,N#F"*F4(I0u^"Mj0N('R"O>"MN4"D@"(I*^"O+V0'"(1'5"?34#F
/R#\?2uI"0]FG4"4G"*+,-."<0:"WN5"R4"[GA0I"P'4"�0N4"(I"M
"OI"[*F0%�T4"A"*F0T0UFG4"G0+j0N('R"OI"*I09+N5"G5"D0^R"D545
M.(V"D545"MN5"R4"<0-,^"G#2>"Q'0-."(1'5"O>"MN4"*'0:
OI*^"MN5" R4" O,N#F"�N0-^"Mj0N('R" P+)4?3" a9q5?-:5"W
*63"O>"5G45"M96:4"/R4?34"D@"0F"Oq0J^"P'4"*+\"4G"D0^R"D4#F
"�?-->?9q#F"OI"D0^R"D545"<0EI"OI84m9E=F"?9q#F"<4(I"*7j45
!E545"MN5"R4" W"5#XA"OI"*^#6%"GA0I"P'4"#'G0-N"P'4"G5
b?:"*7.4"M,h-^" O>"MN4" /?^@"O3" [G#2>" G5" /?)"<G4el
"[*F4(I0u^"A"*F0T0UFG4"84m9E=F"fA(V"A"?9q#F"R4"5#N"�J>
"*F4(I0u^"84m9E=F"<(9lG0>" OI"�0N4(I"M,h-^"�J>" OS7I
MN4" G#2>" M,-." a>" G5" W5G4A"0I" *F4(I0u^" 84m9E=F" 84
<GA0-V"P'(F?'?X?)"?:4#j"�X#^"0935"RAG"<0:"D4('4"O>
<GA0-V" R4" /50h+N4"A"*F4(I0u^"Mj0N('R"G5"b0S)" [#3"<0:
/?6%?)0I" O+)4?3" *30EX" �cN" 0I" <4" W"O>" K06+\4" P'4
/01-IOr4G4"<0:OI"*F0T0UFG4"80^?j" �?-:5"G5"Y345" 5#U3"a9q5
|"A"/?-'@"8H#LF"�#�j<GA0-V"(6%�j("QV0-^"�'0C(I"A"0:
O'0^(N" OI" [Gel5AR/R#\"G5"<G4el"?-->" i4?`4"�N0-^03"<0:
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
!"#$%&'()*$+,#(-.$/")01$%2(345673$+0(089$:;<0'&$2=$/:(>53=$(?$@(A(B.&=
CW
#N"t'" R4AA"M9V(�" 50='4" OI" R093"P9-�6:"G5"<?-634#F
/R#\MI0`G" M97I0`" O>" *'0:/01-I" <4(I" *'H0I" <('eC"<0:
M'#qA4"[(1'5"<#N"R4"[?3G45"*30EX"�.(%"G5"G#2>"<G4el
G#+N5"G5"4G"/545"G4(`"MqA5"G0>AM'#qA4"P'4"O+Uq4"G5"<G4el
v'A(N"A"80^?j"�R#\"P'4"R4"A"5#I"?:4#j"*+j0N('R"<0:
/01-I"[AG"50='4"G#2>"G5"O-9^R"P'4"G5"*cN#+^"A"t|#>"<0:
?)"?:4#jW
"?-+V0'"O,N#F"(+29I"809rmX"0I"0:#'G0-N"O>"*^01-:"K0\(:"OI
"*7.4"80%#z#^" 5(>"{u2^"*%#3" OI"?'0IAM'#qA4"<0:
(:"G5"/?)"*'0N0-)t'*^"(s3"OI"G#c|"0:#'G0-N"R4"�?NG
�9N@" O|<('eC"i4?>" o?34" (99kF" OS-'4A" 5G45" 5#XA" *'0:
"R4" /50h+N4" 0I" O>" 5G45" O%#6=^" a>" <AG" *lGmI" (9n0F" (9k+^
*^"p+J9N"*'0'#C"5(S'AGMV0'"MN5"g'0+3"P'4"OI"D4#F& �'W
$\8I,$kZ*.N"[($c`0d$%"=0_+"B3$%"j#
*+,-."/R#\"OI0�^"OI"84(I0u^ "Mj0N"('R"OI0�^"OI"84(I0u^*+,-.
/R#\"R4"M'06\�0j"*+,-."<0:
STUV:TW:XYZ[:X\]^V_`abc:d]e
fg]hc:fg:iWjg]`ckalbm:STUV
nUobc:fg:dnWpq:f\]cjrkstW[:iWuvYUw:flrUw
S]xbg:djvq:yz{|n}g:d]e
jg:]e:S]xbg:}~j^wuvYUw
kalbm:dnWpq:X\UYZW
iWuvYUw:TW:X\]^VkstW[
�U�V:�]o�:[U���gdjz�:XvzY]c
k�n]t:d]e:S]xbg:]g:dn]z e��W[:�]�a�W:nUobc:fg
dnWpq:f\]cjr:�p�k�n]t
iWjg]`c:Xlbm:u{n
iW[nWZ:X\[Zu�c [ZnZ:dWjg:d}\n:fc]�jgk�]��:d]enWT]g:fg
�
��
��
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
fg]hc:fg:iWjg]`ckalbm:STUV
�`g:inu�:�\W}�WkmU�t
dT]r:kmU�tiWjg]`c:Xlbm
[WT�:nWT]g:[]�a�W
uvYUw:jg:}~j^wkag]�n:d]��:[]�\W
nU�~:n[
iWuvYUw:TW:X\]^VkstW[ �U�V:�]o�:[U��g
djz�:XvzY]c
yv��w:Z:ka\]^V:���XYZ[:djq
S]xbg:dub^�WUw:�\W}�WkstW[:d]e
d]e:S]xbg:]g:dn]z^e�]�a�W:nUobc:fg:k�n]t
kb�:��W[
�
�
�
�
�
�
� �
�
�
�
Xt]r:j\T:flrUwkwWjg]`c:d]e
XYZ[:���:�e]~
d]enUwWj�W:nU�Vk�n]t
]g:u\u�:d]en]~:Z:_�~:[]�\Wi]cut:f�WnW:jg:}~j^w
kwWjg]`cub�:d]e:S]xbg:nU�VnU�~:n[:kavsc
�`g:nU�V:�\W}�WkmU�t �j�:Xlbm:Xv^eW:�\W}�W
i]���W:dnZ]b�:Z:nW}�W
iW[nWZ:�\W}�W
nWT]g:d]��:[]�\Wkag]�n
uvYUw:�vl�wkstW[:�]qubb~
n[:dnWpq:f\]cjriW}v��w:u\jt
[WT�:nWT]g:[]�a�W
�
���
�
�
�
6
�
�
�
�
�
�
!E iW}v��w:iW[nWZ
!E �]�at]r:j\T
�
!E iW}v��w
�nZ]b�:iW}v��w:uvYUwi]�]�wnWZ:i]���W
�nZ]b�:iW}v��w:iWn[]mi]�]�wnWZ:i]���W �
�
6�
"C7
�
�
�
f�[UgZ:�nWpq:f\]cjrjx\[:�]e:�`g
i]���W:�nZ]b�:f�[Ug:y��aYZ[:jv�:�`g:i]�]�wnWZ
jv�:�`g:�nWpq:f\]cjrXt]r:j\T:n[:�aYZ[
j\T:�`g:Xv^eW:X���iW}v��w:uvYUw:fg:Xt]r
��
jv�:�`g:�nWpq:f\]cjriW}v��w:uvYUw:n[:�aYZ[
�
6
XYZ[:X\] V
��
j\T:fg:�Ugjc:f�[UgXt]r
iW}v��w:uvYUw:f�[Ug
�nZ]b�:f�[Ug:y�XYZ[:i]�]�wnWZ:i]���W
�
�
�
6
*+I0`G"G4R0I"50='4
