76
IBERICOS 2016 11 th Iberian Cosmology Meeting SOC ANA ACHรšCARRO (LEIDEN/BILBAO), FERNANDO ATRIO-BARANDELA (SALAMANCA), MAR BASTERO-GIL (GRANADA), JUAN GARCIA- -BELLIDO (MADRID), RUTH LAZKOZ (BILBAO), CARLOS MARTINS (PORTO), JOSร‰ PEDRO MIMOSO (LISBON), DAVID MOTA (OSLO) LOC ANA CATARINA LEITE, CARLOS MARTINS (CHAIR), FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PEIXOTO (SYSADMIN), ANA MARTA PINHO, IVANย RYBAK, ELSA SILVA (ADMIN) VILA DO CONDE, PORTUGAL, 29-31 MARCH, 2016 SERIES OF MEETINGS WHICH AIM TO ENCOURAGE INTERACTIONS AND COLLABORATIONS BETWEEN RESEARCHERS WORKING IN COSMOLOGY AND RELATED AREAS IN PORTUGAL AND SPAIN. www.iastro.pt/ibericos2016

LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

IBERICOS2016

11th Iberian Cosmology Meeting

SOCโ€‚ANA ACHรšCARRO (LEIDEN/BILBAO), FERNANDO ATRIO-BARANDELA (SALAMANCA), MAR BASTERO-GIL (GRANADA), JUAN GARCIA-

-BELLIDO (MADRID), RUTH LAZKOZ (BILBAO), CARLOS MARTINS (PORTO), JOSร‰ PEDRO MIMOSO (LISBON), DAVID MOTA (OSLO)

LOCโ€‚ANA CATARINA LEITE, CARLOS MARTINS (CHAIR), FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PEIXOTO (SYSADMIN), ANA MARTA PINHO, IVAN RYBAK, ELSA SILVA (ADMIN)

VILA DO CONDE, PORTUGAL, 29-31 MARCH, 2016

SERIES OF MEETINGS WHICH AIM TO ENCOURAGE INTERACTIONS AND COLLABORATIONS BETWEEN RESEARCHERS WORKING IN COSMOLOGY AND RELATED AREAS IN PORTUGAL AND SPAIN.

www.iastro.pt/ibericos2016

Page 2: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Catarina M. CosmePhD student under the supervision of

Prof. Joรฃo Rosa and Prof. Orfeu Bertolami

30 March 2016

arXiv: 1603.06242

Scalar field dark matter and the Higgs field

Page 3: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

What is dark matter made of?

Introducing the problem

Scalar field dark matter and the Higgs field30/03/2016 2

โ€ข We propose: oscillating scalar field as DM candidate, coupled to the Higgs boson;

โ€ข Previous works: โ€œHiggs-portalโ€ DM models: abundance of DM is set by the decoupling and

freeze-out from thermal equilibrium ๐‘š ~ ๐บ๐‘’๐‘‰ โˆ’ ๐‘‡๐‘’๐‘‰ (Weakly Interacting Massive

Particles - WIMPs) [Silveira, Zee 1985; Bento, Bertolami, Rosenfeld 2001; Burgess, Pospelov, ter Veldhuis 2001;

Tenkanen 2015];

โ€ข Dark matter (DM) - 26.8 % of the mass-energy content of the Universe [Planck Collaboration 2015];

Page 4: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

30/03/2016 Scalar field dark matter and the Higgs field 3

Oscillating scalar field as dark matter candidate

Our proposal

โ€ข Oscillating scalar field, ฯ†, as DM candidate;

โ€ข ฯ† acquires mass through the Higgs mechanism;

โ€ข ฯ† starts to oscillate when๐‘šฯ† ~ ๐ป, after the electroweak phase transition;

โ€ข Weakly interactions with the Higgs boson ๐‘šฯ† โ‰ช ๐‘’๐‘‰ , extremely small self-

interactions oscillating scalar condensate that is never in thermal equilibrium.

Page 5: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

30/03/2016 Scalar field dark matter and the Higgs field 4

Oscillating scalar field as dark matter candidate

๐œŒฯ•,0 =1

2

๐‘šฯ•2

๐‘Ž03 ฯ•๐‘–

2

Energy density

ฮฉฯ•,0 โ‰ก๐œŒฯ•,0

๐œŒ๐‘,0

DM abundance

๐‘šฯ• ฯ•๐‘– =

๐ป๐ธ๐‘Š~10โˆ’5 ๐‘’๐‘‰

2 ร— 10โˆ’5๐‘”โˆ—100

1/2 ฯ•๐‘–1013 ๐บ๐‘’๐‘‰

โˆ’4

๐‘’๐‘‰ , ๐‘šฯ•> ๐ป๐ธ๐‘Š.

3 ร— 10โˆ’5๐‘”โˆ—100

1/2 ฯ•๐‘–1013 ๐บ๐‘’๐‘‰

โˆ’4

๐‘’๐‘‰, ๐‘šฯ• < ๐ป๐ธ๐‘Š.

Page 6: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

โ€ข Light fields during inflation quantum fluctuations do not respect the limit of the Cold

Dark Matter (CDM) isocurvature perturbations.

โ€ข Gravitational interactions during inflation ๐“›๐‘–๐‘›๐‘ก=๐‘

2

ฯ•2๐‘‰ ฯ‡

๐‘€๐‘ƒ๐‘™2 ๐‘šฯ•~ ๐ป๐‘–๐‘›๐‘“ CDM

isocurvature perturbations compatible with observations [Planck Collaboration 2015] ;

โ€ข Constraints on CDM isocurvature perturbations lead to:

โ€ข ๐ป๐‘–๐‘›๐‘“โ‰ƒ 2.5 ร— 1013 ๐‘Ÿ

0.01

1

2๐บ๐‘’๐‘‰, ๐‘Ÿ < 0.11. [Planck Collaboration 2015].

