36
APPENDIX D AIR QUALITY EMISSIONS CALCULATIONS

LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

APPENDIX D

AIR QUALITY EMISSIONS CALCULATIONS

Page 2: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)
Page 3: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Air

Qu

ali

ty E

mis

sion

Calc

ula

tion

s

Sum

mar

yS

um

marizes tota

l em

issio

ns b

y c

ale

ndar

year.

Com

bust

ion

Estim

ate

s e

mis

sio

ns fro

m n

on-r

oad e

quip

ment

exhaust

as w

ell

as p

ain

ting.

Fugi

tive

Estim

ate

s fin

e p

art

icula

te e

mis

sio

ns f

rom

eart

hm

ovin

g,

vehic

le t

raff

ic,

and w

indblo

wn d

ust

Gra

ding

Alt1

Decom

mis

sio

n the U

SC

G L

OR

AN

–C

Pro

gra

m a

nd t

erm

inate

the N

ort

h A

merican L

OR

AN

–C

Sig

na

l

Alt2

Tra

nsfe

r m

anagem

ent of th

e L

OR

AN

–C

Pro

gra

m t

o a

noth

er

Govern

ment

agency

Alt3

Auto

mate

, secure

, and u

nsta

ff L

OR

AN

sta

tions

Alt4

Convert

Sig

nal to

Enhanced L

OR

AN

(eLO

RA

N),

secure

and u

nsta

ff L

OR

AN

sta

tions

Estim

ate

s the n

um

ber

of days o

f site p

repara

tion,

to b

e u

sed f

or

estim

ating h

eavy e

quip

ment

exh

au

st

an

d

eart

hm

ovin

g d

ust em

issio

ns

D-1

Page 4: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Air

Qu

ali

ty E

mis

sion

Calc

ula

tion

s

Air

Qua

lity

Emis

sion

s fr

om P

ropo

sed

Act

ion

NO

xVO

CC

OSO

2PM

10(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)A

lt1C

onstr

uction C

om

bustion

0.1

62

0.0

26

0.2

16

0.0

03

0.0

05

Constr

uction F

ugitiv

e D

ust

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

7.0

91

TO

TA

L A

lt1

0.1

62

0.0

26

0.2

16

0.0

03

7.0

96

Air

Qua

lity

Emis

sion

s fr

om P

ropo

sed

Act

ion

NO

xVO

CC

OSO

2PM

10(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)A

lt2 a

nd A

lt3C

onstr

uction C

om

bustion

0.0

002

0.0

0003

0.0

002

0.0

00003

0.0

0001

Constr

uction F

ugitiv

e D

ust

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

703

TO

TA

L A

lt2 a

nd A

lt3

0.0

002

0.0

0003

0.0

002

0.0

00003

0.0

703

Air

Qua

lity

Emis

sion

s fr

om P

ropo

sed

Act

ion

NO

xVO

CC

OSO

2PM

10(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)A

lt4Lo

wC

onstr

uction C

om

bustion

3.1

97

0.5

66

3.7

33

0.0

66

0.1

07

Constr

uction F

ugitiv

e D

ust

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

28.7

43

TO

TA

L A

lt4Low

3.1

97

0.5

66

3.7

33

0.0

66

28.8

50

Air

Qua

lity

Emis

sion

s fr

om P

ropo

sed

Act

ion

NO

xVO

CC

OSO

2PM

10(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)(to

n)A

lt4H

igh

Constr

uction C

om

bustion

25.4

76

3.8

87

29.7

60

0.5

12

0.8

55

Constr

uction F

ugitiv

e D

ust

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

91.3

20

TO

TA

L A

lt4H

igh

25.4

76

3.8

87

29.7

60

0.5

12

92.1

75

D-2

Page 5: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n C

ombu

stio

n Em

issi

ons

for D

ecom

mis

sion

the

USC

G L

OR

AN

–C P

rogr

am a

nd te

rmin

ate

the

Nor

th A

mer

ican

LO

RA

N–C

Sig

nal

Com

bustion E

mis

sio

ns o

f V

OC

, N

Ox,

SO

2, C

O a

nd P

M10 D

ue t

o C

onstr

uction

Inclu

des:

1D

em

olis

h T

ow

er

7,0

00

ft2

2D

em

olis

h c

opp

er

radia

ls240,0

00

ft2

3D

em

olis

h T

ransm

itte

r B

uild

ing

5,0

00

ft2

4D

em

olis

h M

onitorin

g S

ite F

acili

ty100

ft2

Assum

ptions:

Tow

er

is 7

00 feet ta

ll b

uilt

on a

100ft2 c

oncre

te p

ad.

Land d

istu

rbance for

ea

ch c

opper

radia

l is

1,0

00 ft lo

ng b

y 2

ft

wid

e.

There

are

120 c

opper

radia

ls p

er

site.

Tota

l B

uild

ing C

onstr

uction A

rea:

0ft

2(N

one

)

Tota

l D

em

olis

hed A

rea:

12,1

00

ft2

(1,

3,

and 4

)

Tota

l P

aved A

rea:

0ft

2(N

one

)

Tota

l D

istu

rbed A

rea:

252,1

00

ft2

(1-4

)

Constr

uction D

ura

tion:

1.0

year(

s)

Annual C

onstr

uction A

ctivity:

230

days/y

r

Alt1

Com

bust

ion

D-3

Page 6: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

Fac

tors

Use

d fo

r Con

stru

ctio

n Eq

uipm

ent

Refe

rence: G

uid

e to A

ir Q

ualit

y A

ssessm

ent, S

MA

QM

D,

2004

Em

issio

n facto

rs a

re taken fro

m T

able

3-2

. A

ssum

ptions r

egard

ing t

he t

ype a

nd n

um

ber

of

equip

ment

are

fr

om

Table

3-1

unle

ss o

therw

ise n

ote

d.

Gra

ding

No.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Bulld

ozer

129.4

03.6

62

5.0

90

.59

1.1

7M

oto

r G

rader

110.2

21.7

61

4.9

80

.20

0.2

8W

ate

r T

ruck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.42

0.5

8T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

360.5

19.0

27

0.6

91

.21

2.0

3

Pavi

ngN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Paver

17.9

31.3

71

1.6

20

.16

0.2

2R

olle

r1

5.0

10.8

67

.34

0.1

00

.14

Tota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

212.9

42.2

31

8.9

60

.26

0.3

6

Dem

oliti

onN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Loader

17.8

61.3

51

1.5

20

.16

0.2

2H

aul T

ruck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.42

0.5

8T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

228.7

54.9

54

2.1

40

.58

0.8

0

Bui

ldin

g C

onst

ruct

ion

No.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Eq

uip

mentd

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

S

tationary

Genera

tor

Set

111.8

31.4

71

0.0

90

.24

0.4

7In

dustr

ial S

aw

11

7.0

22.1

21

4.5

20

.34

0.6

8W

eld

er

14.4

80.5

63

.83

0.0

90

.18

M

obile

(non-r

oa

d)

Tru

ck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.84

0.5

8F

ork

lift

14.5

70.7

96

.70

0.1

80

.13

Cra

ne

18.3

71.4

41

2.2

70

.33

0.2

3T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

667.1

69.9

87

8.0

32

.02

2.2

7

Note

: F

ootn

ote

s fo

r ta

ble

s a

re o

n follo

win

g p

age

Alt1

Com

bust

ion

D-4

Page 7: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Arc

hite

ctur

al C

oatin

gsN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Air C

om

pre

ssor

16.8

30.8

55

.82

0.1

40

.27

Tota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

16.8

30.8

55

.82

0.1

40

.27

a)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 g

uid

ance s

uggests

a d

efa

ult e

quip

ment

fleet

for

each a

ctivitiy

, assum

ing 1

0 a

cre

s o

f th

at

activity,

(e

.g., 1

0 a

cre

s o

f gra

din

g, 10 a

cre

s o

f pavin

g, e

tc.)

. T

he d

efa

ult e

quip

ment

fleet

is incre

ased f

or

each 1

0 a

cre

incre

me

nt

in

the s

ize o

f th

e c

onstr

uction p

roje

ct. T

hat is

, a 2

6 a

cre

pro

ject

would

round t

o 3

0 a

cre

s a

nd t

he f

leet

siz

e w

ould

be

th

ree tim

es the d

efa

ult fle

et fo

r a 1

0 a

cre

pro

ject.

b)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 r

efe

rence lis

ts e

mis

sio

n facto

rs f

or

reactive o

rganic

gas (

RO

G).

F

or

the p

urp

oses o

f th

is w

ork

sh

ee

t R

OG

= V

OC

.

c)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 r

efe

rence d

oes n

ot pro

vid

e S

O2 e

mis

sio

n f

acto

rs.

For

this

work

sheet,

SO

2 e

mis

sio

ns h

ave b

ee

n e

stim

ate

d

based o

n a

ppro

xim

ate

fuel use r

ate

for

die

sel e

quip

ment

and t

he a

ssum

ption o

f 500 p

pm

sulfur

die

sel fu

el.

For

the

ave

rag

e o

f

th

e e

quip

ment

fleet, the r

esultin

g S

O2 facto

r w

as f

ound t

o b

e a

ppro

xim

ate

ly 0

.04 t

imes t

he N

Ox e

mis

sio

n f

acto

r fo

r th

e m

ob

ile e

qu

ipm

en

t (b

ase

d

upon 2

002 U

SA

F IE

RA

"A

ir E

mis

sio

ns Invento

ry G

uid

ance")

and 0

.02 t

imes t

he N

Ox e

mis

sio

n f

acto

r fo

r all

oth

er

eq

uip

me

nt

(ba

se

d o

n A

P-4

2,

Ta

ble

3.4

-1)

d)

Typic

al equip

me

nt fleet fo

r build

ing c

onstr

uction

was n

ot

item

ized in S

MA

QM

D 2

004 g

uid

ance.

The e

quip

ment

list a

bo

ve

wa

s assum

ed b

ased

on S

MA

QM

D 1

994 g

uid

ance.

PRO

JEC

T-SP

ECIF

IC E

MIS

SIO

N F

AC

TOR

SU

MM

ARY

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2**

PM

10

135.0

20

5.2

20

40

.91

10

.70

01

.17

51

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

10.7

99

0.1

38

1.1

71

0.0

16

0.0

22

10.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

10.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

Exam

ple

: S

MA

QM

D E

mis

sio

n F

acto

r fo

r G

radin

g E

quip

ment

NO

x =

(T

ota

l G

radin

g N

Ox p

er

10 a

c*(

(tota

l dis

turb

ed a

rea

/43

56

0)/

10

))*(

Eq

uip

me

nt

Mu

ltip

lier)

Air C

om

pre

ssor

for

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating

Sourc

e

Gra

din

g E

quip

ment

SM

AQ

MD

Em

issio

n F

acto

rs (

lb/d

ay)

Equip

ment

Multip

lier*

**E

mis

sio

n facto

r is

fro

m the e

vapora

tion o

f solv

ents

during p

ain

ting,

per

"Air Q

ualit

y T

hre

shold

s o

f S

ignific

ance",

SM

AQ

MD

, 1

99

4

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating**

*The e

quip

ment m

ultip

lier

is a

n inte

ger

that re

pre

sents

units o

f 10 a

cre

s f

or

purp

oses o

f estim

ating t

he n

um

ber

of

equip

me

nt

req

uire

d f

or

the

pro

ject

Dem

olit

ion E

quip

ment

Build

ing C

onstr

uction

Pavin

g E

quip

ment

Alt1

Com

bust

ion

D-5

Page 8: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Sum

mary

of In

put P

ara

mete

rsT

ota

l D

ays

Gra

din

g:

252,1

00

5.7

94

(fro

m "

Alt1

Gra

din

g"

wo

rksh

ee

t)P

avin

g:

00.0

00

Dem

olit

ion:

12,1

00

0.2

8230

Build

ing C

onstr

uction:

00.0

00

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating

00.0

00

(per

the

SM

AQ

MD

"A

ir Q

ua

lity o

f T

hre

sh

old

s o

f S

ign

ific

an

ce

", 1

99

4)

NO

TE

: T

he 'T

ota

l D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

pavin

g is c

alc

ula

ted b

y d

ivid

ing t

he t

ota

l num

ber

of

acre

s b

y 0

.21 a

cre

s/d

ay,

wh

ich

is a

fa

cto

r d

erive

d f

rom

th

e 2

00

5 M

EA

NS

Heavy C

onstr

uction

Cost D

ata

, 19th

Editio

n, fo

r 'A

sphaltic

Concre

te P

avem

ent,

Lots

and D

rivew

ays -

6"

sto

ne b

ase',

wh

ich

pro

vid

es a

n e

stim

ate

of

sq

ua

refe

et paved p

er

day. T

here

is a

lso a

n e

stim

ate

for

'Pla

in C

em

ent

Concre

te P

avem

ent',

how

ever

the e

stim

ate

for

aspha

lt is u

se

d b

eca

use

it

is m

ore

co

nse

rva

tive

.T

he 'T

ota

l 'D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

dem

olit

ion is c

alc

ula

ted b

y d

ivid

ing t

he t

ota

l num

ber

of

acre

s b

y 0

.02 a

cre

s/d

ay,

whic

h is a

fa

cto

r a

lso

de

rive

d f

rom

th

e 2

00

5

ME

AN

S r

efe

rence. T

his

is c

alc

ula

ted b

y a

vera

gin

g t

he d

em

olit

ion e

stim

ate

s f

rom

'Build

ing D

em

olit

ion -

Sm

all

Build

ing

s,

Co

ncre

te', a

ssu

min

g a

he

igh

t of 30 feet fo

r a tw

o-s

tory

build

ing; fr

om

'Build

ing F

ootings a

nd F

oundations D

em

olit

ion -

6"

Thic

k,

Pla

in C

oncre

te';

and

fro

m 'D

em

olis

h,

Re

mo

ve

P

avem

ent and C

urb

- C

oncre

te to 6

" th

ick, ro

d r

ein

forc

ed'.

