Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
Lone Star College- Cy Fair
Associate Degree Nursing Program
(implemented Spring, 2018)
Systematic Plan of Evaluation (SPE)
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
EPSLO #1: Demonstrate accountability and
responsibility for the
delivery of care within the
ethical and legal scope of
practice, professional
standards and best
practice.
HESI Exit exam item scores (direct)
90% of students will attain a score 850 or better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
Subspecialty: (11) legal/ethical = 912
ELA met in all subcategories
Quality & safety education: (4) ethical legal = 994
(7) scope of practice = 1035
RNSG 2560 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in these identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Member of a profession: A = 47% *
* Please see note
C = 47% *
Provider of patient-centered care: E = 68% *
F = 53% *
Patient safety advocate: A = 35% *
F = 71% *
2
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
Pediatrics HESI exam item scores (direct)
90% of students will attain a score 850 or better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
Subspecialty: (6) legal/ethical = 1050
ELA met in all subcategories
Quality & safety education: (4) ethical legal = 1050
(7) scope of practice = 988
RNSG 2160 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in these identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Member of a profession: A = 100% of students rated 4 or above
ELA met in all subcategories
C =100% of students rated 4 or above
Provider of patient-centered care: E = 100% of students rated 4 or above
F = 100% of students rated 4 or above
Patient safety advocate: A = 100% of students rated 4 or above
F = 100% of students rated 4 or above
Student Program Evaluation (indirect)
80% of the students will agree or strongly agree that the nursing curriculum provided the opportunity to
End of fall & spring semesters
Question 3= 81.25% ELA met
3
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
meet this end-of-program student learning outcome
RNSG 2560 Leadership experience written assignment (direct)
90% of the students will attain a score of 75% or above on this assignment
End of fall & spring semesters
Aggregate assignment grade = 95.1% Grade range= 8-10 100% of students met ELA
ELA met
EPSLO #2: Manage information using
technology to support
decision making to
improve patient care and
families.
HESI Exit exam item scores (direct)
90% of students will attain a score 850 or better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
AACN: (8) information management & patient care technology = 938
ELA met in all subcategories
Quality & safety education: (15) nursing infomatics = 936
Nursing concepts: (55) information-technology = 929
RNSG 2560 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Member of the healthcare team: E = 47% *
* Please see not
Pediatrics HESI Exit exam item scores (direct)
90% of students will attain a score 850 or better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
AACN: (8) information management & patient care technology = 960
ELA met in all subcategories
Quality & safety education: (15) nursing infomatics = 899
4
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
Nursing concepts: (48) information-technology = 963
RNSG 2160 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Member of the healthcare team: E = 100% of students rated 4 or above
ELA met
Student Program Evaluation (indirect)
80% of the students will agree or strongly agree that the nursing curriculum provided the opportunity to meet this end-of-program student learning outcome
End of fall & spring semesters
Question 4= 87.5% ELA met
EPSLO #3: Demonstrate responsibility for
continued competence in
nursing practice and
develop insight through
reflection, self-analysis
and self-directed learning.
RNSG 2560 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Member of the healthcare team: C = 29% *
* Please see note
D = 53% *
Patient safety advocate: D = 68% *
RNSG 2160 Clinical Evaluation Tool
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Member of the healthcare team: C = 100% of students rated 4 or above
ELA met in all subcategories
5
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
(direct) D = 100% of students rated 4 or above
Patient safety advocate: D = 100% of students rated 4 or above
Student Program Evaluation (indirect)
80% of the students will agree or strongly agree that the nursing curriculum provided the opportunity to meet this end-of-program student learning outcome
End of fall & spring semesters
Question 5= 87.5% ELA met
Blogs for SIRE and CFISD (RNSG 2160) (direct)
90% of the students will attain a score of 75% or above on this assignment
End of fall & spring semesters
SIRE = Aggregate assignment grade = 99.3% Grade range= 98-100 100% of students met ELA
ELA met in both subcategories
CF ISD = Aggregate assignment grade = 92.1% Grade range= 0-100 100% of students met ELA
RNSG 2207 Personal philosophy
90% of the students will attain a score of 75% or above on this assignment
End of fall & spring semesters
Aggregate assignment grade = 94.75% Grade range= 90- 98
ELA met
6
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
of nursing assignment (direct)
93% of students met ELA
EPSLO #4: Provide safe, compassionate,
comprehensive,
individualized patient-
centered nursing care,
based on the nursing
process and evidence-
based practice, to
culturally diverse patients
and families across the
life span and wellness-
illness continuum.