30/03/2016 Scalar field dark matter and the Higgs field 5

Initial conditions

ฯ•๐‘– โ‰ƒ ฮฑ ๐ป๐‘–๐‘›๐‘“, ฮฑ โ‰ƒ 0.1 โˆ’ 0.25;

๐‘Ÿ โ‰กโˆ†๐‘ก2

โˆ†๐“ก2

Page 7: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

30/03/2016 Scalar field dark matter and the Higgs field 6

Initial conditions โ€“ Results

๐‘šฯ• < ๐ป๐ธ๐‘Š

๐‘šฯ• > ๐ป๐ธ๐‘Š

๐‘šฯ•~ 10โˆ’6 ๐‘’๐‘‰

๐‘šฯ•~ 10โˆ’5 ๐‘’๐‘‰

Page 8: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

30/03/2016 Scalar field dark matter and the Higgs field 7

Non-renormalizable interactions model

DM fieldConformal symmetry

Higgs boson (and Standard Model fields)

Hidden sector Visible sector

Heavy messengers,

Gravitybroken by non-renormalizable

operators

๐“›๐‘–๐‘›๐‘ก =๐‘Ž62

2โ„Ž 4

ฯ•2

๐‘€2 ๐‘šฯ• = ๐‘Ž6

๐‘ฃ2

๐‘€~ 2.5 ร— 10โˆ’5 ๐‘Ž6

๐‘€

๐‘€๐‘ƒ

โˆ’1

eV;

Electroweak symmetry breaking

Page 9: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

30/03/2016 Scalar field dark matter and the Higgs field 8

Warped extra-dimension model

Randall-Sundrum inspired model:

0 yL

Higgs

5D bulk

Visible/Infrared brane

Planck brane

ฯ†

๐‘ฃ โ‰ƒ ๐‘’โˆ’๐‘˜๐ฟ๐‘€๐‘ƒ๐‘’โˆ’๐‘˜๐ฟ ~ 10โˆ’16

๐‘† = ๐‘‘4๐‘ฅ ๐‘‘๐‘ฆ โˆ’๐บ1

2๐บ๐‘€๐‘๐œ•๐‘€ฮฆ๐œ•๐‘ฮฆโˆ’

1

2๐‘€ฮฆ2ฮฆ2 + ๐›ฟ ๐‘ฆ โˆ’ ๐ฟ ๐บ๐‘€๐‘๐œ•๐‘€โ„Ž

โ€ ๐œ•๐‘โ„Ž โˆ’ ๐‘‰ โ„Ž +1

2๐‘”52ฮฆ2โ„Ž2

[L. Randall, R. Sundrum 1999]

๐‘‘๐‘ 2 = ๐‘’โˆ’2๐‘˜ ๐‘ฆ ๐‘”๐œ‡ฮฝ๐‘‘๐‘ฅ๐œ‡๐‘‘๐‘ฅฮฝ + ๐‘‘๐‘ฆ2Metric:

Page 10: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

30/03/2016 Scalar field dark matter and the Higgs field 9

Warped extra-dimension model

โ€ข Decompose ฮฆ in Kaluza-Klein modes: ฮฆ ๐‘ฅ๐œ‡ , ๐‘ฆ =1

2๐ฟ ๐‘›=0โˆž ฯ•๐‘› ๐‘ฅ

๐œ‡ ๐‘“๐‘› ๐‘ฆ ;

โ€ข ฮฆ0 ๐‘ฅ๐œ‡ , ๐ฟ =

1

2๐ฟฯ•0 ๐‘ฅ

๐œ‡ 2๐‘˜๐ฟ

๐‘”4 ~ ๐‘”52๐‘˜๐‘’โˆ’2๐‘˜๐ฟ โ‰ƒ ๐’ช 1 ร—

๐‘ฃ

๐‘€๐‘ƒ~10โˆ’16

๐“›๐‘–๐‘›๐‘ก =1

2๐‘”52๐‘˜๐‘’โˆ’2๐‘˜๐ฟฯ•0

2โ„Ž2

๐‘šฯ• ~๐‘ฃ2

๐‘€๐‘ƒ~ 10โˆ’5 eV

Mass in the required range;In agreement with non-renormalizableinteractions model.

Planck-suppressed non-renormalizable operator

Renormalizable interaction in a higher-dimensional warped geometry.

Page 11: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

โ€ข DM candidate: oscillating scalar field ฯ†, which acquires mass through the Higgs

mechanism.

โ€ข Lower bound: ๐‘šฯ• โ‰ณ 10โˆ’6 โˆ’ 10โˆ’5 ๐‘’๐‘‰ ;

โ€ข ๐‘šฯ•~๐‘ฃ2

๐‘€๐‘ƒ~10โˆ’5 ๐‘’๐‘‰ obtained through either non-renormalizable interactions

between ฯ† and the Higgs field or through a warped extra-dimension model.

30/03/2016 Scalar field dark matter and the Higgs field 10

Conclusions

Thank you for your attention!

