Manuel Jesus Olivas-Matta, A021 179 705 (BIA Aug. 9, 2010)

7/30/2019 Manuel Jesus Olivas-Matta, A021 179 705 (BIA Aug. 9, 2010)

1/25

.:.!

:' , V.S Depant Jus:;e );K HLER, ESQUIP. Box 85Fnc / 852300

Name: VAS-M MUEL JESS

Exuiv Ofc r Imigon Rew

Board f Immigation ApelsOfce the Crk

S/07 Lrb P i1c 000Faft Chul.

l I

S OHSTrla te UnEA Box 25158Phoenx 85

A2179

Da f i noice: 8/900

Eclos s a py o Bo's dsion ad o t abov-fc as.

nco

Pael Mmbers:

M Hug G .

Sly,

DCarChiCle

Cite as: Manuel Jesus Olivas-Matta, A021 179 705 (BIA Aug. 9, 2010)


2/25

OV-MO NEL JSUSIC, 1705 . HNA RD02-95EOY 85231

c Oce r Imigation Revew

Board ofImmigton ApeOce of e Clek

Lb Pik S 1

Fl Chmf Y

S DHSTral Aory UnlPO. Box 5158Pheix, 8500

ame: OIV-MOA MAUEL JESUS 177

)t hs oce 8/00

Enclosed is a pyof he Bar' dson n he above-refeenced Thi y Is bengprovd o you a esy. Y aey o eeeta a bee e wth idesion 8 F 1292.S(a) If h ae deson odetha you be emov the Uit ate an mmraton Jde'deon oen thyo beemov, any eton eviewo h ataced decon must l w nd rev y eprrae o apa tn day the ae te ec

Eosu

Pe Mb:M H G

D cDo Cahef lk



3/25

D Execuve Ocefor Iigton

Dcso oh Bod o m Appal

Fl Chu, Viia e: 0 179 705 - Elo Date UG 9 Z0

In re: MAUL JSS OLIVAS-MOTIA a.ka Muel JesOivoa OV PROEEDS

PP

O BHL OF PODN Ka Hle, Eqe

O BEHALF O :

RG

Sh AeAsst iefouel

Noie Se. 3(a)2A(i, & At [8 S.C. 7a}(2)A)i)] Covce ofo oroe cme volg oal titude

PPLIATO ceaton of removal

e e a ae d czen f Mexc h tely pealed e in udge'Ap 8 0, dciion denying cclao o eova o scion 240A() o hemn d Naoni Ac e "A 8 S. 29A) Th appa wl dmd

We ee e Ito udges dings o ac, cluigas o e dibi of sionude the "cey eeous ad whe e revew nva qesos o aw djudgee S & D 493 BIA 08); 8 CFR .d( Gient e respondent' pplation w led er a 200 ee rocen oee bye povons of e ID A o 005 S-B, 2 &N Dec. 2 B 206ece e ee ae y A D Ac o co 240( oh At 8 USC 129c)appl o s ce

on n ew e ae t he mmon Jde a e roe is emovable en covic o o o mo crmes olg o de CT ud eco

237a)((A(i) o Ac (.J a 56) The esd do no diue s convco raclon (a psesio o ajua sae) n a o Azoa Re -4 6 x 4C Ex 4 Hov he sares wt emmo Judge ccun s coo edgen volaon oA -101xh. 4-0 wa a C Repondens Befa 6).

dee g wa pacl oe ivove mo d p e b e Ao eea N D 687 A 8 We al a caeoc appoach o eeine hethr he s a "aliscoabi" a i s



4/25

A021 79 05

sate of coio ould appie o eah ont tat does ot iove ol eI a 689-0. Whe e agorica ayss does no esole te issue, we proe wh a moitgoa q a ea e aie's eor o oio iig oe sc tehgg ome jme ctos sge ly pea, and pea tsc iatoa e oe oe o 6 Fily, e o ovcto scocsve we a o te exen eessa d appoae ose evdee byo e aonco doce o sce the ae o he deyig ovic

