Upload
nocompromisewtruth
View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 1/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl 0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ^zi Xl `od eiz ^f`kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
77777777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
DLHF@Z@TKIO IE ^MKFK^ G/
JLZB& LXP\KZL
D`tl ie Ml`zkob7 A`{ 2& :>0:
Tkal ie Ml`zkob7 0>7>> /a/
Fih`tkio7 Hi|ztziia 0>D
DLHF@Z@TKIO ie ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB& LXP\KZL
K& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& `a iulz tml `bl ie 0= `od `a ` ~`zt{ ti tml rktmko
`htkio/ K m`ul ~lzxio`f coirfldbl ie tml e`htx mlzlko& `od ke h`ffld ti di& K hi|fd
`od ri|fd hia~ltlotf{ tlxtke{/ K `a a`ckob tmkx Dlhf`z`tkio |odlz tml ~lo`ft{ ie
~lzg|z{ ie tml F`rx ie tml \oktld Xt`tlx ~|zx|`ot ti := \/X/H/ ¢0245/
0/ K `a `o @ttizol{ ko biid xt`odkob& fkhloxld ti ~z`htkhl f`r ko tml
Hiaaiorl`ftm ie ^loox{fu`ok`/ K `a fkhloxld ti ~z`htkhl ko tml \/X/ Dkxtzkht
Hi|ztx& Akddfl `od L`xtlzo Dkxtzkht ie ^loox{fu`ok`3 Tmkzd Hkzh|kt Hi|zt ie
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:04=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 2/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl :
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
@~~l`fx3 tml Okotm Hkzh|kt Hi|zt ie @~~l`fx3 tml ^loox{fu`ok` X|~zlal Hi|zt3 `od
tml \/X/ X|~zlal Hi|zt/ @od& K `a tml @ttizol{ ie Zlhizd eiz ff tml ^f`kotkeex ko
tmkx h`xl/
:/ K `a a`ckob tmkx Dlhf`z`tkio ko x|~~izt ie f`kotkeex I~~ixktkio ti
Tidd X`ocl{ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/‛x S‖X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx‑Q Aitkio ti
Rktmdz`r tml @dakxxkiox Dllald ‖@dakttld‑/
8/ K m`d xlulz`f hioulzx`tkiox rktm A`zh Hiflo& Lxp|kzl& `ttizol{ eiz
Olkf X`ocl{& Tidd X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh
ko zlb`zdx ti tmlkz Koktk`f Dkxhfix|zlx `od ^f`kotkeex zlp|lxtld Dkxhiulz{/
4/ Io G`o|`z{ :>& :>0: K zlhlkuld ` xt hc ie dih|alotx ezia Az/ Hiflo
`x tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx Koktk`f Dkxhfix|zlx/ Kohf|dld ko tmlxl dih|alotx rlzl
xl`zhmlx hiod|htld dkzlhtf{ tmzi|bm @hh|zkot io ^f`kotkee Fkx` Fkjlzk io A`zhm 05
:>>;& ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie rmkhm kx `tt`hmld `x L]MKJKT ‖0‑0/
</ Tmkx xl`zhm io f`kotkee Fkx` Fkjlzk r`x z|o |xkob Azx/ Fkjlzk‛x o`al
`od `ddzlxx/ Tml xl`zhm io Azx/ Fkjlzk zlt|zold Azx/ Fkjlzk‛x o`al3 Xihk f
Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz& jitm ifd `od olr3 d`tl ie jkztm3 `od `ddzlxxlx/ L`hm o`al fkxtld
`x jlfiobkob ti Azx/ Fkjlzk kohf|dld Azx/ Fkjlzk‛x Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz `od d`tl
ie jkztm& `ftmi|bm a`o{ ie tml o`alx olulz jlfiobld ti iz rlzl |xld j{ Azx/
0K m`ul zld`htld `ff ~lzxio`f koeiza`tkio ko tml xl`zhmlx `od zl~iztx hiod|htld io `ff tml
^f`kotkeex& rmkhm `zl `tt`hmld `x L}mkjktx ti tmkx Dlhf`z`tkio/ Tml `ht|`f dih|alotx zlhlkuldezia tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx rlzl oit zld`htld/
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:04;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 3/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl 8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
Fkjlzk/ K m`ul zld`htld Azx/ Fkjlzk‛x Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlzx `od aiotm `od d`{
ie jkztm eiz tmkx ekfkob/ @x kodkh`tld j{ tml @hh|zkot xl`zhm `tt`hmld `x L]MKJKT
‖0‑ tmkx xl`zhm r`x hiod|htld dkzlhtf{ ko tml @hh|zkot d`t j`xl fih`tld t
mtt~x7))xlh|zl/`hh|zkot/hia)`~~)j~x)a`ko j{ Olkf X`ocl{ j{ `od tmzi|bm Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ @x h`o jl xllo& tml xl`zhm io Fkjlzk r`x hiod|htld dkzlhtf{
tmzi|bm @hh|zkot‛x d`t`j`xl j{ Olkf X`ocl{ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ `x dl~khtld
io L]MKJKT ‖0‑ io tml jittia flet ie l`hm ~`bl/
5/ ^f kotkee Fkx` Fkjlzk‛x hia~zlmloxkul hiox|alz zl~izt ijt kold j{
Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ io A`zhm 05& :>>; r`x kohf|dld rktm tml X`ocl{
Dlelod`otx Koktk`f Dkxhfix|zlx/ Xll ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie Fkjlzk‛x
hia~zlmloxkul zl~izt `tt`hmld `x L]MKJKT ‖:‑/ Azx/ Fkjlzk‛x zl~izt hiot`kox
mlz& o`al3 lulz{ o`al lulz |xld& kohf|dkob a`kdlo3 `ddzlxxlx3 jitm mlz ifd `od
olr Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlzx3 d`tl ie jkztm3 kohial& ld|h`tkio& la~fi{alot& mial
u`f|lx& |ofkxtld `od |o~|jfkxmld tlfl~miol o|ajlzx3 x~i|xlx o`al& d`tl ie jkztm
`ddzlxxlx& Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz3 ezklodx kohf|dkob tmlkz o`alx& Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{
o|ajlzx& zlf`tkulx kohf|dkob tmlkz ezklodx& zlf`tkulx& d`tlx ie jkztm& `ddzlxxlx& mial
u`f|l& kohial& ld|h`tkio3 Azx/ Fkjlzk‛x zlf`tkulx kohf|dkob o`alx& `ddzlxxlx&
Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlzx& d`tlx ie jkztm& ezklodx `od zlf`tkulx& kohf|dkob tmlkz Xihk`f
Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlzx& d`tlx ie jkztm& mial u`f|lx& ld|h`tkio& kohial& zlf`tkul `od
ezklodx koeiza`tkio& lulz{ o`al lulz |xld& kohf|dkob a`kdlo o`alx3 kohial& mial
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:0<>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 4/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl 4
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
u`f|l3 ld|h`tkio3 olkbmjizx o`alx& `ddzlxxlx `od ~zku`tl d`t`& lth/:
Tml zl~izt
`fxi hiot`kox o|alzi|x kohizzlht o`alx& `ddzlxxlx `od itmlz ~zku`tl d`t`
`xxihk`tld ti Fkjlzk j{ mlz Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz `od d`tl ie jkztm/
2/ Azx/ Fkjlzk‛x zl~izt hiot`kox mlz |ofkxtld `od |o~|jfkxmld hlff ~miol
o|ajlz3 mlz hlff ~miol h`zzklz3 mlz la~fi{alot mkxtiz{ rktm mlz Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{
o|ajlz& mlz ~ixktkio& tkal la~fi{ld& `ddzlxx ie la~fi{lz3 g|dbalotx bikob j`hc
ti 0;;8 hiot`kokob Azx/ Fkjlzk‛x o`al& Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz& `ddzlxx& hzldktiz
`ai|ot ie tml G|dbalot& `od d`tl ekfld3 j`ocz|~th{ koeiza`tkio3 hzkako`f d`t`& lth
Tml zl~izt `fxi hiot`kox o`alx ie Azx/ Fkjlzk rktm mlz Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz `od
d`tl ie jkztm tm`t m`ul olulz jllo Azx/ Fkjlzk‛x o`alx iz |xld j{ Azx/ Fkjlzk& lth/
=/ @fxi kohf|dld ko tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx Koktk f Dkxhfix|zlx r`x `
Hia~zlmloxkul Hiox|alz Zl~izt z|o j{ Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ io @~zkf 5& :>>;
io Jzlot Fkjlzk& x~i|xl ie ^f`kotkee Fkx` Fkjlzk/ Xll L]MKJKT ‖8‑& tml
Hia~zlmloxkul hiox|alz zl~izt z|o io Jzlot Fkjlzk/ @x xmiro io tmkx
Hia~zlmloxkul Zl~izt& tmkx zl~izt kohf|dlx tml x`al ~zku`tl ~lzxio`f koeiza`tkio
`x tm`t hiot`kold ko tml zl~izt z|o io Azx/ Fkjlzk/
;/ Olkf X`ocl{ tmlo z`o `ddktkio`f hiox|alz zl~iztx io Fkjlzk `od mlz
m|xj`od io @~zkf 0<& :>>;3 @~zkf 05& :>>;3 @~zkf 0;& :>>;3 `od A`{ 2& :>>; `od
z`o hiox|alz zl~iztx io Fkx` Ixtlff` `od mlz m|xj`od io @~zkf 08& :>>; `od @~zkf
: @x xmiro ko tml Hia~zlmloxkul Zl~iztx& tml zl~iztx hiot`ko tmzll -8+ dlbzllx ie zlf`tkulx/
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:0<0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 5/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl <
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
0;& :>>;/ Xll DO 4;0!: `t ~~/ 02!0=& Oi/ <83 `od DO 4;0!0& ~/ =& µH-`+/
0>/ Io @~zkf 0>& :>>;& Olkf X`ocl{ ezia Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ xlot `o
La`kf ti Zl~iztlz Jij \oz|m ie Rizfd Olt D`kf{/ Tmkx La`kf xlot ezia Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ hiot`kold koeiza`tkio t`clo ezia ^f`kotkee Fkjlzk‛x
hia~zlmloxkul hiox|alz zl~izt& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti mlz o`al& mlz ifd `od
olr Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlzx& d`tl ie jkztm& m|xj`od‛x o`al& Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{
o|ajlz3 `od tml o`alx& d`tlx ie jkztm `od Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlzx ie ezklodx `od
zlf`tkulx ie ^f`kotkee Fkjlzk/ Tml La`kf lulo zlelzlohlx Az/ Fkjlzk‛x xkxtlz‛x f`xt
o`al ‖Mlfflz‑/ Xll ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie tmkx La`kf `tt`hmld `x L]MKJKT
‖4‑/
00/ Io @~zkf 08& :>>;& Olkf X`ocl{ ezia Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh
eizr`zdld ` hi~{ ie tml La`kf xlot ti Jij \oz|m ti Izf{ T`ktw/ Xll ` tz|l `od
hizzlht hi~{ `tt`hmld mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖<‑/ T`ktw zl~l`tldf{ ~|jfkxmld
^f`kotkee Fkjlzk‛x ~zku`tl d`t` ko ` dih|alot xml h`ffld ‖Dixxklz Oi/ 5‑ `ff iulz tml
Kotlzolt3 j{ ZXX Elldx3 Ezklodx Elldx3 Xihk`f Oltrizcx3 A`xx La`kfkob3 M`od
Dlfkulz{3 io mlz iro rljxktl3 dkxh|xxld kt ko z`dki kotlzuklrx3 TU kotlzuklrx3 ekfld
kt rktm F`r Loeizhlalot3 `od ekfld kt ko mlz Hi|zt h`xlx/ T`ktw Dixxklz Oi/ 5 m`x
jllo ekfld rktm tmkx Hi|zt o|alzi|x tkalx `od kx xtkff `u`kf`jfl rktm Olkf X`ocl{‛x
La`kf io tml Kotlzolt `t mtt~7))rrr/ikfeizkaakbz`tkio/izb)e`htx)9~1042=& rktm
Fkjlzk‛x e|ff Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz/
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:0<:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 6/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl 5
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
0:/ Io A`{ :=& :>>; Olkf X`ocl{ zl~zlxlotkob mkaxlfe `x ` ^zku`tl
Koulxtkb`tiz rktm Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ `dakttld ml ijt`kold hiox|alz zl~iztx io tml
^f`kotkeex3 `od dkxh|xxld hzldkt ktlax ezia Azx/ Fkjlzk‛x hzldkt zl~izt/ Ko ~`ztkh|f`z
r`x ` fi`o Azx/ Fkjlzk m`d g|xt t`clo i|t eiz mlz xio‛x ekzxt {l`z ie hifflbl/ Tml
tz`oxhzk~t ezia tmkx z`dki xmir m`x jllo ekfld o|alzi|x tkalx rktm tmkx Hi|zt `od `
hi~{ ie tml lotkzl kotlzuklr r`x ~ziukdld ti G|dbl Zijzloi‛x Hi|zt io @|b|xt ;
:>>;/
08/ Tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx dkd oit t|zo iulz `ff tml zl~iztx tml{
~|zhm`xld io tml ^f`kotkeex/ K m`ul dla`odld tml `ddktkio`f zl~iztx& `od akxxkob
~`blx& j|t tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx m`ul zle|xld ti e|zokxm tmla/
04/ K xlzuld ^f kotkeex Ekzxt Xlt ie Dkxhiulz{ io tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx
G`o|`z{ 0;& :>0: j{ r`{ ie La`kf `od tmzi|bm tml \oktld Xt`tlx ^ixt`f Xlzukhl
^zkizkt{ A`kf& xkbo`t|zl zlp|kzld/ ^f`kotkeex Dkxhiulz{ zlp|lxtx xlzuld |~io Tidd
X`ocl{& Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/& Olkf X`ocl{ `od X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ rlzl
Kotlzzib`tizklx3 Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx3 `od Zlp|lxtx eiz
@dakxxkio/ @ tz|l od hizzlht hi~{ ie7
@/ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz Kotlzzib`tizklx xlzuld |~io Tidd X`ocl{ kx
`tt`hmld mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖5‑3
J/ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx xlzuld |~io Tidd
X`ocl{ kx `tt`hmld mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖2‑3
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:0<8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 7/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl 2
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
H/ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox xlzuld |~io Tidd X`ocl{ kx `tt`hmld
mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖=‑3
D/ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx xlzuld |~io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ kx `tt`hmld
mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖;‑3
L/ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx xlzuld |~io Tml X`ocl{
Ekza& Koh/ kx `tt`hmld mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖0>‑3 `od
E/ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox xlzuld |~io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ kx
`tt`hmld mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖00‑/
0</ Az/ Hiflo `hcoirfldbld tml dkxhiulz{ xlot j{ La`kf io mkx hfklotx
Xll ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie tml La`kf `tt`hmld `x L]MKJKT ‖0:‑ `od xkbold eiz
tml m`zd hi~klx ie ^f`kotkeex Dkxhiulz{ io G`o|`z{ :0& :>0:& ` tz|l `od hizzlht
hi~{ ie rmkhm kx `tt`hmld mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖08‑/ Tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx
Zlx~ioxlx rlzl d|l io iz jleizl Eljz|`z{ :0& :>0:/ Tmkx kohf|dlx Olkf X`ocl{
`od X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ rmi io A`zhm ;& :>0: ekfld ` Hm`~tlz 2
J`ocz|~th{/
05/ Io Eljz|`z{ 0>& :>0:& K zlhlkuld tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx dkxhiulz{
~zi~i|odld io ^f`kotkeex j{ r`{ ie Kotlzzib`tizklx `od Ei|z M|odzld `od Trlot{
Tmzll S4:8Q Zlp|lxtx eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx xlzuld xl~`z`tlf{ |~io l`hm
^f`kotkee/ ^f`kotkeex‛ zlx~ioxlx rlzl d|l io iz jleizl A`zhm 0:& :>0:/ ^f`kotkeex
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2 ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:0<4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 8/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl =
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
Zlx~ioxlx ti tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx Dkxhiulz{ rlzl xlzuld io tml X`ocl{
Dlelod`otx A`zhm ;& :>0:/
02/ Tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx e`kfld ti zlx~iod ti `o{ ie tml ^f kotkeex
Dkxhiulz{ zlp|lxtx& kohf|dkob l`hm ie tml Zlp|lxtx eiz @dakxxkio tm`t rlzl
~zi~i|odld/
0=/ Io Eljz|`z{ :<& :>0:& K xlot `o La`kf ti Az/ Hiflo koeizakob mka ie
^f`kotkeex kotlot io ekfkob ` Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot/ @ tz|l `od hizzlht
hi~{ ie tmkx La`kf kx `tt`hmld mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖04‑/ Io Eljz|`z{ :2& :>0:
koxtl`d ie dkxh|xxkob tml kxx|lx& Az/ Hiflo zlx~iodld rktm ` ulz{ kaa`t|zl La`kf&
` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie rmkhm kx `tt`hmld `x L]MKJKT ‖0<‑/ K zlx~iodld ti
Az/ Hiflo‛x La`kf xt`tkob ml tiic mkx zlx~ioxl `x ml dkd oit `bzll rktm ^f`kotkeex
kotlotkio ie ekfkob ` Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot/ Xll ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{
`tt`hmld mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖05‑/ K xi|bmt Fl`ul ie Hi|zt ti ekfl ` Aitkio eiz
X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx/ Xll ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{
`tt`hmld mlzlti `x L]MKJKT ‖02‑/
0;/ Io A`zhm 0& :>0:& Az/ Hiflo xlot al `o La`kf xt`tkob eiz
|o`otkhk~`tld zl`xiox& tml zlx~ioxl ti ^f`kotkeex Dkxhiulz{ zlp|lxtx rlzl f`tl& `
tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie rmkhm kx `tt`hmld `x L]MKJKT ‖0=‑/ Az/ Hiflo xt`tld
^f`kotkeex ri|fd zlhlkul tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx zlx~ioxlx ko tri S:Q rllcx& rmkhm
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl = ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:0<<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 9/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 10/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl 0>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
`hhi|ot rktm KZJxl`zhm& FFH/ Tidd X`ocl{ m`d ti `xxkbo Olkf X`ocl{ ` |xlz KD
rmkhm ml dkd `xxkbokob ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hia/ X`al bilx eiz Olkf
X`ocl{‛x La`kf `ddzlxx ie ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hia& rmkhm r`x |xld `x Olkf
X`ocl{‛x |xlz o`al ko Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/‛x `hhi|otx3 Tidd m`d ti hzl`tl `od
`xxkbo tml La`kf `ddzlxx ti Olkf X`ocl{ ezia mkx La`kf xlzulz/ L`hm zl~iz
~|zhm`xld io tml ^f`kotkeex& Tidd X`ocl{ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ ri|fd m`ul
jllo jkffld eiz/ L`hm La`kf xlot `od zlhlkuld j{ Olkf X`ocl{ ri|fd jl xtizld ko
Tidd X`ocl{ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/‛x La`kf xlzulz tm`t Tidd X`ocl{ ri|fd
m`ul `hhlxx ti/
:4/ Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ m`x jllo `r`zl ie tmkx f`r x|kt xkohl A`{ 5
:>>; rmlo tml{ rlzl ~lzxio`ff{ xlzuld rktm tml Izkbko`f Hia~f`kot/ Olkf X`ocl{
hiotko|ld |xkob tml La`kf `ddzlxx ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hia tmzi|bm :>00
Olkf X`ocl{ r`x hiot`htkob DD@ Xlhizd ko tml X`o Jlzo`zdkoi Hi|ot{ Dkxtzkht
@ttizol{‛x Ieekhl3 tml X`ot` El `od X`o Jlzo`zdkoi Hi|ot{ ^zij`tkio
Dl~`ztalotx3 X`ot` El ^ifkhl Dl~`ztalot3 `od itmlz Dlelod`otx ko tmkx H`xl
`ttla~tkob ti m`ul ^f`kotkee Fkjlzk `zzlxtld `od g`kfld j`xld io e`fxl `fflb`tkiox/
:</ Dkxhiulz{ h|t!iee ko tmkx h`xl r`x A`zhm <& :>0:/ Tml X`ocl{
Dlelod`otx dlf`{ld tmlkz Aitkio |otkf `etlz Olkf X`ocl{ ekfld eiz J`ocz|~th{&
coirkob kt r`x ~zlhf|dkob ^f`kotkeex ezia ijt`kokob `o{ ie tml Dkxhiulz{
~zi~i|odld io Olkf X`ocl{ `od dl~zkukob tml ^f`kotkeex tml i~~izt|okt{ ti dl~ixl
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:0<2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 11/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl 00
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
Olkf X`ocl{/ Olkf X`ocl{ kx ` cl{ rktolxx ko tmkx h`xl `x dlaioxtz`tld j{ tml
L}mkjktx `tt`hmld mlzlti `od L}mkjktx ekfld ko tmkx h`xl/
:5/ Olkf X`ocl{ ~ziukdld ` Dlhf`z`tkio hiot`kokob e fxl `od ~lzg|zld
xt`tlalotx ti tml Zlld Dlelod`otx ko x|~~izt ie tmlkz Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{
G|dbalot/ Xll DO 4;4/ Mirlulz ^f`kotkeex `zl ~zlhf|dld ezia hiot`htkob
Dlelod`ot Olkf X`ocl{ d|l ti tml J`ocz|~th{ xt`{ `od tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx
m`ul zle|xld ti hia~f{ rktm Dkxhiulz{/
:2/ K r`x i|t ie tml Ieekhl |otkf T|lxd`{& @~zkf 02& :>0: d|l ti x|zblz{ K
m`d/ K dkd oit zlhlkul tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx Aitkio ti Rktmdz`r |otkf tm`t tkal/
Tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx e`kfld ti ~ziukdl trlot{!lkbmt S:=Q d`{x‛ Oitkhl `x
zlp|kzld j{ tml Hi|zt‛x Fih`f Z|flx/
:=/ Xmi|fd tmkx Hi|zt bz`ot tml Dlelod`otx Aitkio `od `ffir tmla ti
Rktmdz`r tmlkz @dakxxkiox Dllald ‖@dakttld‑& ^f`kotkeex rkff jl xlulzlf{
~zlg|dkhld/ ^f`kotkeex `zl |o`jfl ti xlh|zl tml Dkxhiulz{ tml{ ri|fd olld ti
~zi~lzf{ fktkb`tl tmkx h`xl `b`koxt Tidd X`ocl{ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ `x `
zlx|ft ie tmlkz e`kf|zl ti ~zid|hl `od hia~f{ rktm Dkxhiulz{ `od `x ` zlx|ft ie tml
J`ocz|~th{ Xt`{ `x ti Olkf X`ocl{/
))
))
))
))
))
))
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 00 ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:0<=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 12/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl 0:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
K dlhf`zl |odlz tml ~lo`ft{ ie ~lzg|z{ ie tml F`rx ie tml \oktld Xt`tlx `od
H`fkeizok` tm`t tml eizlbikob kx tz|l `od hizzlht/
tmd`{ ie @~zkf& :>0: ko tml Hiaaiorl`ftm ie ^loox{fu`ok`
Hi|ot{ ie Aiotbialz{/
)x) ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& Dlhf`z`ot
L}lh|tld tmkx 0;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie 0: ^`bl KD(70:0<;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 13/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖0‑
08
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:05>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 14/38304
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:050
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 15/3830<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:05:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 16/38305
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:058
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 17/38302
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:054
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 18/3830=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:05<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 19/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖:‑
0;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:055
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 20/383:>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:052
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 21/383:0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:05=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 22/383::
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:05;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 23/383:8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:02>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 24/383:4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:020
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 25/383:<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:02:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 26/383:5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl = ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:028
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 27/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 28/383:=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:02<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 29/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 30/3838>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:022
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 31/38380
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 08 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:02=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 32/3838:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 04 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:02;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 33/38388
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0< ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0=>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 34/38384
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 05 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0=0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 35/3838<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 02 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0=:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 36/38385
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0= ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0=8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 37/38382
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0; ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0=4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 38/3838=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :> ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0=<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 39/3838;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :0 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0=5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 40/3834>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :: ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0=2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 41/38340
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :8 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0==
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 42/3834:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :4 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0=;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 43/38348
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :< ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0;>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 44/38344
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :5 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0;0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 45/3834<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :2 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0;:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 46/38345
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl := ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0;8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 47/38342
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :; ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0;4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 48/3834=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8> ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0;<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 49/3834;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 80 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0;5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 50/383<>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8: ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 51/383<0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 88 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:0;=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 52/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 53/383<8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8< ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::>>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 54/383<4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 85 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::>0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 55/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 56/383<5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8= ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::>8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 57/383<2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8; ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::>4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 58/383<=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4> ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::><
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 59/383<;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 40 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::>5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 60/3835>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4: ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::>2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 61/38350
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 48 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::>=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 62/3835:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 44 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::>;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 63/38358
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4< ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::0>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 64/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 65/3835<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 42 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::0:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 66/38355
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4= ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::08
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 67/38352
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4; ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::04
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 68/3835=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl <> ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::0<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 69/3835;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl <0 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::05
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 70/3832>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl <: ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::02
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 71/38320
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl <8 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::0=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 72/3832:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl <4 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::0;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 73/38328
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl << ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:::>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 74/38324
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl <5 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:::0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 75/3832<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl <2 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::::
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 76/38325
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl <= ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:::8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 77/38322
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl <; ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:::4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 78/3832=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5> ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:::<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 79/3832;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 50 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:::5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 80/383=>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5: ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:::2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 81/383=0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 58 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:::=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 82/383=:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 54 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70:::;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 83/383=8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5< ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::8>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 84/383=4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 55 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::80
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 85/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 86/383=5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5= ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::88
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 87/383=2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5; ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::84
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 88/383==
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2> ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::8<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 89/383=;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 20 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::85
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 90/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 91/383;0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 28 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::8=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 92/383;:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 24 ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::8;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 93/383;8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2< ie 2< ^`bl KD(70::4>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 94/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖8‑
;4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie := ^`bl KD(70::40
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 95/383;<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie := ^`bl KD(70::4:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 96/383;5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie := ^`bl KD(70::48
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 97/383;2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie := ^`bl KD(70::44
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 98/383;=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie := ^`bl KD(70::4<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 99/383;;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie := ^`bl KD(70::45
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 100/3830>>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2 ie := ^`bl KD(70::42
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 101/3830>0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl = ie := ^`bl KD(70::4=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 102/3830>:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl ; ie := ^`bl KD(70::4;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 103/3830>8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie := ^`bl KD(70::<>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 104/3830>4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 00 ie := ^`bl KD(70::<0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 105/3830><
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie := ^`bl KD(70::<:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 106/3830>5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 08 ie := ^`bl KD(70::<8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 107/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 108/3830>=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0< ie := ^`bl KD(70::<<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 109/3830>;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 05 ie := ^`bl KD(70::<5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 110/38300>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 02 ie := ^`bl KD(70::<2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 111/383000
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0= ie := ^`bl KD(70::<=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 112/38300:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0; ie := ^`bl KD(70::<;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 113/383008
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :> ie := ^`bl KD(70::5>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 114/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 115/38300<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :: ie := ^`bl KD(70::5:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 116/383005
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :8 ie := ^`bl KD(70::58
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 117/383002
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :4 ie := ^`bl KD(70::54
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 118/38300=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :< ie := ^`bl KD(70::5<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 119/38300;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :5 ie := ^`bl KD(70::55
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 120/3830:>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :2 ie := ^`bl KD(70::52
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 121/3830:0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!8 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl := ie := ^`bl KD(70::5=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 122/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖4‑
0::
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!4 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie : ^`bl KD(70::5;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 123/383
Ezia7 Olkf X@OCL[ Sa`kfti7ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hiaQXlot7 Ezkd`{& @~zkf 0>& :>>; 0>7>0 @ATi7 Jij \oz|mX|jglht7 FKX@ FKJLZK lth
Jij mlzl `zl xial j`zl e`htx `ji|t Jlzb‛x `xxkxt`ot/ Xll jlfir `od`tt`hmalotxK dio‛t coir mir a|hm ie tml xtiz{ {i| m`ul `fzl`d{& j|t kx lxxlotk`ff{ `ji|tRMI xml zl`ff{ kx `od tml p|lxtkiox tm`t |oeizt|o`tlf{ jzkobx |~ `ji|t Jlzb/H`ff& ke {i| olld ti& `t {i|z hiouloklohl/
Olkf X`ocl{Koulxtkb`tiz % Hiox|ft`ot/
TML X@OCL[ EKZA
Xkak U`ffl{& H`fkeizok` ;8>58
ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hia
=>< <:> 80<0=0= :0: 250< hlff
-@ddlod|a+
FKX@ ZLOLL FKJLZK/ Jo <):=)0;5</ 45:!4<!}}}}& 5::!0;!480: -% itmlzx+
@hhizdkob ti tml ^ifkhl xml r`x jizo HI\ZUKFFL `od a`zzkld ` Zkhm`zdxio-^ixxkjfl @f`o Di|bf`x Zkhm`zdxio& h|zzlotf{ zlxkdkob ko F`x Ulb`x /+ KE kt r`xtml itmlz r`{ `zi|od& tmlo tml Hi|zukffl kx Jkff A`zxm`ff Hi|zukffl 00)0>)50 ieMi|xtio & T}/ 4<2!20!} K m`ul xlulz`f XX("x eiz mlz `od ` FIT ie @C@"x/ Mlz zl`fXX( kx ~zij`jf{ 45:!4<!}}}}/ Aixt ~ziakolot itmlzrkxl `zl <58!5>!}}}}& <2:!02!}& 5::!0;!} Xml rlot JC ko :>>: Mlz jzitmlz kx ~zij`jf{ F`rzlohl L Aizzkxie Eiot`o` `od Z`ohmi H|h & H@ / Ml r`x jizo 0)05)54 Mlz M|xj`od& Jzlot G& `^`zifll& K m`ul oit zlxl`zhmld tm`t/ Kx ~zij`jf{ Jzlot G AhHiza`hc <58!22& `fxi
|xlx 880!>:!}
Tmlzl kx `fxi ` Glzz{ MLFFLZ `od Di|bf`x Hz`alz fiic kotlzlxtkob& j|t rmlzldi {i| xti~9/
0:8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!4 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie : ^`bl KD(70::2>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 124/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖<‑
0:4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!< Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 8 ^`bl KD(70::20
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 125/383
Ezia7 Olkf X@OCL[ ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hiaX|jglht7 ER7 FKX@ FKJLZK lthTi7 dzYt`ktwN{`mii/hiaD`tl7 Aiod`{& @~zkf 08& :>>;& 27>4 ^A
Mlzl kx tml Fkjlzk xt|ee {i| zlp|lxtld/ Tmkx kx `fxi rm`t K xlot ti Jij \oz|m/
Ezia7 Olkf X@OCL[ Sa`kfti7ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hiaQXlot7 Ezkd`{& @~zkf 0>& :>>; 0>7>0 @ATi7 Jij \oz|mX|jglht7 FKX@ FKJLZK lth
Jij mlzl `zl xial j`zl e`htx `ji|t Jlzb‛x `xxkxt`ot/ Xll jlfir `od
`tt`hmalotxK dio‛t coir mir a|hm ie tml xtiz{ {i| m`ul `fzl`d{& j|t kx lxxlotk`ff{ `ji|tRMI xml zl`ff{ kx `od tml p|lxtkiox tm`t |oeizt|o`tlf{ jzkobx |~ `ji|t Jlzb/H`ff& ke {i| olld ti& `t {i|z hiouloklohl/
Olkf X`ocl{Koulxtkb`tiz % Hiox|ft`ot/
TML X@OCL[ EKZA
Xkak U`ffl{& H`fkeizok` ;8>58
ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hia
=>< <:> 80<0=0= :0: 250< hlff
-@ddlod|a+
FKX@ ZLOLL FKJLZK/ Jo <):=)0;5</ 45:!4<!}}}}& 5::!0;!480: -% itmlzx+
@hhizdkob ti tml ^ifkhl xml r`x jizo HI\ZUKFFL `od a`zzkld ` Zkhm`zdxio-^ixxkjfl @f`o Di|bf`x Zkhm`zdxio& h|zzlotf{ zlxkdkob ko F`x Ulb`x /+ KE kt r`xtml itmlz r`{ `zi|od& tmlo tml Hi|zukffl kx Jkff A`zxm`ff Hi|zukffl 00)0>)50 ieMi|xtio & T}/ 4<2!20!} K m`ul xlulz`f XX("x eiz mlz `od ` FIT ie @C@"x/ Mlz zl`fXX( kx ~zij`jf{ 45:!4<!}}}}/ Aixt ~ziakolot itmlzrkxl `zl <58!5>!}}}}& <2:!02!}& 5::!0;!} Xml rlot JC ko :>>: Mlz jzitmlz kx ~zij`jf{ F`rzlohl L Aizzkx
0:<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!< Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 8 ^`bl KD(70::2:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 126/383
ie Eiot`o` `od Z`ohmi H|h & H@ / Ml r`x jizo 0)05)54 Mlz M|xj`od& Jzlot G& `^`zifll& K m`ul oit zlxl`zhmld tm`t/ Kx ~zij`jf{ Jzlot G AhHiza`hc <58!22& `fxi|xlx 880!>:!}
Tmlzl kx `fxi ` Glzz{ MLFFLZ `od Di|bf`x Hz`alz fiic kotlzlxtkob& j|t rmlzl
di {i| xti~9/
0:5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!< Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 8 ^`bl KD(70::28
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 127/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖5‑
0:2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::24
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 128/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX KOTLZZIB@TIZKLX @DDZLXXLD TI
DLELOD@OT TIDD X@OCL[ ‘ XLT IOL
^FL@XL T@CL OITKHL& ko `hhizd`ohl rktm Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ 88& {i| `zl
mlzlj{ oitkekld `od zlp|kzld ti zlx~iod ti tml eiffirkob Kotlzzib`tizklx
~zi~i|odld j{ ^f`kotkeex Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& Bi
L}hlf Bfij`f `od Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb Smlzlko`etlz ‖^f`kotkeex‑Q
mlzlko& tmzi|bm tmlkz `ttizol{ ie zlhizd& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& F`r Ieekhlx ie
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& <<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:& F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80&
rktmko tmkzt{ S8>Q d`{x ezia xlzukhl mlzlie ko `hhizd`ohl rktm tml ~ziukxkiox ie tml
Eldlz`f Z|flx ie Hkukf ^zihld|zl/
0:=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::2<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 129/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
[i| `zl e|ztmlz ~f`hld io oitkhl& ~|zx|`ot ti Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ :5-l+& tm`t tmlxl
Kotlzzib`tizklx `zl dllald hiotko|kob& zlp|kzkob x|~~flalot`f zlx~ioxlx tmlzlti ko
tml lulot zlp|lxtld koeiza`tkio jlhialx `u`kf jfl rmkhm ri|fd zlp|kzl
`alodalot iz x|~~flalot`tkio ie {i|z zlx~ioxlx ko izdlz tm`t tml{ ri|fd jl
~zi~lz `od tz|tme|f/
KOXTZ\HTKIOX
0/ Ko `oxrlzkob tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx& ~fl`xl e|zokxm `ff koeiza`tkio
rmkhm kx `u`kf`jfl ti {i|& kohf|dkob& rktmi|t fkakt`tkio& `ff koeiza`tkio ko tml
~ixxlxxkio ie {i|z `ttizol{x& `hhi|ot`otx& `eekfk`tlx& `|dktizx& `blotx& la~fi{llx&
ieekhlzx& dkzlhtizx& xm`zlmifdlzx& hiotz`htizx& iz itmlz ~lzxioolf& `od oit alzlf{
x|hm koeiza`tkio `x kx ko {i|z ~ixxlxxkio/
:/ Ke {i| h`ooit zlx~iod ti `o{ ie tml eiffirkob Kotlzzib`tizklx ko e|ff
`etlz l}lzhkxkob d|l dkfkblohl ti xlh|zl koeiza`tkio ti di xi& ~fl`xl xi xt`tl& `od
zlx~iod ti tml l}tlot ~ixxkjfl& x~lhke{kob `ff zl`xiox rm{ {i| `zl |o`jfl iz
|orkffkob ti zlx~iod ti tml zla`kodlz& xt`tkob rm`tlulz koeiza`tkio {i| m`ul
hiohlzokob tml |o~zid|hld koeiza`tkio& `od rm`t leeiztx {i| a`dl ti xlh|zl
koeiza`tkio x|eekhklot ti `ffir {i| ti zlx~iod e|ff{ ti tml ~`ztkh|f`z Kotlzzib`tiz{/
8/ @ftmi|bm iol iz aizl ie tml eiffirkob Kotlzzib`tizklx a`{ oit `~~l`z
ti jl `~~fkh`jfl ti iz dkzlhtld ti {i|& ~fl`xl zlx~iod ti l`hm `od lulz{ iol ie tmla
ti tml l}tlot tm`t {i| `zl `jfl ti ~ziukdl `o{ zlx~ioxl tmlzlti rmltmlz x|hm
0:;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::25
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 130/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
zlx~ioxl hioxkxtx ie koeiza`tkio rktmko {i|z iro coirfldbl iz rm`t {i| m`ul
ijt`kold ezia itmlzx/
4/ Mirlulz& eiz lulz{ zlx~ioxl ko rmkhm {i| kohf|dl koeiza`tkio
zlhlkuld ezia itmlzx& ~fl`xl ~ziukdl tml o`al& `o{ coiro `ddzlxx& `od `o{ coiro
~miol o|ajlz ie tml ~lzxio ezia rmia {i| xi zlhlkuld x|hm koeiza`tkio/ @od& ko
lulz{ x|hm koxt`ohl ~fl`xl xt`tl tm`t {i| h`ooit ulzke{ x|hm ie {i|z iro ~lzxio`f
coirfldbl& kdlotke{kob ~`ztkh|f`zf{ tml koeiza`tkio eiz rmkhm {i| h`ooit ui|hm/
</ E|ztmlz& tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx hiot`ko rizdx iz ~mz`xlx rmkhm zlp|kzl
{i| ti zlelz ti tml *Dlekoktkiox* xlhtkio ie tmkx dih|alot ~ziukdld mlzlko jlfir/
5/ \oflxx itmlzrkxl xt`tld& l`hm Kotlzzib`tiz{ ~lzt`kox ti tml tkal ~lzkid
jlbkookob G`o|`z{& :>>=& tmzi|bm tml ~zlxlot d`tl/ Tm|x& {i|z zlx~ioxlx xmi|fd jl
e|ff{ `oxrlzld `x tml{ ~lzt`ko ti koeiza`tkio rktmko tm`t tkal ez`al/
2/ E|ztmlz& l`hm Kotlzzib`tiz{ xmi|fd kdlotke{ tml `~~zi~zk`tl tkal ez`al
ke {i|z zlx~ioxl zlp|kzlx x`al/
=/ Ke ijglhtkio kx t`clo ti `o{ ie tml eiffirkob Kotlzzib`tizklx iz ke `o{
Kotlzzib`tiz{ rkff oit jl hia~fkld rktm ko e|ff& ~fl`xl xt`tl tml x~lhkekh bzi|odx
tmlzleizl& kohf|dkob ko dlt`kf `ff tm`t {i| m`ul diol ko izdlz ti tz{ `od hia~f{
tmlzlrktm& `od hia~f{ rktm x|hm Kotlzzib`tiz{ ti tml l}tlot ti rmkhm tmlzl kx oi
ijglhtkio/ Ke ~zkukflbl kx `fflbld `x ti `o{ dih|alotx iz hiaa|okh`tkiox& e|ff{
kdlotke{ tml dih|alotx iz hiaa|okh`tkiox eiz rmkhm ~zkukflbl kx `xxlztld `od
08>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::22
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 131/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 4
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
l}~f`ko ko dlt`kf tml bzi|odx ie x|hm ~zkukflbl3 `od rktmi|t fkakt`tkio& x|hm
kdlotkekh`tkio `od l}~f`o`tkio xm`ff xlt eiztm `t tml fl`xt tml eiffirkob7
`+ Tml o`alx ie tml `|tmiz-x+ `od `ddzlxxll-x+ iz zlhk~klot-x+ ie tml
dih|alot3
j+ Tml o`al-x+ ie tml ~lzxio-x+ ti rmi hi~klx rlzl xlot iz rmi rlzl
~zlxlot d|zkob `o{ ~`zt ie tml hiaa|okh`tkio3
h+ Tml d`tl ie tml dih|alot iz hiaa|okh`tkio3
d+ Tml d`tl io rmkhm tml dih|alot r`x zlhlkuld j{ tmixl m`ukob
~ixxlxxkio ie tml dih|alot3
l+ @ jzkle dlxhzk~tkio ie tml o`t|zl `od x|jglht a`ttlz ie tml dih|alot iz
hiaa|okh`tkio3 `od
e+ Tml xt`t|tl& z|fl& iz dlhkxkio tm`t kx hf`kald ti bkul zkxl ti tml
~zkukflbl/
;/ Ko `hhizd`ohl rktm Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ :5-l+& tmkx Ekzxt Xlt ie
Kotlzzib`tizklx ti Dlelod`ot xm`ff jl dllald hiotko|kob xi `x ti zlp|kzl
x|~~flalot f `oxrlzx ke tml ~`zt{ zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx iz
mkx)mlz)tmlkz `ttizol{x ijt`ko e|ztmlz koeiza`tkio jltrllo tml tkal ie hia~fk`ohl
`od `t tml tkal ie tzk`f/
0>/ Rmlolulz `~~zi~zk tl& tml xkob|f z eiza ie ` rizd `fxi xm`ff jl
kotlz~zltld ti kohf|dl tml ~f|z`f/ *@od* `x rlff `x *iz* xm`ff jl hioxtz|ld lktmlz
dkxg|ohtkulf{ iz hiog|ohtkulf{ `x olhlxx`z{ ti jzkob rktmko tml xhi~l ie `o{
zlp|lxt& `o{ koeiza`tkio tm`t akbmt itmlzrkxl jl hioxtz|ld ti jl i|txkdl ktx xhi~l
080
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::2=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 132/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ <
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
*Mkx* xm`ff jl kotlz~zltld ti kohf|dl *mlz* `od ktx&* `od kx oit kotlodld ti jl
l}hf|xkul iz blodlz!x~lhkekh/
00/ Ko zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx& {i| xm`ff ~zid|hl `f
zlx~ioxkul dih|alotx rmkhm `zl ko {i|z ~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{& iz hiotzif iz ko tml
~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{& iz hiotzif ie {i|z ~zldlhlxxizx& x|hhlxxizx& ~`zlotx
x|jxkdk`zklx& dkukxkiox& iz `eekfk`tlx& iz `o{ ie {i|z zlx~lhtkul dkzlhtizx& ieekhlzx&
a`o`bkob `blotx& `blotx& la~fi{llx& `ttizol{x& `hhi|ot`otx iz itmlz
zl~zlxlot`tkulx/ @ dih|alot xm`ff jl dllald ti jl rktmko {i|z hiotzif ke {i| m`ul
tml zkbmt ti xlh|zl tml dih|alot iz ` hi~{ ie tml dih|alot ezia `oitmlz ~lzxio
m`ukob ~ixxlxxkio iz h|xtid{ ie tml dih|alot/
0:/ Ke `o{ dih|alotx iz ~`ztx ie dih|alotx h`ffld eiz j{ tmlxl
Kotlzzib`tizklx m`ul jllo dlxtzi{ld& dkxh`zdld& iz itmlzrkxl dkx~ixld ie& {i|
xmi|fd ~ziukdl ` fkxt xlttkob eiztm `x ti l`hm x|hm dih|alot tml eiffirkob
koeiza`tkio7
`/ Tml o t|zl ie tml dih|alot& l/b/& flttlz& alaiz`od|a& tlflbz`a& lth/3
j/ Tml o`al `ddzlxx& ihh|~`tkio& tktfl `od j|xkolxx `eekfk`tkio ie l`hm
~lzxio rmi ~zl~`zld& zlhlkuld& uklrld& `od m`x iz m`x m`d
~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{& iz hiotzif ie tml dih|alot3
h/ Tml d`tl ie tml dih|alot3
d/ @ dlxhzk~tkio ie tml x|jglht a`ttlz ie tml dih|alot3
l/ Tml d`tl ie dlxtz|htkio iz itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
08:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::2;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 133/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 5
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
e/ @ xt`tlalot ie tml zl`xiox eiz dlxtz|htkio iz itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
b/ Tml o`al& `ddzlxx& ihh|~`tkio& tktfl `od j|xkolxx `eekfk`tkio ie l`hm
~lzxio rmi `|tmizkwld dlxtz|htkio iz itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
m/ Tml o`al& `ddzlxx& ihh|~`tkio& tktfl `od j|xkolxx `eekfk`tkio ie l`hm
~lzxio rmi dlxtzi{ld iz dkx~ixld ie tml dih|alot3 `od
k/ Tml Kotlzzib`tiz{ ti rmkhm tml dih|alot kx zlx~ioxkul/
DLEKOKTKIOX
0/ @x |xld mlzlko7
`+ *^f`kotkeex‑ xm`ff al`o ^f`kotkeex Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& ^mkfk~ G
Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& Bi L}hlf Bfij`f `od tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb3 ^f`kotkeex
X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/
j+ ‖Dlelod`ot* xm`ff al`o Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{/
h+ *Kohkdlot* xm`ff al`o `x dlekold ko tml Hia~f`kot/
d+ ‖H|xtialz-x+‑ xm`ff al`o ~li~fl rmi ~|zhm`xl ~zid|htx ezia Tidd
X`ocl{ `od)iz mkx hia~`oklx/
l+ ‖La~fi{ll-x+‑ xm`ff al`o `o{ ~lzxio la~fi{ld j{ [i| iz `htkob `x
`o `blot eiz [i|/
e+ ‖[i|‑ iz ‖{i|z‑ al`ox tml ~lzxio iz lotkt{ zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl
Kotlzzib`tizklx `od `o{ ~zlxlot iz eizalz la~fi{llx& `blotx& hiox|ft`otx iz itmlz
~lzxio `htkob iz ~|z~iztkob ti `ht io jlm`fe ie x|hm ~lzxio iz lotkt{/
088
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::=>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 134/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 2
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
b+ *Dih|alot-x+* xm`ff al`o `o{ rzktkobx ie `o{ ckod `od xm`ff kohf|dl
tml izkbko`f `od l`hm oio!kdlotkh`f hi~{ iz dz`et tmlzlie/ Tml tlza `x tml x`al
al`okob `x ‖rzktkobx‑& rmkhm kx dlekold ko Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ 84-`+ `od Eld/ Z/ Lukd/
0>>0`x kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti& `o{ lflhtziokh`ff{ xtizld d`t`& d`t`j`xlx
dih|alotx& `od lflhtziokh hiaa|okh`tkio -x|hm `x L!a`kf rktm e|ff ml`dlz
koeiza`tkio+& xtizld ko hia~|tlzx iz itmlzrkxl& rmltmlz iz oit lulz ~zkotld iz
dkx~f`{ld& tm`t m`ul oit ~zluki|xf{ jllo ~zid|hld/ @ hi~{ iz d|~fkh`tl ie `
dih|alot tm`t m`x jllo ~zid|hld/ @ hi~{ iz d|~fkh`tl ie ` dih|alot tm`t m`x `o{
hioeizakob oitlx& a`zbko`f `ooit`tkiox& iz itmlz a`zckobx& `x rlff `x `o{
~zlfkako`z{ ulzxkio& dz`et& iz zlukxkio ie tml eizlbikob& xm`ff jl hioxkdlzld `
xl~`z`tl dih|alot rktmko tml al`okob ie tmkx tlza/ Tml tlza Dih|alot xm`ff `fxi
kohf|dl lulz{ itmlz al`ox j{ rmkhm koeiza`tkio kx zlhizdld iz tz`oxakttld
kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti& lflhtziokh a`kf rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio& Kotlzolt
Kotlzolt ~ixtkobx& t`~l zlhizdkobx& ukdli zlhizdkobx& akhziekfax& ~|ohm h`zdx
hia~|tlz a`boltkh t`~l& hia~|tlz dkxhx& hia~|tlz ~zibz`ax& xtiz`bl t`~lx&
~zkoti|tx& d`t` ~zihlxxkob zlhizdx& `od tml rzkttlo koeiza`tkio olhlxx`z{ ti
|odlzxt`od `od |xl x|hm koeiza`tkio/ Eiz l`hm *dih|alot* zlx~ioxkul ti `o{
zlp|lxt rktmmlfd ezia ~zid|htkio j{ {i| io tml bzi|od ie `o{ ~zkukflbl& ~fl`xl
xt`tl7
-k+ Tml o`t|zl ie tml dih|alot -l/b/& flttlz& alaiz`od|a& hiotz`ht& lth/+3
084
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl = ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::=0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 135/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 136/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ ;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
g+ ‖Lflhtziokh D`t`‑ xm`ff al`o `o{ `od `ff d`t` hiot`kold rktmko `o{ ie
Tidd X`ocl{‛x d`t`j`xl x{xtlax& hia~|tlzx& m`zd!dzkulx& zlaiu`jfl xtiz bl
dlukxlx& l/b/ hlff ~miolx& g|a~ dzkulx& `od xlzulzx ~lzt`kokob ti hiox|alzx& hfklotx
~li~fl& j|xkolxxlx& lth/
c+ ‖Lflhtziokh A`kf‑ xm`ff al`o xlot `od zlhlkuld l!a`kfx rktm tml e|ff
ml`dlz koeiza`tkio ezia `o{ `od `ff la`kf `hhi|otx ko rmkhm {i| m`ul `hhlxx/
f+ *^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx* al`ox ` ~lzxio"x o`al iz Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{
o|ajlz iz itmlz |okp|l d`t` rmkhm kdlotkeklx iz kx `xxihk`tld rktm ` ~`ztkh|f`z
*~lzxio*/
a+ *Kdlotke{* iz ti bkul tml *kdlotkt{* ie xm`ff al`o7
@/ Ko tml h`xl ie ` o`t|z f ~lzxio& ti xt`tl7
-k/+ @o{ `od `ff o`alx& flb`f& tz`dl iz `xx|ald3
-kk/+ F`xt coiro mial `od j|xkolxx `ddzlxxlx `od tlfl~miol
o|ajlzx3
-kkk/+ @ff tlfl~miol `od tlfl!e`} o|ajlzx |xld3
-ku/+ @ff rljxktlx irold od |xld3
-u/+ @ff la`kf `ddzlxxlx irold `od |xld3
-uk/+ La~fi{lz iz j|xkolxx eekfk`tkio3
-ukk/+ Ihh|~`tkio `od j|xkolxx ~ixktkio -kohf|dkob tktfl+ mlfd3
-ukkk/+ La~fi{lz"x o`al& `ddzlxx& ~miol o|ajlz `od tml
la~fi{lz"x zlf`tkioxmk~ ti `o{ `od `ff Dlelod`otx ko tml
`jiul h`~tkiold `htkio3 `od& ke `~~fkh`jfl7
085
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::=8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 137/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
-k}/+ Jz`od& a`cl& a`o|e`ht|zlz"x o`al& `ddzlxx& ~miol o|ajlz
`od tml a`o|e`ht|zlz"x zlf`tkioxmk~ ti `o{ `od `ff
Dlelod`otx ko tml `jiul h`~tkiold `htkio3
J/ Ko tml h`xl ie `o iz`f xt`tlalot ie hiaa|okh`tkio& ti xt`tl7
-k/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml a`clz-x+ `od zlhk~klot-x+ ie tml iz`f
xt`tlalot iz hiaa|okh`tkio3
-kk/+ Rmlzl `od rmlo tml iz`f xt tlalot iz hiaa|okh`tkio r`x
a`dl3
-kkk/+ Tml kdlotktklx ie `ff ~lzxiox ~zlxlot rmlo tml iz`f xt`tlalot
iz hiaa|okh`tkio r`x a`dl3
-ku/+ Tml aidl ie hiaa|okh`tkio3 `od
-u/+ Tml x|jglht a`ttlz ie tml iz`f xt tlalot iz hiaa|okh`tkio/
H/ Ko tml h`xl ie `o `ht iz iakxxkio& ti xt`tl7
-k/+ @ dlt kfld dlxhzk~tkio ie tml `ht iz iakxxkio3
-kk/+ Tml d`tl rmlo kt ihh|zzld3
-kkk/+ Tml ~f`hl rmlzl kt ihh|zzld3
-ku/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~lzxio iz ~lzxiox ~lzeizakob x|hm `htx
iz ko tml h`xl ie `o iakxxkio& tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~lzxio iz
~lzxiox e`kfkob ti `ht3 `od
-u/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie `ff ~lzxiox rmi m`ul coirfldbl ie tml ht iz
iakxxkio/
D/ Ko tml h`xl ie ~mitibz ~m iz ~mitibz ~mkh zl~zid|htkio& ti xt`tl7
-k/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~mitibz`~m iz ~lzxio zlx~ioxkjfl eiz tml
a`ckob ie tml ~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio3
082
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 00 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::=4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 138/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 00
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
-kk/+ Tml o|ajlz ie ~mitibz ~mx t clo iz ~mitibz`~mkh
zl~zid|htkiox a`dl3
-kkk/+ Rmlo `od rmlzl tml ~mitibz`~mx rlzl t clo iz tml
~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkiox rlzl a`dl3
-ku/+ Tml x|jglht a`ttlz dl~khtld ko l`hm ~mitibz ~m iz
~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio3 od
-u/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi m`x ~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{& iz
hiotzif ie l`hm ~mitibz`~m iz ~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio/
m/ Tml ~mz`xl *zlf tlx ti&* *zlf tkob ti&* iz *ko zlf`tkio ti* al`ox ti
hioxkxt ie& zlelz ti& zleflht& iz jl ko `o{ r`{ fibkh`ff{& e`ht|`ff{& iz flb`ff{
hioolhtld rktm tml a`ttlz dkxh|xxld/
k/ *@|dkt Tz`kf* al`ox ` hia~fltl& dlt`kfld fkxtkob ie l`hm `od lulz{
`ftlz`tkio& dlfltkio& kop|kz{ koti& aidkekh`tkio iz itmlz hm`obl ti tml hzldkt zl~izt
iz ~ziekfl `x a`kot`kold ko zlhizdld eiza& ko tml jzi`dlxt xloxl& j{ *{i|*/ Tml
fkxtkob xmi|fd kohf|dl tml kdlotkt{& `ddzlxx& la~fi{lz `od tktfl ie tml ~lzxio-x+
t`ckob tml `htkio& tml kdlotkt{& `ddzlxx& la~fi{lz `od tktfl ie tml ~lzxio-x+
`|tmizkwkob tml `htkio& ` dlt`kfld l}~f`o`tkio ie tml `htkio t`clo& tml d`tl ie tml
`htkio& tml al`ox |xld ti leelht x|hm `htkio& tml fih`tkio ie izkbko ie tml `htkio `od
tml zl`xio tml `htkio r`x t`clo/ Tml tlza *`|dkt tz`kf* `fxi kohf|dlx tml dlekoktkio
~ziukdld eiz tml ~mz`xl ko tml EldlzJ|xm& Eldlz`f Tz`dl Hiaakxxkio `od Eiza`
Xt`ee I~kokio Flttlz& A`zhm 0>& 0;=8/
08=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::=<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 139/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
g/ *D`t`* al`ox tml ~m{xkh`f x{ajifx ko tml jzi`dlxt xloxl tm`t
zl~zlxlot koeiza`tkio& zlb`zdflxx ie rmltmlz tml koeiza`tkio kx iz`f& rzkttlo iz
itmlzrkxl zlhizdld/
c/ *Hia~|tlz* al`ox `o{ `od ff ~zibz`aa`jfl lflhtziokh dlukhlx iz
`~~`z`t|xlx& kohf|dkob m`zdr`zl& xietr`zl& `od itmlz d`t`j`ocx& tm`t h`o xtizl
zltzklul& `hhlxx& |~d`tl& hiajkol& zl`zz`obl& ~zkot& zl`d& ~zihlxx iz itmlzrkxl `ftlz
d`t` rmltmlz x|hm d`t` a`kot`kold ko tm`t dlukhl iz `t xial itmlz fih`tkio/ Tml
tlza *hia~|tlz* kohf|dlx `o{ `od `ff a`boltkh zlhizdkobx iz x{xtlax& x{xtlax
i~lz`tkob io iz a`kot`kokob d`t` ko dkbkt`f& `o`fib& iz m{jzkd eiza`t& iz itmlz
alhm`okh`f dlukhlx& iz itmlz dlukhlx h`~`jfl ie a`kot`kokob rzktkobx iz
zlhizdkobx& ie `o{ ckod& ko hiodloxld eiza`t& `od kohf|dlx `o{ dkxc& t`~l&
zlhizdkob& iz itmlz koeiza`tkio`f xi|zhl& zlb`zdflxx ie ktx ~m{xkh`f dkaloxkio iz
xkwl/
f/ *Eiza`t* al`ox tml blolz`f a`cl|~ iz blolz`f ~f`o ie
izb`okw`tkio iz `zz`oblalot ie d`t`/
a/ *L}~f ko* al`ox ti lf|hkd tl& a`cl ~f ko iz |odlzxt od`jfl& ti
bkul tml zl`xio eiz iz h`|xl ie& `od ti xmir tml fibkh`f dlulfi~alot iz
zlf`tkioxmk~x tmlzlie/
o/ *Dlxhzkjl* al`ox ti zl~zlxlot iz bkul `o hhi|ot ie ko rizdx/
08;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 08 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::=5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 140/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 08
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
i/ ‖\xlz‑ al`ox `o{ ~lzxio iz hia~|tlz rmkhm kotlz`htx rktm `
dkeelzlot hia~|tlz/
~/ ‖@hhlxx ^zibz`ax‑ al`ox tmlxl ~zibz`ax& ~m{xkh`f iz hia~|tlz!