Pavin

g is d

ouble

-weig

hte

d s

ince p

roje

cts

typic

ally

involv

e m

ore

pa

vin

g d

em

olit

ion

.T

he 'T

ota

l D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

build

ing c

onstr

uction is a

ssum

ed t

o b

e 2

30 d

ays,

unle

ss p

roje

ct-

specific

data

is k

now

n.

Tota

l Pro

ject

Em

issi

ons

by A

ctiv

ity (l

bs)

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2P

M10

Gra

din

g E

quip

ment

140.0

8

20.8

8

163.6

5

2.8

0

4

.70

Pavin

g-

-

-

-

-

Dem

olit

ion

183.6

8

31

.63

269.2

3

3.6

7

5

.11

Build

ing C

onstr

uction

-

-

-

-

-

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oatin

gs

-

-

-

-

-

Tota

l Em

issi

ons

(lbs)

: 32

3.76

52

.51

432.

87

6.48

9.

81

Res

ults

: To

tal P

roje

ct A

nnua

l Em

issi

on R

ates

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2P

M10

Tota

l P

roje

ct E

mis

sio

ns (

lbs)

323.7

6

52

.51

432.8

7

6.4

8

9

.81

Tota

l P

roje

ct E

mis

sio

ns (

tons)

0.1

62

0.0

26

0.2

16

0.0

03

0.0

05

To

talA

rea

(ft2

)

Tota

l A

rea

(acre

s)

Alt1

Com

bust

ion

D-6

Page 9: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n Fu

gitiv

e D

ust E

mis

sion

s fo

r Dec

omm

issi

on th

e U

SCG

LO

RA

N–C

Pro

gram

and

term

inat

e th

e N

orth

Am

eric

an L

OR

AN

–C S

igna

l

Calc

ula

tion o

f P

M10 E

mis

sio

ns D

ue to S

ite P

repara

tion (

Uncontr

olle

d).

User

Input P

ara

mete

rs / A

ssum

ptions

Acre

s g

raded p

er

year:

5.7

9acre

s/y

r(F

rom

"A

lt1 C

om

bustion"

work

sheet)

Gra

din

g d

ays/y

r:3.2

3days/y

r(F

rom

"A

lt1 G

radin

g w

ork

sheet)

Exposed d

ays/y

r:90

assum

ed d

ays/y

r gra

ded a

rea is e

xposed

Gra

din

g H

ours

/day:

8hr/

da

yS

oil

pile

s a

rea fra

ction:

0.1

0(a

ssu

med f

raction o

f site a

rea c

overe

d b

y s

oil

pile

s)

Soil

perc

ent silt

, s:

8.5

%(m

ean s

ilt c

onte

nt;

expecte

d r

ange:

0.5

6 t

o 2

3,

AP

-42

Ta

ble

13

.2.2

-1)

Soil

perc

ent m

ois

ture

, M

:50

%(h

ttp:/

/ww

w.c

pc.n

oaa.g

ov/p

roducts

/soilm

st/

w.s

htm

l)A

nnual ra

infa

ll days, p:

140

days/y

r ra

infa

ll exceeds 0

.01 inch/d

ay (

AP

-42 F

ig 1

3.2

.2-1

, A

ve.

range f

rom

40

-24

0 d

ays/y

r o

n U

.S.

co

astlin

e)

Win

d s

peed >

12 m

ph %

, I:

20

%A

vera

ge n

ational w

indspeed

Fra

ction o

f T

SP

, J:

0.5

per

Calif

orn

ia E

nvironm

enta

l Q

ualit

y A

ct

(CE

QA

) A

ir Q

ualit

y H

andboo

k,

SC

AQ

MD

, 1

99

3,

p.

A9

-99

Mean v

ehic

le s

peed, S

:5

mi/hr

(On-s

ite)

Dozer

path

wid

th:

8ft

Qty

constr

uctio

n v

ehic

les:

3.0

0vehic

les

(Fro

m "

Alt1 G

radin

g w

ork

sheet)

On-s

ite V

MT

/vehic

le/d

ay:

5m

i/veh/d

ay

(Exclu

din

g b

ulld

ozer

VM

T d

uring g

radin

g)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r k

1.5

lb/V

MT

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r a

0.9

(dim

ensio

nle

ss)

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r b

0.4

5(d

imensio

nle

ss)

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

Mean V

ehic

le W

eig

ht W

40

tons

assum

ed f

or

aggre

gate

tru

cks

TS

P -

Tota

l S

uspended

Part

icula

teV

MT

- V

ehic

le M

iles T

ravele

d

D-7

Page 10: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

s D

ue to

Soi

l Dis

turb

ance

Act

iviti

es

Opera

tion P

ara

mete

rs (

Calc

ula

ted fro

m U

ser

Inputs

)G

radin

g d

ura

tion p

er

acre

4.5

hr/

acre

Bulld

ozer

mile

age p

er

acre

1V

MT

/acre

(Mile

s t

ravele

d b

y b

ulld

ozer

during g

radin

g)

Constr

uction V

MT

per

day

15

VM

T/d

ay

Constr

uction V

MT

per

acre

8.4

VM

T/a

cre

(Tra

vel on u

npaved s

urf

aces w

ithin

site)

Equations U

sed (

Corr

ecte

d for

PM

10)

AP

-42 S

ection

Opera

tion

Em

piric

al E

quation

Units

(5th

Editio

n)

Bulld

ozin

g0.7

5(s

1.5

)/(M

1.4

)lb

s/h

rT

able

11.9

-1,

Overb

urd

en

Gra

din

g(0

.60

)(0.0

51

)s2.0

lbs/V

MT

Table

11.9

-1,

Vehic

le T

raffic

(unpaved r

oads)

[(k(s

/12

)a(W

/3)b

)][(

365-P

)/365

] lb

s/V

MT

Section 1

3.2

.2

Sourc

e: C

om

pila

tion o

f A

ir P

ollu

tant E

mis

sio

n F

acto

rs,

Vol. I

, U

SE

PA

AP

-42,

Section 1

1.9

date

d 1

0/9

8 a

nd S

ection 1

3.2

da

ted

12

/03

Calc

ula

tion o

f P

M10 E

mis

sio

n F

acto

rs for

Each O

pera

tio

n

Em

issio

n

Facto

rE

mis

sio

n

Facto

rO

pera

tion

(mass/

unit)

Opera

tion

Para

mete

r(lbs/

acre

)B

ulld

ozin

g0.0

8lb

s/h

r4.5

hr/

acre

0.4

0lb

s/a

cre

Gra

din

g0.7

7lb

s/V

MT

1V

MT

/acre

0.8

0lb

s/a

cre

Vehic

le T

raffic

(unpaved r

oads)

2.1

7lb

s/V

MT

8.4

VM

T/a

cre

18.3

0lb

s/a

cre

D-8

Page 11: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

s D

ue to

Win

d Er

osio

n of

Soi

l Pile

s an

d Ex

pose

d G

rade

d Su

rfac

e

Refe

rence: C

alif

orn

ia E

nvironm

enta

l Q

ualit

y A

ct (C

EQ

A)

Air Q

ualit

y H

andbook,

SC

AQ

MD

, 1993.

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

1.7

(s/1

.5)[

(365 -

p)/

235](

I/15)(

J)

= (

s)(

365 -

p)(

I)(J

)/(3

110.2

941),

p.

A9-9

9.

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

6.1

lbs/d

ay/a

cre

covere

d b

y s

oil

pile

s

Consid

er

soil

pile

s a

rea

fra

ction s

o that E

F a

pplie

s to g

raded a

rea

Soil

pile

s a

rea fra

ction:

0.1

0(F

raction o

f site a

rea c

overe

d b

y s

oil

pile

s)

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

0.6

1lb

s/d

ay/a

cre

s g

raded

Gra

ded S

urf

ace E

F =

26.4

lbs/d

ay/a

cre

(re

com

mended in C

EQ

A M

anual, p

. A

9-9

3).

Cal

cula

tion

of A

nnua

l PM

10 E

mis

sion

s

Gra

ded

Exposed

Em

issio

ns

Em

issio

ns

Sourc

eE

mis

sio

n

Facto

rA

cre

s/y

rdays/y

rlb

s/y

rto

ns/y

rB

ulld

ozin

g0.4

0lb

s/a

cre

5.7

9N

A2

0.0

01

Gra

din

g0.8

0lb

s/a

cre

5.7

9N

A5

0.0

02

Vehic

le T

raffic

18.3

0lb

s/a

cre

5.7

9N

A106

0.0

53

Ero

sio

n o

f S

oil

Pile

s0.6

1lb

s/a

cre

/day

5.7

990

318

0.1

59

Ero

sio

n o

f G

raded S

urf

ace

26.4

0lb

s/a

cre

/day

5.7

990

13,7

51

6.8

75

TO

TA

L

14,1

81

7.0

9

Soil

Dis

turb

ance E

F:

19.5

0lb

s/a

cre

Win

d E

rosio

n E

F:

27.0

1lb

s/a

cre

/day

Back c

alc

ula

te to g

et E

F:

758.0

5

lb

s/a

cre

/gra

din

g d

ay

D-9

Page 12: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n (G

radi

ng) S

ched

ule

for D

ecom

mis

sion

the

USC

G L

OR

AN

–C P

rogr

am a

nd te

rmin

ate

the

Nor

th A

mer

ican

LO

RA

N–C

Sig

nal

Estim

ate

of tim

e r

equired to g

rade a

specifie

d a

rea.

Input P

ara

mete

rsC

onstr

uction a

rea:

5.7

9acre

s/y

r (f

rom

"A

lt1 C

om

bustion"

Work

sheet)

Qty

Equip

ment:

3.0

0(c

alc

ula

ted b

ased o

n 3

pie

ces o

f equip

ment

for

every

10 a

cre

s)

Assum

ptions.

Terr

ain

is m

ostly fla

t.A

n a

vera

ge o

f 6"

soil

is e

xcavate

d fro

m o

ne h

alf o

f th

e s

ite a

nd b

ackfille

d t

o t

he o

ther

half o

f th

e s

ite;

no s

oil

is h

aule

d o

ff-s

ite

or

bo

rro

we

d.

200 h

p b

ulld

ozers

are

used for

site c

learing.

300 h

p b

ulld

ozers

are

used for

str

ippin

g, excavation, an

d b

ackfill.

Vib

rato

ry d

rum

rolle

rs a

re u

sed for

com

pacting.

Str

ippin

g, E

xcavation, B

ackfill

and C

om

paction r

equire a

n a

vera

ge o

f tw

o p

asses e

ach.