Page 12: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

IBERICOS2016

11th Iberian Cosmology Meeting

SOCโ€‚ANA ACHรšCARRO (LEIDEN/BILBAO), FERNANDO ATRIO-BARANDELA (SALAMANCA), MAR BASTERO-GIL (GRANADA), JUAN GARCIA-

-BELLIDO (MADRID), RUTH LAZKOZ (BILBAO), CARLOS MARTINS (PORTO), JOSร‰ PEDRO MIMOSO (LISBON), DAVID MOTA (OSLO)

LOCโ€‚ANA CATARINA LEITE, CARLOS MARTINS (CHAIR), FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PEIXOTO (SYSADMIN), ANA MARTA PINHO, IVAN RYBAK, ELSA SILVA (ADMIN)

VILA DO CONDE, PORTUGAL, 29-31 MARCH, 2016

SERIES OF MEETINGS WHICH AIM TO ENCOURAGE INTERACTIONS AND COLLABORATIONS BETWEEN RESEARCHERS WORKING IN COSMOLOGY AND RELATED AREAS IN PORTUGAL AND SPAIN.

www.iastro.pt/ibericos2016

Page 13: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Scalar field inflation in the presence of anon-minimal matter-curvature coupling

Clรกudio Gomesโ€ Universidade do Porto and Centro de Fรญsica do Porto

IberiCos 2016, Vila do Conde, 30 March 2016

โ€ In collaboration with Orfeu Bertolami and Joรฃo RosaFundaรงรฃo para a Ciรชncia e a Tecnologia, SFRH/BD/102820/2014

1/11

Page 14: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Contents

1. Inflation

2. Alternative theories of gravityThe non-minimal coupling between matter and curvature (NMC)

3. Scalar field inflation with a matter-curvature NMC

2/11

Page 15: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Why Inflation?

Hot Big Bang model: Evolutionary Universe; CMB; BBN...

Leaves some conundrums: Large scale homogeneity and isotropy (horizon problem); Flatness problem; Absence of observed topological defects (monopole problem); Origin of the energy density fluctuations,...

Cosmic Inflation (paradigm, not theory) provides a suitable solution forthe above problems by a mechanism of accelerated expansion of theUniverse at early times (between Planck and GUT epochs).

1. Inflation 3/11

Page 16: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Scalar field inflation

Real scalar field with:ฯ•+ 3Hฯ•+ V โ€ฒ(ฯ•) = 0 (1)

Inflation occurs in the so-called slow-roll approximation:

V โ‰ซ ฯ•2/2 =โ‡’ ฯ โ‰ˆ V (ฯ•) (2)

V โ‰ˆ const. (3)This is the same as stating that the slow-roll parameters are:

ฯตฯ• =M2

P

2

(V โ€ฒ

V

)2

โ‰ช 1 (4)

ฮทฯ• = M2P

V โ€ฒโ€ฒ

Vโ‰ช 1 (5)

1. Inflation 4/11

Page 17: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Why to go beyond GR?

Successes: Solar System constraints; GPS;

But there were still some conundrums: Not compatible with quantum mechanics; Existence of singularities; Cosmological constant problem; Large scale data requires DM and DE; Astrophysical data requires DM.

Alternative theories of gravity: f(R) Horndeski gravity; Jordan-Brans-Dicke; NMC [Bertolami, Bรถhmer, Harko, Lobo 2007]...

2. Alternative theories of gravity 5/11

Page 18: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Alternative theories of gravity: the NMC

Generalisation of f(R) theories[Bertolami, Bohmer, Harko, Lobo, 2007]:

S =

โˆซ[ฮบf1 (R) + f2 (R)L]

โˆšโˆ’gd4x , (6)

where ฮบ = M2P /2 = 1/16ฯ€G.

Varying the action relatively to the metric gยตฮฝ :

2 (ฮบF1 โˆ’ F2ฯ)

(Rยตฮฝ โˆ’ 1

2gยตฮฝR

)=f2Tยตฮฝ + ฮบ (f1 โˆ’ F1R) gยตฮฝ+

+ F2ฯRgยตฮฝ + 2โˆ†ยตฮฝ (ฮบF1 โˆ’ F2ฯ)

(7)

One recovers GR by setting f1(R) = R and f2(R) = 1.

2. Alternative theories of gravity 6/11

Page 19: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Using the Bianchi identities, one finds the non-covariant conservationof the energy-momentum tensor:

โˆ‡ยตTยตฮฝ =

F2

f2(gยตฮฝL โˆ’ Tยตฮฝ)โˆ‡ยตR (8)

For a perfect fluid, the extra force due to the NMC can be expressedas:

fยต =1

ฯ+ p

[F2

1 + f2(Lm โˆ’ p)โˆ‡ฮฝR+โˆ‡ฮฝp

]hยตฮฝ , (9)

with hยตฮฝ = gยตฮฝ + uยตuฮฝ being the projection operator.

2. Alternative theories of gravity 7/11

Page 20: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Degeneracy-lifting of the Lagrangian choice [O. Bertolami, F. S. N.Lobo, J. Pรกramos, 2008]

Mimicking Dark Matter (galaxies, clusters) [O. Bertolami, J. Pรกramos,2010; O. Bertolami, P. Frazรฃo, J. Pรกramos, 2013]

Cosmological Perturbations [O. Bertolami, P. Frazรฃo, J. Pรกramos,2013]

Preheating scenario after inflation [O. Bertolami, P. Frazรฃo, J.Pรกramos, 2011]

Modified Friedmann equation [O. Bertolami, J. Pรกramos, 2013]

Modified Layzer-Irvine equation and virial theorem [O. Bertolami, C.Gomes, 2014]...

2. Alternative theories of gravity 8/11

Page 21: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Scalar field inflation in the presence of a non-minimalmatter-curvature curvature

At first approximation:

ฯ•+ 3Hฯ•+ V โ€ฒ(ฯ•) โ‰ˆ 0 (10)

In the slow-roll regime, and for f1(R) = R, we have a modifiedFriedmann equation:

H2 โ‰ˆ f2

1 + 2F2ฯM2

P

ฯ

3M2P

(11)

3. Scalar field inflation with a matter-curvature NMC 9/11

Page 22: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Choosing the non-minimal coupling function to be:

f2(R) = 1 +

(R

Rn

)n

(12)

we find that for the large density limit: n = 2 we retrieve the Friedmann equation as in GR n โ‰ฅ 3 the modified Friedmann equation becomes (An, Bn โˆˆ R)

H2 = An โˆ’ Bn

ฯ(13)

whilst in the low density regime, this model gives a smallcorrection to the Friedmannโ€™s equation.