A e is aC volves eensble conuc oied w some degee of seheer specic ite ebeeess less o kessess Mater of Silva-Tv,sa a 6 & n5

Und AS 320 a pso coms eagee by ekessy aerg anoepeso wih a ssia s of m eah o pysca e ao ode ha theoese s categoia a e iog moal uide sy ase of he rks es a

elee We h ha oense novn cless sae omnd wll no e eeed a eog o e ase pesnce o so agaatg aco sh as e ea of apeso or he co of o at fFuaa JN Dec 4 7 (BI 1996); aro Wojtw 8 &N Dec. BA 19); Ma o Mdna 5 &N Dec 6 (BI 6Hoee RS 20 dos o a a eeet sh aggaatig ao s theaeoica aoah oes o nw e son o wethe he oense s a rme iovgmo te he od oria appoah s o be applied S ar arvo pa.

he Iiaon J e beyond he ma oo doens to ise a ersens vt was a n detn ha he respos covco was

.prehensible od" she ied te poice reo c shwed ha dug a ispe erese sho s wie n he adome t a ht e Ex ). We age ih heto e a these dngs ae sue o so epehesi codt. S aofao supa a 0 n gog yo e or ofv, e maioJdge o moy coser e espondens cou ky 'Ahcro 3 F3d3 9 C 200 (Resndens Brie a 1 Regdess of wehe te shoo w aen o no (Rspons Befa rese oce unde a ae a

alz ks cond no re acenl od Ths e a of elessesshe oupe ih he rpehese conuc o he esonde s e g so wth dng an gme is scet o abish e oa idos ature of he spondsoense, espte he bc o a spic ne o e espes p o hs ifeordy ar h on u ha he epodn s eovab a aie woas mm to es oig o ue.

a ion J' ecs o en p apco celaon o o o240A(a o h a 7-1). T esode coeds ha Iga ed o n esde isio eef (Rsodes Befa a -17 The Itio ly se h he ea sdads odiga so evalao ad oroghly a adaey di d ad he osie



5/25

021 19 705

eatie ao e spodet's siatio. See Maer C-VT. 2 l&N D 7 (BIA99)(i t e e d deveod i ae of ain, 16 &N D. 5 55BA 7 re exie odsceone seto22coeAcU.C.((994wch he pdecessor poisio o secton 40Aa) o he ct e appibto h odision uder secio 2Aa ote ct) Revewi e Iiaio Jes disciodnia de ovo we d o ss to rve he miaion Jude deteinao a espodedoes n eherelfocelao fval i teeeie o do ee ;ate Ste, 3 &N D. (BA200

ote faco deeed ere o en he are d uderln ciuma ofhe emoabil d a sse te pc o adiioal sic violaions t cu'imitio law e eiece oaimina eo d, i so its ar, ceny ad u

d e psee of ote eidence indicatie of a detsbd cactr rudii aen resde oft on Faoal onsieations icud such facors as fl iesii Ued States resien o ong uon i hiscoupculalwhe thecep

o esidece cced whl he resndn o on ag) edece o adsp o esde nd iy if ccr seice i iscouns ed ors d a soof empome. ddiioal aorbe ctors cue he eistece p or sess tie,evience ovaue d seice the com, pof of nuie rehabilitaon ifaminal reexs, oe vence ei t eonde ood c g das ends d responsbe oni psenaies auef-VT saat ctig atefa spa