Excavation a

nd B

ackfill

are

assum

ed to involv

e o

nly

ha

lf o

f th

e s

ite.

Calc

ula

tion o

f days r

equired for

one p

iece o

f equip

ment

to g

rade t

he s

pecifie

d a

rea.

Refe

rence: M

eans H

eavy C

onstr

uction C

ost D

ata

, 19th

Ed.,

R.

S.

Means,

2005.

Means L

ine N

o.

Opera

tion

Description

Outp

ut

Units

Acre

s p

er

eq

uip

-da

y)

equip

-da

ys

per

acre

Acre

s/y

r

(pro

ject-

sp

ecific

)

Eq

uip

-da

ys

pe

rye

ar

2230 2

00 0

550

Site C

learing

Dozer

& r

ake, m

ediu

m b

rush

8acre

/day

80

.13

5.7

90

.72

2230 5

00 0

300

Str

ippin

gT

opsoil

& s

tockpili

ng

, advers

e s

oil

1,6

50

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.0

50

.49

5.7

92

.83

2315 4

32 5

220

Excavation

Bulk

, open s

ite, com

mon e

art

h,

150' h

aul

800

cu.

yd/d

ay

0.9

91

.01

2.8

92

.92

2315 1

20 5

220

Ba

ckfill

Str

uctu

ral, c

om

mon

eart

h,

150' h

aul

1,9

50

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.4

20

.41

2.8

91

.20

2315 3

10 5

020

Com

paction

Vib

rating r

olle

r, 6

" lifts

, 3 p

asses

2,3

00

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.8

50

.35

5.7

92

.03

TO

TA

L9

.70

Calc

ula

tion o

f days r

eq

uired for

the indic

ate

d p

ieces o

f equip

ment

to g

rade t

he d

esig

nate

d a

cre

age.

(Equip

)(day)/

yr:

9.7

0Q

ty E

quip

ment:

3.0

0G

radin

g d

ays/y

r:3.2

3

Alt1

Gra

ding

D-1

0

Page 13: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n C

ombu

stio

n Em

issi

ons

for T

rans

fer m

anag

emen

t of t

he L

OR

AN

–C P

rogr

am to

ano

ther

Gov

ernm

ent a

genc

yan

d A

utom

ate,

sec

ure,

and

uns

taff

LOR

AN

sta

tions

Com

bustion E

mis

sio

ns o

f V

OC

, N

Ox,

SO

2, C

O a

nd P

M10 D

ue t

o C

onstr

uction

Inclu

des:

1C

onstr

uct P

erim

ter

Fence for

Tow

er

2,5

00

ft2

Assum

ptions:

Appro

xim

ate

ly 5

00 lin

ear

feet of fe

ncin

g w

ould

be r

equired p

er

site.

Land d

istu

rbance w

ould

be 5

feet w

ide to insta

ll th

e p

erim

ete

r fe

ncin

g.

Tota

l B

uild

ing C

onstr

uction A

rea:

0ft

2(N

one

)

Tota

l D

em

olis

hed A

rea:

0ft

2(N

one

)

Tota

l P

aved A

rea:

0ft

2(N

one

)

Tota

l D

istu

rbed A

rea:

2,5

00

ft2

(1)

Constr

uction D

ura

tion:

1.0

year(

s)

Annual C

onstr

uction A

ctivity:

230

days/y

r

Alt2

-3 C

ombu

stio

n

D-1

1

Page 14: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

Fac

tors

Use

d fo

r Con

stru

ctio

n Eq

uipm

ent

Refe

rence: G

uid

e to A

ir Q

ualit

y A

ssessm

ent, S

MA

QM

D,

2004

Em

issio

n facto

rs a

re taken fro

m T

able

3-2

. A

ssum

ptions r

egard

ing t

he t

ype a

nd n

um

ber

of

equip

ment

are

fr

om

Table

3-1

unle

ss o

therw

ise n

ote

d.

Gra

ding

No.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Bulld

ozer

129.4

03.6

62

5.0

90

.59

1.1

7M

oto

r G

rader

110.2

21.7

61

4.9

80

.20

0.2

8W

ate

r T

ruck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.42

0.5

8T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

360.5

19.0

27

0.6

91

.21

2.0

3

Pavi

ngN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Paver

17.9

31.3

71

1.6

20

.16

0.2

2R

olle

r1

5.0

10.8

67

.34

0.1

00

.14

Tota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

212.9

42.2

31

8.9

60

.26

0.3

6

Dem

oliti

onN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Loader

17.8

61.3

51

1.5

20

.16

0.2

2H

aul T

ruck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.42

0.5

8T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

228.7

54.9

54

2.1

40

.58

0.8

0

Bui

ldin

g C

onst

ruct

ion

No.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Eq

uip

mentd

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

S

tationary

Genera

tor

Set

111.8

31.4

71

0.0

90

.24

0.4

7In

dustr

ial S

aw

11

7.0

22.1

21

4.5

20

.34

0.6

8W

eld

er

14.4

80.5

63

.83

0.0

90

.18

M

obile

(non-r

oa

d)

Tru

ck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.84

0.5

8F

ork

lift

14.5

70.7

96

.70

0.1

80

.13

Cra

ne

18.3

71.4

41

2.2

70

.33

0.2

3T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

667.1

69.9

87

8.0

32

.02

2.2

7

Note

: F

ootn

ote

s fo

r ta

ble

s a

re o

n follo

win

g p

age

Alt2

-3 C

ombu

stio

n

D-1

2

Page 15: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Arc

hite

ctur

al C

oatin

gsN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Air C

om

pre

ssor

16.8

30.8

55

.82

0.1

40

.27

Tota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

16.8

30.8

55

.82

0.1

40

.27

a)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 g

uid

ance s

uggests

a d

efa

ult e

quip

ment

fleet

for

each a

ctivitiy

, assum

ing 1

0 a

cre

s o

f th

at

activity,

(e

.g., 1

0 a

cre

s o

f gra

din

g, 10 a

cre

s o

f pavin

g, e

tc.)

. T

he d

efa

ult e

quip

ment

fleet

is incre

ased f

or

each 1

0 a

cre

incre

me

nt

in

the s

ize o

f th

e c

onstr

uction p

roje

ct. T

hat is

, a 2

6 a

cre

pro

ject

would

round t

o 3

0 a

cre

s a

nd t

he f

leet

siz

e w

ould

be

th

ree tim

es the d

efa

ult fle

et fo

r a 1

0 a

cre

pro

ject.

b)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 r

efe

rence lis

ts e

mis

sio

n facto

rs f

or

reactive o

rganic

gas (

RO

G).

F

or

the p

urp

oses o

f th

is w

ork

sh

ee

t R

OG

= V

OC

.

c)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 r

efe

rence d

oes n

ot pro

vid

e S

O2 e

mis

sio

n f

acto

rs.

For

this

work

sheet,

SO

2 e

mis

sio

ns h

ave b

ee

n e

stim

ate

d

based o

n a

ppro

xim

ate

fuel use r

ate

for

die

sel e

quip

ment

and t

he a

ssum

ption o

f 500 p

pm

sulfur

die

sel fu

el.

For

the

ave

rag

e o

f

th

e e

quip

ment

fleet, the r

esultin

g S

O2 facto

r w

as f

ound t

o b

e a

ppro

xim

ate

ly 0

.04 t

imes t

he N

Ox e

mis

sio

n f

acto

r fo

r th

e m

ob

ile e

qu

ipm

en

t (b

ase

d

upon 2

002 U

SA

F IE

RA

"A

ir E

mis

sio

ns Invento

ry G

uid

ance")

and 0

.02 t

imes t

he N

Ox e

mis

sio

n f

acto

r fo

r all

oth

er

eq

uip

me

nt

(ba

se

d o

n A

P-4

2,

Ta

ble

3.4

-1)

d)

Typic

al equip

me

nt fleet fo

r build

ing c

onstr

uction

was n

ot

item

ized in S

MA

QM

D 2

004 g

uid

ance.

The e

quip

ment

list a

bo

ve

wa

s assum

ed b

ased

on S

MA

QM

D 1

994 g

uid

ance.

PRO

JEC

T-SP

ECIF

IC E

MIS

SIO

N F

AC

TOR

SU

MM

ARY

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2**

PM

10

10.3

47

0.0

52

0.4

06

0.0

07

0.0

12

10.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

10.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

10.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

10.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

Exam

ple

: S

MA

QM

D E

mis

sio

n F

acto

r fo

r G

radin

g E

quip

ment

NO

x =

(T

ota

l G

radin

g N

Ox p

er

10 a

c*(

(tota

l dis

turb

ed a

rea

/43

56

0)/

10

))*(

Eq

uip

me

nt

Mu

ltip

lier)

SM

AQ

MD

Em

issio

n F

acto

rs (

lb/d

ay)

Equip

ment

Multip

lier*

**E

mis

sio

n facto

r is

fro

m the e

vapora

tion o

f solv

ents

during p

ain

ting,

per

"Air Q

ualit

y T

hre

shold

s o

f S

ign

ific

an

ce

", S

MA

QM

D,

19

94

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating**

*The e

quip

ment m

ultip

lier

is a

n inte

ger

that re

pre

sents

units o

f 10 a

cre

s f

or

purp

oses o

f estim

ating t

he n

um

ber

of

equip

me

nt

req

uire

d f

or

the

pro

ject

Dem

olit

ion E

quip

ment

Build

ing C

onstr

uction

Pavin

g E

quip

ment

Air C

om

pre

ssor

for

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating

Sourc

e

Gra

din

g E

quip

ment

Alt2

-3 C

ombu

stio

n

D-1

3

Page 16: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Sum

mary

of In

put P

ara

mete

rsT

ota

l D

ays

Gra

din

g:

2,5

00

0.0

61

(fro

m "

Al2

-3 G

rad

ing

" w

ork

sh

ee

t)P

avin

g:

00.0

00

Dem

olit

ion:

00.0

00

Build

ing C

onstr

uction:

00.0

00

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating

00.0

00

(per

the

SM

AQ

MD

"A

ir Q

ua

lity o

f T

hre

sh

old

s o

f S

ign

ific

an

ce

", 1

99

4)

NO

TE

: T

he 'T

ota

l D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

pavin

g is c

alc

ula

ted b

y d

ivid

ing t

he t

ota

l num

ber

of

acre

s b

y 0

.21 a

cre

s/d

ay,

wh

ich

is a

fa

cto

r d

erive

d f

rom

th

e 2

00

5 M

EA

NS

Heavy C

onstr

uction

Cost D

ata

, 19th

Editio

n, fo

r 'A

sphaltic

Concre

te P

ave

me

nt,

Lo

ts a

nd

Drive

wa

ys -

6"

sto

ne

ba

se

', w

hic

h p

rovid

es a

n e

stim

ate

of

sq

ua

refe

et paved p

er

day. T

here

is a

lso a

n e

stim

ate

for

'Pla

in C

em

ent

Concre

te P

avem

ent',

how

ever

the e

stim

ate

for

asph

alt is u

se

d b

eca

use

it

is m

ore

co

nse

rva

tive

.T

he 'T

ota

l 'D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

dem

olit

ion is c

alc

ula

ted b

y d

ivid

ing t

he t

ota

l num

ber

of

acre

s b

y 0

.02 a

cre

s/d

ay,

whic

h is a

fa

cto

r a

lso

de

rive

d fro

m t

he

20

05

M

EA

NS

refe

rence. T

his

is c

alc

ula

ted b

y a

vera

gin

g t

he d

em

olit

ion e

stim

ate

s f

rom

'Build

ing D

em

olit

ion -

Sm

all

Build

ing

s,

Co

ncre

te', a

ssu

min

g a

he

igh

t of 30 feet fo

r a tw

o-s

tory

build

ing; fr

om

'Build

ing F

ootings a

nd F

oundations D

em

olit

ion -

6"

Thic

k,

Pla

in C

oncre

te';

and

fro

m 'D

em

olis

h,

Re

mo

ve

P

avem

ent and C

urb

- C

oncre

te to 6

" th

ick, ro

d r

ein

forc

ed'.

