Liberi v Taitz - Appellees Reply to Taitz's Response in Opposition to Appellees Motion to Strike Doc 46-1

7/31/2019 Liberi v Taitz - Appellees Reply to Taitz's Response in Opposition to Appellees Motion to Strike Doc 46-1

1/19

Cosl E|bhlxs> ??"


2/19

j

VOHIL GA CGEVLEVS

Pomls

VOHIL GA CGEVLEVS%%%%%%%j

VOHIL GA O\VDGXJVJLS%%%%%jj"q

J% JESVLOF ga OFFXLSSJEM vdl JSS\LS je

OPPLIILLS BGVJGE) VOJV^ \SLS VDLJX

GPPGSJVJGE vg A\XVDLX IJVJMOVL VDLJX

JSS\LS ge OPPLOI%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%?"3

JJ% OPPLIIOVL CG\XVS GEIZ CGESJFLX vdl

XLCGXF HLAGXL vdl FJSVXJCV CG\XV geOPPLOI%%3"1

JJJ% VDL CG\XV GXFLXLF o CGESGIJFOVLF

XLPIZ HXJLA) ja o XLPIZ }os AJILF1"4

JQ% SOECVJGES OMOJESV NLAAXLZ C\EEJEMDOB)

LS_\JXL oef djs CIJLEV) GXIZ VOJV^) LS_\JXL

oxl ]OXXOEVLF4"?0

Q% CGECI\SJGE%%%%%%%%%%%%?0

Cosl> ??"


3/19

jj

VOHIL GA O\VDGXJVJLS

Cosls Poml$s*

Oigl Qlxo ga Oblxjco) Jec% q% \ejvlf Svovls)

H%K%H% q% Bo|j Pgijcl Flpv%)

8=1 A%3f ?0:?) ??0="04 $:vd

Cjx% 8008*%:

Coxxjmoe q% Coi% Svovl Ilmjsiov|xl)813 A%8f


4/19

jjj

VOHIL GA O\VDGXJVJLS " Cgevje|lf

Cosls Poml$s*

Kjxsdelx q% \ejfle Cgxp% Ga Oblxjco)

468 A%8f ?0=6) ?0== $:vd

Cjx%?:44*%%%6) 1

Ilevjej q% Coi% Cvx% agx vdl Oxvs)3=0 A%3f 43=) 463 e%1 $:vd Cjx% 8006*%%%%%%%3

BocFgeoif q% Mxocl Cd|xcd Slovvil)

6


5/19

jq

VOHIL GA O\VDGXJVJLS " Cgevje|lf

Cosls Poml$s*

Qlss q% Cjho"Mljmz Cgxp% \SO)

3?= A%3f ?0:= $:vd

Cjx% 8003*%?

]gisvge q% Xloflx-s Fjmlsv Osse) Jec%) $?:=:* 663 \%S% ?


6/19

q

EJEVD CJXC\JV IGCOI X\ILS

Poml$s*

X|il 30"8%%%4

X|il 30"?%%%4

X|il 30"?%4$o*%%%%3

Cosl> ??"


7/19

?

OPPLIILLS XLPIZ vg OPPLIIOEV GXIZ VOJV^S GPPGSJVJGE vg

OPPLIILLS BGVJGE vg SVXJKL

Oppliills Ijso Ijhlxj [IjhlxjR) Ijso Gsvliio [GsvliioR) Mg Ltcli Mighoi)

Pdjijp N% Hlxm) Lsq|jxl [HlxmR) oef vdl Io} Gaajcls ga Pdjijp N% Hlxm)

[OppliillsR ajil vdl }jvdje Xlpiz vg Oppliioev Gxiz Vojv~s [Vojv~R Gppgsjvjge

vg Oppliills Bgvjge vg Svxjkl) agx Soecvjges) Ovvgxelz Alls oef Cgsvs%

J% JESVLOF ga OFFXLSSJEM vdl JSS\LS je OPPLIILLS

BGVJGE) VOJV^ \SLS VDLJX GPPGSJVJGE vg A\XVDLX

IJVJMOVL VDLJX JSS\LS ge OPPLOI>

Oppliills je vdljx Bgvjge bglf vg Svxjkl el} oxm|blevs oef Vojv~s

S|ppilblevoi Ltclxpv ga Xlcgxf je }djcd Vojv~ aojilf vg xojsl hlagxl vdl Fjsvxjcv