We further note that modifications of the Friedmann equation havebeen well studied in the literature: brane models, loop quantumcosmology, ...

3. Scalar field inflation with a matter-curvature NMC 10/11

Page 23: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Thank you for your attention!

Rob Gonรงalves

3. Scalar field inflation with a matter-curvature NMC 11/11

Page 24: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

IBERICOS2016

11th Iberian Cosmology Meeting

SOCโ€‚ANA ACHรšCARRO (LEIDEN/BILBAO), FERNANDO ATRIO-BARANDELA (SALAMANCA), MAR BASTERO-GIL (GRANADA), JUAN GARCIA-

-BELLIDO (MADRID), RUTH LAZKOZ (BILBAO), CARLOS MARTINS (PORTO), JOSร‰ PEDRO MIMOSO (LISBON), DAVID MOTA (OSLO)

LOCโ€‚ANA CATARINA LEITE, CARLOS MARTINS (CHAIR), FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PEIXOTO (SYSADMIN), ANA MARTA PINHO, IVAN RYBAK, ELSA SILVA (ADMIN)

VILA DO CONDE, PORTUGAL, 29-31 MARCH, 2016

SERIES OF MEETINGS WHICH AIM TO ENCOURAGE INTERACTIONS AND COLLABORATIONS BETWEEN RESEARCHERS WORKING IN COSMOLOGY AND RELATED AREAS IN PORTUGAL AND SPAIN.

www.iastro.pt/ibericos2016

Page 25: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

The variation of the fine-structure constant from disformalcouplings

Nelson NunesInstituto de Astrofฤฑsica e Ciencias do Espaco

in collaboration with: Jurgen Misfud and Carsten van de Bruck,arXiv:1510.00200

EXPL/FIS-AST/1608/2013UID/FIS/04434/2013

Page 26: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Disformal couplings

Let us consider the action

S = Sgrav (gยตฮฝ , ฯ†) + Smatter(g(m)ยตฮฝ ) + SEM(Aยต, g

(r)ยตฮฝ )

The metrics g(m)ยตฮฝ and g

(r)ยตฮฝ are related to gยตฮฝ via a disformal transformation:

g(m)ยตฮฝ = Cm(ฯ†)gยตฮฝ +Dm(ฯ†)ฯ†,ยตฯ†,ฮฝ

g(r)ยตฮฝ = Cr(ฯ†)gยตฮฝ +Dr(ฯ†)ฯ†,ยตฯ†,ฮฝ .

Cr and Cm are conformal factorsDr and Dm are disformal factorsWe can also write,

g(r)ยตฮฝ =CrCm

g(m)ยตฮฝ +

(Dr โˆ’

CrDm

Cm

)ฯ†,ยตฯ†,ฮฝ โ‰ก Ag(m)

ยตฮฝ +Bฯ†,ยตฯ†,ฮฝ

Page 27: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Electromagnetic sector

The action

SEM = โˆ’1

4

โˆซd4x

โˆšโˆ’g(r)h(ฯ†)gยตฮฝ(r)g

ฮฑฮฒ(r)FยตฮฑFฮฝฮฒ โˆ’

โˆซd4x

โˆšโˆ’g(m)gยตฮฝ(m)jยตAยต

- Fยตฮฝ is Faraday tensor; jยต is the fourโ€“current;- h(ฯ†) is the coupling between the electromagnetism and ฯ†.

In the frame in which matter is decoupled from the scalar field

SEM = โˆ’1

4

โˆซd4x

โˆšโˆ’g(m)hZ

[gยตฮฝ(m)g

ฮฑฮฒ(m) โˆ’ 2ฮณ2gยตฮฝ(m)ฯ†

,ฮฑฯ†,ฮฒ]FยตฮฑFฮฝฮฒ

โˆ’โˆซd4x

โˆšโˆ’g(m)gยตฮฝ(m)jยตAยต

where

Z =(

1 + BA g

ยตฮฝ(m)โˆ‚ยตฯ†โˆ‚ฮฝฯ†

)1/2, ฮณ2 = B

A+Bgยตฮฝ(m)

โˆ‚ยตฯ†โˆ‚ฮฝฯ†

Page 28: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

The field equation for Aยต

Varying the action with respect to Aยต

โˆ‡ฮต (hZF ฮตฯ)โˆ’ โˆ‡ฮต(hZฮณ2ฯ†,ฮฒ

(gฮตฮฝ(m)ฯ†

,ฯ โˆ’ gฯฮฝ(m)ฯ†,ฮต)Fฮฝฮฒ

)= jฯ

With g(m)ยตฮฝ = ฮทยตฮฝ , and Ei = F i0

โˆ‡ ยทE =Zฯ

h

where ฯ = j0. Integrating this equation over a volume V using, E = โˆ’โˆ‡V , we get theelectrostatic potential

V (r) =ZQ

4ฯ€hrโ‡’ ฮฑ โˆ Z

h

The fine structure constant depends on Z.