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
D.(*$%"E#%;F8G$;H3$I:=&J3(73$K#(),L*$II%&'()*$'$4,M$!(3N&(EOI$/&(PQR$I$S(56?(.TUVT
CT
$F<&l,$k$%0_+"B3$%*ml*$X_.U!,
K*0BDEI"no*$F&($+)$.7pL($G"o?K"_.l
q.I
Mj0N('R"O,N#F0: !E: /�+):;9+A39A+8(
"YuI"G5"5#X#^"Mj0N('R"D4m9^"(9k+^"P'4 !E*^"D023"4G?:5"W"D@"Y=-N"?\4A/(EI"54(V4"?.G5MN4"O,^0X"G5"Mj0N('R"R4"?-^"W"O+)el"?3AG"D5GA@"MN5"OI"<4(I
Mj0N('R"[Mj0N('R"O,N#3"G5"M3(+-'4"A"*�u)"(F#9w^0>"[/4(6:"Ph7F"[Ph7F"<0:/?)"O+V(l"(s3?34W
"/R#\"G5"84G50. !E !E: ¡H-+9
!"#$%&' !"()*+ ,"#$- !".- ,*/0 "( (1/2 3" 4(*5 6789) : ;<" =&>? @"A7B?" C8D C)*EF?" .G1H I3(" 8J"K 3" ("8L- :67 A$MF- ;<" B%N @(*$O- ,"1>P
6LQ>- @*9("3*7 () (1/2 (1RJ .7*<3("B?" C8D S*TF0" .0*%N K @":
C31J () !")("K !" !"# $%&'( !"#$%&' !")("K ,"#$- !".- ,*/0 "( (1/2 4(*5 3"89) : ;<" =&>? @"A7
B?" C8D C)*EF?" .G1H I3(" 8J"K 3" ("8L-:
!"#$%&' 8$G1' !" !"#)'&*+,(-&. !"#$%&' 8$G1' ,"#$- A$MF- ;<" !".- ,*/0 "( (1/2 U5") ()89) : =&>? @"A7
C8D C)*EF?" .G1H I3(" 8J"K 3" ("8L- ;<"B?":
=T7 C)K#V" I3(" !" !"#/01+2#3**2*
("8L- ;$$O' @"A745)=T7 C)K#V" I3(" WXN IK( 3" Y8- ;<" () C)*EF?" *9B?" C8D :B?" !"A7*T- 67 Z17A- [F\$? ,1] *&><" () =T7 K) 67 C)K#V" I3("
=T7 A<*? K !"A7*T- =T7 C)K#V" I3("B?" C8D ^$_E' *9 :
A<*? C)K#V" I3("=T7*96(72'# )0'(# /01+23**2*
=T7 () 60`*? C)K#V" I3(" C8>9) ,*/0 A$a @*9 !"B?":
45)45)67 62 B?" .b5") cG*5*0 8$G1' (1/2 @)*dFe" 8D( .7*<3(" B%N @(*$O- ,"1>P
B?" C8D C)*EF?" Y8- (): () .+1d5 =T7 6<*-A?
!"8&.#4&9# !" .92:($2.(
6<*-A? U2 C31J () .+1d5 =T7 @("fg !".- ,*/0 "(89):
() .+1d5 =T7 6<*-A?B5*?A<3
.;'0#<('+,(+'2#8&.4&92'.$2.(01 .92:($2.(
6<*-A? 3" .FX\e C8>9) ,*/0 B5*?A<3 C31J () 62 B?" .+1d5 =T7 @("fghA+.-)1D:
() .+1d5 =T7 6<*-A?!"#$%&'
=>+-%#)'&*+,(-&.#8&.4&92'.$2.(01# .92:($
6<*-A? 3" .FX\e C8>9) ,*/0 8$G1' C31J () 62 B?" .+1d5 =T7 @("fg .'"A7*T- !"#$%&'hA+.-)1D:
B<*XJ<+%%&'(,*/0B<*XJ C8>9)i"K 6EGj- K) @"(") 62 B?" .+1d5 =T7 3" BGK) @*9 @*9
B$V*O- K .FGK)B?" .'*$G*- @*9:i"K*9?&0.: A$MF- ;<"i"K ,"#$- C31J () .+1d5 =T7 67 BGK) @*9 !".- ,*/0 "(89):
.'*$G*- B$V*O-"0@ C31J () .'*$G*- B$V*O- kG*l- U2 m1X&- An0*/0 A$MF- ;<" !"B?" Y*? ^< (): 6<*-A? U2 =T7 .+1d5
B5*?A<3 ()"&(01# <84 ,*/0 A$MF- ;<"6<*-A? m1X&- C8>9) C31J () .+1d5 =T7 @("fg K B5*?A<3
B<*XJB?" BX\e ;<" () .FGK) @*9:6<*-A? U2=T7 .+1d5
!"#$%&' ()"&(01#=)84 ,*/0 A$MF- ;<"6<*-A? m1X&- C8>9) !"#$%&' 8$G1' C31J () .+1d5 =T7 @("fg
B<*XJ KB?" BX\e ;<" () .FGK) @*9: () BGK) 6N)17 U2 !""&(01#4&9# !"#A+*B2( C31J () BGK) 60`*? 6N)17 A$MF- ;<" !".- ,*/0 "(89):
6<*-A? B%N BGK) 6N)17C.FGK) @("fg82(#4&9# !"#A+*B2(
i"K A\2 3" A$MF- ;<".- B?) 67 6N)17 3" .FGK) @*9,*/0 K 8<o6N)17 U2 C8>9) @" C31J () BGK) p?1' 62 B?" !"6<*-A?.- @("fg)1D:
.F5*?A<3 6N)17 !" .;'0#<('+,(+'2#A+*B2(.- B5*?A<3 =T7 hA+ 62 B?" BGK) cG*5 6N)17 3" ./T7)1D: () BGK) .'"#$%q' 6N)17
!"=>+-%$2.(# )'&*+,(-&.A+*B2(
.- !"#$%&' =T7 hA+ 62 B?" BGK) cG*5 6N)17 3" ./T7)1D:
=T7 B$X9" Bl\0 =T7 67 B5*?A<3
!"#$%&' .;'0#<('+,(+'2#D0(-&
B<1GK" ,"#$- Bl\0 ;<" =T7 *7 r*$e () "( B5*?A<3 =T7 67 BGK) .9).- cT/- !"#$%&'8>2:
!"#$%&'()*+,'-$.
'!/01234'56)67&'839:;
sU$bq'K 6<#&' @"A7 .DK( [F\$? .<*<1H )A_<K( 6G*\- UJ
K6$lD.- [F\$? @3*?8D*7EtF: @"A7 .DK( ^$>_' ;<"
[F\$? U$bq' K 6<#&'6$lD ^X2 67 C8$u$H Uv*\-K *9 @3*?
67 @A'1$w-*2.- (*XD)K(EtxF 69) () 62tyz{ p?1'
AF?(*Vt C*n/0") ()G "BV*< 6O?1'Et|F67 K AdFT- (1}
HC I&''2:(2'www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
!"#$%&'()#*+"',-#.!(/0#$1'234562#*/'/78#9:;/&%#1<#.9'=42<#'>#?'@'A-%<
BC
.- C8D 6G1-AV IK( ^< [F\$? .<*<1H IK( BEg ,"1'
@"#N" U$bq'K 6<#&' @"A7 ~?*>- @"(") 62 B?" .XF\$?