Pavin

g is d

ouble

-weig

hte

d s

ince p

roje

cts

typic

ally

involv

e m

ore

pa

vin

g d

em

olit

ion

.T

he 'T

ota

l D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

build

ing c

onstr

uction is a

ssum

ed t

o b

e 2

30 d

ays,

unle

ss p

roje

ct-

specific

data

is k

now

n.

Tota

l Pro

ject

Em

issi

ons

by A

ctiv

ity (l

bs)

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2P

M10

Gra

din

g E

quip

ment

0.3

5

0.0

5

0.4

1

0.0

1

0

.01

Pavin

g-

-

-

-

-

Dem

olit

ion

-

-

-

-

-

Build

ing C

onstr

uction

-

-

-

-

-

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oatin

gs

-

-

-

-

-

Tota

l Em

issi

ons

(lbs)

: 0.

35

0.

05

0.

41

0.

01

0.01

Res

ults

: To

tal P

roje

ct A

nnua

l Em

issi

on R

ates

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2P

M10

Tota

l P

roje

ct E

mis

sio

ns (

lbs)

0.3

5

0.0

5

0.4

1

0.0

1

0

.01

Tota

l P

roje

ct E

mis

sio

ns (

tons)

0.0

002

0.0

0003

0.0

00

2

0.0

00

00

3

0

.00

00

1

To

talA

rea

(ft2

)

Tota

l A

rea

(acre

s)

Alt2

-3 C

ombu

stio

n

D-1

4

Page 17: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n Fu

gitiv

e D

ust E

mis

sion

s fo

r Tra

nsfe

r man

agem

ent o

f the

LO

RA

N–C

Pro

gram

to a

noth

er G

over

nmen

t age

ncy

Calc

ula

tion o

f P

M10 E

mis

sio

ns D

ue to S

ite P

repara

tion (

Uncontr

olle

d).

User

Input P

ara

mete

rs / A

ssum

ptions

Acre

s g

raded p

er

year:

0.0

6acre

s/y

r(F

rom

"A

lt2-3

Com

bustion"

work

sheet)

Gra

din

g d

ays/y

r:0.0

3days/y

r(F

rom

"A

lt2-3

Gra

din

g w

ork

sheet)

Exposed d

ays/y

r:90

assum

ed d

ays/y

r gra

ded a

rea is e

xposed

Gra

din

g H

ours

/day:

8hr/

da

yS

oil

pile

s a

rea fra

ction:

0.1

0(a

ssum

ed f

raction o

f site a

rea c

overe

d b

y s

oil

pile

s)

Soil

perc

ent silt

, s:

8.5

%(m

ean s

ilt c

onte

nt;

expecte

d r

ange:

0.5

6 t

o 2

3,

AP

-42

Ta

ble

13

.2.2

-1)

Soil

perc

ent m

ois

ture

, M

:50

%(h

ttp:/

/ww

w.c

pc.n

oaa.g

ov/p

roducts

/soilm

st/

w.s

htm

l)A

nnual ra

infa

ll days, p:

140

days/y

r ra

infa

ll exceeds 0

.01 inch/d

ay (

AP

-42 F

ig 1

3.2

.2-1

, A

ve.

range f

rom

40

-24

0 d

ays/y

r o

n U

.S.

co

astlin

e)

Win

d s

peed >

12 m

ph %

, I:

20

%A

vera

ge n

ational w

indspeed

Fra

ction o

f T

SP

, J:

0.5

per

Calif

orn

ia E

nvironm

enta

l Q

ualit

y A

ct

(CE

QA

) A

ir Q

ualit

y H

andboo

k,

SC

AQ

MD

, 1

99

3,

p.

A9

-99

Mean v

ehic

le s

peed, S

:5

mi/hr

(On-s

ite)

Dozer

path

wid

th:

8ft

Qty

constr

uctio

n v

ehic

les:

3.0

0vehic

les

(Fro

m "

Alt2-3

Gra

din

g w

ork

sheet)

On-s

ite V

MT

/vehic

le/d

ay:

5m

i/veh/d

ay

(Exclu

din

g b

ulld

ozer

VM

T d

uring g

radin

g)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r k

1.5

lb/V

MT

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r a

0.9

(dim

ensio

nle

ss)

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r b

0.4

5(d

imensio

nle

ss)

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

Mean V

ehic

le W

eig

ht W

40

tons

assum

ed f

or

aggre

gate

tru

cks

TS

P -

Tota

l S

uspended

Part

icula

teV

MT

- V

ehic

le M

iles T

ravele

d

Alt2

-3 F

ugiti

ve

D-1

5

Page 18: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

s D

ue to

Soi

l Dis

turb

ance

Act

iviti

es

Opera

tion P

ara

mete

rs (

Calc

ula

ted fro

m U

ser

Inputs

)G

radin

g d

ura

tion p

er

acre

4.5

hr/

acre

Bulld

ozer

mile

age p

er

acre

1V

MT

/acre

(Mile

s t

ravele

d b

y b

ulld

ozer

during g

radin

g)

Constr

uction V

MT

per

day

15

VM

T/d

ay

Constr

uction V

MT

per

acre

8.4

VM

T/a

cre

(Tra

vel on u

npaved s

urf

aces w

ithin

site)

Equations U

sed (

Corr

ecte

d for

PM

10)

AP

-42 S

ection

Opera

tion

Em

piric

al E

quation

Units

(5th

Editio

n)

Bulld

ozin

g0.7

5(s

1.5

)/(M

1.4

)lb

s/h

rT

able

11.9

-1,

Overb

urd

en

Gra

din

g(0

.60

)(0.0

51

)s2.0

lbs/V

MT

Table

11.9

-1,

Vehic

le T

raffic

(unpaved r

oads)

[(k(s

/12

)a(W

/3)b

)][(

365-P

)/365

] lb

s/V

MT

Section 1

3.2

.2

Sourc

e: C

om

pila

tion o

f A

ir P

ollu

tant E

mis

sio

n F

acto

rs,

Vol. I

, U

SE

PA

AP

-42,

Section 1

1.9

date

d 1

0/9

8 a

nd S

ection 1

3.2

da

ted

12

/03

Calc

ula

tion o

f P

M10 E

mis

sio

n F

acto

rs for

Each O

pera

tio

n

Em

issio

n

Facto

rE

mis

sio

n

Facto

rO

pera

tion

(mass/

unit)

Opera

tion

Para

mete

r(lbs/

acre

)B

ulld

ozin

g0.0

8lb

s/h

r4.5

hr/

acre

0.4

0lb

s/a

cre

Gra

din

g0.7

7lb

s/V

MT

1V

MT

/acre

0.8

0lb

s/a

cre

Vehic

le T

raffic

(unpaved r

oads)

2.1

7lb

s/V

MT

8.4

VM

T/a

cre

18.3

0lb

s/a

cre

Alt2

-3 F

ugiti

ve

D-1

6

Page 19: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

s D

ue to

Win

d Er

osio

n of

Soi

l Pile

s an

d Ex

pose

d G

rade

d Su

rfac

e

Refe

rence: C

alif

orn

ia E

nvironm

enta

l Q

ualit

y A

ct (C

EQ

A)

Air Q

ualit

y H

andbook,

SC

AQ

MD

, 1993.

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

1.7

(s/1

.5)[

(365 -

p)/

235](

I/15)(

J)

= (

s)(

365 -

p)(

I)(J

)/(3

110.2

941),

p.

A9-9

9.

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

6.1

lbs/d

ay/a

cre

covere

d b

y s

oil

pile

s

Consid

er

soil

pile

s a

rea

fra

ction s

o that E

F a

pplie

s to g

raded a

rea

Soil

pile

s a

rea fra

ction:

0.1

0(F

raction o

f site a

rea c

overe

d b

y s

oil

pile

s)

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

0.6

1lb

s/d

ay/a

cre

s g

raded

Gra

ded S

urf

ace E

F =

26.4

lbs/d

ay/a

cre

(re

com

mended in C

EQ

A M

anual, p

. A

9-9

3).

Cal

cula

tion

of A

nnua

l PM

10 E

mis

sion

s

Gra

ded

Exposed

Em

issio

ns

Em

issio

ns

Sourc

eE

mis

sio

n

Facto

rA

cre

s/y

rdays/y

rlb

s/y

rto

ns/y

rB

ulld

ozin

g0.4

0lb

s/a

cre

0.0

6N

A0

0.0

00

Gra

din

g0.8

0lb

s/a

cre

0.0

6N

A0

0.0

00

Vehic

le T

raffic

18.3

0lb

s/a

cre

0.0

6N

A1

0.0

01

Ero

sio

n o

f S

oil

Pile

s0.6

1lb

s/a

cre

/day

0.0

690

30

.00

2E

rosio

n o

f G

raded S

urf

ace

26.4

0lb

s/a

cre

/day

0.0

690

136

0.0

68

TO

TA

L

141

0.0

7

Soil

Dis

turb

ance E

F:

19.5

0lb

s/a

cre

Win

d E

rosio

n E

F:

27.0

1lb

s/a

cre

/day

Back c

alc

ula

te to g

et E

F:

76,4

41.8

4

lbs/a

cre

/gra

din

g d

ay

Alt2

-3 F

ugiti

ve

D-1

7

Page 20: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n (G

radi

ng) S

ched

ule

for T

rans

fer m

anag

emen

t of t

he L

OR

AN

–C P

rogr

am to

ano

ther

Gov

ernm

ent a

genc

yan

d A

utom

ate,

sec

ure,

and

uns

taff

LOR

AN

sta

tions

Estim

ate

of tim

e r

equired to g

rade a

specifie

d a

rea.

Input P

ara

mete

rsC

onstr

uction a

rea:

0.0

6acre

s/y

r (f

rom

"A

lt2-3

Com

bustion"

Work

sheet)

Qty

Equip

ment:

3.0

0(c

alc

ula

ted b

ased o

n 3

pie

ces o

f equip

ment

for

every

10 a

cre

s)

Assum

ptions.

Terr

ain

is m

ostly fla

t.A

n a

vera

ge o

f 6"

soil

is e

xcavate

d fro

m o

ne h

alf o

f th

e s

ite a

nd b

ackfille

d t

o t

he o

ther

half o

f th

e s

ite;

no s

oil

is h

aule

d o

ff-s

ite

or

bo

rro

we

d.

200 h

p b

ulld

ozers

are

used for

site c

learing.

300 h

p b

ulld

ozers

are

used for

str

ippin

g, excavation, an

d b

ackfill.

Vib

rato

ry d

rum

rolle

rs a

re u

sed for

com

pacting.

Str

ippin

g, E

xcavation, B

ackfill

and C

om

paction r

equire a

n a

vera

ge o

f tw

o p

asses e

ach.

Excavation a

nd B

ackfill

are

assum

ed to involv

e o

nly

ha

lf o

f th

e s

ite.

Calc

ula

tion o

f days r

equired for

one p

iece o

f equip

ment

to g

rade t

he s

pecifie

d a

rea.

Refe

rence: M

eans H

eavy C

onstr

uction C

ost D

ata

, 19th

Ed.,

R.

S.

Means,

2005.

Means L

ine N

o.

Opera

tion

Description

Outp

ut

Units

Acre

s p

er

eq

uip

-da

y)

equip

-da

ys

per

acre

Acre

s/y

r

(pro

ject-

sp

ecific

)

Eq

uip

-da

ys

pe

rye

ar

2230 2

00 0

550

Site C

learing

Dozer

& r

ake, m

ediu

m b

rush

8acre

/day

80

.13

0.0

60

.01

2230 5

00 0

300

Str

ippin

gT

opsoil

& s

tockpili

ng,

advers

e s

oil

1,6

50

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.0

50

.49

0.0

60

.03

2315 4

32 5

220

Excavation

Bulk

, open s

ite, com

mon e

art

h,

150' h

aul

800

cu.

yd/d

ay

0.9

91

.01

0.0

30

.03

2315 1

20 5

220

Ba

ckfill

Str

uctu

ral, c

om

mon

eart

h,

150' h

aul

1,9

50

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.4

20

.41

0.0

30

.01

2315 3

10 5

020

Com

paction

Vib

rating r

olle

r, 6

" lifts

, 3 p

asses

2,3

00

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.8

50

.35

0.0

60

.02

TO

TA

L0

.10

Calc

ula

tion o

f days r

eq

uired for

the indic

ate

d p

ieces o

f equip

ment

to g

rade t

he d

esig

nate

d a

cre

age.