Cg|xv gx je dlx Oppliioevs Gplejem Hxjla%

Jesvlof ga offxlssjem vdl el} oxm|blevs) Vojv~ a|xvdlx oxm|ls vdl Fjsvxjcv

Cg|xvs Flejoi ga dlx Oevj"SIOPP Bgvjge oef vdl Oevj"SIOPP svov|vl% Vojv~ oisg

xojsls oxm|blevs ohg|v Oppliills Oes}lxjem Hxjla oef vdl cosls Qlxj~ge

Flio}oxl) Jec% q% Cgqof Cgbbs% Cg%) 3== A%3f ?04? $:vd Cjx% 8006*) Qlss q% Cjho"

Mljmz Cgxp% \SO) 3?= A%3f ?0:= $:vd Cjx% 8003*) oef Mxllespxjems Hopvjsv

Cdxjsvjoe Aliig}sdjp Vx|sv q% Cjiilz) 18: A%3f ?016 $:vd Cjx% 80?0* os vdl hosjs agx

Oppliills Bgvjge vg Svxjkl?% Vdjs js egv }dov Oppliills osklf vdjs Cg|xv vg Svxjkl)

egx js jv o s|aajcjlev hosjs vg oiig} oxm|blevs oef s|ppgslf ljflecl vdov }os

? Vojv~ ciojbs vdlsl vdxll [3R cosls coeegv hl jevxgf|clf hlco|sl Oppliills fjf egv pxlslev

vdlb vg vdl Fjsvxjcv Cg|xv% Oppliills cjvlf vg vdlsl vdxll [3Rcosls plxvojejem vg vdl opploiohjijvz

ga vdl Oevj"SIOPP Gxflx) }djcd js egv o ajeoi Gxflx) }dle Ilol vg Oblef js Mxoevlf%

Cosl> ??"


8/19

8

egv pxlslevlf vg vdl Fjsvxjcv Cg|xv xlmoxfjem Vojv~s Oevj"SIOPP Bgvjge gx je

Vojv~s Gplejem Hxjla%

Vojv~ ciojbs hlco|sl Oppliills Ovvgxelz bofl svovlblevs vg vdl N|fml je

Pleeszioejo ohg|v djs hlijla xlmoxfjem Gxiz Vojv~ vdov Ijhlxj oef Gsvliio oxl

Hjxvdlxs% Gsvliio }os Ossjsvoev ]lhbosvlx agx Vojv~ agx o sdgxv plxjgf ga vjbl;

oef Ijhlxj jevlxelf os Bx% Hlxms Poxoilmoi% O svovlblev bofl hz gel jefjjf|oi)

}dg xlpxlslevs Gsvliio oef Ijhlxj fgls egv bokl Gsvliio oef Ijhlxj Hjxvdlxs%

Egel ga vdl Oppliills $Piojevjaas* hligemlf gx omxllf }jvd Vojv~s pgijvjcoi

fjssjflev bglblev%Egel ga vdl Oppliills s|ppgxv glxvdxg}jem g|x mglxeblev

gx poxvjcjpovlf je oez ga vdl ocvjjsbs Vojv~ dos dloflf |p vg doxb oezgel%

Vdl aocv vdov Gsvliio oef Ijhlxj }lxl }gxkjem agx Ovvgxelzs fgls egv bokl

Gsvliio oef Ijhlxj Hjxvdlxs gx bokl vdlb jegilf je oez vzpl ga Pgijvjcoi

Bglblev% Gsvliio oef Ijhlxj oxl egv p|hijc jefjjf|ois oef vdlz oxl egv

Hjxvdlxs% Svovlblevs hz Oppliills Gsvliio oef Ijhlxjs cg|esli fgls egv

vxoesagxb Gsvliio oef Ijhlxj jevg p|hijc ajm|xls; oez vzpl ga pgijvjcoi bglblev;

gx jevg Hjxvdlxs% ]gisvge q% Xloflx-s Fjmlsv Osse) Jec%) $?:=:* 663 \%S% ?