6LbJK .LQ>- @*>7A<3 s.G1bO-K .bP p7"K( (153*7 @*9
8>F\9 :.g�<K ;<" 62 C8D �<AO' B?() 1<(*>? ^<() *9
.- [/] 67)(15EtzF: 3" C)*EF?" @*<"#- ;<" 67 "( )A_<K(
.- A<3 �AD)AXD A7 ,"1'Et�F�
t�Y8- 8><"AV () @)*LF0"K .b$bq' )A_<K( U$G) 673*? ;<" s@
.- [9"AV [F\$? (*F5*? 3" @AF%7 �() 8><"AV8>2:
��Y8- .X2 @*9A$MF- ,)A2 )("K ,*_-" [F\$? .<*<1H @*9
67 "( .E$2K.- [9"AV [F\$? () ,*-#X9 (1}8>2:
K)[F\$? AF%7 [%V @"A7 62 @("#7" C)*EF?" )(1- *<1H @*9
.- ("Ae.- ,*<AN (")1X0K .G1bO-K .bP (")1X0 )A$g8D*7:
'!<5=7>?@$'5>A'.,B7C+
.bP (")1X0 ;$7 .bP p7"K( 62 B?" @(")1X0 .G1bO-
.- ,*/0 .g)*? 67 "( [F\$? @*9A$MF-89) : s("#7" ;<" *7
Y8-C)*? )"AV" .>9� @*9.- �() A')1DEt�F:
*%0o ;$7 p7"K( K [F\$? A7 ("fgA�" @*9AF-"(*H 4"ATF?" @"A7
.bP (")1X0 [?( (1�>- 67 � m1�1- 6>$/$HK !*$7)" 3" .G1bO-
67 6N1' *7 "#N" ;<" ,)17 W0*- K W-*NK B?" C8D C)*EF?"
.- ;$$l' �Lq- p?1' [F\$? C8D ;$$O' 3A-)1D : (")1X0
.bP� U_D () .G1bO-�>? [F\$? ^< @"#N" s "( *<1H .<1<(*
.- A<1d' 67 80(") U7*LF- 6Q7"( An<8_< *7 628/2: @*9A$MF-
YK8N () Y8- () C8D 6FVAg(*2 67t67 .VAO- Z1\l- (1}
B?" C8D:
'! D)6EF'.,B7C+
An<8_< *7 [F\$? ^< @*9A$MF- ;$7 U-*O' C1q0 s(")1X0 ;<"
.- ,*/0 "(.-K 89) Y8- ^< 6O?1' @"A7 .<*>l- 80"1' .X2
8D*7 : C(*l0" i1%E- K) *7 .<*>Do s,*<AN (")1X0 [$?A' ()
B?" @(KA� ,*<ANK:
=9*2 *< =<"#V" *9A$MF- 3" .5A7 ("8L- [F\$? A9 ()
.- *%0o 67 62 87*<JC(*l0" @*9A$MF- @"�CA$5��J.- 6FEg)1D :
*9A$MF- ;<" =9*2 *< =<"#V" �A0J,*<ANJ.- C80"15)1D
EtyF:
,*<AN ()Y1-AV 3" (")1X0 ;<" B5*? .E$2 p7"K( s.X2 @*9
B?" C8D C)*EF?" @)8P W7"1'K : U_D� 67 Z17A- ,*<AN
.- ,*/0 "( 6OG*Q- )(1- .<1<(*>? [F\$?89):
G:H<'I'J76.)94'5=7>?@$'5>A'KL@/
!" KLMNOPQ#KLRSLT
!" UVOWXVY#Z[\
]
!" KLMNOPQ
USTV^_#KLMNOPQ#`NabQKVcVdQSLT#KVefcL
USTV^_#KLMNOPQ#KLSRVgKVcVdQSLT#KVefcL ]
]
C]
45)
]
]
]
hiRbjT#USLkl#h[VmZYZn[R#UVo#pqj
KVefcL#USTV^_#hiRbj#rstWaTR#ZNu#pqj#KVcVdQSLT
ZNu#pqj#USLkl#h[VmZYvXVY#Z[\#SR#tWaTR
Z[\#pqj#vNwoL#vdxyKLMNOPQ#`NabQ#hj#vXVY
]]
ZNu#pqj#USLkl#h[VmZYKLMNOPQ#`NabQ#SR#tWaTR
]
C
vaTR#v[Vwz
]]
Z[\#hj#cbjZm#hiRbjvXVY
KLMNOPQ#`NabQ#hiRbj
USTV^_#hiRbj#rsvaTR#KVcVdQSLT#KVefcL
]
]
]
C
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
D-')#$!E"$:F7G#:H2#I9<%J2'62#K"'(+L)#II$%&'()#+M# '2N%'EOI#.%'PQR#I#S'45>'-TUVT
BU
G:H 'I.,B7C+'MH)N+, 'J76.)94'D)6EF/
U_D () 62 (1} ,*X9�.- C8<)s)1D !"#$%&' !" ;<"()
*7 ,o ("8L- 62 B?" C(*l0" ^< Y8- K !")("K U�- .'*0*<AN
!`1dq- 8$G1' !".- =<"#V" 67 @An<) ,*<AN *7 K 87*<
!"#$%&' !"()*+ i*0 !".- =9*2i"K K 87*< B$V*O-K *9
67 .'*$G*-,KA7 A$MF- ,"1>PB?" C8D 6FVAg A�0 () "3:
An<) C(*l0" ^<45).- 62 A$MF- ;<" m10 �*qG 67 62 8D*7
.- .OX&'.- =<"#V" C("1X9 8D*787*< : A$MF- ^< B<*XJ
,KA7.- "3 B?) 67 .'*$G*- B$V*O-K i"K WXN3" 62 8D*7
.- Y8- B$OQe i8P @)1XP 8O7 67 6N1' *7 K 8<o4A8
� B<*XJC31J 3" BGK)~TF>- @*9� @*9("#7" We"K () s
.- .'*$G*- B$V*O-K i"K .F<*XJ B?*$? Y*XP"8D*7 : A$MF-
,KA76<*-A? An<) @"3.- .+1d5 =T7 @*98D*7:
6N)1767 .FGK) @*9,KA7 A$MF- ^< ,"1>P 62 B?" An<) @"3
Y8-() B$OQe i8P .LV" 8O7 67 6N1' *74A8� !"A7*T-
67 ^< ,"1>PB5*?A<3 � Bl\0 sB?*$? ;<" Y*XP" ("#7"
.- B5*? A<3 6O?1' 67 6N)17 c$dT'8D*7 :
B?*$? ;<" 3" ^$-"82 Y*XP" 8<) 8<*7 Y*J i"82 A9 62 *9
@K( @AF/$7 A$�*' 8>F\9 B$OQe i8P )*O7" 3" ._<3" A�*F-
45) .g(#7 A$�*' A$MF- i"82 A$$M' �80" *< K �BD") 89"15
[F\$? "#N" U2 @K( K Y8- B\'3" �H 62 �)(")
6$lD BX\e () ,o .&>?(*lFP" !`"1? ;<" 67 Y8- @3*?