Teeae siica neatie co ha miliae aas a avoae eecise of disceion he respodes se cically te respode a coced i Aus 3 facaionll ssessio o maja wch heived yes pobaio.ad Noveer200

egee, rwch e eceied a a ece of2 e. ee Exhs 4C d.A esdet wo a a crimial cor il ordnrly q e

realio e gted amae of dsceo. ee e ofa pa a 5;ee ao e of cem 9 D 6 A 9. Howee, applo invonovice es mus e eauaed o a cebyse b, reailiio a aor o osiered i te xerciseofscio. aeofEa20&ND9BA9 e haehedtata showg ofhabiliaio is o absolue pequisit i ee civovin awi acrimial cd aef aa oe, he esens cml ordi e sos Red e cliio coictio s te Immigraton Jdge alue o eoey Geelas satedthat fermes a o explitveh dg rckig a .See te of--23 J& Dec 25 AG.2002 e cumcs fe me tatrndet alwed a iend to storeor 200 pudso hushe sha wihs wfe d mallchil T t 374; 88 e ets edeet nictions lso ulg i e facs sow a swfe w so adomen dg e e fen te spoen kea loae e n ouse were is salcidn se li of e seroessof he spodens cmial ecord habilitaio s imp cor inis e. owee, he pod di o e y abilitaion o g his 2 y ipison a 3 Tr. a 93



6/25

A021 79 705

th Iio Judg did, rd h bia qi uidi d h Uid Sa h 0 da d (. a 9 2 T odha la p d ad td a iz idi i wf ohid h ad (Ja 9-0) W hav ao do ha h od'ova o Mxi wd a h v taa oa hadh ad hi av Ui od u hdh oa oc io va d a aoay od y ho codi odo o o has d i h nd F ad ha t e a o ia i

ai aio c h d eo o b aoqu How d ia od c ad v ma hd h siv aiv c t t dtd hee c$ od e e

Acd w a d

OER: i d

4



7/25

tU S DPTMT OF TICE

XC OC OR IGTION RVIWGTION COUR

lo, izo

F A 21 179 5 Dat: Ap 8, 0

n t Matt of

ML ESS OVSMOTTA

Resonden

))))

IN OV PROEEIGS

CGE Seto 23( 2} A) (i) of t Igraond toalt t - conviced o to msong moa tutd o asg o o asigl scheme of ciia msconduct

ITION

APS

Caclltio of Remoal fo Lawful PenRidt der Secio 240A() of t ActVounta rt

O OF RSPOEN: O O TE EPO OD SECIT

0Ee Jr, s

; Sh Ast sre

O DECION O E IION G

:

The Repondt s a a-od ard mal , atv d

cit o eco Th Uit Sats eatm o omd

ct ogt ts remol procedigs gas te Resodet

d th autoi o e mmigtio d Ntoni ct


8/25

Poceegs ee coence e g

o a Notce Aea

it the Immgraio ou on p 6 009 See Ei .

