Managing Diversity in Education: The Malaysian ExperienceProfessor Datin Dr. Amla Salleh

Faculty of Education

UKMPlenary Paper 1Abstract

In a country such as Malaysia, with its uniquely diverse population, national unity is essential to harmonious living among its citizens. To achieve this, Malaysia has demonstrated serious efforts to its economic and social programs. The meaning of national unity has evolved. The aspiration to promote unity began as an effort to seek and develop commonness and shared values among Malaysian. Over the years, the concept has changed to learning to accept and respect one anothers differences while holding shared visions of a developed nation. This paper reports a fragment of Malaysias experience in its course to realize one of its national agendasaspiring for a harmonious societyvia the educational route. Since the educational curriculum determines academic activities, the discussion will focus on Malaysian national school curriculum from the viewpoint of the multicultural analysisKeywords: national unity, multiculturalism, inclusiveness, national school curriculum

*Amla Salleh, Professor of Guidance and Counselling, Department of Education and Community Wellbeing Faculty of Education, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Bangi, 43600 Selangor, Malaysia

Email: amla@ukm.edu.my

Introduction

To begin my discussion, let me pose a question first asked in the UNESCO Delores Commissions 1996 report, which is related to the theme of the conference todayeducation and learner diversity. The commission asked, Is it possible to devise a form of education which might make it possible to avoid conflicts or resolve them peacefully by developing respect for other people, their cultures and their spiritual values? (UNESCO, 1996).What was the context of this question?

It was a global scenario of rising tensions and conflictsespecially in countries whose citizens came from different cultural backgrounds. This pushed the issue of multiculturalism onto the center stage of the debate on conflict resolution and avoidance. This discussion has created awareness of the importance of equipping citizens, especially young people, with the knowledge, skills, and attitudes necessary to cultivate a culture of peace and tolerance.I find this question highly relevant to Malaysia because of the countrys need to effectively manage its diverse, multicultural population.Malaysia is characterized as having a plural society because its citizens are multicultural, multi-religious, and multilingual. As of 2010, Malaysia had a total population of 28.3 million, including 8% who were non-citizens. The population consisted of the following ethnic groups: Bumiputera (67.4%), Chinese (24.6%), Indians (7.3%), and others (0.7%).

Since gaining independence in 1957, Malaysia has been known as a model of multicultural society because of its serious, deliberate efforts and success in maintaining peace and harmony among diverse people. Malaysias Federal Constitution, economic programs, and education sectors are all intended to promote multicultural-related values and competencies. The goal to promote unity based on citizens similarities and shared values have expanded to encouraging acceptance and respect of differences within a shared vision for developing the nation. The recently introduced concept of 1Malaysia values unity as equal to diversity, which means acknowledging the presence of multiracial, multicultural, multi-religious, and multilingual others, and as equal to inclusiveness, which means embracing and celebrating diversity. Although Malaysia has been regarded as a model for multicultural society, no comprehensive study has addressed how and why Malaysia had acquired such a reputation. Research to understand fully what elements contribute to Malaysias success in managing its multicultural population is needed.MulticulturalismThe term multiculturalism carries a wide variety of meanings, from positive attitudes toward other cultures, to advocacy of equal rights for all minority groups, to policies regarding these groups and the maintenance of cultural diversity. Caleb (1997:6) reports that multiculturalism has been described as a salad bowl, cultural mosaic, or stew pot in contrast to a melting pot.

Modood and Ahmad (2007) define multiculturalism from a Muslim perspective and stress two characteristics: i) mutual acceptance and ii) the celebration of commonality. Mutual acceptance entails interactions which generate understanding, acceptance, and respect of the rights of others and the willingness to share public space with them. Mutual acceptance goes beyond tolerating other religious communities, which is considered the lowest level of acceptance (2005:198). Celebrating commonality is preferred over celebrating diversity because the respondents believe that most cultural and religious beliefs are common to everyone; when focusing on similarities, differences become insignificant and more acceptable. The authors emphasize that multiculturalism is acceptable to Muslims because Islam is naturally multicultural.