Page 29: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

The evolution of ฮฑ

For FLRW Universe,

Z =

(1โˆ’ Dr

Crฯ†2

1โˆ’ DmCm

ฯ†2

)1/2

Time derivative of ฮฑ,ฮฑ

ฮฑ=

1

Z

(โˆ‚Z

โˆ‚ฯ†ฯ†+

โˆ‚Z

โˆ‚ฯ†ฯ†

)โˆ’ 1

h

dh

dฯ†ฯ†

Redshift evolution of ฮฑ,

โˆ†ฮฑ

ฮฑ(z) โ‰ก ฮฑ(z)โˆ’ ฮฑ0

ฮฑ0=h0Z

hZ0โˆ’ 1

Page 30: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Constrains on the evolution of ฮฑ

1 Atomic Clocks at z = 0,

ฮฑ

ฮฑ

โˆฃโˆฃโˆฃโˆฃ0

= (โˆ’1.6ยฑ 2.3)ร— 10โˆ’17 yrโˆ’1

2 Oklo at z โ‰ˆ 0.16,|โˆ†ฮฑ|ฮฑ

< 1.1ร— 10โˆ’8

3 187Re meteorite at z โ‰ˆ 0.43,

โˆ†ฮฑ

ฮฑ= (โˆ’8ยฑ 8)ร— 10โˆ’7

4 CMB at z ' 103โˆ†ฮฑ

ฮฑ= (3.6ยฑ 3.7)ร— 10โˆ’3

Page 31: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Astrophysical constrains on the evolution of ฮฑ

1 Keck/ HIRES141 absorbers (MM method) [M.T. Murphy et al. 2004]

2 VLT/ UVES154 absorbers (MM method) [J.A. King et al. 2012]

3 Keck/ HIRES Si IV absorption systems (AD method) [M.T. Murphy et al. 2001]

4 Comparison of HI 21 cm line with molecular rotational absorption spectra [M.T.Murphy et al. 2001]

5 11 UVES absorbers [P. Molaro et al. 2013, T.M. Evans et al. 2014]

Page 32: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Gravity and matter field sector

Is the evolution of ฯ† compatible with constraints on the evolution of ฮฑ?

S =

โˆซd4xโˆšโˆ’g(

1

2Rโˆ’ 1

2gยตฮฝโˆ‚ยตฯ†โˆ‚ฮฝฯ†โˆ’ V (ฯ†)

)+ Smatter(g

(m)ยตฮฝ )

with the equation of motion

ฯ†+ 3Hฯ†+ V โ€ฒ = Qm +Qr,

ฯm + 3H(ฯm + pm) = โˆ’Qmฯ†,ฯr + 3H(ฯr + pr) = โˆ’Qrฯ†,

where Qm and Qr are complicated functions of ฯm, ฯr, ฯ†, Cr, Cm, Dr, Dm and theirfield derivatives.

Page 33: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Couplings and parameters

We specify to exponential couplings and potential and to linear direct coupling h(ฯ†):

Ci(ฯ†) = ฮฒiexiฯ†, Di(ฯ†) = Mโˆ’4i eyiฯ†,

h(ฯ†) = 1โˆ’ ฮถ(ฯ†โˆ’ ฯ†0), V (ฯ†) = M4V eโˆ’ฮปฯ†.

Parameters xi, yi, ฮป, ฮฒi, Mi, MV and ฮถ are tuned such that their are in agreementwith constraints on ฮฑ and on the cosmological parameters from Planck.

Parameter Estimated valuew0,ฯ† โˆ’1.006ยฑ 0.045

H0 (67.8ยฑ 0.9) km sโˆ’1Mpcโˆ’1

ฮฉ0,m 0.308ยฑ 0.012

Page 34: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Disformal and electromagnetic couplings

Mr Mm MV ฮฒm xm |ฮถ| ฮปโˆผ 1 meV โˆผ 1 meV 2.69 meV 1 0 < 5ร— 10โˆ’6 0.45

Page 35: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Disformal and conformal couplings

Mr Mm MV ฮฒm xm |ฮถ| ฮป25-27 meV 15 meV 2.55 meV 8 0.14 0 0.45

Page 36: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Summary

1 A variation in the fine-structure constant can be induced by disformal couplingsprovided that the radiation and matter disformal coupling strengths are notidentical.

2 Such a variation is enhanced in the presence of the usual electromagnetic coupling.

3 Laboratory measurements with molecular and nuclear clocks are expected toincrease their sensitivity to as high as 10โˆ’21 yrโˆ’1.

4 Better constrained data is expected from high-resolution ultra-stablespectrographs such as PEPSI at the LBT, ESPRESSO at the VLT and ELT-Hiresat the E-ELT.

Page 37: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

IBERICOS2016

11th Iberian Cosmology Meeting

SOCโ€‚ANA ACHรšCARRO (LEIDEN/BILBAO), FERNANDO ATRIO-BARANDELA (SALAMANCA), MAR BASTERO-GIL (GRANADA), JUAN GARCIA-

-BELLIDO (MADRID), RUTH LAZKOZ (BILBAO), CARLOS MARTINS (PORTO), JOSร‰ PEDRO MIMOSO (LISBON), DAVID MOTA (OSLO)

LOCโ€‚ANA CATARINA LEITE, CARLOS MARTINS (CHAIR), FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PEIXOTO (SYSADMIN), ANA MARTA PINHO, IVAN RYBAK, ELSA SILVA (ADMIN)

VILA DO CONDE, PORTUGAL, 29-31 MARCH, 2016

SERIES OF MEETINGS WHICH AIM TO ENCOURAGE INTERACTIONS AND COLLABORATIONS BETWEEN RESEARCHERS WORKING IN COSMOLOGY AND RELATED AREAS IN PORTUGAL AND SPAIN.

www.iastro.pt/ibericos2016

Page 38: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

COSMIC MICROWAVE

BACKGROUND ANISOTROPIES

GENERATED BY DOMAIN

WALL NETWORKS

Lara SousaInstituto de Astrofรญsica e Ciรชncias do Espaรงo

arXiv:1507.01064

Page 39: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

DOMAIN WALLS

DOMAIN WALLS ARE FORMED WHEN DISCRETE SYMMETRIES ARE SPONTANEOUSLY BROKEN IN

PHASE TRANSITIONS.