8D 89"15 C)") �?*H:
'!ODP'.)N1A,$'KL@'M2;
=<"#V" "( Y8- 67 )*XFP" B$b7*e s,o (*lFP"K Y8- B\'
.-.- `*7 "( ,o ,)17 @)A7(*2 67 )*XFP" K 89))A7 : (*lFP"
@(*FV( (*lFP"A7 Y8- @(*F5*? .0*-3 *%>' K )(") B<1GK" ,o
.- B?" (*lFP" @"(") Y8- (*F5*? 62 "( Y8- (*FV( (*lFP" ,"1'
)") ("Ae .?(A7 )(1-E�{F:
Y8-.- "( [F\$? .<*<1H @*9C)") ^X2 67 ,"1' @*9
WXN67 C8D @(Ko )1N1- !*$7)" 3" C)*EF?" *7K .0"8$- !(1+
K 8$/T7 (*lFP" K )A2 U<8O' .b_D 67 B\' @"A7 "( @("#7"
)") 6O?1' �bFT- @*91<(*>? ,)A2: ;<" 67 .7*$F?) @"A7
.- Y8- 3" ,*>$X}",1-3o 3" ,"1')A2 C)*EF?" A<3 @*9ExF
!O!/56)Q+'LR'D7@SP
BG*J () Y8- .b+" A$MF- 8>] ("8L- s,1-3o ;<" () @*9
A7"A7 () Y8- B$?*\J ,"#$- K C8D C)") A$$M' �bFT- @8J
;<"8<)Ag .?(A7 !"A$$M' :,*/0 �<*F0 .LQ>- (*FV( C8>9)
)17 @8J !`*J () Y8-:
!"KLMNOPQ !" `NabQ !" KLSRVg
v[Vwz
!" vXVY#Z[\
!" KLRSLT]
45) !"{RTM_L#|\SL
pqj
]
hiRbj#?&&}+%~"-$2�
~"-$2�
~"-$2�6)A� #?&&}+%
Vo#�LT
KVNaVm
]
]~"-$2�
Vo#�LT#?&&}+%
KVNaVm?&&}+%
ZNu#pqj#USLkl#h[VmZYKLMNOPQ#`NabQ#SR#tWaTR2.(
KLMNOPQ`NabQ#hiRbj
vXVY#Z[\#hiRbj
]
ZNu#pqj#USLkl#h[VmZYvXVY#Z[\#h�YbQ#SR#tWaTR
tWaTR#ZNu# !" hiRbj
Z[\#pqj#vNwoL#vdxyKLMNOPQ#`NabQ#hj#vXVY
tWaTR#ZNu#pqj# !"USLkl#h[VmZY
]
]
h[VmZY#?&&}+%
vXVYZ[\#pqj#vNwoL#vdxyKLMNOPQ#`NabQ#?&&}+%
hiRbjT#USLkl#h[VmZYVo#pqj#Z[VY
Z[VY#{RTM_L#|\SLVo#pqj
C
~ Z[\#pqj#vNwoL#vdxyKLMNOPQ#`NabQ#hj#vXVY�
]
C
pqj#h[VmZY#rsKLMNOPQ#SR#�gb�X
pqj#h[VmZY#rsvXVYZ[\#SR#�gb�X
]
]
]
]
]]
~ Z[\#pqj#vNwoL#vdxyKLMNOPQ#`NabQ#hj#vXVY�
C
vaTR# !" hiRbj#rs~Vo#�LT�
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
!"#$%&'()#*+"',-#.!(/0#$1'234562#*/'/78#9:;/&%#1<#.9'=42<#'>#?'@'A-%<
BR
67 @*9A$MF- A<)*L- Y*�- ,"1>P 8ID3<"D�!"�D=
D3" 6s"6"3?#46/=D#A�5�="#A�5�="s?638s
"3�s868# 46/=D8# !"# A�5�=" BG*J 3A- *'
W7*' (*FV(K 8D C)") A$$M' @8J45) W7*' 8<)Ag .?(A7
45) C)A2 �EJ "( )15 .LQ>-K @)1O+ BG*J C("1X9
B?"�U_Dx:�
G:HO'I56)Q+'LR'D7@SP'.)1T.'54.EU$ !"
KAn<) hA} 3" @*9A$MF- A<)*L- 8ID3<"D�!"�D=
D3" 6s"6"3?#46/=D#A�54="#A�54="s?638s
"3�s868#46/=D8# !"#A�54=" @8J BG*J 3A- *'
W7*' (*FV(K 8D C)") A$$M' !" =�� )G=8" .?(A7
W7*' 8<)Ag !"# =�� )G=8"<K .GK#0 BG*J C("1X9
B?" C)A2 �EJ "( )15 .LQ>-�U_D|:�
G:HV'I.)1T.'54.EU'$'56)Q+LR'D7@SP#$%&'()#"*'+%
!O!<D7@SPKL@'J,WF,'5XYU'J)#
Y8- A<3 67 Y8-s ,1-3o ;<" ()C)*? @*9 �w? sC8D [$\L' A'
B\' .EbFT- @*9�6bXN 3"B\'.<*%0 8J @*9 � @K(
Y8- A<3 3" ^<A9Y8- A<3 *F<*%0 s6FVAg i*&0" *9 Y8- () *9
B?" C8D C)") ("Ae .<*%0:
!O! K$LF'J.)ZS)4'D7@SPJBLA'J)#
6P1X&- [9 @K(A7 *9A$MF- 3" .5A7 A�" .?(A7 @"A7 3" @"
8<o .- B?) 67 ,*gAl5 A�0 �l} 62 @)8P YK"8N *< W7"1'
*EF?" )(1-s.- ("Ae C))A$g : A<)*L- 8<*7 @(*g3*? ,1-3o ()
62 .'(1+ () K )") ("Ae .?(A7 )(1- "( @)8P YK"8N ;<"
.- Y8- .LQ>- A$a (*FV( �P*7 62 801D C8<) @A<)*L- 801D
67C)") ,"1>PC)") ;$73" !AH @*9 (*2 ;<" 62 80)Ag hfJ *9
BVAg i*&0" Y8- @K( #$0:
'!V[3NHKL@'JS)4
!"#$!%&' (')*+& ," ,-*./ 0"'1( 2' 345 67 ,8 9!7:-
;5 9*<8' #=' ;7*7(!<= >?@A= 67 B'C-' D':AAE.:F' 9'*.
>?@A= B'C-' :G7) :" '( >?@A= HI?J5 B'C-'2' 67:K
):8 ,LM!N5 O,A%$ B':" :AF!. ;=(:" 1 345 B2!=
0P;Q5," !7 #7:745 HI?J5 B!K B!K:AE?5 () :AAE. ;.(!%R
91:" '2S:& 2' >?@A= :">A@&1 ('CT'U#=' V4$ ,?T:W 6+8 O
,A%$ B':" ,?%M',5!&:" B2!=S:& XB:.*AY5!8 B!K B!K('CT'
;5 >A@&1 !Z&[ \7:?Z" ,8 #=' V4$ ,]'(' B)4L?54$!"O ()
() *7(!<= >?@A= (!?T( X,5')'^ ,LM!N5 )(*5 \_+5 #AL`1
#=' ,?T:W (':a O;5 bcd5 :K ,?%M' :7!= 4&'*.#AL`1 B!K
4<8 ;=(:" CA& '( \_+5O
!"#$%&'(!)*&+,-.!/01&2345& 5,6& 7,8&93&:;1&+<,=
2$.5><
,A%$ 2' ef B!K:AE?5 94&!5 #"!F g:T !" X345 B2!=
91:"4$ ,LM!N5 345 X'2 O )(*5 h(!?T( ,8 B:AE?5 \AM1'
;5 (':a ,-*. ):AW !";5 i_$ () ,84$!"j V)') 9!Q&
#=' V4$O
!"#$%&'()& !"*+,-$ ./01$,2234$*+5-/6
#$ %&'()*www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
!"#$%&'(%)*+,$)-.$/0123."4.$5("678#$//%29"6#$9$:7;$<".=2"'>/$?2"@AB$/$C"DEF"!GHIG
JK
;5 V47) ,8 (*k 9!+K ," l1:$ :mn 9!52 2' (')*+& \7' )*$
#=' o7'CT' ,"1( ;7!+& 4&1( 67 !"1 V):8 o7'CT'O
D'CAZp. ,?T:W (':a :q& 45 9[ (!?T( ,8 B4L" :AE?5
;5 ;.':"!J5;5 ;M1C& 4&1( B'(') ,8 4$!" i_$ () ,8 4$!"