9/19

3

A%3f ?03:) ?064 $:vd Cjx% 8003*% Jss|ls xojslf agx vdl ajxsv vjbl je oe Oppliioevs

Xlpiz Hxjla oxl cgesjflxlf }ojlf) vdl Cg|xv xg|vjeliz xla|sls vg cgesjflx vdlb%

Sll) l%m%) Ilevjej q% Coi% Cvx% agx vdl Oxvs) 3=0 A%3f 43=) 463 e%1 $:vd Cjx% 8006*;

\ejvlf Svovls q% Xloxfle) 36: A%3f 104) 1?6 e%8 $:vd Cjx% 8003*; Clfoeg"Qjlxo q%

Osdcxgav) 386 A%3f ?018) ?011 e%< $:vd Cjx% 8003*> Mxoqls q% Oxpojg) 183 A%3f

?063) ?064 $:vd Cjx% 80?0* $plx c|xjob*;Lhlxil q% Cjvz ga Oeodljb) :0? A%8f 4?6)

4?4 $:vd Cjx%?::0*%

Vdl xlosge agx vdjs js aojxelss% ]dle oe jss|l js xojslf agx vdl ajxsv vjbl je o

Xlpiz Hxjla) jv bloes vdov vdl Oppliills dol egv dof oe gppgxv|ejvz vg xlspgef vg

vdov jss|l% Sll Ilevjej) 3=0 A%3f ov 463 e%1%

Agx vdlsl xlosges) vdl svovlblevs'jss|ls'oxm|blevs opploxjem ge pomls ?0"?8

ga Oppliioevs Xlpiz; Oppliioevs el} xlq|lsvlf xlijla ge poml 8

Vojv~ splefs o igv ga vjbl ovvlbpvjem vg cgejecl vdjs Cg|xv vdov vdljx el}

oxm|blevs oef S|ppilblevoi Ltclxpv ga Xlcgxf ga oe O|m|sv =) 800: Vxoescxjpv je

oegvdlx Cg|xv je Pleeszioejo js pxgplx je xlspgefjem vg Oppliills Oes}lxjem

Hxjla% [Vojv~ Gpp% J"JJ) pp% ?"


10/19

6

Fjsvxjcv Cg|xvs Xlcgxf xlmoxfjem Vojv~s Oevj"SIOPP Bgvjge) egx }os jv xojslf je

vdljx Oppliioevs Gplejem Hxjla% [Vojv~s Gpp% p% 3R

Vdl Oppliiovl Xlcgxf coeegv jeci|fl aocv|oi oiilmovjges gx s|ppgslf

ljflecl |es|ppgxvlf hz vdl Fjsvxjcv Cg|xv Xlcgxf% Zejm|l~ q% Oxj~geoes agx

Gaajcjoi Lemijsd) 68 A%3f ?8?=) ?88?) e% 3 $:vd Cjx% ?::6*% Vdl cxlovjge ga vdl

xlcgxf ge opploi gcc|xs sgiliz je vdl Fjsvxjcv Cg|xv% Oppliiovl Cg|xvs cgesjflx

geiz vdl xlcgxf hlagxl vdl vxjoi n|fml }dle djs flcjsjge }os bofl $lbpdosjs je

gxjmjeoi* Kjxsdelx q% \ejfle Cgxp% Ga Oblxjco) 468 A%8f ?0=6) ?0== $:vd

Cjx%?:44*%

Eljvdlx vdl Oppliioev egx vdl Oppliill coe off vg gx leioxml vdl xlcgxf ge

Opploi vg jeci|fl bovlxjoi vdov }os egvhlagxl vdl Fjsvxjcv Cg|xv%Bgxxjsge q% Doii)