In Malaysia, the term most commonly used to describe peoples from different cultures is multiethnic, while the mechanism to achieve harmony and peace among multiethnic people is the promotion of unity or a united people. National unity has been set as the top priority in the official national agenda expressed in the past 10 five-year National Economic Plans (NEP).For the purposes of this study, multiculturalism is defined as educational efforts to support and develop attitudes which create and sustain unity, harmony, and peace among the multiethnic people of Malaysia. This definition includes mutual acceptance as described by Modood and Ahmad. The Present Study In this presentation, I discuss part of a large research project on National Social Cohesion in Malaysia led by Distinguished Professor Dr. Shamsul Amri Baharudin. Specifically, I present the findings from a subproject which I lead examining elements of multiculturalism in the Malaysian national education curriculum.Research MethodologyLet me briefly describe how we conducted our study. We undertook qualitative research with an exploratory design. Using samples of documents and respondents, we performed document content analysis and face-to-face (group and individual) interviews guided by a protocol.

Our sample documents included the national curriculum, subject curricula for history and Islamic education in forms 15, and teaching materials (current textbooks).The respondents consisted of three groups of education stakeholders: those involved in curriculum development (24 policy makers), those involved in implementing the curriculum (22 teachers), and those who benefit from the curriculum (88 students). There were a total of 134 respondents, and data were analyzed using thematic approach. 3. Multiculturalism NEPNEP 10: Definition of Unity

4. Policy Framework education laws and reports

2. Curriculum content

Subjects (case study of history subjects)

Pedagogyteaching and learning activities (case study of moral education)Materialstextbooks (case study of History and Islamic Education)AssessmentexaminationsCo-curriculum and extra-curricular activitiesTeachers multicultural competences

Figure 1: Conceptual Framework of the Study1.Multicultural Elements in the National Education Curriculum

As shown in the conceptual framework, this study encompasses four domains.Domain 1: We examine the extent of multicultural elements in the national education curriculum.Domain 2: The concept of multiculturalism used in the study is derived from the concept of national unity described by the Malaysia (NEP). Domain 3: Multicultural elements in the curriculum are examined, particularly in the curriculum content, syllabi for sample subjects, pedagogy (classroom teaching and learning), teaching and learning materials (textbook content), and teachers multicultural competences. We also look at co-curriculum and extra-curricular activities. Domain 4: These elements in the curriculum within the framework of national education policies and. Now let us look at the definition of curriculum given by Malaysia Education Act 1996:An educational program that includes curricular and co-curricular activities which encompasses all the knowledge, skills, norms, values, cultural elements and beliefs to help develop a pupil fully in the physical, spiritual, mental and emotional aspects as well as to inculcate and develop desirable moral values and to transmit knowledge.

What do our education policies and frameworks say about multiculturalism?

Two major reports which stand as landmarks in Malaysian educational policy and practices regarding unity are Razaks Report (1956) and Rahman Talibs Report (1960). These two reports became the main source for the 1961 Education Act, which incorporated elements of multiculturalism into the Malayan (now Malaysian) educational system. The three major goals of public education stated in the 1961 law are i) to promote national unity ii) to produce the human resources required for national development, and iii) to develop a progressive, disciplined Malaysian society. These goals were translated into the National Philosophy of Education (NPE), which stipulates that all students should receive an integrated education which develops their full intellectual, spiritual, emotional, and physical potentials.

The 1966 Education Act, which repealed the 1961 Education Act, initiated the democratization of education and strengthened policies related to national unity, thereby reinforcing diversity in education. The act stipulates that there shall be no discrimination against any citizen in the education system and that i)every religious group has the right to establish and maintain institutions for education in its own religion ii)The Malay language will be the medium of instruction in all types of national schools, with the aim to promote national unity by developing skills to communicate within and among various communities iii)students mother tongue, including Chinese and Tamil (for Indian communities), will be used as the medium of instruction at the primary level in and students will be allowed to continue learning their mother tongue at the secondary level

Malaysias national educational policy focuses on supporting equal education rights and giving equal educational opportunities for all school-age children (Ministry of Education [MOE], 2005). Among the national education policys philosophy-related goals are to develop a national consciousness, to inculcate students with desirable moral values, such as belief in God, and putting emphasis on universal values, high moral standards, and healthy attitudes, and to nurture the desire for national integrity and unityThe Education Development Plan 20012010, called the blueprint, focuses on integrating information and communication technology into the teaching and learning process. Another emphasis is on improving the teaching and learning of the national language, which is also the medium of instruction in schools, as well as the English language. The plan also provides strategies for developing well-rounded students with solid communication and critical thinking skills, adequate knowledge, and good moral values.