Repoe thoug Cosel ated the factua

egaos otain i he chagng oumnt e owee enie

e cage eece ove Respone ese Mxo as he

o o oval shoud tha bome eessar

e 2 009 Rsonen fe aplcation or

ellaon o eova pursuan to Secto 40Aa he Act

ee Ehi O Otoe 26, 200, Resoent motone oeiae ova oceedis ee ii 6 The eaten of

Hoelad Sriys oposion o the Resoes motio o

teiae s coai n hbt 7

Dae of omeln euy sie

uheicae ocunaon o sablish alee convictios

d h chae otaine in hbt # he Deparen o

Hoe eciy has the buen o prove cea an conncng

eice ha he Responden s eovae as chagd. o ecso

on eorai shal e vai uess is ase upon easole

ssttial n robatve vience Base upo he Cour's evew

o the convo docues he applcable staute a uizig

the amewor poulgated y he Aoey Geeal iva-revio, itti itt in azng he wo ovco

is Cour denied he Responen's oion to eiae

sustaied the sge chage o eovbi nng h the

pret of Hol Seur hd et ts uen of cea

A 17 705 2 A 8 00


9/25

convincng vdnc

T ocunts stt b t ptmnt of Hom

Sct n b #4 stls tat on Ast 00

sodnt was covc n t upo o o o fo t

offn o actato nlawf possssion o majua fo

sal volaon o Aona s ttt cto

0 T ocnts al so stlsh tt sponnt oovr 6 20 was lso covct o t ofns o

ndnnt in volao o zo vs tatu con

0

To dtn hth spon ovcos al as

cms involvn moa t s Co folows t Atto

Gnas cn amwo s oth Matt o vavio

cato oit . T tto Gal n at cas pomgat

t foow on o a c nolg oa tuptu to

qaf as a c nvovn moal tt t c must

nvov pnsbl couct ad som g of scnt

wt spcfc tt lbatnss wllunss o

cssnss" T Ato Gral a t clar a ts

na no of oa tutd so to copass a

dscib stn oad pcn odn s to vaios spcs of

a copton s ll s ouct t s l bs

vl or pav an cont to th accpt ls o molit

d t ts o btw psons o to socit ga

Th sct t s mt b conuct ta s

A 2 705 Ap 0


10/25

eoal, wlul or reckess ee ecess eqs

aca was o e sk cad by e ca voao's

acos Te Ud aes o of Appes o e N

Cc ose jsdco s cas ases as eld a a

a Cos eeece o e decsos o e Boa o Igrao

as eeg ee paul oese aes as a

cre ovg oa e e go Ls S

Marolejo-Cmpo v Hod 58 F3d 90 ( 200)zg e S-eo appoc o deee e

ae o oese s a cgorl approac ms

eploye er c cl sae a ss s xa o

ascea e o e c o a oess

a ae a ealsc o of bg posc de a

sae codc a ayss grt Jde s o

eee ee es a asc poy e se

or eea ca sae pu o c Rspode as

coced l e ape o rac coc a os o ol

moa ue Te Co m e a e me o e

ales eoal poceeg, y cul cs xss c e

ele cma sae as app o coc d o

ole oa e as o ee so appled

a case cd e espoe cse, e mm

Jde c esoly coclde a l coco e e

sae cagorcal ad s oes o oa

pde

1 17 705 4 A 8 200


11/25

,jSecon, he isse co be resoe une he

caegoca approach, a od fie caegoica approach is o be

eraken hch reires inecion o specie ocuens

comprsng o the aliens record o conicon o sce he

nae of the unerlyig conco nal ly he recor of

concton s nconcse, he oe Genera has he ha,

becase ora e s no a el een o he cime, eidence

beyond he record of con cion ay be consere n eauatig

heher aens ofense coues a cie nolig oral

tuue The scope o sc ree is no sec to he

eienta tatons of Tayor ne aes oSepherd nie Sae The oey Genea mkes cear hhe goa of he oie categorical inq is to iscern the

ue o the deryn conction hee a ee eainaon o

the aue itse oes no ye the necessay inoaion I

s no occaso o eae as or o reen a a all

eence bean on an ains couc lea o he covicio

o a e oese o acato

conane an es se na l eeent soe egree of oar acton

oas he coeon of he crie cosuing the unerlyi

offee n Resonen case, he eying off ene a s

osses sion fo ale of arua gualy he e analy

o ay as a socaio a unla possesso f

aiuana or sae hich he Nn Circui Cour o eas h

od to be a mol is oese ea o he sae

21 179 705 5 pril 8 201


12/25

(o arjua. S Barragan-Lopez v Mukasey, F3 899, 903-.4 ( 27) Bae po bv,

tat Repnen' o l, wl

oo o ja o s a cri volvg mora

u R' ov o voa

zo Rve Sau Section 1 ads

g by rcy i o n w e

ssania isk o inet ica nj.