j`xld& rmkhm kox|zl `|tmizkw`tkio& kdlotkekh`tkio& ulzkekh`tkio& `hhlxx hiotzif
`hhi|ot`jkfkt{ `od xlh|zkt{ `|dkt ie {i|z hiox|alz d`t`j`xl/
p/ ‖Koeiza tkio ^zitlhtkio @zhmktlht|zl‑ al`ox ` xt tlalot ie tml
iulz`ff dlxkbo `od i~lz`tkob ijglhtkulx eiz tml xlh|zkt{& hiotko|kt{ `od hiotzif ie
{i|z hiox|alz d`t`j`xl/
TKAL ^LZKID
\oflxx itmlzrkxl xt`tld& `ff Kotlzzib`tizklx `od Dih|alotx zlp|lxtld `zl eiz
tml ~lzkid ie tkal ezia G`o|`z{ 0& :>>= tmzi|bm tml d`tl ie zlx~ioxl iz ~zid|htkio
`od kohf|dl rktmko tmlkz xhi~l Koeiza`tkio `od Dih|alotx rmkhm zlelz iz zlf`tl ti
`ff iz `o{ ~iztkio ie tm`t ~lzkid/ @oxrlzx `od Dih|alotx e`ff rktmko tmkx tkal
~lzkid ke tml{ zleflht ~ifkhklx `od)iz ~z`htkhlx ko leelht d|zkob tml tkal ~lzkid& lulo
ke tml dih|alotx rlzl rzkttlo iz hzl`tld jleizl tml zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid/
KOTLZZIB@TIZKLX7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 07
Kdlotke{ tml o`alx& `ddzlxxlx& `od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx ie `ff ~lzxiox rmi
x|~~fkld koeiza`tkio zlx~ioxkul ti tmlxl kotlzzib`tizklx/
@OXRLZ7
04>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 04 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::=2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 141/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 04
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ :7
^fl`xl xt`tl {i|z e|ff o`al3 lulz{ o`al {i| m`ul |xld ko tml ~`xt& `od tml
d`tlx ie x|hm |xl3 {i|z h|zzlot zlxkdlotk`f `ddzlxx `od tml `ddzlxxlx {i| m`ul
zlxkdld `t eiz tml ~`xt ekul -<+ {l`zx& rktm tml d`tlx `x ti l`hm `ddzlxx3 {i|z ~f`hl
ie la~fi{alot& kohf|dkob `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz `od ~ixktkio3 {i|z ~f`hl `od
d`tl ie jkztm3 {i|z e|ff Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ O|ajlz3 `od [i|z e|ff Dzkulz‛x fkhloxl
O|ajlz& kohf|dkob tml xt`tl ie kxx|`ohl/ Ke {i| `zl a`zzkld& ~fl`xl ~ziukdl tml
x`al eiz {i|z x~i|xl/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 87
M`ul [i|& Olkf X`ocl{& tml X`ocl{ Ekza& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox
~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia iz `o{ la~fi{ll iz `bbzlb`tl `od)iz ` 8zd
~`zt{ ie `o{
ckod& hiod|htld `o{ t{~l ie x|zulkff`ohl io `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex
X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx9 Ke xi& `x ti l`hm
x|zulkff`ohl& xt`tl tml o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& la~fi{alot o`al
`ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi hiod|htld tml x|zulkff`ohl& d`tl
`od tkal ie tml x|zulkff`ohl& t{~l ie x|zulkff`ohl& fih`tkio ie tml x|zulkff`ohl& tml
^f`kotkee ko rmkhm tml x|zulkff`ohl r`x hiod|htld io& rmltmlz `o{ ~mitibz`~mx iz
040
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0< ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::==
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 142/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ukdlit`~lx rlzl hiod|htld iz t`clo d|zkob tml x|zulkff`ohl& tml fih`tkio ie `o{
x|hm ~mitibz`~mx& ukdlit`~lx& `od zl~iztx iz itmlz dih|alotx tm`t rlzl hzl`tld iz
a`dl `x ` zlx|ft ie `o{ x|zulkff`ohl3 `od ~ziukdl ` hi~{ ie tml x`al/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 47
^fl`xl kdlotke{ tml o`al& `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie l`hm `od lulz{
~lzxio kotlzuklrld j{ [i|& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza ko zlf`tkiox ti `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/ ^fl`xl kohf|dl tml p|lxtkiox `xcld& ke
tml p|lxtkiox)`oxrlzx rlzl dih|alotld j{ `o{ al`ox& kohf|dkob lflhtziokh`ff{&
zlx~ioxlx tmlzlti `od rm`t j`xlx& ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f `|tmizkt{ Olkf
X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza m`d ko x|hm Kotlzuklr-x+
`od ~fl`xl ~ziukdl ` hi~{ ie l`hm dih|alotld hiaa|okh`tkio/
@OXRLZ7
04:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 05 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::=;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 143/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 05
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ <7
^fl`xl ~ziukdl l`hm `od lulz{ Kodkukd|`f& Hia~`o{& J|xkolxx& Lotkt{& Xt`tl
@bloh{& Biulzoalot`f @bloh{ ‘ jitm Xt`tl `od Eldlz`f& iz `o{ itmlz j|xkolxx
`xxihk`tkio& tmlkz o`alx& `ddzlxxlx& `od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx rmi ~ziukdld `o{ t{~l
ie dih|alot`tkio iz koeiza`tkio ti [i|& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh
`od)iz Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& ~lzt`kokob ti `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx
^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx d|zkob tml tkal ~lzkid ie
G`o|`z{ 0& :>>= tmzi|bm tml d`tl tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx `zl `oxrlzld/ ^fl`xl
dlxhzkjl ko dlt`kf& tml d`tl& tml koeiza`tkio zlhlkuld& l`hm dih|alot hzl`tld iz
zlhlkuld `od ~ziukdl ` hi~{ ie tml x`al/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 57
^fl`xl ~ziukdl ko dlt`kf lulz{ d`t` jziclz& hzldkt zl~iztkob `bloh{& hiox|alz
zl~iztkob `bloh{& ~zku`tl koulxtkb`tkio `bloh{& iz `o{ itmlz `bloh{& kohf|dkob
tmixl {i| m`ul d`t` xm`zkob& lflhtziokh elldx& d`t` jitx& d`t`!xm`zkob `bzllalotx
`o{ ~lzxio`f xi|zhl `hhlxx kohf|dkob `o{ |odlz tml BFJ @ht |tkfkwld j{ [i|
Tidd X`ocl{& ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& `od Tml
048
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 02 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::;>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 144/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 02
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
X`ocl{ Ekza& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& tml
d`tl& rlj `ddzlxx& la`kf `ddzlxx& koeiza`tkio ~ziukdld `od zlhlkuld& tml
~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl |xld ti xlh|zl tml koeiza`tkio& `od |xlz o`al eiz [i|& Tidd
X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza |xld ti ijt`ko iz
~ziukdl `o{ t{~l ie Zl~izt& dih|alot`tkio iz koeiza`tkio ~lzt`kokob ti `o{ ie tml
^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx
^fl`xl ~ziukdl ` hi~{ ie tml x`al/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 27
^ziukdl ` fkxt ie `ff kodkukd|`fx& j|xkolxxlx& 8zd
~`ztklx& kohf|dkob d`t` jziclz
hia~`oklx& hzldkt zl~iztkob `blohklx& hiox|alz zl~iztkob `blohklx& xt`tl lotktklx&
lotktklx& biulzoalot`f `blohklx iz lotktklx& la~fi{lzx& lth/& o`alx& `ddzlxxlx& `od
tlfl~miol o|ajlzx tm`t ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz
^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx ~lzxio`f kdlotkeklzx `od ~lzxio`f d`t` m`ul jllo
~ziukdld& e|zokxmld& xifd `od)iz zlxifd ti j{ [i|& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{
Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& tml X`ocl{ Ekza `od ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`ktio/hia& kohf|dkob l!
a`kf& d`t` tz`oxelzx& t{~lx ie d`t` tz`oxelzzld `od tml o`alx& tktfl& j|xkolxx
`ddzlxx& mial `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie `ff kodkukd|`fx ~ixxlxxkob tml
044
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0= ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::;0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 145/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0=
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
h`~`hkt{ iz h`~`jkfkt{ eiz x|hm tz`oxelz& kohf|dkob fkxtx `od o`alx ie `|tmizkwld
i|txkdl |xlzx ie lflhtziokh a`kf rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ =7
Xt`tl rmltmlz dlfltkio |tkfkt{ ~zibz`ax `zl |xld io `o{ ie [i|z d`t`j`xlx
xlzulzx& iz hia~|tlz x{xtlax d|zkob tml zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid ie tmkx fktkb`tkio
kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti tml o`al ie tml ~zibz`a-x+ `od tml d`tlx tml ~zibz`a
r`x |xld ti ~lza`olotf{ dlfltl ekflx/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ ;7
Xt`tl rmltmlz `o{ hia~|tlz m`zdr`zl m`x jllo |~bz`dld d|zkob tml zlflu`o
tkal ~lzkid ie tmkx fktkb`tkio& `od dlxhzkjl tml t{~l ie |~bz`dl `od rmltmlz tml
zl~f`hld ~`ztx rlzl zlt`kold& ke xi tml `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie rmlzl tml
~`ztx `zl fih`tld& `x rlff `x tmlkz hioolhtkukt{ `od kotlze`hl jltrllo tml hia~|tlz
x{xtlax/
@OXRLZ7
04<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0; ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::;:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 146/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 0>7
Kdlotke{ `o{ d`t`j`xlx `od hia~|tlz dzkulx tm`t rlzl lz`xld iz zleiza`ttld
d|zkob tml zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid ie tmkx fktkb`tkio& tml d`tl tml hia~|tlz dzkulx rlzl
lz`xld iz zleiza`ttld& tml zl`xio tml dzkulx rlzl lz`xld iz zleiza`ttld& `od
rmltmlz tml{ rlzl j`hcld |~/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 007
^fl`xl ~ziukdl ` fkxt& kohf|dkob o`alx& `ddzlxxlx& tlfl~miol o|ajlzx& zl~izt
o|ajlzx& h`xl o|ajlzx& ie lulz{ hia~f`kot ekfld j{ [i|& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{
Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& tml X`ocl{ Ekza& ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia iz `o{ itmlz o`al
|xld j{ tmlxl dlelod`otx ko ekfkob hi|zt `htkiox ‘ kohf|dkob ti zluicl ~zij`tkio
zl~iztx `od)iz hia~f`kotx `b`koxt `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx rktm `o{ Dl~`ztalot iz @bloh{
kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti Hkt{& Hi|ot{& Xt`tl& iz Eldlz`f `blohklx `od)iz f`r
loeizhlalot& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti Bz`od G|zklx& Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{
@dakokxtz`tkio& Kotlzo`f Zlulo|l Xlzukhl& Xt`tl T`} Ieekhlx& Xmlzkee‛x
dl~`ztalotx& Hi|ztx& Hkt{ ^ifkhl Dl~`ztalotx& Xt`tl ^ifkhl& Eldlz`f J|zl`| ie
Koulxtkb`tkiox& ^zij`tkio Dl~`ztalotx& Dl~`ztalot ie G|xtkhl& jitm xt`tl `od \/X/
045
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :> ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::;8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 147/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^fl`xl ~ziukdl ` dlt`kf ie tml zl~izt iz `fflb`tkiox a`dl& `o{ t{~l ie koulxtkb`tkio
tm`t r`x hiod|htld& rmltmlz `o{ `zzlxtx rlzl a`dl `od ~ziukdl `ff dih|alot`tkio
`od zl~iztx ie tml x`al/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 0:7
Kdlotke{ tml h|zzlot `od ~zlxlot ~lzxiox& kohf|dkob tmlkz o`alx& `ddzlxxlx
`od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx& zlx~ioxkjfl eiz tml iobikob i~lz`tkiox& a`kotlo`ohl
l}~`oxkio& `zhmkukob `od |~cll~ ie l`hm d`t`j`xl& oltrizc& @hhlxx ^zibz`ax& od
Koeiza`tkio ^zitlhtkio @zhmktlht|zl ko |xl j{ [i|& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{
Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& tml X`ocl{ Ekza `od ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia `od tkal ko tm`t
~ixktkio/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 087
^ziukdl tml o`al& la~fi{lz& tktfl& j|xkolxx `ddzlxx& mial `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol
o|ajlzx ie l`hm ~lzxio zlx~ioxkjfl eiz tml d`{!ti!d`{ t`xcx ie j`hckob |~ ekflx
`od `zhmkukob ekflx `od d`t` hia~kfld ko ~`~lz eiza`t& hia~|tlz m`zd dzkulx&
042
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :0 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::;4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 148/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
d`t`j`xlx& lth/ hiot kokob `od kohf|dkob `o{ d`t` jlfiobkob ti tml ^f kotkeex d|zkob
tml zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid ie tmkx fktkb`tkio `x rlff `x `o{ zlhizd zltlotkio `od
dlxtz|htkio ~ifkhklx od ~zihld|zlx/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 047
^fl`xl ~ziukdl `ff |xlzo`alx& `hhi|otx& |xlz `bzllalotx& `|tmizkw`tkiox& od
hiotz`htx [i|& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia&
`od tml X`ocl{ Ekza m`x)m`d rktm Izf{ T`ktw& Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie Izf{ T`ktw& Izf{
T`ktw& Koh/& Dlelod i|z Ezlldiax Ei|od`tkiox& Koh/& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \/X/ Xl`zhm&
T`flotrkxl& W`jj`xl`zhm/hia& Hioek!Hmlc& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx/hia& Fl}kxOl}kx
Bzi|~& @hh|zkot& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx
Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/& Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/ iz `o{ ie ktx
`eekfk`tlx& Lp|ke`}& L}~lzk`o& Tz`ox\okio& `od `o{ itmlz o`alx |tkfkwld j{ `o{ ie
tml Dlelod`otx ezia G`o|`z{ 0& :>>= |otkf tml d`tl rmkhm tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx `zl
`oxrlzld/
@OXRLZ7
04=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :: ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::;<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 149/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ ::
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 0<7
Xt`tl {i|z ~zihld|zlx dlxkbold ti `xx|zl tml a`}ka|a ~ixxkjfl `hh|z`h{ ie
tml koeiza`tkio {i| zlhlkuld io kodkukd|`fx& kohf|dkob ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex
X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/ Ko `oxrlzkob tmkx
Kotlzzib`tiz{& ~fl`xl l}~f`ko mir [i|& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/
~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia& `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza zlhlkulx tml d`t`& mir tml
koeiza`tkio kx)r`x `xxihk`tld rktm ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo
`od)iz f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 057
Kdlotke{ tml o`alx& `ddzlxxlx& `od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx ie `ff ~lzxiox rmi
m`ul ~lzxio`f coirfldbl ie `o{ ie tml e`htx& lulotx& iz a`ttlzx tm`t `zl `fflbld ko
^f`kotkeex Hia~f`kot& {i|z @oxrlz& `otkhk~`tld `oxrlz& `od)iz dleloxlx tmlzlti `od
dlxhzkjl `od l}~f`ko {i|z |odlzxt`odkob ie tml a`ttlzx io rmkhm tml ~lzxiox
o`ald m`ul coirfldbl/
@OXRLZ7
04;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :8 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::;5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 150/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 027
M`ul [i|& Olkf X`ocl{ iz `o{ la~fi{ll iz `bbzlb tl ie X`ocl{
Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/& ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia `od)iz ` 8zd
~`zt{ ie `o{ ckod& hiod|htld `o{ t{~l ie x|zulkff`ohl io `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex&
^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx9 Ke xi
xt`tl tml o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& la~fi{alot o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol
o|ajlz ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi hiod|htld tml x|zulkff`ohl& d`tl ie x|zulkff`ohl& t{~l
ie x|zulkff`ohl& fih`tkio ie tml x|zulkff`ohl& tml ^f`kotkee ko rmkhm tml x|zulkff`ohl
r`x hiod|htld io& `od ~ziukdl `ff zl~iztx& dih|alot`tkio& ekfax& lflhtziokh
hiaa|okh`tkiox rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio& hiotz`htx& dlt`kfx& `od `o{ `od `f
koeiza`tkio ~lzt`kokob ti x`kd x|zulkff`ohl/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 0=7
^fl`xl dlxhzkjl ko dlt`kf `o{ hioul{`ohl ie& tz`oxelz ie& iz ke {i| xifd `o{
zl`f ~zi~lzt{3 zlhzl`tkio`f ulmkhflx3 j`oc `hhi|otx3 hlztkekh`tl ie dl~ixktx
zltkzlalot `hhi|otx3 ulmkhflx ie `o{ t{~l3 f`od3 eko`ohk`f `hhi|otx ie `o{ t{~l
iz `o{ itmlz t`obkjfl iz u`f|`jfl ktla ezia A`{ 4& :>>; tmzi|bm tml d`tl {i|
0<>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :4 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 151/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 152/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
x|~~iztkob l`hm dlok`f& `eekza`tkul dleloxl iz x~lhk`f dleloxl& xt`tl tml o`al&
`ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie `ff ~lzxiox rmi m`ul coirfldbl ie tml e`htx3 `od
fkxt `o{ dih|alotx rmkhm {i| jlfklul a`{ x|~~izt l`hm dlok`f& @eekza`tkul
Dleloxl& X~lhk`f Dleloxl `od)iz E`htx/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ :07
Fkxt `ff eiz|ax& jfibx& hm`t ziiax& z`dki ~zibz`ax& rljxktlx& kohf|dkob j|t
oit fkaktld ti Tml Eibjir& ^ifktkg`j& rizfd Olt D`kf{& Dlaihz`tkh Dkx`xtlz tm`t
{i| `zl ` alajlz ie `od tm`t {i| |tkfkwl `od ~ixt io& x|~~f{ `ztkhflx ti& kohf|dkob
`o{ `ztkhflx iz d`t` ~lzt`kokob ti `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkee x& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/ [i|z `oxrlz a|xt kohf|dl kotlzolt
rlj `ddzlxxlx eiz l`hm& flobtm ie alajlzxmk~& `ff |xlzo`alx& tml o`al ie tml
`ztkhflx x|~~fkld& `o{ `od `ff koeiza`tkio x|~~fkld& `od `o{ hiaa|okh`tkiox
koeiza`tkio xm`zkob& zlb`zdkob `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx ezia G`o|`z{ 0& :>>= |otkf tml d`tl ko
rmkhm {i| `oxrlz tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx/ ^fl`xl ~ziukdl tml e|ff hiotlotx ie tml
`ztkhflx& hiaa|okh`tkiox& koeiza`tkio xm`zkob& dih|alot`tkio& lth/ `od ~ziukdl `
hi~{ ie tml x`al/
@OXRLZ7
0<:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :5 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70::;;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 153/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 154/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :2
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlz‛x d`t` ko |xl d|zkob tml
zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid ie tmkx fktkb`tkio/ [i|z dlxhzk~tkio xmi|fd kohf|dl& j|t kx oit
fkaktld ti zlaitl `hhlxx ~lzakxxkiox ezia `eekfk`tlx)hiffl`b|lx kohf|dkob j|t oit
fkaktld ti lflhtziokh a`kf rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio `od ~~fkh`tkiox/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ :47
Ke {i| hiotlod tm`t `o{ ~lzxio& j|xkolxx& hiz~iz`tkio iz lotkt{& j{ zl`xio ie
`o `ht iz iakxxkio iz itmlzrkxl& h`|xld iz hiotzkj|tld ti tml kog|zklx x|eelzld j{
^f`kotkeex& `x i|tfkold ko ^f`kotkeex hia~f`kot& kdlotke{ l`hm x|hm ~lzxio& j|xkolxx&
hiz~iz`tkio iz lotkt{ iz hia~`o{ j{ o`al& `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz& `od
l}~f`ko tml j`xkx eiz tmkx hiotlotkio& kohf|dkob tml kdlotkt{ ie `ff dih|alotx `od)iz
rktolxxlx tm`t x|~~izt {i|z hf`ka/
@OXRLZ7
0<4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl := ie 80 ^`bl KD(70:8>0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 155/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :=
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ :<7
M`ul [i|& Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia& Olkf X`ocl{ iz
X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox lulz jllo dlokld iz h`ohlffld `o{ x|jxhzk~tkio iz `hhi|ot
eiz `o{ zl`xio rktm Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx/hia& Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/& @hh|zkot
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx
Bzi|~& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& Hmikhl^ikot iz `o{ itmlz d`t` jziclz& ke xi& ~fl`xl
~ziukdl tml e|ff o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& zl`xio eiz tlzako`tkio iz zl`xio
eiz zle|x`f ie `o `hhi|ot& tml d`tl ie h`ohlff`tkio& tlzako`tkio iz zle|x`f `od tml
zl`xiox `od hkzh|axt`ohlx zlf`tkob ti tml h`ohlff`tkio& tlzako`tkio iz zle|x`f/
@OXRLZ7
Zlx~lhte|ff{ x|jakttld&
D`tld7 G`o|`z{ 0;& :>0: YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
@ttizol{ eiz ^f`kotkeex
0<<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :; ie 80 ^`bl KD(70:8>:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 156/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
7777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX HLZTKEKH@TL IE
XLZUKHL
K& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& mlzlj{ hlztke{ ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie ^f`kotkeex
Kotlzzib tizklx ~zi~i|odld |~io Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{ rlzl xlzuld tmzi|bm La`kf `od
Ekzxt Hf`xx A`kf rktm ^ixt`bl e|ff{ ~zl~`kd tmkx 0;tm
d`{ ie G`o|`z{ :>0:& |~io tml
eiffirkob7
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp|kzl
F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
<282 C`o`o Zi`d& X|ktl 842
@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0
La`kf7 ahifloNhiflof`r/hiaXkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio7 :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0=<
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7 Olkf X`ocl{3 Tidd X`ocl{3
X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
0<5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8> ie 80 ^`bl KD(70:8>8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 157/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 8>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
Gimo @ Uibt& Gz/& Lxp|kzl
Ldr`zd X`o Hm`ob& Lxp|kzl
Giolx D`{8050 Akhmlfxio Dzkul& X|ktl =>>
Kzukol& H@ ;:50:
La`kf7 g`uibtNgiolxd`{/hia
La`kf7 lhm`obNgiolxd`{/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/
G`alx E AhH`jl& Lxp|kzl
Aizzkxio % Eilzxtlz4:< A`zclt Xtzllt
X`o Ez`ohkxhi& H@ ;40><!:4=:La`kf7 gahh`jlNaiei/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7
Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& Koh
Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Xlkxkot& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Hmikhl~ikot& Koh/
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0<2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!5 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 80 ie 80 ^`bl KD(70:8>4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 158/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖2‑
0<=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8><
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 159/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIOX @DDZLXXLD TI
DLELOD@OT TIDD X@OCL[ ‘ XLT IOL
^FL@XL T@CL OITKHL& ko `hhizd`ohl rktm Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ :5 `od 84
{i| `zl mlzlj{ oitkekld `od zlp|kzld ti zlx~iod ti tml eiffirkob Zlp|lxt Eiz
^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld j{ ^f`kotkeex Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& Bi
L}hlf Bfij`f& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl `od Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
Smlzlko`etlz ‖ f`kotkeex‑Q mlzlko& tmzi|bm tmlkz `ttizol{ ie zlhizd& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
Lxp|kzl& F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& <<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80& rktmko tmkzt{ S8>Q d`{x ezia xlzukhl mlzlie ko
`hhizd`ohl rktm tml ~ziukxkiox ie tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie Hkukf ^zihld|zl/
0<;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8>5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 160/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
[i| `zl e|ztmlz ~f`hld io oitkhl& ~|zx|`ot ti Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ :5-l+& tm`t tmlxl
Zlp|lxt Eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx `zl dllald hiotko|kob& zlp|kzkob
x|~~flalot f ~zid|htkio tmlzlti ko tml lulot zlp|lxtld dih|alotx jlhial
`u`kf`jfl rmkhm ri|fd zlp|kzl `alodalot iz x|~~flalot`tkio ie {i|z zlx~ioxlx ko
izdlz tm`t tml{ ri|fd jl ~zi~lz `od tz|tme|f& jlhial coiro ti {i|/
^|zx|`ot ti Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ 84-j+& ^f`kotkeex zlp|lxt tm`t Dlelod`ot& Tidd
X`ocl{ ~zid|hl zlx~ioxkul lflhtziokh ff{ xtizld koeiza`tkio S‖LXK‑Q ko tml
eiza`t i|tfkold ko @~~lodk} ‖@‑ `od `hhizdkob ti tml LXK B|kdlfkolx
hiot`kold ko @~~lodk} ‖J‑/
DLEKOKTKIOX
Eiz ~|z~ixlx ie tmkx Ekzxt Xlt ie Zlp|lxtx eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx& tml
eiffirkob tlzax m`ul tml al`okob xlt eiztm jlfir7
0/ ‖^f`kotkeex‑ zlelzx ti Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& Bi L}hlf Bfij`f& mkfk~
G/ Jlzb& Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& tmlkz X~i|xlx& Hmkfdzlo `od)iz E`akf{
Alajlzx/
:/ ‖Dlelod`ot* xm`ff al`o Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{/
8/ ‖^li~fl Ekodlz d`t`‑ xm`ff al`o Dirofi`d`jfl hia~|tlz xietr`zl
o`alf{ hiff`jiz`tkio xietr`zl& eiz tml e`hkfkt`tkio& `o`f{xkx `od lu`f|`tkio ie
hiox|alz `od ~li~fl d`t`& coirfldbl `od ~zihlxxlx& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti
xietr`zl |tkfkwld ti ~|ff xihk`f ~ziekfkob ie hiox|alz `od ~li~fl d`t`& eko`ohk`f
05>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8>2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 161/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 162/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 4
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
xmirkob& alotkiokob& zleflhtkob& ~lzt`kokob ti& dl`fkob rktm& zlf`tkob ti ko `o{ r`{
iz a`oolz& iz ko `o{ a`oolz rm`txilulz ~lztkolot ti tml x|jglht/
0>/ ‖H|xtialz‑ iz ‖H|xtialzx‑ al`o ~li~fl rmi mkzl Tidd X`ocl{ eiz
~zku`tl koulxtkb`tkio e|ohtkiox/
00/ ‖Dih|alot‑ iz ‖Dih|alotx‑ zlelzx ti `o{ `od `ff rzktkobx ie `o{
ckod `od xm`ff kohf|dl tml izkbko`f `od l`hm oio!kdlotkh`f hi~{ iz dz`et tmlzlie/
Tml tlza m`x tml x`al al`okob `x ‖rzktkobx‑& rmkhm kx dlekold ko Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/
84-`+ `od Eld/ Z/ Lukd/ 0>>0 `x kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti `o{ lflhtziokh`ff{
xtizld d`t`& d`t`j`xlx& dih|alotx& `od lflhtziokh hiaa|okh`tkiox -x|hm `x La`kf+
xtizld ko hia~|tlzx iz itmlzrkxl& rmltmlz iz oit lulz ~zkotld iz dkx~f`{ld& tm`t
m`ul oit ~zluki|xf{ jllo ~zid|hld/ @ hi~{ iz d|~fkh`tl ie ` dih|alot tm`t m`x
`o{ oiohioeizakob oitlx& a`zbko`f `ooit`tkiox& iz itmlz a`zckobx& `x rlff `x `o{
~zlfkako`z{ ulzxkio& dz`et& iz zlukxkio ie tml eizlbikob& xm`ff jl hioxkdlzld `
xl~`z`tl dih|alot rktmko tml al`okob ie tmkx tlza/ Tml tlza Dih|alot xm`ff `fxi
kohf|dl lulz{ itmlz al`ox j{ rmkhm koeiza`tkio kx zlhizdld iz tz`oxakttld
kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti& lflhtziokh La`kf& Kotlzolt ~ixtkobx& t`~l zlhizdkobx
ukdli zlhizdkobx& akhziekfax& ~|ohm h`zdx& hia~|tlz a`boltkh t`~l& hia~|tlz
dkxcx& hia~|tlz ~zibz`ax& xtiz`bl t`~lx& ~zkoti|tx& d`t` ~zihlxxkob zlhizdx& `od tml
rzkttlo koeiza`tkio olhlxx`z{ ti |odlzxt`od `od |xl x|hm koeiza`tkio/
05:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8>;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 163/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ <
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
0:/ ‖La~fi{ll‑ iz ‖La~fi{llx‑ xm`ff al`o o{ ~lzxio la~fi{ld j{ {i|
iz `htkob `x `o `blot eiz {i|/
08/ *^lzxio‑& ‖~lzxiox‑ iz ‖~li~fl‑ kx kdlotkekld `x `o{ o`t|z`f ~lzxiox
gikot irolzx& `xxihk`tkiox& hia~`oklx& gikot ulot|zlx& ~`ztolzxmk~x& hiz~iz`tkiox
tz|xtx& lxt`tlx& `blohklx& dl~`ztalotx iz j|zl`|x -biulzoalot`f iz ~zku`tl+
`eekfk`tlx& j|xkolxx `bbzlb`tlx& iz `o{ j|xkolxx& flb`f iz biulzoalot`f lotkt{/
04/ ‖[i|‑ iz ‖{i|z‑ al`ox tml ~lzxio iz lotkt{ zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl
Zlp|lxtx& `od `o{ ~zlxlot iz eizalz la~fi{llx& `blotx& hiox|ft`otx& iz itmlz
~lzxiox `htkob iz ~|z~iztkob ti `ht io jlm`fe ie x|hm ~lzxio iz lotkt{/
0</ Tml tlza *kohf|dkob* al`ox kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti `od)iz
kohf|dkob rktmi|t fkakt`tkio/
05/ Tml xkob|f`z eiza ie ` rizd xm`ff jl kotlz~zltld `x tml ~f|z`f `od tml
~f|z`f eiza ie ` rizd xm`ff jl kotlz~zltld `x tml xkob|f`z rmlolulz `~~zi~zk`tl ko
izdlz ti jzkob rktmko tml xhi~l ie tmkx Zlp|lxt Eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx `o{
koeiza`tkio tm`t akbmt itmlzrkxl jl hioxkdlzld ti jl jl{iod tmlkz xhi~l/
02/ Tml hioolhtkulx *`od* `od *iz* xm`ff jl hioxtz|ld lktmlz dkxg|ohtkulf{
iz hiog|ohtkulf{ `x olhlxx`z{ ti jzkob rktmko tml xhi~l ie tmkx Dkxhiulz{ `o{
koeiza`tkio tm`t akbmt itmlzrkxl jl hioxtz|ld ti jl i|txkdl ie tmlkz xhi~l/
0=/ Tml ~zlxlot tloxl xm`ff jl hioxtz|ld ti kohf|dl tml ~`xt tloxl `od tml
~`xt tloxl xm`ff jl hioxtz|ld ti kohf|dl tml ~zlxlot tloxl `x olhlxx`z{ ti jzkob
058
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:80>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 164/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 5
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
rktmko tml xhi~l ie tmkx Dkxhiulz{ `o{ koeiza`tkio tm`t akbmt itmlzrkxl jl
hioxtz|ld ti jl i|txkdl tmlkz xhi~l/
KOXTZ\HTKIOX
0/ Tmlxl zlp|lxtx eiz tml ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx `zl hiotko|kob `od
zlp|kzl tml xlzukhl ie x|~~flalot`f `oxrlzx ~zid|hld ko `hhizd`ohl rktm tml
zlp|kzlalotx ie Eldlz`f Z|fl ie Hkukf ^zihld|zl Z|fl :5-l+/
:/ Ko zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl zlp|lxtx& {i| xm`ff ~zid|hl `ff zlx~ioxkul
dih|alotx tm`t `zl ko {i|z ~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{ iz hiotzif iz tml ~ixxlxxkio&
h|xtid{ iz hiotzif ie {i|z ~zldlhlxxizx& x|hhlxxizx& ~`zlotx& x|jxkdk`zklx&
dkukxkiox& iz `eekfk`tlx& iz `o{ ie tmlkz zlx~lhtkul ieekhlzx& a`o`bkob `blotx
la~fi{llx& `ttizol{x& `hhi|ot`otx iz itmlz zl~zlxlot`tkulx/ @ dih|alot xm`ff jl
dllald ti jl rktmko {i|z hiotzif ke {i| m`ul tml zkbmt ti xlh|zl tml dih|alot iz `
hi~{ ie tml dih|alot ezia `oitmlz ~lzxio m`ukob ~ixxlxxkio iz h|xtid{ ie tml
dih|alot/
8/ [i| `zl ti ~zid|hl& eiz kox~lhtkio `od hi~{kob& izkbko`f zlx~ioxkul
dih|alotx ko tml izdlz tml{ `zl cl~t ko tml |x|`f hi|zxl ie j|xkolxx& `od x|hm
dih|alotx xm`ff jl ~zid|hld ko tmlkz izkbko`f eifdlzx& jkodlzx& hiulzx& iz
hiot`kolzx& iz e`hxkakfl tmlzlie/
054
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:800
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 165/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 166/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ =
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
d/ @ dlxhzk~tkio ie tml x|jglht a`ttlz ie tml dih|alot3
l/ Tml d`tl ie dlxtz|htkio iz itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
e/ @ xt`tlalot ie tml zl`xiox eiz dlxtz|htkio iz itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
b/ Tml o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& ihh|~`tkio& tktfl `od
j|xkolxx `eekfk`tkio ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi `|tmizkwld dlxtz|htkio iz
itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
m/ Tml o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& ihh|~`tkio& tktfl `od
j|xkolxx `eekfk`tkio ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi dlxtzi{ld iz dkx~ixld ie
tml dih|alot3 `od
k/ Tml Zlp|lxt iz Zlp|lxtx ti rmkhm tml dih|alot kx zlx~ioxkul/
2/ Ke `o{ dih|alot zlx~ioxkul ti tmlxl zlp|lxtx kx rktmmlfd |odlz `
hf`ka ie ~zkukflbl iz |~io `o{ itmlz bzi|od& `x ti l`hm x|hm dih|alot& ~ziukdl tml
eiffirkob koeiza`tkio ko x|eekhklot dlt`kf ti ~lzakt tml Hi|zt ti z|fl io {i|z hf`ka7
`/ Tml o`t|zl ie tml ~zkukflbl jlkob xxlztld iz itmlz z|fl zlfkld |~io
`od tml e`htx x|~~iztkob {i|z `xxlztkio tmlzlie3
j/ Tml ~`zt{ rmi kx `xxlztkob tml ~zkukflbl3 `od
h/ Tml eiffirkob koeiza`tkio `ji|t tml ~|z~iztldf{ ~zkukflbld
dih|alot7
-k+ Tml `|tmiz& ~zka`z{ `ddzlxxll& `od xlhiod`z{ ddzlxxllx
iz ~lzxiox hi~kld& kohf|dkob tml zlf`tkioxmk~ ie tmixl
~lzxiox ti `o{ ~`zt{ ko tmkx fktkb`tkio `od)iz `|tmiz iedih|alot3
-kk+ @ jzkle dlxhzk~tkio x|eekhklot ti kdlotke{ tml t{~l& x|jglht
a`ttlz& `od ~|z~ixl ie tml dih|alot3
-kkk+ @ff ~lzxiox ti rmia ktx hiotlotx m`ul jllo dkxhfixld3
055
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl ; ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:808
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 167/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ ;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
-ku+ Tml d`tl tml dih|alot r`x ~zl~`zld& tml d`tl tml
dih|alot jl`zx& tml d`tl tml dih|alot r`x xlot& `od tml
d`tl tml dih|alot r`x zlhlkuld3 `od
-u+ @ ~zlhkxl dlxhzk~tkio ie tml ~f`hl rmlzl l`hm hi~{ ie
tm`t dih|alot kx cl~t& kohf|dkob tml tktfl iz dlxhzk~tkio ie
tml ekfl ko rmkhm x`kd dih|alot a`{ jl ei|od `od tml
fih`tkio ie x|hm ekfl/
=/ Ke ` ~iztkio ie `o{ dih|alot zlx~ioxkul ti tmlxl zlp|lxtx kx rktmmlfd
|odlz hf`ka ie ~zkukflbl ~|zx|`ot ti tml ~zlhldkob koxtz|htkio& `o{ oio!~zkukflbld
~iztkio ie x|hm dih|alot a|xt jl ~zid|hld rktm tml ~iztkio hf`kald ti jl
~zkukflbld zld`htld/
;/ [i| `zl ti ~zid|hl l`hm dih|alot zlp|lxtld mlzlko ko ktx lotkzlt{
rktmi|t dlfltkio iz l}hkxkio -l}hl~t `x p| fkekld j{ tml ~zlhldkob tri S:Q
koxtz|htkiox+& zlb`zdflxx ie rmltmlz {i| hioxkdlz tml lotkzl dih|alot ti jl zlflu`ot
iz zlx~ioxkul ti tml zlp|lxtx/
0>/ Rmlolulz ` dih|alot kx oit ~zid|hld ko ktx lotkzlt{& kohf|dkob `ff
`tt`hmalotx& iz kx ~zid|hld ko zld`htld eiza& xi kodkh`tl io tml dih|alot& xt`tl
rktm ~`ztkh|f`zkt{ tml zl`xio iz zl`xiox kt kx oit jlkob ~zid|hld ko ktx lotkzlt{& `od
dlxhzkjl ti tml jlxt ie {i|z coirfldbl& koeiza`tkio `od jlfkle `od rktm `x a|hm
~`ztkh|f`zkt{ `x ~ixxkjfl& tmixl ~iztkiox ie tml dih|alot tm`t `zl oit jlkob
~zid|hld/
052
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:804
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 168/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
00/ \oflxx rizdx iz tlzax m`ul jllo bkulo ` x~lhkekh dlekoktkio mlzlko
l`hm rizd iz tlza |xld mlzlko xm`ff jl bkulo ktx |x|`f `od h|xtia`z{ dkhtkio`z{
dlekoktkio l}hl~t rmlzl x|hm rizdx m`ul ` x~lhkekh h|xtia `od |x`bl dlekoktkio ko
{i|z tz`dl iz kod|xtz{& ko rmkhm h`xl tml{ xm`ff jl kotlz~zltld ko `hhizd`ohl rktm
x|hm |x|`f h|xtia `od |x`bl dlekoktkio ie rmkhm {i| `zl `r`zl/ Ko hioxtz|kob tml
kop|kz{ `od zlp|lxt mlzlko7 -k+ tml xkob|f`z xm`ff kohf|dl tml ~f|z`f `od tml ~f|z`f
xm`ff kohf|dl tml xkob|f`z3 -kk+ ` a`xh|fkol& elakokol& iz ol|tlz ~zioi|o xm`ff oit
l}hf|dl tml itmlz blodlzx3 -kkk+ tml tlza ‖`o{‑ `od ‖`ff‑ xm`ff jl |odlzxtiid ti
al`o ‖`o{ `od `ff‑3 `od -ku+ tml rizdx ‖`od‑ `od ‖iz‑ xm`ff jl zl`d ko tml
hiog|ohtkul iz dkxg|ohtkul iz jitm& `x tml h`xl a`{ jl& `ff ti tml lod tm`t tml
kotlz~zlt`tkio `~~fkld zlx|ftx ko tml aizl l}~`oxkul ~zid|htkio/
TKAL ^LZKID
\oflxx itmlzrkxl xt`tld ko ` Zlp|lxt& `ff Dih|alotx zlp|lxtld `zl zlp|lxtld
eiz tml ~lzkid ie tkal ezia G`o|`z{ 0& :>>= tmzi|bm tml d`tl ie ~zid|htkio `od
kohf|dl rktmko tmlkz xhi~l Dih|alotx rmkhm zlelz iz zlf`tl ti `ff iz `o{ ~iztkio ie
tm`t ~lzkid/ Dih|alotx e`ff rktmko tmkx tkal ~lzkid ke tml{ zleflht ~ifkhklx `od)iz
~z`htkhlx ko leelht d|zkob tml tkal ~lzkid& lulo ke tml dih|alotx rlzl rzkttlo iz
hzl`tld jleizl tml zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid/
05=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 00 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:80<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 169/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 00
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
DIH\ALOTX ZLP\LXTLD
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 07 @ff dih|alotx `od lflhtziokh
d`t`& kohf|dkob L!A`kfx rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio& Hiaa|okh`tkiox& Zl~iztx
koeiza`tkio& ~mitibz`~mx& ukdlibz`~m{& hiohlzokob l`hm ie tml o`ald ^f`kotkeex&
^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo od ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :7 ^ziukdl ff lflhtziokh a`kf rktm
e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio ezia lulz{ L!a`kf `hhi|ot |xld ko hiod|htkob `o{ `od `f
hioulzx`tkiox ko zlb`zdx ti `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo od)iz f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 87
@ff dih|alotx rktm tml ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixlx fkxtld tm`t [I\ ~ziukdld ti
`o{ lotkt{& flb`f iz itmlzrkxl& kohf|dkob `o{ ie tml Dlelod`otx& ti ijt`ko Zl~iztx
Koeiza`tkio& D`t`& Hzldkt Zl~iztx iz `o{ t{~l ie `hhlxx ti tml ^f`kotkeex ^li~fl
Ekodlz D`t`& ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx `od)iz ^lzxio`f Koeiza`tkio io ^f`kotkeex
^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
05;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:805
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 170/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 47 @ff hiotz`htx& `bzllalotx
dih|alotx `od koeiza`tkio lktmlz ko ~`~lz iz lflhtziokh eiza`t hiohlzokob
`bzllalotx `od hizzlx~iodlohl rktm tmkzd!~`ztklx& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti
Alzfko& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \X Xl`zhm& Hioek!Hmlc& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx/hia& Fl}kxOl}kx
Bzi|~& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio
@o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/& Coir]& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& @hh|zkot& Dl~`ztalot ie Aitiz
Ulmkhflx& Biulzoalot lotktklx& Hi|ztx& Xt`tl @blohklx& lth/ ti ijt`ko hiox|alz
h|xtialzx& `od)iz ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex
E`akf{ Alajlz‛x ^li~fl Ekodlz D`t`& ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx& Eko`ohk`f D`t`& Hzldkt
D`t`& ^lzxio`f Kdlotke{kob d`t`& Hzkako`f d`t`& ml`ftm d`t`& aldkh`f d`t`
ld|h`tkio`f d`t`& mial u`f|lx& kohial d`t`& lth/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ <7 ^ziukdl `o{ `od @ff dih|alotx
koeiza`tkio& `bzllalotx& hizzlx~iodlohl kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti ~`~lz `od
lflhtziokh eiza`t& hiaalohld jltrllo [I\ `od `o{ ie tml itmlz o`ald
Dlelod`otx ko tmkx f`rx|kt/
ZLX^IOXL7
02>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 08 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:802
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 171/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 08
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 57 ^ziukdl `ff d t & kohf|dkob
l`hm ~lzxio `od)iz lotkt{ hiot`htld& tmlkz o`alx `ddzlxxlx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx
`ff lflhtziokh a`kf hiaa|okh`tkiox rktm tml e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio& tlfl~miokh
hioulzx`tkiox& ~lzxio`f alltkobx -eiz ~lzxio`f alltkobx ~ziukdl tml d`tl& tkal
fih`tkio `od rmi tml alltkob r`x rktm+ ko b`tmlzkob `o{ koeiza`tkio ~lzt kokob ti
`o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo& `od)iz ^f`kotkeex
E`akf{ Alajlzx/ Ko zlx~iodkob ti tmkx zlp|lxt& ~fl`xl kohf|dl `o{ xt`tlalotx
[I\ a`dl ti `o{ kodkukd|`f `x ti rm{ {i| rlzl b`tmlzkob koeiza`tkio io `o{ ie
tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex E`akf{
Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 27 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff X|j~ilo`x
iz rzkttlo zlp|lxtx kxx|ld ti b`ko koeiza`tkio io `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& f`kotkeex
X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo& `od)iz ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/ [I\Z zlx~ioxl
ti tmkx zlp|lxt xmi|fd hiot`ko tml o`al ie tml Kodkukd|`f iz Lotkt{ X|j~ilo`ld iz
zlp|lxtld eiz koeiza`tkio& tmlkz @ddzlxx `od Tlfl~miol o|ajlz3 zlhizdx xi|bmt&
d`tl `od tkal tml X|j~ilo`& dih|alot iz koeiza`tkio zlp|lxtx rlzl xlzuld& mir
tml x|j~ilo` iz zlp|lxt rlzl xlzuld `od ` hi~{ ie rm`t {i| zlhlkuld iz `o{ dlok`f
tmlzlie/
ZLX^IOXL7
020
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 04 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:80=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 172/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 04
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ =7 ^ziukdl `ff lflhtziokh a k
rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio& `od hm`t fibx jltrllo [I\& `o{ tmkzd ~`zt{ `od `o{
ie tml Dlelod`otx zlb`zdkob `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo od)iz f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ ;7 ^ziukdl `ff dih|alotx& d`t`
hia~kf`tkiox& `od t`obkjfl tmkobx tm`t [I\ a`{ |xl ti x|~~izt [i|z dleloxlx ti
tml hf`kax ko ^f`kotkeex hia~f`kot/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 0>7 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff dih|alotx
hiohlzokob `o{ hm`oblx iz `ftlz`tkiox {i| a`dl ti `o{ dih|alot [I\ ijt`kold iz
`o{ dih|alotx ko [I\Z ~ixxlxxkio io ^f`kotkeex& ^f kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo `od)iz f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/ Tml dih|alotx xmi|fd l}~fkhktf{
dl~kht tml hm`oblx iz `ftlz`tkiox {i| a`dl& j{ |xkob ` mkbmfkbmtlz/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 007 ^ziukdl ff dih|alotx
~lzt`kokob ti `o{ `od `ff koulxtkb`tkiox [I\ hiod|htld io `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex
^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo od ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
02:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0< ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:80;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 173/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 0:7 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff dih|alotx
hiohlzokob od3)iz ~lzt kokob ti [I\Z zlx~ioxl ti o{ kop|kz{ iz koulxtkb`tkio j{
`o{ biulzoalot`f jid{& f`r loeizhlalot `bloh{& Xt`tl @bloh{& iz tzkj|o`f& iz
`o{ hiox|alz bzi|~ iz izb`okw`tkio& koti Hia~f`kotx a`dl `b`koxt iz j{ tml
^f`kotkeex& f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 087 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff dih|alotx
hiohlzokob iz zlelzzkob ti [I\Z ~ifkhklx `od ~zihld|zlx zlb`zdkob tml dlxtz|htkio
iz zltlotkio ie dih|alotx& lflhtziokh d`t` iz itmlz koeiza`tkio/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 047 ^ziukdl `ff j|xkolxx hiotz`htx
hiotz`htx& `od)iz `bzllalotx [I\ m`ul rktm Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx/hia
Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& @hh|zkot& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Zlld
Lfxluklz& Koh/& L}~lzk`o& Lp|ke`}& Tz`ox\okio& Coir} `od tml ~lzakxxkjfl
~|z~ixl [i| ~ziukdld `od |xld ti `hhlxx tml ^f`kotkeex d`t`/
ZLX^IOXL7
028
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 05 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8:>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 174/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 05
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 0<7 ^ziukdl ` hi~{ ie ff d`t`
`fiob rktm ` hia~fltl fkxt ie ff lotktklx `od kodkukd|`fx& tmlkz o`alx& `ddzlxxlx `od
tlfl~miol o|ajlzx& ^f`kotkeex d`t` m`x jllo ~ziukdld ti `x rlff `x t{~lx ie d`t`
tz`oxelzzld `od tml o`alx& tktfl& j|xkolxx& `ddzlxx& mial `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol
o|ajlz ie `ff kodkukd|`fx ~ixxlxxkob tml h`~`hkt{ iz h`~`jkfkt{ eiz x|hm tz`oxelz
kohf|dkob fkxtx `od o`alx ie `ff hiot`htx rktm lflhtziokh a`kf/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 057 ^ziukdl `ff dih|alotx
hiotz`htx& `bzllalotx& hizzlx~iodlohl& `od lflhtziokh d`t` tz`oxelzx [I\ m`ul
rktm Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Alzfko& \X Xl`zhm& Hioek!Hmlc& Koh/& `od `o{ ie tml itmlz
o`ald Dlelod`otx ti ijt`ko iz ~ziukdl koeiza`tkio& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti
~lzxio`f kdlotke{kob koeiza`tkio& ~li~fl ekodlz d`t`& ~lzxio`f kdlotkeklzx& eko`ohk`f
d`t`& hzldkt d`t`& aldkh`f d`t`& kohial d`t`& hzkako`f d`t`& lth/ ~lzt`kokob ti {i|z
h|xtialzx& hfklotx& hiox|alzx& kohf|dkob ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo& ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx `od {i|z ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl |xld ti ijt`ko
tml d`t`/
ZLX^IOXL7
024
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 02 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8:0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 175/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 02
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 027 ^ziukdl `ff dih|alot`tkio
hizzlx~iodlohl& hiotz`htx `od `bzllalotx jltrllo [I\ `od [ixle T`ktw& `od
D`{fkbmt Hmlakh`f Koeiza`tkio X{xtlax& Koh/& iz tmlkz la~fi{llx& hiotz`htizx& iz
i|txkdl ulodizx& tmlkz `ddzlxxlx `od ~miol o|ajlzx `x rlff `x tml lflhtziokh d`t`
tm`t kx xm`zld jltrllo izb`okw`tkiox/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 0=7 ^ziukdl `ff fkhloxlx {i| mifd ti
~lzeiza {i|z zku`tl Koulxtkb`tiz e|ohtkiox/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 0;7 ^ziukdl `ff xl`zhmlx ~lzeizald
j{ [I\ rktm `o{ Kodkukd|`f& @bloh{& Lotkt{& J|xkolxx& Hiz~iz`tkio& `o{ ie tml
o`ald Dlelod`otx ko tmkx f`rx|kt& Hi|zt‛x& Hi|ot{ Zlhizdx& Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{
@dakokxtz`tkio& Kotlzo`f Zlulo|l Xlzukhl& Biulzoalot`f iz Xt`tl @bloh{& lth/ io
`o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo& ^f`kotkeex E`akf{
Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
02<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0= ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8::
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 176/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0=
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :>7 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
hia~f kotx {i| m`ul zlhlkuld zlb`zdkob `o{ ie [I\Z ~zku tl koulxtkb`tkio
e|ohtkiox/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :07 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
dih|alot`tkio& hizzlx~iodlohl& koeiza`tkio `od d`t`& ko `ff eizax kohf|dkob
lflhtziokh`ff{& ~lzt`kokob ti ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo
`od)iz ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx& ~ziukdld ti `od xm`zld rktm `o{ @eekfk`tlx
Kodkukd|`fx& Zl~iztlzx& Rljxktlx& Jfibx& ZXX Elldx& j|xkolxx `bbzlb`tlx3 8zd
~`zt{
lotktklx3 `o{ ie tml Dlelod`otx3 `od `o{ itmlz j|xkolxx& hiz~iz`tkio& biulzoalot
lotkt{& hi|ztx& hzldkt zl~iztkob `blohklx& `od)iz xt`tl `blohklx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ ::7 ^zid|hl hi~klx ie `ff
dih|alotx tm t [I\ zluklrld iz zlfkld |~io ko zlx~iodkob ti tml ~zlhldkob
kotlzzib`tizklx `od Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox `od hi~klx ie `ff dih|alotx zlelzlohld
ko {i|z zlx~ioxl ti tml ~zlhldkob kotlzzib`tizklx `od Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox/
ZLX^IOXL7
025
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0; ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8:8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 177/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :87 ^ziukdl ` hia~fltl fkxt
rktm o`alx& `ddzlxxlx& rlj `ddzlxxlx& `od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx& `fiob rktm `ff
koeiza`tkio zlhlkuld& ie `ff lotktklx& kohf|dkob tmkzd ~ zt{ d t`j`xlx |tkfkwld j{
[I\ ti ijt`ko `o{ t{~l ie koeiza`tkio io ^f kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/ L/b/& Dl~`ztalotx ie ^|jfkh X`elt{
Lp|ke`}& Tz`ox\okio& L}~lzk`o& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx& T`} @xxlxxizx
Ieekhlx& Hi|ot{ Zlhizdx& Xt`tl Zlhizdx& Tktfl Hia~`oklx& Eko`ohk`f Koxtkt|tkiox
lth/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :47 ^ziukdl ` hi~{ ie `o{
dih|alot& kohf|dkob lflhtziokh a`kf rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio `od flttlzx [I\
x|jakttld ti `o{ `bloh{& lotkt{ iz kodkukd|`fx zlb`zdkob `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex&
^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo od)iz f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :<7 ^ziukdl `ff Kotlzolt ~ixtx a`dl
j{ [I\ `ji|t `o{ ie tml f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo& `od)iz
^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
022
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :> ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8:4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 178/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :57 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
dih|alot`tkio& Zl~iztx& Oitlx& Ekflx& [I\ ~|ffld& `hhlxxld iz hia~kfld io `o{ ie
tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex E`akf{
Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :27 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff dih|alotx
~lzt kokob ti `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od
^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx [I\ ~ziukdld ti `o{ tmkzd ~`ztklx& kohf|dkob tml itmlz
Dlelod`otx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :=7 ^ziukdl `ff ~ifkhklx& a`o|`fx
Koxtz|htkiox& @bzllalotx& Hiotz`htx& Dih|alotx& iz `o{tmkob ~lzt`kokob ti [I\ iz
Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/‛x ~ifkh{ zlb`zdkob koulxtkb`tkio tlhmokp|lx |xld io
kodkukd|`fx `od mir tml ~zku`tl d`t` ie `o{ `od `ff kodkukd|`fx& ko rmkhm [I\
koulxtkb`tl& kx ti jl m`odfld `od tzl`tld/
ZLX^IOXL7
02=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :0 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8:<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 179/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :;7 ^ziukdl `ff ~ifkhklx& a`o|`fx
koxtz|htkiox& dih|alot`tkio& Hiotz`htx& @bzllalotx& j|xkolxx hiotz`htx& iz
`o{tmkob ~lzt kokob ti [I\ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x ~ifkhklx zlb`zdkob tml
hioekdlotk`fkt{ ie koeiza`tkio ~ziukdld io `o{ kodkukd|`f iz hia~`o{ ti [I\Z
hfklotx `od rm`t {i|z ~zihlxx kx ti lox|zl `ff d`t` zla`kox ~zku`tl `od hioekdlotk`f/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 8>7 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
dih|alot`tkio& hiotz`htx `od `bzllalotx [I\ `od)iz Tml X`ocl{ Ekza lotlzld
koti rktm `o{ ie tml Dlelod`otx ti tmkx f`rx|kt/
ZLX^IOXL7
Zlx~lhte|ff{ x|jakttld&
D`tld7 G`o|`z{ 0;& :>0: YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
@ttizol{ eiz ^f`kotkeex
02;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :: ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8:5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 180/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ ::
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=@^^LODK] ‖@‑
0=>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :8 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8:2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 181/383
0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
@^^LODK] ‖@‑Ti ^f`kotkeex Ekzxt Zlp|lxtx eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx7
^f`kotkeex zlp|lxtld lflhtziokh`ff{ Xtizld Koeiza`tkio ^zid|htkio Eiza`t
^|zx|`ot ti Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ 84-j+& ^f`kotkeex a`{ x~lhke{ tml eiza iz eizax ko
rmkhm lflhtziokh`ff{ xtizld koeiza`tkio S‖LXK‑Q kx ti jl ~zid|hld/ @x x|hm
^f`kotkeex zlp|lxt tm`t `ff LXK jl ~zid|hld ko ‖o`tkul‑ eiza`t& tibltmlz rktm `o
‖ka`bld‑ ekfl rktm tml hizzlx~iodkob ‖ka`bl fi`d ekfl‑& ‖IHZ tl}t ekfl‑& `od tml
‖`xxihk`tld alt`hiotlot ie tml d`t`j`xl‑/ Tml cl{ hiohl~tx `zl l}~f`kold jlfir7
0/ O`tkul7 tml eiza`t ko rmkhm tml lflhtziokh`ff{ xtizld koeiza`tkio r`x
izkbko`ff{ hzl`tld -l/b/& Akhzixiet Rizd& Akhzixiet L}hlf& Akxhzixiet @hhlxx+3 `
0=0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :4 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8:=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 182/383
:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ekfl ~`tm ti tml o`tkul ekfl xm`ff jl ~ziukdld ko tml alt hiotlot ie tml d`t j`xl `x
dlxhzkjld ko aizl dlt`kf jlfir/
:/ Ka`bld7 ` TKEE iz ^DE ka`bl hioulztld ezia tml o`tkul ekfl `x kt r`x
izkbko`ff{ hzl`tld3
`/ @ff ka`blx xm`ff jl jf`hc `od rmktl3
j/ J`tlx o|ajlzx xm`ff jl jz`odld ti tml ka`blx xi tm`t tml o|ajlzx ~zkot3
h/ Ka`blx xm`ff jl xkobfl ~`bl TKEE‛x iz iol TKEE ekfl eiz l`hm ~`bl -oit
iol TKEE ekfl eiz l`hm dih|alot+3
8/ Ka`bl Fi`d Ekflx7 @ fi`d ekfl ko ` xt`od`zd fi`d eiza`t -l/b/& `xhkk&
dkk& I~tkhio+ xm`ff jl ~ziukdld rmkhm ~ziukdlx7
`/ Tml dih|alot o|ajlz eiz l`hm ka`bl3
j/ Tml e|ff ~`tm o`al-x+ ie l`hm TKEE tm`t zl~zlxlotx o ka`bl3
h/ Tml dih|alot ji|od`zklx eiz l`hm dih|alot iz e`akf{ alajlz
bzi|~kob hioxkxtkob ie tml eiffirkob7
-k+ L`hm zlhizd& kohf|dkob tml f`xt zlhizd xmi|fd jl tlzako`tld
rktm ` h`zzk`bl zlt|zo iz h`zzk`bl zlt|zo)fkol elld ~`kz/ -Oitl
tm`t tml ekzxt zlhizd eiz `o{ bkulo dih|alot kodkh`tlx tm`t
e`ht j{ ef`bbkob hif|ao 4& `od fkxtx tml tit`f o|ajlz ie
~`blx ko hif|ao 2+3
d/ Tml fi`d ekfl xm`ff jl ko tml izdlz tm`t `~~zi~zk`tlf{ hizzlx~iodx
rktm l`hm ka`bl ekfl3 `od
0=:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :< ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:8:;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 183/383
8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
l/ Tml eiffirkob zl~zlxlotx tml eiza`t ie xt`od`zd fi`d ekfl7
J`tlx&HDYUIF&^@TMYtiYka`bl&DihYJzl`c&EifdlzYJzl`c&Ji} Jzl`c&Tit`fY^`blx/
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>0/TKEE&[&&&0
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>:/TKEE&[&&&0AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>8/TKEE&[&&&0
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>4/TKEE&[&&&:
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>></TKEE&&&&
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>5/TKEE&[&&&0
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>2/TKEE&[&&&4
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>=/TKEE&&&&
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>;/TKEE&&&&
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>0>/TKEE&&&&
4/ IHZ Tl}t Ekfl7 @o IHZ tl}t ekfl rmkhm hizzlx~iodx ti l`hm ka`bld
dih|alot xm`ff jl ~ziukdld `x eiffirx7
`/ Iol IHZ tl}t ekfl eiz l`hm ka`bld ~`bl& oit iol IHZ tl}t ekfl eiz
l`hm ka`bld dih|alot3
j/ IHZ tl}t fih`tld ko tml x`al dkzlhtiz{ x tml ka`blx3
h/ IHZ tl}t ekflx xmi|fd jl ko `xhkk eiza`t3
d/ Fkolx `od jzl`cx ko tml izkbko`f ka`bld dih|alot rkff jl
~zlxlzuld `od fkolx xm`ff jl xl~`z`tld j{ fkol elldx iz HZ!FE
~`kzx3 `od
l/ Tml IHZ ekfl o`al xmi|fd jl tml x`al `x tml o`al ie tml ka`bl
ekfl& eiffirld j{ /t}t/
</ @xxihk tld Alt`hiotlot ie tml D`t`j`xl7 ` d`t`j`xl xm`ff jl
~ziukdld tm`t l}tz`htx d`t` koti eklfdx ko ` d`t`j`xl fi`d ekfl& `od `fxi kohf|dlx `
0=8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :5 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:88>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 184/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 185/383
<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
l}hl~tkio ekflx kohf|dl& rktmi|t fkakt`tkio& hizz|~tkio& ~`xxrizd ~zitlhtkio& dkbkt`f
zkbmtx a`o`blalot& iz ~zi~zklt`z{ xietr`zl `xxihk`tld ti tml ekfl/
0=<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl := ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:88:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 186/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
@^^LODK] ‖J‑
0=5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :; ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:888
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 187/383
0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
@^^LODK] ‖J‑Ti ^f`kotkeex Ekzxt Zlp|lxtx eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx7
LXK B|kdlfkolx
Tmlxl B|kdlfkolx `zl kotlodld xiflf{ ti e`hkfkt`tl tml ~zid|htkio ie
Lflhtziokh`ff{ Xtizld Koeiza`tkio S‖LXK‑Q ~|zx|`ot ti tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie Hkukf
^zihld|zl& ti `uikd akx|odlzxt`odkobx hiohlzokob LXK& `od ti mkbmfkbmt biid!e`ktm
dkx`bzllalotx `ji|t LXK xi tm`t tml{ a`{ jl ~zia~tf{ zlxifuld/ Tml{ `zl oit
kotlodld ti l}~`od -iz hiotz`ht+ hi|oxlf‛x ijfkb`tkiox |odlz tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie
Hkukf ^zihld|zl iz `~~fkh`jfl fih`f z|flx iz hi|zt izdlzx/
0=2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8> ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:884
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 188/383
:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
0/ Rm`t LXK Kx/ LXK kohf|dlx7 l!a`kf3 tl}t alxx`bkob -hiz~iz`tl `od
kotlzolt j`xld+3 uikhl alxx`bkob x{xtlax3 lflhtziokh ekflx xtizld io xlzulzx&
dlxcti~x& f`~ti~x& `od itmlz zlaiu`jfl aldk`3 `od lflhtziokh d`t` xtizld ko
d`t`j`xlx/
:/ La`kf Hifflhtkio/ D|zkob hifflhtkio ie l!a`kf tml hia~fltl a`kfji}
xmi|fd jl h`~t|zld/ Tmkx kohf|dlx xlot eifdlzx& dlfltld eifdlzx& `zhmkuld eifdlzx
`od `ff itmlz eifdlz xtz|ht|zlx rktmko ` a`kfji}/
8/ ^|zbkob X{xtlax/ ‖Xlfe!~|zbkob‑ iz ‖xrll~!`od!cll~‑ ~ifkhklx `zl
ietlo ka~flalotld io `o izb`okw`tkiox l!a`kf x{xtla/ @ xlfe!~|zbkob x{xtla
`|tia`tkh`ff{ dlfltlx l!a`kf alxx`blx fih`tld ko x~lhkekh eifdlzx `etlz ` hlzt`ko
o|ajlz ie d`{x/ Xrll~!`od!cll~ x{xtlax hifflht `od zlt`ko `ff kohiakob iz
i|tbikob l!a`kf& zlb`zdflxx ie hiotlot/ Xlfe!~|zbkob x{xtlax xmi|fd jl dl`htku`tld
ke tml{ zl ko ukif`tkio ie tml fktkb`tkio mifd/ Xrll~!`od!cll~ x{xtlax olld oit jl
dl`htku`tld& j|t xtl~x xmi|fd jl t`clo ti lox|zl tm`t tml ‖xrl~t `od cl~t‑ l!a`kf kx
hifflhtld `x ~`zt ie tml hifflhtkio ie l!a`kf blolz`ff{/
4/ Fih`tkiox ie LXK/ @ff oltrizc xlzulzx& dlxcti~x `od f`~ti~x
zlaiu`jfl aldk` -l/b/& m`od mlfd dlukhlx& k^idx& tm|aj iz ef`xm dzkulx& l}tlzo`f
m`zd dzkulx& t`~l& HD iz DUD+ hiot`kokob LXK xmi|fd jl hioxkdlzld d|zkob
hifflhtkio/ Ko `ddktkio& hi|oxlf xmi|fd oit iulzfiic tmlxl fih`tkiox eiz LXK7
▧ Zlaitl Fih`tkiox/ Jz`ohm& x`tlffktl& iz x|jxkdk`z{ ieekhlx/
0==
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 80 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:88<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 189/383
8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
▧ Kotlzo`f Rljxktlx/ Ietlo izb`okw`tkiox ka~flalot kotlzo`f iz
kotz`olt rljxktlx& rmkhm& ie hi|zxl& hiot`ko LXK/
▧ Tmkzd ^`zt{ Xtiz`bl/ Iee!xktl iz tmkzd!~`zt{ d`t` xtiz`bl lktmlz ko
~m{xkh`f zlaiu`jfl aldk` iz zl`f!tkal d`t` mixtkob)`zhmkul -l/b/& l!
a`kf `zhmku`f xlzukhlx ~ziukdld j{ X@OT@W& Koh/ iz Kzio Ai|ot`ko
Kohiz~iz`tld+/
▧ ^lzxio`f Hia~|tlzx/ La~fi{llx‛ iz hiotz`htizx‛ ~lzxio`f
hia~|tlzx ietlo hiot`ko LEX/
▧ Eizalz La~fi{llx/ LXK ezia tz`oxelzzld iz ~`xt la~fi{llx a`{
m`ul jllo aiuld ezia ` xm`zld fih`tkio ti ` xl~`z`tl la~fi{ll
`zhmkul fih`tkio/
▧ Ifd X{xtlax/ Dlhiaakxxkiold iz ifd hia~|tlz x{xtlax oi fioblz ko
|xl a`{ hiot`ko LXK `od xmi|fd `fxi jl hioxkdlzld d|zkob hifflhtkio/
0=;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8: ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:885
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 190/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :4
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
7777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX HLZTKEKH@TL IE
XLZUKHL
K& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& mlzlj{ hlztke{ ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie ^f`kotkeex
Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld |~io Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{ rlzl
xlzuld tmzi|bm La`kf `od Ekzxt Hf`xx A`kf rktm ^ixt`bl e|ff{ ~zl~`kd tmkx 0;tm
d`{ ie
G`o|`z{ :>0:& |~io tml eiffirkob7
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp|kzl
F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
<282 C`o`o Zi`d& X|ktl 842
@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0
La`kf7 ahifloNhiflof`r/hiaXkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio7 :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0=<
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7 Olkf X`ocl{3 Tidd X`ocl{3
X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
0;>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 88 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:882
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 191/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
G`alx E AhH`jl& Lxp|kzl
Aizzkxio % Eilzxtlz
4:< A`zclt Xtzllt
X`o Ez`ohkxhi& H@ ;40><!:4=:
La`kf7 gahh`jlNaiei/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7 Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& Koh/&
Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/&
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/& Xlkxkot& Koh/ d)j)` @hh|zkot& Hmikhl~ikot& Koh/
Gimo @ Uibt& Gz/& Lxp|kzl
Ldr`zd X`o Hm`ob& Lxp|kzl
Giolx D`{8050 Akhmlfxio Dzkul X|ktl =>>
Kzukol& H@ ;:50:
La`kf7 g`uibtNgiolxd`{/hia
La`kf7 lhm`obNgiolxd`{/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0;0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!2 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 84 ie 84 ^`bl KD(70:88=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 192/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖=‑
0;:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie :> ^`bl KD(70:88;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 193/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIOX TI
DLELOD@OT TIDD X@OCL[ ‘ XLT IOL
^FL@XL T@CL OITKHL& ko `hhizd`ohl rktm Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ :5 `od 85
{i| `zl mlzlj{ oitkekld `od zlp|kzld ti zlx~iod ti tml eiffirkob Zlp|lxt eiz
@dakxxkiox ~zi~i|odld j{ ^f`kotkeex Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& Bi L}hlf Bfij`f
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl `od Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb Smlzlko`etlz
‖^f`kotkeex‑Q mlzlko& tmzi|bm tmlkz `ttizol{ ie zlhizd& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& F`r
Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& <<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:& F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@
0;444!:<80& rktmko tmkzt{ S8>Q d`{x ezia xlzukhl mlzlie ko `hhizd`ohl rktm tml
~ziukxkiox ie tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie Hkukf ^zihld|zl/
0;8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie :> ^`bl KD(70:84>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 194/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ :
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOXTZ\HTKIOX
Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{‛x Zlx~ioxlx ti tmlxl Zlp|lxtx eiz @dakxxkiox xm`f
x~lhkekh`ff{ `dakt iz dlo{ l`hm xl~`z`tlf{ xt`tld a`ttlz& iz xlt eiztm ko dlt`kf tml
zl`xiox rm{ Tidd X`ocl{ h`ooit tz|tme|ff{ `dakt iz dlo{ tml a`ttlz/ @ dlok`
xm`ff e`kzf{ allt tml x|jxt`ohl ie tml zlp|lxtld @dakxxkio& `od rmlo biid e`ktm
zlp|kzlx tm`t Tidd X`ocl{ p|`fke{ ktx `oxrlz iz dlo{ iof{ ` ~`zt ie tml a`ttlz ie
rmkhm `o `dakxxkio kx zlp|lxtld& Tidd X`ocl{ xm`ff x~lhke{ xi a|hm ie kt `x kx tz|l
`od p|`fke{ iz dlo{ tml zla`kodlz/ Tidd X`ocl{ a`{ oit bkul f`hc ie koeiza`tkio
iz coirfldbl `x ` zl`xio eiz e`kf|zl ti `dakt iz dlo{ |oflxx Tidd X`ocl{ xt`tlx
tm`t tml{ a`dl zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tm`t tml koeiza`tkio coiro iz zl`dkf{
ijt`ko`jfl j{ tmla kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl mka ti `dakt iz dlo{/ Ke ko zlx~iodkob
ti tmlxl Zlp|lxtx eiz @dakxxkio Tidd X`ocl{ hioxkdlzx tm`t ` a ttlz ie rmkhm `o
`dakxxkio m`x jllo zlp|lxtld ~zlxlotx ` blo|kol kxx|l eiz tzk`f& ml a`{ oit io tm`t
bzi|od `fiol ijglht ti tml Zlp|lxt/
Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{ kx e|ztmlz `dukxld tm`t l`hm a`ttlz mlzlko`etlz xlt
eiztm rkff jl dllald `dakttld j{ tmla |oflxx& rktmko tmkzt{ S8>Q d`{x `etlz jlkob
xlzuld tmlzlrktm tml{ xlzul |~io ^f`kotkeex hi|oxlf tmlkz rzkttlo `oxrlz iz
ijglhtkio `ddzlxxld ti tml a ttlz `od xkbold j{ Tidd X`ocl{ iz tmlkz `ttizol{
E|ztmlz& ke x`kd Dlelod`ot dloklx `o{ a`ttlz mlzlko xi|bmt ti jl `dakttld `od
^f`kotkee f`tlz ~ziulx ` dih|alot ti jl blo|kol iz tml a`ttlz tz|l& ^f`kotkee a`{
0;4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie :> ^`bl KD(70:840
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 195/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
aiul tm`t tml ~`zt{ rmi e`kfld ti `dakt ~`{ mkx zl`xio`jfl l}~loxlx& kohf|dkob
@ttizol{"x Ellx& koh|zzld ko a`ckob tm`t ~ziie/ Eko`ff{& Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{ kx
`dukxld tm`t Z|fl 82-`+-4+ ie tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie Hkukf ^zihld|zl ~ziukdlx tm`t `o
lu`xkul iz kohia~fltl zlx~ioxl ti `o{ ie tml eiffirkob Zlp|lxtx rkff jl tzl`tld `x
` e`kf|zl ti zlx~iod eiz ~|z~ixlx ie hia~lffkob dkxhiulz{ `od)iz xllckob x`ohtkiox
ko Hi|zt/
DLEKOKTKIOX
Oitrktmxt`odkob tml x~lhkekh dlekoktkiox jlfir& l`hm rizd& tlza& iz ~mz`xl
|xld ko tmlxl Zlp|lxtx xmi|fd jl bkulo tmlkz aixt l}~`oxkul `od kohf|xkul
al`okob/ @x |xld7
`+ *^f`kotkeex‑ xm`ff al`o ^f`kotkeex Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& Bi L}hlf
Bfij`f& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& `od ^f`kotkeex
X~i|xlx& Hmkfdzlo `od E`akf{ Alajlzx/
j+ ‖Dlelod`ot* xm`ff al`o Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{/
h+ *Kohkdlot* xm`ff al`o `x dlekold ko tml Hia~f`kot/
d+ ‖H|xtialz-x+‑ xm`ff al`o ~li~fl rmi mkzl `od |tkfkwl Dlelod`ot
Tidd X`ocl{‛x koulxtkb`tkio xlzukhlx3
l+ ‖La~fi{ll-x+‑ xm`ff al`o `o{ ~lzxio la~fi{ld j{ {i| iz `htkob `x
`o `blot eiz {i|/
0;<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie :> ^`bl KD(70:84:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 196/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 197/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ <
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
zlp|lxt rktmmlfd ezia ~zid|htkio j{ {i| io tml bzi|od ie `o{ ~zkukflbl& ~fl`xl
xt`tl7
-k+ Tml o`t|zl ie tml dih|alot -l/b/& flttlz& alaiz`od|a& hiotz`ht& lth/+3
-kk+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~lzxio-x+ ~zl~`zkob kt `od ie tml xlodlz-x+3
-kkk+ Ktx tktfl iz& ke kt m`x oi tktfl& ` dlxhzk~tkio ie tml blolz`f o`t|zl ie ktx
x|jglht a`ttlz3
-ku+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml `ddzlxxll-x+& ke o{3
-u+ Tml d`tl tml dih|alot r`x `|tmizld& xlot& od)iz zlhlkuld3
-uk+ Fih`tkio ie tml izkbko`f& iz& ke tmlzl kx oi izkbko`f& tml fih`tkio ie `ff
hi~klx& `od kdlotkt{ ie ~zlxlot h|xtidk`o3 `od
-ukk+ Rmltmlz tml dih|alot kx hf kald ti jl ~zkukflbld3 ke {i| hf ka tml
dih|alot kx ~zkukflbld& tml zl`xio x|hm dih|alot kx `fflbldf{
~zkukflbld/
m+ *^lzxio-x+* al`ox `o{ m|a`o jlkob& `o{ ekza& `eekfk`tl& gikot ulot|zl
koxtkt|tkio& hiz~iz`tkio& xifl ~zi~zkltizxmk~& fkaktld ~`ztolzxmk~& ~`ztolzxmk~&
`xxihk`tkio& bzi|~ ie m|a`o jlkobx& itmlz flb`f iz dl e`hti lotkt{& iz hiz~iz`tkio&
ie rm`tlulz ckod& iz `o{ itmlz j|xkolxx iz biulzoalot`f lotkt{ ie `o{ hm`z`htlz
rm`txilulz& tibltmlz rktm tml ~`ztolzx& tz|xtllx& ieekhlzx& dkzlhtizx& la~fi{llx& iz
`blotx tmlzlie/
k+ *Hiaa|okh`tkio* xm`ff al`o `ff eizax ie rzkttlo iz ulzj`f
kotlzhi|zxl& kohf|dkob rktmi|t fkakt`tkio kop|kzklx& dkxh|xxkiox& hioulzx`tkiox
olbitk`tkiox& `bzllalotx& |odlzxt`odkobx& alltkobx& tlfl~miol hioulzx`tkiox
0;2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie :> ^`bl KD(70:844
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 198/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 5
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
flttlzx& oitlx& tlflbz`ax& olrx~`~lz iz a`b`wkol `ztkhflx& `dulztkxlalotx& `od itmlz
dih|alotx `x ~zluki|xf{ dlekold/
g+ ‖^li~fl Ekodlz d`t`‑ xm`ff al`o Dirofi`d`jfl hia~|tlz xietr`zl
o`alf{ hiff`jiz`tkio xietr`zl& eiz tml e`hkfkt`tkio& `o`f{xkx `od lu`f|`tkio ie
hiox|alz `od ~li~fl d`t`& coirfldbl `od ~zihlxxlx& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti
xietr`zl |tkfkwld ti ~|ff xihk f ~ziekfkob ie hiox|alz `od ~li~fl d`t`& eko`ohk`f
d`t`& hzldkt d`t`& ~lzxio`f kdlotke{kob d`t`& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti o`alx
Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlzx& `blx& d`tlx ie jkztm& `ddzlxxlx& mial u`f|`tkiox& kohial&
lth/& `bl d`t`& ld|h`tkio`f d`t`& hzkako`f d`t`& ml`ftm h`zl d`t`& aldkh`f d`t`&
hmkfdzlo d`t`& lth/
c+ ‖Lflhtziokh D`t`‑ xm`ff al`o `o{ `od ff d`t` hiot`kold rktmko `o{ ie
Tidd X`ocl{‛ d`t`j`xl x{xtlax `od xlzulzx ~lzt`kokob ti hiox|alzx& hfklotx
~li~fl& j|xkolxxlx& lth/
f+ ‖Lflhtziokh A`kf‑ xm`ff al`o ff l!a`kfx xlot `od zlhlkuld rktm tml
e|ff ‖ml`dlz‑ koeiza`tkio/
a+ *^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx* al`ox ` ~lzxio"x o`al iz Xihk f Xlh|zkt{
o|ajlz iz itmlz |okp|l d`t` rmkhm kdlotkeklx iz kx `xxihk`tld rktm ` ~`ztkh|f`z
*~lzxio/*
o+ *Kdlotke{* iz ti bkul tml *kdlotkt{* ie xm`ff al`o7
@/ ko tml h`xl ie ` o`t|z f ~lzxio& ti xt tl7
0;=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2 ie :> ^`bl KD(70:84<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 199/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 2
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
-k/+ @o{ `od `ff o`alx& flb`f& tz`dl iz `xx|ald3
-kk/+ F`xt coiro mial `od j|xkolxx `ddzlxxlx `od tlfl~miol
o|ajlzx3
-kkk/+ @ff tlfl~miol `od tlfl!e`} o|ajlzx |xld3
-ku/+ @ff rljxktlx irold od |xld3
-u/+ @ff La`kf `ddzlxxlx irold `od |xld3
-uk/+ La~fi{lz iz j|xkolxx eekfk`tkio3
-ukk/+ Ihh|~`tkio `od j|xkolxx ~ixktkio -kohf|dkob tktfl+ mlfd3
-ukkk/+ La~fi{lz"x o`al& `ddzlxx& ~miol o|ajlz `od tml
la~fi{lz"x zlf`tkioxmk~ ti `o{ `od `ff Dlelod`otx ko tml
`jiul h`~tkiold `htkio3 `od& ke `~~fkh`jfl7
-k}/+ Jz`od& a`cl& a`o|e`ht|zlz"x o`al& `ddzlxx& ~miol o|ajlz
`od tml a`o|e`ht|zlz"x zlf`tkioxmk~ ti `o{ `od `ff
Dlelod`otx ko tml `jiul h`~tkiold `htkio3
J/ Ko tml h`xl ie `o iz`f xt`tlalot ie hiaa|okh`tkio& ti xt`tl7
-k/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml a`clz-x+ `od zlhk~klot-x+ ie tml iz`f
xt`tlalot iz hiaa|okh`tkio3
-kk/+ Rmlzl `od rmlo tml iz`f xt tlalot iz hiaa|okh`tkio r`x
a`dl3
-kkk/+ Tml kdlotktklx ie `ff ~lzxiox ~zlxlot rmlo tml iz`f xt`tlalot
iz hiaa|okh`tkio r`x a`dl3
-ku/+ Tml aidl ie hiaa|okh`tkio3 `od
-u/+ Tml x|jglht a`ttlz ie tml iz`f xt tlalot iz hiaa|okh`tkio/
H/ Ko tml h`xl ie `o `ht iz iakxxkio& ti xt`tl7
0;;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl = ie :> ^`bl KD(70:845
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 200/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ =
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
-k/+ @ dlt kfld dlxhzk~tkio ie tml `ht iz iakxxkio3
-kk/+ Tml d`tl rmlo kt ihh|zzld3
-kkk/+ Tml ~f`hl rmlzl kt ihh|zzld3
-ku/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~lzxio iz ~lzxiox ~lzeizakob x|hm `htx
iz ko tml h`xl ie `o iakxxkio& tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~lzxio iz
~lzxiox e`kfkob ti `ht3 `od
-u/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie `ff ~lzxiox rmi m`ul coirfldbl ie tml ht iz
iakxxkio/
D/ Ko tml h`xl ie ~mitibz ~m iz ~mitibz ~mkh zl~zid|htkio& ti xt`tl7
-k/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~mitibz`~m iz ~lzxio zlx~ioxkjfl eiz tml
a`ckob ie tml ~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio3
-kk/+ Tml o|ajlz ie ~mitibz ~mx t clo iz ~mitibz`~mkh
zl~zid|htkiox a`dl3
-kkk/+ Rmlo `od rmlzl tml ~mitibz`~mx rlzl t clo iz tml
~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkiox rlzl a`dl3
-ku/+ Tml x|jglht a`ttlz dl~khtld ko l`hm ~mitibz ~m iz
~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio3 od
-u/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi m`x ~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{& iz
hiotzif ie l`hm ~mitibz`~m iz ~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio/
m/ Tml ~mz`xl *zlf`tlx ti&* *zlf`tkob ti&* iz *ko zlf`tkio ti* al`ox ti
hioxkxt ie& zlelz ti& zleflht& iz jl ko `o{ r`{ fibkh`ff{& e`ht|`ff{& iz flb`ff{
hioolhtld rktm tml a`ttlz dkxh|xxld/
k/ *@|dkt Tz`kf* al`ox ` hia~fltl& dlt`kfld fkxtkob ie l`hm `od lulz{
`ftlz`tkio& dlfltkio& kop|kz{ koti& aidkekh`tkio iz itmlz hm`obl ti tml hzldkt zl~iz
:>>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl ; ie :> ^`bl KD(70:842
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 201/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ ;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
iz ~ziekfl `x a`kot`kold ko zlhizdld eiza& ko tml jzi`dlxt xloxl& j{ *{i|*/ Tml
fkxtkob xmi|fd kohf|dl tml kdlotkt{& `ddzlxx& la~fi{lz `od tktfl ie tml ~lzxio-x+
t`ckob tml `htkio& tml kdlotkt{& `ddzlxx& la~fi{lz `od tktfl ie tml ~lzxio-x+
`|tmizkwkob tml `htkio& ` dlt`kfld l}~f`o`tkio ie tml `htkio t`clo& tml d`tl ie tml
`htkio& tml al`ox |xld ti leelht x|hm `htkio& tml fih`tkio ie izkbko ie tml `htkio `od
tml zl`xio tml `htkio r`x t`clo/ Tml tlza *`|dkt tz`kf* `fxi kohf|dlx tml dlekoktkio
~ziukdld eiz tml ~mz`xl ko tml EldlzJ|xm& Eldlz`f Tz`dl Hiaakxxkio `od Eiza`
Xt`ee I~kokio Flttlz& A`zhm 0>& 0;=8/
g/ *D`t`* al`ox tml ~m{xkh`f x{ajifx ko tml jzi`dlxt xloxl tm`t
zl~zlxlot koeiza`tkio& zlb`zdflxx ie rmltmlz tml koeiza`tkio kx iz`f& rzkttlo iz
itmlzrkxl zlhizdld/
c/ *Hia~|tlz* al`ox `o{ `od ff ~zibz`aa`jfl lflhtziokh dlukhlx iz
`~~`z`t|xlx& kohf|dkob m`zdr`zl& xietr`zl& `od itmlz d`t`j`ocx& tm`t h`o xtizl
zltzklul& `hhlxx& |~d`tl& hiajkol& zl`zz`obl& ~zkot& zl`d& ~zihlxx iz itmlzrkxl `ftlz
d`t` rmltmlz x|hm d`t` a`kot`kold ko tm`t dlukhl iz `t xial itmlz fih`tkio/ Tml
tlza *hia~|tlz* kohf|dlx `o{ `od `ff a`boltkh zlhizdkobx iz x{xtlax& x{xtlax
i~lz`tkob io iz a`kot`kokob d`t` ko dkbkt`f& `o`fib& iz m{jzkd eiza`t& iz itmlz
alhm`okh`f dlukhlx& iz itmlz dlukhlx h`~`jfl ie a`kot`kokob rzktkobx iz
zlhizdkobx& ie `o{ ckod& ko hiodloxld eiza`t& `od kohf|dlx `o{ dkxc& t`~l&
:>0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie :> ^`bl KD(70:84=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 202/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
zlhizdkob& iz itmlz koeiza`tkio`f xi|zhl& zlb`zdflxx ie ktx ~m{xkh`f dkaloxkio iz
xkwl/
f/ *Eiza`t* al`ox tml blolz`f a`cl|~ iz blolz`f ~f`o ie
izb`okw`tkio iz `zz`oblalot ie d`t`/
a/ *L}~f`ko* al`ox ti lf|hkd tl& a`cl ~f ko iz |odlzxt od`jfl& ti
bkul tml zl`xio eiz iz h`|xl ie& `od ti xmir tml fibkh`f dlulfi~alot iz
zlf`tkioxmk~x tmlzlie/
o/ *Dlxhzkjl* al`ox ti zl~zlxlot iz bkul `o hhi|ot ie ko rizdx/
i/ ‖\xlz‑ al`ox `o{ ~lzxio iz hia~|tlz rmkhm kotlz`htx rktm `
dkeelzlot hia~|tlz/
~/ ‖@hhlxx ^zibz`ax‑ al`ox tmlxl ~zibz`ax& ~m{xkh`f iz hia~|tlz!