r 9!Q&#=' V4$ V)')O
!"7$%&'()&#$%&'()#"*'+%*+,-$ ./01$,2234$*+5-/6
,L=*. ,?T:W (':a ;=(:" )(*5 9[ (!?T( ,8 B4L" :AE?5
#P!=:72+,-;5 i_$ () ,8 4$!"s#=' V4$ V)') 9!Q&O
!"8$%&'()&#$%&#+,-.&/%-)$%)-'$ ./01$,2234$*+5-
*+,-/6
9!+K(')*+& B1( 2' ,8 (*k #=' ;7!+& 4&1( #=' tJQ5
S4R )!L"' ," ,-*. !" *7(!<= \7' () ,_<7' ," ,-*. !" ,8
(!?T( \7' >A?@K C8:+?5 #P!=:72 ,L=*. B1( :" #ALNa
;5 :q& ," ;LA%k4=(O
!"#$?&'&;!74@&(5& A,=.B<&CD5& !E->& )FG&93&.!!/@
B47$>&H>I!JK@&9>3L !"#$%&'#()'(#*%+$',-M
#AL`1 ()u ):AG" >A+v. #M1) V4<7[ () ,8 V4$ g:T
D'CAZp. 4AM*. ," #%@& #P!=:72 ," ,-)*" tAvJ.
#7*M1' (')+,- B:?QA" :AF!. #=!A= \7' !7[ 4K) o7'CT' '(
B1( !" ,-)*" #M1) ,_<7' ;<L7 e_R #=!A= !7 )(')
#7*M1' D'CAZp. 4AM*. w:n '( B:?QA" (!?T( 9*<8' x4<8 (')
L`1 B!K:?5'(!f #AU ()u;5 ;=(:" V4$ ,?mW #M!y !. )*$
):AG" oAf #M1) '( #=!A= S'48 )*$ \AAL.o7'CT' !"
," '( B:?QA"#$') 4K'*P 3!%&) O #='( #+= B!K(')*+&
B!K(')*+& 1 #P!=:72 ," ,-)*" tAvJ. #%@& oK!8
#P!=:72 ," ,-)*" tAvJ. #%@& o7'CT' z{ #+=
+,-;5 9!Q& '(4<K)O
() #AL`1 \7' ," |*":5 B!K(')*+&} i_$~� S!+. X
#AL`1 () !K:AE?5 (!?T( ,@7!c5 !. #=' V4$ V)') 9!Q& !K
#AL`14$!" \_+5 HI?J5 B!K O9!+K B1( 2' ,8(*k
oJ" ," :?QA" ,-)*" tAvJ. #=' tJQ5 !K(')*+&
B1( B:?QA" ;IAP :AF!. D'CAZp. 4AM*. ," #%@& #P!=:72
!")(')O
!"#$N& '@O07$3& (P345& 93& .!!/L./.01%2/34% 5.
67829.M
;5 g:T #M!y \7' () '( ,-)*" o7'CT' #=!A= #M1) )*$
B1( :" ,-)*" o7'CT':AF!. \7' D(*n \7' () ):AG" oAf ()
4K'*P D(*n ,{ ," #P!=:72 ,L=*. 1 D'CAZp. 4AM*.
9!+K x)*" i_$ B1( 2' ,8 (*kU� o7'CT' !" #=' tJQ5
,L=*. ,-)*" D'CAZp. 4AM*.1 ,?T!7 o7'CT' #P!=:72
S4R ," ,-*. !" ,8 #=' ,?T!7 oK!8 ,8 *7(!<= \7' #ALNa
;5 #P!=:72 ,L=*. :" C8:+?5 ,A-*. i"!a ,M!@5 \7' 4$!"
:?QA" ;IAP #P!=:72 >Z= ,-)*" o7'CT' !" �a'1 () 1 #='
;5 D'CAZp. 4AM*. 2'4$!"O
& !"#$Q& '& R>$& 93& .!!/@:1/0;<!/@& $& !S,"1& 93& .!
O@,!7,1
B1( :" ('�W:AF!. i5'*R 2' ;_7./""01-X S'1 9'CA5
;5 #M1) 0=*. ;n!v?P'4$!"O ;.!AM!5 #AT!L5 :G7) i5!R
#=' >AK) o7'CT' '( #7!+y :W' ,8} 1 ;.!AM!5 #AT!L5 9'CA5
S'1>AK) o7'CT' '( !K�S4R #+= ," �a'1 () #7!+y #ALNa
V2*y 2' () �J?<5 B!K;5 oAf ;?"!a( ('2!" i"!c5>71(O
:AF!. ,@7!c5 :AAE.ui5!R(*8�5," 9!Q& ,&!W'4- (*k
;5 �a'1 () i_$ () V4$ V)') 9!Q& #M!y ,= :K () ,8 4K)
S'1}2034 � :AF!. ;.!AM!5 #AT!L5 1 #=' �M!� ,cIy
B1( :" (!?T( :" ;&'4<{ !" 1+,-
+4513.-1/,-/16 1+,-7 68/+"964-4K'*J&
#$')O
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
<&($%29"6#$L7("M!$?&6NO$%P".:DE4.$LN"N+Q$0)RN92$P1$?0"SD.1$"F$T"U"V!21
JW
$ !"9$%&'()& !"+##+#'*+,-$,23(.$&:,2234$,;/$&:$</6#+,-.&/%-)$%)-'&-.%#0=,23(.$>?'@+$>A/B)/%
$ !"CD$%$&'()& !"$+##$+#'*+,-$,23(.$&:$>A/B)/$,;/$&:$</6%0%.1& 02&#$%&3)! '%
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
!"#$%&'(%)*+,$)-.$/0123."4.$5("678#$//%29"6#$9$:7;$<".=2"'>/$?2"@AB$/$C"DEF"!GHIG
JX
\7':5'9!Q&#AT!L5 CA{!& :AF!. V4<K) (!?T( :" ;.!AM!5 B!K
;5 �d" )(*5 B!K:AE?5 9[ :7)!c5 V4$ g:T ,_<7'!" ,8 4$!"
CA{!& 9[ :AF!. 3!y \7' !" 4$!" 3!y 9!52 :"':" 4<{ V4<7[ ()
;?7!+y #=!A= 2' #+@a \7' 47!" #M1) ef #=' V)*"
)*P4<8 #7*c. '( O 1 S'1 D':AAE. #='( #+= B!K(')*+&
9!Q& '( ;.!AM!5 #AT!L5 () :AAE. z{ #+= B!K(')*+&
;5 4<K)}i_$UUO�
& !"#$T&'(B,1.=&93&.!!/@OU4VA&CD5&+9>WX
,7!5:= () o7'CT' o7'CT' ;n*vP oJ" B('�W() !" 1
+':;<7 (=;>?=>;&7 +,-'CAZp. 4AM*. B1( 1 )(') :" () '( D
() CA& ;n*vP oJ" ,8 #=' 9[ #IR )('4& B:AF!.
#=!A= 2' ,-)*" tAvJ.;5 B1:Af #M1) ;I8 B!K 1 4<8
,7!5:= #P!=:72 oJ" B1(;5 B('�W1 4<8 V4+R #+@a
#P!=:72 ,L=*. #+= ," CA& ;n*vP oJ" () ,7!5:=
;5 :72':= )*$}i_$UuO�
i_$UU �(!?T( !" 1++ 1+691:" B!K:AE?5 () o7'CT' :F' () B'22034. 1-3@
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
<&($%29"6#$L7("M!$?&6NO$%P".:DE4.$LN"N+Q$0)RN92$P1$?0"SD.1$"F$T"U"V!21
JJ
$ !"CE$%&'()& !"$+##$+#'*+,-$<'?,23(.$&:$>A/B)/$,;/$&:$</6+0+&#$%&#+2'/%*'+%
F$G#HA'I.$JK@$LA'(MN'?
