17
Liyi Gu (Univ. of Tokyo; SJTU) Naohisa Inada (Nara Na;onal College of Tech.) Tadayuki Kodama (NAOJ) Saori Konami (Tokyo Univ. of Science/Riken) Kazuhiro Nakazawa (Univ. of Tokyo) Madoka Kawaharada (ISAS) Poshak Gandhi (ISAS) Kazuhiro Shimasaku (Univ. of Tokyo) Kazuo Makishima (Univ. of Tokyo) XMMNewton Workshop on Galaxy Clusters, Madrid, 2012/5/23

LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

Liyi  Gu  (Univ.  of  Tokyo;  SJTU)  Naohisa  Inada  (Nara  Na;onal  College  of  Tech.)  Tadayuki  Kodama  (NAOJ)  Saori  Konami  (Tokyo  Univ.  of  Science/Riken)  Kazuhiro  Nakazawa  (Univ.  of  Tokyo)  Madoka  Kawaharada  (ISAS)  Poshak  Gandhi  (ISAS)  Kazuhiro  Shimasaku  (Univ.  of  Tokyo)  Kazuo  Makishima  (Univ.  of  Tokyo)  

                                               XMM-­‐Newton  Workshop  on  Galaxy  Clusters,  Madrid,  2012/5/23  

Page 2: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

Ø  Ram  pressure,  cold  front,  shock,  turbulence,  MHD  effects,  dynamical  fric;on…  

Ø  Free  energy  transfered  from  galaxy  to  ICM  Ø  Galaxy  more  and  more  concentrated  than  the  ICM  

M86  Randall+08  

A3627  Sun+09  

NGC  6338    

Page 3: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

More  individual  case  study?  Galaxy  environmental  effect?  ICM  hea;ng/turbulence  probe?  Metal  mass-­‐to-­‐light  ra;o?    Why  not  do  more  directly  

                                   108                                                                                    109                                                          1010                    yrs  

Time  to  consume  total  galaxy  energy  

one  cross  ;me  ICM  conduc;on  ;me  ISM  strip  &  morphology  change  

cluster  age  

Long-­‐term  process

On-­‐going  process Quick  

smearing

Galaxy  light  distribu0on  vs.  ICM  distribu0on  for  different-­‐z  

Page 4: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

We  study  a  sample  of    clusters,  with  redshie  range  of   .  The  sample  is  selected  via  Ø  Similar  average  ICM  temperature  

(5±2  keV)  Ø  Relaxed  X-­‐ray  morphology  Ø  Apparent  central  dominate  galaxy  Ø  Offset  between  X-­‐ray/op;cal  peak  

<  0.02  R500    Datasets  Ø  UH88  I-­‐band  image  (PI:  Dr.  Inada)  Ø  XMM-­‐Newton  for  z<0.5  Ø  Chandra  (if  available)  for  z>0.5    

Page 5: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

Normalized  to  innermost  

Normalized  to  innermost  

filtering  

Background  subtrac;on  

Mul;-­‐band  

Field  observa;on  

Projec;on  along      line-­‐of-­‐sight  

Deprojected  spectral  analysis  

Chandra/XMM  data  

3-­‐D  density  profiles  

2-­‐D  mass  profiles  

UH88  photo-­‐  metric  data    

Cosmic  background  

B-­‐R  (B-­‐I,  R-­‐I)  color-­‐magnitude  

diagram  

2-­‐D  integrated  light  profiles  

Galaxy  light  vs  ICM  mass  profiles  

Page 6: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM
Page 7: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