j`xld& rmkhm kox|zl `|tmizkw`tkio& kdlotkekh`tkio& ulzkekh`tkio& `hhlxx hiotzif
`hhi|ot`jkfkt{ `od xlh|zkt{ `|dkt ie {i|z hiox|alz d`t`j`xl/
p/ ‖Koeiza tkio ^zitlhtkio @zhmktlht|zl‑ al`ox ` xt tlalot ie tml
iulz`ff dlxkbo `od i~lz`tkob ijglhtkulx eiz tml xlh|zkt{& hiotko|kt{ `od hiotzif ie
{i|z hiox|alz d`t`j`xl/
z/ ‖Hiox|alz D`t`j`xl‑ kx kotlodld ti al`o Tidd X`ocl{‛x lotkzl
hiox|alz oltrizc& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti tl}t ekflx a`dl& ekfl ~|zbl& ekfl
zlizb`okw`tkio aidl& `ff i~lz`tiz ~zl`ajfl& kdlotkekh`tkio `od ~`xxrizd aidlx&
:>:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 00 ie :> ^`bl KD(70:84;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 203/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 00
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
`od `ff itmlz xkobfl iz iulzf`{kob ~zibz`ax& `~~fkh`tkiox `od)iz x{xtlax `od dilx
kohf|dl& j|t kx oit fkaktld ti tml a`ko i~lz`tkob x{xtla/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIOX7
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 07
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl `od `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ ti |xl [I\Z fib ko
hzldlotk`fx ti `hhlxx ^f`kotkeex ^li~fl Ekodlz d`t `od ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx tmzi|bm
tml Zlld Dlelod`otx -Zlld Dlelod`otx kohf|dlx Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx
Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/3
Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/+
`od Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/ rktmi|t `o{ t{~l ie ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f
lotktflalot/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ :7
@dakt [I\ m`ul `hhi|otx rktm Hioek!Hmlc& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Kotlfk|x& Koh/
Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx
Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/+
:>8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie :> ^`bl KD(70:8<>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 204/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 87
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl `od `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ ti |xl [I\Z fib!ko
hzldlotk`fx `od ijt`ko ^f`kotkeex eko`ohk`f zlhizdx& hzldkt zlhizdx& la~fi{alot
zlhizdx& aldkh f zlhizdx `od itmlz zlhizdx ezia Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc
Xif|tkiox& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot
`od Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Coir]& Hioek!Hmlc& lth/
rktmi|t ` ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz `o{ t{~l ie flb`f lotktflalot/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 47
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ kx oit ` fkhloxld ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tiz eiz tml X`ocl{
Ekza/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ <7
@dakt [I\ `zl tml irolz `od i~lz`tiz ie Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 57
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl `od `xxkxtld Olkf X`ocl{ ko ekfkob e`fxl `fflb`tkiox
`ji|t tml ^f`kotkeex rktm Xt`tl `od Eldlz`f @blohklx& kohf|dkob ~zij`tkio
dl~`ztalotx/
:>4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 08 ie :> ^`bl KD(70:8<0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 205/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 08
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 27
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ |xld [I\Z ieekhl& [I\Z tlfl~miol o|ajlz& [I\Z
Hia~`o{& Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& `od [I\Z fib!ko hzldlotk`fx ti ijt`ko tml ^li~fl
Ekodlz d`t`& eko`ohk`f d`t`& xl`fld hi|zt dih|alotx& aldkh`f d`t`& `od ^lzxio`f
Kdlotkeklzx ie tml ^f`kotkeex/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ =7
@dakt [I\ `hhlxxld `od ijt`kold tml ^li~fl Ekodlz d`t`& ^lzxio`f
Kdlotkeklzx& Hzldkt Zl~iztx& Eko`ohk`f Zl~iztx& Xl`fld Hi|zt Dih|alotx `od itmlz
dih|alotx io tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od ^f`kotkeex
E`akf{ alajlzx tmzi|bm Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od
Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot& `od Hmikhl^ikot
Koh/& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Coir]& Hioek!Hmlc& lth/& rktmi|t `o{ t{~l ie
~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f lotktflalot `od ~ziukdld ^f kotkeex d`t` ti tml itmlz
Dlelod`otx& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti Olkf X`ocl{
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ ;7
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ m`x ~iztz`{ld mkaxlfe `x ` ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tiz eiz Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza/
:><
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 04 ie :> ^`bl KD(70:8<:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 206/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 04
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 0>7
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl Olkf X`ocl{ xlot `o la`kf ti Zl~iztlz Jij \oz|m
rktm Rizfd Olt D`kf{& ezia tml X`ocl{ Ekza& `ji|t ^f`kotkee Fkx` Fkjlzk tm`
hiot`kold ^f`kotkee Fkjlzk‛x e|ff Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz& d`tl ie jkztm& x~i|xlx
o`al `od Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz `od itmlz ~zku`tl d`t`/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 007
@dakt tml H`fkeizok` J|zl`| ie Xlh|zkt{ `od Koulxtkb`tkul Xlzukhlx zlxtzkhtx
^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tizx ezia `hhlxxkob `od ijt`kokob ` ~lzxio-x+ e|ff Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{
o|ajlz `od itmlz ~zku`tl kdlotke{kob koeiza`tkio eiz tml ~|z~ixl ie ~|jfkxmkob ti
m`za tml kodkukd|`f-x+/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 0:7
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl `od `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ ti |tkfkwl [I\Z fib ko
hzldlotk`fx `od ijt`ko koeiza`tkio ezia tml H`fkeizok Dl~`ztalot ie Aitiz
Ulmkhflx& itmlz ~lzxio-x+& `blohklx `od lotktklx& kohf|dkob tml itmlz Dlelod`otx& io
tml ^f`kotkeex j`xld io e`fxl ~zltloxlx/
:>5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0< ie :> ^`bl KD(70:8<8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 207/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 087
@dakt [I\ m`ul hzl`tld kzzlulzxkjfl m`za `od d`a`blx ti f`kotkeex j{
dkxxlako`tkob lzzioli|x koeiza`tkio3 tmlkz ^li~fl Ekodlz D`t` `od tmlkz ^lzxio`f
Kdlotkeklzx ti `o kaal`x|z jfl `ai|ot ie ~li~fl od j|xkolxxlx/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 047
@dakt [I\ dkd oit m`ul `o{ ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f lotktflalot ti
`o{ koeiza`tkio zlb`zdkob `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 0<7
@dakt [I\ `zl |o`jfl ti dlaioxtz tl mir a`o{ ~li~fl m`ul zlhlkuld
^f`kotkeex ~zku`tl ~lzxio`f kdlotke{kob koeiza`tkio `od kohizzlht koeiza`tkio
jlh`|xl ie tml o`t|zl ie tml kotlzolt `od tml o|alzi|x r`{x kt r`x zl~l`tldf{
~ixtld io tml Kotlzolt `od xlot i|t j{ Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw/
:>2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 05 ie :> ^`bl KD(70:8<4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 208/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 05
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 057
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl Olkf X`ocl{ e`fxlf{ `hh|xld ^f kotkee Fkx` Fkjlzk‛x
m|xj`od ie jlkob ` ‖~`zifll‑ `od dkulztkob e|odx ezia ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl‛x
rljxktl/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 027
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl `od `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ ti |xl [I\Z fib!ko
hzldlotk`fx `od [I\Z zlxi|zhlx ti `xxkxt Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw ko m`zakob `od
h`|xkob d`a`blx ti tml f`kotkeex/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 0=7
@dakt Fl}kxOl}kx -Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/+ h`ohlffld [I\Z x|jxhzk~tkio ko iz
`ji|t :>0> ti tmlkz ~zid|htx d|l ti `j|xl/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 0;7
@dakt [I\ olulz zl~iztld ti f`r loeizhlalot tml akx|xl ie ^f`kotkeex
^li~fl Ekodlz D`t` `od ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklz d`t` tm`t Olkf X`ocl{ tmzi|bm [I\ `od
tml X`ocl{ Ekza& ijt`kold `od ~ziukdld ti Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw `od tml itmlz
Dlelod`otx `od `ffirld Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw ti dkxtzkj|tl ^f`kotkeex d`t` `ff iulz
tml Kotlzolt& tmzi|bm a`xx la`kfkob& a`xx a`kfkob& lth/
:>=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 02 ie :> ^`bl KD(70:8<<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 209/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 02
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ :>7
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl `od `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ ti |xl {i|z fib!ko
hzldlotk`fx `od `hhlxx `od ~|ff xl`fld dih|alotx kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti
xl`fld hi|zt dih|alotx ~lzt`kokob ti tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo od ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
Zlx~lhte|ff{ x|jakttld&
D`tld7 G`o|`z{ 0;& :>0: YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
@ttizol{ eiz ^f`kotkeex
:>;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0= ie :> ^`bl KD(70:8<5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 210/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0=
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
7777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX HLZTKEKH@TL IE
XLZUKHL
K& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& mlzlj{ hlztke{ ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie ^f`kotkeex
Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox ~zi~i|odld |~io Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{ rlzl xlzuld tmzi|bm
La`kf `od Ekzxt Hf`xx A`kf rktm ^ixt`bl e|ff{ ~zl~`kd tmkx 0;tm
d`{ ie G`o|`z{ :>0:& |~io
tml eiffirkob7
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp|kzl
F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
<282 C`o`o Zi`d& X|ktl 842
@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0
La`kf7 ahifloNhiflof`r/hiaXkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio7 :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0=<
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7 Olkf X`ocl{3 Tidd X`ocl{3
X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
:0>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0; ie :> ^`bl KD(70:8<2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 211/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tidd X`ocl{ 0;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
Gimo @ Uibt& Gz/& Lxp|kzl
Ldr`zd X`o Hm`ob& Lxp|kzl
Giolx D`{8050 Akhmlfxio Dzkul X|ktl =>>
Kzukol& H@ ;:50:
La`kf7 g`uibtNgiolxd`{/hia
La`kf7 lhm`obNgiolxd`{/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/
G`alx E AhH`jl& Lxp|kzl
Aizzkxio % Eilzxtlz4:< A`zclt Xtzllt
X`o Ez`ohkxhi& H@ ;40><!:4=:La`kf7 gahh`jlNaiei/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7
Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& Koh
Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Xlkxkot& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Hmikhl~ikot& Koh/
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
:00
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :> ie :> ^`bl KD(70:8<=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 212/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖;‑
:0:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:8<;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 213/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX KOTLZZIB@TIZKLX @DDZLXXLD TI
DLELOD@OT TML X@OCL[ EKZA& KOH/ ‘ XLT IOL
^FL@XL T@CL OITKHL& ko `hhizd`ohl rktm Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ 88& {i| `zl
mlzlj{ oitkekld `od zlp|kzld ti zlx~iod ti tml eiffirkob Kotlzzib`tizklx
~zi~i|odld j{ ^f`kotkeex Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff` `od Bi L}hlf Bfij`f
Smlzlko`etlz ‖ f`kotkeex‑Q mlzlko& tmzi|bm tmlkz `ttizol{ ie zlhizd& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
Lxp|kzl& F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& <<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80& rktmko tmkzt{ S8>Q d`{x ezia xlzukhl mlzlie ko
`hhizd`ohl rktm tml ~ziukxkiox ie tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie Hkukf ^zihld|zl/
:08
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie :; ^`bl KD(70:85>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 214/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
[i| `zl e|ztmlz ~f`hld io oitkhl& ~|zx|`ot ti Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ :5-l+& tm`t tmlxl
Kotlzzib`tizklx `zl dllald hiotko|kob& zlp|kzkob x|~~flalot`f zlx~ioxlx tmlzlti ko
tml lulot zlp|lxtld koeiza`tkio jlhial `u`kf`jfl rmkhm ri|fd zlp|kzl `alodalot
iz x|~~flalot`tkio ie {i|z zlx~ioxlx ko izdlz tm`t tml{ ri|fd jl ~zi~lz `od
tz|tme|f& jlhial coiro ti {i|/
KOXTZ\HTKIOX
0/ Ko `oxrlzkob tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx& ~fl`xl e|zokxm `ff koeiza`tkio
rmkhm kx `u`kf`jfl ti {i|& kohf|dkob& rktmi|t fkakt`tkio& `ff koeiza`tkio ko tml
~ixxlxxkio ie {i|z `ttizol{x& `hhi|ot`otx& `eekfk`tlx& `|dktizx& `blotx& la~fi{llx&
ieekhlzx& dkzlhtizx& xm`zlmifdlzx& hiotz`htizx& iz itmlz ~lzxioolf& `od oit alzlf{
x|hm koeiza`tkio `x kx ko {i|z ~ixxlxxkio/
:/ Ke {i| h`ooit zlx~iod ti `o{ ie tml eiffirkob Kotlzzib`tizklx ko e|ff
`etlz l}lzhkxkob d|l dkfkblohl ti xlh|zl koeiza`tkio ti di xi& ~fl`xl xi xt`tl& `od
zlx~iod ti tml l}tlot ~ixxkjfl& x~lhke{kob `ff zl`xiox rm{ {i| `zl |o`jfl iz
|orkffkob ti zlx~iod ti tml zla`kodlz& xt`tkob rm`tlulz koeiza`tkio {i| m`ul
hiohlzokob tml |o~zid|hld koeiza`tkio& `od rm`t leeiztx {i| a`dl ti xlh|zl
koeiza`tkio x|eekhklot ti `ffir {i| ti zlx~iod e|ff{ ti tml ~`ztkh|f`z Kotlzzib`tiz{/
8/ @ftmi|bm iol iz aizl ie tml eiffirkob Kotlzzib`tizklx a`{ oit `~~l`z
ti jl `~~fkh`jfl ti iz dkzlhtld ti {i|& ~fl`xl zlx~iod ti l`hm `od lulz{ iol ie tmla
ti tml l}tlot tm`t {i| `zl `jfl ti ~ziukdl `o{ zlx~ioxl tmlzlti rmltmlz x|hm
:04
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:850
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 215/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
zlx~ioxl hioxkxtx ie koeiza`tkio rktmko {i|z iro coirfldbl iz rm`t {i| m`ul
ijt`kold ezia itmlzx/
4/ Mirlulz& eiz lulz{ zlx~ioxl ko rmkhm {i| kohf|dl koeiza`tkio
zlhlkuld ezia itmlzx& ~fl`xl ~ziukdl tml o`al& `o{ coiro `ddzlxx& `od `o{ coiro
~miol o|ajlz ie tml ~lzxio ezia rmia {i| xi zlhlkuld x|hm koeiza`tkio/ @od& ko
lulz{ x|hm koxt`ohl ~fl`xl xt`tl tm`t {i| h`ooit ulzke{ x|hm ie {i|z iro ~lzxio`f
coirfldbl& kdlotke{kob ~`ztkh|f`zf{ tml koeiza`tkio eiz rmkhm {i| h`ooit ui|hm/
</ E|ztmlz& tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx hiot`ko rizdx iz ~mz`xlx rmkhm zlp|kzl
{i| ti zlelz ti tml *Dlekoktkiox* xlhtkio ie tmkx dih|alot ~ziukdld mlzlko jlfir/
5/ \oflxx itmlzrkxl xt`tld& l`hm Kotlzzib`tiz{ ~lzt`kox ti tml tkal ~lzkid
jlbkookob G`o|`z{& :>>=& tmzi|bm tml ~zlxlot d`tl/ Tm|x& {i|z zlx~ioxlx xmi|fd jl
e|ff{ `oxrlzld `x tml{ ~lzt`ko ti koeiza`tkio rktmko tm`t tkal ez`al/
2/ E|ztmlz& l`hm Kotlzzib`tiz{ xmi|fd kdlotke{ tml `~~zi~zk`tl tkal ez`al
ke {i|z zlx~ioxl zlp|kzlx x`al/
=/ Ke ijglhtkio kx t`clo ti `o{ ie tml eiffirkob Kotlzzib`tizklx iz ke `o{
Kotlzzib`tiz{ rkff oit jl hia~fkld rktm ko e|ff& ~fl`xl xt`tl tml x~lhkekh bzi|odx
tmlzleizl& kohf|dkob ko dlt`kf `ff tm`t {i| m`ul diol ko izdlz ti tz{ `od hia~f{
tmlzlrktm& `od hia~f{ rktm x|hm Kotlzzib`tiz{ ti tml l}tlot ti rmkhm tmlzl kx oi
ijglhtkio/ Ke ~zkukflbl kx `fflbld `x ti `o{ dih|alotx iz hiaa|okh`tkiox& e|ff{
kdlotke{ tml dih|alotx iz hiaa|okh`tkiox eiz rmkhm ~zkukflbl kx `xxlztld `od
:0<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:85:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 216/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 4
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
l}~f`ko ko dlt`kf tml bzi|odx ie x|hm ~zkukflbl3 `od rktmi|t fkakt`tkio& x|hm
kdlotkekh`tkio `od l}~f`o`tkio xm`ff xlt eiztm `t tml fl`xt tml eiffirkob7
`+ Tml o`alx ie tml `|tmiz-x+ `od `ddzlxxll-x+ iz zlhk~klot-x+ ie tml
dih|alot3
j+ Tml o`al-x+ ie tml ~lzxio-x+ ti rmi hi~klx rlzl xlot iz rmi rlzl
~zlxlot d|zkob `o{ ~`zt ie tml hiaa|okh`tkio3
h+ Tml d`tl ie tml dih|alot iz hiaa|okh tkio3
d+ Tml d`tl io rmkhm tml dih|alot r`x zlhlkuld j{ tmixl m`ukob
~ixxlxxkio ie tml dih|alot3
l+ @ jzkle dlxhzk~tkio ie tml o`t|zl `od x|jglht a`ttlz ie tml dih|alot iz
hiaa|okh`tkio3 `od
e+ Tml xt`t|tl& z|fl& iz dlhkxkio tm`t kx hf`kald ti bkul zkxl ti tml
~zkukflbl/
;/ Ko `hhizd`ohl rktm Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ :5-l+& tmkx Ekzxt Xlt ie
Kotlzzib`tizklx ti Dlelod`ot xm`ff jl dllald hiotko|kob xi `x ti zlp|kzl
x|~~flalot f `oxrlzx ke tml ~`zt{ zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx iz
mkx)mlz)tmlkz `ttizol{x ijt`ko e|ztmlz koeiza`tkio jltrllo tml tkal ie hia~fk`ohl
`od `t tml tkal ie tzk`f/
0>/ Rmlolulz `~~zi~zk tl& tml xkob|f z eiza ie ` rizd `fxi xm`ff jl
kotlz~zltld ti kohf|dl tml ~f|z`f/ *@od* `x rlff `x *iz* xm`ff jl hioxtz|ld lktmlz
dkxg|ohtkulf{ iz hiog|ohtkulf{ `x olhlxx`z{ ti jzkob rktmko tml xhi~l ie `o{
zlp|lxt& `o{ koeiza`tkio tm`t akbmt itmlzrkxl jl hioxtz|ld ti jl i|txkdl ktx xhi~l
:05
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie :; ^`bl KD(70:858
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 217/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ <
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
*Mkx* xm`ff jl kotlz~zltld ti kohf|dl *mlz* `od ktx&* `od kx oit kotlodld ti jl
l}hf|xkul iz blodlz!x~lhkekh/
00/ Ko zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx& {i| xm`ff ~zid|hl `f
zlx~ioxkul dih|alotx rmkhm `zl ko {i|z ~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{& iz hiotzif iz ko tml
~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{& iz hiotzif ie {i|z ~zldlhlxxizx& x|hhlxxizx& ~`zlotx
x|jxkdk`zklx& dkukxkiox& iz `eekfk`tlx& iz `o{ ie {i|z zlx~lhtkul dkzlhtizx& ieekhlzx&
a`o`bkob `blotx& `blotx& la~fi{llx& `ttizol{x& `hhi|ot`otx iz itmlz
zl~zlxlot`tkulx/ @ dih|alot xm`ff jl dllald ti jl rktmko {i|z hiotzif ke {i| m`ul
tml zkbmt ti xlh|zl tml dih|alot iz ` hi~{ ie tml dih|alot ezia `oitmlz ~lzxio
m`ukob ~ixxlxxkio iz h|xtid{ ie tml dih|alot/
0:/ Ke `o{ dih|alotx iz ~`ztx ie dih|alotx h`ffld eiz j{ tmlxl
Kotlzzib`tizklx m`ul jllo dlxtzi{ld& dkxh`zdld& iz itmlzrkxl dkx~ixld ie& {i|
xmi|fd ~ziukdl ` fkxt xlttkob eiztm `x ti l`hm x|hm dih|alot tml eiffirkob
koeiza`tkio7
`/ Tml o t|zl ie tml dih|alot& l/b/& flttlz& alaiz`od|a& tlflbz`a& lth/3
j/ Tml o`al `ddzlxx& ihh|~`tkio& tktfl `od j|xkolxx `eekfk`tkio ie l`hm
~lzxio rmi ~zl~`zld& zlhlkuld& uklrld& `od m`x iz m`x m`d
~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{& iz hiotzif ie tml dih|alot3
h/ Tml d`tl ie tml dih|alot3
d/ @ dlxhzk~tkio ie tml x|jglht a`ttlz ie tml dih|alot3
l/ Tml d`tl ie dlxtz|htkio iz itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
:02
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:854
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 218/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 5
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
e/ @ xt`tlalot ie tml zl`xiox eiz dlxtz|htkio iz itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
b/ Tml o`al& `ddzlxx& ihh|~`tkio& tktfl `od j|xkolxx `eekfk`tkio ie l`hm
~lzxio rmi `|tmizkwld dlxtz|htkio iz itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
m/ Tml o`al& `ddzlxx& ihh|~`tkio& tktfl `od j|xkolxx `eekfk`tkio ie l`hm
~lzxio rmi dlxtzi{ld iz dkx~ixld ie tml dih|alot3 `od
k/ Tml Kotlzzib`tiz{ ti rmkhm tml dih|alot kx zlx~ioxkul/
DLEKOKTKIOX
0/ @x |xld mlzlko7
`+ *^f`kotkeex‑ xm`ff al`o ^f`kotkeex Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& ^mkfk~ G
Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& Bi L}hlf Bfij`f `od tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb3 ^f`kotkeex
X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/
j+ ‖Dlelod`ot* xm`ff al`o Dlelod`ot Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
h+ *Kohkdlot* xm`ff al`o `x dlekold ko tml Hia~f`kot/
d+ ‖H|xtialz-x+‑ xm`ff al`o ~li~fl rmi ~|zhm`xl ~zid|htx ezia Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ `od)iz ktx eekfk`tlx/
l+ ‖La~fi{ll-x+‑ xm`ff al`o `o{ ~lzxio la~fi{ld j{ [i| iz `htkob `x
`o `blot eiz [i|/
e+ ‖[i|‑ iz ‖{i|z‑ al`ox tml ~lzxio iz lotkt{ zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl
Kotlzzib`tizklx `od `o{ ~zlxlot iz eizalz la~fi{llx& `blotx& hiox|ft`otx iz itmlz
~lzxio `htkob iz ~|z~iztkob ti `ht io jlm`fe ie x|hm ~lzxio iz lotkt{/
:0=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:85<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 219/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 2
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
b+ *Mkxtizkh`f Zlhizdx* xm`ff kohf|dl ff dih|alotx zlf`tkob ti tml
eiza`tkio ie Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/& `ff ako|tlx ie ~`ztolzx"& blolz`f ~`ztolzx"& iz
itmlz irolzx" alltkobx& `od `ff dih|alotx zlf`tkob ti tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x alzblz
rktm& `hp|kxktkio ie iz ~|zhm`xl& iz x`fl ie iz j{ `o{ itmlz hia~`o{/
m+ *Dih|alot-x+* xm`ff al`o `o{ rzktkobx ie `o{ ckod `od xm`ff kohf|dl
tml izkbko`f `od l`hm oio!kdlotkh`f hi~{ iz dz`et tmlzlie/ Tml tlza `x tml x`al
al`okob `x ‖rzktkobx‑& rmkhm kx dlekold ko Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ 84-`+ `od Eld/ Z/ Lukd/
0>>0`x kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti& `o{ lflhtziokh`ff{ xtizld d`t`& d`t`j`xlx&
dih|alotx& `od lflhtziokh hiaa|okh`tkio -x|hm `x L!a`kf+& xtizld ko hia~|tlzx iz
itmlzrkxl& rmltmlz iz oit lulz ~zkotld iz dkx~f`{ld& tm`t m`ul oit ~zluki|xf{ jllo
~zid|hld/ @ hi~{ iz d|~fkh`tl ie ` dih|alot tm`t m`x jllo ~zid|hld/ @ hi~{ iz
d|~fkh`tl ie ` dih|alot tm`t m`x `o{ hioeizakob oitlx& a`zbko`f `ooit`tkiox& iz
itmlz a`zckobx& `x rlff `x `o{ ~zlfkako`z{ ulzxkio& dz`et& iz zlukxkio ie tml
eizlbikob& xm`ff jl hioxkdlzld ` xl~`z`tl dih|alot rktmko tml al`okob ie tmkx
tlza/ Tml tlza Dih|alot xm`ff `fxi kohf|dl lulz{ itmlz al`ox j{ rmkhm
koeiza`tkio kx zlhizdld iz tz`oxakttld kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti& lflhtziokh
la`kf& Kotlzolt& Kotlzolt ~ixtkobx& t`~l zlhizdkobx& ukdli zlhizdkobx& akhziekfax
~|ohm h`zdx& hia~|tlz a`boltkh t`~l& hia~|tlz dkxhx& hia~|tlz ~zibz`ax& xtiz bl
t`~lx& ~zkoti|tx& d`t` ~zihlxxkob zlhizdx& `od tml rzkttlo koeiza`tkio olhlxx`z{ ti
|odlzxt`od `od |xl x|hm koeiza`tkio/ Eiz l`hm *dih|alot* zlx~ioxkul ti `o{
:0;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl = ie :; ^`bl KD(70:855
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 220/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ =
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
zlp|lxt rktmmlfd ezia ~zid|htkio j{ {i| io tml bzi|od ie `o{ ~zkukflbl& ~fl`xl
xt`tl7
-k+ Tml o`t|zl ie tml dih|alot -l/b/& flttlz& alaiz`od|a& hiotz`ht& lth/+3
-kk+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~lzxio-x+ ~zl~`zkob kt `od ie tml xlodlz-x+3
-kkk+ Ktx tktfl iz& ke kt m`x oi tktfl& ` dlxhzk~tkio ie tml blolz`f o`t|zl ie ktx
x|jglht a`ttlz3
-ku+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml `ddzlxxll-x+& ke o{3
-u+ Tml d`tl tml dih|alot r`x |tmizld& xlot& od)iz zlhlkuld3
-uk+ Fih`tkio ie tml izkbko`f& iz& ke tmlzl kx oi izkbko`f& tml fih`tkio ie `ff
hi~klx& `od kdlotkt{ ie ~zlxlot h|xtidk`o3 `od
-ukk+ Rmltmlz tml dih|alot kx hf kald ti jl ~zkukflbld3 ke {i| hf`ka tml
dih|alot kx ~zkukflbld& tml zl`xio x|hm dih|alot kx `fflbldf{
~zkukflbld/
k+ *^lzxio-x+* al`ox `o{ m|a`o jlkob& `o{ ekza& `eekfk`tl& gikot ulot|zl
koxtkt|tkio& hiz~iz`tkio& xifl ~zi~zkltizxmk~& fkaktld ~`ztolzxmk~& ~`ztolzxmk~&
`xxihk`tkio& bzi|~ ie m|a`o jlkobx& itmlz flb`f iz dl e`hti lotkt{& iz hiz~iz`tkio&
ie rm`tlulz ckod& iz `o{ itmlz j|xkolxx iz biulzoalot`f lotkt{ ie `o{ hm`z`htlz
rm`txilulz& tibltmlz rktm tml ~`ztolzx& tz|xtllx& ieekhlzx& dkzlhtizx& la~fi{llx& iz
`blotx tmlzlie/
g+ *Hiaa|okh`tkio* xm`ff al`o `ff eizax ie rzkttlo iz ulzj`f
kotlzhi|zxl& kohf|dkob rktmi|t fkakt`tkio kop|kzklx& dkxh|xxkiox& hioulzx`tkiox
olbitk`tkiox& `bzllalotx& |odlzxt`odkobx& alltkobx& tlfl~miol hioulzx`tkiox
::>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl ; ie :; ^`bl KD(70:852
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 221/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ ;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
flttlzx& oitlx& tlflbz`ax& olrx~`~lz iz a`b`wkol `ztkhflx& `dulztkxlalotx& `od itmlz
dih|alotx `x ~zluki|xf{ dlekold/
c+ ‖Lflhtziokh D`t`‑ xm`ff al`o `o{ `od ff d`t` hiot`kold rktmko `o{ ie
Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/‛x d`t`j`xl x{xtlax& hia~|tlzx& m`zd!dzkulx& zlaiu`jfl
xtiz`bl dlukxlx& l/b/ hlff ~miolx& g|a~ dzkulx& `od xlzulzx ~lzt`kokob ti hiox|alzx
hfklotx& ~li~fl& j|xkolxxlx& lth/
f+ *^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx* al`ox ` ~lzxio"x o`al iz Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{
o|ajlz iz itmlz |okp|l d`t` rmkhm kdlotkeklx iz kx `xxihk`tld rktm ` ~`ztkh|f`z
*~lzxio*/
a+ *Kdlotke{* iz ti bkul tml *kdlotkt{* ie xm`ff al`o7
@/ Ko tml h`xl ie ` o`t|z f ~lzxio& ti xt`tl7
-k/+ @o{ `od `ff o`alx& flb`f& tz`dl iz `xx|ald3
-kk/+ F`xt coiro mial `od j|xkolxx `ddzlxxlx `od tlfl~miol
o|ajlzx3
-kkk/+ @ff tlfl~miol `od tlfl!e`} o|ajlzx |xld3
-ku/+ @ff rljxktlx irold od |xld3
-u/+ @ff la`kf `ddzlxxlx irold `od |xld3
-uk/+ La~fi{lz iz j|xkolxx eekfk`tkio3
-ukk/+ Ihh|~`tkio `od j|xkolxx ~ixktkio -kohf|dkob tktfl+ mlfd3
-ukkk/+ La~fi{lz"x o`al& `ddzlxx& ~miol o|ajlz `od tml
la~fi{lz"x zlf`tkioxmk~ ti `o{ `od `ff Dlelod`otx ko tml
`jiul h`~tkiold `htkio3 `od& ke `~~fkh`jfl7
::0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie :; ^`bl KD(70:85=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 222/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 223/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 00
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
-kk/+ Tml o|ajlz ie ~mitibz ~mx t clo iz ~mitibz`~mkh
zl~zid|htkiox a`dl3
-kkk/+ Rmlo `od rmlzl tml ~mitibz`~mx rlzl t clo iz tml
~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkiox rlzl a`dl3
-ku/+ Tml x|jglht a`ttlz dl~khtld ko l`hm ~mitibz ~m iz
~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio3 od
-u/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi m`x ~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{& iz
hiotzif ie l`hm ~mitibz`~m iz ~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio/
m/ Tml ~mz`xl *zlf tlx ti&* *zlf tkob ti&* iz *ko zlf`tkio ti* al`ox ti
hioxkxt ie& zlelz ti& zleflht& iz jl ko `o{ r`{ fibkh`ff{& e`ht|`ff{& iz flb`ff{
hioolhtld rktm tml a`ttlz dkxh|xxld/
k/ *@|dkt Tz`kf* al`ox ` hia~fltl& dlt`kfld fkxtkob ie l`hm `od lulz{
`ftlz`tkio& dlfltkio& kop|kz{ koti& aidkekh`tkio iz itmlz hm`obl ti tml hzldkt zl~izt
iz ~ziekfl `x a`kot`kold ko zlhizdld eiza& ko tml jzi`dlxt xloxl& j{ *{i|*/ Tml
fkxtkob xmi|fd kohf|dl tml kdlotkt{& `ddzlxx& la~fi{lz `od tktfl ie tml ~lzxio-x+
t`ckob tml `htkio& tml kdlotkt{& `ddzlxx& la~fi{lz `od tktfl ie tml ~lzxio-x+
`|tmizkwkob tml `htkio& ` dlt`kfld l}~f`o`tkio ie tml `htkio t`clo& tml d`tl ie tml
`htkio& tml al`ox |xld ti leelht x|hm `htkio& tml fih`tkio ie izkbko ie tml `htkio `od
tml zl`xio tml `htkio r`x t`clo/ Tml tlza *`|dkt tz`kf* `fxi kohf|dlx tml dlekoktkio
~ziukdld eiz tml ~mz`xl ko tml EldlzJ|xm& Eldlz`f Tz`dl Hiaakxxkio `od Eiza`
Xt`ee I~kokio Flttlz& A`zhm 0>& 0;=8/
::8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie :; ^`bl KD(70:82>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 224/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
g/ *D`t`* al`ox tml ~m{xkh`f x{ajifx ko tml jzi`dlxt xloxl tm`t
zl~zlxlot koeiza`tkio& zlb`zdflxx ie rmltmlz tml koeiza`tkio kx iz`f& rzkttlo iz
itmlzrkxl zlhizdld/
c/ *Hia~|tlz* al`ox `o{ `od ff ~zibz`aa`jfl lflhtziokh dlukhlx iz
`~~`z`t|xlx& kohf|dkob m`zdr`zl& xietr`zl& `od itmlz d`t`j`ocx& tm`t h`o xtizl
zltzklul& `hhlxx& |~d`tl& hiajkol& zl`zz`obl& ~zkot& zl`d& ~zihlxx iz itmlzrkxl `ftlz
d`t` rmltmlz x|hm d`t` a`kot`kold ko tm`t dlukhl iz `t xial itmlz fih`tkio/ Tml
tlza *hia~|tlz* kohf|dlx `o{ `od `ff a`boltkh zlhizdkobx iz x{xtlax& x{xtlax
i~lz`tkob io iz a`kot`kokob d`t` ko dkbkt`f& `o`fib& iz m{jzkd eiza`t& iz itmlz
alhm`okh`f dlukhlx& iz itmlz dlukhlx h`~`jfl ie a`kot`kokob rzktkobx iz
zlhizdkobx& ie `o{ ckod& ko hiodloxld eiza`t& `od kohf|dlx `o{ dkxc& t`~l&
zlhizdkob& iz itmlz koeiza`tkio`f xi|zhl& zlb`zdflxx ie ktx ~m{xkh`f dkaloxkio iz
xkwl/
f/ *Eiza`t* al`ox tml blolz`f a`cl|~ iz blolz`f ~f`o ie
izb`okw`tkio iz `zz`oblalot ie d`t`/
a/ *L}~f ko* al`ox ti lf|hkd tl& a`cl ~f ko iz |odlzxt od`jfl& ti
bkul tml zl`xio eiz iz h`|xl ie& `od ti xmir tml fibkh`f dlulfi~alot iz
zlf`tkioxmk~x tmlzlie/
o/ *Dlxhzkjl* al`ox ti zl~zlxlot iz bkul `o hhi|ot ie ko rizdx/
::4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 08 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:820
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 225/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 08
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
i/ ‖\xlz‑ al`ox `o{ ~lzxio iz hia~|tlz rmkhm kotlz`htx rktm `
dkeelzlot hia~|tlz/
~/ ‖@hhlxx ^zibz`ax‑ al`ox tmlxl ~zibz`ax& ~m{xkh`f iz hia~|tlz!