(Equip

)(day)/

yr:

0.1

0Q

ty E

quip

ment:

3.0

0G

radin

g d

ays/y

r:0.0

3

Alt2

-3 G

radi

ng

D-1

8

Page 21: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n C

ombu

stio

n Em

issi

ons

for C

onve

rt S

igna

l to

Enha

nced

LO

RA

N (e

LOR

AN

), se

cure

and

uns

taff

LOR

AN

sta

tions

Com

bustion E

mis

sio

ns o

f V

OC

, N

Ox,

SO

2, C

O a

nd P

M10 D

ue t

o C

onstr

uction

Inclu

des:

1C

onstr

uct T

ow

er

7,0

00

ft2

2In

sta

ll C

opp

er

Rad

ials

914,7

60

ft2

3C

onstr

uct T

ransm

itte

r B

uild

ing

5,0

00

ft2

4C

onstr

uct M

onitorin

g S

ite F

acili

ty100

ft2

5C

onstr

uct A

ccess R

oad

79,2

00

ft2

6In

sta

ll U

tilit

ies to S

ite

15,8

40

ft2

Assum

ptions:

Tow

er

is 7

00 feet ta

ll b

uilt

on a

100ft

2 c

oncre

te p

ad.

Land d

istu

rbance for

insta

lling the 1

20 c

opper

radia

ls w

ould

be a

ppro

xim

ate

ly 2

1 a

cre

s.

Access r

oad w

ould

be 1

mile

long b

y 1

5 ft w

ide. R

oad w

ould

be g

raded a

nd c

overe

d w

ith g

ravel.

Tre

nch for

utilit

ies to th

e s

ite w

ould

be 1

mile

long b

y 3

ft

wid

e.

Tota

l B

uild

ing C

onstr

uction A

rea:

12,1

00

ft2

(1,

3,

and 4

)

Tota

l D

em

olis

hed A

rea:

0ft

2(N

one

)

Tota

l P

aved A

rea:

0ft

2(N

one

)

Tota

l D

istu

rbed A

rea:

1,0

21,9

00

ft2

(1-6

)

Constr

uction D

ura

tion:

1.0

year(

s)

Annual C

onstr

uction A

ctivity:

230

days/y

r

Alt4

Low

Com

bust

ion

D-1

9

Page 22: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

Fac

tors

Use

d fo

r Con

stru

ctio

n Eq

uipm

ent

Refe

rence: G

uid

e to A

ir Q

ualit

y A

ssessm

ent, S

MA

QM

D,

2004

Em

issio

n facto

rs a

re taken fro

m T

able

3-2

. A

ssum

ptions r

egard

ing t

he t

ype a

nd n

um

ber

of

equip

ment

are

fr

om

Table

3-1

unle

ss o

therw

ise n

ote

d.

Gra

ding

No.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Bulld

ozer

129.4

03.6

62

5.0

90

.59

1.1

7M

oto

r G

rader

110.2

21.7

61

4.9

80

.20

0.2

8W

ate

r T

ruck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.42

0.5

8T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

360.5

19.0

27

0.6

91

.21

2.0

3

Pavi

ngN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Paver

17.9

31.3

71

1.6

20

.16

0.2

2R

olle

r1

5.0

10.8

67

.34

0.1

00

.14

Tota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

212.9

42.2

31

8.9

60

.26

0.3

6

Dem

oliti

onN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Loader

17.8

61.3

51

1.5

20

.16

0.2

2H

aul T

ruck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.42

0.5

8T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

228.7

54.9

54

2.1

40

.58

0.8

0

Bui

ldin

g C

onst

ruct

ion

No.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Eq

uip

mentd

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

S

tationary

Genera

tor

Set

111.8

31.4

71

0.0

90

.24

0.4

7In

dustr

ial S

aw

11

7.0

22.1

21

4.5

20

.34

0.6

8W

eld

er

14.4

80.5

63

.83

0.0

90

.18

M

obile

(non-r

oa

d)

Tru

ck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.84

0.5

8F

ork

lift

14.5

70.7

96

.70

0.1

80

.13

Cra

ne

18.3

71.4

41

2.2

70

.33

0.2

3T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

667.1

69.9

87

8.0

32

.02

2.2

7

Note

: F

ootn

ote

s fo

r ta

ble

s a

re o

n follo

win

g p

age

Alt4

Low

Com

bust

ion

D-2

0

Page 23: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Arc

hite

ctur

al C

oatin

gsN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Air C

om

pre

ssor

16.8

30.8

55

.82

0.1

40

.27

Tota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

16.8

30.8

55

.82

0.1

40

.27

a)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 g

uid

ance s

uggests

a d

efa

ult e

quip

ment

fleet

for

each a

ctivitiy

, assum

ing 1

0 a

cre

s o

f th

at

activity,

(e

.g., 1

0 a

cre

s o

f gra

din

g, 10 a

cre

s o

f pavin

g, e

tc.)

. T

he d

efa

ult e

quip

ment

fleet

is incre

ased f

or

each 1

0 a

cre

incre

me

nt

in

the s

ize o

f th

e c

onstr

uction p

roje

ct. T

hat is

, a 2

6 a

cre

pro

ject

would

round t

o 3

0 a

cre

s a

nd t

he f

leet

siz

e w

ould

be

th

ree tim

es the d

efa

ult fle

et fo

r a 1

0 a

cre

pro

ject.

b)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 r

efe

rence lis

ts e

mis

sio

n facto

rs f

or

reactive o

rganic

gas (

RO

G).

F

or

the p

urp

oses o

f th

is w

ork

sh

ee

t R

OG

= V

OC

.

c)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 r

efe

rence d

oes n

ot pro

vid

e S

O2 e

mis

sio

n f

acto

rs.

For

this

work

sheet,

SO

2 e

mis

sio

ns h

ave b

ee

n e

stim

ate

d

based o

n a

ppro

xim

ate

fuel use r

ate

for

die

sel e

quip

ment

and t

he a

ssum

ption o

f 500 p

pm

sulfur

die

sel fu

el.

For

the

ave

rag

e o

f

th

e e

quip

ment

fleet, the r

esultin

g S

O2 facto

r w

as f

ound t

o b

e a

ppro

xim

ate

ly 0

.04 t

imes t

he N

Ox e

mis

sio

n f

acto

r fo

r th

e m

ob

ile e

qu

ipm

en

t (b

ase

d

upon 2

002 U

SA

F IE

RA

"A

ir E

mis

sio

ns Invento

ry G

uid

ance")

and 0

.02 t

imes t

he N

Ox e

mis

sio

n f

acto

r fo

r all

oth

er

eq

uip

me

nt

(ba

se

d o

n A

P-4

2,

Ta

ble

3.4

-1)

d)

Typic

al equip

me

nt fleet fo

r build

ing c

onstr

uction

was n

ot

item

ized in S

MA

QM

D 2

004 g

uid

ance.

The e

quip

ment

list a

bo

ve

wa

s assum

ed b

ased

on S

MA

QM

D 1

994 g

uid

ance.

PRO

JEC

T-SP

ECIF

IC E

MIS

SIO

N F

AC

TOR

SU

MM

ARY

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2**

PM

10

3425.8

62

63.4

82

49

7.5

08

8.5

17

14

.28

71

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

10.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

11.8

66

0.2

77

2.1

68

0.0

56

0.0

63

10.1

90

0.0

24

0.1

62

0.0

04

0.0

08

8.9

65

Exam

ple

: S

MA

QM

D E

mis

sio

n F

acto

r fo

r G

radin

g E

quip

ment

NO

x =

(T

ota

l G

radin

g N

Ox p

er

10 a

c*(

(tota

l dis

turb

ed a

rea

/43

56

0)/

10

))*(

Eq

uip

me

nt

Mu

ltip

lier)

SM

AQ

MD

Em

issio

n F

acto

rs (

lb/d

ay)

Equip

ment

Multip

lier*

**E

mis

sio

n facto

r is

fro

m the e

vapora

tion o

f solv

ents

during p

ain

ting,

per

"Air Q

ualit

y T

hre

shold

s o

f S

ignific

ance",

SM

AQ

MD

, 1

99

4

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating**

*The e

quip

ment m

ultip

lier

is a

n inte

ger

that re

pre

sents

units o

f 10 a

cre

s f

or

purp

oses o

f estim

ating t

he n

um

ber

of

equip

me

nt

req

uire

d f

or

the

pro

ject

Dem

olit

ion E

quip

ment

Build

ing C

onstr

uction

Pavin

g E

quip

ment

Air C

om

pre

ssor

for

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating

Sourc

e

Gra

din

g E

quip

ment

Alt4

Low

Com

bust

ion

D-2

1

Page 24: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Sum

mary

of In

put P

ara

mete

rsT

ota

l D

ays

Gra

din

g:

1,0

21,9

00

23.4

614

(fro

m "

Alt4

Lo

w G

rad

ing

" w

ork

sh

ee

t)P

avin

g:

00.0

00

Dem

olit

ion:

00.0

0230

Build

ing C

onstr

uction:

12,1

00

0.2

8230

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating

12,1

00

0.2

820

(per

the

SM

AQ

MD

"A

ir Q

ua

lity o

f T

hre

sh

old

s o

f S

ign

ific

an

ce

", 1

99

4)

NO

TE

: T

he 'T

ota

l D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

pavin

g is c

alc

ula

ted b

y d

ivid

ing t

he t

ota

l num

ber

of

acre

s b

y 0

.21 a

cre

s/d

ay,

wh

ich

is a

fa

cto

r d

erive

d f

rom

th

e 2

00

5 M

EA

NS

Heavy C

onstr

uction

Cost D

ata

, 19th

Editio

n, fo

r 'A

sphaltic

Concre

te P

avem

ent,

Lots

and D

rivew

ays -

6"

sto

ne b

ase',

wh

ich

pro

vid

es a

n e

stim

ate

of

sq

ua

refe

et paved p

er

day. T

here

is a

lso a

n e

stim

ate

for

'Pla

in C

em

ent

Concre

te P

avem

ent',

how

ever

the e

stim

ate

for

asph

alt is u

se

d b

eca

use

it

is m

ore

co

nse

rva

tive

.T

he 'T

ota

l 'D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

dem

olit

ion is c

alc

ula

ted b

y d

ivid

ing t

he t

ota

l num

ber

of

acre

s b

y 0

.02 a

cre

s/d

ay,

wh

ich

is a

fa

cto

r a

lso

de

rive

d f

rom

th

e 2

00

5

ME

AN

S r

efe

rence. T

his

is c

alc

ula

ted b

y a

vera

gin

g t

he d

em

olit

ion e

stim

ate

s f

rom

'Build

ing D

em

olit

ion -

Sm

all

Build

ing

s,

Co

ncre

te', a

ssu

min

g a

he

igh

t of 30 feet fo

r a tw

o-s

tory

build

ing; fr

om

'Build

ing F

ootings a

nd F

oundations D

em

olit

ion -

6"

Thic

k,

Pla

in C

oncre

te';

an

d f

rom

'D

em

olis

h,

Re

mo

ve

P

avem

ent and C

urb

- C

oncre

te to 6

" th

ick, ro

d r

ein

forc

ed'.

Pavin

g is d

ouble

-weig

hte

d s

ince p

roje

cts

typic

ally

involv

e m

ore

pa

vin

g d

em

olit

ion

.T

he 'T

ota

l D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

build

ing c

onstr

uction is a

ssum

ed t

o b

e 2

30 d

ays,

unle

ss p

roje

ct-

specific

data

is k

now

n.

Tota

l Pro

ject

Em

issi

ons

by A

ctiv

ity (l

bs)

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2P

M10

Gra

din

g E

quip

ment

5,9

62.0

7

888.7

4

6,9

65.1

1

11

9.2

4

2

00

.02

Pavin

g-

-

-

-

-

D

em

olit

ion

-

-

-

-

-

Build

ing C

onstr

uction

429.0

8

63.7

6

498.5

3

12

.90

1

4.5

0

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oatin

gs

3.7

9

179.7

7

3.2

3

0.0

8

0

.15

Tota

l Em

issi

ons

(lbs)

: 6,

394.