9!+K i_$ () ,8 (*kU� :AF!. \7:?QA" #=' V4$ V)') 9!Q&
B1( :" !" oJ" ,-)*"1 !K S'1 '(+,- ;<L7 \7' 4&(')
S4R �!=' :" ':72 X*7(!<= )!L"' !" �!%N&'#ALNa H7:L. B!K
*7(!<= V4$}V2*y 2' #7!+y 1 #P!=:72 ,L=*. B!K
�J?<5 �#7!+y ;?M1) B!K}S'1!K � (!A@" *7(!<= \7' ()
;5 ('�W:AF!.4$!" 4&'*.O
$ !"CF$%O/,2234 !"PQ'R$&:SK(T.$<'?
() ,8 (*k 9!+K i_$U� ;?7!+y oc& #=' tJQ5
#P!=:72 ,L=*. () #M1);5 ('�W:F' (!A@" !K4$!"O
$ !"CU$%$O/,2234#$%&#+,./%-)$%)-'/PQ'R$&:$<'?
SK(T.
i_$ ()U^CA&#=' tJQ5,8 o7'CT' B':" ;?=!A= �AK
*7(!<= \7' () ,8 #=' 9[ #IR #=' V)*%& 45'(!8 D'CAZp.
S4R ," ,-*. !"#ALNa !K} ;?7!+y oc& 1 #P!=:72 ,L=*.
#M1) � 4AM*. i"!c5 () #P!= :72 ,L=*. B1( :" C8:+.
#=' D'CAZp.O
$ !"CV$%O/,2234#$%&'()#"*'+%PQ'R$&:SK(T.$<'?
A
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
!"#$%&'(%)*+,$)-.$/0123."4.$5("678#$//%29"6#$9$:7;$<".=2"'>/$?2"@AB$/$C"DEF"!GHIG
JI
S4R �a'1 ()Na#AL *7(!<= :K () ,?T:W (':a :q& 45 B!K
V:AG?=) 4<&!5;M:?<8 B!K#=!A= !7 19�8 B!K i+R
;5;+& V2!-' ,8 4<<8#=!A= ,8 4<K) V4$ ,?T:W (!8 ," B!K
#=!A= ;<L7 4<$!" 2!=(!8 !Z&[ V)14d5 2' �(!P:G7) ," B!K
�(!P ,8 4<?@K 45'(!8 ;7!- !. *7(!<= :K () V4$ ,?T:W (!8
S4R 3:?<8 V2*y 2'#ALNa4<$!%& !K O
UGNW2(M$<,2X
67 B'C-' \A" 0"'1( 2' !7*f 345 67 4$ ;L= ,M!c5 \7' ()
2'*7(!<=�)*-*5 B*7(!<=V2*y()+,-)*$ ,]'(' O h1(
6A<_. �!=' :" bAcd. \7' () ,?T( (!8 ," ;@7*&*7(!<=
B4S4R :" ;<?%5 ,8#ALNa;5 X#=' B4AI8 B!K4$!" O ef
>?@A= ;7!7*f ):_71( 2' V)!m?=' !" ,8 *7(!<= 345 ,AZ. 2'
,A%$ >A@&1 ('CT' S:& 0=*. 1 47):W ,AZ. B:.*AY5!8 B2!=
() 345 X4$^#T:W (':a ;=(:" )(*5 HI?J5 #AL`1O
#AL`1 ()U91:" B!K:AE?5 :AAE. 914" #AL`1 X'2u :AAE.
4AM*. ," #P!=:72 oJ" #A+K' #%@& () XD'CAZp.
#AL`1� #AL`1 X;?M1) ,-)*" () :AAE.� () :AAE.
S'1 oJ" ," V4$ V)') tAvJ. B!K+,- #AT!L5 () :AAE. 1
#AL`11 ;.!AM!5^:AAE.(),7!5:= ;n*vP oJ" B('�W
;54$!"$ Y,A%$ ," ,-*. !"B2!= 345 \7' () ,?T:W S!p&' B!K
;5B*7(!<= )(*5 () :72 �7!?& ," 9'*.U 345 B4 V(!$'
):8�
UO V2*y ," ,-)*" tAvJ. () #M1)+,-;5 4&'*.u
):AG" oAf () '( D1!m?5 �5!8 #=!A= � C8:+.
!" ,8 XD'CAZp. 4AM*. !71 #P!=:72 ,L=*. B1(
#A=!@y iAId. ," ,-*. V4$ S!p&' B!K tAvJ.
4AM*. ," #%@& #P!=:72 oJ" ," :?QA" ,-)*"
4$( B1( B:?QA" ;IAP :AF!. D'CAZp. !" )(')
}i_$~O�
uO#A=!@y iAId. 1 *7(!<= \7' !" b"!N5 S!p&' B!K
V4$ #P!=:72 ,L=*. X#M1) ,-)*" o7'CT' !" X
!" ,8 #=' ,?T!7 oK!8 D'CAZp. 4AM*. 1 o7'CT'
S4R ," ,-*.*7(!<= \7' #ALNa :" C8:+?5 ,8
;5 #P!=:72 ,L=*. ,A-*. i"!a ,M!@5 \7' 4$!"
#P!=:72 >Z= ,-)*" o7'CT' !" �a'1 ()1 #='
;5 4$( D'CAZp. 4AM*. 2' :?QA" ;IAP 4<8
}i_$U�O�
�O V2*y 2' #7!+y #=!A= :W'+,- >AK) o7'CT' '(
S'1 1 ;.!AM!5 #AT!L5 9'CA5 ;<L7 >AK) o7'CT' '( !K
+y #+= ," �a'1 ()V2*y 2' #7! () �J?<5 B!K
\7' :AAE. :AF!. ,@7!c5 >71:" oAf ;?"!a( ('2!" i"!c5
u," i5!R;5 9!Q& ,&!W'4- (*k �a'1 () ,8 4K)
S'1}2034 � ;.!AM!5 #AT!L5 1 #=' �M!� ,cIy
B1( :" (!?T( :" ;&'4<{ :AF!. !" 1C++D7 +,-
+4513.-1/,-/16 1+,-7 68/+"964-C+6D
#$')4K'*J&9!Q& \7' ,8 CA{!& :AF!. V4<K)
#AT!L5 �d" )(*5 B!K:AE?5 (!?T( :" ;.!AM!5 B!K
;5 V4<7[ () 9[ :7)!c5 V4$ g:T ,_<7'!" ,8 4$!"
CA{!& 9[ :AF!. 3!y \7' !" 4$!" 3!y 9!52 :"':" 4<{
#=!A= 2' #+@a \7' 47!" #M1) ef #=' V)*"
4<8 #7*c. '( )*P ;?7!+y}i_$UUO�
�O o7'CT',7!5:=() o7'CT' ;n*vP oJ" B('�W
!" 1+,-7 +4513.-1/,-/16. :" () '(
1 )('):AF!. D'CAZp. 4AM*. B1( )('4& ;&'4<{
tAvJ. () CA& ;n*vP oJ" ,8 #=' 9[ #IR
#=!A= 2' ,-)*";5 B1:Af #M1) ;I8 B!K 1 4<8
,7!5:= #P!=:72 oJ" B1(;5 B('�W1 4<8
vP oJ" () ,7!5:= V4+R #+@a ," CA& ;n*
;5 :72':= #P!=:72 ,L=*. #+=)*$E
^O9!+K i_$ () ,8 (*kU^ �AK #=' tJQ5
D'CAZp. 9'CA5 o7'CT' B':" ;?=!A= ;.':"!J5
#=' V)*%& 45'(!8O *7(!<= \7' () ,8 #=' 9[ #IR
S4R ," ,-*. !"#ALNa !K} oc&1 #P!=:72 ,L=*.