j`xld& rmkhm kox|zl `|tmizkw`tkio& kdlotkekh`tkio& ulzkekh`tkio& `hhlxx hiotzif
`hhi|ot`jkfkt{ `od xlh|zkt{ `|dkt ie {i|z hiox|alz d`t`j`xl/
p/ ‖Koeiza tkio ^zitlhtkio @zhmktlht|zl‑ al`ox ` xt tlalot ie tml
iulz`ff dlxkbo `od i~lz`tkob ijglhtkulx eiz tml xlh|zkt{& hiotko|kt{ `od hiotzif ie
{i|z hiox|alz d`t`j`xl/
TKAL ^LZKID
\oflxx itmlzrkxl xt`tld& `ff Kotlzzib`tizklx `od Dih|alotx zlp|lxtld `zl eiz
tml ~lzkid ie tkal ezia G`o|`z{ 0& :>>= tmzi|bm tml d`tl ie zlx~ioxl iz ~zid|htkio
`od kohf|dl rktmko tmlkz xhi~l Koeiza`tkio `od Dih|alotx rmkhm zlelz iz zlf`tl ti
`ff iz `o{ ~iztkio ie tm`t ~lzkid/ @oxrlzx `od Dih|alotx e`ff rktmko tmkx tkal
~lzkid ke tml{ zleflht ~ifkhklx `od)iz ~z`htkhlx ko leelht d|zkob tml tkal ~lzkid& lulo
ke tml dih|alotx rlzl rzkttlo iz hzl`tld jleizl tml zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid/
KOTLZZIB@TIZKLX7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 07
Kdlotke{ tml o`alx& `ddzlxxlx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx ie `ff ~lzxiox rmi
x|~~fkld koeiza`tkio zlx~ioxkul ti tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx/
@OXRLZ7
::<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 04 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:82:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 226/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 04
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ :7
Xt`tl {i|z l}`ht flb`f o`al& tml zlbkxtlzld `blot eiz xlzukhl ie ~zihlxx& tml
ieekhlzx `od tml dkzlhtizx/ ^fl`xl ~ziukdl tml o`al-x+ xt`tld ko tml h|zzlot @ztkhflx
ie Kohiz~iz`tkio3 `ff itmlz o`alx |xld j{ tml Hiz~iz`tkio d|zkob tml ~`xt tlo S0>Q
{l`zx `od tml d`tlx l`hm r`x |xld3 tml d`tl `od ~f`hl ie kohiz~iz`tkio3 tml `ddzlxx
ie tml ~zkohk~`f ~f`hl ie j|xkolxx3 `od tml o`al& `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie
tml H|xtidk`o ie Zlhizdx/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 87
Kdlotke{ tml o`alx& `ddzlxxlx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx ie `ff ~lzxiox rmi
m`ul ~lzxio`f coirfldbl ie `o{ ie tml e`htx& lulotx& iz a`ttlzx tm`t `zl `fflbld ko
^f`kotkeex Hia~f`kot& {i|z @oxrlz& `otkhk~`tld `oxrlz `od)iz dleloxlx tmlzlti `od
dlxhzkjl `od l}~f`ko {i|z |odlzxt`odkob ie tml a`ttlzx io rmkhm tml ~lzxiox
o`ald m`ul coirfldbl/
@OXRLZ7
::5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0< ie :; ^`bl KD(70:828
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 227/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 47
Ke {i| `zl oit ` hiz~iz`tkio& ~fl`xl kdlotke{ `ff ~lzxiox iz itmlz lotktklx rktm
`o irolzxmk~ kotlzlxt ko {i|/ @od& ke {i| `zl oit ` Hiz~iz`tkio& ~fl`xl xt`tl tml
`ddzlxx rmlzl tml Mkxtizkh`f Zlhizdx ie tmkx Dlelod`ot `zl h|zzlotf{ fih`tld3 `od
tml o`al& gij tktfl `od h|zzlot `ddzlxx ie tml H|xtidk o eiz {i|z Mkxtizkh`f
Zlhizdx/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ <7
Ke {i| hiotlod tm`t `o{ ~lzxio& j|xkolxx& hiz~iz`tkio iz lotkt{& j{ zl`xio ie
`o `ht iz iakxxkio iz itmlzrkxl& h`|xld iz hiotzkj|tld ti tml kog|zklx x|eelzld j{
^f`kotkeex& `x i|tfkold ko ^f`kotkeex Hia~f`kot& kdlotke{ l`hm x|hm ~lzxio& j|xkolxx
hiz~iz`tkio iz lotkt{ iz hia~`o{ j{ o`al& `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz& `od
l}~f`ko tml j`xkx eiz tmkx hiotlotkio& kohf|dkob tml kdlotkt{ ie `ff dih|alotx `od)iz
rktolxxlx tm`t x|~~izt {i|z hf`ka/
@OXRLZ7
::2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 05 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:824
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 228/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 05
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 57
^fl`xl ~ziukdl ko dlt`kf lulz{ d`t` jziclz& hzldkt zl~iztkob `bloh{& hiox|alz
zl~iztkob `bloh{& ~zku`tl koulxtkb`tkio `bloh{& iz `o{ itmlz `bloh{& kohf|dkob
tmixl {i| m`ul d`t` xm`zkob& lflhtziokh elldx& d`t` jitx& d`t`!xm`zkob `bzllalotx
`o{ ~lzxio`f xi|zhl `hhlxx kohf|dkob `o{ |odlz tml BFJ @ht |tkfkwld j{ {i|& Tidd
X`ocl{& ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia& Olkf X`ocl{& `od X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/
kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& tml d`tl& rlj
`ddzlxx& La`kf `ddzlxx& koeiza`tkio ~ziukdld `od zlhlkuld& tml ~lzakxxkjfl
~|z~ixl |xld ti xlh|zl tml koeiza`tkio& `od |xlz o`al eiz {i|& Tidd X`ocl{&
X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Olkf X`ocl{ |xld ti ijt`ko iz ~ziukdl `o{ t{~l ie
zl~izt& dih|alot`tkio iz koeiza`tkio ~lzt`kokob ti `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex
X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/ ^fl`xl ~ziukdl `
hi~{ ie tml x`al/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 27
^ziukdl ` fkxt ie `ff kodkukd|`fx& j|xkolxxlx& 8zd
~`ztklx& kohf|dkob d`t` jziclz
hia~`oklx& hzldkt zl~iztkob `blohklx& hiox|alz zl~iztkob `blohklx& xt`tl lotktklx&
lotktklx& biulzoalot`f `blohklx iz lotktklx& la~fi{lzx& lth/& o`alx& `ddzlxxlx& `od
::=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 02 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:82<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 229/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 02
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
tlfl~miol o|ajlzx tm`t ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz
^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx ~lzxio`f kdlotkeklzx `od ~lzxio`f d`t` m`ul jllo
~ziukdld& e|zokxmld& xifd `od)iz zlxifd ti j{ {i|& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{
Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& Tidd X`ocl{ `od ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`ktio/hia& kohf|dkob La`kf
rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio& d t` tz oxelzx& t{~lx ie d`t` tz oxelzzld `od tml
o`alx& tktfl& j|xkolxx `ddzlxx& mial `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie `ff
kodkukd|`fx ~ixxlxxkob tml h`~`hkt{ iz h`~`jkfkt{ eiz x|hm tz`oxelz& kohf|dkob fkxtx
`od o`alx ie `|tmizkwld i|txkdl |xlzx ie lflhtziokh a`kf/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ =7
Xt`tl rmltmlz dlfltkio |tkfkt{ ~zibz`ax `zl iz rlzl |xld io `o{ ie {i|z
d`t`j`xlx& xlzulzx& iz hia~|tlz x{xtlax d|zkob tml zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid ie tmkx
fktkb`tkio& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti tml o`al ie tml ~zibz`a-x+ `od tml d`tlx tml
~zibz`a r`x |xld ti ~lza`olotf{ dlfltl ekflx/
@OXRLZ7
::;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0= ie :; ^`bl KD(70:825
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 230/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0=
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ ;7
Xt`tl rmltmlz `o{ hia~|tlz m`zdr zl m`x jllo |~bz`dld d|zkob tml zlflu`ot
tkal ~lzkid ie tmkx fktkb`tkio& `od dlxhzkjl tml t{~l ie |~bz`dl `od rmltmlz tml
zl~f`hld ~`ztx rlzl zlt`kold& ke xi tml `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie rmlzl tml
~`ztx `zl fih`tld& `x rlff `x tmlkz hioolhtkukt{ `od kotlze`hl jltrllo tml hia~|tlz
x{xtlax/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 0>7
Kdlotke{ `o{ d`t`j`xlx& hia~|tlz x{xtlax `od hia~|tlz dzkulx tm`t rlzl
lz`xld iz zleiza`ttld d|zkob tml zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid ie tmkx fktkb`tkio& tml d`tl tml
hia~|tlz dzkulx rlzl lz`xld iz zleiza`ttld& tml zl`xio tml dzkulx rlzl lz`xld iz
zleiza`ttld& `od rmltmlz tml{ rlzl j`hcld |~/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 00
Dkd {i| m`ul ko leelht `o{ t{~l ie kox|z`ohl eiz tml ~lzkid ie tkal jlbkookob
G`o|`z{ 0& :>>=& rmkhm {i|& Olkf X`ocl{ `od)iz Tidd X`ocl{ rlzl iz akbmt jl
kox|zld ko `o{ a`oolz -eiz l}`a~fl lzzizx `od iakxxkiox hiulz`bl& ~zielxxkio`f
:8>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0; ie :; ^`bl KD(70:822
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 231/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
fk`jkfkt{ hiulz`bl& l}hlxx fk`jkfkt{ hiulz`bl& lth/+ eiz tml d`a`blx& hf`kax `od
`htkiox tm`t m`ul `zkxlo i|t ie tml Kohkdlot9 Ke xi& ~fl`xl xt`tl tml ckod ie
hiulz`bl3 tml o`al `od `ddzlxx ie tml kox|z`ohl hia~`o{3 tml o`al `ddzlxx `od
tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie l`hm o`ald kox|zld3 tml ~ifkh{ o|ajlz3 tml fkaktx ie
hiulz`bl eiz l`hm t{~l ie hiulz bl hiot`kold ko tml ~ifkh{3 tml fkaktx ie hiulz`bl
eiz l`hm t{~l ie hiulz`bl hiot`kold ko tml ~ifkh{3 rmltmlz `o{ zlxlzu`tkio ie zkbmtx
iz hiotziulzx{ iz hiulz`bl dkx~|tl l}kxtx jltrllo {i| `od tml kox|z`ohl hia~`o{
tml o`al& `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie tml h|xtidk`o ie tml ~ifkh{3 `od
~ziukdl ` hi~{ ie x`kd ~ifkh{/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 0:7
Kdlotke{ tml h|zzlot `od ~zlxlot ~lzxiox& kohf|dkob tmlkz o`alx& `ddzlxxlx
`od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx& zlx~ioxkjfl eiz tml iobikob i~lz`tkiox& a`kotlo`ohl
l}~`oxkio& `zhmkukob `od |~cll~ ie l`hm d`t`j`xl& hia~|tlz x{xtla& m`zd!dzkulx
oltrizc& @hhlxx ^zibz`ax& `od Koeiza`tkio ^zitlhtkio @zhmktlht|zl ko |xl j{ {i|&
Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& Tidd X`ocl{ `od
~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia `od tkal ko tm`t ~ixktkio/
@OXRLZ7
:80
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :> ie :; ^`bl KD(70:82=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 232/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 087
^ziukdl tml o`al& la~fi{lz& tktfl& j|xkolxx `ddzlxx& mial `ddzlxx `od
tlfl~miol o|ajlzx ie l`hm ~lzxio zlx~ioxkjfl eiz tml d`{!ti!d`{ t`xcx ie j`hckob
|~ ekflx `od `zhmkukob ekflx `od d`t` hia~kfld ko ~`~lz eiza`t& hia~|tlz m`zd
dzkulx& d`t`j`xlx& lth/ hiot`kokob `od kohf|dkob `o{ d`t` jlfiobkob ti tml ^f`kotkeex
d|zkob tml zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid ie tmkx fktkb`tkio `x rlff `x `o{ zlhizd zltlotkio `od
dlxtz|htkio ~ifkhklx `od ~zihld|zlx/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 047
^fl`xl ~ziukdl `ff |xlzo`alx& `hhi|otx& |xlz `bzllalotx& `|tmizkw`tkiox& od
hiotz`htx {i| m`ul)m`d rktm Izf{ T`ktw& Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie Izf{ T`ktw& Izf{ T`ktw
Koh/& Dlelod i|z Ezlldiax Ei|od`tkiox& Koh/& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \/X/ Xl`zhm
T`flotrkxl& W`jj`xl`zhm/hia& Coir]& Hioek!Hmlc& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx/hia&
Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& @hh|zkot& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/& Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/ iz `o{
ie tmlkz `eekfk`tlx& Lp|ke`}& L}~lzk`o& Tz`ox\okio& `od `o{ itmlz o`alx |tkfkwld j{
`o{ ie tml Dlelod`otx ezia G`o|`z{ 0& :>>= |otkf tml d`tl rmkhm tmlxl
Kotlzzib`tizklx zl oxrlzld/
@OXRLZ7
:8:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :0 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:82;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 233/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 0<7
Xt`tl {i|z ~zihld|zlx dlxkbold ti `xx|zl tml a`}ka|a ~ixxkjfl `hh|z`h{ ie
tml koeiza`tkio {i| zlhlkuld io kodkukd|`fx& kohf|dkob ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex
X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx3 tml hioekdlotk`fkt{
ie tml a`tlzk`fx `od {i|z ~zihld|zlx ti lox|zl {i|z hfklotlfl a`kot ko tml a`tlzk`
`od koeiza`tkio ijt`kold io ` ~lzxio& kodkukd|`f iz j|xkolxx kx a`kot`kold
hioekdlotk`f/ Ko `oxrlzkob tmkx Kotlzzib`tiz{& ~fl`xl l}~f`ko mir {i| zlhlkul tml
d`t`& mir tml koeiza`tkio kx)r`x `xxihk`tld rktm ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx&
^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 057
M`ul {i|& Olkf X`ocl{& Tidd X`ocl{ iz `o{ la~fi{ll iz `bbzlb tl `od)iz
` 8zd
~`zt{ ie `o{ ckod& hiod|htld `o{ t{~l ie x|zulkff`ohl io `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex&
^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlzx9 Ke xi& `x
ti l`hm x|zulkff`ohl& xt`tl tml o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& la~fi{alo
o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi hiod|htld tml x|zulkff`ohl&
d`tl `od tkal ie tml x|zulkff`ohl& t{~l ie x|zulkff`ohl& fih`tkio ie tml x|zulkff`ohl&
tml ^f`kotkee ko rmkhm tml x|zulkff`ohl r`x hiod|htld io& rmltmlz `o{ ~mitibz`~mx
:88
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :: ie :; ^`bl KD(70:8=>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 234/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ ::
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
iz ukdlit`~lx rlzl hiod|htld iz t`clo d|zkob tml x|zulkff`ohl& tml fih`tkio ie `o{
x|hm ~mitibz`~mx& ukdlit`~lx& `od zl~iztx iz itmlz dih|alotx tm`t rlzl hzl`tld iz
a`dl `x ` zlx|ft ie `o{ x|zulkff`ohl3 `od ~ziukdl ` hi~{ ie tml x`al/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 027
^fl`xl dlxhzkjl ko dlt`kf `o{ hioul{`ohl ie& tz`oxelz ie& iz ke {i| xifd `o{
zl`f ~zi~lzt{& zlhzl`tkio`f ulmkhflx3 j`oc `hhi|otx3 hlztkekh`tl ie dl~ixktx3
zltkzlalot `hhi|otx3 ulmkhflx ie `o{ t{~l3 f`od3 eko`ohk`f `hhi|otx ie `o{ t{~l3 iz
`o{ itmlz t`obkjfl iz u`f|`jfl ktla ezia A`{ 4& :>>; tmzi|bm tml d`tl {i| `oxrlz
tmlxl Kotlzzib`tizklx/ [i|z zlx~ioxl xmi|fd kohf|dl tml d`tl& tml flb`f dlxhzk~tkio
tml `ai|ot ie x`fl& tml o`al& `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie tml ~lzxio iz
j|xkolxx lotkt{& flb`f iz itmlzrkxl& tml ktla-x+ rlzl tz`oxelzzld& hioul{ld iz xifd
ti/
@OXRLZ7
:84
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :8 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:8=0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 235/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 0=7
Kdlotke{ `ff hizzlx~iodlohl `od)iz dih|alotx tm`t zlelz iz zlf`tl ti `o{
hizzlx~iodlohl iz hiaa|okh tkio jltrllo {i| `od `o{ itmlz ~lzxio zlf`tkob iz
zlelzzkob ti tml e`htx& `htx& lulotx& iz a`ttlzx `fflbld ko ^f`kotkeex Hia~f`kot& iz
{i|z @oxrlz& `otkhk~`tld oxrlz od)iz dleloxlx tmlzlti/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ 0;7
Eiz l`hm ~`z`bz`~m ie ^f`kotkeex Hia~f`kot rmkhm {i| dlo{ tml `fflb`tkiox
`xxlzt `o @eekza`tkul iz X~lhk`f Dleloxl& ~fl`xl dlxhzkjl `od l}~f`ko `o{ e`htx
x|~~iztkob l`hm dlok`f& @eekza`tkul Dleloxl iz X~lhk`f Dleloxl& xt`tl tml o`al&
`ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie `ff ~lzxiox rmi m`ul coirfldbl ie tml e`htx3 `od
fkxt `o{ dih|alotx rmkhm {i| jlfklul a`{ x|~~izt l`hm dlok`f& @eekza`tkul
Dleloxl& X~lhk`f Dleloxl `od)iz E`htx/
@OXRLZ7
:8<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :4 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:8=:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 236/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :4
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ :>7
Fkxt `ff rljxktlx& eiz|ax& jfibx& j|ffltko ji`zdx& lth/ irold `od i~lz`tld j{
{i|/ [i|z zlx~ioxl a|xt kohf|dl tml o`al& rljxktl& Kotlzolt rlj `ddzlxx& La`kf
`ddzlxxlx& mixtkob hia~`o{& lth/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ :07
^ziukdl tml j|xkolxx o`t|zl `od dl`fkobx ie {i|& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{
Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& Tidd X`ocl{& ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia iz `o{ itmlz o`al rktm
Izf{ T`ktw& [ixle T`ktw& Izf{ T`ktw& Koh/& F`r Ieekhlx ie Izf{ T`ktw& Dlelod i|z
Ezlldiax Ei|od`tkiox& Koh/& @~~l`fkob Dlotkxtz{& D`{fkbmt Hmlakh`f Koeiza`tkio
X{xtlax& Koh/& kohf|dkob ff hiotz htx& o{ ~zku`tl koulxtkb`tkio dih|alot`tkio& `od
j|xkolxx `bzllalotx `x rlff `x tml lflhtziokh d`t` tm`t kx xm`zld jltrllo tml ~`ztklx
fkxtld& t{~lx ie d`t` tz`oxelzzld `od tml o`alx& tktfl& j|xkolxx& `ddzlxx& mial
`ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie `ff kodkukd|`fx ~ixxlxxkob tml h`~`hkt{ iz
h`~`jkfkt{ eiz x|hm tz`oxelz& kohf|dkob fkxtx `od o`alx ie `|tmizkwld i|txkdl |xlzx
ie lflhtziokh a`kf/ ^fl`xl ~ziukdl `ff dih|alot`tkio `od)iz koeiza`tkio ~lzt`kokob
ti `o{ hiotz`ht& koeiza`tkio xm`zkob& La`kf l}hm`oblx rktm e|ff ml`dlz
koeiza`tkio& j|xkolxx `bzllalotx& ~zku`tl koulxtkb`tkio bzllalotx& lth/
@OXRLZ7
:85
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :< ie :; ^`bl KD(70:8=8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 237/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ ::7
Dlxhzkjl l`hm hia~|tlz& d`t`j`xl/ hia~|tlz oltrizc iz ekfl xm`zkob x{xtla
|xlzo`alx `od `hhi|otx& tm`t hiot`ko ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex e`akf{ alajlz‛x d`t` ko |xl d|zkob tml zlflu`ot tkal
~lzkid ie tmkx fktkb`tkio/ [i|z dlxhzk~tkio xmi|fd kohf|dl& j|t kx oit fkaktld ti
zlaitl `hhlxx ~lzakxxkiox ezia `eekfk`tlx)hiffl`b|lx kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti
lflhtziokh a`kf `od `~~fkh`tkiox/
@OXRLZ7
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ :87
Kx tml X`ocl{ Ekza& `o{ ie ktx la~fi{llx& Olkf X`ocl{ iz Tidd X`ocl{
jiodld9 Ke xi& ~fl`xl xt`tl tml la~fi{llx o`al& `ddzlxx& Gij Tktfl& Gij e|ohtkiox
`od d`tl ie la~fi{alot3 ~fl`xl ~ziukdl tml `ai|ot ie l`hm jiod j{ {i|& Tidd
X`ocl{& Olkf X`ocl{ `od l`hm la~fi{ll& tml o`al tml jiodx `zl |odlz `od rmlzl
tml jiodx h`o jl fih`tld/
@OXRLZ7
:82
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :5 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:8=4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 238/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :5
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOTLZZIB@TIZ[ OI/ :47
M`ul {i|& `o{ ie {i|z la~fi{llx& Tidd X`ocl{& ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tkio/hia&
Olkf X`ocl{ iz X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox lulz jllo dlokld iz h`ohlffld `o{
x|jxhzk~tkio iz `hhi|otx eiz `o{ zl`xio rktm Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx/hia&
Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/& @hh|zkot& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od
Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& Hmikhl^ikot iz `o{ itmlz
d`t` jziclz& ke xi& ~fl`xl ~ziukdl rmltmlz kt r`x {i|& Tidd X`ocl{& Olkf X`ocl{&
iz `oitmlz la~fi{ll& tml la~fi{ll‛x e|ff o`al& `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz& tml
e|ff o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie tml lotkt{ rmi h`ohlffld tml `hhi|ot iz
zle|xld `o `hhi|ot& zl`xio eiz tlzako`tkio iz zl`xio eiz zle|x`f ie `o `hhi|ot& tml
d`tl ie h`ohlff`tkio& tlzako`tkio iz zle|x`f `od tml zl`xiox `od hkzh|axt`ohlx
zlf`tkob ti tml h`ohlff`tkio& tlzako`tkio iz zle|x`f/
Zlx~lhte|ff{ x|jakttld&
D`tld7 G`o|`z{ 0;& :>0: YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084La`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
@ttizol{ eiz ^f`kotkeex
:8=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :2 ie :; ^`bl KD(70:8=<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 239/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :2
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
7777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX HLZTKEKH@TL IE
XLZUKHL
K& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& mlzlj{ hlztke{ ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie ^f`kotkeex
Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld |~io Dlelod`ot Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ rlzl xlzuld tmzi|bm
La`kf `od Ekzxt Hf`xx A`kf rktm ^ixt`bl e|ff{ ~zl~`kd tmkx 0;tm
d`{ ie G`o|`z{ :>0:& |~io
tml eiffirkob7
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp|kzl
F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
<282 C`o`o Zi`d& X|ktl 842
@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0
La`kf7 ahifloNhiflof`r/hiaXkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio7 :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0;:
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7 Olkf X`ocl{3 Tidd X`ocl{3
X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
:8;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl := ie :; ^`bl KD(70:8=5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 240/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Kotlzzib`tizklx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :=
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
Gimo @ Uibt& Gz/& Lxp|kzl
Ldr`zd X`o Hm`ob& Lxp|kzl
Giolx D`{8050 Akhmlfxio Dzkul& X|ktl =>>
Kzukol& H@ ;:50:
La`kf7 g`uibtNgiolxd`{/hia
La`kf7 lhm`obNgiolxd`{/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/
G`alx E AhH`jl& Lxp|kzl
Aizzkxio % Eilzxtlz4:< A`zclt Xtzllt
X`o Ez`ohkxhi& H@ ;40><!:4=:La`kf7 gahh`jlNaiei/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7
Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& Koh
Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Xlkxkot& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Hmikhl~ikot& Koh/
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
:4>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :; ie :; ^`bl KD(70:8=2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 241/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖0>‑
:40
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:8==
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 242/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIOX @DDZLXXLD TI
DLELOD@OT TML X@OCL[ EKZA ‘ XLT IOL
^FL@XL T@CL OITKHL& ko `hhizd`ohl rktm Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ :5 `od 84
{i| `zl mlzlj{ oitkekld `od zlp|kzld ti zlx~iod ti tml eiffirkob Zlp|lxt Eiz
^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld j{ ^f`kotkeex Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& Bi
L}hlf Bfij`f& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl `od Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
Smlzlko`etlz ‖ f`kotkeex‑Q mlzlko& tmzi|bm tmlkz `ttizol{ ie zlhizd& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
Lxp|kzl& F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& <<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80& rktmko tmkzt{ S8>Q d`{x ezia xlzukhl mlzlie ko
`hhizd`ohl rktm tml ~ziukxkiox ie tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie Hkukf ^zihld|zl/
:4:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:8=;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 243/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
[i| `zl e|ztmlz ~f`hld io oitkhl& ~|zx|`ot ti Eld/ Z/ Hku/ / :5-l+& tm`t tmlxl
Zlp|lxt Eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx `zl dllald hiotko|kob& zlp|kzkob
x|~~flalot f ~zid|htkio tmlzlti ko tml lulot zlp|lxtld dih|alotx jlhial
`u`kf`jfl rmkhm ri|fd zlp|kzl `alodalot iz x|~~flalot`tkio ie {i|z zlx~ioxlx ko
izdlz tm`t tml{ ri|fd jl ~zi~lz `od tz|tme|f& jlhial coiro ti {i|/
^|zx|`ot ti Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ 84-j+& ^f`kotkeex zlp|lxt tm`t Dlelod`ot& Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ ~zid|hl zlx~ioxkul lflhtziokh`ff{ xtizld koeiza`tkio S‖LXK‑Q ko
tml eiza`t i|tfkold ko @~~lodk} ‖@‑ `od `hhizdkob ti tml LXK B|kdlfkolx
hiot`kold ko @~~lodk} ‖J‑/
DLEKOKTKIOX
Eiz ~|z~ixlx ie tmkx Ekzxt Xlt ie Zlp|lxtx eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx& tml
eiffirkob tlzax m`ul tml al`okob xlt eiztm jlfir7
0/ ‖^f`kotkeex‑ zlelzx ti Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& Bi L}hlf Bfij`f& mkfk~
G/ Jlzb& Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& tmlkz X~i|xlx& Hmkfdzlo `od)iz E`akf{
Alajlzx/
:/ ‖Dlelod`ot* xm`ff al`o Dlelod`ot Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ S‖Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza‑Q
8/ ‖^li~fl Ekodlz d`t`‑ xm`ff al`o Dirofi`d`jfl hia~|tlz xietr`zl
o`alf{ hiff`jiz`tkio xietr`zl& eiz tml e`hkfkt`tkio& `o`f{xkx `od lu`f|`tkio ie
hiox|alz `od ~li~fl d`t`& coirfldbl `od ~zihlxxlx& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti
:48
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:8;>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 244/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
xietr`zl |tkfkwld ti ~|ff xihk`f ~ziekfkob ie hiox|alz `od ~li~fl d`t`& eko`ohk`f
d`t`& hzldkt d`t`& ~lzxio`f kdlotke{kob d`t`& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti o`alx&
Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlzx& `blx& d`tlx ie jkztm& `ddzlxxlx& mial u`f|`tkiox& kohial&
lth/& `bl d`t`& ld|h`tkio`f d`t`& hzkako`f d`t`& ml`ftm h`zl d`t`& aldkh`f d`t`&
hmkfdzlo d`t`& lth/
4/ ‖Lflhtziokh D`t`‑ xm`ff al`o o{ od `ff d`t` hiot`kold rktmko `o{ ie
Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ hia~|tlz x{xtlax& m`zd!dzkulx& d`t`j`xl x{xtlax `od
xlzulzx/
</ ‖Lflhtziokh A`kf‑ xm`ff al`o `ff l!a`kfx xlot `od zlhlkuld rktm tml
e|ff ‖ml`dlz‑ koeiza`tkio/
5/ *^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx* al`ox ` ~lzxio"x o`al iz Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{
o|ajlz iz itmlz |okp|l d`t` rmkhm kdlotkeklx iz kx `xxihk`tld rktm ` ~`ztkh|f`z
*~lzxio/*
2/ ‖Hiaa|okh`tkio‑ iz ‖Hiaa|okh`tkiox‑ al`ox tml tz`oxaktt`f ie
koeiza`tkio -ko tml eiza ie e`htx& kdl`x& kop|kzklx& iz itmlzrkxl+& rmltmlz leelhtld
tmzi|bm iz`f& rzkttlo& tlfl~miokh& lflhtziokh& iz `o{ itmlz al`ox& kohf|dkob tmzi|bm
dih|alotx/
=/ ‖Hia~f`kot‑ iz ‖Hia~f`kotx‑ al`ox `o iz`f iz rzkttlo bzklu`ohl ezia
^f`kotkeex hiohlzokob tml kohkdlot i|tfkold ko ^f`kotkeex Ekzxt @alodld Hia~f`kot/
:44
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:8;0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 245/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 4
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
;/ ‖Hiohlzo& ‖Hiohlzox‑ iz ‖Hiohlzokob‑ al`ox lukdlohkob& zlb`zdkob
dkxh|xxkob& lajid{kob& dlxhzkjkob& x|aa`zkwkob& hiot`kokob& hioxtkt|tkob
xmirkob& alotkiokob& zleflhtkob& ~lzt`kokob ti& dl`fkob rktm& zlf`tkob ti ko `o{ r`{
iz a`oolz& iz ko `o{ a`oolz rm`txilulz ~lztkolot ti tml x|jglht/
0>/ ‖H|xtialz‑ iz ‖H|xtialzx‑ al`o ~li~fl rmi mkzl Tml X`ocl{ Ekza
Koh/ eiz ~zku`tl koulxtkb`tkio e|ohtkiox/
00/ ‖Dih|alot‑ iz ‖Dih|alotx‑ zlelzx ti `o{ `od `ff rzktkobx ie `o{
ckod `od xm`ff kohf|dl tml izkbko`f `od l`hm oio!kdlotkh`f hi~{ iz dz`et tmlzlie/
Tml tlza m`x tml x`al al`okob `x ‖rzktkobx‑& rmkhm kx dlekold ko Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/
84-`+ `od Eld/ Z/ Lukd/ 0>>0 `x kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti `o{ lflhtziokh`ff{
xtizld d`t`& d`t`j`xlx& dih|alotx& `od lflhtziokh hiaa|okh`tkiox -x|hm `x La`kf+
xtizld ko hia~|tlzx iz itmlzrkxl& rmltmlz iz oit lulz ~zkotld iz dkx~f`{ld& tm`t
m`ul oit ~zluki|xf{ jllo ~zid|hld/ @ hi~{ iz d|~fkh`tl ie ` dih|alot tm`t m`x
`o{ oiohioeizakob oitlx& a`zbko`f `ooit`tkiox& iz itmlz a`zckobx& `x rlff `x `o{
~zlfkako`z{ ulzxkio& dz`et& iz zlukxkio ie tml eizlbikob& xm`ff jl hioxkdlzld `
xl~`z`tl dih|alot rktmko tml al`okob ie tmkx tlza/ Tml tlza Dih|alot xm`ff `fxi
kohf|dl lulz{ itmlz al`ox j{ rmkhm koeiza`tkio kx zlhizdld iz tz`oxakttld
kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti& lflhtziokh La`kf& Kotlzolt ~ixtkobx& t`~l zlhizdkobx&
ukdli zlhizdkobx& akhziekfax& ~|ohm h`zdx& hia~|tlz a`boltkh t`~l& hia~|tlz
:4<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:8;:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 246/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 247/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 5
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
0=/ Tml ~zlxlot tloxl xm`ff jl hioxtz|ld ti kohf|dl tml ~`xt tloxl `od tml
~`xt tloxl xm`ff jl hioxtz|ld ti kohf|dl tml ~zlxlot tloxl `x olhlxx`z{ ti jzkob
rktmko tml xhi~l ie tmkx Dkxhiulz{ `o{ koeiza`tkio tm`t akbmt itmlzrkxl jl
hioxtz|ld ti jl i|txkdl tmlkz xhi~l/
KOXTZ\HTKIOX
0/ Tmlxl zlp|lxtx eiz tml ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx `zl hiotko|kob `od
zlp|kzl tml xlzukhl ie x|~~flalot`f `oxrlzx ~zid|hld ko `hhizd`ohl rktm tml
zlp|kzlalotx ie Eldlz`f Z|fl ie Hkukf ^zihld|zl Z|fl :5-l+/
:/ Ko zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl zlp|lxtx& {i| xm`ff ~zid|hl `ff zlx~ioxkul
dih|alotx tm`t `zl ko {i|z ~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{ iz hiotzif iz tml ~ixxlxxkio&
h|xtid{ iz hiotzif ie {i|z ~zldlhlxxizx& x|hhlxxizx& ~`zlotx& x|jxkdk`zklx&
dkukxkiox& iz `eekfk`tlx& iz `o{ ie tmlkz zlx~lhtkul ieekhlzx& a`o`bkob `blotx
la~fi{llx& `ttizol{x& `hhi|ot`otx iz itmlz zl~zlxlot`tkulx/ @ dih|alot xm`ff jl
dllald ti jl rktmko {i|z hiotzif ke {i| m`ul tml zkbmt ti xlh|zl tml dih|alot iz `
hi~{ ie tml dih|alot ezia `oitmlz ~lzxio m`ukob ~ixxlxxkio iz h|xtid{ ie tml
dih|alot/
8/ [i| `zl ti ~zid|hl& eiz kox~lhtkio `od hi~{kob& izkbko`f zlx~ioxkul
dih|alotx ko tml izdlz tml{ `zl cl~t ko tml |x|`f hi|zxl ie j|xkolxx& `od x|hm
dih|alotx xm`ff jl ~zid|hld ko tmlkz izkbko`f eifdlzx& jkodlzx& hiulzx& iz
hiot`kolzx& iz e`hxkakfl tmlzlie/
:42
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:8;4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 248/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 249/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ =
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
d/ @ dlxhzk~tkio ie tml x|jglht a`ttlz ie tml dih|alot3
l/ Tml d`tl ie dlxtz|htkio iz itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
e/ @ xt`tlalot ie tml zl`xiox eiz dlxtz|htkio iz itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
b/ Tml o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& ihh|~`tkio& tktfl `od
j|xkolxx `eekfk`tkio ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi `|tmizkwld dlxtz|htkio iz
itmlz dkx~ixktkio3
m/ Tml o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& ihh|~`tkio& tktfl `od
j|xkolxx `eekfk`tkio ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi dlxtzi{ld iz dkx~ixld ie
tml dih|alot3 `od
k/ Tml Zlp|lxt iz Zlp|lxtx ti rmkhm tml dih|alot kx zlx~ioxkul/
2/ Ke `o{ dih|alot zlx~ioxkul ti tmlxl zlp|lxtx kx rktmmlfd |odlz `
hf`ka ie ~zkukflbl iz |~io `o{ itmlz bzi|od& `x ti l`hm x|hm dih|alot& ~ziukdl tml
eiffirkob koeiza`tkio ko x|eekhklot dlt`kf ti ~lzakt tml Hi|zt ti z|fl io {i|z hf`ka7
`/ Tml o`t|zl ie tml ~zkukflbl jlkob `xxlztld iz itmlz z|fl zlfkld |~io
`od tml e`htx x|~~iztkob {i|z `xxlztkio tmlzlie3
j/ Tml ~`zt{ rmi kx `xxlztkob tml ~zkukflbl3 `od
h/ Tml eiffirkob koeiza`tkio `ji|t tml ~|z~iztldf{ ~zkukflbld
dih|alot7
-k+ Tml `|tmiz& ~zka`z{ `ddzlxxll& `od xlhiod`z{ ddzlxxllx
iz ~lzxiox hi~kld& kohf|dkob tml zlf`tkioxmk~ ie tmixl
~lzxiox ti `o{ ~`zt{ ko tmkx fktkb`tkio `od)iz `|tmiz iedih|alot3
-kk+ @ jzkle dlxhzk~tkio x|eekhklot ti kdlotke{ tml t{~l& x|jglht
a`ttlz& `od ~|z~ixl ie tml dih|alot3
-kkk+ @ff ~lzxiox ti rmia ktx hiotlotx m`ul jllo dkxhfixld3
:4;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl ; ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:8;5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 250/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ ;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
-ku+ Tml d`tl tml dih|alot r`x ~zl~`zld& tml d`tl tml
dih|alot jl`zx& tml d`tl tml dih|alot r`x xlot& `od tml
d`tl tml dih|alot r`x zlhlkuld3 `od
-u+ @ ~zlhkxl dlxhzk~tkio ie tml ~f`hl rmlzl l`hm hi~{ ie
tm`t dih|alot kx cl~t& kohf|dkob tml tktfl iz dlxhzk~tkio ie
tml ekfl ko rmkhm x`kd dih|alot a`{ jl ei|od `od tml
fih`tkio ie x|hm ekfl/
=/ Ke ` ~iztkio ie `o{ dih|alot zlx~ioxkul ti tmlxl zlp|lxtx kx rktmmlfd
|odlz hf`ka ie ~zkukflbl ~|zx|`ot ti tml ~zlhldkob koxtz|htkio& `o{ oio!~zkukflbld
~iztkio ie x|hm dih|alot a|xt jl ~zid|hld rktm tml ~iztkio hf`kald ti jl
~zkukflbld zld`htld/
;/ [i| `zl ti ~zid|hl l`hm dih|alot zlp|lxtld mlzlko ko ktx lotkzlt{
rktmi|t dlfltkio iz l}hkxkio -l}hl~t `x p| fkekld j{ tml ~zlhldkob tri S:Q
koxtz|htkiox+& zlb`zdflxx ie rmltmlz {i| hioxkdlz tml lotkzl dih|alot ti jl zlflu`ot
iz zlx~ioxkul ti tml zlp|lxtx/
0>/ Rmlolulz ` dih|alot kx oit ~zid|hld ko ktx lotkzlt{& kohf|dkob `f
`tt`hmalotx& iz kx ~zid|hld ko zld`htld eiza& xi kodkh`tl io tml dih|alot& xt`tl
rktm ~`ztkh|f`zkt{ tml zl`xio iz zl`xiox kt kx oit jlkob ~zid|hld ko ktx lotkzlt{& `od
dlxhzkjl ti tml jlxt ie {i|z coirfldbl& koeiza`tkio `od jlfkle `od rktm `x a|hm
~`ztkh|f`zkt{ `x ~ixxkjfl& tmixl ~iztkiox ie tml dih|alot tm`t `zl oit jlkob
~zid|hld/
:<>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:8;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 251/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
00/ \oflxx rizdx iz tlzax m`ul jllo bkulo ` x~lhkekh dlekoktkio mlzlko
l`hm rizd iz tlza |xld mlzlko xm`ff jl bkulo ktx |x|`f `od h|xtia`z{ dkhtkio`z{
dlekoktkio l}hl~t rmlzl x|hm rizdx m`ul ` x~lhkekh h|xtia `od |x`bl dlekoktkio ko
{i|z tz`dl iz kod|xtz{& ko rmkhm h`xl tml{ xm`ff jl kotlz~zltld ko `hhizd`ohl rktm
x|hm |x|`f h|xtia `od |x`bl dlekoktkio ie rmkhm {i| `zl `r`zl/ Ko hioxtz|kob tml
kop|kz{ `od zlp|lxt mlzlko7 -k+ tml xkob|f`z xm`ff kohf|dl tml ~f|z`f `od tml ~f|z`f
xm`ff kohf|dl tml xkob|f`z3 -kk+ ` a`xh|fkol& elakokol& iz ol|tlz ~zioi|o xm`ff oit
l}hf|dl tml itmlz blodlzx3 -kkk+ tml tlza ‖`o{‑ `od ‖`ff‑ xm`ff jl |odlzxtiid ti
al`o ‖`o{ `od `ff‑3 `od -ku+ tml rizdx ‖`od‑ `od ‖iz‑ xm`ff jl zl`d ko tml
hiog|ohtkul iz dkxg|ohtkul iz jitm& `x tml h`xl a`{ jl& `ff ti tml lod tm`t tml
kotlz~zlt`tkio `~~fkld zlx|ftx ko tml aizl l}~`oxkul ~zid|htkio/
TKAL ^LZKID
\oflxx itmlzrkxl xt`tld ko ` Zlp|lxt& `ff Dih|alotx zlp|lxtld `zl zlp|lxtld
eiz tml ~lzkid ie tkal ezia G`o|`z{ 0& :>>= tmzi|bm tml d tl ie ~zid|htkio `od
kohf|dl rktmko tmlkz xhi~l Dih|alotx rmkhm zlelz iz zlf`tl ti `ff iz `o{ ~iztkio ie
tm`t ~lzkid/ Dih|alotx e`ff rktmko tmkx tkal ~lzkid ke tml{ zleflht ~ifkhklx `od)iz
~z`htkhlx ko leelht d|zkob tml tkal ~lzkid& lulo ke tml dih|alotx rlzl rzkttlo iz
hzl`tld jleizl tml zlflu`ot tkal ~lzkid/
:<0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 00 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:8;=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 252/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 00
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
DIH\ALOTX ZLP\LXTLD
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 07 ^ziukdl `ff dih|alotx
`od lflhtziokh d`t`& kohf|dkob La`kfx rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza tkio
hiaa|okh`tkiox& zl~iztx& koeiza`tkio& ~mitibz`~mx& ukdlibz`~m{& hiohlzokob l`hm
ie tml o`ald ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od ^f`kotkeex
E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :7 ^ziukdl `ff lflhtziokh
a`kf rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio ezia lulz{ La kf `hhi|ot |xld ko hiod|htkob
`o{ `od `ff hioulzx`tkiox ko zlb`zdx ti `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx&
^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo od)iz ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 87 @ff dih|alotx rktm tml
~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixlx fkxtld tm t {i| iz `o{ ie {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ ~ziukdld ti `o{
lotkt{& flb`f iz itmlzrkxl& kohf|dkob `o{ ie tml Dlelod`otx& ti ijt`ko Zl~iztx&
Koeiza`tkio& D`t`& Hzldkt Zl~iztx iz `o{ t{~l ie `hhlxx ti tml ^f`kotkeex ^li~fl
Ekodlz D`t`& ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx `od)iz ^lzxio`f Koeiza tkio io ^f kotkeex
^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo od)iz f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
:<:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:8;;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 253/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 47 ^ziukdl `ff dih|alotx
hiotz`htx& `bzllalotx& hizzlx~iodlohl& `od lflhtziokh d`t` tz`oxelzx hiohlzokob
`bzllalotx `od hizzlx~iodlohl rktm tmkzd!~`ztklx& kohf|dkob j|toit
fkaktld ti
Alzfko& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \X Xl`zhm& Hioek!Hmlc& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx/hia& Fl}kxOl}kx
Bzi|~& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio
@o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/& Coir]& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& @hh|zkot& Dl~`ztalot ie Aitiz
Ulmkhflx& Biulzoalot lotktklx& Hi|ztx& Xt`tl @blohklx& lth/ ti ijt`ko hiox|alz
h|xtialzx& `od)iz ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex
E`akf{ Alajlz‛x ^li~fl Ekodlz D`t`& ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx& Eko`ohk`f D`t`& Hzldkt
D`t`& ^lzxio`f Kdlotke{kob d`t`& Hzkako`f d`t`& ml`ftm d`t`& aldkh`f d`t`
ld|h`tkio`f d`t`& mial u`f|lx& kohial d`t`& lth/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ <7 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
dih|alotx& koeiza`tkio& `bzllalotx& hizzlx~iodlohl kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti
~`~lz `od lflhtziokh eiza`t& hiaalohld jltrllo {i| iz `o{ ie {i|z la~fi{ll-x+
`od `o{ ie tml itmlz o`ald Dlelod`otx ko tmkx f`rx|kt/
ZLX^IOXL7
:<8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 08 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:4>>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 254/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 08
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 57 ^ziukdl `ff d`t`
kohf|dkob l`hm ~lzxio `od)iz lotkt{& tmlkz o`alx `ddzlxxlx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx
`ff lflhtziokh a`kf hiaa|okh`tkiox rktm tml e|ff ml`dlz koeiza`tkio& tlfl~miokh
hioulzx`tkiox& ~lzxio`f alltkobx -eiz ~lzxio`f alltkobx ~ziukdl tml d`tl& tkal
fih`tkio `od rmi tml alltkob r`x rktm+ hiot`htld j{ {i| iz `o{ la~fi{ll-x+ ko
b`tmlzkob `o{ koeiza`tkio ~lzt`kokob ti `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx
^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo& `od)iz ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/ Ko zlx~iodkob ti tmkx
zlp|lxt& ~fl`xl kohf|dl `o{ xt`tlalotx {i| iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ a`dl ti `o{
kodkukd|`f `x ti rm{ {i| rlzl b`tmlzkob koeiza`tkio io `o{ ie tml ^f kotkeex
^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo od)iz f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 27 ^ziukdl ` hia~fltl fkxt
j{ o`al& `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie l`hm fkhloxld ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tiz
la~fi{ld j{ {i|/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ =7 ^ziukdl ` hia~fltl fkxt
j{ o`al& `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz ie l`hm la~fi{ll& kohf|dkob tmlkz tktfl `od
d`tl ie mkzl/
ZLX^IOXL7
:<4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 04 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:4>0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 255/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 04
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ ;7 ^ziukdl `ff dih|alotx
d`t` hia~kf`tkiox& `od t`obkjfl tmkobx tm`t {i| a`{ |xl ti x|~~izt {i|z dleloxlx ti
tml hf`kax ko ^f`kotkeex Hia~f`kot/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 0>7 ^ziukdl ` fkxt ie `ff
Dia`kox `od O`al Xlzulzx tm t `ff {i|z rljxktlx& jfibx& Kotlzolt Xktlx& J|ffltko
Ji`zdx `od La`kf `ddzlxxlx zlxkdl io xkohl G`o|`z{ :>>= |otkf tml d`tl {i|
`oxrlz tmlxl Zlp|lxtx/ [i|z Zlx~ioxl a|xt kohf|dl tml j|xkolxx o`t|zl `od)iz
zlf`tkioxmk~ ie tml lotktklx rktm {i|& Tidd X`ocl{ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ tm`t
mixtx tmla/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 007 ^ziukdl `ff dih|alotx
~lzt kokob ti `o{ `od `ff koulxtkb`tkiox {i| iz `o{ ie {i|z la~fi{llx hiod|htld io
`o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od ^f`kotkeex E`akf{
Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
:<<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0< ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:4>:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 256/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 0:7 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
dih|alotx hiohlzokob iz ~lzt`kokob ti {i| iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ zlx~ioxl ti `o{
kop|kz{ iz koulxtkb`tkio j{ `o{ biulzoalot`f jid{& f`r loeizhlalot `bloh{& Xt`tl
@bloh{& iz tzkj|o`f& iz `o{ hiox|alz bzi|~ iz izb`okw`tkio& koti Hia~f kotx a`dl
`b`koxt iz j{ tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex
E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 087 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
dih|alotx hiohlzokob iz zlelzzkob ti {i|z ~ifkhklx `od ~zihld|zlx zlb`zdkob tml
dlxtz|htkio iz zltlotkio ie dih|alotx& lflhtziokh d`t` iz itmlz koeiza`tkio/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 047 ^ziukdl `ff dih|alot`tkio
hizzlx~iodlohl& hiotz`htx `od `bzllalotx jltrllo {i| `od [ixle T`ktw& `od
D`{fkbmt Hmlakh`f Koeiza`tkio X{xtlax& Koh/& iz tmlkz la~fi{llx& hiotz`htizx& iz
i|txkdl ulodizx& tmlkz `ddzlxxlx `od ~miol o|ajlzx `x rlff `x tml lflhtziokh d`t`
tm`t kx xm`zld jltrllo izb`okw`tkiox/
ZLX^IOXL7
:<5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 05 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:4>8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 257/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 05
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 0<7 ^ziukdl `ff xl`zhmlx
~lzeizald j{ {i| iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ rktm `o{ Kodkukd|`f& @bloh{& Lotkt{
J|xkolxx& Hiz~iz`tkio& `o{ ie tml o`ald Dlelod`otx ko tmkx f`rx|kt& Hi|zt‛x&
Hi|ot{ Zlhizdx& Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ @dakokxtz`tkio& Kotlzo`f Zlulo|l Xlzukhl
Biulzoalot`f iz Xt`tl @bloh{& lth/ io `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx
^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo& f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 057 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
hia~f`kotx {i| m`ul zlhlkuld zlb`zdkob `o{ ie {i|z i~lz`tkiox iz la~fi{llx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 027 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
dih|alot`tkio& hizzlx~iodlohl& koeiza`tkio `od d`t`& ko `ff eizax kohf|dkob
lflhtziokh ff{& ~lzt kokob ti ^f`kotkeex& ^f kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f kotkeex Hmkfdzlo
`od)iz ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx& ~ziukdld ti `od xm`zld rktm `o{ @eekfk`tlx
Kodkukd|`fx& Zl~iztlzx& Rljxktlx& Jfibx& ZXX Elldx& j|xkolxx `bbzlb`tlx3 8zd
~`zt{
lotktklx3 `o{ ie tml Dlelod`otx3 `od `o{ itmlz j|xkolxx& hiz~iz`tkio& biulzoalot
lotkt{& Hi|ztx& hzldkt zl~iztkob `blohklx& `od)iz xt`tl `blohklx/
ZLX^IOXL7
:<2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 02 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:4>4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 258/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 02
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 0=7 ^zid|hl hi~klx ie `ff
dih|alotx tm t {i| zluklrld iz zlfkld |~io ko zlx~iodkob ti tml ~zlhldkob
Kotlzzib`tizklx `od Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox `od hi~klx ie ff dih|alotx zlelzlohld
ko {i|z zlx~ioxl ti tml ~zlhldkob Kotlzzib tizklx `od Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ 0;7 ^ziukdl ` hia~fltl fkxt
rktm o`alx& `ddzlxxlx& rlj `ddzlxxlx& `od tlfl~miol o|ajlzx& `fiob rktm `ff
koeiza`tkio zlhlkuld& ie `ff lotktklx& kohf|dkob tmkzd ~`zt{ d`t`j`xlx |tkfkwld j{ {i|
iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ ti ijt`ko `o{ t{~l ie koeiza`tkio io ^f kotkeex& ^f kotkeex
X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx& l/b/& Dl~`ztalotx
ie ^|jfkh X`elt{& Lp|ke`}& Tz`ox\okio& L}~lzk`o& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx
T`} @xxlxxizx Ieekhlx& Hi|ot{ Zlhizdx& Xt`tl Zlhizdx& Tktfl Hia~`oklx& Eko`ohk`f
Koxtkt|tkiox& lth/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :>7 ^ziukdl ` hi~{ ie `o{
dih|alot& kohf|dkob lflhtziokh a`kf rktm e|ff ml`dlz koeiza tkio `od flttlzx {i|
iz `o{ la~fi{ll-x+ x|jakttld ti `o{ `bloh{& lotkt{ iz kodkukd|`fx zlb`zdkob `o{ ie
:<=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0= ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:4><
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 259/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0=
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz ^f`kotkeex E`akf{
Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :07 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
dih|alot`tkio& Zl~iztx& Oitlx& Ekflx& {i| iz `o{ la~fi{ll ~|ffld& `hhlxxld iz
hia~kfld io `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od)iz
^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/ Ke kt r`x `o la~fi{ll& {i|z zlx~ioxl a|xt kohf|dl tml
la~fi{ll‛x o`al& `ddzlxx `od tlfl~miol o|ajlz/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ ::7 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
dih|alotx ~lzt`kokob ti `o{ ie tml ^f kotkeex& ^f kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo `od ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx {i| iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ ~ziukdld ti `o{
tmkzd ~`ztklx& kohf|dkob tml itmlz Dlelod`otx/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :87 ^ziukdl `ff ~ifkhklx
a`o|`fx& Koxtz|htkiox& @bzllalotx& Hiotz htx& Dih|alotx& iz `o{tmkob ~lzt`kokob
ti Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/‛x ~ifkhklx zlb`zdkob koulxtkb`tkio tlhmokp|lx |xld io
:<;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0; ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:4>5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 260/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
kodkukd|`fx `od mir tml ~zku`tl d`t` ie `o{ `od `ff kodkukd|`fx& ko rmkhm Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ koulxtkb`tlx& kx ti jl m`odfld `od tzl`tld/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :47 ^ziukdl `ff ~ifkhklx
a`o|`fx& koxtz|htkiox& dih|alot`tkio& Hiotz`htx& @bzllalotx& j|xkolxx hiotz`htx
iz `o{tmkob ~lzt kokob ti Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x ~ifkhklx zlb`zdkob tml hioekdlotk`fkt{
ie koeiza`tkio ~ziukdld io `o{ kodkukd|`f iz hia~`o{ ti {i|z hfklotx `od rm`t
{i|z ~zihlxx kx ti lox|zl `ff d`t` zla`kox ~zku`tl `od hioekdlotk f/
ZLX^IOXL7
ZLP\LXT EIZ ^ZID\HTKIO OI/ :<7 ^ziukdl `o{ `od `ff
dih|alot`tkio& hiotz`htx `od `bzllalotx Tml X`ocl{ Ekza lotlzld koti rktm `o{
ie tml Dlelod`otx ti tmkx f`rx|kt/
ZLX^IOXL7
Zlx~lhte|ff{ x|jakttld&
D`tld7 G`o|`z{ 0;& :>0: YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
@ttizol{ eiz ^f`kotkeex
:5>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :> ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:4>2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 261/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= @^^LODK] ‖@‑
:50
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :0 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:4>=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 262/383
0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
@^^LODK] ‖@‑Ti ^f`kotkeex Ekzxt Zlp|lxtx eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx7
^f`kotkeex zlp|lxtld lflhtziokh`ff{ Xtizld Koeiza`tkio ^zid|htkio Eiza`t
^|zx|`ot ti Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ 84-j+& ^f`kotkeex a`{ x~lhke{ tml eiza iz eizax ko
rmkhm lflhtziokh`ff{ xtizld koeiza`tkio S‖LXK‑Q kx ti jl ~zid|hld/ @x x|hm
^f`kotkeex zlp|lxt tm`t `ff LXK jl ~zid|hld ko ‖o`tkul‑ eiza`t& tibltmlz rktm `o
‖ka`bld‑ ekfl rktm tml hizzlx~iodkob ‖ka`bl fi`d ekfl‑& ‖IHZ tl}t ekfl‑& `od tml
‖`xxihk`tld alt`hiotlot ie tml d`t`j`xl‑/ Tml cl{ hiohl~tx `zl l}~f`kold jlfir7
0/ O`tkul7 tml eiza`t ko rmkhm tml lflhtziokh`ff{ xtizld koeiza`tkio r`x
izkbko`ff{ hzl`tld -l/b/& Akhzixiet Rizd& Akhzixiet L}hlf& Akxhzixiet @hhlxx+3 `
:5:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :: ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:4>;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 263/383
:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ekfl ~`tm ti tml o`tkul ekfl xm`ff jl ~ziukdld ko tml alt hiotlot ie tml d`t j`xl `x
dlxhzkjld ko aizl dlt`kf jlfir/
:/ Ka`bld7 ` TKEE iz ^DE ka`bl hioulztld ezia tml o`tkul ekfl `x kt r`x
izkbko`ff{ hzl`tld3
`/ @ff ka`blx xm`ff jl jf`hc `od rmktl3
j/ J`tlx o|ajlzx xm`ff jl jz`odld ti tml ka`blx xi tm`t tml o|ajlzx ~zkot3
h/ Ka`blx xm`ff jl xkobfl ~`bl TKEE‛x iz iol TKEE ekfl eiz l`hm ~`bl -oit
iol TKEE ekfl eiz l`hm dih|alot+3
8/ Ka`bl Fi`d Ekflx7 @ fi`d ekfl ko ` xt`od`zd fi`d eiza`t -l/b/& `xhkk&
dkk& I~tkhio+ xm`ff jl ~ziukdld rmkhm ~ziukdlx7
`/ Tml dih|alot o|ajlz eiz l`hm ka`bl3
j/ Tml e|ff ~`tm o`al-x+ ie l`hm TKEE tm`t zl~zlxlotx o ka`bl3
h/ Tml dih|alot ji|od`zklx eiz l`hm dih|alot iz e`akf{ alajlz
bzi|~kob hioxkxtkob ie tml eiffirkob7
-k+ L`hm zlhizd& kohf|dkob tml f`xt zlhizd xmi|fd jl tlzako`tld
rktm ` h`zzk`bl zlt|zo iz h`zzk`bl zlt|zo)fkol elld ~`kz/ -Oitl
tm`t tml ekzxt zlhizd eiz `o{ bkulo dih|alot kodkh`tlx tm`t
e`ht j{ ef`bbkob hif|ao 4& `od fkxtx tml tit`f o|ajlz ie
~`blx ko hif|ao 2+3
d/ Tml fi`d ekfl xm`ff jl ko tml izdlz tm`t `~~zi~zk`tlf{ hizzlx~iodx
rktm l`hm ka`bl ekfl3 `od
:58
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :8 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:40>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 264/383
8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
l/ Tml eiffirkob zl~zlxlotx tml eiza`t ie xt`od`zd fi`d ekfl7
J`tlx&HDYUIF&^@TMYtiYka`bl&DihYJzl`c&EifdlzYJzl`c&Ji} Jzl`c&Tit`fY^`blx/
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>0/TKEE&[&&&0
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>:/TKEE&[&&&0AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>8/TKEE&[&&&0
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>4/TKEE&[&&&:
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>></TKEE&&&&
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>5/TKEE&[&&&0
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>2/TKEE&[&&&4
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>=/TKEE&&&&
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>;/TKEE&&&&
AY>0>>>>>&>50<>0>0&D7)>50<>0>0)>>>>)>>>0>/TKEE&&&&
4/ IHZ Tl}t Ekfl7 @o IHZ tl}t ekfl rmkhm hizzlx~iodx ti l`hm ka`bld
dih|alot xm`ff jl ~ziukdld `x eiffirx7
`/ Iol IHZ tl}t ekfl eiz l`hm ka`bld ~`bl& oit iol IHZ tl}t ekfl eiz
l`hm ka`bld dih|alot3
j/ IHZ tl}t fih`tld ko tml x`al dkzlhtiz{ x tml ka`blx3
h/ IHZ tl}t ekflx xmi|fd jl ko `xhkk eiza`t3
d/ Fkolx `od jzl`cx ko tml izkbko`f ka`bld dih|alot rkff jl
~zlxlzuld `od fkolx xm`ff jl xl~`z`tld j{ fkol elldx iz HZ!FE
~`kzx3 `od
l/ Tml IHZ ekfl o`al xmi|fd jl tml x`al `x tml o`al ie tml ka`bl
ekfl& eiffirld j{ /t}t/
</ @xxihk tld Alt`hiotlot ie tml D`t`j`xl7 ` d`t`j`xl xm`ff jl
~ziukdld tm`t l}tz`htx d`t` koti eklfdx ko ` d`t`j`xl fi`d ekfl& `od `fxi kohf|dlx `
:54
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :4 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:400
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 265/383
4
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ekfl ~`tm fkoc ti tml o`tkul ekfl/ Tml eklfdld d`t` xmi|fd `dmlzl ti tml eiffirkob
~`z`altlzx ke `t `ff ~ixxkjfl7
`/ @uikd lxh`~l hm`z`htlzx& h`zzk`bl zlt|zo)fkol elld hiajko`tkiox
lajlddld xl~`z`tizx `od lajlddld h`zzk`bl zlt|zox ko `ff eklfdld
d`t`3
j/ J`tlx o|ajlz eklfdx h ooit hiot ko x~`hlx iz tml ) V hm`z`htlzx3
h/ Ko xt`od`zd d`t` ekflx |xl tml ulztkh`f j`z ‑v‑ ti xl~`z tl eklfdx `od
_‛x ti dlfkakt tml eklfdx3
d/ @ff d`t` t{~lx xmi|fd jl dlfkaktld& oit g|xt tl}t3
l/ A|ftk!u`f|l eklfdx xmi|fd |xl xlak!hifiox ‖3‑ x tmlkz xl~`z`tiz3
e/ D`t h`ooit hiot ko t jx iz h`zzk`bl zlt|zox3
b/ L`hm zlhizd kohf|dkob tml f`xt zlhizd xmi|fd jl tlzako`tld rktm `
h`zzk`bl zlt|zo iz h`zzk`bl zlt|zo)fkol elld ~`kz3
m/ Tml ~zlelzzld d`tl eiza`t kx AA!DD![[[[3
k/ Tml d`t` ekfl xmi|fd hiot`ko ` ml`dlz3 `od
g/ Tml eiffirkob kx ` x`a~fl d`t` ekfl7
_EkzxtJ`tlx_v_LodJ`tlx_v_Jlzb@tt`hm_v_Lod@tt`hm_v_@|tmiz_v_Zlhk~klot_v_D`tl_
_EGFY>>04;22_v_EGFY>>04;2<_v_EGFY>>0<0:>_v_Mldjlzb&D`ukd_v_Oiol_
v_Oiol_v_>0):0)0;;:__EGFY>>04;2=_v_EGFY>>04;2=_v_EGF!>>04;2<_v_Xmllm`o&Ukzbkf3Hif|aji&
Gixl~m_v_Oiol_v_>;):2)0;;0_v
5/ L}hl~tkio Ekflx7 @ff ekflx tm`t h`ooit jl ~zid|hld iz ka`bld d|l ti
tlhmokh`f dkeekh|ftklx xm`ff jl kdlotkekld `x l}hl~tkio ekflx `od kdlotkekld io ` fib
fkxtkob tml ekfl‛x o`al& h|xtidk`o& `od zl`xio eiz tml l}hl~tkio/ Hiaaio
:5<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :< ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:40:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 266/383
<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
l}hl~tkio ekflx kohf|dl& rktmi|t fkakt`tkio& hizz|~tkio& ~`xxrizd ~zitlhtkio& dkbkt`f
zkbmtx a`o`blalot& iz ~zi~zklt`z{ xietr`zl `xxihk`tld ti tml ekfl/
:55
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :5 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:408
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 267/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= @^^LODK] ‖J‑
:52
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :2 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:404
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 268/383
0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
@^^LODK] ‖J‑Ti ^f`kotkeex Ekzxt Zlp|lxtx eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx7
LXK B|kdlfkolx
Tmlxl B|kdlfkolx `zl kotlodld xiflf{ ti e`hkfkt`tl tml ~zid|htkio ie
Lflhtziokh`ff{ Xtizld Koeiza`tkio S‖LXK‑Q ~|zx|`ot ti tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie Hkukf
^zihld|zl& ti `uikd akx|odlzxt`odkobx hiohlzokob LXK& `od ti mkbmfkbmt biid!e`ktm
dkx`bzllalotx `ji|t LXK xi tm`t tml{ a`{ jl ~zia~tf{ zlxifuld/ Tml{ `zl oit
kotlodld ti l}~`od -iz hiotz`ht+ hi|oxlf‛x ijfkb`tkiox |odlz tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie
Hkukf ^zihld|zl iz `~~fkh`jfl fih`f z|flx iz hi|zt izdlzx/
:5=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl := ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:40<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 269/383
:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
0/ Rm`t LXK Kx/ LXK kohf|dlx7 l!a`kf3 tl}t alxx`bkob -hiz~iz`tl `od
kotlzolt j`xld+3 uikhl alxx`bkob x{xtlax3 lflhtziokh ekflx xtizld io xlzulzx&
dlxcti~x& f`~ti~x& `od itmlz zlaiu`jfl aldk`3 `od lflhtziokh d`t` xtizld ko
d`t`j`xlx/
:/ La`kf Hifflhtkio/ D|zkob hifflhtkio ie l!a`kf tml hia~fltl a`kfji}
xmi|fd jl h`~t|zld/ Tmkx kohf|dlx xlot eifdlzx& dlfltld eifdlzx& `zhmkuld eifdlzx
`od `ff itmlz eifdlz xtz|ht|zlx rktmko ` a`kfji}/
8/ ^|zbkob X{xtlax/ ‖Xlfe!~|zbkob‑ iz ‖xrll~!`od!cll~‑ ~ifkhklx `zl
ietlo ka~flalotld io `o izb`okw`tkiox l!a`kf x{xtla/ @ xlfe!~|zbkob x{xtla
`|tia`tkh`ff{ dlfltlx l!a`kf alxx`blx fih`tld ko x~lhkekh eifdlzx `etlz ` hlzt`ko
o|ajlz ie d`{x/ Xrll~!`od!cll~ x{xtlax hifflht `od zlt`ko `ff kohiakob iz
i|tbikob l!a`kf& zlb`zdflxx ie hiotlot/ Xlfe!~|zbkob x{xtlax xmi|fd jl dl`htku`tld
ke tml{ zl ko ukif`tkio ie tml fktkb`tkio mifd/ Xrll~!`od!cll~ x{xtlax olld oit jl
dl`htku`tld& j|t xtl~x xmi|fd jl t`clo ti lox|zl tm`t tml ‖xrl~t `od cl~t‑ l!a`kf kx
hifflhtld `x ~`zt ie tml hifflhtkio ie l!a`kf blolz`ff{/
4/ Fih`tkiox ie LXK/ @ff oltrizc xlzulzx& dlxcti~x `od f`~ti~x
zlaiu`jfl aldk` -l/b/& m`od mlfd dlukhlx& k^idx& tm|aj iz ef`xm dzkulx& l}tlzo`f
m`zd dzkulx& t`~l& HD iz DUD+ hiot`kokob LXK xmi|fd jl hioxkdlzld d|zkob
hifflhtkio/ Ko `ddktkio& hi|oxlf xmi|fd oit iulzfiic tmlxl fih`tkiox eiz LXK7
▧ Zlaitl Fih`tkiox/ Jz`ohm& x`tlffktl& iz x|jxkdk`z{ ieekhlx/
:5;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :; ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:405
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 270/383
8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
▧ Kotlzo`f Rljxktlx/ Ietlo izb`okw`tkiox ka~flalot kotlzo`f iz
kotz`olt rljxktlx& rmkhm& ie hi|zxl& hiot`ko LXK/
▧ Tmkzd ^`zt{ Xtiz`bl/ Iee!xktl iz tmkzd!~`zt{ d`t` xtiz`bl lktmlz ko
~m{xkh`f zlaiu`jfl aldk` iz zl`f!tkal d`t` mixtkob)`zhmkul -l/b/& l!