HESI Exit exam item scores (direct)
90% of students will attain a score 850 or better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
Client Needs: (4) health promotion & maintenance = 915
ELA met in all subcategories
(5) psychosocial integrity = 916
Sub-specialty: (12) research/theory = 1249
AACN: (1) scholarship = 969
(12) provider of care = 1004
Quality & safety education: (10) research & EBP = 989
Nursing concepts: (19) comfort = 1015
(33) family dynamics = 946
RNSG 2560 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Member of a profession: B = 47% *
* Please see note
Provider of patient-centered care: A = 53% *
B = 53% *
C = 47% *
D = 53% *
E = 53% *
Client Needs: ELA met in all
7
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
Pediatric HESI exam item scores (direct)
90% of students will attain a score 850 or better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
(4) health promotion & maintenance = 1050
subcategories
(5) psychosocial integrity = 983
Sub-specialty: (8) research/theory = 1063
AACN: (1) scholarship = 991
(11) provider of care = 979
Quality & safety education: (10) research & EBP = 984
Nursing concepts: (19) comfort = 1047
(26) family dynamics = 1001
RNSG 2160 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Member of a profession: B = 100% of students rated 4 or above
ELA met in all subcategories
Provider of patient-centered care: A = 100% of students rated 4 or above
B = 100% of students rated 4 or above
C = 100% of students rated 4 or above
D = 100% of students rated 4 or above
8
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
E = 100% of students rated 4 or above
Student Program Evaluation (indirect)
80% of the students will agree or strongly agree that the nursing curriculum provided the opportunity to meet this end-of-program student learning outcome
End of fall & spring semesters
Question 6= 81.25% ELA met
RNSG 2160 Nursing care plan (direct)
90% of the students will attain a score of 75% or above on this assignment
End of fall & spring semesters
Aggregate assignment grade = 89.1% (wk 1) 90.2% (wk 2) Grade range= 80-97 100% of students met ELA
ELA met
RNSG 2560 Nursing care plan/concept map (direct)
90% of the students will attain a score of 75% or above on this assignment
End of fall & spring semesters
Aggregate assignment grade = 91.5% Grade range= 83-100 100% of students met ELA
ELA met
EPSLO #5: Develop, implement and evaluate
90% of students will attain a score 850 or
Sub-specialty: (13) teaching = 927
ELA met in both subcategories
9
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
teaching plans to address
health promotion,
maintenance and
restoration.
HESI Exit exam item scores (direct)
better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
Nursing concepts: (44) teaching & learning-patient education = 971
RNSG 2560 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Provider of patient-centered care: G = 59% *
* Please see note below
Pediatric HESI exam item scores (direct)
90% of students will attain a score 850 or better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
Sub-specialty: (9) teaching = 1016
ELA met in both subcategories
Nursing concepts: (36) teaching & learning-patient education = 1038
RNSG 2160 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Provider of patient-centered care: G = 100%
Student Program Evaluation (indirect)
80% of the students will agree or strongly agree that the nursing curriculum provided the opportunity to meet this end-of-
End of fall & spring semesters
Question 7 = 81.25% ELA met
10
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
program student learning outcome
RNSG 2160 Teaching & safety plan (direct)
90% of the students will attain a score of 75% or above on this assignment
End of fall & spring semesters
Aggregate assignment grade = 90.8% Grade range= 68-100 93% of students met ELA
ELA met
EPSLO #6: Advocate for the provision of safe
quality health care for
patients and their families.