81? A%3f 4:1) :00) ae%6 $:vd Cjx% 800?*% Oppliiovl Cg|xvs boz cgesjflx geiz vdgsl

bovvlxs vdov }lxl hlagxl vdl Fjsvxjcv Cg|xv }dle vdl flcjsjge) hljem opploilf) }os

levlxlf% \ejvlf Svovls q% &88)6=6%00 je \%S% C|xxlecz) 861 A%3f ?8?8) ?8?4 $:vd

Cjx% 800?*%

Vdl x|il pxgdjhjvjem leioxmlblev ga vdl xlcgxf js svxjcviz cgesvx|lf% Vdl

Ejevd Cjxc|jv }jii svxjkl ltvxoelg|s bovvlxs axgb vdl xlcgxf ge jvs g}e bgvjge)

lle ja vdl poxvjls dol svjp|iovlf vg vdljx jeci|sjge je vdl Xlcgxf ge Opploi%

Poeo}jl} Fggx q% ]jefg} Cg% q% Xlzegifs Blvoi Cg%) 8


11/19

''fjcvjgeoxz%xlalxlecl%cgb'hxg}sl'cgesgijfovlf7s2v%

Nlaaxlz C|eejemdob) Lsq|jxl oef djs cijlev) Oppliioev Gxiz Vojv~ oxl hgvd

slosgelf ovvgxelzs) oef sdg|if keg} vdl bloejem ga o Cg|xv Gxflx% O Xlpiz

Hxjla js oiig}lf =)000 }gxfs gx ajavlle [?


14/19

4

ag|x [16R pomls os vdljx Cgesgijfovlf Xlpiz Hxjla) je jgiovjge gaAlf% X% Opp% P%

38$o*$=*$H*$jj*%

JQ% SOECVJGES OMOJESV NLAAXLZ C\EEJEMDOB) LS_\JXL

oef djs CIJLEV) GXIZ VOJV^) LS_\JXL oxl ]OXXOEVLF>

Vojv~ ciojbs vdov Oppliills aojilf vg cjvl }dov vdlz fjf vdov }oxxoevs

soecvjges% Vdjs sjbpiz js egv vdl cosl%

Oppliills a|iiz cjvlf vg vdl aocvs vdov Vojv~ oef dlx ovvgxelz) Nlaaxlz

C|eejemdob) Lsq|jxl jeci|flf el} oxm|blevs oef fgc|blevs je o S|ppilblevoi

Ltclxpv ga Xlcgxf vdov }lxl egv pxlslevlf vg vdl Fjsvxjcv Cg|xv je xlmoxfs vg

Vojv~s Oevj"SIOPP Bgvjge) egx }lxl vdlz jeci|flf je Vojv~s Oppliioevs

Gplejem Hxjla% Oppliills oisg osklf agx Soecvjges oef Ovvgxelz Alls agx Vojv~

oef dlx Ovvgxelz) Nlaaxlz C|eejemdob) Lsq|jxls) aoji|xl vg ohjfl hz vdl Cg|xvs

Alhx|oxz 3) 80?8 Gxflx% Oii ga vdl agxlmgjem }djcd js ltovjg|s) ovvlbpvjem vg

pxln|fjcl vdjs Cg|xv omojesv Oppliills) oef dos |exlosgeohiz jecxloslf vdl cgsv ga

ijvjmovjge hz vdljx jeci|sjge ga |eelclssoxz oef jeofbjssjhil bovlxjois%

Soecvjges oxl pxgplx }dle o poxvz aojis vg Cgbpiz }jvd Cjxc|jv X|il 30"?)