a`kf `zhmku`f xlzukhlx ~ziukdld j{ X@OT@W& Koh/ iz Kzio Ai|ot`ko
Kohiz~iz`tld+/
▧ ^lzxio`f Hia~|tlzx/ La~fi{llx‛ iz hiotz`htizx‛ ~lzxio`f
hia~|tlzx ietlo hiot`ko LEX/
▧ Eizalz La~fi{llx/ LXK ezia tz`oxelzzld iz ~`xt la~fi{llx a`{
m`ul jllo aiuld ezia ` xm`zld fih`tkio ti ` xl~`z`tl la~fi{ll
`zhmkul fih`tkio/
▧ Ifd X{xtlax/ Dlhiaakxxkiold iz ifd hia~|tlz x{xtlax oi fioblz ko
|xl a`{ hiot`ko LXK `od xmi|fd `fxi jl hioxkdlzld d|zkob hifflhtkio/
:2>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8> ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:402
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 271/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ ::
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
7777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX HLZTKEKH@TL IE
XLZUKHL
K& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& mlzlj{ hlztke{ ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie ^f`kotkeex
Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld |~io Dlelod`ot Tml X`ocl{ Ekza
Koh/ rlzl xlzuld tmzi|bm La`kf `od Ekzxt Hf`xx A`kf rktm ^ixt`bl e|ff{ ~zl~`kd tmkx 0;tm
d`{ ie G`o|`z{ :>0:& |~io tml eiffirkob7
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp|kzl
F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
<282 C`o`o Zi`d& X|ktl 842@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0
La`kf7 ahifloNhiflof`r/hia
Xkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio7 :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0;:
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7 Olkf X`ocl{3 Tidd X`ocl{3
X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
:20
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 80 ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:40=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 272/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ ^f`kotkeex Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
G`alx E AhH`jl& Lxp|kzl
Aizzkxio % Eilzxtlz4:< A`zclt Xtzllt
X`o Ez`ohkxhi& H@ ;40><!:4=:
La`kf7 gahh`jlNaiei/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7 Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& Koh/&
Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/&
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/& Xlkxkot& Koh/ d)j)` @hh|zkot& Hmikhl~ikot& Koh/
Gimo @ Uibt& Gz/& Lxp|kzl
Ldr`zd X`o Hm`ob& Lxp|kzl
Giolx D`{
8050 Akhmlfxio Dzkul X|ktl =>>Kzukol& H@ ;:50:
La`kf7 g`uibtNgiolxd`{/hia
La`kf7 lhm`obNgiolxd`{/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
:2:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8: ie 8: ^`bl KD(70:40;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 273/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖00‑
:28
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:4:>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 274/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIOX TI
DLELOD@OT TML X@OCL[ EKZA& KOH/ ‘ XLT IOL
^FL@XL T@CL OITKHL& ko `hhizd`ohl rktm Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ :5 `od 85
{i| `zl mlzlj{ oitkekld `od zlp|kzld ti zlx~iod ti tml eiffirkob Zlp|lxt eiz
@dakxxkiox ~zi~i|odld j{ ^f`kotkeex Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& Bi L}hlf Bfij`f
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl `od Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb Smlzlko`etlz
‖^f`kotkeex‑Q mlzlko& tmzi|bm tmlkz `ttizol{ ie zlhizd& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& F`r
Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& <<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:& F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@
0;444!:<80& rktmko tmkzt{ S8>Q d`{x ezia xlzukhl mlzlie ko `hhizd`ohl rktm tml
~ziukxkiox ie tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie Hkukf ^zihld|zl/
:24
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:4:0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 275/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
KOXTZ\HTKIOX
Dlelod`ot Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxlx ti tmlxl Zlp|lxtx eiz @dakxxkiox
xm`ff x~lhkekh`ff{ `dakt iz dlo{ l`hm xl~`z`tlf{ xt`tld a`ttlz& iz xlt eiztm ko dlt`kf
tml zl`xiox rm{ Tml X`ocl{ Ekza h`ooit tz|tme|ff{ `dakt iz dlo{ tml a`ttlz/ @
dlok`f xm`ff e`kzf{ allt tml x|jxt`ohl ie tml zlp|lxtld @dakxxkio& `od rmlo biid
e`ktm zlp|kzlx tm`t Tml X`ocl{ Ekza p|`fke{ ktx `oxrlz iz dlo{ iof{ ` ~`zt ie tml
a`ttlz ie rmkhm o `dakxxkio kx zlp|lxtld& Tml X`ocl{ Ekza xm`ff x~lhke{ xi a|hm
ie kt `x kx tz|l `od p|`fke{ iz dlo{ tml zla`kodlz/ Tml X`ocl{ Ekza a`{ oit bkul
f`hc ie koeiza`tkio iz coirfldbl `x ` zl`xio eiz e`kf|zl ti `dakt iz dlo{ |oflxx
Tml X`ocl{ Ekza xt`tlx tm`t tml{ a`dl zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tm`t tml koeiza`tkio
coiro iz zl`dkf{ ijt ko`jfl j{ tmla kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl mka ti `dakt iz dlo{
Ke ko zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl Zlp|lxtx eiz @dakxxkio Tml X`ocl{ Ekza hioxkdlzx tm`t `
a`ttlz ie rmkhm `o `dakxxkio m`x jllo zlp|lxtld ~zlxlotx ` blo|kol kxx|l eiz tzk`f
ml a`{ oit io tm`t bzi|od `fiol ijglht ti tml Zlp|lxt/
Dlelod`ot Tml X`ocl{ Ekza kx e|ztmlz `dukxld tm`t l`hm a`ttlz mlzlko`etlz
xlt eiztm rkff jl dllald `dakttld j{ tmla |oflxx& rktmko tmkzt{ S8>Q d`{x `etlz
jlkob xlzuld tmlzlrktm tml{ xlzul |~io ^f`kotkeex hi|oxlf tmlkz rzkttlo `oxrlz iz
ijglhtkio `ddzlxxld ti tml a`ttlz `od xkbold j{ Tml X`ocl{ Ekza iz tmlkz `ttizol{
E|ztmlz& ke x`kd Dlelod`ot dloklx `o{ a`ttlz mlzlko xi|bmt ti jl `dakttld `od
^f`kotkee f`tlz ~ziulx ` dih|alot ti jl blo|kol iz tml a`ttlz tz|l& ^f`kotkee a`{
:2<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:4::
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 276/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 8
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
aiul tm`t tml ~`zt{ rmi e`kfld ti `dakt ~`{ mkx zl`xio`jfl l}~loxlx& kohf|dkob
@ttizol{"x Ellx& koh|zzld ko a`ckob tm`t ~ziie/ Eko`ff{& Dlelod`ot Tml X`ocl{
Ekza kx `dukxld tm t Z|fl 82-`+-4+ ie tml Eldlz`f Z|flx ie Hkukf ^zihld|zl ~ziukdlx
tm`t `o lu`xkul iz kohia~fltl zlx~ioxl ti `o{ ie tml eiffirkob Zlp|lxtx rkff jl
tzl`tld `x ` e`kf|zl ti zlx~iod eiz ~|z~ixlx ie hia~lffkob dkxhiulz{ `od)iz xllckob
x`ohtkiox ko Hi|zt/
DLEKOKTKIOX
Oitrktmxt`odkob tml x~lhkekh dlekoktkiox jlfir& l`hm rizd& tlza& iz ~mz`xl
|xld ko tmlxl Zlp|lxtx xmi|fd jl bkulo tmlkz aixt l}~`oxkul `od kohf|xkul
al`okob/ @x |xld7
`+ *^f`kotkeex‑ xm`ff al`o ^f`kotkeex Fkx` Fkjlzk& Fkx` Ixtlff`& Bi L}hlf
Bfij`f& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& Tml F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& `od ^f`kotkeex
X~i|xlx& Hmkfdzlo `od E`akf{ Alajlzx/
j+ ‖Dlelod`ot* xm`ff al`o Dlelod`ot Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ S‖Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza‑Q/
h+ *Kohkdlot* xm`ff al`o `x dlekold ko tml Hia~f`kot/
d+ ‖H|xtialz-x+‑ xm`ff al`o ~li~fl rmi mkzl `od |tkfkwl Dlelod`ot Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza‛x koulxtkb`tkio xlzukhlx3
l+ ‖La~fi{ll-x+‑ xm`ff al`o `o{ ~lzxio la~fi{ld j{ {i| iz `htkob `x
`o `blot eiz {i|/
:25
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:4:8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 277/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 4
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
e+ ‖[i|‑ iz ‖{i|z‑ al`ox tml ~lzxio iz lotkt{ zlx~iodkob ti tmlxl
Kotlzzib`tizklx `od `o{ ~zlxlot iz eizalz la~fi{llx& `blotx& hiox|ft`otx iz itmlz
~lzxio `htkob iz ~|z~iztkob ti `ht io jlm`fe ie x|hm ~lzxio iz lotkt{/
b+ *Dih|alot-x+* xm`ff al`o `o{ rzktkobx ie `o{ ckod `od xm`ff kohf|dl
tml izkbko`f `od l`hm oio!kdlotkh`f hi~{ iz dz`et tmlzlie/ Tml tlza m`x tml x`al
al`okob `x ‖rzktkobx‑& rmkhm kx dlekold ko Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ 84-`+ `od Eld/ Z/ Lukd/
0>>0`x kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti& `o{ lflhtziokh`ff{ xtizld d`t`& d`t`j`xlx&
dih|alotx& `od lflhtziokh hiaa|okh`tkio -x|hm `x L!a`kf+& xtizld ko hia~|tlzx iz
itmlzrkxl& rmltmlz iz oit lulz ~zkotld iz dkx~f`{ld& tm`t m`ul oit ~zluki|xf{ jllo
~zid|hld/ @ hi~{ iz d|~fkh`tl ie ` dih|alot tm`t m`x jllo ~zid|hld/ @ hi~{ iz
d|~fkh`tl ie ` dih|alot tm`t m`x `o{ hioeizakob oitlx& a`zbko`f `ooit`tkiox& iz
itmlz a`zckobx& `x rlff `x `o{ ~zlfkako`z{ ulzxkio& dz`et& iz zlukxkio ie tml
eizlbikob& xm`ff jl hioxkdlzld ` xl~`z`tl dih|alot rktmko tml al`okob ie tmkx
tlza/ Tml tlza Dih|alot xm`ff `fxi kohf|dl lulz{ itmlz al`ox j{ rmkhm
koeiza`tkio kx zlhizdld iz tz`oxakttld kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti& lflhtziokh
La`kf& Kotlzolt& Kotlzolt ~ixtkobx& t`~l zlhizdkobx& ukdli zlhizdkobx& akhziekfax&
~|ohm h`zdx& hia~|tlz a`boltkh t`~l& hia~|tlz dkxhx& hia~|tlz ~zibz`ax& xtiz`bl
t`~lx& ~zkoti|tx& d`t` ~zihlxxkob zlhizdx& `od tml rzkttlo koeiza`tkio olhlxx`z{ ti
|odlzxt`od `od |xl x|hm koeiza`tkio/ Eiz l`hm *dih|alot* zlx~ioxkul ti `o{
:22
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:4:4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 278/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ <
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
zlp|lxt rktmmlfd ezia ~zid|htkio j{ {i| io tml bzi|od ie `o{ ~zkukflbl& ~fl`xl
xt`tl7
-k+ Tml o`t|zl ie tml dih|alot -l/b/& flttlz& alaiz`od|a& hiotz`ht& lth/+3
-kk+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~lzxio-x+ ~zl~`zkob kt `od ie tml xlodlz-x+3
-kkk+ Ktx tktfl iz& ke kt m`x oi tktfl& ` dlxhzk~tkio ie tml blolz`f o`t|zl ie ktx
x|jglht a`ttlz3
-ku+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml `ddzlxxll-x+& ke o{3
-u+ Tml d`tl tml dih|alot r`x |tmizld& xlot& od)iz zlhlkuld3
-uk+ Fih`tkio ie tml izkbko`f& iz& ke tmlzl kx oi izkbko`f& tml fih`tkio ie `ff
hi~klx& `od kdlotkt{ ie ~zlxlot h|xtidk`o3 `od
-ukk+ Rmltmlz tml dih|alot kx hf kald ti jl ~zkukflbld3 ke {i| hf ka tml
dih|alot kx ~zkukflbld& tml zl`xio x|hm dih|alot kx `fflbldf{
~zkukflbld/
m+ *^lzxio-x+* al`ox `o{ m|a`o jlkob& `o{ ekza& `eekfk`tl& gikot ulot|zl
koxtkt|tkio& hiz~iz`tkio& xifl ~zi~zkltizxmk~& fkaktld ~`ztolzxmk~& ~`ztolzxmk~&
`xxihk`tkio& bzi|~ ie m|a`o jlkobx& itmlz flb`f iz dl e`hti lotkt{& iz hiz~iz`tkio&
ie rm`tlulz ckod& iz `o{ itmlz j|xkolxx iz biulzoalot`f lotkt{ ie `o{ hm`z`htlz
rm`txilulz& tibltmlz rktm tml ~`ztolzx& tz|xtllx& ieekhlzx& dkzlhtizx& la~fi{llx& iz
`blotx tmlzlie/
k+ *Hiaa|okh`tkio* xm`ff al`o `ff eizax ie rzkttlo iz ulzj`f
kotlzhi|zxl& kohf|dkob rktmi|t fkakt`tkio kop|kzklx& dkxh|xxkiox& hioulzx`tkiox
olbitk`tkiox& `bzllalotx& |odlzxt`odkobx& alltkobx& tlfl~miol hioulzx`tkiox
:2=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:4:<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 279/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 5
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
flttlzx& oitlx& tlflbz`ax& olrx~`~lz iz a`b`wkol `ztkhflx& `dulztkxlalotx& `od itmlz
dih|alotx `x ~zluki|xf{ dlekold/
g+ ‖^li~fl Ekodlz d`t`‑ xm`ff al`o Dirofi`d`jfl hia~|tlz xietr`zl
o`alf{ hiff`jiz`tkio xietr`zl& eiz tml e`hkfkt`tkio& `o`f{xkx `od lu`f|`tkio ie
hiox|alz `od ~li~fl d`t`& coirfldbl `od ~zihlxxlx& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti
xietr`zl |tkfkwld ti ~|ff xihk f ~ziekfkob ie hiox|alz `od ~li~fl d`t`& eko`ohk`f
d`t`& hzldkt d`t`& ~lzxio`f kdlotke{kob d`t`& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti o`alx&
Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlzx& `blx& d`tlx ie jkztm& `ddzlxxlx& mial u`f|`tkiox& kohial&
lth/& `bl d`t`& ld|h`tkio`f d`t`& hzkako`f d`t`& ml`ftm h`zl d`t`& aldkh`f d`t`&
hmkfdzlo d`t`& lth/
c+ ‖Lflhtziokh D`t`‑ xm`ff al`o `o{ `od ff d`t` hiot`kold rktmko `o{ ie
Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛ d`t`j`xl x{xtlax `od xlzulzx ~lzt`kokob ti hiox|alzx& hfklotx&
~li~fl& j|xkolxxlx& lth/
f+ ‖Lflhtziokh A`kf‑ xm`ff al`o ff l!a`kfx xlot `od zlhlkuld rktm tml
e|ff ‖ml`dlz‑ koeiza`tkio/
a+ *^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx* al`ox ` ~lzxio"x o`al iz Xihk f Xlh|zkt{
o|ajlz iz itmlz |okp|l d`t` rmkhm kdlotkeklx iz kx `xxihk`tld rktm ` ~`ztkh|f`z
*~lzxio/*
:2;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:4:5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 280/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 2
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
o+ *Kdlotke{* iz ti bkul tml *kdlotkt{* ie xm`ff al`o7
@/ ko tml h`xl ie ` o`t|z f ~lzxio& ti xt tl7
-k/+ @o{ `od `ff o`alx& flb`f& tz`dl iz `xx|ald3
-kk/+ F`xt coiro mial `od j|xkolxx `ddzlxxlx `od tlfl~miol
o|ajlzx3
-kkk/+ @ff tlfl~miol `od tlfl!e`} o|ajlzx |xld3
-ku/+ @ff rljxktlx irold od |xld3
-u/+ @ff La`kf `ddzlxxlx irold `od |xld3
-uk/+ La~fi{lz iz j|xkolxx eekfk`tkio3
-ukk/+ Ihh|~`tkio `od j|xkolxx ~ixktkio -kohf|dkob tktfl+ mlfd3
-ukkk/+ La~fi{lz"x o`al& `ddzlxx& ~miol o|ajlz `od tml
la~fi{lz"x zlf`tkioxmk~ ti `o{ `od `ff Dlelod`otx ko tml
`jiul h`~tkiold `htkio3 `od& ke `~~fkh`jfl7
-k}/+ Jz`od& a`cl& a`o|e`ht|zlz"x o`al& `ddzlxx& ~miol o|ajlz
`od tml a`o|e`ht|zlz"x zlf`tkioxmk~ ti `o{ `od `ff
Dlelod`otx ko tml `jiul h`~tkiold `htkio3
J/ Ko tml h`xl ie `o iz`f xt`tlalot ie hiaa|okh`tkio& ti xt`tl7
-k/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml a`clz-x+ `od zlhk~klot-x+ ie tml iz`f
xt`tlalot iz hiaa|okh`tkio3
-kk/+ Rmlzl `od rmlo tml iz`f xt tlalot iz hiaa|okh`tkio r`x
a`dl3
-kkk/+ Tml kdlotktklx ie `ff ~lzxiox ~zlxlot rmlo tml iz`f xt`tlalot
iz hiaa|okh`tkio r`x a`dl3
-ku/+ Tml aidl ie hiaa|okh`tkio3 `od
:=>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl = ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:4:2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 281/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ =
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
-u/+ Tml x|jglht a`ttlz ie tml iz`f xt tlalot iz hiaa|okh`tkio/
H/ Ko tml h`xl ie `o `ht iz iakxxkio& ti xt`tl7
-k/+ @ dlt kfld dlxhzk~tkio ie tml `ht iz iakxxkio3
-kk/+ Tml d`tl rmlo kt ihh|zzld3
-kkk/+ Tml ~f`hl rmlzl kt ihh|zzld3
-ku/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~lzxio iz ~lzxiox ~lzeizakob x|hm `htx
iz ko tml h`xl ie `o iakxxkio& tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~lzxio iz
~lzxiox e`kfkob ti `ht3 `od
-u/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie `ff ~lzxiox rmi m`ul coirfldbl ie tml ht iziakxxkio/
D/ Ko tml h`xl ie ~mitibz ~m iz ~mitibz ~mkh zl~zid|htkio& ti xt`tl7
-k/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie tml ~mitibz`~m iz ~lzxio zlx~ioxkjfl eiz tml
a`ckob ie tml ~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio3
-kk/+ Tml o|ajlz ie ~mitibz ~mx t clo iz ~mitibz`~mkh
zl~zid|htkiox a`dl3
-kkk/+ Rmlo `od rmlzl tml ~mitibz`~mx rlzl t clo iz tml
~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkiox rlzl a`dl3
-ku/+ Tml x|jglht a`ttlz dl~khtld ko l`hm ~mitibz ~m iz
~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio3 od
-u/+ Tml kdlotkt{ ie l`hm ~lzxio rmi m`x ~ixxlxxkio& h|xtid{& iz
hiotzif ie l`hm ~mitibz`~m iz ~mitibz`~mkh zl~zid|htkio/
m/ Tml ~mz`xl *zlf tlx ti&* *zlf tkob ti&* iz *ko zlf`tkio ti* al`ox ti
hioxkxt ie& zlelz ti& zleflht& iz jl ko `o{ r`{ fibkh`ff{& e`ht|`ff{& iz flb`ff{
hioolhtld rktm tml a`ttlz dkxh|xxld/
:=0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl ; ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:4:=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 282/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ ;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
k/ *@|dkt Tz`kf* al`ox ` hia~fltl& dlt`kfld fkxtkob ie l`hm `od lulz{
`ftlz`tkio& dlfltkio& kop|kz{ koti& aidkekh`tkio iz itmlz hm`obl ti tml hzldkt zl~izt
iz ~ziekfl `x a`kot`kold ko zlhizdld eiza& ko tml jzi`dlxt xloxl& j{ *{i|*/ Tml
fkxtkob xmi|fd kohf|dl tml kdlotkt{& `ddzlxx& la~fi{lz `od tktfl ie tml ~lzxio-x+
t`ckob tml `htkio& tml kdlotkt{& `ddzlxx& la~fi{lz `od tktfl ie tml ~lzxio-x+
`|tmizkwkob tml `htkio& ` dlt`kfld l}~f`o`tkio ie tml `htkio t`clo& tml d`tl ie tml
`htkio& tml al`ox |xld ti leelht x|hm `htkio& tml fih`tkio ie izkbko ie tml `htkio `od
tml zl`xio tml `htkio r`x t`clo/ Tml tlza *`|dkt tz`kf* `fxi kohf|dlx tml dlekoktkio
~ziukdld eiz tml ~mz`xl ko tml EldlzJ|xm& Eldlz`f Tz`dl Hiaakxxkio `od Eiza`
Xt`ee I~kokio Flttlz& A`zhm 0>& 0;=8/
g/ *D`t`* al`ox tml ~m{xkh`f x{ajifx ko tml jzi`dlxt xloxl tm`t
zl~zlxlot koeiza`tkio& zlb`zdflxx ie rmltmlz tml koeiza`tkio kx iz`f& rzkttlo iz
itmlzrkxl zlhizdld/
c/ *Hia~|tlz* al`ox `o{ `od ff ~zibz`aa`jfl lflhtziokh dlukhlx iz
`~~`z`t|xlx& kohf|dkob m`zdr`zl& xietr`zl& `od itmlz d`t`j`ocx& tm`t h`o xtizl
zltzklul& `hhlxx& |~d`tl& hiajkol& zl`zz`obl& ~zkot& zl`d& ~zihlxx iz itmlzrkxl `ftlz
d`t` rmltmlz x|hm d`t` a`kot`kold ko tm`t dlukhl iz `t xial itmlz fih`tkio/ Tml
tlza *hia~|tlz* kohf|dlx `o{ `od `ff a`boltkh zlhizdkobx iz x{xtlax& x{xtlax
i~lz`tkob io iz a`kot`kokob d`t` ko dkbkt`f& `o`fib& iz m{jzkd eiza`t& iz itmlz
alhm`okh`f dlukhlx& iz itmlz dlukhlx h`~`jfl ie a`kot`kokob rzktkobx iz
:=:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:4:;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 283/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
zlhizdkobx& ie `o{ ckod& ko hiodloxld eiza`t& `od kohf|dlx `o{ dkxc& t`~l&
zlhizdkob& iz itmlz koeiza`tkio`f xi|zhl& zlb`zdflxx ie ktx ~m{xkh`f dkaloxkio iz
xkwl/
f/ *Eiza`t* al`ox tml blolz`f a`cl|~ iz blolz`f ~f`o ie
izb`okw`tkio iz `zz`oblalot ie d`t`/
a/ *L}~f`ko* al`ox ti lf|hkd tl& a`cl ~f ko iz |odlzxt od`jfl& ti
bkul tml zl`xio eiz iz h`|xl ie& `od ti xmir tml fibkh`f dlulfi~alot iz
zlf`tkioxmk~x tmlzlie/
o/ *Dlxhzkjl* al`ox ti zl~zlxlot iz bkul `o hhi|ot ie ko rizdx/
i/ ‖\xlz‑ al`ox `o{ ~lzxio iz hia~|tlz rmkhm kotlz`htx rktm `
dkeelzlot hia~|tlz/
~/ ‖@hhlxx ^zibz`ax‑ al`ox tmlxl ~zibz`ax& ~m{xkh`f iz hia~|tlz!
j`xld& rmkhm kox|zl `|tmizkw`tkio& kdlotkekh`tkio& ulzkekh`tkio& `hhlxx hiotzif
`hhi|ot`jkfkt{ `od xlh|zkt{ `|dkt ie {i|z hiox|alz d`t`j`xl/
p/ ‖Koeiza tkio ^zitlhtkio @zhmktlht|zl‑ al`ox ` xt tlalot ie tml
iulz`ff dlxkbo `od i~lz`tkob ijglhtkulx eiz tml xlh|zkt{& hiotko|kt{ `od hiotzif ie
{i|z hiox|alz d`t`j`xl/
z/ ‖Hiox|alz D`t`j`xl‑ kx kotlodld ti al`o Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x
lotkzl hiox|alz oltrizc& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti tl}t ekflx a`dl& ekfl ~|zbl
ekfl zlizb`okw`tkio aidl& `ff i~lz`tiz ~zl`ajfl& kdlotkekh`tkio `od ~`xxrizd
:=8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 00 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:48>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 284/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 00
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
aidlx& `od `ff itmlz xkobfl iz iulzf`{kob ~zibz`ax& `~~fkh`tkiox `od)iz x{xtlax
`od dilx kohf|dl& j|t kx oit fkaktld ti tml a`ko i~lz`tkob x{xtla/
^F@KOTKEEX ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIOX7
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 07
@dakt L]MKJKT ‖@‑ `tt`hmld mlzlti kx `o La`kf xlot ezia Tml X`ocl{
Ekza& Koh/ j{ Olkf X`ocl{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ :7
@dakt {i| m`ul `hhi|otx rktm Hioek!Hmlc& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld
Lfxluklz& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx
Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~3
@hh|zkot& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& `od Coir]/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 87
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ `od Tidd X`ocl{ |xld {i|z fib!ko hzldlotk fx `od
ijt`kold ^f`kotkeex eko`ohk`f zlhizdx& hzldkt zlhizdx& la~fi{alot zlhizdx& aldkh f
zlhizdx `od itmlz zlhizdx ezia Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc
`od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/3
Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot& `od Hmikhl^ikot
:=4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:480
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 285/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0:
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
Koh/& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Coir]& Hioek!Hmlc& lth/ rktmi|t ` ~lzakxxkjfl
~|z~ixl iz `o{ t{~l ie flb`f lotktflalot/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 47
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ kx oit ` fkhloxld zku`tl Koulxtkb tiz eiz Tml X`ocl{
Ekza/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ <7
@dakt {i| `zl zlx~ioxkjfl eiz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ htkiox od ko`htkiox/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 57
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tkiox fkhloxkob kx
biulzold j{ tml H`fkeizok` J|zl`| ie Xlh|zkt{ `od Koulxtkb`tkul Xlzukhlx
S‖JXKX‑Q/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 27
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `zl zlp|kzld ti `dmlzl ti tml H`fkeizok`
f`rx `od tml b|kdlfkolx& zlp|kzlalotx& `od zlb|f`tkiox i|tfkold ko tml H`fkeizok`
JXKX/
:=<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 08 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:48:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 286/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 08
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ =7
@dakt {i| `od)iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `hhlxxld `od ijt`kold tml ^li~fl Ekodlz
d`t`& ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx& Hzldkt Zl~iztx& Eko`ohk`f Zl~iztx& Xl`fld Hi|zt
Dih|alotx `od itmlz dih|alotx io tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo `od ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ alajlzx tmzi|bm Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc
Xif|tkiox& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot
`od Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Coir]& Hioek!Hmlc& lth/
rktmi|t `o{ t{~l ie ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f lotktflalot `od ~ziukdld
^f`kotkeex d`t` ti tml itmlz Dlelod`otx& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti Olkf X`ocl{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ ;7
@dakt L]MKJKT ‖@‑ `tt`hmld mlzlti hiot`kox f`kotkee Fkx` Fkjlzk‛x o`al
Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz-x+& d`tl ie jkztm& X~i|xlx o`al& d`tl ie jkztm `od Xihk`f
Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz `od itmlz hioekdlotk`f koeiza`tkio ijt`kold ezia Kotlfk|x& Koh/&
Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx/hia& Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~&
@hh|zkot& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od
Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/
:=5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 04 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:488
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 287/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 04
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 0>7
@dakt rmlo {i| iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ koulxtkb`tl `o Kodkukd|`f& {i| `od
{i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `zl zlp|kzld ti a`kot`ko tml Kodkukd|`f-x+ ~zku`tl `od ~lzxio`f
d`t`& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz& d`tl ie jkztm&
~f`hl ie jkztm& Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz& aitmlz‛x a`kdlo o`alx& eko`ohk`f `od
hzldkt d`t`& aldkh`f d`t`& lth/ hioekdlotk`f od oit xm`zl kt rktm tml ~|jfkh/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 007
@dakt tml H`fkeizok` JXKX zlxtzkhtx {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ ezia
`hhlxxkob `od ijt`kokob ` ~lzxio-x+ e|ff Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz `od itmlz ~zku`tl
kdlotke{kob koeiza`tkio eiz tml ~|z~ixl ie ~|jfkxmkob tml ~lzxio`f d`t` ti m`za tml
kodkukd|`f-x+/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 0:7
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ `od Tidd X`ocl{ |tkfkwld {i|z fib ko hzldlotk`fx `od
ijt`kold koeiza`tkio ezia tml H`fkeizok` Dl~`ztalot ie Aitiz Ulmkhflx& itmlz
~lzxio-x+& `blohklx `od lotktklx& kohf|dkob tml itmlz Dlelod`otx& io tml ^f`kotkeex
j`xld io e`fxl ~zltloxlx/
:=2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0< ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:484
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 288/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0<
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 087
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ m`ul hzl`tld kzzlulzxkjfl m`za `od
d`a`blx ti ^f`kotkeex j{ dkxxlako`tkob lzzioli|x koeiza`tkio3 tmlkz ^li~fl Ekodlz
D`t` `od tmlkz ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx ti `o kaal`x|z`jfl `ai|ot ie ~li~fl `od
j|xkolxxlx/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 047
@dakt {i| iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ dkd oit m`ul `o{ ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz
flb`f lotktflalot ti `o{ koeiza`tkio zlb`zdkob `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ 0<7
@dakt {i| `zl |o`jfl ti dlaioxtz tl mir a`o{ ~li~fl m`ul zlhlkuld
^f`kotkeex ~zku`tl ~lzxio`f kdlotke{kob koeiza`tkio `od kohizzlht koeiza`tkio
jlh`|xl ie tml o`t|zl ie tml kotlzolt `od tml o|alzi|x r`{x kt r`x zl~l`tldf{
~ixtld io tml Kotlzolt `od xlot i|t j{ Dlelod`otx Izf{ T`ktw& Olkf X`ocl{ `od tml
itmlz Dlelod`otx/
:==
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 05 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:48<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 289/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 290/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 02
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ :>7
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ ti |xl {i|z fib!ko
hzldlotk`fx `od `hhlxx `od ~|ff xl`fld dih|alotx kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti
xl`fld hi|zt dih|alotx ~lzt`kokob ti tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex
Hmkfdzlo od ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ :07
@dakt rmlo {i| `od)iz {i|z ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tiz-x+ zl zlp|lxtld iz mkzld ti
~lzeiza ` gij eiz ` hfklot& {i| `od {i|z ^zku tl Koulxtkb`tiz-x+ `zl zlp|kzld ti
lox|zl {i|z hfklot m`x ` ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f lotktflalot ti tml koeiza`tkio
xi|bmt/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DAKXXKIO OI/ ::7
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `zl zlp|kzld ti ulzke{ tml ~lzakxxkjfl
~|z~ixl `od)iz flb`f lotktflalot ie {i|z Hfklot ti Kodkukd|`f-x+ ^li~fl Ekodlz
D`t`& ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklz D`t`& Eko`ohk`f Zlhizdx& Hzldkt D`t`& `od itmlz
koeiza`tkio/
:;>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0= ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:482
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 291/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 292/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ 0;
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=L]MKJKT ‖@‑
:;:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :> ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:48;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 293/383
Ezia7 Olkf X@OCL[ 6ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hia?
X|jglht7 ER7 FKX@ FKJLZK lth
Ti7 dzYt`ktwN{`mii/hia
D`tl7 Aiod`{& @~zkf 08& :>>;& 27>4 ^A
Mlzl kx tml Fkjlzk xt|ee {i| zlp|lxtld/ Tmkx kx `fxi rm`t K xlot ti Jij \oz|m
Ezia7 Olkf X@OCL[ Sa`kfti7ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hiaQ
Xlot7 Ezkd`{& @~zkf 0>& :>>; 0>7>0 @A
Ti7 Jij \oz|m
X|jglht7 FKX@ FKJLZK lth
Jij mlzl `zl xial j`zl e`htx `ji|t Jlzb‛x `xxkxt`ot/ Xll jlfir `od `tt`hmalotxK dio‛t coir mir a|hm ie tml xtiz{ {i| m`ul `fzl`d{& j|t kx lxxlotk`ff{ `ji|t RMI xmlzl`ff{ kx `od tml p|lxtkiox tm`t |oeizt|o`tlf{ jzkobx |~ `ji|t Jlzb/H`ff& ke {i| olld ti& `t {i|z hiouloklohl/
Olkf X`ocl{Koulxtkb`tiz % Hiox|ft`ot/
TML X@OCL[ EKZA
Xkak U`ffl{& H`fkeizok` ;8>58
ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hia
=>< <:> 80<0=0= :0: 250< hlff
-@ddlod|a+
FKX@ ZLOLL FKJLZK/ Jo <):=)0;5</ 45:!4<!}}}}& 5::!0;!480: -% itmlzx+
@hhizdkob ti tml ^ifkhl xml r`x jizo HI\ZUKFFL `od a`zzkld ` Zkhm`zdxio -^ixxkjfl@f`o Di|bf`x Zkhm`zdxio& h|zzlotf{ zlxkdkob ko F`x Ulb`x /+ KE kt r`x tml itmlz r`{`zi|od& tmlo tml Hi|zukffl kx Jkff A`zxm`ff Hi|zukffl 00)0>)50 ie Mi|xtio & T}/ 4<2!20!} K
m`ul xlulz`f XX("x eiz mlz `od ` FIT ie @C@"x/ Mlz zl`f XX( kx ~zij`jf{ 45:!4<!}}}}/
Aixt ~ziakolot itmlzrkxl `zl <58!5>!}}}}& <2:!02!}& 5::!0;!} Xml rlot JC ko :>>:Mlz jzitmlz kx ~zij`jf{ F`rzlohl L Aizzkx ie Eiot`o` `od Z`ohmi H|h & H@ / Ml r`xjizo 0)05)54 Mlz M|xj`od& Jzlot G& ` ^`zifll& K m`ul oit zlxl`zhmld tm`t/ Kx ~zij`jf{Jzlot G AhHiza`hc <58!22& `fxi |xlx 880!>:!}
Tmlzl kx `fxi ` Glzz{ MLFFLZ `od Di|bf`x Hz`alz fiic kotlzlxtkob& j|t rmlzl di {i|xti~9/
:;8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :0 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:44>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 294/383
? Ezia7 ox`ocl{Ntmlx`ocl{ekza/hia
? Ti7 fkx`ixtlff`Nmita`kf/hia3 dzYt`ktwN{`mii/hia? X|jglht7 ER7 ??????????\zblot KA^IZT@OT KOEI X@AL X\JGLHT66666
? D`tl7 Aio& 05 A`z :>>; 047<2708 >2>>
?
??
? ^FL@XL OITL TML F@XT FKOL!?
? Tm|zxd`{& @~zkf 0>& :>>=
??
? Olr Al}khi Ria`o Xlotlohld ko Kdlotkt{ Tmlet `od Zl`f Lxt`tl Ez`|d
?
?? Fkx` Fkjlzk& `c` Fkx` Zkhm`zdxio& 4:& Olr Al}khi& r`x xlotlohld ko
? hioolhtkio rktm elfio{ hm`zblx kouifukob kdlotkt{ tmlet `od eizbld? dih|alotx/ Fkjlzk `~~l`zld ko X`o Jlzo`zdkoi Hi|ot{& Z`ohmi H|h`aiob`&? X|~lzkiz Hi|zt& io A`zhm :0& :>>=/ Xml r`x xlotlohld ti ` xt`tl ~zkxio tlza
? ie = {l`zx& ka~ixld j|t xt`{ld& `od ~f`hld io x|~lzukxld ~zij`tkio eiz 8
? {l`zx `x ~`zt ie ` ~fl` `bzllalot/ Fkjlzk r`x xlotlohld io tlo elfio{? hi|otx z`obkob ezia Bz`od Tmlet& Eizblz{& `od Ekfkob E`fxl Dih|alotx/
?