E has l k o wi

sbal o i a

oy w p w conved T

o k s v tauo nuage Rgi

w po fene c b c as a pb

o aegoica apa

mal s o o all v

ali bliy o eng recue u

U o aeoa oac u

i o or o onvct cotae i Eb 4 aso

o or olv r

ov s Ct t it mt cr

evence beon of covto Unde d Sp as

ee r Sva-evo, e C od h pl

t contaEb #5 Tose du vl a spe i

79 75 pl B


13/25

in ile. Based upo the Cor's eview of he adonl

docens tis ou oud a espone's conc ws

eprehensbe d ereore he oese o edngeent

constued cime iolv orl uude heb

susaned e ve eerenced hage

OF H W

To be eligbe o caelin o eoval e eo

240A() o he on nd Naoni c len mus

demonae tha he hs ee aull admied wi peen

eece for n less ve es hs rese in he Ue

es connuoly o seven yes ae avn bee died in

y stus d has no bee conved of aggvaed elony.

ddo o ssing ese hree suto

eigibly eremens ppca o reef de econ

240A o the At st esabsh h he wrs such ele as

mae o sceon. he geeral san evelope

ae of Mn 6 De. 51 (BI 97) o e excise of

dsceon unde 1c o e c ae ppe o e eecse

o dceton de econ 20A ee Mer o 22 &

Dec 7 BIA 8 mmgti Jdge uon evew o e

ecor s whoe s be he dvese co evdecng the

es eb a a ee esie t e sa

ne oseaios presee s beh o ee wte

t g o ee appes e bes eres o s

con e lit or ccelaon hwever ee no r

1 179 05 7 Apil 8 200


14/25

eet tetog sa or osneqiie See 23 I& Dec 21 (BIA 200).

Favorabe conideao clud sc aco as a

tie win te Ud Stae, residece f on duao n this

cor particar we h cepo o esdece occurred a

a yo age evdece of dsip o e Repodet d hi fa

i eoal occurs sece this con's ed oces a

o of eplent te exitece of operty or sie ies

evdence of vue and ece o e cony oof o ee

eiao a crma recod es d oer eece

ates o a epoets ood ara.

o aco deee adese o a aien are e

nae d unerlyg ccmtc of e grods o eoal a

are a sue the preence o addoa sct voaon of

h cut's Igrao Lw e etece of a cia

record d if so is ature, rececy ad eroess d te

reence o oter evdece dcaive o a epondens bad

chaacte or derb a peren reiden o s

cont Wit repect to te ie o reabtaon a

eonde o a a crnal record wil odiarly e rered

to rese evdene of reiiao eore ee is graed as

a e o sceo. Hee appcao on ovied

aie us be eauaed on a case b case ba wi

eabiiatio a facor to be cosdered in te erse o

diceon.

A 21 179 05 8 Ap , 2oio


15/25

(FINGS YIS

e Rendt hs bee lawfu pat reidet for

mor h fiv ys a he a lo has esidd U S

cntusly v ya after vig bn dme i ay

sus. A e Rspoen as bee ccd h

cocts a f gavae ey. T ue n this

cs ee he dseo bag os

k Me of C-VT.

Pi e comecee o e eis Hng e

Dm ld ec ioed e h l

ks ee cod ad hat a eco could e

edee i s mt. i o e ss

i, Rsp was g e pp e a

eessa: cios pia d wo o

e s Cur a e plici s ec a

as l te d e te es i kd

I d dciio is e, t C a

t co t e evee s

a o e ad 9

n d e dcmea eee, Cou bs as

ieed o t Rsod s fe

Repoe i e id Sa

10 o s , sd v

H s s x s U

9 Apri 6 0lO

' '


16/25

(consisng o, t not lmted o hs ite tates tze we

of teeandaal ears wo Ue ates en hilren,

awf eaent esent fhe and three sisters who e a

eay present n ths ot Atouh Resonden hs am

in Mo he stated at e does not hae ay cotac wt he.