The following blueprint, The Malaysia Education Development Plan 20132025 (MOE, 2012) provides a clear framework for promoting elements of multicultural values. The framework requires that all students in Malaysia develop competent critical thinking skills, broaden their knowledge, acquire effective leadership skills, be able to converse in two languages, possess good ethical and spiritual values, and appreciate the national identity. Three departments under the MOE are responsible for the implementation of this plan: the Curriculum Development, Islamic Education, and School Management divisions. These clear policies and frameworks with elements of multiculturalism provide guidelines for curriculum development.National Education CurriculumThe analysis of materials related to national curriculum produced the following findings.

All schools in the national educational system use a common, locally oriented curriculum, medium of instruction (Bahasa Melayu), and examination system. The national educational curriculum consists of core, compulsory, and elective subjects. The Education Act provides for a free basic education consisting of six years of primary and five years of secondary education. Primary education is compulsory. Eleven years of compulsory education (six years at the primary level and five at the secondary level) will be introduced in 2015.As stipulated in education policies and framework the role of the school curriculum is to work towards the holistic development of the individual mentally, physically, spiritually, and emotionally through imparting general knowledge and skills, cultivating, instilling and fostering healthy attitudes and accepted moral values. As the curriculum is to bring forth the Malaysian citizen who is balanced and well-rounded individual, trained, skilful, and cherishes the national aspiration for unity, therefore elements of multicultural competency are inherent in learning objectives.Looking at the learning objectives 1 (socialization process) and 2 (development of personality and attitudes) of preschool; learning objectives 2 (acquisition of complex skills and knowledge), 3 (development of personality, attitudes and values), and 4 (leadership qualities and self-confidence development) of primary school and learning objectives 1 (to increase language proficiency and communication skills), 3 (acquisition of knowledge and mastery skills and to use them in daily living), 4 (development of abilities and faculties for the betterment of self and society) and 5 (development self-confidence and resilience to face challenges in life) of secondary school, it is clear that these learning objectives are related to multiculturalism.

The National Curriculum has been formulated on a number of curriculum principles to ensure the continuity of education from preschool to primary and secondary levels; general education for all; Integration of the intellectual, spiritual, emotional and physical aspects; Mastery of Malay Language and English Language; Emphasis on values and attitudes development and; Life-long learning

The curriculum is content and skill-based and the integrated approach is the main focus in the design of the curriculum. In the lists the subjects for primary and secondary schools, there are subjects who reflect the contents of multicultural competencies such as Citizenship and Civic Education, Moral Education and Islamic Education. The multicultural elements are also taught in other subjects. Each subject must incorporate the inculcation of moral values and positive attitudes. The elements of knowledge, skills and values are incorporated in order to bring about the integrated development of the intellectual, spiritual, emotional, social and physical aspects of the individual.

The national curriculum at both primary and secondary school levels ensures that students develop desirable attitudes and behavior based on human, religious, and spiritual values. The inculcation of the multicultural approach is made possible through stand alone- subjects, carrier subjects and infusion through non-academic subjects and students activities: SHAPE \* MERGEFORMAT

Figure 2: Multicultural approach in School Curriculum

a) Stand-alone Subjects

There are three subjects identified as standalone subjects are Moral Education, Civics and Citizenship Education, and Islamic Study. They are all compulsory subjects for all levels, primary and secondary.

b) Carrier Subjects

There are seven carrier subjects. With the exception of local Language, most of these are compulsory subjects. Table 1: Carrier Subjects in Malaysian National CurriculumSubjectPrimaryLower SecondaryUpper Secondary

Local StudiesCompulsory

HistoryCompulsoryCompulsory

GeographyCompulsoryElective

Bahasa MalaysiaCompulsoryCompulsoryCompulsory

English LanguageCompulsoryCompulsoryCompulsory

Local Language (Mandarin, Tamil, Iban)Compulsory (Mandarin in Chinese Primary School; Tamil in Tamil Primary School)

Elective (National Primary School)ElectiveElective

c) Infusion through Non Academic Subjects/Activities

The third method of inculcating multicultural elements lies within non-academic subjects, such as Life Skills, Visual Arts, and Music, and through weekly school assemblies, co-curricular activities, and a new unity program called the Student Integration Plan for Unity. Most of these activities are compulsory, except for Visual Arts and music which are not compulsory for all level.