V (ฯ•)

ฯ•โˆ’ยฟฯ•+ ยฟ

DOMAIN WALLS!

Page 40: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

DOMAIN WALL CMB Q&A

WHY?- FOR EXISTING!- REPULSIVE GRAVITY

HOW? ACTIVE GENERATION OF PERTURBATIONS.

WHERE? - SUBDOMINANT CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE TEMPERATURE AND E-MODES - POSSIBLY SIGNIFICANT B-MODE CONTRIBUTION

WHAT DOES IS MEAN? SIGNIFICANT VECTOR

CONTRIBUTIONS

Page 41: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

CMBACT CODE

ENERGY-MOMENTUM TENSOR IS CALCULATED USING THE UNCONNECTED SEGMENT MODEL:

- SET OF UNCORRELATED STRAIGHT STRING SEGMENTS;- RANDOMLY DISTRIBUTED AND MOVING IN RANDOM DIRECTIONS;- A FRACTION OF SEGMENTS DECAY IN EACH EPOCH (ENERGY LOSS DUE TO INTERACTIONS);- LENGTH AND VELOCITY OF THE SEGMENTS ARE DEFINED USING THE VOS MODEL;

PHENOMENOLOGICAL APPROACH:

Page 42: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

CMBACT CODE

ENERGY-MOMENTUM TENSOR IS CALCULATED USING THE UNCONNECTED SECTION MODEL:

- SET OF UNCORRELATED FLAT AND SQUARE DOMAIN WALL SECTIONS;- RANDOMLY DISTRIBUTED AND MOVING IN RANDOM DIRECTIONS;- A FRACTION OF SECTIONS DECAY IN EACH EPOCH (ENERGY LOSS DUE TO INTERACTIONS);- AREA AND VELOCITY OF THE SECTIONS ARE DEFINED USING THE VOS MODEL;

PHENOMENOLOGICAL APPROACH:

Page 43: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

ENERGY-MOMENTUM TENSOR

T ฮผ ฮฝโˆšโˆ’g=ฯƒโˆซ d 3ฮพฮด

4[ xฮผ

โˆ’xฮผ(ฮพ

a)]โˆšโˆ’hhab x , a

ฮผ x , bฮฝ

ยฟ

S=โˆ’ฯƒโˆซ d3ฮพโˆšโˆ’hNAMBU-GOTO ACTION:

WE NEED TO COMPUTE THE ENERGY-MOMENTUM TENSOR FOR EACH OF THESE SECTIONS.

xฮผ=xฮผ(ฮพa) , a=0,1 ,2WITH

WORLD-VOLUME

Page 44: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

ENERGY-MOMENTUM TENSOR

ฮธ00=4ฯƒ ฮณ โˆš2cos(kโ‹…x+vk ฯ„)sin (kl x3

' (1)/2)sin (kl x3

' (2)/2)

k 2 x3' (1) x3

' (2)

x=x0+ฮพ1 x' (1)

+ฮพ2 x' (2)

+v ฯ„ x

ฮธij=ฮธ00 [v2 ห™x i ห™x jโˆ’(1โˆ’v2

) x i' (1) x j

' (1)+ x i

' (2) x j' (1)

]

FORTUNATELY, IN THIS CASE

ANALYTICAL SOLUTIONS:

Page 45: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

ENERGY-MOMENTUM TENSOR

2ฮธS=ฮธ00[v2(3 ห™x3

ห™x3โˆ’1)โˆ’(1โˆ’v2)(3 x3

' (1) x3' (1)

+3 x3' (2) x3

' (2)โˆ’2)]

THE REST FOLLOWS FROM E-M CONSERVATION...

ฮธV=ฮธ00[v2 ห™x1

ห™x3โˆ’(1โˆ’v2)( x1

' (1) x3' (1)

+ x1' (2) x3

' (2))]

ฮธT=ฮธ00[v2 ห™x1

ห™x2โˆ’(1โˆ’v2)( x1

' (1) x2' (1)

+ x1' (2) x2

' (2))]

WE NOW HAVE 3 OF THE E-M COMPONENTS REQUIRED BY CMBFAST:

Page 46: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

THE RESULTS: CDM POWER SPECTRUM

DOMAIN WALLS CONTRIBUTE MOSTLY ON LARGE SCALES...

Page 47: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

THE RESULTS: CMB SPECTRA

Gฮผ=G ฯƒ L0=10โˆ’7

Page 48: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

THE RESULTS: CONSTRAINTS

FRACTIONAL CONTRIBUTION TO THE TT-

POWER SPECTRUM

ENERGY SCALE OF THE DOMAIN-WALL-FORMING

PHASE TRANSITIONฮท<0,92MeV

f dw<0,2

THERE IS STILL OBSERVATIONAL ROOM FOR DOMAIN WALLS:

Page 49: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

THE RESULTS: CONSTRAINTS

โ€ฆ AND THEY MAY PRODUCE SIGNIFICANT B-MODES!