Respondent ateded scool to he nit grade in e ed

ates He as wed m at ad Prode, long

tks d kn nveno

esode stated a f he s reoved fro he nted

aes e has deed that his chldre woul reai i the

ned Staes as wod be nabe o suor te Mexco

e's aso oneed as to how t wo afect hs fae. Pror

o hs etenton esonde state he saw hs aer ay

d e ao asssted his father finay escorted m to

his docto visits Resonden estfe as to hs ates

edca ondtn Aordng o te Resoden, n adto to

he docents otane in Ebt Resones fater sfers

ro g probems artris ad he has probems w is sina

d aes at he as sffeed or te whle esodent

desribed is nsp wh is wfe as a god one e

tfed tat alg e ot ge mared 2 e ha

een n a log-te: reatonsh wth he rior o heir o

Resonden stated hat f he were to eur exio he wo

so e dfcul adjtg to fe in tat cout as e s

la t at co

A 2 7

e beleves a hs eeo s

0 r 8 2


17/25

bee dfficl or aml especa so wo a ome

leg dabiy a s eveope ebelos He

beev e fil wo o e flly s o s

we doe od -me empoet, se1s epe ecig ica

icy.

Respoet ste tat e oes ot ve y pobe

w alcoo s eve bee reste o vg e te

ece d ee bee e wi g Repodet

ie to pior g se 2 is paicipatio g

ecto ces i 0 wic e complete esodet sd

e di o ake dg classes wie i o tt e

e gs o Ne Ye' Da i 7

espoet tested i el regag wo

covctios e mitted o eg coviced 2 o te

ofese o acilitto afl possesso o sae o

mij Accog to e espoet a fe o is w

eerecig mrl ificltes wc cae e ie o

epoly ee t te Respodets ome o appoxmaey wo

o ree mo Accdg o e espode e e sk

im o oe some cs o Repoet1

popery eqe o ic e espoet coseed

Apoimaey oe mot ate te d v o espe

eece Reoet ee tat te e ws soi

mij e ome o ms te te e ove

wt te espodet Repde we eaed

A 9 1 ri a 2


18/25

bn stod i the home. d aorin o e Responde, e

wife isapproe of e on Te esponde sted tht h

t skd is fid o c te soage o te ds

o, but ha he ren resed to do so I ode o ge e

Rsondt o an slt out th g actvty th

spodt sttd ha th rid g m $500 hih th

esot acct Te soa he ajuaa Rd s

home cod tl pod as aese. A oa of

approxatly 21. os o a aa a o i o

oo of Rspodt's gg sodt pd ty o e

o ng o t spodt th offs wa

sely uc to do d coplt hs

poatio

spodt so ttifid abo his 2007 ovo for

gt spodts ws t ct o hs of

on o h podt ha pevously o is s

eluar phone d to jealoy O is occo podt

reqese ta oc i c o

or fo m to t ot owd and aso fo hi to vei

th a of her cals Accodg o t espone s e

cod ot t hm t exa oaion o t bill h case

hm o beom susios Rspod t ddd o g oe o

is faher's sdc d s wf did o w i o leae e

ous Rspodt tstid t as rocee to sd

spondt spoted hs hs l i hs ost a eazed

9 05 2 Ai 8 00


19/25

( e e prin ma on it. Reponden ten procd

to cean gn. He aed tat a e a lang t gn, h

we ged he ile nd ponted t toad herelf He

aempe o ke he rife aay from e we wn of ad

h wie in he bdoe. epondent ed tat he nee

intended to ha e and he wa ae e fe a

h cle w loded

Repondent acnoedged ta the satement poded b

i ife o polce ho ate te ootig ored a

diferent ro tatemen tat te hootng a accient.

e eeve i fe' taeent at ta e ere ae

we h w de nuece of he medcation he d ee

give eonden wfe h ied lee on Reonen s

b hee proceedig n c he aed 007

onvicton w a acen Reonde w orginaly cargedwih atped fis egee mu an aggrvae aaul oeti