As mentioned earlier Moral Education is one of the stand alone subjects which dedicated for the inculcation of multicultural value: The goal of Moral Education curriculum is to develop individuals who are responsible and able to contribute towards the prosperity and stability of the nation and the global community. The content of Moral Education is classified into seven learning areas consisting of 40 values (Table 2).

Table 2: Learning areas in Moral EducationNo.Learning AreaValues

1Self-Developmentbelieve in God, trustworthiness, self-esteem, responsibility, humility, tolerance, self-reliance, diligence, creativity, love, justice, rationality, moderation

2Familylove and care for parents, respect for family, family norms and ethics, duty and obligations

3Environmentlove and care for the environment, harmony between people and environment, sustainability of environment, sensitivity to environmental issues

4Patriotismlove for the nation, loyalty and devotion, willingness to sacrifice, importance of national interest

5Human Rightsprotection of rights of children, women, labor, the unfortunates, consumers

6Democracyrespects for rules and regulations, freedom of speech and expression, religious freedom, participation, openness

7Peace and Harmonyliving together in harmony, non-violent approach to resolve conflicts, mutual help and cooperation, mutual respects among nations

The second stand alone subject is Civics and Citizenship Education:Civics and citizenship education aims to inculcate awareness in pupils of their roles and responsibilities towards society and their country, to create united members of society and patriotic citizens, and to contribute towards the welfare of the country and the world. Civics and citizenship education has three major components, namely knowledge, skills, and values.

The knowledge component is the acquisition of basic knowledge and information to become responsible and effective citizens. Among the topics discussed are

i. Identify behavior which can contribute towards development of character and conduct.

ii. Explain role and responsibility towards family member to create a happy family.

iii. Explain importance of living in harmony.

iv. Understand diverse religions, tradition and culture of Malaysian society

v. Explain system of Malaysian government and contribution of countrys leader.

vi. Identify challenges and threats in society.

The skills component emphasizes the process of developing skills for civic participation in the following areas:

i. Manage self and responsibility.

ii. Practice moderation in behavior.

iii. Interact by graceful with family member, partner, and society

iv. Learn to live together for personal well-being and society.

v. Join community activity for common good.

vi. Handle self conflict, family and peer

vii. Making wise decision by considering self and other people interest.

The value component focuses on the acquisition of dispositions that provide the foundation for civic attitudes and beliefs in the following areas:

i. Have confidence on self ability.

ii. Appreciate contribution parents and family member.

iii. Respect race and other cultures.

iv. Care for the environment.

v. Show we-spirit.

vi. Respect leader and appreciate their contribution.

vii. Show pride and love for the country.

Islamic Education

Islamic education aimed to provide basic skills of reading the al-Quran, consolidating the faith, understanding Islamic characteristics and way of life, and the nurturing of a noble and courteous personality. Among subjects taught in Islamic Education, History of Prophet Muhammad (peace upon Him) and Moral Character are regarded as having elements multicultural competencies.

In history of Prophet Muhammad there are a number of knowledge component from which students could learn aspects of multicultural values and competencies. The topics include Prophet Muhammad strategies and approaches in conflict resolution; his communication in preaching of Islam (dakwah); his management style in family affairs and community matters, and; his characters and values

Moral character has two major components which are knowledge component and value component. The knowledge components covers topics such as code of conduct or etiquette related food consuming (table manners); Relation with parents and elders; Friendship; Social relation; Responsibility toward public facilities; Responsibility towards natural environment, and ; Patriotism and nationalism. While in values component of Moral Character stresses on the values such as harmony, love, respect, cooperate, honour and tolerance.Teacher CompetenciesOn Teachers competencies, it is well established that teachers competences have direct impacts on students learning. The rule also applies to integrating elements of multiculturalism into the classroom. Following the four major constructs suggested by the literature, teachers multicultural knowledge, awareness, attitudes, and skills were assessed during classroom observations and interviews of teachers and students.

We found the following elements within each of these constructs.

The knowledge construct included students background, knowledge of the nation and other cultures and religions, level of national language proficiency, and grasp of the subject matter.

The awareness constructs concerned national educational policies, teachers roles, cultural differences, and the multicultural aspects of students backgrounds, including their behaviors.

In the attitude construct, teachers demonstrated good values, such as being caring, helpful, tolerant, appreciative, respectful, good listeners, willing to share with students, professional, and patriotic.