94

1,

132.

28

7,

466.

87

13

2.22

214.

67

Res

ults

: To

tal P

roje

ct A

nnua

l Em

issi

on R

ates

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2P

M10

Tota

l P

roje

ct E

mis

sio

ns (

lbs)

6,3

94.9

4

1,1

32.2

8

7,4

66.8

7

13

2.2

2

2

14

.67

Tota

l P

roje

ct E

mis

sio

ns (

tons)

3.1

97

0.5

66

3.7

33

0.0

66

0

.10

7

Tota

l A

rea

(acre

s)

To

talA

rea

(ft2

)

Alt4

Low

Com

bust

ion

D-2

2

Page 25: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n Fu

gitiv

e D

ust E

mis

sion

s fo

r Con

vert

Sig

nal t

o En

hanc

ed L

OR

AN

(eLO

RA

N),

secu

re a

nd u

nsta

ff LO

RA

N s

tatio

ns

Calc

ula

tion o

f P

M10 E

mis

sio

ns D

ue to S

ite P

repara

tion (

Uncontr

olle

d).

User

Input P

ara

mete

rs / A

ssum

ptions

Acre

s g

raded p

er

year:

23.4

6acre

s/y

r(F

rom

"A

lt4Low

Com

bustion"

work

sheet)

Gra

din

g d

ays/y

r:13.1

0days/y

r(F

rom

"A

lt4Low

Gra

din

g w

ork

sheet)

Exposed d

ays/y

r:90

assum

ed d

ays/y

r gra

ded a

rea is e

xposed

Gra

din

g H

ours

/day:

8hr/

da

yS

oil

pile

s a

rea fra

ction:

0.1

0(a

ssu

med f

raction o

f site a

rea c

overe

d b

y s

oil

pile

s)

Soil

perc

ent silt

, s:

8.5

%(m

ean s

ilt c

onte

nt;

expecte

d r

ange:

0.5

6 t

o 2

3,

AP

-42

Ta

ble

13

.2.2

-1)

Soil

perc

ent m

ois

ture

, M

:50

%(h

ttp:/

/ww

w.c

pc.n

oaa.g

ov/p

roducts

/soilm

st/

w.s

htm

l)A

nnual ra

infa

ll days, p:

140

days/y

r ra

infa

ll exceeds 0

.01 inch/d

ay (

AP

-42 F

ig 1

3.2

.2-1

, A

ve.

range f

rom

40

-24

0 d

ays/y

r o

n U

.S.

co

astlin

e)

Win

d s

peed >

12 m

ph %

, I:

20

%A

vera

ge n

ational w

indspeed

Fra

ction o

f T

SP

, J:

0.5

per

Calif

orn

ia E

nvironm

enta

l Q

ualit

y A

ct

(CE

QA

) A

ir Q

ualit

y H

andboo

k,

SC

AQ

MD

, 1

99

3,

p.

A9

-99

Mean v

ehic

le s

peed, S

:5

mi/hr

(On-s

ite)

Dozer

path

wid

th:

8ft

Qty

constr

uctio

n v

ehic

les:

3.0

0vehic

les

(Fro

m "

Alt4Low

Gra

din

g w

ork

sheet)

On-s

ite V

MT

/vehic

le/d

ay:

5m

i/veh/d

ay

(Exclu

din

g b

ulld

ozer

VM

T d

uring g

radin

g)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r k

1.5

lb/V

MT

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r a

0.9

(dim

ensio

nle

ss)

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r b

0.4

5(d

imensio

nle

ss)

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

Mean V

ehic

le W

eig

ht W

40

tons

assum

ed f

or

aggre

gate

tru

cks

TS

P -

Tota

l S

uspended

Part

icula

teV

MT

- V

ehic

le M

iles T

ravele

d

Alt4

Low

Fug

itive

D-2

3

Page 26: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

s D

ue to

Soi

l Dis

turb

ance

Act

iviti

es

Opera

tion P

ara

mete

rs (

Calc

ula

ted fro

m U

ser

Inputs

)G

radin

g d

ura

tion p

er

acre

4.5

hr/

acre

Bulld

ozer

mile

age p

er

acre

1V

MT

/acre

(Mile

s t

ravele

d b

y b

ulld

ozer

during g

radin

g)

Constr

uction V

MT

per

day

15

VM

T/d

ay

Constr

uction V

MT

per

acre

8.4

VM

T/a

cre

(Tra

vel on u

npaved s

urf

aces w

ithin

site)

Equations U

sed (

Corr

ecte

d for

PM

10)

AP

-42 S

ection

Opera

tion

Em

piric

al E

quation

Units

(5th

Editio

n)

Bulld

ozin

g0.7

5(s

1.5

)/(M

1.4

)lb

s/h

rT

able

11.9

-1,

Overb

urd

en

Gra

din

g(0

.60

)(0.0

51

)s2.0

lbs/V

MT

Table

11.9

-1,

Vehic

le T

raffic

(unpaved r

oads)

[(k(s

/12

)a(W

/3)b

)][(

365-P

)/365

] lb

s/V

MT

Section 1

3.2

.2

Sourc

e: C

om

pila

tion o

f A

ir P

ollu

tant E

mis

sio

n F

acto

rs,

Vol. I

, U

SE

PA

AP

-42,

Section 1

1.9

date

d 1

0/9

8 a

nd S

ection 1

3.2

da

ted

12

/03

Calc

ula

tion o

f P

M10 E

mis

sio

n F

acto

rs for

Each O

pera

tio

n

Em

issio

n

Facto

rE

mis

sio

n

Facto

rO

pera

tion

(mass/

unit)

Opera

tion

Para

mete

r(lbs/

acre

)B

ulld

ozin

g0.0

8lb

s/h

r4.5

hr/

acre

0.4

0lb

s/a

cre

Gra

din

g0.7

7lb

s/V

MT

1V

MT

/acre

0.8

0lb

s/a

cre

Vehic

le T

raffic

(unpaved r

oads)

2.1

7lb

s/V

MT

8.4

VM

T/a

cre

18.3

0lb

s/a

cre

Alt4

Low

Fug

itive

D-2

4

Page 27: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

s D

ue to

Win

d Er

osio

n of

Soi

l Pile

s an

d Ex

pose

d G

rade

d Su

rfac

e

Refe

rence: C

alif

orn

ia E

nvironm

enta

l Q

ualit

y A

ct (C

EQ

A)

Air Q

ualit

y H

andbook,

SC

AQ

MD

, 1993.

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

1.7

(s/1

.5)[

(365 -

p)/

235](

I/15)(

J)

= (

s)(

365 -

p)(

I)(J

)/(3

110.2

941),

p.

A9-9

9.

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

6.1

lbs/d

ay/a

cre

covere

d b

y s

oil

pile

s

Consid

er

soil

pile

s a

rea

fra

ction s

o that E

F a

pplie

s to g

raded a

rea

Soil

pile

s a

rea fra

ction:

0.1

0(F

raction o

f site a

rea c

overe

d b

y s

oil

pile

s)

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

0.6

1lb

s/d

ay/a

cre

s g

raded

Gra

ded S

urf

ace E

F =

26.4

lbs/d

ay/a

cre

(re

com

mended in C

EQ

A M

anual, p

. A

9-9

3).

Cal

cula

tion

of A

nnua

l PM

10 E

mis

sion

s

Gra

ded

Exposed

Em

issio

ns

Em

issio

ns

Sourc

eE

mis

sio

n

Facto

rA

cre

s/y

rdays/y

rlb

s/y

rto

ns/y

rB

ulld

ozin

g0.4

0lb

s/a

cre

23.4

6N

A9

0.0

05

Gra

din

g0.8

0lb

s/a

cre

23.4

6N

A19

0.0

09

Vehic

le T

raffic

18.3

0lb

s/a

cre

23.4

6N

A429

0.2

15

Ero

sio

n o

f S

oil

Pile

s0.6

1lb

s/a

cre

/day

23.4

690

1,2

88

0.6

44

Ero

sio

n o

f G

raded S

urf

ace

26.4

0lb

s/a

cre

/day

23.4

690

55,7

40

27

.87

0T

OT

AL

57,4

85

28

.74

Soil

Dis

turb

ance E

F:

19.5

0lb

s/a

cre

Win

d E

rosio

n E

F:

27.0

1lb

s/a

cre

/day

Back c

alc

ula

te to g

et E

F:

187.0

1

lb

s/a

cre

/gra

din

g d

ay

Alt4

Low

Fug

itive

D-2

5

Page 28: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n (G

radi

ng) S

ched

ule

for C

onve

rt S

igna

l to

Enha

nced

LO

RA

N (e

LOR

AN

), se

cure

and

uns

taff

LOR

AN

sta

tions

Estim

ate

of tim

e r

equired to g

rade a

specifie

d a

rea.

Input P

ara

mete

rsC

onstr

uction a

rea:

23.4

6acre

s/y

r (f

rom

"A

lt4

Low

Com

bustion"

Work

sheet)

Qty

Equip

ment:

3.0

0(c

alc

ula

ted b

ased o

n 3

pie

ces o

f equip

ment

for

every

10 a

cre

s)

Assum

ptions.

Terr

ain

is m

ostly fla

t.A

n a

vera

ge o

f 6"

soil

is e

xcavate

d fro

m o

ne h

alf o

f th

e s

ite a

nd b

ackfille

d t

o t

he o

ther

half o

f th

e s

ite;

no s

oil

is h

aule

d o

ff-s

ite

or

bo

rro

we

d.

200 h

p b

ulld

ozers

are

used for

site c

learing.

300 h

p b

ulld

ozers

are

used for

str

ippin

g, excavation, an

d b

ackfill.

Vib

rato

ry d

rum

rolle

rs a

re u

sed for

com

pacting.

Str

ippin

g, E

xcavation, B

ackfill

and C

om

paction r

equire a

n a

vera

ge o

f tw

o p

asses e

ach.

Excavation a

nd B

ackfill

are

assum

ed to involv

e o

nly

ha

lf o

f th

e s

ite.

Calc

ula

tion o

f days r

equired for

one p

iece o

f equip

ment

to g

rade t

he s

pecifie

d a

rea.

Refe

rence: M

eans H

eavy C

onstr

uction C

ost D

ata

, 19th

Ed.,

R.

S.

Means,

2005.

Means L

ine N

o.

Opera

tion

Description

Outp

ut

Units

Acre

s p

er

eq

uip

-da

y)

equip

-da

ys

per

acre

Acre

s/y

r

(pro

ject-

sp

ecific

)

Eq

uip

-da

ys

pe

rye

ar

2230 2

00 0

550

Site C

learing

Dozer

& r

ake, m

ediu

m b

rush

8acre

/day

80

.13

23

.46

2.9

32230 5

00 0

300

Str

ippin

gT

opsoil

& s

tockpili

ng,

advers

e s

oil

1,6

50

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.0

50

.49

23

.46

11

.47

2315 4

32 5

220

Excavation

Bulk

, open s

ite, com

mon e

art

h,

150' h

aul

800

cu.

yd/d

ay

0.9

91

.01

11

.73

11

.83

2315 1

20 5

220

Ba

ckfill

Str

uctu

ral, c

om

mon

eart

h,

150' h

aul

1,9

50

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.4

20

.41

11

.73

4.8

52315 3

10 5

020

Com

paction

Vib

rating r

olle

r, 6

" lifts

, 3 p

asses

2,3

00

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.8

50

.35

23

.46

8.2

3

TO

TA

L3

9.3

1

Calc

ula

tion o

f days r

eq

uired for

the indic

ate

d p

ieces o

f equip

ment

to g

rade t

he d

esig

nate

d a

cre

age.

(Equip

)(day)/

yr:

39.3

1Q

ty E

quip

ment:

3.0

0G

radin

g d

ays/y

r:13.1

0

Alt4

Low

Gra

ding

D-2

6

Page 29: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n C

ombu

stio

n Em

issi

ons

for C

onve

rt S

igna

l to

Enha

nced

LO

RA

N (e

LOR

AN

), se

cure

and

uns

taff

LOR

AN

sta

tions

Com

bustion E

mis

sio

ns o

f V

OC

, N

Ox,

SO

2, C

O a

nd P

M10 D

ue t

o C

onstr

uction

Inclu

des:

1C

onstr

uct T

ow

er

7,0

00

ft2

2In

sta

ll C

opp

er

Rad

ials

3,1

40,0

00

ft2

3C

onstr

uct T

ransm

itte

r B

uild

ing

5,0

00

ft2

4C

onstr

uct M

onitorin

g S

ite F

acili

ty100

ft2

5C

onstr

uct A

ccess R

oad

79,2

00

ft2

6In

sta

ll U

tilit

ies to S

ite

15,8

40

ft2

Assum

ptions:

Tow

er

is 7

00 feet ta

ll b

uilt

on a

100ft

2 c

oncre

te p

ad.