hz jeci|fjem jxxlilqoev bovlxjois je vdl Ltclxpvs ga Xlcgxfs gx Ltdjhjvs ajilf

}jvd o Hxjla [lbpdosjs offlfR% Sll vdjs Cg|xvs Cjxc|jv X|il 30"88% Vdl Ejevd

Cjxc|jv Igcoi X|il 30"8 oiig}s agx Soecvjges) Cgsvs oef Ovvgxelz Alls omojesv oe

8Vdl Ejevd Cjxc|jv Cg|xv dos vdl jedlxlev pg}lx vg svxjkl jxxliloev bovlxjoi% Cjxc|jv X|il 30"?;

Sll oisg ca% Coxxjmoe q% Coi% Svovl Ilmjsiov|xl) 813 A%8f


15/19

:

Ovvgxelz }dg qltovjg|siz oef |exlosgeohiz jecxlosls vdl cgsv ga ijvjmovjge hz

jeci|sjge ga |eelclssoxz bovlxjoi je vdl ltclxpvs ga xlcgxf) os Gxiz Vojv~) Lsq|jxl

oef Nlaaxlz C|eejemdob) Lsq|jxl) Ovvgxelz agx Gxiz Vojv~ dol fgel vg vdl

Oppliills dlxlje%

84 \%S%C% ?:8= oiig}s vdjs Cjxc|jv vg Soecvjge oe Ovvgxelz }dg sg

b|ivjpijls vdl pxgcllfjems je oez cosl |exlosgeohiz oef qltovjg|siz agx vdgsl

ltclss cgsvs) ltplesls) oef ovvgxelzs alls xlosgeohiz jec|xxlf os o xls|iv ga

ovvgxelzs cgef|cv% Xlckilsselss s|aajcls |eflx ?:8=) h|v vdl Cg|xv b|sv ajef

vdlxl }os hof aojvd%H%K%H% q% Bo|j Pgijcl Flpv%) 8=1 A%3f ?0:?) ??0="04 $:vd Cjx%

8008*% Vdlxl js eg q|lsvjge vdov Gxiz Vojv~) Lsq|jxl oef Nlaaxlz C|eejemdob)

Lsq|jxl) }dg oxl hgvd slosgelf Ovvgxelzs ijcleslf vg pxocvjcl io} je vdl Svovl ga

Coijagxejo) ocvjges ga jeci|fjem el} oxm|blevs oef ovvlbpvjem vg jeci|fl o

vxoescxjpv ga oe O|m|sv =) 800: Cg|xv dloxjem vdov }os elqlx pxgjflf vg vdl

Fjsvxjcv Cg|xv gx je Vojv~s Gplejem Hxjla) oii ga }djcd }os je hof aojvd oef jv js

s|ppgxvlf hz vdljx ajijem ge Opxji ?:) 80?8) }djcd js cilox oef cgeqjecjem

lqjflecl% Je xl Ildvjele)


16/19

?0

Nlaaxlz C|eejemdob) Lsq|jxl) cg|esli agx Gxiz Vojv~) Lsq|jxl jgiovlf vdl

Cg|xvs Alhx|oxz 3) 80?8 Cgesgijfovjge Gxflx) hz ossjsvjem Gxiz Vojv~ je ajijem o

slcgefoxz Xlpiz Hxjla ge hldoia ga FGAA) }djcd oigel }oxxoevs Soecvjges oef oe

o}oxf ga Ovvgxelz Alls oef Cgsvs vg Oppliills) Oigl Qlxo ga Oblxjco) Jec% q%

\ejvlf Svovls) 3=1 A%3f :10 $:vd Cjx% 8006* $Soecvjges oxl oppxgpxjovl }dle o

poxvz p|xpgsliz jgiovls o Cg|xv Gxflx*Jf% ov :11%

Q% CGECI\SJGES>

Agx vdl xlosges g|vijelf dlxlje) Oppliioevs Gxiz Vojv~ oef Flalef g|x

Axllfgbs Ag|efovjges) Jec%s Xlpiz Hxjla) FE 60"?) Cosl Eg% ??"


17/19


18/19


19/19

Documents

Liberi v Taitz - Appellees Reply to Taitz's Response in Opposition to Appellees Motion to Strike Doc 46-1