In the skills construct, teachers showed the ability to develop knowledge by integrating multicultural issues into subject content, using multicultural examples, and fostering high-level thinking. Teachers also worked to reduce prejudice towards and among students and to strengthen their ability to discuss certain issues. Teachers treated students from different cultural backgrounds fairly and demonstrated effective interpersonal communication by being good listeners and helping students resolve conflicts peacefully. The theme of good classroom management also emerged when teachers took into consideration the wellbeing of students with diverse backgrounds when deciding the classroom sitting arrangement, decoration, distribution of assignment and tasks, rules, and regulations.

The content of these subjects and the co-curricular activities, therefore, are designed to cultivate values and skills of a multicultural society. Examining materials in the three stand alone subjects and observing the classroom activities in History class provide insight on how multicultural element is integrated into classroom practice.Co curriculum

The second part of the curriculum being examined is the Co-curriculum which is an extension of the classroom teaching and learning process. The activities in the co-curricular programs are structured to provide opportunities for students to increase reinforce and put into practice the knowledge, skills and values acquired in the classroom. Participation in co-curricular activities is compulsory for all students. Participation in co-curricular activities begins at Year 3 in primary school. Each pupil is expected to become member at least one club/society, uniform group and take part in one sports/game. Co-curricular activities are part of the school hours. There are four categories of co curriculum activities:

Societies and clubs ; An assembly of special interest groups, some of which support the academic subjects in the curriculum, such as English language society, drama club and religious societies. committees to organize activities for the members

Uniform Groups: The groups require members to wear uniform. Their activities which usually include drill, emphasis discipline, team work and leadership training. Some of them also have community services. Examples of uniform groups are scouts, red crescent society, police cadet and brigades

Sports and Games: Students are involved in athletes or games of their choices. This group of co-curricular activities focuses on students physical development and motor skills as well in the development of sportsmanship, team work, team spirit and co-operation. Most students involve in the activities at the recreational level, while others who show potentials are encouraged to participate at competitive level.

Others: Others consist of activities with emphasis on the pursuit of certain hobbies or providing community services such as gotong-royong in cleanliness campaign, visits to old folks home, charity drives, etc. A student advisor is appointed to oversee students activities.

Co curriculum provides opportunity for students to interact and to foster relationship.

Our observation of the related documents and teaching and learning materials and activities used in and outside the classroom suggests three major themes of multicultural values: instilling the relationship or bond between/among students, Instilling a feeling of unity and sense of belonging and, Instilling the ability to work togetherDiscussion and ConclusionsOur observation of the related documents and teaching and learning materials and activities used in and outside the classroom suggests three major themes of multicultural values: instilling the relationship or bond between/among students, Instilling a feeling of unity and sense of belonging and, Instilling the ability to work togetherDefining curriculum as the design of the teaching and learning processes, this investigation has found that Malaysian national curriculum has been designed to incorporate elements of multiculturalism into the teaching and learning processes both in formal classroom learning and in informal learning setting such as activities in co curricular, in content based subjects like history and civic education and in process based approach across the curriculum. The incorporation of multicultural content in the national curriculum has been guided continuously by education policies and Malaysia five-year Economic Pelan (MEP) since independence to the present time. This implies the genuine intention of the past and the present government to promote a way to live together peacefully among its multi ethnics people through education. Evidence from all the circulars (1957- present) that were studied suggests that the implementation of multicultural policies is monitored closely. To borrow Nye (2007)s expression with regard to multicultural process, the approach taken by Malaysia indicate that there is an active management and governance of managing multiculturalism in Malaysian national curriculum. We summarize our finding as follows:The Malaysian national education curriculum has three major multicultural elements:

i) A multicultural approach to education; the multicultural approach includes a clear multicultural framework and policies and active management and governance of themii) A multicultural process in education; the multicultural process centers on having a common national language, syllabus, and examination system. Both English and mother tongues are taught as second languages. Teachers possess multicultural competencies; students continue to learn about others, having a vision of a developed nation, become knowledgeable, skilled, and ethical citizens.iii) Multicultural content in education; The multicultural value content includes knowing and appreciating others cultures, languages, and religions; respecting others different way of life; being tolerant; loving the country, or being patriotic; understanding the constitution. These values are taught as subject content.In conclusion, Malaysia has developed several strategies for the dynamic governance of multicultural issues in education. Although we did not examine the impact of the curriculum, we aware that not every step to unite the people has been realized, nor is Malaysia completely free from racial challenges. However, the country generally enjoys more times of peace than conflict. Such a state of affairs implies that these multicultural strategies, including those in educational, are achieving positive impacts, while the need periodical reviews to identify areas requiring improvement remains. Having said that, looking at the time of Dolor Commission raised its concern on the role of education in promoting peace in 1996 and Malaysia has designed a school curriculum with a goal to promote unity among its multicultural people five decades before that, could Malaysia National Curriculum become one of the models that answer such concern?