? Ezia :>>> ti :>>4& Fkjlzk lob`bld ko ` hia~fl} ez`|d kouifukob e`fxkekh`tkio
? ie ~ifkhl zl~iztx& a`ok~|f`tkio ie hzldkt j|zl`| zl~iztx& fi`o ez`|d& `od? hi|otlzelktkob ie hi|zt dih|alotx zlx|ftkob ko m|odzldx ie tmi|x`odx ie
? diff`zx ko fixxlx ti j`ocx `od hzldkt |okiox/
?? Ko :>>:& X`o Jlzo`zdkoi Hi|ot{ Xmlzkee"x Dl~`ztalot ~lzxioolf `zzlxtld
? Fkjlzk io tmlet j{ e`fxl ~zltloxl hm`zblx/ Ko G|f{ :>>4& Koulxtkb`tizx ezia
? tml X`o Jlzo`zdkoi Hi|ot{ Dkxtzkht @ttizol{"x Zl`f Lxt`tl Ez`|d \okt? `zzlxtld Fkjlzk `t tml Iot`zki Kotlzo`tkio`f @kz~izt eiz `ddktkio`f elfio{
? hm`zblx rmkfl xml r`x i|t io j`kf/
?? Xml m`x `o l}tloxkul hzkako`f zlhizd bikob j`hc ti tml ;>"x/
:;4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :: ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:440
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 295/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 296/383
@zzlxt Hm`zblx
Hi|ot Hm`zbl Xlulzkt{ Dlxhzk~tkio Ukif`tkio D`tl
^fl` Xt`t|x
0 ^H 4<; E J\ZBF@Z[ ><)0=):>>0
Ekfld Hm`zblx
Hi|ot Hm`zbl Xlulzkt{ Dlxhzk~tkio Ukif`tkio D`tl
^fl` Xt`t|x
0^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 MT@
:^H42>-D+
E EIZBLZ[ ><)0=):>>0 MT@
8 ^H 42: E EIZBL IEEKHK@F XL@F ><)0=):>>0 MT@
4^H00<-@+
EIEELZ)LTH E@FXL)EIZBLDKOXTZ\ALOT TI EKFL
><)0=):>>0 MT@
< ^H4=2-@+ E BZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>> ><)0=):>>0 MT@
5^H42>-D+
E EIZBLZ[ ><)0=):>>0 MT@
2 ^H 42: E EIZBL IEEKHK@F XL@F ><)0=):>>0 MT@
=^H00<-@+
EIEELZ)LTH E@FXL)EIZBLDKOXTZ\ALOT TI EKFL
><)0=):>>0 MT@
;^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 MT@
0>^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 MT@
00^H
4=2-D+-0+E
BZ@OD TMLET7
@\TIAIJKFL)@OKA@F)LTH><)0=):>>0 MT@
0:^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 MT@
08^H4=2-D+-0+
EBZ@OD TMLET7@\TIAIJKFL)@OKA@F)LTH
><)0=):>>0 MT@
04^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 MT@
0<^H4=2-D+-0+
EBZ@OD TMLET7@\TIAIJKFL)@OKA@F)LTH
><)0=):>>0 MT@
05^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 MT@
02
^H
4=2-@+ E
BZ@OD TMLET7
^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>> ><)0=):>>0 MT@
Koeiz Hm`zblx
Hi|ot Hm`zbl Xlulzkt{ Dlxhzk~tkio Ukif`tkio D`tl
^fl` Xt`t|x
0^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 B\KFT[ HIOUKHTLD
:;5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :4 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:448
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 297/383
:^H425@-@+
EOIOX\EEKHKLOT E\ODX7HMLHCX
><)0=):>>0 B\KFT[ HIOUKHTLD
8^H42>-D+
E EIZBLZ[ ><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
4 ^H 42: E EIZBL IEEKHK@F XL@F ><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
< ^H00<-@+ E IEELZ)LTH E@FXL)EIZBLDKOXTZ\ALOT TI EKFL ><)0=):>>0 B\KFT[ HIOUKHTLD
5^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 B\KFT[ HIOUKHTLD
2 ^H 425 EA@CKOB& IXXLXXKOB&\TTLZKOB EKHTKI\XKOXTZX
><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
=^H42>-D+
E EIZBLZ[ ><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
; ^H 42: E EIZBL IEEKHK@F XL@F ><)0=):>>0 B\KFT[ HIOUKHTLD
0>^H00<-@+
EIEELZ)LTH E@FXL)EIZBLDKOXTZ\ALOT TI EKFL
><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
00 ^H4=2-@+
E BZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 B\KFT[ HIOUKHTLD
0:^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 B\KFT[ HIOUKHTLD
08^H4=2-D+-0+
EBZ@OD TMLET7@\TIAIJKFL)@OKA@F)LTH
><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
04^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
0<^H4=2-D+-0+
EBZ@OD TMLET7@\TIAIJKFL)@OKA@F)LTH
><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
05^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
02 ^H4=2-D+-0+
E BZ@OD TMLET7@\TIAIJKFL)@OKA@F)LTH
><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
0=^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 B\KFT[ HIOUKHTLD
0;^H4=2-@+
EBZ@OD TMLET7^ZI^LZT[)LTH IULZ $4>>
><)0=):>>0 B\KFT[ HIOUKHTLD
:>^H00<-@+
EIEELZ)LTH E@FXL)EIZBLDKOXTZ\ALOT TI EKFL
><)0=):>>0 B\KFT[ HIOUKHTLD
:0^H42>-D+
E EIZBLZ[ ><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
::^H42>-D+
E EIZBLZ[ ><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
:8 ^H 42: E EIZBL IEEKHK@F XL@F ><)0=):>>0 DKXAKXXLD
H`xl ERU>:=>>> Dlelod`ot 05>=00: FKJLZK& FKX@ ZLOLL ! ^zij`tkio
^zij`tkio T{~l7 EIZA@F Bz`otld7 >8):0):>>= L}~kzl7 >8):0):>00
:;2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :< ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:444
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 298/383
X\^LZUKXLD ^ZIJ@TKIO BZ@OTLD EIZ @ ^LZKID IE 85 AIOTMX IO EIFFIRKOBTLZAX @OD HIODKTKIOX7
0+
XLZUL :5 D@[X KO @ X@O JLZO@ZDKOI HI\OT[ G@KF E@HKFKT[& RKTM HZLDKTEIZ TKAL XLZULD& @ A@TTLZ IE :5 D@[X& ^F\X HIOD\HT HZLDKT^\ZX\@OT TI 0!^H4>0; OD @JKDL J[ @FF Z\FLX @OD ZLB\F@TKIOX IE TML
E@HKFKT[ RKTMI\T TML ^IXXKJKFKT[ IE HI\OT[ ^@ZIFL/:+ UKIF@TL OI F@R/
8+
ZL^IZT TI TML ^ZIJ IEEKHLZ KO ^LZXIO KAALDK@TLF[ >! ODTMLZL@ETLZ IOHL LULZ[ EI\ZTLLO -04+ D@[X IZ @X DKZLHTLD/ ZL^IZTTI TML ^ZIJ IEEKHLZ KO ^LZXIO KAALDK@TLF[ >! OD TMLZL@ETLZ IOHLLULZ[ EI\ZTLLO -04+ D@[X IZ @X DKZLHTLD/
4+HII^LZ@TL RKTM TML ^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ KO @ ^F@O IE ZLM@JKFKT@TKIO@OD EIFFIR @FF ZL@XIO@JFL DKZLHTKULX IE TML ^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ/
<+XLLC @OD A@KOT@KO B@KOE\F LA^FI[ALOT& IZ @TTLOD XHMIIF& @ODCLL^ TML ^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ KOEIZALD IE XT@T\X IE LA^FI[ALOT& IZXHMIIF/
5+
CLL^ TML ^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ KOEIZALD IE ^F@HL IE ZLXKDLOHL @ODHIM@JKT@OTX @OD BKUL RZKTTLO OITKHL TI TML ^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ
TRLOT[!EI\Z -:4+ MI\ZX ^ZKIZ TI @O[ HM@OBLX/ ^ZKIZ TI @O[ AIUL^ZIUKDL RZKTTLO @\TMIZKW@TKIO TI TML ^IXT IEEKHL TI EIZR@ZDA@KF TI TML OLR @DDZLXX/ ^LZAKT UKXKTX @OD XL@ZHMLX IE ^F@HLX IEZLXKDLOHL J[ @BLOTX IE TML ^ZIJ@TKIO DL^T/ @OD)IZ F@RLOEIZHLALOT EIZ TML ^\Z^IXL IE LOX\ZKOB HIA^FK@OHL RKTM^LZAKT UKXKTX @OD XL@ZHMLX IE ^F@HLX IE ZLXKDLOHL J[ @BLOTX IETML ^ZIJ@TKIO DL^T/ @OD)IZ F@R LOEIZHLALOT EIZ TML ^\Z^IXL IELOX\ZKOB HIA^FK@OHL RKTM ^LZAKT UKXKTX @OD XL@ZHMLX IE ^F@HLX IEZLXKDLOHL J[ @BLOTX IE TML ^ZIJ@TKIO DL^T/ @OD)IZ F@RLOEIZHLALOT EIZ TML ^\Z^IXL IE LOX\ZKOB HIA^FK@OHL RKTM TMLTLZAX @OD HIODKTKIOX IE ^ZIJ@TKIO3 OIT DI @O[TMKOB TI KOTLZELZLRKTM TMKX ZLP\KZLALOT& IZ DLTLZ IEEKHLZX EZIA E\FEKFFKOB TMKXZLP\KZLALOT& X\HM @X TML TLZAX @OD HIODKTKIOX IE ^ZIJ@TKIO3 OITDI @O[TMKOB TI KOTLZELZL RKTM TMKX ZLP\KZLALOT& IZ DLTLZIEEKHLZX EZIA E\FEKFFKOB TMKX ZLP\KZLALOT& X\HM @X LZLHTKOB @O[FIHCLD ELOHLX)B@TLX TM@T RI\FD DLO[ @HHLXX TI ^ZIJ@TKIOIEEKHLZX& IZ M@UL @O[ @OKA@FX IO TML ^ZLAKXLX TM@T RI\FDZL@XIO@JF[ DLTLZ& LZLHTKOB @O[ FIHCLD ELOHLX)B@TLX TM@T RI\FDDLO[ @HHLXX TI ^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZX& IZ M@UL @O[ @OKA@FX IO TML^ZLAKXLX TM@T RI\FD ZL@XIO@JF[ DLTLZ& TMZL@T TMZL@TLO TMLX@ELT[ IE& IZ KOTLZELZL RKTM& IEEKHLZX LOEIZHKOB TMKX TLZA/ LO TMLX@ELT[ IE& IZ KOTLZELZL RKTM& IEEKHLZX LOEIZHKOB TMKX TLZA/
2+OLKTMLZ ^IXXLXX OIZ M@UL \ODLZ [I\Z HIOTZIF @O[ D@OBLZI\X IZDL@DF[ RL@^IOX IZ L]^FIXKUL DLUKHLX IZ A@TLZK@FX TI A@CLL]^FIXKUL DLUKHLX/
=+
X\JAKT TI @ XL@ZHM @OD XLKW\ZL IE [I\Z ^LZXIO& ZLXKDLOHL @OD)IZ^ZI^LZT[ \ODLZ [I\Z HIOTZIF @T @O[ TKAL IE TML D@[ IZ OKBMT J[
@O[ F@R!LOEIZHLALOT IEEKHLZ& RKTM IZ RKTMI\T @ XL@ZHM R@ZZ@OT&@OD RKTM IZ RKTMI\T H@\XL -^LI^FL !U! JZ@UI+/
;+OLKTMLZ \XL OIZ ^IXXLXX @O[ HIOTZIFFLD X\JXT@OHL RKTMI\TALDKH@F ^ZLXHZK^TKIO/ @ ^M[XKHK@OX"X RZKTTLO OITKHL KX TI JL BKULOTI TML ^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ/
0>+X\JAKT TI @ HIOTZIFFLD X\JXT@OHL TLXT @T DKZLHTKIO IE ^ZIJ@TKIOIEEKHLZ/ L@HM TLXT KX X\JGLHT TI @O $00/>> ELL& TI JL HIFFLHTLD J[HLOTZ@F HIFFLHTKIOX
00+ OIT ^IXXLXX @O[ T[^L IE DZ\B ^@Z@^MLZO@FK@& @X DLEKOLD KO
:;=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :5 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:44<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 299/383
M%X00854/<-D+
0:+
^@ZTKHK^@TL KO @ HI\OXLFKOB ^ZIBZ@A @X DKZLHTLD J[ TML ^ZIJ@TKIOIEEKHLZ& X\JAKT AIOTMF[ ZIIE IE @TTLOD@OHL @OD)IZ X\HHLXXE\FHIA^FLTKIO TI TML ^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ @X DKZLHTLD @OD JLZLX^IOXKJFL EIZ ^@[ALOT IE @FF ^ZIBZ@A ELL-X+/
08+OIT @XXIHK@TL RKTM COIRO HIOUKHTLD ELFIOX IZ @O[IOL @HTKULF[LOB@BLD KO HZKAKO@F @HTKUKT[ J!IZ HIDLELOD@OT-X+ IZ UKHTKA-X+/
04+OIT @XXIHK@TL RKTM COIRO KFFLB@F \XLZX IZ XLFFLZX IEHIOTZIFFLD X\JXT@OHLX&
0<+
OIT A@KOT@KO @ HMLHCKOB @HHI\OT IZ HIA^FLTL IZ LODIZXL @O[HMLHCX \OFLXX A@DL ^@[@JFL TI [I\ @OD OIT M@UL @O[ JF@OCHMLHCX KO [I\Z ^IXXLXXKIO RKTMI\T ^LZAKXXKIO IE TML ^ZIJ@TKIOIEEKHLZ/
05+X\JAKT @ ZLHIZD IE KOHIAL @OD L]^LODKT\ZLX TI TML ^ZIJ@TKIOIEEKHLZ P\@ZTLZF[/
02+OLKTMLZ ^IXXLXX OIZ \XL @O[ HZLDKT H@ZD RKTMI\T ^LZAKXXKIO IETML ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ/
0=+OIT DZKUL IZ ^IXXLXX CL[X IZ DIH\ALOT@TKIO TI @O[ AITIZULMKHFL \OFLXX FLB@FF[ ZLBKXTLZLD TI [I\ IZ @O KAALDK@TL E@AKF[ALAJLZ& L]HL^T KO TML HI\ZXL IE LA^FI[ALOT/
0;+ ZL^IZT @FF AITIZ ULMKHFLX ZLBKXTLZLD TI [I\ TI TML ^ZIJ@TKIOIEEKHLZ RKTMKO XLULO -2+ D@[X IE @HP\KXKTKIO/
:>+X\JAKT TI @OD HII^LZ@TL KO @ EKLFD KOTLZZIB@TKIO J[ @O[ ^L@HLIEEKHLZ @T @O[ TKAL IE TML D@[ IZ OKBMT/
:0+
H@ZZ[ @T @FF TKALX @ U@FKD DZKULZX FKHLOXL IZ DL^@ZTALOT IEAITIZ ULMKHFLX KDLOTKEKH@TKIO H@ZD @OD DKX^F@[ X\HMKDLOTKEKH@TKIO \^IO ZLP\LXT J[ @O[ ^\Z^IXL RKTMI\T EKZXTOITKE[KOB TML I/ HIOT@KOKOB [I\Z TZ\L O@AL @BL @OD H\ZZLOT@DDZLXX
::+LOZIFF KO TML DZ\B TZL@TALOT ^ZIBZ@A @T TML DKZLHTKIO IE TML^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ& @OD XMIR ^ZIIE IE LOZIFFALOT TI TML^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ RKTMKO XLULO -2+ D@[X/
:8+
A@CL ZLXTKT\TKIO TI TML UKHTKA-X+ -XLL ^ZIJ@TKIO ZL^IZT+ KO TML
@AI\OT IE $;::8/22 ^F\X @ 0>, @DAKOKXTZ@TKUL ELL& TI JL ^@KDTMZI\BM HLOTZ@F HIFFLHTKIOX
:4+A@CL ZLXTKT\TKIO TI TML UKHTKA -XLL ^ZIJ@TKIO ZL^IZT+ KO TML @AI\OT IE $8<>>>/>> ^F\X @ 0>, @DAKOKXTZ@TKUL ELL& TI JL^@KD TMZI\BMHLOTZ@F HIFFLHTKIOX
:<+A@CL ZLXTKT\TKIO TI TML UKHTKA -XLL ^ZIJ@TKIO ZL^IZT+ KO TML @AI\OT IE $55;<0/>= ^F\X @ 0>, @DAKOKXTZ@TKUL ELL& TI JL ^@KD TMZI\BMHLOTZ@F HIFFLHTKIOX
:5+^@[ @ ZLXTKT\TKIO EKOL KO TML @AI\OT IE $:>>/>>& ^F\X @ TLO ^LZHLOT-0>,+ @DAKOKXTZ@TKUL ELL TMZI\BM HLOTZ@F HIFFLHTKIOX/
:2+TML DLELOD@OT KX OIT TI EKFL @O[ F@RX\KT)FLB@F @HTKIO RKTMI\T^ZKIZ HIOT@HT RKTM ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ/
:=+DI OIT @^^F[ EIZ HZLDKT IZ @ FI@O RKTMI\T ^ZKIZ HIOT@HT RKTM
^ZIJ@TKIO IEEKHLZ/:;+ HIA^F[ RKTM @O[ HI\ZT!IZDLZLD ^@[ALOT XHMLD\FL/
8>+A@CL ZLXTKT\TKIO TI UKHTKA -XLL ^ZIJ@TKIO ZL^IZT+ KO @O @AI\OT TIJL DLTLZAKOLD J[ ^ZIJ@TKIO/
80+A@CL ZLXTKT\TKIO TI UKHTKA -XLL ^ZIJ@TKIO ZL^IZT+ KO @O @AI\OT TIJL DLTLZAKOLD J[ ^ZIJ@TKIO/
8:+^ZIJ@TKIO A@[ JL XLZULD TMZI\BM KOTLZ XT@TL HIA^@HT @BZLLALOTKO TML XT@TL IE OLR AL]KHI \^IO @^^ZIU@F EZIA ^ZIJ@TKIO/
:;;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :2 ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:445
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 300/3838>>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl := ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:442
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 301/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :>
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
7777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX HLZTKEKH@TL IE
XLZUKHL
K& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& mlzlj{ hlztke{ ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie ^f`kotkeex
Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox ~zi~i|odld |~io Dlelod`ot Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ rlzl xlzuld
tmzi|bm La`kf `od Ekzxt Hf`xx A`kf rktm ^ixt`bl e|ff{ ~zl~`kd tmkx 0;tm
d`{ ie G`o|`z{
:>0:& |~io tml eiffirkob7
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp|kzl
F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
<282 C`o`o Zi`d& X|ktl 842
@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0
La`kf7 ahifloNhiflof`r/hiaXkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio7 :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0;:
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7 Olkf X`ocl{3 Tidd X`ocl{3
X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
8>0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :; ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:44=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 302/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ ^f`kotkeex ZE@ ~zi~i|odld io Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ :0
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
Gimo @ Uibt& Gz/& Lxp|kzl
Ldr`zd X`o Hm`ob& Lxp|kzl
Giolx D`{8050 Akhmlfxio Dzkul X|ktl =>>
Kzukol& H@ ;:50:
La`kf7 g`uibtNgiolxd`{/hia
La`kf7 lhm`obNgiolxd`{/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/
G`alx E AhH`jl& Lxp|kzl
Aizzkxio % Eilzxtlz4:< A`zclt Xtzllt
X`o Ez`ohkxhi& H@ ;40><!:4=:La`kf7 gahh`jlNaiei/hia
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx7
Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& Koh
Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Xlkxkot& Koh/
Fl}kxOl}kx Hmikhl~ikot& Koh/
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
8>:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!00 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8> ie 8> ^`bl KD(70:44;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 303/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖0:‑
8>8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 8 ^`bl KD(70:4<>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 304/383
Ezia7 A`zh Hiflo 6ahifloNhiflof`r/hia?
D`tl7 Ezk& G`o :>& :>0: `t 0:742 ^AX|jglht7 Zl7 Fkjlzk& lt `f u/ T`ktw& lt `f& H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!!>>4=< ! Dkxhiulz{ Zl7 Tidd X`ocl{
Ti7 ^mkfk~ Jlzb 6~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia?
Tml dihx tm`t rl xlot rkff jl dlfkulzld ti {i| tid`{/
G|xt bf`ohld `t {i|z zlp|lxtx `od oitl p|ktl xial ~zijflax rmkhm rl rkff dl`f rktm ko d|l tkal/
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
Tm l Hiflo F`r Ekza
<282 C`o `o Zi`d& Xtl / 842
@bi|z ` M kffx& H@ ;0 8> 0
Tlf7 0 /=0=/205/:=;0E`}7 0 /=0=/<;2/4580
Tmkx l!a`kf -kohf|dkob o{ tt`hmalotx+ a`{ hiot`ko koeiza`tkio tm`t kx ~zku`tl& hioekdlotk`f& iz ~zitlhtld j{ ttizol{!hfklot iz itmlz~zkukflbl/ Ke {i| zlhlkuld tmkx l!a`kf ko lzziz& ~fl`xl dlfltl kt ezia {i|z x{xtla rktmi|t hi~{kob kt `od oitke{ xlodlz j{ zl~f{ l!a`kf&xi tm`t i|z zlhizdx h`o jl hizzlhtld/
Io G`o 0;& :>0:& `t 0>78= ^A& ^mkfk~ Jlzb rzitl7
G`o|`z{ 0;& :>0:
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp|kzl
F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
<282 C`o`o Zi`d& X|ktl 842@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0
Xlot uk` La`kf ti ahifloNhiflof`r/hia& fhifloN`if/hia& `od
fhifloNhiflof`r/hia3 `od
8>4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 8 ^`bl KD(70:4<0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 305/383
\/X/^/X/& Xkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio7 :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0=<
Zl7 Fkjlzk& lt `f u/ T`ktw& lt `f &
H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB^f`kotkeex Dkxhiulz{ xlzuld |~io Dlelod`ot
Tidd X`ocl{
^fl`xl ekod `tt`hmld tml hizzlx~iodlohl `od dkxhiulz{ ~zi~i|odld io
Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{ j{ tml ^f`kotkeex/
Zlx~lhte|ff{&
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
F`r Ieekhlx ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
^m7 -50>+ =:<!8084
E}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
Hlff7 -50>+ 55:!8>><
La`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
hh7 G`alx AhH`jl& @ttizol{ eiz tml Zlld Dlelod`otx3 odLdr`zd Hm`ob `od Gimo @/ Uibt&
@ttizol{"x eiz Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/3
6Fkjlzk ! ftz ti hi|oxlf eiz Tidd X`ocl{ zl Dkxhiulz{ >0//~de?6Fkjlzk ^fex Kotlzzibx zl Tidd
X`ocl{ 0/0;/~de?6Fkjlzk ^fex Zlp|lxt @dakxxkiox io Tidd X`ocl{/~de?6Fkjlzk& ^fex ZE^ ti
Tidd X`ocl{/~de?
8><
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0: Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 8 ^`bl KD(70:4<:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 306/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖08‑
8>5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!08 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:4<8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 307/383
FLB@F
^zku`h{ ^ifkh{ ‷
Tlzax ie \xl ‷
EIK@ ‷
Oi EL@Z @ht LLI D`t` ‷
IO \X^X/HIA
Biulzoalot Xlzukhlx ‷
J|{ Xt`a~x % Xmi~ ‷
^zkot ` F`jlf rktm ^ixt`bl ‷
H|xtialz Xlzukhl ‷
Xktl Kodl} ‷
IO @JI\T/\X^X/HIA
@ji|t \X^X Mial ‷
Olrxziia ‷
A`kf Xlzukhl \~d`tlx ‷
Eizax % ^|jfkh`tkiox ‷
H`zllzx ‷
ITMLZ \X^X XKTLX
J|xkolxx H|xtialz B`tlr`{ ‷
^ixt`f Kox~lhtizx ‷
Kox~lhtiz Blolz`f ‷
^ixt`f L}~fizlz ‷
Hi~{zkbmt« :>0: \X^X/ @ff Zkbmtx Zlxlzuld/
Xl`zhm \X^X/hia iz Tz`hc ^`hc`blx
Tz`hc % Hioekza
[I\Z F@JLF O\AJLZ XLZUKHL XT@T\X IE [I\Z KTLA D@TL % TKAL FIH@TKIO EL@T\ZLX
:8>=8:<>>>>><:44=0;:
Zlxtizl @zhmkuld Dlt`kfx
^zkizkt{ A`kf Dlfkulzld G`o|`z{ :0& :>0:& 27<< a @BI\Z@
MKFFX& H@ ;08>0^ziie ie Dlfkulz{
:8>=8:<>>>>><:44=0=<
Zlxtizl @zhmkuld Dlt`kfx
^zkizkt{ A`kf Dlfkulzld G`o|`z{ :0& :>0:& 27<< a @BI\Z@
MKFFX& H@ ;08>0^ziie ie Dlfkulz{
¯
¯
Hmlhc io @oitmlz Ktla
Rm`t"x {i|z f`jlf -iz zlhlk~t+ o|ajlz9
H|xtial z Xl zu khl \X^X AijkflLobfkxm Zlbkxtlz ) Xkbo Ko
/hia¯ ! Tz`hc % Hioekza mtt~x7))tiifx/|x~x/hia)bi)Tz`hcHioekza@ht
4)0=):>0:
8>2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!08 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:4<4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 308/383
D`tl7 >4)0=):>0:
^MKFK^ JLZB7
Tml eiffirkob kx ko zlx~ioxl ti {i|z >4)0=):>0: zlp|lxt eiz dlfkulz{ koeiza`tkio io {i|zXkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio-TA+ ktla o|ajlz :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0=</ Tml dlfkulz{ zlhizdxmirx tm`t tmkx ktla r`x dlfkulzld io >0):0):>0: `t >27<< @A ko @BI\Z@ MKFFX& H@ ;08>0ti Z XMZI[LZ/ Tml xh`oold ka`bl ie tml zlhk~klot koeiza`tkio kx ~ziukdld jlfir/
Xkbo`t|zl ie Zlhk~klot7
@ddzlxx ie Zlhk~klot7
Tm`oc {i| eiz xlflhtkob tml ^ixt`f Xlzukhl eiz {i|z a`kfkob olldx/ Ke {i| zlp|kzl `ddktkio`f`xxkxt`ohl& ~fl`xl hiot`ht {i|z fih`f ^ixt Ieekhl iz ~ixt`f zl~zlxlot`tkul/
Xkohlzlf{&
\oktld Xt`tlx ^ixt`f Xlzukhl
8>=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!08 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:4<<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 309/383
D`tl7 >4)0=):>0:
^MKFK^ JLZB7
Tml eiffirkob kx ko zlx~ioxl ti {i|z >4)0=):>0: zlp|lxt eiz dlfkulz{ koeiza`tkio io {i|zXkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio-TA+ ktla o|ajlz :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0;:/ Tml dlfkulz{ zlhizdxmirx tm`t tmkx ktla r`x dlfkulzld io >0):0):>0: `t >27<< @A ko @BI\Z@ MKFFX& H@ ;08>0ti Z XMZI[LZ/ Tml xh`oold ka`bl ie tml zlhk~klot koeiza`tkio kx ~ziukdld jlfir/
Xkbo`t|zl ie Zlhk~klot7
@ddzlxx ie Zlhk~klot7
Tm`oc {i| eiz xlflhtkob tml ^ixt`f Xlzukhl eiz {i|z a`kfkob olldx/ Ke {i| zlp|kzl `ddktkio`f`xxkxt`ohl& ~fl`xl hiot`ht {i|z fih`f ^ixt Ieekhl iz ~ixt`f zl~zlxlot`tkul/
Xkohlzlf{&
\oktld Xt`tlx ^ixt`f Xlzukhl
8>;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!08 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:4<5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 310/383
Fkjlzk& lt f ‘ >0)0;):>00 Flttlz ti Hi|oxlf eiz Tidd X`ocl{ zl Dkxhiulz{ 0
F@R IEEKHLX IE
^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
YYYYYYYYYYYYYY
-50>+ =:<!8084
OIZA@O J/ JLZB& ^`z`flb`f SDlhl`xldQ
E`} -50>+ =84!25<;
L!A`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
G`o|`z{ 0;& :>0:
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp|kzl
F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
<282 C`o`o Zi`d& X|ktl 842
@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0
Xlot uk` La`kf ti ahifloNhiflof`r/hia& fhifloN`if/hia& `od fhifloNhiflof`r/hia3 `od\/X/^/X/& Xkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio7 :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0=<
Zl7 Fkjlzk& lt `f u/ T`ktw& lt `f& H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB^f`kotkeex Dkxhiulz{ xlzuld |~io Dlelod`ot Tidd X`ocl{
Dl`z Az/ Hiflo7
^fl`xl ekod lohfixld tml eiffirkob Dkxhiulz{ jlkob ~zi~i|odld |~io {i|z hfklot& Dlelod`ot
Tidd X`ocl{ j{ tml f`kotkeex/
0/ ^f`kotkeex Ekzxt Xlt ie Kotlzzib`tizklx3
:/ ^f kotkeex Ekzxt Xlt ie Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx3 `od
8/ ^f kotkeex Ekzxt Xlt ie Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox/
^fl`xl di oit mlxkt`tl hiot`htkob al xmi|fd {i| m`ul `o{ p|lxtkiox/
Zlx~lhte|ff{&
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
^GJ7gjLohfix|zlx
Hh7 G`alx AhH`jl& Lxp|kzl ‘ Hi|oxlf eiz tml Zlld Dlelod`otx j{ La`kfGimo @/ Uibt& Lxp|kzl ‘ Hi|oxlf eiz Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/ j{ La`kf
80>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!08 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:4<2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 311/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f ‘ >0)0;):>00 Flttlz ti Hi|oxlf eiz Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ zl Dkxhiulz{ 0
F@R IEEKHLX IE
^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
YYYYYYYYYYYYYY
-50>+ =:<!8084
OIZA@O J/ JLZB& ^`z`flb`f SDlhl`xldQ
E`} -50>+ =84!25<;
L!A`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
G`o|`z{ 0;& :>0:
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp|kzl
F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo<282 C`o`o Zi`d& X|ktl 842
@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0
Xlot uk` La`kf ti ahifloNhiflof`r/hia& fhifloN`if/hia& `od fhifloNhiflof`r/hia3 `od\/X/^/X/& Xkbo`t|zl Hioekza`tkio7 :8>= 8:<> >>>> <:44 =0;:
Zl7 Fkjlzk& lt `f u/ T`ktw& lt `f& H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB
^f`kotkeex Dkxhiulz{ xlzuld |~io Dlelod`ot Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
Dl`z Az/ Hiflo7
^fl`xl ekod lohfixld tml eiffirkob Dkxhiulz{ jlkob ~zi~i|odld |~io {i|z hfklot& Dlelod`ot
Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ j{ tml ^f`kotkeex/
0/ ^f`kotkeex Ekzxt Xlt ie Kotlzzib`tizklx3:/ ^f kotkeex Ekzxt Xlt ie Zlp|lxt eiz ^zid|htkio ie Dih|alotx3 `od
8/ ^f kotkeex Ekzxt Xlt ie Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox/
^fl`xl di oit mlxkt`tl hiot`htkob al xmi|fd {i| m`ul `o{ p|lxtkiox/
Zlx~lhte|ff{&
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
^GJ7gj
Lohfix|zlx
Hh7 G`alx AhH`jl& Lxp|kzl ‘ Hi|oxlf eiz tml Zlld Dlelod`otx j{ La`kf
Gimo @/ Uibt& Lxp|kzl ‘ Hi|oxlf eiz Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/ j{ La`kf
800
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!08 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie 5 ^`bl KD(70:4<=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 312/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖04‑
80:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!04 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie 8 ^`bl KD(70:4<;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 313/383
Ezia7 ^mkfk~ Jlzb6~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia?
D tl7 X t& Elj :<& :>0: t ;780 A
X|jglht7 Fkjlzk lt f u/ T ktw lt f& H xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB
Ti7 A`zh Hiflo 6ahifloNhiflof`r/hia?& fhifloNhiflof`r/hia
Eljz|`z{ :<& :>0:
Zl7 Fkjlzk lt `f u/ T`ktw lt `f& H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB^f`kotkeex *Allt `od Hioelz* ~|zx|`ot ti Fih`f Z|fl 2!8/
Dl`z A`zh&
Ko tml ulz{ ol`z e|t|zl& ^f`kotkeex kotlod ti aiul eiz X|aa`z{G|dbalot io tml hf`kax `b`koxt Tidd X`ocl{& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{
Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& `od tml X`ocl{ Ekza S*Tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx*Q/ Krzktl ti x`tkxe{ ^f`kotkeex *Allt `od Hioelz* ijfkb`tkio |odlz Fih`f Z|fl2!8/
Tmlzl `zl oit `o{ blo|kol kxx|lx ie a`tlzk`f e htx `od tmlzleizlX|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx kx `~~zi~zk`tl/ Rktmtml lukdlohl x|~~fkld ti {i| `od {i|z hfklotx ko ^f`kotkeex Koktk`fDkxhfix|zlx& `od tml `ddktkio`f ~zku`tl hiox|alz zl~iztx ijt`kold j{tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx io tml ^f`kotkeex x|~~fkld rktm tml X`ocl{"xKoktk`f Dkxhfix|zlx& tmlzl kx loi|bm lukdlohl ti x|jxt`otk`tl ^f`kotkeex
hf`kax `b`koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx `od zlodlz g|dbalot ko e`uiz ietml ^f`kotkeex/
K zlp|lxt tml hi|ztlx{ ie ` Zlx~ioxl ti tmkx hiaa|okh`tkio oi f`tlztm`o tml lod ie j|xkolxx& Aiod`{& Eljz|`z{ :2& :>0:/ Ke K di oit ml`zezia {i| j{ tmlo& K rkff aiul eizr`zd `od xllc Fl`ul ie Hi|zt ti ekfl `Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx/
K fiic eizr`zd ti ml`zkob ezia {i|/
Zlx~lhte|ff{&
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzlF@R IEEKHLX IE MKFK G/ JLZB<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F e`{lttl Mkff& @ 0;444!:<80m7 -50>+ =:<!8084
808
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!04 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie 8 ^`bl KD(70:45>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 314/383
E}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
Hlff7 -50>+ 55:!8>><
La kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
804
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!04 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie 8 ^`bl KD(70:450
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 315/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖0<‑
80<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0< Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie < ^`bl KD(70:45:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 316/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 317/383
aitkiox ti hia~lf rkff dlf`{ {i|z AXG e|ztmlz/ Xialmir K tmkoc tm`t K rkff jl ekfkob x|hm
aitkiox/
Tml eiffirkob kx ` dlfkol`tkio ie ` ulz{ elr ~iztkio ie tml `|tmizkt{ tm`t K a`dl |xl/
E/Z/H^/ <5
@odlzxio u/ Fkjlzt{ Fijj{ -0;=5+ 422 \X :4:
L`xta`o Cid`c u/ Ka`bl -0;;:+ <>4 \X/ 4<0
Jz{`ot u/ M`ff -<tm
Hz 0;<5+ :8= Eld :od
:=8
Dl^koti u/ ^ziukdlot -;tm
Hz/ 0;58+ 8:8 Eld/:od
=:5
M`zzkx u/ Ktw`ck -;tm
Hz/ 0;;;+ 0=8 Eld/8zd
0>48
Mi~ckox u/ @od`{` -;tm
Hz/ 0;;:+ ;<= Eld/:od
==0
Fir u/ ^`tl -<tm
Hz 0;22+ <<= Eld/:od
25;
O|olw u/ X|~lzkiz Ikf -<tm
Hz 0;==+ <2: Eld :od
000;
XLHu/ Ciz hiz~ -;tm
Hz/ 0;2=+ <2< E/:d 5;:
Xkaklo u/ Czlxbl - <tm
Hz 0;2=+ <55 Eld/:od
<<0
T/R Lflh u/ ^`hkekh -;
tm
Hz/ 0;=2+ =>; Eld/:
od
5:5
\oktld Xt`tlx u/ Iol Tkotizltti -:od
@Hz 0;=:+ 5;0 Eld/ 5>8
Rfxio u/ Hmkh`bi -2tm
Hz/ 0;==+ =40
802
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0< Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie < ^`bl KD(70:454
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 318/383
Loi|bm& K rkff ekokxm a{ zlxl`zhm `od {i| rkff di {i|z iro zlxl`zhm/ Ko `o{ lulot& K `a
tit`ff{ hioekdlot tm`t {i| rkff fixl `o{ AXG `od rl lod tmkx h xl j{ r { ie g|z{/ Rl‛ul
bit ` tzk`f `ttizol{ ~khcld i|t/
Zlb`zdx&
A zh
Ezia7 ^mkfk~ Jlzb 6~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia?
D`tl7X t& :< Elj :>0: :8780742 !><>>
Ti7AXH m{xkhx 6ahifloNhiflof r/hia?& 6fhifloNhiflof r/hia?
X|jglht7 Fkjlzk lt f u/ T ktw lt f& H xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB
Eljz|`z{ :<& :>0:
Zl7 Fkjlzk lt `f u/ T`ktw lt `f& H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB^f`kotkeex *Allt `od Hioelz* ~|zx|`ot ti Fih`f Z|fl 2!8/
Dl`z A`zh&
Ko tml ulz{ ol`z e|t|zl& ^f`kotkeex kotlod ti aiul eiz X|aa`z{G|dbalot io tml hf`kax `b`koxt Tidd X`ocl{& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{
Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& `od tml X`ocl{ Ekza S*Tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx*Q/ Krzktl ti x`tkxe{ ^f`kotkeex *Allt `od Hioelz* ijfkb`tkio |odlz Fih`f Z|fl2!8/
Tmlzl `zl oit `o{ blo|kol kxx|lx ie a`tlzk`f e htx `od tmlzleizlX|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx kx `~~zi~zk`tl/ Rktmtml lukdlohl x|~~fkld ti {i| `od {i|z hfklotx ko ^f`kotkeex Koktk`f
80=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0< Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie < ^`bl KD(70:45<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 319/383
Dkxhfix|zlx& `od tml `ddktkio`f ~zku`tl hiox|alz zl~iztx ijt`kold j{tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx io tml ^f`kotkeex x|~~fkld rktm tml X`ocl{"xKoktk`f Dkxhfix|zlx& tmlzl kx loi|bm lukdlohl ti x|jxt`otk`tl ^f`kotkeexhf`kax `b`koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx `od zlodlz g|dbalot ko e`uiz ietml ^f`kotkeex/
K zlp|lxt tml hi|ztlx{ ie ` Zlx~ioxl ti tmkx hiaa|okh`tkio oi f`tlztm`o tml lod ie j|xkolxx& Aiod`{& Eljz|`z{ :2& :>0:/ Ke K di oit ml`zezia {i| j{ tmlo& K rkff aiul eizr`zd `od xllc Fl`ul ie Hi|zt ti ekfl `Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx/
K fiic eizr`zd ti ml`zkob ezia {i|/
Zlx~lhte|ff{&
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
F@R IEEKHLX IE MKFK G/ JLZB<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:F e`{lttl Mkff& @ 0;444!:<80
m7 -50>+ =:<!8084E}7 -50>+ =84!25<;Hlff7 -50>+ 55:!8>><
La kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
80;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0< Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie < ^`bl KD(70:455
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 320/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 321/383
Ezia7 ^mkfk~ Jlzb 6~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia?
D`tl7 Aio& Elj :2& :>0: `t :7<8 ^AX|jglht7 Zl7 Fkjlzk lt `f u/ T`ktw lt `f& H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB
Ti7 A`zh Hiflo 6ahifloNhiflof`r/hia?
A`zh&
Ko zlx~ioxl ti {i|z La`kf& K xlot tml La`kf iulz tml rllclod xi {i| ri|fd m`ul kt ekzxt tmkob tmkx
aizokob/ K zlp|lxtld ` zlx~ioxl tm`t {i| zlhlkuld a{ La`kf j{ tml lod ie Aiod`{& Eljz|`z{ :2&
:>0:& rmkhm {i| dkd/ [i|& `x `o @ttizol{& `fr`{x m`ul tml zkbmt ti zlx~iod tm`t ` dkeelzlot d`tliz tkal kx olldld& rmkhm {i| dkd oit di/
@x eiz {i|z dkx`bzllalotx rktm ^f`kotkeex ekfkob ` X|aa`z{ G|dbalot Aitkio& K t`cl tmkx ti al`o
{i| `zl oit ko `bzllalot `od dkx bzll/ Tmlzleizl& K rkff ~zihlld eizr`zd `od xllc fl`ul ie Hi|zt ti ekfl ^f`kotkeex Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt {i|z hfklotx/
@ X|aa`z{ G|dbalot Aitkio h`o jl jzi|bmt `t `o{ tkal/
Zlx~lhte|ff{&
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
Io Aio& Elj :2& :>0: `t 0:7:2 ^A& A`zh Hiflo 6ahifloNhiflof`r/hia? rzitl7
Dl`z ^mkf&
[i| olld oit xlod tl}t ko jifd eiot/ A{ l{lx `zl oit rm`t tml{ rlzl& j|t K h`o zl`d xa`ff
tl}t io a{ tri hia~|tlz xhzllox/ Ko `o{ lulot& kt kx `ooi{kob/ Tmkx a`oolz ie tmkx
zlx~ioxl alzlf{ `x `o l}`a~fl ie `ooi{kob tl}t `od oit kotlodld `x ` ~lzxio`f iz
~zielxxkio`f xfkbmt/
Tml eiffirkob `zl ` elr hiaalotx3 tmlxl `od aizl rkff jl |xld ti zlx~iod ti {i|z
tmzl`tlold zlp|lxt ti tml Hi|zt/
K di|jt tm`t tml G|dbl rkff fiic eiodf{ io ` ‖Allt `od Hioelz‑ xlot iulz tml rllclod `od
tm|x io ` Aiod`{ aizokob xmi|fd m`ul ` dl`dfkol ti zlx~iod io tml x`al d`{/ [i|z
dl`dfkolx m`ul jllo `od ijuki|xf{ hiotko|l ti jl rktmi|t alzkt/ K jlfklul tm`t {i|z
8:0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!05 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie < ^`bl KD(70:45=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 322/383
hiod|ht kx x ohtkio`jfl3 tm`t {i| m`ul Fkjlzk di{i|z rizc rkff oit jl `o l}h|xl/ Rl‛ff
hlzt`kof{ ekod i|t/
Rmltmlz ` ~`ztkh|f`z `fflb`tkio kx ` a`tlzk`f e`ht rkff jl i~lo ti p|lxtkio `od {i|z`jkfkt{ ti lxt`jfkxm `o{tmkob `t tmkx ~ikot kx ako|xh|fl iz flxx& `x {i| rkff
xll/ Dlhf`z`tkiox j{ Fkjlzk rkff jl hm`fflobld7 xml kx x hioukhtld elfio `od mlz
hioukhtkiox kohf|dl ez`|d/ Tml{ rkff jl dkxhi|otld/
@AXG kx oit bikob ti m`~~lo |otkf i|z dkxhiulz{ kx hia~fltl/ [i| m`ul oit ~ziukdld
zlx~ioxlx ti i|z dkxhiulz{ `od K x|x~lht tm`t {i|z zlx~ioxlx rkff zlp|kzl aitkiox ti
hia~lf/ Dlf`{kob {i|z zlx~ioxlx |otkf tml dl`dfkol iz zlx~iodkob ko `o ko`dlp|`tl
a`oolz kx oit ti {i|z `du`ot`bl/ f`xt Xlodkob al ko`~~zi~zk`tl zl~fklx tm`t zlp|kzl
aitkiox ti hia~lf rkff dlf`{ {i|z AXG e|ztmlz/ Xialmir K tmkoc tm`t K rkff jl ekfkob x|hm
aitkiox/
Tml eiffirkob kx ` dlfkol`tkio ie ` ulz{ elr ~iztkio ie tml `|tmizkt{ tm`t K a`dl |xl/
E/Z/H^/ <5
@odlzxio u/ Fkjlzt{ Fijj{ -0;=5+ 422 \X :4:
L`xta`o Cid`c u/ Ka`bl -0;;:+ <>4 \X/ 4<0
Jz{`ot u/ M`ff -<tm Hz 0;<5+ :8= Eld :od :=8
Dl^koti u/ ^ziukdlot -;tm
Hz/ 0;58+ 8:8 Eld/:od
=:5
M`zzkx u/ Ktw`ck -;tm
Hz/ 0;;;+ 0=8 Eld/8zd
0>48
Mi~ckox u/ @od`{` -;tm
Hz/ 0;;:+ ;<= Eld/:od
==0
8::
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!05 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie < ^`bl KD(70:45;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 323/383
Fir u/ ^`tl -<tm
Hz 0;22+ <<= Eld/:od
25;
O|olw u/ X|~lzkiz Ikf -<tm
Hz 0;==+ <2: Eld :od
000;
XLHu/ Ciz hiz~ -;tm
Hz/ 0;2=+ <2< E/:d 5;:
Xkaklo u/ Czlxbl - <tm
Hz 0;2=+ <55 Eld/:od
<<0
T/R Lflh u/ ^`hkekh -;tm
Hz/ 0;=2+ =>; Eld/:od
5:5
\oktld Xt`tlx u/ Iol Tkotizltti -:od
@Hz 0;=:+ 5;0 Eld/ 5>8
Rfxio u/ Hmkh`bi -2tm
Hz/ 0;==+ =40
Loi|bm& K rkff ekokxm a{ zlxl`zhm `od {i| rkff di {i|z iro zlxl`zhm/ Ko `o{ lulot& K `a
tit`ff{ hioekdlot tm`t {i| rkff fixl `o{ AXG `od rl lod tmkx h xl j{ r { ie g|z{/ Rl‛ul
bit ` tzk`f `ttizol{ ~khcld i|t/
Zlb`zdx&
A zh
Ezia7 ^mkfk~ Jlzb 6~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia?
D`tl7X t& :< Elj :>0: :8780742 !><>>Ti7AXH m{xkhx 6ahifloNhiflof r/hia?& 6fhifloNhiflof r/hia?
X|jglht7 Fkjlzk lt f u/ T ktw lt f& H xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB
8:8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!05 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie < ^`bl KD(70:42>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 324/383
Eljz|`z{ :<& :>0:
Zl7 Fkjlzk lt `f u/ T`ktw lt `f& H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB^f`kotkeex *Allt `od Hioelz* ~|zx|`ot ti Fih`f Z|fl 2!8/
Dl`z A`zh&
Ko tml ulz{ ol`z e|t|zl& ^f`kotkeex kotlod ti aiul eiz X|aa`z{G|dbalot io tml hf`kax `b`koxt Tidd X`ocl{& Olkf X`ocl{& X`ocl{Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/& `od tml X`ocl{ Ekza S*Tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx*Q/ Krzktl ti x`tkxe{ ^f`kotkeex *Allt `od Hioelz* ijfkb`tkio |odlz Fih`f Z|fl2!8/
Tmlzl `zl oit `o{ blo|kol kxx|lx ie a`tlzk`f e htx `od tmlzleizl
X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx kx `~~zi~zk`tl/ Rktmtml lukdlohl x|~~fkld ti {i| `od {i|z hfklotx ko ^f`kotkeex Koktk`fDkxhfix|zlx& `od tml `ddktkio`f ~zku`tl hiox|alz zl~iztx ijt`kold j{tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx io tml ^f`kotkeex x|~~fkld rktm tml X`ocl{"xKoktk`f Dkxhfix|zlx& tmlzl kx loi|bm lukdlohl ti x|jxt`otk`tl ^f`kotkeexhf`kax `b`koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx `od zlodlz g|dbalot ko e`uiz ietml ^f`kotkeex/
K zlp|lxt tml hi|ztlx{ ie ` Zlx~ioxl ti tmkx hiaa|okh`tkio oi f`tlztm`o tml lod ie j|xkolxx& Aiod`{& Eljz|`z{ :2& :>0:/ Ke K di oit ml`z
ezia {i| j{ tmlo& K rkff aiul eizr`zd `od xllc Fl`ul ie Hi|zt ti ekfl `Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx/
K fiic eizr`zd ti ml`zkob ezia {i|/
Zlx~lhte|ff{&
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
F@R IEEKHLX IE MKFK G/ JLZB<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F e`{lttl Mkff& @ 0;444!:<80m7 -50>+ =:<!8084
E}7 -50>+ =84!25<;Hlff7 -50>+ 55:!8>><
La kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
8:4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!05 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie < ^`bl KD(70:420
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 325/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖02‑
8:<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!02 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie < ^`bl KD(70:42:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 326/383
Ezia7 ^mkfk~ Jlzb 6~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia?