Normalized  to  innermost  

Normalized  to  innermost  

filtering  

Background  subtrac;on  

Two-­‐band  

Field  observa;on  

Projec;on  along      line-­‐of-­‐sight  

Deprojected  spectral  analysis  

Chandra/XMM  data  

3-­‐D  density  profiles  

2-­‐D  mass  profiles  

UH88  photo-­‐  metric  data    

Background/foreground  

B-­‐R  (B-­‐I,  R-­‐I)  color-­‐magnitude  

diagram  

2-­‐D  integrated  light  profiles  

Galaxy  light  vs  ICM  mass  profiles  

Page 8: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

Selected  red-­‐sequence  Central  dominant  galaxy  

Page 9: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

Schechter  LF  

Page 10: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

Normalized  to  innermost  

Normalized  to  innermost  

filtering  

Background  subtrac;on  

Two-­‐band  

Field  observa;on  

Projec;on  along      line-­‐of-­‐sight  

Deprojected  spectral  analysis  

Chandra/XMM  data  

3-­‐D  density  profiles  

2-­‐D  mass  profiles  

UH88  photo-­‐  metric  data    

 background/foreground  

B-­‐R  (B-­‐I,  R-­‐I)  color-­‐magnitude  

diagram  

2-­‐D  integrated  light  profiles  

Galaxy  light  vs  ICM  mass  profiles  

Page 11: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

z=0.1-­‐0.2,BS  z=0.1-­‐0.2,CMF  z=0.2-­‐0.5,BS  z=0.2-­‐0.5,CMF  z=0.5-­‐0.9,BS  z=0.5-­‐0.9,CMF  

Page 12: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

z=0.1-­‐0.2,BS  z=0.1-­‐0.2,CMF  z=0.2-­‐0.5,BS  z=0.2-­‐0.5,CMF  z=0.5-­‐0.9,BS  z=0.5-­‐0.9,CMF  

Page 13: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

z=0.1-­‐0.2,BS  z=0.1-­‐0.2,CMF  z=0.2-­‐0.5,BS  z=0.2-­‐0.5,CMF  z=0.5-­‐0.9,BS  z=0.5-­‐0.9,CMF  

✗  Cluster  color  gradient  ✗  Over-­‐luminous  BCG  ✗  Varia;on  of  galaxy  luminosity  by  e.g.,  star  forma;on  

z=0.1-­‐0.2,CMF,same-­‐RF  z=0.1-­‐0.2,CMF  z=0.2-­‐0.5,CMF,same-­‐RF  z=0.2-­‐0.5,CMF  z=0.5-­‐0.9,CMF,same-­‐RF  z=0.5-­‐0.9,CMF  

Page 14: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

z=0.1-­‐0.2,BS,total  mass  z=0.1-­‐0.2,BS  z=0.2-­‐0.5,BS,total  mass  z=0.2-­‐0.5,BS  z=0.5-­‐0.9,BS,total  mass  z=0.5-­‐0.9,BS  

Ø  Galaxy/ICM/DM  follow  similar  distribu;on  at  high-­‐z  Ø  Concentra;on:  galaxy<DM<ICM  

Page 15: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

FDF = -4πρtotal(GMgalaxy)2 lnΛ [erf(X)-(2X/√π)exp(-X2)] /v2 Dynamical  fric;on    Ram  pressure  

FRP = πRInt2 ρgv2, RInt ~ RD

Dynamical  fric0on  only  effec0ve  for  most  massive  galaxies  0 109 2×109 3×109 4×109 5×109

100

1000

200

500

0 109 2×109 3×109 4×109 5×109

100

1000

200

500

r  (kpc)  

t  (yr)  

Mgalaxy=1×1011 M¤ Dynamical friction alone Dynamical friction + ram pressure

1×1012 M¤

Page 16: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

Dynamical  fric0on  alone  insufficient  to  explain  the  evolu0on  

z=0.1-­‐0.2,BS,m<1011M¤  z=0.1-­‐0.2,BS  z=0.2-­‐0.5,BS,m<1011M¤  z=0.2-­‐0.5,BS  z=0.5-­‐0.9,BS,m<1011M¤  z=0.5-­‐0.9,BS  

Page 17: LiyiGu(Univ.ofTokyo;SJTU) · Rampressure,coldfront,shock,turbulence,MHDeffects, dynamical fricon…! Freeenergy$ transferedfromgalaxytoICM! GalaxymoreandmoreconcentratedthantheICM

Ø  Stellar  component  concentrated  faster  than  the  ICM  from  z=0.9-­‐0.1;  galaxy  light-­‐to-­‐ICM  mass  ra0os  drop  by  ~2  within  0.5  R500  

Ø  The  evolu0on  is  robust  against  various  redshiN-­‐dependent  biases  

Ø  This  result  provides  important  supports  for  galaxy-­‐ICM  interac0on  

 

 XMM-­‐Newton  Workshop  on  Galaxy  Clusters,  Madrid,  2012/5/23