References:Bahagian Pendidikan Guru. 2012. Falsafah Pendidikan Guru. Retrieved on 8 June 2013 from http://www.moe.gov.my/bpg/index.php/mengenai-bpg/falsafah-pendidikan-guruBahagian Perancangan dan Penyelidikan. (2011). Inisiatif pendidikan ke arah pendidikan berkualiti.

Department of Statistics Malaysia, (2013). Official Portal. Retrieved 24 May 2013 from www.statistics.gov.my/portal/index.php?option=com_content&id=1215 Department of the National Service Training. (2012). Buku Laporan Tahunan 2011. Kuala Lumpur: Kementerian Pertahanan MalaysiaEconomic Planning Unit. 2001. The Eight Malaysia Plan. Putrajaya: The Prime Minister Department.Education Act 1996 (Act 550). Peraturan-peraturan dan kaedah-kaedah terpilih. Petaling Jaya : International Law Book Services.Mahathir Mohamad. 1998. The Way Forward. London : Weidenfeld and Nicolson.Malaysian Demographic Profile, 2013. CIA World Factbook. Retrieved on 28 June 2013 from http://www.indexmundi.com/malaysia/demographics_profile.htmlMERCY Malaysia. (2013). Online source: http://mercy.org.my/0910060509%C2%BBDisaster_Risk_Reduction_(DRR).aspx

Milne, R.S & Mauzy, D.K. 1997. Politics and Government in Malaysia. Federal Publication, Kuala Lumpur.Ministry of Education. 2005. Sukatan Pelajaran Pendidikan Sivik dan Kewarganegaraan. Kuala Lumpur: Pusat Perkembangan Kurikulum. Ministry of Education. 2012. Preliminary Report: Malaysia Education Blue Print 2013-2025. Retrieved on 8 June 2013 from http://www4. unescobkk. org/nespap/ sites/default/ files/Preliminary-Blueprint-ExecSummary-Eng_0.pdfModood T. and Ahmad F. 2007. British Muslim Perspectives on Multiculturalism. Theory, Culture & Society. Vol. 24, No. 2, pp 187213. London, SAGE Publication. Retrieved 28 June 2013 from http://tcs.sagepub.com/content/24/2/187.full.pdf+htmlMohamad, M. (2002). Speech. 31st IASL Conference, 4-9 August, Petaling Jaya, Malaysia. Prime Minister Department. 2010. Vision 2020. Retrieved on 28 June 2013 from http://www.pmo.gov.my/?menu=page&page=1904Rahman Talib Report. 1960. Penyata Jawatankuasa Penyemak Pelajaran 1960. Kuala Lumpur : Percetakan Kerajaan. Razak Report.1956. Penyata Jawatankuasa Pelajaran 1956. Kuala Lumpur. Percetakan Kerajaan.Shamsul A.B. 2011. Public Policy & Social Cohesion in Malaysia: A Systematic, Systemic and Symbiotic Relation. Public lecture at Razak School of Government. Retrieved 28 June 2013 http://www.rsog.com.my/media/130.pdf.Shamsul A.B., 1990. From British to Bumiputera Rule. Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.)

Suara Rakyat Malaysia. 2013. Access online on the 28th May 2013 from http://www.suaram.net/?page_id=4790The 1Malaysia Concept. 2013. From http://www.pmo.gov.my/dokumenattached/1Malaysia_B.pdfUNESCO. 1996. Learning: The Tresure Within. France, United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization.William Shaw. (1976). Tun Razak His Life and Times. Singapore: Longman Group Ltd.

Stand alone subject

( Moral Education, Islamic Education; Civics and Citizenship Education

Infusion/permeation through non-academic 'carrier' subjects/activities

Co-curricular Activities, Sports& Games

Academic carrier subjects

(Local Studies; History, Geography, Languages)

1