D`tl7 Aio& Elj :2& :>0: `t 47>4 ^AX|jglht7 Fkjlzk& lt `f u/ T`ktw& lt `f& H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @GB ! Zlp|lxt eiz Fl`ul ie Hi|zt
Ti7 Fkx` Jzld`mf 6@BYHm`ajlzxNh`hd/|xhi|ztx/biu?
Hh7 *Akfflz& Akhm`lf J/* 6AJAkfflzNaiei/hia?& *AhH`ff& H/ G/* 6HGAhh`ffNaiei/hia?&
lhm`obNgiolxd`{/hia& ahifloNhiflof`r/hia& gh|ookobm`aNxzzf`rekza/hia&cxhm|a`ooNxzzf`rekza/hia& izf{/t`ktwNba`kf/hia& g`uibtNgiolxd`{/hia& *AhH`jl& Gka*
6GAhH`jlNaiei/hia?
Eljz|`z{ :2& :>0:
Mioiz`jfl @odzlr G/ B|kfeizd
G|dbl& \oktld Xt`tlx Dkxtzkht Hi|zt
\/X/ Dkxtzkht Hi|zt& Hlotz`f Dkxtzkht ie H@& Xi|tmlzo Dkukxkio
400 R/ 4tm
Xtzllt& Hi|ztziia 0>!D
X`ot` @o`& H@ ;:2>0
Xlot uk` La`kf ti7 @BYHm`ajlzxNh`hd/|xhi|ztx/biu
Zl7 Fkjlzk& lt `f u/ T`ktw& lt `f & H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @B
Dl`z G|dbl B|kfeizd7
^fl`xl ekod `tt`hmld mlzlti f`kotkeex flttlz Zlp|lxtkob Fl`ul ti ekfl `Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt Dlelod`otx& Olkf X`ocl{& TiddX`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
Tm`oc {i|/
Zlx~lhte|ff{&
8:5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!02 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie < ^`bl KD(70:428
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 327/383
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:F`e`{lttl Mkff& @ 0;444!:<80^m7 -50>+ =:<!8084E}7 -50>+ =84!25<;Hlff7 -50>+ 55:!8>><La`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
hh7
Gleezl{ H|ookobm`a& Lxp|kzl& @ttizol{ eiz Izf{ T`ktw3
Izf{ T`ktw& @ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`ot Dlelod i|z Ezlldiax Ei|od`tkiox&
Koh/3Gka AhH`jl& Lxp|kzl `od Akhm`lf J/ Akfflz&
@ttizol{x eiz tml Zlld Dlelod`otx3Gimo @ Uibt& Gz/& Lxp|kzl& `od Ldr`zd X`o Hm`ob& Lxp|kzl&@ttizol{x eiz Dlelod`ot Kotlfk|x& Koh/3 `odA`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp|kzl&@ttizol{ eiz Olkf X`ocl{& Tidd X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `odtml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
8:2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!02 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie < ^`bl KD(70:424
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 328/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f& ^f`kotkeex flttlz xllckob Fl`ul ti ekfl ` Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx 0
F@R IEEKHLX IE
^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
YYYYYYYYYYYYYY
-50>+ =:<!8084
OIZA@O J/ JLZB& ^`z`flb`f SDlhl`xldQE`} -50>+ =84!25<;
L!A`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
Eljz|`z{ :2& :>0:
Mioiz`jfl @odzlr G/ B|kfeizd
G|dbl& \oktld Xt`tlx Dkxtzkht Hi|zt
\/X/ Dkxtzkht Hi|zt& Hlotz`f Dkxtzkht ie H@& Xi|tmlzo Dkukxkio400 R/ 4tm Xtzllt& Hi|ztziia 0>!D
X`ot` @o`& H@ ;:2>0
Xlot uk` La`kf ti7 @BYHm`ajlzxNh`hd/|xhi|ztx/biu
Zl7 Fkjlzk& lt `f u/ T`ktw& lt f& H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @B -@GR}+
Dl`z G|dbl B|kfeizd7
^|zx|`ot ti tmkx Hi|zt‛x Izdlz ie G|ol 04& :>00& Dihclt Oi/ ::2& ^f`kotkeex `zl xllckob Fl`ulti Ekfl ` Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt Olkf X`ocl{& Tidd X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox&
Koh/ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& ~|zx|`ot ti Eld/ Z/ Hku/ ^/ <5/
@x rkff jl i|tfkold ko ^f`kotkeex ~zix~lhtkul Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot& tml kodkx~|t`jfllukdlohl rkff xmir tm`t ^f`kotkeex `zl lotktfld ti X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt Olkf X`ocl{& Tidd
X`ocl{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ `od tml X`ocl{ Ekza `x ` a`ttlz ie f`r `x ti `ff ^f`kotkeex hf`kax/Tmlzleizl& ^f`kotkeex zlx~lhte|ff{ x|jakt tm`t biid h`|xl l}kxtx ti Bz`ot ^f`kotkeex Fl`ul ti ekfl `
Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot/
Tm`oc {i|/
Zlx~lhte|ff{&
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
^GJ7gj
8:=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!02 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie < ^`bl KD(70:42<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 329/383
Fkjlzk& lt `f& ^f`kotkeex flttlz xllckob Fl`ul ti ekfl ` Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx :
Mioiz`jfl @odzlr G/ B|kfeizd Eljz|`z{ :2& :>0:
G|dbl& \oktld Xt`tlx Dkxtzkht Hi|zt
\/X/ Dkxtzkht Hi|zt& Hlotz`f Dkxtzkht ie H@& Xi|tmlzo Dkukxkio
^`bl Tri
hh7 Gleezl{ H|ookobm`a& Lxp|kzl& @ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx Izf{ T`ktw& F`r Ieekhlx ie Izf{ T`ktw&
`od Izf{ T`ktw& Koh/
Izf{ T`ktw& Lxp|kzl& @ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`ot Dlelod i|z Ezlldiax Ei|od`tkiox& Koh/
A`zh X/ Hiflo& Lxp|kzl& @ttizol{ eiz X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx
G`alx AhH`jl& Lxp|kzl& `od Akhm`lf J/ Akfflz& Lxp|kzl @ttizol{x eiz tml Zlld Dlelod`otx
Gimo @/ Uibt& Gz/& Lxp|kzl& `od Ldr`zd X/ Hm`ob& Lxp|kzl& @ttizol{x eiz Dlelod`ot
Kotlfk|x& Koh/
8:;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!02 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie < ^`bl KD(70:425
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 330/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖0=‑
88>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie : ^`bl KD(70:422
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 331/383
Ezia7 A`zh Hiflo 6ahifloNhiflof`r/hia?
D`tl7 Tm|& A`z 0& :>0: `t 007:5 @A
X|jglht7 Zlx~ioxlx
Ti7 ^mkfk~ Jlzb 6~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia?
Mlffi& mkfk~&
Eiz |o`otkhk~`tld zl`xiox tml zlx~ioxlx ti {i|z dkxhiulz{ kx f tl/ Rl rkff olld oitmlz :
rllcx a`}/ ti blt kt ti {i|/
K a r`zl ie tml kxx|l ie r`kukob ijglhtkiox od kotlod ti zlx~iod rktmi|t ijglhtkiox/
A`zh
880
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0= Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie : ^`bl KD(70:42=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 332/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖0;‑
88:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:42;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 333/383
T ml H iflo F`r E kza
<282 C`o`o Zi`d& Xtl/ 842 @bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0Tlfl~miol -=0=+ 205!:=;0 E`hxkakfl -=0=+ <;2!4580 Rzktlz‛x la`kf7 ahifloNhiflof`r/hia
HFE
A`zhm 2& :>0:
Mioiz`jfl @odzlr G/ B|kfeizdG|dbl& \oktld Xt`tlx Dkxtzkht Hi|zt\/X/ Dkxtzkht Hi|zt& Hlotz`f Dkxtzkht ie H@& Xi|tmlzo Dkukxkio400 R/ 4tm Xtzllt& Hi|ztziia 0>!DX`ot` @o`& H@ ;:2>0
Xlot uk` La`kf ti7 @BYHm`ajlzxNh`hd/|xhi|z tx/biu
Zl7 Fkjlz k& lt f u/ T`ktw& lt f & H`xl Oi/ =700!hu!>>4=< @B
Dl`z G|dbl B|kfeizd7
Dlelod`otx Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ `od Tidd X`ocl{ zlp|lxt tm`t tmkxMioiz`jfl Hi|zt ~lzakt tmlxl Dlelod`otx ti ekfl ` Aitkio ~|zx|`ot ti Z|fl85 io tml j`xlx tm`t tml `dakxxkiox `zl hiotz`z{ ti tml `ht|`f e`htx& tm`t tml~zlxlot`tkio ie tml h`xl io tml alzktx rkff jl ~zlhf|dld `od tm`t tmlzl rkff jloi ~zlg|dkhl ti tml ^f`kotkeex/
Tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx
Tmlzl `zl tri dkxtkoht bzi|~x rktmko tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`otx/ Tml ekzxt bzi|~kx hia~zkxld ie Tidd X`ocl{ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ rmkhm rkff mlohleiztm
jl zlelzzld ti `x ‖TXE/‑ Tml xlhiod bzi|~ kx hia~zkxld ie Olkf X`ocl{ `odmkx iro hia~`o{& X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/ Tml{ rkff jl ekfkob eiz
j`ocz|~th{ ~zitlhtkio rktmko ` rllc/ Tmkx flttlz `od tml ~zi~ixld aitkio kx
tm|x hioekold ti TXE/
Kaaldk`tl @hcoirfldblalot ie Lzziz
@x ` zlx|ft ie ` e`kf|zl ie i|z h`flod`zkob x{xtla `od hioxlp|lotf{ a{ irolzziz& rl e`kfld ti zlx~iod ti tml ^f`kotkeex‛ dkxhiulz{ ko tkalf{ e`xmkio/ @x
888
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4=>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 334/383
Mioiz`jfl @odzlr G/ B|kfeizdG|dbl& \oktld Xt`tlx Dkxtzkht Hi|ztA`zhm 2& :>00^`bl :
xiio `x rl xi dltlzakold& K xlot `o la`kf ti Az/ Jlzb xt`tkob i|z`hcoirfldblalot ie lzziz `od tm`t rl ri|fd zlx~iod e|ff{ ti mkx lotkzl
uif|akoi|x dkxhiulz{ rktmi|t ijglhtkio rktmko 04 d`{x Sdlx~ktl tm`t tml fkaktie :< kotlzzib`tizklx kx l}hlldld j{ a`o{ m|odzldx `od tm`t tml zlp|lxtx eiz`dakxxkiox `zl ka~zi~lzQ/
Zlx~ioxlx
Xlot mlzlrktm `zl tml Zlx~ioxlx ti tml Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox/ Tml{ `zlh|zzlotf{ |oxkbold3 tml ekzxt d`{ tm`t Tidd X`ocl{ `od K h`o allt kx X`t|zd`{
`etlz rmkhm tml izkbko`fx rkff jl xlot ti tml ^f`kotkeex‛ hi|oxlf rktm hi~klx tihi|oxlf/
@ZB\ALOT
@/ Tml Zlp|lxtx z l Hiot z `z { ti tm l @ht| `f E`htx
0/ Tmlzl kx oi zlf`tkioxmk~ jltrllo TXE `od tml rizc ~lzeizald j{ OlkfX`ocl{& Tidd‛x e`tmlz& eiz Izf{ T`ktw/ Olkf X`ocl{ rizcld eiz Izf{ T`ktw io `
~ziglht ie tmlkz a|t|`f kotlzlxt& tml ^zlxkdlot Ij`a` jkztm hlztkekh`tl kxx|l/
:/ TXE m`x olulz m`d `o{ kotlzlxt ko tml Ij`a` jkztm hlztkekh`tl kxx|l `odolulz dkd `o{ rizc hiohlzokob tm`t kxx|l/
8/ TXE m`x olulz jllo zlt`kold j{ Izf{ T`ktw ti di `o{ rizc eiz mlz& olulz uif|otllzld ti di xi `od olulz dkd `o{ x|hm rizc/
4/ Tidd X`ocl{ `daktx ` xkobfl Zlp|lxt rmkhm zlp|lxtld ie `o `dakxxkiotm`t Olkf X`ocl{ kx oit ` fkhloxld ~zku`tl koulxtkb`tiz eiz Tml X`ocl{ Ekza/
Tmkx kx ~zlhkxlf{ TXE‛x hiotlotkio/ Tm`t kx xmiro io tml hi~{ ie tmlZlx~ioxlx xlot mlzlrktm/
</ Tml X`ocl{ Ekza `daktx tmzll Zlp|lxtx ie rmkhm tri `zl leelhtkulf{ kdlotkh`f/ Tml oio!d|~fkh`tkul Zlp|lxt kx tml x`al `x tml iol `x eiz TiddX`ocl{3 Tml X`ocl{ Ekza `bzllx tm`t Olkf X`ocl{ kx oit ` fkhloxld ~zku`tlkoulxtkb`tiz eiz Tml X`ocl{ Ekza/ Tml d|~fkh`tkul Zlp|lxt dlxkzlx tml`dakxxkio tm`t ~zku`tl koulxtkb`tizx `zl zlb|f`tld j{ tml H`fkeizok` J|zl`| ie
884
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4=0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 335/383
Mioiz`jfl @odzlr G/ B|kfeizdG|dbl& \oktld Xt`tlx Dkxtzkht Hi|ztA`zhm 2& :>00^`bl 8
Xlh|zkt{ od Koulxtkb`tkul Xlzukhlx/ Oi x|jxt`otk ul dakxxkiox rlzl a`dl/ Tm`tkx xmiro io tml hi~{ ie tml Zlx~ioxlx xlot mlzlrktm/
5/ Tml hiohf|xkiox ie f`r tm`t `zl xka~f{ rziob/
2/ Oi `hp|kxktk>o ie koeiza`tkio hiohlzokob tml ^f`kotkeex r`x ~lzeizald j{ Tidd X`ocl{ iz Tml X`ocl{ Ekza/
=/ Oi dkxxlako`tkio ie ~|z~iztldf{ hioekdlotk`f koeiza`tkio r`x~lzeizald j{ Tidd X`ocl{ iz Tml X`ocl{ Ekza/
J/ Tmlxl Dlelod `ot x R k ff Jl z lhf|dld eiz ^z lxlot k ob tm lk z H`xl io K tx‛ A lz kt x
‖\~mifdkob tml SdllaldQ `dakxxkiox ri|fd ~z`htkh`ff{ lfkako`tl `o{ ~zlxlot`tkio ie tml alzktx ie tml h`xl/‑ Hiofio u/ \/X/& 424 E/8d 505&5:: -;tm Hkz/ :>>2+/
Ke tml ^f`kotkeex‛ `zl dlxlzukob ie ~zlu`kfkob io ` Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot tm`o tml{ xmi|fd di xi io tml j`xkx ie tml alzktx ie tmkx h`xl/
H/ Tmlz l k x Oi ^z lg |d k hl ti tm l f`k ot k e ex
^f`kotkeex rkff ijt`ko e`z aizl koeiza`tkio tm`o tml{ ri|fd m`ul zlhlkuld ke tml zlx~ioxlx m`d jllo tkalf{/ Tml e`htx |~io rmkhm TXE j`xlx ktx oio!`dakxxkiox& tml zlflu`ot rktolxxlx `od tml dih|alotx x|~~iztkob tml oio!`dakxxkiox& oiol ie rmkhm ri|fd m`ul jllo ~ziukdld jlh`|xl TXE f`xt fixttml `jkfkt{ ti ijglht ti tml `xtzioiakh`f `ai|ot ie kotlzzib`tizklx `odx|j~`ztx/
D/ @ A it kio eiz X|aa `z { G|dbalot kx Oit T kalf{ ko `o{ Lulot
0/ ^f`kotkeex m`ul oit {lt zlx~iodld ti tml X`ocl{ Dlelod`ot‛x dkxhiulz{ `od oi Aitkio eiz X|aa`z{ G|dbalot `b`koxt tmla h`o ~zihlld |otkf `ff tmllotkzlt{ ie tmlkz dkxhiulz{ kx hia~fltld/ Kt `~~l`zx mkbmf{ fkclf{ tm`t tmlZlx~ioxlx j{ tml Dlelod`otx rkff jl ~zijfla`tkh jlh`|xl ie Az/ Jlzb‛x
88<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4=:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 336/383
Mioiz`jfl @odzlr G/ B|kfeizdG|dbl& \oktld Xt`tlx Dkxtzkht Hi|ztA`zhm 2& :>00^`bl 4
hioefkht dlzkuld ezia mkx zifl `x jitm ` ~f`kotkee `od `x hi|oxlf eiz tmlzla`kokob ^f`kotkeex‛ hi|oxlf `od tml Zlx~ioxlx rkff oit jl `~~zi~zk`tl/ Ktxllax zl`xio`jf{ fkclf{ tm`t iol iz aizl aitkiox ti hia~lf rkff jl zlp|kzldti zlxiful tmlxl kxx|lx/
:/ Oi dkxhiulz{ hi|fd jl m`d ezia tml T`ktw dlelod`otx jlh`|xl ie tmlXt`{/ Tm`t dkxhiulz{ kx hzktkh`f ti tml dleloxl ie tmkx `htkio/
HIOHF\XKIO
Ko uklr ie tml eizlbikob& K zlx~lhte|ff{ zlp|lxt fl`ul ie Hi|zt ti ekfl ` Aitkio~|zx|`ot ti Z|fl 85 ti `ffir Tidd X`ocl{ `od Tml X`ocl{ Ekza ti ~zi~lzf{ zlx~iod ti ^f`kotkeex‛ Zlp|lxtx eiz @dakxxkiox/ Tm`t ijglhtkiox rlzl r`kuldkx oit dkx~|tld/
Zlx~lhte|ff{ {i|zx&
A zh X/ Hiflo
A`zh X/ Hiflo
885
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4=8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 337/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tidd X`ocl{‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox 0
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& xjo 0>=:2<F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo<282 C`o`o Zi`d& Xtl/ 842
@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0Tlfl7 =0=/205/:=;0
E`}7 =0=/<;2/4580
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx Olkf X`ocl{&Tidd X`ocl{& Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/&`od X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@& RLXTLZO DKUKXKIO
Fkx` Fkjlzk& lt `f/&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
Izf{ T`ktw& lt `f/&
Dlelod`otx
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
+-++++++++++++
H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B -@GR}+
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ
@DA K XXK IOX XLT 0
^ZI^I\ODK OB @ZT[7^F@K OTK EEX FK X@ FK JLZK &FK X@ IXTLFF@& ^M K FK ^ G/JLZB& LXP\K ZL& BI L] HLFBFIJ@F @OD TM L F@RIEEK HLX IE ^M K FK ^ G/ JLZB
ZLX^IODK OB ^@ZT[7
DLELOD@OT& TIDD X@OC L[
882
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4=4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 338/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 339/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tidd X`ocl{‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox 8
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
hzldlotk`fx `od ijt`ko ^f`kotkeex eko`ohk`f zlhizdx& hzldkt zlhizdx& la~fi{alot
zlhizdx& aldkh`f zlhizdx `od itmlz zlhizdx ezia Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld Lfxluklz&
Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc
Xif|tkiox& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot&`od Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Coir]& Hioek!Hmlc& lth/
rktmi|t ` ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz `o{ t{~l ie flb`f lotktflalot/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 8
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 47
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ kx oit ` fkhloxld ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tiz eiz tml X`ocl{
Ekza/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 4
@dakt/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ <7
@dakt [I\ `zl tml irolz `od i~lz`tiz ie Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/
)))
)))
)))
)))
88;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl = ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4=5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 340/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tidd X`ocl{‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox 4
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ <
@dakt tm`t K `a `o irolz ie Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/ Tml dlekoktkio ie
‖i~lz`tiz ie tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/‑ kx oit ~ziukdld oiz |odlzxtiid ‘ tml rizdi~lz`tiz kx oit |xld j{ fkhloxld ~zku`tl koulxtkb`tizx/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 57
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl `od `xxkxtld Olkf X`ocl{ ko ekfkob e`fxl `fflb`tkiox
`ji|t tml ^f`kotkeex rktm Xt`tl `od Eldlz`f @blohklx& kohf|dkob ~zij`tkio
dl~`ztalotx/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 5
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 27
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ |xld [I\Z ieekhl& [I\Z tlfl~miol o|ajlz& [I\Z
Hia~`o{& Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& `od [I\Z fib!ko hzldlotk`fx ti ijt`ko tml ^li~fl
Ekodlz d`t`& eko`ohk`f d`t`& xl`fld hi|zt dih|alotx& aldkh`f d`t`& `od
^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx ie tml ^f`kotkeex/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 2
Dlo{/
)))
84>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl ; ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4=2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 341/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tidd X`ocl{‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox <
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ =7
@dakt [I\ `hhlxxld `od ijt`kold tml ^li~fl Ekodlz d`t`& ^lzxio`f
Kdlotkeklzx& Hzldkt Zl~iztx& Eko`ohk`f Zl~iztx& Xl`fld Hi|zt Dih|alotx `oditmlz dih|alotx io tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx& ^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od
^f`kotkeex E`akf{ alajlzx tmzi|bm Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/3
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc
Xif|tkiox& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot&
`od Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Coir]& Hioek!Hmlc& lth/&
rktmi|t `o{ t{~l ie ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f lotktflalot `od ~ziukdld
^f`kotkeex d`t` ti tml itmlz Dlelod`otx& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti Olkf
X`ocl{/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ =
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ ;7
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ m`x ~iztz`{ld mkaxlfe `x ` ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tiz eiz Tml
X`ocl{ Ekza/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ ;
K m`ul a`dl ` zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tml koeiza`tkio coiro iz zl`dkf{
ijt`ko`jfl kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl al ti `dakt iz dlo{/
)))
840
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4==
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 342/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tidd X`ocl{‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox 5
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0> 7
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl Olkf X`ocl{ xlot `o la`kf ti Zl~iztlz Jij \oz|m
rktm Rizfd Olt D`kf{& ezia tml X`ocl{ Ekza& `ji|t ^f`kotkee Fkx` Fkjlzk tm`thiot`kold ^f`kotkee Fkjlzk‛x e|ff Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz& d`tl ie jkztm& x~i|xlx
o`al `od Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz `od itmlz ~zku`tl d`t`/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0>
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ 007
@dakt tml H`fkeizok` J|zl`| ie Xlh|zkt{ `od Koulxtkb`tkul Xlzukhlx zlxtzkhtx
^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tizx ezia `hhlxxkob `od ijt`kokob ` ~lzxio-x+ e|ff Xihk`f
Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz `od itmlz ~zku`tl kdlotke{kob koeiza`tkio eiz tml ~|z~ixl ie
~|jfkxmkob ti m`za tml kodkukd|`f-x+/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 00
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 0:7
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl `od `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ ti |tkfkwl [I\Z fib ko
hzldlotk`fx `od ijt`ko koeiza`tkio ezia tml H`fkeizok` Dl~`ztalot ie Aitiz
Ulmkhflx& itmlz ~lzxio-x+& `blohklx `od lotktklx& kohf|dkob tml itmlz
Dlelod`otx& io tml ^f`kotkeex j`xld io e`fxl ~zltloxlx/
84:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 00 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4=;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 343/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tidd X`ocl{‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox 2
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0:
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 087
@dakt [I\ m`ul hzl`tld kzzlulzxkjfl m`za `od d`a`blx ti ^f`kotkeex j{
dkxxlako`tkob lzzioli|x koeiza`tkio3 tmlkz ^li~fl Ekodlz D`t` `od tmlkz
^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx ti `o kaal`x|z`jfl `ai|ot ie ~li~fl `od j|xkolxxlx/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 08
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ 047
@dakt [I\ dkd oit m`ul `o{ ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f lotktflalot ti
`o{ koeiza`tkio zlb`zdkob `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 04
Dlo{ tm`t K zlp|kzl `o{ ~|z~ixl iz lotktflalot ti ijt`ko ~|jfkhf{ `u`kf`jfl
koeiza`tkio `ji|t tml ^f`kotkeex/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 0<7
@dakt [I\ `zl |o`jfl ti dlaioxtz`tl mir a`o{ ~li~fl m`ul zlhlkuld
^f`kotkeex ~zku`tl ~lzxio`f kdlotke{kob koeiza`tkio `od kohizzlht koeiza`tkio
848
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4;>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 344/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tidd X`ocl{‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox =
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
jlh`|xl ie tml o`t|zl ie tml kotlzolt `od tml o|alzi|x r`{x kt r`x zl~l`tldf{
~ixtld io tml Kotlzolt `od xlot i|t j{ Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0<
@dakt tm`t K `a |o`jfl ti dlaioxtz`tl mir a`o{ ~li~fl m`ul ijt`kold
koeiza`tkio hiohlzokob tml ^f`kotkeex/ @x ti tml zlxt& K m`ul a`dl ` zl`xio`jfl
kop|kz{ `od tml koeiza`tkio coiro iz zl`dkf{ ijt`ko`jfl kx kox|eekhklot ti
lo`jfl tmkx zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ ti `dakt iz dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ 057
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl Olkf X`ocl{ e`fxlf{ `hh|xld ^f`kotkee Fkx` Fkjlzk‛x
m|xj`od ie jlkob ` ‖~`zifll‑ `od dkulztkob e|odx ezia ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb&
Lxp|kzl‛x rljxktl/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 05
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 027
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl `od `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ ti |xl [I\Z fib!ko
hzldlotk`fx `od [I\Z zlxi|zhlx ti `xxkxt Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw ko m`zakob
`od h`|xkob d`a`blx ti tml ^f`kotkeex/
)))
)))
844
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 08 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4;0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 345/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tidd X`ocl{‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox ;
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 02
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0=7
@dakt Fl}kxOl}kx -Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/+ h`ohlffld [I\Z x|jxhzk~tkio ko iz
`ji|t :>0> ti tmlkz ~zid|htx d|l ti `j|xl/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0=
K m`ul a`dl ` zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tml koeiza`tkio coiro iz zl`dkf{
ijt`ko`jfl kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl al ti `dakt iz dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ 0;7
@dakt [I\ olulz zl~iztld ti f`r loeizhlalot tml akx|xl ie ^f`kotkeex
^li~fl Ekodlz D`t` `od ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklz d`t` tm`t Olkf X`ocl{ tmzi|bm
[I\ `od tml X`ocl{ Ekza& ijt`kold `od ~ziukdld ti Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw `od
tml itmlz Dlelod`otx `od `ffirld Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw ti dkxtzkj|tl ^f`kotkeex
d`t` `ff iulz tml Kotlzolt& tmzi|bm a`xx la`kfkob& a`xx a`kfkob& lth/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0;
Tmkx Zlp|lxt kx xi hiouif|tld `x ti jl |okotlffkbkjfl/ J`xld io a{ jlxt
~ixxkjfl b|lxx ie rm`t kt al`ox& K `dakt tm`t K olulz zl~iztld `o{tmkob ti f`r
loeizhlalot hiohlzokob `o{ ~iztkio ie tmkx h`xl/ Dlo{ tm`t Olkf X`ocl{ dkd
`o{tmkob tmzi|bm al/ @x ti tml zlxt& K m`ul a`dl ` zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tml
84<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 04 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4;:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 346/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tidd X`ocl{‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp|lxt eiz @dakxxkiox 0 >
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
koeiza`tkio coiro iz zl`dkf{ ijt`ko`jfl kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl tmkx
zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ ti `dakt iz dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ :>7
@dakt [I\ rlzl `r`zl `od `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ ti |xl {i|z fib!ko
hzldlotk`fx `od `hhlxx `od ~|ff xl`fld dih|alotx kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld ti
xl`fld hi|zt dih|alotx ~lzt`kokob ti tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx&
^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ :>
Dlo{/
D`tld tmkx YYY ie A`zhm& :>0:
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYA`zh Xtlulo HifloF`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx Olkf X`ocl{&Tidd X`ocl{& Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/&`od X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/
845
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0< ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4;8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 347/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox ! ****************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& xjo 0>=:2<F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo<282 C`o`o Zi`d& Xtl/ 842
@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0Tlfl7 =0=/205/:=;0
E`}7 =0=/<;2/4580
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx Olkf X`ocl{&Tidd X`ocl{& Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/&`od X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@& RLXTLZO DKUKXKIO
Fkx` Fkjlzk& lt `f/&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
Izf{ T`ktw& lt `f/&
Dlelod`otx
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
+-++++++++++++
H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B -@GR}+
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ
@DAKXXKIOX
XLT 0
^ZI^I\ODK OB @ZT[7^F@K OTK EEX FK X@ FK JLZK &FK X@ IXTLFF@& ^M K FK ^ G/JLZB& LXP\K ZL& BI L] HLFBFIJ@F @OD TM L F@RIEEK HLX IE ^M K FK ^ G/ JLZB
ZLX^IODK OB ^@ZT[7
DLELOD@O T& TML X@OC L[
EKZA & K OH/
842
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 05 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4;4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 348/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox (****************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 07
@dakt L]MKJKT ‖@‑ `tt`hmld mlzlti kx `o La`kf xlot ezia Tml X`ocl{ Ekza&
Koh/ j{ Olkf X`ocl{/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0
Tmkx Zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ m`x a`dl ` zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tml koeiza`tkio
coiro iz zl`dkf{ ijt`ko`jfl kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl tmkx zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ ti
`dakt iz dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ :7
@dakt {i| m`ul `hhi|otx rktm Hioek!Hmlc& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld
Lfxluklz& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx
Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& `od Coir]/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ :
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 87
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ `od Tidd X`ocl{ |xld {i|z fib!ko hzldlotk`fx `od
ijt`kold ^f`kotkeex eko`ohk`f zlhizdx& hzldkt zlhizdx& la~fi{alot zlhizdx&
aldkh`f zlhizdx `od itmlz zlhizdx ezia Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/3
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc
84=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 02 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4;<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 349/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox $****************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
Xif|tkiox& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot&
`od Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Coir]& Hioek!Hmlc& lth/
rktmi|t ` ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz `o{ t{~l ie flb`f lotktflalot/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 8
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 47
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ kx oit ` fkhloxld ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tiz eiz Tml X`ocl{
Ekza/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 4
@dakt/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ <7
@dakt {i| `zl zlx~ioxkjfl eiz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `htkiox `od ko`htkiox/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ <
Dlo{ `x ti `ff `htkiox `od ko`htkiox& `dakt tm`t tmkx Zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ m`x
fkaktld zlx~ioxkjkfkt{ eiz ` elr `htkiox `od ko`htkiox ie ktx la~fi{llx/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 57
84;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0= ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4;5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 350/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox ,****************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tkiox fkhloxkob kx
biulzold j{ tml H`fkeizok` J|zl`| ie Xlh|zkt{ `od Koulxtkb`tkul Xlzukhlx
S‖JXKX‑Q/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 5
@dakt/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 27
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `zl zlp|kzld ti `dmlzl ti tml H`fkeizok`
f`rx `od tml b|kdlfkolx& zlp|kzlalotx& `od zlb|f`tkiox i|tfkold ko tml
H`fkeizok` JXKX/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 2
@dakt/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ =7
@dakt {i| `od)iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `hhlxxld `od ijt`kold tml ^li~fl Ekodlz
d`t`& ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx& Hzldkt Zl~iztx& Eko`ohk`f Zl~iztx& Xl`fld Hi|zt
Dih|alotx `od itmlz dih|alotx io tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx&
^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ alajlzx tmzi|bm Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld
Lfxluklz& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/3
Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx/hia3 Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/3 Fl}kxOl}kx
Bzi|~3 @hh|zkot& `od Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Kotlfk|x& Koh/& \/X/ Xl`zhm& Coir]&
Hioek!Hmlc& lth/& rktmi|t `o{ t{~l ie ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f lotktflalot
8<>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0; ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4;2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 351/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox %****************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
`od ~ziukdld ^f`kotkeex d`t` ti tml itmlz Dlelod`otx& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld
ti Olkf X`ocl{/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ =
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ ;7
@dakt L]MKJKT ‖@‑ `tt`hmld mlzlti hiot`kox ^f`kotkee Fkx` Fkjlzk‛x o`al&
Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz-x+& d`tl ie jkztm& X~i|xlx o`al& d`tl ie jkztm `od
Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz `od itmlz hioekdlotk`f koeiza`tkio ijt`kold ezia
Kotlfk|x& Koh/& Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx/hia& Fl}kxOl}kx& Koh/&
Fl}kxOl}kx Bzi|~& @hh|zkot& Hmikhl^ikot& Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc Xif|tkiox&
Koh/& Fl}kxOl}kx Zkxc `od Koeiza`tkio @o`f{tkhx Bzi|~& Koh/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ ;
Tmkx Zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ m`x a`dl ` zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tml koeiza`tkio
coiro iz zl`dkf{ ijt`ko`jfl kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl tmkx zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ ti
`dakt iz dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0> 7
@dakt rmlo {i| iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ koulxtkb`tl `o Kodkukd|`f& {i| `od
{i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `zl zlp|kzld ti a`kot`ko tml Kodkukd|`f-x+ ~zku`tl `od
~lzxio`f d`t`& kohf|dkob j|t oit fkaktld ti o`al& `ddzlxx& tlfl~miol o|ajlz&
d`tl ie jkztm& ~f`hl ie jkztm& Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz& aitmlz‛x a`kdlo o`alx&
8<0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :> ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4;=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 352/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox " ****************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
eko`ohk`f `od hzldkt d`t`& aldkh`f d`t`& lth/ hioekdlotk`f `od oit xm`zl kt rktm
tml ~|jfkh/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0>
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ 007
@dakt tml H`fkeizok` JXKX zlxtzkhtx {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ ezia
`hhlxxkob `od ijt`kokob ` ~lzxio-x+ e|ff Xihk`f Xlh|zkt{ o|ajlz `od itmlz
~zku`tl kdlotke{kob koeiza`tkio eiz tml ~|z~ixl ie ~|jfkxmkob tml ~lzxio`f d`t`
ti m`za tml kodkukd|`f-x+/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 00
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 0:7
@dakt Olkf X`ocl{ `od Tidd X`ocl{ |tkfkwld {i|z fib ko hzldlotk`fx `od
ijt`kold koeiza`tkio ezia tml H`fkeizok` Dl~`ztalot ie Aitiz Ulmkhflx&
itmlz ~lzxio-x+& `blohklx `od lotktklx& kohf|dkob tml itmlz Dlelod`otx& io tml
^f`kotkeex j`xld io e`fxl ~zltloxlx/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0:
Dlo{/
8<:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :0 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:4;;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 353/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox - ****************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 087
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ m`ul hzl`tld kzzlulzxkjfl m`za `od d`a`blx
ti ^f`kotkeex j{ dkxxlako`tkob lzzioli|x koeiza`tkio3 tmlkz ^li~fl EkodlzD`t` `od tmlkz ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx ti `o kaal`x|z`jfl `ai|ot ie ~li~fl `od
j|xkolxxlx/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 08
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ 047
@dakt {i| iz {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ dkd oit m`ul `o{ ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f
lotktflalot ti `o{ koeiza`tkio zlb`zdkob `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 04
Dlo{ tm`t Tml X`ocl{ Ekza zlp|kzlx `o{ ~`ztkh|f`z ~|z~ixl iz lotktflalot ti
ijt`ko ~|jfkhf{ `u`kf`jfl koeiza`tkio/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ 0<7
@dakt {i| `zl |o`jfl ti dlaioxtz`tl mir a`o{ ~li~fl m`ul zlhlkuld
^f`kotkeex ~zku`tl ~lzxio`f kdlotke{kob koeiza`tkio `od kohizzlht koeiza`tkio
jlh`|xl ie tml o`t|zl ie tml kotlzolt `od tml o|alzi|x r`{x kt r`x zl~l`tldf{
~ixtld io tml Kotlzolt `od xlot i|t j{ Dlelod`otx Izf{ T`ktw& Olkf X`ocl{ `od
tml itmlz Dlelod`otx/
8<8
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :: ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:<>>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 354/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox + ****************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0<
@dakt tm`t Tml X`ocl{ Ekza kx |o`jfl ti dlaioxtz`tl `o{tmkob zlb`zdkob tml
^f`kotkeex/ @x ti tml zla`kodlz& m`x a`dl ` zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tmlkoeiza`tkio coiro iz zl`dkf{ ijt`ko`jfl kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl tmkx
zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ ti `dakt iz dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ 057
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ a|xt m`ul ` ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl `od flb`f
lotktflalot ti `hhlxx `o{ kodkukd|`f-x+ ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklzx& ^li~fl Ekodlz
d`t`& eko`ohk`f d`t`& hzldkt d`t`& aldkh`f d`t`& `od `o{ itmlz koeiza`tkio `od
d`t`/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 05
Dlo{ tm`t Tml X`ocl{ Ekza zlp|kzlx `o{ ~`ztkh|f`z ~|z~ixl iz lotktflalot ti
ijt`ko ~|jfkhf{ `u`kf`jfl koeiza`tkio/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 027
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ `od Tidd X`ocl{ ti
|xl {i|z fib!ko hzldlotk`fx `od {i|z zlxi|zhlx ti `xxkxt Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw
ko m`zakob `od h`|xkob d`a`blx ti tml ^f`kotkeex/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 02
Dlo{
8<4
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :8 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:<>0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 355/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox ' ****************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0=7
@dakt Fl}kxOl}kx -Zlld Lfxluklz& Koh/+ h`ohlffld {i|z x|jxhzk~tkio ko iz
`ji|t :>0> ti tmlkz ~zid|htx d|l ti `j|xl/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0=
Tml X`ocl{ Ekza m`x a`dl ` zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tml koeiza`tkio coiro
iz zl`dkf{ ijt`ko`jfl kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl tmkx zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ ti `dakt iz
dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ 0;7
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ e`kfld ti zl~izt ti f`r loeizhlalot tml
akx|xl ie ^f`kotkeex ^li~fl Ekodlz D`t` `od ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklz d`t` tm`t Olkf
X`ocl{ tmzi|bm {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+& ijt`kold `od ~ziukdld ti
Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw `od tml itmlz Dlelod`otx `od `ffirld Dlelod`ot Izf{
T`ktw ti dkxtzkj|tl ^f`kotkeex d`t` `ff iulz tml Kotlzolt& tmzi|bm a`xx La`kfkob&
a`xx a`kfkob& lth/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ 0;
Tmkx zlp|lxt kx |okotlffkbkjfl j|t ti tml l}tlot tm`t ` zlx~ioxl h`o jl a`dl&
Tml X`ocl{ Ekza `ddktkio`ff{ zlx~iodx `x eiffirx7 Tml X`ocl{ Ekza tiic oi
`htkiox ti `xxkxt Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw/ @x ti tml zla`kodlz& Tml X`ocl{ Ekza
m`x a`dl ` zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tml koeiza`tkio coiro iz zl`dkf{
ijt`ko`jfl kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl tmkx zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ ti `dakt iz dlo{/
8<<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :4 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:<>:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 356/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox ! #***************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ :>7
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `ffirld Olkf X`ocl{ ti |xl {i|z fib!ko
hzldlotk`fx `od `hhlxx `od ~|ff xl`fld dih|alotx kohf|dkob& j|t oit fkaktld tixl`fld hi|zt dih|alotx ~lzt`kokob ti tml ^f`kotkeex& ^f`kotkeex X~i|xlx&
^f`kotkeex Hmkfdzlo `od ^f`kotkeex E`akf{ Alajlzx/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ :>
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ :07
@dakt rmlo {i| `od)iz {i|z ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tiz-x+ `zl zlp|lxtld iz mkzld ti
~lzeiza ` gij eiz ` hfklot& {i| `od {i|z ^zku`tl Koulxtkb`tiz-x+ `zl zlp|kzld ti
lox|zl {i|z hfklot m`x ` ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f lotktflalot ti tml
koeiza`tkio xi|bmt/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ :0
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ ::7
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ `zl zlp|kzld ti ulzke{ tml ~lzakxxkjfl
~|z~ixl `od)iz flb`f lotktflalot ie {i|z Hfklot ti Kodkukd|`f-x+ ^li~fl Ekodlz
D`t`& ^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklz D`t`& Eko`ohk`f Zlhizdx& Hzldkt D`t`& `od itmlz
koeiza`tkio/
8<5
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :< ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:<>8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 357/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox ! ! ***************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ ::
Dlo{/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ :87
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ e`kfld ti ijt`ko `od)iz ulzke{ Izf{ T`ktw‛x&
~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl `od)iz flb`f lotktflalot ti ^f`kotkeex ^li~fl Ekodlz D`t`&
^lzxio`f Kdlotkeklz D`t`& Eko`ohk`f D`t`& J`hcbzi|od Hmlhcx& Hzldkt D`t`& iz
`o{ itmlz koeiza`tkio `od)iz d`t`/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ :8
Dlo{ tm`t Tml X`ocl{ Ekza m`d `o{tmkob ti di rktm Dlelod`ot Izf{ T`ktw/
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO OI/ :47
@dakt {i|z hfklot& Izf{ T`ktw& dkd oit m`ul `o{ t{~l ie ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl
iz flb`f lotktflalot ti `o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex d`t`/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO O I/ :4
Tml X`ocl{ Ekza m`x a`dl ` zl`xio`jfl kop|kz{ `od tml koeiza`tkio coiro
iz zl`dkf{ ijt`ko`jfl kx kox|eekhklot ti lo`jfl tmkx zlx~iodkob ^`zt{ ti `dakt iz
dlo{/
)))
)))
8<2
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :5 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:<>4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 358/383
Fkjlz k u/ T`ktw H`xl Oi/7 =700!hu!>>4=< @B Tml X`ocl{ Ekza‛x Zlx~ioxl ti Zlp/ eiz @dakxxkiox ! (***************
0
:
8
4<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:=
ZLP\LXT EIZ @DA K XXK IO O I/ :<7
@dakt {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+ rlzl e|ff{ `r`zl Izf{ T`ktw iz `o{ ie tml
itmlz Dlelod`otx& dkd oit m`ul ` ~lzakxxkjfl ~|z~ixl iz flb`f lotktflalot ti`o{ ie tml ^f`kotkeex koeiza`tkio iz d`t`& j|t {i| `od {i|z la~fi{ll-x+
~ziukdld kt `o{r`{/
ZLX^IOXL TI ZLP\LXT EIZ @D A K XXK IO OI/ :<
Dlo{/
D`tld tmkx YYY ie A`zhm& :>0:
YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYA`zh Xtlulo HifloF`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
@ttizol{ eiz Dlelod`otx Olkf X`ocl{&Tidd X`ocl{& Tml X`ocl{ Ekza& Koh/&`od X`ocl{ Koulxtkb`tkiox& Koh/
8<=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!0; Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :2 ie :2 ^`bl KD(70:<><
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 359/383
Dlhf`z`tkio ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
:5
:2
:= L]MKJKT ‖:>‑
8<;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<>5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 360/38385>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl : ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<>2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 361/383850
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 8 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<>=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 362/38385:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 4 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<>;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 363/383858
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl < ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<0>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 364/383854
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 5 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<00
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 365/38385<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 2 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<0:
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 366/383855
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl = ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<08
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 367/383
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 368/38385=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0> ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<0<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 369/38385;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 00 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<05
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 370/38382>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0: ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<02
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 371/383820
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 08 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<0=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 372/38382:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 04 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<0;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 373/383828
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0< ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<:>
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 374/383824
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 05 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<:0
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 375/38382<
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 02 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<::
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 376/383825
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0= ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<:8
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 377/383822
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0; ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<:4
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 378/38382=
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :> ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<:<
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 379/38382;
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :0 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<:5
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 380/3838=>
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :: ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<:2
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 381/3838=0
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :8 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<:=
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 382/3838=:
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:> Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl :4 ie :4 ^`bl KD(70:<:;
8/2/2019 Liberi v Taiitz Philip J Berg Esq Decl in Opp ToSankey's Rule 36(b) Motion_Doc 499
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/liberi-v-taiitz-philip-j-berg-esq-decl-in-opp-tosankeys-rule-36b-motiondoc 383/383
0
:
8
4
<
5
2
=
;
0>
00
0:
08
04
0<
05
02
0=
0;
:>
:0
::
:8
:4
:<
^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl -^@ K/D/ ;=52+
L!a`kf7 ~mkfgjlzbNba`kf/hia
F@R IEEKHLX IE ^MKFK^ G/ JLZB
<<< @odizz` Bflo Hi|zt& X|ktl 0:
F`e`{lttl Mkff& ^@ 0;444!:<80
Tlfl~miol7 -50>+ =:<!8084 E`}7 -50>+ =84!25<;
@ttizol{ ko ~zi xl `od eiz ^f kotkeex
\OKTLD XT@TLX DKXTZKHT HI\ZT
EIZ TML HLOTZ@F DKXTZKHT IE H@FKEIZOK@&
XI\TMLZO DKUKXKIO
FKX@ FKJLZK& lt `f&
^f`kotkeex&
ux/
IZF[ T@KTW& lt `f&
Dlelod`otx/
7
7777777777
HKUKF @HTKIO O\AJLZ7=700!hu!>>4=<!@B -@GR+
^F@KOTKEEX HLZTKEKH@TL IE
XLZUKHL
K& ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb& Lxp|kzl& mlzlj{ hlztke{ ` tz|l `od hizzlht hi~{ ie ^mkfk~ G/ Jlzb
Lxp|kzl‛x Dlhf`z`tkio ko x|~~izt ie ^f`kotkeex I~~ixktkio ti Tidd X`ocl{ `od Tml X`ocl{
Ekza& Koh/‛x Aitkio ti Rktmdz`r tmlkz @dakxxkiox Dllald @dakttld r`x xlzuld tmzi|bm
tml LHE ekfkob x{xtla tmkx 0;tm
d`{ ie @~zkf :>0: |~io tml eiffirkob7
A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo& Lxp/
F`r Ieekhlx ie A`zh Xtlulo Hiflo
<282 C`o`o Zi`d& Xtl/ 842
@bi|z` Mkffx& H@ ;08>0
La`kf7 ahifloNhiflof`r/hia
H`xl =700!hu!>>4=<!@B!@GR Dih|alot 4;;!:0 Ekfld >4)0;)0: ^`bl 0 ie : ^`bl KD(70:<8>