#M1) ;?7!+y � #P!=:72 ,L=*. B1( :" C8:+.
c5 ()#=' D'CAZp. 4AM*. i"!O
S4R �a'1 ()#ALNa *7(!<= :K () ,?T:W (':a :q& 45 B!K
V:AG?=) 4<&!5 ;M:?<8 B!K#=!A= !719�8 B!K;5 i+R 4<<8
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
<&($%29"6#$L7("M!$?&6NO$%P".:DE4.$LN"N+Q$0)RN92$P1$?0"SD.1$"F$T"U"V!21
IY
;+& V2!-' ,8#=!A= ,8 4<K)," B!K:G7) V4$ ,?T:W (!8
#=!A= ;<L7 4<$!" 2!=(!8 !Z&[ V)14d5 2' �(!P (!8 ," B!K
:K () V4$ ,?T:W 2' �(!P ,8 4<?@K 45'(!8 ;7!- !. *7(!<=
S4R 3:?<8 V2*y#ALNa \7' () ,_<7' ," ,-*. !" 1 4<$!%& !K
;5 #P!=:72 ,L=*. B1( C8:+. *7(!<=#=!A= 4$!" B!K
," 4&4$ 45'(!8!& D'CAZp. 4AM*. #Z- () V4$ ,?T:W (!8
} i_$U^O�
.Z-'[-454647849
F#G B<;H<(IJEI7 KLLKI ! "#$% &!'($)* +% ! "#$)* !!"#$%&'()"!*+,-' ).'/)*+%0'$,$*01+1'+,'&,)2*!"-!' ).1314$+,$#*!' "!5!*)/(!,46$,' +,1+-74' +,' 4)' 47!!,%0%*)/!"+$' ) ' *+ !' 13//).4' 1014!(1 ! "#$%&'()*+,-.,/01 $2+--!()*+,-.345
!"# $%&'#()*# $+,-./# )# ,01'# $23456789:# $ !"#$% &'%()*+,% -./01%*2
'34';',<=#$>-?6#@-5AB#CD,1#$E
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
9"# $*?FD#23GH#IJ50J#K5L0LM=# CD,17899# $-./01%()5*/6% ()*+,
7'30'%)8%9*:;<'7NONE
P"5-5Q# $2GH$#$21',<R# $.3M1.0J#$2-5ST5ST# $5U*.03V#$5D,W#;'*X',R
X'C<R# $265YGJ# $>ZM1[53D.0J# $;50\5ST# )$789]# $`# 5^15Q7NON#_
`+*5`6#a.A-b#,0Z1#*X#c5d#>0eZf6`#$=6*>?)%@$*/AB6#$N7gB#$#E79#h
7N#E
7O"2G06X?iZ1# $$#$.3M1# $;50S0ST# $j)*?D# $2L-.B# $>ZV# $2k5d*X
.-,l#$c',30D#)#.0iJ#$506,e6mD$789!#$`#+n=',eJ'#(,T#K5i&5Y1#%Bmo
*?FD# 2eiAB# %iJ?=`AB# a5`F6'X# $#)# I-,-.1# a.pF6'X# $q-,W# 2ei
X5re/'E
6==8 a@4+-2/ ! M5 ! OPP7 =+.!*!11' ;).!1+-74' :%!,$.+)1) '47!'>)#+*!'=).*"'+,'?@AB !;2./!<,+3K!b!%2/-56=O8 #G%F$( ! OPP= ! Q:.3! %3S3/:.! F3J./2+20K9243-,0.:V !;@N@/56=78 #G%F$( ! OPPL ! Q:.3! $,0.:.! F3J./2+20K9243-,0.:V !;@N@/56=H8 92443-:34 ;5<5 =>?= C,"314.+$*' "0,$(+%1 #3Tc24Z ;2./!<,+3K!b %2/-56=L8 D+3--, %5 ! OPP7 ! QY3-,0/,/0! 3B)J@:,2/@+! -)NN24:,/! -K-:3A! BK/@A,J- d*@-3B! ,/:34@J:,S3! +3@4/,/03/S,42/A3/:-V 1+(3*$4+),'D' -$(+,- ! 7=WOX ! NN5! =I^1=>?56=?8 M343/B- ! (5! @/B! D5e5\5 ! [2AA3 ! =>>> Q-,A)+@:,2/!@-!@!43-3@4J.!:22+!,/!A@/@03A3/:!-:)B,3-V E3.)/!$,'>$,$-!(!,4'F)3.,$* !=I !NN5!LI?1L^756=I8 M4)JZA@/ ! e5 ! OPP= ! Qe+2*@+! A2B3+,/0V ;343.!1 !77 !NN5!=71OP56=^8 %:34A@/ !;5Y5 !OPPP G31+,!11'"0,$(+%1H' 1014!(147+,&+,-' $,"' ()"!*+,-' ).' $' %)(/*!I' 2).*" ! #3Tc24Z CJe4@T1],++56=>8 a,4ZT22B ! &5<5 ! =>>^ ! Q%K-:3A! YK/@A,J-C3:.2B-E! Df),JZ! ,/:42B)J:,2/V ! J2++303! 2R! *)-,/3-- D4,g2/!%:@:3!"/,S34-,:K56OP8 %.,! F5!@/B!e,++ 
Archive
of S
ID
!
!"#$% &'#() *#+,-.'
/+01 2%#,034 5*'6#,4 6 701 89#:9 /;-6<=%&5L1#s5t#%R#u-53=#K*?B#*X#%R#IJ'#.A3Fk'?o#%15AGrl#>-'#*X
.A-51,l#%v?=#u-w#K5p6_7#hKx5L12=5L0LM=#%&5L1#upW#%R#.-5R#u0B'W'4,0,/@+ D4:,J+3X
#[5V#*X#5-#a.F6#s5t#2v*5o#5-#2Go'X#23GH#Kmy1#*X#zmS/#)#aX?R.W5S6#2J*,R#E.W#.k'?f6#%el,-{Q#2y-),=#5-#+*),1#Kx5L1E
!h;5R|# %R# Kx5L15-# 2J*5l# +5k21# %el,-{Q# 2Z0G`6'.6?W#EIJ'#+*),U#;5R|#)X#,k#%R#a.0pt#[5J*'E
8hX?R#.k'?o#2p06),ep&'#upW#%R# z5=*),U#Kx5L1#[5J*'#E#+',R#I-,-.1# 2p06),ep&'# %6515J# }-,T# |'# '*# X?o# u-5l# *?~A1# >-'#*?FD# 23GH# IJ50J# K5L0LM=# CD,1# I-5J# *X# Kmy1
TTT5/4,-N5@J5,4i;%F(R# 5-# )# .0-536# [5J*'#2p06),ep&'# IZQ# %h-:Nj/4,-N5@J5,4.0eJ,^RE
Nh#2651|5J#I0i/?1# )#;5d.AZ-?6# 5-# a.AZ-?6#215J'#}0/X# ,DwIJ'#+*),U#;56b#2p06),ep&'#j*Xb#a',3k#%RE
:ha|?V|'#.A=*5SH#%15AGrl#I0&5il#+5k#_hc5~6;51|5J#)#+*)b?6#+5k�+*)5Al#)#�GH#2kX#h�GH#uR5Le1#K',0��=+*)5Al)5R$%i15v��mo'#)#�Ak,lh#�>06'?/#)#�?LV#5R#+*)5Al#)#�GH#uR5Le1#K',0��=h�6'X#I-,-.12G1#�YJ#*X�h#I-,-.1[bY�h21?R#)#%H5W'#$[5Le6'�+*)5Al#)#�6'X#+|5JhIJ50J�+*)5Al#)#�GH#+*'{dh�%6'*)5Al#2A-,lb*5D#)#+*)5Al#)#�GH#X5re/'h�0Q#�+*)5Al#)#�GH#2R5-|*'#)#2A0RhIJ50J#*X#�GH#K5i&5Y1#X,R*5D+*)5Al#)#�GH#+*'{dE
]h;b#+',R#%D#%65`0R#K5VmYB'#$K5/)'#2o,R[X5i1#5k#2J*5l#�*X# �.S1# ;5R|# K*?B# ;53k# %R# Kx5L1# *X# $IJ'# a.W# @U)
21.6?W# E# %Gy1# *5eJ',-)# .At,k216'?=a�')# .#'*# 21?3H# +5k.AD#(mB'# .6'X,d,R# 2J*5l# %R# )�#�.0ZR?J#+5v# %R# %6'*5-# .A651%R# +*)5Al# +5v+�?&?Ap=%R# +X,Sk'*# �#Cv# )# �-n=',eJ'# +5v
>-'5k�#2J*5l# %R#2rrf=#K5VmYB'#u-.S=# $�IJX;b#�D#2-5kIJ'#a.W#�5fe6'#2&X5i1#;5F-',R#%D#�#)#$;5^&�1#X?o#�.<H#|'#5<A=
21,R# a|?V#,k#;5rrfe1.-b# E#)#�GH#IJ50J#�15AGrl#%D# 5y6b#|'#%B,H# >-'# ;5-?yF6'X# )# ;'X5eJ'# +',R# +,Sei1# @v,1# +*)5Al
%R21#*53W#2J*5l#%R#%65`0R#K5VmYB'#;.6'X,d,R#)#.-b216'?=#%R#.