Land d

istu

rbance for

insta

lling the 1

20 c

opper

radia

ls w

ould

be a

ppro

xim

ate

ly 7

2 a

cre

s.

Access r

oad w

ould

be 1

mile

long b

y 1

5 ft w

ide. R

oad w

ould

be g

raded a

nd c

overe

d w

ith g

ravel.

Tre

nch for

utilit

ies to th

e s

ite w

ould

be 1

mile

long b

y 3

ft

wid

e.

Tota

l B

uild

ing C

onstr

uction A

rea:

12,1

00

ft2

(1,

3,

and 4

)

Tota

l D

em

olis

hed A

rea:

0ft

2(N

one

)

Tota

l P

aved A

rea:

0ft

2(N

one

)

Tota

l D

istu

rbed A

rea:

3,2

47,1

40

ft2

(1-6

)

Constr

uction D

ura

tion:

1.0

year(

s)

Annual C

onstr

uction A

ctivity:

230

days/y

r

Alt4

Hig

h C

ombu

stio

n

D-2

7

Page 30: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

Fac

tors

Use

d fo

r Con

stru

ctio

n Eq

uipm

ent

Refe

rence: G

uid

e to A

ir Q

ualit

y A

ssessm

ent, S

MA

QM

D,

2004

Em

issio

n facto

rs a

re taken fro

m T

able

3-2

. A

ssum

ptions r

egard

ing t

he t

ype a

nd n

um

ber

of

equip

ment

are

fr

om

Table

3-1

unle

ss o

therw

ise n

ote

d.

Gra

ding

No.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Bulld

ozer

129.4

03.6

62

5.0

90

.59

1.1

7M

oto

r G

rader

110.2

21.7

61

4.9

80

.20

0.2

8W

ate

r T

ruck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.42

0.5

8T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

360.5

19.0

27

0.6

91

.21

2.0

3

Pavi

ngN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Paver

17.9

31.3

71

1.6

20

.16

0.2

2R

olle

r1

5.0

10.8

67

.34

0.1

00

.14

Tota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

212.9

42.2

31

8.9

60

.26

0.3

6

Dem

oliti

onN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Loader

17.8

61.3

51

1.5

20

.16

0.2

2H

aul T

ruck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.42

0.5

8T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

228.7

54.9

54

2.1

40

.58

0.8

0

Bui

ldin

g C

onst

ruct

ion

No.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Eq

uip

mentd

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

S

tationary

Genera

tor

Set

111.8

31.4

71

0.0

90

.24

0.4

7In

dustr

ial S

aw

11

7.0

22.1

21

4.5

20

.34

0.6

8W

eld

er

14.4

80.5

63

.83

0.0

90

.18

M

obile

(non-r

oa

d)

Tru

ck

120.8

93.6

03

0.6

20

.84

0.5

8F

ork

lift

14.5

70.7

96

.70

0.1

80

.13

Cra

ne

18.3

71.4

41

2.2

70

.33

0.2

3T

ota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

667.1

69.9

87

8.0

32

.02

2.2

7

Note

: F

ootn

ote

s fo

r ta

ble

s a

re o

n follo

win

g p

age

Alt4

Hig

h C

ombu

stio

n

D-2

8

Page 31: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Arc

hite

ctur

al C

oatin

gsN

o.

Reqd.a

NO

xV

OC

bC

OS

O2

cP

M10

Equip

ment

per

10 a

cre

s(lb/d

ay)

(lb/d

ay)

(lb

/da

y)

(lb

/da

y)

Air C

om

pre

ssor

16.8

30.8

55

.82

0.1

40

.27

Tota

l per

10 a

cre

s o

f activity

16.8

30.8

55

.82

0.1

40

.27

a)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 g

uid

ance s

uggests

a d

efa

ult e

quip

ment

fleet

for

each a

ctivitiy

, assum

ing 1

0 a

cre

s o

f th

at

activity,

(e

.g., 1

0 a

cre

s o

f gra

din

g, 10 a

cre

s o

f pavin

g, e

tc.)

. T

he d

efa

ult e

quip

ment

fleet

is incre

ased f

or

each 1

0 a

cre

incre

me

nt

in

the s

ize o

f th

e c

onstr

uction p

roje

ct. T

hat is

, a 2

6 a

cre

pro

ject

would

round t

o 3

0 a

cre

s a

nd t

he f

leet

siz

e w

ould

be

th

ree tim

es the d

efa

ult fle

et fo

r a 1

0 a

cre

pro

ject.

b)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 r

efe

rence lis

ts e

mis

sio

n facto

rs f

or

reactive o

rganic

gas (

RO

G).

F

or

the p

urp

oses o

f th

is w

ork

sh

ee

t R

OG

= V

OC

.

c)

The S

MA

QM

D 2

004 r

efe

rence d

oes n

ot pro

vid

e S

O2 e

mis

sio

n f

acto

rs.

For

this

work

sheet,

SO

2 e

mis

sio

ns h

ave b

ee

n e

stim

ate

d

based o

n a

ppro

xim

ate

fuel use r

ate

for

die

sel e

quip

ment

and t

he a

ssum

ption o

f 500 p

pm

sulfur

die

sel fu

el.

For

the

ave

rag

e o

f

th

e e

quip

ment

fleet, the r

esultin

g S

O2 facto

r w

as f

ound t

o b

e a

ppro

xim

ate

ly 0

.04 t

imes t

he N

Ox e

mis

sio

n f

acto

r fo

r th

e m

ob

ile e

qu

ipm

en

t (b

ase

d

upon 2

002 U

SA

F IE

RA

"A

ir E

mis

sio

ns Invento

ry G

uid

ance")

and 0

.02 t

imes t

he N

Ox e

mis

sio

n f

acto

r fo

r all

oth

er

eq

uip

me

nt

(ba

se

d o

n A

P-4

2,

Ta

ble

3.4

-1)

d)

Typic

al equip

me

nt fleet fo

r build

ing c

onstr

uction

was n

ot

item

ized in S

MA

QM

D 2

004 g

uid

ance.

The e

quip

ment

list a

bo

ve

wa

s assum

ed b

ased

on S

MA

QM

D 1

994 g

uid

ance.

PRO

JEC

T-SP

ECIF

IC E

MIS

SIO

N F

AC

TOR

SU

MM

ARY

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2**

PM

10

83608.5

30

537.9

10

42

15

.61

77

2.1

71

12

1.0

60

10.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

10.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

0.0

00

11.8

66

0.2

77

2.1

68

0.0

56

0.0

63

10.1

90

0.0

24

0.1

62

0.0

04

0.0

08

8.9

65

Exam

ple

: S

MA

QM

D E

mis

sio

n F

acto

r fo

r G

radin

g E

quip

ment

NO

x =

(T

ota

l G

radin

g N

Ox p

er

10 a

c*(

(tota

l dis

turb

ed a

rea

/43

56

0)/

10

))*(

Eq

uip

me

nt

Mu

ltip

lier)

Sourc

e

Gra

din

g E

quip

ment

SM

AQ

MD

Em

issio

n F

acto

rs (

lb/d

ay)

Equip

ment

Multip

lier*

**E

mis

sio

n facto

r is

fro

m the e

vapora

tion o

f solv

ents

during p

ain

ting,

per

"Air Q

ualit

y T

hre

shold

s o

f S

ignific

ance",

SM

AQ

MD

, 1

99

4

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating**

*The e

quip

ment m

ultip

lier

is a

n inte

ger

that re

pre

sents

units o

f 10 a

cre

s f

or

purp

oses o

f estim

ating t

he n

um

ber

of

equip

me

nt

req

uire

d f

or

the

pro

ject

Dem

olit

ion E

quip

ment

Build

ing C

onstr

uction

Pavin

g E

quip

ment

Air C

om

pre

ssor

for

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating

Alt4

Hig

h C

ombu

stio

n

D-2

9

Page 32: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Sum

mary

of In

put P

ara

mete

rsT

ota

l D

ays

Gra

din

g:

3,2

47,1

40

74.5

414

(fro

m "

Alt4

Hig

h G

rad

ing

" w

ork

sh

ee

t)P

avin

g:

00.0

00

Dem

olit

ion:

00.0

0230

Build

ing C

onstr

uction:

12,1

00

0.2

8230

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oating

12,1

00

0.2

820

(per

the

SM

AQ

MD

"A

ir Q

ua

lity o

f T

hre

sh

old

s o

f S

ign

ific

an

ce

", 1

99

4)

NO

TE

: T

he 'T

ota

l D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

pavin

g is c

alc

ula

ted b

y d

ivid

ing t

he t

ota

l num

ber

of

acre

s b

y 0

.21 a

cre

s/d

ay,

wh

ich

is a

fa

cto

r d

erive

d f

rom

th

e 2

00

5 M

EA

NS

Heavy C

onstr

uction

Cost D

ata

, 19th

Editio

n, fo

r 'A

sphaltic

Concre

te P

avem

ent,

Lots

and D

rivew

ays -

6"

sto

ne b

ase',

wh

ich

pro

vid

es a

n e

stim

ate

of

sq

ua

refe

et paved p

er

day. T

here

is a

lso a

n e

stim

ate

for

'Pla

in C

em

ent

Concre

te P

avem

ent',

how

ever

the e

stim

ate

for

asph

alt is u

se

d b

eca

use

it

is m

ore

co

nse

rva

tive

.T

he 'T

ota

l 'D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

dem

olit

ion is c

alc

ula

ted b

y d

ivid

ing t

he t

ota

l num

ber

of

acre

s b

y 0

.02 a

cre

s/d

ay,

wh

ich

is a

fa

cto

r a

lso

de

rive

d f

rom

th

e 2

00

5

ME

AN

S r

efe

rence. T

his

is c

alc

ula

ted b

y a

vera

gin

g t

he d

em

olit

ion e

stim

ate

s f

rom

'Build

ing D

em

olit

ion -

Sm

all

Build

ing

s,

Co

ncre

te', a

ssu

min

g a

he

igh

t of 30 feet fo

r a tw

o-s

tory

build

ing; fr

om

'Build

ing F

ootings a

nd F

oundations D

em

olit

ion -

6"

Thic

k,

Pla

in C

oncre

te';

an

d f

rom

'D

em

olis

h,

Re

mo

ve

P

avem

ent and C

urb

- C

oncre

te to 6

" th

ick, ro

d r

ein

forc

ed'.

Pavin

g is d

ouble

-weig

hte

d s

ince p

roje

cts

typic

ally

involv

e m

ore

pa

vin

g d

em

olit

ion

.T

he 'T

ota

l D

ays' e

stim

ate

for

build

ing c

onstr

uction is a

ssum

ed t

o b

e 2

30 d

ays,

unle

ss p

roje

ct-

specific

data

is k

now

n.

Tota

l Pro

ject

Em

issi

ons

by A

ctiv

ity (l

bs)

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2P

M10

Gra

din

g E

quip

ment

50,5

19.4

2

7,5

30.7

4

59,0

18.6

3

1

,01

0.3

9

1

,69

4.8

3

P

avin

g-

-

-

-

-

Dem

olit

ion

-

-

-

-

-

Build

ing C

onstr

uction

429.0

8

63.7

6

498.5

3

12

.90

1

4.5

0

Arc

hitectu

ral C

oatin

gs

3.7

9

179.7

7

3.2

3

0.0

8

0

.15

Tota

l Em

issi

ons

(lbs)

: 50

,952

.29

7,

774.

27

59

,520

.39

1,

023.