Page 50: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

IBERICOS2016

11th Iberian Cosmology Meeting

SOCโ€‚ANA ACHรšCARRO (LEIDEN/BILBAO), FERNANDO ATRIO-BARANDELA (SALAMANCA), MAR BASTERO-GIL (GRANADA), JUAN GARCIA-

-BELLIDO (MADRID), RUTH LAZKOZ (BILBAO), CARLOS MARTINS (PORTO), JOSร‰ PEDRO MIMOSO (LISBON), DAVID MOTA (OSLO)

LOCโ€‚ANA CATARINA LEITE, CARLOS MARTINS (CHAIR), FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PEIXOTO (SYSADMIN), ANA MARTA PINHO, IVAN RYBAK, ELSA SILVA (ADMIN)

VILA DO CONDE, PORTUGAL, 29-31 MARCH, 2016

SERIES OF MEETINGS WHICH AIM TO ENCOURAGE INTERACTIONS AND COLLABORATIONS BETWEEN RESEARCHERS WORKING IN COSMOLOGY AND RELATED AREAS IN PORTUGAL AND SPAIN.

www.iastro.pt/ibericos2016

Page 51: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Evolution of Semilocal String Networks:

Asier Lopez-Eiguren (UPV/EHU)

Segment Evolution

Vila do Conde, 30/03/16

In collaboration with: A. Achรบcarro, A. Avgoustidis, C.J.A.P. Martins, A.S. Nunes, J. Urrestilla

Page 52: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Evolution of String Networks

Numerical Simulations Analytic Models

โ€ข Evolve true eom

โ€ข High computational cost

โ€ข Limited dynamical range

โ€ข Approximate models

โ€ข Simples

โ€ข More tractables

โ€ข Need input from Num. Sim.

TWO methods to analyse the evolution:

OBJECTIVE: CALIBRATE analytic models for SL

Page 53: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Semilocal Strings (A. Achucarro & Vachaspati 1999)

โ€ข Extension of Abelian-Higgs (AH): U(1)l SU(2)g x U(1)l

โ€ข They are not topological

โ€ข They can have ends

โ€ข This ends are effectively global monopoles

Abelian-HiggsSemilocal

Page 54: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Semilocal Strings (A. Achucarro & Vachaspati 1999)

โ€ข The stability of the strings depends on the parameter ฮฒ =mscalar2/mgauge2:

โ€ข ฮฒ > 1 Unstable

โ€ข ฮฒ = 1 Neutrally stable

โ€ข ฮฒ < 1 Stable

โ€ข For lower ฮฒ they behave more like AH

S =

Z

d

4x

nh

@ยต iAยต

i2

1

4F

2

4(+

2)2o

Page 55: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Velocity-one-scale Model

โ€ข Two variables:

(Martins & Shellard 1996,2002)

dv

dt= (1 v2)

k

L v

ld

(4 n)dL

dt= (4 n)HL+ v2

L

ld+ cv

L4n =M

M n

1

ld= nH +

1

lf

rms Velocity

Typical Length ScaleInterdefect distance

Damping scale

particle friction

n= dim. of defect

Page 56: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Semilocal VOS Models

โ€ข Compare simulations with analytic models

โ€ข Obtain the best values for the parameters

Model A Model B

Hybrid Networks: strings + monopoles

Page 57: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Field Theory Simulationsโ€ข 10243 lattices in radiation and matter eras in expanding universe

โ€ข Magnetic energy to detect strings

arXiv:1312.2123/PhysRevD.89.063503: Large Scale properties were analysed

Page 58: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

t=150

t=300

t=450

Field Theory Simulations

Page 59: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Segment Distribution

Model A

Model B

Simulations

Initial ls seed from simulations Phenomenological vs distribution

Evolve VOS models

Page 60: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Segment Distribution

โ€ข We perform ฯ‡2 analysis to determine the best values for the parameters

Page 61: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Summary

โ€ข TWO VOS models for Semilocal string networks

โ€ข We perform X2 analysis:

โ€ข Determine the best values of the parameters

โ€ข Conclude which model describes better the network

Page 62: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Future Workโ€ข Improve parameter analysis:

โ€ข Obtaining vs distribution from simulations

โ€ข Obtain segment end (monopole) velocities

Page 63: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

IBERICOS2016

11th Iberian Cosmology Meeting

SOCโ€‚ANA ACHรšCARRO (LEIDEN/BILBAO), FERNANDO ATRIO-BARANDELA (SALAMANCA), MAR BASTERO-GIL (GRANADA), JUAN GARCIA-

-BELLIDO (MADRID), RUTH LAZKOZ (BILBAO), CARLOS MARTINS (PORTO), JOSร‰ PEDRO MIMOSO (LISBON), DAVID MOTA (OSLO)

LOCโ€‚ANA CATARINA LEITE, CARLOS MARTINS (CHAIR), FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PEIXOTO (SYSADMIN), ANA MARTA PINHO, IVAN RYBAK, ELSA SILVA (ADMIN)

VILA DO CONDE, PORTUGAL, 29-31 MARCH, 2016

SERIES OF MEETINGS WHICH AIM TO ENCOURAGE INTERACTIONS AND COLLABORATIONS BETWEEN RESEARCHERS WORKING IN COSMOLOGY AND RELATED AREAS IN PORTUGAL AND SPAIN.

www.iastro.pt/ibericos2016

Page 64: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale modelfor domain walls.