-),=# )# ;.W#IJ.p-#�3D#�GH#uk'# ;501# *X#K5VmYB'#>-'#�21# %0B?=# '{&# $.AD2eV# c,eM1# ;5d.AZ-?6# X?W#|'# *).L3&'
[X5i1.AAD#aX5^eJ'#2J*5l#+5kE�h#*X# 2J*5l# ,0�# @v',1# ;5d.AZ-?6# 215J'# ,Dw# �?ro# *X
#.-5R#$%&5L1#>e1#2Z0G`6'#%R#5<6b#c56X?W#gfF1#2/*)5Q#*XE9h;)*X#K5H5v*'#+',R#)X#Kmy1#*X#2Ae1#X?v)#K)5^e1#�?0W
X*'X# E#j5J',R#@v,1#�*53W# $a.W#uL6#�GY1#uR5L1# $a?0W#�-#*X#a.1b#%&5L1#;5-5Q#*X#%D#2iR5A1#IJ,<l�m�1#_ 7"�21#�*X#$#)#X?W
21# ,�'# *5Fe6'# [5J# )#q&�1# c56# $c)X# �?0W# *X#*X# %15AGrl# %D# .-b21#aX5^eJ'#[)'#�)*#|'#$;5^&�1#*5D#2dX5J#+',R#,U5V#[5V.ADE
{&.AAD#aX5^eJ'#�)*#>03k#|'#.-5R#�k#c,eM1#;5d.AZ-?6#'E#%R#c|xa*53W#�0=,=#%D#IJ'#,Dw#%R#.-5R#@R5A1#I3Z/#*X#@v',1#+*'{d
.W5R#>e1#*X#a.W#,Dw#�0=,=EPh#5-#�5eD#;'?AH#)#%1?0d#;)*X#*X#%&5L1#;'?AH#$@R5A1#�fR#*X
-'#�G/# 5R# %Gy1�0&5e��*?1# �X?W#�*X# E'# *5Fe6'#[5J# $>0A�3k#,�.-50R#;5^&�1#c56#|'#�Q#%GB5lmRE
7O#h�t?D# 2H,l# >-)5AH# �G/# �|'.6'#)# .W5R# 2GB'# ;'?AH# |'# ,=;b#�*53WX?W#�*X#�t#%R#IJ'*#|'#5k#E21#X5<AF0Q#$>0A�3k#X?W
.W5R#%eW'X#a*53W#C06#%1.L1#�fR#%D#E77#h# a�')# |'# aX5^eJ'�K50RX'# �#(mYB'#uR5L1# *XW\,:34@:)43X#%R
#+5Ai1��k)nQ#�A0F0Q#$2Fk)nQ#*5�b#$>e1#�;b#.A651#)#IJ*X56#$5k# 2J*5l# ��')# >-'# .At,k# �IJ'�X?o# IJ*X56# +5Ai1# *X# �#*X
�k)nQIJ'#a.W#[)'.e1#*50ZR#23GH#)#2k5`F6'X#+5kE7!#h# �3GD�;5d�')# �#��')# ,R',R# *X# %D# IJ'# 2rrf=# 2VmYB'
\3k,J2/�3GD# @3v# K*?B# 5R# ;b# +5Ai1# )# a.W# @U)�a�')#��a�')5k# �IJ'#K)5^e1# E>-'# |'%R# $)*#�0D,=# |'# aX5^eJ'#+5v�#.0GD
;5d�')#�#K*5SH#$a.0pt#�fR#*X�a�')#.0GD5k#�X?W#aX5^eJ'E78#h#%&5L1#,k#;5d�')#X'.i=.-5R#,�D'.V9OOO.W5R#%3GDE7N#hIJ50J# *X# �<1# )# +.0GD# K5p6#$+*)5Al# )# �GH# +*'{d216'?=#�&5/#*X#.A�,0RX,J#%R#%156�#*X#,�D'.V#$NOO#*5Fe6'#%3GD
.AR5-E7:#h%v?=X?W%D*X@R5A12J*5l$15J'2?6;5d.AZ-5R.-
/#q^f1#%6#)#u15D#*?YR.0XX,dE7]#hX'.i=@v',1Kx5L1�*.A1*X%15AGrlIJ50J�GH)
+*)5Al$#,�D'.VNO1X*?12.W5RE
23GH#%15AGrlh2Fk)nQ
*'6#,4 6 701 89#:9 >#9?'#@A B'#+C DE DF#GHI#JKLMK
www.SID.ir
Archive
of S
ID
93
Modeling the Interactive Future ofInformation Technology Based onthe System's Dynamics Approach
Mehdi Fateh Rad1, Sahar Kousari2
1- Faculty Member of Academic Board, SharifUniversity of Technology
2- PhD Student in Future Studies, University ofTehran
Abstract
One of the methods for firms to be successful ininformation technology industry is to reduce theprobability of the failure by adopting flexiblescenarios and developing strategies for thedevelopment . Among the current scenario-making methods is the uncertainty approachusing Global Business Network (GBN) method.In GBN, each scenario is made out of the cross-impact of two or three driving forces that have ahigh associated uncertainty. On the other hand,each scenario has a series of variables thatinteract with each other and every tiny change ineach of these variables would have a huge impacton other variables. This can be extremelyimportant in the field of policy making. Thus,scenario modeling as a dynamic system canmake decision makerscapable of realizing thefuture risks and opportunities. Using systemdynamism approach, in this paper a dynamicmodel of a scenario in the field ofcommunications, along with a pre-foresight planwill be offered. Then using Vensim software, wewill study the effects of different components ofthis scenario on each other in five differentsituations in identifying the variables that havethe strongest effect in the growth of the GDP.We also examine the effect of government’sbudget on the IT infrastructure developmentand on the production of ICT equipment.
Corresponding Author: [email protected]
Additionally we specify how the mentionedincrease in the government's budget will affectthe governmental supportive policies (loans andtax exemptions) or the investments of the privatesector.
Keywords: System's Dynamic, Scenario, GBNMethod, Tele Communications.
Volume 4, Number 4, Summer 2012Journal of
Science & Technology Policy
www.SID.ir