iolce e ed uil to an aee count of ng an

w eneced o two year n pon Ding h two-yea

eence Repnden did n e a eaiao cae

ahogh ee y hae ee oe oec oence ce

offered

Wn t Cot wgh a o Repondent' oe

eqtie aant negate acor h ort in at e

eiou eve co iiate agait te fvole exese

o ceton preoy noed epondent reoe

2 79 705 3 i 8,


20/25

ese e wa onvte o a oa u offe

relan o e ae of ajana Te ecod urte eec

e eonde ' s cnd as igy cpe s ws e

rg rgs i me eei i f n n

sde n cse xiy. ed of edey

eang g drgs i oe ponen

cpted $50 f s e a sig e a

oe i oe a Rpnt oge appove of

ai epe ak fen o eae ee

e ooe uce acepe e pae d

h e o ri e oe e gs

of x 21.3 pos mrijuana a o s

on oo of Re gg Rso gui

aca h esee ms e ple o g

knoege oe en a cg ie o o

ffee d a e oie e e e

eans r rn e oso o e fe

awful oesson of o s. e Aoney

Genea a epeaey epized e e i oe

xpie an g fickng d ee yet ha ae es

onve o oo oder an pie o e cY-

c e Mae o . 23 I& De 27 275 276 (G00) Ts, lie w as kwg povid aner ero

a r ppr o oe aina o a

knoee a e p a o or ee

19 0 4 A 8 210


21/25

uc ac a dffc ta of demonsrai t


22/25

;-snt ad hi fr, tt e wld ffer

emotoll y w t b epr Resoe ee o

removed T etim o eon ' faher vdnce

ee fo Reoen o rm te Ute Sttes. A smlr

etl b s ou Rede , e

ce I ssessg p it rie b

vitue e pe ' emo Cou cn co

eoe oe smoe r o o

j coe oxy o ar. Suc oor un o i ft

xcb k e c,

g coe oimy o s h ec

s ne w oe Te or es t tt

oo s o er s ouie o

e s dsp or oe eue h Uiteq e ur ccstaces r te

rdh1 gy epoe

u- s dur Resdet's bsece te e

ee o ove or T

cto t t ' r ol p pn te

Repen or c s

I vo os o'

cs, ts Ct e R' r

eqi h e uv t oi tse e g the c ecdA 79 7 16 A 8 00


23/25

epecally his 3 covco for facang posson of

majua for ale , hs ort fin at a favoe exerce ofd ce on s not wae d #lc disiuion of ugas , d conties to ri cotls l es the rc

sociey on a ay bass h Cort os no fn y xcepoa

mtaig irctances pree t Rspoet a fo hs

Court to l othw T Cout spathzs wt

esponden fay ees who w noutdy expeec

har p oton wt i oal Howeer h ou st

appy t aw o the fac egares of how sypathe te

aur of te fac as pte re o t Cout. I

con eo of ts u i Cou ust coue that a

faoale eercse of scrto wou ot e te bt teest

o te U d Stats i ts a

Fo he aoe state ros oa eare wil

aso e nied th Cot iceto I u e Cour

an h facta aegatos d chage of rmob: as N " , fod n h oce to Appea a nies rq or re .

as a mater o eto e Resoet as o expese y_

1

,: .-

fea of eecuo or toue if eoed to Mexco has: "),-r ' -" Jn;

fad t e his eigility for y ohe fo";f @f

Accon h o ow orr a

O

I IS HBY ODERED th oton to nat be

dene d

A 79 0 Apl 8 2


24/25

!_.. ).

T BY h Rese ' l co o

eon of ovl ee.

IT HB vo erue ee

T HEREBY R Roe e eove ro e

Ue e o exo

Reivd&QbyDLww/ob of ROP

79 70

L PCR WRo Je

A 20


25/25

CERTIFIE PAGE

eeby ce d ceeg ee

L SPCE-WS er :

MEL JESU OVM

2 9

z

eld s een e , n s rgn

rcp ee h e e Oce

n Reew

k/

Ke Seele, Trnscbe

YORK SOGIC SEVS , 4 N Gege SreeYk, env 66( ) 8 5 4-

M 2

en De

Documents

Manuel Jesus Olivas-Matta, A021 179 705 (BIA Aug. 9, 2010)