I.Yu. Rybak,

CAUP, IA

in collaboration with

C.J.A.P. Martins,

A. Avgoustidis,

E.P.S. Shellard

Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)

Vila do Conde, IberiCos 2016I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 65: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

V0

-0

0

ฮพฮพ

Introduction

Kibble mechanism

[Kibble,J.Phys.A9(1976),1387-1398ICTP/75/5]

L = 12 (โˆ‚ฯ•)

2 โˆ’ V (ฯ•)

V (ฯ•) = V0

(1โˆ’ ฯ•2

ฯ•20

)2

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 66: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

-0

0

V0

ฮพ ฮพ

Introduction

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 67: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Walls-0

0

V0

Introduction

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 68: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

ฮป 1/10

1/5

1/4

1/3

2/5

1/2

3/5

2/3

3/4

4/5

9/10

19/20

ฯ„

ฯ„

ฯ ฯ„

(ฮณ ฯ…

)2

ฮป 19/20

9/10

4/5

3/4

2/3

3/5

1/2

2/5

1/3

1/4

1/5

1/10

Field theory simulation (40963 boxes)

Scalar eld model:

[Press,Ryden,Spergel, Astrophys.J.347,590(1989)]

โˆ‚2ฯ†โˆ‚ฯ„2

+ 3 d ln ad ln ฯ„

โˆ‚ฯ†โˆ‚ฯ„ โˆ’

โˆ‚2ฯ†โˆ‚x iโˆ‚xi

= โˆ’โˆ‚Vโˆ‚ฯ† ,

Measured values (asymptotic):

โ€ข (ฮณฯ…)2 (ฯ… - velocity).

โ€ข ฮพc/ฯ„ (ฮพc - correlation length โˆผ 1ฯ)

(for a โˆผ tฮป)

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 69: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Velocity-depend one scale (VOS) model

Dirac-Nambu-Goto action: S = โˆ’ฯƒwโˆซ โˆš

Gd2ฯƒdฯ„ ,[Sousa,Avelino,Phys.Rev.D,84,063502(2011)]

(averaged) โ‡“ โˆซ ...d2ฯƒ

dLdt

=(1+ 3ฯ…2

)HL+ cwฯ…,

dฯ…dt

=(1โˆ’ ฯ…2

) (kwLโˆ’ 3Hฯ…

),

Scaling solution is: L = ฮตt, ฯ… (ฮต, ฯ… - constants).

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 70: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Momentum parameter for VOS model

From the microscopic description

kw (ฯ…) = k01โˆ’(qฯ…2)

ฮฒ

1+(qฯ…2)ฮฒ

Physical restrictions:

โ€ข 0 โ‰ค k0 โ‰ค 2

โ€ข 0 < 1qโ‰ค ฯ…2w = 2

3

k0 = 1.73ยฑ 0.01,

q = 4.27ยฑ 0.10 (< ฯ… >โ‰ˆ 0.48),

ฮฒ = 1.69ยฑ 0.08.

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 71: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Energy loss for VOS model

Energy loss mechanisms:

โ€ข creation of closed objects โ€ข scalar radiation (โˆผ curvaturer )

cwฯ… d [k0 โˆ’ k(ฯ…)]r

r = 1.30ยฑ 0.02, d = 0.28ยฑ 0.01, cw = 0.00ยฑ 0.01.

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 72: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Extended VOS model

The whole model with found parameters

dLdt

=(1+ 3ฯ…2

)HL+ cwฯ… + d (k0 โˆ’ k(ฯ…))r ,

dฯ…dt

=(1โˆ’ ฯ…2

) (k(ฯ…)Lโˆ’ 3Hฯ…

),

k(ฯ…) = k01โˆ’(qฯ…2)

ฮฒ

1+(qฯ…2)ฮฒ

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 73: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Radiation-matter transition

Scale factor

a(ฯ„)aeq

=(ฯ„ฯ„โˆ—

)2+ 2

(ฯ„ฯ„โˆ—

),

where ฯ„โˆ— = ฯ„eq/(โˆš2โˆ’ 1).

Simulations with dierent aeq, ฯ„eq to span the entire transition

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 74: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Results

The largest currently available eld-theory simulations;

Adjustment of the VOS model;

Direct comparison of energy loss mechanisms;

Description of the radiation-matter transition by the extended VOS model;

Interesting avenues for further study

To extend this analysis to the case of cosmic strings for better understanding the

dierences between Goto-Nambu and eld theory simulations;

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 75: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

Thank you for your attention!

SFRH/BD/52699/2014

I.Yu. Rybak, CAUP, IA in collaboration with C.J.A.P. Martins, A. Avgoustidis, E.P.S. Shellard Phys.Rev.D93(2016)no.4,043534, (arxiv[hep-ph] 1602.01322)Extending the velocity-dependent one-scale model for domain walls.

Page 76: LOC FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PORTUGAL, (ADMIN) 29 โ€ฆย ยท Hidden sector Visible sector Heavy messengers, Gravity broken by non-renormalizable operators ๐“›๐‘– ๐‘ก= ๐‘Ž6 2 2 โ„Ž4

IBERICOS2016

11th Iberian Cosmology Meeting

SOCโ€‚ANA ACHรšCARRO (LEIDEN/BILBAO), FERNANDO ATRIO-BARANDELA (SALAMANCA), MAR BASTERO-GIL (GRANADA), JUAN GARCIA-

-BELLIDO (MADRID), RUTH LAZKOZ (BILBAO), CARLOS MARTINS (PORTO), JOSร‰ PEDRO MIMOSO (LISBON), DAVID MOTA (OSLO)

LOCโ€‚ANA CATARINA LEITE, CARLOS MARTINS (CHAIR), FERNANDO MOUCHEREK, PAULO PEIXOTO (SYSADMIN), ANA MARTA PINHO, IVAN RYBAK, ELSA SILVA (ADMIN)

VILA DO CONDE, PORTUGAL, 29-31 MARCH, 2016

SERIES OF MEETINGS WHICH AIM TO ENCOURAGE INTERACTIONS AND COLLABORATIONS BETWEEN RESEARCHERS WORKING IN COSMOLOGY AND RELATED AREAS IN PORTUGAL AND SPAIN.

www.iastro.pt/ibericos2016