HESI Exit exam item scores (direct)
90% of students will attain a score 850 or better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
Client needs: (9) reduce risk potential = 960
ELA met in all subcategories
AACN: (7) leadership for quality care & patient safety = 994
Quality & safety education: (11) quality improvement = 952
(14) national patient safety resources = 972
RNSG 2560 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Patient safety advocate: B = 47% *
* Please see note
C = 68% *
E = 68% *
Member of the healthcare team: B = 53% *
Pediatric HESI exam item scores
90% of students will attain a score 850 or
End of fall & spring semesters
Client needs: (9) reduce risk potential = 951
ELA met in all subcategories
AACN:
11
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
(direct) better in each of this HESI items
(7) leadership for quality care & patient safety = 960
Quality & safety education: (11) quality improvement = 984
(14) national patient safety resources = 978
RNSG 2160 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Patient safety advocate: B = 100% of students rated 4 or above
ELA met in all subcategories
C = 100% of students rated 4 or above
E = 100% of students rated 4 or above
Member of the healthcare team: B = 100% of students rated 4 or above
Student Program Evaluation (indirect)
80% of the students will agree or strongly agree that the nursing curriculum provided the opportunity to meet this end-of-program student learning outcome
End of fall & spring semesters
Question 8= 81.25% ELA met
12
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
EPSLO #7: Coordinate human information and
material resources in
providing care for patients
and their families.
HESI Exit exam item scores (direct)
90% of students will attain a score 850 or better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
AACN: (10) designer/manager/coordinator of care = 985
ELA met in all subcategories
Quality & safety education: (6) member of a team = 989
(9) system/team functions = 988
Pediatrics HESI exam item scores (direct)
90% of students will attain a score 850 or better in each of this HESI items
End of fall & spring semesters
AACN: (10) designer/manager/coordinator of care = 1092
ELA met in all subcategories
Quality & safety education: (6) member of a team = 951
(9) system/team functions = 940
RNSG 2560 Clinical Evaluation Tool (direct)
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
Provider of patient-centered care: H = 53% *
* Please see note
Member of the healthcare team: A = 68% *
C = 29% *
D = 53% *
RNSG 2160 Clinical
90% of students will attain a rating of 4 or
Provider of patient-centered care:
ELA met in all subcategories
13
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
Evaluation Tool (direct)
better in this identified criteria
End of fall & spring semesters
H =100% of students rated 4 or above
Member of the healthcare team: A = 100% of students rated 4 or above
C = 100% of students rated 4 or above
D = 100% of students rated 4 or above
Student Program Evaluation (indirect)
80% of the students will agree or strongly agree that the nursing curriculum provided the opportunity to meet this end-of-program student learning outcome
End of fall & spring semesters
Question 9= 81.25% ELA met
License Exam Pass Rate: NCLEX pass rates from TBON
ELA: Aggregate first-time NCLEX pass rate will be 80% or better (TBON)
Annually (Oct)
93.94% (fiscal year 2016-7)
ELA exceeded
Program Completion Rate:
Cohort statistics
ELA: ≤ 70% (THECB)
End of fall & spring semesters
Spring 17 cohort = 58% (projected) Fall 16= 42%
Retention Task Force formed
14
End Of Program Student Learning Outcomes and ACEN Program Outcomes Component Assessment
Method
Expected Level of
Achievement
(ELA)
Frequency
of
Assessment
Results of Data Collection Analysis/Actions
Spring 16 =49% Fall 15 cohort = 57% Spring 15 cohort = 57%
Retention Action Plan developed;
implementation ongoing
Job Placement Rate: (includes graduates in BSN programs)
Student Program
Evaluation & personal follow up
ELA: 75% of graduates will be either employed in nursing or be attending a FT BSN program (faculty)
End of fall & spring semesters
Fall 17 cohort =75% (80% response rate) Spring 17 = 75% (67% response rate) Fall 16 = 100% (67% response rate) Spring 16 = > 5% response rate
As response rates have increased with
intervention, better data supports that ELA being
met.
* 6/20/18 – question the reliability of RNSG 2560 clinical evaluation tool results. One instructor rated all students as “3” for every
area- that seems an unreliable finding at best. Scores very disconnected from RNSG 2160 ratings. With the small N of 17, data
very skewed. Instructor will receive follow-up and education about accurately completing the clinical evaluation tool based on
the individual student and not what is expedient. Will reassess criteria and ELA after fall, 2018 data collection and analysis.