37

1,70

9.49

Res

ults

: To

tal P

roje

ct A

nnua

l Em

issi

on R

ates

NO

xV

OC

CO

SO

2P

M10

Tota

l P

roje

ct E

mis

sio

ns (

lbs)

50,9

52.2

9

7,7

74.2

7

59,5

20.3

9

1

,02

3.3

7

1

,70

9.4

9

T

ota

l P

roje

ct E

mis

sio

ns (

tons)

25.4

76

3

.88

7

29.7

60

0

.51

2

0.8

55

To

talA

rea

(ft2

)

Tota

l A

rea

(acre

s)

Alt4

Hig

h C

ombu

stio

n

D-3

0

Page 33: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n Fu

gitiv

e D

ust E

mis

sion

s fo

r Con

vert

Sig

nal t

o En

hanc

ed L

OR

AN

(eLO

RA

N),

secu

re a

nd u

nsta

ff LO

RA

N s

tatio

ns

Calc

ula

tion o

f P

M10 E

mis

sio

ns D

ue to S

ite P

repara

tion (

Uncontr

olle

d).

User

Input P

ara

mete

rs / A

ssum

ptions

Acre

s g

raded p

er

year:

74.5

4acre

s/y

r(F

rom

"A

lt4H

igh C

om

bustion"

work

sheet)

Gra

din

g d

ays/y

r:13.9

6days/y

r(F

rom

"A

lt4H

igh G

radin

g w

ork

sheet)

Exposed d

ays/y

r:90

assum

ed d

ays/y

r gra

ded a

rea is e

xposed

Gra

din

g H

ours

/day:

8hr/

da

yS

oil

pile

s a

rea fra

ction:

0.1

0(a

ssu

med f

raction o

f site a

rea c

overe

d b

y s

oil

pile

s)

Soil

perc

ent silt

, s:

8.5

%(m

ean s

ilt c

onte

nt;

expecte

d r

ange:

0.5

6 t

o 2

3,

AP

-42

Ta

ble

13

.2.2

-1)

Soil

perc

ent m

ois

ture

, M

:50

%(h

ttp:/

/ww

w.c

pc.n

oaa.g

ov/p

roducts

/soilm

st/

w.s

htm

l)A

nnual ra

infa

ll days, p:

140

days/y

r ra

infa

ll exceeds 0

.01 inch/d

ay (

AP

-42 F

ig 1

3.2

.2-1

, A

ve.

range f

rom

40

-24

0 d

ays/y

r o

n U

.S.

co

astlin

e)

Win

d s

peed >

12 m

ph %

, I:

20

%A

vera

ge n

ational w

indspeed

Fra

ction o

f T

SP

, J:

0.5

per

Calif

orn

ia E

nvironm

enta

l Q

ualit

y A

ct

(CE

QA

) A

ir Q

ualit

y H

andboo

k,

SC

AQ

MD

, 1

99

3,

p.

A9

-99

Mean v

ehic

le s

peed, S

:5

mi/hr

(On-s

ite)

Dozer

path

wid

th:

8ft

Qty

constr

uctio

n v

ehic

les:

8.9

5vehic

les

(Fro

m "

Alt4H

igh G

radin

g w

ork

sheet)

On-s

ite V

MT

/vehic

le/d

ay:

5m

i/ve

h/d

ay

(Exclu

din

g b

ulld

ozer

VM

T d

uring g

radin

g)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r k

1.5

lb/V

MT

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r a

0.9

(dim

ensio

nle

ss)

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

PM

10 A

dju

stm

ent F

acto

r b

0.4

5(d

imensio

nle

ss)

(AP

-42 T

able

13.2

.2-2

12/0

3

for

PM

10 f

or

unpaved r

oa

ds)

Mean V

ehic

le W

eig

ht W

40

tons

assum

ed f

or

aggre

gate

tru

cks

TS

P -

Tota

l S

uspended

Part

icula

teV

MT

- V

ehic

le M

iles T

ravele

d

Alt4

Hig

h Fu

gitiv

e

D-3

1

Page 34: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

s D

ue to

Soi

l Dis

turb

ance

Act

iviti

es

Opera

tion P

ara

mete

rs (

Calc

ula

ted fro

m U

ser

Inputs

)G

radin

g d

ura

tion p

er

acre

1.5

hr/

acre

Bulld

ozer

mile

age p

er

acre

1V

MT

/acre

(Mile

s t

ravele

d b

y b

ulld

ozer

during g

radin

g)

Constr

uction V

MT

per

day

45

VM

T/d

ay

Constr

uction V

MT

per

acre

8.4

VM

T/a

cre

(Tra

vel on u

npaved s

urf

aces w

ithin

site)

Equations U

sed (

Corr

ecte

d for

PM

10)

AP

-42 S

ection

Opera

tion

Em

piric

al E

quation

Units

(5th

Editio

n)

Bulld

ozin

g0.7

5(s

1.5

)/(M

1.4

)lb

s/h

rT

able

11.9

-1,

Overb

urd

en

Gra

din

g(0

.60

)(0.0

51

)s2.0

lbs/V

MT

Table

11.9

-1,

Vehic

le T

raffic

(unpaved r

oads)

[(k(s

/12

)a(W

/3)b

)][(

365-P

)/365

] lb

s/V

MT

Section 1

3.2

.2

Sourc

e: C

om

pila

tion o

f A

ir P

ollu

tant E

mis

sio

n F

acto

rs,

Vol. I

, U

SE

PA

AP

-42,

Section 1

1.9

date

d 1

0/9

8 a

nd S

ection 1

3.2

da

ted

12

/03

Calc

ula

tion o

f P

M10 E

mis

sio

n F

acto

rs for

Each O

pera

tio

n

Em

issio

n

Facto

rE

mis

sio

n

Facto

rO

pera

tion

(mass/

unit)

Opera

tion

Para

mete

r(lbs/

acre

)B

ulld

ozin

g0.0

8lb

s/h

r1.5

hr/

acre

0.1

0lb

s/a

cre

Gra

din

g0.7

7lb

s/V

MT

1V

MT

/acre

0.8

0lb

s/a

cre

Vehic

le T

raffic

(unpaved r

oads)

2.1

7lb

s/V

MT

8.4

VM

T/a

cre

18.3

0lb

s/a

cre

Alt4

Hig

h Fu

gitiv

e

D-3

2

Page 35: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Emis

sion

s D

ue to

Win

d Er

osio

n of

Soi

l Pile

s an

d Ex

pose

d G

rade

d Su

rfac

e

Refe

rence: C

alif

orn

ia E

nvironm

enta

l Q

ualit

y A

ct (C

EQ

A)

Air Q

ualit

y H

andbook,

SC

AQ

MD

, 1993.

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

1.7

(s/1

.5)[

(365 -

p)/

235](

I/15)(

J)

= (

s)(

365 -

p)(

I)(J

)/(3

110.2

941),

p.

A9-9

9.

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

6.1

lbs/d

ay/a

cre

covere

d b

y s

oil

pile

s

Consid

er

soil

pile

s a

rea

fra

ction s

o that E

F a

pplie

s to g

raded a

rea

Soil

pile

s a

rea fra

ction:

0.1

0(F

raction o

f site a

rea c

overe

d b

y s

oil

pile

s)

Soil

Pile

s E

F =

0.6

1lb

s/d

ay/a

cre

s g

raded

Gra

ded S

urf

ace E

F =

26.4

lbs/d

ay/a

cre

(re

com

mended in C

EQ

A M

anual, p

. A

9-9

3).

Cal

cula

tion

of A

nnua

l PM

10 E

mis

sion

s

Gra

ded

Exposed

Em

issio

ns

Em

issio

ns

Sourc

eE

mis

sio

n

Facto

rA

cre

s/y

rdays/y

rlb

s/y

rto

ns/y

rB

ulld

ozin

g0.1

0lb

s/a

cre

74.5

4N

A7

0.0

04

Gra

din

g0.8

0lb

s/a

cre

74.5

4N

A60

0.0

30

Vehic

le T

raffic

18.3

0lb

s/a

cre

74.5

4N

A1,3

64

0.6

82

Ero

sio

n o

f S

oil

Pile

s0.6

1lb

s/a

cre

/day

74.5

490

4,0

92

2.0

46

Ero

sio

n o

f G

raded S

urf

ace

26.4

0lb

s/a

cre

/day

74.5

490

177,1

17

88

.55

8T

OT

AL

182,6

40

91

.32

Soil

Dis

turb

ance E

F:

19.2

0lb

s/a

cre

Win

d E

rosio

n E

F:

27.0

1lb

s/a

cre

/day

Back c

alc

ula

te to g

et E

F:

175.4

6

lb

s/a

cre

/gra

din

g d

ay

Alt4

Hig

h Fu

gitiv

e

D-3

3

Page 36: LORAN Check Final PEIS 3.26.09 aep - NAVCEN · 2009. 6. 2. · Air Quality Emission Calculations Air Quality Emissions from Proposed Action NO x VOC CO SO 2 PM 10 (ton) (ton) (ton)

Con

stru

ctio

n (G

radi

ng) S

ched

ule

for C

onve

rt S

igna

l to

Enha

nced

LO

RA

N (e

LOR

AN

), se

cure

and

uns

taff

LOR

AN

sta

tions

Estim

ate

of tim

e r

equired to g

rade a

specifie

d a

rea.

Input P

ara

mete

rsC

onstr

uction a

rea:

74.5

4acre

s/y

r (f

rom

"A

lt4

Hig

h C

om

bustion"

Work

sheet)

Qty

Equip

ment:

8.9

5(c

alc

ula

ted b

ased o

n 3

pie

ces o

f equip

ment

for

every

10 a

cre

s)

Assum

ptions.

Terr

ain

is m

ostly fla

t.A

n a

vera

ge o

f 6"

soil

is e

xcavate

d fro

m o

ne h

alf o

f th

e s

ite a

nd b

ackfille

d t

o t

he o

ther

half o

f th

e s

ite;

no s

oil

is h

aule

d o

ff-s

ite

or

bo

rro

we

d.

200 h

p b

ulld

ozers

are

used for

site c

learing.

300 h

p b

ulld

ozers

are

used for

str

ippin

g, excavation, an

d b

ackfill.

Vib

rato

ry d

rum

rolle

rs a

re u

sed for

com

pacting.

Str

ippin

g, E

xcavation, B

ackfill

and C

om

paction r

equire a

n a

vera

ge o

f tw

o p

asses e

ach.

Excavation a

nd B

ackfill

are

assum

ed to involv

e o

nly

ha

lf o

f th

e s

ite.

Calc

ula

tion o

f days r

equired for

one p

iece o

f equip

ment

to g

rade t

he s

pecifie

d a

rea.

Refe

rence: M

eans H

eavy C

onstr

uction C

ost D

ata

, 19th

Ed.,

R.

S.

Means,

2005.

Means L

ine N

o.

Opera

tion

Description

Outp

ut

Units

Acre

s p

er

eq

uip

-da

y)

equip

-da

ys

per

acre

Acre

s/y

r

(pro

ject-

sp

ecific

)

Eq

uip

-da

ys

pe

rye

ar

2230 2

00 0

550

Site C

learing

Dozer

& r

ake, m

ediu

m b

rush

8acre

/day

80

.13

74

.54

9.3

22230 5

00 0

300

Str

ippin

gT

opsoil

& s

tockpili

ng,

advers

e s

oil

1,6

50

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.0

50

.49

74

.54

36

.44

2315 4

32 5

220

Excavation

Bulk

, open s

ite, com

mon e

art

h,

150' h

aul

800

cu.

yd/d

ay

0.9

91

.01

37

.27

37

.58

2315 1

20 5

220

Ba

ckfill

Str

uctu

ral, c

om

mon e

art

h,

150' h

aul

1,9

50

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.4

20.4

137.2

71

5.4

22315 3

10 5

020

Com

paction

Vib

rating r

olle

r, 6

" lifts

, 3 p

asses

2,3

00

cu.

yd/d

ay

2.8

50

.35

74

.54

26

.14

TO

TA

L1

24

.91

Calc

ula

tion o

f days r

eq

uired for

the indic

ate

d p

ieces o

f equip

ment

to g

rade t

he d

esig

nate

d a

cre

age.

(Equip

)(day)/

yr:

124.9

1Q

ty E

quip

ment:

8.9

5G

radin

g d

ays/y

r:13.9

6

Alt4

Hig

h G

radi

ng

D-3

4